ANALYSIS OF CREW ON ATHENIA SEPTEMBER 1939

Sources Main Source (Scotsman 5 Sep 1939 p11) 319 total including 1 labelled as "not on board," (A Love) plus 8 others added below, less 2 others not on board from Press "cuttings"(G Kennedy, D Swan) = 324.

(Maximum) 324 crew

(Uncertainty remains over 31 with no landing recorded or other confirmation of being on board, apart from appearance on a crew list, who either bypassed landing registration at Greenock (or Galway), were hospitalised without record and without their landing being recorded, or were never on board despite being on crew list.)

324 crew, 70 Deck Department, 32 Engine Department, 161 Stewards Department, 61 Cooks Department.

Crew List Versions Different versions of crew lists used as follows

(Scotsman 5 Sep 1939 p11) = crew lists A

(Liverpool Daily Post 5 Sep 1939 p3) = crew lists B

(Liverpool Echo 4th Sep 1939 p6 and 8) = crew lists C

(Daily Record 5 Sep 1939 p11) = crew lists D

Carroll (2012) ... 316 crew 220 cabin crew (Stewards plus Cooks Departments), about 63 deck crew, about 29 engine crew.

41 new cabin crew on final trip (Carroll, 2012)

Mitchell Library, Glasgow TD49/72/4(2) 306 crew- 220 cabin crew, 57 deck crew, 29 engine crew

Official List of Officers and Crew "landed Galway" (Scotsman 7 Sep 1939 p11)

134 (135 less 1 as John Burke listed twice consecutively) = "landed Galway."

List of survivors "landed Greenock" - Scotsman 6 Sep 1939 p6 (72 under crew, 3 in passengers but noted as crew, 42 in passengers not noted as crew, total 117 = "landed Greenock").

1 landed Halifax (Denis McCaffrey).

31 no landing information or other confirmation at all

22 no landing information, but quoted in press or mentioned in reliable book accounts or applied to Athenia Relief Fund (documents in Mitchell library, Glasgow) etc.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 1 of 23

19 (immediate) casualties (Scotsman 27 Sep 1939 p7).

Passenger Lists from Montreal Gazette Sep 9, 1939, p9: 4 lists - 721 known survivors, including 113 non-Americans on City of Flint, 111 Americans on City of Flint, and List 4 - puzzling Donaldson Line 58 known survivors (Montreal Gazette Sep 9, 1939, p9). Many on list 4 are actually crew members.

DECK DEPARTMENT

Master - James Cook, King's Commendation (50), 35 Herries Road, Pollokshields, Glasgow. Captain Cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Chief Officer - Barnet ("Barney") Mackenzie Copland, OBE, Lloyd's War Medal (32), 276 Strathmartine Road, Dundee (parents' address). Chief Officer M Barnett [sic], landed Greenock, not under "crew." Captain B Copland acknowledged Caulfield (1958) for "repeated assistance on several knotty points." Crew lists A, B, C, D (all B M Copeland).

First Mate / First Officer - John Jamieson Emery (28), Hanwell, 21 Robsland Avenue, Ayr, South Ayrshire. Emery, first officer, landed Galway. In Caulfield (1958), in Carroll (2012). Crew lists A (A, J J Emmery), B, C, D (D, J J Emmery).

Second Mate / Second Officer - Kenneth Gordon Crockett (32) 190 Baldwin Avenue, Knightswood, Glasgow. Crockett, second officer, landed Galway. In Caulfield (1958) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Third Mate / Third Officer - Colin Porteous (28), 16 Ashdale Drive, Moss Park, Glasgow (parents' address). Porteous, third officer, landed Galway. Captain Colin Porteous acknowledged in Caulfield (1958), in Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Surgeon - Doctor Albert "Bert" Sharman 19 Kelvin Court, Glasgow. A Starman (male) British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." (In Caulfield, 1958 and Carroll, 2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Nurse - A D ("Nanny") Weir 4 Melrose Street, Glasgow. A D Weir, nurse, landed Greenock. (In Caulfield, 1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Nurse - M K Moffat 56 Arisaig Drive, Glasgow. M K Moffat, assistant nurse, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Hospital Assistant - H Hammond 25 Braid Street, Glasgow. H Hammond, hospital assistant, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Chief Purser - Alexander Hamilton Wotherspoon 27 Fotheringay Road, Glasgow. Wotherspoon, purser, landed Galway. In 1946 of 11 Hutchinson Drive, Bearsden 1938. In Caulfield (1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Purser - Andrew Taylor 103 Montford Avenue, Glasgow. Taylor, assistant purser, landed Galway. Assistant purser Taylor (in Caulfield, 1958 and Carroll, 2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 2 of 23

