Vol. 625 Thursday, No. 3 12 October 2006

DI´OSPO´ IREACHTAI´ PARLAIMINTE PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES

DA´ IL E´ IREANN

TUAIRISC OIFIGIU´ IL—Neamhcheartaithe (OFFICIAL REPORT—Unrevised)

Thursday, 12 October 2006.

Requests to Move Adjournment of Da´il under Standing Order 31 ……………… 737 Order of Business ……………………………… 738 Investment Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 [Seanad]: Second Stage … … 751 Road Traffic (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2006: First Stage ……………… 757 Investment Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 [Seanad]: Second Stage (resumed) …………………………… 758 Referral to Select Committee ………………………… 803 Ceisteanna — Questions Minister for Defence Priority Questions …………………………… 804 Other Questions …………………………… 815 Adjournment Debate Matters …………………………… 830 Adjournment Debate Prison Accommodation …………………………… 831 Traffic Management …………………………… 834 Services for People with Disabilities ……………………… 836 Planning Issues ……………………………… 839 Questions: Written Answers …………………………… 845 737 738

DA´ IL E´ IREANN including gardaı´ from Mayo, are required else- where, such as in Moyross. ———— An Ceann Comhairle: Having considered the De´ardaoin, 12 Deireadh Fo´mhair 2006. matters raised, they are not in order under Stand- Thursday, 12 October 2006. ing Order 31.

———— Order of Business. Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): It is pro- Chuaigh an Ceann Comhairle i gceannas ar posed to take No. 1, Investment Funds, Compan- 10.30 a.m. ies and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 [Seanad] — Second Stage. ———— An Ceann Comhairle: There are no proposals Paidir. for the House on the Order of Business. Prayer. Mr. Kenny: I ask the Government Whip to ———— explain why the Da´il was shut down yesterday for an extended period. A total of 16 Bills are due to Requests to move Adjournment of Da´il under go through the House. For example, the Health Standing Order 31. Bill was promised on three separate occasions last An Ceann Comhairle: Before coming to the year. The Da´il returned from its 82 day summer Order of Business, I propose to deal with a break only for Members to find that it closed number of notices under Standing Order 31. down for a period yesterday.

Mr. Connolly: I seek the adjournment of the Mr. F. McGrath: It was for the match. Da´il under Standing Order 31 to raise a matter of national importance, namely, the situation in Mr. Kenny: Has the Government run out of which 18% of all trolley-bound patients in Ireland business or did not foresee a situation in which are located in two hospitals in the north-east time would be available? Given all the requests region, that is, Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, made by Members from all sides to discuss var- Drogheda, with 10% of the national total of ious matters—— patients and Cavan General Hospital with 8%, which is a regular feature of the region; and call Mr. O’Donovan: Deputy Kenny wastes for the opening of the new six -bay treatment enough time. room at Monaghan General Hospital on a seven Mr. Kenny: ——the House deserves an expla- day, 24-hour basis, particularly as staffing com- nation from the Government Whip in this regard. plements have been agreed and its operation will I ask the Minister when Members can expect be cost-neutral. the new ethics Bill to be brought before the Ms C. Murphy: I seek the adjournment of the House. Given the close and warm relationship Da´il under Standing Order 31 to raise a matter between the Taoiseach and Ta´naiste, they have of national and local importance, namely, the now arranged that—— imminent opening of the Dublin Port tunnel and An Ceann Comhairle: The Deputy should con- the redirection of heavy goods vehicles to the fine himself to the legislation. We cannot discuss M50, which, without lifting the tolls at West Link, its possible contents or what the Deputy would will cause complete mayhem on both the M50 like it to include. and the national primary roads that feed on to it. This matter now requires urgent attention as we Mr. Kenny: —— anyone who has any doubts are only weeks away from a predictable crisis. should go to the Standards in Public Office Com- mission. When will the—— Dr. Cowley: I seek the adjournment of the Da´il under Standing Order 31 to raise a matter of An Ceann Comhairle: On the legislation. national importance, namely, the reason tax- \ payers should be obliged to pay 675,639 for ten Mr. Kenny: ——new Progressive Democrats days of Garda overtime, not including Garda sal- amendment to the laws of conscience be brought ary costs, to pay for the cost of hundreds of gardaı´ before the House? to quash a peaceful protest against the building of the Corrib gas refinery that will be of little use An Ceann Comhairle: I call the Minister. to the people of County Mayo or Ireland and which Shell is able to pay, given its profits of $3 Mr. Kenny: When will Members see it, in case million per hour; and that the 114 gardaı´ people get ideas about themselves? deployed from divisions outside Mayo were badly needed elsewhere and the 69 who remain, not Mr. J. Brady: A special Mullingar accord. 739 Order of 12 October 2006. Business 740

Mr. Rabbitte: Invective from Deputy Johnny have any legislation to propose, why does it not Brady. make provision for a discussion on one of the three Morris reports? Would it not be possible to An Ceann Comhairle: I call the Minister. provide for a discussion on the botched privatis- ation of Aer Lingus? Mr. Durkan: Hail to Deputy Johnny Brady. Deputies: Hear, hear. An Ceann Comhairle: Allow the Minister to reply. Mr. Rabbitte: Why can the House not discuss the Barr report on Abbeylara, or the conclusions Mr. Cowen: As for the debate yesterday, I of the investigation on the Dean Lyons case? understand—— Why was no thought given to avoiding yester- day’s situation, when the House was meeting but Mr. Kenny: People were talking about Deputy had no business to conduct? The Minister for Johnny Brady in Oldcastle last night to Deputy Justice, Equality and Law Reform spoke last English. week about the new laws which were proposed to Mr. J. Brady: I have a farm there. allow the Government to shut down tribunals. It was reported that Government sources had made Mr. Cowen: I understand that no guillotine it clear that the Minister, Deputy McDowell, had motion was in force yesterday in the House. indicated the legislation was a priority for the Although Members had an opportunity to speak Department of Justice, Equality and Law on the agreed issues, the Opposition did not Reform. If it was a priority for the Department, appear to have much to say about it. why did it fall off the schedule yesterday and today? It is not on the schedule for next week, (Interruptions). although some other major business is planned that should last approximately half a day in each Mr. Durkan: The Government should arrange case. I understand the House will debate the the business of the House. Nuclear Test Ban Bill 2006, which decrees that “a person who carries out, or causes the carrying out An Ceann Comhairle: The Minister, without of, a nuclear explosion in the State shall be guilty interruption please. of an offence”.

Mr. Kenny: The Minister gave the longest An Ceann Comhairle: We cannot discuss next answer himself. week’s business now.

Mr. Cowen: It is not my problem if the Oppo- Mr. Howlin: We had better get back on our sition is unable to get anyone into the House to motorbikes quick. say a few words. An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Rabbitte has Mr. Ring: The Government muzzled us last made his point. week. Mr. Rabbitte: The new provisions will be Mr. Cowen: As for the legislation, it will be immensely reassuring to the public. Should we prepared as quickly as possible and will be presume it was not an offence up to now? brought before the Government for its approval. At present, the advice of the Attorney General An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Rabbitte, you is being sought by my Department. Hence, the Government will move on this matter quickly. have made your point.

Mr. Rabbitte: That was an extraordinary Mr. Brennan: It is important to clear it up. response from the Minister for Finance. The House collapsed last Thursday at 2.35 p.m. and Mr. Rabbitte: In certain cases, the District was not reconvened until 3.30 p.m. because of a Court may try the person charged with that lack of business. The House collapsed yesterday offence summarily. evening at 5.15 p.m. and could not reconvene until 7 p.m. Today, the House has a single An Ceann Comhairle: You have made your measure before it that probably will not occupy point. it beyond lunchtime. The pretence that the Oppo- sition orders the business of the House is com- Mr. Rabbitte: A Cheann Comhairle, one has to pletely transparent. The reason there is no legis- fill the time with something. lation, of course, is that the Government has been so preoccupied since the return of the Da´il with An Ceann Comhairle: It is not in order this saving its own skin that there is no legislation to morning, Deputy. The Chair has given you plenty put to the House. If the Government does not of latitude. 741 Order of 12 October 2006. Business 742

Mr. Rabbitte: What is going on over there? It in some of today’s business. That is a decision for is usual for a new Government with new and that party. That Bill needs to be dealt with. It is reforming legislative ideas to take some time at an old legacy from the rainbow Administration. I the outset of its time in office to put legislation heard it could not get agreement on the matter in place—— around the Cabinet table.

An Ceann Comhairle: You have made your Mr. O’Dea: Among other things. point, Deputy. Mr. Cowen: A few pro-nuclear people were Mr. Rabbitte: ——but this is an old, clapped- around at that time. The important point to make out and worn-out Government. is that Deputy Rabbitte——

An Ceann Comhairle: I ask the Deputy to Mr. Rabbitte: The Minister, Deputy McDowell, give way. must be going off again next week — that is the reason for the nuclear ban. Mr. Rabbitte: It is divided. Mr. Cowen: ——continues to stand up every Mr. D. Wallace: Speak for yourself. morning to talk about the botched privatisation Mr. Rabbitte: It is sundering before our eyes. of Aer Lingus. There has not been a botched pri- vatisation. An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Rabbitte, we cannot have an omnibus debate on the matter Mr. Howlin: Even investment bankers are call- this morning. ing it that now.

Mr. Rabbitte: Usually—— Mr. Cowen: A very successful initial public offering has taken place. Many IPOs have had to An Ceann Comhairle: Sorry, Deputy Rabbitte, be withdrawn over the last 12 months. Deputy I ask you to resume your seat. Rabbitte’s continuing attempt to characterise the IPO in this case as anything other than successful Mr. Rabbitte: What is going on over there? is simply not supported by the facts. It is important to point out that the business of the An Ceann Comhairle: I call the Minister for House can be proceeded with. It is a matter for Finance. the Whips at all times to decide what that busi- ness will be. Mr. Rabbitte: It is unbelievable. Mr. Howlin: The Government orders the Mr. O’Dea: The Deputy should look behind business. him. Mr. Gormley: I remind the Minister that the Mr. Ring: I knew the country was in safe hands Government produced just one speaker during when Deputy O’Dea was made Minister for one of the debates yesterday. Defence. An Ceann Comhairle: We are not having any Mr. O’Dea: I am looking at all the youthful more debate on that. The Deputy had an oppor- faces over there. tunity to offer if he wanted to when that was being discussed. Mr. Cowen: I note that Deputy Rabbitte has been energised by our 1-1 draw last night. Mr. Boyle: On a point of order, it was question- Mr. Durkan: We are surviving. answer, question-answer with both of the pre- vious speakers. Mr. Cowen: This House is getting through all its legislation very efficiently. An Ceann Comhairle: No.

Ms O’Sullivan: Some plans have been on hold Mr. Gormley: Yes. for the last five years. Mr. Boyle: Yes, it was. Mr. Cowen: Some 28 Bills have been enacted this year and a further 29 Bills have been passed. An Ceann Comhairle: No. This is the Order of It is a question of ordering the business. We have Business. That issue has been dealt with. If business to discuss today. I do not know how Members want to contribute on the same issue, many Opposition speakers there will be. Given they generally intimate that to the Chair—— the sort of parliamentary party it has, I expect the Labour Party will have far more interest in the Mr. Gormley: I did indicate, a Cheann Comh- Nuclear Test Ban Bill 2006 next week than it has airle, with respect. 743 Order of 12 October 2006. Business 744

An Ceann Comhairle: Sorry, Deputy Gormley, morning. The various conventions deal with I am not going to have an argument with you. important matters which need to be addressed. I am glad some people in the Labour Party do not Mr. Gormley: I do not want an argument. regard it as a matter of ridicule that international conventions should be ratified and discussed in An Ceann Comhairle: You will obey the rules. the House. I will seek to obtain the list required I am not going to debate them. by the Deputy. As he is aware, there have always been delays between the ratification and signing Mr. Gormley: Can I ask about the continuation of international conventions. The domestic busi- of the important debate on the Green Paper on ness of the House has taken precedence on many Energy? We had an opportunity to continue that occasions. I accept this matter has been of con- debate yesterday and we may have another tinuing interest to the Deputy. I will ask the rel- opportunity today. I would also like to ask about evant Departments to convey the current position a further important matter relating to climate to him. change, which is the biggest challenge faced by humanity. I refer to the carbon fund Bill. Mr. M. Higgins: I asked specifically about the Mr. Cowen: I understand the Whips discussed UN Convention against Corruption, as I have last night the possibility of proceeding with the been doing for about two years. debate on the Green Paper on Energy. I look for- ward to that debate taking place in the House. Mr. Cowen: I am not aware of the implications of the convention or the current position in that Mr. Boyle: Just two hours have been provided regard. for it over the last two weeks. Mr. M. Higgins: The Department of Justice, Mr. Cowen: The Whips have discussed it. I Equality and Law Reform has not even prepared understand there will be a continuing debate on the heads of the legislation needed to deal with that issue. That has been acceded to. the convention.

Mr. Gormley: I asked about the carbon fund Mr. Cowen: I will convey the position to the Bill but I did not get a reply. Deputy. I understand the Bill will not be intro- duced this year. Mr. Cowen: I understand the Bill will be intro- duced early next year. Mr. M. Higgins: It is listed for 2007. The heads of the Bill are not yet in place. Mr. Boyle: We will not see it until a full year after the budget. Mr. Cowen: It is listed for 2007.

Mr. M. Higgins: The White Paper on Irish Aid Mr. M. Higgins: It will not be ratified in the refers to the need for a debate in the parliamen- lifetime of this Government. tary assemblies of Europe on the issue of development. What arrangements are being Mr. Cowen: We will wait and see. We hope to made for a debate on the White Paper in this be here for quite some time in 2007 and there- House? The White Paper does not include a com- after. We can ratify the convention after the mitment to the UN Convention against Corrup- election. tion being ratified by Ireland. I want to save time in future by putting it to the Minister for Finance Mr. Durkan: Can the Minister shed some light now that he should give the House a list of the UN conventions which have been signed by on the development of the proposals in Ireland but not ratified. Is the Minister not con- Delivering Better Government? The proposals in cerned that the UN Convention against Corrup- question, like many other things, were included tion will not be ratified in the lifetime of this in the Fianna Fa´il manifesto at the last election. Government? Is he concerned that the White I am interested in how the proposals can be Paper on Irish Aid, which took such a long time squared with the recent substantial increase in the to produce, does not include a commitment to price of gas. passing the legislation needed to ratify the con- vention in the lifetime of the Government? Per- An Ceann Comhairle: That does not arise on haps the House will be given an assurance next the Order of Business. week as to whether the iodine tablets are out of date. Mr. Durkan: That increase was authorised at a time when the product was free on world Mr. Cowen: I agree with the Deputy that the markets. ratification of international conventions is important. The leader of his party ridiculed one An Ceann Comhairle: It does not arise on the such convention in his contribution earlier this Order of Business. 745 Order of 12 October 2006. Business 746

Mr. Durkan: I know the Minister is ready to An Ceann Comhairle: I call Deputy Dan give the answer. Boyle.

An Ceann Comhairle: I call Deputy Gilmore. Mr. Gilmore: I will start again at the beginning. There is a report from the Commission on Elec- Mr. Durkan: He is just shy. tronic Voting, which, as it happens is embarrass- ing for the Minister for Transport, Deputy An Ceann Comhairle: Sorry, Deputy. Cullen. When will this report be debated in this House, as is normal practice? Mr. Durkan: There is nothing wrong with that for him. Mr. Cowen: I do not know, offhand, when the report will be debated in the House or if it will An Ceann Comhairle: I ask the Deputy to be debated in the House. The Whips should allow Deputy Gilmore to speak. address the issue as that is their job. Mr. Durkan: I am asking about the minerals development Bill. It needs to be brought before Mr. Rabbitte: The Minister is head of Govern- the House so the Minister’s colleagues can give ment today. some indication of how this matter will be dealt with. Mr. Gilmore: Could the Minister make inquir- ies so that I can ask him again next week? Mr. Cowen: The minerals development Bill will be introduced in the middle of next year. If the Mr. Cowen: We will return to this issue. Deputy knows anywhere where we can get gas for nothing, he should give me a shout so I can Mr. Boyle: I wish to ask the Minister a number contact Bord Ga´is E´ ireann. of questions on legislation under the Order of Business. Will the Bord na gCon (amendment) Mr. O’Donoghue: The Deputy knows a fair bit Bill give effect to the recommendations of the about gas. recent Dalton report and when is it likely to be published? Has the privacy Bill been approved by (Interruptions). Cabinet and where is it listed in the Govern- ment’s legislative programme? The Citizens’ Mr. Durkan: It was free on the world market. Information Bill is meant to be published today; is there any indication of when there will be a Mr. Gilmore: When I asked the Minister for debate on that Bill? Will it be before Christmas? Finance last week about the possibility of having The final piece of legislation about which I wish a debate in the House on the report of the Com- to inquire is the Curragh of Kildare Bill. It is in mission on Electronic Voting, the Minister kindly section A on the pink sheets of the Government’s agreed and indicated the Whips would arrange it. legislative programme, where it has been for four years. Mr. O’Donoghue: He did not — that is the problem. Mr. Cowen: The Curragh of Kildare Bill will be dealt with during this session and I am really Mr. Gilmore: Can the Minister indicate today looking forward to it. The privacy Bill will be when the debate will take place in the House? dealt with in the Seanad and the Citizens’ Infor- mation Bill will be published tomorrow and taken Mr. Cowen: The Deputy is a gas man — I did in the House in the coming weeks. not agree to that at all. Mr. Rabbitte: It will be published today, Mr. Gilmore: The Minister agreed to it. actually. Mr. Cowen: No, I did not. Mr. Cowen: I am very interested in the Bord Mr. Gilmore: He said it would be referred to na gCon (amendment) Bill and it will be dealt the Whips. with next year.

Mr. Cowen: No. Mr. Boyle: Will that be early or late next year?

Mr. Gilmore: What would be the point of refer- Mr. Cowen: Some time next year. If the ring it to the Whips? Deputy knows of any fast greyhounds he can give me a shout. Mr. Cowen: That does not mean I agreed to anything. Mr. Ring: Is there any hope of having a debate in this House on decentralisation? Does the Mini- Mr. Gilmore: Now we know what the Whips ster remember that this was promised some years are for. ago? The only decentralisation I have seen is in 747 Order of 12 October 2006. Business 748

[Mr. Ring.] Mr. Costello: Have the heads of the immi- jobs in the Department of Agriculture and Food gration and residence Bill been approved by taken from my county. Cabinet and is it intended to publish this Bill before the end of term? An Ceann Comhairle: To what legislation is Deputy Ring referring? Mr. Cowen: The heads were approved in September and the Bill will be published next Mr. Ring: When will there be a debate on year. decentralisation now that a such a botch has been made of the whole matter? Mr. Crawford: When will the sale of alcohol Bill be brought before the House to allow us dis- Mr. Durkan: It is another botch job. cuss the ongoing problems in that area? The fines Bill is on the pink sheets. We were promised a An Ceann Comhairle: This does not arise on Bill on the enforcement of fines between 12 and the Order of Business. 18 months ago, yet gardaı´ are still out collecting fines. Mr. Ring: Of course it arises on the Order of Business. Mr. Cowen: It is not possible to say when the Mr. S. Ryan: We have agreed the Order of enforcement of fines Bill will be taken. The sale Business for today and there is no backup Bill. of alcohol Bill will be taken early in the next The wrong message will go out if—— session.

An Ceann Comhairle: That has already been Mr. Rabbitte: Yesterday a Minister of State discussed and it does not arise on the Order of made a serious allegation in an early morning Business. interview against an institution established by the State. Mr. S. Ryan: Will the Ceann Comhairle allow me to finish my point? An Ceann Comhairle: That does not arise on the Order of Business. An Ceann Comhairle: It is almost 11 a.m. and at least four of the Deputy’s colleagues wish to Mr. Rabbitte: The last time a Minister of State speak. I would like to facilitate them, although it gave such an interview he fell asleep on the tele- may not be possible. phone. Does the Minister plan to keep Ministers of State away from early morning interviews or is Mr. Rabbitte: The Deputy is trying to be there anything we can do to contain them? helpful. An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Rabbitte is out Mr. S. Ryan: I have a relevant point to make. of order and I ask him to resume his seat.

An Ceann Comhairle: If the Deputy’s point is Mr. McEntee: Do those in the health service relevant we will hear it. and the Minister for Health and Children realise that last Monday in Our Lady of Lourdes Mr. S. Ryan: On the need for a backup Bill Hospital, Drogheda, which has been declared a for today—— hospital of excellence in the north east, GPs in the area —— An Ceann Comhairle: That is not relevant, we have moved past that issue at this point. An Ceann Comhairle: That does not arise on Mr. S. Ryan: I ask the Minister for Finance to the Order of Business. Has the Deputy a question facilitate a debate on Aer Lingus as a backup. on legislation?

An Ceann Comhairle: That does not arise on Mr. McEntee: The blood testing service has the Order of Business. We are moving on to the been closed down. The outpatients’ physio- next piece of business and the Deputy must therapy unit has been closed down. Yesterday the resume his seat. Taoiseach called on people ——

Mr. S. Ryan: Will the Minister avail of the An Ceann Comhairle: I ask Deputy McEntee opportunity to debate Aer Lingus and clarify the to resume his seat. This is the Order of Business situation there? and the Chair is happy to read the Standing Order for the benefit of Members. This is not an An Ceann Comhairle: I ask Deputy Ryan to omnibus Question Time on a Thursday. The resume his seat as he is out of order. I ask him to Chair tries to facilitate as many Members as pos- show respect to his colleagues and also to the sible but if Members ramble on aimlessly, this Chair. cannot be done. 749 Order of 12 October 2006. Business 750

Mr. McEntee: I would like to know who is Waterford application. When is it intended to responsible. enact sections 55 to 62 of the Local Government Act 2001? This provides for the establishment of Mr. Howlin: We have enough time to facili- a local government commission to deal with the tate everyone. aforementioned issue.

An Ceann Comhairle: We will not spend the Mr. Cowen: I will have to return to the Deputy entire day on the Order of Business. on that question as I do not have the relevant information. Ms O’Sullivan: I think I am in order because the Bill I wish to raise, the third level students Mr. Kehoe: When will the education mis- support Bill, has been on the Government’s legis- cellaneous provisions Bill be published? lative programme for a number of years, is very urgent and could have filled in time yesterday and Mr. Cowen: This session. today. Parents who obeyed the Government and opened special savings incentive accounts, SSIAs, Dr. Cowley: On legislation concerning access are now being punished in terms of their chil- to public services, there are ill old people who dren’s eligibility for third level grants. The legis- cannot get transport to hospital—— lation has been lingering for years. Has it been agreed by Cabinet and when will it be debated in An Ceann Comhairle: We cannot debate what this House? Will it address the problem of might be in the legislation. To what Bill is the parents being punished for opening SSIAs? Deputy referring?

Mr. Cowen: The heads were approved in July Dr. Cowley: To finish on that point, old people and it should be taken during this session. The cannot even get enough money to stay in a Minister for Education and Science dealt with private nursing home—— this matter adequately. An Ceann Comhairle: What legislation is the Mr. Rabbitte: What about SSIAs? Deputy talking about? \ An Ceann Comhairle: That does not arise on Dr. Cowley: The difficulty is that 675,000 has the Order of Business. If Deputy Rabbitte wishes been spent over the past ten days doing Shell’s me to read out Standing Order 26, I will. I ask business in Bellanaboy. him to give way to his colleague in the Labour An Ceann Comhairle: We will proceed to No. Party, Deputy Brian O’Shea. 1, the Investment Funds, Companies and Mis- Mr. Rabbitte: What of parents who have taken cellaneous Provisions Bill 2006. out SSIAs? Dr. Cowley: That is a disgrace.

An Ceann Comhairle: This does not arise on An Ceann Comhairle: I call the Minister of the Order of Business. I suggest Deputy Rabbitte State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and submit a question to the line Minister in relation Employment, Deputy Michael Ahern, to move to the subject. He cannot come into this House that the Bill be now read a Second Time. and ride roughshod over Standing Orders. Deputy Rabbitte is out of order and I ask him to (Interruptions). allow his colleague to make a contribution. An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Cowley is out Mr. Rabbitte: Does it arise that parents who of order. opened SSIAs will be penalised in terms of grants for their college-going children because they Dr. Cowley: Shell is making \3 million every accepted the offer of Government regarding hour in profit. these accounts? An Ceann Comhairle: Will the Deputy allow An Ceann Comhairle: Deputy Rabbitte is out the Minister of State to proceed? of order; he knows the rules like everyone else. Dr. Cowley: The money should be used for Mr. Rabbitte: The Government is befuddled hospital services—— and confused, as usual. An Ceann Comhairle: I ask Deputy Cowley to Mr. Cowen: The Government is anything but allow the Minister of State, who has been called, befuddled and confused. to proceed.

Mr. O’Shea: I wish to raise the matter of appli- Dr. Cowley: ——instead of subsidising Shell, cations by local authorities for borough boundary which is making \3 million every hour. It is dis- extensions and I have a particular interest in the graceful. 751 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 752

Investment Funds, Companies and based, regulated, globalised and environmentally Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 [Seanad]: sustainable economy. Second Stage. Dublin today is recognised as a global centre for securitisation. It is ranked only second to Minister of State at the Department of London and ahead of Frankfurt in terms of asset- Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Mr. M. backed securities. The aggregate amount of asset- Ahern): I move: “That the Bill be now read a backed securities investments, managed by Second Time.” Dublin-based investors, has experienced con- This amending legislation responds to a siderable growth in recent years. In 1999, the number of issues, some of which have been raised aggregate amount of asset-backed securities by industry as matters of concern for Irish com- investments was around \6 billion. This grew to panies. In particular, the develop- between \30 billion and \35 billion in 2003 and 11 o’clock ment and growth of the securitisation today the figure is at least \80 billion. These fig- industry, which has enormous poten- ures demonstrate the position and importance of tial, has been placed at a significant disadvantage securitisation in terms of the domestic economy by the reluctance of insurers to underwrite risks and the tremendous strides made in recent times. that their international competitors would not be The strong track record that Ireland has similarly required to undertake. The provision on developed in the asset-backed securities sector is dematerialisation is necessary to allow Irish com- a result of many factors. These include a con- panies to continue to compete in international ducive business environment, a common law markets, thereby allowing us to maintain our system and the presence of skilled personnel with competitiveness in key areas where it has been considerable international experience. All of established. The need to increase the audit these factors, together with Government support, exemption threshold for companies also requires have fuelled the growth I have described. priority treatment. Existing developments in securitisation afford In addition, key provisions are included to us the potential to develop as a primary centre allow for the smooth and effective transposition for specialist debt-financing products. Business of the EU transparency directive which deals with regulation in the field of company law feeds into the disclosure of information by certain listed improvements to our national competitiveness, companies on an ongoing basis. This directive is through high standards of corporate governance, due to be transposed by January 2007. and brings about a stable and predictable envir- Provisions are also included relating to the onment in which entrepreneurs can establish amendment of the Irish Takeover Panel Act businesses, investors can invest, creditors can 1997. Some of these provisions are consequent on lend and the interests of the employees, con- the transposition of the EU takeovers directive sumers and other stakeholders are protected. on 20 May last in line with the EU target date. Ireland’s economic future is inextricably bound It is necessary to amend the Consumer Infor- up with the global economy through investment, mation Act 1978 to allow for the appointment of trade, people and business generally. We must be a person to perform the functions of the Director at the top of the game in every aspect that of Consumer Affairs for a period of more than affects competitiveness. six months. The need for this arises as a result of I will now turn to the provisions of the Bill and the resignation of the previous incumbent and in explain in greater detail what each is designed to order to allow the functions of the director to achieve. Part 1 of the Bill, which covers sections 1 to 5, contains some preliminary technical matters, continue to be carried out by a temporary including the commencement of the legislation, appointee until the National Consumer Agency is interpretation, the making of orders and regu- established on a statutory basis. lations and how parts of the Bill will relate to the In summary, the amendments proposed in this existing Companies Acts. Bill are designed to facilitate business develop- Part 2, which covers sections 6 to 8 of the Bill, ment, copperfasten our competitiveness in key provides for various amendments to company sectors where it has been developed and ease the law legislation. regulatory burden on business while facilitating Section 6 amends section 32 of the Companies the giving of full effect to EU directives we (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 1999 to increase the must transpose. audit exemption limits for turnover and balance Ireland is now a modern, highly globalised, sheet totals, which will allow more companies to credibly regulated, competitive economy. We avail of the audit exemption. need to ensure we retain our attractiveness as a Exemption from audit removes the need for place to do business and as a location for foreign companies to engage an independent, external direct investment vis-a`-vis competitor juris- auditor and is allowed under EU law since 1978. dictions. Audit exemption was introduced in Ireland in We will achieve this objective by committing February 2000 under Part III of the Companies ourselves to fostering the conditions which sup- (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 1999. The provision in port enterprise and in meeting the challenges and this Bill increases the turnover limit to \7.3 mil- opportunities of an increasingly knowledge- lion and the balance sheet total limit to \3.65 mil- 753 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 754 lion. The existing thresholds are \1.5 million and As many Irish equities are listed on both the \1.9 million, respectively. Irish and UK markets, it is desirable from an Irish The background to this initiative is that, in July perspective that dematerialisation is implemented 2005, a small business forum to was set up to con- in as similar a manner as possible in both sider the environment in which small businesses markets. The Irish market generally is keen to operate in Ireland. Among the topics the forum ensure that Ireland responds appropriately and examined was the current level of audit exemp- immediately so that it is in line with best inter- tion allowable in Ireland. Its examination focused national practice. Failure to progress this issue on the disparity between the turnover threshold will be a competitive disadvantage to the Irish in Ireland of \1.5 million and that in the UK and market in an increasingly harmonised European a number of other member states where it was securities market. Both retail and professional pitched at the EU maximum permissible thres- investors in the Irish equity market would directly hold of \7.3 million. It reasoned that increasing experience the benefits of dematerialisation. our audit exemption threshold to \7.3 million The removal of share certificates from the Irish would bring Ireland into line with its nearest com- equity market is a strategic imperative in order to petitor and a number of member states, and this meet the best practice benchmarks of the global formed the basis for one of the recommendations market. Dematerialisation will facilitate ease and in its report of April 2006. speed of trading by investors; enhance the inter- I am most anxious that the new thresholds national competitiveness of Ireland for securities should be available to companies for the financial trading; reduce the current costs associated with year beginning on 1 January 2007. However, one the cumbersome process of managing paper- will note from the text of the measure that a mini- based transactions; and avoid the risk of the mum two-month gap has been provided for escalation of the current settlement costs for Irish certificated transactions, which would occur if between commencement of the provision and the there was a successful implementation of dema- financial year in which it can take effect. This terialisation of UK securities, with share certifi- delay has been inserted to allow for a stipulated cates still remaining for Irish securities. minimum minority of shareholders to object to a The European Commission’s financial services company availing of the audit exemption. With action plan is the legislative backdrop to a con- the provision as drafted at present, and given how siderable amount of change fundamentally close we are to the end of the year, it is unlikely impacting the operation of securities markets. that the Bill could be enacted in sufficient time to One of the core themes of the next phase of the enable companies to avail of the new exemption European Commission’s policy drive is clearing thresholds for the financial year beginning on 1 and settlement. In order to prosper in this chang- January 2007. ing global environment, markets need to continu- Rather than simply accepting this, I have asked ally critically assess and develop their offerings to officials of my Department to re-examine the ensure they are meeting the demands of their measure to determine whether it could be refined customers. in such a way as to make it capable of being Dematerialisation has already taken place in availed of from the desired date. As a result, a many other countries such as France, Denmark, formula that I hope will achieve this objective is Sweden, Italy, India, Australia and New Zealand. being worked on and it will, I hope, form the I understand it is being considered in the UK, basis of an amendment to address this issue on Belgium, the Netherlands, Spain and the US. It is Committee Stage. important to reiterate that dematerialisation will Section 7 amends section 239 of the 1990 Act not impact in any way on the legal ownership to allow the Minister to provide by regulations rights of shareholders, as those who currently for the introduction of mandatory dematerialis- hold shares in certificated form and who are on a ation of securities of listed or unlisted PLCs. share register will continue to hold securities on Dematerialisation is an electronic system to the share register in their own name. Share- replace paper share certificates and stock transfer holders will also continue to retain the right to forms. These will be replaced by a paper share- receive information that is currently provided to holder statement and shareholder reference those whose names appear on the share register number. The provision also allows the regulations of the company, such as annual reports and cor- to provide for any necessary consequential pro- porate action information as well as dividends. visions to implement this requirement. Securities This information will continue to be provided markets worldwide are undergoing significant directly by the company, or its registrar, to the changes as to the manner in which transactions shareholder. are processed with a view to providing a more Section 8 amends section 43 of the 2005 Act efficient and harmonised processing of securities relating to prospectuses in order to limit the obli- transactions. An extensive consultation carried gations of a guarantor in respect of statements out by the Irish Stock Exchange in late 2004 included in, or omitted from, a prospectus relat- established that dematerialisation should be pur- ing to non-equity securities, apart from those that sued as a matter of priority for the Irish equity relate to the guarantor or the guarantee. This market. amendment is designed to address an issue which 755 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 756

[Mr. M. Ahern.] Sections 15 and 16 amend section 2 of the Irish is causing great concern for the securitisation Takeover Panel Act 1997. Under section 2 of the industry. The current wording of the law relating Irish Takeover Panel Act as originally enacted, to prospectuses which was introduced last year the provisions applied to companies whose has created a potential liability for financial securities were quoted on markets regulated by a guarantee insurers known as “monoline recognised stock exchange. The Irish Stock insurers”. This has resulted in the monoline Exchange was the only prescribed recognised industry advising issuers that it is not willing to stock exchange. Moreover, the focus of the Act insure their products listed in, or issued out of, was on securities that gave the holders voting Ireland. Business lost to other jurisdictions as a rights — that is, enabled them to effectively con- result of this will be difficult to attract back, so trol a company. By virtue of the Irish Takeover swift action is required to deal with this situation. Panel Act 1997 (Relevant Company) Regulations Part 3 covers sections 9 to 14 of the Bill. It con- 2001, SI 87 of 2001, Irish companies whose securi- tains provisions designed to facilitate the smooth ties were not listed on the Irish Stock Exchange, and effective transposition of the EU trans- but were listed on a number of specified foreign parency directive. The directive applies to certain markets, were brought within the scope of the listed companies, those whose securities are Irish Takeover Panel. The 2001 regulations admitted to trading on a regulated market, and is applied in respect of companies which, while no due to be transposed into Irish law by January longer being listed on any of these markets, had 2007. The transparency directive will raise the been listed on any one of them in the previous quality of information available to investors on five years. In view of the fact that the focus of the companies’ performance and financial positions Irish Takeover Panel Act is on those securities as well as on changes in major shareholdings. This that give effective control over the affairs of a should contribute to better investor protection, company, as represented by the holding of securi- enhanced investor confidence and a better func- ties carrying voting rights, and as the Financial tioning of European capital markets. The pro- Services Funds Industry has increasingly used the visions of Part 3 mirror similar provisions company structure as one of its entities of choice included in the Investment Funds, Companies in developing investment projects, principally and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 2005 in connec- through the issue and listing of debt securities, tion with the transposition of the market abuse where the control of the company through voting and prospectus directives last year. Section 9pro- rights is not an issue, section 75 of the Investment vides for definitions used in Part 3. Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions Section 10 gives the Minister power to make Act 2005 exempted such companies from the regulations to give effect to the transparency remit of the Irish Takeover Panel, but only in so directive and any other supplemental measures. far as they were listed on the market operated by Regulations to implement the transparency the Irish Stock Exchange. These provisions make directive are being prepared. However, certain similar changes in respect of debt securities lis- provisions must be made in primary law. Section tings on the markets brought in by the 2001 regu- 11 provides for penalties on conviction on indict- lations. These provisions were inserted on Com- ment for offences under Irish transparency law. mittee Stage in the Seanad. Section 12 gives the Financial Regulator, who Section 17 amends section 8 of the Irish Take- is being designated competent authority for pur- over Act 1997 to allow the Takeover Panel to poses of the directive, the power to make sup- make provision in its rules to give effect to EU plementary rules to allow the regulator to fulfil law in this area. The need for this amendment to his or her role as competent authority. be made in primary law only arose quite recently Section 13 amends the Central Bank Act 1942, in the context of the transposition of the EU as amended, to include the transparency directive takeovers directive which came into effect on 20 in the list of directives which the Central Bank May 2006. The Takeover Panel, which has been and Financial Regulator have responsibility to designated as the competent authority for pur- enforce. This deals with confidentiality of infor- poses of the directive, already has the power to mation obtained by the competent authority and make rules under section 8 of the Irish Takeover effectively prohibits its disclosure except by vir- Panel Act 1997. This power is not, however, wide tue of Irish transparency law. enough to enable the panel to make rules directly Section 14 provides that the Minister may, by to give effect to changes in this area arising from order, cite the markets to which transparency law the takeovers directive, and such power must be shall apply. It is important that requirements provided separately and in primary law, to reflect under the transparency directive be capable of a number of judicial decisions of recent years. being applied to markets outside the scope of the Section 18 amends the Schedule to the Irish directive, for example the Irish Enterprise Takeover Panel Act 1997 to align the general Exchange market, and to any new market that principles in the Schedule to the 1997 Act with may be established in the future. those of the takeover bids directive as transposed Part 4, which covers sections 15 to 21 deals with in Regulation 7 of SI 255 of 2006, except for the miscellaneous amendments to the Takeover Substantial Acquisition of Securities General Panel and Consumer Information Acts. Principles, which is being retained. The objective 757 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 758 here is to have one set of general principles to Ms O. Mitchell: I move: “That the Bill be taken apply to all the transactions comprehended in the in Private Members’ time.” 1997 Act. Section 19 is a consequential provision to Question put and agreed to. sections 15 and 16. It revokes the 2001 regulations I mentioned earlier and was inserted on Commit- Investment Funds, Companies and tee Stage in the Seanad. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 [Seanad]: Section 20 is a consequential provision on Second Stage (Resumed). section 18. It amends regulation 7 of SI 255 of 2006 — the regulations which transposed the Question again proposed: “That the Bill be general principles of the Takeover Bids Directive. now read a Second Time.” The purpose of the amendment is to effectively Mr. Hogan: Fine Gael will support this Bill. repeal the general principles in regulation 7, as This is important legislation in the context of the these will be reflected in the amended Schedule issues the Minister of State alluded to, partic- in section 18, and to remove any confusion which ularly regarding the dematerialisation of security may be caused by the existence of two sets of certification. This has become an issue in recent general principles. times, with particular reference to our relation- Section 21 amends the Consumer Information ship with Britain. I am conscious that this is an Act 1978 by repealing section 9(11)(b). The urgent issue. The Bill also deals with the trans- amendment is required to allow for the appoint- position of an EU directive on transparency and ment of a person to perform the functions of the takeovers. The Bill gives us an opportunity to Director of Consumer Affairs for a period of assess where we stand on investment, consumer more than six months. The need for this arises as law and the health and well-being of our compan- a result of the resignation of the previous incum- ies. Today’s economic climate is excellent. All the bent and to allow the functions of the director to economic growth indicators are solid. We have continue to be carried out by a temporary warnings from time to time from the usual appointee until the National Consumer Agency is sources such as the Central Bank and the established on a statutory basis. ESRI—— The Government is committed to supporting industry by responding in an appropriate way to Minister of State at the Department of the new challenges which are presented by this Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Mr. M. ever-changing global marketplace. The Bill is evi- Ahern): And Jim Power. dence of this commitment and I commend it to the House. Mr. Hogan: The Government has its own econ- omist, Dan McLaughlin, but he does not warn Debate adjourned. people.

Road Traffic (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill Mr. M. Ahern: He does a good job and gets 2006: First Stage. it right. An Ceann Comhairle: If the House is agree- Mr. Hogan: They are all going okay. The able, we will now take a Private Members’ Bill National Competitiveness Council, which the proposal that would normally be taken on the Government should heed because it is its own Order of Business. organisation——

Ms O. Mitchell: I thank the Ceann Comhairle Mr. M. Ahern: It is an independent body. for facilitating me. I move: That leave be granted to introduce a Bill Mr. Hogan: It is an independent group that entitled an Act to amend and extend the Road meets from time to time to assess our perform- Traffic Acts 1961 to 2006 and to provide for ance. The Taoiseach and the then Ta´naiste were the indexation of fines for road traffic offences. warned in December 2001 that Ireland was becoming a high cost location for business. The electoral cycle intervened in 2002 and the issues An Ceann Comhairle: Is the Bill opposed? that were raised have not been addressed. In recent years, the solution for dealing with matters Minister of State at the Department of of direct and indirect cost problems in the econ- Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Mr. M. omy was to establish a regulator. No matter Ahern): No. where the problem was in the economy, regu- lators were established under the guise of enhanc- Question put and agreed to. ing competition. Regulators have failed for one reason: no pol- An Ceann Comhairle: Since this is a Private itical perspective or direction has been given to Members’ Bill, Second Stage must, under Stand- them. It should have been given to them on their ing Orders, be taken in Private Members’ time. establishment so that they understand it is not 759 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 760

[Mr. Hogan.] The level of personal indebtedness is at a just a matter of bringing new players into the record high. We have moved from having a high market, but also ensuring that it does not grant national debt to having a high level of personal increases in prices across the public utilities and indebtedness. Citizens are still in debt, in an irres- local government charges on top of the existing ponsible way according to the Central Bank. The high cost base. role and function of the Central Bank needs to We need to assess where we are going with the be called into question if it is going to allow itself regulators that have been appointed and the to be drawn into a debate about the fact that it policy remit that has been given to them. We do has done nothing towards meeting the policy not need to look any further than the recent objectives regularly enunciated by the Governor. activities of the Commission For Energy Regu- The increase in the cost base of the economy lation. It has sanctioned 34% and 20% increases caused by the indirect taxes and charges imposed in gas and electricity prices respectively. At a by the Government since 2002 has been over the time when wholesale prices on the oil markets are top. VAT was increased by 1% in the first budget going down, these price increases have been sug- after the 2002 general election. The Government gested. The ordinary business consumer cannot also applied a 9% stamp duty rate, up from 6%, understand it. The manner in which the CER on commercial transactions in that budget. I makes its calculations often uses a historical cost know substantial revenue has been raised by this, base. but people have to trade and do business. They The Minister for Communications, Marine and must now factor this into their costs. Enormous Natural Resource, Deputy Noel Dempsey, stands sums of money are required to keep small busi- idly by and sees no necessity to meet with the nesses going. In addition to those issues, the inac- CER and seek to understand the rationale for tivity of regulators in introducing new competi- approving these price increases. I ask the Minister tors to the market and reducing costs has been of State to convey this view to the CER. I do not striking. mind if he does so directly or indirectly. This I have been critical of the Competition Auth- House is not satisfied that the establishment of ority for some time. It exposed its own a Commission for Energy Regulation has been ineffectiveness as recently as this week when it successful from the perspective of the consumer allowed the Statoil takeover to take place by let- or the economy as a whole. ting the time in which it had to make a submission We were told that we would have to raise expire. That is disgraceful action by the Compe- energy prices in order to encourage other firms tition Authority. Has the Minister called in the to compete with the ESB in the provision of elec- new chairman, Mr. Prasifka, and his team to find tricity generation. What kind of logic is that? At out the reason that happened? That action has a time when small business people must be con- effectively created a monopoly in petrol station scious of the competition they endure from outlets in this jurisdiction. There are many eastern Europe and the Far East, our policy gives examples of companies being put through the rig- the regulator a free hand to increase costs irres- ours of the law by the Competition Authority for pective of properly explaining the necessity for what appears, on the face of it, less dominance in this to either the Government or the public. We the marketplace. What is in place now is effec- require a trigger mechanism, politically as well as tively a monopoly in terms of the sale of petrol in economically, for the Government to deal with forecourts throughout the country. The authority this issue. stands indicted on that matter and it should be The Central Bank regularly preaches about the deeply embarrassed about it. high level of personal indebtedness of our citi- In conjunction with my colleague, Deputy zens. It talks of the irresponsible nature of people Lynch, I intend to invite representatives from the in taking 100% interest only loans from the authority to the next meeting of the Oireachtas associated banks and building societies. The Cen- committee to ask them what went wrong, what tral Bank could do something about this in the they are doing about it and what resources they morning if it wished. In conjunction with IFSRA, require, if resources are an issue, to keep up with the Central Bank is the supervisory authority for the takeover issues mentioned, even throughout dealing with the associated banks. The Central this Bill. Perhaps we should amend the legislation Bank and the Department of Finance set down in that context to ensure nothing like that hap- banking policy. The Governor of the Central pens again, notwithstanding the incompetence of Bank regularly lectures on the dangers of holding the Competition Authority on this occasion. high levels of personal debt. If there is, as The Internal Market has enormous potential expected, a further 1% rise in interest rates from for Irish consumers. As an island nation, we are the ECB, what impact will this have on dispos- on the periphery of Europe but consumers here able household income? If the Central Bank is do not get the benefits of bulk purchasing, buying so concerned about the irresponsibility of these or selling available to consumers on the mainland practices, why has it not done something about of Europe. It is critical that the Commissioner, it? This would ensure a soft landing if there were Mr. McCreevy, takes every opportunity, with the to be changes in the construction or property necessary support and impetus of the Govern- sectors. ment, to implement the trans-frontier trading and 761 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 762

Internal Market services that can be provided ies do not see the difference between North and much more freely than is available currently to South of Ireland and Luxembourg or any of the us. If the Internal Market is brought to its logical countries in Europe. They see Europe as the conclusion, it will create difficulties, but it will set location and we must be ever vigilant of making up consumers for a bonanza and it is up to Irish the necessary changes and be adaptable to ensure business, and the Government through its policy, we have a strong financial services sector here. to ensure we are competitive. It is a challenge, The Government must be conscious of that and I realise some vested countries here will not aspect. want that, but if we are serious about keeping On consumer protection, I have been critical of prices down for consumers and business, we must the Government about the lack of consumer take action in the Internal Market. Commissioner policy in recent years. The Minister, Deputy McCreevy has promoted the concept of complet- Martin, decided belatedly that the National Con- ing the Internal Market in a number of areas as sumer Agency should be established on an quickly as possible. He deserves the full support interim basis. He took his time about doing that of this House in realising the potential for small because he did not appreciate the urgency of it. businesses and consumers. The previous Ta´naiste and Minister for On the audit exemption, as the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy State is aware, I tabled an amendment in that Harney, did not see the need for it. regard in previous legislation and it was voted down. I am glad the Government has changed its Ms Lynch: Shop around. mind and brought into line our own audit exemp- tion thresholds with our neighbours in Northern Mr. Hogan: In an open market it is fine, in Ireland and in the United Kingdom in particular. theory, to say we must shop around but Irish con- The Minister of State will be aware from his pre- sumers are in a small market, often in areas vious profession that there is substantial leakage where there is not much choice, particularly rural of business from this jurisdiction into Northern areas where the question of shopping around Ireland because of the failure to implement the does not arise. If we are talking about the basic issue of increasing audit exemption thresholds. basket of goods on which people must survive on When I proposed such an amendment on Com- a day-to-day basis, the Government’s policy of mittee Stage of the Companies Bill, the then abolishing the groceries order was welcome but Ta´naiste, Deputy Harney, appeared not to fully what it put in its place was critical. The Compan- understand the leakage of business that was tak- ies (Amendment) Act did not address the issues ing place. I am glad the Minister of State has now that would have ensured that the pockets of con- rectified that matter and brought it into line in sumers benefited from whatever competition terms of the competitive area in respect of those came into the food sector. services, namely, the British and Irish markets. The Government’s policy has put more money The role of financial services in this jurisdiction into the pockets of the large multinational com- has been enormous. I add my support and con- panies and the major supermarkets at the gratulations to the efforts made to make the Irish expense of small suppliers and consumers. We financial services sector in Dublin one of the lead- have not seen the benefits of the notional figure ing such sectors in Europe and the world. The trotted out by the then chairman of the Compe- number of well-paid, good quality jobs that have tition Authority, Dr. Fingleton, that there would been created in Dublin arose from the foresight be an annual saving of \500, on average, per in the late 1980s of the former Taoiseach, the late household. That was nonsense but, unfortunately, Charles Haughey, who did not get sufficient cre- the Government accepted his view without any dit for it. Nevertheless, the support of the finan- analysis in terms of how that laudable objective cial sector in bringing the necessary hedge fund would be achieved. We are all in the business of companies into the financial services area has not trying to ensure that customers have the highest only benefited financial services in Dublin, but possible disposable income and that they are not there has been a trickle of employment into the ripped off, but a theoretical notion of how that various regions arising from the financial services might be achieved was advanced by the Compe- dynamic created by that initiative. In my constitu- tition Authority and the Minister of the day ency and that of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, accepted it without question. there is an important employer, State Street Legislation must be introduced to ensure that International, which now employs up to 400 the rebates and discounts available now to the people in the city of Kilkenny. That is just one large suppliers with financial muscle in this juris- example of the considerable progress that has diction in terms of the purchase of food products been made in bringing some modicum of financial are passed on to consumers rather than pocketed services employment and understanding of this in higher profits. One multiple has boasted that it complex area into the regions. offers significant grocery price cuts on products We cannot be complacent about these issues, previously covered by the groceries order, but it however, because there is keen competition from did not highlight the increases on products not Belfast and Luxembourg. If foreign direct invest- covered by the groceries order. The overall ment is coming to this jurisdiction, those compan- budget available to the Irish consumer means that 763 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 764

[Mr. Hogan.] members. There are too many examples of misap- prices have increased by an average of 10% in propriation of money. This Investment Funds, the past year. That is because the Government Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill would not listen to the advice it got on the issue provides an opportunity to reflect on whether we from many quarters, including Members of this have sufficient protection and information for House who sit on the Government benches. consumers. For the people involved this may be The Minister should consider amending the a very important investment decision and may Companies Act to ensure greater transparency in have a major impact on how they retire. the food sector and in price sensitive areas gener- Fine Gael supports this legislation and under- ally that are important to the household budget. stands the valid reasons why the Government is We should amend the Companies Act to ensure bringing it before the Houses. I will table some transparency in turnover and profitability on the amendments, to which I have referred. I hope this big multiples here. That was a recommendation legislation will provide an opportunity to demon- in the report of the Joint Committee on strate to the Irish people that the Competition Enterprise and Small Business which was not Authority is awake to the consequences for con- implemented. This legislation provides another sumers of investment funds and takeover bids. It opportunity to do so in order to know whether will not stand idly by and allow such matters to the price strategies of these companies are con- occur without regulation. We also have a review tributing to higher profits at the expense of the of regulators, who regulate on behalf of the coun- consumer. We know the companies’ turnover in try, its citizens and customers and not on behalf this jurisdiction, as well as the turnover of some of vested interests. private companies which are not obliged to release this information. From the information Ms Lynch: Before the debate Deputy Hogan they release we can see the pricing areas on which told me he would not speak for very long. He we must focus in the interest of consumers. feels passionately about this matter and has Another area of consumer protection is the something most worthwhile to say that takes lack of information given to clients purchasing longer than five minutes to express. investment products. As an accountant, the Mini- ster of State is aware of the plethora of policy Mr. M. Ahern: He spoke a lot but did not speak proposals, including life policies or investment for very long on the Bill. intermediary products, available to consumers. Little information is available to consumers Mr. Hogan: It is a miscellaneous provisions before they sign on the dotted line and begin pay- Bill. ing the premium, which is frustrating for them. As a former insurance intermediary, I was always Ms Lynch: His contribution was of enormous conscious of the lack of information available to interest to every consumer and for that he should people who were not brought up in the culture be congratulated. of understanding investment, the stock exchange, The Labour Party is broadly supportive of the equity investment and other factors that make up Investment Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous the return one should receive as suggested by the Provisions Bill in so far as it is intended to resolve sales pitch. Insufficient information is provided anomalies in company law and implement rela- and insurance companies should be required to tively minor, yet significant, changes to the legal give further information to clients on investment framework in which business must be conducted. and to be transparent in explanations. Funds may This is a technical Bill and the real detail must be perform well or badly and there is a minimum scrutinised closely on Committee Stage. and maximum return on a fund, depending on As with all modern economies, it is vital that performance. At a time when people have money we work to ensure our corporate legislative to spend and as many SSIAs will be maturing framework can keep pace with the changes in shortly we must work to make more investment business practice and keep Ireland competitive information available to clients. The differences on world markets. The Labour Party also wel- between products are confusing and there may be comes the transposition by this Bill of the EU hidden charges of which banking institutions or transparency and takeovers directives, about building societies are not fully informing which I will speak in more detail later. customers. Analysis is required by IFSRA to The potential of the sections of this Bill dealing demonstrate the difference between products so with the securitisation industry is important. The people can compare them and not be exposed to securitisation industry is a major sector of inter- risk or hidden charges. national financial business, and our current legis- In the 1970s and 1980s, some financial invest- lative framework is restrictive compared to our ment brokers played on the weaknesses of ordi- European counterparts. The success of the new nary people when they received a lump sum from financial services hub in the Dublin docklands, the sale of property or road construction works and of the business it generates across the coun- being carried out. We cannot be overprotective try, will rest on the ease with which international of such a sum on behalf of people who wish to financial services business can be conducted have a nest egg for retirement or for family under Irish law. The securitisation industry is one 765 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 766 of many where we must be sure we get the right holdings could be conducted electronically for mix of regulation for the protection of customers, those persons who wish it, thereby not only sav- most of whom are businesses, and flexibility of ing the small shareholder the significant incon- operation for businesses. venience of securely storing valuable share certifi- The owners of small and medium businesses cates but also preventing the considerable will welcome the thrust of increases in audit environmental damage caused by printing and exemption thresholds. Reducing bureaucracy and distributing that many share certificates. the regulatory burden on small businesses is a key When he discussed this Bill in the Seanad, element of Labour’s enterprise policy. This move Senator Quinn informed the House of the diffi- will bring us to approximately the same limits as culties which he, an eminent and highly experi- the United Kingdom and to the EU maximum. enced businessman, had in reconstituting some of Small businesses are the great drivers behind our his shareholdings after a fire in his office. If an economy. All companies started small. We must individual like Senator Quinn, who is an expert in work to enable as many as possible to grow to the field of business and shares, could experience become large companies, a matter on which the these difficulties, one wonders how a normal Government and Opposition agree. While we member of the public would fare. The creation of may wish for fewer companies to be covered by a system allowing for electronic versions of share- the audit requirements we hope more companies holdings would give those members of the public, can grow to the size that will require full audits. as well as experienced shareholders and busi- There is a minor anomaly in this section of the nesses, an additional backup should events such Bill, which we will examine more closely on Com- as those which befell Senator Quinn take place. mittee Stage. The Minister of State might con- The transposition of the transparency directive sider it with respect to amendments he may is welcome. However, I question whether the make. New international auditing standards are Government will steer this Bill through all Stages to be implemented from now on in auditing of by the transposition deadline in January 2007. company accounts. Many small accountancy firms This directive has been on the books since 2004. have a large proportion of clients who currently Why was it not transposed in the Investment fall within the requirements for audited accounts, Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions but would fall outside those limits after this Bill Act 2005? This is an important directive and it is passed. The cost to small accounting businesses compliments the earlier prospectus directive and of training up or outsourcing to meet these stan- market abuse directive. It will bring an additional dards is quite significant, especially when one level of protection for small investors, in part- considers they will probably only need that know- icular, who may not have the same research ledge for one financial year. The Minister of State resources as the pension funds and larger inves- should examine this on Committee Stage. tors. I also hope the Minister will be allocating The dematerialisation of securities will bring us some additional resources to the Financial Regu- broadly in line with the rest of Europe, especially lator to police this new provision, one which is with regard to compatibility with the CREST obviously taken seriously given the inclusion of system. However, there is some concern on this criminal sanctions. point. The explanatory memorandum released The completion of transposition of the take- with the Bill suggests that dematerialisation will over directive will also enacted by this Bill. affect only securities of companies trading on a However, as with far too many directives regulated market. I heard the Minister of State recently, this final part of the transposition is sig- speak about this in his opening speech. It appears nificantly past the deadline agreed by EU to the Labour Party and to all those it has con- member states, including Ireland. The original sulted, among them very eminent corporate law- transposition by SI 255 of 2006 was sloppy yers, that the provisions will apply to all public because it created two sets of general principles companies, including those with securities listed to be followed by the takeovers panel. This on IEX and AIM. directive should have been completely and prop- A more welcome aspect of this section is that erly transposed by last May at the latest. Again, we can be assured it will reduce paperwork. If it was agreed in early 2004. As with the trans- only we could do the same for public representa- parency directive, I would like the Minister of tives. The many members of the public who were State to explain why this directive was not fully stung by the Government in the Eircom flotation transposed earlier. If we continue to be so sloppy and now own shares in Vodafone as a result will in respect of directives, we will quickly fall behind be aware of the volumes of paperwork that pass the rest of Europe in our corporate regulatory through their hands in respect of minor changes structure. in shareholdings, especially if they are reinvesting In respect of the provisions of the takeover their dividends in the share purchase scheme. directive transposition section of this Bill, Part 4, Under current regulations, additional share cer- and the amendments to the Irish Takeover Panel tificates must be issued every time a shareholder’s Act 1997, I am glad to see the takeover panel will stake is increased or decreased, even if the now be empowered to consider relevant EU law change only involves a single share. Under the when ruling on takeover applications. However, changes proposed here, these alterations in share- the Labour Party has a problem with section 18 767 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 768

[Ms Lynch.] Mr. Eamon Ryan: I welcome the opportunity of this Bill, which would repeal section 9(11)(b) to speak on Second Stage. While there may be of the Consumer Information Act 1978, as difficulties on Committee Stage, I hope to speak amended, and has already been discussed by on Report Stage. A number of measures in the Deputy Hogan. Section 18 allows for the post of Bill will be welcomed across the House. The Director of Consumer Affairs to be left empty Green Party launched a paper this year which for more than six months. Surely a more suitable dealt with trying to ease the burden of regulation, solution would be to appoint a person to replace particularly on small Irish businesses. I welcome the resigning director fully and appoint a new the proposal in the Bill to raise the audit exemp- Director of Consumer Affairs until such time as tion limit to the maximum amount allowed in the the national consumer agency can be fully estab- EU. It is not a fundamental change because many lished. Continuing for an indefinite period with small companies will still have to draw up their an interim acting director is unfair both on the annual accounts and submit them to the Compan- person in question and on his or her staff and ies Registration Office and will still use account- must necessarily weaken the Office of the Direc- ants in this regard. However, it does reduce the tor of Consumer Affairs at a time when con- cost somewhat. In particular, as the audit require- sumers need more protection than ever before. ments become onerous each year, it makes it eas- On a related point, I would appreciate if the ier for accountancy practices dealing with those Minister could tell me when he expects the small companies not to have to go through national consumer agency to be fully established unnecessary regulatory and bureaucratic control. by statute. Can we to take it from this section of I was a small businessman before I entered the the Bill that it is not envisaged this will happen House and I found the relationship with my com- in the immediate future? pany accountant to be extremely beneficial and The moving of this Bill again brings to the fore- positive. The annual audit was one of the few front a problem which has been of serious con- occasions when I was probably pulled back to the cern for some time. We are still waiting for the nuts and bolts of what the business was actually Company Law Consolidation and Reform Bill, doing and whether it was making money. It is which was promised several years ago. There are very important to maintain and encourage this at least 15, and some estimate there may be more connection between the accountancy profession than 20, different pieces of legislation in the field and small Irish businesses but it does not need of company law which businesses must bear in to include regulated and audited accounts which mind. The difficulties created by this and the more properly apply to larger businesses. The necessary complexity of corporate legal issues audit exemption limit of \7.3 million is an accur- that arise from time to time are a significant drain ate reflection of the difference between small and on resources, especially for small and medium- medium-sized companies which might be forced sized enterprises. to take on those. Consolidating all company law into one single I also understand and support the proposal in piece of legislation would greatly simplify the the Bill for the dematerialisation of the stock matter for small business owners and directors. It market share processing process within the Irish would allow them to easily understand their Stock Exchange and in our dealings rights and obligations without requiring them to 12 o’clock with other international stock have recourse to legal advisers on even the most exchanges. It has been promised for minor issues. I am informed the company law many years. I remember approximately 30 years review group, which was established by my col- ago when computers started becoming common- league, Deputy Ruairı´ Quinn, when he was Mini- place it was stated we would have paperless ster for Enterprise, Trade and Employment, will offices in no time. It is remarkable how the quan- soon publish the result of its extremely extensive tity of paper used has increased rather than investigation and attempt at consolidation of the decreased since then. Dematerialisation makes existing body of corporate law. I hope the Mini- sense and I welcome it. However, it must be ster of State will take this opportunity to assure properly managed and major security provisions the House that he will move this process forward must be included to ensure fraudulent or other to the introduction of a Bill to the House as soon improper behaviour cannot take place. as possible because it is clear to everyone that it I welcome the opportunity provided by this Bill is urgently needed. It will be a massive Bill with to transpose the European directive on trans- hundreds of sections and require intense and parency in business. On many occasions in this deep scrutiny by every party in the House. There House I spoke on the wisdom, merit and effec- is every possibility this Bill will be taken by the tiveness of having greater transparency and open- Labour Party in Government. ness in business decision-making. This returns to what I stated about my experience as a small Mr. Eamon Ryan: I wish to share time with business person. Commentators may argue Deputy Paudge Connolly. greater transparency is an imposition or breaches the need for a business to have confidentiality. An Leas-Cheann Comhairle: The Deputy may I disagree. The more business and commerce is do so. conducted in the broad open light of day, the 769 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 770 better the quality of business and commerce may be lurking in the complex debt instruments which will be undertaken. dreamed up by the finance industry. It also states I will make my main comments on the pro- a major concern is a potential danger to regulated visions outlined in section 8 of the Bill, regarding banks from the faceless institutions, such as hedge the restriction of liability where non-equity funds, with which they now do much of their debt securities are involved. This is the one element of trading. It is interesting to note these comments the Bill about which I am cautious. were made not in a socialist worker publication, I welcome the development of the Irish Finan- but in The Economist, a publication at the heart cial Services Centre. It has been a major success. of the free market and free capital movement. Approximately 20,000 people now work there The article also argued particular risk is and traded finance amounts to approximately involved with new innovative products such as \4.5 billion net cash inflow. We must seek to con- credit-default swaps and insurance products. Two tinue, support and develop that. I attended an articles quote researchers at the European Cen- Irish Bankers Federation dinner at which the tral Bank as stating part of the problem with cre- Taoiseach spoke. It was noticeable the Taoiseach dit-default swaps is that they are used for specu- made clear to the banking industry that the lation as well as hedging. The European Central Government would provide whatever flexibility Bank is also quoted as stating, “We have intro- was necessary to ensure the continued success of duced a new product, “insurance“, that appears the IFSC. to be used by people not looking for insurance. It While I welcome that, I would sound a note of is not the instrument[s] which [are] causing caution. Banking, re-insurance and asset manage- liquidity concerns but the way market partici- ment industries seek flexible regulatory and pants may be using them.” Government support. It is one of the criteria A current debate in the financial regulatory these industries use in deciding where to locate. industry is whether the provision of liquidity itself We must make that provision and be responsive. will be good for markets or whether allowing such It is extremely responsive to immediately change unregulated access to liquidity will build up a sig- a provision of the 2005 Act which causes the fin- nificant risk in the event of a downturn in the ancial services industry difficulty. However, we markets which could lead to an extremely serious must be careful to ensure standards in the indus- crash. We need only to look at the case of Brian try are at the highest international level. We must Hunter, a Canadian hedge fund operator who not be seen as an easy and attractive offshore made $100 million for himself during the first six haven of low taxes and a relatively light regulat- months of the year. He made $2 billion on a gas ory regime. In the long run, a successful and play in the hedge fund markets during the first stable financial services industry is one viewed as six months of the year and subsequently lost $5 based on a good, strong regulatory system rather billion in a week. That hedge fund was then in than a fly-by-night operation where rules can be severe difficulty. bent. Finance requires trust, and trust requires These products and their prospectuses are strong and effective governance and regulatory extremely complex. The companies involved are systems. not like AIB, Bank of Ireland, Deutsche Bank or We have natural advantages, such as our time any other mainstream banks. They are new zone location, English language usage and our innovative financial companies offering pro- education system. For many years, Irish mothers spectuses for new non-equity, non-traditional urged Johnny or Mary to go into commerce or bond funding often in insurance and on a credit the bank. In hindsight, after 20 or 30 years, it was worthy note. That is the background to my con- not bad advice to have given the young men and cern on reading that section 8 appears to contain women now working in the Irish Financial no liability other than the strict liability contained Services Centre and elsewhere. in the guarantee within such a prospectus. A number of recent events increased my cau- I need to hear from the Minister what exactly tiousness about a particular provision in the Bill, are the implications of this and how we will place as did reading the consideration of new non- ourselves internationally. The Minister states in equity products in a series of articles in The Econ- the absence of such a regulatory change, we may omist and a number of newspapers. Recently, The lose some of these new monoline insurance Economist stated phenomenal growth occurred in instruments and companies to other locations. I these slightly unusual non-equity securities. am sure that is also argued by the industry. According to a recent article in The Economist, However, we must be careful to protect existing last year approximately $600 billion was issued in jobs and asset management portfolios in the equities throughout the world, $685 billion was IFSC. We must not simply chase after the latest, issued in standard bonds and loan volumes of the newest, most liquid financial instrument. We new innovative financial packages, which I want must maintain Dublin’s success and not always be to see regulated, increased to $3.5 trillion during at the edge or on the crest of the latest instru- the same period. ment. This market changes extremely rapidly. An editorial article in The Economist stated Suddenly, $30 billion is traded within a short central bankers and supervisors are increasingly period on new instruments which did not exist a worried about the risk to financial stability which year ago. 771 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 772

[Mr. Eamon Ryan.] ments to company law. It is a pleasant change to We must walk a difficult line between being come in and welcome amendments to the law. ambitious, creative, innovative, flexible and The amendments are designed to increase ahead of the pack and being as prudent, con- Ireland’s attractiveness as a place to invest and servative, cautious, above board and exemplary they entail the considerable improvement of our as is required in financing, so Dublin will not be competitiveness. It is vital that Irish companies seen as a place which will allow slightly riskier can compete in international markets while instruments than other capital markets. It is a thin remaining competitive and participating more line to walk but that is the only worry I have efficiently in international commerce. about this Bill. We may be putting ourselves in Previously, I thought we were only losing low an attractive position in the short term to gain skilled jobs in the international market and that certain business, but if some of the hedge funds was where my concerns lay. I heard, however, on or non-traditional fund management systems run the radio yesterday of financial analysts, whom into difficulty in Dublin, it may damage other we would consider as highly skilled, seeing their business we have successfully built up over the jobs moving to India. An analyst here can earn past 20 years and harm the reputation of Irish more than \50,00, while in India he can be paid financial management. Funds of this scale would \10,000 and is considered exceptionally well paid. also have a significant global effect. I wanted to Such high skilled jobs can also leave the country. raise that concern on Second Stage. We are deal- Before our concern was outsourcing — Fruit of ing with such complex funds and such a new the Loom in Donegal was a prime example. It industry that this must be teased out on Commit- destroyed our clothing trade and we lost many tee Stage. jobs in Buncrana. Small business people welcome the audit In Cavan-Monaghan, the furniture trade was a exemptions in the Bill. It is a concern that our major employer for many part-time farmers, with economy benefits from a number of industries, secure jobs available for many years. Now, that with property being the main driver of growth trade is being outsourced as well and more often and enterprise. The IFSC is an example that than not, people from Monaghan have decided to shows we do not have to trade widgets to be suc- move to areas with lower cost bases. These con- cessful internationally; we can trade services. It is cerns affect us. One would have thought that it disappointing, however, that the export perform- was only major multinational companies that ance of indigenous industry has been declining in would suffer at such a time, but small indigenous recent years despite the efforts of Enterprise industries have also suffered. Effectively, they Ireland and the IDA. If we look at the Irish Stock have decided to move manufacturing and pur- Exchange, we have not been successful in chasing to overseas locations, merely assembling developing new companies that raise capital to the furniture in Ireland. Many of the big invest in new entrepreneurial activity. We are suf- employers have disseminated their workforce. fering from what used to be known as Dutch oil The shoe trade was another major employer in disease, where economies with access to a major north Monaghan but many of the shoe factories industry, like oil, do not develop any other indus- are closing because of cheap imports. Quality try, weakening their economy. Something similar does not always matter; these manufacturers are is happening here, because the over-emphasis on producing a top quality item but they find it diffi- property for enterprise and growth has sucked cult. On a larger scale, beef is being imported into entrepreneurial activity from the rest of the econ- the country that does not undergo the same type omy. That has placed us in an increasingly of testing as our own produce. It is imported exposed position. because it makes a profit and is attractive to the While we are correctly opening our stock consumer, never mind the quality assurance market to more innovative systems with dema- procedures. terialisation of the stock exchange trading system, The exemption limits in the Companies Audit- I am concerned about the lack of Irish companies ing and Accounting Act 2003 are totally inad- seeking to be listed on the exchange or in London equate and must be increased to a realistic level to raise capital for new projects. Why are com- from the current level of \1.5 million. That panies not seeking to develop wave and tidal sounded like a lot of money once upon a time but energy, where we should have a competitive we are now dealing in euro and wages and costs advantage? Why are Irish companies not trying have increased. The proposal to increase the to raise \400 million on the Irish Stock Exchange exemption thresholds to the maximum permitted to invest in research in that area? Why are com- of \7.3 million for turnover and \3.65 million for panies not investing in innovative food processes balance sheets is progressive, although I would be or other services where we could succeed? That concerned about those figures eventually becom- is my concern regardless of the systems on the ing inadequate. The maximum permitted might exchange. be increased further down the line. We must look at our nearest neighbour. The British Govern- Mr. Connolly: I welcome this Bill, which pro- ment has already increased these thresholds, plac- poses a number of sound, common sense amend- ing us at a competitive disadvantage, especially 773 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 774 since we share a border with Northern Ireland. company failures in the past. It is important that That is relevant to us and makes a lot of sense. the House acknowledge these people. The standards of auditing are undergoing pro- The House should also spread the word that found change, which has contributed to the need my constituency is an attractive location for for a realistic adjustment of audit exemption lev- investment. The people of both Cavan and els. I know someone close to me in an auditing Monaghan have a strong work ethic and are not department and he is not the most popular person afraid to take a chance. Outside companies there. He went from website design to auditing should also be aware of the constituency’s good and the greetings he gets have changed. transport connections, with access to open roads, ports and airports. For example, it takes me Mr. M. Ahern: Been there, done that. approximately 90 minutes to travel from my home to Dublin Airport, a commutable distance, Mr. Connolly: My son has just discovered that; particularly when one considers the length of it was one of the big shocks in life. time it can take to cross Dublin by car. South Small and medium sized companies were Monaghan can be reached from Dublin Airport among the most adversely affected by the current in 45 minutes. On the Northern side, we also have low threshold figure, so this Bill is significant to access to Belfast’s airports. We should shout them. The raising of the audit exemption thres- about these advantages. hold to \7.3 million will considerably lighten the Small businesses will be assisted by the pro- regulatory burden on small and medium sized visions of the legislation because they will not be business that currently must conduct an annual required to employ professional accountants to audit, which is costly in terms of both time and audit their books at the end of each year. By nat- money. It will also help to improve life for busi- ure, an accountant will examine a company’s nesses and investors by dispensing with the need turnover and submit a price based on the time for red tape. Nevertheless, it does not dispense required for his or her audit, the level of turnover with the necessity to maintain good day-to-day and other factors. Accountants also like accounts books of accounts, as required by company law. to be well prepared and maintained. As treas- It is important that records will continue to be urers of clubs and so forth will agree, they, too, kept for future examination. must have their books done by professionals. It is Small and medium sized businesses are the in the best interests of small companies to ensure driving force of the economy and one cannot their books are correct, meticulous and up to overestimate the importance of a healthy busi- date. ness sector. Recently, when examining the type Mandatory dematerialisation is another posi- of employment available in my constituency I tive aspect of the Bill which will be welcomed by found the emphasis had shifted from small com- small business. The new provision makes it panies producing for the domestic market to mandatory to hold in electronic form stock firms producing goods for export markets. transfer forms and share certificates. This is the Approximately 55 companies in counties Cavan way forward. In a modern and progressive econ- and Monaghan export to world markets, with 30 omy such as this and given its exposure to the of them located in the former and 25 in the latter. global economy, it is essential to maintain and Between them, the two counties account for 10% improve our competitiveness. Holding Irish of exports by domestic companies, as opposed to securities in electronic form will be instrumental overall national exports. in reducing the costs involved in share dealing Companies in counties Monaghan and Cavan and should increase our competitiveness in this beaver away, quietly doing their business on the area. world market. Both have some large players, for To meet the challenges posed by the increas- example, Combilift Limited in County Monaghan ingly globalised and competitive world markets it which operates across the world and Quinn Life is essential to maintain competitiveness. We must in County Cavan, household names that have protect the interests of the small indigenous com- moved into the world market. We should be panies which drive the economy and, where proud of them, especially given that the local necessary, change laws to keep them intact. economy used to be dominated by small furniture Many Irish equities are listed on Irish and companies, small farmers, etc. United Kingdom markets. The greatest possible Recent changes in the business sector in my degree of harmonisation in dematerialisation in constituency were achieved without much assist- both markets would be in our national interest. It ance from Government agencies and can be attri- is vital that the Irish market is not placed at a buted to people taking a chance. I bump into competitive disadvantage with the UK and that people who tell me they have been in Shanghai, electronic processing of Irish equities is carried Bangkok, Australia and many other places mar- out in line with best international practice. In keting their products, getting out on the world other words, it is in our national interest to bring stage and doing business. If that is the case in my our auditing processes into line with those constituency, I am sure it also applies to other operated in the United Kingdom, our closest constituencies. Many of those who operate suc- neighbour. Britain may be a close competitor but cessful companies have experienced a couple of we have a good trading relationship and depend 775 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 776

[Mr. Connolly.] the trade of securities, the legislation takes into on it to take a significant amount of goods and account the greater use of technology in the services produced here. We must, therefore, work exchange of securities. closely with the UK on these matters. Ireland has been driven by a remarkable ability The elimination of paper share certificates will to persuade financial services companies to base have a series of beneficial effects. Trading will be their European headquarters here. While many processed in seconds and dependence on snail observers attribute this development solely to tax mail will be removed. It will also improve Irish incentives, the supply of great human resources competitiveness in trading securities, consider- and the talent of the Irish workforce have been ably reduce the costs involved in paper trading major factors in this regard. It is vital in reg- and bring practices here into line with current ulating business that we walk the fine line UK practice. between ensuring business is correctly regulated The Bill also makes provision for the amend- and conducted in a transparent and ethical man- ment of the Consumer Information Act 1978 to ner and ensuring it is not choked with unnecess- permit the temporary appointment of a director ary administration and regulations. Business does of consumer affairs. Legislation to establish a new not always recognise that politics has its best national consumer agency was promised for 2005 interest at heart and our imposition of regulations after the Consumer Strategy Group recom- is often resented. I hope this legislation will be mended the creation of such a body in May of the taken in the required spirit to update and mod- same year. This provision is an ad hoc, stop gap ernise our rules and regulations to reflect chang- arrangement and will result in consumers losing ing technology and a greater need to govern the out on their rights. It is unfair to ask consumers information flow and transparency of companies. to pay. I hope the establishment of a national I wish to deal first with the changes to the consumer agency on a statutory basis will not be Companies Acts. I welcome the increasing of the further delayed. audit exemption thresholds up to the maximum A further feature of the Bill is the provision to levels permitted by the EU and the new threshold allow for the transposition of the European for turnover of \7.3 million and \3.65 million for Union transparency directive. Directive a balance sheet. This means we now catch up and 2004/109/EC relates to the exercise of voting pass out England which has a £2.5 million audit rights by shareholders of companies, having regis- exemption, as well as the rest of Europe, which tered their office in a member state and whose has an average exemption of approximately \5 shares are admitted to trading on a regulated million. The previous relatively low audit exemp- market. It will facilitate the cross-border exercise tion limit was particularly significant when one of shareholders’ rights in listed companies considers that the auditor was obliged to report through the introduction of minimum standards all company law discrepancies, including minor and ensure that shareholders, irrespective of their ones which were punished severely in the 2001 place of residence in the European Union, will Act. I also welcome the ability to hold in elec- have timely access to complete information and tronic form securities of companies based on a simple means to exercise voting rights at a regulated market. This merely reflects the man- distance. ner in which securities are being traded in the I welcome the Bill, which will serve to improve modern era. the environment for business and share trading. The Minister of State has said that dematerial- It meets the needs of small business and investors isation will facilitate ease and speed of trading by and, as such, I support it. investors, enhance the international competi- tiveness of Ireland for securities trading, reduce Mr. Callanan: I wish to share time with Deputy the current costs associated with the cumbersome Martin Brady. process of managing paper-based transactions, and avoid the risk of an escalation of the current An Leas-Cheann Comhairle: Is that agreed? settlement costs for Irish certificate transactions Agreed. that would occur if there was a successful imple- mentation of dematerialisation of UK securities. Mr. Callanan: I welcome the opportunity to Dematerialisation is being considered in the UK address the House on the issues laid before us and has already taken place in other European in the Bill. This legislation covers many changes countries such as France, Denmark, Sweden and needed to bring the regulation of business into Italy. It also exists in other competing world the next century. In particular, it deals with our markets such as India, Australia and New position as a market leader in asset-backed Zealand. securities investment in Europe. It will ensure This Bill will ensure more of the financial that we continue to hold a lead in financial services industry can be based anywhere in services and will address some concerns which Ireland that has good commercial broadband and have been raised by industry experts. telecommunications infrastructure. With the The Bill should reflect the greater need for recent roll out of fibre optic in Gort, Loughrea, regulation of transparency in business which is all Ballinasloe and Athenry, I hope we will start to important. With the near removal of barriers in see financial services jobs in the west. Our road 777 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 778 structure also has a part to play in this. Ireland is increase the audit exemption threshold for com- now a modern, highly globalised, credibly regu- panies is seen as requiring priority treatment. lated, competitive economy. We need to ensure This will have a significant impact in terms of we retain our attractiveness as a place to do busi- lessening the regulatory burden on small business ness and as a location for foreign direct invest- and is seen as a priority measure in terms of ment. We will achieve this objective by commit- maintaining our competitiveness generally. ting ourselves to fostering the conditions which The Bill proposes to increase audit exemption support enterprise and in meeting the challenges limits for turnover and balance sheet totals, and opportunities of an increasingly knowledge- thereby allowing more companies avail of the based, regulated, globalised and environmentally audit exemption. The provision in this Bill sustainable economy. increases the turnover limit to \7.3 million and Dublin today is recognised as a global centre the balance sheet total limit to \3.65 million. for financial services. It is ranked only second to I commend the Bill to the House. London and ahead of Frankfurt in terms of asset- backed securities. The aggregate amount of asset- Mr. M. Brady: I thank the Minister of State for backed securities investments managed by bringing this important Bill before the House. I Dublin-based investors has witnessed huge congratulate him for placing the emphasis on growth in recent years. In 1999, the aggregate small businesses because these usually become amount of asset-backed securities investments large businesses. We have many examples of this was around \6 billion. This grew to between \30 in the Oireachtas, such as Senators Quinn and and \35 billion in 2003. Today, the figure is at White who started in a small way and now own least \80 billion. These figures demonstrate the major businesses. In Deputy Connaughton’s con- position and importance of securitisation in terms stituency, Mr. Pat McDonagh of Supermacs gave of the domestic economy and the tremendous a talk to members of the Joint Committee on strides made in recent times. The strong track Enterprise and Small Business when we visited record that Ireland has developed in the asset- Ballinasloe. It was interesting to listen to him backed securities sector is a result of many speak about the problems he encountered along factors. These include a conducive business envir- the way. onment, a common law system and the presence The joint committee visited Ennis a few weeks of skilled personnel with considerable inter- ago and we met with people who set up small national experience. All of these factors, along businesses. One person who started employing with Government support, have fuelled this five people is now employing 80 people. We also growth. met students and we asked them what they felt Existing developments in securitisation give us would hinder the setting up of small businesses. the potential to develop as a primary centre for Everybody commented that the bureaucracy specialist debt-financing products. Business regu- involved in setting up small businesses is horrific. lation in the field of company law feeds into One must drive all over the country to establish improvements to our national competitiveness the assistance available. There are agencies all through high standards of corporate governance. over the place. We should have a one-stop shop It brings about a stable and predictable envir- to advise people who want to set up a small busi- onment in which entrepreneurs can establish ness on grants available. businesses, investors can invest, creditors can There is a perception that we are only lend and the interests of the employees, con- interested in big businesses and foreign investors sumers and other stakeholders are protected. — who are given everything — and that we are Ireland’s economic future is inextricably bound not concerned about small businesses. That is not up with the global economy through investment, the case. What is really being stated is that the trade, people and business. We have to be at the system is so cumbersome and convoluted and top of the game in every aspect that affects com- contains so many layers of bureaucracy that petitiveness. people immediately erect mental barriers and do Part 2 of the Bill contains a number of amend- not proceed with their businesses. I was informed ments to the Companies Acts 1963 to 2005, which by one woman that a friend of hers opened a increase the thresholds below which companies small business and immediately received approxi- are eligible to avail of exemption from having to mately 20 letters from the Revenue Commis- have their accounts audited, amend the powers of sioners relating to various matters. That can be the Minister to make regulations dealing with the extremely off-putting. holding of securities of companies in electronic The provisions of the Bill involve facilitating form, otherwise called dematerialisation, and business development and securing our competi- which amend the provisions of the Investment tive edge in key sectors where it has been Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions developed. Where possible, we should ease the Act 2005 dealing with the circumstances where regulatory burden on businesses. That is already issuers of prospectuses for non-equity securities happening here, where a flexible, responsive and may be held liable in civil actions to parties who business-focused regulatory system is developing. may have suffered a loss as a result of subscribing This is vitally important because, as has been for the securities in question. The need to stated, like all developed economies, our econ- 779 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 780

