Leishmania. Taxonomie et phylogenèse. Applications éco-épidémiologiques. (Coll. int. CNRS/INSERM, 1984). IMEEE, Montpellier, 1986, 143-148.

The of Leishmania-like parasites of

R. Killick-Kendrick*, R. Lainson**, J.-A. Rioux***, and V.M. Sarjanova****

SUMMARY — The taxonomic position of the Leishmania-hke parasites occurring as amastigotes or promasti- gotes in the gut or blood of reptiles is reviewed and it is concluded that they should be grouped in the Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973, with Sauroleishmania tarentolae (Wenyon, 1920) as the type . The principal differences between Leishmania Ross, 1903 and Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973 include the verte- brate and invertebrate hosts, the host cells inhabited by the amastigote, the sites of development in the sandfly, the kDNA and the distance between the subpelUcular microtubules of the promastigotes.

KEY-WORDS — Sauroleishmania — — Taxonomy.

Ali current, modern methods of distinguishing trypanosomatids by examining nucleic acids, isoenzymes or antigens have failed to reveal a close relationship between the leishmaniae of mammals and of reptiles [7] and there now appears to be general agreement that the Leishmania-like parasites of reptiles should be classified separately from the mammalian species of Leishmania. The taxonomic position of the reptilian parasites is, however, confused. In this note, we review the relevant publications and propose that they should be transfered to the genus Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973. : n Parasites which occur as amastigotes, promastigotes, or both in the blood or cloaca of lizards, or which can be cultured purely as promastigotes from the blood or viscera of lizards, were at first assigned to either the genus Leptomonas Kent, 1880 [21] or the genus Herpetomonas Kent, 1880 [21] (see [15] ). In 1920, Wenyon [52] named two new species of parasites and put them into the genus Leishmania Ross, 1903 [41]. From that time, most other species of similar parasites of lizards have been assigned to this genus. In 1982, Saf janova [42] used the subgeneric name Sauroleishmania to accommodate the so-called leishmaniae of reptiles with Leishmania (Sauroleishmania) gymnodactyli Khodukin and Sofiev, 1947 (cited from Adler [1] ) as the type species. Saf janova's name had, however, already been used in 1973 in a thesis by Ranque [38], although as a genus with a different type species. We have looked into the question of whether or not Ranque's thesis constitutes a publication within the meaning of the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature of 1985 [19] and conclude that it is fully acceptable. It satisfies the three criteria in Article 8(a) and was produced by offset printing [Article 8(c) ], not by electrostatic or xerographic methods [see Article 9(3) ]. The next mention of the name was by Nicoli and Nourrit in 1974 [33] who wrote « Sauro• leishmania R.M. Nicoli et Ph. Ranque, 1973, pour les Trypanosomidés (sic) de Nématocères (Phlebotomidae). Développement postérieur prenant chez les Sauropsidés la forme promastigote (infestation par piqúre ou ingestion). Espèce type : Sauroleishmania tarentolae (CM. Wenyon, 1921) de mauritanica. » There was, however, no publication by Nicoli and Ranque in 1973 and the citation was modified from that given in Ranque's thesis (R.M. Nicoli, pers. comm.). The differences between Leishmania Ross, 1903 [41], emend. Vickerman, 1976 [50], and Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973 [38] (Table I) are sufficiently marked to warrant taxonomic

* Medicai Research Council Externai Scientific Staff, Department of Pure and Applied Biologj', Imperial CoUege at Silwood Park, Ascot, United Kingdom. ** Wellcome Parasitology Unit, Instituto Evandro Chagas, Belém, Pará, Brazil. *** Laboratoire d'Ecologie médicale et de Pathologie parasitaire (Pr. J.-A. Rioux), Faculte de Médecine, Montpellier, France. **** Gamaleya Institute of Epidemiology and Microbiology, Academy of Medicai Sciences of the U.S.S.R., Moscow, U.S.S.R. 144

TABLE I Principal differences between Leishmania and Sauroleishmania.