Junior Assistant Purser - W A McClymont Rumling or Ruomlig or Uromlig, Norbreck Drive, Giffnock, Glasgow. McClymont, purser, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Purser's Clerk - Eric Bridges (21), 12 Corunna Street, Glasgow. Bridges, purser's clerk, landed Galway. Crew lists A (Elie Bridges), B, C, D.

Purser's Clerk - B Doreton 47 Ashleigh Street, Glasgow. (Ashley Street?). B Dorecton (Liverpool Evening Express 4 Sep 1939 p6). Possibly B Doctor, Landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Purser's Clerk - E G Sabatini 4 Dellfield Close, Watford, Hertfordshire. E Sabatini (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Purser's Clerk - Andrew J Wilson 32 St Andrews Street, Galashiels, Scottish Borders (parents' address). Wilson, assistant purser, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

First Radio Officer - David Don (45), 113 Westburn Road, Cambuslang, South Lanarkshire Don, chief wireless operator, landed Galway. Acknowledged source for Caulfield (1958) and in Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Second Radio Officer - Donald McRae 2 Orchy Gardens, Clarkston, East Renfrewshire, Glasgow. Macrae, second wireless operator, landed Galway. (In Caulfield, 1958 and Carroll, 2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Third Radio Officer - Hugh W Ramsay (26) Congrett Manse, New Deer, Aberdeenshire. Ramsay (in hospital), landed Galway. In Caulfield (1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Carpenter - James "Jimmy" Mitchell 52 Clynder Street, Glasgow. J Mitchell, carpenter, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Carpenter's Mate / Ship's Joiner - Harry Logie 28 McLellan Street, Glasgow. H Logie, carpenter's mate, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Bosun - William Harvey, BEM, Lloyd's War Medal (59) 138 Milnpark Street, Glasgow. W Harvey (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." (Acknowledged Caulfield, 1958, in Carroll, 2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Senior Bosun's Mate - Robert Young 16 McLean Street, Glasgow. Robert Young, boatswain's mate, landed Galway. (Acknowledged Caulfield, 1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Bosun's Mate - Donald McDonald 45 Boyd Street, Glasgow. Donald McDonald, bosun's mate, landed Galway. In Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Lamps - Murdo McDonald 15 Water Row, Glasgow. Murdo McDonald, sailor, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stores - John McEwan (19), lodgings at 19 Ancroft Street, Glasgow. J McEwan, stores, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, Guy McEwan), D.

Quartermaster - George Bowman 958 Govan Road, Glasgow. George Bowman, QM, landed Galway. (Acknowledged Caulfield, 1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 3 of 23

Quartermaster - Alexander "Alex" Campbell 91 Pollok Street, Glasgow. Alexander Campbell, quartermaster, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Quartermaster - Joseph Crossland 153 Mathieson Street, Glasgow. J Crossland (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Quartermaster - James Fraser? 393 Dumbarton Road, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Quartermaster - Angus Graham (28), 12 Aird Point, Stornoway, Lewis, Western Isles and c/o McQueen, 11 McLellan Street, Plantation, Glasgow. A Graham, quartermaster, landed Greenock, and to Western Infirmary, Glasgow. In Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Quartermaster - Allan McLean 5 Russell Street, Rothesay, Argyll and Bute. Allan McLean, quartermaster, landed Galway. (In Caulfield, 1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - W Baird? 56 Glendale Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - D Campbell 16 Pollok Street, Glasgow. D Campbell, AB, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, not on list D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Ian Crombie Riverside, Callander, Perthshire. J Crombie, AB, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Harry Dillon (28) 28 Clark Street, Kinning Park, Glasgow. H Dillon, sailor, landed Greenock. Harry Dillon acknowledged Caulfield (1958), in Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C (all sailor, D Dillon), D (D, able bodied seaman D Dillon.

Able Bodied Seaman - John Herriot Burnside Cottage, Lochgilphead, Argyll and Bute. John Harriott, AB, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, J Herriod), D.

Able Bodied Seaman - J Leckie 20 Ashley Street, Glasgow. J Leckie, sailor, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (A, B and C, no designation, sailor? J Leckie), D.