[Mr. M. Brady.] The forum also pointed out that while there are omy depends increasingly on services as it moves advantages in obliging companies to undertake away from basic manufacturing to higher ups- statutory audits, these advantages can be out- caled manufacturing and services. If we do not weighed by the enormous cost of such an audit, have a system which will allow people to be flex- which can sometimes amount to between \10,000 ible and respond quickly to changes in the and \20,000. IDA Ireland is committed to marketplace, we will lose out. I believe we will developing the breadth and depth of the inter- continue to be successful but we must keep our national financial services industry in Ireland. eyes on the ball. While continuing to market this country as a The Minister of State and his officials have list- centre of excellence for transaction processing, ened carefully and responded to the concerns of IDA Ireland is also targeting other sophisticated small and medium-sized businesses. As stated revenue generating activities. Existing devel- earlier, I hope he will take on board the points I opments in securitisation give us the potential to have made in respect of small businesses and how develop as a primary centre for specialist debt they are set up. and financing products. This is in line with lDA The legislation incorporates as many recom- Ireland’s strategy to drive the development of mendations from businesses as fall under the knowledge-intensive high-value investments. remit of the Minister of State, and that is rep- Business regulation in the field of company law resentative of the partnership-style of Govern- feeds into improvements to our national competi- ment which has been so successful for our econ- tiveness through high standards of corporate omy over the past ten years. The most welcome governance. This brings about a stable and pre- development in the Bill for small and medium- dictable environment in which entrepreneurs can sized businesses is the raising of the audit exemp- establish businesses and investors can invest. tion threshold to the maximum allowable under Ireland’s economic future is bound up with the EU rules, namely, \7.3 million turnover, up from global economy through investment, trade, \1.5 million. people and business in general. We must be at the top of the game in respect of the transposition The Bill will ease the additional administrative of the two EU directives, which will bolster burden of annual audits for thousands of busi- Ireland’s competitiveness and help us attract nesses and create a parity in the audit exemption foreign investment in an ever more competitive thresholds with businesses in the North, the global market. They will also help us to encour- United Kingdom and other EU states. Many age people in Ireland, if they are given proper small businesses, such as that established by Pat assistance, to invest and establish businesses here. McDonagh in Ballinasloe, have extended their I commend the Bill to the House. I thank the interests to the United States and other countries. Minister of State and his officials for the excellent That gives an indication of the importance of work and research invested in it. This is an small businesses and they way they can grow and important Bill and it will prove of great assistance spread to other countries. This also affects volun- to small businesses. It will also help those who tary and community organisations, which will be are considering establishing such businesses and relieved of the time and regulation burden of encourage young people in this regard. In my being audited because they fall under the new view, that is the way to proceed. threshold. The roll-back of the regulation has a symbolic Mr. Connaughton: Like previous speakers, my significance in that the process of more and more party and I welcome the Bill. There are many regulation will henceforth be tempered. The aspects to the Bill and one could refer to a large important message to business people who par- number of them in the context of the changes to ticipate on business fora, committees, etc, is that which its enactment will lead. they will be listened to. The report of the Small The first matter to which I wish to refer is the Business Forum, published last April, recom- increase in the audit exemption level. This has mends that Departments should formally assess been a topic of discussion among those in the the merits of exempting small businesses from small industries sector for a couple of years. new regulations, or of modifying such regulations Everybody thought that it would have happened to make allowance for the special needs of small much sooner than has proved to be the case. The businesses. The forum was set up by the Minister Institute of Chartered Accountants, which has for Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy access to greater expertise than that at my dis- Martin, and chaired by the general manager of posal, has been discussing this matter, in so far as Microsoft Ireland, Joe Macri. the competitive aspect is concerned, for a long Raising the audit exemption threshold to \7.3 period million will ease the regulatory burden and obli- Everyone is aware that the Bill was introduced gation on many small and medium-sized busi- as a result of what happened in Northern Ireland nesses to conduct a costly, cumbersome and bur- and Great Britain. Once the authorities in the densome annual audit. This was a key North decided to opt for a much higher exemp- recommendation in the Small Business Forum’s tion level, a great deal of business began to seep report. across the Border. The Government was aware 781 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 782 of this for some time and I cannot understand people who break out in a cold sweat in the why action was not taken much sooner. middle of the night are those who have their It is important that Ireland should be able to assets on the line. I refer to their houses and the match the best in the world. As far as its competi- last penny in their pockets. The Minister of State tiveness is concerned, all is not well. As stated in understands this point. Such people have put the House on a number of recent occasions, everything on the line that is considered to be Ireland dropped from fourth in 2000 to 21st this important, such as their house, insurance etc. I year in the World Economic Forum’s global com- have seen business men and women in a terrible petitiveness report. Regardless of the scientific state because their expectations regarding a part- evidence one can produce or the political spin icular investment were contradicted by the one can put on that, it is not a good position for marketplace and they were left almost penniless. Ireland to be in. A major slippage has occurred. However, such people are responsible for build- One cannot state that it is directly linked to the ing up this country and are the source of its subject matter to which the Bill relates, but it is prosperity. a symptom of what is happening in this country. As Deputy Martin Brady correctly stated, The Government and the Administration that many people were lucky enough at the heel of succeeds it will be obliged to pay major attention the reel to become well known throughout the to this issue in the next couple of years. world for their particular expertise. I refer to the The National Competitiveness Council stated Smurfits of this world. However, in a manner that Irish prices rose by 22% more than those in similar to the world of professional golf, for every other EU countries in the years 1999 to 2003. such success, there is no shortage of dead bodies That is an official statistic. Ireland is 20th in the on the ground. Against that background, it is World Economic Forum’s global information incumbent on all Governments, present and technology report, which measures the techno- future, to go out of their way for the men and logical readiness of countries, behind countries women who put their neck out to keep the wheels such as the US, the UK, the Netherlands, of industry and commerce turning. Most business Sweden, Germany and Austria. people I know personally believe that, for some Members are aware that in February 2006, due strange reason, no Government understands the to the Government’s failure to deregulate prop- phenomenon I have just explained. erly the electricity market, Airtricity announced It would do no harm to revisit this issue in the its departure from the Irish market. fora that have been established. Ultimately, These are not straws in the wind and legislators Members should do their best for those who are from all sides of the House must take note. As prepared to put their neck on the line. The nature a result, costs for the small business community of the game dictates there will always be failures. continue to rise at an alarming rate. For example, While such people may start out with a profit one can make comparisons with the United motive — I am not silly enough to believe they Kingdom. It is a huge trading partner for Ireland do so for charitable purposes — they take terrible and shares the same language. The two countries chances. Although I might have taken similar have close business connections and have been chances when I was younger, I would not like to interlinked for generations. The cost of elec- so do now and this is true for many Members. tricity, insurance, landfill and broadband is 50%, The world of industry is difficult, big and bad and 20%, 350% and 10% higher, respectively, in when Members get an opportunity to discuss this Ireland than in the United Kingdom. All such issue in the House, they should not forget the costs form part of small enterprise activity. It is central issue involved, namely, the steps such evident that when Irish firms compete on the people must take and the environment in which British or other markets, they do so with one they must operate. hand tied behind their backs. I do not understand why it is impossible for the This raises the question of what can be done in Commission for Energy Regulation to revisit its this regard. While I cannot claim to be an expert decision — I will refer to other decisions — once in this field, I have begun to wonder who will it became plain that the world price of oil was regulate the regulators. For example, the Com- falling substantially and is likely to remain in this mission for Energy Regulation was established in state for a number of months or perhaps a couple a blaze of glory some time ago amid claims that of years. A mechanism should be put in place that this was the right way to go. However, many vot- would allow the process to be wound back. I pre- ers do not understand how the regulator could sume there will be no change in respect of the oil allow 20% and 34% increases in the price of elec- and gas cost increases, which poses a difficulty for tricity and gas, respectively, on the day before small industry. Possibly, the next increase, when- world prices of oil began to fall. I cannot under- ever it takes place, will be held for a longer period stand this and I do not know whether the Mini- than normal. However, this will do no good for ster of State can. Worse, this has a fundamental small business people or industrialists who will be cost implication for all businesses and for small saddled with an unwarranted level of cost businesses in particular. increase until the next decision is made. Given my dealings with the small business fra- Many people will ask serious questions for the ternity over the years, I have noticed that the remainder of the year regarding the regulator’s 783 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 784

[Mr. Connaughton.] I hope the changeover to the new recording rationale. Initially, no one took much notice system has been well thought-out. It has been because of developments on the world oil market. used in many other countries for a long time. I When the regulator took his decision, everyone hope there will not be any mix-ups this time. Such accepted there was a reason for doing so at the difficulties would be embarrassing and would sug- time. At present, however, there is general gest to people throughout the world that we acceptance that the basis for making that decision were incompetent. no longer exists. Nevertheless, it appears the I would like to highlight a technical matter. I Commission for Energy Regulation does not hope the Minister will refer to it when he is sum- intend to do anything in this regard and will per- ming up. Does this measure have data protection mit the current status to continue. This is a false implications? I assume a raft of legislation kicks premise because oil is no longer as costly as when in when records are computerised. I am sure the decision was made. When Members discuss national law is relevant in this regard, although I the lack of competitiveness, this is a central issue am not sure about international law. I remind the that must be addressed this year and I hope House that every time a proposal of this nature someone will do so. Earlier, I questioned who is introduced, we should know what we are doing, would regulate the regulators. I hope this will be we should implement it properly and efficiently possible under this legislation. and we should ensure there is no egg on any- I wish to raise another aspect of this legislation body’s face by the time the process has been about which I cannot claim to have great personal completed. knowledge. I will approach it from a different I want to talk about the functions of the Direc- perspective. I refer to the proposed dematerialis- tor of Consumer Affairs. I understand this is a ation of the security certification. I understand technical matter. There is no director in place at this to mean that those records that were paper- present. This legislation provides for someone to based will be computerised. I see Deputy Fleming hold that position until the National Consumer is present and I assume he will speak shortly. He Agency has been established on a statutory basis. and I served on the Committee of Public I have often wondered why the agency has not Accounts for a number of years. Indeed, he still been put on a statutory footing long before now. serves on it and has always been an important I cannot understand that. member. I did not spend a single day at that com- I do not intend to repeat the comments of some mittee without hearing of major problems eman- of my colleagues about the groceries order etc. ating from the computerisation of existing People tried to convince me and my colleagues records. This is true of all Government agencies on all sides of the House that there would be a visible decrease in supermarket prices the day that I encountered while serving on the Commit- after the groceries order was abolished. That did tee of Public Accounts. All cases created havoc not happen. I never thought it would happen. The and trouble, as well as costing the taxpayer much concept of abolishing the order was right — I had money. For several months, a stock answer at the no trouble with it. However, we have not committee went along the lines that the reason replaced it with anything, as far as I can tell. It for a particular event was that computerisation seems two vital sectors of society are being was taking place, a new system was being intro- affected by the discounting which is taking place duced, no one was responsible, the hardware ven- all the time. The abolition of the groceries order dor had left — as had the person who bought it was supposed to be the best thing to happen con- — and the system did not work. Before we knew sumers in the last ten years. However, all the fig- where we were, the thing was in a hames, to put ures show there has been a continual increase in it bluntly. I will outline what I want to know. the price of one’s shopping basket. If one speaks There were problems with electronic voting, of to people with limited means, they will say how course. We have an awfully bad record in this expensive their shopping is every Friday. country of doing this particular job. I hope we can I do not have time to speak in detail about the do it better in this instance. manner in which consumers and primary pro- We are in very good company. We are in the ducers are being squeezed. Inordinate pressure is company of the best brains — the whizz kids of being put on people at both ends of the spectrum. the world. I refer to people in this country who The real money is being made by middle men and deal with securities, for example. We retailers. I appreciate that retailers have their 1 o’clock are lucky to have financial services own trouble. Primary producers, such as farmers, etc., here. I pay tribute to that sector are the last people to make money and consumers of the community. I have always believed in it. I are the second last people to make money. The remember being in the House when it was intro- people in the middle are making money hand duced and, in fairness to Mr. Haughey, it was a over fist. If the Minister responsible for this issue step in the right direction. We have shown that can bring some balance to it, it will be a good day. Ireland can become a centre of excellence. It has become a centre of excellence in this regard and Mr. Fleming: I welcome the opportunity to continues to be so. A great deal of the work that speak on Second Stage of the Investment Funds, is done in this sector relates to this legislation. Companies and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 785 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 786

2006, which deals with three or four broad issues. regularise the system by removing some of the It amends the parts of the Companies Acts deal- concessions on the basis that such reliefs were not ing with audit and dematerialisation. It imposes available to a similar extent under the taxation transparency requirements on the issuers of laws of other EU countries. The approach taken securities which are admitted to trading on cer- by the EU seems to be that if any member state tain markets. The miscellaneous provisions has an advantage over other member states, the section of the Bill ties up a series of loose ends. first thing that should be done is to eliminate that That summarises the key issues dealt with in the advantage. If we do that, however, we neglect the Bill. overall global picture. Ireland, which is one of the Many of the provisions of Part 3 relate to EU major players in the international horse breeding regulations. They have been included on foot of industry, is competing with the United States and the requirement to transpose various EU Australia. If the EU puts Ireland at a disadvan- directives into national law. I want to make a tage in that sector by forcing it to operate at the general comment about EU directives. The EU lower level of other member states, it disadvan- has to be careful. Ireland, as part of the EU, has tages the entire EU within the global horse to be careful. We are making a relentless effort breeding market. to ensure there is a level playing field within the If we disadvantage individual countries or com- EU. As our focus is often on the internal EU panies within the EU, we will ultimately confer market, we sometimes ignores the overall global benefits on the EU’s competitors in other parts market. While EU member states are important, of the world. We must be careful of that. We are they do not constitute the majority player on the in a global economy and one can overstate the world market. We need to bear in mind that there issue of fortress Europe. We deal not only with are other major players. We need to resist the Berlin, but with Boston and many other places efforts being made to bring each member state to worldwide. We are in competition with many cit- the level of the lowest member state. Such efforts ies, not only those in the EU. As an open econ- are being made by interests which do not have omy, Ireland has more to gain and lose by follow- due regard to the outside world. ing the road of rules harmonisation within the EU I would like to strengthen the point I am mak- without taking due cognisance of what is going ing by highlighting two cases I have observed on outside the EU. over the last year. While there was some logic to I wish to address the issue of auditing, which is the arguments which were made in both dealt with in section 6. It amends section 32 of instances, the logic behind the final decisions was flawed. Some time ago, Ireland submitted a pro- the Companies (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 1999 posal to the EU to be allowed to provide further by increasing the audit exemption threshold for grants and forms of support to Intel, one of the turnover and balance sheet totals up to the biggest employers in the country. The EU maximum levels permitted in the EU. This will bring the new thresholds to \7.3 million for turn- rejected that proposal to a large extent on the \ basis that grants of a similar nature were not over and 3.65 million for the balance sheet. I available in other member states. It was argued understand this will come into effect in a few that if Ireland were to be allowed to make such months time. The Minister will see if this is pos- supports available, competition within the Union sible for financial years commencing on 1 January would be distorted. By closing their minds in that and will return to the issue on Committee Stage. way, those who made the final decision failed to The essence of this is that we are exempting appreciate that Ireland, as an open economy, and companies with a turnover below \7.3 million Intel, as a world player, were operating in the glo- from the requirement of a statutory audit. The bal marketplace. logic is that they are relatively small enterprises, The real problem with the decision to refuse especially in the retail sector where there may be Ireland permission to offer grants to Intel, which high purchases and sales with a limited profit operates in Ireland, was that it will ultimately margin, the effect being low profits despite high work to the advantage of companies outside the turnover. EU. The supports in question would have The issue of exemptions from audit for com- benefitted the Irish economy, Intel and the world panies in the voluntary sector is one I would like economy. The failure to allow Ireland to make to see included in this legislation and I believe the supports available will help companies in this can be done if there is political willingness places like the Far East, the Middle East and and willingness in the Department. I wish to refer South America to make progress, with the assist- to a letter I received from the office of the Mini- ance of state support from the governments in ster for Enterprise, Trade and Employment on 31 such areas. Ultimately, companies which are December 2004. I wrote to the Minister regarding operating in the EU will be disadvantaged. a small rural development company in Laois I would like to highlight another contentious called the Sliabh Margy Development Associ- case, which caused many people to jump up and ation. I also spoke directly to the Minister in con- down some years ago. I refer to Ireland’s decision nection with the Mountrath amalgamated social to offer tax concessions to the horse breeding employment scheme, of which I am a sponsoring industry. Attempts were made by some people to member. 787 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 788

[Mr. Fleming.] under the section is that a company to which I have met the people involved in these organ- the Companies (Amendment) Act 1986 isations and I feel that this relates directly to the applies. The Act does not apply to a variety of Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employ- classes of company, including companies that ment. I will deal with FA´ S schemes first. There is are not trading for the acquisition of gain. a requirement, laid down by FA´ S, that every FA´ S In other words, the exemption does not apply to scheme conduct an audit of its affairs. Many non-profit organisations, but does apply to profit schemes have a turnover of around \300,000 and seeking organisations. This is daft. I would under- 90% of this consists of wages. Previously, this stand this if it was the other way round. The letter may have been unemployment assistance, dis- continues: “Audit exemptions are, therefore, ability allowance, lone parents’ allowance and so never available to non-profit companies, irrespec- on when those on the FA´ S scheme were claiming tive of their level of turnover.” I will come back social welfare. When people join a FA´ S scheme to this in a moment. The letter further states that they are paid through that scheme. Some 90% of the Company Law Review Group is the standing money in most FA´ S schemes covers wages and body charged with reviewing these matters. I was the balance covers insurance, materials and invited to make a submission to the group, which other overheads. I did in 2005, and I have not heard anything since. Under FA´ S rules, schemes must be audited The last paragraph of the letter states: each year which I understand and accept as it is taxpayers’ money. However, the Department of Any possible reforms of the audit exemp- Enterprise, Trade and Employment requires that tions would have to address the requirements such schemes be managed by a limited company of a wide range of non-profit companies that and the limited company is subject to a separate, the law covers, such as community title man- independent audit, despite the fact that it is only agement companies, management companies in a shelf company. There are no exemptions to this housing estates, charities, sporting associations, and the full cost must be borne. This is where development associations, etc. They would also complications arise. have to appropriately balance any possible It is ridiculous that a company with a turnover benefit from a reduction in compliance costs of \7.3 million will not require a statutory audit against the importance of ensuring account- while a local FA´ S scheme, with a turnover of ability, especially where there are public funds \300,000, is required to have two statutory audits involved. with two audit fees. We are trying to eliminate As I mentioned, I am involved in the Sliabh bureaucracy and are doing so for profit making Margy Development Association. The associ- companies, but are ignoring the non-profit sector ation sought to draw a £5,000 grant, through and the community and voluntary sector. Leader, to conduct walks in the rural area. It was Department staff suggested to me that this obliged, under the rules, to do this through a could be remedied if the company and the company. The association set up a company to scheme had the same year-end, creating, effec- carry out two transactions — one to cash a tively, one audit process. There would be a need cheque and one to pay the people who put up for two certificates and perhaps a nominal fee. the signs. The company then had to carry out a However, this is not realistic. When a new com- statutory legal audit. This is farcical — something pany is formed as part of a FA´ S scheme, they confirmed by the letter from the Minister’s office. may have the same year-end for the first year. We should treat the non-profit and voluntary sec- The FA´ S scheme may not run for a couple of tor more fairly. months, however, and it might not resume until That company, which existed solely to cash one the following April. The FA´ S scheme will then cheque, also ran foul of the Companies Regis- require an audit from April to March while the tration Office because, understandably, it was company, a separate legal entity, will adhere to late with its annual return. I contacted the Com- the calendar year for the Companies Registration panies Registration Office and received a small Office. It is neither possible nor practical in many concession, but none was received from the Mini- situations for the two entities to have the same ster’s office relating to the audit. year-end. There is a legal requirement for two The Companies Registration Office wrote to audits. me on 24 November 2004. It stated that it is I will refer now to the letter I received from required that the non-profit status of a company the Minister’s office on 31 December 2004. I am must be included in the memorandum and pleased to have the opportunity to raise it here, articles of association. It must be confirmed in the even at this late stage. The letter stated: articles of association that no dividends will be The law providing for exemptions from the paid and that, on winding up, all of the assets, requirement for a company to engage auditors which would otherwise be available to members, is contained in section 32 of the Companies must be transferred to another company with (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 1999. One of the similar restrictions. The outcome was that the criteria that must be satisfied in order for a company in question changed its memorandum company to qualify for an audit exemption and articles of association as a result of this 789 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 790 suggestion and was allowed a waiver or refund of actions. Dematerialisation has already taken fees from the Companies Registration Office. I place in countries such as France, Denmark, thank the Companies Registration Office for its Sweden, Italy, India, Australia and New Zealand help. and I understand it is being considered in the A standard planning condition now applied by United Kingdom, Belgium, the Netherlands, many local authorities for new estates or apart- Spain and the United States. Section 7 is there- ment developments is that the open area be man- fore very worthwhile. aged by a management company. I will give a Section 12 deals with the Financial Regulator. practical example. Imagine a new estate con- It states the Financial Regulator is the appro- sisting of 100 houses where the planning require- priate body in this area and that it may be free to ment is that the management company cut the introduce supplementary rules to enable it to ful- grass and manage the open area. If the company fil its role. The Minister of State said in his speech charged each house \100 per annum for cutting that \80 billion of asset-backed securities invest- the grass, there would be a turnover of \10,000 ments are managed by Dublin-based investors. per annum. I envisage that more money will have Will he tell us how much of this money is regu- to be spent on the audit fee than on cutting the lated by the Irish regulator? Companies must be grass. This is the thrust of the provision and it is registered in Ireland before they can be regu- a case of excessive bureaucracy. lated here. I want to highlight this matter in the House and The question of the Central Bank arises under I have done so previously in correspondence. section 13. Consider the confidentiality provisions Section 6, in essence, is a pragmatic measure to concerning information available to the Central help the profitable trading and business sector Bank and Financial Regulator. The element of but in making this measure we are placing the secrecy has been sacrosanct and intrinsic to the non-profit and voluntary sector at a further disad- types of industries concerned worldwide but vantage. The latter sector can include sports there are issues to be addressed in this regard, clubs, including GAA clubs, and also charities although not in this legislation. If the Central and many other associations. I want to see the Bank identifies criminal fraud on foot of its flexibility afforded to the profit-making sector knowledge of a company, it cannot notify the extended to the non-profit-making sector. Garda Sı´ocha´na, Revenue Commissioners or Will the Minister make available the infor- Director of Corporate Enforcement. I believe, mation he received from the Company Law however, that it can force the company in ques- Review Group, which information he mentioned tion to publish a relevant statement in its annual to me almost two years ago? How many compan- directors’ report – this is one of the few require- ies are involved? I suspect many organisations are ments. It can notify the Financial Regulator that being caught by the auditing provision and at an issue has arisen but it cannot provide any every annual general meeting attendees mutter details thereon. and grumble that they must pay \1,500 for audit- The Garda, Director of Corporate Enforce- ing. My local FA´ S scheme must pay for it twice ment, Financial Regulator and Revenue Commis- to satisfy the requirements. It has a turnover of sioners may all be investigating a major company, \300,000, 90% of which is expended on wages. A and may sometimes have representatives carrying few bob is spent on materials and the greatest out an investigation in the same company office, remaining expense is the double audit fee. I ask yet they are legally prevented from sharing infor- that common sense prevail sooner rather than mation they have obtained on matters of public later. interest. There should be some mechanism On the increase in exemptions concerning the whereby information relevant to another State audit fees, will it be standard practice for the organisation can be made available to that organ- Revenue Commissioners to accept non-audited isation while respecting the principle of confiden- accounts from now on? Sometimes a company tiality. It is not good enough that there is a pro- with a turnover of \7.3 million can have a very vision for total secrecy in such circumstances. small gross margin whereas a company in the pro- Section 18 allows for the appointment of a per- duction sector can have a very high gross margin son to perform the functions of the Director of of a couple of million euro. Will the Minister of Consumer Affairs. This is only a temporary State confirm the rights of minority shareholders measure but it is essential that it be included in who might feel disadvantaged if they do not get the legislation to enable a person to continue to audited accounts through the major shareholder? carry out that role until such time as the National Section 7 deals with mandatory dematerialis- Consumer Agency is placed on a statutory foot- ation, which effectively means that share certifi- ing and in a position to make such an cates will be stored electronically rather than on appointment. paper. This is a fact of life in this day and age I ask for a reassessment of the legislation in the and it will facilitate and make easier trading by Department to allow flexibility for the voluntary investors. It will enhance Ireland’s international and community sectors, which are forced to carry competitiveness in securities trading and will out audits. Commercial organisations, which reduce the current costs associated with the cum- operate on a much bigger scale, will be exempt bersome process of managing paper-based trans- from the requirement to produce such audits. 791 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 792

Mr. F. McGrath: I welcome the opportunity to have the right mix as regards the political system. speak on this very important Bill, which I sup- There are strong public and private sectors work- port. Let me bury the myth that Independent ing in partnership, rather than seeing each other Members are against everything, both inside and as enemies within the broader society. I get outside the House. We support sensible Bills and annoyed when people, particularly in the private one does find Independent Members supporting sector constantly push their private economic sensible solutions to problems, as was the case agenda to try to dominate and take over during the debate on drug-related crime last night situations in which there is no need for their and as is the case today in respect of investment involvement. For these reasons this debate is funds. very important. This debate is very important in so far as it As we talk about business and investments we impinges on business and investment. We do not should bear in mind that there is another Ireland seem to have had a proper debate on the direc- outside the Dublin 4 stereotype of trendy yuppy tion business is going in Ireland. We are all very Ireland. It is important to acknowledge that excited about and welcome the great wealth and families still live in poverty, despite the economic resources that have become available over the boom. I have a number of suggestions as regards past nine or ten years. However, the debate on helping such families. I should like the emphasis creating wealth in this society is now over and it placed on the most disadvantaged areas of this should now focus on how our wealth and extra and other cities, which only come to our attention resources can be distributed to those most in when some major disaster occurs at community need. This is the key issue both in this debate and level. I am not going to name the communities in other broader economic, social and political my constituency or in other parts of the State debates. again. They have enough on their hands as It is not acceptable for a Minister for Justice, regards fighting negative publicity without poli- Equality and Law Reform to say we have loads ticians making matters worse. The reality is, of money and are looking for ideas on how to however, that sectors of society are totally outside spend it when there are existing projects that the whole political, social and economic zones deserve investment and support. I raise this issue and are not being looked after. We must target because of its relevance to business and invest- resources to help these people. ment, which are dealt with in the legislation. Coming up to the budget and while the There are also ethical questions to be dealt with. Estimates are being prepared a number of The reality is that, despite the great boom and sensible proposals might be put forward. Lower the Celtic tiger, sections of business have become income families, for example, should be allowed damaged, just like politicians, the church and to meet their essential food needs. A proposal other parts of society. We must face this reality was put forward by the Combat Poverty Agency and deal with it head-on. for \10 million to support alternative sources of The Minister of State said in his speech that the healthy food to increase the \20 in social welfare amendments proposed in this Bill are designed to rates being sought and provide daily hot school facilitate business development, copperfasten our dinners. When one looks at the detail, the cost of competitiveness in key sectors where it has been putting a nutritious and well-balanced meal on developed and ease the regulatory burden on the table can account for between 40% and 80% business while facilitating the giving of full effect of the weekly income of families living on social to EU directives we must transpose. I welcome welfare. I ask the Government to extend the this and the fact that the amendments are very school meals programme to provide daily strong. I welcome the Minister of State’s assertion nutritional basic hot school dinners for an esti- that we need to retain our attractiveness as a mated 200,000 children from low income families. place to do business and as a location for foreign I should like to see an increase of the minimum direct investment. We need to debate this \20 in social welfare rates and up to \12 for chil- because we do not always pay sufficient attention dren per week, which are recommended by many to our indigenous industries, including small ones, people. These issues are related to employment, in the broader economic debate. investment and the whole debate on the We must face up to the reality that, because of economy. globalisation and the fact the world seems For example, parents with two children in smaller, there will be a shift of investment to receipt of \400 unemployment assistance per locations where wages are low and where wage week spend a minimum of \170 on basic everyday bills can be cut by 50%. This shift has already food items such as cereals, bread, potatoes, fruit started and we must ensure it does not affect and vegetables, dairy products, meat and fish. our competitiveness. That to me is good budgeting and I do not know We must be very careful not to allow business how they do it. We need to face reality and assist to dominate the economic and political agenda. people. The radical proposal to establish a \10 We will welcome businesses’ contribution and million fund over a three-year period to support support their sensible economic policies but we community initiatives, providing alternative cannot allow big businesses to set the agenda as sources of healthy food for low income families, they have done in other countries. In Ireland we is based on the success of such initiatives in the 793 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 794

UK and the emerging success of Irish initiative about issuers, where securities are admitted to such as the South Hill food co-operative in trading and a regulated market. The directive Limerick and the Dublin food bank. replaces and updates existing EU legislation in As we debate this Bill, it is important we start this area and is designed to enhance transparency to implement the national action plan against on EU capital markets by requiring regulated poverty and social exclusion. I appeal to the Mini- market issuers to produce periodical financial ster to look seriously at increasing the income of reports on shareholdings in such companies that social welfare recipients, maximising the benefits disclose major holdings. The directive also deals for children in poverty, rewarding participation in with the mechanisms through which this infor- the labour market, fostering equality in the tax mation will be disseminated and stored. It is due system and protecting the living standards of the for transposition by January 2007. The provisions most vulnerable. This would be sensible econ- of Part 3 mirror similar provisions included in the omic planning and investment. I assume that if Investment Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous the tax-welfare budget package of \2.36 billion is Provisions Act 2005 in connection with the trans- similar to 2006, almost half of it will be devoted position of the market abuse and prospectus to welfare improvements, some 23% will go to directives last year. Section 10 allows the Minister supports for children and the remainder will be to make regulations under this Act for the pur- allocated to tax reductions. pose of implementing the directive and related My proposals seek to minimise the impact of permission level instruments, as appropriate. this expenditure on labour activation and edu- As regards investment, employment and cational attainment. There is an opportunity to sensible planning, we must also provide for the end poverty, social exclusion and use the next employment of people with disabilities, an area couple of weeks in the run-up to the budget to that is often left out of such Bills. It has become do something in this regard. While we talk about noticeable over the last three years that the rate welfare increases and personal rates, it should be of unemployment among people with disabilities possible to increase the lowest rates by \20, the is extremely high, and this is not acceptable. means-tested State pension and related payments There are many people with disabilities, middle- by \18 and the contributory State pension by \15 aged and elderly included, who are very able and per week. As regards the qualified adult allow- talented and who have a massive contribution to ance, I propose we increase the lower rates by make to society. This must be faced in the debate \16 and the contributory pension rate by \13 per as we talk about investments. week. Increasing social welfare rates is the key At this morning’s meeting of the Joint Commit- mechanism for reducing poverty in Ireland. Cash tee on Justice, Equality, Defence and Women’s transfers are currently 20% less effective in Rights, there was a very interesting discussion reducing poverty than the EU average. about the sectoral plan that deals with the Section 4 of the Investment Funds, Companies employment of people with disabilities. This is and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill provides for very important and should be linked into this the laying of orders and regulations before both debate as well. I note the National Consumer Houses of the Oireachtas and empowers either Agency currently works to address the needs of House to annul the order or regulation within 21 vulnerable consumers, including those with dis- days. Section 5 provides for the authority to meet abilities and where appropriate will work in part- the expenses incurred by the Minister in the nership with and support initiatives being taken administration of the Act. When one digs deeper by organisations in this area. Other features into the legislation one finds that section 6 raised in the sectoral plan discussions included amends section 32 of the Companies embedding the mainstream context costs across a (Amendment) (No. 2) Act by increasing the audit range of services provided by the Department exemption thresholds for turnover and balance and its agencies, compliance with Part 3 of the sheet totals, up to the maximum levels permitted Disability Act 2005 regarding the provision of by the EU. The new thresholds will be \7.3 mil- accessible services to people with disabilities and lion for turnover and \3.65 million for balance the protocol for interdepartmental working. All sheet. This will apply to a company in respect of of this work is to be fully embedded within the a financial year that commences not earlier than Department’s business planning guidelines in the two months after the commencement of this pro- context of further developing and expanding this vision. Section 7 amends section 239 of the Com- process. Disability will also be taken into account panies Act 1990, by providing regulations for the in the Department’s review of the business plan- introduction of mandatory dematerialisation in ning process to be undertaken later in 2006. electronic form. I am urging that the legislation While all these initiatives are very welcome, there be seriously looked at while we are being very is a number of serious concerns I wish to raise. supportive of it. The timeframes for the roll-out of various The purpose of Part 3 is to pass provisions elements of the vocational, training and employ- which need to be enacted in primary law to ment strategy seem to be very tight and slippage ensure the smooth and effective transposition of in one will tend to have a knock-on effect, thus the EU transparency directive on the harmonis- delaying the entire implementation process. It ation of requirements to disclose information will be crucial to structure the work programme 795 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 796

[Mr. F. McGrath.] The Minister of State mentioned that Dublin is in order to avoid this. For example, the Depart- now recognised for securitisation and is ranked ments of Health and Children and Enterprise, alongside London and Frankfurt. When one Trade and Employment, have committed to looks at the sums involved, which currently stand establishing a working group to report to Mini- at approximately \80 billion, one will see this is sters by the end of 2006 regarding the scope and crucial to the domestic economy. As society arrangements for the phased transfer of appro- develops, we must not leave any sector behind. priate employment services from the health sec- In this top class economy there is no excuse for tor to the Department of Enterprise, Trade and leaving people behind. Employment. People using these services and In the course of my contribution I have men- their ancillary supports will comprise a substan- tioned the economy, enterprise, trade, employ- tial proportion of the proposed target group. A ment, investment and the wider debate of how delay in this transfer could delay everything. resources will be distributed. I also mentioned the Research has repeatedly identified benefit specific targeting and inclusion of people with dis- traps as being a major impediment to people with abilities. I was elected on this mandate in Dublin disabilities taking up employment. I consider the North-Central. We must ensure these people are proposal to collaborate with other key Depart- included and are part of the broader society. ments and agencies to promote the removal of St. Michael’s House on the north side of the these benefit trap disincentives as being much too Dublin is an excellent service provider for people weak. This is further borne out by the fact that with disabilities. It currently has 296 people on its the only interdepartmental working arrange- residential waiting list. Some 74% of these people ments proposed are those between the Depart- are living on the north side of Dublin. St. ments of Health and Children and Enterprise, Michael’s House is looking for 70 new places per Trade and Employment. This is only a continu- year to resolve this. That does not seem to be ation of what is already in place. asking too much in this wealthy country and I raise these issues because they are important would be a wise investment for this or any other Government to make. St. Michael’s House also to investment funds and general employment in \ the economy. When one looks at the details of has a deficit of 1.5 million and is under pressure to correct this. I urge the Minister of State to use employment rights and industrial affairs, includ- his influence with his senior colleagues in Cabinet ing the labour inspectorate, one feels this will to help provide services for people with dis- impact substantially on people with disabilities, abilities. The St. Michael’s House project most particularly if the training and employment deserves our support. Senior Ministers have strategy is successful in keeping more such per- spoken about stamp duty and have said they do sons in employment. This can be used wisely. not know what to do with certain revenue. They There are many businesses in the IT and financial need their heads examined. They should look at sectors that could employ more people with dis- the real world where people are seeking help and abilities. They will make a massive contribution support. They could also provide the resources to to society. People often talk of social inclusion — employ 59 additional jobs to assist this huge let us do something about it when we are plan- service provider in Dublin. ning for the State and the economy. This issue is It is important to talk about investment for the part of today’s debate. future. I thank the nuns in Baldoyle who have While I welcome the proposed initiatives made a major contribution to St. Michael’s House regarding entrepreneurship, this should have in the past week or so; they sold property and included a policy of promoting the excellent land worth \30 million to the St. Michael’s organ- training programmes and other supports provided isation for \100. I commend them on and thank to community and voluntary organisations by the them for this. There are times when church county enterprise boards. Deputy Fleming also organisations are hammered in this House by cer- referred to the community and voluntary sector. tain individuals for things they did in the past and Section 13 amends the Central Bank Act 1942 while it is right that they should be challenged, to include the transparency directive in the list we must also acknowledge the contribution of of directives for which the bank has enforcement religious organisations. St. Michael’s House takes responsibility. This deals with confidentiality of people with disabilities out of institutions. This is information obtained by the competent authority a good investment for the future, which creates a and effectively prohibits its disclosure. It is an modern and respectful life for people with dis- important section. Section 14 allows Ministers to abilities. I strongly support the legislation. cite, by provisional order, the markets in addition to regulated markets to which transparency laws Mr. Finneran: I compliment the Minister of shall apply. It is important that the requirements State, Deputy Michael Ahern, and his Cabinet under the transparency directive should be cap- colleague, Deputy Martin, on introducing this able of being applied to markets outside the Bill. It deals with investment funds, updates our directive’s scope, such as, for example, the Irish position on company law and brings us into line enterprise exchange market or any new market with Europe. While part of this relates to dealing that may be established in the future. with European directives, it has also come about 797 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 798 because of the country’s success. This country has because many years ago people brought forward moved forward with such great strides that it is policies and legislation to underpin investment, envied by democracies across the western world. set up the financial services sector by the Liffey, We should not take for granted that these circum- give entrepreneurs an opportunity to start their stances will remain in place no matter what hap- own businesses and provide security to people in pens. It would be terrible folly for people to terms of their investments. That is the reason it believe this. happened. The people at home and abroad have The most important factor in bringing the brought us to where we are today. country to this level was strategic Government An additional 1 million people are working in policy over a number of years that supported this country. Why do people flock to our shores? investment and enterprise and gave entre- Is it because they believe we are good for a cup preneurs the opportunity to create employment of tea or will say hello to them on the street? That and wealth. This did not happen by chance but is not the reason. They are here because they can came about because senior figures at departmen- make money for themselves or to send to their tal and Government level created a playing pitch families in eastern Europe, Brazil and elsewhere. that allows the country to move forward in the Those people have fuelled our economy. They manner we have seen. came here because our economy is able to absorb There is another reality in that we cannot take them and give them an opportunity, and they are for granted that that will be the case into the making a return to our economy in the taxes col- future. We do not have to reflect back too far to lected by the Department of Finance. Deputy see what happened in this country. I am talking Finian McGrath said that the Government should about the 1970s and 1980s. In the marts and fairs give various benefits to people, but we can give in the midlands and the west, people left their nothing if the money does not come in. If the stock behind them in the towns because they finances are not returned to Merrion Street, the could not sell them. They did not bother bringing Minister, Deputy Cowen, or the Government them home. I remember coming out of the mart cannot give it out. The only way it can do that is in Ballinasloe and seeing 17 calves on Society if those in employment pay their taxes and by Street that nobody owned. Those are the facts people investing and becoming involved in the about what happened in our country not many further development of our country. That is the years ago. reality check I spoke about on which we must Irrespective of what happens, we must not take remain focused. I am concerned about statements for granted that the wealth available to the Mini- made by some people, who may or may not be in ster for Finance today to look after the interests Cabinet positions after the next general election, of our people, particularly those who are less in terms of what they will do in that regard, but well-off, will be readily available to him. That is they can do nought if the money does not come not the case. Young people may not understand into the Department of Finance. what I am saying but those facts must be stated. The legislation before the House is welcome In the past ten or 12 years, this country has because it reflects where we are as a nation. It experienced an unprecedented level of growth, as reflects on our success and our ability to become much as 10% in some cases although it is down the envy of Europe in terms of opportunity in to 5% now. That is without parallel in Europe or enterprise and employment. The circumstances the western world. There may be some examples that allowed that are as a result of good, strategic in Asian countries whose economies do not have policies by excellent civil servants and Ministers the transparency or democracy we enjoy. over a period. That is a reality check for the Irish people The provisions in the Bill are many but what is when they go to the polls in May or June. I am their purpose in layman’s terms? They are to not making a party political statement with a view relieve the burden of regulations, facilitate busi- to pointing a finger at any Opposition representa- ness development, provide solidarity for our com- tive. I very much appreciate the constructive con- petitors and give effect to European Union tributions of the Opposition spokesman on directives. We are sometimes criticised because enterprise and employment, Deputy Hogan, who of our rush to meet EU directives but in the fin- is in the Chamber, but some Members regularly ancial and investment areas, it is important we make contributions in which they take for have a clean sheet. We have a clean sheet in the granted that the moneys coming into the coffers eyes of the world, and that is very important. If of the Department of Finance will continue to we are to keep up to speed as regards financial come in irrespective of Government policies. activity and investment, this legislation is That is a myth. necessary. This debate is about investment funds. We are This country has an acceptable common law talking about an increase of asset-backed security practice that always has been supportive of the investments from \6 billion in 1999 to \80 billion business environment. We have the best entre- today. Would any Member of this House say that preneurs compared to those in any country happened by chance or that it fell our way worldwide. Ireland is a country to which other because we are a little green island on the verge countries look up. I am a regular visitor to the of Europe? That is not the case. It happened United States. My family’s background is in the 799 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 800

[Mr. Finneran.] will realise that it would be very difficult to return financial sector in the United States. My father to the days when Irish people were taking the was the first of his generation born in this country boat and had difficulties. These dangers exist and I have kept close links with the United States unless we maintain stability of investment, all my life. I am always amazed by the compli- enterprise, and employment. Otherwise we ments paid to young Irish graduates and busi- cannot support what I seek, namely, that the less nessmen and women on the way they take on new well-off will have a better return after the budget. challenges in IT, finance, business and enterprise. This legislation gives us food for thought in that We should not be slow to compliment ourselves regard. I compliment the Minister for Enterprise, on the ability of Irish people in that regard. Trade and Employment, Deputy Martin, the Mention was made by some speakers of the Minister of State, Deputy Ahern, and his officials. voluntary sector on which I want to comment. I commend the Bill to the House. Some years ago I became fearful that the volun- tary sector would disappear and that Minister of State at the Department of 2 o’clock people would not come forward to Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Mr. M. become involved in voluntary bodies Ahern): I thank all Deputies who have spoken. and organisations because of our rush to live the This is a technical Bill, covering company and high life in this affluent State. I am pleased to say consumer law. The provisions in the Bill facilitate I was wrong because Irish people are as con- business development and secure our competitive cerned with and committed to the voluntary sec- edge in key sectors. Our regulatory environment tor as they ever were. As many, if not more, is a key component of our competitiveness and people as before put themselves forward to act our international reputation. Where possible, we as committee members or officers of voluntary should ease the regulatory burden on business, as organisations. It is important that the State recog- expressed by speakers today. nises and supports this voluntary effort. Deputy Eamon Ryan stated that we must The voluntary sector finds it difficult to deal provide flexibility to industry while keeping with regulation and bureaucracy. In some cases appropriate controls in place. A flexible, respon- small grants have become albatrosses around the sive, business-focused regulatory system has been necks of voluntary organisations. It is now a pain- the cornerstone of Ireland’s development over ful task to deal with a small grant from a State the past 15 years. To ensure a level playing field organisation. I refer to county enterprise boards it is also in our interest to give full effect to and Leader boards. Voluntary people are important EU directives. I appreciate the contri- involved in these matters yet the most qualified butions of Deputies Hogan, Lynch, Eamon Ryan accountants and legal support people would be and others. Interesting points were made during needed to assess and draw down grants. We have the debate. gone overboard on regulation in this area. Deputy Hogan raised the matter of regulators The Minister of State at the Department of but I do not accept all his points, specifically his Enterprise, Trade and Employment, Deputy claim about a lack of policy basis. I agree that Michael Ahern, keeps his finger on the pulse of we should debate the manner in which regulators his constituency. He would not be in this House operate. That is the basis of democracy. for the past 20 years if that was not the case. We must examine how we treat the voluntary sector. Mr. Hogan: I am glad the Minister of State We rush to support it with grants but we ham- agrees with me about regulators. string it when it tries to draw them down. Some years ago lottery grants were a simple matter for Mr. M. Ahern: Deputy Hogan also referred to GAA clubs, soccer clubs and boating clubs. Now, the Central Bank and the Competition Authority. the Office of the Chief State Solicitor has its These matters are of concern but do not concern claws in the process. The paper trail involved in this Bill. The Deputy also referred to the IFSC drawing down a sum greater than \50,000 is and the financial services sector. This underpins unbelievable. These people are gardaı´, county a number of provisions in this Bill. We must council members, farmers or secretaries and are ensure the IFSC is controlled and maintains its involved on a voluntary basis. The must try to reputation. draw down money invested in a local hall, pitch Changes sought by Deputy Hogan to ensure or sporting facility. Such regulation is the way to the benefits of competition are passed on to the hunt people out of the voluntary sector. We must consumer will be considered in the context of the be careful not to exclude people from this area. consumer competition legislation, as opposed to They will wonder why they should endure such this amendment which deals mainly with com- hassle on a voluntary basis, with Departments pany law matters. Deputy Hogan mentioned that piling regulation on organisations for a few euro prices had risen by approximately 10% in the last that contribute to the common good. year or so. Interestingly, another spokesperson This Bill is necessary from a national and Euro- from Deputy Hogan’s party claimed during the pean perspective. Today’s generation must reflect summer recess that, based on a survey carried out on the future. Can we maintain and improve on by Fine Gael, the price controls which had come the level of income with changed policies? People into operation had no benefits for consumers. 801 Investment Funds, Companies and 12 October 2006. Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 802

When this survey was examined, it was revealed Mr. Hogan: The Minister of State is thinking that none of the items covered ever came under the right way. the price control order so I hope the figure of 10% is not based on a similar survey. Mr. M. Ahern: Deputy Eamon Ryan raised the issue of the liability of a guarantor. Section 8 sub- Mr. Hogan: It is based on figures from Govern- stitutes a new section for section 43 of the Invest- ment agencies. ment Funds, Companies and Miscellaneous Pro- visions Act 2005. Essentially, the purpose of this Mr. M. Ahern: Deputy Lynch highlighted the amendment is to limit the potential liability of a training of auditors who will only use information guarantor to the content of a prospectus in so far for one year. I would appreciate if the Deputy as it relates to the guarantor or the guarantee would contact my office to discuss the matter. She given by him or her. It is not an open-ended also highlighted directives which were not being situation where a guarantor can be sued over transposed. In 2005, my Department transposed issues outside the prospectus or the guarantee. the prospectus and market abuse directives and This amendment will undoubtedly be discussed also facilitated international accounting stan- further on Committee Stage. dards. In 2006, the takeover directive was dealt Deputy Connaughton raised the issue of the with and this Bill completes the suites of change to mandatory computer records and effec- tively questioned whether security could be directives with the transparency directive. In guaranteed. Some companies are already addition, the Bill picks up on some points over- operating in this manner since the uncertificated looked in the takeover directive and which securities regulations were made in 1996 and no needed to be tweaked. We are working our way particular difficulties have been brought to my or through these directives very speedily and my Department’s attention. effectively. Deputy Fleming highlighted issues relating to Deputy Lynch also highlighted consumer issues the types of companies which can benefit from and asked why we were introducing an amend- the audit exemption. He quoted from a letter I ment to appoint a person to the post of Director sent to him two years ago in which I stated the of Consumer Affairs for more than six months. matter was being considered by the company law The principal reason for making such an appoint- review group. I raised the issue a number of years ment is because it was considered that a compe- ago with my officials and the company law reform tition, which is the normal procedure for appoint- group. The group is examining the matter ing a director, would be impractical because it because there are a number of perspectives to be was intended to incorporate the Office of the examined in respect of voluntary bodies. Where Director of Consumer Affairs into the new funds are involved, the perspective will differ national consumer agency. Deputy Hogan also from that of a family-owned company or a com- asked this question. Deputy Lynch also asked pany with shareholders. This area needs to be when the national consumer agency would be examined because overregulation and the bur- established. It is expected the Bill will be pub- dens placed on people working in a voluntary lished before the end of the year and that the capacity, as Deputy Finneran noted, can drive agency will be statutorily established in early them away. It is very important to achieve a 2007. balance and I hope this matter will be sorted out Deputy Lynch also asked when the company in due time. law consolidation and reform Bill will be pub- Speakers have mentioned qualified account- lished. The company law reform group is prepar- ants. There is a difference between a qualified ing the heads of the Bill, which contains approxi- accountant and auditor or accountant-auditor. mately 1,500 sections. The term “accountant” is being examined and hopefully in the not too distant future a definition Mr. Hogan: The Minister of State should tell it will be produced to protect the public from to take its time. people setting up as accountants who do not have the qualifications to make them competent in Mr. M. Ahern: Deputy Lynch hopes the this area. Labour Party will be in Government when it is Mr. Hogan: Turf accountants. enacted. Mr. M. Ahern: It is aimed at protecting the Mr. Hogan: We will wait until we are in public. Deputy Fleming also asked about audits Government. and the protection of minority shareholders. A total of 10% or more of a company’s members Mr. M. Ahern: In the meantime, it is being can require that the company’s accounts are aud- moved forward and, hopefully, will be ready in ited. I do not know how the Revenue Commis- the not too distant future. Perhaps Deputy Hogan sioners will treat unaudited accounts but, from might introduce it. my experience of dealing with them, I am confi- 803 Priority 12 October 2006. Questions 804

[Mr. M. Ahern.] Question put and agreed to. dent they have their own standards and pro- cedures and will know whether the accounts Sitting suspended at 2.20 p.m. and resumed at presented represent a true and fair view and dis- 3.30 p.m. play the proper results. Deputy Eamon Ryan commented on small and Ceisteanna — Questions. medium-sized enterprises and implied that Ireland depended on foreign direct investment Priority Questions. and multinationals. Approximately 60% of com- panies in Ireland are small and medium-sized ———— enterprises, in other words, enterprises with less than 50 employees, and the sector employs over Overseas Missions. 113,000 people. The gross national product pro- jected for the coming year is approximately 5.5% 1. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for Defence to 6% and is greater than the gross domestic the role Irish troops will play in the United product, which reveals that indigenous companies Nations Interim Force in Lebanon, UNIFIL II; are now making a greater contribution to employ- and if he will make a statement on the matter. ment and exports. In this light, it is important that [32434/06] our regulatory burden does not prevent our small and medium-sized enterprises from growing and 5. Mr. Gormley asked the Minister for Defence developing and keeping our economy going the situation regarding the mission of Irish soldi- forward. ers to be deployed to Lebanon; the number of Since this Bill was approved by the Govern- troops involved; their duties; the locations where ment, a number of other issues have been raised they will be stationed; if the overall mission is required to disarm Hizbollah; if this deployment with me which may require amendments to the will require the approval of Da´il E´ ireann; and if Bill. Most of the proposals are in the area of com- he will make a statement on the matter. pany law. I will introduce amendments on Com- [32459/06] mittee Stage for those proposals deemed to merit consideration by the Oireachtas. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose The Investment Funds, Companies and Mis- to take Questions Nos. 1 and 5 together. cellaneous Provisions Act 2005 provided for the The United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon, introduction of a new type of investment fund UNIFIL, was originally established on 19 March vehicle, the non-UCITS common contractual 1978 under United Nations Security Council Res- fund. Concern has now arisen in the funds indus- olutions 425 and 426, following the invasion of try regarding the availability of the protections of Lebanon by Israel, with a mandate “to confirm the Netting of Financial Contracts Act 1995, as the withdrawal of Israeli forces, to restore inter- amended, to the non-UCITS common contractual national peace and security and to assist the funds. My officials are examining the issue and, if government of Lebanon in ensuring the return of necessary, I will table an amendment to the Net- its effective authority in the area”. The Secretary ting of Financial Contracts Act on Committee General of the United Nations concluded that, as Stage. of 16 June 2000, Israel had withdrawn its forces I thank all Deputies who contributed to this from Lebanon in accordance with Resolution 425, most useful and informative discussion. I hope I thus partially fulfilling UNIFIL’s original man- have clarified most, if not all, of the questions date. Since then, UNIFIL has continued to raised. A number of issues were raised on which operate in southern Lebanon. The mission con- we will reflect between now and Committee tinued to focus on the remaining part of its man- Stage. date, namely the restoration of peace and security in the region, through observing, monitoring and Question put and agreed to. reporting on developments in its area of oper- ation, liaising with the parties, with a view to cor- Investment Funds, Companies and recting violations along the line of withdrawal, Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2006 [Seanad]: the so-called Blue Line, and preventing the escal- Referral to Select Committee. ation of hostilities. Minister of State at the Department of Ireland has participated in UNIFIL since 1978. Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Mr. M. Between May 1978 and November 2001, the Ahern): I move: Defence Forces had an infantry battalion with an approximate strength of 540 personnel in That the Bill be referred to the Select Com- Lebanon, together with approximately 100 per- mittee on Enterprise and Small Business, in sonnel in UNIFIL Headquarters and the Force accordance with Standing Order 120(1) and Mobile Reserve. Since November 2001, a small paragraph 1(a)(i) of the Orders of Reference number of Defence Forces personnel continued of that committee. to serve at the force headquarters in Naqoura. 805 Priority 12 October 2006. Questions 806

Five personnel are currently deployed at the tion. While the Irish element will be tasked pri- force headquarters. marily for reconnaissance, security and protection In response to the crisis of July and August duties associated with the engineering works, it 2006, the UN decided, under UN Security will also be available to undertake other tasks at Council Resolution 1701, to extend the mandate the request of the UNIFIL force commander. of UNIFIL to the end of August 2007, and to Deployment to UNIFIL will take place on 30 or increase its troop strength from approximately 31 October 2006 and, if approved, will bring the 2,000 troops to a maximum of 15,000. The council total number of Defence Forces personnel serv- also decided that, in addition to carrying out its ing overseas to about 830 which is below the ceil- original mandate under Resolutions 425 and 426, ing of 850. UNIFIL would also monitor the cessation of hos- Initial deployment would be for one year sub- tilities, accompany and support the Lebanese ject to renewal of the mandate and a satisfactory armed forces as they deploy throughout Southern review of the mission at that time. In line with Lebanon and extend its assistance to help ensure standing policy that the duration of any deploy- humanitarian access to civilian populations and ment should be set at the outset of a mission, it the voluntary and safe return of displaced is considered that Defence Forces involvement in persons. UNIFIL should not exceed a maximum of two to The nature of the expanded UNIFIL mandate three years in duration. is such that its role is to be considerably more robust than it was prior to the adoption of Resol- Mr. Timmins: The troops will be leaving ution 1701, while still operating under Chapter VI around 31 October. Does the Minister for of the UN Charter. UNIFIL will assist the Defence, Deputy O’Dea, plan to visit the troops Government of Lebanon in exercising its auth- before Christmas or will he visit the observers ority throughout the UNIFIL area of operations. already out there before the troops are deployed? It will take all necessary action, acting in support The Minister will be aware that this additional of the Government of Lebanon, “to ensure that commitment, which we in the Fine Gael Party its area of operations is not utilised for hostile support, will place additional strain on resources. activities of any kind”. UNIFIL is not charged Does he plan to increase the strength of the with disarming the Hizbollah. The question of Defence Forces? How will he deal with the disarming Hizbollah is a matter for the Lebanese additional strain placed on Defence Forces Government. Moreover, it is recognised that this resources in Ireland, given overseas com- can only take place in the context of an overall mitments? political process in the region. Has the Minister had discussions recently with Following on from the ceasefire, which took either the Israeli ambassador or the Iranian effect on 14 August 2006, the Government here ambassador based here in Dublin or with rep- has been monitoring the situation. As the resentatives of the Lebanese and Syrian embass- Deputies will appreciate, given our other existing ies in London? Has the Minister for Foreign commitments, the Defence Forces have limited affairs engaged in such discussions? If not, would resources to contribute to this mission. Against the Minister for Defence consider meeting them this background, an option was identified before Irish troops are deployed in the area? whereby Ireland might partner Finnish troops These are the countries with influence in the and provide a protection detail to a planned Finn- region and if difficulties arise it is important we ish engineering company. On 3 October 2006, the have a direct link to someone who can bring Government authorised, subject to Da´il approval, influence to bear in the area. the despatch of a contingent of the Defence Forces to UNIFIL. The necessary enabling Mr. O’Dea: I will clarify the situation on motion was approved yesterday. deployment for Deputy Timmins. The first Following detailed discussions between the advance party, consisting of four specialist per- Defence Forces and their Finnish counterparts, sonnel will travel to Lebanon on 14 October, that including a joint reconnaissance mission to is, next week, to make the necessary advance con- Lebanon, the current plan envisages the deploy- tacts at ports, airports and so on. The second ment of a Finnish engineering unit with an Irish advance party, consisting of 35 personnel, will protection detail in the eastern sector area of deploy to Beirut on 24 October and the balance Lebanon. The planned Irish contingent will con- will leave on either 30 or 31 October. sist of approximately 150 Defence Forces person- I have no plans to increase the size of the nel. The five Defence Forces personnel currently Defence Forces. Under the White Paper for the serving in Lebanon will continue to be deployed reorganisation of the Defence Forces the person- at the UNIFIL force headquarters. nel limit was reduced to 10,500 on the basis that The Finnish and Irish engineering unit will we would equip and train them to the highest carry out tasks in support of UNIFIL and also possible standard. When the mission in Liberia some humanitarian work, including dealing with ends next year there will be further personnel unexploded ordnance clearance and reconstruc- available to partake in overseas duties. 807 Priority 12 October 2006. Questions 808

[Mr. O’Dea.] by forceful means. The provision, although not My colleague, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, covered by a typical Chapter VI-type resolution, generally speaks to ambassadors. I do not know is designated a Chapter VI provision by the of any discussions he may have had with the United Nations. ambassadors mentioned but I will ask him and I take the point Deputy Gormley made yester- return to the Deputy on the matter. I will talk to day that the people of Lebanon probably just the Minister for Foreign Affairs before deciding want a Chapter VI mission rather than a Chapter whether I should meet these representatives. I VII mission. However, we have already engaged had one rather fraught meeting with the Israeli in Chapter VII operations. Such missions ambassador, accompanied by the Minister for involved Liberia and Kosovo, and we are there- Foreign Affairs, at the time four UN personnel fore well aware of the dangers. were killed by Israeli munitions. The disarmament of Hizbollah is a difficult Mr. Costello: Was the Minister carrying his matter which has been fudged somewhat by the gun? United Nations. The general understanding is that it is a matter for the Lebanese Government. Mr. O’Dea: No, I was unarmed that day. I was Granted, part of our UNIFIL mandate in south- armed only with my genius. ern Lebanon is to support the Lebanese army as it redeploys through the region and re-establishes Mr. Timmins: The Minister was lightly armed its authority. It is very unclear whether it is envis- in that case, perhaps even still unarmed. aged that UNIFIL troops will be accompanying the Lebanese army in confronting and disarming Mr. O’Dea: Deputy Timmins asked if I plan to Hizbollah. visit the troops in Lebanon. I will do so, after they When the UN General Secretary referred to an deploy, around mid to late November. overall agreement, I believe he meant it would certainly involve the Shebaa Farms. This is cen- Mr. Gormley: The Minister stated yesterday tral to the issue. I cannot see how the agreement and repeated today that this mandate is consider- ably more robust than the previous one. Does this would not involve Syria and it may possibly mean we could be drawn into hostilities at some involve Iran but I do not know the exact par- stage? ameters of the General Secretary’s statement. He From what the Minister stated yesterday and was referring to an overall political settlement, today, the nature of our role in assisting the just as disarmament took place in a part of this Lebanese Government is not clear. Deputy country in the context of an overall political Coveney said yesterday we will be assisting the settlement. I would imagine the settlement in the Lebanese Government to disarm Hizbollah. Is region in question would involve all the the Lebanese Government mandated to disarm interested parties. It would certainly include Syria Hizbollah? Are we not mandated to assist it in but I am not quite clear about Iran. doing so and, if so, are we not thereby disarming Hizbollah indirectly? Mr. Timmins: Has the Minister plans to The Minister stated the disarmament of Hiz- increase the overseas allowance? He may have bollah will only take place in the context of an indicated at a recent conference that he would overall agreement. What does he mean by this? examine this matter. Does an overall agreement involve Syria and Iran A number of memorials were erected in hon- sitting at the table? Does it involve addressing the our of Irish troops who lost their lives in question of the Shebaa Farms, a disputed terri- Lebanon. If a new contingent goes to the region, tory, and the Gaza Strip and West Bank? could it determine whether they need to be repaired or replaced? Mr. O’Dea: The mandate is more robust. In my reply I quoted the terms of the UN resolution Mr. Gormley: Hizbollah clearly has a great laying out the mandate for UNIFIL. It includes interest in the Palestinian problem. As part of the the phrase “to resist attempts by forceful means overall settlement, will the West Bank and Gaza to prevent it from discharging its duties under the mandate of the Security Council”. This is not a Strip not also be discussed? typical run-of-the-mill Chapter VI-type resol- ution. Chapter VI-type resolutions generally Mr. O’Dea: On Deputy Gormley’s question, I come into play when a ceasefire is in operation, would imagine “yes” is the answer. The as it is in this case, admittedly. Generally, Chap- Palestinian question cannot just be syphoned off. ter VI operations involve patrolling, monitoring On the question of overseas allowances, I said and observing. at the PDFORRA annual conference that if the It is contemplated that attempts may be made association were to request an increase in over- to prevent UNIFIL from discharging its mandate seas allowances, it would be considered most and it is given the right to resist those attempts sympathetically. 809 Priority 12 October 2006. Questions 810

Defence Forces Morale. tained. For example, personnel regularly apply to extend their period at sea beyond two years. 2. Mr. Costello asked the Minister for Defence I am very much aware of the report referred to if his attention has been drawn to the recent by the Deputy. On 19 September I held dis- report, A Voyage of Understanding; his views on cussions with PDFORRA and I hope we are the report’s findings of low morale in the Naval moving towards a resolution. Service; if he will address the many issues high- lighted in the report; and if he will make a state- Additional information not given on the floor of ment on the matter. [32597/06] the House. I am pleased that in our meeting we agreed to Mr. O’Dea: The Naval Service is the maritime a process to examine this issue and find potential element of the Defence Forces and has a general solutions. A further series of meetings will take responsibility to meet contingent and actual mari- place between the deputy chief of staff — support time defence requirements. The Naval Service — and PDFORRA over the coming months. The operates eight general purpose patrol ships. All purpose of the meetings is to examine the com- eight ships are involved in coastal and offshore plex issues raised by PDFORRA with a view to patrolling and surveillance for the State in that exploring a possible resolution. I will be monitor- part of the seas where State jurisdiction applies, ing progress in this area closely. such as internal waters, territorial sea and the It goes without saying that members of the Irish sector of the exclusive economic zone. naval service go to sea. My Department and I are The main day-to-day role of the Naval Service committed to ensuring that the Naval Service and is to provide a fishery protection service in the Defence Forces as a whole offer a challenging accordance with the State’s obligations as a and rewarding career and a supportive working member of the European Union. The service is environment. tasked with patrolling all Irish waters from the shoreline to the outer limits of the exclusive fish- Mr. Costello: The Minister said he is aware of ery limits. the report on the effects of long-term sea patrols The current exclusive fishery limits extend to on family life in the Naval Service, entitled A 200 miles off shore and cover an area of 132,000 Voyage of Understanding. It is a large tome and square miles. The Naval Service currently patrols it makes a number of conclusions, the first of the entire 200-mile limit and periodically patrols which states: beyond these limits to protect specific fisheries. Without in any way wanting to sound dra- These patrols are carried out on a regular and matic, the service as experienced by the sur- frequent basis and are directed to all areas of veyed membership is in crisis. This crisis is fix- Irish waters as necessary. The number of patrol able given Government action only. vessels on patrol in Irish waters at any one time varies between three and seven. The Naval My question relates to the low morale in the Service is committed to having at least three ves- Naval Service. A large cohort of people were sur- sels on patrol within the Irish exclusive economic veyed in the PDFORRA study. More than 300 zone at any one time. There are 1,682 patrol days people were surveyed in total, including 212 serv- per annum. ing members and 134 spouses. It is heart-rending to read some of the information on families and The reorganisation of the Naval Service was children and the references to breakdowns, designed to ensure that, when fully implemented, depression and stress. These arise from what all personnel would spend alternate periods of seems to be a very poorly managed service in two years in a shore-based appointment followed respect of shore and sea rotation. by a ship-based appointment. Two years in a ship- Everybody acknowledges that recruits join the based appointment does not imply that people Naval Service to go to sea. However, they are spend two years at sea. This is managed locally profoundly disappointed by the manner in which by the flag officer commanding the Naval Service. the system operates. It is very difficult to engage However, where there are shortages of skilled in family life, in spite of the expression of support personnel within the Naval Service, it may be for family life in the Constitution. The personnel necessary for personnel to carry out sea-going feel so much could be done so easily and that duties more frequently. management, in itself, cannot rectify the problem. The impact of seagoing is well understood by Rather, it is felt that it can only be rectified Naval Service personnel at all levels and the directly through ministerial involvement. Can I service endeavours to operate a planned take it from the Minister that there will be such approach to the rotation of personnel between involvement? sea and shore. Other than for able seamen, there is no part- Mr. O’Dea: Deputy Costello is right. It is a big icular problem with maintaining sea-shore tome and it took me a long time to plough rotation for personnel. There are, however, indi- through it. I do not necessarily accept all the con- vidual cases where this may not be exactly main- clusions in the report. We do not have time to 811 Priority 12 October 2006. Questions 812

[Mr. O’Dea.] Defence if, further to his commissioning of an engage in a long debate on its intricate details, Army inquiry into the events at Niemba, Congo but I note that the situation seems to have wors- on 8 November 1960, preliminary findings have ened somewhat in recent times. I accept Deputy been made; when the full report of the inquiry Costello’s point that PDFORRA and the Naval will be made available to Da´il E´ ireann; and if he Service are of the view that this requires minis- will make a statement on the matter. [32433/06] terial involvement. That is why I decided to get involved personally. I called a meeting between Mr. O’Dea: As the Deputy is aware, I under- the relevant army officers, PDFORRA and took during Priority Questions on Thursday, 23 myself on 19 September. We set up a group com- February 2006 to ask the military authorities to prising representatives from PDFORRA and the revisit this matter in light of the questions raised Naval Service as well as the deputy chief of staff by him on that date. on the support side. I have asked them to try to The Chief of Staff appointed a senior officer to solve this problem. I will keep the situation moni- examine all aspects of the Niemba ambush in the tored and I have told them to come back to me Congo in November 1960. Due to the diversity of with a solution by January. I will sit down with this investigation, this process has taken some them again in January, at the very latest. time. I understand that, in the course of his exam- From my discussions with the deputy chief of ination, the officer interviewed both survivors staff and the relevant officials in the Naval and also contacted other interested parties both Service, together with the recruitment campaign at home and abroad. that is underway at present within the service, I I have been informed by the Chief of Staff that am reasonably confident that we will be able to the report is being finalised and I hope to receive solve this issue. As I said, I have taken personal the final version by the end of this week. I will charge of it because I realise it requires minis- then study its contents and, in particular, its find- terial involvement and I am monitoring the ings and recommendations prior to deciding what situation. My approach is hands-on in this matter. action should be taken.

Mr. Costello: I welcome the Minister’s reply. Mr. F. McGrath: I thank the Minister for his He is acknowledging and accepting the first response. I have a number of detailed questions. recommendation in the report to the effect that Is the Minister satisfied that the official Army the Minister should establish a formal review of version of the Niemba massacre, which shows the operation and management of the Naval that nine members of an 11-man Irish patrol died Service regarding the patrol policy at sea. He is that day, will be upheld by the inquiry? If not, reviewing the situation. will the Minister explain to the House why the The second recommendation is that he should Army’s version of events, which has been shown immediately reduce the length of long-term sea to be wrong in the recent excellent book, The patrols as an interim measure, pending the imple- Irish Army in the Congo, 1960-1964: The Far Bat- mentation of long-term changes. talions, by Dr. David O’Donoghue, has been allowed to remain uncorrected for almost half a Mr. O’Dea: I suppose one could say I am for- century? If, as now seems likely, the Army mally reviewing matters. That committee is for- inquiry finds that eight men died at Niemba and mally reviewing it. Its members are working that a ninth, Trooper Anthony Browne, died together to come up with a better way of doing three miles away some days later in another inci- things. Nothing can be done in the interim. We dent, will the Minister correct the statement he are making an attempt to get a more humane made to the House in this regard earlier this system. However, I do not necessarily accept all year? the conclusions in the report, as I said. For Will the Minister also consider reviewing the example, if one takes the number of patrol days Army’s treatment of the two Niemba survivors, we envisage, 1,680 per annum, it would require a Mr. Tom Kenny and Mr. Joe Fitzpatrick, who ship to be at sea for 200 to 220 days. The claim their good names have been impugned as a maximum we expect anyone on ship duties to be result of the Army’s incorrect history of the at sea is about 160 days. In some cases, that has Niemba incident? As regards the broader issue, been exceeded. The statistics show that, in 2005, we need to be very sensitive towards the serving a total of 29 personnel served more than 180 days. and former members of the Defence Forces and In 2006, a total of 56 served more than 180 days. the families of these men. I have noticed a considerable worsening of the situation and that is why I have taken a hands-on Mr. O’Dea: Deputy Finian McGrath is some- approach. We are hoping to make one strenuous what premature with some of those questions. He effort between us to get this matter sorted out. is asking whether I will correct the official version if the report finds that it is incorrect. I have not read the report yet, as it has not come to hand. I Overseas Missions. do not want to anticipate what is in it. If the 3. Mr. F. McGrath asked the Minister for report points out that the official version is 813 Priority 12 October 2006. Questions 814 wrong, of course we will deal with it. If I said formance of her duties. She is required to report anything incorrect on the record of the Da´il, I will annually to the Da´il. In these circumstances, I do be more than happy to correct it. We will study not consider it appropriate for me to report on the report in that regard. Any complaints the two her behalf or give details as regards her reports men have as regards their treatment or alleged on individual cases, complaints already submitted treatment by the Army can be brought to my per- to the ombudsman, the status of those complaints sonal attention. They have brought a few matters or her current treatment of those cases. to my attention and we have been in touch with I am happy to inform the Deputy that the them. Before I comment in detail on what the primary focus in these cases has been on selection report will reveal, I would like an opportunity to for promotion, courses and overseas service. I can read it first. I am sure the Deputy can understand also indicate that the reports of the ombudsman that point. have made a valuable contribution to the ongoing updating of selection procedures in these three Mr. F. McGrath: Is the Minister satisfied that areas. the inquiry which is being carried out has been very detailed and professional? Mr. Timmins: I do not wish the Minister to take Mr. O’Dea: It has been a very detailed and up the role of Ombudsman for the Defence diverse professional inquiry. That is why it has Forces, but perhaps he can answer this question. taken up to eight months. If a wrong has been done, is it the Minister who will seek to right it in the first place? Does the Defence Forces Ombudsman. Ombudsman for the Defence Forces make recommendations in her reports as to what action 4. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for Defence might be taken by the Minister? Can he indicate if any of the 12 reports received by him from the how many of the 12 reports to date affect former Ombudsman for the Defence Forces to date members, as complainants, and how many affect recommended or stated that a complainant had serving members? Finally, has the Minister been wronged or had a justified concern; if so, recommended any disciplinary action to date on the details of same; the remedy which has been any of the reports or what action has he taken in taken; and if he will make a statement on the respect of them? I would be obliged if he would matter. [32435/06] elaborate on those points. Mr. O’Dea: The Office of the Ombudsman for Mr. O’Dea: Again, I am not attempting to the Defence Forces was established under the avoid answering Deputy Timmins’s question, but Ombudsman (Defence Forces) Act 2004. On 19 the Office for the Ombudsman for the Defence September 2005, Ms Paulyn Marrinan-Quinn SC Forces is modelled on the public was appointed by the President, upon the recom- 4 o’clock services Ombudsman. The public mendation of the Government, as the first services Ombudsman gives an annual Ombudsman for the Defence Forces. report to the Da´il outlining the complaints she The function of the Ombudsman for the received and how they were dealt with by the rel- Defence Forces is to act as the ultimate point of evant Departments. Under the legislation, the appeal for an administrative investigation into Ombudsman will hear the complaint and give her complaints made by members, and former findings to the Department of Defence outlining members, of the Defence Forces against another whether the complaint has been upheld and, if member, former member or civil servant of the so, what action is recommended. The Minister is Department of Defence. The Ombudsman for the obliged to convey to the ombudsman the action Defence Forces may investigate a complaint in taken. This is contained in the annual report, respect of an action or decision, which may have which is due to be published shortly. adversely affected the complainant personally. The action or decision complained of must have On Deputy Timmins’s question about former occurred no earlier than 1 December 2005. and serving members, subject to correction, they As I mentioned in my speech to the 2006 were all made by serving members. Of the 12 annual PDFORRA conference, to date, the cases reported to the ombudsman, nine prelimi- Office of the Ombudsman for the Defence Forces nary and three final reports have issued. The has sent me 12 reports on individual cases relating ombudsman found in favour of the complainant to the PDF with which she has dealt. I have either in eight cases, and against the complainant in responded to or I am in the process of responding four. In the eight cases in question, six related to to the ombudsman in respect of each of these selection processes for career advancement reports. The Minister for Defence is obliged to courses, and two related to selection processes for inform the ombudsman of the measures taken or overseas service. proposed in response to her recommendation. The Ombudsman for the Defence Forces is, in Question No. 5 answered with Question accordance with the Act, independent in the per- No. 1. 815 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 816

Other Questions. time voluntarily cannot be expected to serve side by side with professional soldiers where one ———— group has the best quality protective gear while the others are sloshing around in unsuitable gear. Defence Forces Property. It is time to look again at this matter and provide 6. Mr. Costello asked the Minister for Defence clothing that is geared towards the individual. when the training hall will be constructed on Slie- venamon Road, Thurles, County Tipperary for Mr. O’Dea: To answer the first of Deputy the local Reserve Defence Force unit; when pro- Costello’s questions, no agreement has been tective wet clothing will be made available on an entered into by, or on behalf of, the Department individualised basis for each member of the with any third party. The matter was subject of Reserve Defence Force for when they are train- an application to the local authority for planning ing in inclement weather; and if he will make a permission and that permission, subject to con- statement on the matter. [32168/06] ditions, was granted some time ago. One of the conditions stipulated that the development must Mr. O’Dea: There are no plans to construct a be carried out solely within the property owned training hall in Thurles, County Tipperary for the by the applicant — which one would expect — Reserve Defence Force. The military authorities and that no part of the development should inform me that the current facility in Thurles encroach on the rights of adjoining property meets the needs of the RDF. My Department was owners without prior consent of the owner. I pre- approached some time ago by a developer who sume this refers to the Department of Defence. wished to access his adjoining property through a My Department does not intend to pursue this portion of the RDF property in Thurles. proposal. There is no agreement in place. Refur- However, no agreement has been made by my bishment works were carried out in that building Department to sell any part of this military prop- this year and money has been allocated for erty, nor has any commitment been entered into further works next year. There are no plans to regarding the incorporation of any portion of the sell, lease, loan, or otherwise dispose of any part property into any proposed development in the of the property to any third party. vicinity. I understand the point the Deputy is making There is an ongoing capital building prog- about integration between the Permanent and ramme in my Department designed to modernise Reserve Defence Force. There are 1,500 wet suits the living, training, operational and accom- for each of the four formations. Therefore, there modation facilities available to the Defence are some 6,000 suits for a total reserve com- Forces, both permanent and reserve. There has plement of approximately 9,500 members. It is a been an unprecedented level of spending on the matter of acquiring an additional 3,500 wetsuits. \ programme to date with more than 200 million I will look favourably on this. I am currently spent between 1999 and 2005. This year will see \ engaged in detailed and difficult discussions on a further 21.8 million invested in the prog- the Estimates with the Minister for Finance. I ramme. The programme, based on prioritised estimate the expenditure on the additional wet needs, is agreed between the civil and military suits would range from \1.25 million to \1.5 mil- authorities and approved annually by the lion. I will make the case for it to the Minister Minister. for Finance. On the issue of protective clothing, a quantity of disruptive pattern material, DPM, wet suits is Mr. Costello: I welcome the Minister’s positive available to all members of the RDF on a pool response towards finding the necessary money to basis within each formation. Each formation has an allocation of 1,500 suits. There are currently provide wet suits for the reserve. no plans to provide each member of the RDF The Minister said refurbishment works have with a DPM wet suit. been carried out on the training hall. My infor- mation is that the existing centre is not up to Mr. Costello: If there are plans for a private scratch and something more substantial is needed development at the rear of the training centre, to meet the needs of the Reserve Defence Force when are they due to come to fruition? Has the in the area. Minister secured an agreement with the devel- oper to replace existing buildings with new struc- Mr. O’Dea: The military has informed me that tures? If so, will this meet the future needs of the current accommodation is quite suitable. the centre? Refurbishment works have been carried out in Considering the Reserve Defence Force is due the RDF facilities in Thurles this year. As a result to be more closely integrated with the Permanent of the modernisation, the facilities now include Defence Force, it would be appropriate for it to offices, a lecture room and a reception area. It is have the same protective clothing as the Perma- intended to provide modern office furniture, floor nent Defence Force. Those who give up their covering and IT facilities in 2007. 817 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 818

Mr. Timmins: Deputy Costello’s points about participation in EU battle groups; and if he will providing standard equipment, such as wet suits, make a statement on the matter. [32566/06] for the Reserve Defence Force are well made. Is the Minister satisfied with the amalgamation pro- Mr. O’Dea: I propose to take Questions Nos. cess of the Reserve Defence Force to date? 7, 12, 41, 46, 57, 59, 177 and 178 together. I have on many occasions in the House set out Mr. O’Dea: It is going pretty well and we are the background to EU battle groups, the develop- on target. It is currently under review and we ment of which is strongly endorsed by the United have not had too many complaints. However, Nations, and Ireland’s position on them. Follow- when involved in a process such as this, one will ing the Government decision agreeing to Ireland inevitably get some complaints. We are doing our entering into discussions with like-minded nations best to meet any complaints that arise. on a possible contribution to a battle group, a del- egation from the Department of Defence and the Overseas Missions. Defence Forces met with their Swedish counter- 7. Mr. Crowe asked the Minister for Defence if parts in Stockholm. The detailed parameters of a he will offer a commitment that no member of possible contribution by Ireland to the Nordic the Defence Forces will be ordered to participate battle group are being worked through and are in EU battle group activities overseas; and if he close to finalisation. will make a statement on the matter. [32355/06] The potential Defence Forces contribution will involve an EOD-IEDD contingent with its own 12. Mr. Connaughton asked the Minister for security detail, together with staff posts at the Defence the progress made with regard to Irish operational and force headquarters. The total involvement in EU battle groups; and if he will number of personnel involved is expected to be make a statement on the matter. [32349/06] somewhere between 80 and 100. However, it must be remembered that this level of commit- 41. Aengus O´ Snodaigh asked the Minister for ment will only arise should the battle group be Defence if he will reconcile his assertion, articu- called upon to undertake an operation. In lated in responses by him to parliamentary ques- addition, battle groups are only deployed for tions, that Irish commitments to EU battle groups between 30 and 120 days. Any contribution to a will not necessitate extra defence spending with battle group will be met within the context of the the demand made on radio on 4 October 2006 by overall ceiling of 850 personnel serving overseas Defence Forces representative association at any one time set in the White Paper on PDFORRA for more funding and manpower in Defence and will have no adverse impact on our order to meet their new commitment to EU existing peace support operations. battle groups. [32259/06] A number of issues are currently being finalised and I expect to shortly bring the matter 46. Mr. Coveney asked the Minister for to Government for a final decision. As I have pre- Defence the level of commitment of members of viously stated, any deployment of the Irish con- the Army, Naval Service and Air Corps that tingent as part of the battle group will be a matter Ireland will devote to a future EU battle group; for sovereign decision, which in our case means and if he will make a statement on the matter. the requirements of the triple lock must be [32263/06] satisfied. 57. Mr. Allen asked the Minister for Defence Turning to the question of the voluntary nature the position with regard to Ireland’s participation of participation by members of the Defence in the formation of an EU battle group; and if he Forces in battle groups, a battle group is simply will make a statement on the matter. [32261/06] another vehicle under which the Defence Forces may participate in overseas peace support oper- 59. Mr. Gormley asked the Minister for ations and, as such, the standing arrangements for Defence the further developments in Ireland’s participation in such missions will continue to involvement with EU battle groups; and if he will apply. In general, the despatch of any personnel make a statement on the matter. [32267/06] on overseas missions, including peace support operations, is undertaken, as far as possible, on a 177. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for voluntary basis. That said, however, it would be Defence the extent of discussions to date in unacceptable if a mission to which the Govern- regard to Ireland’s participation in EU battle ment and Da´il E´ ireann were committed could not groups; and if he will make a statement on the be undertaken simply because we could not get a matter. [32565/06] sufficient number of volunteers. As such, all members of the Permanent Defence Force are 178. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for liable for overseas service, subject to the pro- Defence the extent of the training offered to visions of the Defence Acts. I refer in particular members of the Defence Forces in anticipation of to the Defence (Amendment) Act 1993, which 819 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 820

[Mr. O’Dea.] be no requirement for joint training or exercises excludes people who were enlisted prior to that by the Nordic battle group in Ireland. enactment. There are no plans for the involvement of the Aengus O´ Snodaigh: That was an interesting Naval Service or the Air Corps on overseas oper- answer. The Minister said the personnel involved ations. However, individual members of the should be deployed on a voluntary basis as far as Naval Service or the Air Corps may be deployed possible. Will the Minister agree that section 4 of on overseas peace support operations, as they this year’s Defence (Amendment) Act provides have been in the past. for the secondary conscription of Defence Forces The Government’s White Paper on Defence, personnel to undertake overseas services? Until published in February 2000, set out a medium- now, the attitude of the soldiers in the Defence term strategy for defence covering the period up Forces, and I am mindful of the word “defence” to 2010. A major objective of the strategy is to in that title, was civic-minded and the numbers ensure that Ireland has a world-class military volunteering usually exceeded the numbers organisation capable of carrying out the roles required. That attitude has been welcomed assigned to it by the Government, both at home throughout the world in terms of United Nations and abroad. This objective requires an ongoing missions abroad. modernisation process, including an investment Will the Minister communicate with programme, to ensure that the Defence Forces PDFORRA whose general secretary expressed are properly equipped for these roles. With the major concern at the annual conference last week extensive investment in new equipment and train- about the shift in section 4 of the Defence ing over the past number of years and with the (Amendment) Act allows? I do not know if the current policy of continual recruitment to the Minister is aware that the general secretary stated Defence Forces, there is no requirement to that personnel involved in these activities have increase expenditure on equipment or manpower always done so on a voluntary basis and that the to meet battle group commitments. As I have organisation would pursue all means to defend already stated, any proposed battle group com- the voluntary rights of its members on this mitment can be met from within the existing ceil- matter. That could create a crisis and I urge the ing of 850 personnel serving overseas at any one Minister to ensure, if possible, that the situation time. that existed prior to the 2006 Act, and perhaps even prior to the 1993 Act, be endorsed in that Ireland’s proposed contribution to the Nordic members who join the Defence Forces should battle group is based on capabilities and equip- only be obliged to serve overseas if they volun- ment already available to the Defence Forces. A teer to do so. palette of potential offers, ranging from niche Am I correct in stating that the majority of capabilities up to, and including, an APC members of the Defence Forces join to defend mounted infantry company together with support the State’s sovereignty rather than take part in elements, was identified as part of the study on overseas missions or battle groups in operations battle groups undertaken by the inter- throughout the world? Since our foreign affairs departmental working group I established to position has changed in that we will now take part examine the issue. As such, the capabilities and in battle groups, will consideration be given to the requisite equipment in respect of each poten- have 2006 as the cut-off date and that those who tial offer already resides within the Defence joined prior to that would be excused from any Forces and any commitment from the palette will secondary conscription for operations overseas? not give rise to additional manpower or expendi- ture requirements. Mr. O’Dea: Deputy O´ Snodaigh referred to the Regarding training for battle groups, most speech by the general secretary of PDFORRA. I training will take place in the contributing am very familiar with the speech; I listened to it member states, that is, Irish troops will mainly be as it was delivered and, along with everybody else trained in Ireland. That said, some level of joint in the hall, applauded enthusiastically when it training with other battle group elements will be ended. It was a very good speech. an imperative. The extent of any such joint train- Regarding compulsory deployment, the ing and whether training will extend to exercising general position has been that when the Army is a matter for decision by battle group partici- wants people to take part in an overseas mission pants. No such training has taken place to date. it uses volunteers, as the Deputy correctly stated. The Attorney General has advised that there is In fact, it is usually over-subscribed, which was a constitutional impediment to training of foreign the case in the present instance in Lebanon. I am troops in Ireland. As such, there are no plans for open to correction but I understand that since training of foreign troops in Ireland. However, as 1993, the Minister for Defence has been able to we are not a framework nation that should not be deploy people compulsorily if a sufficient number a problem. Sweden has confirmed, as framework of volunteers do not come forward. I understand nation for the Nordic battle group, that there will also that on occasion there have been deploy- 821 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 822 ments of non-volunteers under the legislation Mr. Timmins: Does the Minister foresee a con- when there was a shortage in specialist areas such stitutional referendum on the matter of permit- as cooks, drivers, engineers, technicians etc. That ting troops to serve or train in Ireland? situation will continue. I understand that people who enlisted pre-1993 Mr. O’Dea: No. are excused from being deployed on Chapter VII type missions. If it is the law since 1993 that only Defence Forces Recruitment. people who enlisted prior to 1993 are excused, 8. Mr. Kenny asked the Minister for Defence if it makes little sense now to say we will excuse there has been an increase in the number of everybody who enlisted up to 2006. We would be female applicants to the Defence Forces since the unable to deploy anybody in that case other than reduction in the height requirement; and if he will people who may join in the future. make a statement on the matter. [32354/06]

Aengus O´ Snodaigh: Or those who might 65. Ms McManus asked the Minister for volunteer. Defence the details of the new campaign to attract more women into the Defence Forces; his Mr. O’Dea: People who volunteer will not be views on the comparatively low number of deployed in that case. If we were short a vital women in the Defence Forces; his views on member of staff such as an explosives expert, whether the change in the height restriction for engineer or medic we would not be able to deploy joining the Defence Forces will attract more them. We would have to go without them if we women; and if he will make a statement on the did not get somebody to volunteer. I am sure the matter. [32180/06] ordinary troops and those specialists will volun- teer but it is a residual right of the Government. Mr. O’Dea: I propose to take Questions Nos. 8 We are signed up to be on standby for the and 65 together. Nordic battle group from 1 January 2008 for a I am keen to increase the number of women period of six months. If the Nordic battle group applying to join our Defence Forces. To facilitate is deployed, subject to the triple lock mechanism this, with effect from 1 September 2006, I reduced we are committed to joining that battle group if the minimum height requirement for entry into it is to be deployed in certain circumstances. That both the Permanent Defence Force and the is a commitment by the State and the State must Reserve Defence Force from 162.56 cm, 5’4“, to do everything to ensure it meets that, including 157.48 cm, 5’2“. This change, which applies to ensuring its domestic laws allow it comply with both males and females, has the effect of increas- that commitment, if necessary. ing the annual recruitment pool of females from 60% to 90% and males from 97% to 98%. It is Mr. Costello: The Minister said there will not too early to gauge whether there has been a cor- be any joint training in the context of the battle responding increase in the number of female groups in Ireland and that that is not required applicants to the Defence Forces. However, I will closely monitor the situation in the coming because we are not a framework nation. In terms months. of the legislation we discussed before the summer Height is not the only issue in encouraging and the proposal for assembling the battle groups more women to apply to join the Defence Forces prior to deployment, there would be areas where and I have recently initiated more general the troops would be assembled to allow troops research in this area. Following a tendering pro- from a number of nations to come together and cess TNS mrbi, an independent market research await the signal for redeployment to the theatre company, was awarded the contract to undertake of conflict. Is it a possibility or is it encompassed research into the issue of recruitment and reten- in the existing legislation that such an assembly tion of women in the Defence Forces. The could take place in this jurisdiction? research will test women’s attitudes to military life and a career in the Defence Forces. The Mr. O’Dea: That is not possible. The Attorney research, which has commenced, will include General has advised that no foreign troops bear- interviews with serving female members of the ing arms under foreign command are entitled to Permanent Defence Force and the Reserve be on Irish soil. Defence Force and members of the public. The results of the research will inform policy in this Mr. Costello: What about Shannon Airport? area for the future. The Government is committed to a policy of Mr. O’Dea: Those troops are passing through. equal opportunity for men and women in the The situation postulated will not come to pass. Defence Forces, including the Army, the Air The deployment of the assembly will be within Corps, the Naval Service and the Reserve the framework nation and everything will happen Defence Force, and to the full participation by quickly after that. women in all aspects of Defence Forces activities. 823 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 824

[Mr. O’Dea.] us on the idea is very different from one with con- Women are eligible, on the same basis as men, crete suggestions. for participation in operational and ceremonial I propose to issue a tabular statement on the activities, for assignment to all military appoint- number of women working in the Defence ments, for educational and training courses and Forces. The latest figures available show 9,837 for promotion. All female personnel undergo the males in the Defence Forces and 545 females. same training and receive the same military edu- The position is somewhat better in the reserve, cation as their male counterparts. When consider- with 7,141 males and 2,433 females. Only 60% of ing how to encourage more female personnel to females over 18 years of age were eligible to the Defence Forces it is important to bear this apply before the height requirement was reduced, in mind. making 90% now eligible. Misunderstandings exist in the female population about life in the Mr. Timmins: When will this report be avail- Army despite the best efforts of recruiting able? The Minister requested the Department of officials in the Defence Forces. They produced Education and Science and other groups to send literature and visited schools to explain what an in information on the reluctance of females to attractive life it is. apply to join the Defence Forces. Is that material available? Aengus O´ Snodaigh: It is like politics.