Leishmania Ross, 1903, Sauroleishmania Character emend. Vickerman, 1976 Ranque, 1973 Vertebrate host mammals snakes *" and lizards Form in vertebrate host amastigote amastigote or promastigote Host cell of amastigote* macrophage and its precursors monocyte, thrombocyte or erythrocyte Invertebrate host Phlebotomus spp. (Old World) Lutzomyia spp. (New World) Sergentomyia spp. Psychodopygus spp. (New World) (Old World) Site of development suprapylarian or peripylarian hypopylarian or peripylarian in invertebrate host Mode of transmission bite of vector ingestion or bite of vector** Maxi-circles of kDNA 26-27 kb 32-38 kb Distance between sub- pellicular microtubules 25-40 nm 60-70 nm

1. Belova and Bogdanov (1969). 2. Chatton and Blanc (1914), Léger (1918), Francini (1921). Shortt and Swaminath (1928), David (1929), Frenkel (1941), Rioux et al. (1969, 1979), Edeson and Himo (1973), Nadim (1974), Telford (1979), Ovezmukhammedov and Safjanova (1983). 3. Léger (1918). Wenyon (1920), Zmeyev (1936), Fopov (1941), Andrusko and Markov (1955), Killick-Kendrick and Wallbanks (1981). 4. Telford (1979). 5. Telford (pers. comm.). 6. Lainson and Shaw (1979) 7. Kolesnikov et al. (1984). 8. Safjanova (1982). * Amastigotes of Leishmania divide in the macrophage whereas amastigotes of Sauroleishmania, whether in monocytes, thrombocytes or erythrocytes, appear never to be in division. ** No species of Sauroleishmania has yet been transmitted experimentally from a sandfly to a .

recognition of two distinct groups. By Article 43(a) of the International Code of Zoológica] Nomenclature (1985), a taxon at genus or subgenus rank is simultaneously established for the other rank with the same author and date. The question of whether Sauroleishmania should be accepted as a genus, as treated in the present paper, or as a subgenus of Leishmania, as viewed by Safjanova [42, 43] is, therefore, a matter of opinion. Ranque [38] clearly indicated S. tarentolae (Wenyon, 1921) as the type species of Sauroleish• mania. However, as Gardener [15] pointed out, the date of the naming of the species tarentolae is 1920, not 1921 as usually cited. The confusion arose because of a delay in the publication of the Journal Parasiíology after World War I resulting in two volumes, 11 and 12, being published in the same year (1920) (F.E.G. Cox, Editor of Parasitology, pers. comm.). When first published, the name was spelt tarantolae, not tarentolae. This is construed as an « inadvertent error » on the assumption that Wenyon intended the name to be spelt in the same way as that of the host, Tarentola. Evidence for this is in Wenyon's monograph published in 1926 [53] where he corrected the name to tarentolae without comment. The later name now stands as a correction of an « incorrect original spelling » [Articles 32(c)(ii) and (d) of the Code (1985)]. The identity of Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973 rests on the type species, S. tarentolae (We• nyon, 1920), of which there is no type material available. A culture of promastigotes purporting to be L. tarentolae Wenyon, 1920 (code RTAR/DZ/39/TAR VI) isolated by Parrot [35] in 1939 was recently shown by Wallbanks et al. [51] to be Trypanosoma platydactyli Catouillard, 1909. A comparison of isoenzymes revealed no differences between Parrot's parasite and a double cloned culture of the trypanosome. This work, however, did not show that the amastigotes seen in the blood of Tarentola by Chatton and Blanc [8] and Rioux et al. [39, 40] are developmental forms of a trypanosome and, without evidence to the contrary, these stages are presumably Sauroleish• mania tarentolae (Wenyon, 1920) (see [37] ). 145

