F.16 & Housing Delivery Schedule

This paper undertakes a review of permissions, SHLAA sites and Allocations contained within the Site Allocations DPD.

The following map should be read in conjunction with Table 2. Table 1: Summary of Housing Delivery

1 2 3 Completions 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Town Housing 2010-2017 Permissions Permissions Sites 10 Urban Windfall CLI/other Allocations Total Percentage of target requirement Under 10 10 or over or over SHLAA net net net net net awaiting Net the signing of S106 Penzance 2150 312 115 221 0 9 272 231 1160 2320 108% & Newlyn

Note: The contents of Table 1 represent a summary of the information contained within CC.S4.4. (However, ‘Allocations Net’ has risen from 1090 to 1160 (to reflect the estimated additional capacity of 50-70 dwellings that could come forward on the St Clare allocation, as a result of the recently permitted scheme for only part of the site. The 70 dwellings, represents the estimated delivery on the remaining 2ha of land not covered by the permission)

Table 2: Permissions over 10 dwellings, SHLAA sites, and Allocations

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Map Site Name Reference Decision Date Constraints/availability/delivery: Total number of Number of Number Number of Reference Ref homes homes of homes homes to permitted for expected expected be site to deliver to deliver delivered 2017- 2023- within the 2022 2030 Plan period 2017- 2030

Planning N/A N/A (The list of permissions under 10 dwellings is set out N/A 115 0 115 permissions in Appendix 1) on sites less than 10 dwellings

Sites with Planning Permission for 10 or more homes as at April 2017

1 Churchill Retirement Living. Site built out within the last 12 51 51 0 51 Former Gas months. Works Site PA14/02530 24-Jun-14 Wharf Road Penzance Cornwall TR18

2 Blewett & Scheme not currently coming forward. But it represents a 10 10 0 10 Pender brownfield site within Penzance and there is reasonable prospect Albert Street that the site is available and be developed by the end of the Plan PA12/09689 13-Feb-14 Penzance period Cornwall TR18 2LR

3 Stanmore Original developer not currently taking forward scheme; plus since 67 0 40 40 Hotel Site & permission granted, a consent was given for a small element of Cattrans Coal the site to form part of a Lidl car park. Yard Site, W1/07/P/0075 24-Apr-07 However, site within existing urban area, with good access to Alexandra highway network, so an alternative scheme could be promoted Road, and delivered within the Plan period, with similar if not the same Wherrytown numbers of dwellings

4 Taylors An extant consent, but could be overtaken by the proposed 55 0 55 55 Garage Site allocation of Coinagehall St; however stays on the trajectory until Coinagehall W1/90/P/0668 30-Nov-90 such time that an alternative scheme is brought forward Street Penzance

5 Residual land left over from previous development. Extant 21 0 21 21 consent. Owned by Catran’s and the current consent is no longer The Coombe W1/66/P/21763O 15-Feb-66 expected to deliver. However the site remains a suitable housing Newlyn location and it is reasonable to assume that it will become available and delivered within the Plan period

6 W Harvey & Consent valid as material start made, but no current activity; 20 14 0 14 Sons However, no evidence to suggest it does not represent a The Coombe developable proposals within the Plan period Newlyn PA11/02991 14-Jul-11 Penzance Cornwall TR18 5HF

7 Champions Development almost completed. 10 10 0 10 Yard And 17 Causewayhead PA15/06336 25-Apr-16 Penzance Cornwall TR18 2TA

8 The Orchard PA16/10326 07-Feb-17 Development completed within last 12 months. 20 6 0 6 Alverton Road Penzance TR18 4TE

9 The Orchard Development completed within last 12 months As above 14 0 14 Alverton Road PA16/11046 01-Mar-17 Penzance TR18 4TE

Total Permissions of 10 or more developable within the plan period 221

Cornwall Land Initiative Sites & other potential urban sites

10 Trajectory reflects the part of the site with permission for 127 but there 127 127 127 are two hectares of land left over on the site which at 35 dph would add up to a further 50-70 units. This has been included under the allocation below but in CC.S4.4 the whole yield is shown under the CLI site

Site was owned by and is being brought forward PZ-H9 as part of its Cornwall Land Initiative. The Council has just sold the St Clare site to developer (Galliford Try) and site has permission for 127 dwellings. Section 106 signed and lease agreed.