Mr. O’Dea: Ministers always say this when they Mr. O’Dea: The number of females applying do not want to answer a question but I am glad has increased. Some 5% to 6% of the Army is Deputy Timmins asked me that question. female, but last year 9.5% of applicants were female and 10.5% of recruits were female. The Mr. Timmins: Did he place the material in the number recruited is proportionate to the number Oireachtas library this morning? applying. We are trying to increase the number of females applying by increasing the pool from Mr. O’Dea: No, I want to enlighten Deputy 60% to 90% and by carrying out research to Timmins. The research will be available in eight determine what other measures must be weeks’ time. implemented to make the Army more attractive Regarding the second question, the Depart- to females. ment wrote to a list of organisations and I was Some 25% of members of the reserve are disappointed with the response. The only group female while the figure for the Permanent to respond with concrete proposals was, believe Defence Force is 6%. The same rules apply to the it or not, the ICA. reserve and the Permanent Defence Force. The height restrictions for both have been reduced. Mr. Timmins: Was there a response from the Minister for Education and Science? Mr. Timmins: The Minister’s decision to reduce height restrictions is welcome. I fought for this Mr. O’Dea: No. for many years because the restrictions mitigated against females disproportionately. The Minister Mr. Timmins: I am surprised at the Minister for has referred to other issues that discourage Education and Science. I will have to take it up females from joining. It is more than a year since with her. he wrote to various organisations and the response is disappointing. These organisations Mr. O’Dea: Other groups wished us well and have expertise in various areas, yet the State must thought it was a good idea. The Department also spend money on researching information that invited submissions from the Permanent Defence should be forthcoming from them. The Minister’s Force Other Ranks Representative Association, officials work very hard but I would appreciate if PDFORRA, and the Representative Association the Minister would provide Opposition spokes- of Commissioned Officers, RACO, and have not persons with a copy of the initial letter and the had a response from either. responses he received.

Mr. Costello: When were these proposals Mr. O’Dea: I do not see any objection to that sought? Is there still time for groups to respond? and will discuss it with my officials. I intended to How many women are working in the Defence commission research in any case and had sought Forces at present? Will the Minister explain why Government approval for it. The responses pro- the number is so low, apart from height vided no new ideas and this disappointed me, in restrictions? view of the range of organisations contacted.

Mr. O’Dea: We sought proposals in the middle Mr. Costello: Height restrictions are the same of last year. Most groups, apart from PDFORRA in the reserve as in the Permanent Defence and RACO, responded but the responses did not Force, yet the number of women joining the advance the cause. A response that congratulates reserve is five times the number joining the Per- 825 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 826 manent Defence Force. It would appear the An independent monitoring group was estab- reasons women are not joining the Permanent lished in May 2002 to oversee the implementation Defence Forces are much deeper than simple of these recommendations and its progress issues of height. There must be serious matters report, “Response to the Challenge of a Work- that make the Permanent Defence Force an unat- place”, was launched by my predecessor on 24 tractive option for women. I agree that the Mini- September 2004. Arising from the Doyle report, ster should invite further submissions and per- a number of steps have been taken. Firm guiding haps give the various spokespersons a package principles have been set out in the Defence with material that could be distributed to Forces dignity in the workplace charter. A major schools. educational awareness programme is ongoing throughout the Defence Forces. A new adminis- Mr. O’Dea: I look forward to discovering the trative instruction on interpersonal relationships results of the research. I wrote to the organis- was introduced in March 2003. The instruction ations and asked for their suggestions on how to and a user’s guide were distributed to every attract more women into the Defence Forces. The member of the Defence Forces. research will go deeper than this aspect. Women Designated contact persons, DCPs, have been who have served in the Defence Forces will be fully trained and are deployed throughout all interviewed about their experience of life there Defence Forces posts and barracks, both nation- and women who have not served in the Defence wide and overseas. The DCPs facilitate the oper- Forces will be interviewed about their percep- ation of the formal and informal procedures that tions of life in the Defence Forces. Both percep- may be used by any party wishing to institute a tions and experiences will be compared. It will be complaint. An independent, external confidential an interesting report, which I expect to receive in freephone helpline and counselling service was approximately eight weeks. I have no difficulty set up for members of the Permanent Defence with publishing it. If Deputy Costello believes it Force in March 2003. An independent pilot pro- is a good idea to write to the various organis- ject of exit interviews seeking the experiences and ations, I have no difficulty with sending them a views of outgoing members of the Permanent reminder. Defence Force was conducted. Leadership train- ing has been given by external experts and has Bullying in the Workplace. been the subject of NCO focus groups with an emphasis on “training the trainers”. Changes in 9. Mr. Crowe asked the Minister for Defence if cadet school instruction have been initiated, with his attention has been drawn to the ongoing issues concerning the ranking, selection and train- bullying and harassment of PDFORRA officials ing for cadet school instructors being addressed. within the Defence Forces; and the steps he will Defence Forces regulations, administrative take to address the problem and to ensure that a instructions, policies and procedures have been directive that members of the forces who carry reviewed by an equality steering group under a out representative duties must not be Labour Court chairperson. The Ombudsman for disadvantaged or discriminated against is no the Defence Forces has now been appointed. An longer ignored. [32314/06] officer within the Defence Forces human resources management section has been assigned Mr. O’Dea: I assure the Deputy that any alle- responsibility for equality matters. A training cir- gations of bullying and harassment in the cular entitled military code of conduct for Defence Forces are treated with the utmost students and instructors in all training envir- seriousness. There are extensive processes in onments was issued in 2004 and was followed by place to protect the rights of Defence Forces per- an extensive series of associated workshops for sonnel, including PDFORRA officials. These all relevant personnel. procedures give robust protection and I urge PDFORRA officials to avail of them if they feel Additional information not given on the floor of there are issues to be resolved. the House. As I have stated in the House on previous The specific matter raised by the Deputy is cur- occasions, a wide range of measures have been rently the subject of a claim by PDFORRA under put in place to deal with issues in this area. An the conciliation and arbitration scheme for the external advisory committee, chaired by Dr. Permanent Defence Force. By agreement with Eileen Doyle, was tasked with examining this PDFORRA, discussions under the scheme are issue in the Defence Forces and the committee confidential to the parties involved. Accordingly, presented their original report, “The Challenge of the Deputy will appreciate that it would not be a Workplace”, in March 2002. This independent appropriate for me to comment on this issue at report addressed a wide range of interpersonal this time. issues within the Defence Forces and its contents and recommendations were accepted in full by Aengus O´ Snodaigh: I welcome the Minister’s the Department. reply. He is correct that the Doyle report made a 827 Other 12 October 2006. Questions 828

´ [Aengus O Snodaigh.] Defences Forces Staff. number of recommendations, many of which 10. Mr. Cuffe asked the Minister for Defence have been acted upon. Does he consider it his views on concerns expressed by the strange then that the president of PDFORRA PDFORRA General Secretary at their annual said at its conference last week that certain bar- conference that agreed procedures and criteria rack commanders punish, harass and charge laid down by Defence Forces headquarters in PDFORRA representatives and deny them relation to promotions within the Defence Forces access to courses and overseas duty in order to have not been properly implemented; and if he force them out of the association? The president will make a statement on the matter. [32307/06] of the association made a very specific charge. Is the Minister concerned about it and how does he 19. Mr. Stagg asked the Minister for Defence propose to find out if there is a basis for the the procedures and criteria for promotion within charge and if there is ongoing discrimination, the Defence Forces; if the promotion criteria and punishment or harassment of PDFORRA rep- procedures are being adhered to; if he will resentatives as happened in the past? It happened respond to the criticism by PDFORRA at their when PDFORRA was first set up and continued annual conference of current practices in relation for a while. I, like everyone else, hoped that the to promotions; and if he will make a statement advent of the Doyle report would have stopped on the matter. [32257/06] some of the harassment and victimisation of PDFORRA representatives. Hopefully, the Mini- Mr. O’Dea: I propose to take Questions Nos. ster will take some action on foot of the com- 10 and 19 together. ments of the president of PDFORRA, Willie The regulations governing the promotion of Webb. enlisted personnel are provided for in Defence ´ Force regulations A 10, part II, as issued by the Mr. O’Dea: As Deputy O Snodaigh rightly Minister for Defence. The more detailed pro- acknowledged, the situation was examined by Dr. cedures and criteria for the promotion of enlisted Doyle in 2002. She discovered a number of diffi- personnel are further provided for in “A” admin- culties in respect of people making complaints istrative instruction, Defence Forces, part 10, as about bullying. She made a number of recom- issued by the deputy chief of staff, support. mendations, which were implemented, as out- Promotions to the rank of corporal are effected lined, in 2004. The situation is being kept under by the general officers commanding of forma- review because the Chief of Staff has a very per- tions, in accordance with the Defence Force regu- sonal interest and takes a hands-on approach in lations A 10, paragraph 38 and Defence Forces, trying to eradicate bullying or any perception of “A” administrative instruction, part 10. Pro- bullying in the Army to the greatest possible motions above the rank of corporal are effected extent. This means that the follow-up to the by the deputy chief of staff, support, in accord- Doyle report is being reviewed again next year. ance with the Defence Force regulations A 10, I was surprised at the PDFORRA president’s paragraph 42 and Defence Forces, “A” adminis- comments for a number of reasons, particularly trative instruction, part 10. in light of all the internal procedures that now The Defence Forces internal grievance pro- exist for dealing with bullying. If one examines cedures allow individual personnel who feel that the earlier question about the Ombudsman for procedures have not been applied properly to the Defence Forces, one can see that 12 cases appeal to higher authority. The Defence Forces have been referred to her, after the internal pro- have been actively engaged with PDFORRA in cedure failed, following her appointment on 1 examining the current promotion systems since December 2005, none of which relates to early this year through a subcommittee of the bullying. conciliation and arbitration council with a view to I was doubly surprised by the PDFORRA pres- agreeing a new revised promotion scheme. ident’s remarks because I know that the specific allegation referred to by Deputy O´ Snodaigh that Mr. Costello: The Minister stated there are two PDFORRA members are being discriminated separate systems, one below the rank of corporal against or bullied because of their membership of and one above. Do we have a standardised the association or because they are making rep- system that is adhered to fairly and strongly by resentations has been the subject of a specific the relevant people? Part of PDFORRA’s criti- complaint. This complaint has gone to the appro- cism was that individual senior officers more or priate subcommittee of the conciliation and arbi- less take the law unto themselves and determine tration council. When something goes to this the criteria. Two tiers of criteria seem to operate, council, both the Department and the other namely, the standardised criteria and the informal party, namely, PDFORRA, have a duty to main- criteria applied by individual senior officers. tain confidentiality. I have not inquired as to how At the end of his reply, the Minister mentioned matters stand because I know I am not supposed that a review will take place of the new pro- to talk about it in detail. motions criteria to be established. Will the Mini- 829 Adjournment 12 October 2006. Debate Matters 830 ster elaborate on what that will entail, when we To date the Defence Forces have assisted in can expect it and how it will operate within the providing access to the considerable number of various ranks? witnesses associated with the case and have also facilitated the visit by the investigation team to Mr. O’Dea: I do not have any independent evi- Lebanon and Israel. The weapon which fired the dence that the present promotional system is not fatal shot was handed over by the Defence Forces strictly adhered to as intended. A number of to the Garda Sı´ocha´na for tests. At the request experts are of the view the present system must of the Garda Sı´ocha´na, the Defence Forces also be updated and the Department of Defence has arranged, with the agreement of the UN, for the accepted that. departmental officials and return to Ireland of the billet in which Private PDFORRA are discussing a mutually agreeable Barrett died. Garda inquiries are ongoing and new system and that reply also applies to the final when completed, I expect the Commissioner will question. The matter is in conciliation and arbi- contact me in the matter. tration and they are working it out between them. The scope of the Garda investigation and the Ultimately, whatever scheme they agree will manner in which it proceeds is a matter for the come to me for approval, and we will consider Commissioner. My understanding is the Garda the details. I want to let the two parties involved investigation may be completed before the end of in conciliation and arbitration work it out this year. I understand any decision regarding the between them. exhumation of Private Barrett’s remains, if con- sidered necessary by the Garda Sı´ocha´na to com- Defence Forces Inquiry. plete its investigation, would be a matter for the family of the late Private Barrett. I have no 11. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for further information in this regard. Defence the situation with regard to the investi- gation into the death of a person (details Mr. Timmins: I am sure the Minister and his supplied); and if he will make a statement on the representatives keep in contact with the Barrett matter. [32333/06] family to inform them on the investigation. I hope the investigation can be brought to a speedy con- 39. Ms Lynch asked the Minister for Defence clusion. Were all the witnesses involved in the the position regarding the investigation into the incident available for investigation or death of a person (details supplied); if the exhum- questioning? ation and examination of the persons remains has taken place; the results of that examination; the Mr. Costello: I thank the Minister for his reply way the investigation will proceed; and if he will and I agree with Deputy Timmins. I presume the make a statement on the matter. [32176/06] Barrett family is kept informed at every stage of the investigation. The Minister mentioned the Mr. O’Dea: I propose to take Questions Nos. exhumation of the remains would be an issue for 11 and 39 together. the family. Does the Garda Sı´ocha´na consider it On 2 February 2006, I received a report from to be an essential part of the investigation? Has Mr. Sean Hurley, whom I appointed to carry out any progress been made on it? an independent review of the interaction between the Department of Defence and Defence Forces Mr. O’Dea: I keep the family informed. I do and the parents and family of Private Kevin not know whether all witnesses were available. I Barrett in the aftermath of his tragic death, on 18 handed the matter over to the Garda Sı´ocha´na February 1999, while serving with the 84th Infan- and a Garda investigation is being conducted at try Battalion in Lebanon. Mr. Hurley examined the level of chief superintendent. I hope it will be in detail how the Department and the Defence concluded by the end of the year. Forces interacted with the Barrett family after We should not discuss exhumation orders in Kevin’s death and identified clear failings and the House. I am in close touch with Mrs. Barrett, shortcomings. Kevin Barrett’s mother, and she has no objection Immediately on receipt of Mr. Hurley’s report, to an exhumation order. Where such an order is I contacted the Garda Commissioner and asked necessary for the Garda investigation is a matter him to provide me with his early views on any for the investigation team and I leave it to them. possible assistance the Garda Sı´ocha´na might be in a position to provide. The Garda officer Written Answers follow Adjournment Debate. assigned to the case continues to examine the files of my Department and the Defence Forces on the Adjournment Debate Matters. case, with a view to determining whether the Garda Sı´ocha´na can provide any assistance in the An Leas-Cheann Comhairle: I wish to advise matter. Liaison arrangements have been estab- the House of the following matters in respect of lished between the Garda Sı´ocha´na and the which notice has been given under Standing Defence Forces, who continue to provide the full- Order 21 and the name of the Member in each est co-operation to the Garda Sı´ocha´na. case: (1) Deputy Catherine Murphy — the 831 Prison 12 October 2006. Accommodation 832

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle.] circumstances leading to and surrounding the unequal service being provided by the HSE to death of Gary Douch. They were denied the children with special needs; (2) Deputy Costello opportunity to do so because the Prison Service — the need for the Minister to explain the OPW’s demolished the cell where his murder took place. new transportation policy for the Phoenix Park; I sincerely hope this action by the Prison (3) Deputy Crowe — the need for the Minister Service does not turn out to be an indication of a to investigate and report on the decision to culture of cover-up akin to that operating within demolish a particular cell in Mountjoy Prison; certain sections of the Garda Sı´ocha´na. Twenty and (4) Deputy Broughan — the need for the year old Terence Wheelock died in Garda cus- Minister to ensure that lands at Clare Hall and tody in June 2005. Gardaı´ claimed he hung him- Belmayne, Dublin 13 are not sold without a self but it is widely believed by his family and public tender. friends that he died as a result of Garda brutality. The matters raised by Deputies Crowe, The Wheelock family’s solicitor secured a court Costello, Catherine Murphy and Broughan have order to preserve the cell for forensic evidence. been selected for discussion. However, the order was disregarded and the cell was completely renovated destroying all Adjournment Debate. evidence. It is only right that we question and get to the ———— bottom of the Prison Service’s motive for destroying the holding cell in Mountjoy. It was Prison Accommodation. destroyed before the report of the internal inves- Mr. Crowe: On 31 July, a 20 year old prisoner, tigation into Gary Douch’s murder was pub- Gary Douch, made a request to prison officers in lished, and to the best of my knowledge, before Mountjoy for protection. They placed him in a this report was submitted to the Minister. They holding cell in the basement with at least five destroyed it before any related charges could be other inmates, where he was subsequently bat- laid by the Garda and before the European Com- tered to death. One media outlet reported he was mittee on the Prevention of Torture could inspect beaten for more than one hour, had his head it. At best, the actions of the Prison Service forced down a toilet full of human faeces, his amounts to negligence, at worst a cover-up. chest was stamped on resulting in its collapse and I want to use this opportunity to call for a truly he was eventually strangled. No one saw or independent investigation into the death of Gary heard anything. Douch and all deaths occurring in custody or The cell was demolished by the Prison Service shortly after someone being in custody. Will the before members of the European Committee for Government ratify the optional protocol to the the Prevention of Torture could inspect it this Convention Against Torture as is required by the week. Every State failure to protect the lives of equivalence provisions of the Good Friday those in custody, whether in a Garda station or a Agreement? Will the Minister introduce legis- prison, must be subject to nothing less than an lation to place the prisons’ inspector on a statu- independent investigation. tory footing, introduce a prisoners’ ombudsman In August an investigation was established by and remove the current exemption of children in the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law detention from the remit of the Ombudsman for Reform to be conducted by an official from the Children? Will the Government establish and Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform resource an adequate number of mental health reporting back to the Minister. As argued by the treatment centres with appropriate levels of Irish Penal Reform Trust, “Surely, a truly inde- security to bring an end to the practice whereby pendent inquiry, by definition, must include the prison system acts as a dumping ground for investigators who are not part of the bureaucracy people suffering from mental illness? and ethos of the Prison Service and the Depart- Only truly independent inquiries will uncover ment of Justice, Equality and Law Reform”. The the truth and allow lessons to be learned. By investigation established by the Minister could be insisting on in-house investigations and allowing described more as “in-house” than “independ- the destruction of evidence, the Government ent” and as such, it falls far short of our obli- learns no lessons. Building a super-prison will do gations under the European Convention on nothing to prevent the murder, torture and Human Rights. inhuman and degrading treatment of prisoners. It Inspectors from the European Committee for will simply replicate these conditions on a larger the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman and scale. Degrading Treatment or Punishment, CPT, tasked with monitoring standards in our prison Minister of State at the Department of the system, are visiting this week. The Government Environment, Heritage and Local Government was notified of the timing of this visit earlier this (Mr. N. Ahern): The Committee for the Preven- year. The CPT inspectors could have conducted tion of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treat- a genuinely independent investigation into the ment or Punishment, which operates under the 833 Traffic 12 October 2006. Management 834 aegis of the Council of Europe, was established prison for the requirements placed upon it and under the European Convention for the Preven- that it is incapable of acting as a modern place of tion of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treat- rehabilitation and detention for sentenced per- ment in 1987. The committee is composed of law- sons. It is past its sell by date—— yers, medical doctors, prison experts, parliamentarians etc. from the member states and Mr. Crowe: So is the Minister for Justice, carries out its task by periodic and ad hoc visits Equality and Law Reform. and on the basis of full co-operation from states. During these visits, the committee has the right Mr. N. Ahern: ——and this is why the replace- of unimpeded access at any time of the day or ment of the Mountjoy complex by the site at night to any place where persons are detained, Thornton Hall in north County Dublin is such a whether it be a prison, a Garda station or a men- priority for the Ta´naiste, the Government and the tal hospital, and are entitled to speak in private Irish Prison Service. to any detained person. The CPT has not raised any complaints with The CPT has visited Ireland for inspection pur- the Irish authorities concerning access to the B poses on a number of occasions. The CPT sub- base of Mountjoy Prison. mits a formal report of each visit to the Irish Government, which is subsequently published Mr. Costello: It has asked questions about the along with the Government’s response. The prison, as it has every year. report arising from the visit by the CPT to Ireland in 2002 noted that its delegation had received Traffic Management. excellent co-operation both before and during Mr. Costello: I would like the Minister for Fin- the visit. ance to explain the OPW’s new transport policy The Ta´naiste completely rejects the assertion for the Phoenix Park. The residential community that the instruction to close the holding cell surrounding the park is concerned about the new referred to was in any way linked to the current transportation and traffic plans that the Minister visit by the Committee for the Prevention of Tor- and the OPW have for the park. ture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or This 1,750 acre park, the largest public park in Punishment. In fact the Ta´naiste views such an any capital city in Europe, is a wonderful amenity implication as quite frankly outrageous and com- for the people of Dublin. The purpose of the new pletely at odds with the actions of his Department plan is to reduce through traffic and to make the since this tragic incident. The Deputy should be park more pedestrian friendly. Unfortunately, the aware of the appointment of Mr. Michael Mellett new proposals are such that residents fear they to undertake an independent investigation into will have the opposite effect. the events leading to the death of Mr. Douch. He Chesterfield Avenue bisects the park from had been to the scene of the crime and had con- Castleknock Gate to Parkgate Street and the cluded his examination of the area prior to any quays. The new proposals will introduce a bus action being taken to convert them for alterna- service for the first time, with 20 new buses on tive usage. the route. There are no proposals, however, for a quality bus corridor. Consequently, the new Mr. Crowe: Hardly an independent inquiry. service will only add to existing peak hour traffic, making Chesterfield Avenue a major commuter Mr. N. Ahern: The same position applies in the feeder route into the city. Garda investigation into the incident and they The changes to the other roads in the park will had indicated they had no further requirement of make them unidirectional, with a one way the crime scene for their criminal investigation. entrance from west and north and a one way exit Normal procedure following a serious criminal to the east through Cabra, the North Circular incident in a prison is that the scene of the crime Road and Parkgate Street, directing traffic is sealed and preserved until the gardaı´ have con- towards the city every morning. If the OPW is cluded their examination. In normal circum- serious about traffic reduction, it would introduce stances, the area would then be cleaned and a bus lane and restrict commuter traffic at peak brought back into commission in its previous use. traffic hours through the park. In this case it was clear that such a course of Outside the park, Blackhorse Avenue in Cabra action would be completely inappropriate and the will undoubtedly experience a considerably Director General of the Irish Prison Service made greater volume of traffic, as will the North Circu- the decision, in the immediate aftermath of the lar Road, Infirmary Road, Prussia Street and incident, that for operational reasons, the holding Aughrim Street, which already have high levels cells would be closed with immediate effect and of traffic. that they would no longer accommodate I hope the Minister of State can assure us that prisoners. the report that has just been published will be The Ta´naiste has repeatedly stated on the open for discussion and amendment with the record that Mountjoy Prison is an unsuitable local authority traffic management office, with 835 Services for People 12 October 2006. with Disabilities 836

[Mr. Costello.] the proposed measures contained in the study public representatives and local communities from an environmental protection perspective, a around the park who will be affected by the new vital consideration in the context of this national changes and that this will all be done before any historic park. action is taken regarding the implementation of On completion of the study earlier this month, the report’s recommendations. a number of presentations on the study were arranged on 10 and 11 October for the parties Mr. N. Ahern: In mid March of this year, the outlined above who contributed to the process. Commissioners of Public Works commissioned a This included a presentation to resident associ- traffic management study for the Phoenix Park ations on the perimeter of the Phoenix Park, and the following advertisement was published which I understand Deputy Costello may have on 15 April 2006: attended. PHOENIX PARK TRAFFIC STUDY The commissioning of an independent traffic management study for the Phoenix Park was The Phoenix Park is Ireland’s premier necessary on a number of counts: to protect this National Historic Park, and Europe’s largest national historic park from growing enclosed city park. It is widely acknowledged 5 o’clock traffic pressures, to ensure the as a valuable amenity resource and a major amenities of the park are not environmental lung for Dublin City. On the degraded, to ensure public access to the park and other hand there are competing demands aris- its amenities is enhanced, to significantly reduce ing from increased development and traffic risks to the public arising from traffic movements, congestion in Dublin City. As a result the to collate a range of proposals to achieve these Phoenix Park faces a number of challenges in objectives and to enhance public awareness on ensuring it remains a sustainable, highly valued the need for these measures. and safe recreational amenity. The commissioners are satisfied that positive Against this background the Commissioners intervention to address these challenges is abso- of Public Works have commissioned Messrs. lutely essential and that the “do nothing” Faber Maunsell, Consulting Engineers to carry approach is not an option. Following the recent out a comprehensive traffic study of the consultation process, the commissioners are con- Phoenix Park. The study will address the grow- sidering the phased implementation of a number ing pressures on existing Phoenix Park infra- of the principal measures proposed in the report. structure and develop proposals designed to protect the Phoenix Park and its users, both Services for People with Disabilities. now and for the future, while making every effort to facilitate through traffic. Ms C. Murphy: In the past, we were told it was The study will analyse current and future possible to predict the life chances of babies by commuting patterns, road safety issues and looking at their addresses in the maternity ward. traffic management proposals. It will examine The addresses to which this statement alluded the potential for public traffic and road safety tended to be in areas of significant poverty and improvements. Proposals will be made for disadvantage. If the same review of maternity long-term management and monitoring of wards were to take place today, the address of a traffic in the Phoenix Park, in keeping with the baby would still play a part. However, if a child objectives of the Phoenix Park Management has a special need or disability, where the child Plan. lives will dictate the level of support services The study involves an extensive public con- available and, as a result, his or her life chances. sultation process with interested parties, which The reason is inequality in current service will take place over the coming weeks. provision. This advertisement sets out the background to Although the Health Service Executive is a sin- the study, which included a public consultation gle entity, it appears that eight former health process. A total of 26 submissions from the public boards continue to function behind this organis- were received—— ation. To highlight what I mean I will refer to three children. Conor, who is aged three years Mr. Costello: And ignored. and has a problem with his speech, requires speech and language therapy and has been placed Mr. N. Ahern: ——and in addition to that, on a list for assessment. I received from the HSE stakeholders in the park, the local authorities, the a reply to a query informing me that it currently Garda authorities, the Dublin Transportation takes 23 to 24 months to complete an assessment Office and the Office of Public Works were and it is working off the 2004 list. The reason for consulted. this waiting period, according to the HSE, is low In formulating the study therefore, Messrs. staffing levels relative to the number of referrals. Faber Maunsell took a wide range of views into On checking further, it emerged that more than account and a firm of environmental consultants, 1,500 children are on the County Kildare waiting Messrs. ERM Limited, was also engaged to assess list, a threefold increase since 2002. As Conor’s 837 Services for People 12 October 2006. with Disabilities 838 mother cannot afford to go privately, her child This is shocking. While it is understandable that will have to wait, with the result that he may com- the major focus of the HSE has been on hospital mence school before receiving an assessment, not beds and accident and emergency departments, to mention treatment. the life chances of children are being badly In replies from the Health Service Executive, I affected by the unequal service the organisation have been informed that under the “staff employ- provides. As I indicated, the little boy to whom I ment ceiling” it is not possible to approve all refer is doing well in school. However, his parents necessary posts. Rapidly expanding counties such have been told following a professional assess- as Kildare are disproportionately affected by this ment that if he does not receive the necessary embargo on further recruitment. The State is per- occupational therapy, he will regress. Providing fectly willing to allow a child to attend school support to this child now is an investment in with a known disadvantage in a county with the ensuring he leads an independent life. highest class sizes in the country, yet it wonders There is no problem in finding the parents of why he might underperform. the children in question when the State seeks tax- The second child to whom I draw attention is ation. We need to ensure they receive equal lev- Tim who was born 18 months ago with Down’s els of service from the taxes they pay. syndrome. He lives in my constituency and fea- tured in an article in the most recent issue of The Mr. N. Ahern: I take this Adjournment matter Sunday Tribune. The article compared the on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for services available to Tim with those available to Health and Children, Deputy Harney. I am another child with the same diagnosis who was pleased to have an opportunity to address the born on the same day and lives three miles away general issues raised by the Deputy. in Lucan. Both children reside in the old Eastern I emphasise the Government’s commitment to Regional Health Authority region, albeit in providing high quality service to all people with different sections of it. While the parent in a disability. This commitment is illustrated by the County Kildare had to fight for every service the substantial investment we have made in services child secured, the other parent in the Dublin area in recent years and the multiannual investment received a seamless service. programme provided by the Government for the Services for children with Down’s syndrome in period 2006 to 2009. The Government’s six sec- south Kildare are substantially better than those toral plans on disability, including the plans for available in north Kildare. Tim, like all children the health sector, set out in some detail how we with Down’s syndrome, requires early inter- plan to improve the experience of people with a vention which would make him much more disability. receptive to learning at an early stage, an obvious The recent claims in a newspaper article that advantage. He cannot wait until the State gets “for children it has never been so bad” cannot be around to providing services. supported by the facts. The third case relates to a child of seven years who also lives in my constituency. He was diag- Ms C. Murphy: They are supported by the nosed with autism spectrum disorder when he facts. was three years old but despite his disability, he Mr. N. Ahern: I accept some of the points is doing well in school. Initially placed in a special raised by the Deputy and will not defend the class, he has since progressed to mainstream. HSE regarding some of the unacceptable Until now he has had support from Beechpark responses all Members receive. If the Deputy is services which focuses on early services for chil- correct, services should not relate to where one dren with autism. The child in question requires lives. However, considerable improvements have occupational therapy and speech and language taken place in services for people with a dis- therapy to ensure he does not regress. In ability. For example, between 1997 and 2005 response to a query, his parents received the fol- additional revenue and capital funding of \464 lowing incredible statement from the HSE: millionwas provided for persons with intellectual Unfortunately we must inform you that we disability and autism. This is not acknowledged in do not have resources to treat children with the article the Deputy cited. autism as we are not an autism specific service The Government provided additional revenue and our staffing levels are particularly low at funding of \74 million in 2006 for services for present. We regret to inform you that we do people with physical, sensory and intellectual dis- not have an occupational therapist nor a psy- ability and those with autism. The priority this chologist on our team presently. We realise year is to enhance the assessment and support that this is an unsatisfactory situation, however services for children with disabilities. In part- it is outside the control of this team. We can icular, these moneys are to meet the costs associ- only apologise and regret our lack of resources ated with the commitments in the multiannual at present. Should you be in a position to investment programme for specific high priority source the above therapists in a private capa- disability services. This will also help to build the city, we can forward you some information. additional capacity in multidisciplinary and other 839 Planning 12 October 2006. Issues 840

[Mr. N. Ahern.] \48 million. When city councillors queried the support services required under the Disability reasons for this sale and the price, they were Act 2005 and the Education for Persons with informed the sale was necessary to ensure a new Special Educational Needs Act 2004. city plaza and linkage to the new east-west central With regard to the specific services raised by boulevard could be created quickly, since the pro- the Deputy, I understand from the HSE that the spective purchasers, Stanley Holdings, already relevant services in County Kildare are provided owned some of the lands necessary to create this in the north of the county by a partnership important public realm. The city council was also arrangement between the HSE and the St. John informed last July that the funds realised by the of God services at St. Raphael’s Celbridge and in sale would be ploughed back into public facilities the south of the county in a partnership arrange- of all kinds in the north fringe and in Dublin ment between the HSE, Kare and Moore Abbey. North-East generally. I also understand that the service in west Dublin Despite these assurances, it has emerged that and south Kildare has developed extensively in an independent valuation report on these lands, recent months but it has proved difficult for logis- commissioned by Lisney Auctioneers for the city tical reasons to achieve similar progress in north council, was never published or made known to Kildare. The HSE has assured me it will work councillors before they approved a managerial closely with the St. John of God service to report on the sale. This is an extraordinary state develop early learning services in order that it can of affairs and another typical example of the need attain the type of provision available in south for a root and branch reform of local government. Kildare. The HSE and St. John of God are com- How could city councillors possibly do their job mitted to developing a holistic service that meets when they did not know the real value of the children’s needs in the area. land? I call for the new city manager, Mr. John The development of high quality services, Tierney, to publish immediately the valuation of available on an equitable and equally accessible the Balgriffin and Clare Hall lands which was pre- basis, throughout the country is an important pared by Lisney Auctioneers. It has been alleged objective of the Minister and HSE. I am confi- the city council’s chief valuer at that time has dent that, over time, the varying levels of service moved to new employment with Lisney Auc- provision will be standardised and that the HSE, tioneers. as a single national organisation, will achieve A key difficulty with this sale from the time it this objective. first became known is that there was no open I draw the Deputy’s attention to the Disability public tender process. The earlier city managers Act, Part 2 of which will be commenced on 1 June had reported that because part of the site was next for children under five years. This Part landlocked from some of the new road devel- entitles people with a disability to an assessment opments, the sale price would have been driven of need and to a formal statement of services to steeply down by going to public tender. However, be provided. It will offer greater certainty and the original north fringe master plan signally consistency in the level and type of services avail- failed even to outline the general uses of most of able for children in the circumstances outlined by this district, including the 23 acres in question. the Deputy. I will draw the Minister’s attention That was one reason I strongly opposed that area to the cases raised by the Deputy. action plan in the late 1990s until it was forced through the city council by outgoing city man- Planning Issues. ager, Mr. John Fitzgerald, defeating a motion in Mr. Broughan: Ongoing media reports about my name calling for a new detailed mixed density the sale by Dublin City Council of 23 acres of master plan with a range of community and land in the area of Balgriffin, CIare Hall and public transport facilities. Belmayne in the Dublin North-East constituency It emerged recently that the original commit- have raised serious concerns locally which must ment to sell these lands last June included an be addressed by the Minister for the Envir- uplift clause, allowing the city council to renego- onment, Heritage and Local Government. The tiate a higher price which could be exercised any lands are part of the massive new urban district time up to March 2007. The city council triggered called the north fringe, which is being created in this clause recently and secured a new higher sale this constituency and which may ultimately con- price of \60.4 million. City officials are also claim- tain more than 20,000 housing units and a major ing there will be additional public realm costs of ancillary commercial development around a new \7 million in favour of the council when the new city boulevard running from Coolock to the sea Clare Hall plaza and boulevard is built. However, at Baldoyle and Portmarnock. with six months to go in the timeframe of the Concerns were originally expressed about this uplift clause and with no end to steadily escalat- sale at the Dublin North-Central area committee ing property values on the north side, many of my of Dublin City Council. The then city managers, constituents still wonder if \60.4 million rep- Mr. John Fitzgerald and Mr. Sean Carey, resents full value for these lands and whether informed members that the original sale price was they would be worth \100 million by next March. 841 Planning 12 October 2006. Issues 842

In an earlier debate in this House on affordable now proposes to sell 23 acres of the site to Stanley housing, the Minister of State, Deputy Batt Holdings, which owns sites adjacent to this land, O’Keeffe, stated the Minister of State, Deputy for \60.4 million. Noel Ahern, provided this land to Dublin City There was some discussion between Depart- Council for affordable and social housing. For ment officials and Dublin City Council on the that reason, the sale of this land should be exam- council’s decision to dispose of the site. While a ined by the Comptroller and Auditor General, public tendering process often yields a higher who should then report on it to the Committee value, the council felt the particular circum- of Public Accounts. stances surrounding this site meant the preferable A key failure of local and national government option was to negotiate with the adjacent devel- in the development of the north fringe lands is oper. The site being sold is surrounded by lands the serious lack of joined up planning and public belonging to Stanley Holdings and any successful accountability. The three main developers, Bally- bidder under a public tendering process would more Homes, Gannon Homes and Shannon have to negotiate with that company to secure Homes, accounting for up to 12,000 housing units access rights. This would have the effect of reduc- alone, have never been the subject of a detailed ing any bid for the lands being sold by the urban master plan prepared jointly by Dublin council. It was the view of the council that nego- City and Fingal County Councils. There have tiating directly with the adjacent developer would been planning applications, but there has never leverage the maximum possible outcome for the been a detailed plan. The plan put repeatedly site. before Dublin City Council was only for part of In May 2006, the council negotiated a price of the city council area of the fringe and is based on \48 million with Stanley Holdings, with an uplift vague aspirations and principles which are turn- clause built in that would enable the council to ing out to be a developers’ heaven as they go for revisit the deal if it felt subsequently that a higher ever increasing densities. At the same time, there valuation of the site was merited. The council is almost no public accountability. I proposed the subsequently invoked this clause and recently creation of the north fringe forum which was negotiated a deal worth \60.4 million. Contract accepted by the then city manager, Mr. negotiations are nearing completion at this stage. Fitzgerald, and which held its tenth meeting last However, the deal is worth more than the \60.4 Tuesday and is composed of residents, public rep- million agreed. Part of the north fringe master resentatives and stakeholders. However, the plan involves a plaza and the development of a forum is powerless and just an interested talking new main street and DART station from Bal- shop. doyle to this junction at the Malahide Road end. For these reasons and because of the disturbing As part of the deal negotiated with Stanley Hold- controversy over the Clare Hall and Balgriffin ings, the company will construct this plaza and lands, I urge the new Dublin City and Fingal new main street on their property within 18 county managers to consider applying to the months, and it will then come back into public Minister for strategic development zone status for ownership. the remaining undeveloped north fringe lands in A resolution agreeing to the disposal of the Dublin City and Fingal. The SDZ route should lands was passed by Dublin City Council. It is especially be considered for the lands of Belcamp proposed the council will use the funds arising College, where Gannon Homes applied last year from the sale of these lands for capital projects for a Manhattan style development of skyscrapers within the city. The remaining seven acres from and some of the highest residential density ever the original 30-acre site purchase by the council seen in Ireland. I call on the Minister of State to in 1999 is being held as part of the council’s land ensure the valuation is published and that there bank for future housing needs. will be an open public tender, that the city council The Deputy will note that I had reservations gets full value for money and that the Comptrol- about the sale of this site. It was bought for social ler and Auditor General examines this matter. I and affordable housing and I thought it should be also call on him to consider strategic development used for that purpose. The Deputy’s party has a zone status for the north fringe. majority on the city council and the job of dispos- ing of land is the responsibility of the councillors. Mr. N. Ahern: I am pleased to update the House on the proposed sale of lands at Clare Hall Mr. Broughan: Does the Minister of State not and Belmayne. The purchase of the site was not agree that the councillors did not have the directly funded by my Department. The site was information? part of a 30-acre site bought by Dublin City Council in 1999 for \18.8 million, for social and Mr. N. Ahern: I expressed my concerns to affordable housing purposes, by means of a hous- councillors and they were raised on the floor of ing finance agency loan. That purchase had the the council. I would have preferred that this land approval of the Department of the Environment, was used for a different purpose. The Deputy has Heritage and Local Government. The council often voiced his concern about housing waiting 843 The 12 October 2006. Adjournment 844

[Mr. N. Ahern.] Mr. N. Ahern: The contracts have not been lists and so on and I was shocked when council- signed, but the decision to sell has been approved lors from different parties, including my own and by Dublin City Council. Despite my reservations, that of the Deputy, agreed to sell this. The pro- I do not know how that can be changed at this cess has gone through in accordance with the stage. regulations. The motions and the approval of the decision—— The Da´il adjourned at 5.20 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. Mr. Broughan: The contracts are not signed. on Tuesday, 17 October 2006. 845 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 846

Written Answers.

————————

The following are questions tabled by Members for written response and the ministerial replies as received on the day from the Departments [unrevised].

————————

Questions Nos. 1 to 11 answered orally. Africa, and parts of the Middle East. However, this assignment of responsibility does not entail Question No. 12 answered with Question any bilateral arrangements between USEUCOM No. 7. and Ireland. In addition, there are no arrange- ments in place under which the Commander of Military Co-operation. EUCOM can exercise any authority to plan or conduct operations in Ireland, nor is any such 13. Mr. Sargent asked the Minister for Defence arrangement foreseen. the co-operation involved between the Irish and US Defence Forces arising from the fact that Ireland is listed as within the area of responsi- Overseas Missions. bility of the US European command, with area 14. Mr. Howlin asked the Minister for Defence of responsibility defined as the geographical area the number of Irish troops who are engaged in within which the US European commander has UN missions abroad; the number of troops on authority to plan and conduct operations; and if each mission; when each mission started and he will make a statement on the matter. when it is due to end; the number of Irish troops [32313/06] who are engaged in non-UN work abroad; their locations; the nature of their work; and if he will Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): There is no make a statement on the matter. [32173/06] co-operation involved between Irish and US Defence Forces arising out of the existence or the 62. Mr. Boyle asked the Minister for Defence role assigned to EUCOM by the US military the level of Irish military forces serving overseas authorities. Obviously there is a longstanding following the planned deployment in Lebanon; relationship with the US Military Forces gener- the way this relates to the recommended overseas ally. Moreover, US Forces have also participated Irish military deployments at any one time; and if in UN mandated peacekeeping operations along- he will make a statement on the matter. side Irish troops. Cooperation with US Forces [32305/06] generally involves attendance at training courses, equipment demonstrations, exchanges of experi- Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose ence and briefings on current operations. This is to take Questions Nos. 14 and 62 together. the same sort of engagement that the Defence Ireland is currently contributing 677 Defence Forces would have in the normal course with the Forces personnel to 19 different missions military forces of any country with whom the throughout the world. Full details of all personnel State has close and friendly relations. currently serving overseas on UN mandated I understand that there are nine unified comba- operations, observer missions or undertaking rep- tant commands within the US Military Command resentative or staff postings are listed in the table. structure. Five of these have regional responsibil- The main overseas commitments are to the ities which, taken together, cover the entire sur- United Nations Mission in Liberia (UNMIL), face of the Globe. The US European Command with 328 personnel, to the NATO-led Inter- (EUCOM) is one of these regional combatant national Security presence (KFOR) in Kosovo, commands. Within the US military structures it with 213 personnel and to EUFOR, the EU-led has responsibility for all of Europe, most of operation in Bosnia and Herzegovina, with 58 847 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 848

[Mr. O’Dea.] situation. Having regard to the fragility of the personnel. Other personnel are serving as moni- peace in Kosovo and subject to ongoing assess- tors and observers with the United Nations (UN), ments of the situation on the ground, Ireland has the European Union (EU) and the Organisation decided to maintain a continued presence in for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). KFOR in 2006/2007. Staff are also deployed at the organisational Last month, the Government agreed to the headquarters of the UN, EU, OSCE and NATO. Defence Forces undertaking an additional UNMIL was established in September 2003. A responsibility as Framework Nation for the contingent of the Permanent Defence Forces was Multinational Task Force Centre (MNTF (C)) in deployed for service in December 2003, compris- KFOR from August 2007. This will be a new ing a motorised infantry battalion of 430 person- development for the Defence Forces as we have nel. The main Irish contingent operates as the never before commanded a brigade size force in Force Commander’s Rapid Reaction Reserve. multinational PfP-led peace support operation. The role of the Irish personnel is the provision of Undertaking this new responsibility will contrib- an immediate response capability, deployable in ute significantly to the development of the sufficient strength and with the required level of Defence Forces, improving its capabilities and force, to provide a swift and decisive military heightening its profile as a professional and well- reaction in any crisis situation. The contingent organised force within the international peace- undertakes regular daily patrols within Monrovia keeping community. and is available to the Force Commander to Operation Althea — EUFOR, an EU military provide support in the event of a breakdown of mission, was established in November 2004 to law and order or further conflict. Ireland and replace Stabilisation Force (SFOR), a NATO-led Sweden agreed in December 2005 to provide sup- mission in Bosnia & Herzegovina. Ireland had port in expanding the area of operations to participated in SFOR since 1997. Ireland is part include Sierra Leone, including protection of the of the Austrian-led Multinational Task Force Special Court. (North) and provides personnel for the head- Ireland was due to complete its participation in quarters, the Military Police Unit, Verification UNMIL in November 2006. However, in Teams and a National Support element. Ireland response to a request earlier this year from the currently acts as the Framework Nation for the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Military Police Platoon. Annan, to the Taoiseach, it was decided to extend UNIFIL the duration of the deployment in Liberia to May Earlier this month, the Government agreed, sub- ´ 2007, in order to give the UN time to find a suit- ject to Dail approval, the despatch of a contingent of the Defence Forces for service as part of a joint able replacement for the QRF capability. The Finnish/Irish Unit with United Nations Interim Swedish contingent, which currently partners Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL). The necessary Ireland in the QRF, will withdraw in November, enabling motion was moved in the Da´il on 10 2006, and will be replaced by a Company from October, 2006 and was approved yesterday. Pakistan. In May, 2007, the Irish contingent will The Finnish engineering unit will carry out be withdrawn and, to this end, mission downsiz- tasks in support of UNIFIL and also some ing has now commenced with the agreement of humanitarian work, including dealing with unex- the UN. Pakistan will assume overall responsi- ploded ordnance clearance. While the Irish bility for the provision of the QRF in UNMIL on element will be tasked primarily for reconnais- Ireland’s withdrawal. sance, security and protection duties associated KFOR was established in June, 1999 to support with the engineering works, it will also be avail- the maintenance of civil law and order within able for other taskings by the Force Commander Kosovo, so as to develop a climate of safety and of UNIFIL. security, which will enable the transfer of The Defence Forces contingent of approxi- increased responsibility to the civil authorities. mately 150 troops will bring the numbers cur- Ireland has participated in the KFOR since rently serving overseas to approximately 830. August 1999. The Irish contingent currently com- Ireland’s commitment under the United Nations prises an APC Mounted Infantry Group of some Stand-by Arrangements System (UNSAS) is 850, 213 personnel including a number of personnel in which represents 10% of the total Army strength. staff posts at various KFOR Headquarters. This is the figure set in the White paper on A reorganisation and downsizing of the forces Defence and is the maximum sustainable commit- in KFOR, including the Irish contingent, was ment that Ireland can make to overseas oper- planned and had partly commenced when civil ations. There are no plans at this time to increase disturbances broke out in March 2004 in Kosovo. the level of our commitment to UNSAS and any That downsizing was deferred to allow the contribution to EU or UN Missions will be met situation to settle, this remains the current within the context of the 850 ceiling. 849 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 850

Members of the Permanent Defence Force serving Overseas as of 01 September, 2006

1. UN Missions (i) UNIFIL (United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon) 5 (ii) UNTSO (United Nations Truce Supervision Organisation) — Israel, Syria and Lebanon 13 (iii) MINURSO (United Nations Mission for the Referendum in Western Sahara) 3 (iv) UNMIK (United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo) 4 (v) MONUC (United Nations Mission in Democratic Republic of the Congo) 3 (vi) UNOCI (United Nations Mission in Ivory Coast) 2 (vii) UNMIL (United Nations Mission in Liberia) FHQ 4

UNMIL 95th Inf Bn 324

TOTAL 358

UN Mandated Missions (viii) EUFOR (EU-led Operation in Bosnia and Herzegovina) 58 (ix) KFOR (International Security Presence in Kosovo) 213 (x) ISAF (International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan) 7

Total number of personnel serving with UN missions 636

2. EU Missions (i) European Union Monitor Mission (EUMM) to the former Yugoslavia 5 (ii) EU support to UN authorised African Union Mission in Sudan (AMIS) 3 (iii) ACEH Monitoring Mission (AMM) 1 (iv) EUFOR RD Congo (support mission to MONUC) 7

TOTAL NUMBER OF PERSONNEL SERVING WITH EU MISSIONS 16

3. Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) (i) OSCE Mission to Bosnia & Herzegovina 1 (ii) OSCE Mission in Montenegro 1 (iii) OSCE Presence in Albania 2 (iv) OSCE Mission in FRY 2 (v) OSCE Mission in Georgia 1 (vi) Staff Officer, Higher Level Planning Group, Vienna 1

Total number of personnel serving OSCE 8

4. Head of Military Staff (Brussels) 1 5. EU Military Staff (Brussels/Mons) 6 6. EU Military Staff (New York) 1 7. Liaison Office of Ireland, PfP (Brussels) 2 8. Permanent Representative to EU (Brussels) 3 9. Military Representatives/ Advisers (i) Military Adviser, Permanent Mission to UN, New York 1 (ii) Military Adviser, Irish Delegation to OSCE, Vienna 1 (iii) Military Representative to Partnership Co-ordination Cell/Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers 1 Europe (SHAPE), Mons, Belgium 10. Appointments — UN HQ (New York) Officers seconded to DPKO (Department of Peace Keeping Operations) 1

TOTAL NUMBER DEFENCE FORCES PERSONNEL SERVING OVERSEAS 677

Defence Forces Property. drome, Baldonnel, County Dublin; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32346/06] 15. Mr. Perry asked the Minister for Defence the recent approaches which have been made to Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): Casement him with a view to developing Casement Aero- Aerodrome, Baldonnel is the principal base of 851 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 852

[Mr. O’Dea.] on the report’s findings of low morale in the the Air Corps. With the withdrawal of aircraft Naval Service; if he will address the many issues from Gormanston and the relocation of Air highlighted in the report; and if he will make a Corps headquarters to Baldonnel, the Air Corps statement on the matter. [32179/06] has the basis for better management of its resources. Baldonnel will continue to be the Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose centre of military aviation in Ireland. to take Questions Nos. 16, 29, 44 and 67 together. Periodic interest has been expressed by the The Naval Service provides the maritime private sector during the past decade or so in element of the Defence Forces and has a general relation to the use of Casement Aerodrome for responsibility to meet contingent and actual mari- Civil Aviation purposes. No recent approaches, time Defence requirements. The Naval Service however, have been made to my Department in operates eight general-purpose patrol ships. All this regard. eight ships are involved in coastal and offshore The establishment of facilities for civil aviation patrolling and surveillance for the State in that purposes is primarily a matter for the Minister for part of the seas where State jurisdiction applies Transport. Under the Irish Aviation Authority such as Internal Waters, Territorial Sea and the Act 1993, however, aerodromes under my auth- Irish Sector of the Exclusive Economic Zone. ority are precluded from regulation by the Irish The main day-to-day role of the Naval Service Aviation Authority. Only the regulation of is to provide a fishery protection service in military aviation activities at military aerodromes accordance with the State’s obligations as a comes within my remit. member of the European Union. The Service is Before any consideration could be given to tasked with patrolling all Irish waters from the having commercial aviation at Baldonnel it would shoreline to the outer limits of the Exclusive Fish- be necessary to bring Casement Aerodrome ery Limits. within the licensing and regulatory control of the The current Exclusive Fishery Limits extend to Irish Aviation Authority, which would require an 200 miles offshore and cover an area of 132,000 amendment to Section 3 of the Irish Aviation square miles. The Naval Service currently patrols Authority Act, 1993. This is a matter for con- the entire 200 mile limit and periodically patrols sideration in the first instance by the Minister beyond these limits to protect specific fisheries. for Transport. These patrols are carried out on a regular and frequent basis and are directed to all areas of Naval Service Personnel. Irish waters as necessary. The number of Patrol 16. Ms O. Mitchell asked the Minister for Vessels on patrol in Irish waters at any one time Defence his plans to address the concerns of varies between three and seven. The Naval naval personnel with regard to the time spent on Service is committed to having at least three ves- sea going duty; and if he will make a statement sels on patrol within the Irish Exclusive Econ- on the matter. [32340/06] omic Zone at any one time. Last year the Naval Service achieved a total of 29. Mr. Boyle asked the Minister for Defence 1,682 patrol days, of which 93% related to fishery if he will comment on the report, A Voyage of protection. This was an increase of more than 5% Understanding which he has received from over the total patrol days for 2004. In the course PDFORRA regarding the low morale of the of these patrols, a total of 2,068 vessels were naval forces due to long-term sea patrols; his boarded, 41 were detained and 111 warnings were response to the low morale in the naval forces; issued. These outputs reveal a focused and com- and if he will make a statement on the matter. mitted Naval Service that is continuing to [32304/06] produce high levels of performance. The reorganisation of the Naval Service was 44. Ms McManus asked the Minister for designed to ensure that when fully implemented Defence his views on the recent statement from all personnel would spend alternate periods of the general secretary of PDFORRA that morale two years in a shore based appointment followed among Naval Service members and their families by a ship based appointment. In this regard, I is at an all-time low; his further views on the should point out that two years in a ship based number of Naval Service members currently appointment does not imply that people spend applying to leave the service; the efforts being two years at sea. This is managed locally by the made to ensure that personnel spend a maximum Flag Officer commanding the Naval Service. of 180 days at sea over two years; and if he will However, where there are shortages of skilled make a statement on the matter. [32181/06] personnel within the Naval Service, it may be necessary for personnel to carry out sea-going 67. Mr. Sherlock asked the Minister for duties more frequently. Defence if his attention has been drawn to the The impact of seagoing is well understood by recent report A Voyage of Discovery; his views Naval Personnel at all levels and the Naval 853 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 854

Service endeavours to operate a planned the number of Defence Force members to be approach to the sea/shore rotation of personnel. committed to the UN force in Lebanon; and if he Other than for Able Seamen there is no part- will make a statement on the matter. [32260/06] icular problem with maintaining sea/shore rotation for personnel. There are however, indi- 20. Ms Lynch asked the Minister for Defence vidual, cases where this may not be exactly main- the latest situation in regard to the deployment tained e.g. Personnel regularly apply to extend of Irish troops to assist in international peace- their period at sea beyond 2 years. keeping efforts in the Lebanon; the number of I believe that it is essential that we retain highly troops to be sent to the region; the type of activi- trained and experienced personnel in the Naval ties they will be engaged in; the initial length of Service. However in recent years there are great their stay; and if he will make a statement on the opportunities in the private sector for well quali- matter. [32177/06] fied and highly motivated people. As one might expect, members of the Permanent Defence 43. Mr. Sherlock asked the Minister for Force, including the Naval Service take up offers Defence the risk analysis that has been carried of civilian employment in times of economic pros- out or is currently underway in advance of the perity. There are two quite distinctive factors deployment of Irish troops on peacekeeping which specifically impinge upon the general Per- duties in the Lebanon; and if he will make a state- manent Defence Force situation in this regard. ment on the matter. [32178/06] Firstly, the immediate availability at a relatively young age of pension and gratuities. Secondly, it 52. Mr. Perry asked the Minister for Defence is widely recognised, not least by private sector the role of Irish troops in UNIFIL 2; and if he employers, that the programmes of personal will make a statement on the matter. [32348/06] development and training available in the Defence Forces are second to none and can stand 175. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for comparison with the best in the private sector. Defence the anticipated strength of the Irish UN Obviously, such personnel, already pre-trained deployment to the Lebanon; and if he will make and well experienced to the highest levels, are a a statement on the matter. [32563/06] tempting target to the private sector. In addition, the unique leadership and management skills of Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose personnel has made them a very attractive target to take Questions Nos. 17, 20, 43, 52 and 175 for recruitment in the private sector. together. To date this year there have been 60 discharges UNIFIL was originally established on 19 from the naval service. Of this figure 16 retired March 1978 under United Nations Security on pension/age grounds, 38 left at their own Council resolutions 425 and 426, following the request and the remaining 6 were discharged on invasion of Lebanon by Israel, with a mandate a variety of grounds. “to confirm the withdrawal of Israeli Forces, to I am very much aware of the report A Voyage restore international peace and security and to of Discovery and in fact on the 19th September I assist the Government of Lebanon in ensuring held discussions with a PDFORRA delegation the return of its effective authority in the area”. and representatives of the Naval Service regard- The Secretary General of the United Nations ing the effects of patrol duties on personnel of concluded that as of 16 June, 2000 Israel had the Naval Service. withdrawn its forces from Lebanon in accordance I am pleased to say that our meeting reached with resolution 425 (1978), thus partially fulfilling agreement on a process to examine this issue and UNIFIL’s original mandate. Since then, UNIFIL find potential solutions. A further series of meet- has continued to operate in Southern Lebanon. ings will take place between the Deputy Chief of The mission continued to focus on the remaining Staff (Support) and PDFORRA over the coming part of its mandate: the restoration of peace and months. The purpose of the meetings is to exam- security in the region, through observing, moni- ine the complex issues raised by PDFORRA with toring and reporting on developments in its area a view to exploring a possible resolution. I will be of operation, liaising with the parties, with a view monitoring progress in this area closely. to correcting violations along the line of with- It goes without saying that members of the drawal, the so-called Blue Line, and preventing naval service go to sea. At the same time both my the escalation of incidents. Department and I are committed to ensuring that Ireland has participated in UNIFIL since 1978. the Naval Service and the Defence Forces as a Between May 1978 and November 2001, the whole provides a challenging and rewarding Defence Forces had an infantry battalion career and a supportive working environment. (approx. strength 540 personnel) in Lebanon, together with approximately 100 personnel in UNIFIL Headquarters and the Force Mobile Overseas Missions. Reserve. Since November 2001, a small number 17. Mr. Stanton asked the Minister for Defence of Defence Forces personnel continued to serve 855 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 856

[Mr. O’Dea.] the potential to impact negatively on the peace- at the Force Headquarters in Naqoura. Five (5) keeping operation, while the large quantity of personnel are currently deployed at the Force cluster-bomblets and other unexploded ordnance Headquarters. also present a risk. However, the ceasefire seems In response to the July/August 2006 crisis, the to be holding well and the Defence Forces have UN decided, under UN Security Council Resol- assessed the overall threat as “LOW within a vol- ution 1701, to extend the mandate of UNIFIL to atile situation”, not dissimilar to that encountered the end of August, 2007, and to increase its troop by Irish personnel on other peace support mis- strength from approx 2,000 troops to a maximum sions. Given the Defence Forces equipment, of 15,000. The Council also decided that, in training and experience, the Chief of Staff has addition to carrying out its original mandate advised me that the mission is within the capa- under Council resolutions 425 and 426, UNIFIL bility of Defence Forces personnel and that they would also monitor the cessation of hostilities; can play a meaningful role. accompany and support the Lebanese armed On 3 October, 2006, the Government author- forces as they deploy throughout Southern ised, subject to Da´il approval, the despatch of a Lebanon; and extend its assistance to help ensure contingent of the Defence Forces to UNIFIL. humanitarian access to civilian populations and The necessary enabling motion was moved in the the voluntary and safe return of displaced Da´il on 10 October, 2006 and was approved persons. yesterday. The nature of the expanded UNIFIL mandate Following detailed discussions between the is such that its role is to be considerably more Defence Forces and their Finnish counterparts, robust than it was prior to the adoption of Resol- including a joint reconnaissance mission to ution 1701, while still operating under Chapter VI Lebanon, the current plan envisages the deploy- of the UN Charter. UNIFIL will assist the ment of a Finnish engineering unit with an Irish Government of Lebanon to exercise its authority protection detail in the Eastern Sector area of throughout the UNIFIL area of operations. It will Lebanon. The planned Irish contingent will con- take all necessary action, acting in support of the sist of approximately 150 Defence Forces person- Government of Lebanon, “to ensure that its area nel. The five (5) Defence Forces personnel cur- of operations is not utilised for hostile activities rently serving in Lebanon will continue to be of any kind and to resist attempts by forceful deployed at the UNIFIL Force Headquarters. means to prevent it from discharging its duties” The Finnish/Irish engineering unit will carry under the mandate of the Security Council. out tasks in support of UNIFIL and also some UNIFIL is not charged with disarming the Hez- humanitarian work, including dealing with unex- bollah. The question of disarming Hezbollah is a ploded ordnance clearance and reconstruction. matter for the Lebanese Government. Moreover, While the Irish element will be tasked primarily it is recognised that this can only take place in the for reconnaissance, security and protection duties context of an overall political process in the associated with the engineering works, it will also region. be available to undertake other tasks at the Following on from the ceasefire, which took request of the UNIFIL Force Commander. effect on 14 August, 2006, the Government here Deployment to UNIFIL will take place on has been monitoring the situation with a view to 30/31 October 2006 and, if approved, will bring determining how best Ireland might contribute to the total number of Defence Forces personnel the expanded UNIFIL II mission. As the serving overseas to about 830 personnel which is Deputies will appreciate, given our other existing within the UNSAS ceiling of 850. commitments, the Defence Forces have limited Initial deployment would be for 1 year subject resources to contribute to this mission. Against to renewal of the mandate and a satisfactory this background, an option was identified review of the mission at that time. In line with whereby Ireland might partner Finnish troops standing policy that the duration of any deploy- and provide a protection detail to a planned Finn- ment should be set at the outset of a mission, it ish Engineering Company. is considered that Defence Forces involvement in While there are risks attaching to any peace- UNIFIL should not exceed a maximum of 2 to 3 keeping operation, a key aspect and the primary years in duration. concern in relation to participation in any mission is the safety and security of Defence Forces per- 18. Ms Enright asked the Minister for Defence sonnel. For this reason, the Defence Forces the number of additional Irish military personnel undertook a joint reconnaissance mission to required due to the acceptance of the lead role in Lebanon last month. Following consultation with KFOR; and if he will make a statement on the our Finnish colleagues, UNIFIL and other par- matter. [32324/06] ties, it is assessed that there is no direct threat to UNIFIL personnel. That said, the uncertain and 21. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for Defence volatile situation means that incidents, misunder- if he will send a civil affairs section with the Irish standings or wider political developments all have contingent for the duration of their term as the 857 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 858 lead nation; and if he will make a statement on The role of the Framework Nation is to assume the matter. [32325/06] responsibility for the coordination and control of the Headquarters of the Multinational Task 66. Mr. Gormley asked the Minister for Force (Centre), commanding, controlling and Defence if he will report on the assumption by directing task force operations. The Framework Irish troops of the lead role in the UN task force Nation provides the Force Commander for the in Kosovo; and if he will make a statement on the task force and most of the key planning and logis- matter. [32303/06] tics appointments in the Force Headquarters. It is obliged to provide assets and capabilities to the Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose Task Force, including a substantial input of to take Questions Nos. 18, 21 and 66 together. resources to cater for accommodation, building KFOR was established on 10 June, 1999, in maintenance, water, electricity, sewerage, cater- accordance with UN Security Council Resolution ing, communications, transport, security, admini- 1244, for an initial period of twelve months, to stration and barrack services. In addition, the continue thereafter unless the UN Security Framework Nation is responsible for supporting Council decides otherwise. KFOR’s mandate is to other Task Force contributors in their operations establish a secure environment in Kosovo con- so as to maintain the overall effectiveness of the ducive to the implementation of refugee return Task Force as a whole. and reconstruction. KFOR has a current strength Assumption of the role of Framework Nation of approximately 15,000 troops drawn from 24 will entail the deployment of approximately 60 NATO countries and 11 non-NATO countries additional personnel to KFOR. including Ireland, Austria, Finland and Sweden. KFOR is a multinational operation with contri- The KFOR mandate is expected to continue for butions from a wide range of countries, each of some considerable time to come. which undertakes particular responsibilities, and Ireland has participated in KFOR since August lead roles in relation to certain activities. In the 1999, following Government Decision and sub- case of MNTF (Centre), the Finns have the lead sequent approval by Da´il E´ ireann of the neces- role in the area of Civil Affairs, more commonly sary enabling motion. The Irish contingent cur- known as Civil-Military Cooperation or CIMIC. rently comprises an Infantry Group of some 213 They have performed this role successfully for a personnel including a number of personnel in long period of time. Ireland will continue to staff posts at various Headquarters. The Infantry deploy a Staff Officer in the CIMIC cell in MNTF Group was first deployed in September 2003. Pre- Centre. However, there are no plans to increase viously a Transport Group had been deployed our contribution to this part of the headquarters structure. That said, the Irish contingent will con- with KFOR. tinue to undertake CIMIC type work and KFOR is organised into five Multinational humanitarian tasks within its area of responsi- Task Forces (MNTFs), each having a designated bility with support from Irish Aid. area of responsibility. Each Task Force comes Ireland becoming Framework Nation will rep- under the command of a Framework Nation, resent a significant progression in the develop- being one of the States contributing to the part- ment of Defence Forces peacekeeping capabili- icular Task Force. All Task Forces fall under a ties. For the first time an Irish officer will be in single chain of command, namely the Com- command and control of a multinational brigade mander of KFOR, located at KFOR HQ, in sized force in a Partnership for Peace (PfP) led Pristina. peace support operation. A large number of The Irish Infantry Group serves in the Multi- Defence Forces Officers and NCOs will serve in National Task Force (Centre), which comprises core HQ posts, exercising overall command and approximately 1,200 personnel. Five other control over the operations of the Task Force. In nations participate in this Task force: — Czech addition, Ireland will be seen by its partner Republic, Slovakia, Sweden, Finland and Latvia nations as being prepared to share the burden of with Sweden currently acting as Framework Framework Nation, which is seen as an extremely Nation. The Task Force’s area of responsibility is important and high profile, if onerous, responsi- generally the Pristina region, covering 7 munici- bility. Benefit will also accrue to the Defence palities with a population of approximately 1 mil- Forces, both at operational and individual level, lion people. The Irish commitment comprises a enhancing the depth of experience and contribu- MOWAG mounted APC Company together with ting to the overall development and modernis- support and logistic elements and various HQ ation of the Defence Forces. Other nations, which personnel. Twelve personnel are also serving at have served as Framework Nation, have KFOR HQ. remarked on the positive impact it has had on the Ireland will take over from Sweden as Frame- modernisation and transformation of their armed work Nation in the Multinational Task Force forces. A term as Framework Nation will also (Centre) in KFOR for the first time in August maintain and add to Ireland’s profile and repu- 2007 for a period of one (1) year to 31 July 2008. tation as a provider of professional and interoper- 859 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 860

[Mr. O’Dea.] I have had no contact with the Israeli or able forces for international peace support oper- Lebanese authorities arising from the recent ations, which is a key objective of our article. participation in PfP generally. Defence Forces Reserve. Question No. 19 answered with Question No. 10. 23. Mr. Bruton asked the Minister for Defence the progress with regard to the amalgamation of Question No. 20 answered with Question the Reserve Defence Forces; and if he will make No. 17. a statement on the matter. [32343/06]

Question No. 21 answered with Question 47. Mr. Bruton asked the Minister for Defence No. 18. if members of the Reserve Defence Forces will be permitted to serve overseas; and if he will make a 22. Mr. Gilmore asked the Minister for statement on the matter. [32341/06] Defence his views on the claims made on a Lebanese television station that a member of the Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose Irish Army had been fighting alongside Israeli to take Questions Nos. 23 and 47 together. soldiers in Lebanon; if he has had contact with The White Paper on Defence outlines the blue Lebanese or Israeli authorities on this issue; and print for a new Reserve Defence Force. The new if he will make a statement on the matter. Reserve will have a clearly defined role, an [32175/06] enhanced relationship with the PDF, better equipment and training and opportunities to serve on overseas peace support missions. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I presume the Deputy is referring to a recent press article The Reserve Defence Force Review Imple- concerning allegations made on a Lebanese tele- mentation Plan, which was formally launched in July 2004, is progressing on schedule. This plan vision station that a member of the Irish Army provides for the phased enhancement of Reserve had been fighting alongside Israeli soldiers during capabilities over the period to end 2009. To date the recent conflict in Lebanon. As the basis for the Reserve has been reorganised along similar its assertion, the television station reported that lines to the Permanent Defence Force with three the identity card of a member of the Irish Brigades, a Reserve Defence Force Training Defence Forces was found amongst items reco- Authority located in the Defence Forces Training vered in an area recently vacated by personnel of Centre in the Curragh and a dedicated Naval the Israeli Defence Forces in South Lebanon. Service Reserve. These new organisational struc- There is no information available to the tures were introduced on 1st October 2005. In military authorities to substantiate the claim addition to the reorganisation, the Reserve has made by the Lebanese TV Station ‘AL seen significant improvements in clothing, equip- MANAR’, which I understand is owned and con- ment and enhanced training opportunities. trolled by Hezbollah. However, I can state categ- The development of the integrated element of orically that no member of the Defence Forces the Reserve is currently being progressed and it was fighting alongside the Israeli forces and the is planned to introduce elements of the integrated person, whose ID was found, is still a member of Reserve, on a pilot basis, in 2007. This element the Defence Forces and was not in Lebanon dur- of the Reserve will provide personnel who will ing the recent conflict. integrate with PDF units in contingency The military authorities have confirmed that an situations. The Integrated Reserve will be pro- incident occurred in 1997 and was reported by vided with enhanced military training and PDF them at the time, when an Irish unit serving with unit commanders will be responsible for the train- the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon ing of such Reserve personnel. (UNIFIL) was engaged in mine-clearing duties The phased enhancement of Reserve capabili- outside a village close to one of the outposts ties and improvements in interoperability manned by the then South Lebanese (Christian) between the Reserve and the PDF, as provided Militia (SLA). A member of the Irish unit was for in the plan, are significant enablers in facilitat- injured and medical assistance was rendered by a ing any future participation by Reserve personnel member of the SLA, which required the removal in overseas peace support missions. of the soldier’s trouser leg containing his wallet While there are no immediate plans for partici- and ID card. The loss was reported at the time pation by members of the Reserve in overseas and the ID card, which I understand has since missions, policies to support the selection of suit- expired, was cancelled. We have no information ably qualified personnel for overseas duties will as to how the ID card, which, as I have said, was be developed over the lifetime of the Implemen- lost in 1997, came to be found in items discovered tation Plan i.e. over the period to end 2009. In during the recent conflict in Lebanon. other countries, service by Reservists on overseas 861 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 862 peace support missions is quite common, resentative Association (PDFORRA) in Water- although as specified in the Plan, any such partici- ford last week, I stated that should the Associ- pation by members of the Reserve is likely to be ation wish to submit a claim for an increase in in specialised areas such as medical, transport, these allowances, such a claim would receive sym- engineering and communications and information pathetic consideration. Any such claim would, of services. This will also be subject to personnel course, have to be processed through the normal having suitable qualifications, their personal conciliation and arbitration channels and would availability and appropriate advance training. have to meet the conditions required by the new Development of policies to support the selec- Public Service Pay Agreement-Towards 2016. tion of suitably qualified Reserve personnel for overseas duties will include consideration of the National Emergency Plan. impact of overseas duties on the employment of 25. Mr. Deenihan asked the Minister for Reserve personnel. The question of legislation Defence when the task force on emergency plan- will also be considered in this context. ning last met; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32265/06] Defence Forces Remuneration. 24. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for 56. Mr. Cuffe asked the Minister for Defence Defence his plans to increase overseas allowance; when the interdepartmental working group on and if he will make a statement on the matter. emergency planning and the task force on emer- [32336/06] gency planning last met; when they will next meet; the State’s response to the security alert in Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): Since 1958, August 2006 involving an alleged plot to attack the Defence Forces has had a continuous and dis- aircraft flying out of the UK; and if he will make tinguished presence on peacekeeping duties a statement on the matter. [32306/06] throughout the world and are currently contribu- ting 677 personnel to 19 different missions. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose The main commitments are to the United to take Questions Nos. 25 and 56 together. Nations Mission to Liberia (UNMIL), to the The Government Task Force on Emergency NATO-led International Security presence Planning and the Inter-Departmental Working (KFOR) in Kosovo and to EUFOR, the EU-led Group meet on a regular basis. The last Task operation in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Other per- Force meeting was held on Tuesday 3rd October sonnel are serving as monitors and observers with 2006. The Inter-Departmental Working Group the United Nations (UN), the European Union (IDWG) last met on 20 September 2006. While (EU) and the Organisation for Security and dates have not been decided for the next Task Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). Staff are also Force or IDWG meetings, these are normally deployed at the organisational headquarters of held every four to six weeks. the UN, EU, OSCE, and NATO. The State’s response to any security alert is pri- Last week the Government approved my pro- marily a matter for the Ta´naiste & Minister for posals for the despatch of a contingent of the Justice, Equality and Law Reform. While it Defence Forces to Lebanon as part of a joint would be inappropriate to comment on a part- Finnish/Irish Unit to UNIFIL 2. While the final icular security issue, I can reassure the Deputy details are being worked out it is expected that that the Garda authorities maintain an up-to-date the Irish contingent will comprise approximately assessment of threats through analysis of intelli- 150 personnel. gence gathered from domestic and international When visiting Irish troops serving in Liberia sources. and the Balkans I saw at first hand the dedication I can confirm that the Garda Sı´ocha´na has and professionalism of military personnel in developed excellent lines of communication and bringing comfort and hope to those who are less co-operation with police forces and security services in the European Union and further fortunate than us. I want to again express my afield. The ongoing sharing of intelligence appreciation and that of the Government for the enables a rapid operational response to be put in tremendous work being done by the Defence place where circumstances so warrant. This Forces on the international stage in the cause of includes monitoring of any alerts relating to peace. aviation security, in consultation with the Depart- The current rate of Overseas Peace Support ment of Transport. Allowance (OPSA) payable to enlisted personnel serving overseas ranges from \52.86 to \56.62 per day. In addition to this, an Overseas Armed Decentralisation Programme. Peace Support Allowance (OAPSA) of \21.36 26. Mr. Gogarty asked the Minister for per day is payable for certain missions. When Defence the progress in the decentralisation of addressing the Annual Delegate Conference of his Department and components of the Defence the Permanent Defence Force Other Ranks Rep- Forces to Kildare; the number of people who 863 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 864

[Mr. Gogarty.] Among the responsibilities of the EDA is to have moved to date; when he expects this decen- explore ways in which to strengthen the Euro- tralisation to be fully achieved; and if he will pean Defence Technological and Industrial Base make a statement on the matter. [32309/06] (EDTIB). In this regard, the Agency has been examining a number of areas to support greater Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The cohesion and to reduce the level of fragmentation Government decision on decentralisation, in the sector. At the Steering Board in National announced by the Minister for Finance in his Armaments Directors format on 20 September Budget statement on 3 December 2003, provides 2006, the Board discussed a range of issues relat- for the transfer of all of my Department’s Dublin ing to the Defence Equipment Market and the based civil service staff to Newbridge, Co. Technological and Industrial Base both of which Kildare. The number of staff to be relocated to are complimentary in seeking to reform, rational- Newbridge is 200. Sixty staff from within my ise and strengthen the defence industrial sector. Department have opted to move to Newbridge, The Board reviewed the operation of the code of and in addition twenty-nine staff have been conduct on procurement, the code of best prac- assigned from other Departments to date, giving tice in the supply chain, together with issues relat- a total of 89 staff in place who will be assigned to ing to security of supply, security of information Newbridge. I would expect to have close to my and offsets. All these initiatives are designed to full allocation of staff in place in my Department improve the overall operation of the defence in the next 12 to 18 months. equipment market, eliminate market distortions The Office of Public Works is in advanced and reduce the level of recourse by member negotiations with Kildare County Council in States to Article 296 for defence equipment pro- relation to the acquisition of a site in Newbridge. curement. Once this site is acquired, I would anticipate that In tandem with these market initiatives, the my Department will relocate to Newbridge by Agency is also examining how it can support late 2008. There are currently no plans to move greater co-operation among companies in the staff to Newbridge in advance of this date. European defence industry so as to maintain and The Government decision on decentralisation strengthen the industrial base. The report of the also provides for the transfer of 300 Defence Agency on the European Defence Technological Forces Headquarters staff to the Curragh, Co. and Industrial Base recognises that, given the Kildare. pressure on current national Defence Budgets The brief for the new Defence Forces Head- and continuing fragmentation in both supply and quarters building has been finalised and prelimi- demand, it is likely that the European defence nary topographical and site investigations have industry will struggle to remain globally competi- been completed. The Office of Public Works is tive into the future. The Agency set out a number finalising the outline design currently, to enable of proposals to start addressing this issue. The the project to be sent to tender. It is expected view of the Agency is that the industry, in the that the necessary planning notification will be future, must be Capability driven (responsive to submitted to Kildare County Council before the PMS and EU defence needs), Competent end of 2006, with works commencing as soon as (capable of delivering cutting-edge technology on possible thereafter. time) and Competitive. The Steering Board agreed with the Agency’s European Defence Agency. analysis and tasked the Agency to identity, in consultation with Aerospace and Defence Indus- 27. Mr. Gogarty asked the Minister for tries Association of Europe, the main challenges Defence if he will report on the 20 September and opportunities for the European defence 2006, meeting of the European Defence Agency, industry, and to work with participating Member which held a review of the future of Europe’s States to identify priority technologies for preser- defence technological and industrial base; and if vation or development at European level with a he will make a statement on the matter. view to improving effective R&T collaboration. [32308/06] Departmental Expenditure. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The Euro- pean Defence Agency Steering Board met in 28. Mr. O’Dowd asked the Minister for National Armaments Directors formation in Defence the fuel bill for military vehicles for the Brussels on 20th September, 2006. The EDA years 2004 and 2005; and if he will make a state- Steering Board meets at different levels i.e. at ment on the matter. [32332/06] ministerial level and at official level. In the case of meetings at National Armaments Directors Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): Iam level, an official from my Department acts as our advised that the fuel bill for military vehicles in representative at the Steering Board and 2004 was \2,179,782. The corresponding figure attended the meeting. for 2005 was \2,766,692. 865 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 866

Question No. 29 answered with Question includes Biological Agent Detector and Screen- No. 16. ing Kits, Group Decontamination Equipment and Personal Decontamination Equipment. Defence Forces Equipment. The requirement for additional NBC equip- ment is kept under continuous review by the 30. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for Defence Defence Forces. A programme for the purchase the extent to which all members of the Defence of NBC equipment is ongoing and whatever Forces are issued with the necessary protection in equipment deemed necessary is purchased the event of a gas or chemical attack; and if he expeditiously to meet the changing requirements. will make a statement on the matter. [32359/06] On the issue of body armour, a tender compe- tition was held in 2005 for the provision of body 55. Mr. Neville asked the Minister for Defence armour for the individual soldier on operational the number of nuclear, biological and chemical duties. An order was placed for 6000 units for suits available to members of the Defence Forces; delivery this year. The delivery of the 6000 units and if he will make a statement on the matter. is ongoing at present. The new body armour pro- [32268/06] vides significantly greater protection, comfort and coverage than the old model as well as a doubling 172. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for of the range of sizes available. A further order Defence the extent to which gas masks or other for 2000 units has been placed. It is expected that breathing equipment is available to each member delivery of the 2000 units will also be made by of the Army, Naval Service and Air Corps; and if the end of this year. he will make a statement on the matter. [32560/06] Defence Forces Strength.

173. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for 31. Mr. Kenny asked the Minister for Defence Defence if full body protection is available to all the number of officers commissioned from the members of the Army, Naval Service and Air ranks since July 1997; and if he will make a state- Corps; and if he will make a statement on the ment on the matter. [32353/06] matter. [32561/06] Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): A total of Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose 31 enlisted personnel have been commissioned to take Questions Nos. 30, 55, 172 and 173 from the ranks in the Army, Air Corps and Naval together. Service since 1997. The Garda Sı´ocha´na have primary responsi- The revised cadetship competition is now seen bility for law and order, including the protection as the primary means of commissioning from the of the internal security of the State. The potential ranks. The cadetship competition has been threats to the State arising from terrorism are revised to increase the maximum entry age to 28 continuously monitored by them in cooperation and to award bonus marks to candidates with pre- with the Defence Forces. vious experience in the Permanent Defence Force (PDF) or Reserve Defence Force (RDF). The Defence Forces make contingency plans Results for the 2006 cadetship competition were for a range of scenarios where the security of the encouraging with 13% of PDF and 8% of RDF State may be at risk. In addition, the Defence applicants being successful in obtaining cadet- Forces have contingency plans in place in relation ships as against 4% of “civilian” candidates. to the provision of Aid to the Civil Power Consultations with the representative associ- (meaning in practice to assist, when requested, an ations are ongoing regarding the conditions for Garda Sı´ocha´na), and the provision of assistance a Commissioning From the Ranks competition, to the Civil Authorities for a range of emer- which it is intended to hold in the coming months. gency situations. This competition will provide an opportunity for The Defence Forces have available to them enlisted personnel who have passed the cadet equipment for monitoring and protecting their entry age to compete for entry on a potential members in dealing with Nuclear, Biological or Officers Course and ultimately, a commission. Chemical (NBC) threats identified from time to The outcome of this competition will inform time. They hold an extensive range of modern policy on the issue of similar future competitions. NBC equipment that meets their current require- In addition non-commissioned personnel who ments. This range includes approximately 9,500 hold appropriate qualifications may be com- NBC suits, of which 800 were delivered in missioned to fill specialist appointments where January 2006. In addition, the Defence Forces has vacancies arise. sufficient stock of Respirators for each individual soldier. They also have 98 of the most technologi- Defence Forces Veterans. cally up to date Chemical Agent Monitors and Defence Forces personnel have been trained on 32. Mr. Howlin asked the Minister for Defence their operation. Other equipment on hands the financial assistance he will give to the United 867 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 868

[Mr. Howlin.] Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The case to Nations Veterans’ Association in their efforts to which the Deputy refers relates to the killing of have the old schoolhouse which is part of Arbour Private Thomas Barrett and Private Derek House refurbished; and if he will make a state- Smallhorne while serving with the United ment on the matter. [32172/06] Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) in 1980. The question of the measures open to the 48. Aengus O´ Snodaigh asked the Minister for Irish Authorities to bring the alleged perpetrator Defence if consideration has been given to grant of this crime to justice has been examined in aiding the Irish United Nations Veterans Associ- detail in the Department of Defence in conjunc- ation to assist in their work in support of the 7,000 tion with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Irish soldiers who have served on UN missions in the Attorney General’s Office. over 40 countries since 1958, and the widows and The Attorney General has advised that there dependents of deceased members and in provid- are no provisions in Irish law which provide a ing a headquarters for the association; and if he basis for Ireland to pursue a prosecution against will make a statement on the matter. [32258/06] the alleged perpetrator. The Attorney did indi- cate, however, that while untested and potentially Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose difficult, it might be possible for Ireland to pursue to take Questions Nos. 32 and 48 together. a prosecution under the provisions of the Geneva I can advise the Deputies that in recognition Conventions. While this appears an outside possi- of the valuable work of the Irish United Nations bility, nevertheless, the Minister for Defence has Veterans Association (IUNVA) and to mark asked the DPP, who would be responsible for almost 50 years of Defence Forces involvement pursuing any prosecution, to review the matter. in international peacekeeping with the United The Office of the DPP has examined all the avail- Nations, I was yesterday pleased to mark this able evidence in the case and has concluded that important contribution by supporting the work of he cannot pursue a prosecution against the IUNVA in the form of a once off grant of \50,000 alleged perpetrator. from my Department. I hope that this will go The country with primary jurisdiction in this some way towards assisting IUNVA in its most case is Lebanon. At the request of the Minister valuable and worthwhile activities. for Defence, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, The Irish United Nations Veterans Association through the Embassy of Ireland in Cairo, which (IUNVA) was formed in 1990. The Association is accredited to Beirut, has conveyed to the is non-denominational, non-political and non-sec- Lebanese authorities our earnest desire and tarian. Membership is available to any Irish resi- determination to see the alleged perpetrator dent who has successfully completed a tour of brought to justice and to advise them that we will duty with a UN Force or Organisation, whether he or she is serving or retired. assist in whatever manner we can, should the Lebanese authorities be able to bring him to IUNVA’s primary role is providing advice and justice. counselling to members and their families who have been affected by their overseas service. The The Department of Defence and the Depart- Association, which is financed by membership ment of Foreign Affairs are also in contact with fees, voluntary contributions and fundraising, also the US authorities, where the alleged perpetrator organises social, cultural and sporting events for resides as a naturalised US citizen. The US auth- its members. orities have been kept apprised of developments As fellow veterans of U.N. operations world- in the case. wide, IUNVA supports soldiers, Gardaı´ and civ- The Minister for Defence will continue to ilian personnel who serve in often dangerous and explore such avenues as may be open to him to difficult circumstances. These personnel have seek justice in respect of Privates Barrett and contributed to almost 50 years of peacekeeping Smallhorne. However, it will be appreciated that with courage and professionalism. IUNVA con- the long passage of time since the tragic incident tinues to support such personnel where the need will create its own difficulties in terms of mount- arises with an understanding and insight born of ing a prosecution, even if we can make the their own personal experiences of overseas alleged perpetrator amenable to justice. service. The Defence Forces continue to maintain con- tact with the Barrett and Smallhorne families. Defence Forces Investigations. Defence Forces Strength. 33. Mr. Rabbitte asked the Minister for Defence the circumstances surrounding the 34. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for Defence deaths of persons (details supplied); if investi- his plans to increase the strength of the Defence gations are ongoing; and if he will make a state- Forces; and if he will make a statement on the ment on the matter. [32169/06] matter. [32327/06] 869 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 870

36. Mr. Deasy asked the Minister for Defence 100% in the number of females serving over this the strength of the Defence Forces; and if he will period. make a statement on the matter. [32266/06] The Government is committed to a policy of equal opportunity for men and women in the 53. Mr. Rabbitte asked the Minister for Defence Forces (Army, Air Corps, Naval Defence the number of personnel in the Army, Service) including the Reserve Defence Force, the Naval Service and the Air Corps; the quantity and to the full participation by women in all of sick leave experienced by each sector over the aspects of Defence Forces activities. past 12 months; and if he will make a statement The White Paper on Defence of February 2000 on the matter. [32171/06] sets out a figure of 10,500 personnel for the Per- manent Defence Force, comprising 930 for the 54. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for Defence Air Corps, 1,144 for the Naval Service and 8,426 his views on increasing the strength of the for the Army. It is my intention to maintain the Defence Forces to accommodate and compensate established Government policy of ongoing for overseas deployments; and if he will make a recruitment to the Defence Forces. Recruitment statement on the matter. [32360/06] into the Permanent Defence Force will continue to maintain the strength at the level set out in the 60. Mr. Eamon Ryan asked the Minister for White Paper as required to meet military needs. Defence if he will comment on concerns The Defence Forces continue to have a proactive expressed at the PDFORRA annual conference approach to all aspects of recruiting. that military personnel levels are dropping at a The Defence Forces manage recruit intakes to time when additional commitments are coming keep its annualised monthly average strength at on stream for the Defence Forces; and if he will or around 10,500. The strength of the Defence make a statement on the matter. [32310/06] Forces as at 31 December in the years 2003, 2004 and 2005 respectively was 10,498, 10,551 and 174. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for 10,446. Defence if it is intended to increase the strength There is a planned total intake of 255 personnel of the Defence Forces in line with the require- (Cadets, Apprentices & General Enlistment) ments arising from UN overseas deployments; before the end of 2006, with an expected outflow and if he will make a statement on the matter. of 150 personnel in the same period. Recruit [32562/06] intake will be finalised in December 2006 to ensure that the annualised monthly average 176. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for strength is at or around 10,500. Defence if the strength of the Defence Forces The White Paper on Defence provides for an needs to be augmented in view of current and allocation of up to 850 Permanent Defence Force proposed participation in UN or EU peace- personnel to be deployed overseas at any one keeping or peace enforcement missions; and if he time through the United Nations Standby will make a statement on the matter. [32564/06] Arrangements System (UNSAS). While this may be exceeded for short periods, deployments 180. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for above this level are not sustainable on an ongoing Defence the number of women by rank in the basis within existing resources. Any commitments Army, Naval Service and Air Corps; if these to EU or UN missions will be met within this con- numbers have fluctuated; and if he will make a text. There are no plans to increase the numbers statement on the matter. [32568/06] serving in the Defence Forces above the levels provided for in the White Paper. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose There are currently 663 personnel deployed on to take Questions Nos. 34, 36, 53, 54, 60, 174, 176 overseas operations with a planned deployment and 180 together. of 158 personnel to UNIFIL at the end of The strength of the Permanent Defence Force October, 2006. On deployment to UNIFIL the on 31 August 2006, the latest date for which number of personnel deployed on overseas oper- detailed figures are available, as advised by the ations will be 821 which is within the 850 allo- military authorities is 10,382. A detailed break- cation for overseas deployments that is the down of the numbers in the Army, Naval Service maximum overseas capability of the Defence and Air Corps by rank and gender are in the form Forces. of a Tabular Statement which I propose to circu- Details of the sick leave levels experienced by late with the Official Report. the Army, Naval Service and Air Corps over the In total there are currently 545 female person- last twelve months are not readily available. The nel serving in the Permanent Defence Force. Military Authorities are compiling this infor- Over the past nine years, the strength of female mation such detailed information will take some personnel in the Permanent Defence Force has time to collate from individual records at unit increased from 244 at the end of 1997 to 545 at level, and I will write to the Deputy with this present. This constitutes an increase of over information, as soon as it is available. 871 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 872

[Mr. O’Dea.]

