Anthrax Vaccine n Water Wars n Debating the Draft THE AMERICAN
$2.50 June 2003 The magazine for a strong America MILITARY
“For God and Country since 1919
NOVEMBER 2004 Vol. 157, No. 5 features 12 Missing Pieces From World War I to WMDs, U.S. history 21ST-CENTURY is a stark reminder that intelligence is ARMY 18 seldom perfect. By Alan W. Dowd 18 Q&A: A Blueprint for the Green Lt. Gen. Mark Curran of the Army’s Futures Center describes the force’s 21st-century transformation. 24 How Can Someone Who Lives in Insane Luxury Be a Star in Today’s World? UP CLOSE AND Celebrity writer says a life lived to help PERSONAL 26 others is the only life that matters. By Ben Stein 26 Back from Baghdad War correspondent Karl Zinsmeister delivers fi rsthand balance from the front lines. 32 Meaningful Moments At a convention featuring presidential candidates, generals and cabinet secretaries, U.S. troops mattered most. By Steve Brooks CONSPIRACY Cpl. Terrence Van Doorn enjoys a few THEORIES 54 54 Modern Mythology moments with his wife, Stephanie, and From faked moon landings to alien 1-year-old daughter, Azaliyah, before autopsies, we live in a golden age of shipping out to Iraq. Van Doorn’s infantry conspiracy theories. battalion is assigned to 1st Marine By Dennis McCafferty Division in western Iraq’s al-Anbar province. The deployment is expected to last seven months. David McNew/Getty Images
departments 3 Vet Voice 10 Big Issues 66 Legion News 8 Commander’s Message Legalize medical marijuana 68 Comrades To those forever changed by war 60 Under the Radar 72 Parting Shots 62 Living Well
The American Legion Magazine, a leader among national general-interest publications, is published monthly by The American Legion for its 2.7 million members. These wartime veterans, working through 15,000 community-level posts, dedicate themselves to God and Country and traditional American values; strong national security; adequate and compassionate care for veterans, their widows and orphans; community service; and the wholesome development of our nation’s youth. November 2004 1 The American Legion Magazine
EXCLUSIVELY DESIGNED TO HONOR U.S. WAR VETERANS UNITED STATES MILITARY WAR VETERAN SERVICE RINGS Featuring Official Service Medals and Ribbons, The War Memorials and Gold Service Branch Emblems
700 N. Pennsylvania St. P.O. Box 1055 Indianapolis, IN 46206 NEW! (317) 630-1200 http://www.legion.org National Commander Thomas P. Cadmus Published by The American Legion EDITORIAL Editor John Raughter Managing Editor Jeff Stoffer Contributing Editor Steve Brooks Assistant Editor James V. Carroll Assistant Editor Matt Grills Assistant Editor Elissa Kaupisch Editorial Administrator Patricia Marschand General Administrator Brandy Ballenger General Administrator Robin Bowman GRAPHICS/PRODUCTION Graphics/Production Director Jon Reynolds Vietnam Iraqi Freedom Art Director Holly K. Soria Veteran Ring Veteran Ring Designer Douglas Rollison Designer King Doxsee ADVERTISING Advertising Director Diane Andretti Advertising Assistant Sara Palmer Advertising Assistant Leslie Hankins The American Legion Magazine P.O. Box 7068 Indianapolis, IN 46207 FOX ASSOCIATES, INC. Publisher’s Representatives Chicago: (312) 644-3888 New York: (212) 725-2106 Los Angeles: (213) 228-1250 Desert Storm Korean War WW2 Detroit: (248) 543-0068 Veteran Ring Veteran Ring Veteran Ring Atlanta: (404) 497-7690 THE AMERICAN LEGION MAGAZINE COMMISSION Dennis J. Henkemeyer, Chairman, Bagley, MN YOU HAVE EARNED THE RIGHT TO WEAR THESE SPECIAL RINGS Samuel Barney, Vice Chairman, Lancaster, OH; Charles E. Hartman, National Commander’s Representative, Eau e proudly present our Official in solid 10 KT gold atop genuine onyx. The ring Claire, PA; James J. Charleston, Consultant, Island Military War Rings to honor Veterans is sterling silver in 22 KT antiqued gold finish to Lake, IL; Robert A. Corrigan, Consultant, Bronx, NY. who served in WWII, Korea, Vietnam, enrich the high-relief sculptures of the war Commission Members: Harold F. Arnold, Statesboro, W GA; J.O. Berthelot, Gonzalez, LA; Vincent E. Blank, Desert Storm, Afghanistan, and now in Iraq - medals and memorials. The War ribbons are Vinton, IA; Donald R. Conn, South Bend, IN; James W. fighting the Global War On Terrorism. The top of hand-enameled in their official colors. Wear Conway, Charlestown, MA; Bettylou Evans, Laurel, DE; each ring features your Service Branch emblem your ring with pride in your service to Country. Philip B. Finley, Colby, KS; James Hall, Hopewell, NJ; Theodore Hartmann, Smithton, IL; Charles R. John, Duncan, OK; Bob Legan, Russellville, AR; J. Fred YOUR CHOICE OF SERVICE BRANCH EMBLEM SCULPTED ON TOP OF RING. Mitchell, Brewton, AL; Michael L. Montaney, Ephrata, COAST WA; Silas M. Noel, Frankfurt, KY; Everett G. Shepard III, ARMY NAVY AIR FORCE MARINES GUARD Woodstock, CT; George G. Sinopoli, Fresno, CA; Robert E. Vass Sr., Huntington, WV; Frank C. Ward, Greenville, SC. NEC Liaison Committee: William W. Kile, Chairman, Engraved with your Petersburg, WV; Alfred Pirolli, Philadelphia, PA; Arthur E. initials & years served Sell, Big Timber, MT; Marco A. Valenzuela, Tempe, AZ. FOR FASTEST SERVICE CALL TOLL FREE TO ORDER: 1-800-255-3048 Authorized by the Copyright 2004 by The American Legion Monday - Friday from 9am - 5pm EST Have Credit card and ring size ready when ordering. Korean War Veterans The American Legion (ISSN 0886-1234) is published Memorial Foundation. monthly by The American Legion, 5745 Lee Road, India- ORDER FORM napolis, IN 46216. Periodicals postage paid at Indianapolis, Or, Mail to: Veterans Commemoratives™ Military Rings, 1250 Easton Road, Suite 290, Horsham, PA 19044 IN 46204 and additional mailing offices. Annual non- ❑ member and gift subscriptions, $15 ($21, foreign); post- YES. I wish to order the following Exclusive SHIPPING ADDRESS sponsored and widows’ subscriptions, $6; single copy, (We CANNOT ship to P.O. Boxes) Allow 6-8 weeks for delivery. Service Ring: Check () choice: $3.50. Member annual subscription price $3.00, which ❑ Iraq ❑ Afghanistan (not shown) is included in annual member dues. POSTMASTER: Send ❑ Desert Storm ❑ Vietnam ❑ Korean ❑ WW2 Name ______address changes to The American Legion, Data Services, P.O. Box 1954, Indianapolis, IN 46206. Internet address:
❑ NEWCOH-ALM-1104 Service Branch: Check ( ) choice: http://www.legion.org. ❑ Army ❑ Navy ❑ Air Force Address ______❑ ❑ Change of Address: Notify The American Legion, Data Marine Coast Guard Services, P.O. Box 1954, Indianapolis, IN 46206. (317) City _____State _ Zip ______860-3111. Attach old address label, provide old and new ❑ Initials Desired (3): ______addresses and current membership card number. Signature ______❑ Service Yrs: ______to ______Canada Post International Publications Mall (Canadian Distribution) Sales Agreement No. 546321. Re-entered I NEED SEND NO MONEY NOW. Bill me in four Phone # ______second-class mail matter at Manila Central Post office monthly installments of $48.75* each, with the first * Plus $9.95 for engraving, shipping, and handling. dated Dec. 22, 1991. payment due prior to shipment. A custom ring sizer will PA residents add 6% ($12.30) sales tax. be sent to me before shipment to assure my correct fit. © ICM 2002-2004 These rings have been registered with the Printed in USA And my satisfaction is completely guaranteed. United States Copyright Office, as sculpture. Member Audit Bureau of Circulations VISIT VETERANS COMMEMORATIVES™ ONLINE AT WWW.VETCOM.COM vet voice On their records Enough with records Newspapers and television I’m amazed at the amount of effort by both candidates to have been reporting on the woo the veteran vote. I can’t believe they think my vote will military records of President be based upon the four and a half months one spent in Bush and candidate John Kerry. These two men’s records should Vietnam or the Air National Guard not be an issue, since both men time of the other. My vote will be were honorably discharged. Let based on what they did when they the offi cial paperwork be the word. made their own decisions – Kerry People who try to demean in the Senate and Bush in the either man’s military service hurt White House. We need to pay attention to what they’ve done the veterans community and forget that wearing our country’s out of the military, not in it. uniform in any form is honor- – Pete Doe, York, Maine able. Do we look down on the Sudden respect available to all veterans. On Jan. veteran who was drafted com- Sen. John Kerry says, “If I saw 17, 2003, the Bush