Seagrass Assessment Report of PCA WWF- Semporna PCA Project

February 2011

WWF-Malaysia 49, Jalan SS23/15 Taman SEA 47400 Petaling Jaya Selangor, Malaysia Tel: +60 3 7803 3772 Fax: +60 3 7803 5157 E-mail: [email protected]

Copyright © 2011 WWF-Malaysia.

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.

The opinions of the authors articulated in this publication do not necessarily reflect those of WWF-Malaysia.

Design and layout by Nina Ho and Angela Lim.

First published 2011.

Suggested citation: Ho, Nina , Kassem, Kenneth & Ng, Sharon. (2011). Seagrass Assessment Report of Semporna Priority Conservation Area. Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia: WWF-Malaysia.

Perpustakaan Negara Malaysia Cataloguing-in-Publication Data

Ho, Nina Ann Jin. Seagrass Assessment Report of Semporna Priority Conservation Area / by Nina Ho, Kenneth Kassem, Sharon Ng. ISBN 978-967-0237-03-9 1. Seagrasses--Conservation----Semporna. 2. Marine plants--Sabah-- Semporna. 3. Marine parks and reserves--Sabah--Semporna I. Kassem, Kenneth. II. Ng, Sharon. III. Title. 577.694095952153

Printed in Malaysia

ii

Seagrass Assessment Report of Semporna Priority Conservation Area

by

Nina Ho Kenneth Kassem Sharon Ng

Report Produced Under Project MY0256 Facilitating Collaborative Management of Coral Reefs and Adjacent Ecosystems with Tourism and Fisheries

February 2011

iii Table of Contents Acronyms...... v Acknowledgement...... vi Introduction...... 1 Materials and Methods...... 4 Results ...... 6 Discussion...... 13 Recommendation and Next Steps...... 15 References...... 16 Appendix 1: Marine Animals Associated with Seagrass Beds...... 18 Appendix 2: Seagrass Species Distribution and Habitats Diagram ...... 19 Appendix 3: Seagrass Species Distribution Map in Sabah Waters...... 20 Appendix 4: Seagrass Species Distribution List in Sabah Waters ...... 21 Appendix 5: Seagrass-Watch Monitoring Data Sheet...... 22 Appendix 6: Seagrass Percentage Cover Field Guide ...... 23 Appendix 7: Algal Percent Cover Standards Field Guide ...... 24 Appendix 8: Seagrass Species Code Field Guide 1 ...... 25 Appendix 9: Seagrass Species Code Field Guide 2 ...... 25 Appendix 9: Seagrass Species Code Field Guide 2 ...... 26 Appendix 10: Field Assessment Photos...... 26 Appendix 10: Field Assessment Photos...... 27 Appendix 11: Seagrass Herbarium for Semporna PCA ...... 28 Appendix 12: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 1...... 29 Appendix 13: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 2...... 30 Appendix 14: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 3...... 31 Appendix 15: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 4...... 32 Appendix 16: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Southern Reefs 1...... 33 Appendix 18: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Southern Reefs 3...... 35 Appendix 19: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Semporna PCA ...... 36

iv Acronyms

GPS Global Positioning System PCA Priority Conservation Area SCUBA Self Contained Underwater Breathing Apparatus TEV Total Economic Value WRI World Resources Institute WWF WWF-Malaysia

v Acknowledgement

We thank our project donors from WWF-Netherlands, the Adessium Foundation and the Hupkes Family in the Netherlands. Thanks to all survey participants consisting of local stakeholders and volunteers (Sally Usher, Amelia Ng, Dayang Noor Hasimah binti Datu Pengiran Ahmad, Julia Ng Su Chen, Soo Chun Ian, Norliana Binti Mabustan, Tan Kai Lee, Nor Amy Ajak, Lee Pei San, Salha Alba, Fredyanna Gabriellia Tinsung, Gavin Jolis, Nattelee Lim Shu Lee and Mohd. Haris Bin Bakarah). Thanks to Angela Lim for patiently editing and formatting this report. We also thank Sikula Magupin for producing informative maps for this report.

vi Introduction

Seagrasses are aquatic flowering plants (monocotyledonous angiosperms) that form meadows in nearshore brackish water or marine waters in temperate and tropical regions. There are 60 species of seagrasses described globally, within 12 genera, 4 families and 2 orders; many of which are found in the Indo-Pacific region. Australia has the highest diversity with more than half of the total seagrass species in the world (McKenzie 2001); followed by the Philippines with 19 species (WRI, 2010); Malaysia with 14 species (Zakaria 2003); and Indonesia with 13 species (Kuriandewa 2008).

