The Life of an Anise-Flavored Alcoholic Beverage: Does Its Stability Cloud Or Confirm Theory?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Langmuir 2008, 24, 1701-1706 1701 The Life of an Anise-Flavored Alcoholic Beverage: Does Its Stability Cloud or Confirm Theory? Elke Scholten,†,§ Erik van der Linden,*,† and Herve This‡ Food Physics Group, Department of Agrotechnology and Food Sciences, Wageningen UniVersity, Bomenweg 2, 6703 HD Wageningen, The Netherlands, and INRA Group of Molecular Gastronomy, Laboratory of Chemistry, UMR 214 INRA/AgroParisTech, 16 rue Claude Bernard, 75005 Paris, France ReceiVed July 19, 2007. In Final Form: NoVember 6, 2007 The well-known alcoholic beverage Pastis becomes turbid when mixed with water due to the poor solubility of trans-anethol, the anise-flavored component of Pastis in the water solution formed. This destabilization appears as the formation of micrometer-sized droplets that only very slowly grow in size, thus expanding the life of the anise- flavored beverage. The slow growth has been attributed to an extremely low interfacial tension of the droplets. Fitting experimental droplet growth rates to an Ostwald ripening model, interfacial tensions were deduced in the past. Direct determination of the interfacial tensions was not yet reported on these systems. We have measured the interfacial tensions and used these data to predict droplet growth rates using an Ostwald ripening model and a model for creaming of the droplets. The interfacial tension was measured to be about 11 mN/m for a 30/70 w/w % ethanol/water mixture, and it decreases slightly to a value of 1.4 mN/m in the case of a 70/30 w/w % ethanol/water mixture. These values are not as low as those deduced in the past. The theoretical predictions for both the Ostwald ripening rates and the creaming rates, using the directly measured interfacial tensions, are found to contradict with the experimental results on Ostwald ripening and creaming. While the experiments on Ostwald ripening show an increase in stability with increasing ethanol concentration, the results based on our interfacial tension measurements in combination with the same Ostwald ripening model show a decrease in stability with an increase in ethanol concentration. Further research is needed to understand fully which parameters play a role in both droplet growth and the stability of these three- component emulsions to elucidate the current discrepancy between model and experiment. This could be useful for a better control of “spontaneous emulsification” processes. 1. Introduction causes the oil droplets to form in the solution due to the supersaturation of the oil. The tremendous decrease in solubility In Mediterranean countries, anise-flavored alcoholic beverages due to the addition of water causes a very large supersaturation, are frequently consumed. These beverages include, for example, so that many nuclei form from small fluctuations in concentration. Pastis, Pernod, Ricard (in France), Ouzo (in Greece), Raki (in Although the amount of oil is small, it results in the appearance Turkey), and Sambuca (in Italy). All appear transparent when of a large number of small droplets, since the initial rate of bottled, with an ethanol content around 40% (v/v). Many nucleation is extremely large. These droplets are of the order of manufacturers offer advice to drink this Pastis-like beverage the size of 1 µm or less. Due to the many droplets in the solution, (PLB) with the addition of water (dilution of about 5 times), after visible light gets multiply scattered within the solution, and the which the drink spontaneously changes into an opaque, milky resulting diffusive motion of the light makes the solution to white solution. This phenomenon is known as the Pastis effect1 2,3 appear milky white. The systems created by addition of water or Ouzo effect. Some research has been performed on this to PLBs can therefore be regarded as emulsions, where the oil beverage to gain insight into this physical phenomenon. When is distributed as small droplets in another liquid. However, there bottled, PLBs are three-component homogeneous solutions is a distinct difference between most food emulsions and the composed of water (about 55%), alcohol (about 45%), and “oil” emulsions created by the addition of water to PLBs. The first (about 0.1%). This “oil” consists mainly of trans-anethol, which difference is that most food emulsions are stabilized (indeed it is an ester with a very specific odor that gives its unique anise is only metastability) by one or more surfactants that migrate smell to these beverages. Anethol is soluble in ethanol but toward the water/oil interface, whereas the emulsion formed extremely insoluble in water (calculated log P of 2.91). When from PLBs does not contain an emulsifier. The second difference bottled, the ratio between the ethanol, water, and oil is chosen is that, to make normal emulsions with droplet sizes of the order in such a way that the oil is