1983 Aug.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Rhode Island History Publevhed toy The Rhode lvland H l ~ton c a l Volume 42, Number 3 Societ y, 110 Benevolent Street, providence. Rhode tsland , Ol~ t., and pruned by a grant Irnm rhe Sla le 01 Rhode Contents Island and Providence Plantanon-s. I. Ioscph Garrahy, Gon'rnOf , Su~an L Farmer, Secrerarv ot Sl;ltt,. Images of Moses Brown 75 [, su ~.l Qu.nterly at PmvI.!l'n,e, Rhode NINA Z ANN IE RI Island, februar v ."1ay, AUjolUSI , ami Novem ber Second class p0.,lajolc paid at provi dence. Rhode hJ.and Impoverished Politics: The New Deal's 86 ge n Robert I :'>1 cKenn.a president Impact on City Go vernment in Alden:'>' An.ler r.oTl, "let' president Mr~ Edwin G. FISC hl'f, VICt' p reqdenl Providence, Rhode Island Park Palmer, secte rarv DAVID L. D AVIES ....,. Rach el Cunha, aHHI<JnI sec ret arv Sr..phen C. Wllh.ams, trrasutrr AlI'CTI C ,1 r1ot lJ, <J s</,<rant treasurer Book Review 101 fELLOW, OF Tl I~ 'IKltTY Carl Bridenbaugh Svdnev V lames Anromeue F. DOWOlOlo: Richard K Showman ru Il LlC "' T IO N~ COM MI TTl l Dr Scebe rr I, Gol dnw sk y, chairman Go rdo n Allen Henry L. P Beckwith, It Dr. fu.nCl~ H Chatee Prot . Howard P. Chudac ost goben Allen G rcem: Pamel a A. Kennedy Leonard I, l evin Alan Sim pson Wm . Mc KenZI" Wnnd ....ard "TMF Glenn Warr en Laf'an raarc, ednor Maureen Taylor, picmr.. •'d ,to r Leonard I. levin, copv ediior [ean l.eCwm, deS/Rna Ellen O 'Reilly, t d l/orlal dH/Uanl Gltn n D. Horton. ednonal asststam The Rhode Island Hrst oncal Soclct y avsumes no rtSpClO Slblll1Y 101 the opinions of comnbutors C It,l!< } b)' The Rhod e b land Hrstoncat S<IC ICt y ~H U"~ ISLAM} tll'To"Y 11"" N OOH' ~ l'ot t,ll hgure 1 _~ o- x 40 '/ .1-, Afartm fohnson Heade ( 1819 - 1904), ca. 18~6-18n . Courtesy of Rhude Island Hruonccl Soclely. Images of Moses Brown Nina Zannieri In 11)81 the Rhode Island Historical Society acquired a portrait 01 .\ h Zanmen L ~ ~C I Ln.£ curato r ot the Moses Brown tI7\B-1 836) painted by the noted nineteenth-century Rhod e hl ~ nJ HJ~l tl[l c~1 SOC1 e l~' The, am de IS based upon an ext ubn also er mrlcd artist Martin Johnson Heade. In the port rait Brown is seated In an up lm.i):es ut ~I OM'" s Brown , ' whi ch w ~ ~ holstered Windsor chair at his wnnng table, against a stvhzcd hack mo unted al the .\ 1u!tCum 01 Rhod e b bnJ Hrsr orv ~I Aldu,.; h Hou se an d wh ich ran ground (fig. I I. A search for the sou rce of this posthumous portrait trom ~1~)' I'I ~ I 10> .\ 1.1\' 1'I ~1_ disclosed an interesting connection bet ween this formal likeness and I .\ 1a( k Th ompson. .\10'0" Brown The several of the other known images of Brown . As more images came to Reluclunf Reformer ICIurc:l HilL:'\: C 19" 11. J"'1 hght there emerged a seeming contradiction between the very exis 1 Nmm~n Pennev 10 Ravner W KeI'\C \ tence of severa l portram. of Moses Brown and the traditionally held no tun e q , I'I I ~ Archives. _\ toN:' Bro...-n 'ichool, Providence R I tion that Brown . In acco rdance with his Quaker beliefs, refused to have I· Do rc~s 8m..... n to Thomas Th om pson. his portrait paint ed.' AUIl: 11. lij1 ' , The ongm al Je UCT L~ In th e Further invesngaucn. however, helped to reco ncile the cont radic e LMon .... ,~nl.h cnrl Ccllecuon, LJ br~T\- 01 the RdL.£lUUS '>o<len-01 Fnend-, London tion: it became: clea r that the few portrans made du ring Brown's life le lb~o n. Vol , I. ~ I I ThL~ marerralrs taken time: were: ta ken surrepnnouslv and beca me the sou rces for those done trum ~ parrra l nanscnpuon 01 rha l 1... 11<'1 after his dea th. Even th ough man y of them were created as copies. each bv Norman Penn ey Ausrm .