Seagrasses are distributed along the coasts of Malaysia in patches or meadows. The 14 seagrass species recorded are: Enhalus acoroides, Halophila beccarii, H. decipiens, H. ovalis, H. minor, H. spinulosa, H. pinifolia, H. uninervis, Cymodocea rotundata, C. serrulata, Thalassia hemprichii, Syringodium isoetifolium, Ruppia maritima and Thalassodendron ciliatum (Bujang, 2006).

Seagrasses are complex in morphological structure (Figure 1) and possess multiple ecological functions. They are associated with shallow inter-tidal habitats, mangrove areas, coral reefs, semi-enclosed lagoons and shoals; and have the ability to tolerate a wide range of salinity. As a complex and high productivity ecosystem, seagrass beds provide food, habitats and nursery grounds for a variety of invertebrates, fish and turtles. They also stabilize sediments, recycle nutrients to improve water clarity and contribute to shoreline protection via wave attenuation (Koch et al. 2006). Additionally, seagrasses enhance biodiversity and trophic transfer to adjacent habitats.

Figure 1: Morphological structure of seagrasses (Source: www.seagrasswatch.org)

1 A recent study estimated the annual economic value of seagrass at $3,500 per hectare (Loney, 2009). Most of the marine fishing families in Semporna PCA are highly dependent on seagrass habitats (Stakeholders of Semporna, 2009) that are accessible for “gleaning”; a fishing activity conducted during low tide by walking on seagrass beds or shallow reefs to collect edible marine resources such as shellfish, spider conch (Lambis sp.) or kahanga as it is locally known, sea urchin, clam, sea cucumber, stingray, eel and fish. Gleaning is commonly practised by women and children (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Women and children gleaning on seagrass beds on during low tide.

The high diversity of marine life in seagrass habitats is also becoming an attraction for marine tourism in Semporna PCA. In addition to fishing, marine tourism is one of the main economic activities in Semporna. SCUBA diving to appreciate the interesting marine life associated with seagrass beds can provide a similar enjoyment to diving on coral reefs. Examples of fascinating marine life that can be found in seagrass habitats are marine turtle, seahorse, nudibranch, flamboyant cuttlefish, stonefish, stingray, snake eel and striped catfish (Appendix 1).

Seagrass ecosystems are often overlooked as a fragile ecosystem with a high priority for conservation. They are also highly impacted by anthropogenic activities and natural disturbances which result in declines in seagrass coverage and density. Despite the high dependence of Semporna PCA’s marine tourism and fisheries on the ecological services provided by seagrass habitats, there appears to be little appreciation for this ecosystem. Seagrass habitats continue to be negatively impacted by unsustainable coastal development of resorts, houses and jetties as well as sedimentation and pollution from human waste.

2 The ecological services of seagrass ecosystems need to be highlighted to the government and local communities to enable the planning and implementation of sustainable marine resources management. For this to happen, scientific information on the ecosystem is needed. Thus, this assessment seeks to establish and document baseline ecological information of Semporna PCA’s seagrass habitats including specific threats and socio- economic benefits to the fishing communities and tourism industry.

Geographic scope Between May 2009 and August 2010, assessments were carried out by WWF-Malaysia Semporna PCA Team, volunteers, local villagers and dive operators. A total of 18 sites were surveyed with 54 transects that were representative of most major seagrass beds in Semporna PCA (Map 1). Seagrass beds at the Tun Sakaran Marine Park and Island Park fall under the management and jurisdiction of Sabah Parks. Therefore, they were not surveyed under this project because research in these parks is conducted by the research unit of Sabah Parks.

Map 1: Seagrass sites assessed in the Semporna PCA.