Strength of the Permanent Defence Force

31 August 2006

Lt Maj Brig Col Lt Comdt Capt Lt Total SM BQMS CS CQMS SGTS CPLS Total PTES Cadets Total Gen Gen Gen Col Offrs NCOS

Army 1 2 6 39 127 323 306 271 1,075 33 34 134 244 1,032 1,542 3,019 4,346 36 8,476 Air Corps 0 0 1 2 14 31 45 44 137 7 4 52 14 132 192 401 294 16 848 Naval 0 0 1 2 12 47 40 59 161 6 7 75 16 201 176 481 402 14 1,058 Service

Lt Gen = Lieutenant General Lt Col = Lieutenant Colonel SM = Sergeant Major SGTS = Sergeants Maj Gen = Major General Comdt = Commandant BQMS = Battalion Quartermaster Sergeant CPLS = Corporals Brig Gen = Brigadier General Capt = Captain CS = Company Sergeant NCOS = Non Commissioned Officers Col = Colonel Lt = Lieutenant CQMS = Company Quartermaster Sergeant PTES = Privates

Strength of Females in the Permanent Defence Force

31 August 2006

Lt Maj Brig Col Lt Comdt Capt Lt Total SM BQMS CS CQMS SGTS CPLS Total PTES Cadets Total Gen Gen Gen Col Offrs NCOS

Army 0 0 0 0 1 16 43 41 101 0 0 3 1 12 102 118 226 7 452 Air Corps 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 4 0 0 1 0 1 11 13 13 0 30

Naval 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 11 16 0 0 0 006635663 Service

Strength of Males in the Permanent Defence Force

31 August 2006

Lt Maj Brig Col Lt Comdt Capt Lt Total SM BQMS CS CQMS SGTS CPLS Total PTES Cadets Total Gen Gen Gen Col Offrs NCOS

Army 1 2 6 39 126 307 263 230 974 33 34 131 243 1,020 1,440 2,901 4,120 29 8,024

Air Corps 0 0 1 2 14 31 43 42 133 7 4 51 14 131 181 388 281 16 818 Naval 0 0 1 2 12 47 35 48 145 6 7 75 16 201 170 475 367 8 995 Service

Strength of the Reserve Defence Force

31 January 2006

Lt. Comdt Capt LT Total SM BQMS CS CQMS SGTS CPLS Total PTES Total Col Offrs NCOS

Army Reserve 4 108 182 366 660 21 22 117 109 866 1,453 2,588 6,151 9,399 Naval Reserve 0 4 10 12 26 0 4 13 1 23 32 73 275 374

Strength of Males in the Reserve Defence Force

31 January 2006

Lt. Comdt Capt LT Total SM BQMS CS CQMS SGTS CPLS Total PTES Total Col Offrs NCOS

Army Reserve 4 108 182 313 607 21 22 116 107 801 1,076 2,143 4,112 6,862 Naval Reserve 0 4 10 10 24 0 4 13 1 22 25 65 187 276 873 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 874

Strength of Females in the Reserve Defence Force

31 January 2006

Lt. Comdt Capt LT Total SM BQMS CS CQMS SGTS CPLS Total PTES Total Col Offrs NCOS

Army Reserve 0 0 0 53 53 0 0 1 2 65 377 445 2,039 2,537 Naval Reserve 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 1 7 8 88 98

Strength of the First Line Reserve

31 January 2006

TOTAL OFFRS TOTAL NCOS PTES TOTAL

Army 100 16 133 249 Air Corps 24 2 12 38 Naval Service 39 12 44 95

The main Irish contingent operates as the Overseas Missions. Force Commander’s Rapid Reaction Reserve. The role of the Irish personnel is the provision of 35. Mr. J. O’Keeffe asked the Minister for an immediate response capability, deployable in Defence the number of Defence Force personnel sufficient strength and with the required level of engaged on mission in Liberia; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32264/06] force, to provide a swift and decisive military reaction to any crisis situation. Initially, the Irish Battalion in UNMIL mainly 37. Mr. Sargent asked the Minister for Defence the situation regarding the Irish troop deploy- operated in a path-finding and reconnaissance ment in Liberia; and if he will make a statement role, supporting the deployment of other UN on the matter. [32312/06] contingents. It has also conducted long-range patrols beyond Monrovia and well into the interior of Liberia, showing a UN presence, 179. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for deterring lawlessness and protecting local popu- Defence if it is intended that Irish troops are expected to participate in further peacekeeping lations. The contingent also undertakes regular missions in Liberia; and if he will make a state- daily patrols within the Monrovia area. The Irish ment on the matter. [32567/06] Battalion is available to the Force Commander to provide support and a rapid response capability Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose in the event of a breakdown in law and order or to take Questions Nos. 35, 37 and 179 together. further conflict. Additionally, the Quick Reaction The United Nations Mission in Liberia Force (QRF) conducted patrols to support Elec- (UNMIL) was established on 19 September, tion Profiling efforts for the National Elections 2003, under United Nations Security Council held on the 11th October and 8th November, Resolution 1509. The resolution authorized the 2005. deployment, under Chapter VII of the UN Char- On 11 November, 2005, the UN Security ter, for a period of twelve months, of up to 15,000 Council extended UNMIL’s mandate to include military personnel, to include up to 250 military the apprehension, detention and transfer to the observers, 875 civilian police officers and a civ- Special Court for Sierra Leone of the former ilian component. UNMIL has a current strength Liberian President, Charles Taylor, in the event (31 January 2006) of 15,037 military personnel. of his return to Liberia. UNMIL assumed Following Government and Da´il approval, a responsibility for the security of the Special Court contingent of the Permanent Defence Force was for Sierra Leone from 1 December, 2005. At the deployed for service with UNMIL in December, request of the UN, Ireland and Sweden agreed to 2003, comprising a motorized infantry battalion, provide support in expanding the area of oper- of some 430 personnel. A small number of ations of the QRF to include Sierra Leone, in additional personnel were also deployed at Force particular, the Special Court for Sierra Leone. Headquarters and as Military Observers. On 2 This allowed Irish and Swedish troops to be made November 2004 and 6 December 2005 the available for extraction operations should there Government reviewed and approved the con- be a requirement to evacuate the staff and tinued participation of the Defence Forces in detainees of the Special Court of Sierra Leone UNMIL. in Freetown. 875 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 876

[Mr. O’Dea.] The manner in which escorts are conducted The QRF assisted in the transfer from and where guards are placed on hospitals at Monrovia to the Special Court for Sierra Leone which prisoners from Portlaoise Prison are in Freetown of the former President, Charles attending, has been under review for some time. Taylor, for trial in accordance with the require- I am informed by the military authorities that the ments of the UN, following his arrest in Nigeria construction of a permanent guardroom at Port- on 29 March 2006. The QRF also assisted and laoise hospital is not considered a military provided security for the transfer of the former requirement at this time. President from Sierra Leone to the court in the Hague where he will stand trial. Question No. 39 answered with Question Ireland was due to complete its participation in No. 11. UNMIL in November 2006. However, the Sec- retary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Defence Forces Property. Annan, requested Ireland to consider postponing 40. Mr. O’Dowd asked the Minister for the withdrawal of its troops from UNMIL for a Defence the situation with regard to the building period of at least six months, in order to give the of affordable housing at Gormanstown, County UN time to find a suitable replacement for the Meath; and if he will make a statement on the QRF capability. The Government following a matter. [32335/06] detailed review of the request, was happy to be able to respond positively to the UN Secretary 42. Mr. Gilmore asked the Minister for General and the Defence Forces will undertake Defence the situation regarding plans to develop one further 6 month rotation to May, 2007, Gormanstown Airfield as part of the Govern- whereupon the contingent will then be with- ment’s affordable housing initiative in view of the drawn. Mission downsizing commenced in June fact that the airfield is located within the 2006, following discussions with the UN. The exclusion zone of the only firing range for Swedish contingent, which partners Ireland in the ground-to-air and air-to-ground missiles in the QRF, will withdraw in November, 2006, and will country; if the site is in the ownership of his be replaced by a Company from Pakistan, who Department; the discussions which have taken will eventually assume the role of QRF on place on this issue; and if he will make a state- Ireland’s withdrawal. ment on the matter. [32174/06]

Question No. 36 answered with Question Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose No. 34. to take Questions Nos. 40 and 42 together. The Government decided on 1 July 2003 that Question No. 37 answered with Question lands at Gormanston, Co. Meath would be among No. 35. the State lands released for inclusion in the Sus- taining Progress Affordable Housing Initiative. Defence Forces Operations. How land at this location might play a role in the delivery of affordable housing units is a matter 38. Ms Enright asked the Minister for Defence in the first instance for the Department of the his views on constructing a permanent guard Environment, Heritage and Local Government, room structure at Portlaoise Hospital, County which is the lead Department for the develop- Laois, as the conditions under which hospital ment of the Affordable Housing Initiative. guards operate are unacceptable; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32330/06] Question No. 41 answered with Question No. 7. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The Garda Sı´ocha´na have the primary responsibility for law Question No. 42 answered with Question and order, including the protection of the internal No. 40. security of the State. Among the roles assigned to the Defence Forces is the provision of aid to the Question No. 43 answered with Question civil power (meaning in practice to assist, when No. 17. requested, an Garda Sı´ocha´na), which duties include the protection and guarding of vital Question No. 44 answered with Question installations, the provision of certain security No. 16. escorts etc. On occasion the Defence Forces are requested Departmental Expenditure. to provide assistance to the Garda Sı´ocha´na when 45. Mr. Eamon Ryan asked the Minister for prisoners from Portlaoise are attending the Port- Defence the expenditure incurred by his Depart- laoise Hospital. This mission is achieved by ment during the first half of 2006; the way this means of mobile and foot patrols, providing a compares to the figures projected in the very visible and identifiable presence outside the Estimates; and if he will make a statement on the hospital. matter. [32311/06] 877 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 878

Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): Gross who test positive. All necessary measures, includ- expenditure incurred by my Department for the ing pre-enlistment screening, education, compul- first half of 2006 (i.e. to end-June) amounted to sory random drug testing, monitoring and sanc- \337.180m under the Defence Vote and \85.988m tions, will be taken to maintain a drug free under the Army Pensions Vote. Appropriations environment within the Defence Forces. in aid under these Votes amounted to \12.562m The primary objective of Compulsory Random and \2.564m, respectively. The expenditure fig- Drugs Testing is deterrence. In order to provide ures represent 43% and 49%, respectively, of the a credible level of deterrent, the testing prog- relevant Estimates provisions. ramme has been devised to maximise the possi- bility of random selection for testing. A trained Question No. 46 answered with Question Drugs Testing Team is responsible for taking No. 7. urine samples for compulsory random testing throughout the Defence Forces. Testing com- Question No. 47 answered with Question menced on 14th November 2002 and the prog- No. 23. ramme is now in its fourth year of operation. The target of testing 10% of the Permanent Defence Question No. 48 answered with Question Force each year has been achieved and it is antici- No. 32. pated that this target will also be reached in 2006. A member of the Permanent Defence Force, ran- Drug Abuse. domly selected, may be required, at any time, to provide a urine sample which will be tested for 49. Mr. Ring asked the Minister for Defence evidence of use of controlled drugs, or the abuse the number of personnel who have failed drug or misuse of other substances, or for the detection tests in the Defence Forces for the years 2004 and of the metabolites thereof. A member of the Per- 2005; if all these personnel were discharged; and manent Defence Force who refuses to provide a if he will make a statement on the matter. urine sample, or who provides a urine sample [32352/06] which tests positive, shall be liable to retirement, discharge or relinquishment of commission or Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The withdrawal of cadetship as appropriate under the military authorities advise that the number of provisions of Defence Force Regulations. personnel who tested “positive” under the Com- All personnel have the option of having an pulsory Random Drug Test programme in the independent test carried out on the “B sample” Defence Forces in the years 2004 and 2005 was of any specimen obtained under the Compulsory four and seven respectively. The four members Random Drug testing procedures. Where person- who tested “positive” in 2004 were discharged nel have confirmed positive test results, they are and six of the seven who tested positive in 2005 liable to be discharged or retired in accordance have been discharged. The proposed discharge of with the relevant regulations. In such circum- one of the members who tested “positive” in 2005 stances personnel are afforded a full opportunity is the subject of legal action therefore I cannot to submit representations in relation to any comment further on that case. recommendation that they be discharged or Drug abuse has long been recognised as a retired as a result of a confirmed positive test serious and escalating problem in our society and result. while there have been relatively few instances of drug related problems within the Defence Forces, it is recognised that the Defence Forces, as a com- Decentralisation Programme. ponent of the wider community, mirror the com- 50. Mr. Noonan asked the Minister for Defence munity at large. The implications of drug abuse the position with regard to decentralisation as it in an organisation where personnel have access to impacts on his Department; and if he will make a firearms are too obvious to require elaboration. statement on the matter. [32270/06] A Compulsory Substance Testing Programme was introduced on 1 February 2002, as part of a Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The Defence Forces Substance Abuse Programme, Government decision on decentralisation, following a long consultative process involving announced by the Minister for Finance in his the Office of the Attorney General, the Deputy Budget statement on 3 December 2003, provides Judge Advocate General and the Defence Forces for the transfer of all of my Department’s Dublin Representative Associations. Prior to the launch based civil service staff to Newbridge, Co. of the programme, an education programme and Kildare. The number of staff to be relocated to awareness briefings were conducted throughout Newbridge is 200. A total of 338 personnel, of the Defence Forces. All personnel were issued which 60 are from within the Department, have with a booklet devised to inform them of the pur- opted to move to Newbridge. An additional 29 pose of the new Compulsory Random Drug Test- staff from outside my Department have been ing programme, the administrative procedures assigned to this Department from the Central involved and the potential administrative action Applications Facility for the purpose of relocat- and liability for discharge or retirement for those ing to Newbridge. Twenty-two members of staff 879 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 880

[Mr. O’Dea.] Defence Forces Equipment. who opted not to move to Newbridge have volun- 58. Mr. J. O’Keeffe asked the Minister for teered to transfer to other Government Depart- Defence the average age of both fixed wing air- ments that have units that are proposed for craft and helicopters that make up the Air Corps decentralisation, and some have already moved fleet; and if he will make a statement on the to their new Departments. Of the remaining per- matter. [32271/06] sonnel in my Department who have opted to remain in Dublin, nineteen have been reassigned. Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): There are The Government decision also provides for the a total of 30 aircraft in service with the Air Corps transfer of 300 Defence Forces Headquarters at present, comprising 11 helicopters and 19 fixed staff to the Curragh, Co Kildare. wing aircraft. The type and age of the aircraft is set out in the attached tabular statement, which Defence Forces Property. will be circulated with the Official Report. 51. Mr. G. Mitchell asked the Minister for In addition to the aircraft listed on the sched- Defence his plans to develop the Naval Service ule, four utility AW 139 helicopters are being base at Haulbowline, County Cork; and if he will acquired from Agusta S.p.A. at a cost of \48.4m, make a statement on the matter. [32337/06] inclusive of VAT. The four helicopters are being built at the Agusta facility near Milan, Italy. Two Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): My Depart- AW 139s will be delivered in November 2006 — ment and the Defence Forces are involved in an the first helicopter has been handed over and is ongoing investment programme of refurbishment currently involved in Air Corps pilot training in and new builds to meet Defence Force infrastruc- Italy. The other two AW 139 helicopters will be ture requirements. delivered in 2007. Since January 2000 the following projects have The four AW 139 helicopters will be operated been undertaken in the Naval Base: by the Air Corps in a general purpose military operational and training role. • Refurbishment of Central Supply Unit Building Type and Age of Air Corps Aircraft in Operational Service • New Naval Technical Stores Aircraft Type Number in Age • Renovation of Old Married Quarters Helicopters Service • Upgrade of Accommodation Blocks Alouette 7 32 to 43 years • Refurbishment of the Old Dry Canteen Squirrel* 1 9 years • Cadets Accommodation rewiring & EC 135* 1 4 years heating. EC135 2 under 1 year The following projects are currently underway: Sub-total 11 Aircraft Type Fixed • Refurbishment of Mast House Wing • Refurbishment of Block 6, Office Accom- Cessna 5 34 years modation Beechcraft 1 26 years • Sewage System Upgrade GIV 1 15 years Casa 2 12 years • Reroofing of the Technical Training Bay. Defender* 1 9 years The total cost of the above investment was in Learjet 1 3 years excess of \12 million. This programme of invest- Pilatus 8 2 years ment will continue over the next five years and includes further projects for the Naval Base. Sub-total 19

Question No. 52 answered with Question Total 30 No. 17. * Aircraft owned by the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform but operated by the Air Corps. Question Nos. 53 and 54 answered with Ques- tion No. 34. Question No. 59 answered with Question Question No. 55 answered with Question No. 7. No. 30. Question No. 60 answered with Question Question No. 56 answered with Question No. 34. No. 25. Overseas Missions. Question No. 57 answered with Question 61. Mr. Costello asked the Minister for No. 7. Defence if the investigation into the Niemba 881 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 882 ambush has been completed; when he proposes including my Department. In this regard a to publish the findings; and if he will make a number of meetings have been held between statement on the matter. [32170/06] officials from Department and from the Depart- ment of Foreign Affairs over the last year. These Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): As the meetings have focused on assistance my Deputy is aware I undertook during Priority Department/Defence Forces may be able to Questions on Thursday 23 February 2006 to ask provide in relation to the development of the the military authorities to revisit this matter in RRI with particular reference to the first two pil- light of the questions raised on that date. lars and considerable progress has been made. The Chief of Staff appointed a senior officer to In relation specifically to the second element of examine all aspects of the Niemba ambush in the this initiative — that is, the creation of a register Congo in November 1960. Due to the breadth of of skilled and experienced individuals ready for this investigation, this process has taken some rapid deployment — through working closely time. I understand that in the course of his exam- with my Department and others, the Department ination the officer has interviewed both survivors of Foreign Affairs believes that the initiative will and has also contacted other interested parties enable the release of key skilled people to take both at home and abroad. part in emergency teams deployed to make rapid I have been informed by the Chief of Staff that needs assessments and assist in the coordination the Report is being finalised and I hope to receive of relief. It is hoped that Ireland can help bridge the Final Report by the end of this week. I will some of the gaps in certain key sectors in order to then study the contents of the Report and, in fill particular gaps in capacity in the international particular its Findings and Recommendations, community’s humanitarian response. prior to deciding what action should be taken. Military Archives. Question No. 62 answered with Question No. 14. 64. Mr. Allen asked the Minister for Defence the level of resources available to the military archives; and if he will make a statement on the Overseas Development Aid. matter. [32269/06] 63. Mr. G. Murphy asked the Minister for Defence if he has discussed the formation of a Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The new voluntary corps with the Department of military authorities advise that at present the staff Foreign Affairs; the level of co-operation strength of the Military Archives is three (3), between his Department and the Department of comprising two (2) commissioned officers and Foreign Affairs on this matter; and if he will one (1) Private. The military authorities advise make a statement on the matter. [32262/06] me that a strength of five (5), including suitably qualified replacements for two (2) officers who Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The have retired and who previously also worked in Government’s recently published White Paper on the Archives, is sufficient to meet the current Irish Aid provides for the establishment of a Vol- demands on the Military Archives. I appreciate unteer Corps Unit within the Department of the importance of returning to five (5) full-time Foreign Affairs to harness the strong volunteer equivalent staff in the military archives without spirit, which exists across the country in support delay. of overseas development activities. I am informed The requirement for a more suitable home for by my colleague, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, the Military Archives has been recognised for Deputy Dermot Ahern that his Department is to some time. The primary focus has so far been on open an Irish Aid Volunteering Centre in Dublin the National Museum of Ireland facility at the in early 2007. This centre will provide infor- former Collins Barracks Dublin, long considered mation, support and advice to those wishing to as the most appropriate location for the Military volunteer. Archives. The White Paper on Irish Aid also provides for Facilities are required to protect and safeguard the creation of Ireland’s own specific operational the material currently stored and to provide for capabilities in responding to humanitarian emerg- the deposition of future material, as well as per- encies: the Rapid Response Initiative (RRI). The mitting easy public access. An Inter Departmen- three main components of the initiative are the tal Committee was established in early 2003 with pre-positioning and transportation of material terms of reference to examine and to advise on humanitarian supplies to disaster locations; the the best means of protecting and safeguarding the creation of a register of highly skilled and experi- Military Archives by way of securing their enced individuals for deployment with inter- removal from Cathal Brugha Barracks to new national agencies at short notice; and an overall premises to be developed at the former Collins enhancement of our support to international Barracks Dublin. humanitarian response agencies and mechanisms. The Inter Departmental Committee focussed The Department of Foreign Affairs is working on feasibility studies based on a detailed examin- closely on this initiative with other Departments ation of various locations around and within the 883 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 884

[Mr. O’Dea.] provided to the public. I can confirm to the Collins Barracks site. These studies were carried Deputy that I have received the submission that out up to early 2005 by a firm of architectural he is referring to in the question and I have for- consultants engaged through the Office of Public warded it to the Garda Commissioner for his Works. The consultants identified potential attention. locations within the Collins Barracks site. However, these feasibility studies also raised Garda Investigations. serious issues around the cost, planning and building/architectural protection considerations 69. Mr. Howlin asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- involved in meeting the demands of the Military ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform if he Archives on the Collins Barracks site. The impli- has received a request from a person (details cations of the serious questions raised about the supplied) in County Offaly for the establishment location of the full Military Archives on this site of a tribunal of public inquiry into the death of are being examined in my Department. their son; if he will give consideration to this Particular challenges and difficulties in re-hous- request in view of the many disquieting aspects ing the Military Archives at Collins Barracks of this tragedy; and if he will make a statement would be posed by the provision of extensive on the matter. [32452/06] modern purpose-built facilities within the restric- tions of an historic built environment. Consider- Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and ation of some usage of the Collins Barracks site Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I refer the Deputy has not been exhausted. However, I have asked to my reply to Parliamentary Questions Nos. 217, the Interdepartmental Committee to extend its 229, 234, 237 and 239 of 3 October, 2006. search beyond Collins Barracks and to revert to me with options. I have also requested that any Garda Deployment. scope for locating the Military Archives together 70. Dr. Cowley asked the Ta´naiste and Minister with or alongside the National Archives continue for Justice, Equality and Law Reform his views to be explored in line with that body’s own on the 180 gardaı´ deployed to Rossport, County development plans. Mayo in view of the fact that only five gardaı´ were deployed to the Moyross Estate, Limerick Question No. 65 answered with Question recently when serious crimes were taking place No. 8. on an almost daily basis; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32493/06] Question No. 66 answered with Question No. 18. Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): At the outset, I Question No. 67 answered with Question wish to inform the Deputy that the allocation of No. 16. Garda resources is a matter for the Garda Com- missioner. It is the responsibility of the Divisional Garda Deployment. Officer to allocate personnel within Divisions on 68. Mr. Howlin asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- a priority basis in accordance with the require- ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform if he ments of different areas. These personnel allo- has considered the submission of a forum (details cations are determined by a number of factors supplied) in Dublin 22 in relation to Garda pres- including demographics, crime trends, adminis- ence; his views on the case made for additional trative functions and other operational policing gardaı´ for south west Clondalkin; and if he will needs. Garda management state that such allo- make a statement on the matter. [32451/06] cations are continually monitored and reviewed along with overall policing arrangements and Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and operational strategy. This ensures that optimum Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): As the Deputy will use is made of Garda resources, and that the best be aware, the allocation of Garda resources is a possible service is provided to the public. matter for the Garda Commissioner. It is the I have been informed by the Garda authorities responsibility of the Divisional Officer to allocate that an Operational Order is currently in place to personnel within Divisions on a priority basis in police the situation at the Corrib development accordance with the requirements of different site in Rossport, Co. Mayo. I am further informed areas. These personnel allocations are deter- that the purpose of the Garda action is to enable mined by a number of factors including demo- contractors and their workers to go about their graphics, crime trends, administrative functions lawful business unhindered and to allow people and other operational policing needs. Garda man- to demonstrate peacefully without impinging on agement state that such allocations are continu- the rights of others. A total of 114 Gardaı´ (all ally monitored and reviewed along with overall ranks) were moved on Temporary Transfer to policing arrangements and operational strategy. Belmullet Garda Station on 2 October, 2006, with This ensures that optimum use is made of Garda 45 Gardaı´ (all ranks) returning to their perma- resources, and that the best possible service is nent Stations in the Dublin Metropolitan Region 885 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 886 with effect from 5 October, 2006. Local senior Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Garda management is continuing to monitor the Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): On 9 October situation and personnel requirements in the Ross- 2006, my Department wrote to the applicants port area are reviewed on an on-going basis. legal representatives inviting them to lodge I have also been informed that an additional further representations regarding their appli- 5 Gardaı´ were allocated to the Mayorstone Park cations for leave to remain. Garda Station on permanent transfer as policing I expect the case file in this matter to be sub- requirements in the Moyross area of Limerick mitted to me for decision in due course. This dictated the need for such permanent transfers. decision will be taken having regard to consider- Garda management state that the Moyross area ations specified in section 3(6) of the Immigration of Limerick is regularly patrolled by uniform and Act 1999, as amended. These considerations plain-clothes units, supplemented by the Div- include matters relating to the common good, the isional Units, including the Traffic Corps and person’s family and domestic circumstances, as Mountain Bike Unit as well as District and Div- well as humanitarian considerations. Consider- isional Detective and Drug Units. ation will also be given to the prohibition of refoulement which is contained in section 5 of the Garda management further state that during Refugee Act 1996, as amended. the recent outbreak of serious gun related inci- dents significant additional resources were deployed in the area, including additional armed Youth Services. patrols from within the Division, funded under 72. Mr. M. Higgins asked the Ta´naiste and Operation Anvil and supported by the Emer- Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform gency Response Unit. Personnel from neighbour- further to Parliamentary Question No. 538 of 6 ing Garda Divisions were allocated temporarily, July 2006, if the Garda authorities have now com- to the Limerick Division and an initiative under pleted their consideration of the evaluation Operation ‘Assist’, utilising the Garda Mounted report of the Bris project in Galway; the findings and Dog Units was also put in place in the Div- and recommendations of such a consideration; ision, in conjunction with local policing and the details of such findings. [32500/06] operations. Garda management further state that Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and additional resources have recently been added to Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I am informed by the local Community Policing Unit specifically the Garda authorities that they are completing their consideration of the evaluation report on assigned to the Moyross Estates. I should add the project. The Garda authorities expect to have that the current recruitment drive to increase the completed their consideration of the report and strength of the Garda Sı´ocha´na to 14,000 to make recommendations to me shortly. members, in line with the commitment in the Agreed Programme for Government, is fully on Residency Permits. target. This will lead to a combined strength, of both attested Gardaı´ and recruits in training, of 73. Mr. O’Shea asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- 14,000 by the end of this year. The first three ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform further groups of newly attested Gardaı´ under this accel- to Parliamentary Question No. 372 of 27 erated recruitment programme came on stream in September 2006, when a decision will be reached March, June and September of this year and the regarding the application by a person for resi- fourth such group will become fully attested dency on the basis of family dependency; and if members of the Force later this year. Further he will make a statement on the matter. tranches of approximately 275 newly attested [32515/06] Gardaı´ will follow every 90 days thereafter until the programme is complete. The Garda Com- Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): Further to my missioner will now be drawing up plans on how reply to Question No. 372 of 27 September 2006 best to distribute and manage these additional the documentation requested has recently been resources, and in this context the needs of the received. The application for residency is cur- areas referred to by the Deputy will be given the rently under active consideration and it is fullest consideration. expected that a final decision in the case will issue shortly. Visa Applications. 71. Ms C. Murphy asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- Public Order Offences. ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the 74. Mr. Gregory asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- position regarding an application by a person ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the (details supplied) in County Kildare for leave to number of complaints received in the past there remain in the State; when a decision is expected; weeks regarding anti-social behaviour in an area and if he will make a statement on the matter. (details supplied) in Dublin 9; the number and [32499/06] duration of late night extensions at the licensed 887 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 888

[Mr. Gregory.] Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and premises; if the gardaı´ have contacted the pro- Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): Road traffic legis- prietor regarding the complaints referred to; the lation is a matter for my colleague, the Minister other action which is being taken; and if he will for Transport. The law pertaining to exhaust make a statement on the matter. [32516/06] systems on vehicles is contained in section 29(1) of the Road Traffic (Construction, Equipment Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and and Use of Vehicles) Regulations 1963, as Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I am informed by amended. the Garda authorities that no complaints have I am informed by the Garda authorities that been made during the past three weeks in respect the following table shows the number of pro- of the area mentioned. ceedings commenced and convictions for an I am further informed that during the relevant offence under section 29(1) up to 12 October period there was one incident relating to public 2006. disorder in the vicinity of the premises referred to. Late night exemptions, from 11:30 pm to 2:30 Year Proceedings Convictions am, were granted by the Courts to the licensed commenced premises referred to on every Wednesday, Thurs- day, Friday and Saturday nights during the period 2006* 570 139 in question. 2005 663 299 I am also informed that uniformed and plain- clothes units regularly patrol the area referred to 2004 114 53 and will continue to do so, particularly at closing 2003 66 31 times. Local Garda management will liaise with 2002 66 28 the management of the premises in respect of any *Figures provided are provisional, operational and liable to specific complaints made. change.

Garda Strength. 75. Mr. Quinn asked the Ta´naiste and Minister Residency Permits. for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the pro- 77. Aengus O´ Snodaigh asked the Ta´naiste and jected staffing level of the Garda central vetting Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform unit in Thurles, broken down by number and further to his reply to Parliamentary Question rank or grade; the number of such posts already No. 385 of 5 July 2006, if he has since that date filled, broken down by number and rank or grade; received or is aware of correspondence from a and if he will make a statement on the matter. solicitor in Letterkenny regarding a person [32517/06] (details supplied); if he had received communi- cation from the Garda immigration officer in Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Letterkenny verifying same; and if, in view of this Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The overall sanc- information, he will reconsider the decision to tioned staffing level for the Garda Central Vet- refuse permission to remain. [32519/06] ting Unit and the associated Garda Central Records Office in Thurles is currently 40 posts, comprising 4 Staff Officers, 29 Clerical Officers, Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and 1 Garda Inspector, 3 Garda Sergeants and 3 Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): Further to my Gardaı´. All of these posts, with the exception of reply to Q. No. 385 of 5 July 2006, the docu- the latter three, are currently filled and it is pro- mentation referred to has recently been received. posed to fill the three vacancies shortly. The application for a re-examination of the orig- I am satisfied that these staffing levels are inal decision in this case is currently under con- sufficient to meet current demands on the service. sideration and a decision will issue in due course. However, staffing levels in the Garda Central Vetting Unit will be kept under review in the 78. Mr. Morgan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- light of requirements. ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform when a decision will be made on the application for Road Traffic Offences. permission to remain in the State by a person (details supplied) in County Louth. [32520/06] 76. Mr. Quinn asked the Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the number Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and of cases detected by the gardaı´ of cars with Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The person con- exhaust systems in excess of noise pollution levels cerned, a Nigerian national, arrived in the State in respect of the latest year for which figures are on 14 March 1996 and applied for asylum. On 26 available; the number of such cases where pros- July 2000 he was refused refugee status and did ecutions were initiated; the number of convictions not appeal this decision. He submitted an appli- secured; and if he will make a statement on the cation for residency based on parentage of his matter. [32518/06] Irish born child. This application was refused on 889 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 890

14 December 2005. His case is currently under responsible for the detailed allocation of consideration and a decision is expected shortly. resources, including personnel, that the personnel strength (all ranks) of An Garda Sı´ocha´na increased to a record 12,762 on Friday, 8 Garda Strength. September, 2006, following the attestation of 249 new members. This compares with a total 79. Mr. English asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- strength of 10,702 (all ranks) as at 30 June, 1997 ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the and represents an increase of 2,060 (or 19%) in personnel strength of the Garda stations in the the personnel strength of the Force during that Louth, Meath division for each of the years 2002 period. The Garda Budget now stands at \1.3 to 2006 inclusive, if he will provide the infor- billion, a 13% increase on 2005 and an 85% mation in tabular form; and if he will make a increase since 1997 in real terms. statement on the matter. [32521/06] I have been further informed that the person- nel strength of each Garda Station in the Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Louth/Meath Division as at 31 December, 2002 Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I have been to 2005, inclusively, and as at 11 October, 2006 informed by the Garda authorities, who are was as set out in the table hereunder:

Station 31/12/02 31/12/03 31/12/04 31/12/05 11/10/06

Drogheda 89 90 89 93 89 Castle Bellingham 4 4 4 4 4 Clogher Head 3 2 2 1 2 Dunleer 4 4 4 4 4 Laytown 7 7 8 8 10 Dundalk 96 97 101 101 104 Carlingford 3 3 3 3 3 Hackballscross 14 14 13 12 11 Dromad 13 12 11 9 7 Omeath 14 14 15 10 9 Louth 1 2 1 2 2 Blackrock 4 4 4 5 5 Kells 31 34 31 32 36 Crossakeel 1 — — — — Athboy 6 6 6 6 6 Oldcastle 4 4 4 3 4 Nobber 3 3 3 3 3 Trim 24 25 25 23 25 Kilmessan 1 — — — — Summerhill 2 2 2 2 2 Longwood — — — 1 1 Enfield 16 17 16 13 13 Ballivor 2 2 3 2 2 Ashbourne 37 37 40 37 48 Dunboyne 15 13 12 14 14 Dunshaughlin 11 11 10 9 2 Kilcock 6 5 4 5 5 Balbriggan 35 32 34 32 33 Skerries 10 10 11 10 11 Lusk 4 4 4 4 4 Rush 4 5 5 6 7 Garristown 3 3 3 3 3 Navan 47 49 46 45 48 Ardee 9 10 10 10 10 Collon 2 2 2 2 2 Duleek 3 4 4 3 3 Slane 4 4 4 4 3 891 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 892

[Mr. McDowell.] Road Traffic Offences. In addition, I would point out to the Deputy that 81. Ms Shortall asked the Ta´naiste and Minister the Garda resources for the Louth/Meath Div- for Justice, Equality and Law Reform if he will ision are further augmented by a number of report on the enforcement rate in respect of the Garda National Units such as the Garda National new mandatory alcohol testing for each of the Drugs Unit, the Garda National Immigration months August and September 2006 under head- Bureau (GNIB), the Criminal Assets Bureau ings (details supplied). [32524/06] (CAB) and other specialised units. It is the responsibility of Garda management to Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and allocate personnel to and within Divisions on a Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I regret that the priority basis in accordance with the require- information sought by the Deputy is not readily ments of different areas. These personnel allo- available and is currently being researched. I will cations are determined by a number of factors contact the Deputy again when the information including demographics, crime trends, adminis- is to hand. trative functions and other operational policing needs. Garda management state that such allo- Visa Applications. cations are continually monitored and reviewed along with overall policing arrangements and 82. Mr. Kehoe asked the Ta´naiste and Minister operational strategy. This ensures that optimum for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the status use is made of Garda resources, and that the best of the visa application for a person (details possible service is provided to the public. supplied) in County Wexford; and if he will make I should add that the current recruitment drive a statement on the matter. [32531/06] to increase the strength of the Garda Sı´ocha´na to 14,000 members, in line with the commitment in Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and the Agreed Programme for Government, is fully Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The visa appli- on target. This will lead to a combined strength, cation referred to by the Deputy was received in of both attested Gardaı´ and recruits in training, the Visa Office on 28 August, 2006. I am pleased of 14,000 by the end of this year. The first three to inform the Deputy that the application in ques- groups of newly attested Gardaı´ under this accel- tion was approved on 10 October, 2006. erated recruitment programme came on stream in March, June and September of this year and the Registration of Title. fourth such group will become fully attested 83. Mr. J. O’Keeffe asked the Ta´naiste and members of the Force later this year. Further Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform if tranches of approximately 275 newly attested he is satisfied that adequate staff and resources Gardaı´ will follow every 90 days thereafter until have been provided to the Land Registry Office; the programme is complete. The Garda Com- if his attention has been drawn to the delays in missioner will now be drawing up plans on how relation to the registration of transfers of parts of best to distribute and manage these additional folios and section 49 application for first regis- resources, and in this context the needs of the tration; the position in relation to same; and if he Louth/ Meath Division will be given the fullest will confirm that the necessary resources will be consideration. provided to ensure that such delays will be elim- inated. [32556/06] Garda Investigations. Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and 80. Mr. Gregory asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I am pleased to be ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform if the able to inform the Deputy that the Land Registry references to paramilitary involvement in major has responded successfully to the continued drug dealing (details supplied) are correct and growth in applications arising from a very active accurate; and if he will make a statement on the property market. Staffing levels are kept under matter. [32523/06] ongoing review, having regard to overall Govern- ment policy on public service numbers, but sig- Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and nificant productivity improvements have also Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I am informed by been realised, reflecting the Registry’s business the Garda authorities that there is no evidence at modernisation programme as well as considerable this stage to suggest any paramilitary involvement investment by the Government in the provision associated with the alleged drugs trafficking in of new technology for this service. In the case of question. the vast majority of services provided by the Land The Garda investigation into the incident is Registry, no delays are encountered. Looking to ongoing, and it would not be appropriate for me the future, a major programme of further invest- to make further comment on the matter, includ- ment is underway which will replace existing ing in relation to the personal histories of those paper based maps with a digital mapping system allegedly involved. and which will further enhance the organisation’s 893 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 894 capacity to respond to the considerable demands of burglaries recorded and detected in each of the being made on it. Garda divisions covering Ballymun, Finglas, San- In so far as applications for first registration try and Whitehall Garda stations in each of the based upon adverse possession and applications past three years for which figures are available; under Section 49 are concerned, it should be and if he will make a statement on the matter. noted that these are governed by a detailed and [32582/06] often complex area of land law and the circum- stances of each case dictate the nature and the Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and processing time of each individual application. Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The figures for Such applications may, of necessity, take a long burglaries recorded and detected for each Garda time to process. division are available in the relevant Garda As the Deputy may also be aware, I have Annual Reports, copies of which are available in recently signed an order establishing the Property the Oireachtas Library. Registration Authority which will come into I was pleased to note that the Garda annual effect from 4 November. The main functions of report for 2005 shows that the total number of the new Authority will be to manage and control burglaries recorded in the Dublin Metropolitan the Registry of Deeds and the Land Registry and Region has decreased from 10.3 per 1,000 of to promote and extend the registration of owner- population in 2003 to 9.2 per 1,000 of population ship of land. The new Authority will build on the in 2005. The number of burglaries recorded in the modernisation programme already underway Dublin Metropolitan Region Northern Division, within the Land Registry, with a view to the which includes the Ballymun, Santry and further development of an efficient and high Whitehall areas, fell from 7.1 per 1,000 of popu- quality service for its customers. lation in 2003 to 5.4 per 1,000 of population in 2005. The number of burglaries recorded in the Residency Permits. Dublin Metropolitan Region Western Division, 84. Mr. Durkan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- which includes the Finglas area, fell from 9 per ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the 1,000 of population in 2003 to 5.8 per 1,000 of residency status in the case of a person (details population in 2005. supplied) in County Kildare; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32580/06] Citizenship Applications. 87. Mr. Durkan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The person in position in relation to the naturalisation appli- question is a minor child whose mother has per- cation in the case of person (details supplied) in mission to remain in the State under the revised County Dublin; and if he will make a statement arrangements for parents of Irish children born on the matter. [32583/06] prior to 1 January 2005, commonly referred to as the IBC 05 scheme. Minor children under the age Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and of sixteen in the care of non EU national parents Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): Applications for granted under the IBC/05 scheme avail of the certificates of naturalisation from the persons permission to remain in the State granted to their referred to in the Deputy’s question were parents. When such a minor child attains 16 years of age he or she is obliged to register with the received in the Citizenship Section of my Depart- Garda National Immigration Bureau in their ment on 11 January 2006 and 6 September 2006 own right. respectively. The application for the second named person under the reference quoted by the Deputy was refused on 28 January 2005. A letter 85. Mr. Durkan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- issued to the applicant advising her of this on 1 ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the February 2005. The reference for the new appli- position in regard to the application to remain in cation received from this person is 68/4724/06. A the State in the case of a person (details supplied) letter issued to notify her of this on 15 in County Kildare; and if he will make a state- ment on the matter. [32581/06] September 2006. The average processing time for applications Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and for naturalisation for adults is approximately 24 Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I refer the Deputy months at the present time. However, I under- to Parliamentary Question No. 79 of Thursday, stand that the persons involved are refugees. In 15 June 2006 (ref: 23283/06) and the written reply accordance with the Government’s obligations to that Question. The position is unchanged. under the United Nations Convention relating to the Status of Refugees of 28 July 1951, every effort is made to ensure that applications from Crime Levels. persons with refugee status are dealt with as 86. Ms Shortall asked the Ta´naiste and Minister quickly as possible, having regard to the volume for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the number of applications on hand. 895 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 896

[Mr. McDowell.] refugee status on the 13th February 2002. The I will inform the Deputy and the person con- refugee made an application for Family Reunifi- cerned when I have reached a decision on their cation on behalf of his partner and 2 children. applications. These applications were refused in January 2005. This application is currently being reviewed fol- Residency Permits. lowing the receipt of further documentation and a decision will issue in due course. 88. Mr. Durkan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the Garda Stations. residency status in the case of a person (details supplied) in County Kildare; if he has or will 91. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for Fin- review a previous decision in this case; and if he ance his plans to provide a new Garda station in will make a statement on the matter. [32584/06] Greystones, County Wicklow; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32446/06] Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): I refer the Deputy Minister of State at the Department of Finance to my Reply to his Da´il Question No. 469 of 31 (Mr. Parlon): The Commissioners of Public January 2006, Da´il Question No. 429 of 20 June Works will acquire a site for a new Garda station 2006 and Da´il Question No. 312 of 27 September in Greystones, County Wicklow in accordance 2006. The position in the State of the person con- with the priority allocated by the Department of cerned remains as set out in those replies. Justice, Equality and Law Reform and the Garda authorities. 89. Mr. Durkan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform if he Decentralisation Programme. will extend the residency in the case of a person 92. Mr. O´ Fearghaıl asked the Minister for Fin- (details supplied) in Dublin 8; and if he will make ´ ance further to the publication of the most recent a statement on the matter. [32585/06] report of the decentralisation implementation group; the position with regard to the proposal to Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The person con- locate Revenue Commissioners information tech- cerned arrived in the State on 25 July, 2003 and nology staff to Kildare town; the number of staff applied for asylum. His application was refused volunteering to move to Kildare town; if a site following consideration of his case by the Office has been acquired for the proposed development; of the Refugee Applications Commissioner and, if the site identified in the Kildare town local area on appeal, by the Refugee Appeals Tribunal. plan at Magee Barracks is considered suitable; and if he will make a statement on the matter. Subsequently, in accordance with Section 3 of [32463/06] the Immigration Act, 1999, as amended, he was informed by letter dated 3 February, 2005, that Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): Iam the Minister proposed to make a deportation advised by the Revenue Commissioners that as order in respect of him. He was given the options, part of the Government’s decision on decentralis- to be exercised within 15 working days, of making ation, 380 Revenue posts are due to move to representations to the Minister setting out the Kildare town. One hundred and twenty first pref- reasons why he should be allowed to remain tem- erence applications were received through the porarily in the State; leaving the State before an central applications facility for Kildare. Of these, order is made; or consenting to the making of a 82 staff are from within Revenue and 38 staff deportation order. Representations have been from outside Revenue. received on behalf of the person concerned. I am also informed that the Office of Public This person’s case file, including all represen- Works (OPW) are having discussions on a tations submitted, will be considered under number of potential sites in Kildare town, includ- Section 3(6) of the Immigration Act, 1999, as ing a site at Magee Barracks. When these dis- amended, and Section 5 of the Refugee Act, 1996 cussions are completed, the OPW, in consultation (Prohibition of Refoulement). I expect the file to with the Revenue Commissioners, will decide on be passed to me for decision in due course. the best location. 90. Mr. Durkan asked the Ta´naiste and Mini- Budget Submissions. ster for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the position in regard to residency in the case of a 93. Dr. Cowley asked the Minister for Finance person (details supplied) in County Kildare; and if he will give consideration in budget 2007 to a if he will make a statement on the matter. group (details supplied); and if he will make a [32586/06] statement on the matter. [32489/06]

Ta´naiste and Minister for Justice, Equality and Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): I have Law Reform (Mr. McDowell): The person received a number of submissions on behalf of referred to in the Deputy’s question was granted the group and will keep the Deputy’s represen- 897 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 898 tations in mind in the context of the forth- from penalties is included in these figures and coming budget. cannot be separately identified. The net receipt of stamp duties in 1997 was Tax Code. \538.8 million, which includes penalties amount- ing to approximately \1.7 million. 94. Dr. Cowley asked the Minister for Finance the reason a person in receipt of invalidity pen- Tax Code. sion, REPS and single farm payment has to have their social welfare invalidity pension payment 96. Mr. Broughan asked the Minister for Fin- assessed as income; the income thresholds for ance the level of rules applying to stamp duty for such a person; and if he will make a statement on new and second time buyers and investors; and if the matter. [32497/06] he will make a statement on the matter. [32528/06] Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): Iam informed by the Revenue Commissioners that as Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): I take it that a general principle of taxation, as far as possible, the Deputy is asking the rates of stamp duty on income from all sources should be subject to tax- residential property for first-time owner-occupy- ation. In line with this principle, social welfare ing buyers, non first-time owner-occupying buy- pensions, the single farm payment and, in certain ers and other buyers. circumstances, REPS are reckonable as income for income tax purposes. Treating these payments New Houses — Owner-occupiers as income for income tax purposes is essentially In the case of new houses with a floor area not a matter of equity. exceeding 125m2, there is no stamp duty payable. Social welfare pensions are taxable under Where the house exceeds 125m2, stamp duty is section 19 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 payable on the greater of the site value or 25% which provides that tax under Schedule E shall of the property value. The rates of duty are those be charged in respect of “every public office or applying to non first-time owner-occupiers of employment of profit, and in respect of every second-hand houses, listed below. annuity, pension or stipend payable out of the public revenue of the State”. Social welfare pen- New Houses — Non Owner-occupiers sions liable to income tax include retirement, old The rates of duty are those applying to non age, widowed, invalidity and blind person’s first-time owner-occupiers of second-hand pensions. houses, listed below. The extent, if any, to which taxation actually arises in a given case essentially depends on the Second-hand Houses — First-time Owner- level of income that a recipient has in an income occupiers tax year. If there is no other income besides a The rates of stamp duty payable are: social welfare pension, the basic personal credits in force can be expected in most cases to ensure % that there is no tax to be paid on the social wel- \ fare income itself. However in cases where an Up to 317,500 Nil invalidity pension recipient has other taxable \317,501 — \381,000 3 income such as single farm payment and REPS, \381,001 — \635,000 6 a tax liability may arise. The level of the tax liab- Over \635,000 9 ility will depend on the person’s aggregate tax- able income as is the position for other tax Second-hand Houses — Non First-time payers. Owner-occupiers The rates of stamp duty payable are: Tax Yield. 95. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for Finance % the amount of gift tax which was taken in during Up to \127,000 Nil the years 1993 and 1994; the breakdown of the \127,001 — \190,500 3 figures; the amount of stamp duty which was \ \ taken in by his Department in 1997; the penalties 190,501 — 254,000 4 which were imposed for failure to pay gift tax in \254,001 — \317,500 5 the years 1993 and 1994 or failure to pay stamp \317,501 — \381,000 6 \ \ 1 duty in 1997; and the breakdown of the fig- 381,000 — 635,000 72 ures. [32511/06] Over \635,000 9

Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): Iam informed by the Revenue Commissioners that the 97. Mr. Broughan asked the Minister for Fin- net receipt of gift tax in 1993 and 1994 was \2.5 ance if he will work with the Revenue Commis- million and \4.2 million, respectively. The yield sioners to introduce a more simplified statement 899 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 900

[Mr. Broughan.] this matter investigated and to have a reply issued on tax returns for PAYE sector for the next tax directly to the Deputy. year in view of the fact that the current tax returns form is 18 pages long; and if he will make 100. Mr. Gormley asked the Minister for a statement on the matter. [32529/06] Health and Children when the request for a treat- ment centre and after care service for the greater Minister for Finance (Mr. Cowen): Iam Drogheda area made by the Drogheda Com- informed by the Revenue Commissioners that the munity Drugs and Alcohol Forum will be content of Form 12, the Tax Return Form for the granted; her views on whether a treatment centre PAYE sector, is examined each year to ensure such as the one requested is vital and essential, in that only matters relevant to the proper admini- view of the alarming increase in drug and alcohol stration of PAYE are included in it. abuse in the community in general and the The Form 12 seeks details of income and capi- increase in population in the greater Drogheda tal gains, but it also provides the taxpayer with area; and if she will make a statement on the full details of the Tax Credits, Allowances and matter. [32449/06] Reliefs to which they may be entitled. The cur- rent Form 12 (Return for the year 2005) contains Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): 16 pages, the majority of which are devoted to The question relates to the management and providing the taxpayer with the opportunity to delivery of health and personal social services, claim entitlements to relief from tax. which are the responsibility of the Health Service The vast majority of PAYE taxpayers are not Executive under the Health Act 2004. Accord- required to complete a Form 12 as they can ingly, my Department has requested the request a review of their liability by phone, in parliamentary affairs division of the executive to writing, by calling to a Revenue public office, or arrange to have this matter investigated and to by using the new On-Line self-service facility for have a reply issued directly to the Deputy. PAYE taxpayers. Issue of the form is, in general, restricted to people who request it to declare non- Health Payment Scheme. PAYE income or to claim specific non-standard reliefs and to people on higher incomes whose tax 101. Mr. Neville asked the Minister for Health affairs tend to be more complex than the average and Children the position regarding an appli- PAYE person’s. cation for refund of moneys due under the national repayment scheme for a person (details supplied) in County Limerick. [32450/06] State Property. 98. Ms Shortall asked the Minister for Finance Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): the intention in relation to the future use of a site As the Health Service Executive has responsi- (details supplied) in Dublin 9; and if putting the bility for administering the health repayment building to community use is one of the options scheme, enquiries relating to the scheme are being explored. [32555/06] referred to the parliamentary affairs division of the executive. My Department has asked the Minister of State at the Department of Finance HSE to have this matter investigated and to have (Mr. Parlon): The transfer of the former Central a reply issued to the Deputy. Fisheries Board site, Glasnevin, Dublin 9 to the Commissioners of Public Works is being dealt Health Services. with on behalf of the commissioners by the Chief State Solicitor’s Office. No decision in relation to 102. Mr. F. McGrath asked the Minister for the future use or disposal of the building has Health and Children if assistance will be given to been taken. a person (details supplied) in Dublin 11. [32477/06]

Health Services. Minister of State at the Department of Health 99. Mr. Ring asked the Minister for Health and and Children (Mr. T. O’Malley): The Deputy’s Children when a person (details supplied) in question relates to the management and delivery County Mayo will be called for an appointment of health and personal social services, which are with an occupational therapist. [32448/06] the responsibility of the Health Service Executive under the Health Act 2004. Accordingly, my Minister of State at the Department of Health Department has requested the parliamentary and Children (Mr. T. O’Malley): The Deputy’s affairs division of the executive to arrange to have question relates to the management and delivery this matter investigated and to have a reply issued of health and personal social services, which are directly to the Deputy. the responsibility of the Health Service Executive under the Health Act 2004. Accordingly, my 103. Dr. Cowley asked the Minister for Health Department has requested the parliamentary and Children when evening dialysis will be avail- affairs division of the executive to arrange to have able to dialysis patients in County Mayo; and if 901 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 902 she will make a statement on the matter. and if she will make a statement on the [32484/06] matter. [32512/06]

Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): Health funding for 2006 included additional fund- The Deputy’s question relates to the manage- ing of \8 million for the further development of ment and delivery of health and personal social renal dialysis services. This funding was provided services, which are the responsibility of the to allow the Health Service Executive to increase Health Service Executive under the Health Act the number of dialysis places throughout the 2004. Accordingly, my Department has requested country. the parliamentary affairs division of the executive The allocation of resources and the provision to arrange to have this matter investigated and to of additional dialysis places is a matter for the have a reply issued directly to the Deputy. Executive. Accordingly my Department has requested the parliamentary affairs division of Health Service Staff. the executive to arrange to have a reply issued 107. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for directly to the Deputy in relation to the provision Health and Children if an application has been of evening dialysis in County Mayo. received by the Health Service Executive or Comhairle for the appointment of a consultant Health Service Staff. neurologist for the HSE mid-west region; if so, 104. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for when a decision is expected to be made; when the Health and Children the number of occupational post will be advertised; and if she will make a therapists working for the Health Service Execu- statement on the matter. [32513/06] tive mid-west region; if there are unfilled posts; if she will ensure that additional occupational Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): therapists are provided for the mid-west to Health funding for 2006 included additional fund- address the long waiting times encountered by ing of \3 million for the further development of people with disabilities who need to be assessed neurology and neurophysiology services. This for the provision of aids and appliances essential funding was provided to allow the Health Service to them; and if she will make a statement on the Executive to progress further the implementation matter. [32491/06] of the recommendations made by Comhairle na nOspide´al in respect of these services. Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): The allocation of resources and employment of As this question relates to human resource man- consultant neurologists is a matter for the execu- agement issues and to the management and deliv- tive. Accordingly my Department has requested ery of health and personal social services, which the parliamentary affairs division of the executive are the responsibility of the Health Service to arrange to have a reply issued directly to the Executive under the Health Act 2004, my Depart- Deputy. ment has requested the parliamentary affairs div- ision of the executive to arrange to have this Services for People with Disabilities. matter investigated and to have a reply issued 108. Mr. G. Mitchell asked the Minister for directly to the Deputy. Health and Children the level of diagnosed autism on a county basis; if evidence exists that Health Services. there has been, or will be, a rise in autism in those 105. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for counties where MMR vaccination is above the Health and Children the position in relation to national average; and if she will make a statement dental treatment for a person (details supplied) on the matter. [32514/06] in County Wicklow; and if she will make a state- ment on the matter. [32492/06] Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children (Mr. T. O’Malley): There are no Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): statistics available in Ireland either on a national The Deputy’s question relates to the manage- or county basis on the level of diagnosed autism. ment and delivery of health and personal social The health services has, at regional level, in services, which are the responsibility of the recent years been expanding the level of infor- Health Service Executive under the Health Act mation available to it on the numbers and needs 2004. Accordingly, my Department has requested of persons with autism in its regions. the parliamentary affairs division of the executive While some persons with autism, who also have to arrange to have this matter investigated and to an intellectual disability, are included on the have a reply issued directly to the Deputy. National Intellectual Disability Database, it does not contain information on this group as a whole. 106. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for In addition while the database provides infor- Health and Children the progress which has been mation in relation to the level of services being made on the opening of the remaining three units provided and current and future needs, it does in a centre (details supplied) in County Limerick; not identify persons with specific disabilities such 903 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 904

[Mr. T. O’Malley.] Housing Aid for the Elderly. as autism or Down’s syndrome. Its principal role 111. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for Health is as a planning and monitoring instrument. and Children the position in respect of house This issue is now being examined in the context repairs in the case of a person (details supplied) of the overall information requirements set out in in County Kildare; and if she will make a state- Section 13 of Part 2 of the Disability Act 2005 ment on the matter. [32578/06] which imposes significant requirements on the HSE to keep and maintain detailed records in Minister of State at the Department of Health relation to the Act. Over the next twelve months and Children (Mr. S. Power): The Deputy’s ques- as outlined in the Department’s Sectoral Plan, tion relates to the management and delivery of published in July 2006, the HSE will be reviewing health and personal social services, which are the the existing information management systems responsibility of the Health Service Executive within the disability and mental health services, under the Health Act 2004. This includes to identify what additional resources and infra- responsibility for the provision of the housing aid structure would be required to meet the obli- scheme for the elderly, on behalf of the Depart- gations under Section 13 of Part 2 of the Dis- ment of the Environment, Heritage and Local ability Act 2005. It is intended that the Health Government. Accordingly, the Department has Information and Quality Authority (HIQA), on requested the parliamentary affairs division of establishment, will be requested to set standards the executive to arrange to have this matter inves- in relation to the information and data require- tigated and to have a reply issued directly to the ments under the Disability Act. Deputy. It would be difficult to attempt to correlate the incidence of autism with local variations in the Telecommunications Services. uptake of MMR. It is now widely accepted within scientific circles that there is no connection 112. Mr. O´ Fearghaı´l asked the Minister for between autism and the MMR vaccine. Communications, Marine and Natural Resources when Athy, County Kildare will be included in Health Services. the metropolitan area network broadband prog- ramme; and if he will make a statement on the 109. Mr. Perry asked the Minister for Health matter. [32460/06] and Children if she will ensure that the extra ten hours home help are sanctioned for a person Minister for Communications, Marine and (details supplied) in County Sligo; and if she will Natural Resources (Mr. N. Dempsey): The pro- make a statement on the matter. [32550/06] vision of telecommunications services, including broadband, is a matter in the first instance for Minister of State at the Department of Health the private sector companies operating in a fully and Children (Mr. S. Power): The Deputy’s ques- liberalised market, regulated by the Commission tion relates to the management and delivery of for Communications Regulation (ComReg), the health and personal social services, which are the independent regulator. responsibility of the Health Service Executive However, it has been clear for some time that under the Health Act 2004. Accordingly, the the sector has failed to invest at the level neces- Department has requested the parliamentary sary to keep pace with the demand for broad- affairs division of the executive to arrange to have band. My Department’s regional broadband this matter investigated and to have a reply issued programme is addressing the infrastructure deficit directly to the Deputy. by building high-speed open access broadband networks, in association with the local and 110. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for Health regional authorities, in the major towns and cities. and Children when a person (details supplied) in These Metropolitan Area Networks (MANs) will County Kildare can expect treatment in respect allow the private sector to offer world-class of a prolapsed womb; if they require surgery, if broadband services at competitive costs. The net- they will be given an indication as to when their works offer towns opportunities to attract inward treatment will be completed; and if she will make investment in advanced technology and know- a statement on the matter. [32577/06] ledge based enterprises. Twenty-seven MANs have been completed Minister for Health and Children (Ms Harney): under Phase One and are currently being man- The Deputy’s question relates to the manage- aged by ENet, the Management Services Entity. ment and delivery of health and personal social In planning the second phase of the MANs prog- services, which are the responsibility of the ramme, a review of the availability of broadband Health Service Executive under the Health Act in the regions identified a number of towns with 2004. Accordingly, my Department has requested populations greater than 1,500 that were not the parliamentary affairs division of the executive being offered a broadband option by the private to arrange to have this matter investigated and to sector. Phase Two of the MANs Programme have a reply issued directly to the Deputy. includes the towns of Clane, Kilcock, Kildare, 905 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 906

Maynooth, Monasterevin, Newbridge, Rathan- stands at 381, which equates to 28% of the total gan, and Sallins in County Kildare. number of post offices in the nationwide network. A number of regional towns, including Athy, The number of post office closures that have already had DSL broadband on offer from the occurred since January 2002 throughout the net- service providers, so priority was given to the pro- work is detailed on the table. vision of essential broadband infrastructure in those towns where none existed. Athy is not part County Number of post of the current rollout but may be included in office closures further phases subject to the necessary approvals and Exchequer funding being made available. Carlow 1 Kildare County Council has submitted a case for Cavan 7 a MAN to be built in Athy and this is being kept Clare 4 under review. Cork 12 Donegal 3 Departmental Reports. Dublin 7 113. Mr. O’Shea asked the Minister for Galway 9 Communications, Marine and Natural Resources Kerry 3 if he has received the report of the Independent Salmon Group; if he intends to publish the report; Kildare 2 when he expects to announce decisions based on Kilkenny 5 the recommendations contained in the report; Laois 3 and if he will make a statement on the matter. Leitrim 2 [32469/06] Limerick 9 Longford 3 Minister of State at the Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources Louth 6 (Mr. Browne): The independent group has not as Mayo 12 yet submitted its final report, but I expect that it Meath 5 will be delivered shortly. Until such time as the Monaghan 7 report is presented to Government, I am not in Offaly 4 a position to comment on its recommendations Roscommon 8 or implementation. Sligo 4 Post Office Network. Tipperary 12 Wateford 2 114. Mr. Broughan asked the Minister for Westmeath 6 Communications, Marine and Natural Resources the number of post offices that have been closed Wexford 9 down since January 2006; the number of post Wicklow 3 offices that have been converted to sub-post offices in the same time-frame; the post office closures since January 2002 on a county basis; the Telecommunications Services. number of post offices that existed in January 2002 and are currently in existence in October 115. Mr. Broughan asked the Minister for 2006; the number of post offices out of the total Communications, Marine and Natural Resources network that are not automated; the percentage the number of schools here which do not have of the network this represents; and if he will make broadband Internet services; the number of a statement on the matter. [32525/06] primary and post-primary schools which do not have broadband; the percentage of primary and Minister for Communications, Marine and post-primary schools with broadband internet Natural Resources (Mr. N. Dempsey): The services on a county basis; the breakdown of the matter of post office closures and conversions is, provision of broadband for schools in Dublin, in the first instance, a matter for the board and Meath, Tipperary and Cork; and if he will make management of An Post. a statement on the matter. [32526/06] I have been informed by the company that a total of sixteen post offices have been closed since Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources (Mr. N. Dempsey): A joint January 2006 while the number converted to sub- \ post offices since that time is two. I understand industry/Government fund of 18 million was that the number of post offices that existed in established for the Broadband for Schools Prog- January 2002 and that are still in existence now, ramme to resource the provision of high speed totals 1,378. In relation to the automation of post broadband connectivity to all primary and post primary schools in the country by end Autumn offices, I am informed that the number of non- 2006, at no cost to the schools themselves. The automated post offices in the post office network initiative was established to address the resourc- 907 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 908

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] I should also mention that a further 72 schools ing of broadband access to schools in the shared have had broadband access provided under the belief that accelerated provision of broadband Hermes and Advanced Deployment programme access to schools is a prerequisite to the establish- and therefore have active broadband connections ment of a knowledge based economy and that currently independent of the above mentioned such a development is socially, economically and National Broadband Network. commercially desirable. To date 95% of all primary and secondary The percentage of primary and post-primary schools have broadband installed; the aim is to schools with broadband connectivity by county complete the outstanding schools in the coming and the breakdown of the provision of broadband weeks. Since 2 October, the total number of for schools in Dublin, Meath, Tipperary and Cork schools is 3,936, there are 3,759 schools that have are appended for the Deputy’s information. had their local connectivity installed and of these 3,751 have had their router capability installed This is a crucial strand in the strategy of inte- and tested. The number of schools that had con- grating ICT into teaching and learning and the firmed their Acceptable Use Policy status and Department of Communications, Marine and selected their content filtering option was 3,503. Natural Resources’ wider vision of promoting the Consequently, 177 of the schools have not had use of broadband technologies in local communi- local connectivity installed as yet. ties around the country. 909 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 910 Schools Installed Installed Activated Cloyne, Co. Cork Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 Provision of Broadband in Schools for Cork, Dublin, Meath and Tipperary eBNS, Children 00512D01132V Midleton Convent N01197D S, S N Baile01272O Guairne, Strawberry Hill B01687U N S, S N Chuan01692N Doir, Dromleigh N S,01867W Firmount Mixed N01874T S, Castlelyons B N02114B S, St. Martins Midleton,02278I Senior Co. N.S., Cork S N02452V Baile Ui Ghiblin, Millstreet Cloyne,02707F Convent Co. Sundays N Cork Well, S, Cork Cloyn 02803B Sundays Well03704E G N Chuan S, Doir, Banteer Co. N Cork03993O S, Donoughmore, Macroom, Co. S Co. Cork N Cork04054T Sean Baile Mor, S N Fermoy, Kilworth, Breac04118T Co. Co. Maigh, Cork Cork Ballindangan Mixed04152T N S, Mitchelstown, Co. Leamlara Cork Mixed Millstreet,04186N N Co. S, Cork BT S Ireland N04230N Cnoc An Bhile, S N Bhiorainn,04268P Scoil Cork, Naomh Co. Digiweb Eoin,04442F Cork Digiweb Clochar Na04572S Toirbhirte, ADSL Digiweb Kyle Mallow, Smart N Co.04578H S, Cork Banteer, Co. Mitchelstown, Cork Co. St. Cork Josephs04953H N.S., Castlelyons, Digiweb Co. Cork Ballyvongane Mixed N Wireless05257P S, Satellite Leamlara, Co. Ballyhass Cork Digiweb Mixed N Smart05477G S, Smart Presentation Satellite Convent, Upton,05508O Co. 1 Cork Satellite Laragh Smart N S, Satellite St.05565D Berrings, Columbas Ballincurrig, Co. Doneraile, N.S Leamlara, Cork Co. with Co. Cork Facility Cork 1 for Deaf05636A 1 Satellite Trafrask Mixed N05656G Satellite 1 S, Satellite 1 Dunmanway Aghina, Model Irish Co. N Broadband05940D Cork S, 1 S Digiweb Satellite Dughlas, N Kinsale, Corcaigh An06295F Co. 1 Ghoilin, Cork Digiweb 1 Youghal, Scoil Co. Smart 1 Cecilstown, Ursula, Digiweb Cork Mallow, Co. Wireless Cork Bandon, Co. Cork 1 Freemount Mixed N 1 1 S, Digiweb 1 1 Smart 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Satellite Digiweb 1 Bandon, Satellite Co. Cork 1 Satellite 1 Dunmanway, Bantry, Co. Co. Smart Cork Cork Smart 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Satellite 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Sciobairin, Co. 1 Satellite 1 Cork Digiweb Rathluirc, 1 Co. 1 1 Cork Digiweb 1 BT Blackrock, 1 Ireland Co. 1 1 Digiweb Cork Satellite Satellite 1 1 BT Ireland 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 ADSL Wireless 1 1 BT Satellite 1 Ireland Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity Cork 00467B Ballinspittle N S, Kinsale, Co. Cork Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 911 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 912

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated athluirc, Co. Cork Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 Shortcastle, Mallow, Co. Cork Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 aBNS, R o1NS, 06342L06824G Vicarstown Mixed07006A N S, S N Cuil07101R Aodha, Ballyclough Mixed N07242M S, Inchiclough N S,07651G Cloghroe Mixed N08393P S, Convent of Mercy,08430S S N08828B Rath Dubh, Scoil Naomh Vicarstown,08972I Seosamh, Co. Cork Kilcorney Mixed09161W N S, Mallow, Castlealack Co.09385V N Cork S, Cuil Convent Aodha, of Maigh Mercy, Chromtha,09537S Co. Chorcai Rathduane N S,09815U Blarney, Bantry, Co. Co. Cork Cork Ballinadee N09872J S, Tullaslease Mixed Clonakilty, N Co.10047I S, Cork Cloghoola Skibbereen, Mixed10243I Digiweb Co. N Cork S, Grenagh, Macroom Co.10499U Convent Cork N Rathcoole, S, Mallow, Co. Cork S10523O N Achadh Digiweb Eochaille, Kilgariffe N S,10548H Fermoy Chaislean Bantry, Adair Na Co. N Leacht,10724B Cork S, Bandon, Satellite Co. Cork St. Brendans Digiweb National10739O School, Rathmore, South Mallow, Abbey Co. Rathluirc,10771K NS, Cork Co. Cork Satellite Ballincarriga Bandon, Mxd Co. N11236Q Cork S, Millstreet, Smart Co. Cobh Digiweb Cork N S, Macroom,11245R Co. BT Cork Ireland 1 Newmarket B Digiweb Digiweb N11249C Satellite S, Smart Enniskean, Co. Cork SN Cill Mhic11262R Abhaidh, Bantry, Co. Smart Cork Burnfort 1 N11337W S, Druimne Satellite N Clonakilty, Fermoy, ADSL S, Co.11496T Co. Satellite Cork 1 Cork Kilmagner N S, Satellite Satellite11931L Digiweb 1 Seandrom ADSL Ballinacarriga11992I Smart Mxd, Youghal, Dunmanway, Co. 1 Co. Cork Cork S N12004A Ioseph, Satellite Digiweb Whitegate12012W Mixed N 1 1 S, 1 Mallow 1 N Smart Newmarket, Leap, Digiweb12015F 1 Co. Co. Satellite Cork Cork 1 1 St. Smart Lukes Bellevue, N Cobh,12041G S Co. Douglas, Digiweb Cork 1 Digiweb 1 ADSL Liscarrol N12147W S, St. 1 Satellite John 1 The12169J Mallow, 1 Baptist Co. 1 N 1 Cork S, S Smart N An Rathluirc, Aird, 1 1 Satellite 1 Co. Smart Cork Satellite Fermoy, 1 Co. Templebrady Cork Smart N S, 1 ADSL Satellite 1 Satellite 1 Midleton, 1 Co. Cork 1 Smart 1 1 1 Drinagh, Dunmanway, Co. Cork, 1 1 Cork Co. 1 1 ADSL Cork 1 1 ADSL Smart Smart 1 ADSL Midleton, Co. 1 Cork 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Mallow, 1 Co. 1 Cork ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 Clonakilty, Crosshaven, Digiweb Co. Co. 1 1 Cork Cork Digiweb 1 ADSL 1 1 ADSL 1 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Satellite Digiweb 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 913 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 914 Schools Installed Installed Activated acroom, Co. Cork Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 nNSMxd, M 12203G12259K S N Naomh12263B Antaine, S N Oir12281D Cheann, Gogginshill N12292I S, Walterstown N S,12382J Canovee12383L Mixed N S, Curriglass NS,12395S Union Hall12446J Mixed N S, Rusheen NS,12447L Ballinlough, Cork S N12456M Gleann Na Huladh, Baltydaniel N12473M S, Eyeries, Timoleague Bantry, N Co. S, Cork12505W Ballinhassig, Greenmount Co. Monastery Cork NS,12598J Cobh, Co. Cork Kilbarry N Carrigadrohid, S, Co.12676D Cork Ardagh Boys12685E Cork, N Co. S, Cork Clogheen Mxd Curriglass, N12967O Mallow, S, Co. Cork Rushnacahara N13031I S, Mitchelstown, Co. Cork Inchigeela N S,13095L Coachford, Co. Scoil Cork Muire Na St. Ngras,13125R Josephs Greenmount, Convent Co. N Digiweb Mallow, Cork S, Co. S Cork N Digiweb13234W An Droma Bandon, Mhoir, Co. Cork Scoil Dhairbhre,13286S Cloughduv Smart N S,13375R Digiweb Irish Broadband Tirelto Macroom,13402R Co. Roscarbery, Cork Co. Wireless Digiweb Scoil Cork Carrigrohane, Smart Bhride, Co. Satellite13450F Cork Knockraha Durrns, N Wireless Bantry, S,13483U Co. Cork Rushbrook Digiweb Rathluirc, Digiweb Con13512B Co. Mercy Cork Satellite N S, Satellite S Inchigeela, N Co. Ath Cork13543M Na Aghaville, Lionta, Bantry, Co. Digiweb Satellite Scoil Cork Mhuire 113647B Lourdes 13512b, Satellite 1 Derrinacahara N S,13648D 1 Clonakilty, Co. Cork Smart Castlemartyr N Satellite Satellite13661S S, Digiweb Cloughduv, Crookstown, St. 1 Co. Lukes 1 Cork. Mxd13662U N S, 1 Satellite Dunmanway Convent13663W 1 Cobh, N 1 Co. S, Cork Smart Digiweb Dunmanway Digiweb Convent 1 1 Inf,13696O Cros Mhathuna, Digiweb Carrigaline, Bandon, Glantaun, Co. Lower Co. Cork, Cork Glanmire Cork Co. N13728B Cork S, 1 Satellite 1 Satellite 1 1 St. Vincents Mallow, Convent13747F Co. N Digiweb Cork S, 1 Smart Castletownsend 1 Mxd13779S N 1 Digiweb 1 S, 1 Smart Dunmanway, Satellite Riverstown Co. Satellite 1 N Cork S, Satellite Satellite S N 1 1 Castlemartyr, Dhrom Dunmanway, Co. Athain, 1 Co. Cork 1 Cork BT 1 1 Ireland Mahonys Dunmanway, Ave, Satellite Co. Cork Cork Smart 1 1 1 1 ADSL Satellite 1 1 1 Glanmire, 1 Satellite St. Co. Marys Cork 1 Road, 1 Digiweb Cork 1 1 Skibbereen, Leased 1 1 1 Co. Line 1 Smart Cork Smart 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Glanmire, Digiweb Co. 1 Cork Mallow, 1 Satellite Co. 1 1 Cork 1 1 Smart BT 1 Ireland ADSL ADSL 1 Smart 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 ADSL Irish Wireless Smart Broadband 1 Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 ADSL 1 1 BT 1 Ireland Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Leased 1 1 1 Line 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 915 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 916

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated anway, Co. Cork BT Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 1 anturk, Co. Cork Eircom ADSL 1 1 1 1 yBNS, Dunm kBNS, K S N B Togher Cork, Togher, Cork Irish Broadband WirelessS N C Bhlarna, 1 1 Iosagain, An Bhlarna, Co. Corcai 1 1 BT Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 1 13828F13889C Douglas B13910N N S, Shanbally N13976U S, S N Bun13980L An Tsabhairne, St. Matthias N14000C S,14002G Scoil Naomh14014N Mhuire, Knockaclarig Mxd N14022M S, S N Baile14052V Deasmumhan, Coachford N S,14065H Kantur Crosshaven, Douglas, Co.14107U Cork Cork Sherkin Island Rinn N Scide,14116V S, Co. Cork Castletownroche N S,14198D Church Road, Kilbrittain Ballydehob, Mixed Co. N14225D Cork S, N Mhuire An Naomh Oileain, Eoin Brosna, Sharman Easpal,14227H Tralee, Crawford Co. St, Kerry Cork Mallow, Scoil Co. Bhride, Cork14303U Kilcoe NS,14403B Irish Broadband S N Cleire,14430E Coachford, St. Co. Johns Cork14433K N S, Digiweb Wireless Derrycreha Baltimore, N Smart Co.14726C S, Castletownroche, Cork Co. Cork Abbeystrewry N S,14784Q Kilbrittain, Co. Smart Cork Kinsale Digiweb N14813U S, Mayfield, Co. Dunmanwa Cork14816D Digiweb Satellite Roscarbery Con N 114839P S, ADSL Scoil Lachtain Naofa,14993C Ballydehob, Co. Cork Clondrohid Digiweb Wireless N15010K Satellite S, Skibbereen, S Co. N Cork15011M Rae Na Ndoiri, Satellite 1 Scoil Oilean An Chleire, Smart 1 Chroi An15135H Digiweb Ro Sciobairin, Kinsale, Naofa, Co. Co. Bantry, Chorcai Cork Co. Skibbereen, Cork Co.15140A Cork Digiweb 1 Bantry Boys Satellite N15165Q S, 1 1 Ballingree Smart Mxd N15346U S, Roscarbery, Kinsale, Co. Co. 1 Ballintotas 1 Cork Cork N 1 S,15380U Cill Smart Satellite Digiweb Na Martra, S Co. Satellite N Chorcai Baile 115410D An Mhuirne, Satellite Dromagh 1 Mixed N15484J 1 S, Smart 1 St. Clondrohid, Anne’s Kilcrohane Co. Road, N Cork Blarney, Rae S,15516T Co. Na Cork Satellite Ndoiri, 1 Maigh 1 Chromtha, 1 Co. Glounthaune Digiweb Chorcai Mixed N.S., Satellite 1 Clonpriest ADSL N 1 S, 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 Bantry, Smart Co. Macroom, Cork Co. Digiweb Cork Digiweb ADSL 1 1 1 Satellite Carrig An 1 Digiweb Adhmaid, Castlemartyr, Maigh Smart Co. 1 BT Chromtha, 1 Cork Ireland Co. 1 Chorcai Dromagh, Mallow, 1 Smart 1 Co. 1 Cork 1 1 Glounthaune, Co.Cork ADSL BT Satellite Ireland ADSL Satellite 1 Durrus, 1 Bantry, Smart 1 Co. Cork 1 Satellite ADSL 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 Youghal, Co. 1 Cork ADSL ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite 1 Smart 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 Satellite ADSL 1 Satellite Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 917 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 918 Schools Installed Installed Activated Treasna, Co. Cork Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 acroom, Co. Cork BT Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 1 aGNS, Ath mBNS, M Scoil Naomh Micheal 15550T15563F Ballyheeda N15594Q S, Lisheen Mixed15597W N S, Grange Fermoy N15646J S, Macroo 15701O Coomhola N15718I S, Bartlemy N S,15781P S15792U N Seosamh Cobh, Ballintemple N S, Upper15903D Glanmire N S Ballinhassig,16087E Co. Skibbereen, Cork Co. Cork Killavullen N Fermoy, S, Co.16109L Cork Kealkil N16128P S, Scoil Realt16159D Na Mara, Mitchelstown Con16246V N Bantry, S, Co. Cork Mallow Con N16253S S, Rathcormac, Cobh, Fermoy, Co. Co. Cork Drumclugh Cork N S,16259H Ballintemple N Aghina Upper S, N Glanmire,16271U Crab S, Whites Lane, Cross, Cork Co. Kilcolman Cork N S,16286K Watergrasshill N S, Smart16335U Digiweb Mallow, Carrigboy Co. N Cork S,16339F Ballycotton, Rylane Midleton, N Co. Smart S, Mitchelstown, Cork16377N Co. Cork Bantry, Co. S Cork Smart N16396R Iosef Naofa, Digiweb Cobh Convent, Irish16497A Broadband Mallow, Co. Satellite Boherbue Cork Satellite N S,16648S Bantry, Digiweb Kilworth Co. Junior Cork N16680O S, Wireless ADSL Ath Treasn BT16681Q Ireland Satellite Satellite Caum, Scoil Enniskean, Macroom, Watergrasshill, Colmcille, Co. Co. Co. Cork16683U Cork. Cork Digiweb Scoil Na Mbraithre,16684W 1 1 Bishop Satellite Durrus, Murphy Bantry, Memorial16746S Co. School, Cork Scoil ADSL Smart Na 1 BT Mbraithre, Ireland16863W Cork, 1 Co. Mardyke, Cork Ballygarvan Cork 1 1 N16876I S, Satellite Desertserges Cobh, 1 N Co. 1 Digiweb S, Cork16885J Kilworth, Co. Boherbue, Cork S Co.16900C N 1 Cork Caipin, 1 Fermoy, ADSL Co. Smart Cork. Adrigole N16901E 1 S, Satellite 1 Digiweb 1 1 S Digiweb N16940O Padraig Naofa Smart B, Blarney Rathluirc, St, 1 S Co. Cork 1 N Satellite Cork 116945B Padraig Digiweb Naofa N B, Dundar 1 Mhuighe N S, Digiweb 1 Midleton, Co. Lisgriffin Cork N 1 S, 1 ADSL 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Satellite Ballygarvan, 1 Co. 1 Cork 1 ADSL Enniskean, Co. Satellite Cork 1 1 Digiweb Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 BT Digiweb Ireland Smart 1 Skibbereen, 1 1 Co. Iniscein, Cork Co. 1 1 Skibbereen, Chorcai Adrigole, Co. Smart 1 Bantry, Cork Co. 1 Cork 1 Kinsale, Co. Cork 1 1 1 Satellite Smart Wireless 1 ADSL 1 Irish Broadband Satellite 1 1 1 1 Buttevant, Satellite Co. BT Cork Ireland 1 1 ADSL Wireless 1 1 Smart 1 Digiweb? 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 Digiweb 1 Smart 1 Digiweb 1 1 Smart 1 1 Satellite Satellite 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 ADSL Digiweb ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 919 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 920

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated 16955E17011W S N17024I Na Mona Fliche, Mocomhog N S17045Q Scoil17050J Na Croise Naofa, St. Patricks B17066B N S, S N17067D Naomh Sheamuis, Christ King17079K Mon, Christ King Girls17087J Primary School S N Carraig17103E An Ime, Macroom, Co. S Cork N17105I An Chlochair, St. Marys17112F Convent G, Mahon, Cork Cappaboy, Kealkil, Bantry, Muire Co.17152R Gan Cork Smal C, Turner’s Ballyhea Cross, N Cork17156C S, Ballyhooley Durrus, Road, Co. Cork Cork S N Cnoc17168J Sceach, Scoil Naomh17171V Aine, Turners Cross, Cork S N17245B Inis Eoghanain, S Macroom, N Co. Cuilinn Cork17251T Ui Caoimh, Digiweb Dripsey N17281F S, Kanturk, Carrigtwohill, Co. Co. Cork Cork Ovens N17297U S, Digiweb Togher N Glasheen,17300G S, Cork S N Fearghail17313P Naofa, Satellite Lios Maighir, Irish Broadband17323S Irish Ballyhea, Clanna Broadband Rathluirc, Irish Caoilte, Co. Broadband Co. Cork Our Chorcai Charleville, Lady Co.17324U of Cork Lourdes, Satellite Digiweb Monkstown Inis Mala, N17338I Eoghanan, Co. S, Wireless Co. Chorcai Chorcai Wireless Scoil Wireless Digiweb Naomh Breandan,17360B S 117362F N Cill Digiweb? Bonain, S N17363H Mhuire, Smart Dripsey, Co. Cork Satellite S 1 N17505B Breandan BT Naofa, Ireland Killeagh, 1 Co. SN Ovens, Cork Cros 1 Wireless Co. Tseain,17515E Cork 1 1 Dunmanway, Digiweb S Co. N Cork17527L Cill Digiweb Satellite Ruadhain, Ballinlough, Cork Irish S Broadband N Newmarket,17528N Achadh Co. Bolg, Cork 1 Cnoc Scoil An ADSL ADSL Smart Bhrugh Chuilinn,17533G Thuinne, An 1 1 Smart Rath 1 Monkstown, Mhor, Co. 1 Co. S Cork Chiarrai N Wireless Naomh17579H Caitriona, 1 1 S Satellite N Rathain, Digiweb17600S Satellite 1 S Atharlach, N Co. Ath17602W Chorcai Fhada, Digiweb Rathcool, 1 Mallow, 1 S Co. N Cork Na 1 Scairte Rath 1 Leithe, S Satellite Peacain, 1 1 1 N Blackpool, 1 ADSL Naomh Co. Lachtin, Cork 1 Digiweb Bun 1 An Tabhairne, Corcaigh Glanmire, Satellite Co. 1 Cork Smart Digiweb 1 Churchtown, Smart Mallow, Achadh Co. An Satellite 1 Cork Chrioste, Co. 1 Corcaigh Digiweb Connaithe 1 1 1 Conna, Irish 1 Co. Broadband Cork 1 1 1 1 Satellite Smart 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Wireless Smart Satellite Mallow, Digiweb Co. Saleen Cork Cloyne, Digiweb Rostiallain, Midleton, 1 Satellite Co. 1 Co. Cork Cork Satellite 1 1 Domhnach 1 Mor, Co. 1 1 Chorcai Smart 1 Digiweb 1 1 Digiweb 1 ADSL 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Local 1 Loop Irish Satellite Broadband Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite ADSL Smart 1 Wireless 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Smart Satellite 1 1 Smart 1 BT Ireland 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Leased Line 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 921 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 922 Schools Installed Installed Activated lantane, Mallow, Co. Cork Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 Ballyphehane, Cork Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 aGNS, eBNS, G 17609N17639W Rathcormac N S,17667E Scoil Na Mbraithre,17706L S N17715M Padraig Naofa, S N17754W An Mhaoilinn, S N Rath17755B A Bharraigh, S N Naomh17761T Eoin B, Scoil Naomh17763A Mhuire C, S N17765E Mhuire, Rockchapel N S,17790D Rathcormac, Co. Mitchelstown, Cork Co. S Cork N17794L Re Na Scrine, Curraghagalla N Whitechurch, S,17804L Co. Cork S N Newmarket, Clonakilty,17823P An Co. Co. Phairc, Cork Cork S N17829E Cnoc Na Manach, Ballincollig, Glantan Ballincollig, Co. Co.17848I Cork Cork S N17868O Ath An Mhuillinn, S17887S N Mhuire, Scoil Freastogail Muire,17888U Rockchapel Araglinn, NS, Cill Mallow, S Uird, Co. N Co. Cork17921P Naomh Chorcai BT Padraig, Smart Roscarbery, Ireland Co. S Cork Kilworth, N Co. Na17950W Cork Trionoide, S Smart N17955J Moing Na Minane Miol, Bridge, Shanagarry Cork N S, Youghal,17972J Co. Digiweb Cork Digiweb Muire ADSL Gan17993R Rathluirc, Smal, Co. Cork S Satellite Smart N18000W Smart Cill Mhuire B, Fermoy, Scoil Co. Digiweb Mhuire Cork Gan18020F Smal B, Satellite Digiweb Naomh Mhuire B,18100D Satellite Satellite Gleann Mallow, S An Co. N Phreachain,18128C Cork An Glenville, Gharrain, Co. Cork Lisgriffin 1 N S,18153B Bealad Rossmore, Clonakilty, 1 Digiweb Co. ADSL S Cork ADSL N Clashbee, Satellite18154D Mhuire Mallow, Mxd, Co. Cork Digiweb Satellite S N 118196T Padraig Naofa Shanagarry, C, Midleton, S Co. 1 Smart N Cork Padraig18208A Smart 1 Naofa, 1 Glasheen, Cluain Cork Dilleain, S Fermoy, Digiweb N Co. 118217B Gleannamhain, Cork Lisardagh, Co. Our Satellite Cork Lady Digiweb of18237H Good Counsel Digiweb 1 NS, 1 1 1 Scoil Satellite Carrigtwohill, Padre Co.18238J Pio 1 Cork N 1 S, Maria 1 BT Assumpt Ireland18246I 1 Upton, Satellite Co. Cork Satellite Maria Satellite Assumpta 1 Jnr. Inft, Digiweb S Smart 1 Goleen, Satellite N 1 1 Skibbereen, 1 Baile Digiweb Co. Coisceim, Muine, Satellite Cork Mallow, Dillons 1 1 Co. Cross, Cork Cork Smart Ballincollig, 1 Co. ADSL 1 Cork 1 Dillons Cross, Cork 1 Glanworth, Co. 1 Cork 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite 1 ADSL 1 1 1 Churchfield, 1 Irish Smart Cork Broadband City 1 Ballyphehane, ADSL Cork Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 Ballineen, Digiweb 1 Co. 1 1 Cork 1 Satellite 1 Digiweb ADSL 1 Smart 1 1 1 Satellite Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 Wireless 1 1 Irish ADSL 1 1 Broadband 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Wireless Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 923 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 924