\ l SS, II. "Per soml." Ou~ ker Archwes. Rhode [,lanJ has spec ial qualities that are the natural result of changes in medium. Hrstortcal Socrcev creative whim on the part of each different artist, or the wishes of th e person for whom th e copy was made. Th e earliest known imagrcs of Moses Brown arc th ree clos ely related watercolor port raits. One of these wat ercolors (fig. 2) was reccrulv dis covered in London, at th e Library of th e Religious Society of Friends, where it has been smce IH44.l With the portrait is th e letter that origi nally accompanied it, written in 182 .3 by Brown's daughter-in-law, Dor cas Brown , to Thomas Th ompson , a Quaker schular: it was obtained withou t his knowledge-or suspicion, an acquain tance of mine-took a you ng man th ere-who has a lit tl e sk ill and whil e he was engaged in conversation-and probably read ing- to prolong th e ti me-sketched th e outlines- and afterward s saw him twice at meeting-it is a pretty good representati on - but not perfect-his manner of stru ng is natural but th e co untenance is not exac tly so-it would not be compatible with the feelings of my hon our ed father-to have this done-but I think It admissible to have something of a resemblance of the outward form or ap pea rance-of those we Love when their Bodies may be moulde ring 10 th e dust.' Her comments confirm the old Quaker's desire not to be captured in a portrait and POlOt out the difficu lties created by his reluctance. Unfor tunately, she did not reveal the name of the young artis t who had ,6 IMAGE S O FM O SES BROW N Figure 2 . Water color on paper. 4" x 5", signed "-. l~ " (possibly tosepb PartridxeJ, ca. 1823. Pbcnograpb courtesy of th e Library Com m ittee of the Religious Society of Friends. London. .;. Barbara Mason , l ibrar y nt the Reh· painted the portrait, nor did she mention exactly when the event s de i!:IOUS Soc iety 01 Fne nds, personal corn mu rucaeron. 1have not exammed the scribed in the let ter took place. The onl y clue to th e ident ity of the art actual pam lLnll:, and I am grateful IU Bar ist is the single legible initial "-. P.," printed in th e lower right hand bara Mason an d her colleagues lor their corner of the portrait.' assistanc e In t hiS mailer ~ Dor cas Brown 10 T hom as Th ompson , The most unusual featu re of this portrait, one that distinguishe s it Au !/; \ 1, 11111, Ausnn MSS. I J, "Per from all other known images, is the whi te covering over Brown 's other scnal." RI, HIM S<><;, 6, Rayner WKelsey. Centennial HIS wise typical black, broad-bnmrncd. Quaker hat . In a postscript to her tory of M m e l Brown scnoot. 1819 - 1919. lett er, Dor cas Brown called attention to his hat :"Thou will observe his [Providence, R.I., 11)l 9!. H Hat is covered with wh ite linnen whi ch he wears in warm weather." It 7_DOlUS Brown to Thomas Tbnmpson, Aug . 11, I lll l , Aust in MSS, 13. "Pe r has been suggested that Brown, who suffered from rheumatism, ver son.al," R.I. Hm Soc. tigo, insomnia, fevers and fainting spells during mu ch of hi s life,"wore white lin en on his hat in summer to deflect the sun's rays.'?' This in turn suggests that the portrait was pain ted during the summer, proba bly in 1823. Possibly the most compelli ng aspect of this particul ar Image is also revealed in Dorcas Brown's letter:"I vent ured one day to hold It [the portrait] before him- and as ked if he kne ..... who it resembled-he smiled- and inqu ired 'where l got 11 '- 1 repli ed that 'I was not at lib erty to tell '-and it passed off pleasant ly." Given Moses Brown's feel ings about portraits, it seems likely th at this image was the only like ness of himself that he ever saw or whose existence he ever sus pected . I MAGE.s Of M O ~t S BROWN 77 Figure .j. " aureolor on paper. .t " x s". att rib uted to Joseph Partridge (1192-ca. rSH!. ca. t82 2 -f8 lj . Photograph ccurresv of the fohn Carte r Brown Librorv His reaction seems to haw been that of a rath er kindly elderly man II, tbid who, though aware of hi s relatives' desire to have a keepsake portrait, II, [ would hke to acknowledge the gen . cru~l ty " I Ar thur Band Sybil B, Kern tor was neither impressed with his own look s nor with th e need to have brmgmg thrs rmpotrant port ran to my them recorded. at tcnuon and tor vhanng their mtnrrna non on lovcph Partndgl; The Kcrn~ hav e Dorcas Brown's letter also contains a reference to a copy of th e pic recently com pleted a manU~CTlI-'I tor ture that she plann ed to keep as a "precious mom ento.''' T his reference pchhcanen on the hte and w ork~ ui hel ps to explain the existence of the two other watercolor portraits of lcseph Partr..j~ l' TO.