DOCSLIB.ORG

Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Appeals Court SUFFOLK, SS. NO. 2020-P-0908 SALVATORE F. DIMASI, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. WILLIAM F. GALVIN, Defendant-Appellant. ON APPEAL FROM A FINAL JUDGMENT OF THE SUFFOLK COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT BRIEF OF THE DEFENDANT-APPELLANT MAURA HEALEY Attorney General Julia E. Kobick, BBO # 680194 Assistant Attorney General Government Bureau One Ashburton Place Boston, Massachusetts 02108 (617) 963-2559 email: [email protected] 1 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF AUTHORITIES................................. 4 STATEMENT OF THE ISSUE.............................. 11 STATEMENT OF THE CASE............................... 11 Nature of the Case............................. 11 Statutory Background........................... 12 Factual Background............................. 17 1. DiMasi’s Criminal Conduct and Convictions.......................... 17 2. The Secretary’s Rejection of DiMasi’s Lobbyist Registration and the Presiding Officer’s Affirmance on Administrative Review............. 21 3. The Superior Court’s Decision........ 24 SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENT............................. 26 ARGUMENT............................................ 30 I. The Superior Court Erred in Declining to Defer to the Secretary’s Reasonable Construction of Section 45(m)............. 30 A. Section 45(m) Is, At Best, Ambiguous............................ 32 1. The Statutory Phrase “Shall Automatically Disqualify” is Susceptible to Different Interpretations................. 33 2. The Superior Court Disregarded Canons of Statutory Construction that Support the Secretary’s Reading of Section 45(m)........ 39 a. The Superior Court’s Construction Rendered an Important Part of 2 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM Section 45(m) Meaningless................ 39 b. The Superior Court’s Construction Undermines Legislative Intent and Results in Absurd Consequences............... 44 B. The Secretary’s Interpretation of Section 45(m) Is Reasonable and Warrants Deference................... 50 II. The Secretary Correctly Determined that, in Accordance with Section 45(m), DiMasi’s Felony Convictions Automatically Disqualify Him from Registering as a Lobbyist Until June 2021...................................... 54 CONCLUSION.......................................... 56 CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE........................... 58 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.............................. 58 ADDENDUM............................................ 59 3 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM TABLE OF AUTHORITIES Cases Adamowicz v. Ipswich, 395 Mass. 757 (1985)............................40 AT&T v. Automatic Sprinkler Appeals Bd., 52 Mass. App. Ct. 11 (2001).................31, 52 Banushi v. Dorfman, 438 Mass. 242 (2002).........................39-40 Biogen IDEC MA, Inc. v. Treasurer & Receiver Gen., 454 Mass. 174 (2009)........................51, 54 Blue Hills Cemetery, Inc. v. Bd. of Registration in Embalming & Funeral Directing, 379 Mass. 368 (1979)............................13 Boston Police Patrolmen’s Ass’n, Inc. v. City of Boston, 435 Mass. 718 (2002)............................41 Bridgewater State Univ. Found. v. Bd. of Assessors of Bridgewater, 463 Mass. 154 (2012).....................30, 44-45 Briggs v. Commonwealth, 429 Mass. 241 (1999)............................32 Brookline v. Comm’r of Dept. of Envtl. Quality Eng’g, 398 Mass. 404 (1986)........................32, 51 Casseus v. E. Bus Co., Inc., 478 Mass. 786 (2018)............................45 Chardin v. Police Comm’r of Boston, 465 Mass. 314 (2013)............................48 City of Worcester v. College Hill Props., LLC, 465 Mass. 134, 145 (2013).......................45 Cohen v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co., 41 Mass. App. Ct. 748 (1996)....................31 Collatos v. Boston Retirement Bd., 396 Mass. 684 (1986)....................47, 48, 49 4 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM Comm’r of Correction v. Superior Ct. Dept. of the Trial Ct., 446 Mass. 123 (2006)............................43 Commonwealth v. Hill, 57 Mass. App. Ct. 240 (2003)....................40 Commonwealth v. Pagan, 445 Mass. 315 (2005)....................25, 33, 44 Commonwealth v. Pon, 469 Mass. 296 (2014)............................13 Commonwealth v. Tobin, 392 Mass. 604 (1984)............................55 Commonwealth v. Zawatsky, 41 Mass. App. Ct. 392 (1996)....................41 Connors v. Annino, 460 Mass. 790 (2011)............................39 DaSilveira v. Police Comm’r of Boston, 97 Mass. App. Ct. 1120 (2020)...................37 DiMasi v. State Bd. of Retirement, 474 Mass. 194 (2016)............................31 Dupont v. Chief of Police of Pepperell, 57 Mass. App. Ct. 690 (2003)................37, 48 ENGIE Gas & LNG LLC v. Dep’t of Pub. Utils., 475 Mass. 191 (2016)........................31, 39 Fid. & Deposit Co. of Maryland v. Sproules, 60 Mass. App. Ct. 93 (2003).................36, 47 Franklin Office Park Realty Corp. v. Comm’r of Dept. of Envtl. Prot., 466 Mass. 454 (2013)....................32, 44, 51 Gaffney v. Contributory Ret. Appeal Bd., 423 Mass. 1 (1996)..............................37 Goldberg v. Bd. of Health of Granby, 444 Mass. 627 (2005)....................32, 44, 51 5 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM Guedes v. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms & Explosives, 920 F.3d 1 (D.C. Cir. 2019).......33-34, 35, 38-39 Home Depot v. Kardas, 81 Mass. App. Ct. 27 (2011).....................17 Jackson v. Longcope, 394 Mass. 577 (1985)............................17 Lazlo L. v. Commonwealth, 482 Mass. 325 (2019)............................13 Lindsay v. Dep’t of Soc. Servs., 439 Mass. 789 (2003)............................52 Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Comm’r of Ins., 397 Mass. 416 (1986)............................31 North Shore Realty Trust v. Commonwealth, 434 Mass. 109 (2001)............................45 Pereira v. New England LNG Co., 364 Mass. 109 (1973)............................13 Phillips v. Equity Residential Mgmt., L.L.C., 478 Mass. 251 (2017)........................39, 40 Retirement Bd. of Somerville v. Buonomo, 467 Mass. 662 (2014)....................31, 37, 48 Robinson v. Contributory Ret. Appeal Bd., 62 Mass. App. Ct. 935 (2005)....................36 Skilling v. United States, 561 U.S. 358 (2010).............................21 United States v. McDonough, 737 F.3d 143 (1st Cir. 2013).....17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 45, 55, 56 United States v. Turner, 684 F.3d 244 (1st Cir. 2012)....................45 United States v. Wilkerson, 675 F.3d 120 (1st Cir. 2012).............13, 45-46 6 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM Wallace W. v. Commonwealth, 482 Mass. 789 (2019)............................13 Wheatley v. Mass. Insurers Insolvency Fund, 456 Mass. 594 (2010)............................39 Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Amesbury v. Housing Appeals Committee, 457 Mass. 748 (2010)............................32 Statutes 18 U.S.C. § 201......................................55 18 U.S.C. § 371......................................17 18 U.S.C. § 1341.....................................17 18 U.S.C. § 1343.....................................17 18 U.S.C. § 1346.................................17, 55 18 U.S.C. § 1951.....................................18 42 U.S.C. § 1983.....................................24 G.L. c. 3 .....................................passim G.L. c. 3, § 39...............................14-15, 16 G.L. c. 3, § 45..................................24, 36 G.L. c. 3, § 45(a)...................................22 G.L. c. 3, § 45(m)...............................passim G.L. c. 3, § 50 .....................................16 G.L. c. 30A, § 14 ...................................24 G.L. c. 32, § 15(3A).................................47 G.L. c. 32, § 15(4)..............................36, 37 G.L. c. 55 ....................................passim G.L. c. 55, § 2 .....................................41 7 Massachusetts Appeals Court Case: 2020-P-0908 Filed: 10/30/2020 1:09 PM G.L. c. 55, § 3 .....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 5 .....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 6 .....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 7 .....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 8 .....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 9 .....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 10 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 11 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 12 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 13 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 14 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 15 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 16.....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 16A....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 16B....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 17.....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 18.....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 18B....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 18G....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 22 ....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 22A....................................41 G.L. c. 55, § 23.....................................41 G.L. c. 140, § 121...................................38 G.L. c. 140, § 131(d)............................37, 48 8 Massachusetts
