Of10e of the EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE

Of10E OF ThE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH - KARACHI

No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ /2018, dated: - I-2018

Director (CB), Sindh Public Procurement Regulatory Authority, Government of Sindh, Karachi.

SUBJECT: HOISTING OF BID EVALUATION REPORT ON SPPRA WEBSITE. SPPRA S.#. 35621 DATED 08-12-2017.

With reference to cited above, the Bid Evaluation Reports on prescribed proforma along with Minutes of Bids Opening Meeting, Attendance Sheets, Bidders' Eligibility Reports and Comparative Statements for the works are enclosed herewith for hoisting on SPPRA website please.

End: as above

EXECUTIVE 'INE1((i'&R) DISTRICT MUNICIAtCORPORATION SOUJk

Copy to All concerned.

rr ,

0 OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017.

Method and procedure of procurement: OPEN COMPETITIVE BIDDING (SINGLE STAGE — ONE ENVELOPE)

MINUTES OF 1311) OPENING MEETING Name ol \ork:- Improvement of Sewerage Lines at Kharadar General Hospital and 01 KMA School, UC-5, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 01) P/L I2"Dia Sewerage Pipe Damaged Portion at Tannery Road, Lyari, 02 DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No.02) Improvement of CC, Street No.3 Kulwai Lane UC-14, Lyari, DMC 03 (South), Karachi. (Tender No.03) Improvement of CC, Street No.! & 2 Jadgal Mohalla Lyari, DMC 04 (South), Karachi. (Tender No.04) Improvement of CC Street No.4 in UC -14 Near Mulla Hotel, Lyari, 05 DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No.05) Improvement of CC, Street No.3 at Gabol Road, Lyari, DMC (South), 06 Karachi. (Tender No.06). Replacement of 4", 6" dia AC Water Line by P/L 110mm, 160mm PE 07 Pipe Water Line at Gall No. A2, Al, Singo Lane, Lyari, Karachi. .jiender No.07). P/L 160mm PE Pipe at Singo Lane, Gali No. A3, for improvement of 08 water supply in Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No.08). Replacement of 12" dia RCC I AC Pipe by P/L 315mm PE Pipe at 09 Darya Khan Road, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No.09).

A meeting of the procurement committee of this department was held on 26-12- 2017 at 3:00 p.m. for opening the bids received in respect of subject NITs till the deadlines of submission. The meeting was attended by all! following members of the procurement committee and the representative of bidders. (Attendance sheet are enclosed).

S# NAME OF OFFICER DESIGNATION Executive Engineer (B&R), Lyari Zone, I- Arnanullah Watio DMC (South). Karachi CONVENER / CHAIRMAN Executive Engineer Anwer Au Memon Clifton! KW&SB 2- MEMBER Assistant Accounts Officer 3- Naeem Yousufi DMC (South) l) MEMBER! SECRETARY

Page L of3 - Page -2 -

The following bidders submitted their bids till the deadline of submission:

1- Mis. Aqil Khan Shirani & Brothers. 2- MIs. Mamdani Builders 3- MIs. Asif Enterprises. 4- MIs. Ahmed & Co. 5- Mis. Niaz Muhammad Construction Contractor. 6- MIs. S.M. Builders. 7- Mis. K.Khan & Co. 8- Mis. Bhatti Enterprises. 9- Mis. Jawab Gui & Company 10- Mis.. Hasham & Co.

The bids were opened on 26-12-2017 at 3:00 p.m. in the presence of the above mentioned participants and the rates quoted by bidders were read aloud and encircled by Chairman of the Procurement Committee. All the members of the procurement committee signed each and every page of financial proposal! bids. The bids do not contain any over-writing or cutting. Following is the details of bids announced:

Amount S. . Offered! . . Name of Bidder . of Bid Pay Order 1o./ Date Quoted Price No. Security - TENDER NO.01 01 MIs. Mamdai Builders 997,158 20.000 P/O# 104205587 dated 22-12-2017 MCB, Karachi Nayab Branch 02 M/s. Asif Enterprises 997,457 20,000 P/O#02008530dated22-12-2017 Silk Bank, Site Branch. 03 M/s. S.M Builders 997,657 20,000 PlO # 00586888 dated 15-12-2017 Sindh Bank, Jamshed Qtr TENDER No.02 1 01 M/s. Jawab Gui & 998,012 20,000 PlO # 19525145 dated 26-12-2017 Company HBL, Tamriya Market Br. 02 M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction 998,111 20,000 PlO # 02008478 dated 15-12-2017 Contractor Silk Bank, Site Branch. 03 M/s. Bhatti Enterprises. 998,311 20,000 PlO # 00586889 dated 15-12-2017 Sindh Bank, Jamshed Qtr TENDER No.03 01 M/s. S.M Builders. 997,169 20,000 PlO # 00586866 dated 15-12-20 17 Sindh Bank, Jamshed Qtr. 02 M/s. Ahmed & Co. 997,568 20,000 P!Q# 12055780 dated 15-09-2017 UBL, Mangopir, Br. 03 MIs. Aqil Khan Shirani & I3rothers. 997,767 20,000 P/O#02792964 dated 12-09-2017 MCB, Saddar Branch. 04 MIs. Hasham & Co. 997,867 20,000 PlO # 35962012 dated 24-10-2017 Summit Bank Bahadhar Shah Br.

Page 2 of 3 - Pagc-3-

TENDER No.04 • I 01 Mis. Bhatti Enterprises. 997,294 20,000 P/O# 00586865 dated 15-12-2017 Sindh Bank Jamshed Qtr, Branch 02 M/s. Jawab Gui & Company. 997,594 20,000 PlO If 19525146 dated 26-12-20 17 HBL, Tamriya Market Br. _____ TENDER No.05 01 M/s. S. M. Builders. 997.531 20,000 P/O# 00586864 dated 15-12-2017 Sindh Bank Jamshed Qtr, Branch 02 M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction 997,73 I 20,000 PlO #02008479 dated 15-12-2017 Contractor Silk Bank, Site Branch. TENDER No.06 01 MIs. S. M. Builders. 995,747 20,000 PlO # 00586863 dated 15-12-2017 Sindh Bank, Jamshed Qtr 02 M/s. Asif Enterprises. 995,946 20,000 PlO If 02008531 dated 22-12-20 17 Silk Bank, Site Branch. 03 M/s. Mamdani Builders. 996,344 20,000 PlO # 104205588 dated 22-12-2017 MCB, Karachi Nayab Branch TENDER No.07 01 M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction 997,801 20,000 PlO If 02008474 dated 15-12-2017 Contractor. Silk Bank, Site Branch. 02 M/s. K. Khan & Co. 998,001 20,000 PlO If 005868.90 dated 15-12-2017 Sindh Bank, Jarnshed Qtr 03 M/s. Ahmed & Co 998.200 20.000 P/O# 12055781 dated 15-09-2017 UBL, Mangopir, Br. TENDER No.08 01 M/s. Asif Enterprises. 995,747 20,000 PlO If 02008475 dated 15-12-2017 Silk Bank, Site Branch. 02 M/s. Jawab Gui & Company.. 996,939 20,000 PlO If 19525147 dated 26-12-2017 HBL, Tamriya Market Br. 03 M/s. 1-lasham & Co. 997,932 20,000 P/O If 35962012 dated 24-10-2017 Summit Bank Bahadhar Shah Br. LII. TENDER No.09 01 M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction 998,747 20,000 PlO If 02008525 dated 22-12-20 17 Contractor. Silk Bank, Site Branch. 02 M/s. Aqil Khan Shirani & Brothers 999,147 20,000 P/OIl 02792965 dated 12-09-2017 MCB, Saddar Branch. 03 M/s. Ahmed & Co 999,347 20,000 PlO # 12055782 dated 15-09-2017 UBL, Mangopir, Br.

The committee shall examine all the bids as per the Qualification! eligibility criteria provided in the bidding documents, arithmetical checks and verify the documents and bid security submitted by the bidders.

The meeting ended with the note of thanks to and from the chair.

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeem)c'ó"6ufi) (Arnanul a 9tio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive EnØ1eer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari ZonM1 MC (South), Karachi

page 3 of 3 * • t

ATTENDANCE SHEET

OF PROCUREMENT COMMITTEE

AT THE OFFICE OF EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R) LYARI ZONE, DMC (SOUTH) 3 Floor, TMA Office, Chakiwara No. 01, Shahrah-e-Abdul Raheem, Lyari, Karachi DATED: 26-12-2017

s # NAME OF OFFICER DESIGNATION SIGNATURE

Executive Engineer AMANULLAB WATIO (B&R), Lyari Zone, 1. DMC (South), Karachi.