Demolition works started on site on w/c 5/3/17

Trajectory (E6.2) identified delivery in 18/19 and 19/20, which is in line with contract between the Council and the developer

11 Site was owned by Cornwall Council and is being brought forward 24 24 24 Former as part of its Cornwall Land Initiative. The Council has just sold the Depot site to developer (Galliford Try) and site has permission for 24 dwellings.

12 The White Brownfield site within the centre of Newlyn. DPD Preferred Options 30 30 House and Consultation identified site for 50 units, but the constrained Factory, highway network is unlikely to accommodate a scheme of that Chywoone Hill, scale – estimated for up to 30 dwellings Newlyn

13 Brownfeld site within the centre of Penzance, offers potential for a 50 50 Former Bolitho relatively significant scheme, providing flats within the disused School school building, together with further development within its grounds

Total Cornwall land Initiative Sites 231

Local Plan Allocations

14 Long Rock PZ-H1 HIA (D3.18) – No further assessment required due to limited 150 0 150 150 potential for impacts on non- designated assets. Impacts of views from St Michaels Mount were reviewed with Heritage Officer, concluding that views would not be impacted; also discussed with Historic England, who supported the Council’s position.

HRA (D2.3) - Marshes SPA is located in very close proximity but the SPA is fragmented and located within an area of existing urban infrastructure. Subject to the project-level design of PZ-H1 and E4, and with the incorporation of construction best practice, it is considered unlikely that LSE will occur alone or in- combination. No direct habitat loss will occur. Position supported by Natural England (CC.S5)

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The site is not within or is in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The landscape assessment of cell concluded that the site has a low overall landscape assessment (D15.1.4). This site presents the opportunity to extend the existing community of Long Rock and reinforce the local facilities. It is close proximity to employment sites, has good public transport links and is well served by the road network.

The site is flat and has immediate access of the road to the south of the site, whilst the site would be expected to make highway contributions to support the delivery of the transport strategy measures, there are no requirements that would present the scheme from coming forward. The transport contribution (£3,430) was included within the viability assessments undertaken for the LPSP document (doc ref F.7) when setting appropriate affordable housing targets.

The majority of the site was promoted through SHLAA. The site allocation is now under the control of Westcountry Land and supports the proposed allocation (Reg-19 rep 75c). Westcountry land indicated in their Reg-19 rep their intention to bring forward their scheme for delivery within the next 12-18 months.

With the known landowner / developer activity the Cornwall Housing Trajectory, summarised within (CC.S4.4 – Table 1c) indicates first completions in 2022-23; with development at 35 dwellings pa.

15 Posses Lane PZ-H2 HIA (D3.18) - Potentially within the wider setting of the listed 30 0 30 30 church and Conservation Area. No further assessment required at this stage if cell taken forward in isolation. Position supported by Historic England (CC.S4.3)

HRA (D2) - No direct habitat loss will occur. No loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is 1791 m distant from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA. Natural England had no objection to the site coming forward (CC.S5)

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The site is not within or is in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The landscape assessment of concluded that the site has an intermediate overall landscape assessment. This site presents the opportunity to extend the existing community of Gulval and reinforce the local facilities. It is recognised that the site is within close proximity of the conservation area, but it expected to have a limited negative impact. As a result, it is felt that on balance the delivery of housing, including affordable housing, outweighs the potential for a small negative impact on heritage assets.

Within single ownership and has been promoting the site through the SHLAA process.

The site would have direct access from Posses Lane and it is a clear site with no known constraints.

16 Gulval Central PZ-H3 HIA (D3.18) - Site potentially within wider setting of Gulval listed 68 0 68 68 church and Conservation Area. No further assessment required at this stage. Site is infill with development on 3 sides and lower density on remaining edge. There would be negligible to less than substantial harm to wider setting of nearby listed building & CA. Positon supported by Historic England (CC.S4.3).

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA.

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1. SA (D5.10) - The site is not within or in close proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. This site presents the opportunity to make use of a piece of land within the centre of Gulval village, in doing so improving pedestrian connectivity for the village. Whilst the site is classified as Grade 2 agricultural land and is in the wider setting of the conservation area, it is felt that the negative impacts are outweighed by the benefits discussed, as well as the ability to deliver much needed housing, including affordable housing.