Load more

Recommended publications
  • "First, Do No Harm.” March 28, 2007
    "First, do no harm.” March 28, 2007 Table of Contents Executive Summary & Recommendations ................................................................................................5 Introduction .............................................................................................................................................11 1. Protecting Children and Family Preservation .............................................................................15 2. 51A Reports and Mandated reporters ........................................................................................20 3. DSS Investigations.....................................................................................................................25 4. DSS Staffing...............................................................................................................................27 5. DSS Records Management........................................................................................................34 6. DSS Critiques.............................................................................................................................37 7. Law Enforcement Involvement...................................................................................................39 8. Private Providers........................................................................................................................40 9. Risk Assessment........................................................................................................................43
    [Show full text]
  • The Casino Debate in Massachusetts
    University of Massachusetts Boston ScholarWorks at UMass Boston Financial Services Forum Publications Financial Services Forum 4-1-2011 Dice or No Dice: The aC sino Debate in Massachusetts College of Management, University of Massachusetts Boston Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarworks.umb.edu/financialforum_pubs Part of the Economics Commons, Gaming and Casino Operations Management Commons, and the State and Local Government Law Commons Recommended Citation College of Management, University of Massachusetts Boston, "Dice or No Dice: The asinoC Debate in Massachusetts" (2011). Financial Services Forum Publications. Paper 28. http://scholarworks.umb.edu/financialforum_pubs/28 This Research Report is brought to you for free and open access by the Financial Services Forum at ScholarWorks at UMass Boston. It has been accepted for inclusion in Financial Services Forum Publications by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks at UMass Boston. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Spring 2011 Report Dice or No Dice: The Casino Debate in Massachusetts Dice or No Dice: The Casino Debate in Massachusetts University of Massachusetts Boston, College of Management Financial Services Forum Spring 2011 Report [1] Spring 2011 Report Dice or No Dice: The Casino Debate in Massachusetts Welcome to the UMASS – Boston, College of Management, Financial Services Forum’s 2011 Report on the casino debate in Massachusetts. The debate on casinos has intensified over the last few years. Governor Deval Patrick tried to get approval for three casinos back in September 2008, which was rejected by the then Speaker Salvatore Dimasi. However, two years ago, the Governor stood in the way of casinos by vetoing the bill passed by the House and the Senate.
    [Show full text]
  • Read EEA's Press Statement on the Bill Being
