Health Consultation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HEALTH CONSULTATION Evaluation of Mercury in Trout and White Fish From Lake Pend Oreille, Idaho Bonner County, Idaho Prepared by Idaho Department of Health and Welfare Division of Health Bureau of Community and Environmental Health Under Cooperative Agreement with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry Summary As part of a cooperative agreement with the federal Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), the Bureau of Community and Environmental Health (BCEH), Division of Health, Idaho Department of Health and Welfare (IDHW), prepared this health consultation to evaluate the potential health effects from exposure to mercury in Lake Pend Oreille fish. The State of Montana has a fish advisory for mercury contamination in Flathead Lake, which is upstream of Lake Pend Oreille. Over 90% of the water in Lake Pend Oreille flows from Flathead Lake and other lakes/reservoirs in Montana through the Clark Fork River. The Idaho Department of Fish and Game (IDFG) collected fish samples from Lake Pend Oreille to better understand the mercury contamination in the lake fish and any potential human health effects from eating the fish. The majority of mercury in fish is methylmercury. Exposure to methylmercury is more dangerous for young children than for adults because methylmercury more easily passes into the developing brain of young children and may interfere with the developmental process. Critical periods of neonatal development and the early months after birth are times that are particularly sensitive to the harmful effects of methylmercury on the nervous system. Methylmercury can accumulate in fetal blood to concentrations higher than in the mother. Mothers who are exposed to methylmercury and breastfeed their infant may also expose the child through breast milk. Based upon the available fish tissue data for mercury and other available information, BCEH has drawn the following conclusions and recommendations: Conclusions: 1. For occasional fish consumers who only eat one meal (4-oz for children, 8-oz for adult) per month of trout or white fish from Lake Pend Oreille, the exposure to mercury in fish is a no apparent public health hazard according to ATSDR’s public health hazard categories (Appendix C). 2. A public health hazard may exist for children, pregnant women, and general public who eat more than eight meals per month (two meals per week) of trout or white fish from Lake Pend Oreille. Recommendations: BCEH should issue a fish advisory for trout and white fish caught in Lake Pend Oreille based on the evaluation in this health consultation. BCEH should work with IDFG to post and distribute the fish advisory. Efforts should also be made by BCEH to educate the fishing community on the health implications of fish consumption. The advisory will include the following: 1. Children (6 year old or younger) should not eat more than one 4-oz meal per month of trout or two 4-oz meals per month of white fish from Lake Pend Oreille. 2. Pregnant women, including women planning to become pregnant, and nursing mothers, should not eat more than two 8-oz meals per month of trout or four 8-oz meals per month of white fish from Lake Pend Oreille. 3. General public should not eat more than three 8-oz meals per month of trout or four 8-oz meals per month of white fish from Lake Pend Oreille. 1 4. Do not eat other fish including commercial fish in the same month if you eat up to the recommended limit of trout or white fish from Lake Pend Oreille, since all fish contain various levels of mercury. To find the level of mercury in common commercially available fish, please check the national fish advisory (http://www.epa.gov/waterscience/fishadvice/advice.html). 5. People should eat smaller, younger fish. Typically, the bigger or older the fish, the higher the mercury concentration in the fish fillet. 2 Purpose The Bureau of Community and Environmental Health (BCEH), Division of Health, Idaho Department of Health and Welfare (IDHW) has a cooperative agreement with the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) to conduct public health assessments and consultations for hazardous waste sites in Idaho. In 2004, the Idaho Department of Fish and Game (IDFG) collected trout and white fish samples from Lake Pend Oreille for mercury analysis in fish tissue. As part of the cooperative agreement with ATSDR, BCEH prepared this health consultation to evaluate the potential adverse health effects associated with the consumption of fish from Lake Pend Oreille. Background and Statement of Issue Lake Pend Oreille, the fifth largest natural freshwater lake in the United States, and Idaho’s largest lake, is located in Bonner County, Idaho (Appendix A, Figure A-1). The deepest part of the lake is 1200 feet and the lake has over 100 miles of shoreline. Fishing, waterskiing, sailing and windsurfing