3 Materials and Methods

The seagrass assessment methodology used was based on the Seagrass-Watch protocol for monitoring intertidal seagrass habitats (McKenzie, 2001). Representation of major seagrass areas and accessibility were the two main criteria for site selection.

Four seagrass health and ecological indicators were considered in the assessment: 1) Percentage of seagrass coverage estimated in a fixed size quadrat indicating the density and abundance of seagrass species. 2) The number of species identified indicating seagrass species diversity in the survey site. 3) Percentage of algal coverage estimated in a fixed size quadrat where high algal densities may indicate overloading of nutrient content in water (phosphorus and nitrogen). 4) Canopy height is a general indicator for three-dimensional structure of seagrass beds that has implications on the biomass and richness of associated fish communities (Hori et al, 2009).

Materials: 1. 2.5m x 2.5m quadrat 2. 50m fibreglass measuring tape 3. Compass 4. Clipboard 5. Waterproof paper with printed data sheet 6. Pencil 7. 30cm ruler 8. Magnifying glass 9. Camera with underwater housing 10. Seagrass species code, ID and coverage percentage field guide

4 General steps for seagrass assessment: 1. Select a study site and lay out the three 50m transects parallel to each other, 25m apart and perpendicular to shore. (Figure 3) 2. Use 2.5m x 2.5m quadrat to estimate seagrasses coverage for every 5m along the 50m transect. 3. Take a photograph of the quadrat as vertical as possible, with frame, label and tape measure at 5m, 25m and 45m distance along the transect. 4. Describe sediment composition. 5. Estimate seagrass coverage percentage within quadrat using Seagrass Percentage Cover photo guide (Appendix 6) 6. Identify seagrass species using Seagrass Species Codes field guide (Appendix 8 and 9). 7. Measure canopy height. 8. Estimate algae coverage percentage using Algal Cover Percentage photo guide (Appendix 7) 9. Describe other features and ID/ count of macrofauna. 10. Take a seagrass specimen if uncertain of its identification.

Seagrass beds

Beach

Figure 3: Layout of seagrass assessment transects and quadrats (McKenzie et al, 2001)

5 Results

Eight species of seagrass were identified in Semporna PCA in contrast to the 14 species recorded in Malaysia (Zakaria 2003) and 60 species worldwide (McKenzie, 2001). The seagrass species recorded were Enhalus acoroides (Ea), Thalassia hemprichii (Th), Halophila ovalis (Ho), Cymodocea rotundata (Cr), Cymodocea serrulata (Cs), Halodule pinifolia (Hp), Halodule uninervis (Hu) and Syringodium isoetifolium (Si).

The most frequently encountered species were Thalassia hemprichii (45%), Enhalus acoroides (16%), Cymodocea serrulata (11%), Cymodocea rotundata (8%) and Halophila ovalis (3%) (Chart 1). These 5 species were found in all the survey sites and identified as dominant species in 11 out of 16 survey sites (Table 1). The most dominant and widely distributed species in Semporna PCA, Thalassia hemprichii, is a major part of the diet of green turtles (Chelonia mydas) and dugongs (Dugong dugon) (Figure 4).

Seagrass Species Composition in Semporna PCA Si, 7% Ea, 16% Hu, 10%

Hp, 0%

Cs , 11%

Cr, 8%

Ho, 3% Th, 45%

Chart 1: Seagrass species composition in Semporna PCA.

Figure 4: Green turtle (Chelonia mydas) feeding on Thalassia Hemprichii at Sipadan Island.

6

Northern Reefs Southern Reefs

Family / Species Larapan Timbun Mata Bum-bum 1 Bum-bum 2 Kulapuan Pom-pom Pandanan Mataking Timba-timba Boheyan Omadal Seppangau Si Amil Denawan Mabul Gusungan Nusa Tengah Menampilik Hydrocharitaceae Enhalus acoroides ┼ D ┼ D ┼ R ┼ R ┼ C ┼ D ┼ R ┼ D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ Thalassia hemprichii ┼ D ┼ R ┼ C D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ D ┼ C ┼ D ┼ D ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C