Able Bodied Seaman - John McDonald 143 McLean Street, Glasgow. George McDonald, AB, landed Galway? Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - A MacGregor? 32 Thornwood Terrace, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Alex. McIntosh 18 River Row, Glasgow. Alex. McIntosh, AB, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - W J Macintosh 4 White Street, Glasgow. W Macintosh (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." In Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Jack McKenzie 12 Brock Street, Hilton, Fearn, Ross-shire. Jack McKenzie, AB, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Angus McKinnon? No address, No Landing info. Presumably to Greenock and then hospital. No record. In life boat that fell into sea - rowed with broken

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 4 of 23 arm and leg, with John Sorbie and Stewardess Johnstone (article Hamilton Advertiser 9 Sep 1939, transcribed at sorbie.net). Crew lists - not on any.

Able Bodied Seaman - Norman Mackinnon (18) 24 Marvig, Isle of Lewis, Western Isles. Norman McKenna, sailor, landed Galway. In Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C (A, B and C, sailor N McKinnon), D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Ronald McLeod, King's Commendation (33), Market Stance, Lochmaddy, North Uist, Western Isles. R McLeod (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." In Caulfield (1958) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Donald MacMillan 3 Glen North Telston, Stornoway, Lewis, Western Isles. North Colston ? North Tolsta? (3 Glen Tolsta, North Tolsta) D McMillan, AB, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - R McNeil 50 (or 15?) Watt Street, Glasgow. R McNeil, AB, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Able Bodied Seaman - John Meek 2 Woodhouse Street, Glasgow. John Meek, AB, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - Donald Niven 205 (or 203?) Wolseley Street, Glasgow. Donald Niven, sailor, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, (A, B and C, sailor D Niven), D.

Able Bodied Seaman - D Smith 7 Crown Terrace, Glasgow. D Smith (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - John Stoddart, 16 Torrin, Broadford, Skye, Inverness-shire. John Stoddart, AB, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Able Bodied Seaman - F Townsend 6 Stanley Street, Glasgow. F Townsend, AB, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Ordinary Seaman - D Cruickshanks 92 Meiklewood Road, Glasgow. D Cruickshanks, OS, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Ordinary Seaman - Robert Dillon 28 Clark Street, Glasgow. Robert Dillon, bridge boy, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Ordinary Seaman - John Harrity 49 Drake Street, Glasgow. John Harrity, OS, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Ordinary Seaman - Peter Lacey, 26 Plantation Street, Glasgow. F Lacey, OS, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Ordinary Seaman - James Simpson 313 Nuneaton Street, Glasgow. J Simpson, OS, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Ordinary Seaman - William Stewart 50 (or 80?) Cardwell Road, Gourock, Renfrewshire. William Stewart, OS, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Crew? - Robert Gillan? British ? American, 42 Madras Street, Bridgeton, Glasgow, landed Greenock, not recorded. To Southern Cross, to destroyer (Daily Record 6 Sep 1939 p5). (AP

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 5 of 23 all sources American survivors uninjured or injured pA-9 Wash. Eve. Star 6 Sep 1939). Quoted as crew from Glasgow (e.g. Detroit Free Press 6 Sep 1939 p4). Robert Gillan, Bridgeton, Glasgow quotes (Evening Post, Wellington, 6 Oct 1939, p5). Quoted Australian Press as crew or passenger (Brisbane Courier-Mail 7 Sep 1939 p3) ( Melbourne Herald 6 Sep 1939 p1 and 3). Crew or passenger, but onboard and landed Greenock. Crew lists - not on any. Possibly Michael Gillen, American passenger?

Crew? - Owen Gorman British, no address. Owen Gorman, crew, landed Galway (in official list). Crew or passenger, but onboard and landed Galway. Crew lists - not on any.

Crew? Deckhand - Denis McCaffrey? (23) 123 Rockwell Avenue, Toronto. "Denis McCaffrey, crew, 123 Rockwill Avenue, Toronto", landed Halifax (revised City of Flint list - Scotsman 26 Sep 1939 p3). Dennis McCaffrey in Caulfield (1956). Crew or passenger, but onboard and landed Halifax. Crew lists - not on any. Baggage Master/ Luggage Master - J McHaffie 71 Glenapp Street, Glasgow. J McHaffie (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D. Bandmaster - D McRae? 21 Springvalley Terrace, Edinburgh. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Musician - E Gibson 9 Willowbank Street, Glasgow. No landing info. Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Musician - Arthur Haslan Washington House, Kirkintilloch, East Dunbartonshire. Arthur Haslan, orchestra, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Musician - Bernard Kammerin 33 Carlin Street, Glasgow. Bernard Kammin, orchestra, landed Galway. Kammrin? Bernard Kenmin, request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C Bern. Kammirn), D.