Assistant Accounts NAEEM YOUSUFI 2 Officer, DMC (South) Karachi.

Executive Engineer 3. ANWAR ALl MEMON (Clifton), KW&SB

'-4

ATTENDAN CE SHEET

OF CONTACTORS FOR OPENING OF TENDERS

AT THE OFFICE OF EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R) LYARI ZONE, DMC (SOUTH) 3rd floor, TMA Office, Chakiwara No. 01, Shahrah-e-Abdul Raheem, Lyari, Karachi

DATED: 26-12-2017

s # NAME OF CONTRACTORS / REPRESENTATIVES SIGNATURE j 2 3 4. — T i'JJ ,, M ! 5; n/j

r\\ c., ) '/1 ,c /q' , ;/ K che (> 1) ciL( i(7.

—i-i

VII!!') (Anwer Mi Memon) (Naeezh Yolisufi) (Amanull t)o) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En eer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zo -. MC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONf/DMC(S)/ 871/2017, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 Tender Description! Name of Improvement of Sewerage Lines at Kharadar General Hospital and KMA Work / Item School, UC-5, Lyari, DMC (Soutj), Karachi. (Tender No. 01) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-20 17. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A app licab le) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A (if applicable) 10 Bid rejected Nil 11 Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00 pm 12. Bid Evaluation Report. COST 1 RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR I OFFERRED s # TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE I REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS P/O # 104205587 MIs. Mamdani E.0 996,660 997,158 dated 22-12-2017 Builders 1st Lowest Responsive Bid MCB, Karachi Nayab 0.05% Above Branch Rs.20,000 P/O # 02008530 MIs. Asif E.0 996,660 997457 nd dated 22-12-2017 2 Enterprises Lowest -do- Silk Bank, Site 0.08% Above Branch. Rs.20,000 PlO # 00586888 M/s. S.M E.0 996,660 dated 15-12-2017 997,657 3 Builders 3id Lowest -do- Sindh Bank, 0.10% Above Jamshed Qtr Rs.20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly.

MIs. Mamdani Builders was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer All Mernon) (Naeem ufi) Ama,atio Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive E /gineer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi 1)MC (South), Karachi Lyari Zopt

OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Improvement of Sewerage Lines at Kharadar General Hospital and KMA School, UC-5, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 01)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

Eligibility/Qualification M/s Asif Enterprises s.# M/s. S.M Builders

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Years 60.219(M) 62.160(M) 75.989(M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed I Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified I disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest) (3rd Lowest)

\ /n (Anwer All Memon) (NaeemYu ti) (Amai(uhIi,Watio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Engieer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zote'DMC (South), Karachi

DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: Improvement of Sewerage Lines at Kharadar General Hospital and KMA School, UC-5, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No.01)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1St Lowest 2ndLowest -L 3rd Lowest ENGINEERINGS ESTIMATE M/s Nlamdani Builders M/s Asif Enterprises M/s. S.M Builders PREMIUM I AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) T PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part ( A) Total of Schedule Rs: 996,660 996,660 996660 996,660 %Above / Below Rs: 0.05% Above 498 0.08% Above 797 0.10% Above 997 Total Rs: 996,660 997,158 997,457 997,657

Part ( B) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Gross Total Rs: 996,660 997,158 997,457 997,657

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeen1'S''sufi) (Ama o) Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive E neer(B&R) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi. Lyari Zo DMC (South)

OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency - District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /20 17, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 TenderDescription/Nameof P/L 12"Dia Sewerage Pipe Damaged Portion at Tannery Road, Lyari, DMC Work / Item (South), Karachi.(Tender No.02) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published . SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-20 17. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A (if applicable) !0 Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-2017 at 3:00pm 12. Bid Evaluation Renort. COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED s # TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS PlO # 19525145 M/s. Jawab GuI E.0 998,311 dated 26-12-2017 998,012 and Company 1st Lowest Responsive Bid HBL, Tamriya 0.03 % Below Market Br. Rs. 20,000 M/s. Niaz P/O U 02008478 Muhammad E.0 998,311 dated 15-12-2017 998,111 2 Construction 2 Lowest -do- Silk Bank, Site Contractor 0.02 % Below Branch. Rs.20,000

PlO U 00586889 M/s. Bhatti E.0 998,3 1 1 dated 15-12-2017 998,311 3 Enterprises 3rd Lowest -do- Sindh Bank, At Par Jamshed Qtr Brach. Rs.20,000

I'hc Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly.