Halophila beccarii Halophila decipiens Halophila minor Halophila ovalis ┼ C ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R ┼ C ┼ C ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R Halophila spinulosa Cymodoceaceae Cymodocea rotundata ┼ R ┼ R ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C ┼ R Cymodocea serrulata ┼ R ┼ R ┼ R ┼ C ┼ C ┼ C ┼ D ┼ R Halodule pinifolia ┼ R ┼ Halodule uninervis ┼ C R ┼ C ┼ R ┼ C ┼ R ┼ D ┼ Syringodium isoetifolium C ┼ C ┼ D ┼ R ┼ C ┼ R TOTAL 4 4 2 6 2 3 3 3 3 5 6 3 3 6 6 4 3 4 Table 1: Seagrass species distribution and record from surveys in Semporna PCA. Species distribution indicator: D = Dominant; C = Common; R = Rare (Applicable only to seagrass found in the quadrats)

Seagrass SSpeciespecei s Composition Precentage in Semporna PCA

Menampilik Ea Nusa Tengah Th Sepanggau Ho Omadal Cr

Pantau-Pantau Cs Hp Boheyan Hu Gusungan Si Denawan

Si Amil

Site Larapan

Bum-bum

Timbun Mata

Pandanan

Kulapuan

Mabul

Mataking

Pom-pom

Timba-timba

0 10203040506070 Percentage (%)

Chart 2: Seagrass species composition on each site.

7 Chart 3 shows that the seagrass beds in Semporna PCA were in fair condition with an overall average seagrass coverage percentage of 31.67%. The highest average percentage of seagrass coverage was recorded at Kulapuan Island with 62%, while Timbun Mata Island has the lowest seagrass coverage with only 3 % (Map 2).

Average Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Semporna PCA

70

60 50

40

30

Percentage (%) 20

10

0

Mabul Si Amil

Omadal Larapan Boheyan Mataking Denawan Pom-pom Kulapuan Bum-bum Pandanan

Gusungan Menampilik Sepanggau Timba-timba Nusa Tengah Nusa Timbun Mata Pantau-Pantau

Chart 3: Average percentage of seagrass coverage in Semporna PCA.

Map 2 and Table 2 illustrate that distance from mainland may be the one of the factors affecting the density of seagrass coverage in several survey sites in Semporna PCA. Distance from the mainland has strong influence on water turbidity and substrate types that in turn influence seagrass density. However, there may be other factors contributing to seagrass density, such as density of island inhabitants, waste discharge, availability of nutrients, and algal coverage.

8

Map 2: Status of seagrass coverage in Semporna PCA.

9

Reefs Sites Average Condition Major substrate type Estimated area Percentage Category (Poor 0- distance of 24.9%, Fair 25-49.9%, from Seagrass Good 50-74.9%, mainland Excellent 75-100%) Cover (%) (km) Timbun Mata 3.15 Poor Sand & Rock 11.2 Larapan 13.30 Poor Sand, Mud & Shell 6 .1 Bum-Bum1 34.58 Fair Sand & Mud 2.5 Bum-bum 2 26.61 Fair Mud 13.1 Kulapuan 61.67 Good Sand 26.6 Northern Pom-pom 38.70 Fair Sand & Rubble 31.4 Reefs Pandanan 29.45 Fair Sand & Rock 36.0 Mataking 15.39 Poor Sand & Rubble 39.5 Timba-timba 41.52 Fair Fine Sand 35.5 Boheyan 32.21 Fair Sand & Shell 36.5 Omadal 31.73 Fair Sand, Mud & Rubble 14.5 Sepanggau 12.03 Poor Sand & Course Sand 3.6 Si Amil 55.88 Good Sand & Rubble 30.6 Denawan 42.55 Fair Sand 31.0 Southern Mabul 31.87 Fair Sand & Rubble 16.6 Reefs Gusungan 44.79 Fair Sand 4.6 Nusa Tengah 38.57 Fair Sand & Mud 3.5 Menampilik 16.03 Poor Sand & Mud 3.0 Table 2: Seagrass assessment sites with average coverage percentage, condition category, substrate type and estimated distance from mainland.