administration pared to a veteran who enlisted? somebody burning a fl ag, person- stopped enrolling (some) veterans Do combat veterans look down ally, I’d probably punch them out whose annual household incomes on veterans who serve their and stomp on them.” Does this are above $30,000. Why should country stateside? Do disabled man – this monstrously wealthy veterans, who risked our lives for veterans think veterans who effete product of Swiss boarding our country, be penalized for weren’t wounded served less schools, this friend of the most coming home and going to work? honorably? Does a career military vulgar people in Hollywood, this – Allan Young, Springfi eld, Mo. person think the person who did man who has spent his public life the minimum is less honorable? up to the past year sneering at the No such cut Every person who takes the oath fl ag and veterans – really expect John Kerry says President Bush to preserve and defend the U.S. us to believe this is how he feels? is cutting VA funds. This is a lie, Constitution, under any circum- I believe he thinks this ridiculous according to VA’s own Web page, stances, did it with pride and statement is something the which clearly shows that Bush has provided this defense by per- average veteran would say. He increased funding by $3.2 billion. forming whatever job the Depart- may have chuckled about it – per- Also, Kerry voted against concur- ment of Defense gave him. haps in French – with Teresa over rent receipt both times it came up, The issue is who will be the white wine and brie. Does he according to his voting record. best commander in chief of our expect us to believe the real John Now he says he is for it? military forces and who will give Kerry goes around physically – Daniel Gray, Defi ance, Ohio our veterans the best care and assaulting people who show benefi ts after they have served. disrespect to the fl ag? Bush’s free pass Some of the best veterans advo- Forget for a moment that the You ask Kerry about his 1971 cates have been non-veterans. grammar in the statement is antiwar testimony before Con- Consider these questions as you incorrect. Forget, too, that no one gress but fail to ask Bush why he vote for our next president, and would ever elect to the presidency attacked Iraq, has failed to don’t listen to all the negative a man who cannot control his capture Osama bin Laden, and input by both sides. emotions. The original cover of how he and his administration – Earl A. Rients, Pontiac, Ill. Kerry’s 1971 book, “The New feel about being labeled “chicken Soldier,” had people on the cover hawks” for avoiding the Vietnam Bush’s VA record holding the fl ag upside down as draft. Also, your interview tells us John Kerry says he’s been they mock the fl ag-raising at Iwo a number of Vietnam War veter- fi ghting for 35 years to “plus up” Jima. When and where did Kerry ans have “mixed feelings” about VA funding. What does “plus up” discover this newfound respect Kerry’s antiwar testimony, but mean? Does this translate to for the fl ag? you don’t mention any veterans “increase”? I’ll take President – William A. Roskey, Ames, Iowa having “mixed feelings” about Bush for another four years. Bush avoiding active duty Although he does mangle it Unfair penalty through family connections. This sometimes, he speaks English. In 1996, the Clinton administra- is pretty shoddy reporting. His record with the VA health- tion made VA medical services – L. Carolan, San Diego care system has been to increase
THE AMERICAN LEGION MAGAZINE WELCOMES YOUR OPINIONS Include your hometown and a daytime phone number for verifi cation. All letters are subject to editing. Send to: The American Legion Magazine, P.O. Box 1055, Indianapolis, IN 46206 • [email protected]
November 2004 3 The American Legion Magazine vet voice the budget by more than twice Blind to backlog says he “never pointed to the the amount of increase during President Bush brags about the individual veterans.” Then who President Clinton’s entire tenure fabulous job Secretary of Veterans did he claim “raped,” “cut off in offi ce. He also seems to be Affairs Anthony Principi has done ears” and committed dozens of honest, which doesn’t appear to in reducing the backlog and other horrendous acts in Vietnam? be a trait Kerry espouses. waiting lists for veterans seeking He wasn’t “proud” of us then. – Robert D. Bradshaw, Bellevue, Neb. medical care. But in the same – Raymond Curiale, Glen Head, N.Y. issue, under Veterans Benefi ts, a Used again? headline states, “Veterans’ Who benefi ts? I understand our organization’s Claims, Appeals, Remands Still The candidates’ responses to commitment to bipartisanship, Stacking Up.” According to the the question on outsourcing are but having John Kerry in our article, 86,000 appeals were particularly telling. John Kerry magazine and addressing our pending in 2000. Since then we’ve gave a specifi c response on why convention is a slap in the face of seen a steady rise in the backlog he is against it. The president every Legionnaire who served in of new appeals, which today evidently believes outsourcing is Vietnam. It wasn’t too awfully stands at 130,000 and rising. Why good, for he skirted the issue and long ago that his words and wasn’t President Bush challenged made no real attempt to answer actions toward our country and on his statement? the question. It should come as no his fellow troops would have – Jack Hersh, San Carlos, Calif. surprise that at least one of the resulted in his being hanged or president’s economic advisers has summarily shot. Instead, here we Time for a change said outsourcing is good for the are, in 2004, honoring him with I don’t think President Bush economy. What needs answered an opportunity to yet again use us answered the questions in the is which companies and countries for his own self-interest. Shame September issue, while I think benefi t the most. on you. John Kerry answered all but one. – Wendell Liemohn, Louisville, Tenn. – Howard Pritz, Midlothian, Va. As both a veteran and 21-year Legion member, I will support Bush falls short Insult to veterans Kerry. I feel another four years President Bush says “increasing A swipe at Kerry is a blow to with President Bush would be immigration enforcement will not the face of every veteran. The ruinous for America. He is by itself solve our problems, audacity to smear any veteran’s keeping his budget secret until because our immigration laws are military service for the sole after the election, which tells me not working.” He doesn’t have any purpose of trying to gain political we’ll see more cuts in our social interest or inclination to enforce advantage is appalling. At a time and health-care programs. our current immigration laws, or when veterans are again publicly – Dan Bynum, Eldridge, Iowa see through any meaningful new appreciated and respected, it’s or improved immigration laws. disgusting to see how low one Kerry, Legionnaire Bush recently rejected a proposal will stoop. I was surprised to see that John from Sen. Robert Byrd, D-W.Va., – Jim Shannon, Canton, Ohio Kerry is a member of The Ameri- to hire more Border Patrol agents, can Legion, especially in light of instead approving millions in aid Focus on current war the statement he made in his book for Iraq – specifi cally, to seal that The current emphasis on who “The New Soldier”: “We will not country’s borders. did what during the Vietnam era readily join The American Legion Bush’s immigration position is is distracting our attention from and the Veterans of Foreign Wars – clear: he prefers to leave U.S. more important issues confront- in fact, we will fi nd it hard to join citizens vulnerable to terror ing us today. Both political parties anything at all, and when we do, attack, diseases, social costs, job seem to ignore the war we are we will demand relevancy such as displacement and a $10 billion bill currently waging. other organizations have recently annually infl icted by illegal It is critical we stabilize been unable to provide.” And I aliens. Hopefully he’ll be joining conditions in Iraq and remove thought Kerry is from Massachu- his father as a one-term president. our troops in an orderly fashion. setts. Why does he belong to a – Pete Testa, Millington, N.J. To correctly do this, we need a Legion post in New Hampshire? leader who is intelligent, coura- – Richard S. Churchill, Quincy, Mass. GOP not innocent geous and meticulous. We can’t As President Reagan liked to just drop everything and hastily Evasions and lies say, “There you go again.” In pull out, leading to anarchy and John Kerry says families have “Bush and Kerry Vie for the civil war, but neither should we conducted “bake sales” to buy Hearts of Veterans,” Larry Sabato continue to sacrifi ce our brave body armor to send to their kids writes that “veterans traditionally servicemen and women. We need in Iraq. If Kerry had not voted lean Republican mostly because to plan for the future, not wallow against appropriations for mili- of the GOP’s emphasis on military in the past. tary supplies, “bake sales” would spending and national security.” – Stan Silver, Wyckoff, N.J. not have been necessary. He also This is just another in an unend-
