Melbourne Cup 2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AUSTRALIA Melbourne Cup Quant Style Top ranking horses Going for the trifecta Odds @ Number Horse Name 7pm Mon Event 3 Dunaden $8.50 23 Niwot $10.00 . The Emirates Melbourne Cup is being held today at Flemington Race course. 1 Americain $4.80 The Macquarie Quant team transform racing stats into traditional quant signals to come up with our top picks for the race that stops the nation. 2 Jukebox Jury $13.00 14 Illo $19.00 . For the second year running our model came up trumps in 2010 with the box 10 Mourayan $16.00 trifecta paying dividends. Whilst we were tempted to retire ahead, we thought this would be against the nature of this piece and possibly considered un- Source: Macquarie Research, Race TAB, November 2011 Australian. So this year we go for three in a row. Bottom ranking donkeys Odds @ Impact Number Horse name 7pm Mon . Horses at the top of the model include Dunaden, Niwot, Americain, Jukebox 19 Saptapadi $81.00 Jury, Illo and Mourayan. 13 Hawk Island $81.00 20 Shamrocker $51.00 . Our model is tweaked each year based on market dynamics and this again 12 Red Cadeaux $35.00 appears necessary in 2011. A high AUD has attracted a large legion of foreign horses chasing some Australian prize money. With this in mind, and 6 Manighar $35.00 with some thorough consultation with rouge punters across research, we have 7 Unusual Suspect $41.00 employed a new factor into the model. This factor looks at the record of each Source: Macquarie Research, Race TAB, November 2011 horse in Australia, rewarding those who have won or placed here recently. Cumulative Profit on $1000 investment in . To make way for this new factor, we have slightly down-weighted our Win/Box Trifecta Quant Strategy momentum and sentiment factors given this year’s increased market volatility. $10,000 $9,000 $8,000 . Dunaden comes out on top with Niwot and Americain close behind. Whilst we $7,000 $6,000 $5,000 do like to bet on the top pick in the model, our favoured approach is betting on $4,000 $3,000 the top quartile of horses. This mirrors the way we (quants) approach equity $2,000 $1,000 investing. $- 2007 2008 2009 2010 . The best way to implement this strategy is via a ‘box trifecta’ on the top 6 Source: Macquarie Research, Race TAB, November 2011 horses in the model (see your local bookie for a description of this bet). The payoff to a strategy of betting on a box-trifecta on the top 6 horses and a win on the top horse from our model is shown on the left. We must stress that this model is not intended to be taken seriously. The Quant team has very limited knowledge of horse racing and the purpose of this article is primarily fun. Analysis Quant factors used in the model Quant Signal Factor Weight Sentiment Odds 20% Momentum Odds movement 17.5% Value/Yield Avg prize money per race 5% Hit Rate Win % 15% Form 17.5% John Conomos, CFA Other Age 5% +61 2 8232 5157 [email protected] Francis Lim Barrier 5% +612 8232 9313 [email protected] Australian Form 10% Quality Odds dispersion 5% 31 October 2011 TOTAL 100% Macquarie Securities (Australia) Limited Source: Macquarie Research, November 2011 Please refer to the important disclosures and analyst certification on inside back cover of this document, or on our website www.macquarie.com.au/disclosures. Macquarie Research Melbourne Cup Quant Style Analysis . The table below shows the breakdown for each horse on each of the different factors we use in the model. Fig 1 Detailed rankings Rank # Horse Name OS Age Barrier Odds Prize Money Form Win % Odds Odds Movement Odds Dispersion Age Barrier Form Total Score MAX SCORE 5 17.5 15 20 17.5 5 5 5 10 100 1 3 Dunaden FR 6 13 $ 8.50 2.5 17.50 11.25 20 17.50 3.75 2.5 5 10 90.0 2 23 Niwot 7 9 $ 10.00 3.75 13.13 15 20 17.50 5 