Mitochondrial DNA of Ancient Cumanians: Culturally Asian Steppe Nomadic Immigrants with Substantially More Western Eurasian Mitochondrial DNA Lineages
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by SZTE Publicatio Repozitórium - SZTE - Repository of Publications Mitochondrial DNA of Ancient Cumanians: Culturally Asian Steppe Nomadic Immigrants with Substantially More Western Eurasian Mitochondrial DNA Lineages Erika Bogacsi-Szabo, Tibor Kalmar, Bernadett Csanyi, Gyongyver Tomory, Agnes Czibula, Katalin Priskin, Ferenc Horvath, Christopher Stephen Downes, Istvan Rasko Human Biology, Volume 77, Number 5, October 2005, pp. 639-662 (Article) Published by Wayne State University Press DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/hub.2006.0007 For additional information about this article https://muse.jhu.edu/article/192977 Access provided by University of Liverpool (5 Jan 2017 14:18 GMT) Mitochondrial DNA of Ancient Cumanians: Culturally Asian Steppe Nomadic Immigrants with Substantially More Western Eurasian Mitochondrial DNA Lineages ERIKA BOGA´CSI-SZABO´ ,1 TIBOR KALMA´ R,1 BERNADETT CSA´ NYI,1 GYO¨ NGYVE´ R TO¨ MO¨ RY,1 A´GNES CZIBULA,1 KATALIN PRISKIN,1 FERENC HORVA´TH,2 CHRISTOPHER STEPHEN DOWNES,3 AND ISTVA´ N RASKO´ 1 Abstract The Cumanians were originally Asian pastoral nomads who in the 13th century migrated to Hungary. We have examined mitochondrial DNA from members of the earliest Cumanian population in Hungary from two archeologically well-documented excavations and from 74 modern Hun- garians from different rural locations in Hungary. Haplogroups were defined based on HVS I sequences and examinations of haplogroup-associated poly- morphic sites of the protein coding region and of HVS II. To exclude con- tamination, some ancient DNA samples were cloned. A database was created from previously published mtDNA HVS I sequences (representing 2,615 individuals from different Asian and European populations) and 74 modern Hungarian sequences from the present study. This database was used to de- termine the relationships between the ancient Cumanians, modern Hungari- ans, and Eurasian populations and to estimate the genetic distances between these populations. We attempted to deduce the genetic trace of the migration of Cumanians. This study is the first ancient DNA characterization of an eastern pastoral nomad population that migrated into Europe. The results indicate that, while still possessing a Central Asian steppe culture, the Cu- manians received a large admixture of maternal genes from more westerly populations before arriving in Hungary. A similar dilution of genetic, but not cultural, factors may have accompanied the settlement of other Asian nomads in Europe. Driven by the Mongol invasions of the 13th century, a tribal confederation of pastoral nomads known in Europe as Cumanians (called Polovici in Russian, Valben in German, Comains in French, and Quibcˇa˜q in Arabic-Persian sources or in their own tongue, Qunok) moved from the Trans-Carpathian steppes into 1Institute of Genetics, Biological Research Center of Hungarian Academy of Sciences, PO Box 521, H-6701 Szeged, Hungary. 2Mo´ra Ferenc Museum of Szeged, Szeged, Hungary. 3School of Biomedical Sciences, University of Ulster Coleraine, County Londonderry, BT52 1SA, North- ern Ireland. Human Biology, October 2005, v. 77, no. 5, pp. 639–662. Copyright ᭧ 2005 Wayne State University Press, Detroit, Michigan 48201-1309 KEY WORDS: ANCIENT mtDNA, mtDNA, HVS I, HVS II, CUMANIANS, HUNGARIANS. ................. 15723$ $CH5 12-20-05 14:23:45 PS PAGE 639 640 / boga´csi-szabo´ et al. the territory of Hungary, which had been devastated by the Mongol hordes (Be- rend 2001; Marquart 1914; Ne´meth 1941; Selmeczi 1992). Before the Mongol invasion it was the Hungarian king Be´la IV (1235–1270) himself who welcomed the Cumanians to the country. The king, in return for their military service, invited the Cumanians to settle in areas of the Great Plain between the Danube and the Theiss Rivers (today’s Great Cumania and Little Cumania); this region had become almost uninhabited after the Mongol raids of 1241–1242 (Horva´th 2001). The Cumanians lived there until their settlements were destroyed during the Turkish wars (16th–17th centuries) (Szaka´ly 2000). At the beginning of the 18th century the Cumanian territories were resettled by their Hungarian-speaking descendants (Me´sza´ros 2000). In the middle of the 18th century they got their status by becoming free farmers, and no longer serfs (Lango´ 2000a). They be- came completely assimilated, both genetically and culturally, with the Hungari- ans, leaving only the word Kun as an element in personal and place names. Despite their historical status, the ethnic origins of the Cumanians are un- certain (Pa´lo´czi Horva´th 1998). They appear in Byzantine history in the 11th century as the westernmost