4 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine Special Offer for Firewood Users! ing string of slurs on Democrats TryTry thethe ElectricElectric in your publication. If the GOP ® had really been dedicated to national security, chances are DR WOOD SPLITTER good to excellent that 9/11 would for 6 Months Risk-Free! not have occurred. Instead, the for 6 Months Risk-Free! GOP was interested in two things Give the DR® a try for 6 months. If you don’t prior to that: undoing anything Clinton did or started, and agree this powerful machine is the easiest, most providing fi nancial rewards to convenient way ever to split firewood — indoors Bush’s campaign backers through or out — you can return it for a complete refund immoral tax cuts for the wealthy. (less s & h). No strings attached. – Noah Williamson, Mount Ida, Ark. • QUIET, CLEAN & NO FUMES Use it in your garage or basement. Man under fi re • POWERFUL motor and hydraulic I read the article “Bush and ram produce 4 tons of force. Kerry Vie for the Hearts of • EASY TO USE Plugs in to any Veterans,” and the author should SplitSplit logs 10" thick... household outlet. Push-button start. be ashamed of himself. He says • COMPACT Fits on a workbench. Bush is a wartime president; he is indoorsindoors oror out!out! not. Congress must declare war. I Please send full details of the Amazing Indoor/Outdoor “The DR has enough power to do the Electric DR® WOOD SPLITTER, including your Free Trial Offer, am a veteran with 18 years of low, factory-direct prices, and seasonal savings now in effect. service, both active and reserve. I biggest logs I’ve put on it. And if it’s raining or snowy, I just split inside.” Name______would follow Kerry into battle AML and hopefully into the White — H. Peterson, Equinunk, PA Address______
House. Let’s become aware and City______State______Zip______elect a man who has proven Toll-Free himself under fi re rather than a 1-800-709-0278 E-mail______Inc. © 2004 CHP, COUNTRY HOME PRODUCTS®, Dept. 49144X man who never even showed up www.drwoodsplitter.com Meigs Road, P.O. Box 25, Vergennes, VT 05491 for the National Guard. – Dale Weiss, Bethlehem, Pa. Thank the Democrats ONLY Get a New 2004 American LAST As someone who spent 32 years CHANCE! in veterans employment and $ 95 Eagle Silver Dollar at our cost! training, I fail to understand how 8 with Free You can’t purchase an Uncirculated American Eagle silver dollar directly from any veteran can take the position Shipping! the U.S. Mint, and when this year ends, the 2004 American Eagle will that Republicans are better for never be minted again. But now, while there’s still time, you can veterans than Democrats. Every purchase this official 2004 U.S. silver dollar from Littleton Coin benefi t we enjoy was given or Company at our cost, and with FREE shipment to your home! ©2004 LCC, Inc. The beautiful and sought-after $1 American Eagle is over adopted by Democratic presidents 99.9% pure silver, and carries the same design or congresses. On the other hand, as the popular “Walking Liberty” silver coins every cutback in benefi ts, military of 1916-47. You’ll also receive our fully illustrated catalog, plus other fascinating personnel and base closure was selections from our Free Examination Coins-on- headed by Republican administra- Approval Service, from which you may purchase tions. They like to blame the any or none – return balance in 15 days – with option to cancel at any time. But don’t delay – FREE! current manpower shortage on Plus, get the order your 2004 American Eagle silver dollar NEWLY designed President Clinton, but it started at our cost today! Uncirculated 2004 under President George H.W. Bush 45-Day Money Back Guarantee of Satisfaction Jefferson Nickel! and Secretary of Defense Dick Nearly 60 Years of Friendly Service to Collectors Cheney. Now, as vice president, Special Offer For New Customers Only... Cheney would have you believe 2004 American Eagle Silver Dollar at our cost! ✓ Please send me the Uncirculated American Eagle Silver that it was all the Democrats’ fault. ❏ YES! Dollar at Littleton’s cost and with Free Shipping (limit 5). Plus, my FREE 2004 Uncirculated Nickel (one each per customer, please). –Joseph McCarthy, Reading, Pa. Order deadline: November 30, 2004 Method of payment: How Many (limit 5): ______❏ # 2004 marks the 18th Check or Money Order enclosed No friend to us ❏ VISA ❏ MasterCard Total Cost at $8.95 each: $ ______anniversary of the American ❏ ❏ I had to chuckle at the piece Eagle series American Express NOVUS Cards Shipping & Handling: $ ______FREE! “Why Veterans Should Elect # In beautiful mint Uncirculated Card No. Exp. Date _____ /_____ Total Amount: $ ______condition! Please send to: Democrats to Congress.” The # Limited-time offer for new article is too long for me to pick customers Name______through item by item, outlining # Free 2004 Uncirculated Nickel honoring the Address ______Dept. K6D409 the untruths, so I’ll limit my Lewis & Clark expedition City ______1309 Mt. Eustis Road ORDERS MUST BE RECEIVED Littleton NH 03561-3737 BY NOVEMBER 30, 2004 State ______Zip______–______www.littletoncoin.com/specials vet voice comments to a few major observa- Hastert seriously addresses the istration, over $1 billion a year – tions about the Democratic Party inequities of the military pay an increase of $4.8 billion since as a whole: system for either active duty or this president took offi ce. Still not n At the time, not one Senate retirees. It’s a sad state of affairs enough, but a vast improvement Democrat voted to impeach when both parties feel all they over Pelosi and her party’s eight President Clinton, the president have to do is spout vague rhetoric years in power. That’s one reason who “loathed the military,” lied to in an attempt to garner enough this veteran will vote to elect his draft board and to a professor military votes to put their candi- Republicans to Congress. of military science at the Univer- date over the top. – Harley Hildebrand, Lacey, Wash. sity of Arkansas about his military I offer four easy proposals to intentions, and protested on seriously and benefi cially impact Other choices foreign soil our participation in quality-of-life issues faced by our Your Veterans Pre-Election the Vietnam War. military members: Primer is exclusively devoted to n Almost exclusively through n Tie military retirement pay to what Democrats and Republicans the efforts of Democratic Senate the active-duty pay schedule. This have to say on the issues, as if we and House members has the amounts to a fair COLA adjust- are not already bombarded with amendment to protect our fl ag not ment and not the currently those messages daily in the already become law. ridiculous methodology resulting mainstream media. Of what help n Legislation to improve veter- in a quick evaporation of military is it to veterans to simply replay ans benefi ts that is supported by retirement pay as an effective them? If The American Legion is Democrats in the House and Senate pension program. serious about educating veterans, is often moot when one also n Inaugurate a real veterans devote an entire edition to inter- realizes those same lawmakers preference program. If you are a views with presidential candi- pursue and too often achieve qualifi ed veteran, you get the job, dates from political parties denied similar benefi ts in their myriad effectively ending the process of coverage by the media. I believe a social programs for people who putting veterans at the mercy of lot of veterans would be interest- have done nothing for the good of race- and gender-based affi rmative ed in hearing the views of the this country. Lately, these benefi - action goals. America First, Constitution, Green ciaries have been non-U.S. citizens. n Loosen disability qualifi ca- and Reform parties, among Citizens who believe the tions. Hastert’s boast of 