The site is within the ownership of 2 landowners and was promoted through the SHLAA process.

The site would be accessed via Foxes Fields and it is a clear site within no known constraints.

17 Trannack PZ-H4 HIA (D3.18) - Further assessment not required at this stage. There 290 35 255 290 is an existing landscape character assessment which has influenced the site; furthermore site area has been reduced away from higher ground, and there are no important historic assets on or near to the site. There would very minor impacts on the wider Penzance landscape setting. (Position is supported by Historic England (CC.S4.3))

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA. Natural England supported this position (CC.S5)

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) -The site is not within or in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site. Part of the site to the west has a high overall landscape assessment (D15.1.4). This site presents the opportunity to extend the existing community of Heamoor and reinforce the local facilities. Despite the fact that the site includes some grade 2 agricultural land, it is felt that this loss is outweighed by the benefits that would arise from delivering much needed housing, including affordable housing.

As set out in CC.S4.4 – Table 1b, the developable area has been reduced from the average 70% to 60%, together with a slight reduction on expected dph, to reflect the fact that there is more challenging topography. These reductions mean a reduced quantum of development is expected from the site (33dph).

The access would be via the A30, assumed to be from the existing Trenere Roundabout, where a forth arm can be created from the existing junction, straight into the site.

The site is within single ownership and owner has promoted the site through SHLAA and the site allocations process (Reg-18 rep 0148 & Reg-19 rep 196b), in which they have undertaken some initial masterplanning work and considered access options. The owner has now secured a development partner, who has an architectural practice on board to bring forward the detailed masterplanning etc. The developer’s intentions and proposed timescales for delivery are set out in the Position Statement (PS.196b.2) – including the intention of submitting an application by December 2018 and the aim starting on site in 2020.

With the known landowner / developer activity the Cornwall Housing Trajectory, summarised within (CC.S4.4 – Table 1c) indicates first completions in 2021-22; with development at 35 dwellings pa.

18 Barn Site PZ-H11 A brownfield site within the existing urban area 13 0 13 13

HIA (D3.18) – No designated assets so archaeological & historic building assessments/mitigation and NPPF/Local Plan design requirements will inform the site beyond the allocation stage to ensure adequate mitigation.

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA.

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The site is well located within the existing urban area, without any significant constraints and is located close to an existing primary school.

The site is within single ownership and was promoted through the SHLAA process, plus was promoted to the Council for delivery by local residents. 19 Polmennor PZ-H5 HIA (D3.18) - No further assessment required at this stage. 33 0 33 33 Road Landscape assessment included it within a cell which is highlighted as having a high landscape impact, but the allocation represents only a very small area of the cell (set out in D15.1.4); plus with the rising ground, development could come forward which does not go beyond the ridgeline

HRA (D2) - No direct habitat loss will occur. No loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban areas and is 3539 m distant from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The site is not within or is in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site. Despite the fact that the site includes some grade 2 agricultural land, it is felt that this loss is outweighed by the benefits that would arise from delivering much needed housing, including affordable housing

The site is within single ownership and was promoted through the SHLAA process.

Initial interest in the site has been shown by a local developer, who has been in direct contact with the landowner following discussions with Cornwall Council.

20 Josephs Lane PZ-H6 HIA (D3.18) - No further assessment required at this stage. 16 0 16 16 Landscape assessment included it within a cell which is highlighted as having a high landscape impact, but the allocation represents only a very small area of the cell (set out in D15.1.4); plus with the rising ground, development could come forward which does not go beyond the ridgeline

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA.

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1. SA (D5.10) - site is classified as Grade 3b Agricultural Land so if developed would lead to a loss of agricultural land, however this is not considered the best and most versatile land. The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. Plus the site is not within or is in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site.

The site is within single ownership and was promoted through the SHLAA process.

Initial interest in the site has been shown by a local developer, who has been in direct contact with the landowner following discussions with CC.

21 Poltair PZ-H7 HIA (D3.9) – within close proximity to the Grade II Poltair House 30 0 30 30 Listed Building. Further assessment found potential for less than substantial harm, in agreement with Natural England (CC.S5). Assessment recommended that only land to the south west of the listed asset was suitable for development as it is hidden and has no visual relationship with the front aspect and setting of the listed building. This is reflected by the allocation boundary. There was no objection to the site from Historic England, who supported the Council’s assessment (CC.S4.3)

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA.