In Table II a list is given of named species of Leishmania of lizards which are here transferred to Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973. We give no opinion of the vaUdity of these names some of which may fali into synonymy [15]. Some or ali of those parasitizing the intestinal tract of lizards may be parasites of ingested [10, 18, 49, 50]. In addition of the named species, there are a number of reports of Sauroleishmania published without names. Particularly interesting records include : amastigotes of Chalcides ocellatus in Sicily [13] ; promastigotes cultured from the blood of five species of snakes in the Turkmenian S.S.R. [6] ; promastigotes (some of which were later identified by Saf janova (unpubl. observations) as S. gymnodactyli) cultured from the blood of 4 species of Phrynocephalus, 1 of Agama, 5 of Eremias, 1 of Gymnodactylus and 1 of of the Turkmenian S.S.R. [5] ; a parasite of pipiens on mainland [16] ; amastigotes seen in smears of bone marrow and liver of lizards in [31] ; promastigotes cultured from the heart blood of Agama sp. near Mashad, Iran [32] ; amastigotes in the thrombocytes of Agama agilis and Teratoscincus scincus in Pakis- tan [47] ; two different promastigotes of Chamaeleo dipidis in Zâmbia, one in the cloaca and one an ephemeral infection of the peripheral blood [23] ; unusually small amastigotes in the erythro- cytes of two species of geckoes, Hemidactylus platycephalus and Chemaspis africana, in Tanzânia (Sam Telford Jr, pers. comm.); and amastigotes and promastigotes in the intestine of Anolis lucius in Cuba [20]. There are numerous other records of flagellates in the guts of lizards, often assigned to the genera Herpetomonas and Leptomonas which, like some of the named species of Sauroleishmania in the intestine and cloaca of reptiles, may have been transitory infections of invertebrate kinetoplastids and require further study. In the description of Sauroleishmania, Ranque [38] gives the promastigote as the form generally found in the vertebrate host. These forms have not, however, been reported in smears of blood or other tissues of T. mauritanica, the type host of the type species. We give below an emended description of the genus.

SAUROLEISHMANIA Ranque, 1973

Júnior subjective S3'nonym : Sauroleishmania Saf janova, 1982. Diagnosis : Trypanosomatids of the blood or intestinal tract of reptiles occurring as amas• tigotes and/or promastigotes ; amastigotes in the blood parasitize macrophages and precursors, thrombocytes or erythrocytes ; in the Old World, the invertebrate hosts of the blood-inhabiting forms are species of Sergentomyia (Diptera, Psychodidae) within the gut of which the parasites have a hypopylarian or peripylarian development as a promastigote ; invertebrate hosts of intestinal forms unknown ; transmission assumed to be by bite and/or ingestion of vector. Type species : Sauroleishmania tarentolae (Wenyon, 1920).

A CKNO WLEDGEMENTS

We thank Dr R.S. Bray, Prof. E.U. Canning, Prof. A.G. Chabaud, Dr A. Dubois, Prof. P.C.C. Garnham FRS, Mr Richard Melville, Dr S.R. Telford Jr and Dr K. Wallbanks for advice or comments on this paper. Support is acknowledged from the Medicai Research Council, London (R.K.-K.), WHO, Geneva (R.K.-K., J.-A.R., V.M.S.) and the Wellcome Trust (R.L.). We acknowledge with thanks the help of Mme S. Farice in our enquiries into the method of reproduction of the thesis by Ranque [38]. TABLE II Hosts, forms and type localities of some named species of Sauroleishmania.

Parasite Type host Tissue infected Form(s) in vertebrate host Type locality

S. henríci (Léger, 1918) Anolis ?carolinensis rectum promastigotes Martinique (? rarely in blood) (rarely amastigotes) S. chamaeleonis (Wenyon, 1920) Chamaeleo vulgaris cloaca and intestine promastigotes, amastigotes Egypt S. tarentolae (Wenyon, 1920) Tarentola mauritanica blood amastigotes Algéria S. hemidactyli (Mackie, Das Gupta and Hemidactylus sp. cultured from blood not known índia Swaminath, 1923) S. davidi (Strong, 1924) Cnemidophorus lemniscatus intestine promastigotes Central America lemniscatus S. agamae (David, 1929) Agama stellio blood amastigotes Israel S. ceramodactyli (Adler and Theodor, 1929) Ceramodactylus doriae cultured from blood not known Iraq S. nicollei (Khodukin and Sofiev, 1940) A. sanguinolenta ? 9 Central Phrynocephalus sp. S. gymnodactyli (Khodukin and Sofiev, Gymnodactylus caspius cultured from blood amastigotes Turkmenian S.S.R. 1947) S. zmeevi (Andrushko and Markov, 1955) Fremias sp. cultured from blood ? Turkmenian S.S.R. S. adleri (Heisch, 1958) Latastia longicauda cultured from blood not known Kenya S. sofieffi (Markov, Lukina and Markova, ? ? Shores of 1964) S. hoogstraali (McMillan, 1965) Hemidactylus turcicus cultured from blood not known Sudan S. senegalensis (Ranque, 1973) Tarentola annularis cultured from blood not known Senegal

