<<

The

OFFICERSt Roswell B. Perkins, Chair of the Council Michael Traynor, President Conrad K. Harper, 1st Vice President , 2nd Vice President Bennett Boskey, Treasurer Lance Liebman, Director Elena A. Cappella, Deputy Director Michael Greenwald, Deputy Director

COUNCILt Kenneth S. Abraham Charlottesville Virginia Shirley S. Abrahamson Madison Wisconsin Philip S. Anderson Little Rock Arkansas Susan Frelich Appleton St. Louis Missouri Richard Sheppard Arnold Little Rock Arkansas Josd I. Astigarraga Miami Florida Sheila L. Birnbaum New York Allen D. Black Bennett Boskey Washington District of Columbia Amelia H. Boss Philadelphia Pennsylvania William M. Burke Costa Mesa California FElizabeth J. Cabraser San Francisco California Hugh Calkins Cleveland Ohio Gerhard Casper Stanford California William T. Coleman, Jr. Washington District of Columbia Edward H. Cooper Ann Arbor Michigan N. Lee Cooper Birmingham Alabama Roger C. Cramton Ithaca New York Lloyd N. Cutler Washington District of Columbia George H.T. Dudley St. Thomas U.S. Virgin Islands Christine M. Durham Salt Lake City Utah Kenneth C. Frazier Whitehouse Station George Clemon Freeman, Jr. Richmond Virginia Paul L. Friedman Washington District of Columbia Conrad K. Harper New York New York Geoffrey C. Hazard, Jr.* Philadelphia Pennsylvania D. Brock Hornby Portland Maine William C. Hubbard Columbia South Carolina Vester T. Hughes, Jr. Dallas Mary Kay Kane San Francisco California I lerma Hill Kay Berkeley California Texas Carolyn B. Lamm Washington District of Columbia Douglas Laycock Austin Texas Pierre N. Leval New York New York Betsy Levin Washington District of Columbia

lAs of December 1, 2003 *DirectorEmeritus Hains A. Linde Salem Oregon Martin Lipton New York New York Myles V. Lynk Tempe Arizona Robert MacCrate New York New York Margaret H. Marshall Boston Massachusetts John J. McKetta, III Austin Texas Vincent L. McKusick Portland Maine Daniel J. Meltzer Cambridge Massachusetts Robert H. Mundheim New York New York Kathryn A. Oberly New York New York Roswell B. Perkins New York New York Harvey S. Perlman Lincoln Nebraska Ellen Ash Peters Hartford Connecticut Louis H. Pollak Philadelphia Pennsylvania Roberta C. Ramo Albuquerque New Mexico Mary M.Schroeder Phoenix Arizona Sherwin P.Simmons Miami Florida Win. Reece Smith, Jr. Tampa Florida Robert A. Stein Chicago John T. Subak Boca Grande Florida Michael Traynor San Francisco California Bill Wagner Tampa Florida Patricia M.Wald Washington District of Columbia Elizabeth Warren Cambridge Massachusetts William H. Webster Washington District of Columbia George Whittenburg Amarillo Texas Herbert P Wilkins Boston Massachusetts James H. Wilson,Jr. Atlanta Georgia Diane P.Wood Chicago Illinois

Emeritus Council Members William H. Erickson Denver Colorado Thomas E. Fairchild Madison Wisconsin Nicholas deB. Katzenbach Princeton New Jersey Hale McCown Yellow Springs Ohio Ernest J. Sargeant Boston Massachusetts Lawrence E. Walsh City Oklahoma REPORTER JOHN B. OAKLEY, University of California at Davis School of Law, Davis, California

ADVISERS* BENNErr BOSKEY, Washington, District of Columbia Louis R. COHEN, Washington, District of Columbia [from 2000] EDWARD H. COOPER, The Law School, Ann Arbor, Michigan WILLIAM A. FLETCHER, Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, San Francisco, California RicilARD D. FREER, Emory University School of Law, Atlanta, Georgia SUSAN P.GRABER, Judge, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Portland, Oregon GARY GRINDLER, Washington, District of Columbia [to 2000] PATRICIA M. HYNES, New York, New York ROBIN JACOnSOHN, Washington, District of Columbia [from 20001 RENt-E M. LANDERS, Boston, Massachusetts DAVID F. LEvi, Judge, United States District Court for the Eastern District of California, Sacramento, California VINCENT L. McKUSICK, Portland, Maine; Retired Chief Justice, Supreme Judicial Court of Maine [to 2000] DANIEL J.MELTZER, Law School, Cambridge, Massachusetts RONALD L. OLSON, Los Angeles, California THOMAS R. PHILLIPS, Chief JusticeTexas Supreme Court, Austin,Texas MARY KRISTINA PICKERING, Las Vegas, Nevada Louis H. POLLAK, Judge, United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania DOLORES KORMAN SLOVITER, Judge, United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania [from 1999] JOSEPH F. SPANIOL, JR., Bethesda, Maryland JOAN E. SI'EINMAN, Chicago-Kent College of Law, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, Illinois PATRICIA M. WALD, Judge, International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, The Hague, Netherlands; formerly Judge, United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Washington, District of Columbia