It was observed that seagrass coverage increased with distance from the beach (Chart 4). Seagrass coverage is generally low at the starting point because in most cases this is where strong wave activity and constant shifting sand movement occur. These conditions damage seagrasses and hamper growth. Seagrass coverage gradually increased from 5m until about 25m from shore. Beyond 25m, towards the reef crest area, with increasing depth and attenuated sunlight, seagrass coverage slowly decreases. However, there are variations among the sites due to differences in sea floor topography of the area.

10 Average Seagrass Distribution to Shore

50.00

40.00

30.00 ) % ( 20.00

10.00

0.00 Average CoverPercentage 0 m 5 m 10 m 15 m 20 m 25 m 30 m 35 m 40 m 45 m 50 m Distance from shore

Chart 4: Average seagrass distribution to shore.

The average seagrass canopy height for all sites was 11.17cm. The highest average canopy height was recorded at Bum-bum 1 at 28.67cm. The lowest average canopy height was recorded at Timbun Mata at 1.33cm (Chart 5). Average canopy height is influenced by the type of seagrass species occurring in the quadrat. For example, the tallest seagrass species in Semporna is Enhalus acoroides, which can grow from 30 to 150cm in height. The shortest species found in Semporna is Halophila ovalis that grows from 1 to 3cm in height.

Average algal coverage for all sites was 8.44%, indicating low levels of nutrient overloading. However, there were sites with high average algal coverage: Si Amil (28.64%) and Pantau-pantau (25.91%) are mostly covered by filamentous algae. The lowest average algal coverage was 0.65% at Sepanggau Island (Chart 6).

11 Average Canopy Height of Seagrasses

35 30 25 20 15 10

Average (cm) Height 5 0

a n a n il l u k ing at m a li om k ada ga timb puan Am awan ngan Mabul a dana arap Si u Pantau L Boheyanu- Om Pom-p Mata Kul Pan Bum-bu Den Gus imbun M ta Sepang Menampi Timba- T Nusa Tengah Pan Sites

Chart 5: Average canopy height of seagrass distributed in Semporna PCA.

Average Algal Cover Percentage 35

30

25

20

15

Percentage (%) Percentage 10

5

0

l l h a n ta i n n u a ik b om ing a an a da a l im p puan ana M Am w t - Mabul a rap a- Si Pantau Teng b La Boheya u- Oma Pom Matak Kul Pand Bum-bum Dena Gusungan ta Sepangg Menampi Tim Timbun Nusa Pan Sites Chart 6: Average algal coverage percentage in Semporna PCA.

12 Discussion

Seagrass habitats in Semporna PCA can be considered to be in fair condition with an average coverage percentage of 31.67% and moderate levels of diversity with 8 species recorded from 18 sites. There is some possibility that Halophila dicipiens (Hd) and Halophila minor (Hm) may be overlooked as both are small and difficult to distinguish from Halophila ovalis (Ho). In addition to the total species recorded in Semporna PCA, Halophila spinulosa (Hp) was sighted at 3m depth during a dive at Bum-bum Island (Figure 5). This species was not observed during the formal surveys.

Figure 5: Halophila spinulosa at Bum-bum Island 3m depth

Seagrasses are highly adapted to submerged environments. To provide oxygen to their roots and rhizomes, seagrasses require some of the highest levels of light needed by any plant group worldwide; approaching 25% of incident radiation in some seagrass species, compared to 1% or less for other angiosperm species (Dennison et al. 1993). This means that seagrasses are extremely sensitive in response to environmental changes, especially with altered water clarity. The water clarity might be one of the factors contribute to the density of seagrass in Semporna.

In addition, seagrass ecosystems play crucial roles in nutrient recycling and carbon absorption; critical for combating climate change. The increase in seagrass knowledge is an important step in the fight against climate change and its incorporation into the world’s climate strategy (Bergen 2009).

Environmental, biological, and extreme climatological events have been identified as causes of seagrass loss worldwide. Global climate change has resulted in increased sea surface temperature and sea level; increased frequency and intensity of storms and associated surge and swells; regional shifts in water; as well as more localized impacts such as increased loading of sediment, contaminants, and nutrients (Orth et al., 2006). The major threats

13 observed in Semporna PCA were mostly localized impacts such as sediment and nutrient loading; building or jetty overshadowing seagrass beds; and impacts from boating activities. Several sites have been observed to be impacted by extreme weather events, particularly during storm and typhoon seasons.