1. Cited from Telford [48] : we have not seen the original description. 2. Cited from Adler [1] : we have been unable to find the original description. 3. Cited from Ranque [38]. 147

Taxonomie des Leishmania et parasites similaires de Reptiles

RÉSUMÉ — La position taxonomique des Leishmania et des parasites similaires rencontrés sous forme amastigote ou promastigote dans lintestin ou le sang de Reptiles, fait 1'objet d'une mise au point. Ces Kinetoplastida doivent être regroupés dans le genre Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973, avec Sauroleishmania tarentolae (Wenyon, 1920) comme espèce type. Les differences principales entre Leishmania Ross, 1903 et Sauroleishmania Ranque, 1973 sont: les hôtes vertébrés et invertébrés, les cellules incorporant les amastigotes, les sites de développement dans le Phlébotome, VADNk et la distance entre les microtubules sous-pelliculaires chez les promastigotes.

MOTS-CLÉS — Sauroleishmania — Lézards — Taxonomie.

REFERENCES

[1] Adler S. — Leishmania. In : Advances in parasitology. Dawes B., ed. Academic Press, London, 1964, 34-96. [2] Adler S., Theodor O. — Observations on Leishmania ceramodactyli n. sp. Trans. R. Soe. trop. Med. Hyg., 1929, 22, 343-356. [3] Andrushko A.M., Markov G.S. — The new finding of Leishmania in the reptiles of . Westn. Leningr. gos Univ., 1955, 1, 51-59 (in Russian). [4] Belova E.M. — Detection of leptomonads in some species of lizards in the Turkmenskaya S.S.R. Medskaya Parazit., Moskva, 1966, 31, 281-283 (in Russian). [5] Belova E.M. — Reptiles and their importance in the epidemiology of leishmaniasis. Buli. Wld Hlth Org., 1971, 44, 553-560. [6] Belova E.M., Bogdanov O.P. — Infection ofsnakes with leptomonads in Turkmenskaya S.S.R. Medsfeaja Parazit, Moskva, 1969, 38, 304-306 (in Russian). [7] Chance M.L. — The biochemical and immunological taxonomy of Leishmania. In : Human parasitic diseases. Vol. 1. Leishmaniasis. Chang K.P., Bray R.S., eds. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985, 93-110. [8] Chatton E., Blanc C. — Existence de corps leishmaniformes dans les hématoblastes d'un barbaresque, Tarentola mauritanica (L.) Gunth. C. r. Séances Soe. Biol, 1914, 7, 430-433. [9] David A. — Recherche expérimentale sur un Hématozaire du genre Leishmania (L. agamae A. David). Thèse Doctorat en Sciences, Université de Paris. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, 1929, 54 p. [10] Dollahon N.R., Janovy J. — flagellates from faeces and gut contents of four genera of lizards. J. ParasitoL, 1971, 57, 1130-132. [11] Dollahon N.R., Janovy J. — Experimental infection of New World lizards with Old World lizard Leishmania species. Expl ParasitoL, 1974, 36, 253-260. [12] Edeson J.F.B., Himo J. — Leishmania sp. in the blood of a lizard (Agama stellio) from Lebanon (laboratory demonstration). Trans. R. Soe. trop. Med., Hyg., 1973, 67, p. 27. [13] Francini G. — Sur les flagellés intestinaux du type Herpetomonas de Chamaeleo vulgaris et leur cultura, et sur les Flagellés du type Herpetomonas de Chalcides (Gongylus) ocellatus et Tarentola mauritanica. Buli. Soe. Path. exot., 1921, 14, 641-645. [14] FrenkelJ. — Note on an intracellular stage oí Leishmania chamaeleonisWenyon, 1921. Ind. J. med. Res., 1941, 29, 81-82. [15] Gardener P.J. — Taxonomy of the genus Leishmania : a review of nomenclature and classification. Trop. Dis. Buli., 1977, 74, 1069-1088. [16] Garnham P.C.C. — The genus Leishmania. Buli. Wld Hlth Org., 1971, 44, 477-489. [17] Heisch R.B. — On Leishmania adleri sp. nov. from lacertid lizards (Latastia sp.) in Kenya. Ann. trop. Med. ParasitoL, 1958, 52, 68-71. [18] Hommel M. — The genus Leishmania .-biology of the parasites and clinicai aspects. BulL Inst. Pasteur, Paris, 1978, 75, 5-102. [19] International Code of Zoological Nomenclature. International Trust for Zoological Nomenclature, Lon• don, 1985, 338 p. [20] Jimenez Ozete H. — Informe de Leishmania (Zoomastigophorea, Kinetoplastida) en Anolis lucius en Cuba. Rev. cub. Med. rop., 1981, 33, 106-109. [21] Kent W.S. — A manual of the Infusoria. Vol. 1. London, 1880. [22] Khodukin N.T., Sofiev M.S. — Leishmania of some lizards of Central Asia and their epidemiological significance. In ; Problems of subtropical pathology. Tashkent, 1940, 4, 218-228 (in Russian). [23] Killick-Kendrick R., Wallbanks K.R. — The identity of Leishmania chamaeleonis Wenyon, 1921 (labora• tory demonstration). Trans. R. Soe. trop. Med. Hyg., 1981, 75, 326. 148