M/s. Jawab GuI and Company was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

1,. , (Anwer Au Memon) (Naeem • tj) (Amanu I. atlo) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive E •ineer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi 1)MC (South), Karachi Lyari Zi e, DMC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: PIL 12"Dia Sewerage Pipe Damaged Portion at Tannery Road, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi.(Tender No.02)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

M/s. Niaz Eligibility! Qualification M/s. Jawab GuI and Muhammad S.# M/s. Bhatti Criteria Company Construction Enterprises Contractor

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Years 52.927 (M) 73.865 (M) . 63.901 (M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) - No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes . Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed / Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2 Lowest) (31d Lowest) _____

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem 'o'ufi) (Aman'uhIii io) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En• eer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zo ', MC (South), Karachi DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: P/L 12"Dia Sewerage Pipe Damaged Portion at Tannery Road, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi.(Tender No.02)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1St Lowest 3rd Lowest -,- 2ndLowest ENGINEERING'S ESTIMATE M/s. Niaz Muhammad MIs. Jawab Gui and Company M/s. Bhatti Enterprises Construction Contractor PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM I AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part (A) Total of Schedule Items Rs: 998,311 998,311 998,311 998,311 %Above / Below Rs: 0.03 % Below 299 0.02 % Below 200 At Par 0 Total Rs: 998,311 998,012 998,111 998,311

Part(B)TotalAddOfferRate Rs: NIL Offer Rate NIL Offer Rate NIL Offer Rate NIL Gross Total Rs: 998,311 998,012 998,111 998,311

(Naee YoLlsufi) (Anwer Au Memon) (AmaiuIáhWtio) Assistant Accounts Officer DMC Executive Engineer(Clifton) Executive Epineer(B&R) (South)Karachi. KW&SB (South) Lyari Zn DMC (South) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORMION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /20 17, dated: 07-12-20 17. 3 Tender Description! Name of Improvement of CC, Street No.3 Kulwai Lane UC-14, Lyari, DMC (South), Work / Item Karachi. (Tender No.03) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage—One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 04 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 04 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A fapplicabIe) 30 Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-2017 at 3:00pm 12. Bid Evaluation Renort. COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED s # TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE I REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS PLO # 00586866 M/s. S.M E.0 997,169 dated 15-12-2017 997,169 Builders Lowest Responsive Bid Sindh Bank, At Par JamshedQtr. Branch.Rs 20,000 P/O U 12055780 M/s. Ahmed & E.0 997,169 997,568 2nd dated 15-09-2017 2 Lowest -do-. Co UBL Mangopir, Br. Rs O.04%Above 20,000 M/s Aqil Khan E.0 997,169 P/Ol02792964 dated Shirani & 997,767 3rd 12-09-2017 Lowest -do- Brothers MCB, Saddar Branch. O.06%Above Rs 20,000 P/a U 35962012 M/s. Hasham & E.0 997,169 dated 24-10-2017 997,867 4 Co 4th Lowest -do- Summit Bank O.07%Above Bahadhar Shah Branch.Rs 20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly.

M/s. S.M Builders was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeem V'I fi) (AmaIhfla4i atio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En eer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zo , DMC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE a EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Improvement of CC, Street No.3 Kulwai Lane UC-14, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi.(Tender No.03)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

Eligibility! Qualification MIs. S.M M/s. Ahmed M/s Aqil Khan S.# Mis. Hasham Criteria Builders & Co & Co Brothers 1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Yes Years 75.989(M) 72.024(M) 64.198(M) 63.346(M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed / Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (2fld (3rd (4th (Lowest) Lowest) Lowest) Lowest)

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeem Ydtsufi) (Ama io) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive E er(B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari\Zone MC (South), arachi DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name of work Improvement of CC, Street No.3 Kulwai Lane UC-14, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No.03) RATES QUOTED BY: 1st Lowest 2ndLowest 3rd Lowest 4th Lowest ENGINEERING"S ESTIMATE M/s Aqil Khan Shirani & M/s. S.NI Builders M/s. Ahmed & Co MIs. Hasham & Co Brothers PREMIUM [AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM [ AMOUNT (Rs. PREMIUM I AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM IAMOUNT (Rs.)