    For Immediate Release Contact: Tom Weber (617) 330-7389 (Work) July 31, 2008 (617) 669-3678 (Cell) [email protected] EARLY EDUCATION ADVOCATES PRAISE LANDMARK BILL “An Act Relative to Early Education and Care” Signed into Law at State House Ceremony BOSTON – The Early Education for All (EEA) Campaign today praised the Massachusetts Legislature and Governor Deval Patrick as he signed An Act Relative to Early Education and Care into law at a State House ceremony. The landmark legislation, sponsored by Education Committee Co-Chairs Senator Robert Antonioni and Representative Patricia Haddad, was passed unanimously by both the House and Senate and formally establishes the Universal Pre-Kindergarten (UPK) Program in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The legislation codifies in state law, and helps shape future directions for, a range of programs the Department of Early Education and Care (EEC) has been developing and implementing over the last three years. Specifically, it directs EEC to create strategic recommendations for the UPK Program and to develop a state policy on kindergarten transition. Furthermore, the bill creates a state advisory council on early education that will work to establish formal quality and performance standards to allow for continuous program improvement. It directs EEC to plan for and address the unique needs of families with infants and toddlers. It also further delineates powers and duties of the Board, Department, and Commissioner of EEC and makes technical changes necessary for the effective development of a coordinated and streamlined early education and care system. “This bill represents a major step forward for young children and families, further solidifying the Commonwealth’s commitment to providing universal access to high- quality early education and affirming Massachusetts’ standing as a leader in this important area,” said EEA Campaign Director Amy O’Leary.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Gazette
    VOL. 120 - NO. 50 BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS, DECEMBER 9, 2016 $.35 A COPY Mayor Signs Cable Television License, Mayor’s Enchanted Trolley Tour Bringing Verizon Services to Boston & Prado Tree Lighting Advanced Fiber-Optic Network Will Support Businesses, Bring Consumer Choice to Residents Mayor Martin J. Walsh re- working with Verizon to bring cently announced the City of more choice and upgraded Boston has issued a Final Cable technology to Boston’s residents Television (CATV) License to Ve- and businesses.” rizon New England. The license In April, the City of Bos- covers three neighborhoods: ton and Verizon announced Dorchester, the Dudley Square a partnership to bring a new neighborhood in Roxbury and fi ber-optic network platform to West Roxbury. The license an- Boston, replacing copper infra- ticipates future expansion of the structure. Since then, Verizon service area to additional neigh- has been constructing their net- borhoods, with the fi rst service work and has already installed area expansion expected to fi ber-optic wiring necessary to include Hyde Park, Mattapan, offer service to 25,000 homes and other areas of Roxbury and and businesses by year’s end. Jamaica Plain. The signing of the cable license “Boston will continue to grow clears the way for Verizon to and thrive, and Boston’s resi- begin selling Fios service before dents need fast, reliable com- the end of the year. (Photo by Matt Conti, northendwaterfront.com) munications services built on “We are appreciative of the the latest technologies,” said In his third neighborhood trolley tour, Mayor Mayor were local elected offi cials City Councilor Mayor Walsh.
    [Show full text]
  • Rouse: Westfield's COVID-19 Numbers Reported Accurately
    Search for The Westfield News Westfield350.comTheThe Westfield WestfieldNews News Serving Westfield, Southwick, and surrounding Hilltowns “TIME IS THE ONLY WEATHER CRITIC WITHOUT TONIGHT AMBITION.” Partly Cloudy. JOHN STEINBECK Low of 55. www.thewestfieldnews.com VOL. 86 NO. 151 TUESDAY, JUNE 27, 2017 75 cents $1.00 WEDNESDAY, APRIL 1, 2020 VOL. 89 NO. 079 Rouse: Westfield’s COVID-19 numbers reported accurately By PETER CURRIER be transparent and provide accurate info. everyone that it is here and it continues to Staff Writer Unfortunately, in this situation, it makes us spread,” said Rouse, “Listen to the precau- WESTFIELD — The number of confirmed stand out.” tions, stay home when you can, especially cases of COVID-19 increased to 57 as of Rouse said that the rate of growth of con- stay home if you are sick at all.” Tuesday morning. firmed cases seen thus far in Westfield is Westfield Mayor Donald F. Humason said Public Health Director Joseph Rouse said about the same as what has been reported Monday that his office is now largely operat- March 30 that he has noticed Westfield’s elsewhere. In most communities, no matter ing under the authority of Rouse and the numbers stand out from those of neighboring the size, the number of cases doubles about Health Department when it comes to coordi- communities, most of which are reporting a every three to four days. Last Thursday, nating the city response to the coronavirus. much lower number of confirmed cases. March 26, the number of cases was announced This is due in part because of the emergency He said that he does not believe that at 24.
