D-Bug Hazard Reduction Timber Sale Project Appendix A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
United States Department of Agriculture D-Bug Forest Service Pacific Northwest Hazard Reduction Region Timber Sale Project Appendix A Final Environmental Impact Statement Response to Comments Umpqua National Forest Diamond Lake Ranger District August 2010 D-Bug FEIS Appendix A – Response to Comments 2 D-Bug FEIS Appendix A – Response to Comments Response to Comments The 45-day public comment period for the D-Bug Hazard Reduction Timber Sale Project Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) opened on March 14, 2009, with publication of the Notice of Availability in the Federal Register, and closed on April 27, 2009. Requests for extension of the comment period prompted the Responsible Official to extend the comment period until June 8, 2009. The public was asked to comment on Alternative 4, as described in the DEIS in Chapter 2. A field trip to the planning area was held on June 4, 2009, to generate additional comments and give people the opportunity to visit the planning area with members of the Interdisciplinary Team. The Umpqua National Forest received 428 timely comment letters, e-mails or phone calls. An additional 633 comments, primarily in the form of e-mails, were also received after the close of the extended comment period. Most of these comments resemble the timely comments received and are on file (electronically) at the Umpqua National Forest Supervisor‘s Office. The Forest received comments from the following persons and agencies: Table 1. List of public and agencies who commented on the Dbug Hazard Reduction Timber Sale Project DEIS. Comment Type of Name Organization Date Received Number Comment Diamond Lake 1 Ross Roberts Phone Call 3/19/2009 Summer Home Owner Lemolo Lake Resort Conversation with 2 Scott and Dianna Lamb 4/7/2009 Owners Don Morrison Diamond Lake 3 Karl Staubach Letter 4/15/2009 Summer Home Owner Gary and Peggy Diamond Lake 4 Email 4/21/2009 Shontz Summer Home Owner Diamond Lake 5 Richard Little Letter 4/22/2009 Summer Home Owner Douglas County Forest 6 John Blodgett Letter 4/23/2009 Products Email and 7 Francis Eatherington Umpqua Watersheds 4/23/2009 Attachment 8 Christine Reichgott EPA Letter 4/27/2009 9 M. Bryan Warf Email 5/12/2009 10 Stuart Phillips Email 5/12/2009 11 Stuart Phillips Email 5/12/2009 Jasmine Zimmer- 12 Email 5/12/2009 Stucky 13 Philip Simon Email 5/12/2009 14 Dee Tvedt Email 5/13/2009 15 Preston Sleeger Department of Interior Electronic Letter 6/03/2009 16 Dave Monet Monet Logging Phone Call 6/03/2009 17 Bob Ragon DTO Email 6/04/2009 18 Don Wilson Email 6/05/2009 Diamond Lake 19 Gary Shontz Email 6/05/2009 Summer Home Owner 20 Peggy Shontz Diamond Lake Email 6/05/2009 1 D-Bug FEIS Appendix A – Response to Comments Comment Type of Name Organization Date Received Number Comment Summer Home Owner 21 Don Wilson Electronic letter 6/05/2009 22 Mark Boyer Electronic letter 6/05/2009 23 Ed Cooley Email 6/06/2009 24 Rich Fairbanks Email 6/07/2009 Robert Clavins & Emily 25a Electronic letter 6/07/2009 Cain 25b Susan Applegate Electronic letter 6/07/2009 26 Scott and Diana Lamb Letter 6/07/2009 27 Leslee Sherman Email 6/08/2009 