Part ( A) Total of Schedule Rs: 997,169 997,169 997,169 997,169 997,169 %Above / Below Rs: AtPar 0 O.04%Above 399 O.06%Above 598 O.07%Above 698 Total Rs: 997,169 997,169 997,568 997,767 997,867

Part ( B ) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Gross Total Rs: 997,169 997,169 997,568 997,767 997,867

(Anwer Au Memon) (AmanuI Watlo) Executive Engineer(Clifton) (Naeem Yousufi) Executive Engitleer(B&R) KW&SB (South) Assistant Accounts Officer DMC (South)Karachi. Lyan Zon,lMC (South) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi.

2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871/2017, dated: 07-12-2017.

3 Tender Description/ Name of Improvement of CC, Street No.1 & 2 Jadgal Mohalla Lyari, DMC (South), Work / Item Karachi. (Tender No. 04) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System)

5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-20 17.

6 Total Bid Documents Sold 02 Nos.

7 Total Bid Received 02 Nos.

8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A (if applicable) 10 Bid rejected Nil

11 Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00pm

12. Bid Evaluation Report.

COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED S.# TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS P/a fl 00586865 MIs. Bhatti E.0 997095 dated 15-12-2017 997294 Enterprises Lowest Responsive Bid Sindh Bank Jamshed 0.02% Above Qtr, Branch Rs.20,000 PlO I 19525146 M/s. Jawad GuI E.0 997,095 dated 26-12-2017 2 and Company 2 Lowest -do- HBL, Tamriya 0.05% Above Market Branch. Rs.20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly. MIs. Bliatti Enterprises was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer All Memon) (I' (Amanb1 ab atio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En neer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zo , DMC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-1 2-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Improvement of CC, Street No.1 & 2 Jadgal Mohalla Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 04)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

Eligibility! Qualification M/s. Bhatti M/s. Jawab GuI and S# Criteria Enterprises Company

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Years 63.901 (M) 52.927 (M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction I Overwriting Signed / Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest)

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem '6ufi) (Amathilah/Watio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Eijgineer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zoji DMC (South), Karachi DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: Improvement of CC, Street No.1 & 2 Jadgal Mohallà Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 04)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1St Lowest 2ndLowest ENGINEERINGS ESTIMATE MIs. Jawab Gui & Mis. Bhatti Enterprises Company PREMIUM !AMOUNT (Rs.)! PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part ( A ) Tota' of Schedule items Rs: 9,97,095 - 997,095 997,095 %Above I Below Rs: -- 0.02% Above 199 0.05% Above 499 Total Rs: 9,97,095 997,294 997,594

Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate NH Gross Total Rs: 9,97,095 997,294 997,594

(Amanulrah wattj (Anwer Au Mémon) (Naeem LYoufi) Executive Engtnéer(B&R) Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Lyari Zone,..DMC (South) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi. OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of ProcuringAgency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 TenderDéscription/Nameof Improvement of CC Street No.4 in UC -14 Near Mulla Hotel, Lyari, DMC Work / Item (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 05) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 02 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 02 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified . N/A (if applicable) 10 Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00pm 12. Bid EvaluationReport. COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS PIG if 00586864 M/s. S.M E.0 996,734 dated 15-12-2017 997,531 Builders 1st Lowest Responsive Bid Sindh Bank Jamshed 0.08% Above Qtr, Branch. Rs. 20,000 M/s. Niaz PlO if 02008479 Muhammad E.0 996,734 dated 15-12-2017 997,731 2 Construction 2nd Lowest -do- Silk Bank, Site Contractor 0.10% Above Branch. Rs. 20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly.

M/s. S.M Builders was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem difi) (Ama . a - 'atio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive E ' eer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zone, DMC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Improvement of CC Street No.4 in UC -14 Near MuIla Hotel, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 05)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

M/s. Niaz Muhammad Eligibility! Qualification S•# M/s. S.M Builders Criteria Construction Contractor

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Years 75.989 (M) 73.865 (M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed I Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest)

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem's rufi) (Amaitila1iWatio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive 1gineer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi LyariZoie, 1)MC (South), Karachi

DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: Improvement of CC Street No.4 in UC -14 Near Mulla Hotel, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 05)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1st Lowest 2ndLowest ENGINEERING'S ESTIMATE M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction M/s. S.M Builders Contracrtor PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part ( A) Total of Schedule Items Rs: 996,734 996,734 996,734 %Above I Below Rs: 0.08 % Above 797 0.10% Above 997 Total Rs: 996,734 997,531 997,731

