On the Classification of the Early Tertiary Erinaceomorpha (Insectivora, Mammalia)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln USGS Staff -- Published Research US Geological Survey 1985 On the Classification of the Early erT tiary Erinaceomorpha (Insectivora, Mammalia) Michael J. Novacek American Museum of Natural History Thomas M. Bown U.S. Geological Survey David Schankler Princeton University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/usgsstaffpub Part of the Earth Sciences Commons Novacek, Michael J.; Bown, Thomas M.; and Schankler, David, "On the Classification of the Early erT tiary Erinaceomorpha (Insectivora, Mammalia)" (1985). USGS Staff -- Published Research. 197. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/usgsstaffpub/197 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the US Geological Survey at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in USGS Staff -- Published Research by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. AMERICAN MUSEUM Novitates PUBLISHED BY THE AMERICAN MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY CENTRAL PARK WEST AT 79TH STREET, NEW YORK, N.Y. 10024 Number 2813, pp. 1-22, figs. 1-1 1, table 1 April 10, 1985 On the Classification of the Early Tertiary Erinaceomorpha (Insectivora, Mammalia) MICHAEL J. NOVACEK,I THOMAS M. BOWN,2 AND DAVID SCHANKLER3 ABSTRACT Definitions are provided for three Early Tertiary odont cheek teeth that superficially resemble pri- families of Erinaceomorpha. The family Dorma- mate dentitions. A third family, the Erinaceidae, aliidae includes Dormaalius, Macrocranion, Sce- includes the Early Tertiary genera Litolestes, Leip- nopagus, Ankylodon, Crypholestes, Sespedectes, sanolestes, Entomolestes, Neomatronella, Eolestes, and Proterixoides. Several ofthese genera are tra- Adapisorex, Cedrocherus, and living and fossil ditionally known collectively as "Adapisorici- members of the Galericinae, Brachyericinae, and dae," but Adapisorex is probably an erinaceid and Erinaceinae. Another member of the Erinaceidae the name Adapisorncidae is therefore unavailable is Dartonius, proposed here as a new designation for the above listed taxa. Dormaaliids are char- for "Leptacodon"jepseni. Several erinaceomorphs acterized by a reduction in size and complexity of are either too generalized in structure, too diver- the anterior premolars, a reduced, premolariform gent, or too poorly represented to allow assign- P4, and several other dental specializations. A sec- ment to any of the above families. These incertae ond family, the Amphilemuridae includes Am- sedis taxa are Diacodon, Adunator (including philemur, Gesneropithex, Alsaticopithecus, and Mckennatherium), Diacocherus, Litocherus, Tal- Pholidocercus. Amphilemurids have inflated, bun- pavus, and Talpavoides. INTRODUCTION The erinaceomorph insectivores are a crit- sification of Erinaceomorpha has, however, ical group for understanding eutherian phy- been subject to diverse interpretations. Greg- logeny. Erinaceomorphs have been variously ory (1910, p. 464) named the Section Eri- cited as ancestors or close relatives of tu- naceomorpha as a group including Erinacei- paiids, primates, bats, dermopterans, and dae, Leptictidae, and Dimylidae (table 1). several other major eutherian taxa. The clas- Simpson (1945) retained these families and I Chairman and Assistant Curator, Department ofVertebrate Paleontology, American Museum ofNatural History. 2 Geologist, U.S. Geological Survey, Denver, Colorado 80225. 3Research Assistant, Department of Geological and Geophysical Sciences, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey 08544. Copyright X American Museum of Natural History 1985 ISSN 0003-0082 / Price $2.90 2 AMERICAN MUSEUM NOVITATES NO. 2813 TABLE 1 Classifications of Erinaceomorph Insectivorans Gregory, 1910 Subfamily Creotarsinae (incl. Litolestes, Order Insectivora Xenacodon, Talpavus, Creotarsus, Dor- Suborder Lipotyphla maalius, Entomolestes, Scenopagus, Section Zalambdodonta (incl. Families Centeti- Macrocranion, Amphilemur, Sespe- dae, Potamogalidae, Solenodontidae, dectes, Proterixoides, Amphidozotheri- Necrolestidae, Chrysochloridae) um, Ictopidium, Tupaiodon) Section unnamed (incl. Family Pantolestidae) Subfamily Nyctitheriinae Section Erinaceomorpha (incl. Families Lepticti- Family Erinaceidae dae, Erinaceidae, Dimylidae) Subfamily Galericinae Section Soricomorpha (incl. Families Soricidae, Subfamily Erinaceinae Talpidae) Family Talpidae Suborder Unnamed (incl. Family Hyopsodontidae) Superfamily Soricoidea Simpson, 1945 Russell, Louis, and Savage, 1975 Order Insectivora Suborder Erinaceomorpha Superfamily Deltatheridioidea Family Adapisoricidae Superfamily Tenrecoidea Subfamily Adapisoricinae (incl. Adapisorex) Superfamily Chrysochloroidea Subfamily Dormaaliinae (incl. Litolestes, Superfamily Macroscelidoidea Leipsanolestes, Dormaalius, Entomo- Superfamily Soricoidea lestes, Neomatronella, "Leptacodon" Superfamily Pantolestoidea jepseni, Macrocranion, Scenopagus, Superfamily Mixodectoidea ?Proterixoides, ?Sespedectes, Talpavus, Superfamily Erinaceoidea Ankylodon) Family Zalambdalestidae Krishtalka, 1976a Family Dimylidae Family Adapisoricidae (incl. Mckennatheri- Family Leptictidae (incl. Gypsonictops, Pro- um, Scenopagus, Ankylodon, Macro- diacodon, Acmeodon, Emperodon, Myr- cranion, Talpavus) mecoboides, Adapisorex, Diacodon, Family Erinaceidae (incl. Litolestes, Leipsano- Parictops, Protictops, Ictops, Leptictis, lestes, ?Entomolestes [grangeri], and the ?Xenacodon, ?Sespedectes) subfamilies Galericinae and Erinacei- Family Erinaceidae nae) Subfamily Echinosoricinae (incl. Entomo- THIS PAPER: lestes, Proterioxoides, Metacodon, An- Suborder Erinaceomorpha kylodon, Proterix, Brachyerix, Mete- Family Dormaaliidae (incl. Dormaalius, Mac- chinus, Meterix, Neurogymnurus, rocranion, Scenopagus, Ankylodon, Lantanotherium, Galerix, Pseudogale- Crypholestes, Sespedectes, Proterix- rix, Echinosorex, Hyolomys, Podogym- oides) nura, Neotetracus) Family Amphilemuridae (incl. Amphilemur, Subfamily Erinaceinae (incl. Tetracus, Pa- Gesneropithex, Alsaticopithecus, Pholi- laeoerinaceus, Tupaiodon, Palaeoscap- docercus) tor, Parvericius, Aethechinus, Erinaceus, Atelerix, Family Erinaceidae (incl. Litolestes, Leipsano- Hemiechinus, Paraechinus) lestes, Adapisorex, Entomolestes, Neo- Van Valen, 1967 matronella, Eolestes, Cedrocherus, Dar- Suborder Erinaceota tonius, Proterix, and subfamilies Superfamily Erinaceoidea Galericinae, Erinaceinae, and Brachyer- Family Adapisoricidae icinae) Subfamily Geolabidinae Erinaceomorpha, incertae sedis (incl. Diaco- Subfamily Adapisoricinae (incl. Mcken- don, Adunator [incl. Mckennatherium], natherium, Leptacodon, Adunator, Diacocherus, Litocherus, Talpavus, Tal- Adapisorex, Paschatherium, Messelina) pavoides) added Zalambdalestidae in his Superfamily lambdalestids, and macroscelidids, in addi- Erinaceoidea. Saban (1954), frequently and tion to the families recognized by Gregory. incorrectly cited as the author of the Erina- Several authors in more recent years (Butler, ceomorpha, expanded this category with his 1956a, 1972; McDowell, 1958; McKenna, inclusion ofthe pantolestids, apheliscids, za- 1960, 1975; Russell, 1964; Van Valen, 1967; 1985 NOVACEK, BOWN, SCHANKLER: ERINACEOMORPHA 3 Novacek, 1973, 1976, 1977; Russell, Louis, UCMP, University of California Museum of Pa- and Savage, 1975; Krishtalka, 1976) have ar- leontology, Berkeley gued that Erinaceomorpha seems realistically USGS, United States Geological Survey limited to the Erinaceidae and other early YPM, Yale Peabody Museum taxa generally recognized as "adapisoricids." Several matters remain unresolved. Sige (1977) regards nyctitheriids as members of SYSTEMATICS the Erinaceomorpha contra opinions of McKenna (1975), Krishtalka (1976a, 1976b), CLASS MAMMALIA LINNAEUS, 1758 Novacek (1976), Bown and Schankler (1982), ORDER INSECTIVORA CUVIER, 1817 and others. There is also argument as to whether dimylids (see Schmidt-Kittler, 1973) SUBORDER ERINACEOMORPHA GREGORY, 1910 belong to the Erinaceomorpha (following Van DIAGNOSIS: Insectivorans with the follow- Valen, 1967; Butler, 1972; Novacek, 1976) ing combination of dental features that dis- or the Soricomorpha (following Schmidt- tinguish them from other early eutherian Kittler, 1973; McKenna, 1975). "Amphile- clades. P1 small, single-rooted and P2-3 dom- murids" (Heller, 1935) were transferred from inated by a single cusp. P4 with a short, ba- Erinaceomorpha to Primates by Russell, sined or unbasined talonid; P4 talonid cusps Louis, and Savage (1975) but were returned absent, or, if present, diminutive. M1 3 para- to Erinaceomorpha by Koenigswald and conids compressed, lophid-like, or cresti- Storch (1983). Gingerich (1983) has united form. Molar trigonid cusps lower, less sec- several problematic "adapisoricids" as mem- torial, and more anteriorly canted than in bers ofthe new subfamily Litocherinae. Here Kennalestes, Cimolestes, Procerberus, Asior- we address problems of relationships among yctes, palaeoryctids (sensu stricto), primitive the selected members of the Erinaceomor- leptictids (e.g., Prodiacodon), geolabidids, pha; namely, the Early Tertiary taxa com- early miacids, and creodonts. Talonids on monly recognized as erinaceids, adapisori- MK2 nearly as wide or wider than trigonids. cids, and amphilemurids. Our purpose is to M1 3 with high entoconids and low hypocon- provide a consensus statement on the higher ids often flattened in early stages of wear. P3 level taxonomy of the Erinaceomorpha that small, triangular in occlusal outline (second- reflects,