28 Liz Mitchell Email 6/08/2009 29 Barbara Gicking Email 6/08/2009 30 Rasha Weber Email 6/08/2009 31 Lethi Yodis Email 6/08/2009 32 Sherwood Reese Email 6/08/2009 33 Marylynn King Email 6/08/2009 34 Lance Chess Email 6/08/2009 35 Carol Johnston Email 6/08/2009 36 Steven Zeluck Email 6/08/2009 37 Cathy Robinson Email 6/08/2009 38 Michael Cairns Email 6/08/2009 39 Byron Render Email 6/08/2009 40 Jacqueline Ross Email 6/08/2009 41 Edward Mainwaring Email 6/08/2009 42 George Wuerthner Email 6/08/2009 43 Mark Hanschka Email 6/08/2009 44 Corrina Chase Email 6/08/2009 45 Robert Vaughn Email 6/08/2009 46 Andrew O‘Shea Email 6/08/2009 47 Christopher Kornmann Email 6/08/2009 48 Deb Merchant Email 6/08/2009 49 Brock Roberts Email 6/08/2009 50 Skye Coe Email 6/08/2009 51 Wendy McGowan Email 6/08/2009 52 Sarah Peters Email 6/08/2009 53 Andrew O‘Shea Email 6/08/2009 54 Diana Edwards Email 6/08/2009 55 Pinky Jain Pan Email 6/08/2009 56 Elizabeth Laskey Email 6/08/2009 57 Sidney Smith Email 6/08/2009 58 Tate Peterson Email 6/08/2009 59 Lynn Krupa Email 6/08/2009 60 Irene Saikevych Email 6/08/2009 61 Laura Dufel Email 6/08/2009 62 Brook Kirklin Email 6/08/2009 63 Michael Wilson Email 6/08/2009 64 Geraldine Bish Email 6/08/2009 65 Nino Marchetti Email 6/08/2009 66 Sam Fox Email 6/08/2009 67 Todd Sargent Email 6/08/2009 68 Barbara Gilmour Email 6/08/2009 2 D-Bug FEIS Appendix A – Response to Comments Comment Type of Name Organization Date Received Number Comment 69 Marc Anderson Email 6/08/2009 70 Ilana Sophia Email 6/08/2009 71 Amy Harlib Email 6/08/2009 72 Philip Hubert Email 6/08/2009 73 David Noell Email 6/08/2009 74 Regna Merritt Email 6/08/2009 75 Sarah Hafer Email 6/08/2009 76 Anthony Capobianco Email 6/08/2009 77 Dan Sherwood Email 6/08/2009 78 Rachel Blythe Email 6/08/2009 79 Roger Brewer Email 6/08/2009 80 Brad Martin Email 6/08/2009 81 Carol McBrian Email 6/08/2009 82 Anthony Capobianco Email 6/08/2009 83 Harriet Behm Email 6/08/2009 84 Jennifer Lance Email 6/08/2009 85 Dan Swerbilov Email 6/08/2009 86 David Stowe Email 6/08/2009 87 Thomas Bostwick Email 6/08/2009 88 Ryan Lazzeri Email 6/08/2009 89 Gerry Paulsen Email 6/08/2009 90 Milton Nelson Email 6/08/2009 91 Sara Zielin Email 6/08/2009 92 Elaine Hultengren Email 6/08/2009 93 Brian Runyan Email 6/08/2009 94 Barbara Waright Email 6/08/2009 95 Donald Fontenot Email 6/08/2009 96 Alaina Smith Email 6/08/2009 97 Carol Alexander Email 6/08/2009 98 Saundra Whitten Email 6/08/2009 99 Shannon Wolcott Email 6/08/2009 100 Karl Eysenback Email 6/08/2009 101 Glenn Blanchard Email 6/08/2009 102 Dwight Long Email 6/08/2009 103 Joe Craig Email 6/08/2009 104 Chester Zenone Email 6/08/2009 105 Brent Jensen Email 6/08/2009 106 Mark Scantlebury Email 6/08/2009 107 Monica Gilman Email 6/08/2009 108 Victoria Koch Email 6/08/2009 109 Jack Hallin Email 6/08/2009 110 Sarah Hafer Email 6/08/2009 111 Jim Humphrey Email 6/08/2009 112 Bob Karcich Email 6/08/2009 113 Joel Koedoot Email 6/08/2009 114 Luke Ackerman Email 6/08/2009 115 Tod Wooldridge Email 6/08/2009 116 Ann Takamoto Email 6/08/2009 117 Bill Fowlie Email 6/08/2009 118 Patricia Bitner Email 6/08/2009 119 Paula Perretty Email 6/08/2009 3 D-Bug FEIS Appendix A – Response to Comments Comment Type of