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Carrigaline No.3, Carrigaline, Co. Cork. Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 e3NS, 18253F18266O Scoil Naomh18278V Caitriona, Ballygown NS,18279A S N Faill18292P O Gcobhthaigh, Carrigalin 18296A Gaelscoil An18301N Teaghlaigh Naofa, Dromdhallagh N S,18316D S N Mhuire18356P B, S N Model Fhursa, Farm18377A Road, Corcaigh S N18388F Barra Naofa, Ballydesmond, Iosef Mallow, Naofa, Co. Baile18422C Cork Feithean, Co. Chorcai Ballygown, Scoil Mallow, Naomh Co.18428O Micheal, Cork Scoil Na18431D Nog, S N Baile18444M Nora, SN Drimoleague, Droichead Co. Na Cork18458A Bandan, S N Clogach,18461M Irish St. Broadband Bernadettes Spec Millstreet,18468D Sch, Co. Digiweb Cork S N Muire18472R Na Doirini, Scoil Ladhar, Bharra, Scoil Banteer, Sraid Mhuire, Co. Irish Wireless Gillabbey, Cork18475A Broadband Corcaigh Digiweb Church Road, Blackrock, Scoil Cork Chaitriona,18483W Fermoy, Co. Cork S N Baile18487H Bandon, Ui Wireless Co. Satellite Chroinin, Cork Spastic Sc of18491V Div Gleann Child, Maghair, Co. Chorcai S Baile N Nora, Naomh Waterfall,18497K Mhuire, Co. Satellite 1 Cork Bonnington, Digiweb Montenotte, S Co. Irish N Cork Broadband Garran18535P An Easaigh, Little Island NS,18549D Cloglach, Skibbereen, Timoleague, Co. Co. Cork 1 Cork 1 St. Johns18563U Wireless Girls N Irish S, Broadband S Digiweb Digiweb N 1 Cnoc18566D Na Croighe, Satellite Scoil 1 Naomh Caislean Brid18567F Ui C, Cloyne, Ballynoe, Dhonnabhain, Middleton, Mallow, Drimoleague, Co. Co. S Co. Wireless Cork Cork N Cork Ballintemple, Athair18586J Co. Maitiu 1 Cork C, 1 Digiweb Smart S Smart N18587L Inis, Smart 1 Fearann, Digiweb Satellite Co. Satellite Killbrittain, Scoil 1 Chorcai Co. Eanna,18657G Cork BT 1 Ireland Scoil Mhuire18659K Digiweb Banrion, 1 Scoil Na Mbraithre, 118713N 1 1 Little Island, Lisavaird Wireless Co. Mxd Cork N18734V 1 Ballea S, Rd, Cnoc ADSL Carrigaline, Na Digiweb Satellite Co. Groighe, S ADSL Cork Mallow, Satellite N 1 Co. Fionan ADSL18786R Cork Na 1 1 1 Reanna, Eglantine 1 House, Realt Digiweb Ballinlough, Na Cork Maidine,18829J Digiweb Satellite An 1 Scoil Tochair, Iosagain, Corcaigh 1 1 Digiweb S N 1 1 Chobh Chionn Tsaile, Satellite 1 1 1 Mayfield, 1 Cork 1 1 1 1 Satellite Smart Digiweb Satellite Montenotte, Killeagh, Digiweb Cork Co. Doneraile, 1 1 Cork Co. Cork Smart Digiweb 1 Clonakilty, Wireless Nohoval, Co. 1 Belgooly, Cork Co. Cork 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Ballyphehane, Cork 1 Satellite 1 Satellite Cionn Satellite 1 1 Tsaile, Co. Wireless Chorcaigh Wireless 1 ADSL Farranree, Irish Cork Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Smart 1 1 Digiweb Smart Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 BT 1 1 Ireland 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband Satellite 1 1 Satellite Local Loop Satellite Local Loop Satellite Wireless ADSL 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 925 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 926 Schools Installed Installed Activated Bishopstown, Cork 18883P19000E S N19203S Iosagain, S N19224D An Spioraid Naomh C, Nmh Pol19231A Special School, S N Cillmin19232C S N Barra19249T Naofa Bhuach, S N19256Q Barra Naofa Cailini, Barryroe NS,19307H Scoil Ghobnatan,19342J Curraheen Rd, Bishopstown, Derrinagree Cork N S,19348V Montenotte, Scoil Cork Naomh19351K Eoin Mala, Baiste, Co. Cork Newcestown N S,19381T Beaumount, Cork S N Cill19404F Criodain, Rathmore Beaumont, N Cork19410A S, Cillmin Coalnaconarty, SN Clonakilty, Mhuire, Co. Cork Irish St.19415K Broadband Killians Spec Sch,19420D Mallow, Lislevane, Co. Bandon, Scoil Cork Co. An Kilbrin, Cork Athar19426P Kanturk, Tadhg, Co. Wireless Cork Derrinagree, SN Mallow, Fhiachna, Cork Smart19427R S N19433M Mharcuis B, Newcestown, S Bandon, N Co. Bhreanndain19501D Cork Smart C, Holy Ladysbridge, Family Castlemartyr, S Co.19507P S, Cork Smart Cahermore 1 New Irish Central Broadband19525R S, Baltimore, Skibbereen, Co. Satellite Cork Scoil Adj Chaitigheirn, To:19526T Bishopstown Comm Irish Sch, Broadband Mhichil Westgate Naofa Road, Ballyhooley, Scoil Co.19557H Smart Wireless An Cork Athar Tadhg, Carraig SN Local Na Cill Loop Digiweb19588S Bhfear, Dairbhre, Co. 1 Chorcai Digiweb Caheragh NS, Wireless Irish19595P ADSL Broadband Smart Smart Smart Smart Scoil Gleann Naomh19637F 1 Garbh, Therese, Co. Chorcai An An St. Gleann, Ghleann, Marys Cahermore, Corcaigh Corcaigh19672H Central Co. Wireless School, Cork 1 1 Scoil Satellite Smart Fionnbarra,19714U Satellite 1 Charleville, Co. Scoil Satellite Cork Muire Na19730S Ngrast, 1 Mhuire 1 Ar Na 1 Satellite Chnoc Haorai,19759T Satellite Satellite Haoine, Beanntrai, ADSL Co. Chorcai Scoil Oilibheir,19760E 1 1 1 St. Ballinakilla, Marys Bere Digiweb19761G Spec Island, Kildorrery, 1 Sch, Bantry, 1 Co. Co. Cork Satellite 1 Cork Scoil 1 Triest,19771J 1 Bishopstown, Cork 1 Enniskeane, Dungourney Co. 1 Central Cork Caheragh, Digiweb N Co. Sc, Cork 1 1 1 Scoil Barra, 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Beal Smart Satellite Knocknaheeny, Guala, 1 Beal Digiweb Smart Cork Co. Atha Digiweb Chorcai Ghaorthaidh, Co. 1 1 Chorcai 1 1 Smart 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Ballincollie Wireless 1 Rochestown, Road, Cork Ballyvolane, Dungourney, 1 Cork Co. Satellite Cork 1 Satellite 1 Local 1 1 Loop Satellite 1 Digiweb 1 BT 1 1 Ireland Lota, ADSL 1 Cork Smart 1 Smart 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 Innishmore, 1 Baile Smart 1 1 An 1 Chollaigh, Co. Irish 1 Chorcai Broadband Irish ADSL Broadband Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Satellite Local Wireless 1 Loop Wireless 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 Smart Satellite Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL Satellite 1 Satellite 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 927 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 928

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Chorcai. Na Bandan, Co. Corcai Chorcai 19788D19801P St. Kevins School,19833F Drimoleague Junior19839R Sch, Gaelscoil Chorain,19851H Gael Scoil Ui19852J Riordain, Gaelscoil De Hide,19881Q Gaelscoil Ui19882S Riada, Gaelscoil Carrig Ui19886D Leighinn, Scoil An19899M Athair Tadhg O Drimoleague, Gael Murchu, Co. Scoil Cork Thomais The19906G Daibhis, Rectory, Infirmary Road, Gaelscoile Cork Cobh,19908K Cork N Sraid Cul School Na Rua,19909M Project, Tra, Baile Eochaill, An Co. Chollaigh, Gaelscoil Chorcai. Co. Mhachan, Chorcai19918N Carrig Ui Gaelscoil Duglas, Mainistir Leighinn, Peig Corcaigh Fhearmai, Co. Sayers,19977G Co. Chorcai Chorcai Drinagh Baile Mixed An NS,19978I Easpaig, Co. Chorcai Bandon Magh Boys Ealla, NS, Co.19989N Chorcai Irish Broadband Smart Maulatrahane19993E Central NS, Scoil Mhuire Na20001N Smart Trocaire, Digiweb Wireless Gaelscoil An Grattan Cobh, Ghoirt Street, Co. Alainn, Cork Chorcai Gaelscoil20004T Bheanntrai Smart Carraig Smart Dubh,20006A Corcaigh CSLSLO Na Piarsaigh Scoil C.L.G., ADSL An20009G Parklands, Croi Corcaigh Ro Naofa, Irish Gaelscoil Broadband Satellite Chloich Na Dunmanway,20022V ADSL Coillte, Co. 1 Cork Leap, Gaelscoil Skibbereen, Dr Co. M Smart20024C Cork Ui Irish Shuilleabhain Broadband Bandon, Co. Cill Scoil Smart Cork Na Na Wireless Mullach, Mbuachailli,20025E Aibhinne Co. Murmont, Chorcai Gort ADSL Alainn, ADSL Bun Corcaigh Scoil Muire, Wireless20036J Gaelscoil 1 Droichead 1 Na Bandan 1 Tigh20038N Warner, Sraid 1 Na Bearaice, Beanntrai, North Sraid Co. Presentation Na20049S ADSL An Digiweb Castletownbere, Primary Scoile, Sciobairin, Co. School Cloich Co. Cork. Na Chorcai Scoil 1 Coillte, Smart ADSL Irish Aiseiri Co. Irish Broadband Chriost,20074R Chorcai. Broadband 1 1 Ringaskiddy 1 Lower20077A Harbour 1 1 1 N Smart S, St. Gabriels Digiweb 1 Special20088F C/O Wireless School, Wireless G.A.A. Digiweb Pavilion, Cloich Scoil Smart Charley Na Smart An Hurley Coillte, Spioraid Park,20105C Co. Naomh Droichead Wireless Gerald 1 Chorcai. (Boys), Griffin Street, Scoil Cork 1 Mhuire City.20106E Smart N.S., 1 ADSL 1 1 O’Brien’s Star 1 Place, of 1 Smart Youghal,20107G The Co. Sea 1 1 Cork Primary School, Scoil Ringaskiddy, Nioclais, Co. 1 Satellite Cork. ADSL Satellite 1 1 Gaelscoil Mhainistir Na Corann Smart Smart 1 ADSL Farranree, Satellite 1 Cork. Bishopstown, 1 Cork Curraheen Road, 1 Cork 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 ADSL BT 1 Ireland 1 Passage 1 Irish West, Broadband 1 Co. Cork BT 1 1 Ireland 1 1 1 Ionad 1 ADSL Satellite An Schull, 1 1 Phobail, Co. 1 Mainistir Cork 1 Wireless Na Corann, 1 Contae 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 Digiweb Frankfield, Grange, Cork 1 BT 1 Ireland 1 1 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 Irish Broadband Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite ADSL BT Ireland 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Local Loop 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 ADSL 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 929 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 930 Schools Installed Installed Activated Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 BT Ireland ADSL 1 1Smart 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 ´ ´ rna, Co. Chorcaı ´ ´ ´ , Co. Chorcai BT Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 1 ´ Habhainn, Teamhair, An Bhla C/O Blarney United Soccer Club, Pairc Radharc Na Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 Bakers Road, Charleville, Co. Cork Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 ´ ostaı ´ Naofa, Carraig Na Bhfear, Co. Chorcaı ´ ´ in, Mainistir Fhearmuı ´ ithre Chrı ´ Urmoltaigh, Droichead Na Bandan, Co. Chorcaı ´ iste Na Toirbhirteiste An Chroı iste Muire Ard Aoibhinn, Bandon, Co. Corkiste Cholma BT Ireland Bishop’s St, Cobh, Co. Cork ADSL 1 BT Ireland 1 ADSL 1 1 1 ´ ´ ´ ´ 20119N20140E Cork University Hos20151J School, Scoil Mhuire Fatima,20162O Gaelscoil Mhuscraı 20182U Sonas Special Primaryjunior62050O School St. Endas NS,62060R Ardscoil Uı Childrens62061T Ward, Wilton, Cork Bandon Grammar School,62080A Cola Carrigaline,62090D Co. Cork Ardscoil North Phobal Monastery, Bheanntrai,62130M Cork Scoil Mhuire Gan62140P Smal, Cola 62170B St. Aloysius62180E College, Sacred Heart62200H Secondary Bandon, School Co. Smart Cork Cola Kilnadur,62210K Dunmanway, Co. Bantry, Cork Colaiste Co. Muire, Cork62260C Nagle Rice Secondary62270F School, Cola Blarney, Co.62290L Cork Smart Irish Broadband Loreto Secondary Convent Local62301N School, of Loop Mercy, Clonakilty, Co. Scoil Cork Mhuire,62310O Carrigtwohill, Co. Colaiste Cork An Wireless Phiarsaigh,62320R De Digiweb La Salle62330U College, Doneraile, Co. Cork St. 1 Mary’s ADSL Secondary62350D School Patrician Academy,62360G BT BT Ireland Ireland Crosshaven, St. Co. Mary’s Cork Secondary62370J School 1 Fermoy, Co. Cork Christian Satellite Brothers Smart Secondary62380M S Midleton College,62420V St. Gleann Mary’s 1 ADSL BT Maghair, ADSL High Ireland62421A Co. School, Chorcaı Christian Convent 1 Brothers of Secondary Mercy, Kanturk,62440E S, Macroom, Co. Smart Co. Cork Macroom, Cork Presentation Co. Secondary Cork School,62450H 1 ADSL Convent Scoil of Na Castleredmond, Mercy,62460K Mbra Midleton, Mallow, Co. Co. 1 ADSL Cork Mallow, Cork Co. St. Cork Mary’s Smart Secondary62470N School 1 St. 1 Francis 1 Capuchin62480Q College, Mount Smart Mitchelstown, St. 1 ADSL Co. Michael,62490T BT Cork Ireland St. Midleton, Mitchelstown, Fachtna’s Co. Co. De Midleton, Cork Cork La Co. 1 Salle Smart 1 Cork Col, Mercy Heights Secondary 1 School, 1 1 Satellite Smart 1 BT Ireland Convent ADSL of 1 Mercy, Charleville, Co. ADSL Rochestown, Cork Co. 1 Cork 1 Eircom BT Ireland 1 1 ADSL 1 1 Skibbereen, ADSL Skibbereen, Co. Co. Cork Cork 1 ADSL Smart Rosscarbery, 1 Co. Cork 1 BT 1 Ireland ADSL Smart 1 1 ADSL BT Ireland 1 1 1 BT 1 Ireland BT 1 Ireland 1 1 1 ADSL ADSL 1 1 1 ADSL Smart ADSL 1 1 ADSL 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 Smart Smart 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL ADSL 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 931 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 932

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated BT IrelandBT Ireland ADSL ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ´ ´ al Atha An Ghaorthaidh, Co. Chorcaı ´ , Capwell Road, Cork Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ ost Rı ´ iste Mhuire, An Mhainistir Thuaidh, Corcaigh Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ iste Chrı iste An Spioraid Naoimh, Bishopstown, Cork Digiwebiste An Chraoibhin Wireless 1 Duntaheen Road, Fermoy, Co. Cork 1 1 BT Ireland 1 ADSL 1 ´ ´ ´ 62500T62510W Christian Brothers62520C Loreto Secondary School,62530F Christian Brothers62531H College North Monastery62540I Secondary Scho Gaelchola 62560O Deerpark62570R C.B.S., Cola 62580U Presentation College, Youghal,62590A Co. Cork Our Cola Lady’s Golf Mount, Sidney Links North62621I Hill, Road, Monastery Wellington Youghal, Rd., Road, Co. Cork St. Cork. Cork Vincent’s Secondary62630J School, North62640M Presentation, St. Aloysius62650P Digiweb School St. Angela’s College,62661U Ursuline Secondary62690E School, St. Patrick’s Mount Road, Mercy Cork BT St. College, Digiweb62691G Ireland Mary’s Mardyke, Road, Cork Cork Scoil Mhuire,62692I Wireless Regina Mundi College,62693K Christ Smart62730N King Girls Sec. ADSL School, Presentation Farranree, Secondary Cork School70910L Wireless St. Blackrock, Patricks St. Cork College,70920O Maries of St. The Patrick’s Isle, Hill, 1 St. Sharman Cork Brogan’s Crawford70930R College Street, Cork Colaiste Ghobnatan, Model70931T Farm Digiweb Road, Cork ADSL St. Goban’s College70950A Digiweb 1 1 Scoil South Douglas Mhuire, Douglas Joe Road,70960D Road, Murphy Cork Digiweb 1 Cork Rd, Ballyphehane, Cork Clonakilty Community College, 270970G Sydney Place, Wellington Coachford Road, Smart College, Cork70990M Wireless Cobh Community 1 College71000A 1 Wireless 1 Gardiner’s Cola Hill, Cork71020G Wireless 1 Kilbrogan, Colaiste Bandon, Treasa, Co. Cork71030J Digiweb Baile Mhic Digiweb Ire, Davis Clonakilty, Co. College Digiweb Co. Chorcaı 71040M Cork Smart ADSL Digiweb Sheskin, Smart 1 Bantry, Mcegan Co. 1 College,71050P 1 Cork 1 St. 1 Fanahan’s Digiweb College71080B 1 1 St. Colman’s Be 71090E Carrignafoy, Community Wireless Cobh, College Smart Co. Coachford, Cork Wireless Co. Mannix Cork College, Wireless71100E 1 Wireless Rossa College, ADSL 1 1 1 1 Local Loop Colaiste Eoin Wireless BT 1 Ireland Digiweb Kanturk, Co. 1 Youghal Cork Road, 1 Midleton, ADSL Co. Cork 1 1 1 Annabella, 1 Smart SUMMERHILL, 1 Mitchelstown, 1 Co. 1 BT Mallow, Cork Macroom, Ireland Co. Co. Cork ADSL 1 Cork 1 1 BT Ireland Wireless 1 1 1 Charleville, 1 Co. 1 Cork 1 1 ADSL 1 Smart 1 1 ADSL Skibbereen, Co. BT 1 Cork Ireland Smart 1 ADSL 1 Golf Links 1 Road, 1 Youghal, 1 Co. Cork BT 1 Ireland 1 1 1 1 BT 1 Ireland ADSL 1 Satellite 1 1 ADSL 1 BT 1 Ireland 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL BT Ireland 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 933 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 934 Schools Installed Installed Activated Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 ´ Ballyroan, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 Lucan, Co. Dublin Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 n Naofa, Tramore Road, Cork Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ nBNS, nBNS, iste Choilm, Ballincollig, Co. Cork Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 ´ 71101G71102I St. Aidan’s Community71103K College Schull71110H Community College Cola 71120K Nagle Community College71121M College of Commerce,71122O St. John’s Ballincolly, Central71123Q Dublin College, Hill, Cork Colaiste Stiofa 71124S Terence Mac Swiney76064F Colla Community Road, C Schull, Co. Colaiste Cork Daibheid,76067L Glanmire Community Mahon,76086P College Blackrock, Cork Colaiste Pobail81008W Naomh Mhuire, Maria Immaculata Morrison’s81009B Sawmill Community Hollyhill, Island, Street, Col, Knocknaheeny, Cork Cork Cork Ashton School,91386O Irish Broadband Boherbue Comprehensive91387Q School Ballincollig Community School91388S Riverstown, Glanmire, Co. Beara Cork Wireless Community Smart Cill School91390F Dunmanway, Na Co. Mullach, Cork Co. Chorcaı Carrigaline An Community TArdan91391H School Theas, Corcaigh Millstreet Community91396R School, Boherbue, Smart Mallow, St. Co. Peter’s Cork Community91397T Smart School, Douglas Community Innishmore, School Ballincollig,91400F 1 Co. Cork Satellite Bishopstown Digiweb Community91499E School, Blackrock Digiweb Road, Cork Mayfield Community Irish Waterpark School Castletownbere, Broadband Road, Beara, Carrigaline, Co. Co. Cork Kinsale Cork Community00714P School, ADSL Millstreet Town, Co. 1 Cork Local Loop00729F Passage West, Wireless Co. Digiweb Cork Luca Wireless BT00743W 1 Ireland Bishopstown, Clermont Cork Wireless Clochar Avenue, Loreto Douglas, Smart00752A N Cork Smart S, Mater Dei Primary01170G School, Smart Old 1 Central Youghal 1 Senior Road, Mxd 101795A Mayfield, N Cork S, ADSL S 1 Kinsale, Wireless 1 N Smart Co. Na02872U Cork HAille, 1 Central Infs School, 103359N Digiweb Sandyford Satellite Mxd ADSL N03917V 1 S, Smart 1 Ballyroa 1 ADSL04992R Smart 1 Naomh 1 1 Padraig Basin Boys,05600C BT 1 Lane, Ireland James 1 Street, Satellite 1 Dublin Scoil Grange 8 An Digiweb Road, Croi05933G Rathfarnham, Naofa, Dublin 14 Wireless Clochar Marlboro San St, Dominic, Dublin 1 1 Smart 1 1 Georges 1 Hill Convent, Satellite 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 ADSL Marlboro 1 St, The Dublin 1 Wireless Naul, 1 Co. Dublin Sandyford, 1 Co. BT Dublin 1 Ireland Digiweb 1 Smart 1 Local Loop Cambridge Road, 1 Ringsend, Dublin 1 1 4 1 Glasnevin, 1 1 Dublin 1 1 11 Dunlaoghaire, Co. 1 Dublin ADSL 1 1 Georges Hill, Wireless Dublin 1 7 1 Smart Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 Smart Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 Local Loop 1 1 1 1 Wireless Irish Broadband 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 Satellite ADSL 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity Dublin 00697S St. Brigids Mxd N S, Castleknock, Dublin 15 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 935 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 936

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated y N S (2), Dalkey, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 06200O06468K Booterstown Boys,07546J St. Laurence O09492W Toole Senior Girls Goldenbridge Convent,09642P Balscadden N S,09750S Burrows N09932B S, St. Josephs10296G Boys N S, Seville Stanhope Place, St. Dublin10494K Convent, 1 Scoil Naomh Mearnog,10653E Booterstown, All Blackrock, Saints Co. N11525A Dublin S, Chapelizod Goldenbridge, N Inchicore,11578V S, Dublin 8 St. Patricks N11583O School, City Quay Boys11638N N Balscadden, S, Ring St. Commons, Andrews Co. N Dublin11776C S, Terenure, Whitechurch Dublin Nat 6 School, Stanhope11873A Street, Sutton, Dublin Dublin Irish 7 13 Broadband St. Strand Laurence Road,11894I O Portmarnock, Toole Co. Junior Dublin Boys Rathmichael Irish N Broadband S,12014D Irish Broadband Wireless Scoil12358M Mhuire, Smart St. Andrews Carysfort N12448N Wireless Ave, S, Drumcondra, Blackrock, Wireless Dublin Chapelizod, Co. Swords 9 Dublin Dublin Borough 20 N12755W S, Seville Gardiner City Place, Street Quay, Dublin Convent, Dublin13217W 1 HERMES 2 Whitechurch, Rathfarnham, Kildare Dublin Place 16 N13447Q S, 1 Malahide, Co. Holy Dublin Family National13611D ADSL School, Irish 1 Broadband Scoil Mhuire, 113612F Digiweb Presentation Irish Wireless Primary Broadband School,13815T Rathmichael, Shankill, Co. HERMES Dublin Presentation Wireless 1 Primary14180H School, Howth Irish Rd Broadband Wireless14463T Mxd 1 Dumhach N Gardiner Swords Lucan, Tragh, 1 S, Street, Borough Co. Dublin Dublin N Holmpatrick Dublin 4 1 S, N 1 Swords, S,14556D Co. Rathcoole, Dublin Irish Co. Broadband Wireless Irish Dublin St. Broadband Columbas14586M Wireless N Wireless 1 S Mxd, St. Endas 1 Irish 96 Primary Broadband14647G 1 Upper School, Rathmines Blackpitts, Digiweb Rd, Dublin Carysfort Wireless Dublin 8 NS, 6 Wireless14717B 1 1 1 Terenure 1 Irish Irish Road Dalke Broadband Broadband West, Dublin14917J 6w Wireless Irish Broadband Rathgar 1 N Lucan, 114939T S, Co. Dublin 1 1 1 Wireless Zion Wireless Parish14980Q Primary School, Wireless Wireless Rathfarnham Howth Parish Rd, 1 1 N Clontarf, 1 S, Dublin 1 3 1 1 Irish Glasnevin Broadband Smart N S, Holmpatrick, North St. Skerries, Strand, Endas Co. Dublin 1 1 Primary Dublin 3 Digiweb School, 1 Whitefriar 1 1 St, Dublin Irish Irish 8 Broadband Broadband 1 Wireless 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 Smart Wireless Wireless Convent Bushy Road, Smart Park 1 Blackrock, Road, Co. Local Rathgar, Dublin Loop 1 Dublin Wireless 6 1 1 1 Washington Lane, 1 1 Templeogue, 1 Dublin 1 14 Rathgar, Irish Dublin 1 Smart Wireless Broadband 6 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Wireless Botanic Avenue, Glasnevin, 1 1 1 Irish Dublin Broadband 9 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 Irish Broadband Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 ADSL Wireless 1 ADSL 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 937 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 938 Schools Installed Installed Activated Dublin Iona Road, Glasnevin, Dublin 9, 109 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 nG&I 15056L15132B S N15253N San Vinseann Cailin, Harold Boys15284B N S, St. Patricks Girls15315J NS, Taney N S,15569R St. Georges N S15618E Scoil Moibhi,15622S Sandford N North15625B S, William St, Dublin 1 St. Patricks15650A NS, St. Catherines15816I West N S, Corduff Dalkey, N Cambridge Co. S, Road, Dublin15895H Dublin 4 St.15995L Vincents Inf Boys, Drumcondra N S,16177F Canon O16267G Hanlon Sydenham St. Memorial Villas, Georges N Dundrum, N S, Dublin S, Lindsay 14 Hampton Road16332O Street, N Balbriggan, S, Co. Portrane Boys N Milverton,16333Q S, Skerries, Irish Co. Broadband Dublin St. Donore Patricks Avenue, Snr Ranelagh,16352U South Mixed, Dublin Circular 6 Smart Road, St. Dublin Chapelizod Patricks 8 Village, Jnr.16353W Chapelizod, Mixed, Dublin 20 St. Wireless Brigids Irish Boys16461C Sandymount, Broadband N Dublin S, 4 North St. Irish William Brigids Broadband Street, Girls Dublin16567S N 1 S, Lusk, Smart Co. Irish Dublin Broadband Caisleain Nua16577V Liamhna, Church Avenue, Wireless Drumcondra, Dublin 9 St. Wireless Brigids16629O Convent ADSL N Irish S, Broadband St. Wireless Brigids Convent, 116651H Lindsay Smart Road, Glasnevin, Dublin Kilternan 9 Church Donabate, of Skerries, Co.16659A Ireland Co. Dublin NS, Dublin, 137 St. Wireless Clares Skerries, Convent Wireless16675V Co. N Dublin, S, 137 St. 1 Columbas Co 16695E 1 Irish Broadband 1 Foxrock, Mulhuddart Dublin Irish NS, Irish 1 18, Broadband Broadband16753P 118 1 Foxrock, Newcastle Scoil Dublin ADSL Lyons, Na 18, Co.16754R Mbrathar, 118 Dublin, Irish 128 Broadband Wireless St. Kilternan, Vincent Haddington 116759E Co. De Road, Wireless Wireless Dublin, 1 Pauls Dublin 1 118 Irish Girls 4, Broadband School 104 St. 1 Vincents Convent16786H Inf N Wireless S, Glasnevin, 1 Irish 1 S Dublin 1 Broadband N 11,16792C Mhuire 111 Na Mbrathar, St. Wireless Brigids Harolds Convent16794G Cross N Road, S, Dublin 1 1 BT 6w, St. Ireland 126 Brigids Wireless 1 1 Irish16799Q Convent Broadband N 1 S, 1 BT 1 St. Ireland Brigids Griffith 1 N Avenue,16844S S Dublin Irish 9, Broadband 103 1 St. 1 1 Michaels 1 C16860Q B Mulhuddart S, Wireless Village, Irish Dublin Broadband 67 Scoil North 15, Griffith Irish N. Brunswick 11516864B Avenue, Broadband 1 Breandan Street, 1 ADSL Dublin Dublin 9, Irish 7, 109 Broadband 1 Wireless Corpus 1 107 Christi N 1 1 1 ADSL S Irish 1 1 Broadband Marino, Dublin St. 9, Wireless Josephs 1 109 Special Irish Sch, Wireless Broadband 1 1 Wireless The 1 Coombe, Irish Dublin Broadband 8, 108 Wireless 1 1 Killester, Dublin 5, 1 105 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb Wireless Irish Irish Broadband Broadband 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Merville Inchicore, 1 Rd, Dublin Stillorgan, 1 8, Blackrock. 108 Co. 1 Dublin, 1 Wireless Wireless 134 Loughshinny, 1 Skerries, Co. 1 Dublin, 1 1 137 1 Cabra, 1 Home Dublin Farm 1 1 7 Road, Wireless Drumcondra, 1 Dublin 1 Irish 1 9, Broadband 109 1 1 Wireless 1 Digiweb Smart 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Irish Irish 1 Broadband Broadband 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 939 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 940

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Dubhghaill, Ath Cliath 13. 113 lasnevin, Dublin 9, 109 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 Cabra, Dublin 7, 107Cabra, Dublin 7, 107 Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Scoil Naisiunta Baile Duill, Br Clochaise, Baile HERMES Wireless 1 1 1 1 gBNS, gGNS, nCBS, G eBNS Dublin 16893I16964F S16966J N Naomh Lorcan Scoil Mhuire16970A Ogh 1 Scoil Naisiunta16972E Stratford St. Molaga Senior16983J NS S N16988T Peadar Agus Pol N, S N16989V Naomh Cillin Christ The17055T Kin Christ The Kin 17083B S N17104G Stillorgan, Naomh Kilmacud, Mhuire, Co. Dublin, 1 S 134 Zion N Loreto Road,17110B Muire College, Rathgar, Gan Crumlin Dublin Smal Rd, 6, B, Dublin St. 106 12 Francis Junior17148D National Bremore, School Balbriggan, Co. Naomh Dublin, Lorcan 13917210F O Balbriggan, Tuathail, Co. Dublin, 139 S N Eoin17211H Baisde G Sen Clochar Lughaidh17214N Cailin Robinhood Rd., Clochar Bluebell, Lughaidh Smart Inchicore, Naoidh17263D Dublin 12, Irish Priorswood, 112 Broadband Dublin San 17, Uinsion Irish 117 Broadband S17279S Saggart, N Co. Muire BT Dublin, Inchicore, An Ireland Digiweb 130 Dublin Sean 8, Baile, 108 Sean17284L Wireless Bhaile, Plas Co. Seibhil, Wireless Baile Scoil Atha Muire, Cliath 1, 10117318C Baldoyl ADSL Digiweb BT Seafield Ireland17319E Road, Clontarf, Williams ADSL Dublin Park, 3, Rathmines, Scoil 103 Dublin Williams An 6, Park, Wireless17320M Leinbh 106 Rathmines, Iosa Dublin B 6, 106 An 1 Leinbh17355I Iosa Cailini 1 An Leinbh Iosa17356K Naoidhin Irish ADSL Broadband Muire Digiweb17367P Na 1 Dea Coirle G Muire Na Dea17459U 1 Coirle Irish Inf, 1 Broadband 1 Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Irish Scoil Broadband Broadband Mhuire 1 Irish17464N Gns, Broadband Christ The King17465P I G, Wireless Fionnbarra Haddington Wireless Naofa, Road, Wireless17466R Larkhill, Wireless Wireless Dublin 1 Whitehall, 4, Wireless Dublin 104 9, 109 1 Dominican Convent 1 Larkhill,17470I Girls, Whitehall, Larkhill, Dublin Whitehall, 1 9, Dublin St. 109 9, Catherines 109 1 1 Infant17472M School, St.17507F Raphaelas Mourne N Road, S Drimnagh, Mourne Baile Dublin Road, Satellite Falbach, 1 12, Dublin 1 11217559B 12, 1 112 1 1 1 1 S 1 N 117569E Padraig Naofa 1 1 S N17595F Mhuire, Navan Road, Dublin 7, Cabra, Blessed Irish Irish 107 Dublin Oliver Broadband Broadband 7, N Cabra, 107 S Dublin 7, 1 Cabra, 107 1 Irish Cill Cabra 1 Dublin 1 Broadband Coscain, West, 1 7, Irish 1 1 Dublin 107 Broadband Irish 1 7, Broadband 107 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Upper 1 Kilmacud Road, 1 1 Stillorgan, 1 1 1 Co. Dublin, 1 134 Lusk, Co. Dublin, Gleann 133 Cuillin, 1 Cilltighearnain, 1 Wireless Co. 1 Atha Cliath, 1 118 Digiweb Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 Baile An Ridire, Garristown, Baile 1 Co. DIGIWEB Brigin, Dublin, 1 Co. 143 1 Atha 1 Cliath, Irish Digiweb 1 139 Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband 1 1 The Irish Ward, Broadband Co. 1 Dublin 1 1 BT 1 Ireland Wireless 1 Wireless Satellite Wireless Wireless Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 DIGIWEB 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 941 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 942 Schools Installed Installed Activated Cliath 5, 105 Dublin Cliath 12 Cliath 12 Synge St, Dublin 8, 108 Smart Wireless 1 1 1 1 aCBS, 17603B17683C Scoil Iosagain17730I Muire Og17732M 2 Loreto Con, S N Na Lanai Glasa Scoil17785K Chiarain17820J San Nioclas Myra,17881G Brighde Naofa17890H Scoil Ui Chonaill,17891J Temple St. Hospital17893N N Crumlin S, Road, Dublin 12, Scoil 112 Mhuire17899C Aughavannagh Road, Crumlin, Sancta Dublin Mari 12,17912O 112 Seafield Avenue, Scoil Clontarf, Carmel Dublin17914S 3, 103 S N Eoin Ascal Bosco Ui Buach, Choileain, Domhnach17928G Cairne, St. Baile Oliver Kinsealy, Irish Atha Plunkett Dublin Broadband 17, 11717936F SN N Sailbheastar Temple17944E Nfa, Street, Baile Dublin Irish Rothluis, Nth 1 Broadband Kilsallaghan, Richmond Co. S Street, Wireless Dublin, N Dublin Irish17953F 131 Eoin Smart 1, Broadband Baisde 101 B Sin St. Marys17954H School For Deaf Girls, Wireless S N17961E Bhaile Eamonn, Wireless Scoil Mount Caoimhin Sackville Naofa Convent,17970F Chapelizod, Dublin Navan Smart 20, Road, S 120 Dublin N 7,17971H Lusca, 107 1 Teach Giuise, Cl Local Tallaght, Irish Scoil Loop Dublin17976R Broadband M 24, Na St. 124 Trocaire, Oliver St. Plunkett Irish Michaels NS, Broadband Malahide, Spec Dominican Grove17977T 1 Co. Irish School, Convent, Road, Dublin, Broadband Cabra, Malahide, 123 Dublin Co. Scoil 7 1 Assaim B,17978V Wireless Seafield Rd, Scoil 1 Clontarf, Digiweb Aine Dublin17979A Wireless C, Satellite 3, Smart 103 Wireless 1 Naiscoil Ide17996A S 1 Rathfarnham, N Dublin Cnoc 14,18038B Mount Ainbhil 114 Merrion, Irish 1 Blackrock, Broadband Co. Glen Dublin, Na 134 Smol18046A N S 1 Irish St. 1 Digiweb Broadband Margarets Wireless Baile18047C N 1 An S, Bhothair, Glenmaroon, 1 1 Co. Chapelizod, Wireless Scoil Baile Dublin Bride 1 Atha 20 ADSL B,18080A Cliath, 132 1 Scoil Lusk, Irish Bride Co. Wireless Broadband18104L C, Dublin, Smart 133 1 Irish Scoil Broadband Mhuire Mxd,18137D 1 Raheny, S Dublin 1 Wireless N 5, 118170B De 105 1 Wireless 1 Smart La 1 1 Salle, S Wireless N 1 Naomh Feargal, Raheny, Irish Dublin Broadband 5,18171D SN 1 105 1 Muire Na Lr Freastogala Irish All 1 1 Kilmacud Broadband Saints Rd, Drive, Stillorgan/Blackrock, Raheny, Co. ADSL Dublin Dublin., Glen 5, 1 114 Our Na 105 Lady Smal, Assumption Wireless Tallaght, Bns Dublin 1 Irish 24, 1 St. Broadband 1 124 1 1 Margarets, 1 Co.Dublin. 1 1 Wireless ADSL 1 1 1 Blanchardstown, Dublin Wireless 15 Tucketts Lane, Blanchardstown, Irish Howth, Dublin 1 Broadband Co. 15 Dublin 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 1 Siuracha 1 1 Finglas Na Glasanon 1 West, Carthanachr, Digiweb Smart Road, Dublin Baile 1 Finglas 11 Uailcin, East, Baile 1 Dublin Atha Wireless 11 Siuracha 1 Na 1 Carthanacha, Baile Wireless Uailcin, Irish Baile Broadband 1 Atha Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 Irish Broadband Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 Wireless Satellite 1 HERMES 1 Wireless Local Loop 1 Irish 1 Digiweb Broadband 1 1 Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 943 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 944

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Drumcondra, Dublin 9 Cliath 12 Padraig, Donabate, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 SNCNaomh 18173H18205R S N Briotas,18210K S N An18282M Pharoiste, Orthopaedic Hospital,18317F SN Paroiste Maitiu18323A Nfa, Central Remedial18324C Clinic, Scoil Lorcain B,18341C Scoil Bride18342E C, SN Louise18360G De Marillac C, SN Louise18361I De Marillac, Scoil Bhreandain, Baldoyle, Dublin18362K Finglas, 13 Dublin Brittas, 11 Co. Cranfield Dublin Place, S Sandymount,18370J N Dublin Caitriona 4 C, Vernon Avenue, S Clontarf, N Dublin Caitriona18386B 3 Naionain, Ioclainn Na18411U Pailirise, Marist National18412W School, Palmerstown, Drumfin Dublin St. Rd, 20 Marys Ballyfermot, School, Dublin18417J 10 Ballyfermot, Palmerstown, Dublin Digiweb Dublin 10 2018451J St. Josephs For Blind NS18455R Smart Coolock, Dublin 5 Scoil Lorcain Coolock, Dublin 5 Our18477E Lady Irish of Broadband Coolock, Assumption Dublin 5 Wireless Irish18499O Smart Broadband Digiweb Inchinne, Sandymount Clogher Avenue, Road, Scoil Dublin Crumlin, Na 4 Dublin18519R Mbrathar, 12 Wireless St. Augustines School,18569J Local Loop Wireless Scoil Seamus Greenhills Digiweb C18585H Road, B Tallaght, S, Dublin 24 St. Josephs St. School Declans18602E ForVisually Special Impaired 1 Wireless Sch, Boys, Irish Digiweb SN Broadband Satellite Banrion Na18623M Naingea11, Irish Broadband Scoil Siuracha Mhuire, 1 1 Na18632N Carthanacha, Baile Uailcin, Scoil 1 Baile Naisunta Wireless Atha Irish Chnuacha, Wireless18642Q Broadband Smart Wireless Cearnog S Irish Eaton, N 1 Broadband Baile Eoin18646B Na Bosco Manach, Nai Co. Irish Buac, Smart Atha S Broadband Wireless 1 Irish Cliath Francis N Broadband Obelisk Street, Naomh18647D Park, Dublin Eoin, 1 Wireless Blackrock, 8 Co. Irish 1 Dublin Springdale Broadband N18655C S Wireless 1 Irish S Broadband N Wireless James Ballyfermot, San 35 Street,18671A Wireless Dublin Treasa, Northumberland Dublin 1 10 Road, 8 1 Ballsbridge, Dublin Scoil 4 Naomh Wireless 1 1 Local18682F Seosamh, Loop 1 St. 1 Michaels Wireless Hse 118683H Castleknock, Spec ADSL Dublin Sc, 15 1 1 St. Canices18726W B N 1 Irish 1 S, Navan Broadband St. Rd, 1 Canices Dublin Irish 1 G 7 Clondalkin,18763F Broadband N Dublin 1 S, 22 1 1 S N 1 Seosamh 1 Na Mbrathar, 1 1 1 Wireless St. 1 Michaels Hse 1 Tower Wireless Spec 1 Road, Sc, Clondalkin, 1 Smart Dublin 22 1 1 1 1 Springdale 1 Clondalkin, NS, 1 Dublin 1 Lough 22 Derg 1 Rd, 17 1 The Raheny, Grosvenor Rise, Dublin 1 Road, Digiweb Mt 5 Smart Rathgar, Merrion, Dublin Co. 1 6 Dublin 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Fairview, Irish Irish 1 Dublin Broadband Broadband 3 Finglas, Wireless Dublin 11 1 1 1 1 Finglas, Dublin Irish 1 11 1 Broadband Ballymun Rd, 1 Dublin Wireless 9 Irish Irish Wireless Wireless Broadband Broadband 1 1 Wireless 1 Smart 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband Digiweb 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 945 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 946 Schools Installed Installed Activated BAC6 School, Tallaght, Dublin 24 ilternan, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 Fortfield Park, Terenure, Dublin 6 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 nNS1, K X N S Boys,XGNS, Fortfield Park, Terenure, Dublin 6 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 18778S18788V S N18806U Naomh Mochta, Our Ladys Hospital18815V Sp S, Kilterna 18817C Our Lady of Lourdes School,18843D S N Brighde18863J Bainrion Na NAingal18886V 2, Benincasa Special18904U School, Kill O Crumlin, The18910P Clonsilla, Dublin Grange Dublin 12 N 15 S, St. Peters Special Rochestown18911R Sch, Ave, Dun Laoghaire, Co. Bantiarna Dublin Na18968A Mbuanna B, Bantiarna Na Mbuanna18969C G, St. Malachys B18976W N S, St. Ballyfermot Eithnes Upper, Smart18977B Senior Dublin G 10 1 N Mount S S, Merrion N Cullenswood Ave, Cholmille House, Blackrock,19001G B, Br Co. Feadha Dublin Cuilinn, Raghnallach, S N19006Q Cholmcille Kill C, O The Grange, Ballyboghill Irish Co. N Broadband Dublin S,19007S Lucena Baile Clinic, Munna, 59 Dublin Eoin Orwell 9 Baisde Road, B19015R Dublin Baile Sois, 6 Munna, Irish Dublin Broadband 9 ADSL Digiweb Irish Eoin Broadband Baisde19032R Wireless C Naoidh, St. Josephs G19037E N S, Stewarts Edenmore, Wireless Hos Edenmore, Raheny, Special19039I Raheny, Dublin Wireless Digiweb Sc, Dublin 5 5 St. Monicas19066L N S, Smart Satellite St.19114T Vincents Home Swords, NS, 1 1 Co. Irish Dublin Broadband Loreto National19151C School, Swords, Co. Dublin St. Patrick19158Q Gns, 1 Ballyboghill, Wireless Co. 1 Dublin St. Seafield John Wireless Rd,19159S of Clontarf, Seafield God Dublin Road, Digiweb Sp 3 Clontarf, Sch, Dublin St. 3 Peters B 119177U 1 N ADSL Digiweb 1 S, Palmerstown, St. Dublin Pauls 2019178W G Barry N Irish Avenue, Digiweb S, Broadband Finglas St. 1 West, Pius Dublin19197D 1 11 St. 1 Pius 19207D Navan 1 Rd, Wireless Dublin Edenmore, St. Dalkey, Wireless 7 Raheny, Kevins Co. 1 Dublin B Dublin 1 5 1 N Wireless S, The19208F Adelaide & 1 Meath Hospital Wireless19209H 1 Irish Broadband Irish Irish 1 Islandbridge, Broadband 1 Broadband Dublin Holy 8 Spirit Ballyroan,19220S B Irish Rathfarnham, 1 Smart N Broadband Dublin Irish S 16 Broadband SN An Spioraid19221U Naiomh 1 1 C, 1 1 1 Wireless Wireless Scoil Wireless 1 Naomh Limekiln19242F 1 Ide, Rd, Greenhills, Wireless Dublin Scoil 12 Wireless Irish Naomh Broadband Aine,19258U 1 Incorporating 1 Greenhills, The Kimmage 1 National 1 West, Childrens Our Dublin Hospital Lady 12 Special of 1 Victories Infant Irish N Scoil Broadband S 1 Padraig ADSL 1 Naofa Digiweb Wireless B, 1 1 Barry 1 1 Avenue, 1 1 Irish Finglas Irish Broadband NorthWest, Broadband Dublin 11 Irish 1 Wireless 1 Broadband Sillogue 1 Rd, Ballymun, Dublin 1 11 1 Irish Broadband Wireless Silloge Smart Wireless Rd, 1 Baile Irish 1 Munna, Ballymun Wireless Wireless Broadband Atha Road, Cliath 1 Dublin 1 11 9 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband Clondalkin, 1 Dublin Wireless 22 Clondalkin, 1 Dublin 22 1 Wireless Hollypark, Foxrock, Wireless Dublin 18 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb Irish Broadband Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 947 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 948

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated est, Artane, Dublin 5 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 Beech Park Stillorgan, Co. Dublin. 9Dublin Dublin nBNS, KilmoreRdW 19259W19262L St. Patricks Gns,19297H St. Benedicts19298J N S, Cromcastle Gree 19302U Scoil Nais19303W Ide Cailini, SN Na Maighdine19308J Muire B, Na Maighdine Mhuire19309L St. Brigids19314E Boys N S, Scoil Neasain19316I Scoil Na19319O Maighdine Mhuire Foxrock Boy, Ave, Foxrock, Dublin St. 1819320W Pauls Hospital Grange Special Park, School Raheny, St. Dublin Olafs 5 N Ballymun,19321B S, Dublin 9 Kilmore Our Road Lady West, of Artane,19325J Good Dublin Counsel 5 Boys N Our S Lady Virgin19335M Good MaryGirls Counsel National Gns, School, Ballymun, Dublin Broadford St. 9 Rise, Ciarans19355S Balinteer, Spec Dublin Sch, 16 Scoil Na Howth Smart Aingeal, Beaumont, Road, Dublin Killester, 9 Dublin 519361N Ballyowen Meadows Digiweb Johnstown, Dun Laoghaire, Co.19373U Dublin Baile Harmain, Irish An Baile Broadband Irish Taonad Ath Broadband Reamhscoile19374W Cliath 5 St. Michaels Johnstown, Hse Dun19382V Sp Laoghaire, Sch, Co. Dublin Garran Mhuire, Local Wireless19385E Irish Loop Wireless Broadband Wireless Balally Scoil Drive, Eoin, Dundrum,19390U Dublin Smart 16 Finglas Irish Childrens Broadband St.19393D Centre, Irish Canices Broadband Rd, Wireless Glasnevin, St. Dublin Marks 11 Sen19395H NS, Newtownpark Ave, Mhuire 1 C/O Blackrock, Iosef Mary Co. Junior,19396J Wireless Immac Dublin Smart Irish Sch 1 Broadband Sraid For Wireless 1 Ruthland, Hearing Scoil Baile Impaired Mobhi 1 Atha Boys, Irish19400U Cliath Broadband 1 Raheny Local Na Road, Loop Maighdine19406J Raheny, Muire Dublin Girl, 5 Wireless SN 1 Glen Digiweb Irish Na19409P Broadband Gcaorach Wireless 1 Holy 1 Irish Trinity19430G Irish 1 Broadband Sen Broadband Finglas Goatstown, N 1 1 West, Dublin S, Dublin 14 Casa 11 Local 1 Caterina Loop S Wireless S, 1 Scoil19431I An Tseachtar Laoch Wireless 1 Wireless Armagh19435Q Irish Rd, 1 Broadband Wireless Crumlin, Dublin Springfield, 12 Tallaght, 1 Verbena Dublin St. Estate, 24 119437U Josephs Dublin Jnr, 13 1 1 1 St. Ballinteer, 1 Francis 1 Dublin 1 Xavier Smart 16 J N Wireless S, 1 Scoil19438W Naithi 1 Wyvern, Killiney Bothar 1 Rd, Mobhi, 1 Killiney, Glasnaoin, 1 Co. Baile 1 Scoil DublinDublin Atha Colmcille Cliath Senior, 1 1 9, Dublin Grange Road, 1 Donaghmede, 1 Dublin 1 1 Bothar 13 Bhaile 1 Irish 1 Munna, Broadband Baile Munna, Baile Cabra, Digiweb 1 1 Irish Atha Local Dublin 1 Broadband Cliath Irish Loop 7 Irish Broadband Broadband Irish 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 Broadband Wireless 1 1 Roselawn Wireless Irish Road, Broadband Wireless Wireless Castleknock, 1 Dublin 1 15 Balcurris, 1 Wireless Ballymun, Wireless Dublin Irish 1 11 1 Broadband 1 Wireless 1 Irish Wireless Broadband Wyattville, Ballybrack, 1 Co. 1 1 Dublin 1 Baile An 1 1 Wireless Tsaoir, Dum Droma, Baile 1 Atha Wireless 1 Cliath 1 1 16, Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Eircom 1 Irish 1 Broadband Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 949 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 950 Schools Installed Installed Activated Dublin 17 15 19440J19446V St. Marys19454U NS, Scoil Mhuire Boys, Darndale19456B Ns Junior19462T St. Cronan,19463V Naomh Maolruain,19464A Naomh Maolruain Senior,19465C SN Naomh Colmcille,19466E St. Kevins19470S Boys, St. Kevins19471U Girls, Grange Road, Rathfarnham, Grange Dublin Pk St. 14 View, Francis Our19472W Raheny, Xavier Lady Dublin Senior Immac 5 N Jun St. S, NS, Pauls Darndale, Junior Malahide19473B National Road, School St. Marks Junior19474D N Old S, Bawn, Tallaght, Irish Dublin Broadband Scoil Old 24 Bhride, Bawn,19480V Tallaght, Dublin 24 Brackenstown, Scoil Swords, Colmcille Co. Naofa, Dublin19489Q Homelawns, Tallaght, Dublin Irish 24 St. Broadband Patricks, Wireless19490B SN Coolmine, Naomh Ayrfield, Castleknock, Finnin Irish19494J Malahide Dublin Broadband Rd, 15 Dublin Kilnamanagh, 13 Tallaght, Scoil Dublin Mhuire, Wireless 2419496N Kilnamanagh, Tallaght, Dublin Bishop 24 Galvin19497P NS, Wireless Scoil Fhiachra Soisir,19499T 1 Springfield, Irish Tallaght, Broadband Dublin Scoil Eircom 24 Mhuire,19500B Irish Broadband St. Oliver Irish Knocklyon,19502F Punkett Broadband Templeogue, Sp 1 Dublin Sc 16 Phoenix Wireless Park19503H Spec Donaghmede, Irish Sch, Dublin Broadband Wireless 13 Irish 1 Scoil Broadband 1 Aenghusa Irish19505L Jun Broadband NS, Wireless Scoil Chronain Glenties Irish ADSL Park, Broadband Rivermount, St. Finglas Wireless Patricks South,19509T Close, SN Dublin 1 Dublin Oilibheir Wireless 11, 8 Wireless19510E Ballyboden, Orwell Dublin 1 Park, Digiweb 1 Beaumont, Wireless 16 Scoil Templeogue, Irish Dublin Nano Dublin Broadband 519515O Nagle, 16 1 1 Digiweb Talbot Senior 119520H NS, Alma Place, Carrigbreannan, SN Blackrock, Naomh Co. Treasa,19524P Dublin Wireless 1 1 Phoenix 1 Park, Shankill, Dublin Co. St. 1 8 Dublin Josephs Special19533Q 1 Sch, 1 Balrothery, Tallaght, Dublin 1 Wireless Irish 24 Our 1 Broadband Lady19535U 1 Irish Immac 1 Broadband Sen N Wireless 1 S, S N Muire19537B Agus Iosef, Irish Broadband Brackenstown Senior 1 1 Smart Sraid N19538D Wireless Mor, S, 1 1 Rath Wireless Cuil, 1 1 Co. St. Atha Attractas Cliath Junior 1 N S, Baile St. 1 Wireless 1 An Kevins 1 Bhlacaigh, Junior 1 Cluain Bawnoge, N Saileach, Clondalkin, S, Baile Dublin Irish Atha 22 Broadband 1 Cliath 1 Bawnoge, Clondalkin, Smart Dublin 22 Smart Baile Balrothery, 1 1 Brigin, Tallaght, Co. 1 Dublin Ath 1 Irish 24 1 Cliath Broadband Darndale, Wireless 1 Dublin Wireless 1 17 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 Smart Smart 1 Brackenstown, Bayside, Swords, Sutton, 1 Co. Dublin Wireless 1 Dublin 13 Wireless Meadowbrook, 1 ADSL 1 1 Dundrum, 1 Dublin ADSL 1 16 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Newbrook Ave, 1 1 Donaghmede, 1 Dublin Irish 13 Broadband 1 Satellite ADSL Irish 1 Broadband BT 1 Ireland 1 1 Wireless 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Digiweb 1 1 Irish Irish Broadband Broadband HERMES 1 1 Wireless 1 ADSL 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 951 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 952

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated 22 22 Dublin 16 Dublin Baile Atha Cliath 8 19541P19542R Belgard Heights19543T N S Esker N S19545A Scoil N19546C An Croi Ro Naofa, Corduff N S,19549I St. Oliver19556F Plunkett N S St.19565G Fintans NS St. Killians19566I Junior School, Scoil Treasa Firhouse, Scoil19569O Ard Our Mhuire, Lady Belgard Queen Heights, Killinarden, of Tallaght, Tallaght, Apostles Dublin Dublin 24 24 Neillstown19574H N Irish S Broadband St. Marley19575J Thomas Grange St. NS, NS Helenas Esker, Drive, Lucan, Finglas, Co. Dublin Wireless Dublin19576L 11 Corduff, Castleview, Blanchardstown, Tallaght, Dublin St. Dublin 15 Marys 2419577N Junior N S, S N Queen19578P Aenghusa Scoil of Carrickbrack Treasa Apostles Rd, Ballycullen NS, Sutton, Ave, Clonburris, Scoil Dublin Firhouse, Clondalkin, Iosa 13 Dublin Dublin 24 Eircom19579R St. Digiweb Helens Smart Junior N 1 S19582G Irish Digiweb Archbishop Broadband Mc Quaid19583I NS, St. Irish Maelruains Broadband St. N Peter19589U S Apostle NS, Neillstown, Divine Clondalkin, Word Dublin NS, St. Wireless Irish Marley Josephs ADSL Broadband Grange, Senior 1 Rathfarnham, Wireless N S Gaelscoil19590F Inse HERMES Wireless Chor Rowlagh, ADSL Irish Clondalkin, Broadband Dublin 2219594N Wireless Wireless Physically Disabled19601H Children Irish Broadband Youth Scoil Encounter N Wireless Project, Aenghusa19605P Sin, St. Balrothery, Helens Loughlinstown, Tallaght, St. Junior Dun 1 Dublin 1 Wireless Philip N Laoghaire, 24 The S, Co.19611K 1 Apostle Martello, Dublin Junior 1 Portmarnock, N Co. Wireless Scoil S 1 Scoil Nais Irish Nais Iosa,19612M Broadband Mhuire Tymon Sois, North, 1 Tallaght, 1 Dublin Scoil 24 Naomh Colmcille,19613O 1 Kilclare Irish Avenue, Dalkey Broadband Jobstown, School St. Tallaght, Project, Josephs Dublin19617W Senior 24 1 1 Wireless Smart NS, Deansrath, Balcurris, Scoil 1 Old Ballymun, 1 Cnoc Irish Irish Nangor Dublin 1 700701 Mhuire Broadband Broadband19618B Road, 11 An Sin 1 Clondalkin, Cuarbhothar 1 Dublin Theas, St. 22 Droichead Martin Na Wireless De 1 Mountview, 1 Hinse,19619D Porres 1 Blanchardstown, 41 Smart N Dublin Main S 15 St, Finglas, St. Dublin Pauls Irish Irish 1119623R Sen Broadband Broadband Wireless Wireless NS, Irish Broadband St. Malachys 1 NS,19624T 1 1 St. 1 1 Pauls 1 Jun ADSL Blakestown,19625V NS, Mulhuddart, Wireless Wireless 1 Dublin 1 15 Wireless Newbrook Scoil Rd, Nais 1 Donaghmede, Caitriona, 1 1 Dublin 13 S Glenageary N Local Lodge, Realt Loop Irish Glenageary, Na Broadband Co. Mara, Dublin 1 1 1 Knockmore 1 Ave, 1 Killinarden, Tallaght, Aylesbury, 1 Dublin 1 Old 24 Bawn, 1 Tallaght, Dublin Wireless 1 24 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 1 HERMES Irish Digiweb 1 Irish 1 Broadband Broadband Ayrfield, Malahide Rd, 1 Dublin 13 Wireless 1 Rivermount, Finglas, Dublin 11 1 1 1 Wireless Greenhills, 1 Wireless Digiweb Kenure, Walkinstown, 1 1 Rush, 1 Dublin 1 Co. 12 Dublin 1 Wireless Thomas Hand 1 1 Wireless St, Skerries, Co. Dublin 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 Digiweb Irish 1 Broadband 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 ADSL 1 Wireless Wireless 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 953 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 954 Schools Installed Installed Activated 19627C19628E John Paul19630O Ii N S, St. Fiachras19636D Sen N S, Warrenstown Hse Sp19641T Sch, St. Patricks Senior19642V School, St. Colmcille19643A Jun NS, St. Peter Apostle19644C Sen NS, St. Philips Senior19646G N S, St. Ciarans19647I N S, Scoil Santain,19652B Corduff Road, Blanchardstown, Sonesta, Beaumont, Dublin Malahide, Montrose, St. 15 Co. Dublin19658N Marys Dublin Corduff, 5 Sen Blanchardstown, N Dublin S, 15 An Chroi19660A Ro Naofa Sois, Bishop Shanahan NS,19661C Wyattville, Neillstown, Rush Ballybrack, Clondalkin, NS, Co. Dublin Dublin 2219662E St. Gabriels Smart19663G NS, Mountview, Clonsilla, St. Dublin Michaels 1519668Q NS, St. Raphaels NS,19669S Irish Broadband St. Hartstown, Francis Smart Smart Dublin Senior19676P 15 N S, Killinarden, Lady Tallaght, Bothar of Dublin19693P Na Good 24 Habhann Counsel Rowlagh, Wireless Mor, NS, ADSL Clondalkin, Tamhlacht, Dublin Scoil Ath Smart 22 Aine Cliath Irish19694R Naofa, 24 Broadband Orwell Park, Templeogue, Dublin Mary 16 Queen19702N of Ireland N S, Scoil Irish Mhuire Broadband Sin,19705T Irish Wireless Broadband ADSL ADSL St. Thomas Junior19707A N S, Dominican Campus, Catherine 1 Ballyfermot, Rush, Mc Wireless19716B Dublin Co. Auley 10 Dublin N 1 Sc, Dominican ADSL Wireless Convent, St. Ballyfermot, Ronans Dublin N19721R 10 S, Priorswood, Mourne Dominican Dublin Rd, Convent, 17 Drimnagh, Smart Ballyfermot, St. Dublin Dublin Attractas 12 1019723V Senior Irish N Broadband Irish S, Broadband Holy 1 Family Junior Irish19727G Toberburr, N Broadband Co. 1 S, 1 1 Dublin Queen Irish of Broadband 1 Angels19742C Primary Esker, School, Lucan, 1 Wireless Co. Smart Wireless St. Dublin Marys 1 Central19743E N 1 S, Wireless Irish Broadband St. Colmcille19755L Senior Wireless Jobstown, N Blakestown, 1 Tallaght, Local S, Mulhuddart, 59 Dublin Loop Dublin Lower 24 St. 15 Baggot Bernadettes Street, 1 119757P Junior Dublin N 2 S, 1 Sacred Wireless Irish Heart 1 119762I Broadband N S, 1 Wedgewood, St. Dundrum, 1 Meadowbrook, 1 Michaels Dublin Dundrum, 119764M Spec 16 Dublin Satellite Sch, 14 Deansrath, 1 Forest Clondalkin, St. Fields, Dublin19765O Helens 1 Smart Swords, 22 Wireless Senior 1 Irish Co. N 1 Broadband Dublin S, Our Lady of 1 119766Q Wayside N S, 1 St. Thomas Senior 1 1 1 N Irish Belmont Irish S, Broadband 1 Ave, Broadband 1 1 Donnybrook, Scoil Wireless Irish Knocklyon, Dublin Iosagain/Mhuire, Broadband Dublin 4 1 16 Quarryvale, Irish 1 Clondalkin, Broadband Dublin Irish 22 1 Broadband 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 Digiweb ADSL Digiweb 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Huntstown, Irish Hacketstown, Mulhuddart, Broadband 1 Skerries, Smart Dublin 1 Co. 1 15 Dublin 1 1 1 1 Bluebell, Martello, Inchicore, Portmarnock, Dublin Co. 12 Irish Dublin 1 1 Broadband Wireless Wireless 1 1 Jobstown, Wireless Tallaght, 1 Dublin Smart 24 1 1 Mount 1 La Salle, 1 Ballyfermot, Wireless 1 Dublin 1 1 10 ADSL 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 HERMES 1 1 ADSL 1 Wireless 1 Digiweb Irish 1 Broadband 1 Wireless 1 Irish 1 1 1 Broadband 1 1 1 ADSL 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 955 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 956

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Cliath 5 Dublin 7 /Seosamh, Mount La Salle, Ballyfermot, Dublin 10 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 ´ 19767S19769W Scoil Mhuire 19774P Scoil Thomais,19775R St. Josephs19777V Mxd N S, Scoil Cnoc Mhuire Junior Gaelscoil19782O Mide19785U St. Brigids N19793T S, St. Bernadettes Senior19799I N S, St. Thomas19817H Special Sch Sacred19819L Heart N S, St. Knockmore Marys Ave, Laurel N19831B East Killinarden, Lodge, S Wall, Tallaght, Castleknock, Dublin Dublin Dublin 3 24 15 St. L19834H O’Tooles 2 Spec, Scoil Chaoimhin19837N St. Irish Aidans Broadband Bothar NS,19840C Quarryvale, An Clondalkin, Ghleantain, Dublin Ghlais 22 Cill Drimnagh Bharrog, Castle Baile CBS19845M Atha N S, Holy Brookfield, Family Irish Tallaght, Clonshaugh,19850F School, Broadband Wireless Dublin Priorswood, 24 Coolock, Dublin Digiweb North 17 Dublin Project,19855P Ladyswell N19859A S, Wireless Sruleen, Clondalkin, Dublin Gaelscoil 22 Chluain19865S Dolcain Aldborough Parade, Trinity North House Strand, Irish School,19872P Dublin Broadband Woodview, 1 Esker, Digiweb 1 Lucan, ADSL Co. Archbishop Dublin Irish Ryan19877C Broadband N Drimnagh Sraid S, Castle, Mhaoilbhride, Dublin Baile 12 Scoil Atha Chaitlin Cliath19878E Maude 1 Wireless 1 Holy Brookfield, Family Irish Tallaght,19888H Senior Broadband Dublin N Wireless 24 S Dunedin Park, Ballycragh Irish Monkstown, N Broadband Ballymun Co. 119889J S Road Dublin (Behind Wireless Esso), St. Glasnevin, Annes Dublin Mxd19893A 9 Bothar N Wireless Nangor, S, 1 Cluain Irish Dolcain, Broadband Baile Scoil Irish Atha Colm, Wireless19895E Broadband Cliath 22 Smart St. Digiweb 1 Kilians Ladyswell, Senior Mulhuddart, Lusk, N Dublin Co. S, 15 Dublin Digiweb 119896G Scoil Mhuir Wireless S 1 Iosaf Balgaddy, Wireless Lucan, Co.19898K Dublin Irish 1 Broadband Digiweb 1 Scoil Cnoc Caitriona Mhuire, Na 119901T Tamhlacht, Mbraithre, Baile Irish Forest Atha Broadband Fields, Cliath 1 Gaelscoil River 1 24 An Valley, Duinninigh Swords,19904C Wireless Co. Dublin Wireless 1 Local Booterstown Loop N19907I S, Wireless 1 Wireless 1 Holy Cross 119913D N Ballycragh, S, Stonebridge Firhouse, Road, 1 Tallaght, Wireless Shankill, 1 Irish Digiweb Dublin Co. Broadband 24 Gaelscoil Dublin Smart19919P Mologa 1 St. Castleview, 1 Josephs Tallaght, NS, Dublin19920A 24 Baggot 1 1 St, 1 Dublin St. 2 1 Davids Wireless Armagh19922E N Road, Smart 1 S, St. Crumlin, 1 Marys Dublin 1 St. Place, 12 John Plas of Mhuire, 1 God Off N Dorset Draighnean, 1 S, Street, Feltrim 1 Our Sord, Wireless Digiweb Ladys Co. 1 N Baile Irish S, Atha Broadband Cliath 1 Irish Broadband ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 Cross Broadband 1 1 Ave, Wireless Blackrock, 1 1 Co. Irish Wireless Dublin Local Broadband Loop 1 1 Upper Irish Kilmacud Satellite Broadband Road, 1 Dundrum, Bothar Dublin Wireless Chlareville, Irish 1 14 Baile Broadband Atha Cliath 1 6w 1 Wireless 1 1 Macroom Road, 1 Bonnybrook, 1 Wireless Dublin 1 17 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Kilmore Kilmore Road, Road, Artane, 1 Smart Artane, Dublin Dublin 1 5 5 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 Smart St. Columbanus 1 1 1 Road, Milltown, Irish 1 Dublin Broadband 1 14 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 1 Wireless 1 1 ADSL 1 Wireless 1 1 Irish ADSL Broadband Smart Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 957 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 958 Schools Installed Installed Activated Baile Atha Cliath 22 Dublin 24. Road, Dublin 8 9 Cliath 16 Chabrach, Bac 7 19924I19926M Harolds19928Q Cross N S, Gaelscoil Cholaiste Mhuire,19929S Ranelagh Multi Denom19933J NS, St. Brigids19935N Senior Girls, Scoil Treasa19938T Naofa, Scoil Eoin,19939V St. Josephs,19940G 4 Scoil Cearnog Naisiunta Pharnell, An19943M B.A.C. Dea 1 Aoire, Gaelscoil Ranelagh Naomh Road, Padraig19945Q Dublin Harolds 6 Cross, Dublin St. 6w Damiens NS,19946S Rathfarnham Educate Finglas Together,19949B West, Dublin 11 Rutland Street19950J N S, Islamic Petrie National Road,19954R School, Donore Whitehall Avenue, Road, Dublin Churchtown, 8 Dublin St. 14 Dominics19960M N S, North Bay National19962Q School Leamhcan, Project Irish Co. Loreto Broadband Baile St. Greendale Avenue, Atha Johns Road, Rathfarnham, Cliath N Dublin Dublin19979K S, 5 14 Tivoli Oberstown Road, Boys Dun Centre, Laoghaire,19981U Co. Irish Dublin Broadband Irish St. Wireless Broadband Kevins N19988L S, Beechfield Smart Irish Close, Broadband St. Walkinstown, Marys Dublin N 1219991A S, Greendale Avenue, 19 Wireless Kilbarrack, Roebuck St. Dublin Irish Road, Marys Wireless Lower 5 Broadband Clonskeagh, National Rutland Dublin School, Street, 14 Dublin Irish 1 Gaelscoil Broadband20005V Wireless Na Camoige Irish20010O Broadband Irish 1 Broadband Wireless Scoil Tallaght, Plas Dublin Mhuire, 24 Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband St.20012S Lusk, Roses Co. Special Dublin School HERMES 1 Wireless 1 Digiweb Wireless Irish Broadband20014W Griffith 1 Ballybrack, Barracks Co. Wireless N Dublin S 120015B Grange Road, St. Baldoyle, 1 Agnes Dublin Wireless N 13 Sallynoggin, S, Co. Smart 1 Dublin 1 Wireless 120020R Gaelscoil Bhaile 1 Munna Aras Windsor Chronain, Ave, Bothar 1 Wireless Fairview, An Dublin20021T Ulloird, 1 1 3 Cluain Dolcain, Gaelscoil Thaobh Na20028K 1 1 Coille, 1 Henrietta CSLSLO Street Scoil20029M School, Aengusa St. Smart 1 Sns, Marys 1 Balrothery, Place, 1 Tallaght, Dorset Setanta Street, Special Dublin School, 120035H 7 ADSL 1 1 1 St. Irish Brigids Broadband Infant20043G Irish N 1 1 The Broadband S, Old Guardhouse, St. Irish Griffith 1 Gabriels Broadband College, N South S, 1 Digiweb Circular Irish 1 Gaelscoil Broadband20047O Chnoc 187 Liamhna Wireless Bothar 1 1 Choultrai, Smart Irish Wireless 1 Baile Broadband Munna, Cill ADSL Baile 1 Tiarnain, Atha Wireless B.A.C. 1 Irish Cliath 18 Armagh Gaelscoil Broadband 1 Road, Bharra 1 Irish Crumlin, Broadband 1 Dublin Wireless 12 1 1 Irish Broadband Henrietta Wireless 1 St, Dublin 1 Satellite Wireless 1 Beechpark, Wireless Stillorgan, Co. 1 1 Dublin 1 1 Wireless 1 1 Local Loop Wellmount 1 Avenue, 1 1 1 Finglas West, 1 Dublin Halla 11 1 Na Ngasoga, Bothar 1 Cnoc Liamhna, 1 Baile Atha Cowper Street, Irish 1 1 Dublin Broadband 7 1 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 Irish Irish 1 Broadband Naomh 1 Broadband 1 Fionnbarra Wireless C.L.G., Ascal Digiweb An Fhasaigh, An Wireless 1 1 Wireless 1 Irish Wireless 1 Broadband 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 959 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 960

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Raghnallach, Baile Atha Cliath 6 Fuiseoige, Fionnbhru, B.A.C.9 Cliath Dublin 15 Road, Cabra, Dublin 7 Road, Dublin 7 Road, Fairview Dublin 3 Dublin Portrane Educate Together Ballisk Common, Off Portrane Road, Donabate, Co. Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 ´ 20048Q Gaelscoil20052H Lios Na Nog Gaelscoil20053J Cholmcille20056P Cheeverstown Sp20059V Sch Gaelscoil Phadraig20060G Mother of Divine20064O Grace Monkstown Educate Together20066S NS, Our Teach Lady Fhiodh of20091R Cuilinn, Consolation 21a NS, Bothar Oakley, Lucan Multi20092T Denominational NS St. St. Kevins Peters Boys NS,20095C Club, Br Crestfield, Cnoc St. Na Ultan’s National Monkstown School, Grove, Rowan Blackrock, House, Co.20098I Gaelscoil Cheeverstown, Dublin Brian Templeogue, Boroimhe Dublin 6 Irish20103V Holy Broadband Ascaill Faith Shileann, NS, Baile Ferndale Breac, Ave, Co. Castleknock DIGIWEB Ballygall, Collins Atha20104A Educate Dublin Bewley Ave Cliath Together 11 Way, East, Smart NS Willsbrook, Donnycarney, Lucan, Dublin John Co. 5 Scottus Dublin NS,20109K Wireless St. Audoens NS,20121A Smart Digiweb Ballydowd Special School,20130B Irish Cherry Satellite Broadband Orchard St. Avenue, John Dublin of 10 God Special Smart Beechpark Seanbhaile, School, Avenue, Bothar20131D St. Castleknock, Chill Patricks Irish Dublin Dheaglain, Local NS Broadband 15 Sord, Loop Contae Phibsboro, Wireless Atha 1 Dublin 7 Smart Educate Wireless20136N Together NS ADSL Wireless20137P 1 Crannog Nua Special20139T School, Irish 1 Broadband Mary Ballyowen, ADSL 1 Mother Palmerstown, Glenageary, Northumberland20141G of Dublin Co. Road, To Hope 20 Dublin Dublin be NS, 4 1 decided Inchicore NS,20145O Cook Street, 1 Dublin 8 The ADSL Wireless Harold School,20152L 1 1 1 Swords Educate Together 1 NS, To be decided20153N North Dublin 1 Muslim 1 Ns Project CSLSLO CSLSLO CSLSLO 1 St. The St. Joseph’s High Mochtas 1 School Support NS, For Unit, Porterstown St.20154P The Portrane, Road, Joseph’s Deaf, Co. Clonsilla, Adolescent Navan Dublin Irish Digiweb & 1 Broadband Family 1 1 Ser20161M Littlepace, Irish 1 Digiweb Castaheany, Broadband 1 Dublin Smart 15 Beaumont 1 Hospital Special School Irish Broadband Donabate 20166W 1 Wireless 1 1 Swords, Co. Dublin Irish Wireless CSLSLO Broadband20168D 1 St. Josephs School St. Griffeen For Eden Vincent’s Valley 1 The Road, Hospital, Educate Wireless Deaf, Satellite20173T Glasthule, Convent Together Sarsfield 1 1 Navan Co. Avenue, NS Road, Dublin Richmond Inchicore, Smart Dublin Glasnevin Satellite 10 Educate Together Wireless NS, 1 Local St. Loop St. Raphaels Annes Ward, Primary Digiweb Beaumont Irish School, 1 Hospital, 1 Broadband Dublin 1 9 Smart 1 1 Griffeen Glen Boulevard, 1 Lucan, 1 Co. 1 Dublin. 1 1 Wireless Smart 1 Wireless 1 1 Church Avenue, Glasnevin, Dublin Irish Irish Wireless 9 Broadband 1 Broadband 1 Irish ADSL Broadband 1 1 1 Smart 1 Fettercairn, Tallaght, Wireless Wireless Dublin 1 24 1 1 1 ADSL Wireless 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 961 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 962 Schools Installed Installed Activated LOC, To be decided To be decided 1 ´ osa, To be decided To be decided 1 ´ thair, Co. Atha Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 ´ alaigh, 12u thar Maelı ´ ´ irse ´ thair Stigh Lorgan, Co. Atha Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 ´ thair, Bo ´ Dublin SANDYFORD, DUBLIN 18 LEAMHCA/N, Cliath Fionnglas, Dublin Cliath thar Stigh Lorgan, Baile An Bho ´ in CSLSLO W.F.T.R.A. Hall, Bo ´ in Bo ´ Hearca de New Road, Clondalkin, Dublin 22 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ ´ Ongar Ed. Tog. N.S., Beechpark Avenue, Castleknock To be decided To be decided 1 ´ iste Eoiniste Iosaga Baile An Bho iste Brı ´ ´ ´ 20176C20186F Rush Lusk Educate Together NS20187H Clonee 20190T Archbishop Ryan Senior N.S.,20201V Holy Trinity N.S.20202A Hanna’s Avenue, Tyrellstown Blakes Ed. Cross, Tog.20220C Corduff, N.S., Lusk, Co. Balbriggan Ed. Tog. N.S.,20223I Gaelscoil Uı Digiweb Balgaddy, Lucan60010P Gaelscoil Eiscir Riada60021U Loreto Secondary60030V School, St. Marys Tyrellstown, Secondary60040B Dublin School, Satellite 15 CSLSLO PAROCHIAL Blackrock HOUSE, College, ST.60041D MARY’S, Balbriggan, Willow Park School Cola 60042F To be decided Cola CSLSLO 1 A/rus CLG Na Balbriggan, Sa 60070K Co. Dublin Baldoyle, Dublin 1360081P To be To decided be Dominican decided College,60090Q Rockford Manor 160092U Secondary Schoo, Blackrock, Co. To Rathdown Dublin be School decided60100Q To Rock 1 be Road, Clonkeen decided Blackrock, College Co.60120W Dublin Castleknock College, Mount To Sackville be Secondary decided 160122D Scho, Stradbrook To Rd be Blackrock, decided 1 Co. Dublin60130C Cola BT60140F Ireland Sion Hill, Loreto Blackrock, Abbey 1 Co.60160L Secondary Irish Dublin To School, Broadband be decided Irish Mount Broadband Anville60180R 1 Secondary School, Chapelizod, Dublin Notre 20 Dame Glenageary,60240J Des Dun Missions, Laoghaire, Wireless Co. Digiweb ADSL Dublin Christian BT Brothers Clonkeen Ireland College60250M Road, Wireless Castleknock, Blackrock, Dublin Co. 15 1 Dublin Loreto College,60260P Dalkey, Holy Co. Child Dublin Secondary60261R School Mount Anville St. Rd, Joseph Dublin60262T of 14 Cluny Digiweb Local Wireless Loop St. 1 Benildus College Digiweb60263V 1 1 St. Laurence College, Upper Digiweb Churchtown Road, Dublin St. 14 Josephs Monkstown College, Park, Dun Laoghaire, Co. Dublin 1 Military 1 Irish Wireless Road, Broadband Killiney, Co. 1 1 1 Dublin Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Foxrock, Dublin Wireless Digiweb 18 Digiweb 1 Bellevue Digiweb Park, Ballinclea Wireless Digiweb 1 Rd, Upper 1 Killiney, Kilmacud Co. Rd, 1 1 Dublin Stillorgan, 1 Blackrock, Loughlinstown, Co. Dublin 1 Dublin 18 Irish Broadband Lucan, Smart 1 Co. Dublin Wireless Digiweb 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless Satellite 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 Irish Broadband 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Wireless Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity x 60050E Oatlands Collegex 60121B Moyle Park College, Mount Merrion, Blackrock, Co. Dublin Smart Clondalkin, Dublin 22 ADSL 1 Smart 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 963 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 964

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated , Baile Atha Cliath 7 Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ s Long Mile Road, Walkinstown, Dublin 12 Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ id Rı ´ draig CBS Roselawn, Lucan, Co. Dublin Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 ´ s, Griffith Avenue, Dublin 9 Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 ´ iste Pha iste Choilmiste Mhuire, Dublin Road, Swords, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Bothar Rath To Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ ´ ´ 60264A60272W Cola 60290B The Kings Hospital,60291D St. Pauls60300B College Ardscoil La Salle60310E Manor House Da La60321J Salle College60340N Rockbrook Park60341P School Loreto High School60342R Palmerstown, Dublin Sancta 20 Maria60343T College Colaiste Eanna CBS60361V Sybil Hill, Raheny, St. Dublin Joseph’s 560370W Secondary Raheny School Road, Raheny, St. Dublin Raphaela’s 5 Secondary60380C School St. Fintan’s Upper High Churchtown Watermill School Road, Road, Churchtown, Raheny, Dublin Dublin 14 5 St. Edmondstown Dominic’s Road,60383I High Rathfarnham, School Dublin 1660390F Beaufort, Digiweb Grange Cola Rd,60400F Rathfarnham, Dublin Ballyroan, Convent 14 Rathfarnham, Lane, Dublin Upper Rush, St. 16 Kilmacud Co. Josephs Road,60410I Dublin C.B.S. Digiweb Stillorgan, Co. Ballyroan, Smart Dublin Rathfarnham, St. Dublin Vincents 1660420L C.B.S. Digiweb Glasnevin, Digiweb C.B.S.60430O James Street, Smart Digiweb Dublin Ardscoil Wireless Road, Rı Sutton,60440R Dublin Santa 13 Sabina, Greenfield Smart St. Rd, Pauls Sutton, C.B.S.60450U Dublin Wireless 13 O’Connell School,60470D ADSL Wireless Wireless Digiweb Cola 60471F Irish Glasnevin, Wireless Broadband Dublin Smart Synge 11 Street Irish Local Cbs,60480G Broadband 1 Loop St. David’s60481I C.B.S. Merville ADSL Ave, Fairview, Wireless 1 Meanscoil Dublin Iogna 360490J Wireless Wireless 1 Smart James’s 1 St. Street, 160491L Aidan’s Dublin C.B.S. 8 1 1 1 C.B.S. Westland60500J Row, ADSL St. Declan’s60510M College 1 Christian Brothers, North Marian Nth 1 Richmond College,60511O 1 Brunswick Street, 1 Street, Dublin 1 Dublin 1 1 St. 1 7 Johns 1 College60520P De La 1 1 ADSL Salle Beneavin 1 De La Irish60530S Synge Salle Broadband Street, College Smart Dublin 8 Belvedere Digiweb College,60540V 1 Malahide 1 Road, Artane, 1 1 Dublin Gonzaga 5 College 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Catholic University School, Westland Collins 1 Row, 1 Avenue Dublin Smart Ext, 2 Whitehall, Dublin 9 1 Digiweb Nephin Le 1 Road, Fanu Wireless Cabra, Rd, Local Dublin Ballyfermot, Loop 1 7 Dublin Beneavin 10 1 Road, 1 Finglas, Dublin 11 1 1 1 Ballsbridge, 1 1 Dublin 1 4 1 1 1 Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Wireless 1 6 89 1 Gt Lower Denmark Leeson 1 Street, Street, Smart Dublin Dublin 1 2 1 Sandford 1 1 Road, Ranelagh, Dublin Digiweb 6 1 Digiweb Smart Wireless Smart 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Digiweb 1 Digiweb Wireless 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb 1 1 ADSL ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity x 60320H St. Columba’s College,x Whitechurch, 60381E Dublin 16 Sutton Park School Smart St. Fintans Road, Sutton, Dublin 13 ADSL Smart 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 965 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 966 Schools Installed Installed Activated on, Ath Cliath 9 Digiweb Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ , Glasnaı ´ thar Mobhı ´ 60550B60560E Chanel College,60561G St. Marys60562I College, St. Michaels College,60570H Templeogue60571J College, Terenure College60581M Patrician College60590N St. Kevins College60630W St. Conleths College60640C St. Killian’s Deutsche60650F Schule Coolock, Dublin Sandford 5 Park Rathmines,60660I School Dublin Ltd Ailesbury 6 Road, Dublin St. 4 Andrews60670L College Templeville Road, Dublin 6w St.60690R Patricks Cathedral G.S, The High Templeogue60700R School Road, Terenure, Dublin 6w Dominican College60710U Deanstown Ave, Roebuck Finglas Road, Scoil West, Clonskeagh, Chaitriona Ballygall Dublin Dublin Rd60720A 11 14 East, Finglas, 28 Dublin Clyde Muckross 11 Road, Park Ballsbridge, College,60731F Dublin Sandford 4 Road, Saint Ranelagh, Dominic’s Dublin Secondary 660732H Scho, St. Dominics Digiweb60741I College, St. Patricks Booterstown Caritas Close, Ave, Digiweb College Dublin Digiweb Blackrock, 8 Co.60750J Dublin Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb St. Digiweb60770P Michaels Secondary School Holy Digiweb Faith60791A Secondary Danum, School Digiweb Zion Griffith Ballyfermot, Road, Ave, Dublin St. Rathgar, Drumcondra, 10 Mary’s60792C Dublin Dublin Secondary Wireless 6 9 School Digiweb Donnybrook, St. Dublin Marys Wireless 4 Wireless Secondary60800V School Bo Digiweb Wireless Wireless Wireless Presentation College, Wireless60810B Loreto College, Wireless60820E Cabra, Wellmount Dublin Wireless Road, 7 Loreto Finglas, College, Dublin60840K 11 1 Smart Wireless 1 Loreto Belgrove College, Digiweb Road,60841M 1 Clontarf, 1 Dublin Drumfinn Wireless 3 Smart Road, Maryfield Holy 1 Ballyfermot, College Faith 1 1 Dublin60843Q Convent, 10 Glasnevin, 1 Dublin Rosary 11 College St. Brigids60851P Road, Killester, 1 Dublin St. 5 Josephs 1 Secondary60852R 1 School, Digiweb Assumption 1 1 1 Secondary60853T Wireless Warrenmount, School, Wireless Dublin 1 Digiweb 8 1 1 Smart Mater Christi 1 160860Q Local Loop Digiweb Digiweb Mount Smart Carmel 160870T Secondary School, Crumlin 1 Road, Our Dublin Ladys 12 School60871V 1 Swords, 1 Wireless Co. Our Dublin 1 Lady 160872A Irish of Broadband Mercy Stanhope 1 College, 1 1 St, 53 Wireless 1 1 1 Dublin St. Mercy 7 Stephens College Glandore Digiweb Green, 1 Walkinstown, Coolock60890C Road, 1 Dublin Dublin Drumcondra, ADSL 2 12 Dublin 9 Mercy Wireless Wireless Secondary School 1 Wireless Armagh Kings 1 Local Road, Inn St. Loop Crumlin, Street, Louis Dublin Dublin High 12 1 1 School 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 Wireless 1 Beaumont, Cappagh, 1 1 1 Dublin 1 Finglas, Smart 9 Dublin 1 11 1 1 Digiweb Templeogue Rd, Terenure, Dublin 1 6w St. Digiweb Brendans Drive, 1 1 Coolock, Dublin Goldenbridge, 1 5 Inchicore, 1 Dublin Digiweb 8 Irish 1 Broadband Wireless 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb 1 1 Charleville 1 Road, Rathmines, Dublin Local Digiweb 6 Loop Wireless Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 Digiweb 1 Wireless 1 Smart 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Smart Wireless 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Local 1 Loop Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 967 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 968