[24] Kolesnikov A.A., Saf janova V.M., Stezenko M.M. — Species specificity of the cleavage of kDNA of Leishmania by restrictases. Medskaya Parazit., Moskva, 4, 37-41 (in Russian). [25] Lainson R., Shaw J.J. — The role of animais in the epidemiology of South American leishmaniasis. In : Biology of the Kinetoplastida. Vol. 2. Lumsden W.H.R., Evans D.A., eds. Academic Press, London, 1979, 1-116. [26] Léger N. — Infection sanguine par Leptomonas chez un Saurien. C. r. Soe. BioL, 1918, 81, 772-775. [27] Mackie F.P., Das Gupta B.M., Swaminath CS. — Progress report on kala-azar. Ind. J. med. Res., 1923, 11, 591-599. [28] McMillan B. — Leishmaniasis in the Sudan Republic. 22. Leishmania hoogstraali sp.n. in the gecko. J. Parasitai, 1965, 51, 336-339. [29] Markov G.S., Lukina G.P., Markova L. — Protozoa and ticks. In : The parasites of reptiles of the Caspian Sea shore. Uchenie zapiski Volgogradskogo ped. Instit., 1964, 16, 106-110 (in Russian). [30] Markov G.S., Lukina G.P., Markova L., Mozgina A. A. — Parasites of reptiles in the Northern Caucasus. Kakedry ZooL Fiziol. MorphoL, 1964, 16, 99-105 (in Russian). [31] Nadim A. — 1974. Cited in Saf janova V.M. and Alexeiev A.N., 1977. [32] Nadim A., Seyedi Rashti M. A. — On the nature of leptomonads found in Sergentomyia sintoni in Khorassan, Iran, and their relationship to lizard leishmanias. J. trop. Med. Hyg., 1968, 71, 240. [33] Nicoli R. M., Nourrit J. — Recherches systématiques sur les Trypanosomidés. Définition des genres dans 1'ordre des Trypanosomidés. Buli. Soe. zool. Fr., 1974, 99, 699-704. [34] Ovezmakhammedov A., Saf janova V. M. — On the occurrence of amastigotes of Leishmania gymno- dactyli in the peripheral blood of Gymnodactylus caspius and Agama caucasica. ParazitoL, Leningrad, 1982, 17, 185-188 (in Russian). [35] Parrot L. — Sur quelques souches de Leishmania. Archs Inst. Pasteur Algér., 1949, 27, 106-9. [36] Popov P.P. — Cutaneous leishmaniasis in Azerbaidzhan. In : Problems of cutaneous leishmaniasis. Ashkabad, 1941, 107-112 (in Russian). [37] Pozio E., Gramiccia M., Gradoni L., Maroli M. — Osservazioni sugli emoflagellati dei geconidi (Sauria, Reptilia) italiani. In : Atti 12o Cong. naz. Soe. ital. Parassitol., Como (28-30 giugno 1983). Parassitologia, 1983, 25. [38] Ranque P. — Etude morphologique et biologique de quelques Trypanosomidés récoltés au Senegal. Thèse Doctorat en Sciences, Aix-Marseille, 28 avril 1973. [39] Rioux J.A., Knoepfler L.P., Martini A. — Présence en France de Leishmania