    [Show full text]
  • Former Massachusetts Speaker and Lobbyist Fail to Overturn Corruption Convictions on Appeal −
    NEWSLETTER Friends With Detriments: Former Massachusetts Speaker and Lobbyist Fail to Overturn Corruption Convictions on Appeal − September 2013 Authors In United States v. McDonough, the First Circuit affirmed the − Carol A. Laham convictions and sentences of former Speaker of the Massachusetts Partner House of Representatives Salvatore DiMasi and lobbyist Richard 202.719.7301 McDonough for engaging in transactions characterized by the court [email protected] as “a scheme to funnel money to DiMasi in exchange for political favors.” The court also signaled that harsh sentences may be appropriate when they are needed to combat a culture of public corruption. During a six-week trial, the government presented evidence showing that the scheme began in December 2004 when McDonough approached Joseph Lally, an employee of software company Cognos Corporation, and told him that DiMasi was interested in supplementing his income. DiMasi had been a Massachusetts state representative since 1979 and became Speaker in September 2004. As his legislative duties had increased, the dwindling income from his personal law practice left DiMasi in a financial bind. McDonough, a longtime friend and lobbyist, was looking to help DiMasi take care of his personal debts and increase his cash flow and believed an arrangement with Lally could be fruitful. Lally was responsible for lobbying on behalf of Cognos in its attempts to sell software products to state and local governments. McDonough suggested that Lally have Cognos hire DiMasi's law partner, Steven Topazio, under a sham lobbying contract and pay him a monthly retainer of $5,000. A portion of this payment was then transferred to DiMasi under their pre-existing fee-sharing arrangement.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report Town Officers Town of Rockland Massachusetts
    132nd ANNUAL REPORT OF THE TOWN OFFICERS OF THE TOWN OF ROCKLAND MASSACHUSETTS For the Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2006 IN MEMORIAM 2006 January 21 Edward J. Keane Water Commissioner April 8 Sean T. Ryan School Custodian April 16 William J. Mullin Highway Department Call Firefighter May 24 Dorothea E. Stenberg Election Official June 5 Catherine J. Marshall School Nurse July 14 James S. Kenworthy Industrial Development Commission September 2 Alexander Paton Auxiliary Police October 6 Warren E. Silvia Rockland Housing Authority November 26 Kathleen T. Doucet Cafeteria Aide December 28 Beverly A. Borges Council on Aging Director Town Clerk’s Report 2006 FEDERAL OFFICERS 2006 – 110th U.S. Congress (1st Session) UNITED STATES SENATORS IN CONGRESS (Washington, D.C.) Six year term Two elected from Eleventh Massachusetts Congressional District: Edward M. Kennedy (D-Barnstable) John F. Kerry (D-Boston) UNITED STATES REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS (Washington, D.C.) Two year term Tenth Congressional District William D. Delahunt (D-Quincy) STATE OFFICERS MASSACHUSETTS EXECUTIVE BRANCH GOVERNOR Mitt Romney, Belmont (R) LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR Kerry Murphy Healey, Beverly (R) SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH (4 year term) William Francis Galvin, Boston (D) ATTORNEY GENERAL (4 year term) Thomas F. Reilly, Watertown (D) TREASURER (4 year term) Timothy P. Cahill, Quincy (D) AUDITOR (4 year term) A. Joseph DeNucci, Newton (D) COUNCILLOR (2 year term) Fourth District Christopher A. Iannella, Jr., Boston (D) MASSACHUSETTS LEGISLATIVE BRANCH (General Court) SENATE (40 Members) SENATE PRESIDENT Robert E. Travaglini, Boston (D) STATE SENATOR (2 year term) Norfolk & Plymouth District Michael W. Morrissey, Quincy (D) State House, Room 413D, Boston, MA 02133 (617) 722-1494 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 160 Representatives elected SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE (2 year term) Salvatore DiMasi, Boston (D) STATE REPRESENTATIVE (2 year term) 5th Plymouth District Robert J.