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated in Thuaidh Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 ´ in, Baile Atha Cliath 22 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 1 1 ´ in, Br Thigh Motha ´ Co. Dublin Tamhlacht, Baile Ath Cliath 24 thar Nangor, Cluain Dolca irc Thigh Motha ´ ´ iste De Hide Pa iste Chilliainiste Eanna Bo iste Eoin Kilkieran Road, Cabra, Dublin 7 Cappagh Road, Finglas West, Dublin 11 Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ´ ´ ´ ´ 60891E60892G Our Ladys60902G Grove, The Teresian School60910F St. Pauls Secondary60930L School, Alexandra College,60990G Rosemont School60991I Meanscoil Chroimghlinne61010U Our61020A Lady of Mercy Secondary Wesley Sc College,68071G Stratford College Greenhills, Goatstown Dublin70010V Road, 12 Dublin 12 14 Stillorgan John Road, Scottus Donnybrook, Secondary70020B Dublin School 4 Balbriggan Community College70021D Milltown, Grange Dublin Community 6 314/318 Mourne College Crumlin Road, Road, Drimnagh, Crumlin, Dublin Cola 70030E Dublin 12 12 Temple Road, Blackrock, Co.70040H Dublin Irish Broadband Senior College70041J Dunlaoghaire 74/76 Morehampton Deansrath Rd, Community Donnybrook, College70042L Dublin Pine 4 Ridge, Chapel St., Ballinteer, Wireless Balbriggan, Collinstown Dublin Smart Co. Park 1670050K Dublin Community Irish Col 1 Broadband Zion St. Road, Kevin’s Rathgar, Grange Community Dublin Road, College 6 Donaghmede, Digiweb Dublin Digiweb Dun70060N 13 Laoghaire Digiweb College of Irish Broadband Wireless70070Q BT Ireland Dundrum Eblana College Avenue,70080T Dun New Laoghaire, Nangor Co. 1 Road, College Dublin Clondalkin, of Wireless Dublin Neilstown Further ADSL70081V 22 Rd., Education Rowlagh, Digiweb Clondalkin, Dublin Lucan 22 Wireless Community Wireless70090W College Wireless Fonthill Road, Riversdale Irish Clondalkin, Community Broadband Dublin ADSL College,70100W 22 1 Sallynoggin College of Digiweb70110C BT 1 Ireland Digiweb Cola Further Education, Cumberland Wireless70120F Smart St, 1 Dun Wireless Laoghaire, Irish Broadband Stillorgan 1 College70121H of Further 1 1 Education Dundrum, Main 1 St. St, 1 Finians Dundrum,70130I Community Dublin BT College, 14 Ireland Fingal Local Blanchardstown 1 Community Wireless Loop Sydenham Rd Esker College70140L Road, North, Wireless Drive, 1 Dundrum, Dublin Digiweb Lucan, Dublin 15 Co. Wireless 14 Dublin 1 Greenhills70141N College Old Dublin 1 1 Rd, Stillorgan, Firhouse Local 1 1 Co. Community Loop 1 Dublin70150O College, 1 Jobstown Local Community Further Loop 1 College Education,70160R Pearse 1 St, 1 Sallynoggin, Digiweb Cola Co. Dublin Swords,70170U Co. 1 1 Wireless Dublin 1 St. Kevins 1 1 Digiweb 1 College70180A 1 Digiweb 1 Irish 1 Crumlin Broadband College 1 Seatown of 1 Road,70190D Further Swords, 1 Education Co. 1 Dublin Cola Digiweb 1 Digiweb Firhouse 1 Road, Dublin Colaiste Wireless 24 Ide Wireless 1 Jobstown, Tallaght, 1 Dublin 24 1 Limekiln 1 1 Wireless Avenue, 1 Greenhills, 1 Crumlin Dublin Wireless Rd, 12 Crumlin, 1 Dublin 1 1 12 1 Wireless Wireless 1 1 1 Irish 1 1 Broadband 1 Clogher 1 Road, 1 Crumlin, 1 Dublin 12 Irish 1 Broadband Digiweb 1 Wireless 1 1 Digiweb 1 Irish Broadband Wireless 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 Cardiffsbridge Road, 1 Finglas West, Wireless Dublin 11 Wireless 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 969 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 970 Schools Installed Installed Activated de, Baile Smart Satellite 1 1 1 ´ n, Co. Atha Cliath Smart ADSL 1 , Domhnach Mı ´ ´ insı ´ n, Leamhca ´ fı ´ Atha Cliath 13 thar Mhainistir Na Gra ´ laigh Barryscourt Road, Coolock, Dublin 17 Smart ADSL 1 1 1 ´ iste Reachrann Bo ´ iste Dhu iste Cois Life Gleann An Ghrı ´ ´ 70200D70220J Technical Institute70230M Inchicore College70240P of Further E Killester College of70250S Further Education Kylemore College70260V Marino College70280E St. Mac Dara’s70290H Community Collins Colleg Avenue, Killester, Rathmines Dublin College 570300H Emmet Road, Ballsbridge Inchicore, College Dublin of70310K 8 Busines Pearse Cambridge College Road, Ringsend,70320N Dublin 4 Plunket College70321P Wellington Lane, Whitehall Templeogue, House Dublin Senior70330Q 6w College, Margaret Aylward Kylemore70340T Community Road, Col Ballyfermot, Dublin 10 Cola Digiweb70342A Shelbourne Road, Ballsbridge, 1420 Dublin Liberties Marino 4 College, Mart,76062B Digiweb Fairview, Dublin 3 Digiweb Ballyfermot Town College Hall, of Rathmines,76065H Irish Further Dublin Broadband Education 6 Swords Castleknock Road, Community Dublin76077O College 9 The Thatch Road, Cola Whitehall, Wireless Dublin 976078Q Digiweb Wireless Ballyfermot Clogher Larkin Road, Road, Community Dublin Crumlin, College,76085N 10 Dublin Wireless 12 Digiweb Swords Road, Wireless Skerries Whitehall, Community Dublin College, 9 Digiweb Gealchola 76092K Carpenterstown Road,81001I Castleknock, Dublin 1 15 Wireless Presentation College, Digiweb81002K 1 Digiweb Bull Alley Street, Wireless Newpark Dublin 181003M Comprehensive 8 School 1 Mount Temple Wireless 1 Comprehensive81004O Champions Sch, Avenue, Irish Digiweb Dublin Boys Broadband Skerries, 1 Comprehensive Co. School, Dublin81015T Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Girls 1 Comprehensive 1 School,91301D Wireless Wireless 1 Ballymun Wireless 1 Senior91302F Comprehensive 1 Holy Newtown Family Malahide Park Community91305L Road, Avenue, School Dublin Blackrock, 1 3 Co. Wireless Dublin Phobailscoil Iosolde,91310E Terenure, Wireless Dublin Wireless 6w 1 Wireless Ballinteer 1 Community91315O School, Ballymun Road, 1 1 Dublin 1 Cabinteely Digiweb 1 9 Community 191316Q School, 1 Smart Ballymun, Digiweb Ballymun Dublin Scoil Road, 9 Phobail 1 Ballymun, Chuil Dublin91318U Mhin, 9 Blakestown Kilteel Community 1 Road, School,91324P Rathcoole, Co. Dublin 1 1 The 1 Donahies 1 Community 1 1 School, BT 1 Ireland 1 1 Portmarnock 1 Wireless 1 Community School Ballinteer, Dublin Wireless 16 1 Local Cabinteely, Loop Dublin 18 Palmerstown, Smart 1 Dublin 20 1 1 Smart 1 1 Blanchardstown, Dublin ADSL 15 1 Streamville 1 Cluain Road, Saileach, Esat Dublin Baile 13 Irish Smart 1 Atha Broadband Cliath 15 1 Carrickhill 1 Road, 1 1 Portmarnock, Co. Dublin 1 Wireless Local Irish 1 Loop Broadband 1 Local 1 Loop 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 Wireless ADSL Irish Broadband Smart Digiweb 1 Smart Irish Broadband 1 Irish 1 Broadband 1 Smart 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Wireless 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Wireless ADSL 1 1 ADSL 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 971 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 972

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated 91325R91330K Malahide Community School91332O Holy Child Community91335U School St. Marks Community91336W School Tallaght Community School91337B Old Bawn Community91338D School Killinarden Community91339F School Broomfield, Malahide, St. Co. Aidan’s Dublin Community91342R Pearse School St, Sallynoggin, Co. Hartstown Dublin Community91343T School Cookstown Rd, Pobalscoil Tallaght, Neasain, Dublin91344V 24 Balrothery, St. Tallaght, Tiernan’s Dublin91510M Community 24 Old School Bawn, Tallaght, Rosmini Dublin Community 24 Killinarden, School Tallaght, Dublin 24 Pobail Scoil Naomh00885T Brookfield, Coilm Tallaght, Cille Dublin 24 Irish Broadband01309L Hartstown, Clonsilla, Dublin Irish 15 Ratoath Broadband Junior01421F N S, Irish Stackallen Parkvale, Broadband N Balally,02905J S, Wireless Dublin 16 Kilskyre Mixed Wireless03275H N S, Baldoyle, Grace Digiweb Dublin Park S 13 Scholarstown Road, N Wireless04210H Rd, Drumcondra, Naomh Knocklyon, Dublin Padraig, Dublin 9 16 Irish Newtown Broadband N Digiweb S,05062A Kilmessan Mxd N05630L S, Irish Broadband 1 Kells Parochial Wireless N07120V S, Digiweb 1 Scoil Wireless Mhichil09238I Na Buachailli 1 Wireless Digiweb Killyon Ratoath, N Co. S, Wireless10801Q Digiweb Meath Irish Broadband Ballinlough11039O 1 N S, Drumbarragh Kilskyre, Stackallen, N Kells, Navan, 1 S,11978O Co. Co. Meath Meath 1 Wireless Kilbeg Baile N Bacuin, S, 1 Wireless12068D Enfield, 1 Co. Meath Scoil Wireless Mhuire 1 NS,12488C Wireless Irish 1 Broadband Kilmessan, Our Co. Lady Newtown, Meath of Scoil Ardee,12788O 1 Mercy Na Co. NS, Mbrathar, Louth Patrick Kells, Oldcastle Street, Co. Mxd Trim, 1 1 Meath12897T N Co. S, Meath Wireless Flowerfield 1 1 N S, 113775K 1 1 Ughtyneill N Digiweb 114348T 1 S 1 St. Patricks N15104T 1 S, Smart Killyon, BT Cnoc Smart Ballinlough, Ireland Carrickleck An Kells, Drumbarragh, N Dun, 1 Co. 1 Digiweb Kells,15483H S, Co. Meath Co. Meath 1 Meath Bride 1 Naofa 1 116067V 1 N S, 1 St. 1 Louis Kells, N 1 Wireless 1 Co. S, Moylagh, Meath Oldcastle, Kilbeg, Co. Digiweb Scoil Carlanstown, Meath Nais Co. Finin ADSL Meath Naofa, Digiweb Chapel Satellite 1 St, Satellite Oldcastle, Satellite 1 Co. 1 Meath 1 1 Trim 1 Rd, 1 Navan, Co. 1 Digiweb Meath Digiweb 1 1 Satellite Ughtyneill, Smart Moynalty, Digiweb Kells, Co. Meath Trim, Co. Satellite 1 Meath 1 1 Carrickleck, 1 1 Kingscourt, 1 Co. Meath 1 Digiweb Cannistown, Digiweb Navan, 1 Co. Meath Clonard, 1 Enfield, Satellite 1 Wireless Co. Meath Smart Rathkenny, 1 Satellite Navan, 1 Co. ADSL Meath 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Digiweb 1 Irish Satellite Satellite Broadband 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Wireless Smart Digiweb 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 Satellite 1 Wireless 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity Meath 00883P Aine Naofa N S, Navan, Co. Meath Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 973 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 974 Schools Installed Installed Activated 16100Q16143L Mercy Convent N16549Q S, S N16646O Pheadair Agus Phoil, Knockcommon N S,16655P St. Marys Convent16722E N S, Scoil Nais16774A Ma Dearmhai, Scoil Cholmcille,16790V Scoil Nais An16825O Obair, S N Naomh16991I Seosamh, Navan, Drumconrath, Kilbride Co. Navan, National Meath Co. School,17029S Meath Carnaross17088L N S, Knockcommon, Beauparc, S Co. N Trim, Meath17123K Naomh Co. Cianain, Meath Longwood, S Enfield, N Co.17162U An Meath Athar Ui Gramhna, Kilmainham Wood N17175G S, S N Bhrighde,17203I Navan Road, Nobber, Kells, Bohermeen Co. Co. N Meath Meath S,17213L Clonee, Dunsany, Smart Co. Co. Meath Meath S17220I N Digiweb Ultain Naofa, S N17312N Mhuire, S17480L N Rathcairn, Bhrighde, Co. Na S Midhe Cushenstown, Irish Smart N Ashbourne, Broadband Carn Cul Co.17494W Na An Meath Ros, Mhuilinn, Ceannannas Mor, S Kilmainham Co. N Wood, Satellite Na17513A Baile Kells, Satellite Mi Cheant, Co. Meath S N An Wireless17520U Rath Mhor, Smart Digiweb S N Cill17521W Bhrighde, S N Baile Mhuire,17560J Corr, Kells, Bohermeen, Co. Satellite Navan, S Meath Co. N Meath Colmcille, Smart17623H Digiweb Digiweb Domhnach 1 Padraig, 1 An Digiweb S Uaimh, N17629T Co. Irish Seosamh Na Broadband Naomtha, 1 Midhe Scoil Digiweb Wireless Nais Ui17652O ADSL Gramhna, Culmullen, Ma Drumree, Nealta, Co. Esat S Ceannanus Meath N Mor,17705J Padraig Co. Meath Naofa, Na Hill, Wireless Midhe Drumconrath, Scoil Co. Oilibheir Meath 1 Naofa, 117741N 1 Baile Digiweb Satellite Satellite Cheant, Satellite An Rathmore, Uaimh, S Satellite Athboy, Co. 1 N17742P Co. Na Cros Meath Mi Ban, Scoil Satellite Nais Aitinn17821L Kilbride, 1 Bhui, Trim, Co. Smart Meath Scoil Digiweb Nais 117839H Mhuire Digiweb Naofa, 1 Scoil Satellite 1 Nais Dun17840P 1 Mhuire Doire, Naofa, 1 An Robinstown, Satellite Uaimh, Navan, S Co. Co. Athboy, Scrin, N 1 1 Na Meath Co. Tara, Digiweb Bheinn 1 117856H Mi Meath Co. Naofa Digiweb Meath B, 1 1 S N17857J Bheinin 1 Naofa C, 1 Smart S N Wireless Ard Dun Coillcluana, A’chatha, Uabhair, Satellite Co. Garristown, Satellite Na 1 Co. 1 Mi Dublin S Digiweb N 1 Aindreis 1 1 Naofa, 1 1 1 1 1 Beauparc, Satellite Navan, Satellite Co. Meath Kiltale, 1 Dunsany, 1 Co. Meath Whitecross, Digiweb Julianstown, Enfield, 1 Co. Co. Meath Digiweb Meath Satellite 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Digiweb 1 1 1 Duleek, 1 Co. Meath 1 1 Duleek, Co. 1 1 1 Meath Smart Satellite BT 1 Ireland 1 Satellite Dun 1 Ubhair, 1 Drogheda, 1 Satellite Co. 1 Louth Curraha, 1 Ashbourne, Co. Smart Smart Meath 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Smart 1 1 Digiweb 1 ADSL Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 BT 1 Ireland Satellite Satellite 1 1 Satellite 1 Satellite Digiweb Smart 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 BT 1 Ireland 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 ADSL Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 975 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 976

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated Louth Meath 17930Q17946I S N Seachnaill17947K Naofa, Scoil17964K Nais Naomh Aine Maio Scoil Naomh Bride,17969U S N Mhuire17986U Naofa, S N Mhuire,18016O S N Nmh18037W Sheosamh, S N Columbain,18040L S N Tierworker, Mhuire, Kells,18044T Co. Dunshaughlin, Meath Co. Meath S N18051Q Naomh Padraig, S N18106P Naomh Padraig, Coole Boardsmill, N.S, Trim, Co.18132Q Meath S N Rathfeigh,18169Q Na Tara, Trionoide Co. Naofa, Meath S N Muire,18174J Boyerstown, S Navan, N Co. Rath Meath18195R Riagain, An Uaimh, Co. S Na N18344I Mi Caitriona Naofa, Digiweb Baile St. Iomhair, Finian Co. N Na18358T S, Midhe BT Slane, Ireland Co. S Meath18413B N Mhuire, Baile Ui Earain, Stamullen, S Baile Co. N Loibin, Meath18429Q Fiach, Co. Na Smart Mi S Lios N Muilinn,18448U Naomh Cros Treasa, An Greallaigh, Satellite Co. S Na N Midhe Smart Mhuire,18453N ADSL Garradice, Smart S Kilcock, N Co. Rath18500T Kildare. Beagain, S N Mhichil18762D Baile Naofa, Smart An Bhothair, Dun Baile Carlanstown, Digiweb S Boinne, Oirthir, Kells, N Co. Ceannanus Co. Satellite Naomh Na Mor, Meath Colmcille, Smart Midhe Co. Na S18767N Midhe Smart N 1 Realt Na Mara (B) Satellite 1 Clonalvy, Garristown, Satellite S18887A Co. N Meath Realt Na Smart Mara (C)19018A Moynalvey, Satellite Summerhill, Bellewstown, Digiweb Smart Satellite Scoil Co. Smart Drogheda, Nais Meath Co. Maol19216E Louth Hosae, Smart 1 1 Dangan Baile Satellite Mixed Na N Criadh,19253K S, Oldcastle, ADSL 1 Co. Meath St. Rath 1 Ultans Beagain,19292U Special Dun Cul Sch, Seachnaill, Ronain, Co. Baile 1 Na Cill, Iomhair, Wilkinstown Digiweb Midhe Rath Co. N Cnoc Molladhain, Meath S,19300Q Hanobhar, Co. Drogheda, Na Satellite Co. Mi Louth Castletown Wireless 1 N Domhnach 1 S, Cearnaigh, 1 Mornington, Satellite 1 Satellite Drogheda, Digiweb Co. Castlejordan Central Satellite NS,19486K 1 1 1 Digiweb Domhnach Smart Cearnaigh, Mornington, Smart 119560T 1 Drogheda, Co. Digiweb Irish Broadband Scoil Satellite Nais Kilcock, Deaglain, Co. Kildare 1 St. 1 Digiweb 1 Marys 1 Special Irish School, Broadband 1 Irish Satellite Broadband 1 Dangan, 1 Wireless 1 Summerhill, Co. Flower Meath 1 Hill, 1 1 Navan, Digiweb Satellite 1 Co. Meath 1 Satellite Satellite Wireless Satellite Wireless Wilkinstown, 1 Castlejordan, Navan, 1 Tullamore, Co. 1 1 Co. Meath Offaly 1 Satellite 1 1 Navan, Co. 1 Meath 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Ashbourne, Johnstown, Co. Navan, 1 1 1 Meath 1 Co. 1 Meath 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Satellite 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite 1 BT Ireland 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 Satellite 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity x 19476H St. Oliver Plunkett NS, Navan, Co. Meath Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 977 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 978 Schools Installed Installed Activated th Cairn, Athboy, Co. Meath Smart Satellite 1 1 1 1 ´ iste Pobail Rath Cairn Ra ´ 19671F19725C St. Pauls19768U N S, Gaelscoil Eanna,19779C Scoil Mhuire,19813W Gaelscoil Na19867W Cille, Kildalkey Central N20017F S, Scoil Na Rithe,20032B Scoil An20033D Spioraid Naoimh, Dunboyne Junior20051F N S, Dunboyne Senior N20082Q S, Gaelscoil Na20164S Boinne, Br. Ath Abbeylands, Throim, Navan, Gaelscoil An Co. Dhun Uaimh, Meath Buinne, Co.20179I Na Midhe Navan Cill Kildalkey, Ashbourne, Educate20180Q Dheaglain, Co. Co. Together Ashbourne, Meath Meath NS Co. Meath St.20191V Stephens Laytown, NS, Co. Meath. Scoil Naomh Eoin20200T Dun St. Seachlainn, Peters Co. National20215J Irish Na Dunboyne, School, Broadband Mi Co. Meath Ratoath Senior20216L Dunboyne, School, Co. Meath. St. Paul’s76088T N.S., Dublin BT Wireless Irish Road, Dun Ireland Broadband Trim, Rock Buinne, Scoil Co. Lodge, Co. Oilibheir, Meath.64350N Flower Na Hill, Mi Navan, Co.Meath. Rathoath College,64360Q St. Wireless Patrick’s Classical64370T School St. Joseph’s BT Secondary ADSL64410F Ireland Dunboyne, School Smart Co. Meath C/O Loreto St. 1 Secondary Clonmagadden Marthas Smart64420I School Valley, College, Windtown, Johnstown, Navan, Co. Irish Co. Meath Broadband Eureka Smart Meath Ratoath, Secondary64450R School, Franciscan71950F College, Smart 1 Smart ADSL Digiweb Scoil Mhuire Wireless71960I BT Digiweb Ireland 1 Moatlands, St. 1 Navan, Peter’s Satellite Co. Ratoath,71970L College, Meath Mercy Convent, Smart Navan, Bettystown, ADSL Co. Community Fairyhouse Meath71980O College, Racecourse, Rathoath ADSL St. 1 Fintinas Post Primary St. Scho Michaels, O’Carolan Wireless ADSL Navan, ADSL College, Co. ADSL71991T Meath Kells, Satellite 1 Co. 1 1 1 Meath72010I Smart 1 Cola 91456J ADSL 1 Gormanstown, 1 Beaufort Co.91495T College Meath 1 Digiweb St. 1 1 1 Ciaran’s91508C Smart Community To School be 1 Longwood, 1 1 1 decided Enfield, 1 Ashbourne 1 Co. Community Dunboyne, Meath 191517D School Co. Convent Meath of Dunshaughlin, Mercy, Co. Trim, Boyne Meath Co. Community ADSL To Meath School, be decided Smart Athboy Community 1 1 School, 1 To be Nobber, 1 decided Co. Wireless Meath 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL To To 1 To be be Navan be decided decided Rd, decided Kells, Co. Meath Deerpark, Ashbourne, Co. Meath Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Smart ADSL Trim Digiweb Rd, 1 Navan, Smart Co. 1 Trim, To Meath 1 1 To Co. 1 be 1 1 be Meath decided 1 decided Athboy, Co. Meath 1 1 Smart BT Ireland 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 Wireless Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 BT Ireland 1 Digiweb Smart ADSL 1 ADSL 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 Wireless Satellite 1 Digiweb Smart 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity xx 71990R St. Oliver Post Primary Oldcastle, Kells, Co. Meath Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 979 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 980

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated ichael’s St, Tipperary BT Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 Thiobrad Arann Tipperary Cashel, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 Borrisoleigh, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 hBNS, yGNS, St.M nBNS, 00606M01285A Monard N S,01569O Tipperary Jnr. Bn01594N S, Ballycahill N S,01862M St. Johns,02237R Tipperar 02428B Dualla N S02670I Lackamore N04005G S, San04067F Isadoir, S N Naomh04075E Peadar, Tipperary, Convent Co. of Tipperary04620D Mercy, Monard, Solohead, Co. Tipperary Moyglass N05144C S, Ballycahill, Thomastown Thurles, N Co. S,06658P Tipperary New In 06789H Kildangan Roscrea, N Co. S Tipperary07048Q Lisronagh N Newport, S, Co.07245S Dualla, Tipperary Cashel, Co. Tipperaryy Mohober N S,07358I Horse Digiweb And Jockey, Thurles, Co. Cullen Bothar Tipperary N08316U Leathan, S, Cashel, Newport, Digiweb Smart Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary S08903M N Sceichin A Rince Newtown N S,09190G Moyglass, Thomastown, Fethard, Fethard Golden Co. Convent, Cashel, Tipperary Co.09432E Tipperary Satellite Boher Smart N S,09967U Satellite Convent of10120P Mercy, ADSL BT Digiweb Cill Ireland Digiweb An Upper Daingin Newtown Pocon, N Aonach10533R S, Urmhun, Co. Digiweb Digiweb Lisronagh, S Clonmel, N11367I Co. Mhuire Tipperary Na Trocaire, 1 Ballydrehid N Mohober, S,11384I Mullinahone, Co. Tipperary ADSL An ADSL Chuirt 1 Portroe Smart Doite, Smart11453B N An S, Satellite Chathair, Smart Satellite Co. Cullen, Thiobraid Gurtagarry Co. Arann 111470B N Tipperary S, Satellite Satellite Lisnamrock Newtown, N Fethard, Solohead,11605V S Co. Co. 1 Tipperary Digiweb Tipperary Slieveardagh N S, 1 Rosegreen11872V N Tipperary, Digiweb S Co. Tipperary 1 Upper Digiweb Newtown, 1 1 Satellite Boher, Carrick12124K Satellite Cahir, 1 Killaloe, On 1 Co. Co. Suir, Satellite Tipperary Clare Co. Clochar Tipperary Na Toirbhirte,12180U 1 1 1 Rear Satellite N S, Presentation Cahir, Primary 1 Co. School, Digiweb Tipperary 1 BT Satellite 1 Ireland 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Nenagh, Toomevara, 1 Co. 1 Nenagh, Tipperary Digiweb Co. Tipperary Coalbrook, Thurles, Smart 1 Co. Tipperary The Commons, Thurles, 1 Co. Leased Satellite Tipperary Line 1 1 BT 1 Presentation Ireland 1 1 1 1 Convent, Cnocan 1 Carrick 1 An Clonmel, On Digiweb Teampail, 1 Co. Suir, Rosegreen, Tipperary Co. Cashel Tipperary Co. 1 1 Satellite Smart 1 Smart 1 ADSL Digiweb 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Newport, Digiweb 1 1 Co. Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Tipperary Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Smart ADSL ADSL 1 Satellite 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite Satellite Satellite 1 1 BT Ireland 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Local 1 1 Loop 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity Tipperary 00590A Borrisoleig 981 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 982 Schools Installed Installed Activated Cronans NS, Roscrea, Co. Tipperary Smart ADSL 1 1 1 1 Meala, Co. Thiobraid Arann aNSNo2, St. 12349L12540B S N Muire Na Naingeal13014I Clonmore N13210I S, S13404V N Naomh Padraig, St.13678M Josephs National School, Convent of Mercy,13847J Killurney N S13867P Hollyford N13991Q S, Clochar Na Roscre Carthanachta, Sraid14008S Mortuin, Cluain Birdhill N S,14181J S Ballingarry, N14426N Thurles, Bhride, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Fethard, Templemore, Poulicapple Co. Co. N14460N Tipperary Tipperary S, Knockavilla N S,14791N Killea N New S, Inn,15008A Cashel, Co. Tipperary Cappawhite N S,15157R Shronell N Wireless Ballypatrick, S,15299O Clonmel, Co. Tipperary Mount Bruis Hollyford, N15362S Digiweb Co. S, Tipperary Gaile N S,15560W S N15696B Michil Naofa, Killaloe, Co. Bishop Digiweb Tipperary Harty NS,15778D 1 Callan, Dun Silvermines Co. Digiweb Na N Kilkenny Sciath, Digiweb15795D S, Curraghpoor, Satellite Dundrum, Co. Co. Tipperary St. Tipperary Digiweb Marys N15970S S, St. Marys N16059W S, Cappawhite, Co. Satellite Tipperary Templemore, Ballytarsna 1 Co. N16077B Tipperary S, Emly N Satellite S, Digiweb16111V Satellite Lattin, Mount Tipperary Bruis, Digiweb Tipperary Ardfinnan 1 Satellite Town, N Co.16112A S, Tipperary Killusty N S,16166A Mullinahone, Thurles, St. Co. Marys 1 Holycross, Tipperary Ballinree, Convent, Thurles,16211C 1 Nenagh, Co. Digiweb Co. Tipperary Tipperary Carrig N S,16250M Satellite 1 1 Digiweb Nenagh, 1 Satellite Co. Two Tipperary BT Mile Ireland Digiweb16276H Borris N 1 S, Templetuohy N S, Nenagh,16344V Co. Smart Tipperary Digiweb Carrig 1 N 1 S, Templemore,16725K Co. Satellite Tipperary Cashel, St. Co. Marys 1 Tipperary Jnr.16727O Smart 1 B 1 N Leased Satellite S, 1 Line S N 1 Mhuire 1 Satellite Na Digiweb Mbraithre, Digiweb Scoil Clonmel, Emly, Na Co. Co. Mbraithre, Tipperary Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Nenagh, 1 Co. Satellite Tipperary Fethard, Co. Tipperary 1 1 1 1 1 Thurles, 1 Co. Satellite 1 Tipperary 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 Birr, Satellite Co. Thurles, Offaly Co. Tipperary Satellite 1 Smart Eircom 1 Carrick 1 1 On Suir, Nenagh, Co. Co. 1 Tipperary Tipperary 1 1 Ballycommon, 1 Nenagh, Digiweb 1 Co. Tipperary 1 1 Satellite Nenagh, Co. 1 Tipperary 1 Smart 1 1 1 Digiweb ADSL 1 ADSL BT Ireland Digiweb 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Smart 1 1 Smart 1 Smart 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite ADSL Satellite 1 1 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 BT 1 Ireland 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Smart 1 Satellite Satellite 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 983 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 984

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated 16728Q16729S St. Marys N16810B S, St. Peter16835R And Paul, Eochaille Ara16933R N S, S N Naomh16979S Treasa, Loch Mor Maigh17114J N S, Scoil Colmcille,17140K S N17179O An Ghabhailin, S N Baile17237C Sluagh, S N An17244W Cillin, S N Clonmel, Irishtown,17276M Cill Co. Clonmel, Barfhionn, Tipperary Co. S Tipperary N Naomh Newtown,17296S Ruadhain, Nenagh, Co. Tipperary Scoil Na Borrisoleigh, Mbraithre, Thurles,17332T Co. Tipperary Templemore, Co. Tipperary S N17486A Baile Na Hinse, St. Marys17498H Parochial School, Templemore, S Co. N Cashel, Tipperary Cleireachain,17511T Co. Tipperary S N Naomh17512V Sheosamh, Thurles, BT Co. Ireland Tipperary S N17542H Baile An Iubhair, Smart S Digiweb N Coolbawn, Lorrha, Flannain17543J Birr, Nenagh, Nenagh, Naofa Co. Co. Co. Offaly Tipperary Tipperary S Smart N Rath17580P Chaomhghin, Tipperary, Co. Cloughjordan Tipperary Clonmel, Local N17608L Digiweb Co. Loop S, Tipperary. S N Birdhill,17620B Gort Limerick Na Huaighe, S Satellite N17621D Lua Satellite Naofa, Smart S N Toomevara,17634M Rois Nenagh, Clonmel, Mhoir Co. Co. ADSL Tipperary Tipperary S 1 N An17640H Digiweb Bhealaigh, Satellite Digiweb Thurles, Scoil Co. Ailbhe, Tipperary17653Q Digiweb Digiweb S Rath N Clonmel, Chobain, Colmain17665A Co. Roscre, Naofa, Tipperary 1 Co. Tiobrad Arann Castle 1 Iny N ADSL17679L S, S N BT Gleann17681V Cloughjordan, Ireland Guail, Satellite Co. 1 Thurles, Tipperary Satellite Co. BT 1 Tipperary S Smart Ireland N17694H Digiweb Brighde, Satellite Satellite S N 1 Na17703F Maighne, 1 Digiweb S N Lorrha, Chluainin, Digiweb Nenagh,17712G Co. Tipperary ADSL Clonoulty, S 1 1 Smart Goolds N Clonoulty,17731K Cross, Ard Goolds Local Co. Croine, 1 Cross, Loop Tipperary Co. S Tipperary 1 N 1 Chiarda17779P Satellite Naofa, ADSL Digiweb Tir 1 S Da N 1 1 Glas, Thurles, Iosef Nenagh, Co. Naofa, 1 Co. Tipperary Tipperary Satellite Smart Powerstown N Satellite S, 1 Digiweb Luach 1 Magh, Thurles, 1 Templemore, Co. 1 1 Co. Tipperary 1 1 Tipperary Satellite Digiweb Digiweb 1 Smart 1 Satellite 1 1 Digiweb 1 Fantan, 1 Thurles, Borrisoleigh Co. Thurles, Tipperary Co. 1 Tipperary Satellite 1 1 Satellite Clonmel, Digiweb 1 Co. 1 Tipperary 1 1 1 Digiweb Nenagh, Kilkeary, Co. Nenagh, Tipperary 1 Satellite Co. 1 1 Tipperary Satellite 1 1 1 Satellite Satellite Templemore, Digiweb 1 Co. Tipperary Smart 1 Clonmel, 1 Co. Tipperary 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Digiweb 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Digiweb 1 Digiweb ADSL 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 BT Ireland 1 1 1 1 Satellite Satellite 1 1 BT Ireland 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite ADSL 1 1 1 Leased 1 Line 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 985 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 986 Schools Installed Installed Activated 17783G17799V S N Chuirt17850S Doighte, S N Na17940T Haille S N18062V Phadraig Naofa, S N18085K Na Mbuachailli S N An18087O Grainseach, Ballyneale N S,18135W S N Odhran18164G Naofa, Scoil Angela,18207V S Cahir, N Co. Buirgheas, Tipperary18213Q S N Baile18285S An Atha, S Pairc N Na Leamhach,18322V Coille, An Borrisokane, Mhoin Co. Ard, Tipperary Co. S Tiobrad Tulach N Arann Seasta,18326G Cill Newport, Chuimin, Co. Tipperary S Clonmel, N Co. An18343G Tipperary Droma, S N Naomh18345K Padraig, S Carrick N On Baile Chaoimhghin, Suir, Na18350D Digiweb Co. Cloiche, Tipperary Silvermines Nenagh, S Co. N Tipperary Iosef18369B Naofa, S N Ursuline Na18379E Convent, Digiweb Hinse, Thurles, Digiweb Co. Digiweb Tipperary S Nenagh, N Co. Killaloe,18396E Cill Tipperary Co. Digiweb Ruadhain, Clare Barnane N18435L S, Satellite Thurles, S Co. N Tipperary18443K Rath Eilte, Thurles, Co. Tipperary Sacred Heart18459C Primary Satellite School, Satellite BT Cill Smart Satellite Ireland S Thurles, Chais, N Co. Clonmel, Digiweb Iosef18465U Tipperary Co. Naofa, Satellite Tipperary Scoil Mhuire, Baile18486F Dhaith, Thurles, Co. Tipperary S 1 N Lios18501V An Halla, Cor An S Bhile, N18512D Roscrea, Leased Cill Co. Line Siolain Tipperary Grangemockler 1 1 NS, Nenagh, Satellite Thurles,18528S 1 Co. Co. ADSL Tipperary Tipperary Newline, Roscrea, Scoil 1 Digiweb Co. Phroinsias Tipperary Naofa,18538V 1 Annacarty Smart N Digiweb18557C S, Templemore, Co. Tipperary BT Scoil 1 Ireland Mhuire Thurles, Digiweb Co.18559G Tipperary 1 Digiweb 1 S 1 N18582B Teampall Doire, 1 BT Ireland 1 Eaglais, S Borrisokane, Digiweb Satellite N Co. Cill18716T Tipperary 1 Na 1 Naomh, Ballylooby N Cill Nenagh, S, Satellite Mheanman, Co. Leased Mullinahone Tipperary Line Thurles, ADSL Co. Cahir Tipperary B Satellite N BT S, 1 Ireland Carrick 1 Satellite On 1 Suir, Garryshane, Cill ADSL Co. Co. Siolain, 1 Tipperary Tipperary Clonmel, Digiweb 1 Co. Tipperary 1 Satellite Digiweb Digiweb 1 1 Digiweb Digiweb 1 Annacarty, ADSL Co. Tipperary 1 1 1 1 Nenagh, Co. 1 Digiweb Tipperary 1 Caislean 1 Nua, 1 Satellite Clonmel, Co. 1 1 Tipperary Killeen, 1 Nenagh, Satellite Satellite Co. 1 Tipperary Satellite Smart 1 Cahir, Satellite Digiweb Co. Tipperary Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Digiweb Satellite 1 1 Cahir, Co. 1 1 Tipperary 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 Satellite Satellite 1 1 BT 1 Satellite 1 Ireland 1 Satellite Digiweb 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 Leased 1 Line 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Smart 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 987 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 988

[Mr. N. Dempsey.] Schools Installed Installed Activated plemore Road, Cloughjordan, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite 1 1 1 1 Thiobraid Arann Arann Road, CarrickOnSuir, County Tipperary o1NS, Tem 18775M19230V S N Micheal19294B Naofa, Cormaic Special School,19305D Lisvernane N19356U S, Tankerstown N S,19370O Killenaule N S,19421F St. Annes Special19422H Sch, Kilross NS,19540N Cloughjordan N 19615S Cashel, Clogheen Holycross, Co. Central Thurles, Tipperary N19640R Co. S, Tipperary Scoil Aonghusa,19645E Scoil Mhuire,19677R Galbally, St. Co. Oliver Tipperary Tankerstown,19687U Plunketts Bansha, NS, Co. Tipperary Scoil Iosagain,19689B Roscrea, Co. Tipperary St. Killenaule, Josephs Thurles, Special Co.19690J Sch, Tipperary Bansha N19692N S, Smart Clonoulty Central19696V Clogheen, N Co. S, Tipperary Kilross, St. Co. John Tipperary The19874T Baptist Cashel BT Digiweb Deanery, Ireland19879G Cashel, Co. Scoil Tipperary Heywood Na Rd,19880O Toirbhirte, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary Naomh Padraig Satellite Lismackin, Junior,19937R Smart Roscrea, Co. Digiweb Tipperary Naomh Padraig Ferryhouse, Senior, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary ADSL Gaelscoil19968F Upperchurch Aonach Satellite Central Smart NS, Thurles, Co. Tipperary20007C Goolds Cross, Gaelscoil Co. Durlas20027I Tipperary Eile 1 Gaelscoil Digiweb Bansha, Satellite Chluain Co. Old Digiweb Meala ADSL Tipperary Road, Smart Cashel, Co. Tipperary20062K Gaelscoil Thiobraid Digiweb Arann 1 Cashel, Digiweb20085W 1 Co. Tipperary Presentation ADSL Drangan, BT Convent Thurles, Scoil Ireland NS, Co. Mhuire, Thurles, Tipperary Co. Tipperary Smart Drangan, Gaelscoil Thurles, 120129Q Charraig Co. Na Tipperary Siuire Wireless Satellite 120155R Scoil 1 Satellite Teampall Smart 1 Satellite Toinne, Bothar 165240L Naomh Chonlain, Satellite Leased Aonach Line St. Urmhumhan, John Co. The Digiweb65241N Durlas, Baptist Baile Co. Boys Gaelach, Tiobraid School Cluain BT Arainn 1 Meala, Presentation Ireland Morgaiste, Co. Secondary Baile65270U 1 Thiobraid School Thiobraid Arann Arann, ADSL BT Co. 1 St. Ireland Thiobraid Josephs 1 College65280A 1 1 Digiweb Digiweb C.B.S., CSLSLO 1 Carrick65300D Smart 1 1 1 Utd 1 Football ADSL Club, Digiweb Scoil Coolnamuck Mhuire 1 Smart Satellite ADSL 1 Smart Rockwell College, Cashel, Co. 1 ADSL Tipperary Borrisokane, Co. 1 1 Tipperary Ballyporeen, Digiweb 1 Cahir, Ballingarry, Co. Thurles, 1 Tipperary 1 Co. Tipperary Satellite Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite ADSL Smart 1 1 1 ADSL 1 ADSL 1 1 Borrisoleigh, 1 Satellite 1 Thurles, 1 Co. Tipperary 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 Smart 1 ADSL 1 1 Cashel, Co. Greenhill, Tipperary Smart Carrick CarrickOnSuir, On 1 1 Co. Suir, 1 Tipperary Co. 1 1 Tipperary 1 BT Ireland 1 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite Satellite 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 Satellite 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 Satellite 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Digiweb 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 Wireless 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 989 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 990 Schools Installed Installed Activated Corville Rd, Roscrea, Co. Tipperary BT Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 1 ´ s Cre ´ ithre, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary BT Ireland Local Loop 1 1 1 1 ´ il Ro ´ Cashel, Co. Tipperary 65320J65330M Ardscoil Na65340P Mbra Loreto Secondary School65350S Presentation Secondary65370B School, Patrician Presentation65380E St. Joseph’s65400H C.B.S St. Mary’s65410K Secondary School, St. Mary’s Secondary65440T School, Cistercian College, Clonmel,65450W Co. Coleville Tipperary Rd., Clonmel, Co. Our Tipperary Ladys65460C Secondary School, C.B.S. Thurles65470F Presentation Secondary Rocklow65490L School, Rd., Fethard, Co. Nenagh, Tipperary Co. Ursuline Tipperary Secondary65500L School, Newport, Co. The Tipperary Abbey72370P Summerhill, School Nenagh, Co. Tipperary St. Smart Anne’s72400V Secondary School Templemore, Co. Borrisokane Tipperary Community72420E College, Vocational Roscrea, Thurles, School, Co. Co. Tipperary72430H Tipperary Esat Central Smart Technical72440K Institute, Scoil Ruain Thurles, Co.72450N Tipperary ADSL O’donovan Nenagh Rossa Vocational St, School72470T Thurles, BT Co. Ireland Borrisokane, Tipperary Co. St. Convent Tipperary Joseph’s of College, Mercy,72480W Rosanna Road, BT Tipperary Ireland Town St. Sheelan’s Station72490C College, Road, Smart Tipperary Town, Satellite St. Co. ADSL Alibe’s Tipperary School76063D BT BT Ireland Ireland Vocational ADSL Clonmel, Smart School Co.76069P Tipperary 1 Colaiste CarrickOnSuir, Dun Co. Iascaigh Tipperary91497A ADSL Smart Colaiste Smart BT Phoba Dromin Ireland Road, Nenagh, Co. Cashel Tipperary Community ADSL Satellite 1 School, ADSL Dualla Road, 1 Smart 1 Smart Killenaule, Newport, ADSL Thurles, 1 Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary Templemore, Co. ADSL Tipperary BT Ireland 1 Satellite ADSL 1 Rosanna 1 Road, Tipperary 1 Town, Smart 1 Tipperary 1 Castlemeadows, Smart 1 Thurles, Cashel 1 Co. Road, Tipperary Cahir, ADSL Co. Smart Tipperary Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 ADSL ADSL 1 Smart BT Smart Ireland ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 Smart 1 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL ADSL ADSL 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 ADSL Satellite 1 1 1 1 1 ADSL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Total Connectivity Router Connectivity 991 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 992

Swimming Pool Projects. to say what level of interest there will be in the assets. 116. Mr. O’Donovan asked the Minister for The amount of monies paid in supports by Arts, Sport and Tourism if Cork County Council Enterprise Ireland to the company in County has submitted an application for the provision of Limerick since 1994 was \552,465. a new swimming pool at Dunmanway, County Cork or for the refurbishment of the existing Job Losses. pool; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32485/06] 118. Mr. Morgan asked the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment the number Minister for Arts, Sport and Tourism (Mr. of jobs lost in Donegal in 2005 and to date in O’Donoghue): In June 2002, Cork County 2006; the percentage of jobs lost which were in Council submitted the contract documents for the the textile sector; and the retraining initiatives refurbishment of the swimming pool in Dunman- provided to workers made redundant including way to my Department, under the terms of the the number of those made redundant which have Local Authority Swimming Pool Programme. availed of retaining provided by the State. Before the contract documents can be approved, [32444/06] the County Council has to address management and operational aspects of the pool, post refur- 119. Mr. Morgan asked the Minister for bishment. As soon as the County Council submits Enterprise, Trade and Employment the percent- to the Department its proposals in this respect, age of jobs in Donegal at present which are in the the project will be considered further. textile sector and the percentage breakdown by sector of other jobs in County Donegal. Grant Payments. [32445/06] 117. Mr. Ferris asked the Minister for Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employ- Enterprise, Trade and Employment the amount ment (Mr. Martin): I propose to take Questions of grants a company (details supplied) received Nos. 118 and 119 together. since 1994; and if he will make a statement on the The number of job losses in 2005 in Donegal, matter. [32443/06] for IDA Ireland and Enterprise Ireland sup- ported companies, totals 578, the majority of 121. Mr. Neville asked the Minister for which were in the textile sector. It should also be Enterprise, Trade and Employment if he has had noted that 648 jobs were created in IDA and EI discussions with interested parties with regard to supported companies in 2005. 2006 figures are not taking over a company (details supplied); if he yet available. will grant assist such a proposal; and if he will A breakdown of sectoral employment for 2005, make a statement on the matter. [32510/06] for Enterprise Ireland and IDA supported com- panies located in Donegal is set out in the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employ- attached tabular statement. ment (Mr. Martin): I propose to take Questions The Deputy will also be aware that there have Nos. 117 and 121 together. been significant job announcements in Donegal I should point out that responsibility for the recently. poultry sector rests with the Minister for Agri- SITA INC (Information Networking culture and Food. However, I have been in con- Computing) announced on the 31st March 2005 tact with the Minister in regard to the future of that it plans to expand its software operation in the company in question. My Ministerial col- Letterkenny, County Donegal, with the support league met with a group representing the pro- of IDA Ireland, which will lead to the creation of ducers that supply live chickens to the company 123 high quality software development jobs over on 3 October and I understand that various scen- a three year period. arios in regard to the operation were discussed. Zeus Industrial Products Inc. announced, on As regards my own area, Shannon Development the 22 September 2005, that it intends to set up a also met with this group on 9 October and the European Operations Centre in Letterkenny Industrial Training agency FA´ S is meeting with where it hopes to create 150 jobs over the next the company on 16 October. Shannon Develop- three years. ment will assist the group in whatever way it can In March 2006, Abbott announced its intention and is now awaiting further contact from the to establish a manufacturing facility in Donegal group. Town which will create 155 jobs while AssetCo I also met with representatives of the work- announced its intention to create 130 jobs in Lis- force on 11th of October 2006 and discussed a fannon with the support of Enterprise Ireland. number of issues which were of concern to them. Retraining of workers previously employed in The situation in relation to the future of the traditional sectors such as clothing and textiles is company is constantly evolving. I am aware that a very important element in the strategy to the assets of the company have now been adver- address the relatively difficult employment tised for sale by the Liquidator but it is too early situation in Donegal. FA´ S will continue to play 993 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 994 an active and very positive role in providing sup- Breakdown of sectoral employment for 2005, for Enterprise port to workers who have lost their jobs and Ireland and IDA supported companies located in Donegal require retraining to take up jobs in different sec- Enterprise Ireland tors. Services offered by FA´ S to workers losing their jobs and requiring retraining comprise the Sector Full Time Jobs following elements. There will be liaison with Senior Management in the Company affected % with regard to how the process will be conducted Textiles 6.4 and information sessions for all affected workers Clothing 11.5 if required. The aim of these sessions is to outline Drink/Tobacco 6.3 the range of support and services available from FA´ S and other public bodies. FA´ S Employment Food 31.5 Services staff conduct full registration interviews Furniture 3.4 with all workers. These interviews help assess Services 7.6 suitable career progression options for each Metals/ Engineering 14.7 redundant worker and identify their training and Mining/Quarrying 3.6 ´ development needs. FAS prepares a “Skills Misc. manufactured 0.4 Analysis Report” detailing a composite of the Non-metallic minerals 7.1 skills of the workforce. This is available to the Paper/Printing 1.2 development organisations such as IDA and Enterprise Ireland on request. A Skills/Training Plastics/Rubber 1.8 Aspiration List is also compiled to inform FA´ Sof Chemicals 1.0 the required re-training and upskilling needs of Wood/Wood products 3.5 the redundant workers. This training is delivered by various means, and existing scheduled training IDA programmes are delivered by our three training centres within the region, Letterkenny, Gwee- Sector Full Time Jobs dore and Sligo, or in the case of a specialist train- ing requirement, at any FA´ S centre throughout % the country. Contracted training and community Textiles 17 based training can also be availed of. In the past, Metals & Engineering 35 FA´ S increased dramatically its range of Contrac- Plastics/Non-metallic Minerals 1 ted Training Courses to meet the retraining needs of redundant workers. Special training needs not International Services 47 catered for by the existing FA´ S suite of prog- rammes can be facilitated through its Customised Training Fund, evenings/Saturday courses and e- Grant Payments. learning options. The provision of information, 120. Mr. Noonan asked the Minister for career guidance and advice is an ongoing element Enterprise, Trade and Employment if assistance of the service to redundant workers. Redundant is available from the State or any of its agencies, workers are given initial and on-going infor- to a person, who wishes to establish a restaurant mation and support to keep them “in touch with to promote Irish food in China; and if he will the labour market”. They are advised of the make a statement on the matter. [32473/06] “FA´ S Jobs Ireland” database which allows job- seekers to register their CV and source jobs via Minister of State at the Department of ´ the internet. They are also informed of the FAS Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Mr. M. Call Centre which provides a job matching facility Ahern): Assistance is not available from the for job-seekers and they are provided with infor- Agencies of my Department to establish res- mation on the Cross-Border and Eures websites. taurants at home or abroad. On the matter of Redundant workers who do not succeed promoting Irish food, the restaurant promoter through the above interventions will be referred might wish to contact Bord Bia, with a view to to FA´ S once again via the National Employment seeing if they can be of assistance. Action Plan Strategy, on reaching the 6 month unemployment threshold. They will then be Question No. 121 answered with Question assigned a FA´ S officer and become a caseload No. 117. client. They will be interacted with on a regular basis to assist their re-entry to the workforce. Community Employment Schemes. While most workers being made redundant 122. Mr. Connaughton asked the Minister for would have availed of at least some of the Enterprise, Trade and Employment the reason services above, some 1,000 workers in Donegal persons over 55 years of age are not allowed to availed of full retraining over the last 10 years. work until they reach retirement age on com- munity employment schemes; if his attention has 995 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 996

[Mr. Connaughton.] The scheme runs for 29 weeks of the year. been drawn to the fact that there is a tranche of Budget 2006 provided for an increase in the rate such workers, relatively small in number, who will of fuel allowance of EUR 5.00 from EUR 9.00 to find for maybe five or six years before they reach EUR 14.00 (EUR 17.90 in designated smokeless old age pension, that their chances of obtaining areas). employment is almost nil; and if he will make a Eligibility to the fuel allowance scheme is sub- statement on the matter. [32596/06] ject to inter alia, a means test, which has been eased in recent years. Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employ- People who are in receipt of relevant means ment (Mr. Martin): Community Employment tested non-contributory payments do not have to (CE) is an active labour market programme undergo a further means test to qualify for a fuel designed to provide eligible long term unem- allowance. The majority of people who receive ployed people and other disadvantaged persons fuel allowances qualify because they satisfy the with an opportunity to engage in useful work relevant means test for their primary weekly within their communities on a temporary basis. payment. In the case of contributory pensions which are CE helps unemployed people to re-enter the not means tested, a person may have a combined open labour market by breaking their experience household income of up to EUR 51 per week of unemployment through a return to a work rou- over and above the maximum rate of state pen- tine and to assist them to enhance/develop both sion (contributory) or savings/investments of up their technical and personal skills. to EUR 46,000, and still qualify for fuel With effect from 10 November 2004 those aged allowance. 55 years of age and over were eligible to partici- Income from investments and money in savings pate on CE for a maximum period of 6 years, accounts are not counted as means for means based on participation since 3rd April 2000. Sub- assessment purposes. Instead all cash values of sequently, the participation limit for persons eli- investments and property, all money in savings gible for CE based on a Social Welfare disability accounts and cash-in-hand are added together linked payment was increased by 1 year. These and that total is equated to a level of weekly measures were introduced in recognition of the means in accordance with the following formula: fact that older participants and participants with the first EUR 20,000 of capital is disregarded; a disability may find it more difficult to progress capital between EUR 20,000 and EUR 30,000 is into the open labour market. assessed as equivalent to EUR 1 weekly means for each EUR 1,000 of capital; capital between Social Insurance. EUR 30,000 and EUR 40,000 is assessed as equiv- alent to EUR 2 weekly means for each EUR 123. Mr. Ring asked the Minister for Social and 1,000 of capital; and capital above EUR 40,000 is Family Affairs if a PPS number will be supplied assessed as equivalent to EUR 4 weekly means to a person (details supplied). [32453/06] for each EUR 1,000 of capital.

Minister for Social and Family Affairs (Mr. Social Welfare Benefits. Brennan): In the case of the person in question 125. Mr. Gilmore asked the Minister for Social who is deceased, the PPS Number was confirmed and Family Affairs if he has considered the sub- to the solicitors dealing with his affairs. missions made by a group (details supplied) However, the solicitor had used the incorrect regarding the way in which retirement lump sum name in correspondence with the Department payments are being treated in the assessment of and this name was incorrectly used in the Depart- entitlement to the qualified adult allowance; his ment’s reply. An official of the Department con- proposals to remedy the problem; and if he will tacted the solicitor on 9 October 2006 to confirm make a statement on the matter. [32467/06] the correct details. Minister for Social and Family Affairs (Mr. Social Welfare Code. Brennan): A qualified adult allowance (QAA) is payable in respect of a spouse or partner who is 124. Mr. G. Mitchell asked the Minister for wholly or mainly maintained by the claimant. Social and Family Affairs the way his Depart- Account is taken of the spouse or partner’s ment takes savings into account when determin- income for the purposes of determining entitle- ing entitlement to fuel allowance. [32466/06] ment. A spouse or partner’s income includes income from capital, including retirement lump Minister for Social and Family Affairs (Mr. sum payments. Brennan): The aim of the national fuel scheme is Where capital is in the joint names of the claim- to assist householders on long-term social welfare ant and spouse or partner, half the capital is or health service executive payments with meet- assessed against each. ing the cost of their heating needs during the win- Prior to Budget 2006, a qualified adult allow- ter season. ance at the maximum rate was payable where the 997 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 998 spouse/partner’s income was less than \88.89 per ant with an income. The value of a person’s week and tapered reduced rates were payable primary residence is not taken into account in the where income was greater than \88.89, up to \220 means test. per week. A QAA was not payable where income The sale of residence provisions are designed exceeded \220 per week. These limits were to facilitate certain persons who are in receipt of increased in the Budget to \100 and \250 a means tested payment from this Department in respectively. selling their principal residence for the purpose When these improved arrangements are fully of: buying or renting alternative accommodation in place, and assuming that the spouse/partner which s/he occupies as his/her only or main resi- has no other means, a full rate QAA will be pay- dence; or moving into a private nursing home able where the spouse has capital of up to \57,000 which has been registered under Section 4, while capital between \57,000 and up to \95,000 Health (Nursing Home) Acts, 1990; moving in will give entitlement to a reduced rate of QAA. with their carer who is in receipt of carer’s allow- This will mean that a pension or redundancy ance or carer’s benefit in respect of them; or mov- lump sum, lodged in joint names, would have to ing to sheltered or special housing in the volun- \ be in excess of 114,000 before it would affect tary, co-operative, statutory or private sectors entitlement to a full rate qualified adult that is funded under the Capital Assistance allowance. Scheme operated by the Department of the I should also mention that if at any time the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. amount of capital held by the spouse or partner Where alternative accommodation is being (either jointly or singly) is reduced, they can purchased, the difference between the agreed sale request my Department to reassess their entitle- price of the former residence and the agreed pur- ment to a QAA payment. chase price of the replacement residence, subject I consider that the provisions I have outlined to a maximum of \190,461, is exempt from the offer substantial flexibility to couples where a means test. Where no alternative accommodation pension or redundancy lump sum is a factor but is being purchased, the gross proceeds of the sale the matter will be kept under review. are defined as the agreed sale price of the resi- dence and are disregarded in the means test also Social Welfare Code. to a maximum of \190,461. 126. Ms Shortall asked the Minister for Social These provisions apply to people aged over age and Family Affairs the way in which the means 66 years who receive a means tested payment test for the social assistance payments operates from this Department as well as to people aged when the recipient in availing of the financial con- under 66 who are in receipt of disability allow- tribution scheme for senior citizens in circum- ance or blind person’s pension. The purpose of stances where the initial proceeds of the sale are these provisions is to facilitate choice for certain initially above the \190,500 disregard threshold people who might previously have been living but where in later years this amount, then held in alone or in unsuitable accommodation. The dis- a bank account, dwindles to below this threshold, regard of \190,461 will continue to apply to the if in these circumstances the disregard still applies proceeds of the sale of the residence for the dur- or if a separate means calculation is applied; and ation of the claim. if he will make a statement on the matter. [32495/06] 127. Mr. Wall asked the Minister for Social and Family Affairs the mechanism used to determine Minister for Social and Family Affairs (Mr. the income limits for the family income sup- Brennan): Financial contribution schemes are plement for one child and two children and so on; operated by local authorities in order to facilitate older people who wish to move from private and if he will make a statement on the matter. accommodation, which may be too large for [32591/06] them, into local authority housing as tenants. The issue for my Department is how the proceeds of Minister for Social and Family Affairs (Mr. such a sale are treated in the means test for social Brennan): Family income supplement is designed assistance payments. to provide cash support for employees on low Social assistance payments are designed to earnings with families. FIS is paid on a weekly provide financial support for people who do not basis over a period of 52 weeks, taking into qualify for one of the contributory pension or account a family’s net earnings and the number benefit schemes. Entitlement to these payments of children under age 18 or aged between 18 and is based on a means test which is intended to 22 years and in full time education. ensure that available resources are targeted at Subject to a minimum weekly payment of \20, those who are most in need. Accordingly, any FIS is calculated at 60% of the difference resources that a claimant and his or her spouse or between a person’s net family income, (i.e. gross partner may have are assessed. These resources pay less tax, PRSI, Health levies, may include cash income, property, or an asset Superannuation), and the income limit applicable which could bring in money or provide the claim- to the family size. 999 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1000

[Mr. Brennan.] It has further advised that the decision has The FIS thresholds are normally increased in been appealed to the Health Service Executive’s each Budget to take account of the increases in Appeals Office and that a decision on the matter the job-seekers assistance personal payment rate is expected shortly. and in the associated increase for a qualified adult. In Budget 2006, the approach was adjusted Air Services. to take greater account of family size so that larger families received greater increases. 129. Mr. F. McGrath asked the Minister for This has resulted in a more equitable arrange- Transport if the Government will buy back Aer ment, where the gap has been reduced between Lingus shares in order to prevent a takeover. the average FIS weekly payment per child in [32458/06] different sized families. The tabular statement attached shows the Minister for Transport (Mr. Cullen): It was increases in FIS thresholds in Budget 2006 over always the intention of the Government to main- Budget 2005 and the maximum payment increase tain a significant minority shareholding in Aer for each family. Lingus for the purpose of ensuring that our stra- tegic interests are protected and that remains Table 1: FIS Thresholds 2005 and 2006 the position. A shareholding of 25.1% ensures that another Number of Children 2005 2006 Increase in company cannot acquire the 75% threshold that Threshold Threshold family is required to force de-listing. It also means that payment the company’s Memorandum and Articles of \\ \ Association cannot be changed without the State’s agreement. The State’s shareholding is in 1 446 465 11.40 fact 28.3%. 2 472 510 22.80 Even if another Company buys up a majority 3 497 565 40.80 share, Aer Lingus would have to continue to 4 522 630 64.80 operate on an independent basis in the best 5 554 705 90.60 interests of all its shareholders. The Government 6 580 775 117.00 does not currently propose to increase its shareholding. 7 601 845 146.40 8 or more 623 905 169.20 Road Safety. 130. Mr. Gregory asked the Minister for Trans- Social Welfare Benefits. port the number of heavy goods vehicles inspec- tions performed in 2005 at his Department’s insti- 128. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for Social gated checkpoints; the number of defects or and Family Affairs the reason rent and sup- driver standards items detected; the broad nature plementary welfare support was terminated on of defects; the number of prosecutions which the basis of cohabitation in the case of a person resulted; and the number of successful outcomes (details supplied) in County Dublin when clear for authorities. [32468/06] evidence to the contrary was provided; if his attention has been drawn to the hardship caused Minister for Transport (Mr. Cullen): Since 13 to the persons and their children, that they have September 2006 as a consequence of the Road been given notice to quit their home and that Safety Authority (Conferral of Functions) Order they have been approved for asylum status; if 2006 responsibility for vehicle standards and the payment will be restored; and if he will make a enforcement of driver hours, tachograph and statement on the matter. [32594/06] licensing regulations has passed to the Road Safety Authority. Minister for Social and Family Affairs (Mr. During 2005, Transport Officers of my Depart- Brennan): The supplementary welfare allowance ment inspected 1388 heavy goods and large pass- scheme is administered on my behalf by the Com- enger vehicles at road-side checks for the pur- munity Welfare division of the Health Service poses of the enforcement of driver hours, Executive. tachograph and licensing regulations. These The Health Service Executive has advised that inspections revealed 4120 infringements. The it terminated payment of a weekly supplementary infringements detected related to breaches of the welfare allowance and rent supplement to the driving times, breaks and rest period rules. person concerned as it was not satisfied as to the A prosecution in respect of any of these household composition in this case. The evidence infringements may be initiated any time within provided by the person concerned is not clear and two years of the date of the commission of the the Executive is satisfied that there are sufficient alleged offence. To date 181 prosecutions have grounds for refusing supplementary welfare been initiated in respect of these infringements, allowance. The person’s immigration status is not some of which involve multiple offences. It is too at issue in this case. 1001 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1002 early to determine at this stage the total number Beef Exports. of prosecutions which will be taken in respect of 133. Mr. Noonan asked the Minister for Agri- the infringements detected at road-side checks culture and Food if Irish beef may be exported to in 2005. China without restriction; and if she will make a In relation to the enforcement of vehicle stan- statement on the matter. [32471/06] dards legislation, my Department (henceforth the Road Safety Authority) does not specifically Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary instigate checkpoint inspections for that purpose. Coughlan): Ireland cannot at present export its Enforcement of road traffic law and the pros- beef products to the Peoples Republic of China ecution of alleged offences are matters for the because of the ban imposed as a result of BSE. Garda Sı´ocha´na. A formal approach was made in March this year to the veterinary authorities in China with a view Driving Tests. to having the ban lifted. The matter was raised 131. Ms Shortall asked the Minister for Trans- again during the Ireland-China Joint Commission port his plans to consolidate the driver licensing meeting in June. system for motorcyclists in order that all riders Since then Ireland and the Peoples Republic of who pass may be deemed competent to drive all China have signed a Memorandum of Under- motorcycle types with one successful test; and if standing on Agricultural Cooperation between he will make a statement on the matter. the two countries. I feel that this will provide the [32537/06] basis for enhanced levels of contact between both administrations and will help to remove any Minister for Transport (Mr. Cullen): The Road obstacles to the development of trade between Traffic (Licensing of Drivers) Regulations 1999 our two nations. In this context it will greatly as amended provide, in accordance with the assist in the ongoing discussions with the Chinese requirements of the EU Directive on driving authorities on the importation of Irish beef. The licences, for minimum ages for access to the success we have had so far in opening the Chinese different categories of driving licence for motor- market to Irish pigmeat in recent months was cycles. A minimum age of 18 applies to category very encouraging and I hope the experience A which covers all motorcycles while a minimum gained in that exercise will contribute positively age of 16 applies to category A1 which covers to a similar outcome for beef. motorcycles with an engine capacity not Overall, I am committed in my efforts to re- exceeding 125 cubic centimetres and with a power open all international markets to Irish beef with rating not exceeding 11 kilowatts. the assistance of An Bord Bia and the Depart- A successful test in category A qualifies a ment of Foreign Affairs. motorcycle rider to ride all motorcycles. Such a test must be carried out on a motorcycle with an Sugar Beet Industry. engine capacity exceeding 125 cubic centimetres. I do not propose to require all motorcyclists to 134. Mr. Aylward asked the Minister for Agri- undergo this test as such a measure would effec- culture and Food when formal applications forms tively raise the minimum age for category A1 to will be made available to machinery contractors 18 years and remove the option for those who do and hauliers to allow them claim under the sugar not wish to ride a larger motorcycle to learn on beet compensation scheme; and if she will make a category A1 motorcycle and undergo a test in a statement on the matter. [32475/06] that category. Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary Community Development. Coughlan): Under the relevant EU Regulations, eligibility for the EU restructuring aid for the 132. Mr. Ring asked the Minister for Com- sugar industry is confined to three categories: munity, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs if plays- processors, beet growers and certain specialized chools (details supplied) in County Mayo will be machinery contractors who worked for the grow- provided with workers under the rural social ers. In accordance with the EU Regulations, the scheme. [32504/06] Government in July made certain decisions con- cerning implementation of the restructuring aid, Minister for Community, Rural and Gaeltacht in particular the percentage to be reserved for Affairs (E´ amon O´ Cuı´v): The Rural Social beet growers and machinery contractors. These Scheme currently has one participant working in decisions were based on the recommendations of Scribbles Community Play-school in Kilmaine, an independent expert, Indecon International County Mayo. A second RSS participant is due Economic Consultants, following a rigorous con- to start work in Scribbles on 16 October 2006. sultation exercise with interested parties. The Robeen Community Play-school has applied independent expert acknowledged that other for a RSS participant to work in their play-school. groups apart from the three eligible categories Despite the efforts from the local RSS Imple- might be affected directly or indirectly by the menting Body, a suitable individual has yet to closing of the sugar industry, including hauliers be recruited. and other suppliers of goods and services, but 1003 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1004

[Mary Coughlan.] in the past five years. Their locations are set out also recognised that they are not eligible for aid in the table. under the EU Regulations. The Government decisions are now the subject Carlow 1 of Judicial Review proceedings instituted by Cavan 4 Greencore Group plc in the High Court. Under Clare 1 the EU Regulations, the first instalment of the Donegal 3 aid would fall to be paid in June 2007. An announcement about the application procedure Galway 8 will be made in due course. Kerry 5 Kildare 1 Question No. 135 withdrawn. Kilkenny 1 Laois 1 Departmental Agencies. Leitrim 3 136. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for Agri- Limerick 2 culture and Food the position in relation to the Mayo 7 proposed acquisition by Coillte of a company Monaghan 2 (details supplied) in County Tipperary. Roscommon 4 [32486/06] Tipperary 3 Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary Waterford 1 Coughlan): Coillte’s purchase of the company in Westmeath 3 question is subject to the approval of the Compe- Wexford 1 tition Authority. I understand that the Compe- tition Authority is currently carrying out a full (Phase 2) investigation in relation to the pro- 139. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for Agri- posed acquisition. culture and Food when was the last course for REP scheme planning agents; when the next Food Industry. course will be held; and if she will make a state- 137. Mr. Neville asked the Minister for Agri- ment on the matter. [32536/06] culture and Food if she has had discussions with interested parties with regard to taking over a Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary company (details supplied); if she will assist such Coughlan): The next courses for REPS planning a proposal; and if she will make a statement on agencies will be held on Tuesday 17 October in the matter. [32503/06] Mitchelstown, Co Cork and Wednesday 18 October in Ballinasloe, Co Galway. The last Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary course was held in Bunclody, Co Wexford, in Coughlan): I met growers’ representatives on 3 September 2004. October. Various issues relating to the poultry industry generally and Castlemahon in particular Live Exports. were discussed. The growers indicated that they 140. Mr. Crawford asked the Minister for Agri- were developing plans to buy the Castlemahon culture and Food if she will change the regu- business as a going concern and that this plan lations that will allow purebred cattle to be would be sent to the liquidator. exported through Rosslare and Du´ n Laoghaire in the same way as horses can be transported; her Rural Environment Protection Scheme. views on whether it is unreasonable that animals 138. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for Agri- have to be brought from the deep south, up culture and Food the reason there are so few through Belfast and Larne to Stranraer across courses for REP scheme planning agents; the through Scotland and all the way down through number of licenses she issued in the past five England to a purchaser on the Welsh border or years in each county; and if she will make a state- even down to Devon or Cornwall; if she will jus- ment on the matter. [32535/06] tify the cost and the stress on the animal; and if she will make a statement on the matter. Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary [32542/06] Coughlan): My Department holds REPS plan- Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary ning agency training courses when there are a Coughlan): There are no regulations in place that sufficient number of applicants to justify holding prevent cattle being exported through the ports a course. My Department held 4 REPS planning referred to or indeed through other locations that agency training courses in the past 5 years, 2 in have adequate facilities. My Department’s func- 2001, 1 in 2002 and 1 in 2004. A further 2 courses tion in relation to the transport of livestock by are scheduled for next week. Some 51 individuals sea is to approve vessels based on statutory have been approved as REPS planning agencies requirements regarding the protection of animal 1005 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1006 welfare. The actual provision of services for the timeframe for the move of FETAC, HETAC and transport of livestock by sea is a matter for the the NQAI. service providers operating on the routes. Any ferry operator intending to transport live- Schools Building Projects. stock from the State to another Member State, or 143. Aengus O´ Snodaigh asked the Minister for to a Third Country, must have the vessel Education and Science the status of the building inspected and approved by my Department. project at a college (details supplied) in County Approval for the carriage of livestock on roll on Donegal, as authorisation had already been given roll off vessels is considered on a case-by-case to proceed to the point where detailed bill of basis, having regard to the characteristics of the quantities were to be prepared; and if she will individual vessel, whereas there are specific statu- provide date for commencement of the work. tory requirements which apply across the board [32439/06] where dedicated livestock vessels are concerned. My Department works closely with companies Minister for Education and Science (Ms that seek approval for the transport of livestock Hanafin): The proposed extension project for the to ensure that the conditions aboard such vessels school referred to by the Deputy is at an early are consistent with national and E.U. animal wel- stage of architectural planning and is one of the fare requirements. 124 schools that I announced in April of 2005 to progress through the architectural planning Rural Environment Protection Scheme. process. 141. Mr. Connaughton asked the Minister for On the 20th March 2006 a letter issued to the Agriculture and Food the reason a 10% penalty School Authorities with revised schedules of was imposed on a person (details supplied) in accommodation requesting them to get their County Galway; if her attention has been drawn Design Team to revise the original stage 1 (Initial to the fact that the person in question has Sketch Scheme) as presented to the Department restored old farm machinery for many years and in October 2001 to reflect the impact of the that was the reason such machinery was in their revised schedules. yard at that point in time; and if she will make a My Department has received the revised stage statement on the matter. [32551/06] 1 (Initial Sketch Scheme) from the School’s Design Team and will shortly arrange a meeting with the School Authorities and the Design Team Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mary in order to evaluate the submission. It is envis- Coughlan): A penalty was notified in this case aged that unless there are very exceptional cir- because the REPS undertakings in respect of the cumstances involved, the meeting will be farmyard had not been complied with. sufficient to authorise the project to progress to I am aware that the person named has the next stage of architectural planning. Pro- appealed the decision to the Agriculture Appeals gression of projects to tender and construction Office. I understand that an oral hearing has will be considered in the context of the School taken place and that a decision will issue shortly. Building and Modernisation Programme 2006- 2010. Decentralisation Programme. 142. Ms Enright asked the Minister for Edu- Vocational Training Opportunities Scheme. cation and Science the position in relation to 144. Dr. Cowley asked the Minister for Edu- decentralisation to Edenderry; the number due to cation and Science if she intends to increase the be decentralised; the timeframe expected for this child care grant awarded to VTOS students in to take place; and if she will make a statement on view of the ever increasing child care and cre`che the matter. [32576/06] costs and in further view of the fact that this grant has not been increased in five years; and if she Minister for Education and Science (Ms will make a statement on the matter. [32440/06] Hanafin): The organisations to decentralise to Edenderry are the Further Education & Training Minister of State at the Department of Edu- Awards Council, FETAC, the Higher Edu- cation and Science (Miss de Valera): My Depart- cation & Training Awards Council, HETAC, and ment provides funding to VECs to assist towards the National Qualifications Authority of Ireland, the child care expenses of participants in certain NQAI. These organisations are State agencies further education programmes, one of which is under the aegis of my Department. The overall the Vocational Training Opportunities Scheme number of posts involved is in the region of 90. (VTOS). The other programmes are Youthreach All three agencies are public service agencies and Senior Traveller Training. rather than civil service agencies. The Deputy will The grant is intended as a contribution to costs be aware of the work that is ongoing at the cen- and the amount of grant that each VEC receives tral level in relation to the decentralisation of the is determined by reference to the number of public service agencies, which will impact on the students it has enrolled on these programmes 1007 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1008

[Miss de Valera.] (b) The Vocational Education Committees’ who require assistance with child care and the Scholarship Scheme total amount provided to the Department for this (c) The Third Level Maintenance Grants purpose. VECs determine the level of child care Scheme for Trainees provision and also have the discretion to bridge any gap between the Department’s grant and (d) The Maintenance Grant Scheme for actual costs they approve. Students Attending Post Leaving Certificate Expenditure by my Department on further Courses. education child care grants to VECs has grown Under the terms of the Maintenance Grants \ \ from 3.25m in 2001 to 5.45m in 2005. The pro- Scheme for Post Leaving Certificate Courses \ vision for 2006 is 5.69m 2006, grants are available to eligible candidates who are entering approved PLC courses for the School Staffing. first time in the 2006/2007 academic year. Under 145. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for Edu- Clause 3.2 of the PLC Scheme candidates are cation and Science if she will facilitate the making ineligible if they already hold a FETAC Level 5 permanent of teaching staff in a special teaching qualification (formerly known as a FETAC unit at a school (details supplied) in County (NCVA) Level 2 qualification) or FETAC Level Kildare in order to ensure that continuity is main- 6 qualification (formerly known as a FETAC tained for the students of the unit, and the (NCVA) Level 3 qualification) or a third level general administration of same; and if she will qualification at Level 6 or higher. However, not- make a statement on the matter. [32441/06] withstanding this condition candidates who already hold a FETAC Level 5 qualification Minister for Education and Science (Ms (formerly known as a FETAC (NCVA) Level 2 Hanafin): The recruitment and appointment of qualification) and are now pursuing a course that teachers to fill teaching posts at second level is a offers progression may be deemed eligible for matter for individual school authority subject to grant aid. agreed procedures. The candidate, to whom the Deputy refers, Teacher allocations for second level schools are already holds a Diploma. As outlined above, the approved by my Department on an annual basis candidate is ineligible for grant assistance in in accordance with generally applied rules based respect of her FETAC Level 5 Course. on recognised pupil enrolments on the 30th of I regret the news is not better in relation to this September of the preceding school year. student, but the Deputy will appreciate that the The pupil teacher ratio at second level has terms of the schemes are of general application improved significantly in recent years. The ratio and it is not open to me or my Department to fell from 16:1 to 13.2:1 during the period from depart from the terms of the Scheme and make 1996/97 to 2005/2006. exceptions in individual cases In line with Government policy, my Depart- ment will continue to provide further reductions Mobile Telephony. in the pupil teacher ratio within available 147. Mr. G. Mitchell asked the Minister for resources and subject to spending priorities Education and Science if guidelines put in place within the education sector. Priority will be given in relation to the location of mobile phone masts to pupils with special needs and those from near schools, such as a school (details supplied) disadvantaged areas. in Dublin 6, are still in place; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [32461/06] Higher Education Grants. Minister for Education and Science (Ms 146. Mr. P. Breen asked the Minister for Edu- Hanafin): My Department has not issued any cation and Science the reason a person (details guidelines to schools in relation to the location of supplied) in County Clare has not qualified for a mobile phone masts. The erection of such masts grant with the vocational educational committee; are subject to normal planning regulations which and if she will make a statement on the are administered by the relevant Local Authority. matter. [32442/06] I am aware that the Department of Environment, Heritage and Local Government issued guide- Minister for Education and Science (Ms lines on Telecommunications Antennae and Sup- Hanafin): My Department funds three means- port Structures to Planning Authorities in 1996 tested maintenance grant schemes for third level and that these guidelines are still in place. In education students in respect of attendance on addition, in 2005 the Oireachtas Joint Committee approved courses in approved third level insti- on Communications, Marine and Natural tutions and one maintenance grant scheme in Resources issued a report titled “Report on non- respect of students attending approved Post ionising radiation from mobile phone handsets Leaving Certificate Courses in approved PLC and masts”. On foot of the recommendations of Centres: that report the Department of Communications, (a) The Higher Education Grants Scheme Marine and Natural Resources established an 1009 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1010 inter-departmental committee to examine the Higher Education Grants. health effects, if any, of non-ionising radiation. 150. Mr. N. O’Keeffe asked the Minister for The work of that committee is currently Education and Science the reason a person underway — the committee is expected to report (details supplied) in County Tipperary has been to Government before the end of this year. approved for fees only under the higher edu- cation grant scheme; and if she will arrange for Departmental Expenditure. the application to be reconsidered with a view to 148. Mr. O’Shea asked the Minister for Edu- approving the maximum grant. [32480/06] cation and Science her proposals to increase funding of second level education to an appro- Minister for Education and Science (Ms priate level; and if she will make a statement on Hanafin): Under the terms of my Department’s the matter. [32462/06] third level student maintenance grant schemes, where the applicant is not an independent mature Minister for Education and Science (Ms student, the reckonable income to be determined Hanafin): There has been substantial progress for the purposes of the award of the maintenance made in the funding of our schools since 2003, grant is income from all sources of the candidate the financial year indicated in the OECD Report and his/her parents or guardians where referred to by the Deputy. applicable. Spending by my Department on second level The means test arrangements of the Student education increased by 17% between 2003 and Maintenance Grant Schemes have been in oper- 2005. In 2005, \2.7 billion was spent on second- ation since 1983 and are applied nationally. In the level education – up from \2.3 billion in 2003 and case of both the employed and self-employed \1.25 billion in 1997. These increases have gross income is assessed with certain specified allowed for major progress to be made both in social welfare and health board payments the staffing and in the day-to-day funding of our excluded. schools. In the 2006/2007 academic year where 2 or With regard to staffing, it should be noted that more children (or the candidate’s parent) are pur- there is now one teacher for every 13 students at suing a course of study listed below the reckon- \ second level. able income limits may be increased by 4,525 \ Day to day funding for our schools has also where there are 2 such children, 9,050 where increased significantly in recent years. Since the there are 3 such children and so on, by increments \ financial year referred to in the OECD report — of 4,525. 2003 — second-level schools have benefited from As all applications for financial support are substantial increases in funding. The standard means tested in accordance with the terms of the capitation grant of \266 per pupil in 2003 now student maintenance grant schemes, a candidate stands at \298 per pupil from 1 January last. In shall not be eligible for a grant if the reckonable addition, the support services grant for secondary income for the purpose of the means testing is schools has been increased from \127 per pupil over the prescribed income limits irrespective of in 2003 to \159 per pupil from January last. This the individual circumstances. per capita grant is in addition to a range of equal- Officials in my Department understand that isation grants of up to some \15,500 per school the reckonable income in the case referred to by per annum that were also approved for voluntary the Deputy entitled the person in question to a secondary schools. fees only grant as prescribed in the Higher Edu- These significant increases in the funding and cation Grant Scheme 2006. staffing of schools are a clear demonstration of my commitment to prioritise available resources 151. Mr. M. Higgins asked the Minister for to address the needs of schools. Education and Science the position regarding an application for funding for a third-level course by a person (details supplied) in County Clare; the School Transport. action this person should take in this regard; and 149. Mr. Hayes asked the Minister for Edu- if she will make a statement on the matter. cation and Science the position in the case of a [32496/06] person (details supplied) in County Tipperary who has requested an extension of the school bus Minister for Education and Science (Ms service in their area. [32472/06] Hanafin): If the Deputy could arrange to have the full details of the course and person in question Minister of State at the Department of Edu- forwarded to the Student Support Unit of my cation and Science (Miss de Valera): My Depart- Department the matter will be examined further. ment has requested an updated report from Bus A reply will issue directly to the person referred E´ ireann regarding the background to the case to by the Deputy regarding an application for referred to by the Deputy in the details supplied. funding once the case has been examined. 1011 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1012

School Accommodation. Deputy. Currently site options are under con- sideration by my Department with the intention 152. Mr. McCormack asked the Minister for of identifying the most suitable site to facilitate Education and Science the decisions her Depart- the development of a new school building. The ment has taken with regard to the provision of site assessment process is not yet complete. When a new building for a school (details supplied) in finalised, my officials will be in further contact County Galway; if a decision has been made as with the school authorities in relation to the to the proposed location of the school; when her application for capital funding. Department will be in a position to apply for planning permission for this new school; if pro- School Staffing. vision will be made on the planning of this school to cater for 16 teachers which will be required for 153. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for Edu- cation and Science if she will provide an answer the future need of the school; the result of the to Parliamentary Question No. 272 of 24 May technical inspection which was carried out on the 2006 regarding promotional posts for post- sites; and if she will make a statement on the primary teachers; and if she will make a state- matter. [32506/06] ment on the matter. [32507/06] Minister for Education and Science (Ms Minister for Education and Science (Ms Hanafin): An assessment of the school’s appli- Hanafin): The current position regarding pro- cation for capital funding for a new school has motional posts as available on the payroll data- been completed and a decision taken to provide base of my Department is outlined in the a new 16 classroom school to meet the school’s attachment. long term accommodation needs. Boards of Management are currently advising My Department has been actively pursuing a my Department of new appointees to posts of suitable site to facilitate the construction of a per- responsibility for the 2006/2007 school year and manent building for the school referred to by the accordingly the statistics quoted may alter. 1013 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1014 65 = 1 2 111 21 121 744373713 1 15 237172 1 11 4 11 4 21 4 9 1 Λ Λ Λ Λ Λ 34485157122643 Age <40 Age 40-44 Age 45-49 Age 50-54 Age 55-59 Age 60-64 Age > Age and Gender Breakdown of Post Primary Teachers in Promotional Posts a POR of Teachers Primary with a POR Teachers with Total Number % of Post Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female Allowance Post Assistant Principal Special Duties Allowance Allowance Assistant PrincipalDeputy PrincipalDirector of Adult EducationGrade AGrade BPersonal rate of AP/A PostPersonal rate of DP/VP 3,072 AllowancePersonal rate 52 of Grade BPersonal rate of Principal 469Personal rate 17.47 of Special Duties/B 27 0.30 39Principal — Adult Education 2.67Principal Allowance 6 31 0.15Programme 0.22 Co-Ordinator 4 7 — 2 73 24 28 11Programme Co-Ordinator — 11 0.03 71 47Special 15 Duties 0.02 Allowance 0.04 1 0.42 0.14 Vice Principal 65POR/SFA 190 18 Allowance 1 495 0.40 106 164 1 24 247 1.08 4,633 38 2.82 0.60 453 1 1 45 667 12 26.35 2 13 1 53 15 1 548 21 285 53 9 454 4 20 10 1 0.01 679 243 0.01 81 28 13 5 16 1 311 123 45 21 11 8 662 9 4 1 67 65 8 404 37 2 6 19 31 1 731 13 20 9 2 9 85 386 10 27 2 585 2 52 1 7 13 187 102 5 4 20 252 1 33 1 63 3 8 35 1 87 2 20 1 1 1015 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1016