40 others. As long as veterans and Democratic Party to be a friend of percent dual compensation is other Americans believe they only the military are only fooling laughable when juxtaposed have one choice – the Repub- themselves. against VA’s stringent and cost- licrats – this nation will continue – Charles P.B. Busbey, driven refusal to properly qualify to decay from within. Dripping Springs, Texas veterans who are in pain and – Donald H. Walker, Fowlerville, Mich. have served their country. More to the story n Delegate to commanding Great strides Speaker of the House Dennis offi cers the powers of an election I’m a sergeant fi rst class in the Hastert tries to persuade Legion offi cial and announce the military Minnesota National Guard, members to vote Republican vote command by command. Since stationed in Iraq, and a member of because he claims Republicans no president would want to claim American Legion Post 257 in supported concurrent receipt of the title “commander in chief” and Springfi eld, Minn. My wife sends military retired pay and VA have it known that his party lost me The American Legion Magazine dis ability pay. The real story is the military vote by 90 percent, in care packages. I like the ar- that Hastert held this legislation each candidate would immediately ticles, and had to write about hostage in committee because he begin to court the military vote August’s “From Factory to Fox- knew it would have been over- with a real benefi ts package. hole.” I totally agree that the whelmingly passed in a fl oor vote. – Matthew M. O’Connell, Topeka, Kan. military has made great strides in Not until Democrats shamed the the movement of equipment, Republicans into releasing the bill Vast improvement personnel and supplies. Gen. John with a discharge petition did the In September’s issue, Nancy W. Handy should be proud, and legislation pass. As for health Pelosi continues the negative I’m proud to be part of the greatest care, Hastert can obfuscate the campaign against the current fi ghting force on this earth. Just issue all he wants with mislead- administration. Where were she looking at the numbers in the ing statistics, but the fact remains and her party during the eight article is mind-boggling, especially that under President Bush, years of the Clinton administra- when they cover only a fi ve- to six- Category 8 veterans have been tion, when the defense budget was month period. I want to express denied health care. cut, when troops applied for food my thanks to TRANSCOM. – Gerald J. Ladouceur, Slingerlands, N.Y. stamps to feed their families and – J.D. Davidson, Springfi eld, Minn. when veterans were ignored? VA’s Sad state medical budget has increased Hospice angels Neither Nancy Pelosi nor Dennis every year under the Bush admin- I just fi nished reading Keith
6 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine EXCLUSIVE U.S. VETERAN MILITARY
Renninson’s article “Compassion at SERVICE WATCHES Death’s Door” (August), and I must FEATURING YOUR SERVICE MEDAL AND RIBBON ON THE WATCHBAND add my thoughts to his. My wife of 60 years, Ruby, suffered from extreme diffi culty in breathing. In February, our doctor advised that he could do nothing more to help her and that he would call a hospice. Within 20 minutes, a hospice representative came to speak with me. In the short time it took to get her discharged from the hospital and drive to our home, hospice had set up a hospital room in front of her favorite window so she could continue to watch her beloved birds and neighbors. Not enough kind words are in the English language to properly praise the people of hospice. I call them my angels, and though my sweetheart went to be with our VIETNAM KOREAN WW2 Lord on March 4, they still check VETERAN VETERAN VETERAN on me by phone and mail. God We proudly present our Official Veterans Military Watches to honor your service bless them. to our Country. These unique watches have exclusive, copyrighted features – Joseph A. Harrison, La Plata, Md. not found in any other watches, at any price: False hope? # Exclusive watchbands inset with replicas of U.S. # Water-resistant case and adjustable bracelet, Military Conflict Service Medals, minted like fine both decorated with 23-karat gold. The short article “Stem-Cell coins, and the Service Ribbons in official hand- # Case-back engraved with your initials, Research Not So Partisan” (Living enameled colors. Well, August) reports on a poll years served and Legion Post Number. # Watch dials imprinted with your Military Branch # Your satisfaction is guaranteed or you publicized by the Juvenile Diabe- Service Emblem. tes Research Foundation that may return your watch within 30 days shows many conservatives favor # Precision quartz movement for accuracy within for replacement or refund – no questions embryonic stem-cell research. It seconds per month. asked. So, order yours today! said nothing about adult stem DIALS IMPRINTED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF SERVICE BRANCH EMBLEM DESERT STORM COMING SOON! cells, a curious omission. The difference is important; embryonic NAVY stem cells have not helped even ARMY MARINES AIR FORCE one human being. Adult stem cells COAST GUARD have helped people and are treating human diseases right FOR FASTEST SERVICE CALL TOLL FREE TO ORDER:1- 8 00 -255-3048 now. The embryonic stem-cell Monday - Friday from 9am - 5pm EST Have Credit Card ready when ordering. research so highly touted cruelly ORDER FORM misleads those suffering from OR, MAIL TO: Veterans Commemoratives™, 1250 Easton Road, Suite 290, Horsham, PA 19044 terrible affl ictions, fraught with YES. Please send me the following Veteran Service Watch, featuring the Service Medal terrifying implications reminiscent and Ribbon of my choice on the watchband. K VIETNAM K KOREA K WORLD WAR II K DESERT STORM RESERVE of Nazi medical “experiments.” MINE NOW! BNDWAT-ALM-11-04 As Florida congressman and SERVICE BRANCH DIAL: (check choice) CREDIT CARD: exp.___/___ KArmy KNavy KAir Force physician Dave Weldon reported KVISA KMC KAMEX KDISCOVER on the House fl oor in June, of the KMarine KCoast Guard Juvenile Diabetes Research CC# ______INITIALS DESIRED (3): ______Foundation’s $80 million research Signature ______and education budget, $3 million YRS. SERVED: __ to __ POST #: __ was spent on embryonic stem-cell SHIPPING ADDRESS (WE CANNOT SHIP TO P.O. BOXES) I WISH TO PAY AS FOLLOWS: Name ______research and $15 million on adult K Enclosed is my check or money order for stem-cell research. Why would the $125* per watch payable to “Veterans Address ______organization direct research that Commemoratives” as payment in full, OR City __ State Zip ______way if embryonic stem cells hold K Charge my credit card $ 125* per watch as out great hope? payment in full, OR Daytime Phone # ( ___ ) ______– Edward W. Atkinson, ALLOW 4-6 WEEKS FOR DELIVERY. K Charge my credit card in two monthly * PLUS $7.95 PER WATCH FOR ENGRAVING, S& H. Princeton Junction, N.J. installments of $62.50* each. * PA RESIDENTS ADD 6% ($7.98) SALES TAX. ©ICM 2003. Service Medal and Ribbon watch bands and case designs have been registered by Veterans Commemoratives with the U.S. Copyright Office. VISIT VETERANS COMMEMORATIVES™ ONLINE AT WWW.VETCOM.COM commander’s message To those forever changed by war can talk about service, and I will. I can talk about how service drives membership, how American ILegion posts must publicly work their programs to show that veterans are the patriotic fi ber of our country. But such talk doesn’t mean much until you have taken a seat next to a bandaged young man whose skull was recently crushed in combat. He will never be the same. After meeting him and others like him, neither will I. He is one of nearly 10,000 U.S. troops, as of this writing, who have been medically evacuated from the Iraq and Afghanistan operations in the war on terrorism. I met him in a restaurant in Washington, D.C., where every Friday night, wounded soldiers recovering at Walter Reed Army Medical Center are treated to a free dinner. The people you meet on those nights – or any time you should happen to visit Ward National Commander Thomas P. Cadmus visits a patient at Walter 57 at Walter Reed – will clarify your understanding of Reed Army Medical Center. Chester Simpson the war and of our duty, as Legionnaires, to support the new veterans coming home from it. I met a man who has spent nine years in the regular Army. All memoranda he ever wanted to be was an infantry soldier. Last summer, in GIFT MEMBERSHIPS