Part ( B ) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Offer Rate Offer Rate Gross Total Rs: 996,734 997,531 997,731

(Anwer Ali Memon) (Naeem'Yoü'sufi) (Ama nIflh'Watio4' Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En9ineeflB&R) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi. Lyari Zone, DMC (South) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 Tender Description! Name of Improvement of CC, Street No.3 at Cabol Road, Lyari, DMC (South), Work I Item Karachi. (Tender No. 06) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-20 17. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualifid N/A (if applicable) 10 Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00pm 12. Bid Evaluation Report. COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED s # TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS - P/O #00586863 M/s. S.M E.0 995,150 995,747 1st dated 15-12-2017 Builders Lowest Responsive Bid Sindh Bank, Jamshed 0.06% Above Qtr,Brach.Rs.20,000 P/O#02008531 M/s. Asif E.0 995,150 995,946 dated 22-12-2017 2 Enterprises 2 Lowest -do- Silk Bank, Site 0.08% Above Branch. Rs.20,000 PlO # 104205588 M/s. Mamdani E.0 995,150 996,344 dated 22-12-2017 3 Builders 3 Lowest -do- MCB, Karachi Nayab 0.12% Above Branch. Rs.20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly.

MIs. S.M Builders was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeemufi) (Amaiiuila4,Watio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Egineer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zone, DMC (South), /Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Improvement of CC, Street No.3 at Gabol Road, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 06)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

MIs. S.M M/s. Asif T Eiigibility/Qualification M/s. Mamdani S# Criteria Builders Enterprises Builders

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes . Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Years 75.989(M) 62.160(M) 60.219(M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed / Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified I disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest) (31d Lowest)

(Anw'er Au Niemon) (Naeem YotMifi) (Ama atlo) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive gineer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi 1)MC (South), Karachi Lyari Z e, DMC (South), Karachi

DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: Improvement of CC, Street No.3 at Gabol Road, Lyari, DMC (South), Karachi. (Tender No. 06)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1st Lowest 2ndLowest 3rd Lowest •1 ENGINEERING'S ESTIMATE M/s. S.M Builders M/s. Asif Enterprises M/s. Mamdani Builders

PREMIUM TAMOUNT (Rs.)l PREMIUM I AMOUNT (Rs.) t PREMIUM I AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part (A) Total of Rs: 995,150 995,150 995,150 995,150 %Above I Below Rs: 0.06% Above 597 0.08% Above 796 0.12%Above 1,194 Total Rs: 995,150 995,747 995,946 996,344

(B ) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Gross Total Rs: 995,150 995,747 995,946 996,344

(AnwerAli Memon) (Naeenv4(o'tufi) (Amanullah .tio) Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En neer(B&R) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi. Lyari Zon:, DMC (South) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 Tender Description! Name of Replacement of 4", 6" dia AC Water Line by P/L 110mm, 160mm PE Pipe Work / Item Water Line at Gali No. A2, Al, Singo Lane, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No.07) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-20 17. 6 lotal Rid E)ocumenis Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A (if applicable) 10 Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00pm 12. id Evaluation Report. COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE I REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS M/s. Niaz PlO # 02008474 Muhammad E.0 996,904 dated 15-12-2017 Silk 997,801 Construction 1 Lowest Responsive Bid Bank, Site Brnach. Contractor 0.09%Above Rs. 20,000

P/O U 00586890 M/s. K. Khan & E.0 996,904 998,001 dated 15-12-2017 2 Co. 2nd Lowest -do- Sindh Bank, Jamshed 0.11% Above Qtr, Brnach.Rs. 20,000 P/O U 12055781 M/s. Ahmed & E.0 996,904 998,200 dated 15-09-2017 3 Co. 3rd Lowest -do- UBL, Mangopir, 0.13%Above Brnach.Rs. 20,000

The Concerned biddcr is being informed accordingi>

M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction Contractor was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem'YWufi) (Amala1i atio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En' eer ( 13&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zon MC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Replacement of 4", 6" dia AC Water Line by P/L 110mm, 160mm PE Pipe Water Line at Gali No. A2, Al, Singo Lane, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No.07)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

M/s. Niaz Muhammad M/s. K. Khan Eligibility! Qualification M/s. Ahmed & S•# Criteria Construction & Co. Co. Contractor