Removing identified causes of seagrass loss is the best solution, complemented with the rehabilitation of seagrass beds. There have been a few success stories of seagrass rehabilitation. An example can be found in Calancan Bay, Philippines where transplanting was carried out to restore heavily damaged seagrass beds. However, unless damaging impacts are removed, seagrass beds affected by pollution and siltation cannot be restored. Additionally, restoration of seagrass beds on a meaningful scale is extremely time consuming and expensive. Hence, it is better to preserve natural seagrass habitat and adopt a preventive approach (Talbot 2001).

14 Recommendation and Next Steps

1) Long-term monitoring programme Establish a long-term programme involving stakeholders for seagrass habitat monitoring. A regular and systematic monitoring programme is necessary to assess the status of seagrass.

2) Capacity building Provide training to increase capacity for carrying out seagrass assessment among stakeholders including local villagers, tourists, dive operators and government agencies as part of the effort to foster a collaborative management of marine resources in Semporna PCA.

3) Information dissemination, education and publication Develop a set of annual report cards for specific seagrass beds and disseminate information about status and importance of seagrass in Semporna PCA.

4) Resource mapping and survey Habitat mapping throughout the entire Semporna PCA is needed to detect changes of seagrass habitat size and provide useful zoning information for decision makers in Semporna PCA. A completed Total Economic Valuation (TEV) study of seagrass beds complements ecological information, and is important in efforts to raise awareness and economic appreciation for the seagrass ecosystem.

5) Water quality management Seagrass health is tied closely with good water quality. Excessive nutrients in the water put seagrass at a disadvantage with algal overgrowth. However, the proximity of seagrass beds to coastal areas makes seagrass vulnerable to pollution from human waste. Therefore, monitoring water quality to detect increased levels of nutrient loading is also an essential part of seagrass monitoring, and effort must be put into improving wastewater treatment on islands and coastal areas.

6) Policy and legislation The susceptibility of seagrass to coastal construction and boating activities makes it necessary to regulate human activities in areas where seagrasses are found.

15 References

Bergen, M. (2009). The Hidden Value of Seagrasses. Conservation International. http://www.conservation.org/FMG/Articles/Pages/hidden_value_seagrasses.aspx

Bujang, J.S., Zakaria, M.H. & Arshad, A. (2006). Distribution and significance of seagrass ecosystems in Malaysia. Aquatic Ecosystem Health & Management, 9(2):201-214.

Conservation International. 2008. Economic Values of Coral Reefs, Mangroves, and Seagrasses: A Global Compilation. Center for Applied Biodiversity Science, Conservation International, Arlington, VA, USA.

Dennison, W.C., Orth, R.J., Moore, K.A., Stevenson, J.C., Carter, V., Kollar, S., Bergstrom, P.W.,Batiuk, R.A.. (1993). Assessing water quality with submersed aquatic vegetation. BioScience 43: 86–94.

Edang, L., Rizally, F. A.R, Ang, N. F. A. (2008). Rumput Laut Perairan Sabah. Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka, Kuala Lumpur.

Hori, M., Suzuki, T., Monthum, Y., Srisombat, T., Tanaka, Y., Nakaoka, M., & Mukai, H. (2009). High seagrass diversity and canopy-height increase associated fish diversity and abundance. Marine Biology Vol.156 No. 7:1447-1458.

Koch, E.W., J. Ackerman, M. van Keulen, and J. Verduin. 2006. Fluid dynamics in seagrass ecology: from molecules to ecosystems. In Seagrasses: Biology, ecology and conservation. A. W. D. Larkum, R. J. Orth and C. M. Duarte, ed. Springer Verlag, 193- 225.

Kuriandewa, T.E., UNEP. (2008). National Reports on Seagrass in South China Sea. UNEP/GEF/SCS Technical Publication No.12. . Chapter 4 : Indonesia.