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site. The site is not within or is in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The is contained within a wooded area, so cannot be seem within the wider landscape

Within single ownership and have promoted the site through the DPD process (Reg-19 rep 196c). Initial interest in the site has been shown by a local developer, who has been in direct contact with the landowner following discussions with Cornwall Council.

22 Heamoor PZ-H8 HIA (D3.3) – Various assessments undertaken to consider and 350 0 350 350 minimise any impacts on heritage assets including the setting of the Grade II Listed Trengwainton House and Grade II* Registered park and garden. In agreement with Historic England, assessments have set out the boundary being reduced and the inclusion of an area of open space along with a number of mitigation measures; the results is that there would be less than substantial harm to the setting of Trengwainton and other assets in the vicinity, in particular a minor negative impact on long distance views. (With the inclusion of modifications to the policy, set out in the Schedule of Modifications (CC.S4.1.1), Historic England are supportive of the allocation (CCS4.3).

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European sites

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site. The site is not within a designated AONB or AGLV, The landscape assessment of the cell concluded that the majority of the land identified for built development having a low overall landscape assessment (D15.1.4).

The site is within 4 ownerships, with the majority within 2 ownerships, including a developer (Inox); with Cornwall Council owning a strip of land adjacent to Roscadghill Road, which will represent the main access.

The two main owners have submitted Reg-19 reps highlighting their interest in bringing the site forward (196a & 303). Plus the site was promoted through the SHLAA process.

The vehicular access would be off of Roscadghill Road, where the existing road can be extended straight into the site (this land is owned by Cornwall Council). The Cornwall Housing Trajectory, summarised within (CC.S4.4 – Table 1c) indicates first completions in 2022-23, with 35 dwellings in the first year, then 70 per year moving forward, in line with the Cornwall Five Year Housing Statement – Appendix 3 Lead in Times & Delivery Rates Methodology (E6.3).

23 St Clare PZ-H9 The Allocations Policy indicates 130 dwellings; however permission 70 70 0 70 has recently been granted for 127 dwellings on the majority of the site (See CLI site above – No.10) but 2ha of land remain without permission, which could delivery in the region of 60-70 dwellings.

The site is well located on the edge of the existin urban area, on the town side of the A30

HIA (D3.18) – No remaining issues, as points raised within the assessment regarding York housing relate to the area of land now given permission.

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur.

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site. The site is well located with the existing urban area. It is recognised that part of the site is identified as grade 2 agricultural land. The site is not within or is in proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV

The remainder of the site is within single ownership, who has indicated an interest in bring forward the site.

The policy indicates vehicular access should be through the rest of the allocation, which the permission (PA16/12037) would enable.

24 Harbour Car PZ-M1 A brownfield site contained within Penzance town centre 30 0 30 30 Park HIA (D3.18) - Within the Conservation Area and Listed building opposite. Other listed buildings in the wider area, including listed harbour piers/structures. Site is an existing car park. There are existing conservation management plans and an urban survey report which apply to this site so due to this context further site assessment is not required at this stage.

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European site.

SFRA (D4.5) – Flood Zone 3a, site subject to Exception Test. Key objective of proposed development is Town Centre/Waterfront Regeneration. The Council considers that the wider sustainability planning objectives outweigh the flood risks in relation to the site. This information can be viewed in Appendix 3. It is considered that the above information also satisfies part 2 of the exception test. A site specific flood risk assessment will be required by applicants to meet requirements of the Exception Test which will be assessed by the Council in consultation with Environment Agency.

SA (D5.10) – The site is within Penzance town centre and offers the opportunity to make a significant positive contribution to the vitality of the town centre. Plus the site links well with wider aspirations relating to reconnecting the town to the sea and creating ped/cycle links along the waterfront. It is recognised that the site is in a critical drainage area and a Flood Zone 3a area; however the site is part of a wider area that is recognised to need protection regarding shoreline management, therefore the site offers the opportunity to support these wider aspirations to deliver flood protection for the town. Plus the exception test indicated that there are no reasonable alternatives to deliver proposals to support the town centre and there is the ability to create a safe means of access and egress for any vulnerable uses. Furthermore, it is recognised that there are some listed buildings / structures that are on the edge of the site; however it is felt that the impact can be less than substantial and that a sensitive scheme could manage these impacts further. As a result, on balance it is felt that the potential negative impacts are outweighed by the benefits that the site’s development can provide to the town and particularly the town centre.