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Years 73.865(M) 71.754(M) 72.024(M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes . Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed / Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified I disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest) (31d Lowest)

(Anwer All Memon) (NaeemA'1sufi) (Aman ' 1 ah . tb) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive En: eer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zon , I MC (South), Karachi DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: Replacement of 4", 6" dia AC Water Line by PIL 110mm, 160mm PE Pipe Water Line at Gali No. A2, Al, Singo Lane, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No.07)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1st Lowest a 2ndLowest 1 3rd Lowest ENGINEERING'S ESTIMATE M/s. Niaz Muhammad M/s. K. Khan & Co M/s. Ahmed & Co. Construction Contractor PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.)l PREMIUM IAMOUNT (Rs.) I PREMIUM IAMOUNT (Rs.)

Part(A)Totalof Schedule Rs: 996,904 996,904 996,904 996,904 Items %Above I Below Rs: O.09%Above 897 0.11% Above 1,097 0.13%Above 1296 Total Rs: 996,904 997,801 998,001 998,200

Part ( B ) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Gross Total Rs: 996,904 997,801 998,001 998,200

(AnwerAli Memon) (Naeem2f'i16ufi) (AmanIIäh Wtio) Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Er)gt'neer(B&R) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi. Lyari ZonKDMC (South) V

OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. •2 Tender Reference No. EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 Tender Description! Name of P/L 160mm 1'E Pipe at Singo Lane, Gali No. A3, for Improvement of water Work / Item supply in Lyari, Karachi.(Tender Nt). 08) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-20 17. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A (if applicable) lO Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00pm 12. Bid Evaluation Report. COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE I REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS P/O 1*02008475 dated M/s. Asif E C 992,967 Responsive 15-12-2017 Silk Bank, Enterprises 1' Lowest Bid Site Brnach.Rs. 20000 0.28 %Above

P/O 1* 19525147 dated M/s. Jawab GuI E.0 992,967 996,939 26-12-2017 2 2nd Lowest -do- and Company HBL, Tamriya Market 0.40% Above Brnach.Rs. 20000 P/o 1*35962012 dated M/s. Hasham & E.0 992,967 24-10-2017 997,932 3 Co. 3rd Lowest -do- Summit Bank 0.50 %Above Bahadhar Shah Brnach.Rs. 20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly.

M/s. Asif Enterprises was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem'4Vsufi) (Amanult tio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive EniIeer (B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zon,p'flMC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-1 2-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method and Procedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: PIL 160mm PE Pipe at Singo Lane, Gali No. A3, for Improvement of water supply in Lyari, Karachi.(Tender No. 08)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

M/s. Jawab M/s. Asif Eligibility! Qualification GuI and M/s. Hasham S.# . . Enterprises Criteria Company

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Years 62.160 (M) 52.927 (M) 63.346 (M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction I Overwriting Signed I Stamped by Bidders 9.. Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest) (31d Lowest)

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeem o.ifi) (Amañta yao) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Eniner ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zon)4MC (SOuth), Karachi

DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: P/L 160mm PE Pipe at Singo Lane, Gall No. A3, for Improvement of water supply in Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No. 08) RATES QUOTED BY: 1st Lowest 2ndLowest 3rd Lowest ENGINEERING"S ESTIMATE M/s. Asif Enterprises M/s. Jawab Gui & Company M/s. Hasham & Co

PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) T PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM 1 AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part ( A) Total of Schedule Items Rs: 992,967 992,967 992,967 992,967 %Above I Below Rs: 0.28% Above 2,780 0.40% Above 3,972 0.50% Above 4,965 Total Rs: 992,967 995,747 996,939 997,932

Part ( B ) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Gross Total Rs: 992,967 995,747 996,939 997,932

(Naeem i'oüufi) (Ama Wafio) (Anwer All Memon) Executive E gineer(B&R) Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Lyari Zo9-OMC (South) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi.