0 5 10 89.4 3 1 Americain USA 7 15 $ 4.80 5 17.50 15 20 17.50 3.75 0 0 10 88.8 4 2 Jukebox Jury IRE 6 6 $ 13.00 5 17.50 15 20 13.13 3.75 2.5 5 0 81.9 5 14 Illo GER 6 1 $ 19.00 1.25 17.50 15 15 17.50 2.5 2.5 5 5 81.3 6 10 Mourayan IRE 6 14 $ 16.00 5 17.50 3.75 15 17.50 3.75 2.5 5 10 80.0 7 5 Glass Harmonium IRE 6 23 $ 26.00 5 17.50 7.5 15 13.13 5 2.5 0 10 75.6 8 9 Lucas Cranach GER 5 11 $ 11.00 3.75 13.13 15 20 8.75 2.5 5 5 2.5 75.6 9 17 At First Sight IRE 5 10 $ 14.00 5 8.75 3.75 20 17.50 3.75 5 5 5 73.8 10 16 Modun IRE 5 5 $ 26.00 2.5 13.13 15 15 8.75 5 5 5 0 69.4 11 22 Tullamore NZ 5 12 $ 26.00 3.75 13.13 7.5 15 8.75 5 5 5 5 68.1 12 21 The Verminator 5 4 $ 101.00 2.5 17.50 11.25 5 4.38 5 5 5 10 65.6 13 4 Drunken Sailor IRE 7 8 $ 41.00 2.5 17.50 11.25 10 8.75 5 0 5 2.5 62.5 14 18 Moyenne Corniche GB 7 17 $ 26.00 1.25 13.13 3.75 15 13.13 2.5 0 0 5 53.8 15 15 Lost In The Moment IRE 5 3 $ 35.00 1.25 8.75 7.5 10 13.13 1.25 5 5 0 51.9 16 24 Older Than Time 5 20 $ 101.00 2.5 8.75 11.25 5 13.13 1.25 5 0 5 51.9 17 8 Fox Hunt IRE 5 19 $ 26.00 1.25 8.75 11.25 15 8.75 1.25 5 0 0 51.3 18 11 Precedence NZ 6 2 $ 41.00 3.75 4.38 3.75 10 8.75 5 2.5 5 2.5 45.6 19 7 Unusual Suspect ISA 8 7 $ 41.00 3.75 8.75 3.75 10 8.75 1.25 0 5 2.5 43.8 20 6 Manighar FR 6 21 $ 35.00 3.75 4.38 11.25 10 4.38 2.5 2.5 0 2.5 41.3 21 12 Red Cadeaux GB 6 16 $ 35.00 1.25 8.75 7.5 10 8.75 2.5 2.5 0 0 41.3 22 20 Shamrocker NZ 4 24 $ 51.00 5 8.75 7.5 5 4.38 2.5 5 0 2.5 40.6 23 13 Hawk Island IRE 7 18 $ 81.00 2.5 8.75 7.5 5 4.38 1.25 0 0 5 34.4 24 19 Saptapadi IRE 6 22 $ 81.00 1.25 4.38 3.75 5 13.13 1.25 2.5 0 2.5 33.8 Source: Macquarie Research, Race TAB, November 2011 . Sentiment was measured by the last available odds before publication as this is representative of the mood of the market. Horses with strong sentiment include Americain, Dunaden, Niwot, Lucas Cranach and At First Sight. Momentum was measured by movement in the odds from opening prices until the latest available odds. Horses with strong momentum include Americain, Dunaden, Mourayan, Illo, At First Sight and Niwot. Value was measured by average prize money per race as this represents the return of each horse. Leaders in this category were Americain, Jukebox Jury, Glass Harmonium, Mourayan, At First Sight and Shamrocker. Hit rate was measured by the horses winning percentage and by the form over the last five races for the horse. Horses with a good hit rate include Americain, Jukebox Jury, Dunaden, Drunken Sailor, Glass Harmonium and The Verminator. Quality/Risk was measured by odds dispersion amongst bookmakers to indicate the variance of the perceived value of the horses. Horses with low odds dispersion are Niwot, Glass Harmonium, Modun, Tullamore and The Verminator. Australian form takes account for the large number of foreign horses in the field. If the horse has successfully raced, won or placed in Australia it receives a higher weighting (depending on result). We also took into account factors that made up previous winners of the Melbourne Cup. Starting barrier can give the horse an obvious advantage. According to historical analysis, winning horses are almost twice as likely to have started in one of the first 14 barriers. The age of the horse can also make a difference. Almost half of winners since 1861 have been aged four or five. A horse’s weight handicap showed no correlation and was therefore left out of the model. 31 October 2011 2 Macquarie Research Melbourne Cup Quant Style Historic Profitability of the model . The Macquarie Quant team first ran the Melbourne cup model in 2007. Taking a box trifecta on the Top 6 horses in the model in 2007 paid handsomely. In 2008, we warned to be wary of the ‘Black Swan’ and unfortunately our model yielded little success. At $41, Viewed came from nowhere to win the cup.