still soluble in the mixture, so the of 1 µm, energy (e.g., mechanical energy such as in homog- mixture appears transparent. However, when the alcoholic enization) is required to compensate for the important increase beverage is poured into water, the oil is no longer soluble. This in surface energy (about 1 J for a 100 mL drink). However, the emulsification process of the PLB mixing with water does not * To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: erik. require the addition of any form of mechanical energy. Therefore, [email protected]. † Wageningen University. this process is called “spontaneous emulsification”. It is nowadays ‡ UMR 214 INRA/AgroParisTech. frequently used for the production of nanocapsules and nano- § Current affiliation: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department particles,4,5 which makes it possible to create particles smaller of Chemical Engineering, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, Mas- than those created with conventional methods, such as solvent sachusetts 02139. (1) Grillo, I. Colloids Surf., A 2003, 225, 153-160. (2) Vitale, S. A.; Katz, J. L. Langmuir 2003, 19, 4105-4110. (4) Ganachaud, F.; Katz, J. L. ChemPhysChem 2005, 6, 209-216. (3) Sitnikova, N. L.; Sprik, R.; Wegdam, G.; Eiser, E. Langmuir 2005, 21, (5) Bouchemal, K.; Briancon, S.; Perrier, E.; Fessi, H.; Bonnet, I.; Zydowicz, 7083-7089. N. Int. J. Pharm. 2004, 269,89-100. 10.1021/la702186g CCC: $40.75 © 2008 American Chemical Society Published on Web 01/24/2008 1702 Langmuir, Vol. 24, No. 5, 2008 Scholten et al. evaporation techniques. This technique can also be used to create the continuous phase is also at its saturation level. To saturate the small nanospheres, liposomes, and vesicles.4 ethanol/water mixtures, we added an excess of trans-anethol to the Measurements performed with various techniques, such as solution. The mixtures were then heated up to 35 °C, 10 °C above small angle light scattering, small angle neutron scattering, the desired temperature of the experiments, to increase the solubility of the oil into the mixtures. This ensured full saturation of the mixtures electrical resistance, and dynamic light scattering, mostly show ° 1,2,3,6 when the temperature was lowered down to 25 C. The excess trans- that the droplet diameters are of the order of 1 µm, though anethol was centrifuged down, as the density of the used ethanol/ some experiments even show that the size of the droplets can water mixtures was lower than that of the oil. The oil-saturated 6 be as small as 200 nm. This is rather small, as no mechanical mixtures were then poured into a cuvette. A millimeter-sized droplet agitation is used. Several experiments have followed the increase of trans-anethol was inserted in the ethanol/water mixtures using a of the size of the droplets with time. Although the size appears syringe, equipped with a needle, and its size was determined by the to increase slightly in the beginning, it stabilizes after a few software. Since ethanol is soluble in the oil droplets, little diffusion hours; PLB-based emulsions can then stay stable for days, weeks, of ethanol into the droplets was expected. We therefore measured or even months. The initial size of the droplets and the droplet the volume of the droplet and the interfacial tension in time. As the size obtained after stabilization depend on the ethanol/water ratio volume of the droplets (and the interfacial tension) did not change and the amount of oil present in the system. Experiments1,3 also significantly during time, we assumed the system to be in equilibrium. Since the size of the droplet did not change, we assumed the density indicated that the growth of the droplets immediately after of the oil droplet to be unchanged and constant throughout the time nucleation of the oil is obtained via a process called Ostwald span of the experiment. The droplet size and its shape were then ripening rather than through droplet coalescence. Both coales- used to calculate the interfacial tension with the use of the density cence and Ostwald ripening can be studied by monitoring the difference between the trans-anethol and the ethanol/water mixtures. droplet size with time. Droplet growth via coalescence occurs In practice, the ethanol/water mixtures were poured into a sample due to the merging of two or multiple droplets, and the volume holder of a few milliliters. A syringe with a curved needle was of the droplets increases exponentially in time. The growth of inserted into the mixture. The end of the needle was facing up so the droplets due to Ostwald ripening does not depend on the that the droplets were placed on top of the needle. Using a needle merging of droplets but rather by the diffusive transport of the facing upward prevents the droplets from falling down, and gives dissolved oil through the medium, and this process is characterized the droplet a more oblate spheroid shape rather than a prolate spheroid by a linear droplet growth in time.