ONLINE Iraq, he took a bullet in the back that rendered him, in his words, Gift memberships in The American Legion family “unable to perform 100 percent as an infantryman anymore.” He – the Legion, Sons of The American Legion or is resigned to the fact that he will have to retire from the Army American Legion Auxiliary – are easy to order he loves and restart life with a service-connected disability. online and make great gifts for the holidays. Visit I met a man from Ohio, an Army Reservist who lost a leg in www.legion.org for details. combat. He is learning to get along without it. His wife was with him. They expressed no regrets, only an understanding that he JOIN THE CADMUS CAVALRY was part of something greater. We talked about college football. American Legion and Legion family members are I met a general whose son recently lost an arm in combat. It now being mustered to join the Cadmus Cavalry. was hard to digest the complexity of that sacrifi ce, between A special Thomas P. Cadmus Cavalry commemo- offi cer and soldier, father and son. rative pin will be awarded to recruiters for every I met more than 50 such men and their families. I heard no fi ve new members they sign up for the 2005 self pity or despair. I listened intently to their stories and un- membership year. Certifi cation forms for the daunted enthusiasm. They showed courage at the onset of a program may be submitted at any time but must journey into the uncharted waters of a life irreversibly changed arrive at National Headquarters on or prior to by war. In time, they will transition from DoD to VA, from May 31, 2005. The national membership staff wounded soldiers to disabled veterans. That’s where we come in. will confi rm the new members, and pins will be Similar wounded U.S. troops occupied the minds and hearts mailed within three weeks. For more informa- of those war-weary soldiers who met in Paris in 1919 and tion, interested recruiters may contact Assistant decided that caring for disabled veterans and their families Director Bill Sloan at (317) 630-1321, or at his would be a fundamental duty of a new organization they email address [email protected]. would call The American Legion. It is also a timeless duty. Now is our time. IMPACT ’04 STRAW POLL RESULTS This month we celebrate Veterans Day across the country. The Legion’s Impact ’04 voter-education Wreaths are placed, speeches given, war stories swapped and campaign has been a big hit on both the national dinner tables set in honor of all who swore with their lives to and local levels. Legionnaires around the protect our blessings. I will undoubtedly be at such an event. country, like those at Post 575 in Lubbock, But my heart will be on Ward 57 with those who are coming Texas, hosted forums and events that drove home, and I will remind my fellow veterans why we fi ght for awareness of veterans issues. In Lubbock, VA health care, new career opportunities, well-funded educa- congressional candidates and VA Secretary tions, and for the benefi ts veterans and their families earned Anthony Principi were among those asked to and deserve. They are not alone. The American Legion exists address major veterans issues heading into this month’s general election. Look for results at to serve them. That’s what I mean when I talk about service. www.impact04.legion.org from the Impact ’04 online straw poll Nov. 1, between the top two presidential candidates. Most important, don’t forget to vote Nov. 2. Veterans and their families can make an impact.
8 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine NIGHT OF TERROR – NIGHT OF GRACE 1943. On board the Dorchester, 900 soldiers heading for war are torpedoed off frigid Greenland. With not enough life jackets for everyone, the four chaplains on board give their own life vests to the troops. Watch the inspiring, true story of a Catholic priest, a Jewish rabbi, and two Protestant ministers, whose last moments passed praying, arm-in-arm, as the Dorchester went down. A TRUE STORY.
If you don’t have Hallmark Channel, call 1-866-4HALLMARK Visit www.hallmarkchannel.com for local channel number. big issues Legalize medicinal marijuana YES NO Ethan Nadelmann John P. Walters n Nadelmann is founder and n The federal drug czar under executive director of the Drug President Bush, Walters served Policy Alliance, which as deputy director for supply promotes alternatives to the reduction in the Offi ce of war on drugs. National Drug Control Policy. arijuana may be an unconventional medicine, n America today, well-fi nanced organizations Mbut it works. Montel Williams, decorated Iand individuals are exploiting the pain of sick former naval intelligence offi cer and talk-show people, and the compassion of those who care host, uses medical marijuana to help him control about them, to legalize marijuana. Advocating for the symptoms of multiple sclerosis. So does Keith the use of a smoked weed under the guise of Vines, an assistant district attorney, retired Air medicine is dishonest, scientifi cally irresponsible Force captain and former federal narcotics pros- and contradictory to the high standards of quality ecutor living with AIDS. effectiveness guaranteed by the U.S. Food and These men are just two of Drug Administration. hundreds of thousands of THE HEART OF THE ISSUE Our medical system relies on Americans who use marijuana proven scientifi c research to to treat pain from accidents or Several U.S. states have laws on the protect U.S. citizens from debilitating conditions such as books permitting some form of unsafe and ineffective prod- MS; to help restore appetite medical marijuana use, a violation of ucts. Research has not demon- during chemotherapy; to treat strated that smoked marijuana the symptoms of AIDS, glau- federal law. The U.S. Supreme Court is is helpful as medicine. The coma and epilepsy; and for a expected to rule on a lower court FDA has also stated that while host of other medical reasons. decision barring federal action against marijuana use has no proven The vast majority are law- benefi ts, it does have long-term abiding citizens who suffer medicinal marijuana use in California. risks associated with it. from chronic pain and illness. Furthermore, the British Lung They use marijuana as medicine because it works Foundation says that smoking three to four mari- better than anything else, with fewer negative side juana cigarettes a day is as harmful for your lungs effects. Many never smoked marijuana until they as smoking 20 tobacco cigarettes. became sick. Dozens of scientifi c studies demon- Some claim smoking marijuana helps ease symp- strate marijuana’s safety and therapeutic value. toms associated with certain illnesses. The fact More than two thirds of Americans say mari- that smoking a joint may make them feel better is juana should be legal for medical purposes – and not in dispute. But simply feeling better is not the that’s the law now in 10 states. standard of modern medicine. If it were, snake oils Only one big problem: the federal government. and miracle potions would still line our medicine The Clinton administration was callous, and the cabinets today. Bush administration has been downright cruel, The reality is that modern science has afforded arresting and prosecuting patients and providers. us safe alternatives to smoking a crude plant. The Federal drug enforcement agents, acting at the FDA-approved drug Marinol makes the component behest of the Justice Department, even raided a in marijuana known as THC available in pill form. hospice and handcuffed frail and elderly patients A product that delivers marijuana’s THC through who use marijuana as medicine. an inhaler is currently in development. The The crackdown represents a shameful abuse of difference between these medicines and smoking a power: punishing sick people for using the medi- joint: the user does not get high. cine that works best for them, threatening doctors Our veterans have sacrifi ced much to secure the who exercise responsible medical judgment, and blessings we enjoy today, including a safe and prohibiting state governments from acting in the reliable medical system grounded in research and interests of their own citizens. unparalleled in the world. We owe it to them to It’s time to tell the feds to get out of the doctor’s protect the integrity of that system and to prevent offi ces and medicine cabinets, and out of the way those seeking to legalize marijuana from riding on of citizens who simply want to do what’s right. the coattails of our compassion.