are all popular sports on the lake. The State of Montana has a fish advisory for mercury contamination in Flathead Lake, which is upstream of Lake Pend Oreille. Over 90% of the water in Lake Pend Oreille (Appendix A, Figure A-1) comes from the watershed of Flathead Lake and other lakes/reservoirs in Montana through the Clark Fork River (Personal communication: Chris Downs, fishery biologist, IDFG, phone, Feb. 18, 2005). Local fishermen expressed concern to IDFG about possible mercury contamination in Lake Pend Oreille fish. However, there were no mercury concentration data available for Lake Pend Oreille fish. After consulting with the Idaho Fish Consumption Advisory Program (IFCAP), the IDFG collected 14 trout and 15 white fish samples in February and March 2004 to better understand the mercury contamination in the fish of Lake Pend Oreille and any potential health effects from eating the fish. Whole fish samples were sent to IDHW’s Bureau of Laboratories for tissue analysis. Fish samples were processed and analyzed for mercury concentrations in the fillets or meat. Sampling and analysis protocol developed by IFCAP (BCEH 2004) were followed. Mercury occurs naturally as a mineral and is distributed throughout the environment by both natural processes and human activities. The natural global bio-geochemical cycling of mercury is characterized by evaporation of mercury from soils and surface waters, followed by atmospheric transport, deposition of mercury back to land and surface water, and sorption of the compound to soil or sediment particulates. Mercury deposited on land and open water is in part re-volatilized back into the atmosphere. This emission, deposition, and re-volatilization create difficulties in tracing the movement of mercury to its sources. Major human activities which release mercury to the environment include mining and smelting; industrial processes involving the use of mercury, including chlor-alkali production facilities; combustion of fossil fuels, primarily coal; production of cement; and medical and municipal waste incinerators and industrial/commercial boilers (EPA 1996). Members of the general public with potentially high exposures to mercury include individuals who live in proximity to former mercury mining or production sites, secondary production 3 (recycling) facilities, municipal or medical incinerators, or coal-fired power plants. Some people may be exposed to higher levels of mercury in the form of methylmercury if they have a diet high in fish, shellfish, or marine mammals that come from mercury-contaminated waters. Methylmercury accumulates up the food chain, so that fish at the top of the food chain will have the most mercury in their meat. Of these fish, the biggest fish will have the highest levels of mercury (ATSDR 1999). Discussion Mercury Concentrations in Fish Mercury was analyzed in 14 trout samples and 15 white fish samples collected from Lake Pend Oreille by IDFG in February and March 2004. The body weight of sampled trout ranged from 1.46 kilogram (kg) to 5.90 kg and the sampled white fish ranged from 0.52 kg to 0.94 kg (Appendix B, Table B-1). The range and the geometric mean of the mercury concentrations in the fish fillet are reported in Table 1. The geometric means of mercury concentrations in trout and white fish were 0.421 and 0.264 milligram per kilogram (mg/kg), respectively. Table 1. Levels of Mercury Found in Fish Fillet from Lake Pend Oreille Fish Number of Body Weight Mercury Concentration (mg/kg) Species Samples (kg) (pound) Range Geometric Mean Trout 14 1.46-5.90 3.2-13.0 0.285-0.930 0.421 White Fish 15 0.52-0.94 1.1-2.1 0.163-0.354 0.264 Methylmercury constitutes over 99% of the total mercury detected in fish muscle tissue (fillet), with no detection of inorganic or dimethylmercury (Grieb et al. 1990; Bloom 1992). BCEH conservatively assumed that the total mercury values reported here (Table 1) to be all methylmercury. Methylmercury is the form of mercury most easily absorbed through the gastrointestinal tract (about 95% absorbed). Therefore, BCEH also assumed that the bioavailability of total mercury in fish were 100%. Exposure Pathway To determine whether people are exposed to mercury, BCEH considered five elements: the source of contamination; the movement of the contaminants in soil, air or water; the point at which people can come in contact with the contaminants; the routes of exposure (such as eating contaminated fish); and the population that can potentially be exposed. All five elements must be present for an exposure pathway to be complete. Exposure pathways are classified as a completed pathway, a potential pathway, or an eliminated pathway. If a pathway is complete, exposure is reasonably likely to have occurred in the past, is currently occurring, or is likely to occur in the future. If a potential pathway exists, exposure might have occurred, may be occurring, or may yet occur.