It is recognised that further masterplanning needs to take place to inform the detail of the scheme, which is why a very conservative estimate of housing provided by the site has been included.

The site has also been recognised by the emerging Penzance Neighbourhood Plan as a development / regeneration opportunity for the town / town centre

25 Coinagehall PZ-M2 A brownfield site within the existing urban area, within the 10 10 0 10 ownership of Cornwall Council

HIA (D3.18) – Historic Urban Core and Conservation Area. Proposals must consider the wider historic buildings and the wider landscape, and respond to existing heritage assessment and management plans for the area; but no key impediments to delivery (Position supported by Historic England (CC.S4.3))

HRA (D2) - No direct habitat loss will occur. No loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is 2921 m distant from the closest European site, Marazian Marsh SPA

SFRA (D4.3) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - Development of the site offers the opportunity to regenerate a poor quality area of the town; plus it offers the opportunity to support the wider aspirations to reconnect the town to the sea. It is recognised that there a Grade II* Church within the vicinity of the site, plus the Grade II listed Jubilee Pool. There is the potential for limited impact on these assets; although a high quality scheme could also make a positive contribution in comparison with the current buildings on the site.

The site is owned by Cornwall Council and undertook a procurement process to secure a development partner. The partner is now in place and are working together to bring forward a mixed use scheme

26 Gurnick PZ-H12 HIA (D3.18) – Concluded that design should reference protecting 30 0 30 30 the skyline and setting, but should not be an impediment to delivery.

HRA (D2) No direct habitat loss will occur and no loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is a substantial distance from the closest European sites.

SFRA (D4-2) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The area does not fall within a Special Area of Conservation, Site of Special Scientific Interest, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance. The site does not fall within or is adjacent to a Cornwall Wildlife Site. The site is not within or in close proximity to a designated AONB. The landscape assessment of cell concluded that the site has an intermediate overall landscape assessment (D15.1.4)

Site within 3 ownerships, all part of the same family. Majority of site was promoted through the SHLAA process. Site can be accessed from the north of the site, with pedestrian access onto the Gurnick Estate.

27 Bellair PZ-H13 Brownfield site on the edge of the town centre, in the ownership of 40 0 40 40 the NHS

HIA (D3.18) - A site long identified for redevelopment; viewed as an opportunity to enhance the historic setting.

HRA (D2) - No direct habitat loss will occur. No loss of supporting habitat or fragmentation will occur. The site is situated on land immediately adjacent to existing urban/industrial areas and is 3539 m distant from the closest European site.

SFRA (D4-2) – Built development will be contained entirely within Flood Zone 1.

SA (D5.10) - The site is well located within the existing urban area, without any significant constraints. The site is not within or in close proximity to a designated AONB or AGLV. The area does not fall within a SAC, SSSI, or other designated site of international, national or regional significance

Site in single ownership, the NHS, who has indicated that it is likely to be disposed of within the next 2-3 years

Access would be directly on to Alverton Terrace, as set out in Part C of the policy.

Total allocations developable within the plan period 1160

Urban SHLAA sites

28 Land at The S1289 Currently not being pursued but potential for delivery. 9 0 9 9 Close, Penzance

Total Urban SHLAA sites developable within the plan period 9

Notes:

Source Cornwall Housing Trajectory 31st March 2017 - E7.2

All the information in the above table, other than column 4, is sourced from the Housing Trajectory (E7.2) and Summary trajectories (E7.1) appended to the Housing Implementation Strategy (E7). The information is also already summarised and broken down for each town in examination document CCS.4.4. Completions on any site prior to April 2017 are not recorded in the above schedule 1st Five year period 2017-22 (column 6) represents the deliverable supply. This information in the housing trajectory has been used as the basis for the five year supply statement (E6.5) which together with its appendices (E6.1-6.4) have been used successfully at numerous appeals to demonstrate a 6.2 years supply.

The council is of the view that all planning permissions should be considered deliverable unless there is clear evidence produced to indicate otherwise (see footnote 11 to the NPPF para 47)

The second 8 year period (column 7) to the end of the Local Plan represents the developable supply in accordance with the tests identified in NPPF paragraph 47 and footnotes. The council is therefor of the view that all sites with permission should be considered developable unless there is clear evidence produced to suggest otherwise.

