Arxiv:2003.05821V1 [Quant-Ph] 12 Mar 2020 One of the Basic Pillars of Physical Science Is the Measure- 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Photonic Quantum Metrology Emanuele Polino,1, a) Mauro Valeri,1, a) Nicolò Spagnolo,1 and Fabio Sciarrino1, 2, b) 1)Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Piazzale Aldo Moro 5, I-00185 Roma, Italy 2)Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Istituto dei Sistemi Complessi (CNR-ISC), Via dei Taurini 19, 00185 Roma, Italy (Dated: 13 March 2020) Quantum Metrology is one of the most promising application of quantum technologies. The aim of this research field is the estimation of unknown parameters exploiting quantum resources, whose application can lead to enhanced per- formances with respect to classical strategies. Several physical quantum systems can be employed to develop quantum sensors, and photonic systems represent ideal probes for a large number of metrological tasks. Here we review the basic concepts behind quantum metrology and then focus on the application of photonic technology for this task, with particular attention to phase estimation. We describe the current state of the art in the field in terms of platforms and quantum resources. Furthermore, we present the research area of multiparameter quantum metrology, where multiple parameters have to be estimated at the same time. We conclude by discussing the current experimental and theoreti- cal challenges, and the open questions towards implementation of photonic quantum sensors with quantum-enhanced performances in the presence of noise. CONTENTS IV. Adaptive estimation protocols 20 1. Adaptive Bayesian protocols 22 I. Introduction 1 2. Machine Learning offline estimation A. Outline 2 techniques 23 II. Quantum Metrology: Fundamentals 2 V. Multiparameter quantum metrology 23 A. Estimation Process 2 A. Generalized theoretical framework for 1. Estimators 3 multiparameter quantum metrology 24 B. Fisher Information and Cramer Rao bound 4 B. Multiphase estimation 25 C. Quantum Fisher Information and Quantum 1. Photonic platforms for multiphase estimation Cramer Rao Bound 5 problems 27 D. Standard Quantum Limit, Entanglement and C. Simultaneous quantum estimation of phase and Heisenberg Limit 6 noises 27 1. Phase and phase diffusion estimation 28 III. Photonic Quantum Metrology: Schemes and 2. Phase and visibility estimation 28 Platforms 7 D. Other scenarios 29 A. Phase estimation problem 8 B. States and schemes 9 VI. Conclusions and Perspectives 30 1. Coherent states 9 2. N00N states 10 Acknowledgments 31 3. Continuous variable states 10 4. Squeezed states 11 5. Other states 13 I. INTRODUCTION C. Photonic platforms 13 1. Photonic degrees of freedom 13 arXiv:2003.05821v1 [quant-ph] 12 Mar 2020 One of the basic pillars of physical science is the measure- 2. Generation and detection of photons 14 ment process. The goal of a measure is to associate a value 3. Integrated photonic circuits 14 to a physical quantity, giving an estimate of it. Together with D. Platforms for the generation of phase-sensitive each experimental estimate, an uncertainty has to be provided, quantum states 15 that is the "parameter, associated with the result of a measure- 1. Platforms for N00N-like states 15 ment, that characterizes the dispersion of the values that could 2. Platforms for squeezed states 17 reasonably be attributed to the measured quantity" (definition 3. Platforms for other states 19 from ISO1). The statistical error which affects the measure- E. Other schemes and platforms 19 ment result, can have different natures: technical or funda- mental. The technical one is mostly represented by the acci- dental error, due to out-of-control imperfections in the mea- surement process. Conversely, there are fundamental limits a)These authors contributed equally to the manuscript preparation on uncertainty, such as those due to Heisenberg relations, that b)Electronic mail: [email protected] are imposed by physical laws. Quantum mechanics is the 2 most successful, predictive and fundamental theory describ- tum systems for several scenarios are photons, due to their ing small scales phenomena. For this reason, a study of the properties like high mobility, low interaction with the envi- measurement process and the ultimate achievable precision ronment, together with the available technology for their gen- bounds has to be done under the light of such theory2,3. On eration, manipulation and detection169–171. Hence, it is of sig- one hand, quantum mechanics imposes fundamental limits on nificant importance the development of platforms and tech- the estimate precision. On the other hand, in order to achieve niques to generate suitable quantum photonic states, able to such limits, quantum resources have to be employed. provide quantum-enhancement in different metrology tasks. Remarkably, the exploitation