OFFICE OF ThE EXECUTIVE EN GINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

BID EVALUATION REPORT

1 Name of Procuring Agency District Municipal Corporation (South), Karachi. 2 Tender Reference No. EEILYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. 3 Tender Description! Name of Replacement of 12" dia RCC / AC Pipe by P/L 315mm PE Pipe at Darya Work / Item Khan Road, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No. 09) 4 Method of Procurement (Single Stage — One Envelope System) 5 Tender Published SPPRA Website at serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017. 6 Total Bid Documents Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bid Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date (if N/A applicable) 9 No. of Bid Technically Qualified N/A (if applicable) 10 Bid rejected Nil II Financial Bid Opening Date 26-12-20 17 at 3:00pm 12. Bid Evaluation Report. CoST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASON FOR NAME OF FIRM OR OFFERRED s # TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATED ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS BIDEDER BY THE COST COST REJECTION BIDDERS M/s. Niaz . P/O #020088525 Muhammad E.0 999,747 dated 22-12-2017 Silk 998747 Construction lILowest Responsive Bid Bank, Site Branch. Contractor 0.10 % Below Rs. 20,000

M/s Aqil Khan E.0 999,747 P/O#02792965 dated Shirani & 999,147 2nd 12-09-2017 2 Lowest -do- Brothers MCB, Saddar Branch. 0.06 %Below Rs. 20,000 PlO # 12055782 E.0 999,747 M/s Ahmed & Co 999,347 3rd dated 15-09-2017 Lowest -do- UBL, Mangopir, 0.04 % Below . Branch. Rs. 20,000

The Concerned bidder is being informed accordingly. M/s. Niaz Muhammad Construction Contractor was declared as the lowest responsive bidder.

Signature of the members of Procurement Committee.

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeem'Yufi) (Ama fll. h)Wátib) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Engtheer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zon,j(DMC (South), Karachi OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R), LYARI ZONE DISTRICT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION SOUTH — KARACHI

NIT NO: EE/LYZONE/DMC(S)/ 871 /2017, dated: 07-12-2017. Hoisted on SPPRA Serial No. 35621 dated 08-12-2017.

Method andProcedure: Open Competitive Bidding (Single Stage — One Envelope)

Description of Work: Replacement of 12" dia RCC / AC Pipe by PIL 315mm PE Pipe at Darya Khan Road, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No. 09)

BIDDER'S ELIGIBILITY! QUALIFICATION REPORT

MIs. Niaz M/s. Aqil Muhammad Eligibility! Qualification Khan Shirani M/s. Ahmed & S•# Construction Criteria & Brothers Co. Contractor

1. NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 2. Registration with Sindh Yes Yes Yes Revenue Board (SRB) 3. Minimum three Years Yes Yes Yes Experience of Relevant Field 4. Turnover of at least three Yes Yes Yes Years 73.865(M) 64.198(M) 72.024(M) 5. List of Litigation (if any) No No No 6. Affidavit that firm has never Affidavit Affidavit Affidavit been Blacklisted Attached Attached Attached 7. Required Bid Security is Yes Yes Yes Attached. 8. Bid is Signed, Named and Yes Yes Yes Stamped by the Authorized Person of the Firm, Correction / Overwriting Signed I Stamped by Bidders 9. Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified (Lowest) (2fld Lowest) (31d Lowest)

(Anwer All Memon) (Naeem oufi) (Amaniil!a'li,Watio) Executive Engineer (Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Enjiiieer ( B&R) KW&SB, Karachi DMC (South), Karachi Lyari Zoije'DMC (South), Karachi

DISTRICT MUNICIPAL COPORATION (SOUTH) KARACHI EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (B&R)

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

Name Of Work: . Replacement of 12" dia RCC / AC Pipe by PIL 315mm PE Pipe at Darya Khan Road, Lyari, Karachi. (Tender No. 09)

RATES QUOTED BY: 1st Lowest 2ndLowest 3rd Lowest ENGINEERING'S ESTIMATE M/s. Niaz Muhammad M/s Aqil Khan Shirani & Brothers M/s Ahmed & Co Construction Contractor PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.) PREMIUM AMOUNT (Rs.)

Part (A) Total o Schedule Items Rs: 999,747 999,747 999,747 999,747 %Above / Below Rs: ______0.10% Below 1,000 0.06 % Below 600 0.04 % Below 400 Total Rs: 999,747 998,747 999,147 999,347

Part ( B ) Total Add Offer Rate Rs: Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Offer Rate Nil Gross Total Rs: 999,747 998,747 999,147 999,347

(Anwer Au Memon) (Naeenc'YtIsufi) (Amariu/ Watio) Executive Engineer(Clifton) Assistant Accounts Officer Executive Engineer(B&R) KW&SB (South) DMC (South)Karachi. Lyari Zone(bMC (South) /