Trajectory compiled using average lead in times and delivery rates the methodology for which is appended to the Housing Supply Statement 2017 Appendix 3 (E6.2) unless otherwise stated in the table above.

Small sites less than 10 units with permission after a 10% discount for non-delivery are assumed will deliver within 5 years (deliverable). Delivery on such sites from year 6 onwards will be through a small sites windfall allowance (details of this is further explained in both the Five Year Supply Statement (E6.2) and Housing Implementation Strategy (E7). Appendix 1: List of Sites with Permission under 10 dwellings

Sites with permission not started or under construction on sites less than 10 units 31st March 2017

ADDRESS Planning App Ref Not Started Under Construction

The Buildings Station Road Long Rock PA11/08227 0 1 Cornwall TR20 9TT

Land Adj Nancealverne Lodge Heamoor PA16/11510 3 0 Penzance

1 Penbrea Road Treneere W1/09-0607 1 1 Penzance

Land Adjacent To Alexandra Road Penzance W1/09-0877 5 0 Cornwall TR18 4LZ

Glen Trewithen Trewithen Road Penzance PA11/02407 2 0 Cornwall TR18 4LS

69-71 Morrab Road W1/07/P/1194 0 1 Penzance

The Granary 15D Causewayhead Penzance PA11/10235 4 0 Cornwall TR18 2SN

Land Between 35 And 35A Rosevean Road Rosevean Road PA16/02563 1 0 Penzance Cornwall

Land To The South Of 32 Belgravia Street Penzance PA12/11488 0 3 Cornwall

Medrose House Barwis Hill Penzance PA15/06273 0 1 Cornwall TR18 2AN 46 Queen Street Penzance PA12/07470 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4BQ 1 Albert Terrace Penzance W1/06/P/1542 0 1 Cornwall TR18 2DD 61 - 62 Chapel Street Penzance PA13/01657 7 0 Cornwall TR18 4AE E R Jenkins Old Premises St James Street Penzance PA12/00358 0 2 Cornwall TR18 2BT

Land Adj To 16 Jennings Street Penzance PA16/03878 0 2 Cornwall TR18 2LU

Trereife Barton Penzance W1/95/P/0761 1 0 Cornwall TR20 8TJ The Spinney Laregan Hill Penzance PA13/04865 0 1 Cornwall

Groveland 2 Lidden Road W1/09-1039 0 1 Penzance

Land Off Quillet Road And St Golder Road Newlyn Coombe PA15/02166 0 2 Newlyn Cornwall

Land Adj. 24 Gurnick Road Newlyn Penzance PA12/07180 0 1 Cornwall TR18 5DG Gurnick Road Faugan Parc Newlyn W1/02/P/0766 2 0 Penzance Cornwall TR18 5DG Plot 7 Phase 4 W1/05/P/1296 0 1 Faugan Parc Newlyn Old Newlyn School Kenstella Road Newlyn PA13/04062 4 0 Penzance Cornwall TR18 5AB Land Opposite Bayside Fore Street W1/04/P/0541 0 1 Newlyn Trewarveneth Farm W1/88/P/0239 1 1 Newlyn Chywoone Farm W1/89/P/0988 0 1 Newlyn

Luthergwearne Farm W1/90/P/0295 0 1 Heamoor

1A Rock Terrace Heamoor PA13/08382 1 0 Penzance TR18 3JJ 53 Chapel Street Penzance PA14/04940 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4AF 5 Market Jew Street Penzance PA14/03036 2 0 Cornwall TR18 2HN

Former R Cars First Floor Offices The Regent Chapel Street PA14/03012 2 0 Penzance Cornwall TR18 4AE

Red Rose Textiles 7 Alverton Street Penzance PA14/01097 1 0 Cornwall TR18 2QW

Barn Rear Of 25-26 Market Jew Street Penzance PA13/11564 0 1 Cornwall TR18 2HR

Barn Rear Of 25-26 Market Jew Street Penzance PA13/11564 0 2 Cornwall TR18 2HR

10 Chyandour Cliff Penzance PA14/02426 0 1 Cornwall TR18 3LQ Land Adj. Predannack Fradgan Place Newlyn PA13/04084 1 0 Penzance Cornwall TR18 5BD Garages Opposite No 1 Gloucester Place Newlyn Penzance PA14/03977 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5DR

