Outdoor Sports Facilities and Open Spaces Report of The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DP4418 Scrutiny Report Cover 5/12/06 16:09 Page 2 OUTDOOR SPORTS FACILITIES AND OPEN SPACES REPORT OF THE CULTURE, ECONOMY AND SUSTAINABILITY SCRUTINY AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT BOARD DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 1 CONTENTS FOREWORD 3 INTRODUCTION 4 BACKGROUND 4 SCRUTINY EXERCISE - TERMS OF REFERENCE 4 MEMBERSHIP OF THE WORKING GROUP 4 MEETINGS OF THE WORKING GROUP 5 EVIDENCE GATHERING 6 CONCLUSIONS 22 RECOMMENDATIONS & MANAGEMENT RESPONSE 23 APPENDICES 38 1. INCOME AND EXPENDITURE 39 2. CONDITION SURVEY 39 3. PRICING INFORMATION 40 4. SURVEY RESULTS 52 REPORT OF THE CULTURE, ECONOMYREPORT OF THE CULTURE, AND SUSTAINABILITY WORKING GROUP 1 DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 2 REPORT OF THE CULTURE, ECONOMYREPORT OF THE CULTURE, AND SUSTAINABILITY WORKING GROUP 2 DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 3 Chair’s Foreword The following report is the result of issues raised by members of the general public who expressed concerns over the condition and management of sporting facilities within our parks. It was clear that while our user groups welcomed the increased investment in many of our parks and recognised the improving conditions, they nevertheless felt that the sporting provision within many of our parks and open spaces could be improved and managed differently. A particular concern raised by our elderly users was the bowling greens. We offer the findings of our scrutiny exercise to the Cabinet for approval. I would like to take this opportunity to thank members, officers and the user groups who have worked hard and contributed positively to our work and particularly, Jason Dietsch, for pulling it all together in such a coherent form. Peter Price, Chair. REPORT OF THE CULTURE, ECONOMYREPORT OF THE CULTURE, AND SUSTAINABILITY WORKING GROUP 3 DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 4 REPORT OF THE WORKING GROUP • Consider alternative sources of provision and non-traditional 1. INTRODUCTION provision as a means of offering some potential to help solve both 1.1 The purpose of this report is to problems of quality and quantity. detail the outcome of the scrutiny exercise undertaken by the Working • Following the Working Group’s Group examining sporting facilities examination of these issues, to in Parks, which was established by report and draw up a series of the former Development, recommendations to be Environment and Leisure Scrutiny considered by the Scrutiny Board Board at its meeting held on 16th concerning how improvements to December, 2004, together with the sporting facilities in Parks might Working Group’s recommendations. be implemented. 2. BACKGROUND TO THE 3. SCRUTINY EXERCISE - TERMS SCRUTINY EXERCISE OF REFERENCE 2.1 At its meeting on 21st October 2004, 3.1 The following terms of reference the former Development, were agreed by the Scrutiny Board, Environment and Leisure Scrutiny at its meeting on 16th December Board considered the condition of 2004: the City’s parks sports pitches and agreed to: 1 To examine the potential for self - management by clubs on • Establish a Member Working selected sites. Group to work with officers to 2 Consider the balance of spend examine the potential for between formal sports and non- extending the self-management sporting activities. REPORT OF THE CULTURE, ECONOMYREPORT OF THE CULTURE, AND SUSTAINABILITY WORKING GROUP by clubs on selected sites. 3 Examine the potential rationalisation of facilities to • Consider the opportunities for reflect changing demands and extending community use of alternative, possible non- schools. traditional sources of provision. • Examine the balance of spending 4. MEMBERSHIP OF THE WORKING between formal sports and non- GROUP sporting activities. 4.1 It was agreed by the Development • Look at the potential Environment and Leisure Scrutiny rationalisation of facilities to Board, that the Working Group reflect changing demand. comprise the following Members: 4 DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 5 Councillors Trevor Bagshaw, David and of Sheffield and District Parks Bowls Barker, Janet Bragg, Martin Brelsford, Association and President of Millhouses Jean Cromar, Jackie Drayton, Sylvia Park Bowling Club Dunkley, Arthur Dunworth, Alan Law, Mike Various members of bowls clubs in the Peat (Joint Chair), Peter Price (Joint City and Parks Woodlands and Chair), Ian Saunders, Anne Smith and Countryside staff spoken to on site visits. Garry Weatherall. 