CONTACT YOUR LEADERS The Honorable (name), U.S. Senate, Washington, DC 20510 • Phone: (202) 224-3121 The Honorable (name), House of Representatives, Washington, DC 20515 • Phone: (202) 225-3121
10 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine
Missing Pieces
U.S. intelligence has, since World War I, been a jigsaw puzzle of imprecision and uncertainty, ever a work in progress. BY ALAN W. DOWD
n 1929, after learning about a Ever since, the high-stakes Telegram, which detailed German code-breaking intelligence nature of intelligence operations plans to use Mexico as a proxy for Ioperation jointly run by the and the self-critical nature of our war against the United States. Of Army and State Department, representative system of govern- course, it was British intelligence Secretary of State Henry Stimson ment have conspired to expose services that cracked the German promptly de-funded it and de- intelligence failures and to code, underscoring how inad- clared, “Gentlemen do not read impugn this “ungentlemanly” equate U.S. intelligence was. each other’s mail.” line of work. This has never been The Army soon created Military Actually, they do, and they more apparent than in the wake Intelligence Section 8, which always have – even the gentlemen of the Sept. 11 attacks and Iraq scored perhaps its most signifi cant who founded the United States. In war, as congressmen and com- successes after the war. MI-8 fact, in 1775, the Second Continen- missions seem more concerned broke the code Japanese negotia- tal Congress created the Commit- about fi xing blame than fi xing tors used to cable back and forth tee of Correspondence, which the intelligence problem. to Tokyo during the Washington funded propaganda, performed The good news is that U.S. Naval Conference in 1921 and covert operations, developed codes history offers a roadmap for how 1922, enabling U.S. diplomats to and – gasp – intercepted mail. to deal with intelligence failures. outmaneuver their counterparts. Even back then, the country’s spies The bad news: this isn’t the fi rst Before the decade was out, and military were not always on time intelligence problems have however, MI-8 would be out of the same page: on one occasion, led to serious political and mili- business, thanks to Stimson. The Gen. George Washington sent a tary problems. embittered head of MI-8 later task force to Bermuda with orders wrote a book airing the organiza- to seize gunpowder stored at the Blame Game. America’s entry into tion’s many secrets (sound Royal arsenal. But when Washing- both world wars is often blamed familiar?), and the Japanese ton’s ships arrived, the ammuni- on intelligence failures, but some changed their codes. tion was gone – it had already been of the blame is unfair. Intelligence The dismantling of MI-8 contrib- secretly acquired by agents of the services actually played a crucial uted to the country’s limited code- Continental Congress. role in uncovering the Zimmerman breaking capabilities at the onset
12 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine Lapse of intelligence In its 521-page report on pre-war intelligence in Iraq, the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence leveled heavy criticism on the Intelligence Community: n The committee blasted the IC for succumbing to “group-think” that led analysts to interpret “ambiguous evidence as conclusively indicative of a WMD program” and for painting an intelligence picture that overstated the Iraqi threat. n The committee found “signifi cant shortcomings in almost every aspect of the Intelligence Community’s human-intelligence collection efforts.” Because of these shortcomings, the IC relied too heavily on defectors and foreign governments. This created a cycle that fed on itself and led to what Sen. Pat Roberts, R-Kan., called “a global intelligence failure.” Even so, the committee conceded that Iraq’s predisposition to deceive and unwillingness to come clean “could have led analysts to the reasonable conclusion” that Saddam still had his WMDs. Additionally, the committee concluded that IC assessments regarding Saddam’s missile arsenal, likely use of his own agents to conduct terror attacks, connections to certain terror groups and providing safe haven to al-Qaida, were all reasonable. of World War II. Even so, Ameri- Because of the imprecise nature a puzzle without knowing what it ca’s hamstrung intelligence assets of the warnings, U.S. offi cials in was supposed to look like. actually sounded the alarm over Hawaii were more concerned Japan in time to avert disaster. about protecting against uncon- From SOS to OSS. In what would In January 1941, almost a full ventional attacks, such as sabo- become a pattern, intelligence year before the attack on Pearl tage by Japanese expatriates, than reform followed intelligence Harbor, the Secretary of the Navy about bracing for a conventional failure. Just as the Zimmerman predicted that hostilities on the military attack. (Oddly, on Sept. Telegram led to MI-8, Dec. 7, 1941, part of Imperial Japan “would be 11, 2001, Washington seemed led to redoubled efforts at code- initiated by a surprise attack upon more concerned about conven- breaking – by mid-1942, the Navy the fl eet or the naval base at Pearl tional threats from without – a was intercepting some 60 percent Harbor.” Two weeks before the rogue missile attack, a surging of Tokyo’s naval communications attacks, the Navy Department China, a crumbling Russia – than – and to the creation of the Offi ce warned of “a surprise aggressive about unconventional attacks of Strategic Services. movement in any direction by the from within.) At the height of its power, the Japanese.” Similar warnings were Although the intelligence was OSS fi elded 13,000 intelligence issued Dec. 1 and Dec. 7. imprecise, it was still sounding agents. Working with their more One postwar inquiry concluded the alarm. Policymakers at Pearl seasoned British counterparts, OSS that offi cials in Washington and and in D.C. were not yet listening agents supported Allied operations Hawaii “were fully conscious of – or, perhaps better said, the right in North Africa, developed target the danger from air attack … and policymakers weren’t listening. lists for the bombing campaigns in they were adequately informed of This foreshadows Sept. 11. In the Europe and secretly brokered the the imminence of war.” Congress run-up to Pearl Harbor, as in run- surrender of Nazi forces in Italy. also found that the Navy and War up to 9/11, intelligence assets But the State Department and departments had “failed to give knew something was coming – military branches blocked the careful and thoughtful consider- they just didn’t know exactly upstart OSS from decoding Axis ation to the intercepted messages where or when. In both cases, communications, thus stunting its from Tokyo to Honolulu.” they were trying to piece together capabilities.
November 2004 13 The American Legion Magazine Repeating Stimson’s mistakes, But the pattern continued for President Truman shut down the the balance of the Cold War, with OSS after the war and unwittingly more perfect storms of poor continued the pattern. Yet two policymaking and incomplete years later, he signed the National intelligence, more complacency, Security Act and created the more ups, more downs. Central Intelligence Agency to In the wake of Vietnam, make sense of the vast amounts of policymakers tore into the intelligence landing on his desk. Intelligence Community with After the surprise invasion of gusto, this time using reform as South Korea, which led to the way to weaken rather than secondary surprise of China’s strengthen. The Church Commis- entry in the war, Truman formed sion, named after Idaho Sen. a special committee to examine Frank Church, led the way by the nation’s intelligence gaps. In airing some of the IC’s dirtiest What went wrong? the span of a year, he created the little secrets – plots to kill foreign National Security Agency by leaders, develop poisons, harass The underestimation that led to executive fi at in part because civil-rights leaders, use illegal Sept. 11 and overestimation that led to Iraq came after more America’s nascent Intelligence wiretaps and build secret data- than a decade of serious Community (IC) needed a central bases of U.S. citizens. intelligence problems. node for monitoring and decipher- The commission ultimately n After the Gulf War of 1990- ing information from the Cold made 100 recommendations, many 1991, the IC conceded it had War’s many fronts. aimed at limiting the IC’s ability to underestimated Iraq’s push for A decade later, in a bid to monitor threats, conduct domestic nuclear weapons by nine years. overthrow Fidel Castro, the CIA surveillance and target foreign n The IC failed to thwart a committed perhaps its greatest leaders. But if the commissioners’ number of major attacks in the blunder. After delivering some motives were good, the results 1990s, from the fi rst World 1,200 exiles to the Cuban coast, were not. “Over in the Soviet bloc, Trade Center attack to the the CIA hoped to spark a counter- we regarded it as a triumph,” said Khobar Towers and U.S. revolution with little risk or Ion Mihai Pacepa, former chief of embassy bombings. When linkage to Washington. The ill- Romania’s communist-era spy President Clinton retaliated conceived operation “had all the agency. He recalls how former with missile strikes on a disadvantages of involving Romanian dictator Nicolae Ceaus- purported chemical-weapons America morally and politically,” escu popped open a bottle of plant in Sudan in 1998, the IC recalls historian Paul Johnson, champagne after hearing about came under criticism for shaky intelligence. “with none of the real advantages the Church report. The damage of U.S. air and naval participa- was even worse at home: after the n In the late 1990s, intelligence tion.” The CIA’s exiles were Church Commission, as Derek assets tracked bin Laden and had him in their sights on decimated. Leebaert writes in “The Fifty-Year several occasions, but Yet the IC soon redeemed itself, Wound,” “The CIA would rarely be disagreement among mainly because President Kennedy given the benefi t of the doubt by policymakers about whether to gave it a chance to do so. Rather increasingly skeptical Americans.” kill or capture him allowed him than retreating into a cocoon of Yet the CIA proved resilient. In to escape. commissions, he reminded the early 1980s, after the Soviet n Before 9/11, the FBI and CIA America and the world that Castro invasion of Afghanistan, CIA were barred from sharing and communism were the prob- Director William Casey – an OSS information about terror lem, not the CIA. And Kennedy veteran – told his deputies to “go suspects. Likewise, key remained doggedly committed to out and kill me 10,000 Russians agencies wrangled over the use containing communism through until they give up.” Working with of armed Predator drones in intelligence activities. In fact, the mujahadeen, the CIA did that Afghanistan. photoreconnaissance and signals and then some. Indeed, it pays to n On 9/11, just 1 percent of the intelligence intercepted by the recall that some of the greatest CIA’s 18,000 employees was NSA proved invaluable in uncover- intelligence success stories are tasked to counter-terrorism. ing a Kremlin plan to nuclearize never known to the general public. Cuba a year after the Bay of Pigs. Even so, the CIA was caught
14 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine $500 CASH ALLOWANCE
THIS TIME, WE’RE PUTTING SOMEONE ELSE UP ON A PEDESTAL.