82 Chywoone Hill Newlyn PA14/05873 2 0 Penzance TR18 5AH 19 Polwithen Road Penzance PA16/07065 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4JW

Land Adj To Chyconnick Villa Chycornick Terrace Gulval PA14/11809 1 0 Cornwall TR18 3BU

10 Eden Terrace Newlyn PA14/11685 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5ES Richmond Hall Tolver Place Penzance PA15/00108 1 0 Cornwall TR18 2AB Land East Of Landicia School Lane Gulval PA15/10031 2 0 Cornwall TR18 3BG

1 Gwel Lewern Eastern Green PA16/03609 1 0 Penzance TR18 3AX

Crownley 15 Chapel Street Penzance PA15/00783 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4AW Lizaire Bowjey Hill Newlyn PA15/00723 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5LR Lizaire Bowjey Hill Newlyn PA15/05139 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5LR Trevidren Lescudjack Penzance PA13/06188 1 0 Cornwall TR18 2AY 4 Trewarveneth Street Newlyn PA15/03438 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5JQ

4 Trewarveneth Street Newlyn PA16/04868 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5JQ

32 Lannoweth Road Penzance PA15/01859 2 0 Cornwall TR18 3AB

Penzance Cricket Club St Clare Street Penzance PA15/01724 1 0 Cornwall TR18 2SA

Trewella 18 Mennaye Road Penzance PA15/04578 3 0 Cornwall TR18 4NG Land S Of 17 Pendennis Close Penzance PA15/04674 1 0 Cornwall

Land Adacent To Primrose Bank Alexandra Road Penzance PA15/03453 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4LZ

The Grand Casino Promenade Penzance PA15/05380 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4HH Land R/O 11 Greenbank Greenbank Alverton Road PA14/06822 1 0 Penzance Cornwall

Carlton Hotel Promenade Penzance PA15/07340 0 3 Cornwall TR18 4NW OSullivans Gwavas Quay Newlyn PA15/09666 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5BB Land NE Of Chy An Lyn Gloucester Road Newlyn PA15/09999 1 0 Cornwall

Rock Hall Rock Terrace Heamoor PA16/00833 1 0 Penzance Cornwall TR18 3JJ Redundant Restaurant Abbey Street Penzance PA16/02046 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4AR

37 Medrose Terrace Rosevean Road Penzance PA15/12033 1 0 Cornwall TR18 2BS

Land WSW Of White Dove Studio Bread Street Penzance PA16/01294 1 0 Cornwall

PZ360 St Marys Terrace Penzance PA16/01707 6 0 Cornwall TR18 4DZ 16 Market Jew Street Penzance PA16/04050 2 0 Cornwall TR18 2HR Land South Of 14 Laregan Hill Penzance PA16/01230 1 0 Cornwall

1 Lannoweth Terrace Chyandour Cliff Penzance PA16/04652 1 0 Cornwall TR18 3LN

Suite 6 Camelot Court Alverton Street PA16/02797 1 0 Penzance Cornwall TR18 2QN

Land West Of Trevarrack Row Gulval PA16/04870 1 0 Cornwall Land Adjacent To 26 Gurnick Road Newlyn Penzance PA16/05146 1 0 Cornwall TR18 5DG

66 Morrab Road Penzance PA16/07456 1 0 TR18 2QT

Tattoo Studio 2 Taroveor Road Penzance PA16/07665 1 0 Cornwall TR18 2AA Adjacent/ Behind 36 Market Jew Street On The Corner Of Bread Street Wood Street PA16/07702 4 0 Penzance Cornwall

Alphington House Alverton Place PA16/07719 1 0 Penzance TR18 4JJ

Bosuns Locker Eating House Dock Lane Penzance PA15/04574 2 0 Cornwall TR18 4AS

3 Alverton Terrace Alverton Road PA16/09197 1 0 Penzance TR18 4JH

15 Clements Road Penzance PA16/10777 1 0 TR18 4LL

7 Regent Terrace Penzance PA16/11384 1 0 TR18 4DW

Land South West Of 29 Lansdowne Road Penzance PA17/00050 1 0 Cornwall TR18 4RG