5. MEETINGS OF THE WORKING Meetings were also open to all Members GROUP of the Scrutiny Board to attend, and Members did use the opportunity to Meetings of the Working Group were held participate on a casual basis to monitor on 7 occasions and reports and evidence the progress and work of the Group. In submitted by officers from Parks, addition, with the establishment of the Woodlands and Countryside, Activity Culture, Economy and Sustainability Sheffield and Development Services were Scrutiny and Policy Development Board examined. in May 2005, Members of the Board also attended on an ad hoc basis. Contributions to a meeting of the Working Group were made from a representative Meetings of the Working Group were also of one of the City’s bowling clubs, Mr attended and supported by the following Derek Ellis, Chair of the Hillsborough Council Officers: Park Bowling Club in relation to the Martin Page (Parks, Woodlands and management and operation of clubs and Countryside) the general condition of bowling greens in David Hargate (Parks, Woodlands and Sheffield. Countryside) Ian Blakemore (Activity Sheffield) A piece of work, carried out by Strategic Sarah Smith (Development Services) Leisure, already commissioned by the Jason Dietsch (Scrutiny Policy Officer, Council’s Development Services was also ECONOMYREPORT OF THE CULTURE, AND SUSTAINABILITY WORKING GROUP Legal and Governance) presented to Members, which was taken John Challenger (Committee Secretariat, into account in their deliberations. Legal and Governance) In addition, a tour of the City’s parks took External attendees participating in the place on 7th June, during which Members exercise were: visited the locations (detailed below) and benefited from speaking to users of Adam Clarke, Strategic Leisure bowling greens and staff located in parks: Derek Ellis, Chair of the Hillsborough Park Bowling Club Parks visited: Robert Jackson, President of the British Graves Park Parks Crown Green Bowling Association Abbeyfield Park 5 DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 6 Parson Cross Park The need to inform the provision of Colley Park sports facilities by a number of Longley Park initiatives and influences such as the Concord Park work of Activity Sheffield, the Steel City outdoor playing pitch assessment and strategy for Sheffield and 6. EVIDENCE GATHERING strategies relating to site categorisation and reinvestment and 6.1 Scene Setting - the current including the recently produced condition of sport provision in the action plans for parks for each of the City’s Parks 12 Area Panel areas was highlighted. As a precursor to the scrutiny exercise, members of the Other activities such as walking, Development, Environment and cycling and other individual exercise Leisure Scrutiny Board considered a regimes which might not require report by the Head of Parks, specific facilities but which were Woodlands and Countryside which promoted nationally and locally as provided an overview of services part of an informed healthy lifestyle and detailed expenditure on sports choice should also be considered in facilities. Also outlined were the development of provision for charges for sports and activities in physical activities in the City’s parks. parks. Discussions had been held between The quality and range of sports officers in Parks, Woodlands and pitches and associated buildings Countryside and Activity Sheffield on varied and continues to suffer from a the extension of self-management lack of infrastructure investment by clubs on selected sites, REPORT OF THE CULTURE, ECONOMYREPORT OF THE CULTURE, AND SUSTAINABILITY WORKING GROUP which has resulted in an investment opportunities for extending backlog with regard to community use of schools, how improvements such as drainage, expenditure might be balanced changing accommodation and between formal sport and non- fencing. sporting facilities and finally, how facilities might be rationalised to The maintenance of sports facilities reflect both the changing demand is carried out by the Parks, for activities, alternative sources of Woodlands and Countryside provision and to combat problems of gardening staff, together with Street both quality and quantity of Force and some sports clubs carried provision. out maintenance directly with grant assistance from Parks, Woodlands and Countryside. 6 DP4418 Scrutiny Report Inners V4 5/12/06 16:04 Page 7 Robert Jackson, president of the The growth of urban sports such as British Parks Crown Green Bowling skateboarding and BMX had a Association and of Sheffield and strong base and provided positive District Parks Bowls Association and lifestyle and cultural influences President of Millhouses Park amongst young people, however the Bowling Club, attended the Board development of facilities for such meeting, at which he outlined the activity would require further merits of Crown Green Bowling as a significant work as well as sport in which a variety of age investment and funding for groups participated, particularly maintenance if levels of demand providing gentle exercise for middle were to be addressed.