Name Organization Date Received Number Comment 120 Kristin Shisler Email 6/08/2009 121 Kevynne Layne Email 6/08/2009 122 Anne May Email 6/08/2009 123 Wendy Holzman Email 6/08/2009 124 Robert Schofield Email 6/08/2009 125 Dogan Ozkan Email 6/08/2009 126 Chris Roe Email 6/08/2009 127 Darcie Hildreth Email 6/08/2009 128 John Miller Email 6/08/2009 129 Richard Potestio AIA Email 6/08/2009 130 Gerritt Rosenthal Email 6/08/2009 131 Jason Crowder Email 6/08/2009 132 John Reilly Email 6/08/2009 133 Steven Christian Email 6/08/2009 134 Susan Vecchio Email 6/08/2009 135 Craig Schellsmidt Email 6/08/2009 136 Eric Wilborn Email 6/08/2009 137 Ryan Hunter Email 6/08/2009 138 Sara Butcher Email 6/08/2009 139 Beth Bown Email 6/08/2009 140 Lajeanne Kline Email 6/08/2009 141 M. Aulenbach Email 6/08/2009 142 Harriet Miller Email 6/08/2009 143 Earl Hafer, Jr. Email 6/08/2009 144 Sue Donora Email 6/08/2009 145 Dominic Aiello Email 6/08/2009 146 Neil Kagan Email 6/08/2009 147 Jeremy Olsen Email 6/08/2009 148 A. Murray Email 6/08/2009 149 David Harrison Email 6/08/2009 Michael Werner and 150 Email 6/08/2009 Katie Campbell 151 Earl Hafer, Jr Email 6/08/2009 152 Tom Melville Email 6/08/2009 Craig Downer and Alice 153 Email 6/08/2009 Downer 154 John Koenig Email 6/08/2009 155 Kristen Macuga Email 6/08/2009 156 Lagah Lkadgah Email 6/08/2009 157 Jessica Martin Email 6/08/2009 158 Deanna Larson Email 6/08/2009 159 Dennis Hebert Email 6/08/2009 160 Susan Applegate Email 6/08/2009 161 Karen Baker Email 6/08/2009 162 Wade Stoddard Email 6/08/2009 163 Larry Kanner Email 6/08/2009 164 Brandon Hasty Email 6/08/2009 165 Michael Orzen Email 6/08/2009 166 Kevin Bartel Email 6/08/2009 167 Brian Wegener Email 6/08/2009 168 Glenda Phillips Email 6/08/2009 4 D-Bug FEIS Appendix A – Response to Comments Comment Type of Name Organization Date Received Number Comment 169 Kenny Jones Email 6/08/2009 170 Kellie Smith Email 6/08/2009 171 Michael Williams Email 6/08/2009 172 Megan Garton Email 6/08/2009 173 Chuck Shelton Email 6/08/2009 174 George Olsen Email 6/08/2009 175 Michael Downs Email 6/08/2009 176 Karen Griswold Email 6/08/2009 177 Amy Gibson Email 6/08/2009 John and Martha 178 Email 6/08/2009 Stoltenberg 179 Karen Marks Email 6/08/2009 180 Margaret Turner Email 6/08/2009 181 Dorothy Kimbell Email 6/08/2009 182 James Thompson Email 6/08/2009 183 Michele Boderck Email 6/08/2009 184 Brian Schick Email 6/08/2009 185 Beth Melville Email 6/08/2009 186 Susan Rouzie Email 6/08/2009 187 Thomas Ouweleen Email 6/08/2009 188 Susan Rouzie Email 6/08/2009 189 Janine Bertram Email 6/08/2009 190 Randy Pearson Email 6/08/2009 191 Jenny Jones Email 6/08/2009 192 Paul Milbourn Email 6/08/2009 193 Sumner Williams Email 6/08/2009 194 Michael Cooper Email 6/08/2009 195 Jenny Forrester Email 6/08/2009 196 Charles Thomas Email 6/08/2009 197 Sandra Wallsmith Email 6/08/2009 198 Sylvia Nikes Email 6/08/2009 199 Stanley Seleen Email 6/08/2009 200 Jessica White Email 6/08/2009 201 Wendell Wood Email 6/08/2009 202 Shannon Davis Email 6/08/2009 Communities for 202a Javier Goirigolzarri Electronic Letter 6/08/2009 Healthy Forests Gerald and Robin 203 Electronic Letter 6/08/2009 Wisdom 204 Jane Steadman Email 6/08/2009 205 Judith Beck Email 6/08/2009