OStatus as of May 17,2001 EX OFFICIO ROSWELt B. PERKINS, New York, New York Chair of the Council, The American Law Institute CIIARL -S ALAN WRIGHT, Austin, Texas President,The American Law Institute [to 2000] MICHAEL TRAYNOR, San Francisco, California President,The American Law Institute [from 2000] GEOFFREY C. HAZARD, JR., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Director, The American Law Institute [to 1999] LANCE LIEBmAN, New York, Ncw York Direrfor, The American Law Institute [from 1999] MEMBERS CONSULTATIVE GROUP (as of March 28,2001)

CHARLES W. ADAMS, Tulsa, TERESA STANTON COLLETr, Oklahoma Houston, Texas IRWIN M. ALTERMAN, Troy, DENISE D. COLLIERS, Michigan Philadelphia, Pennsylvania JAMES G. APPLE, Washington, JULIAN A. COOK, JR., United D.C. States District Court for the DAVID ASHI.EY BAGWELL, Eastern District of Michigan, Mobile, Alabama Detroit, Michigan THOMAS E. BAKER, Des Moines, MICHAEL D. COPER, Canberra, Iowa Australia STEVEN K. BALMAN, Tulsa, Oklahoma JAMES B. CRAVEN II, Durham, North Carolina WILLIAM T. BARKER, Chicago. Illinois STEWART UALZELL, United States District Court G. ROBERT BLAKEY, Notre for the Dame, Indiana Eastern District of Pennsylvania, SUSAN Low BLOCH, Washington, Philadelphia, D.C. Pennsylvania SANFORD L. BOHRER, Miami, LAURIE WEBB DANIEL, Atlanta, Florida Georgia ROBERT G. BONE, Boston, ANTHONY E. DIRESTA, Massachusetts Washington, D.C. KAREN KENNEDY BROWN, United GORDON L. DOERFER, Trial States Bankruptcy Court for Court of Massachusetts, the Southern District of Superior Court Department, Texas, Houston, Texas Boston, Massachusetts KATHLEEN B. BURKE, Cleveland, DONALD L. DOERNBERG, White Ohio Plains, New York ROBERT L. BYER, Pittsburgh, MITCHELL F. DOLIN, Washington, Pennsylvania D.C. Jost A. CARDENAS, Phoenix, C. Arizona WILSON DuBOSE, Madison, Georgia ROBERT C. CASAD, Lawrence, Kansas DAVID N. ELLENHORN, New York, New York WILLIAM RICHARD CASTO, Lubbock, Texas C. RONALD ELLINGTON, Athens, NORMAN J. CHACHKIN, New Georgia York, New York KEITH P. ELLISON, United States YEE WAH CHIN, New York, New District Court for the York Southern District of Texas, FRANK PHILLIP CIHLAR, Laredo,' Iexas Washington, D.C. HENRY F. FIELD, Framingham, MICHAEL MARKS COHEN, New Massachusetts York, New York JILL FISCH, New York, New York ROBERT G. FLANDERS, JR., ALVIN K. HELLERSTEIN, United Rhode Island Supreme Court, States District Court for the Providence, Rhode Island Southern District of New JOSEPH Z. FLEMING, Miami, York, New York, New York Florida LAWRENCE K. HELLMAN, ERIC M. FREEDMAN, Hempstead, , Oklahoma New York EDWIN E. HUDDLESON, III, JosE A. FusTt, United States Washington, D.C. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, San Juan, RICHARD W. HULBERT, New Puerto Rico York, New York ANTONIO GARCIA-PADLLA, San SAMUEL ISSACHAROFF, New Juan, Puerto Rico York, New York NANCY GERTNER, United States RALPH A. JACOBS, Philadelphia, District Court for the District Pennsylvania of Massachusetts, Boston, ROBERTA JACOBS-MEADWAY, Massachusetts Philadelphia, Pennsylvania CHARLES GARDNER GEYH, Bloomington, Indiana RICHARD L. JACOBSON, Washington, D.C. JAMES T. GILES, United States District Court for the Eastern BRADLEY D. JEssoN, Fort Smith, District of Pennsylvania, Arkansas Philadelphia, Pennsylvania PAUL F. JONES, Buffalo, New R. NICHOLAS GIMBE., York Philadelphia, Pennsylvania MICHAEL EDWARD KEASLER, BARRY P. GOODE, San Francisco, Texas Court of Criminal California Appeals, Austin, Texas ROBERT A. GOODIN, San MICIHAEL J. KEATING, St. Louis, Francisco, California Missouri PATRICIA J. GORENCE, United RT. lION. JUSTICE SIR KENNETH States District Court for the KEITH, Court of Appeal of Eastern District of Wisconsin, New Zealand, Wellington, Milwaukee, Wisconsin New Zealand JOAN B. GOTrSCHALL, United MARK R. KILLENBECK, States District Court for the Fayetteville, Arkansas Northern District of Illinois, RICtlARD A. KILLWORIH, Chicago, Illinois Dayton, Ohio MICHAEL D. GREEN, Winston- EDWARD