    [Show full text]
  • July 23, 2008 Hon. Salvatore Dimasi, Speaker Hon. Therese Murray
    July 23, 2008 Hon. Salvatore DiMasi, Speaker Hon. Therese Murray, President Massachusetts House of Representatives Massachusetts State Senate State House, Room 356 State House, Room 332 Boston, MA 02133 Boston, MA 02133 Dear Speaker DiMasi and Senate President Murray: On behalf of a broad group of business organizations and health plans committed to ensuring access to quality and affordable health care in the Commonwealth, we are writing to express our strong opposition to the provisions in Governor Patrick's 2008 Supplemental Budget Bill imposing new assessments and taxes to fund the state's Health Care Reform Law. The bulk of these costs will be borne by employers, who have already increased their health care spending by an estimated $500 million due to various components of the law, and would do nothing to control the underlying factors driving health care costs. Massachusetts struck a delicate balance in the passage of the Health Care Reform Law and is now a national leader in comprehensive health insurance reform. This model was unique not only because of its innovative features but because of its broad and diverse stakeholder support, the business community being most notable among them. Several of the signatories below were part of the broad coalition that helped to pass the Health Care Reform Law. We understand the importance of ensuring that those programs are fully funded. However, the underlying assumptions driving the need for new revenue are uncertain at best, based on projected growth in enrollment of 50,000 covered lives when, in fact, enrollment in Commonwealth Care has been flat for several months.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Matter of the Boston Municipal Court, Department of the Trial
    7 v CLERK'S COPY COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS SUFFOLK, SS. SUPREME JUDICIAL COURT NO. SJC-OE-085 IN THE MATTER OF THE BOSTON MUNICIPAL COURT ;s DEPARTMENT OF THE TRIAL COURT Report of Special Master and Commissioner Dean Paul R. Sugarman Suffolk University Law School 41 Temple Street Boston, MA 02114 February 4, 1991 TABLE OF CONTENTS I . INTRODUCTION 1 1. Order Appointing Special Master and Commissioner 1 2. The Boston Globe Series 1 3. Methodology of Investigation 3 II. HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE, STRUCTURE, ORGANIZATION AND PRESENT OPERATION OF BMC 12 1. Brief History of the Boston Municipal Court and the District Courts 12 2. Efforts to Reorganize the Courts 18 3. The Court Reorganization Act of 1978 21 4. The Trial De Novo System 24 a. Criminal Jurisdiction of the District Courts and BMC 24 b. Trial De Novo Prior to 1979 25 c. Trial De Novo Changes of 1979 26 d. The Debate over Abolition of De Novo 28 5. Budget and Physical Facilities of BMC 30 6. Case Load of BMC 33 7. Administrative Structure of BMC 36 8. BMC Probation Department 37 9. Operation of BMC Primary Court for Criminal Business 3 9 10. Operation of BMC Jury-of-Six Session 3 9 11. Assignment of Judges, Clerks, and Cases to Sessions 51 a. Assignment of Cases 51 b. Assignment of Clerks to Sessions 55 c. Assignment of Cases 56 12. Conferencing of Cases 57 13. "Admission to Sufficient Facts" and "Continuance Without A Finding" 60 14. Suffolk County District Attorney's Office 62 15. "Operating Under the Influence" Cases 68 16.