Loney, J. (2009). Loss of world's seagrass beds accelerating study. http://planetark.org/enviro-news/item/53609

McKenzie, L.J., Campbell, S.J. & Roder, C.A. (2001). Seagrass-Watch: Manual for Mapping & Monitoring Seagrass Resources by Community (Citizen) Volunteers. (QFS, NFC, Cairns) 100pp

Orth R.J., Carruthers, T.J.B., Dennison, W.C., Duarte, C.M., Fourqurean, J.W., Heck, JR. K.L., Hughes, A.R., Kendrick, G.A., Kenworthy, W.J., Olyarnik, S., Short, F.T., Waycott, M. & Williams, S.L. (2006). A Global Crisis for Seagrass Ecosystems. Bioscience Vol. 56 No. 12.

Stakeholders of Semporna. (2009). A Share Vision for Semporna. WWF-Malaysia.

16 Talbot, F. & Wilkinson, C. (2001). Coral Reefs, Mangroves and Seagrasses: A Sourcebook for Managers. Australian Institute of Marine Science, Townsville, Australia.

Zakaria, M.H., Bujang, J.S. & Abdul Razak, F.R. (2003). Occurrence and Morphological Description of Seagrasses from Pulau Redang, Terengganu, Malaysia. University of Technology Malaysia. Journal Technology, 38(C) June. 2003: 29–39

WRI. EarthTrends website. http://earthtrends.wri.org/pdf_library/cp/coa_cou_608.pdf

17 Appendix 1: Marine Animals Associated with Seagrass Beds

a) b)

c) d)

Figure 6: Example of marine animals found in seagrass beds. a) striped catfish (Plotosus lineatus) b) false clown anemone fish (Amphiprion ocellaris) c) robust ghost pipefish (Solenostomus cyanopterus) d) spider conch (Lambis sp.)

18 Appendix 2: Seagrass Species Distribution and Habitats Diagram

c) d) a) b)

Figure 7: Indo-Pacific Seagrass Species Distribution and Habitats (Fort 2007)

19 Appendix 3: Seagrass Species Distribution Map in Sabah Waters

Figure 8: Seagrass species distribution in Sabah waters (Edang et. al, 2008).

20 Appendix 4: Seagrass Species Distribution List in Sabah Waters

Taman Laut Taman-taman Sabah T T T T Famili dan T P P M Spesies A P T T R S Teluk Sepanggar Tanjung Kaitan , KK Sg. Salut Sg. Mengkabung Pulau Labuan Pulau Layang-Layang Tg. Mengayau, Kudat Bak-Bak, Kudat Sandakan Kunak Pulau Bagahak Semporna Pulau Sipadan Pulau Mabul Pulau Bum-Bum Pulau Maganting Pulau Tabawan

Cymodoceaceae Cymodocea x x x x x x x X x x rotundata Cymodocea serrulata x x xx x Halodule pinifolia x x x x x x Halodule uninervis x x x xxx xxxxX x x x Syringodium x x x x isoetifolium Thalassodendron x ciliatum Hydrocharitaceae Enhalus acoroides x x x x xx xxx x x x Halophila decipiens x x Halophila ovalis x x x xxx x xxx X x x x Halophila minor x x x X x x x Halophila spinulosa x x Halophila beccarii Thalassia hemprichii x x x x x xxx xxxxx x x Jumlah spesies 10 2 7 7 3 2 6 8 1 1 3 2 5 3 4 1 4 11 2 3 7

Table 3: Seagrass species distribution list in Sabah waters (Edang et. al, 2008)

21 Appendix 5: Seagrass-Watch Monitoring Data Sheet

Source: Seagrass-Watch Manual

22 Appendix 6: Seagrass Percentage Cover Field Guide

Source: Seagrass-Watch Manual

23 Appendix 7: Algal Percent Cover Standards Field Guide

Source: Seagrass-Watch Manual

24 Appendix 8: Seagrass Species Code Field Guide 1

Source: Seagrass-Watch Manual

25 Appendix 9: Seagrass Species Code Field Guide 2

Source: Seagrass-Watch Manual

26 Appendix 10: Field Assessment Photos

a) b)

d) c)

.

e) f)

Figure 9: (a) Syringodium isoetifolium; (b) Halodule uninervis; (c) Healthy seagrass bed at Mabul Island; (d) Seagrass bed with algal overgrowth related to nutrient loading; (e)Dense seagrass bed on Mabul island; (f) Low density of seagrass.