LABATON, New York, Salem, North Carolina New York JEFFREY J. GREENBAUM, Newark, LAWRENCE J. LATro, Washington, New Jersey D.C. WILLIAM T. HANGLEY, PAUL A. LEBEL, Tallahassee, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Florida RICHARD E. V. HARRIS, JOHN LEUBSDORF, Newark, New Piedmont, California Jersey DAVID I. LEVINE, Berkeley, RICHARD L. NEUMEIER, Boston, California Massachusetts WILLIAM H. LEVIT, JR., TRACY A. NICHOLS, Miami, Milwaukee, Wisconsin Florida DONALD M. LEwis, Minneapolis, RONALD A. NORWOOD, St. Louis, Minnesota Missouri HAROLD S. LEWIS, JR., Macon, JAMES M. O'FALLON, Eugene, Georgia Oregon ROBERTA D. LIEBENBERG, BETrY R. OWENS, Houston, Texas Philadelphia, Pennsylvania RICHARD W. PAINTER, JEFFREY 17. LIss, Washington, Champaign, Illinois D.C. ROBERT W. PASS, "allahassee, HOUSTON PUTNAM LOWRY, Florida Meriden, Connecticut JAMES E. PrANDER, Champaign, WILLIAM V. LUNEBURG. Illinois Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania EDWARD M. POSNER, MYLES V. LYNK, tuinpe, Arizona Philadelphia, Pennsylvania FRED T. MAGAZINER, SHELDON RAAB, New York, New Philadelphia, Pennsylvania York MORTON M. MANEK ER, New MYRNA SHARON RAEDER, Los York, New York Angeles, California RAYMOND B. MARCIN, BERNARD D. REAMS, JR., San Washington, D.C. Antonio, Texas RICHARD L. MARCUS, San JUDITH RESNIK, New Haven, Francisco, California Connecticut ELIZABETH PHILLIPS MARSH, JANET LEACIi RICHARDS, Hamden, Connecticut Memphis, Tennessee PRENTICE H. MARS) IALL, KENNETH F. RIPPLE, United Daytona Beach, Florida States Court of Appeals for STEPHEN J. MATHES, the Seventh Circuit, South Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Bend, Indiana JAMES R. MAXEINER, Murray JAMES L. ROBERTSON, Jackson, Hill, New Jersey Mississippi COLLEEN MCMAHON, United JEFFREY A. ROSEN, Washington, States District Court for the D.C. Southern District of New WILLIAM GEORGE Ross, York, White Plains, New York Birmingham, Alabama DANIEL JOHN MEADOR, THOMAS D. ROWE, JR., Durham, Charlottesville, Virginia North Carolina ARTHUR D. MEI.FNDRE.S, TIMOTHY C. RUSSELL, Albuquerque, New Mexico Philadelphia, Pennsylvania RIa LARD A. MICHAEL, Chicago, PFTER M. SAPAROFF, Boston, Illinois Massachusetts GREGORY G. MURPHY, Billings, JAMEs F. SCHATZ, Minneapolis, Montana Minnesota ANTHONY J. SciRicA, United STANLEY A. TWARDY, JR., States Court of Appeals for Stamford, Connecticut the Third Circuit, WILLIAM D. UNDERWOOD, Waco, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Texas MARY DAVIES Sco'rr, United SARAH S.VANCE, United States States Bankruptcy Courts for District Court for the Eastern the Eastern and Western District of Louisiana, New Districts of Arkansas, Little Orleans, Louisiana Rock, Arkansas GEORGE K. WALKER, Winston- MILO SitaN, Pittsburgh, PETER Salem, North Carolina Pennsylvania NICHOLAS J. WVALLWORK, GENE R. SHREVE, Bloomington, Phoenix, Arizona Indiana HOWARD P. VALTHALL, LINDA J. SILBERMAN, New York, Birmingham, Alabama New York LouisE WEINBERG, Austin, Texas GREGORY CHARLES SISK, Des Moines, Iowa CItARLEs R. WEINER, United CARL A. SOLANO, Philadelphia, States District Court for the Pennsylvania Eastern District of Philadelphia, ELIZABETH S. STONG, New York, Pennsylvania, New York Pennsylvania GuY MILLER SmUVE, New York, LESLEY BROOKS WELLS, United New York States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, E. THOMAS SULLIVAN, Ohio Minneapolis, Minnesota Cleveland, KENT D. SYVERUD, Nashville, MICHAEL WELL., Athens, Tennessee Georgia COLIN TAtT, Hartford, RALPH Ui. W1IIITrEN, Omaha, Connecticut Nebraska LOUISE E. TErrz, Bristol, Rhode THOMAS SAMUEL WILLIAMSON, Island JR., Washington, D.C. WILLIAM H. Timis, Winnetka, ANDREW J. WISTRICH, United Illinois States District Court for the Central District of California, ELIZABETH G.THORNBUR, Dallas,Texas Los Angeles, California JAY TIDMARSH, Notre Dame, GORDON 0. YoUNG, Baltimore, Indiana Maryland ROSCOE TRIMMIER, JR., Boston, ERIC H. ZAGRANS, Cleveland, Massachusetts Ohio