Vocational Education Committees. Departmental Agencies. 154. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for Edu- 156. Mr. Gregory asked the Minister for Edu- cation and Science when funding will be allocated cation and Science when all of her appointments to County Louth vocational educational commit- will be made to the Grangegorman Development tee in order that they can provide students at a Agency; if persons resident in the area will be school (details supplied) with an equal number of appointed by her; when the agency will have its practical class hours in woodwork, home econ- first meeting; and if she will make a statement on omics and art as students in other post-primary the matter. [32522/06] schools; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [32508/06] Minister for Education and Science (Ms Hanafin): I announced earlier this year the Minister for Education and Science (Ms appointment of Mr. John Fitzgerald as Chair- Hanafin): My Department allocates additional person of the Grangegorman Development teaching hours to VECs to support the delivery Agency and I am now actively considering the of education programmes in a range of facilities, other appointments to the Agency. In the interim, including special schools. Such allocations are a temporary Chief Executive Officer has been made under the heading Co-Operation Hours appointed and is undertaking some necessary with Other Institutions and are made in response work such as the sourcing of suitable office to specific applications which are submitted by accommodation and staff in preparation for the the VEC’s in advance of the commencement of new Agency. the school year to which they relate. As the Deputy will be aware, Section 17 of the The special school to which the Deputy refers Grangegorman Development Agency Act 2005 is currently in receipt of 1350 co-operation hours specifies that the residents of the Grangegorman for three subjects to cater for the 59 students neighbourhood are entitled to nominate one per- enrolled in this school who are pursuing a course son to be a member of the Agency following an of study at post primary level. election process to be conducted by the Chair- My Department is currently undertaking a person. This election has taken place and a resi- review of allocations to VECs under Co-Oper- dent has been nominated for appointment to the ation Hours with Other Institutions and the needs Agency. of this special school will be considered in the In addition, Section 22 of the Act provides for context of this review. the establishment, by the Agency, of a consulta- tive group that is representative of all stake- holders interested in the development of the School Accommodation. Grangegorman Site. The legislation recognises 155. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for Edu- the residents of the Grangegorman neighbour- cation and Science the progress in relation to a hood specifically among the stakeholders that school (details supplied) in County Tipperary should be represented on the Consultative regarding the cost of classrooms which the school Group. Up to 2 members of the Consultative funded and for which it is seeking retrospective Group may be nominated by the residents of the payment or rent; and if she will make a statement Grangegorman neighbourhood. on the matter. [32509/06] I expect to be in a position announce shortly the membership and date of the first meeting Minister for Education and Science (Ms the Agency. Hanafin): In 2002 the school to which the Deputy refers was granted \170,000 for the provision of Telecommunications Services. two permanent classrooms. In 2003 it built a third 157. Mr. Broughan asked the Minister for Edu- classroom without prior approval from the cation and Science the number of schools here Department. which do not have broadband internet services; The School Building Programme lists projects the number of primary and post-primary schools to be funded in any given year. Projects under- which do not have broadband; the percentage of taken by schools without the approval or agree- primary and post-primary schools with broad- ment of the Department will not be funded as, to band internet services on a county basis; the do so, would reward queue jumping and under- breakdown of the provision of broadband for mine the openness and transparency of the schools in Dublin, Meath, Tipperary and Cork; system, which is the essential point of publishing and if she will make a statement on the the School Building Programme. It also would be matter. [32527/06] impossible to manage the capital budget if there was no central prioritisation and allocation Minister for Education and Science (Ms system in place. Hanafin): The Deputy will be aware that my Circular Letter 5/04, ‘Schools Seeking Funding Department is engaged in the roll-out of broad- Retrospectively for Capital Works’, governs this band internet connectivity to all recognised issue. A copy has been issued to the management primary and post-primary schools. This project is authority of the school in question. being undertaken in partnership with industry in 1017 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1018 the context of a Government — IBEC/TIF (AUP) in place and it must indicate which con- (Telecommunications and Internet Federation) tent filtering option it requires prior to the acti- Agreement to provide local broadband con- vation of the school’s connectivity via the Schools nectivity to schools. The broadband connectivity National Broadband Network. is being provided via a Schools National Broad- As of 2nd October, 3,759 schools have had band Network supported by HEAnet, which will their local connectivity installed and of these provide managed Internet access, email, security 3,751 have had their router capability installed controls, content filtering and other services and tested. The number of schools that had con- designed to enhance the educational process. A firmed their AUP status and selected their con- Broadband Support Service Desk has also been tent filtering option was 3,503. Of the remaining established to assist schools with advice and infor- 177 schools, some 23 schools have refused the mation relating to the roll-out and ongoing use of service offered under the arrangements, 44 instal- their broadband connectivity within the schools lations have been deferred due to school building network. The total cost of the project for the programmes, 35 schools are in the process of three year period will be in the region of \30m. being re-awarded (or awarded in the case of new schools) and a further 75 school installations are Following a public tendering process, contracts being addressed at present. were finalised in 2005 with six Service Providers It should be noted that a number of the schools for the provision of local access connectivity to that have not been connected under the Schools 3,925 schools and with a further Provider for the Broadband Access Programme will have their installation of a broadband router at school level own independent broadband connnectivity. where appropriate. The count of the number of I should also mention that a further 72 schools schools countenanced under this arrangement has have had broadband access provided under the since been amended to take into account the Hermes and Advanced Deployment programmes effect of a number of school closures, amalgama- and therefore currently have active broadband tions and new opening and stands currently at connections independent of the above mentioned 3,936. National Broadband Network. The percentage of Roll out of the local connectivity and router primary and post-primary schools with broad- installation commenced in June 2005. The instal- band connectivity by county (based on the lation process has two stages starting with the Schools Broadband Access Programme instal- local broadband connectivity installation lations and the Hermes and Advanced Deploy- (involving DSL, satellite or wireless technology) ment programmes) and the breakdown of the followed by the installation of a high-speed router provision of broadband for schools in Dublin, and circuit and acceptance testing. A school then Meath, Tipperary and Cork is illustrated in the must confirm that it has an Acceptable Use Policy table for the Deputy’s information. 1019 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1020 Cloyne, Co. Cork Smart Satellite Provision of Broadband In Schools for Cork, Dublin, Meath and Tipperary eBNS 00512D01132V01197D Midleton Convent N01272O S S N Baile01687U Guairne Strawberry Hill B01692N N S S N Chuan01867W Doir Dromleigh N S01874T Firmount Mixed N02114B S Castlelyons B N S02278I St. Martins Senior02452V N.S. S N Baile02707F Ui Ghiblin Millstreet Convent02803B N S Cloyn 03704E Sundays Well G03993O N S Banteer N S04054T S N Sean04118T Baile Mor Midleton, Co. S Cork N Breac04152T Maigh Ballindangan Mixed N04186N S Cloyne, Co. Sundays Leamlara Cork Well, Mixed Cork N04230N S S N Cnoc04268P An Bhile S N Chuan Bhiorainn Doir,04442F Co. Cork Scoil Naomh Donoughmore, Eoin Macroom, Co.04572S Co. Cork Cork Clochar Na Toirbhirte04578H Fermoy, Kilworth, Co. Co. Cork Kyle Cork N S04953H St. Josephs Mitchelstown,05257P N.S. Co. Cork Millstreet, Ballyvongane Co. Mixed Cork N05477G S Ballyhass Mixed N05508O S Presentation Convent05565D Cork, Co. Cork Laragh N S05636A St. Columbas N.S05656G Mallow, Co. Cork Trafrask Banteer, Mixed Co. N Mitchelstown, Cork05940D S Co. Cork Dunmanway Castlelyons, Model Co. BT N Cork Ireland06295F S S N Leamlara, An Co. Ghoilin Cork Scoil Ursula Digiweb Upton, Digiweb Co. Freemount Cork Mixed N S Digiweb Smart ADSL Berrings, Ballincurrig, Co. Doneraile, Leamlara, Cork Co. Co. Cork Cork Digiweb Wireless Aghina, Digiweb Co. Satellite Cork Smart Smart Kinsale, Co. Cork Youghal, Satellite Co. Cecilstown, Smart Cork Mallow, Co. Cork Satellite Bandon, Co. Cork Satellite Satellite With Satellite Facility Irish Satellite For Broadband Bandon, Deaf Dunmanway, Bantry, Co. Children, Co. Co. Cork Dughlas, Cork Cork Corcaigh Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Smart Digiweb Wireless Sciobairin, Co. Digiweb Cork Rathluirc, Co. Smart Cork Blackrock, Co. Cork Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Smart Satellite Smart Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite BT Ireland Digiweb Satellite Satellite BT Ireland Wireless Satellite Satellite BT Ireland ADSL Smart Satellite Digiweb ADSL Digiweb ADSL Digiweb Irish Broadband Satellite Satellite Wireless Satellite Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Cork 00467B Ballinspittle N S Kinsale, Co. Cork Smart Satellite 1021 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1022 athluirc, Co. Cork Smart Satellite Shortcastle, Mallow, Co. Cork Smart ADSL aBNS R o1NS 06342L06824G07006A Vicarstown Mixed N07101R S S N Cuil07242M Aodha Ballyclough Mixed N07651G S Inchiclough N S08393P Cloghroe Mixed N S08430S Convent of Mercy08828B S N Rath08972I Dubh Scoil Naomh09161W Seosamh Kilcorney Mixed N09385V S Castlealack N09537S S Convent of Mercy09815U Rathduane N S09872J Ballinadee N10047I S Tullaslease Mixed N10243I S Vicarstown, Co. Cork Cloghoola Mixed10499U N S Macroom Convent10523O N Mallow, S Co. Cork S Cuil N10548H Aodha, Achadh Maigh Eochaille Chromtha, Kilgariffe Co. N Chorcai S10724B Fermoy Adair Blarney, Bantry, N Co. Co.10739O S Cork Cork St. Brendans National10771K School Clonakilty, Co. Cork South Abbey NS11236Q Skibbereen, Co. Ballincarriga Cork Mxd N11245R S Grenagh, Co. Cork Cobh Rathcoole, N Mallow, S11249C Co. Cork Newmarket B N11262R S SN Cill Mhic Chaislean11337W Abhaidh Bantry, Na Co. Leacht, Cork Bandon, Burnfort Co. N Cork S11496T Druimne N Rathmore, S11931L Mallow, Digiweb Co. Rathluirc, Cork Kilmagner Co. N Cork S11992I Bandon, Co. Cork Seandrom Millstreet, Co.12004A Cork Digiweb Macroom, Co. S Cork N Ioseph12012W Enniskean, Whitegate Co. Mixed Cork12015F N S Mallow Bantry, N Co. Satellite Cork12041G Digiweb St. Lukes N S12147W Douglas Clonakilty, Fermoy, Co. Co. Cork Cork Liscarrol N S12169J Satellite St. Smart John Digiweb The Baptist N Ballinacarriga S BT S Mxd, Youghal, Ireland N Dunmanway, Co. An Co. Cork Aird Cork Digiweb Digiweb Smart Templebrady Satellite N S Smart Newmarket, Leap, Co. Co. Cork Cork Bellevue, Cobh, Satellite Co. ADSL Cork Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Smart Mallow, Co. ADSL Cork Rathluirc, Co. Cork Digiweb Fermoy, Satellite Co. Cork Smart Digiweb Midleton, Smart Co. Satellite Cork Digiweb Digiweb Drinagh, Dunmanway, Co. Cork, ADSL Cork Co. Cork Satellite Smart Midleton, Co. Cork Smart Satellite Smart Satellite Mallow, Co. Cork ADSL Satellite Satellite Smart Clonakilty, Crosshaven, Co. Co. Cork Cork ADSL Smart Smart ADSL ADSL Digiweb ADSL Digiweb Digiweb ADSL Digiweb ADSL Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Smart Satellite Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Wireless ADSL Satellite Satellite Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1023 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1024

[Ms Hanafin.] acroom, Co. Cork Digiweb Satellite nNSMxd M 12203G12259K12263B S N Naomh12281D Antaine S N Oir12292I Cheann Gogginshill N S12382J Walterstown N S12383L Canovee Mixed12395S N S Curriglass NS12446J Union Hall Mixed12447L N S Rusheen NS12456M S N12473M Gleann Na Huladh Baltydaniel N S12505W Timoleague N S12598J Greenmount Monastery NS12676D Kilbarry N S12685E Ardagh Boys12967O N S Clogheen Mxd Ballinlough, N Cork13031I S Rushnacahara N S13095L Inchigeela N Eyeries, S13125R Bantry, Co. Cork St. Ballinhassig, Josephs Co.13234W Convent Cork N S Cobh, S Co. N Cork An13286S Droma Carrigadrohid, Mhoir Co. Cork Scoil Dhairbhre13375R Cloughduv Cork, N Co. S Cork13402R Curriglass, Mallow, Co. Tirelto Cork13450F Mitchelstown, Scoil Co. Bhride Cork13483U Knockraha Coachford, N Co. Scoil S Cork Muire13512B Na Ngras, Greenmount, Rushbrook Co. Con Mallow, Cork Mercy13543M Co. N Cork S S Bandon, N Co. Ath Cork13647B Na Lionta Scoil Mhuire Lourdes13648D 13512b Derrinacahara N S13661S Macroom, Castlemartyr Co. Roscarbery, N Cork Co. S13662U Cork Carrigrohane, Co. Cork St. Lukes Mxd13663W N Durrns, S Bantry, Co. Digiweb Dunmanway Cork Convent Digiweb13696O N S Rathluirc, Co. Dunmanway Cork Convent Inf13728B Inchigeela, Co. Cork Lower Glanmire Aghaville, Smart N Bantry, S Co.13747F Cork Digiweb St. Irish Vincents Broadband Convent13779S N S Castletownsend Clonakilty, Digiweb Mxd Co. Smart N Cork S Wireless Riverstown Satellite Cloughduv, N Crookstown, S Co. Cork. Wireless S N Digiweb Dhrom Digiweb Athain Cobh, Co. Cork Satellite Satellite Cros Mhathuna, Carrigaline, Digiweb Bandon, Glantaun, Co. Co. Cork, Cork Cork Co. Cork Satellite Satellite Mallow, Co. Cork Smart Digiweb Satellite Satellite Dunmanway, Co. Cork Castlemartyr, Satellite Dunmanway, Co. Smart Digiweb Co. Cork Digiweb Cork Mahonys Digiweb Dunmanway, Ave, Co. Cork Cork Satellite Satellite Digiweb Glanmire, Smart St. Co. Marys Cork Road, Cork Digiweb Skibbereen, Smart Co. Cork Satellite Satellite Satellite Satellite BT Ireland Smart Glanmire, Satellite Co. Cork Mallow, Co. Cork ADSL Satellite Satellite Digiweb Smart Smart Leased Line ADSL Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Smart BT Ireland ADSL ADSL Smart Irish Broadband Satellite Satellite Irish Smart Broadband ADSL Wireless Smart Satellite ADSL Wireless Irish Broadband BT ADSL Ireland Satellite Wireless Leased Line County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1025 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1026 anway, Co. Cork BT Ireland ADSL anturk, Co. Cork Eircom ADSL yBNS Dunm kBNS K S N B Togher Cork Togher, CorkS N C Bhlarna Irish Broadband Wireless Iosagain, An Bhlarna, Co. Corcai BT Ireland ADSL 13828F13889C13910N Douglas B N13976U S Shanbally N S13980L S N Bun14000C An Tsabhairne St. Matthias N14002G S14014N Scoil Naomh Mhuire14022M Knockaclarig Mxd N14052V S S N Baile14065H Deasmumhan Coachford N S14107U Kantur 14116V Sherkin Island N14198D S Castletownroche N S14225D Kilbrittain Mixed N14227H S Naomh Eoin Easpal14303U Scoil Bhride14403B Kilcoe NS14430E Crosshaven, Douglas, Co. Cork Cork S N Cleire14433K Rinn Scide, Co. St. Cork Johns N14726C S Derrycreha N Church S Road,14784Q Ballydehob, Co. Cork Abbeystrewry N N Mhuire S An14813U Oileain, Brosna, Sharman Tralee, Crawford Kinsale Co. St, N Kerry Cork S Mallow,14816D Co. Cork Dunmanwa 14839P Roscarbery Con N14993C S Scoil Lachtain Naofa Coachford,15010K Co. Cork Clondrohid N S15011M Baltimore, Co. Castletownroche, Cork S Co. N Cork Rae15135H Na Ndoiri Kilbrittain, Scoil Co. An Cork Chroi15140A Ro Naofa Mayfield, Co.15165Q Cork Irish Bantry Broadband Boys N15346U S Ballingree Mxd N15380U S Ballydehob, Ballintotas Digiweb Co. N Cork S15410D Smart Wireless S N Baile Skibbereen,15484J An Co. Mhuirne Cork Smart Dromagh Mixed Digiweb N15516T S Oilean Chleire, An Kilcrohane Sciobairin, Kinsale, N Co. Co. Bantry, S Chorcai Cork Co. Skibbereen, Cork Co. Digiweb Cork Glounthaune Mixed N.S. Satellite Clonpriest N S ADSL Roscarbery, Kinsale, Digiweb Co. Co. Cork Cork Cill Wireless Na Satellite Martra, Co. Chorcai Satellite Smart Digiweb St. Clondrohid, Anne’s Co. Road, Cork Blarney, Rae Co. Digiweb Na Cork Ndoiri, Maigh Chromtha, Co. Chorcai Satellite Smart Smart Digiweb Bantry, Co. Satellite Macroom, Cork Co. Cork Satellite Satellite Smart Carrig An Adhmaid, Castlemartyr, Maigh Co. Chromtha, Cork Co. Chorcai Dromagh, Mallow, Digiweb Satellite Co. Cork Glounthaune, Co.Cork Satellite ADSL Durrus, Bantry, Smart Co. Cork Smart Digiweb Digiweb ADSL Youghal, Co. Digiweb Cork Satellite Smart BT Ireland Smart BT Ireland ADSL Satellite ADSL Satellite Smart Satellite ADSL ADSL ADSL ADSL Digiweb Smart Satellite Digiweb Digiweb Irish Broadband Digiweb Satellite Satellite ADSL Satellite Wireless Digiweb Satellite Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1027 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1028

[Ms Hanafin.] Treasna, Co. Cork Smart ADSL acroom, Co. Cork BT Ireland ADSL aGNS Ath mBNS M 15550T15563F15594Q Ballyheeda N S15597W Lisheen Mixed N15646J S Grange Fermoy N15701O S Macroo 15718I Coomhola N15781P S Bartlemy N S15792U S N15903D Seosamh Cobh Ballintemple N S16087E Upper Glanmire N16109L S Killavullen N S16128P Kealkil N S16159D Scoil Realt Na16246V Mara Mitchelstown Con N16253S S Mallow Con N16259H S Drumclugh N S16271U Aghina N Ballinhassig,16286K S Co. Skibbereen, Cork Co. Kilcolman Cork N Fermoy, S16335U Co. Cork Watergrasshill N S16339F Carrigboy N S16377N Rylane N S16396R Bantry, Co. Cork S N Iosef16497A Naofa Rathcormac, Cobh, Fermoy, Co. Cobh Co. Cork Convent Cork16648S Boherbue Ballintemple Scoil N N Naomh S S,16680O Micheal, Crab Upper Lane, Glanmire, Cork Kilworth Whites Junior Cross, N Co.16681Q S Cork Ath Treasn Mallow,16683U Co. Cork Scoil Colmcille Ballycotton,16684W Midleton, Co. Mitchelstown, Cork Scoil Co. Na Cork Bantry, Mbraithre Co.16746S Cork Bishop Murphy Memorial16863W School Scoil Smart Na Mallow, Mbraithre Co.16876I Cork Ballygarvan Bantry, N Co.16885J S Cork Desertserges N S Smart16900C Digiweb S Caum, N16901E Enniskean, Macroom, Watergrasshill, Caipin Co. Co. Co. Cork Cork. Cork Smart Adrigole N16940O S S N Satellite Padraig16945B Naofa Digiweb Durrus, B Bantry, Co. S Cork N Irish Padraig Broadband Naofa N B Dundar Mhuighe Cork, N Satellite Co. Mardyke, S Satellite Cork Cork Digiweb Lisgriffin N Cobh, S Co. Cork BT Wireless Kilworth, Ireland ADSL Co. Boherbue, Cork Co. Cork Digiweb Fermoy, Satellite Co. Cork. Blarney Smart BT Rathluirc, St, Satellite Ireland Co. Cork Cork ADSL Midleton, Digiweb Co. Cork Satellite Smart Ballygarvan, Co. ADSL Cork Enniskean, Co. Digiweb Cork Digiweb Satellite Smart Digiweb Satellite Skibbereen, Co. Iniscein, Cork Co. Digiweb Skibbereen, Chorcai Adrigole, Co. Bantry, Cork Co. Cork Kinsale, Co. Cork ADSL Satellite Satellite ADSL Satellite Digiweb Buttevant, Digiweb Co. Cork Satellite BT Digiweb Ireland Smart Smart Smart Irish Satellite Wireless Broadband ADSL Satellite BT Ireland Satellite Smart ADSL Wireless Digiweb? ADSL Digiweb ADSL Smart Digiweb Smart Satellite Satellite Smart Satellite Digiweb Satellite ADSL ADSL Satellite Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1029 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1030 16955E17011W17024I S N Na17045Q Mona Fliche Mocomhog N S17050J Scoil Na17066B Croise Naofa St. Patricks B17067D N S S N17079K Naomh Sheamuis Christ King Mon17087J Christ King Girls17103E Primary School S N Carraig17105I An Ime S N17112F An Chlochair St. Marys Convent17152R G Muire Gan17156C Smal C Ballyhea N S17168J S N Cnoc17171V Sceach Scoil Naomh Aine17245B S N Macroom,17251T Inis Co. Eoghanain Cork S N Cuilinn17281F Ui Caoimh Dripsey Mahon, Cappaboy, N Cork Kealkil, S17297U Bantry, Co. Cork Ovens N Turner’s S17300G Cross, Cork Ballyhooley Togher Durrus, Road, N Co. Cork S17313P Cork S N Fearghail17323S Naofa Lios Turners Maighir Cross, Cork17324U Our Lady of17338I Macroom, Lourdes Co. Cork Monkstown N17360B S Scoil Kanturk, Naomh Carrigtwohill, Co. Breandan Co. Cork17362F Cork S N17363H Cill Bonain Glasheen, S Cork N Mhuire17505B S N Breandan17515E Naofa SN Ballyhea, Clanna Cros Rathluirc, Caoilte, Tseain Co. Co.17527L Cork Chorcai Charleville, Digiweb Co. Cork S N Cill17528N Ruadhain Inis Mala, Eoghanan, Co. S Co. Chorcai N Chorcai Achadh17533G Bolg Digiweb Scoil Bhrugh Thuinne17579H S N Naomh17600S Caitriona S Dripsey, N Co. Rathain Irish17602W Cork Satellite Irish Broadband Broadband Irish S Broadband N Killeagh, Ath Co. Fhada Ovens, Cork Co. Cork S Digiweb N Dunmanway, Na Co. Satellite Scairte Cork Leithe S N Ballinlough, Naomh Cork Digiweb Wireless Lachtin Wireless Newmarket, Wireless Co. Cork Cnoc An Chuilinn, Digiweb? An Rath Monkstown, Mhor, Co. Co. Cork Chiarrai Smart BT Satellite Ireland Atharlach, Co. Chorcai Wireless Digiweb Rathcool, Mallow, Co. Digiweb Cork Irish Rath Broadband Satellite Peacain, Blackpool, Co. Cork Bun An Smart Tabhairne, Smart Corcaigh Glanmire, Co. ADSL ADSL Cork Churchtown, Mallow, Achadh Wireless Co. An Cork Chrioste, Co. Digiweb Corcaigh Satellite Connaithe Conna, Co. Satellite Cork Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Mallow, ADSL Co. Saleen Cork Cloyne, Rostiallain, Midleton, Co. Co. Cork Cork Smart Digiweb Domhnach Satellite Mor, Co. Smart Chorcai Satellite Digiweb Irish Broadband Smart Satellite Smart Satellite Digiweb Wireless Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Smart Digiweb Digiweb ADSL Irish Broadband Satellite Digiweb Local Loop Satellite Smart Satellite ADSL Wireless Satellite Smart Satellite Smart BT Ireland Satellite Satellite Leased Line Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1031 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1032

[Ms Hanafin.] lantane, Mallow, Co. Cork Digiweb Satellite allyphehane, Cork Irish Broadband Wireless aGNS B eBNS G 17609N17639W17667E Rathcormac N S17706L Scoil Na Mbraithre17715M S N Padraig17754W Naofa S N An17755B Mhaoilinn S N Rath A17761T Bharraigh S N Naomh Eoin17763A B Scoil Naomh Mhuire17765E C S N Mhuire17790D Rockchapel N S17794L S N Re17804L Na Scrine Curraghagalla N S17823P S N An17829E Phairc S N Cnoc17848I Na Manach Glantan 17868O S N Ath17887S An Mhuillinn Rathcormac, S Co. Mitchelstown, N Cork17888U Co. Mhuire Cork Scoil Freastogail Muire17921P Whitechurch, Co. Cork S N17950W Naomh Padraig Newmarket, Clonakilty, S Co. Co. N Cork Cork Na17955J Trionoide S N Moing17972J Ballincollig, Na Ballincollig, Co. Miol Co. Shanagarry Cork Cork N S17993R Muire Gan18000W Smal S N18020F Cill Mhuire B Scoil Rockchapel Mhuire Araglinn, NS, Gan Cill18100D Mallow, Smal Uird, Co. B Co. Cork Naomh Chorcai Mhuire Roscarbery, B Co.18128C Cork Kilworth, Co. Cork S N An18153B Gharrain Lisgriffin N Minane S Bridge,18154D Cork Youghal, Co. S Cork N Mhuire18196T Mxd Rathluirc, S Co. N Cork Padraig18208A Naofa C S N Padraig Fermoy,18217B Naofa Co. Cork BT Smart Ireland S N Gleannamhain18237H Our Lady of Smart Gleann18238J Good Mallow, An Counsel Co. Phreachain, NS Cork Glenville, Scoil Co. Padre Cork Pio18246I N S Digiweb Bealad Maria Rossmore, Digiweb Assumpt Clonakilty, Co. Cork Clashbee, Mallow, ADSL Co. Maria Cork Assumpta Jnr. Smart Smart Inft Shanagarry, Satellite S Midleton, Digiweb N Co. Baile Cork Muine Digiweb Glasheen, Cluain Cork Dilleain, Fermoy, Satellite Co. Cork Lisardagh, Co. Satellite Cork Satellite Carrigtwohill, Co. Cork Digiweb ADSL ADSL Satellite Upton, Digiweb Co. Cork Satellite Smart Smart Goleen, Skibbereen, Co. Coisceim, Cork Mallow, Dillons Digiweb Co. Cross, Cork Cork Ballincollig, Co. Cork Digiweb Dillons Satellite Cross, Digiweb Cork Glanworth, Co. Cork Satellite BT Ireland Satellite Churchfield, Cork Satellite City Satellite Ballyphehane, Digiweb Smart Cork Digiweb Satellite Smart Satellite ADSL Ballineen, Co. Cork Satellite Irish Smart Satellite Broadband ADSL Smart ADSL Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Smart ADSL Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband ADSL Wireless Wireless Satellite Wireless Digiweb Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1033 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1034 Carrigaline No.3, Carrigaline, Co. Cork. Smart ADSL e3NS 18253F18266O18278V Scoil Naomh Caitriona18279A Ballygown NS18292P S N Faill18296A O Gcobhthaigh Carrigalin 18301N Gaelscoil An Teaghlaigh18316D Naofa Dromdhallagh N S18356P S N Mhuire18377A B S N Fhursa18388F S N Barra18422C Naofa Iosef Naofa18428O Scoil Naomh Micheal18431D Scoil Na Nog18444M S N Baile18458A Nora SN Droichead Na18461M Bandan Model Farm S Road, N Corcaigh Clogach18468D St. Bernadettes Spec Ballydesmond,18472R Sch Mallow, Co. Baile Cork Feithean, S Co. N Chorcai Muire Na Ballygown,18475A Doirini Mallow, Co. Cork Scoil Mhuire18483W Scoil Chaitriona18487H S N Baile18491V Ui Drimoleague, Chroinin Co. Cork Spastic Sc of Div18497K Child S N Naomh18535P Mhuire Millstreet, S Co. N Cork Garran18549D An Easaigh Little Island Scoil Ladhar, NS Bharra,18563U Banteer, Sraid Co. Gillabbey, Cork Corcaigh Church St. Road, Johns Blackrock, Girls18566D Cork N S S Fermoy, N Co. Cnoc Cork18567F Na Croighe Bandon, Scoil Co. Naomh Cork Brid18586J C Gleann S Maghair, Irish N Co. Broadband Athair Chorcai18587L Maitiu Baile C Nora, Digiweb Waterfall, Co. S Cork Bonnington, N Montenotte, Inis18657G Co. Cork Scoil Eanna Irish18659K Broadband Digiweb Cloglach, Skibbereen, Scoil Wireless Timoleague, Co. Mhuire Co. Cork Banrion18713N Cork Scoil Na Mbraithre18734V Lisavaird Mxd N Wireless 18786R Satellite S Caislean Ui Cloyne, S Ballynoe, Dhonnabhain, Middleton, N Mallow, Drimoleague, Co. Fionan Co. Co.18829J Cork Na Cork Cork Reanna Ballintemple, Co. Realt Cork Digiweb Na Irish Maidine Satellite Broadband Scoil Iosagain Fearann, Co. Killbrittain, Chorcai Co. Cork S N Chobh Chionn Tsaile Irish Broadband Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Little Island, Co. Cork Satellite Ballea Rd, Cnoc Carrigaline, Na Co. Groighe, Cork Mallow, Co. Wireless Cork Digiweb Smart Eglantine Smart House, Ballinlough, Cork Smart Digiweb An Tochair, BT Corcaigh Ireland Satellite Satellite Digiweb Mayfield, Cork Wireless Digiweb Montenotte, Killeagh, Cork Co. Doneraile, ADSL Cork Co. Satellite Cork ADSL Satellite ADSL Digiweb Digiweb Clonakilty, Nohoval, Co. Belgooly, Cork Co. Cork Satellite Digiweb Ballyphehane, Cork Cionn Tsaile, Co. Satellite Chorcaigh Smart Farranree, Digiweb Cork Digiweb Satellite Satellite Smart Digiweb Wireless Irish Broadband Satellite Satellite Satellite Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless ADSL Wireless Digiweb Smart Digiweb Smart Smart Digiweb BT Ireland Irish Broadband Satellite Satellite Local Loop Satellite Local Loop Satellite Irish Broadband Wireless ADSL Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1035 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1036

[Ms Hanafin.] 18883P19000E19203S S N Iosagain19224D S N An19231A Spioraid Naomh C Nmh Pol19232C Special School S N Cillmin19249T S N Barra19256Q Naofa Bhuach S N Barra19307H Naofa Cailini Barryroe NS19342J Scoil Ghobnatan19348V Derrinagree N S19351K Scoil Naomh19381T Eoin Baiste Newcestown N S19404F S N Cill19410A Criodain Rathmore N S19415K SN Mhuire19420D St. Curraheen Killians Rd, Spec Bishopstown,19426P Sch Cork Scoil An Athar19427R Tadhg Montenotte, Cork SN Mala, Fhiachna Co. Cork19433M S N Beaumount, Mharcuis19501D Cork B S N Bhreanndain19507P C Beaumont, Cork Holy Family Cillmin, S Coalnaconarty, S19525R Clonakilty, Co. Cork Cahermore New Central19526T S Scoil Chaitigheirn19557H Mallow, Lislevane, Co. Mhichil Bandon, Cork Naofa Co. Kilbrin, Cork19588S Kanturk, Co. Cork Derrinagree, SN Mallow, Cill Cork Dairbhre19595P Caheragh NS19637F Newcestown, Scoil Bandon, Naomh Co.19672H Therese Cork Ladysbridge, St. Irish Castlemartyr, Marys Broadband Co. Central19714U Cork School Scoil Fionnbarra19730S Baltimore, Skibbereen, Co. Scoil Cork Muire Adj Na To:19759T Ngrast Bishopstown Comm Scoil Smart Sch, Mhuire An Wireless Westgate Ar Athar Road, Ballyhooley, Chnoc Tadhg,19760E Bishopstown, Co. Haoine Carraig Cork Cork Na Bhfear, Co. Scoil Chorcai Oilibheir19761G St. Marys Smart Spec19771J Sch Gleann Garbh, Scoil Co. Triest Chorcai An An Smart Gleann, Ghleann, Irish Cahermore, Corcaigh Corcaigh Broadband Co. Dungourney Irish Cork Central Broadband N Sc Scoil Satellite Charleville, Barra Co. Cork Irish Broadband Smart Wireless Na Haorai, Beanntrai, Wireless Co. Digiweb Chorcai Local Loop Digiweb Smart Ballinakilla, Smart Bere Wireless Smart Smart Island, ADSL Bantry, Kildorrery, Co. Co. Cork Cork Bishopstown, Cork Enniskeane, Co. Cork Caheragh, Co. Cork Smart Satellite Satellite Satellite Beal Knocknaheeny, Guala, Beal Satellite Cork Co. Atha Chorcai Ghaorthaidh, Co. Chorcai Satellite Satellite ADSL Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Ballincollie Rochestown, Road, Cork Ballyvolane, Dungourney, Cork Co. Cork Digiweb Smart Digiweb Smart Digiweb Lota, Cork Satellite Smart Satellite Innishmore, Baile An Chollaigh, Co. Chorcai Wireless Satellite Satellite Local Loop Satellite Digiweb BT Ireland Smart Smart ADSL Digiweb Smart Irish Broadband Irish Broadband ADSL Satellite Satellite Satellite Local Wireless Loop Wireless Smart Smart Digiweb Satellite ADSL Smart Satellite Satellite ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1037 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1038 19788D19801P19833F St. Kevins School19839R Drimoleague Junior Sch19851H Gaelscoil Chorain,19852J Gael Scoil Ui19881Q Riordain Gaelscoil De Hide19882S Gaelscoil Ui19886D Riada Gaelscoil Carrig Ui19899M Leighinn Scoil An19906G Athair Tadhg O Gael Murchu Scoil Thomais19908K Daibhis Gaelscoile Cobh19909M Cork N School19918N Project Gaelscoil Mhachan19977G Gaelscoil Peig Sayers19978I Drinagh Mixed NS19989N Bandon Boys Drimoleague, NS19993E Co. Cork The Rectory, Infirmary Maulatrahane Road, Central20001N Cork NS Scoil Mhuire Na20004T Sraid Trocaire Cul Na Rua, Tra, Baile Eochaill, Gaelscoil An Co. An Chollaigh, Chorcai. Ghoirt20006A Co. Alainn Chorcai Gaelscoil Bheanntrai Carrig Ui20009G Duglas, Mainistir Leighinn, Corcaigh Fhearmai, Co. Co. Chorcai Scoil Chorcai An Croi20022V Ro Baile Naofa An Gaelscoil Easpaig, Chloich Co. Na Chorcai Magh20024C Coillte Ealla, Co. Gaelscoil Chorcai Dr M20025E Ui Shuilleabhain Scoil Na Mbuachailli20036J Bun Scoil Muire20038N Grattan Cobh, Street, Co. Gaelscoil Cork Chorcai Droichead Na20049S Bandan North Carraig Presentation Dubh,20074R Primary Corcaigh School C/O Na Scoil Piarsaigh Aiseiri C.L.G., Chriost20077A Parklands, Corcaigh Irish Broadband Ringaskiddy Lower Smart20088F Harbour Dunmanway, N Co. S Cork St. Leap, Gabriels Skibbereen, Special Co.20105C Smart School Cork Bandon, Digiweb Scoil Co. Cill An Cork Na Spioraid Mullach,20106E Naomh Aibhinne Co. (Boys) Murmont, Wireless Chorcai Gort Alainn, Scoil Corcaigh Mhuire N.S.,20107G Smart Star Smart of The Sea Primary Tigh School Warner, Scoil Sraid Nioclais Sraid Na An Na Bearaice, Sciobairin, Castletownbere, Scoile, Beanntrai, ADSL Co. Co. Irish Cloich Co. Chorcai Cork. Gaelscoil Broadband Na Chorcai. Mhainistir Coillte, Na Co. Corann Chorcai. Satellite ADSL Irish Broadband Smart Smart C/O G.A.A. Wireless Pavilion, Gerald Charley Cloich Griffin Hurley Na Street, ADSL Park, Coillte, Cork ADSL Droichead Co. City. Na Chorcai. Bandan, Co. Corcai Wireless Smart O’Brien’s Place, Youghal, Ringaskiddy, Co. Co. Cork Cork. Digiweb Smart Smart Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Farranree, ADSL Cork. Bishopstown, Cork ADSL Curraheen Road, Cork Digiweb Smart Digiweb Wireless Smart Wireless Passage West, Co. ADSL Cork Wireless ADSL Ionad An Smart Schull, Phobail, ADSL Co. Mainistir Cork Na Corann, Contae Chorcai Smart Satellite Smart Satellite ADSL Frankfield, Grange, Satellite Cork Irish Broadband BT Ireland ADSL BT Ireland Wireless ADSL Satellite BT Ireland Digiweb ADSL ADSL Smart Irish Broadband ADSL Irish Broadband BT Ireland Satellite Wireless Wireless Local Loop Smart Digiweb ADSL Satellite Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1039 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1040

[Ms Hanafin.] BT Ireland ADSL Smart Satellite Smart ADSL ´ ´ ´ ´ , Co. Chorcai BT Ireland ADSL ´ rna, Co. Chorcaı ´ Bhla C/O Blarney United Soccer Club, Pairc Radharc Na Habhainn, Teamhair, An Smart ADSL Bakers Road, Charleville, Co. Cork Smart ADSL ´ ostaı ´ Naofa Carraig Na Bhfear, Co. Chorcaı ´ ´ in Mainistir Fhearmuı ´ ithre Chrı ´ Urmoltaigh Droichead Na Bandan, Co. Chorcaı ´ iste Na Toirbhirteiste An Chroı iste Muireiste Cholma Ard Aoibhinn, Bandon, Co. Cork Bishop’s St, Cobh, Co. Cork BT Ireland ADSL BT Ireland ADSL ´ ´ ´ ´ 20119N20140E20151J Cork University Hos School Scoil20162O Mhuire Fatima20182U Gaelscoil Mhuscraı 62050O Sonas Special Primaryjunior62060R School St. Endas NS62061T Ardscoil Uı 62080A Bandon Grammar School62090D Cola 62130M Ardscoil Phobal Bheanntrai62140P Scoil Mhuire Gan62170B Smal Cola 62180E St. Aloysius College62200H Childrens Ward, Sacred Wilton, Heart Cork Secondary62210K School Cola 62260C Carrigaline, Co. Colaiste Cork Muire62270F North Monastery, Cork Nagle Rice Secondary62290L School Cola 62301N Loreto Secondary School62310O Scoil Mhuire62320R Bandon, Colaiste Co. An Cork Phiarsaigh62330U Kilnadur, De Dunmanway, La Co. Bantry, Salle Cork62350D Co. College Cork St. Mary’s Secondary62360G School Patrician Academy62370J Blarney, Co. Cork St. Mary’s Secondary62380M School Convent of Christian Mercy, Brothers Clonakilty, Secondary Co.62420V S Cork Smart Midleton Carrigtwohill, College Co.62421A Cork St. Mary’s High School62440E Christian Doneraile, Brothers Co. Secondary62450H Cork S Presentation Secondary School62460K Smart Scoil Irish Na Broadband Crosshaven, Mbra Co.62470N Cork St. Fermoy, Mary’s Local Co. Secondary Loop Cork62480Q School St. Francis Capuchin62490T College Mount Wireless St. Digiweb Michael Gleann Maghair, Co. St. Chorcaı Fachtna’s — Convent De of La Mercy, Salle Kanturk, Macroom, ADSL Col Co. Co. Mercy Cork Cork Heights Macroom, Secondary Co. School Cork BT BT Ireland Ireland Convent of Castleredmond, Mercy, Midleton, Mallow, Co. Co. Cork Cork Mallow, Smart Co. Cork Satellite BT Ireland Mitchelstown, Co. ADSL ADSL Cork Midleton, Mitchelstown, Co. Co. Smart Midleton, Cork Cork Co. Cork ADSL Convent Smart of ADSL Mercy, Charleville, Co. Cork Rochestown, Co. Cork Smart BT Ireland Skibbereen, Co. ADSL Cork Skibbereen, Co. Cork Smart Rosscarbery, Co. Cork Smart BT Ireland Satellite ADSL ADSL Eircom BT Ireland ADSL ADSL Smart ADSL BT Smart Ireland ADSL BT Ireland ADSL BT Ireland BT Ireland ADSL ADSL Smart ADSL ADSL ADSL ADSL Smart Smart Smart Satellite ADSL ADSL ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1041 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1042 BT Ireland ADSL BT Ireland ADSL ´ ´ al Atha An Ghaorthaidh, Co. Chorcaı ´ Capwell Road, Cork Digiweb Wireless ´ ost Rı ´ iste Mhuire An Mhainistir Thuaidh, Corcaigh Digiweb Wireless ´ iste Chrı iste An Spioraid Naoimh Bishopstown, Corkiste An Chraoibhin Digiweb Wireless Duntaheen Road, Fermoy, Co. Cork BT Ireland ADSL ´ ´ ´ 62500T62510W62520C Christian Brothers62530F Loreto Secondary School62531H Christian Brothers College62540I North Monastery Secondary62560O Scho Gaelchola 62570R Deerpark C.B.S.62580U Cola 62590A Presentation College62621I Cola 62630J St. Vincent’s Secondary62640M School North Presentation62650P St. Aloysius62661U School St. Angela’s College62690E Ursuline Secondary School62691G Youghal, Mount Co. Mercy Our Cork College Lady’s62692I Golf Mount, Sidney Links North Hill, Road, Monastery Wellington Youghal, Scoil Rd., Road, Co. Mhuire Cork Cork. Cork62693K Regina Mundi College62730N Christ King70910L Girls Sec. School Presentation Secondary School70920O St. Patricks College70930R St. St. Brogan’s Patrick’s College Road,70931T Cork St. Mary’s Mardyke, Colaiste Road, Cork Ghobnatan Cork70950A St. Goban’s College70960D Scoil Mhuire70970G Digiweb Clonakilty Community College70990M Farranree, Cork Coachford College71000A St. Blackrock, Maries Cork of Cobh St. The Community Patrick’s Isle, BT College Hill, Digiweb Sharman71020G Ireland Cork Crawford Street, Cola Cork71030J Model Farm Colaiste Road, Treasa Cork Wireless 71040M Davis College71050P Smart South Douglas Joe Douglas Road, Murphy Road, Cork Rd, Cork Ballyphehane, Mcegan Cork College71080B ADSL 2 St. Sydney Fanahan’s Wireless Place, College Wellington71090E Road, Cork St. Colman’s Community71100E College Mannix College Gardiner’s Hill, Digiweb Cork Rossa College Kilbrogan, Bandon, Co. Digiweb Cork ADSL Colaiste Baile Eoin Mhic Ire, Clonakilty, Co. Digiweb Co. Chorcaı Cork Sheskin, Bantry, Co. Cork Smart Wireless Carrignafoy, Be Cobh, Co. Cork Coachford, Wireless Co. Cork Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Smart Digiweb Smart ADSL Kanturk, Youghal Co. Digiweb Road, Cork Midleton, Co. Cork Annabella, Summerhill, Mitchelstown, Co. Smart Mallow, Cork Co. Macroom, Cork Co. Wireless Cork Wireless Wireless Wireless ADSL Local BT Loop Ireland Charleville, Wireless Co. Cork Digiweb Skibbereen, Co. Cork ADSL Smart Golf BT Links Ireland Road, Youghal, Co. Cork ADSL BT Ireland Wireless Smart ADSL BT Ireland ADSL ADSL Smart BT Ireland BT Ireland ADSL Satellite BT Ireland ADSL ADSL BT Ireland ADSL Smart Smart ADSL ADSL ADSL ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1043 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1044

[Ms Hanafin.] Smart Satellite ´ allyroan, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16 Irish Broadband Wireless Lucan, Co. Dublin Smart ADSL n Naofa Tramore Road, Cork Digiweb Wireless ´ nBNS B nBNS iste Choilm Ballincollig, Co. Cork Smart ADSL ´ 71101G71102I71103K St. Aidan’s Community71110H College Schull Community71120K College Cola 71121M Nagle Community College71122O College of Commerce71123Q St. John’s Central College71124S Colaiste Stiofa 76064F Terence Mac Swiney76067L Community C Colaiste Daibheid76086P Glanmire Community College81008W Colaiste Pobail Naomh81009B Mhuire Maria Immaculata Community91386O Ballincolly, Col Dublin Ashton Hill, School Cork91387Q Boherbue Comprehensive School91388S Colla Ballincollig Road, Community Schull, School Co.91390F Cork Beara Community School91391H Mahon, Blackrock, Cork Carrigaline Community91396R School Millstreet Community School91397T Hollyhill, Morrison’s Sawmill Knocknaheeny, Island, St. Street, Cork Cork Peter’s Cork Community91400F School Douglas Community School91499E Bishopstown Community School Riverstown, Glanmire, Mayfield Co. Community Cork School00714P Cill Dunmanway, Na Kinsale Co. Mullach, Community Cork Co. School00729F Chorcaı An T-Ardan Theas, Corcaigh00743W Boherbue, Luca Mallow, Co.00752A Cork Irish Broadband Clochar Loreto N01170G Innishmore, S Ballincollig, Mater Co. Dei Cork Primary School01795A Central Senior Blackrock Mxd Smart Road,02872U N Cork S Waterpark Wireless Castletownbere, Road, S Beara, Carrigaline, N Co. Co. Na Cork Cork03359N H-Aille Central Millstreet Infs Town, School Co.03917V Cork Smart Sandyford Passage Mxd West, N Co.04992R S Cork Smart Ballyroa Bishopstown, Clermont Cork05600C Avenue, Douglas, Cork Naomh Padraig Digiweb Boys05933G Satellite Scoil Digiweb An Old Croi Youghal Irish Naofa Road, Broadband Mayfield, Cork Clochar San Dominic Kinsale, Co. Cork Georges Hill ADSL Convent Local Loop Digiweb Wireless BT Ireland Wireless Smart Smart Wireless Basin Smart Lane, James Street, Dublin Grange 8 Road, Rathfarnham, Dublin Smart 14 Marlboro St, Wireless ADSL Dublin 1 Digiweb Satellite ADSL Smart Marlboro The St, Smart Naul, Dublin Co. 1 Dublin ADSL Sandyford, Co. BT Dublin Ireland Digiweb Satellite Cambridge Road, Ringsend, Dublin 4 Wireless Smart Glasnevin, Dublin 11 Dunlaoghaire, Co. Dublin Satellite Georges ADSL ADSL Hill, Dublin 7 Wireless BT Ireland Digiweb Smart Local Loop ADSL Wireless Smart Wireless Irish Broadband Smart Digiweb Irish Broadband Wireless Local Loop Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband Satellite Irish ADSL Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Dublin 00697S St. Brigids Mxd N S Castleknock, Dublin 15 Irish Broadband Wireless 1045 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1046 y N S (2) Dalkey, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Wireless 06200O06468K07546J Booterstown Boys09492W St. Laurence O09642P Toole Senior Girls Goldenbridge Convent09750S Balscadden N S09932B Burrows N S10296G St. Josephs10494K Boys N S Stanhope St. Convent10653E Scoil Naomh Mearnog11525A All Saints N11578V S Chapelizod N S11583O St. Patricks N11638N School City Quay Boys11776C N S St. Andrews Seville N Place,11873A S Dublin 1 Whitechurch Nat School11894I St. Laurence O Booterstown,12014D Toole Blackrock, Junior Co. Boys Dublin Rathmichael N S12358M Goldenbridge, Inchicore, Dublin 8 Scoil Mhuire12448N St. Andrews N12755W S Swords Borough Balscadden, N Ring S13217W Commons, Co. Dublin Gardiner Street Convent Terenure,13447Q Dublin 6 Stanhope Kildare Street, Sutton, Place Dublin Dublin N 7 13 S13611D Strand Road, Holy Portmarnock, Family Co. National Dublin School13612F Scoil Mhuire13815T Presentation Primary School14180H Carysfort Ave, Presentation Drumcondra, Blackrock, Primary Dublin Chapelizod, Co. School 914463T Dublin Dublin 20 Howth Rd Seville Mxd14556D Place, City N Dublin Quay, S 1 Dublin Holmpatrick 2 Irish N Whitechurch, Broadband S Rathfarnham,14586M Dublin 16 St. Malahide, Irish Columbas Co. Broadband N14647G Dublin S Irish Mxd Broadband St. Endas Primary14717B School Carysfort Smart Wireless NS14917J Rathmichael, Dalke Shankill, Wireless Co. Dublin14939T Wireless Rathgar N S14980Q Hermes Dumhach Gardiner Swords Lucan, Zion Tragh, Street, Borough Co. Parish Dublin Dublin N Dublin Primary 4 1 S, School Swords, Co. Rathfarnham Rathcoole, Dublin Parish Co. N Dublin S Glasnevin Irish N Broadband ADSL S 96 Upper Digiweb Rathmines Blackpitts, Irish Rd, Dublin Broadband Dublin 8 6 Hermes Terenure Road Wireless West, Dublin Wireless 6w Irish Broadband Lucan, Co. Dublin Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Howth Rd, Wireless Clontarf, Dublin Wireless 3 Irish Broadband Wireless Holmpatrick, North Digiweb St. Skerries, Strand, Endas Co. Dublin Primary Dublin 3 School, Whitefriar Wireless St, Irish Dublin Wireless Irish Broadband 8 Broadband Irish Broadband Wireless Convent Bushy Road, Park Blackrock, Wireless Road, Wireless Co. Rathgar, Dublin Dublin 6 Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Smart Washington Lane, Templeogue, Dublin 14 Rathgar, Digiweb Dublin 6 Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Digiweb Wireless Botanic Avenue, Glasnevin, Dublin Smart 9 Smart Wireless Wireless Local Loop Wireless Irish Smart Broadband Smart Wireless Wireless Irish Wireless Wireless Broadband Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Irish Broadband ADSL Wireless ADSL Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1047 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1048

[Ms Hanafin.] Iona Road, Glasnevin, Dublin 9, 109 Irish Broadband Wireless nG&I 15056L15132B15253N S N San15284B Vinseann Cailin Harold Boys N15315J S St. Patricks Girls15569R NS Taney N S15618E St. Georges15622S N S Scoil Moibhi15625B Sandford N S15650A St. Patricks15816I NS St. Catherines West15895H N S Corduff N S15995L St. Vincents16177F Inf Boys Drumcondra N S16267G Canon O Hanlon16332O Memorial N S Lindsay Road N16333Q North S William St, Portrane Dublin Boys 1 N16352U S St. Patricks Snr16353W Mixed St. Dalkey, Patricks Cambridge Co. Jnr. Road,16461C Dublin Mixed Dublin 4 St. Brigids Boys16567S N S St. Brigids Girls N16577V S Caisleain Nua Liamhna16629O Sydenham St. Villas, Georges Dundrum, N Dublin S, St. 14 Hampton Brigids Street16651H Convent Balbriggan, N Co. S Milverton, Dublin St. Skerries, Brigids Co. Convent Dublin16659A Donore Avenue, Ranelagh, South Kilternan Dublin Circular Church 6 Road, of Dublin16675V Ireland Chapelizod 8 NS Village, Chapelizod, St. Dublin Clares 20 Convent16695E N S Sandymount, St. Dublin Columbas 4 Co North16753P William Street, Dublin Mulhuddart 1 Lusk, NS Co. Dublin16754R Church Scoil Avenue, Na Drumcondra, Mbrathar Dublin16759E 9 Smart St. Vincent De16786H Irish Pauls Broadband Girls Lindsay School St. Road, Vincents Glasnevin, Convent Dublin16792C Inf 9 Donabate, N Skerries, Co. S Co. Dublin S Dublin, N 137 Mhuire16794G Na Mbrathar Skerries, Co. St. Dublin, Brigids Irish 137 Convent Broadband16799Q Wireless N S Irish Smart Broadband St. Brigids Convent Foxrock,16844S N Dublin Irish S 18, Broadband 118 St. Brigids ADSL N Foxrock, Newcastle16860Q S Dublin Lyons, 18, Co. Irish Dublin, St. Broadband Wireless 128 Michaels C16864B B Smart S Kilternan, Wireless Haddington Co. Road, Dublin, Dublin Scoil 118 4, N. 104 Breandan Wireless Corpus Christi N Glasnevin, S Dublin 11, Wireless 111 St. Wireless Josephs Special Sch Harolds Irish Cross Broadband Road, Dublin Irish Irish 6w, Broadband Broadband 126 Griffith Avenue, Irish Dublin Broadband ADSL 9, 103 Wireless Irish Mulhuddart Broadband Village, Wireless Wireless Dublin 67 North 15, Griffith Brunswick 115 Avenue, Street, Dublin Dublin Irish 9, 7, Broadband 109 107 Wireless Marino, Dublin 9, 109 Wireless BT Ireland Irish The Broadband Coombe, Dublin BT Wireless 8, Ireland 108 Killester, Dublin Irish 5, Broadband 105 Irish Broadband Irish Wireless Broadband ADSL Merville Irish Irish Rd, Wireless Inchicore, Broadband Broadband Stillorgan, Dublin Blackrock. 8, Co. ADSL 108 Dublin, 134 Irish Loughshinny, Broadband Skerries, Wireless Co. Dublin, Wireless 137 Irish Home Cabra, Broadband Farm Dublin Road, 7 Drumcondra, Dublin 9, 109 Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Wireless Digiweb Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Digiweb Smart Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Smart Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Satellite Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1049 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1050 lasnevin, Dublin 9, 109 Irish Broadband Wireless Scoil Naisiunta Baile Duill, Br Clochaise, Baile Dubhghaill, Ath Cliath 13. 113 Hermes Wireless Cabra, Dublin 7, 107Cabra, Dublin 7, 107 Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Wireless gBNS gGNS nCBS G eBNS 16893I16964F16966J S N16970A Naomh Lorcan Scoil Mhuire Ogh16972E 1 Scoil Naisiunta16983J Stratford St. Molaga Senior16988T NS S N Peadar16989V Agus Pol N S N17055T Naomh Cillin Christ The Kin 17083B Christ The Kin 17104G S N Naomh17110B Mhuire S N Muire17148D Gan Smal B St. Francis Junior17210F National School Naomh Lorcan O17211H Tuathail S N Eoin17214N Baisde G Sen Clochar Lughaidh Cailin17263D Clochar Lughaidh Naoidh17279S Stillorgan, Kilmacud, San Co. Uinsion Dublin, 1 13417284L Zion Loreto Road, College, Rathgar, Crumlin S Dublin Rd, N 6, Dublin Muire 106 12,17318C An 112 Sean Baile Bremore, Scoil Balbriggan, Muire Co.17319E Dublin, 139 Balbriggan, Co. Baldoyl Dublin, 13917320M Scoil An Leinbh17355I Iosa B An Robinhood Leinbh Rd., Iosa Bluebell,17356K Cailini Inchicore, Dublin An 12, Leinbh Priorswood, 112 Iosa Dublin Naoidhin17367P 17, 117 Muire Na17459U Saggart, Dea Co. Coirle Dublin, G Inchicore, Muire 130 Dublin Na 8, Dea 10817464N Coirle Inf Plas Seibhil, Scoil Baile Mhuire Atha Gns17465P Cliath 1, 101 Christ The King17466R I G Seafield Irish Fionnbarra Road, Broadband Naofa Clontarf, Williams Smart Dublin Park,17470I 3, Rathmines, 103 Dublin Williams 6, Park, 106 Dominican Rathmines, Convent Dublin Irish Girls 6,17472M Broadband 106 St. Catherines Infant BT17507F School Ireland Digiweb Wireless St. Sean Raphaelas17559B Bhaile, N Co. S Dublin Baile Falbach Wireless 17569E S N Padraig17595F BT ADSL Naofa Ireland S N Mhuire ADSL Larkhill, Whitehall, Blessed Dublin Oliver Haddington 9, Wireless N Road, 109 S Dublin Larkhill, 4, Whitehall, 104 Larkhill, Dublin Cill Whitehall, 9, Coscain Dublin 109 9, 109 Irish Broadband ADSL Mourne Digiweb Road, Drimnagh, Dublin Mourne 12, Road, 112 Dublin 12, Irish 112 Irish Broadband Broadband Irish Broadband Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Wireless Navan Road, Dublin 7, Cabra, 107 Dublin 7, Cabra, 107 Wireless Wireless Dublin 7, Wireless Cabra, 107 Wireless Wireless Cabra Dublin Wireless West, 7, Dublin 107 7, 107 Digiweb Upper Kilmacud Road, Stillorgan, Co. Dublin, 134 Irish Broadband Lusk, Co. Gleann Dublin, Irish Cuillin, 133 Broadband Cilltighearnain, Irish Co. Broadband Irish Atha Broadband Irish Cliath, Broadband 118 Baile An Ridire, Wireless Baile Garristown, Brigin, Co. Co. Dublin, Satellite Atha 143 Wireless Cliath, 139 Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband The Ward, Co. Dublin Wireless Digiweb Irish Broadband Digiweb Irish Digiweb Broadband Irish Broadband Irish Wireless Broadband BT Ireland Wireless Wireless Wireless Satellite Wireless Satellite Irish Broadband ADSL Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Satellite Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1051 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1052

[Ms Hanafin.] Synge St, Dublin 8, 108 Smart Wireless aCBS 17603B17683C17730I Scoil Iosagain17732M Muire Og 217785K Loreto Con S N17820J Na Lanai Glasa Scoil Chiarain17881G San Nioclas Myra17890H Brighde Naofa17891J Scoil Ui Chonaill17893N Temple St. Hospital17899C N S Scoil Mhuire17912O Sancta Mari 17914S Scoil Carmel17928G S N Eoin17936F Bosco Buach St. Oliver17944E Plunkett SN N Sailbheastar17953F Nfa S N Eoin17954H Baisde Crumlin B Road, Sin Dublin St. 12, Marys 112 School17961E For Aughavannagh Deaf Road, Girls Crumlin, S Dublin N 12, Bhaile 11217970F Eamonn Seafield Avenue, Scoil Clontarf, Caoimhin Dublin Naofa 3,17971H 103 S N Lusca Ascal17976R Ui Choileain, Kinsealy, Domhnach Dublin Cl Cairne, 17, Scoil Baile 117 M Atha17977T Na Cliath Trocaire 5, 105 St. Michaels Spec17978V Temple School Baile Street, Rothluis, Dublin Kilsallaghan, Nth 1 Scoil Co. Richmond Assaim Dublin, Street, B 131 Dublin17979A 1, 101 Scoil Aine C17996A Naiscoil Ide18038B S Mount N Sackville Cnoc Convent, Irish18046A Ainbhil Chapelizod, Broadband Dublin Navan 20, Glen Road, 120 Na Irish Dublin Smol Broadband 7,18047C N 107 S Teach Giuise, St. Tallaght, Margarets Dublin N18080A 24, S St. 124 Malahide, Dominican Oliver Co. Scoil Convent, Plunkett Dublin, Bride Cabra, NS, 123 B Dublin Wireless Grove18104L 7 Road, Irish Malahide, Broadband Co. Smart Scoil Dublin Wireless Seafield Bride Rd, C18137D Clontarf, Dublin 3, Scoil 103 Mhuire Mxd18170B S N De18171D Smart Rathfarnham, La Wireless Dublin Mount Salle 14, Merrion, S 114 Blackrock, N Co. Naomh Dublin, Feargal 134 Irish SN Broadband Muire Na Freastogala Baile Irish Our An Broadband Lady Bhothair, Glenmaroon, Local Assumption Irish Co. Chapelizod, Loop Bns Broadband Baile Dublin Smart Atha 20 Cliath, 132 Lusk, Co. Wireless Dublin, Digiweb 133 Satellite Wireless Wireless Raheny, Dublin 5, 105 Irish Broadband Raheny, Dublin Digiweb 5, 105 Irish Lr ADSL All Broadband Kilmacud Saints Rd, Drive, Stillorgan/Blackrock, Raheny, Co. Dublin Dublin., Wireless Glen 5, 114 Na 105 Smal, Irish Wireless Tallaght, Broadband Dublin 24, Smart Irish 124 St. Broadband Margarets, Co. Dublin. Wireless Smart Blanchardstown, Dublin Wireless 15 Wireless Tucketts Lane, Wireless Blanchardstown, Irish Howth, Dublin Broadband Co. 15 Dublin Irish Broadband Siuracha Na Finglas Carthanachr, Glasanon West, Baile Road, Siuracha Dublin Uailcin, Finglas Na 11 Baile East, Carthanacha, ADSL Atha Dublin Baile Cliath 11 Uailcin, Irish 12 Baile Broadband Atha Wireless Cliath 12 Wireless ADSL Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Digiweb Smart Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband Hermes Satellite Wireless Irish Digiweb Broadband Local Loop Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1053 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1054 Padraig Donabate, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Wireless SNCNaomh 18173H18205R18210K S N Briotas18282M S N An18317F Pharoiste Orthopaedic Hospital18323A SN Paroiste Maitiu Nfa18324C Central Remedial Clinic18341C Scoil Lorcain B18342E Scoil Bride C18360G SN Louise De18361I Marillac C SN Louise De18362K Marillac Scoil Bhreandain18370J S N18386B Caitriona C S N Caitriona18411U Naionain Ioclainn Na18412W Pailirise Marist National School18417J St. Marys School18451J18455R Baldoyle, Dublin Finglas, 13 Dublin St. Brittas, 11 Josephs Co.18477E Cranfield For Dublin Place, Blind Sandymount, NS Dublin Scoil 4 Vernon Lorcain18499O Avenue, Clontarf, Dublin Our 3 Lady of18519R Assumption Scoil Na Mbrathar18569J St. Augustines Palmerstown, Drumfin School Dublin18585H Rd, 20 Ballyfermot, Dublin Scoil 10 Seamus C18602E B S Ballyfermot, Palmerstown, Dublin Dublin 10 St. 20 Declans18623M Special Sch SN Banrion Na18632N Naingea11 Coolock, Dublin Scoil 5 Mhuire18642Q Coolock, Dublin 5 Scoil Naisunta Chnuacha18646B Coolock, Dublin 5 S N Inchinne, Eoin18647D Sandymount Bosco Clogher Avenue, Nai Road, Dublin Buac Crumlin, S 4 Dublin N 12 Naomh18655C Eoin Digiweb Springdale N S18671A Greenhills S Road, N Smart Tallaght, San18682F Dublin Treasa St. 24 Josephs School Scoil for Naomh Visually Seosamh Impaired18683H Boys, Drumcondra, Dublin St. 9 Irish Michaels Siuracha Broadband Hse Na18726W Spec Carthanacha, Sc Baile Irish Uailcin, Smart Broadband Baile Digiweb St. Atha Canices Cliath Wireless B18763F 12 N S Cearnog St. Eaton, Canices Baile G Na N Manach, Francis S Co. Obelisk Street, S Atha Park, Dublin N Wireless Smart Cliath Blackrock, 8 Seosamh Co. Na Dublin Mbrathar Local Digiweb Loop Wireless St. Michaels Hse Spec James Sc Ballyfermot, 35 Street, Dublin Northumberland Dublin 10 Road, 8 Irish Ballsbridge, Digiweb Broadband Dublin 4 Wireless Irish Satellite Broadband Irish Broadband Castleknock, Dublin 15 Irish Broadband Wireless Navan Local Wireless Rd, Loop Irish Dublin Broadband 7 Clondalkin, Wireless Dublin 22 Smart Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Wireless Broadband Tower Road, Clondalkin, Wireless Dublin 22 Lough Wireless Derg Clondalkin, Rd, Dublin Raheny, 22 Dublin 17 5 Wireless The Grosvenor Wireless Rise, Road, Mt Rathgar, Irish Merrion, Dublin Broadband Co. 6 Dublin Irish ADSL Broadband Fairview, Dublin 3 Finglas, Dublin 11 Wireless Finglas, Dublin Smart 11 Ballymun Wireless Rd, Dublin 9 Digiweb Smart Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Wireless Wireless Smart Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless ADSL Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Digiweb Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1055 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1056

[Ms Hanafin.] Irish Broadband Wireless BAC6 ilternan, Co. Dublin Irish Broadband Wireless Fortfield Park, Terenure, Dublin 6 Irish Broadband Wireless nNS1 K X N S BoysXGNS Fortfield Park, Terenure, Dublin 6 Irish Broadband Wireless Hospital Special School 18778S18788V18806U S N18815V Naomh Mochta Our Ladys Hospital18817C Sp S Kilterna 18843D Our Lady of18863J Lourdes School S N Brighde18886V Bainrion Na N-Aingal18904U 2 Benincasa Special18910P School Kill O The18911R Grange N S St. Peters Special18968A Sch Bantiarna Na Mbuanna18969C B Bantiarna Na Mbuanna18976W G St. Malachys B18977B N S St. Eithnes Senior19001G G N S S N Cholmille B19006Q S N Crumlin, Cholmcille19007S Clonsilla, Dublin C Dublin 12 15 Ballyboghill N S Rochestown19015R Ave, Dun Eoin Laoghaire, Baisde Co. B Dublin19032R Sois Eoin Baisde19037E C Naoidh St. Josephs G Ballyfermot19039I N Upper, S Dublin 10 Stewarts 1 Hos Mount Special19066L Merrion Sc Ave, Blackrock, Co. St. Cullenswood Dublin Monicas House, N Br19114T S Feadha Cuilinn, Kill Raghnallach, O St. The Vincents Grange,19151C Home Co. NS Dublin Lucena Loreto Baile Clinic, National Munna, 59 School Dublin19158Q Orwell 9 Road, Dublin Baile 6 St. Munna, Patrick Dublin Gns 919159S St. John of19177U God Sp Sch St. Smart Peters B19178W N Edenmore, S Edenmore, Raheny, Raheny, Dublin Dublin 5 St. 5 Pauls19197D G N S St. Pius 19207D St. Pius Swords, Co. Dublin St. Irish Swords,19208F Kevins Broadband Co. B Dublin N S Digiweb The Irish Ballyboghill,19209H Adelaide Broadband Co. & Dublin ADSL Meath Seafield Hospital Rd, Incorporating Clontarf, Seafield The Dublin Road,19220S National 3 Clontarf, Childrens Dublin Digiweb 3 Holy Spirit Wireless B19221U N S Palmerstown, SN Dublin An 20 Tallaght, Wireless Spioraid Barry Smart Dublin19242F Naiomh Avenue, 24 C Finglas West, Dublin Scoil 11 Naomh19258U Ide Irish Broadband Scoil Satellite Naomh Aine Navan Rd, Dublin Edenmore, Dalkey, 7 Raheny, Co. Our Dublin Dublin Lady 5 of Victories Wireless Infant N Scoil S Padraig Digiweb Naofa Wireless B Digiweb Islandbridge, Dublin 8 ADSL Ballyroan, Rathfarnham, Dublin Irish 16 Digiweb Broadband Limekiln Rd, Greenhills, Dublin 12 Wireless Greenhills, Wireless Kimmage West, Dublin 12 Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Irish Wireless Broadband Broadband Barry Irish Smart Avenue, Broadband Irish Finglas Broadband North-West, Dublin 11 Sillogue Rd, Ballymun, Dublin 11 Wireless Wireless Wireless Silloge Irish Rd, Broadband Baile Wireless Munna, Ballymun Atha Wireless Road, Cliath Dublin 11 9 Digiweb Irish Clondalkin, Broadband Dublin 22 Clondalkin, Dublin 22 ADSL Wireless Irish Hollypark, Irish Broadband Foxrock, Broadband Dublin Irish 18 Broadband Wireless Irish Broadband Smart Irish Wireless Wireless Broadband Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Digiweb ADSL Digiweb Wireless Wireless Digiweb Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1057 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1058 est, Artane, Dublin 5 Irish Broadband Wireless nBNS KilmoreRdW Virgin Mary Girls National School 19259W19262L19297H St. Patricks Gns19298J St. Benedicts N19302U S Cromcastle Gree 19303W Scoil Nais Ide Cailini SN19308J Na Maighdine Muire B Na Maighdine19309L Mhuire19314E St. Brigids19316I Boys N S Scoil Neasain19319O Scoil Na Maighdine19320W Mhuire Boy St. Pauls19321B Hospital Special School St. Olafs N19325J S Our Lady of Good19335M Counsel Boys N Our S Lady Good19355S Counsel Gns St. Ciarans19361N Spec Sch Scoil Na Aingeal Foxrock19373U Ave, Foxrock, Dublin Ballyowen 18 Meadows, Grange19374W C/O Park, Mary Raheny, Immac Dublin Sch An 5 For Taonad Ballymun, Hearing Reamhscoile Dublin19382V Impaired 9 Kilmore Boys Road St. West, Michaels Artane, Hse Dublin19385E Sp 5 Sch Garran Ballymun, Beech Mhuire Dublin Park 9 Stillorgan,19390U Co. Dublin. Scoil Eoin19393D Broadford Rise, Balinteer, Finglas Dublin Childrens 16 Centre19395H Howth Beaumont, Road, Dublin St. Killester, 9 Marks Dublin Sen 519396J NS Johnstown, Dun Mhuire Laoghaire, Iosef Co. Junior Dublin19400U Baile Harmain, Scoil Baile Mobhi Ath Cliath19406J 5 Na Johnstown, Maighdine Dun19409P Muire Laoghaire, Girl Co. Dublin SN Glen Na19430G Gcaorach Balally Holy Drive, Trinity Dundrum,19431I Sen Dublin N 16 S Digiweb Casa Caterina S19435Q St. S Canices Rd, Scoil Glasnevin, An Irish Dublin Tseachtar Broadband 11 Irish19437U Laoch Broadband Newtownpark Ave, Sraid St. Blackrock, Ruthland, Josephs Co. Baile19438W Jnr Dublin Atha Cliath 1 St. Francis Digiweb Xavier J Raheny N Road, S Raheny, Scoil Dublin Wireless Naithi 5 Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless Smart Scoil Colmcille Senior Irish Broadband Finglas Goatstown, West, Dublin Irish Dublin 14 Smart Broadband 11 Wireless Wireless Smart Irish Armagh Broadband Rd, Wireless Crumlin, Dublin Springfield, Irish 12 Tallaght, Broadband Verbena Dublin Wireless Estate, 24 Dublin 13 Local Loop Ballinteer, Dublin 16 Irish Broadband Wireless Local Wyvern, Loop Killiney Bothar Wireless Rd, Mobhi, Irish Killiney, Irish Glasnaoin, Broadband Co. Broadband Baile Dublin Atha Cliath 9 Grange Local Road, Loop Donaghmede, Bothar Dublin Wireless Bhaile Irish 13 Munna, Broadband Baile Munna, Baile Cabra, Atha Dublin Cliath Wireless Wireless 7 9 Smart Roselawn Road, Castleknock, Wireless Dublin 15 Balcurris, Ballymun, Dublin 11 Wyattville, Ballybrack, Co. Dublin Baile An Tsaoir, Dum Droma, Digiweb Baile Irish Atha Irish Broadband Cliath Broadband 16 Local Irish Loop Broadband Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Wireless Wireless Broadband Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Digiweb Wireless Eircom Smart Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless ADSL ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1059 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1060

[Ms Hanafin.] Our Lady Immac Jun NS 19440J19446V19454U St. Marys NS Scoil19456B Mhuire Boys Darndale19462T Ns Junior19463V St. Cronan19464A Naomh Maolruain19465C Naomh Maolruain Senior19466E SN Naomh Colmcille19470S St. Kevins Boys19471U St. Kevins Girls19472W St. Francis19473B Xavier Senior N St. S Pauls Junior19474D National School St. Marks Junior N19480V S Scoil Bhride19489Q Scoil Colmcille Naofa19490B St. Patricks19494J SN Grange Naomh Road, Finnin Rathfarnham, Grange19496N Dublin Pk Darndale, 14 View, Malahide Raheny, Road, Scoil Dublin Dublin Mhuire 5 1719497P Bishop Galvin19499T NS Old Scoil Bawn, Fhiachra Tallaght, Soisir Dublin19500B Old 24 Bawn, Tallaght, Dublin Scoil 24 Mhuire Brackenstown,19502F Swords, Co. Dublin Homelawns, St. Tallaght, Oliver Dublin Punkett 2419503H Sp Sc Phoenix Park Spec19505L Sch Ayrfield, Coolmine, Malahide Castleknock, Rd, Dublin Scoil Dublin 15 Aenghusa 13 Kilnamanagh, Jun19509T Tallaght, NS Dublin 24 Scoil Chronain Kilnamanagh,19510E Tallaght, Dublin 24 SN Oilibheir19515O Scoil Springfield, Nano Tallaght, Nagle19520H Dublin 24 Talbot Irish Senior Broadband NS19524P Knocklyon, Templeogue, SN Dublin Naomh Irish 16 Treasa Broadband19533Q Irish Broadband Donaghmede, St. Dublin Josephs 13 Special19535U Sch Wireless Our Lady Immac19537B Sen Glenties N Park, S S Rivermount, N Finglas St. Wireless Muire South, Patricks19538D Agus Dublin Close, Wireless Iosef 11 Dublin 8 Brackenstown Irish Senior Broadband N Eircom S Irish Ballyboden, Broadband Orwell Dublin St. Park, Beaumont, 16 Attractas Templeogue, Dublin Junior Dublin 5 Irish N 16 Broadband S St. Kevins Junior N Alma S Irish Place, Broadband Carrigbreannan, Irish Wireless Blackrock, Broadband Co. Dublin Irish Wireless Phoenix Broadband Park, Shankill, Dublin Co. 8 Dublin Wireless Irish Balrothery, Broadband Tallaght, Dublin 24 ADSL Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Irish Broadband Sraid Mor, Wireless Digiweb Rath Cuil, Co. Atha Cliath Baile Bawnoge, An Clondalkin, Bhlacaigh, Dublin Cluain 22 Saileach, Baile Bawnoge, Atha Wireless Clondalkin, Cliath Dublin 15 22 Baile Balrothery, Brigin, Irish Tallaght, Co. Broadband Dublin Ath 24 Cliath Irish Our Broadband Wireless Lady Immac Sen NS, Darndale, Wireless Dublin Irish 17 Broadband Brackenstown, Bayside, Smart Swords, Sutton, Co. Dublin Dublin 13 Wireless Wireless Meadowbrook, Dundrum, Dublin 16 Wireless Irish Broadband Smart Newbrook Ave, Smart Donaghmede, Dublin 13 Irish Broadband Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband Smart Smart Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless ADSL Digiweb ADSL Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Wireless Satellite BT ADSL Ireland Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Digiweb Wireless Irish Broadband Hermes Wireless ADSL Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1061 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1062 19541P19542R19543T Belgard Heights N19545A S Esker N S19546C Scoil N An19549I Croi Ro Naofa Corduff N S19556F St. Oliver Plunkett19565G N S St. Fintans19566I NS St. Killians Junior19569O School Scoil Treasa Firhouse19574H Our Lady19575J Queen of Apostles Neillstown N S19576L Marley Grange NS19577N St. Marys19578P Junior N S S N Aenghusa19579R Scoil Iosa19582G St. Helens Scoil Junior19583I Ard N Mhuire, S Belgard Archbishop Heights, Mc Killinarden, Tallaght, Quaid Tallaght, Dublin19589U NS Dublin 24 24 St. Maelruains N19590F S St. Josephs19594N Senior St. N Thomas St. S NS, Gaelscoil Helenas Esker, Inse Drive, Lucan, Chor Finglas, Co.19601H Dublin Dublin 11 Corduff, Physically Castleview, Blanchardstown, Disabled Tallaght, Dublin Children19605P Dublin 15 24 Youth Encounter Project19611K Queen of Carrickbrack Scoil Apostles St. Rd, Treasa NS, Philip Sutton, Ballycullen Clonburris, The Dublin Ave, Clondalkin,19612M Apostle 13 Firhouse, Dublin Junior Dublin 22 N 24 S Irish Scoil Broadband Nais Mhuire19613O Sois Scoil Naomh Colmcille19617W Dalkey School Project St. Divine19618B Peter Word Apostle NS, NS, Scoil Wireless Marley Neillstown, Cnoc Grange, Clondalkin, Mhuire Rathfarnham, Dublin19619D Sin Dublin Rowlagh, 22 16 Clondalkin, St. Dublin Martin 22 De Porres19623R N S St. Pauls Sen19624T NS Scoil Digiweb N Eircom Loughlinstown, St. Aenghusa Dun Malachys Sin, Martello, Laoghaire, NS Balrothery, Smart Portmarnock, Co.19625V Tallaght, Co. Dublin Dublin Dublin 24 St. Pauls Jun NS Scoil Digiweb Irish Nais Broadband Iosa, Scoil Tymon Nais North, Caitriona Tallaght, Dublin Kilclare Irish 24 Avenue, Broadband S Jobstown, Balcurris, N Tallaght, Deansrath, Ballymun, Realt Dublin Irish Old Dublin Na 24 Broadband Nangor 11 Mara Road, Clondalkin, Irish Dublin Irish Broadband 700-701 22 Broadband An Wireless Mountview, Cuarbhothar Wireless Blanchardstown, Theas, Hermes ADSL Dublin Droichead 41 15 Na Main Hinse, St, Baile Finglas, Atha Dublin Wireless ADSL Cliath 11 8 Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Blakestown, Irish Mulhuddart, Broadband Dublin 15 Newbrook Rd, Donaghmede, Dublin 13 Glenageary Wireless Lodge, Glenageary, Irish Co. Smart Broadband Dublin Irish Wireless Broadband Knockmore Ave, Wireless Killinarden, Tallaght, Aylesbury, Irish Dublin Old Broadband 24 Bawn, Tallaght, Irish Dublin Broadband 24 Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Ayrfield, Wireless Malahide Rd, Dublin Wireless 13 Rivermount, Wireless Finglas, Dublin Irish ADSL 11 Broadband Smart Greenhills, Kenure, Walkinstown, Rush, Dublin Co. 12 Dublin Thomas Hand St, Skerries, Co. Wireless Irish Dublin Broadband Hermes Irish Irish Digiweb Broadband Broadband Wireless Local Loop Digiweb Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Smart Digiweb Irish Broadband Smart Irish Broadband Wireless ADSL Wireless Wireless ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1063 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1064

[Ms Hanafin.] 19627C19628E19630O John Paul Ii19636D N S St. Fiachras Sen19641T N S Warrenstown Hse Sp19642V Sch St. Patricks Senior19643A School St. Colmcille Jun19644C NS St. Peter Apostle19646G Sen NS St. Philips Senior19647I N S St. Ciarans N19652B S Scoil Santain19658N St. Marys19660A Sen N S An Chroi Ro19661C Naofa Sois Bishop Shanahan NS19662E Rush NS19663G St. Gabriels NS19668Q St. Michaels NS19669S St. Corduff Raphaels Road, NS Blanchardstown, Sonesta,19676P Beaumont, Dublin Malahide, Montrose, 15 Co. Dublin Dublin St. Corduff, 5 Francis Blanchardstown, Senior Dublin19693P N 15 S Lady of19694R Good Counsel NS Scoil Aine Wyattville, Neillstown, Naofa19702N Ballybrack, Clondalkin, Co. Dublin Dublin 22 Mary Queen of19705T Ireland N S Scoil Mountview, Mhuire Clonsilla, Sin19707A Dublin 15 St. Thomas Junior19716B N S Catherine Mc Auley19721R Hartstown, N Dublin Sc 15 St. Ronans N Killinarden,19723V S Tallaght, Bothar Dublin Na 24 St. Habhann Attractas Rowlagh, Mor, Senior Clondalkin, Tamhlacht,19727G N Dublin Ath S 22 Cliath 24 Orwell Holy Park, Family Templeogue, Junior Smart19742C Dublin N 16 S Queen of Angels19743E Primary School St. Marys Central19755L N S Irish Broadband St. Colmcille Dominican Senior Smart Smart19757P Campus, N Ballyfermot, Rush, S Dublin Co. St. 10 Dublin Bernadettes Dominican Junior Convent,19762I N Ballyfermot, S Dublin 10 Priorswood, Sacred Mourne Dominican Dublin Heart Rd, Convent, Smart 17 N Drimnagh, Ballyfermot,19764M Irish S Dublin Wireless Dublin Broadband ADSL 12 10 St. Michaels Spec19765O Sch Toberburr, Co. St. Irish Dublin Helens Broadband19766Q Senior N Irish S Our Broadband Esker, Lady Lucan, of Co. Wayside Wireless Dublin N ADSL ADSL S St. Thomas Senior N S Jobstown, Scoil Blakestown, Tallaght, Iosagain/Mhuire Wireless Mulhuddart, 59 Dublin Dublin Lower 24 15 Baggot ADSL Street, Wireless Dublin 2 Smart Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Wedgewood, Dundrum, Irish Meadowbrook, Dublin Broadband Dundrum, 16 Dublin 14 Irish Deansrath, Broadband Forest Clondalkin, Fields, Dublin Swords, 22 Smart Co. Dublin Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Belmont Ave, Wireless Donnybrook, Local Knocklyon, Dublin Loop Dublin 4 16 Quarryvale, Clondalkin, Dublin Irish 22 Broadband Wireless Satellite Smart Irish Huntstown, Broadband Hacketstown, Mulhuddart, Skerries, Dublin Wireless Co. 15 Dublin Bluebell, Martello, Inchicore, Portmarnock, Dublin Co. 12 Irish Irish Dublin Broadband Broadband Irish Broadband Irish Wireless Jobstown, Broadband Tallaght, Irish Dublin Broadband 24 Mount La Salle, Ballyfermot, Digiweb Dublin 10 Digiweb Wireless Wireless ADSL Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Smart Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Smart Wireless Wireless ADSL Digiweb Irish Broadband Smart Hermes Digiweb ADSL Irish Wireless Broadband Irish Wireless Broadband ADSL Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1065 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1066 19767S19769W19774P Scoil Mhuire/Seosamh19775R Scoil Thomais19777V St. Josephs Mxd19782O N S Scoil Cnoc Mhuire19785U Junior Gaelscoil Mide19793T St. Brigids N19799I S St. Bernadettes Senior19817H N S St. Thomas Special19819L Sch Sacred Heart19831B N S St. Marys N19834H S St. L O’Tooles19837N 2 Spec Scoil Chaoimhin19840C St. Aidans NS19845M Drimnagh Castle CBS19850F N Mount S La Salle, Holy Ballyfermot, Family Dublin School19855P 10 North Dublin Project19859A Knockmore Ladyswell Ave, N Laurel Killinarden, S19865S East Lodge, Tallaght, Wall, Castleknock, Dublin Dublin Dublin 24 3 15 Gaelscoil Chluain Dolcain19872P Trinity House School19877C Quarryvale, Clondalkin, Archbishop Dublin Bothar Ryan 22 An19878E N Ghleantain, S Ghlais Cill Scoil Bharrog, Chaitlin Baile Maude Atha19888H Brookfield, Cliath Clonshaugh, Tallaght, 5 Priorswood, Dublin Holy Coolock, 24 Family Dublin Senior 1719889J N S Ballycragh N S19893A St. Annes Sruleen, Mxd Clondalkin,19895E N Dublin S 22 Aldborough Scoil Parade, Colm19896G North Strand, Irish Irish Woodview, Dublin St. Broadband Broadband Esker, 1 Kilians Lucan, Irish Senior Co. Broadband19898K N Dublin S Sraid Drimnagh Scoil Mhaoilbhride, Castle, Mhuir Baile Dublin S19901T Atha 12 Iosaf Cliath 1 Scoil Caitriona Na19904C Mbraithre Brookfield, Digiweb Wireless Wireless Tallaght, Dublin Gaelscoil 24 Wireless An Dunedin Duinninigh19907I Park, Monkstown, Ballymun Co. Road Dublin Booterstown (Behind N Esso), S19913D Glasnevin, Dublin Bothar 9 Nangor, Holy Cluain Cross Dolcain, N Irish19919P Baile S Broadband Atha Cliath Digiweb 22 Gaelscoil Mologa19920A Ladyswell, Mulhuddart, Lusk, St. Dublin Co. Josephs Irish 15 Dublin NS Broadband ADSL 19922E Balgaddy, St. Lucan, Davids Wireless Co. N Irish Dublin S Broadband St. Cnoc John Mhuire, Irish of Tamhlacht, Broadband God Baile Forest N Atha Fields, S Cliath River Our Wireless 24 Valley, Ladys Swords, N Co. S Dublin Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Wireless Broadband Smart Digiweb Wireless Ballycragh, Firhouse, Stonebridge Tallaght, Road, Dublin Shankill, Digiweb 24 Co. Dublin Wireless Castleview, Baggot Tallaght, St, Wireless Irish Dublin Dublin Broadband Digiweb 24 2 Armagh Irish Road, St. Broadband Crumlin, Marys Dublin Place, Draighnean, 12 Plas Feltrim Mhuire, Sord, Off Co. Dorset Baile Street, Atha Wireless Dublin Cliath 7 Local Wireless Loop Wireless Wireless Irish Digiweb Broadband Cross Smart Ave, Blackrock, Wireless Co. Dublin Upper Kilmacud Road, Bothar Dundrum, Chlareville, Dublin Baile 14 Atha Smart Cliath Wireless 6w Macroom Road, Bonnybrook, Digiweb Dublin Irish Irish 17 Broadband Broadband Wireless Kilmore Irish Kilmore Road, Broadband Road, Artane, Artane, Dublin Dublin 5 ADSL 5 Irish Broadband St. Columbanus Road, Wireless Wireless Milltown, Dublin 14 Wireless Local Loop Irish Broadband Irish Satellite Broadband Wireless Smart Wireless Irish Wireless Broadband Smart Irish Broadband Irish Wireless Broadband Wireless ADSL Irish Broadband Wireless Smart Irish ADSL Broadband Wireless Wireless ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1067 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1068