    [Show full text]
  • Supreme Court of the United States
    No. _________ ================================================================ In The Supreme Court of the United States --------------------------------- --------------------------------- SALVATORE F. DiMASI, Petitioner, v. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Respondent. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari To The United States Court Of Appeals For The First Circuit --------------------------------- --------------------------------- PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI --------------------------------- --------------------------------- THOMAS R. KILEY Counsel of Record WILLIAM J. CINTOLO COSGROVE EISENBERG & KILEY, PC One International Place, Suite 1820 Boston, MA 02110 617.439.7775 (tel.) [email protected] (email) Counsel for Petitioner ================================================================ COCKLE LEGAL BRIEFS (800) 225-6964 WWW.COCKLELEGALBRIEFS.COM i QUESTIONS PRESENTED (1) Whether the principles underlying the McCormick “explicit agreement” requirement in the campaign contribution context apply as well in the context of a part-time citizen legislator’s receipt of professional fees or of other funds in anticipation of a future business arrangement. (2) Whether an elected state legislator can be convicted of violating federal bribery laws without considering the state laws claimed to permit the legislator’s conduct. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page QUESTIONS PRESENTED ................................ i TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ................................. iv OPINION BELOW
    [Show full text]
  • Forging Consensus
    Forging Consensus The PaTh To healTh RefoRm in massachusetts Irene M. Wielawski July 2007 I Forging Consensus The PaTh To healTh RefoRm in massachusetts Irene M. Wielawski July 2007 About the Author Irene M. Wielawski is a health care journalist with 20 years experience on daily newspapers, including the Providence Journal-Bulletin and the Los Angeles Times, where she was a member of the investigations team. She has written extensively on problems of access to care among the poor and uninsured, and other socioeconomic issues in American medicine. From 1994 through 2000, Wielawski, with a research grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, tracked the experiences of the medically uninsured in 25 states following the demise of President Clinton’s health reform plan. In two previous reports published by the Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts Foundation, she contributed profiles of uninsured Massachusetts residents. Wielawski has been a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for medical reporting, among other honors. She is a founder and former director of the Association of Health Care Journalists. Contact author: [email protected] Funding for this report was provided by the Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts Foundation. The analysis presented here is that of the author and should not be attributed to the Foundation or its directors, officers, or staff. 2 Forging Consensus: The Path to Health Reform in Massachusetts inTRoDUCTION The ink was barely dry on Massachusetts’ new health reform law before commentators began to hold forth. The 2006 legislation’s promise—access to affordable health insurance for virtually all residents—was certainly commendable but would it ever be realized? After all, Massachusetts had been down this road 18 years before under the administration of Democratic Governor Michael S.
    [Show full text]
  • Lobbyists 2021 617.646.1000 - Boston - Washington Dc Greg M
    Directory of Massachusetts LOBBYISTS 2021 617.646.1000 - www.oneillandassoc.com BOSTON - WASHINGTON DC GREG M. PETER J. MATTHEW P. VICTORIA E. D’AGOSTINO D’AGOSTINO MCKENNA IRETON Providing comprehensive state and municipal advocacy. PRACTICE AREAS: TRANSPORTATION | HEALTH CARE PUBLIC SAFETY | REGULATIONS | ENERGY ENVIRONMENT | CANNABIS FINANCIAL SERVICES | EMERGING INDUSTRIES WWW . T ENAXSTRATEGI E S . COM Theodore J. Aleixo, Jr. Joseph D. Alviani Rafael Antigua A Essential Strategies Inc. Alviani Associates (Joseph D. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. One State Street, Suite 1100 Alviani dba Alviani Associates) 4 New York, Plz Floor, 17 Anthony Arthur Abdelahad Boston, MA 02109 8 Holbeck Corner New York, NY 10004 Ventry Associates LLP (617) 227-6666 Plymouth, MA 02360 (212) 499-1404 (617) 645-5628 1 Walnut Street Daniel Allegretti Chelsea Elizabeth Aquino- Boston, MA 02108 Exelon Generation Company, LLC Oamshri Amarasingham Fenstermaker (617) 423-0028 1 Essex Drive American Civil Liberties Mass Mentoring Partnership Tate Abdols Bow, NH 03304 Union of Massachusetts 75 Kneeland Street Onex Partners Advisor Inc. (603) 290-0040 211 Congress Street 11th Floor 161 Bay Street Boston, MA 02110 Boston, MA 02111 Matthew John Allen (617) 482-3170 (617) 695-2476 Toronto , ON M5J 2S1, CA American Civil Liberties (416) 362-7711 Union of Massachusetts Robert J. Ambrogi Derek Armstrong Brendan Scott Abel 211 Congress Street Law Office of Robert Ambrogi Bank of America, N.A. Massachusetts Medical Society Boston, MA 02110 128 Main Street 100 Federal Street, MC: MA5-100-09-12 860 Winter Street (508) 410-1547 Gloucester, MA 01930 Boston, MA 02110 (978) 317-0972 (617) 434-8613 Waltham, MA 02451 Travis Allen (781) 434-7682 Enterprise Rent-A-Car Shannon Ames Kristina Ragosta Arnoux Lisa C.
    [Show full text]