tarentolae Wenyon, 1921, parasite du Gecko Tarentola mauritanica (L., 1758). Annls Parasit. hum. comp., 1969, 44, 115-116. [40] Rioux J.A., Killick-Kendrick R., Garnham P.C.C. — Leishmania tarentolae and other blood parasites of geckoes at Banyuls in the south of France (laboratory demonstration). Trans. R. trop. Med. Hyg., 1979, 73, 319. [41] Ross R. — Further notes on Leishman's bodies. Brit. med. J., 1903, ii, 1401. [42] Saf janova V.M. — The problem of taxonomy with Leishmania. In .-The leishmanias. Ser. Protozoology. Soviet Academy of Science. Science, Leningrad, 1982, 7, 5-109 (in Russian). [43] Saf janova V.M. — The problem of classification and phylogeny of Leishmania. In : Leishmania. Taxonomie et phylogenèse. Applications éco-épidémiologiques. {Coll. int. CNRS/INSERM, 2-6 juillet 1984). IMEEE, Montpellier, 1986, 247-255. [44] Saf janova V.M., Alexeiev A.N. ~ Mixed experimental infection of Phlebotomus papatasi (Scop.) with different species of Leishmania. Coll. int. CNRS, n° 239, Montpellier (18-24 aoút 1974), 1977, 153-155. [45] Shortt H.E., Swaminath CS. — Preliminary note on three species of Trypanosomatidae. Ind. J. med. Res., 1928, 16, 241-244. [46] Strong R.P. — Investigations upon flagellate infections. Am. J. trop. Med., 1924, 4, 345-385. [47] Telford S.R. — Evolutionary implications of Leishmania amastigotes in circulatory blood cells of lizards. Parasitai, Cambridge, 1979, 79, 317-324. [48] Telford S.R. — Hemoparasites of reptiles. /a.Diseases of amphibians and reptiles. Hoof G., Frye F.L., Jacobsen E.R., eds. Plenum Publishing Corporation, 1984, 385-517. [49] Vickerman K. — The identity of Leishmania chamaeleonis Wenyon, 1921 (laboratory demonstration). Trans. R. trop. Med. Hyg., 1965, 59, p. 372. [50] Vickerman K. — The diversity of kinetoplastid flagellates. In : Biology of the Kinetoplastida. Vol. 1. Lumsden W.H.R., Evans D.A., eds. Academic Press, London, 1976, 1-34. [51] Wallbanks K.R., Maazoun R., Canning E.U., Rioux J.A. — The identity of Leishmania tarentolae Wenyon, 1921. Parasitai, Cambridge, 1985, 90, 67-78. [52] Wenyon CM. — Observations on the intestinal protozoa of three Egyptian lizards, with a note on a cell-invading fungus. Parasitai, Cambridge, 1920 [sic], 12, 350-365. [53] Wenyon CM., — Protozoology. Vol. 1. Baillière, Tindall and Cox, London, 1926, p. 438. [54] Zmeyev G.J. — Haemoparasite fauna of wild vertebrates in some southern áreas of Tadzhikistan. Trans. Tadzhik base Acad. Scl U.S.S.R., 1936, 6, 249-266 (in Russian).