[Ms Hanafin.] 19924I19926M19928Q Harolds Cross19929S N S Gaelscoil Cholaiste Mhuire19933J Ranelagh Multi Denom19935N NS St. Brigids19938T Senior Girls Scoil Treasa19939V Naofa Scoil Eoin19940G St. Josephs19943M Scoil Naisiunta An19945Q Dea Aoire Gaelscoil Naomh Padraig19946S St. Damiens NS19949B Rathfarnham Educate Together19950J Rutland Street19954R N S Islamic National School19960M St. Dominics 419962Q N Cearnog S Pharnell, B.A.C. North 1 Bay National19979K School Ranelagh Project Road, St. Dublin Harolds Johns 6 Cross, N Dublin S19981U 6w Oberstown Boys Centre19988L Finglas West, St. Dublin Kevins 11 N19991A S St. Marys N20005V S Petrie Road, Donore St. Whitehall Avenue, Marys Road, Dublin National Churchtown,20010O 8 School Dublin 14 Gaelscoil Na Camoige20012S Leamhcan, Scoil Co. Plas Baile Loreto Mhuire Atha Greendale20014W Avenue, Cliath Road, Rathfarnham, Dublin Dublin 5 St. 14 Roses Tivoli Special20015B Road, School Dun Laoghaire, Co. Griffith Dublin Barracks20020R N S St. Agnes Beechfield N Close, S20021T Walkinstown, Dublin 12 Greendale Gaelscoil Avenue, Bhaile Kilbarrack, 19 Munna20028K Dublin Roebuck 5 Road, Lower Clonskeagh, Rutland Gaelscoil Dublin Street, Thaobh 14 Dublin Na 120029M Coille Irish Henrietta Broadband Street School20035H Setanta Special Tallaght, School Dublin20043G 24 Irish St. Broadband Brigids Irish Lusk, Infant Broadband Co. N20047O Dublin S Wireless Smart Irish St. Broadband Gabriels N S Ballybrack, Gaelscoil Co. Chnoc Dublin Liamhna Irish Broadband Wireless Gaelscoil Grange Irish Wireless Bharra Road, Broadband Baldoyle, Dublin 13 Sallynoggin, Co. Wireless Dublin Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Aras Chronain, Windsor Bothar Ave, An Fairview, Ulloird, Dublin Wireless Cluain 3 Irish Dolcain, Broadband Baile Wireless Atha Wireless Cliath C/O 22 Hermes Scoil Aengusa Digiweb St. Sns, Irish Marys Balrothery, Broadband Place, Wireless Tallaght, Dorset Dublin Wireless Street, 24. Dublin 7 The Old Wireless Guardhouse, Smart Griffith College, South Circular 187 Road, Bothar Cill Dublin Choultrai, Smart Tiarnain, 8 Baile B.A.C. Wireless Munna, 18 Baile Atha Cliath 9 Armagh Road, Crumlin, Dublin Wireless 12 Wireless Henrietta St, Dublin 1 Beechpark, Smart Stillorgan, Co. Dublin Irish ADSL Broadband Wellmount Avenue, Finglas West, Halla Dublin Irish ADSL Na 11 Broadband Ngasoga, Irish Bothar Broadband Cnoc Liamhna, Baile Atha Cliath Cowper Digiweb 16 Street, Irish Dublin Broadband Wireless 7 Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Naomh Wireless Local Fionnbarra Irish Loop Wireless C.L.G., Irish Broadband Ascal Broadband An Fhasaigh, An Chabrach, Bac 7 Wireless Wireless Wireless Irish Satellite Wireless Broadband Wireless Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Wireless Irish Irish Broadband Broadband Digiweb Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1069 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1070 20048Q20052H20053J Gaelscoil Lios Na20056P Nog Gaelscoil Cholmcille20059V Cheeverstown Sp20060G Sch Gaelscoil Phadraig20064O Mother of Divine20066S Grace Monkstown Educate Together20091R NS Our Lady of20092T Consolation NS Lucan Multi20095C Denominational NS St. Peters NS20098I St. Ultan’s National20103V School Gaelscoil Brian Boroimhe20104A Castleknock Educate20109K Together NS John Scottus NS20121A St. Audoens NS20130B Teach Fhiodh Ballydowd Cuilinn, Special 21a School Bothar20131D Oakley, Raghnallach, St. Baile St. Kevins Atha John Boys Cliath of Club, 620136N God Br Special Crestfield, School Cnoc Monkstown St. Rowan Na Grove, Patricks House, Fuiseoige, Blackrock, NS Cheeverstown, Fionnbhru,20137P Co. Templeogue, B.A.C.9 Dublin Dublin 6 Irish Educate Broadband Together NS Holy Ascaill20139T Faith Shileann, NS, Baile Ferndale Breac, Crannog Smart Ave, Co. Nua Ballygall, Atha Special Collins Dublin Bewley20141G Cliath School Ave 11 Way, East, Willsbrook, Donnycarney, Lucan, Dublin Mary Co. 5 Mother Dublin of20145O Hope NS Wireless Inchicore NS20152L The Harold School20153N Cherry Orchard Swords Beechpark Avenue, Educate Avenue, Dublin Together Castleknock, 1020154P NS Dublin 15 Seanbhaile, Bothar North Chill Dublin Dheaglain, Local Muslim20161M Sord, Loop Ns Contae Project Atha Phibsboro, Digiweb St. Cliath Dublin Joseph’s 7 Adolescent20166W & Family Ser Beaumont Hospital Special20168D School Donabate/Portrane Educate Together Digiweb Smart20173T Ballyowen, Griffeen Palmerstown, Glenageary, Valley Northumberland Dublin Co. Educate Irish Road, 20 Dublin Together Broadband Dublin NS 4 Glasnevin Educate Cook Together Street, Smart NS Dublin Satellite 8 Smart St. Irish Annes Broadband Primary School Wireless C/O The High C/O Support St. Wireless Unit, Joseph’s Portrane, School Co. C/O For Dublin ADSL St. The Mochtas Deaf, NS, Navan Wireless Irish Porterstown Road, Littlepace, Broadband Road, Cabra, Castaheany, Clonsilla, Dublin Dublin Dublin 7 15 15 ADSL To Be Swords, Decided ADSL Co. Dublin St. C/O Vincent’s St. Hospital, Josephs Convent Wireless School Avenue, For Richmond The Eden Road, Deaf, Road, Fairview Navan Glasthule, Sarsfield Irish Ballisk Dublin Road, Co. St. Road, Broadband Common, 3 Dublin Dublin Raphaels Inchicore, Off 7 Ward, Dublin Portrane Beaumont 10 Road, Hospital, Donabate, Dublin Co. 9 Dublin To Griffeen Be Glen Digiweb Decided Boulevard, Lucan, Co. Dublin. Irish Broadband Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Irish Church Broadband Avenue, Smart Glasnevin, Dublin 9 Wireless Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Fettercairn, Wireless Wireless Tallaght, Smart Dublin 24 Smart Satellite Satellite Wireless Smart Wireless Local Smart Loop Irish Broadband Irish Irish ADSL Broadband Broadband Wireless Smart ADSL Wireless ADSL Wireless Wireless Irish Broadband Wireless Digiweb ADSL Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1071 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1072

[Ms Hanafin.] n, To Be Decided To Be Decided ´ osa, Fionnglas To Be Decided To Be Decided thair, Co. Atha Cliath Digiweb Wireless ´ Loc, Leamhca ´ ´ thar Maelı ´ alaigh, 12u thair Stigh Lorgan, Co. Atha Cliath Digiweb Wireless ´ ´ irse ´ thair, Bo ´ rusClgNaSa ´ thar Stigh Lorgan, Baile An Bho ´ in C/O W.F.T.R.A. Hall, Bo ´ in Bo ´ Hearca de New Road, Clondalkin, Dublin 22 Irish Broadband Wireless ´ ´ iste Eoiniste Iosaga iste Brı Baile An Bho ´ ´ ´ 20176C20186F20187H Rush Lusk Educate20190T Together NS Clonee/Ongar Ed. Tog.20201V N.S. Archbishop Ryan Senior20202A N.S. Holy Trinity N.S.20220C Tyrellstown Ed. Tog.20223I N.S. Balbriggan Ed. Tog.60010P N.S. Gaelscoil Uı 60021U Gaelscoil Eiscir60030V Riada Loreto Secondary School60040B St. Marys Secondary60041D School Blackrock College60042F Willow Park School Hanna’s Avenue, Blakes Cross, Cola Corduff, Lusk, Co.60070K Dublin Cola 60081P Beechpark Avenue, Castleknock Balgaddy, Lucan60090Q Dominican College60092U Rockford Manor Secondary60100Q Schoo Rathdown Tyrellstown, School Dublin 1560120W C/O Clonkeen Parochial College Balbriggan, House, Digiweb St. Mary’s, Sandyford, Castleknock Dublin College 1860122D Mount Sackville Secondary Scho60130C C/O Balbriggan, a Co. Dublin60140F Baldoyle, Dublin 13 Cola 60160L Loreto Satellite Abbey Secondary60180R School Mount Anville Secondary Blackrock,60240J School Co. Dublin Notre Dame Rock Des60250M Road, Missions Blackrock, To Co. To Be Christian Dublin Be Decided Brothers Decided College60260P Stradbrook Rd, Loreto Blackrock, College60261R Co. Dublin Holy Child Secondary School60262T To St. Sion To Be Joseph Hill, Be Decided of60263V Blackrock, Decided Cluny Co. Dublin St. To Benildus Be College Decided St. Chapelizod, Laurence Dublin College 20 Glenageary, To Dun Be Laoghaire, St. Decided Co. Josephs Dublin College Clonkeen Road, Blackrock, Castleknock, Co. Dublin Dublin 15 To Be Decided Dalkey, Co. Dublin To Be To Mount Decided Be Anville Decided Rd, BT Dublin Ireland 14 Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Upper Churchtown BT Road, Ireland Dublin 14 Monkstown To Park, Be Dun Decided Laoghaire, Digiweb Co. Dublin Wireless ADSL Military Road, Killiney, Wireless Co. Dublin Digiweb Foxrock, Digiweb Local Dublin Loop 18 Bellevue Digiweb Park, Ballinclea Wireless Rd, Upper Killiney, Kilmacud Co. Rd, Dublin Stillorgan Blackrock, Co. Loughlinstown, Dublin Dublin 18 Irish Broadband Lucan, Co. Wireless Dublin Wireless Irish Broadband Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Irish Smart Broadband Digiweb Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Satellite Digiweb Irish Broadband Wireless Digiweb Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type X 60050eX Oatlands College 60121b Moyle Park College Mount Merrion, Blackrock, Co. Dublin Clondalkin, Dublin 22 Smart ADSL Smart ADSL 1073 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1074 , Baile Atha Cliath 7 Digiweb Wireless ´ s Long Mile Road, Walkinstown, Dublin 12 Digiweb Wireless ´ id Rı ´ draig CBS Roselawn, Lucan, Co. Dublin Smart Satellite ´ s Griffith Avenue, Dublin 9 Smart ADSL ´ iste Pha iste Choilmiste Mhuire Dublin Road, Swords, Co. Dublin Bothar Rath To Irish Broadband Wireless ´ ´ ´ 60264A60272W60290B Cola 60291D The Kings Hospital60300B St. Pauls College60310E Ardscoil La Salle Manor House60321J Da La Salle60340N College60341P Rockbrook Park60342R School Loreto High School60343T Sancta Maria College60361V Colaiste Eanna CBS60370W St. Joseph’s Secondary60380C School St. Raphaela’s Secondary School St. Fintan’s High School60383I St. Dominic’s High60390F School Palmerstown, Dublin60400F 20 Cola 60410I Sybil St. Hill, Josephs Raheny, C.B.S.60420L Dublin 5 Raheny Road, St. Raheny, Vincents Dublin C.B.S.60430O 5 Glasnevin C.B.S. James Upper60440R Street Churchtown Watermill Road, Road, Churchtown, Raheny, Ardscoil Dublin Dublin Rı 14 5 Edmondstown60450U Road, Rathfarnham, St. Dublin Pauls 16 C.B.S.60470D O’connell School Beaufort, Grange60471F Rd, Rathfarnham, Cola Dublin Ballyroan, Convent 14 Rathfarnham, Lane, Dublin Upper Rush,60480G 16 Kilmacud Co. Road, Dublin Stillorgan, Synge Co. Ballyroan, Street Dublin Rathfarnham, CBS60481I Dublin 16 St. David’s C.B.S.60490J Meanscoil Iogna Dublin Road,60491L Sutton, Dublin Santa 13 Sabina, St. Greenfield Aidan’s Rd,60500J C.B.S. Sutton, Dublin 13 Digiweb C.B.S. Westland60510M Row St. Declan’s College60511O Digiweb Smart Marian Glasnevin, College Dublin60520P 11 Digiweb Digiweb St. Johns College De60530S La Smart Digiweb Salle Merville Beneavin Ave, De Fairview, La Dublin60540V Salle 3 College Wireless Smart Belvedere College James’s Street, Dublin 8 Gonzaga College Wireless Digiweb Catholic University ADSL Wireless School Wireless Irish Broadband Smart Christian Irish Wireless Brothers, Broadband Nth North Brunswick Richmond Street, Local Street, Dublin Loop Dublin 7 1 ADSL Wireless Synge Street, Dublin Smart 8 Wireless Wireless Malahide Road, Artane, Dublin 5 ADSL Collins Westland Avenue Row, Ext, Dublin Whitehall, 2 Dublin 9 Nephin Le Road, Fanu Cabra, Rd, Dublin Ballyfermot, 7 Dublin Beneavin 10 Road, ADSL Finglas, Irish Dublin Broadband 11 Smart Digiweb Ballsbridge, Dublin 4 Wireless 6 89 Gt Lower Denmark Leeson Street, Smart Street, Dublin Dublin 1 2 Sandford Road, Ranelagh, Digiweb Dublin 6 Wireless Local Loop Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Smart Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Smart Smart Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Wireless ADSL ADSL Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type X 60320h St. Columba’s CollegeX 60381e Sutton Park School Whitechurch, Dublin 16 St. Fintans Road, Sutton, Dublin 13 Smart ADSL Smart ADSL 1075 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1076

[Ms Hanafin.] on, Ath Cliath 9 Digiweb Wireless ´ , Glasnaı ´ thar Mobhı ´ 60550B60560E60561G Chanel College60562I St. Marys College60570H St. Michaels College60571J Templeogue College60581M Terenure College60590N Patrician College60630W St. Kevins College60640C St. Conleths College60650F St. Killian’s Deutsche Schule60660I Sandford Park School60670L Ltd St. Andrews College60690R St. Patricks60700R Cathedral G.S The High School60710U Dominican College60720A Scoil Chaitriona60731F Muckross Park Coolock, College Dublin60732H 5 Rathmines, Saint Dublin Ailesbury Dominic’s 6 Road, Secondary Dublin60741I Scho 4 St. Templeville Dominics Road, College60750J Dublin 6w Caritas College60770P Templeogue Road, Terenure, Dublin St. 6w Michaels60791A Secondary School Deanstown Ave, Roebuck Holy Finglas Road, Faith60792C West, Clonskeagh, Secondary Ballygall Dublin Dublin School Rd 11 14 East, Finglas, St. 28 Dublin Mary’s Clyde 11 Secondary60800V Road, School Ballsbridge, Dublin St. Sandford 4 Marys Road, Secondary Ranelagh,60810B School Dublin 6 Presentation College60820E Loreto St. College Booterstown Patricks Ave,60840K Close, Blackrock, Dublin Co. 8 Dublin Loreto College60841M Loreto College60843Q Maryfield Danum, College Zion Griffith Road, Ballyfermot, Ave,60851P Rathgar, Dublin Drumcondra, Dublin 10 Dublin 6 Rosary 9 College Donnybrook,60852R Dublin 4 St. Bo Josephs Secondary Digiweb60853T School Assumption Secondary Digiweb Digiweb School60860Q Digiweb Mater Digiweb Digiweb Wellmount Cabra, Christi Road, Dublin Digiweb Finglas, 760870T Dublin 11 Mount Carmel 1 Digiweb Secondary60871V Belgrove School Road, Digiweb Clontarf, Our Dublin Ladys Drumfinn 3 School Road, Holy60872A Ballyfermot, Faith Dublin Convent, 10 Digiweb Glasnevin, Our Dublin Wireless Lady 11 of60890C St. Mercy Brigids College Road, Digiweb Killester, Mercy Wireless Wireless Dublin College 5 Coolock Wireless Wireless Wireless Mercy Wireless Secondary School Warrenmount, St. Wireless Dublin Louis 8 High School Wireless Smart Digiweb Wireless Smart Crumlin Road, Wireless Dublin 12 Swords, Co. Dublin Stanhope St, 53 Dublin St. Glandore 7 Stephens Road, Green, Walkinstown, Drumcondra, Dublin Dublin Dublin Digiweb 2 12 9 Digiweb Armagh Wireless Smart Road, Kings Wireless Crumlin, Inn Dublin Street, 12 Dublin 1 Digiweb Digiweb Smart Local Loop Irish Cappagh, Broadband Beaumont, Wireless Finglas, Dublin Dublin 9 11 Digiweb Wireless Templeogue Rd, Terenure, Dublin 6w St. ADSL Brendans Wireless Drive, Wireless Coolock, Dublin Goldenbridge, 5 Inchicore, Dublin Wireless 8 Local Loop Charleville Road, Rathmines, Smart Dublin 6 Wireless Smart Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Irish Broadband Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Digiweb Local Loop Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Smart Wireless Digiweb Wireless Wireless Smart Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Wireless Wireless ADSL Local Loop Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1077 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1078 in Thuaidh, Tamhlacht, Baile Ath Cliath Irish Broadband Wireless ´ in, Baile Atha Cliath 22 Irish Broadband Wireless ´ in, Br Thigh Motha ´ 24 thar Nangor, Cluain Dolca irc Thigh Motha ´ ´ iste De Hideiste Chilliain Pa iste Eannaiste Eoin Bo Kilkieran Road, Cabra, Dublin 7 Cappagh Road, Finglas West, Dublin 11 Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Wireless ´ ´ ´ ´ 60891E60892G60902G Our Ladys Grove60910F The Teresian School60930L St. Pauls Secondary60990G School Alexandra College60991I Rosemont School61010U Meanscoil Chroimghlinne61020A Our Lady68071G of Mercy Secondary Wesley Sc College70010V Stratford College70020B John Scottus Secondary70021D School Balbriggan Community College Grange70030E Community College Cola 70040H70041J Senior College Dunlaoghaire70042L Deansrath Greenhills, Community Goatstown Dublin College Road, 12 1270050K Dublin Stillorgan 14 Road, Donnybrook, Dublin Collinstown 4 Park70060N Community Col St. Kevin’s Community70070Q College Milltown, Dublin Dun 314/318 Mourne 6 Laoghaire Crumlin Road, College Road, Drimnagh,70080T of Crumlin, Dublin Further Dublin 12 Education 12 Dundrum Temple College Road, Blackrock,70081V Co. Dublin College of Further70090W Education Lucan 74/76 Community Morehampton College Rd,70100W Donnybrook, Dublin Pine 4 Ridge, Riversdale Chapel Community St., College70110C Ballinteer, Balbriggan, Dublin Co. 16 Dublin Sallynoggin College 1 of Zion Road,70120F Rathgar, Grange Dublin Road, Cola 6 Donaghmede, Dublin 1370121H Stillorgan College of70130I Further Education Irish Broadband St. Eblana Finians Avenue, Community Dun70140L New College Laoghaire, Cumberland Nangor Co. St, Road, Dublin Fingal Dun Clondalkin, Community Laoghaire, Dublin Neilstown College Co. 22 Rd.,70141N Dublin Rowlagh, Clondalkin, Dublin 22 Greenhills College Smart70150O Fonthill Irish Wireless Road, Broadband Clondalkin, Firhouse Dublin Community 22 College70160R Digiweb Jobstown Digiweb Community Digiweb College70170U Irish Broadband Cola BT70180A Ireland Wireless St. Dundrum, Kevins Main College St,70190D Dundrum, Dublin 14 Crumlin College of Digiweb Blanchardstown Sydenham Wireless Esker Rd ADSL Road, Drive, North, Dundrum, Cola Lucan, Dublin Dublin Co. 15 14 Dublin Wireless Irish Wireless Old Broadband Colaiste Wireless Dublin Ide Rd., Stillorgan, Co. ADSL Dublin Digiweb BT Ireland Digiweb Further Education, BT Pearse Ireland St, Smart Sallynoggin, Co. Dublin Irish Wireless Swords, Broadband Co. Dublin Wireless Seatown Road, Swords, Co. Dublin Digiweb Local Loop Wireless Wireless Firhouse Local Road, Wireless Loop Dublin 24 Jobstown, Tallaght, Dublin 24 Local Loop Limekiln Avenue, Greenhills, Digiweb Dublin 12 Digiweb Digiweb Wireless Irish Broadband Digiweb Digiweb Clogher Road, Crumlin, Dublin 12 Further Education, Wireless Crumlin Rd, Wireless Crumlin, Dublin 12 Wireless Wireless Wireless Cardiffsbridge Road, Wireless Finglas West, Irish Dublin Broadband 11 Irish Digiweb Broadband Wireless Digiweb Irish Broadband Digiweb Wireless Wireless Wireless Digiweb Wireless Wireless Digiweb Wireless Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1079 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1080

[Ms Hanafin.] de, Baile Atha Cliath 13 Smart Satellite ´ n, Co. Atha Cliath Smart ADSL , Domhnach Mı ´ ´ insı ´ n, Leamhca ´ fı ´ thar Mhainistir Na Gra ´ laigh Barryscourt Road, Coolock, Dublin 17 Smart ADSL ´ iste Reachrann Bo ´ iste Dhu iste Cois Life Gleann An Ghrı ´ ´ 70200D70220J70230M Technical Institute70240P Inchicore College70250S of Further E Killester College of Further70260V Education Kylemore College70280E Marino College70290H St. Mac Dara’s70300H Community Colleg Rathmines College70310K Ballsbridge College of70320N Busines Pearse College70321P Plunket College70330Q Whitehall House Senior70340T College Margaret Aylward Community70342A Col Cola Collins Avenue, Killester,76062B Dublin 5 Liberties Emmet College Road,76065H Inchicore, Dublin 8 Ballyfermot College of Cambridge76077O Road, Ringsend, Dublin Castleknock 4 Community College76078Q Cola Wellington Lane, Templeogue,76085N Dublin 6w Larkin Community College76092K Kylemore Road, Ballyfermot, Skerries Dublin Community 10 College81001I Shelbourne Road, Gealchola Ballsbridge, 14-20 Dublin Marino81002K 4 Mart, Fairview, Dublin Presentation 3 College Town81003M Hall, Rathmines, Dublin 6 Newpark Comprehensive Swords81004O School Road, Dublin The 9 Mount Thatch Temple Road, Comprehensive Whitehall,81015T Sch Dublin 9 Boys Comprehensive School Clogher Road,91301D Crumlin, Dublin Girls 12 Swords Digiweb Comprehensive Road, School Whitehall,91302F Dublin 9 Ballymun Senior Comprehensive91305L Digiweb Digiweb Holy Family Carpenterstown Community Road,91310E School Castleknock, Irish Dublin Broadband 15 Phobailscoil Iosolde91315O Further Education, Bull Ballyfermot Alley Road, Ballinteer Street, Dublin Community Dublin 10 School91316Q Digiweb 8 Wireless Cabinteely Community School 191318U Wireless Champions Digiweb Avenue, Dublin Scoil Skerries, 1 Phobail Wireless Co. Chuil Dublin91324P Mhin Wireless Digiweb Blakestown Community School The Donahies Community Newtown School Park Malahide Avenue, Road, Blackrock, Dublin Digiweb Co. Portmarnock 3 Wireless Dublin Community Digiweb School Terenure, Dublin 6w Wireless Ballymun Road, Wireless Dublin Irish Digiweb 9 Broadband Ballymun, Ballymun Digiweb Dublin Digiweb Road, Digiweb 9 Ballymun, Dublin 9 Kilteel Road, Wireless Rathcoole, Co. Wireless Dublin Wireless Ballinteer, Dublin Wireless 16 Cabinteely, Dublin Wireless Wireless 18 Palmerstown, Wireless Dublin 20 Digiweb Digiweb Smart Blanchardstown, Dublin 15 Streamville Cluain Road, Saileach, Dublin Baile 13 Atha Cliath 15 Carrickhill Road, Portmarnock, Co. Dublin BT Ireland Wireless Wireless Smart Local Loop Smart Esat Smart Irish Broadband ADSL Irish Broadband Wireless Local Loop Local Loop Irish ADSL Broadband Wireless ADSL Smart Digiweb Smart Irish Broadband Irish Broadband Smart Wireless Wireless Wireless Wireless ADSL ADSL ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1081 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1082 91325R91330K91332O Malahide Community School91335U Holy Child Community91336W School St. Marks Community91337B School Tallaght Community School91338D Old Bawn Community School91339F Killinarden Community School91342R St. Aidan’s Community91343T School Hartstown Community School91344V Pobalscoil Neasain91510M St. Tiernan’s Community School Rosmini Community School00885T Pobail Scoil Naomh Coilm01309L Cille Broomfield, Malahide, Co.01421F Dublin Pearse St, Ratoath Sallynoggin, Junior Co. N02905J Dublin S Stackallen Cookstown N Rd, S Tallaght,03275H Dublin 24 Kilskyre Mixed Balrothery, N Tallaght,04210H S Dublin 24 Old Bawn, S Tallaght, N Dublin05062A Naomh 24 Killinarden, Padraig Tallaght, Dublin Newtown 24 N S05630L Brookfield, Tallaght, Kilmessan Dublin Mxd 24 N07120V S Hartstown, Kells Clonsilla, Parochial Dublin N 1509238I S Scoil Mhichil Na10801Q Parkvale, Buachailli Balally, Dublin 16 Killyon N S11039O Ballinlough Grace Baldoyle, N Park11978O Dublin S Scholarstown Road, 13 Rd, Drumcondra, Knocklyon, Dublin Drumbarragh Dublin 9 N 16 S12068D Kilbeg N Irish S Broadband12488C Scoil Irish Mhuire Broadband NS12788O Our Irish Lady Broadband of12897T Mercy NS Oldcastle Wireless Mxd N13775K S Ratoath, Co. Meath Flowerfield Wireless Digiweb N S14348T Irish Ughtyneill Wireless Broadband N Digiweb S15104T Kilskyre, Stackallen, Kells, Navan, Co. Co. St. Meath Meath Patricks N15483H S Baile Irish Bacuin, Broadband Enfield, Carrickleck Co. N Meath S16067V Digiweb Wireless Bride Naofa Kilmessan, N Co. S Newtown, Scoil Meath Ardee, Wireless Na St. Digiweb Co. Mbrathar, Louis Louth Patrick N Street, S Kells, Digiweb Trim, Wireless Co. Co. Meath Meath Scoil Wireless Irish Nais Broadband Finin Naofa Wireless Wireless Killyon, Cnoc Ballinlough, An Kells, Drumbarragh, Wireless Dun, Co. Irish Kells, Co. Meath Broadband Co. Meath Meath Wireless Kells, Co. Moylagh, Meath Oldcastle, Kilbeg, Co. Carlanstown, Meath Co. Wireless Meath Digiweb Chapel St, Oldcastle, Co. Meath Smart BT Smart Ireland Trim Rd, Navan, Digiweb Co. Meath Ughtyneill, Moynalty, Kells, Co. Meath Trim, Co. Meath Wireless Digiweb Carrickleck, Kingscourt, Co. Meath Cannistown, ADSL Digiweb Navan, Co. Meath Clonard, Enfield, Satellite Co. Satellite Meath Satellite Rathkenny, Navan, Co. Meath Digiweb Digiweb Smart Digiweb Satellite Satellite Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Wireless Smart Satellite Digiweb ADSL Digiweb Irish Broadband Satellite Satellite Digiweb Satellite Wireless Smart Satellite Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Satellite ADSL Satellite Wireless Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Meath 00883P Aine Naofa N S Navan, Co. Meath Smart ADSL 1083 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1084

[Ms Hanafin.] 16100Q16143L16549Q Mercy Convent N16646O S S N Pheadair16655P Agus Phoil Knockcommon N S16722E St. Marys Convent16774A N S Scoil Nais Ma16790V Dearmhai Scoil Cholmcille16825O Scoil Nais An16991I Obair S N Naomh17029S Seosamh Kilbride National School17088L Carnaross N17123K S S N17162U Naomh Cianain S N An17175G Athar Ui Gramhna Kilmainham Wood N17203I S S N Bhrighde17213L Bohermeen N S Navan, Drumconrath,17220I Co. Navan, Meath Co. Meath S N17312N Ultain Naofa S N Knockcommon, Mhuire17480L Beauparc, Co. Trim, Meath Co. Meath S N Longwood,17494W Bhrighde Enfield, Co. Meath S N Cul17513A An Mhuilinn S N Baile17520U Cheant S Navan N Road, An Nobber, Kells, Rath17521W Co. Co. Mhor Meath Meath S Clonee, Dunsany, N Co. Co. Cill Meath Meath17560J Bhrighde S N Mhuire17623H S N Colmcille17629T Rathcairn, Co. S Na N17652O Midhe Cushenstown, Seosamh Ashbourne, Naomtha Carn Co. Scoil Na Meath Nais Ros, Ui Ceannannas17705J Gramhna Mor, Kilmainham Co. Wood, Na Kells, Mi S Co. N Meath Padraig17741N Naofa Smart Scoil Oilibheir Naofa17742P Digiweb S N17821L Cros Ban Baile Corr, Scoil Kells, Bohermeen, Nais Co. Navan, Aitinn Meath17839H Co. Bhui Meath Scoil Domhnach Irish Nais Smart Padraig, Broadband Mhuire17840P An Naofa Uaimh, Co. Scoil Na Nais Midhe Mhuire17856H Naofa S N Satellite Culmullen, Ma Bheinn Satellite Drumree, Nealta,17857J Naofa Co. Ceannanus B Meath Mor, Co. Meath Smart S Na Hill, Digiweb Wireless N Midhe Drumconrath, Bheinin Co. Naofa Meath C S Baile N Cheant, Dun An Uabhair Rathmore, Uaimh, Athboy, Co. Co. Na Meath Mi S N Smart Aindreis Satellite Naofa Digiweb Digiweb Kilbride, Trim, Co. Digiweb Meath Irish Broadband Digiweb Dun Wireless Doire, An Robinstown, Esat ADSL Uaimh, Navan, Co. Co. Athboy, Scrin, Na Meath Co. Tara, Mi Meath Co. Meath Wireless Digiweb Satellite Satellite Satellite Ard Coillcluana, A’chatha, Satellite Co. Garristown, Na Co. Mi Dublin Satellite Smart Digiweb Beauparc, Digiweb Navan, Co. Meath Kiltale, Dunsany, Co. Meath Satellite Whitecross, Julianstown, Enfield, Co. Co. Digiweb Meath Satellite Meath Digiweb Smart Duleek, Co. Meath Wireless Duleek, Satellite Satellite Co. Digiweb Meath Dun Ubhair, Satellite Drogheda, Co. Satellite Louth Curraha, Ashbourne, Digiweb Co. Meath Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite Smart BT Ireland Satellite Satellite Satellite Smart Smart Smart Satellite Digiweb ADSL Satellite BT Ireland Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Satellite Smart Digiweb BT Ireland ADSL Satellite Satellite ADSL Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1085 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1086 17930Q17946I17947K S N Seachnaill17964K Naofa Scoil Nais17969U Naomh Aine Scoil Naomh Bride17986U S N Mhuire18016O Naofa S N Mhuire18037W S N Nmh18040L Sheosamh S N Columbain18044T S N Mhuire18051Q S N Naomh18106P Padraig S N Naomh18132Q Padraig Coole N.S,18169Q S N Na18174J Trionoide Naofa S N Muire18195R S N Rath18344I Riagain Dunshaughlin, S Co. N Meath18358T Caitriona Naofa Maio, Tierworker, St. Kells, Finian Co. N Meath18413B S S N Boardsmill,18429Q Mhuire Trim, Co. Meath S N Fiach18448U Rathfeigh, Tara, S Co. N Meath Naomh18453N Treasa S N Mhuire Boyerstown,18500T Navan, Co. Meath S N An Rath Uaimh,18762D Beagain Co. Na Mi S N Baile Mhichil18767N Iomhair, Naofa Co. Na Midhe S N Naomh Slane,18887A Colmcille Co. Meath S Baile N Ui Realt Earain, Stamullen,19018A Na Baile Co. Mara Loibin, Meath (B) Co. S Na N Mi Realt19216E Na Lios Mara Muilinn, (C) Cros Scoil An Nais Greallaigh, Maol Co.19253K Hosae Na Midhe Dangan Mixed Garradice, N Kilcock,19292U S Co. Digiweb Kildare. St. Ultans Special19300Q Sch Baile Wilkinstown An BT N Bhothair, Ireland S Dun Baile Carlanstown, Boinne, Oirthir, Kells, Co. Ceannanus Co. Na Castletown Mor, Meath Midhe N Co. S Na19486K Midhe Smart Castlejordan Central NS19560T Clonalvy, Garristown, Co. Meath Satellite Smart Scoil Nais Smart ADSL Deaglain Moynalvey, Summerhill, Bellewstown, Co. Drogheda, Meath Co. St. Louth Marys Special School Baile Smart Na Criadh, Digiweb Oldcastle, Co. Meath Rath Smart Beagain, Dun Cul Satellite Seachnaill, Smart Ronain, Co. Baile Na Cill, Iomhair, Midhe Rath Co. Cnoc Molladhain, Meath Hanobhar, Co. Drogheda, Na Co. Mi Louth Satellite Domhnach Cearnaigh, Mornington, Drogheda, Satellite Smart Co. Louth Domhnach Cearnaigh, Mornington, Drogheda, Digiweb Smart Smart Co. Kilcock, Meath Co. Smart Satellite Kildare Satellite Satellite Dangan, ADSL Summerhill, Co. Flower Meath Hill, Navan, Co. Digiweb Meath Satellite Wilkinstown, Castlejordan, Wireless Navan, Digiweb Tullamore, Co. Co. Meath Offaly Irish Satellite Satellite Broadband Satellite Digiweb Navan, Co. Smart Meath Irish Smart Broadband Digiweb Satellite Ashbourne, Johnstown, Co. Navan, Wireless Digiweb Meath Co. Meath Irish Broadband Wireless Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Satellite Satellite Wireless Satellite Satellite Smart Digiweb Digiweb Smart Smart Satellite Satellite Wireless Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Satellite BT Ireland Wireless Satellite ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type X 19476h St. Oliver Plunkett NS Navan, Co. Meath Smart ADSL 1087 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1088

[Ms Hanafin.] To Be DecidedTo Be Decided To Be Decided To Be Decided th Cairn, Athboy, Co. Meath Smart Satellite ´ iste Pobail Rath Cairn Ra ´ 19671F19725C19768U St. Pauls N19779C S Gaelscoil Eanna19813W Scoil Mhuire19867W Gaelscoil Na Cille20017F Kildalkey Central N S20032B Scoil Na Rithe20033D Scoil An Spioraid20051F Naoimh Dunboyne Junior N20082Q S Dunboyne Senior N20164S S Gaelscoil Na Boinne20179I Gaelscoil Dhun Buinne20180Q Navan Educate20191V Together NS St. Stephens20200T NS Scoil Naomh Eoin20215J St. Peters National20216L School Ratoath Senior School76088T Br. Ath Abbeylands, St. Throim, Navan, Paul’s64350N An Co. N.S. Uaimh, Meath Co. Na Scoil Midhe Oilibheir64360Q Cill Kildalkey, Ashbourne, Dheaglain, Co. Co. Ashbourne, Rathoath Meath Meath Co. College Meath64370T Laytown, St. Co. Patrick’s Meath. Classical64410F School St. Joseph’s Secondary Dun64420I School Seachlainn, Co. Na Dunboyne, Loreto Mi Co. Secondary Meath School64450R Dunboyne, Co. Eureka Meath. Secondary School71950F Dublin Franciscan Road, Dun College Rock71960I Trim, Buinne, Lodge, Co. Co. Flower Meath. Na Hill, Scoil Mi Navan, Mhuire Co. Meath.71970L St. Peter’s College71980O Community College Irish Broadband Dunboyne, St. Co. Fintinas Meath Post C/O71991T Primary St. Clonmagadden Scho Marthas Valley, College, Windtown, O’Carolan Johnstown, Navan, College Co. Co. Meath72010I Meath Ratoath, BT Irish Ireland Broadband91456J Wireless Cola 91495T Beaufort Moatlands, College91508C Navan, Co. Ratoath, Meath Mercy Wireless Convent, St. Navan, Ciaran’s Bettystown,91517D Co. BT Community Meath Ireland School Fairyhouse Smart Racecourse, Rathoath Ashbourne ADSL Community School Smart Boyne St. Irish Community Michaels, Broadband Smart School Navan, Co. Meath Kells, Athboy Co. Community Meath School Smart Smart Digiweb BT Digiweb ADSL Ireland Wireless Gormanstown, Co. Meath Satellite Smart ADSL Longwood, Enfield, Co. ADSL Meath Dunboyne, Convent Co. of Meath Mercy, Dunshaughlin, Trim, Co. Co. Meath Meath ADSL Wireless ADSL ADSL Satellite Smart Nobber, Co. Meath ADSL Navan Rd, Digiweb Kells, Co. Smart Meath Deerpark, To Ashbourne, Be Co. Decided Meath Trim Rd, Navan, Co. Meath Trim, Co. Smart ADSL Meath Athboy, Co. Meath To Be Decided Wireless To Be ADSL Decided Digiweb Smart Digiweb Smart ADSL To Be Decided Smart BT Ireland Wireless Wireless Satellite BT Ireland Satellite Digiweb Smart ADSL ADSL Digiweb ADSL Wireless Digiweb Smart Satellite Wireless Wireless ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Xx 71990r St. Oliver Post Primary Oldcastle, Kells, Co. Meath Smart ADSL 1089 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1090 Borrisoleigh, Co. TipperarySt.Michael’s St, Tipperary Digiweb Satellite BT Ireland ADSL Cashel, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite hBNS yGNS nBNS 00606M01285A01569O Monard N S01594N Tipperary Jnr. Bn01862M S Ballycahill N S02237R St. Johns02428B Tipperar 02670I Dualla N S04005G Lackamore N S04067F San Isadoir04075E S N Naomh04620D Peadar Convent of Mercy05144C Moyglass N S06658P Thomastown N S06789H New In 07048Q Kildangan N S07245S Lisronagh N S07358I Mohober N S Tipperary,08316U Co. Tipperary Monard, Cullen Solohead, N Co.08903M S Tipperary S N Ballycahill,09190G Sceichin Thurles, A Co. Rince Tipperary Newtown N S09432E Fethard Convent09967U Roscrea, Co. Boher Tipperary N S10120P Convent of Newport, Dualla, Mercy10533R Co. Cashel, Tipperary Co. Tipperary Upper Newtown N11367I S Horse And Jockey, Thurles, S Co. N Bothar Tipperary Mhuire11384I Leathan, Na Cashel, Newport, Trocaire Co. Co. Ballydrehid Tipperary Tipperary N S11453B Portroe N11470B S Moyglass, Thomastown, Fethard, Golden Co. Cashel, Gurtagarry Tipperary Co. N11605V Tipperary S Lisnamrock N S11872V Slieveardagh N Digiweb S12124K Cill An Daingin Rosegreen Pocon, N Aonach S12180U Urmhun, Digiweb Lisronagh, Smart Co. Clonmel, Thiobrad Co. Arann Clochar Tipperary Na Toirbhirte Mohober, Mullinahone, Rear Co. N Tipperary S An Chuirt Doite, An Presentation Chathair, Primary Co. School Thiobraid Cullen, Arann Co. Tipperary Smart Satellite Newtown, Fethard, Solohead, Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary Satellite BT Ireland Digiweb Digiweb Smart ADSL Tipperary, Digiweb Digiweb Co. Tipperary Upper Newtown, Boher, Carrick Cahir, Killaloe, On Co. Co. Suir, Tipperary Clare Co. Tipperary Smart Smart ADSL ADSL Cahir, Satellite Satellite Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Satellite Satellite Nenagh, Toomevara, Co. Digiweb Nenagh, Tipperary Co. Digiweb Tipperary Coalbrook, Thurles, Co. Tipperary The Commons, Thurles, Satellite Co. Satellite Tipperary Presentation Convent, Carrick Clonmel, On Co. Suir, Satellite Cnocan Tipperary Co. An Tipperary Teampail, Rosegreen, Cashel Digiweb Co. Tipperary BT Ireland Satellite Satellite Digiweb Newport, Co. Tipperary Smart Leased BT Satellite Line Ireland Digiweb Smart Smart Digiweb Satellite Digiweb ADSL ADSL Digiweb Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Smart Satellite ADSL ADSL Satellite BT Ireland Satellite Satellite Satellite Satellite Digiweb Local Loop Satellite County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type Tipperary 00590A Borrisoleig 1091 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1092

[Ms Hanafin.] Cronans NS, Roscrea, Co. Tipperary Smart ADSL aNSNo2 St. 12349L12540B13014I S N Muire13210I Na Naingeal Clonmore N S13404V S N13678M Naomh Padraig St. Josephs13847J National School Convent of Mercy13867P Killurney N S13991Q Hollyford N14008S S Roscre 14181J Birdhill N S14426N S N14460N Bhride Poulicapple N14791N S Knockavilla N S15008A Killea N S15157R Cappawhite N S15299O Clochar Na Shronell Carthanachta, N Sraid S Mortuin,15362S Cluain Meala, Co. Mount Thiobraid Bruis Arann N15560W S Ballingarry, Thurles, Gaile Co. N Tipperary S Digiweb15696B Fethard, Templemore, Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary S N15778D Michil Naofa Bishop Harty NS15795D New Inn, Cashel, Silvermines Co. N Tipperary S15970S St. Marys N16059W S Ballypatrick, Clonmel, St. Co. Wireless Marys Tipperary N16077B S Hollyford, Co. Ballytarsna Tipperary N16111V S Emly N S16112A Ardfinnan Killaloe, N Co. S16166A Tipperary Killusty N S Callan,16211C Dun Co. Na Kilkenny Sciath, St. Curraghpoor, Dundrum, Marys Co. Co. Convent Tipperary16250M Tipperary Carrig N S16276H Digiweb Two Cappawhite, Mile Co. Borris16344V Tipperary N Templemore, S Co. Tipperary Templetuohy N S16725K Lattin, Carrig Mount Digiweb Tipperary N Bruis, S Tipperary16727O Town, Co. Tipperary St. Marys Digiweb Jnr. B Digiweb N S S Digiweb Mullinahone, N Thurles, Mhuire Satellite Co. Na Holycross, Tipperary Mbraithre Ballinree, Thurles, Nenagh, Scoil Co. Co. Na Tipperary Tipperary Mbraithre Nenagh, Co. Tipperary Satellite Digiweb Nenagh, Satellite Co. Digiweb Tipperary Satellite Satellite Templemore, Co. Tipperary Cashel, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Clonmel, Emly, Co. Co. Tipperary Digiweb Tipperary Satellite BT Ireland Nenagh, Digiweb Co. Satellite Tipperary Fethard, Co. Tipperary Smart Digiweb Thurles, Co. Tipperary Birr, Satellite Co. Smart Thurles, Offaly Co. Tipperary Leased Satellite Line Digiweb Carrick Digiweb On Satellite Suir, Nenagh, Co. Co. Tipperary Digiweb Tipperary Ballycommon, Nenagh, Satellite Co. Tipperary Satellite Nenagh, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Satellite Satellite Smart Eircom Satellite Digiweb Satellite Smart Digiweb BT Ireland ADSL ADSL Digiweb Satellite Smart Smart Smart Digiweb Satellite ADSL Satellite Digiweb BT Ireland Satellite Smart Satellite Satellite Satellite ADSL ADSL Satellite ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1093 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1094 16728Q16729S16810B St. Marys N16835R S St. Peter16933R And Paul Eochaille Ara N16979S S S N Naomh17114J Treasa Loch Mor Maigh17140K N S Scoil Colmcille17179O S N17237C An Ghabhailin S N Baile17244W Sluagh S N An17276M Cillin S N Cill17296S Barfhionn S N Naomh Ruadhain17332T Scoil Na Mbraithre17486A S N17498H Baile Na Hinse St. Marys Parochial17511T School S N Cleireachain17512V S N Naomh17542H Sheosamh Clonmel, Irishtown, Co. Clonmel, S Tipperary Co. N Tipperary Baile17543J An Iubhair Newtown, Nenagh, S Co. N Tipperary Flannain17580P Naofa Borrisoleigh, Thurles, Co. S Tipperary N Templemore, Rath Co.17608L Chaomhghin Tipperary Cloughjordan N17620B S S N Templemore, Gort17621D Co. Na Cashel, Tipperary Huaighe Co. S Tipperary N Lua17634M Naofa S Thurles, N Co. Rois17640H Tipperary Mhoir S N An17653Q Bhealaigh Coolbawn, Lorrha, Birr, Nenagh, Scoil Nenagh, Co. Co. Ailbhe Co. Offaly Tipperary Tipperary17665A S N Colmain Tipperary,17679L Naofa Co. Tipperary Clonmel, Castle Co. Iny Tipperary. N17681V S Birdhill, Limerick S N Gleann17694H Guail BT S Ireland N Brighde17703F Toomevara, Nenagh, Clonmel, S Co. Co. Smart N Digiweb Tipperary Tipperary Na17712G Maighne S N Thurles, Chluainin Smart Co.17731K Tipperary S N Rath Ard17779P Chobain, Croine Clonmel, Digiweb Roscre, Co. Co. S Tipperary Tiobrad N Local Arann Chiarda Loop Naofa S N Iosef Naofa Cloughjordan, Smart Satellite Co. Powerstown Thurles, Tipperary N Co. Satellite S Tipperary ADSL Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Lorrha, Digiweb Nenagh, Digiweb Co. Tipperary Clonoulty, Goolds Cross, Clonoulty, Co. Goolds Tipperary Cross, Co. Tipperary ADSL Tir BT Da Ireland Glas, Thurles, Nenagh, Co. Co. Tipperary BT Tipperary Smart Ireland Satellite Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Luach Magh, Thurles, Digiweb Templemore, Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary Digiweb Smart ADSL Fantan, Thurles, Borrisoleigh Co. Local Thurles, Tipperary Loop Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Clonmel, ADSL Co. Tipperary Smart Nenagh, Kilkeary, Satellite Co. Nenagh, Tipperary Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Templemore, Digiweb Co. Tipperary Satellite Digiweb Smart Clonmel, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Smart Satellite Digiweb Satellite Satellite Digiweb Digiweb ADSL Digiweb Digiweb Satellite BT Ireland Satellite BT Satellite Ireland Satellite Satellite ADSL Leased Line County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1095 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1096

[Ms Hanafin.] 17783G17799V17850S S N Chuirt17940T Doighte S N Na18062V Haille S N18085K Phadraig Naofa S N Na18087O Mbuachailli S N An18135W Grainseach Ballyneale N S18164G S N Odhran18207V Naofa Scoil Angela18213Q S N Buirgheas18285S S N Baile18322V An Atha S N Leamhach18326G S N18343G Cill Chuimin S N An18345K Droma S N Naomh18350D Padraig S N Chaoimhghin Cahir,18369B Co. Tipperary S N Iosef18379E Naofa S N Na18396E Hinse Pairc Na An Coille, Mhoin S Borrisokane, Ard, N Co. Co. Cill Tipperary18435L Tiobrad Tulach Ruadhain Arann Seasta, Newport, Barnane Co. N Tipperary S18443K Clonmel, Co. Tipperary S N Rath18459C Eilte Sacred Heart Primary Carrick18465U School On Baile Suir, Na Co. Cloiche, S Tipperary Silvermines N Nenagh, Iosef18486F Co. Naofa Tipperary Scoil Mhuire18501V Ursuline Convent, S Thurles, N Co. Lios Tipperary18512D An Nenagh, Halla Co. Killaloe, Tipperary Co. S Clare N Cill18528S Siolain Grangemockler NS Thurles,18538V Co. Tipperary Scoil Phroinsias Thurles, Naofa Co.18557C Tipperary Digiweb Annacarty N Cill18559G S Thurles, Chais, Co. Clonmel, Tipperary Co. Scoil Tipperary Mhuire18582B Digiweb Digiweb Baile Dhaith, Digiweb S Thurles, N Co. Teampall Tipperary18716T Doire Digiweb S N Cill Cor Na An Naomh Bhile, Roscrea, Ballylooby Co. N Tipperary S Satellite Nenagh, Thurles, Co. Co. Cahir Tipperary Tipperary B Newline, N Roscrea, S Co. Tipperary BT Smart Ireland Satellite Satellite Digiweb Satellite Templemore, Co. Tipperary Satellite Thurles, Co. Tipperary Eaglais, Borrisokane, Co. Tipperary Leased Line Cill Nenagh, Mheanman, Co. Mullinahone Tipperary Satellite Digiweb Thurles, ADSL Co. Tipperary Carrick On Smart Digiweb Cill Suir, Garryshane, Siolain, Co. Co. Clonmel, Tipperary Tipperary Co. BT Tipperary Ireland Digiweb Digiweb BT Ireland Digiweb Annacarty, Co. Tipperary Satellite Nenagh, Co. Tipperary Caislean Nua, Clonmel, Satellite Co. Leased Tipperary Line Killeen, BT ADSL Nenagh, Ireland Co. Satellite Tipperary Satellite Digiweb ADSL Cahir, Digiweb Digiweb Co. Tipperary Satellite Digiweb Digiweb Cahir, Co. Tipperary ADSL Digiweb Satellite Satellite Satellite Smart Satellite Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Digiweb Satellite Digiweb BT Satellite Ireland Satellite Satellite Digiweb Digiweb Satellite Satellite Leased Line Smart Satellite Satellite Smart Satellite ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1097 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1098 plemore Road, Cloughjordan, Co. Tipperary Digiweb Satellite Tipperary o1NS Tem 18775M19230V19294B S N Micheal Naofa19305D Cormaic Special School19356U Lisvernane N S19370O Tankerstown N S19421F Killenaule N S19422H St. Annes Special19540N Sch Kilross NS19615S Cloughjordan N 19640R Clogheen Central N19645E S Scoil Aonghusa19677R Scoil Mhuire19687U St. Oliver Plunketts19689B NS Scoil Iosagain19690J St. Josephs Special19692N Sch Bansha N Cashel, S19696V Holycross, Co. Thurles, Tipperary Co. Tipperary Clonoulty Central19874T N S St. John The19879G Baptist Cashel Deanery Galbally,19880O Co. Tipperary Tankerstown, Bansha, Scoil Co. Na Tipperary Toirbhirte19937R Roscrea, Naomh Co. Padraig Tipperary Junior19968F Killenaule, Thurles, Co. Naomh Tipperary Padraig Senior20007C Gaelscoil Aonach20027I Clogheen, Co. Gaelscoil Tipperary Durlas Kilross, Eile20062K Co. Tipperary Gaelscoil Chluain Meala20085W Gaelscoil Cashel, Thiobraid Co. Arann Tipperary Heywood Rd, Clonmel, Scoil20129Q Co. Mhuire Tipperary Lismackin, Gaelscoil Roscrea, Charraig20155R Co. Na Tipperary Siuire Ferryhouse, Smart Clonmel, Co.65240L Tipperary Upperchurch Scoil Central Teampall NS, Toinne Thurles,65241N Co. Tipperary St. John The Goolds65270U Baptist Cross, BT Boys Co. Digiweb Ireland School Tipperary Presentation Secondary School65280A Bansha, Old Co. Road, Tipperary St. Cashel, Josephs Co. College Tipperary65300D C.B.S. Smart Digiweb Cashel, Satellite Co. Tipperary Presentation Drangan, Scoil Convent Thurles, Mhuire NS, Co. Thurles, Tipperary Co. Tipperary Drangan, ADSL Smart Rockwell Thurles, College Co. Tipperary Satellite Bothar Naomh Chonlain, Digiweb Durlas, Aonach Baile Co. Digiweb Urmhumhan, Gaelach, Tiobraid Co. Smart Cluain Arainn Satellite Thiobraid Meala, Morgaiste, Arann Co. ADSL Baile Thiobraid Thiobraid Arann Digiweb Arann, Co. Thiobraid Digiweb Arann C/O BT Carrick Ireland Utd Football ADSL Club, Coolnamuck Smart Road, Carrick-On-Suir, County BT Ireland Cashel, Co. Tipperary Wireless Digiweb Borrisokane, Satellite Co. Tipperary Ballyporeen, Smart Ballingarry, Cahir, Thurles, Co. Co. Tipperary Satellite Tipperary Satellite Digiweb Satellite Leased Line BT Ireland Smart ADSL ADSL Smart Borrisoleigh, Digiweb Digiweb Thurles, Co. Satellite Tipperary Digiweb ADSL Smart ADSL Satellite Cashel, Greenhill, Co. Carrick Tipperary On Carrick-On-Suir, Suir, Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary ADSL Smart Satellite Satellite ADSL Satellite ADSL Smart Smart Smart ADSL BT Ireland Smart Satellite Satellite Smart ADSL Satellite Smart Satellite Digiweb ADSL ADSL Wireless County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1099 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1100

[Ms Hanafin.] Corville Rd, Roscrea, Co. Tipperary BT Ireland ADSL ´ s Cre ´ ithre Clonmel, Co. Tipperary BT Ireland Local Loop ´ il Ro ´ 65320J65330M65340P Ardscoil Na65350S Mbra Loreto Secondary School65370B Presentation Secondary School65380E Patrician Presentation65400H St. Joseph’s C.B.S65410K St. Mary’s Secondary65440T School St. Mary’s Secondary65450W School Cistercian College65460C Our Ladys Secondary65470F School C.B.S. Thurles65490L Presentation Secondary School65500L Ursuline Secondary School72370P The Abbey School72400V St. Anne’s Secondary72420E School Clonmel, Co. Coleville Tipperary Rd., Borrisokane Clonmel, Community Co. College72430H Tipperary Vocational School72440K Central Technical Institute72450N Rocklow Rd., Scoil Fethard, Ruain Co. Nenagh, Tipperary72470T Co. Tipperary Nenagh Vocational Newport, School72480W Co. Tipperary Summerhill, Nenagh, St. Co. Joseph’s Tipperary College72490C St. Sheelan’s Templemore, College Co.76063D Tipperary St. Alibe’s School76069P Roscrea, Thurles, Co. Co. Tipperary Tipperary Vocational School91497A Colaiste Dun Iascaigh Thurles, Co. Tipperary Colaiste Phoba O’donovan Rossa St, Thurles, Co. Cashel Tipperary Community Borrisokane, Smart School Convent Co. of Tipperary Mercy, Rosanna Road, Tipperary Town Station Road, Tipperary Town, Co. Tipperary Esat Smart Clonmel, Co. Tipperary Carrick-On-Suir, Co. Tipperary BT ADSL Dromin Ireland Road, Nenagh, Co. Tipperary BT Ireland Smart Killenaule, Thurles, Newport, Co. Co. Satellite Tipperary Tipperary BT BT ADSL Ireland Ireland Templemore, Co. Smart Tipperary ADSL Rosanna Road, Tipperary Smart Town, BT ADSL Tipperary Smart Ireland Castlemeadows, Thurles, Cashel Co. Road, Tipperary Cahir, Co. Tipperary Dualla Road, Cashel, ADSL ADSL Satellite Co. Tipperary Smart Smart ADSL ADSL Satellite ADSL Smart Smart Smart ADSL Satellite Smart Smart ADSL Smart ADSL BT Smart Ireland ADSL Smart BT Ireland ADSL ADSL ADSL ADSL Satellite ADSL ADSL County Roll No. School Address Service Provider Delivery Type 1101 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1102

Installation Status By County

County Total Schools % Connectivity % Router Installed % Connectivity Installed Activated

Carlow 52 96.15 94.23 92.31 Cavan 90 98.89 98.89 94.44 Clare 137 94.89 94.89 91.24 Cork 453 96.47 96.47 89.85 Donegal 202 95.54 95.54 84.16 Dublin 649 94.61 94.14 84.75 Galway 284 97.18 97.18 89.44 Kerry 171 95.32 95.32 92.40 Kildare 129 93.80 93.80 90.70 Kilkenny 95 97.89 97.89 94.74 Laois 78 91.03 91.03 87.18 Leitrim 50 96.00 96.00 92.00 Limerick 184 96.20 96.20 92.93 Longford 50 98.00 98.00 88.00 Louth 90 96.67 95.56 90.00 Mayo 208 99.04 99.04 95.19 Meath 129 91.47 91.47 84.50 Monaghan 77 96.10 96.10 90.91 Offaly 80 98.75 98.75 95.00 Roscommon 102 99.02 99.02 93.14 Sligo 86 94.19 94.19 86.05 Tipperary 196 93.88 93.88 88.78 Waterford 94 95.74 95.74 90.43 Westmeath 91 90.11 89.01 79.12 Wexford 125 94.40 94.40 92.00 Wicklow 106 94.34 92.45 87.74

Total 4,008 95.58 95.38 89.20

Educational Projects. School Transport. 159. Mr. Crawford asked the Minister for Edu- 158. Mr. Perry asked the Minister for Edu- cation and Science when she will give recognit- cation and Science if her attention has been ion to a centre (details supplied) for Monaghan drawn to the difficulties encountered by a per- vocational educational committee; her view on son (details supplied) in County Sligo in relation whether this is a much used centre giving valu- to the school transport: if she will intervene on able opportunities to thousands of young people; their behalf to ensure that the free travel is sanc- if she will give permission to the VEC to pur- tioned to the school; and if she will make a state- chase the site from Coillte to allow it plan and ment on the matter. [32532/06] commit for the future; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [32543/06] Minister of State at the Department of Edu- cation and Science (Miss de Valera): Under the Minister for Education and Science (Ms terms of my Department’s Primary School Hanafin): My Department have requested Transport Scheme pupils who reside 3.2 kilo- further information from Co. Monaghan metres or more, and are attending, their nearest Vocational Education Committee in relation to suitable national school, as determined by my the governance and financial arrangements at Department, are eligible for free school the centre. On receipt of this information, the transport. application for recognition will be given further The pupil referred to by the Deputy, in the consideration. details supplied, does not meet these eligibility Late last year, a request was received from criteria. County Monaghan VEC for approval to incur 1103 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1104

[Ms Hanafin.] ment has been reached between the Department expenditure on the acquisition of a site from and the school authority on the provision of a Coillte Teo for the purpose of developing the new 32-classroom school. Progress on the pro- centre referred to. On the basis of the infor- posed works is being considered in the context mation supplied, approval was not given. of the School Building and Modernisation Prog- ramme from 2007 onwards. School Staffing. With regard to the schools accommodation 160. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for needs for September, 2007 officials in the School Education and Science the number of teachers Planning Section of the Department will be liais- employed at a school (details supplied) in county ing with the school authority with a view to pro- Kildare; the number of pupils enrolled in this viding it with accommodation in line with school; the number of classes in this school; and demand from eligible pupils under its enrol- if she will make a statement on the matter. ment policy. [32544/06] School Enrolments. Minister for Education and Science (Ms 162. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for Hanafin): The staffing in the school referred to Education and Science the number of section 29 by the Deputy for the 2006/2007 school year is appeals that have been lodged with her Depart- as follows: ment pertaining to matters arising for academic 1 Principal Post year 2006 to 2007; the number of these appeals per county; the number of these appeals which 2 Mainstream Class Teacher Posts have resulted in the enrolment of the student in 6 Permanent Developing School Posts question; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [32552/06] 1 Permanent Learning Support/Resource Post Minister for Education and Science (Ms 1 Permanent Special Class Post Hanafin): The information requested by the Deputy is held by my Department on a calendar 3 Temporary Language Support Posts year rather than a school year basis. Accord- My Department recently received the ingly, the attached statistics on appeal hearings September Salary Return form from the Board dealing with refusals to enrol reflect those of Management of the School. This form indi- appeals which have been dealt with from the 1st cated that there were 216 pupils enrolled in the January 2006 to date. school on the 30th September 2006. Table 1: Section 29 Appeal Hearings — Refusal to Enrol — The assignment of classes in a primary school 01/01/06 to 10/10/06 is a matter for the school authorities. The infor- mation requested by the Deputy is provided in Upheld Not upheld Total the annual census of primary schools. The refer- ence date for the provision by schools of this Cavan 3 0 3 information is the 30th September of the school Clare 3 7 10 year in question. As the details for the current Cork 3 6 9 school year have not been collated as of yet, I Donegal 1 0 1 am not in a position to provide the information to the Deputy. Dublin 9 5 14 Galway 2 4 6 Schools Building Programme. Kerry 0 1 1 Kildare 6 3 9 161. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for Limerick 0 1 1 Education and Science if the site for a school (details supplied) in County Kildare has been Longford 0 1 1 acquired; the stage the planning of this develop- Louth 0 1 1 ment is at; the interim measures she intends to Mayo 1 0 1 take for the shortfall in class availability for Meath 7 1 8 September 2007; and if she will make a state- Offaly 1 1 2 ment on the matter. [32549/06] Westmeath 2 0 2 Wexford 4 0 4 Minister for Education and Science (Ms Wicklow 2 0 2 Hanafin): I am pleased to inform the Deputy that a suitable site has been acquired for the Total 44 31 75 school to which the Deputy refers and agree- 1105 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1106

163. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for enrolments each year, as is the case in Kildare. Education and Science the number of students 170 such posts were sanctioned in the 2005/06 enrolled in Kildare schools for the academic school year, compared to 105 in 2004/05. year 2006 to 2007 whose class size is between 28 This Government has shown a clear determi- to 30 students; the number whose class size is nation to improve the staffing in our schools and between 31 to 33 students; the number whose we will continue to prioritise this issue going class size is at or above 34; if her Department forward. has identified the schools where pupil teacher ratios are substantially above the average: the Schools Recognition. strategies which have been devised for each of these schools in order to counteract this serious 164. Ms Shortall asked the Minister for Edu- problem; and if she will make a statement on the cation and Science her views on the concerns of matter. [32553/06] a school (details supplied) in Dublin 9; the basis for her Department’s refusal to grant permanent Minister for Education and Science (Ms recognition of the school; the criteria applying Hanafin): The information requested by the to that decision; the data her Department relied Deputy is provided in the annual census of upon to assess demand for this school; if the primary schools. The reference date for the pro- school was visited as part of the decision making vision by schools of this information is the 30th process; when and by whom; the level of her September of the school year in question. Department’s projected demand for multi- As the details for the current school year have denominational education in this area; the basis not been collated as of yet, I am not in a position for this estimate; if none exists, the reason there- to provide the information to the Deputy. fore; when she expects an estimate to be pro- As the Deputy will be aware, major improve- vided; the discussions her Department has had ments have been made in staffing at primary in with other Government agencies regarding the recent years. At the beginning of the current securing of a site for this school in one of the school year there are no less than 4000 extra soon to be emptied nearby public buildings; if no teachers in our primary schools, compared with discussions have taken place, when discussions 2002. The average class size in our primary are planned; and if she will make a statement on schools is 24 and there is now one teacher for 17 the matter. [32554/06] pupils at primary level. Children with special needs and those from Minister for Education and Science (Ms disadvantaged areas are getting more support Hanafin): The school to which the Deputy refers than ever before to help them to make the most commenced operation in September 2002, with of their time at school. provisional recognition from the Department on Indeed, with the thousands of extra primary the basis that it would be providing multi- teachers hired by this Government, recent years denominational education in the have seen the largest expansion in teacher Clontarf/Marino/Fairview area of Dublin. numbers since the expansion of free education. It is a condition of recognition that the Patron Over the next two school years even more must provide suitable accommodation in the teachers will be put in place both for the above stated area which must be capable of meeting priority areas of disadvantage and special edu- the growing needs of the school. Accom- cation and also under a reduction in the main- modation remains the Patron’s responsibility stream staffing schedule. until the Department is in a position to provide As you know all primary schools are staffed permanent accommodation, assuming the school on a general rule of at least one classroom achieves permanent recognition. teacher for every 28 children. Of course, schools In this case, the promoters were unable to find with only one or two teachers have much lower suitable accommodation in the area that it had staffing ratios than that — with two teachers for intended to serve. Instead, it set itself up, as a just 12 pupils in some cases and so on — but the temporary measure, in a vacated school building general rule is that there is at least one class- in Dublin 9, an area already providing multi- room teacher for every 28 children in the school. denominational education by two other schools. In the 2007/2008 school year, this is being Four main areas are examined in determining reduced to 27 children per classroom teacher. permanent recognition. These are whether or A further initiative that has been of direct not: benefit to primary schools has been the change 1. The school is operating under the Rules in the criteria for developing schools. For the for National Schools. current school year the threshold for getting a developing school post was reduced specifically 2. The school has determined viability in to help schools that are seeing large increases in terms of enrolment. 1107 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1108

[Ms Hanafin.] in County Laois for an extension; the priority 3. The school’s accommodation is deemed that has been assigned to this application; when suitable to meet its needs for the she expects to be in a position to progress this short/medium term or until the Department is project; and if she will make a statement on the in a position to provide permanent accom- matter. [32572/06] modation. 4. The school is meeting a need which is not Minister for Education and Science (Ms already being met by existing schools. Hanafin): I can confirm to the Deputy that the Department is in receipt of an application for While the Department accepts that the school in major capital works from the management auth- question has satisfied the first two criterion, it is ority of the school to which she refers. The appli- not satisfied that it has met the third and fourth, cation has been assessed in accordance with the although the fourth is the overriding issue, given published prioritisation criteria for large scale that the area concerned is already served by 2 projects and has been assigned a Band 2 rating. multi-denominational schools — both of which Progress on the proposed works is being con- have permanent recognition and one of which is sidered in the context of the School Building and based in permanent accommodation. Normally, Modernisation Programme from 2007 onwards. ahead of making new provision of a similar type in an area, the Department, a matter of policy, seeks to maximise existing provision to reduce Higher Education Grants. the burden on the State of resourcing a prolifer- 167. Ms O’Sullivan asked the Minister for ation of small schools. In the context of the Education and Science the instructions which extent of multi-denominational provision in the have been given by her Department to local area concerned, it is incumbent on the Depart- authorities and vocational educational commit- ment to strategically examine this provision to tees on the consideration of SSIA accounts for determine long term requirements and how third level grant applications; and if she will these should best be addressed. The Department make a statement on the matter. [32595/06] is carrying out this assessment which will be completed as quickly as possible. Minister for Education and Science (Ms The school was visited by a school inspector Hanafin): For the purposes of determining grant in 2003 and 2005. As already stated, the sourcing eligibility under my Department’s Maintenance of permanent accommodation does not arise Grants Schemes, all investments must be until a school receives permanent recognition. declared, including deposit accounts, savings cer- tificates, life assurance bonds and other financial 165. Ms Enright asked the Minister for Edu- instruments where the interest/profit is accumu- cation and Science if she has received an appli- cation for a new primary school (details lated and paid out as a lump sum at the end of supplied) in County Offaly; her views on this the investment period. application; if she will consider it in view of a The amount of income to be included in report previously commissioned by her Depart- respect of Special Savings Incentive Accounts ment stating a new primary school will be (SSIAs) as set out in the notes booklet which needed in the town; and if she will make a state- accompanies the student grant application form, ment on the matter. [32571/06] is the government grant earned on the savings in the relevant tax year plus in the case of savings Minister for Education and Science (Ms accounts, the gross interest earned in the rel- Hanafin): A Notice of Intention to Apply for the evant tax year, and in the case of investment recognition of a new primary school to com- accounts, the investment profit earned in the rel- mence operation next September in the area to evant tax year. Investment losses sustained in which the Deputy refers has been submitted to the relevant tax year are deductible. the New Schools Advisory Committee (NSAC). Where income is paid out annually, as hap- As with all such applications, a full application pens with a bank deposit account, the amount must be submitted to the NSAC no later than so paid is required to be included in reckonable 31st of January 2007. Following the NSAC’s income. Where income is not paid out annually report to me in the matter, I expect to announce but is “rolled-up” and paid out with the original my decision in mid-April of 2007. investment at the end of a defined term, the annual amount required to be included in Schools Building Projects. reckonable income is the “rolled-up” income 166. Ms Enright asked the Minister for Edu- divided by the number of years in the term of cation and Science if she has received a sub- the investment. This procedure has been in place mission from a national school (details supplied) for the past ten years. 1109 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1110

Given its similarity with “roll-up” savings impact of overseas duties on the employment of products it was deemed appropriate to include, Reserve personnel. The question of legislation as reckonable income, income from SSIAs on an will also be considered in this context. annual basis. The treatment of the SSIAs in this regard is consistent with the treatment of similar Defence Forces Remuneration. financial products such as Post Office Savings Certificates. 169. Ms Shortall asked the Minister for Defence the arrangements in place to ensure My Department is satisfied that the approach that national pay awards and other increases taken to computing reckonable income for pur- applicable to the pensions of former civilian poses of determining eligibility under the main- Defence Forces staff are paid on time; the tenance grant schemes is appropriate. arrangements in terms of staff numbers to ensure that the national pay agreement award Defence Forces Reserve. due on 1 November 2006 is paid on time; and if 168. Mr. Timmins asked the Minister for he will make a statement on the matter. Defence when members of the Reserve Defence [32487/06] Forces will be permitted to serve overseas; and if he will make a statement on the matter. 170. Ms Shortall asked the Minister for [32436/06] Defence the amount paid out in interest by his Department in the past three years for which fig- Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The White ures are available due to the late payment of pay Paper on Defence outlines the blue print for a and pension increases; and if he will make a new Reserve Defence Force. An Implemen- statement on the matter. [32488/06] tation Plan has been developed that will ensure the realisation of the White Paper vision and this Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I propose will be rolled out over the period to end 2009. to take Questions Nos. 169 and 170 together. The new Reserve will have a clearly defined At the outset, I should explain that the Office role, an enhanced relationship with the PDF, of the Paymaster General, Department of Fin- better equipment and training and opportunities ance, is responsible, upon the receipt from my to serve on overseas peace support missions. Department of the pension rate in each part- The Reserve has already seen significant icular case, for the payment of pensions to improvements in terms of clothing, equipment, retired employees, including retired civilian training and resourcing. It is now organised employees. Every effort is made to ensure that along similar lines to the PDF and the introduc- pension rates for pensioners are updated on a tion of the integrated element of the Reserve is timely basis to take account of any pay increases currently being addressed. All of these changes that might be paid from time to time to serving will enhance the capabilities of the Reserve as employees. well as improving interoperability with the PDF. In general, any pension increases due to These factors are significant enablers in facilitat- retired employees as a result of the application ing any future participation by Reserve person- of any national pay awards are paid as soon as nel in overseas missions. possible following the payment of increases to While there are no immediate plans for par- serving employees. However, from time to time, ticipation by members of the Reserve in over- delays may occur if, for whatever reason, the seas missions, policies to support the selection of rates of pension payable to individual pensioners suitably qualified personnel for overseas duties have to be revised for reasons other than the will be developed over the lifetime of the Imple- application of national pay awards. mentation Plan i.e. over the period to end 2009. The Deputy will be aware from my reply to In other countries, service by Reservists on over- a PQ she tabled on 27 September last that my seas peace support missions is quite common, Department is currently engaged in a review of although as specified in the Plan, any such par- the rates of pension payable to all the retired ticipation by members of the Reserve is likely to civilian employees of my Department. As my be in specialised areas such as medical, trans- Department has in excess of 1,200 civilian pen- port, engineering and communications and sioners, the Deputy will appreciate the scale of information services. This will also be subject to the task involved. I am pleased to inform the personnel having suitable qualifications, their Deputy that the rates of pension paid to a personal availability and appropriate advance majority of the pensioners involved have now training. been reviewed and the revised rates have been Development of policies to support the selec- forwarded to the Paymaster-General’s Office for tion of suitably qualified Reserve personnel for payment. In many cases, the review has resulted overseas duties will include consideration of the in increased levels of pensions for the pensioners 1111 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1112

[Mr. O’Dea.] In relation to the Deputy’s query regarding concerned. I understand from the Paymaster the amount paid out in interest by my Depart- General’s Office, that it is anticipated that any ment in relation to the late payment of pension pension increases due to retired civilian increases, I have made enquiries with the Pay- employees arising from the pay awards set out master General’s Office (the body responsible in the Sustaining Progress Agreement will be for the payment of pensions) concerning this implemented by 1 December 2006. matter. I understand that no interest payments The implementation date of the first phase of have been made to date. the pay increases set out in the new Social Part- Defence Forces Personnel. nership Agreement, Towards 2016, is 1 December 2006. The application of the pay 171. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for increases across the range of employments in the Defence the number of promotions by rank State industrial sector, including civilian approved or pending in the Army, Naval Service employees with the Defence Forces, requires the and Air Corps; and if he will make a statement approval of the relevant Performance Verifi- on the matter. [32559/06] cation Group (PVG) for that sector. The pen- Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The sions of former civilian employees with the military authorities advise that the number of Defence Forces will be adjusted, as appropriate military personnel promoted to date in 2006 and in the normal way, when the PVG has decided the number of promotions anticipated or pend- that payment of the 1 December 2006 pay ing for the remainder of 2006 are as shown in increases is warranted. the table.

Service Rank Number promoted to date Promotions 2006 pending/anticipated remainder of 2006

ARMY Col to Brig Gen 1 1 LtColtoCol 5 1 ComdttoLtCol 13 2 Capt to Acting Comdt 14 8 Lt to Acting Capt 37 2 2nd Lt to Lt 45 Coy Sgt to BSM 3 Coy Sgt to BQMS 0 CQMStoBQMS 3 Sgt to Coy Sgt 8 2 Sgt to CQMS 11 4 Cpl to Sgt 52 16 Pte to Cpl 102

NAVAL SERVICE Lt to Cdr 1 Sub-Lt to Lt 13 Ens to Sub-Lt 12 CPO to WO 1 SCPO to WO 0 CPO to SCPO 0 PO to CPO 6 PO to SPO 1 LS to PO 11 1 A/Sea to L/Sea 54 AIR CORPS Lt to Capt 0 11 QSM to RQSM 1 CQMStoCoySgt 1 Sgt to F/Sgt 3 2 Sgt to FQMS 1 Cpl to Sgt 8 3 1113 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1114

Service Rank Number promoted to date Promotions pending/anticipated 2006 remainder of 2006

Armn to Cpl 6

Brig Gen Brigadier General Col Colonel Lt Col Lieutenant Colonel Comdt Commandant Capt Captain Lt Lieutenant 2ND Lt Second Lieutenant Ens Ensign SM Sergeant Major BQMS Battalion Quarter Master Sergeant CS Company Sergeant CQMS Company Quarter Master Sergeant SGTS Sergeant RQSM Regimental Quarter Master Sergeant-Major F/SGTS Flight Flight Quarter Master SergeantF/QMS Sergeant CPLS Corporals PTES Privates WO Warrant Officer SCPO Senior Chief Petty Officer CPO Chief Petty Officer PO Petty Officer SPO Senior Petty Officer LS Leading Seaman A/S Able Seaman

Questions Nos. 172 and 173 answered with Cash Escorts. Following detailed and intensive Question No. 30. discussions between officials of the IBF, the member Banks and the Department, a detailed Question No. 174 answered with Question formal agreement was signed on 11 May, 2005. No. 34. This agreement, which is for a 5 year period, provides that the banks will pay the total actual Question No. 175 answered with Question costs incurred by the Defence Forces in the pro- No. 17. vision of cash escorts. Costs in respect of each 12 month period to end-December, will be paid Question No. 176 answered with Question the following year on or before the 1st June. No. 34. This is to allow for the compilation of returns Questions Nos. 177 and 178 answered with from the brigades and allocation of costs follow- Question No. 7. ing the year-end. The first payment under the new system was paid on 1 June 2006. I agreed, Question No. 179 answered with Question at the bank’s request, to defer the first payment No. 35. to that date to meet the banks budgeting and accounting timeframe. Question No. 180 answered with Question In return for my agreement to this deferral, a No. 34. transitional payment of \1 million, payable before the end of 2005, was negotiated as part Cash Escorts. of the overall agreement. Therefore in 2005 the \ 181. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for banks made their annual payment of 2.86m plus \ Defence the cost of military escorts in respect of the additional 1m making a total contribution \ \ cash in transit in each of the past five years; the of 3.86m. A figure of 6.03 million was paid in extent to which the financial institutions have 2006. The amount to be paid in 2007 (costs for paid for the service; the extent outstanding; and 2006) will not be available until early 2007. if he will make a statement on the matter. Prior to this initiative it had been the case that \ [32569/06] an annual contribution of 2.86m was being paid by the banks to my Department in respect of the Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): I had a provision of cash escorts since 1995. This figure number of discussions with the Irish Bankers was set by the Department of Finance in the Federation (IBF) in relation to this matter last 1995 budget and had not been altered since. The year, with a view to increasing the level of con- contribution from the Banks was designed to tribution by the Banks in respect of the costs part-cover the total costs to the State of provid- incurred by the Department in the provision of ing cash escorts. At that time, the contribution 1115 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1116

[Mr. O’Dea.] The total cost in respect of the provision by covered approximately 72% of the total cost the Defence Forces of assistance to the Garda arising to the Defence Forces. Based on annual Sı´ocha´na in protecting movements of cash for costings by the Department, the relative level of the years 2001 to 2005 was as shown in the table. the contribution had fallen in real terms over the years to the situation where it was only covering 43% of the total costs.

Year 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005

Total number of escorts 2,488 2,516 2,335 2,425 2,252 Cost of Escorts \6.57m \6.87m \6.5m \7.5m \6.03m Payment received \2.86m \2.86m \2.86m \3.86m \6.03m

Pay accounts for about 54% of the total costs of his views on the reintroduction of the first time providing cash escorts. The non-pay costs buyers grant; and if he will make a statement on include Security Duty Allowance (7%), Subsist- the matter. [32498/06] ence (8%), Transport (28%), and Aerial Surveil- lance (3%). Minister of State at the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government Defence Forces Equipment. (Mr. N. Ahern): Access to affordable housing for first time buyers remains a core objective of 182. Mr. Durkan asked the Minister for housing policy. This objective is being sup- Defence the extent to which all military equip- ported by ment including transport vehicles, aircraft and seagoing vessels are modernised and up-to-date • record levels of housing as evidenced in to international standards; and if he will make a the completion of some 285,000 houses statement on the matter. [32570/06] since the termination of the first time buy- ers grant in 2002, and Minister for Defence (Mr. O’Dea): The • significant output under an expanding acquisition of new equipment for the Defence range of affordable housing schemes: Forces continues to be a key focus for me as some 17,000 units are to be provided Minister for Defence. I am aware that significant through these schemes between 2007 and investment has taken place in recent years and I 2009. will continue the good work in that regard. The unprecedented level of expenditure on These targeted measures, in particular, assist low equipment for the Army, Air Corps and Naval income purchasers. They represent a better Service was made possible by the Government’s means of improving the affordability of house decision that pay savings arising from the reor- purchase and a more effective deployment of ganization of the Defence Forces set out in the resources, than a general first time buyer grant White Paper of 2000, along with proceeds from which would over time become absorbed into the sale of surplus properties, would be reallo- the house price. Other general measures are in cated for investment in modern facilities and place through the tax system to assist first time equipment. buyers, such as stamp duty concessions and Investment in new equipment for the Defence mortgage interest relief. Forces is provided for under various Subheads There is strong activity at present by first time of the Defence Vote relating to defensive equip- buyers in the market. It is estimated that 45% of ment, mechanical transport, aircraft, ships and new house loans in 2005 were taken out by first naval stores, engineering, communications and time buyers. In addition, the average age of Irish Information Technology equipment etc. All first time buyers in 2005 was 30. Over half of elements of the Defence Forces, the Army, Air these purchasers were aged 29 or under. This Corps, Naval Service and the Reserve have ben- compares with a corresponding average age in efited from the investment in new equipment. the United Kingdom of 34. The equipment issued to the Defence Forces The Government will continue to prioritise is in keeping with the most modern requirements effective action to maintain current high levels and the highest international standards. The of supply in the housing market and in part- ongoing investment in the Defence Forces will icular, will accelerate measures to assist those ensure that this remains to be the case. who cannot access affordable housing without assistance. Housing Grants. Architectural Heritage. 183. Dr. Cowley asked the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government 184. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for the 1117 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1118

Environment, Heritage and Local Government practice exists in any local authorities to include if there are grants available towards the refur- the weekly fuel allowance as assessable means or bishment or re-roofing of a stone cowhouse of income when calculating rent increases for local historical importance in County Carlow. authority housing tenants; and if he will make a [32505/06] statement on the matter. [32546/06]

Minister for the Environment, Heritage and 188. Mr. Stanton asked the Minister for the Local Government (Mr. Roche): My Depart- Environment, Heritage and Local Government ment funds a scheme of grants for the conser- if he has issued or intends to issue guidelines to vation of protected buildings, which is adminis- local authorities as to what constitutes assessable tered by the local authorities. It is a matter for income for local authority tenants; the details of each individual local authority to assess and same; and if he will make a statement on the prioritise applications and approve funding. The matter. [32547/06] scheme is aimed at assisting owners and occu- piers to carry out conservation works on struc- Minister of State at the Department of the tures of architectural significance in the Record Environment, Heritage and Local Government of Protected Structures, which the local auth- (Mr. N. Ahern): I propose to take Questions ority has listed under the Planning and Develop- Nos. 187 and 188 together. ment Act 2000. Enquiries regarding this scheme Each local authority calculates the local auth- should be made directly to the relevant local ority housing rents payable in its area in accord- authority. ance with a differential rents scheme adopted by My Department also funds The Heritage the elected members and subject to guidance Council which in turn administers a number of issued by my Department. Heritage and Architectural grants schemes. My Department has issued guidelines to local Information in relation to these schemes may be authorities in relation to rents of local authority obtained from The Heritage Council. dwellings under circular letter HRT 3 / 2002 of the 6 of March 2002. These guidelines set out the Grant Payments. broad principles of a rent scheme and are not prescriptive in determining what items should be 185. Mr. Kehoe asked the Minister for the included in the housing authority’s assessment Environment, Heritage and Local Government of income. if there are grants available for persons in The guidance advises authorities to ensure private dwellings to assist with the connection that rent increases do not absorb an excessive costs to the main sewage scheme in their town; amount of increases in income of tenants on low and if he will make a statement on the incomes, dependent on social welfare payments matter. [32533/06] and on old age pension payments. As a general guideline, no more than 15% of any increase in Minister for the Environment, Heritage and such pension income should be absorbed by an Local Government (Mr. Roche): No such grants increase in rent. are available from my Department. All aspects of the differential rent schemes are currently under examination in my Department Planning Issues. in line with the Government’s commitment in 186. Mr. J. O’Keeffe asked the Minister for the Housing Policy Framework Building Sus- the Environment, Heritage and Local Govern- tainable Communities to implement a fair rents ment when the application for a housing unit policy across all social housing tenures. (details supplied) was lodged in his Department, when approval was given for same, the reason Property Management Companies. for the delay; and if he will make a statement on 189. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for the the matter. [32545/06] Environment, Heritage and Local Government Minister of State at the Department of the the provision he has made to each local auth- Environment, Heritage and Local Government ority for payment of management company fees (Mr. N. Ahern): The application was received on due on dwellings allocated under the social com- 24 March 2004. Following technical examination ponent of Part V of the Planning and Develop- and the receipt of a revised design from Cork ment Act 2000; if no such provision is made, if County Council my Department approved the local authorities are required to pay such fees invitation of tenders for this project on 8 March from their annual budget as allocated via the 2005. local government fund; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32573/06] Local Authority Housing. 190. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for the 187. Mr. Stanton asked the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government Environment, Heritage and Local Government if he plans to offer guidance to local authorities if his attention has been drawn to whether the on the issue of management companies in devel- 1119 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1120

[Ms C. Murphy.] capital cost of their housing construction/ acquis- opments where local authority dwellings have itions programmes. The costs of managing hous- been acquired under Part V of the Planning and ing stock, including apartments properties Development Act 2000; and if he will make a acquired in private developments, must be met statement on the matter. [32574/06] from housing authorities own resources.

191. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for the Planning Issues. Environment, Heritage and Local Government 192. Ms C. Murphy asked the Minister for the the local authorities which have sought assist- Environment, Heritage and Local Government ance from his Department to cover the cost of the number of housing estates that remain to be management company fees incurred by local taken in charge in each local authority area; the authority properties; the nature of the assistance action which is being taken to execute this taking sought; the advice that was given; and if he will in charge; and if he will make a statement on the make a statement on the matter. [32575/06] matter. [32598/06] Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Minister of State at the Department of the Local Government (Mr. Roche): The table sets Environment, Heritage and Local Government out the number of estates for which the planning (Mr. N. Ahern): I propose to take Questions permission expired more than 2 years ago which Nos. 189 to 191, inclusive, together. have not yet been taken in charge, and the I refer to the reply to Questions Nos. 1514, number of those estates proposed to be taken in 1515, 1516 and 1551 of 27 September 2006. My charge in 2006, based on returns supplied by Department will keep developments in this area local authorities to my Department. As regards under review. action being taken to execute the taking in Financial assistance is provided by my Depart- charge, I refer the Deputy to my reply to Ques- ment to housing authorities in relation to the tion No. 227 on 4th October 2006.

Housing estates for which the life of the Housing estates to be taken in relevant planning permission expired charge in 2006. more than 2 years ago which have not yet been taken in charge.

Carlow County Council 11 13 Cavan County Council 25 8 Clare County Council 100 9 Cork County Council 210 40 Donegal County Council 201 20 Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council 42 10 Fingal County Council 32 26 Galway County Council 163 6 Kerry County Council 200 Not supplied Kildare County Council 109 49 Kilkenny County Council Not available 18 Laois County Council 19 16 Leitrim County Council 15 6 Limerick County Council 62 47 Longford County Council 28 5 Louth County Council 51 12 Mayo County Council 78 10 Meath County Council 112 15 Monaghan County Council 18 7 Offaly County Council 30 3 Roscommon County Council 6 6 Sligo County Council 25 20 South Dublin County Council 35 16 Tipperary North County Council Not available 0 Tipperary South County Council 11 15 Waterford County Council 3 8 1121 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1122

Housing estates for which the life of the Housing estates to be taken in relevant planning permission expired charge in 2006. more than 2 years ago which have not yet been taken in charge.

Westmeath County Council 26 18 Wexford County Council 150 8 Wicklow County Council 62 19 Cork City Council 30 16 Dublin City Council 121 1 Galway City Council 47 15 Limerick City Council 70 16 Waterford City Council 16 11 Clonmel Borough Council 14 10 Drogheda Borough Council 24 8 Kilkenny Borough Council 8 2 Sligo Borough Council 13 6 Wexford Borough Council 19 5 Athlone Town Council Included in Westmeath Co. Council return Ballina Town Council 9 8 Ballinasloe Town Council 14 3 Birr Town Council 3 1 Bray Town Council 5 Not known Buncrana Town Council Included in Donegal County Council return Bundoran Town Council Included in Donegal County Council return Carlow Town Council 0 4 Carrickmacross Town Council 1 4 Castlebar Town Council 25 3 Castleblaney Town Council 0 0 Clonakilty Town Council 10 5 Clones Town Council 1 1 Cobh Town Council 4 4 Dundalk Town Council 33 5 Dungarvan Town Council 0 8 Ennis Town Council 28 5 Enniscorthy Town Council 0 0 Kilrush Town Council Included in Clare Co. Council return Letterkenny Town Council Included in Donegal Co Council return Listowel Town Council 8 6 Longford Town Council 2 4 Macroom Town Council 2 3 Monaghan Town Council 6 3 Nenagh Town Council 11 3 New Ross Town Council 1 0 Skibbereen Town Council 1 2 Templemore Town Council 2 2 Thurles Town Council 8 1 Tipperary Town Council 6 0 Trim Town Council 0 0 1123 Questions— 12 October 2006. Written Answers 1124

[Mr. N. Ahern.]

Housing estates for which the life of the Housing estates to be taken in relevant planning permission expired charge in 2006. more than 2 years ago which have not yet been taken in charge.

Tullamore Town Council 13 2 Westport Town Council 16 2 Wicklow Town Council 16 24 Youghal Town Council 12 2

Total 2,423 625