of quantum systems to esti- In particular, since many physical problems can be mapped mate unknown parameters overcomes the precision limits that into phase estimation processes, interferometry represents one can be in principle obtained by using only classical resources. of the most relevant scenarios8–11. This idea is at the basis of the continuously growing research Furthermore, the unknown parameters to be estimated in a area of Quantum Metrology, that aims at reaching the ulti- physical problem can be, in general, more than one. Also in mate fundamental bounds on estimation precision by exploit- this case quantum resources can enhance the simultaneous es- ing quantum probes4–15. Given an unknown parameter to be timation of all parameters172,173. This represents a relatively estimated and m classical probes (with m 1), each inter- new research area with different experimental and theoretical acting a single time with the system under study, the estima- open questions, such as the capability of reaching the quantum tion error will scale at best as ∼ m−1=2. This classical limit is ultimate bounds in the simultaneous estimation of all parame- consequence of central limit theorem, and is called Standard ters. Quantum Limit (SQL). The term "classical" stands for probes that are at most classically correlated. If quantum probes are allowed, the SQL can be surpassed so that the uncertainty of A. Outline −1 the estimator reaches the more fundamentalp scaling ∼ m , improving the precision by a factor m with respect to the In this review we present an overview of quantum metrol- SQL. Such new scaling represents the ultimate limit on esti- ogy through photonic platforms, by analyzing recent advances mation precision and is called Heisenberg Limit (HL). and discussing open problems. In Sec. II we will briefly re- A key role of quantum enhancement in estimation theory is view the definitions of the basic quantities, such as Fisher In- played by entanglement. This quantum phenomena is one of formation and Cramér-Rao bound, that characterize a general the most striking aspects of quantum mechanics and radically estimation process, together with the most relevant theorems. differs from classical view of the world, as recognized by Ein- In particular, the treatment is focused on single parameter es- stein, Podolsky and Rosen16. The relevance of entanglement timation. In Sec. III we describe photonic platforms for the in the fundamental divergence between classical and quantum generation of different quantum states, with the correspond- predictions, was theoretically demonstrated by Bell17. Realiz- ing applications in quantum metrology and in particular on ing his famous test, recent experiments showed, in a nearly un- phase estimation problems. Sec. IV is devoted to adaptive ambiguous way, that the observed quantum correlations aris- protocols able to enhance the estimation processes. In Sec. ing from distant entangled systems cannot be explained by any V we study the generalization of single parameter to multi- classical theory obeying local causality18–21. Quantum corre- parameter quantum metrology. We introduce the generalized lations represent also an extraordinary resource allowing to theoretical framework and then describe the state-of-the-art enhance performances in informational tasks22–25. Quantum of experimental photonic realizations of simultaneous multi- advantage with respect to the best classical strategies lies at parameter estimation. In Sec. VI we conclude by describing the basis of the research area of quantum technologies, com- the challenges towards genuine quantum enhanced metrology prising branches like quantum computation, communication, and providing some perspectives on future developments. simulation and precisely metrology23. Besides the fundamental interest about ultimate pre- cision limits, Quantum Metrology presents different II. QUANTUM METROLOGY: FUNDAMENTALS applications. Indeed, quantum-enhanced sensitiv- ity can benefit different research branches, such as: A. Estimation Process measurement on biological systems26–29, gravitational waves detection30, atomic clocks31–34, interferometry An estimation process aims at measuring an unknown pa- with atomic and molecular matter waves35–38, plas- rameter l embedded in a physical system. In this section we monic sensing39–41, magnetometry42–59, spectroscopy describe the case of single parameter estimation, while the and frequency measurements60–68, lithography69–74, mi- problem of estimating more than one parameter is described in croscopy and imaging75–117, localization of incoherent point Sec. V. Through the interaction between a probe and the sys- sources99,118–120, Hamiltonian estimation121–127, fundamental tem, information about the parameter is encoded in the probe physics effects128–141, coordinates transfer, synchronization