ELIGIBLE SWORN LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS, FIREFIGHTERS, EMT AND PARAMEDICS
NOW GET A $500 CASH ALLOWANCE ON ANY NEW JEEP® VEHICLE.
Introducing the Jeep® Everyday Heroes Reward. It’s Our Way of Saying Thanks for a Job Well Done.
See your dealer for eligibility requirements. Certain government agencies may prohibit personnel from receiving this cash allowance offer; confirm your employer’s rules in advance. Jeep is a registered trademark of DaimlerChrysler Corporation. 1-800-925-JEEP www.jeep.com/heroes unawares as the Soviet empire collapsed a short time later.
Blame Game II. Intel ligence will always be a mix of science and art, guesswork and facts, gut instinct and calculation. When humans interpret the motives and actions of other humans, we are bound to get it wrong sometimes, What went right? making stand-up policymaking Given the press accounts of the past 12 months, it would be easy to and statesmen-like politics crucial. conclude that the IC can do nothing right. In reality: After Pearl Harbor, President Franklin D. Roosevelt focused on n IC memos throughout the late 1990s warned of bin Laden’s determination to attack America. A 1999 report predicted that winning the war rather than terrorists could “crash-land an aircraft … into the Pentagon … winning political points. He CIA or the White House.” created the OSS, poured resources n The CIA disrupted planned attacks in eight different countries in 1999. into code-breaking and prodded America’s embryonic IC to learn n In 2002, the CIA targeted and killed the Yemeni terrorists who from Britain. Truman’s example planned the USS Cole attack. In 2003, the CIA penetrated deep enough into Saddam’s inner circle to come within minutes of killing the dictator reminds us that mid-course after a mole inside his security detail informed the CIA of his corrections are sometimes neces- whereabouts. sary, even if it means giving critics n The ground war in Afghanistan was won largely by CIA agents and fodder for political attacks. And special forces, and as Tom McInerny and Paul Vallely observe in JFK is instructive for what he “Endgame,” “the integration of military special-operations forces and didn’t do, namely packing it in the clandestine services of the CIA was a marked success” in Iraq. and concluding that the Cold War n Libya’s decision to end its WMD program is a result of U.S. intelligence was no longer worth waging efforts. Also, it was the CIA that unearthed how Pakistani scientist A.Q. because of an intelligence mistake. Khan shared nuclear secrets with North Korea, Libya and Iran. Thankfully, it’s the policymak- ers in Congress and the White House – not intelligence analysts – who decide where to deploy the in building the case against much more complex than simply nation’s resources and how to Saddam Hussein – a man who had reading the enemy’s mail, espe- fi ght the nation’s enemies. Given the means and motives to attempt cially in an age of terror. In fact, that intelligence agencies underes- something worse than Sept. 11. it often yields more questions timated Saddam Hussein’s nuclear Of course, postwar intelligence than answers. program in 1991, it’s no surprise may prove as malleable as prewar Is it better for a president to act that they extrapolated the worst in intelligence: offi cials at the U.S. on imprecise intelligence and risk 2003. And if, as some observers National Geospatial Intelligence ridicule, or should he wait until have suggested, Saddam was Agency have surmised that Iraq’s the intelligence is undeniable and pretending to have weapons of WMDs may have been trucked to risk a U.S. city? Is it fair to expect mass destruction as an internal Syria. Last spring, sarin and the IC to think like the enemy? deterrent, then it seems unfair for mustard shells began springing up And can we fi x the IC without policymakers to blame the IC for among conventional caches. And fi rst breaking this pattern – a reporting what its sources inside nine of Saddam’s foremost WMD pattern that begins with our own Iraq were saying. At the very scientists have been killed in complacency, leads to poor policy least, it’s disingenuous after a postwar Iraq. All had been execution and usually ends in decade of budget cuts. interviewed by the coalition’s embarrassment, if not disaster? x Moreover, after being criticized WMD fact-fi nding group, as The for not moving aggressively Weekly Standard has reported. Alan W. Dowd is a senior fellow at enough against Osama bin Laden, Sagamore Institute for Policy for not putting all the puzzle Questions. The search for these Research. pieces together, it seems unfair to weapons of mass confusion blame the IC for being aggressive reminds us that intelligence is Article design: Holly K. Soria
16 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine Expertly crafted in solid sterling silver and finished in brilliant 24-karat gold
Featuring dramatically detailed Marine symbols of honor
Genuine black onyx center stone
A bold and distinctive ring from any angle Enlarged to show detailed craftsmanship
Arrives in a The “USMC SEMPER FI” Ring velvet An Exclusive Edition presentation case with Certificate of Authenticity
In times of peace and conflict, they have always been there, defending PRIORITY COMMISSION AUTHORIZATION freedom wherever it may be challenged, and upholding the Corps’ values of Duty, Honor and Courage. They are the Few, the Proud, the Marines. FOR THE “USMC Semper Fi” RING A Singular Achievement in Craftsmanship and Design YES. I wish to commission the “USMC Now, there is an equally distinctive service ring that any Marine would Semper Fi” ring to be designed for me as be proud to wear. The “USMC Semper Fi” ring is individually crafted of solid described in this announcement. sterling silver and finished in gleaming 24-karat gold. At its center, a 24K- gold-plated Devil Dog—the official Marine mascot—stands guard on an Signature______inlay of genuine black onyx stone. The Corps’ emblem of eagle, globe and anchor are sculpted in relief on each side, and as a final touch the ring is Mr. Mrs. Ms. ______engraved with the USMC insignia and Semper Fidelis motto. Name (Please Print Clearly) An Outstanding Value and Your Satisfaction Guaranteed Address______The perfect way to show your allegiance to the Corps, or a great gift for City ______the Marine in your life, this dramatic ring can be yours for just $99, payable State ______Zip ______in three convenient installments of $33 (plus a total of $9 shipping/service). 69150-E94991 To have a ring commissioned in your name, and backed by our 60-day guar- antee, send no money now. Just fill out and send in the coupon. To assure a proper fit, a ring sizer will be sent to you after your commission has been accepted. Illinois residents add state sales tax. LIMITED TIME OFFER. Commissions will be accepted on a Prices higher in Canada. Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery of your ring first-come-first-served basis. So please respond as soon after we receive your initial deposit. as possible to reserve a “USMC Semper Fi” ring. THE BRADFORD EXCHANGE Neither the U.S. Marines nor any other component of the Department of P.O. Box 806, Morton Grove, IL 60053-0806 ©2004 BGE 69150-BIR Defense has approved, endorsed, or authorized this product. A Blueprint for the Green
Lt. Gen. Mark Curran explains how the Army’s vision is shifting as a new century unfolds.
or the U.S. Army, this is a time of particular challenge. While Ffully engaged in combat, peacekeeping and other operations in more than 120 countries, the Army is conducting its most comprehensive transformation in 50 years. Army leaders are re-examining and challenging organizational structures and institutions. They’re picking the best of current capabilities and attributes while developing others that increase the Army’s ability to respond to any and all threats. The end result of this transformation will be a more relevant and ready force – a campaign-quality army with joint and expeditionary capabilities. To manage the transformation, Army Chief of Staff Peter Lt. Gen. Mark Curran, Schoomaker turned to the Training and Doctrine Command. director, Futures Center, U.S. Army. Charged with building the best force for the nation, TRADOC James V. Carroll and its Futures Center integrates all transformation efforts, including those that focus on the Army’s role in the joint force. Lt. Gen. Mark Curran, the Futures Center’s fi rst director, spoke with The American Legion Magazine in his offi ce at historic Fort Monroe in Hampton Roads, Va.