27 Appendix 11: Seagrass Herbarium for Semporna PCA

e) a) b) c)

c) d)

e) f)

Figure 10: (a) Syringodium isoetifolium; (b) Thalassia hemprichii; (c) Syringodium isoetifolium; (d) Cymodocea rotundata; (e) Enhalus acoroides; (f), Halophila ovalis

a) b)

28

e) f) Appendix 12: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 1

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Timbun Mata, Semporna

35 30 25 T1 20 T2 15 T3 coverage 10 5 Total % seagrass % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Larapan, Semporna

70 60 50 T1 40 T2 30 T3 coverage 20 10 Total % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Bum-bum 1, Semporna

100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 coverage 20

Total % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

29 Appendix 13: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 2

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Pantau-Pantau, Semporna e 100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 20 0

Total % seagrass coverag % seagrass Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Kulapuan, Semporna

100

80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 20

0

Total % seagrass coverage seagrass % Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Pom-pom, Semporna

80 70 60 T1 50 40 T2 30 T3 coverage 20 10 Total % seagrass 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

30 Appendix 14: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 3

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Pandanan, Semporna

60 50 40 T1 30 T2 20 T3 coverage 10

Total % seagrass % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Mataking, Semporna

80 70 60 T1 50 40 T2 30 T3 20 10 0

Total % seagrass coverage 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Timba-timba, Semporna

80 70 60 50 T1 40 T2 30

coverage T3 20 10 Total % seagrass 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

31 Appendix 15: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Northern Reefs 4

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Boheyan, Semporna e 80 70 60 T1 50 40 T2 30 T3 20 10 0

Total % seagrass coverag % seagrass Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Omadal, Semporna e 100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 20 0

Total % seagrass coverag seagrass % Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

32 Appendix 16: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Southern Reefs 1

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Sepanggau, Semporna e 70 60 50 T1 40 T2 30 20 T3 10 0

Total % seagrass coverag % seagrass Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Si Amil, Semporna

100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 coverage 20

Total % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Denawan, Semporna

100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 coverage 20 Total % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

33 Appendix 17: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Southern Reefs 2

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Mabul, Semporna

80 70 60 50 T1 40 T2 30 T3 20 10 0

Total% seagrass coverage 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Gusungan, Semporna

100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 coverage 20 Total % seagrass Total 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Nusa Tengah, Semporna e 100 80 T1 60 T2 40 T3 20 0

Total % seagrass coverag seagrass % Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

34 Appendix 18: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Southern Reefs 3

Percentage of Seagrass coverage at Menampilik, Semporna e 60 50 40 T1 30 T2 20 T3 10 0

Total % seagrass coverag % seagrass Total 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Quadrat (metres from transect origin)

35 Appendix 19: Percentage of Seagrass Coverage in Semporna PCA

Timb a- t imb a

Percentage of Seagrass coverage in Semporna PCA Pom-pom

Mataking

100 Mabul

Kulapuan 80 Pand anan

60 Timbun M ata

Bum-bum 40 Larapan

20 Si Amil

Denawan 0 Gusungan Total %Total seagrass coverage 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Boheyan (0 M) (5 M) (10 M) (15 M) (20 M) (25 M) (30 M) (35 M) (40 M) (45 M) (50 M) Pant au- Pant au Quadrat (metres from transect origin) Omadal S

36

WWF-Malaysia (World Wide Fund for Nature-Malaysia), the national conservation trust, currently runs more than 75 projects covering a diverse range of environmental protection work aimed at conserving our natural resources to secure our good quality of life and our children’s bright future.

WWF’s mission is to stop the degradation of the planet’s natural environment and to build a future in which humans live in harmony with nature by: 1 Conserving the world’s biological diversity 2 Ensuring that the use of renewable natural resources is sustainable 3 Promoting the reduction of pollution and wasteful production

WWF-Malaysia 49, Jalan SS23/15, Taman SEA, 47400 Petaling Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia Tel: +603-78033772 Fax: +603-78035157 E-mail: [email protected] wwf.org.my

37