group of the Kipchaks, whose loose and migratory empire extended from the frontier zone of the Byzantine territory to the steppes north of the Aral Sea (Moravcsik 1983; Pletneva 1990). By the end of the 12th century the Cumanians had advanced from the territories north of the Black Sea to east of the Carpathian Mountains (Ferent¸ 1981; Kocˇkarov 2004). Their lan- guage, known from a 13th-century trilingual Cumanian-Latin-Persian dictionary, was a form of Turkish and was, until the 14th century, a lingua franca over much of the Eurasian steppes (Yule and Cordier 1916). It is clear from this patchy history that the Cumanians had an ancestry well to the east of their eventual settlement in Hungary. Analysis of ancient DNA (aDNA) from the bones of such a group of early settlers is the only reliable means to study the genetic affinities and relationships of the Cumanians in Hungary, because their descendants have been completely assimilated into the modern Hungarian population. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is commonly used in aDNA studies because of its high copy number (up to 10,000 times that of single-copy nuclear se- quences) and the lack of recombination as a result of its exclusively maternal inheritance (Giles et al. 1980). The hypervariable segment I (HVS I) of the mito- chondrial control region (D-loop) is routinely used in human phylogeographic studies because it evolves 10 times faster than the protein coding region of mtDNA (Richards and Macaulay 2001; Vigilant et al. 1991). Human mtDNA D-loop mutations have accumulated sequentially along radiating maternal line- ages during and after the process of human colonization of different geographic regions of the world (Marjoram and Donnelly 1994). Hence groups of mtDNA types often show geographic specificity (J. Chen et al. 1995; Y. S. Chen et al. 1995; Torroni and Wallace 1995). Analysis of mtDNA in populations therefore allows reconstruction of their maternal lineages, making it possible to study the ................. 15723$ $CH5 12-20-05 14:23:46 PS PAGE 640 mtDNA of Ancient Cumanians / 641 genetic traces of migration and admixture of different human communities and helping to estimate the degree of relationships within and between populations. We have therefore analyzed the aDNA of a set of medieval Cumanian sam- ples. DNA was extracted from excavated bones, and the HVS I was sequenced to determine the haplotypes and the monophyletic clades (haplogroups). The in- cidences of the different mitochondrial HVS I haplotypes and haplogroups were also investigated in the modern Hungarian gene pool by collecting hairs from different rural locations in Hungary. To classify mtDNAs that did not harbor a diagnostic haplogroup motif in their HVS I sequence, we assayed additional diagnostic markers out of the HVS I after PCR. To confirm the grouping, we also determined the haplogroup-associated polymorphic site at nucleotide position (nt) 10873 in the coding region in all cases. We compared the mtDNA HVS I sequences of 2,615 samples from 34 European and Asian populations (retrieved from the published data) to HVS I sequences of 74 modern Hungarians and 11 ancient Cumanians from the present study. This data set was used to discover the relationships between Cumanians, Hungarians, and the members of Eurasian populations in order to study the ge- netic traces of the ancient group migrations and to examine their admixture with different human communities. Materials and Methods Populations and Sampling. In the Hungarian village of Csengele, on the bor- ders of what is still called Kiskunsa´g, Little Cumania, an archeological excava- tion in 1975 revealed the ruins of a medieval church with 38 burials. Several burials had all the characteristics of a Cumanian group: richly jeweled, non- Hungarian, and definitely Cumanian-type costumes; the 12-spiked mace as a weapon; bone girdles; and associated pig bones (Horva´th 1978; Kovacs 1971; Sandor 1959). In view of the cultural objects and the historical data, the archeolo- gists concluded that the burials were indeed Cumanian and mid 13th century; hence some of the early settlers in Hungary were from that ethnic group. In 1999 the grave of a high-status Cumanian derived from the same period was discovered about 50 m from the church of Csengele; this was the first anthropologically authenticated grave of a Cumanian chieftain in Hungary (Horva´th 2001), and the contents are consistent with the ethnic identity of the excavated remains from the church burials. A separated area of the chieftain grave contained a complete skeleton of a horse. Bones from 15 skeletons were used in this study, derived from two well- documented excavations at Csengele in 1975 and 1999 (Horva´th 1978, 2001). From the earlier excavation it is known that these skeletons belonged to the earli- est settlers. According to