18 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine q&a
The American Legion Magazine: Q: What lessons have the Army hensive transformation of its forces How have the Afghanistan and Iraq learned from those confl icts? since the early years of World War wars changed the Army’s mission? A: As a learning organization, the II. Not only is it good for the Army, Lt. Gen. Mark Curran: Our Army Army is examining Operation it’s also essential for the entire joint exists to fi ght and win our na- Enduring Freedom and Operation force and the nation. tion’s wars, so in one sense our Iraqi Freedom for insights to be Obviously we have to be able to mission hasn’t changed. The applied to the current force and respond to the new threats we global war on terrorism, though, implications for the future force. face today, but transformation is has changed the kind of war we We recently released a book, “On more than that. We’re building must fi ght. We’re adapting and Point,” which tells the story of the the Army’s future force. It’s a preparing to meet our strategic Army’s role in OIF in the context campaign-quality land force with commitments now and well into of the joint fi ght. The book joint and expeditionary capabili- the future. We do not have the provides insights on how the ties. Transformation will create a luxury to wait. So we’re changing Army trains, equips and fi ghts in campaign-capable Army this while still fi ghting – and that’s major combat operations. The decade. It will require the deep defi nitely not business as usual. Army has already taken action on and personal commitment of Remember, the environment dur- some of the emerging implica- every member of the Army team – ing the Cold War was almost tions. Many lessons have been every leader, soldier, civilian, predictable. We had a defi nable learned at the tactical level where family member and, yes, the enemy: the Soviet Union. Our main the sergeants, lieutenants and support of our veterans. job was deterrence. We built a very captains live, work and fi ght. And Gen. Schoomaker, the chief of robust and heavy force to deal here at TRADOC we’re transform- staff of the Army, has given us a with that threat. Once the Berlin ing the Army education system to tough mission, insisting we Wall came down and the Soviet quickly integrate those lessons at employ a transformation methodol- Union collapsed, our focus shifted. every level. ogy that fi rst and foremost enables We became an army with the Recently a company commander soldiers today. It has to increase ability to deploy anywhere in the in the 101st Airborne Division (Air the speed at which we compile, world, conducting various peace- Assault) talked about some assess and incorporate the hard making or peacekeeping missions. lessons learned when his com- lessons learned by soldiers and Yet during that time the pany survived an leaders. Finally, it must integrate Army was reduced in “Transformation enemy attack that left change in a manner that enhances size by 38 percent. will create a his platoon sergeant combat effectiveness and readiness After the Cold War it campaign-capable seriously wounded. and safeguards our soldiers’ became clear, and Sept. Army this decade.” They counter-attacked advantage in the future. 11 confi rmed, that we the enemy, killing one Gen. Schoomaker has several were in an increasingly unstable and detaining two. He attributed focus areas he wants us to con- world. We now deal with terror- his unit’s success to rehearsals, centrate on in our transformation ists, regional instability and after-action reviews and aggres- efforts. They run the gamut from weapons of mass destruction, all sive leadership at every level. basic soldier issues – improved the while keeping a wary eye on lethality, survivability, communi- some strategic threats that have Q: What does transformation cations, etc. – through compli- not disappeared with our Cold mean, and is it good for the Army? cated global networking and joint War enemies. Our deployments A: Transformation is what we call logistics issues. We also have have been largely unpredictable, the process that shapes the chang- focus areas that are looking at and they go on for longer periods. ing nature of the Army. We’re ways to stabilize the force to We’ve seen an increased need for doing this through new combina- improve unit readiness and the smaller, more agile units – not of tions of concepts, capabilities, lifestyle of our soldiers and their divisional size, but a brigade size people and organizations. The families. We’re looking at several with more capabilities. Army is pursuing the most compre- key areas in the Army Education
November 2004 19 The American Legion Magazine System that will impact both 3rd Infantry Division, the force global war on terrorism. As an leaders and soldiers, not the least that fought so brilliantly in “Army of One,” all components of which is to instill the warrior Operation Iraqi Freedom and is are integrally involved in the ethos for all soldiers, regardless of preparing to go back to Iraq again. current campaigns in Iraq and their specialty or position. If Soon the 10th Mountain and 101st Afghanistan and are also involved nothing else, this war has shown Airborne (Air Assault) Divisions totally with the redesign planning us there is no frontline or rear will also move to the new designs. and decision-making processes area; everyone in the theater must At the same time we will regarding this rebalancing effort. be prepared mentally and physi- reorganize and standardize the cally for close combat. National Guard brigade combat Q: The Army has done some Work prioritizing and identify- teams and standardize unit design amazing things since deploying to ing the resources to realize the in our Reserve component. We Afghanistan and Iraq following the potential from the focus areas has have to be able to easily integrate Sept. 11 attacks. What is the come together as the Army our Reserve component and our Army’s biggest achievement during Campaign Plan – the units have to be inter- that time? Army’s blueprint for the “We have to be changeable. And we A: I guess you’d have to say future. It lays out the more agile, with have to change the way securing the homeland and intent, vision, lines of the ability to we do personnel re- fi ghting two wars in Iraq and operation, objectives and deploy quickly.” placements so that we Afghanistan while simultaneously decision points that will keep units together conducting the biggest transforma- enable us to do this over the next longer. This reduces the amount tion in the Army’s history. And six years. Our business at the of redundant training we do. It we’ve done all this because of the Futures Center is to act as the hub helps us get better by creating the accomplishments of our soldiers as of Army innovation and to work conditions for units to become they answered the nation’s call. with industry to speed the devel- much more cohesive and train They have deployed, fought, bled opment of new technologies and more aggressively – not necessar- and many have died. They’re capabilities. We also develop ily longer, but certainly smarter. staying on to help build democratic warfi ghting concepts and conduct institutions in both Afghanistan experimentation, often with our Q: Is your plan to continue to use and Iraq and in other locales joint partners: the Navy, Air Force, the Guard and Reserve as part of around the world. TIME made the Marines and Coast Guard. the rotation of Army units in Iraq soldier its Person of the Year. Your and Afghanistan? Army is performing magnifi cently. Q: Can you describe some of the A: The short answer is yes. There Our soldiers are world-class; they changes that are occurring? is no way I can overstate the fi ght valiantly and demonstrate a A: We have to be more agile, with magnifi cent contribution of the true warrior spirit. But they also the ability to deploy quickly. Gen. members of the Army’s reserve have in their hearts a very compas- Schoomaker’s intent is to create a components in this time of war. sionate spirit, and we see that dem- modular, brigade-based Army that From securing the homeland to onstrated all around the world on is more responsive to regional engaging in close-action combat, playgrounds in Iraq, in hospitals combatant commanders’ needs. they have been superb. There has and orphanages in Afghanistan, Modular does not mean smaller. It been a very high demand for and in small villages in Africa. means units that quickly deploy certain kinds of units – military lethal, self-contained, tailored police and civil affairs, for in- Q: The Army has also had some packages that can fi ght upon stance – and as a result we need signifi cant challenges. What do arrival. We’re creating units that to look hard at the mix of military you consider the toughest? are designed and trained to fi t into specialties we have in both the A: We do face some tough chal- any combination of joint forces. active and reserve components. lenges. We are deployed in about For example, an Army combat We are internally rebalancing 120 countries around the world. brigade working comfortably in a both the active and Reserve Our operational tempo is as high Marine-led operation. In a little component forces. as it’s ever been. Old rules no over two years we’ll add 10 At the end of the day, the longer apply. The global war on brigade combat teams. We may Reserve components will continue terrorism requires us to challenge add a total of 15 by fi scal year to provide combat, combat old paradigms, to be fl exible and 2007. We’ve already begun support and combat-service adaptable to face a cunning and implementing these changes in the support formations to support the devious enemy. As we win this
20 November 2004 The American Legion Magazine