Musician - John Thomson 112 Kirk Road, Wishaw, North Lanarkshire. George Thomson, musician, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Interpreter - J Synelling 63 Standysmans? Church Road, London. J Synelling, interpreter, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D (all, J Synelli).

Dispenser - Leo Jansen 35 Yewtree Road, Walton, Liverpool. L Jausen (male), British Landed Greenock not in "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D (D, L Jensen).

ENGINE DEPARTMENT

Chief/First Engineer - John Carnegie 12 Viewfield Road, Bishopbriggs, Glasgow. Carnegie, chief engineer, landed Galway. In Caulfield (1958) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Second Engineer - D Jenkins 38 Dunchurch Road, Paisley, Renfrewshire. Jenkins, second engineer, landed Galway. In Caulfield (1958). Crew lists A (D Jenkin), B, C, D.

Junior Engineer - William Russell Jr 27 Cardell Road, Paisley, Renfrewshire. No landing info. (In Caulfield, 1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Third Engineer - H Cockburn 4 Purdon Street, Glasgow. Cockburn, third engineer, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 6 of 23

Fourth Engineer - J Port 5 Uist Street, Glasgow. J Port, fourth engineer, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Fifth Engineer - Thomas A Hastie Ravelston, Chirnside, Berwickshire. T A Hastie, fifth engineer, landed Greenock. (Acknowledged Caulfield, 1958.) Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Sixth Engineer - R Logie 186 Henderson Street, Glasgow. Logie, engineer, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Seventh Engineer - A Marshall 112 Cornwall Street, Glasgow. A Marshall (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Sanitary Engineer - Robert ("Bob") Bryson MacArthur Sim 321 Kingsbridge Drive, Glasgow. Sim, sanitary engineer, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Chief/First Electrician - G B B Bennett 15 Walker Street, Paisley, Renfrewshire. G B B Bennett electrician landed Galway. Chief Electrician Bennet (Caulfield, 1958). Crew lists A, B, C, D (all, J Bennett).

Second Electrician - Charles Donaldson 28 Greenlees Road, Cambuslang. Donaldson, electrician, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Cinema Operator - Jim Clayton 17 Garturk Street, Glasgow. Jim Clayton, wireless operator, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stores - Alexander MacCuaig (56), 123 Heywood Street, Glasgow. Alex. MacCuaig, engine stores, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Greaser and Donkeyman - John Nelson Bekusch 7 Burnside Street, Glasgow. John Bekusch, greaser, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Greaser and Donkeyman - Peter Nelson Bekusch 20 Northburn Street, Glasgow. Caeser Bekusch, greaser, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Greaser and Donkeyman - James Elder (45), 18 Westburn Road, Cambuslang, Lanarkshire. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY

Greaser and Donkeyman - John Fraser? 81 McLean Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Greaser and Donkeyman - James Lenehan (32), c/o O'Brian, 50 Balfour Street, Glasgow. James Lenihan, donkeyman and greaser, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D (D, Joseph Lenehan).

Greaser and Donkeyman - Alex McAuley 167 Neptune Street, Glasgow. Alex. McAulay, donkeyman, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Greaser and Donkeyman - James McConnell (21), 12 Ross Street, Glasgow. James McConnell, greaser and donkeyman, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Fireman and Greaser - Michael Brogan 128 Milnpark Street, Glasgow. Michael Brogan, fireman, landed Galway. lists A (Fireman), B, C (B and C, M Borgan), D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 7 of 23

Fireman and Greaser - E Drummond 104 McLean Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Possibly broken ribs in lifeboat 4 and so in hospital. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Fireman and Greaser - Hugh Gallagher (23) 17 Burleigh Street, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Son of Thomas and Isabel Gallagher. Donaldson Roll of Honour in Dunnett (1960) has H Gallocher (fireman). Crew lists A, B, C, D (all H Gallacher). CASUALTY.

Fireman and Greaser - John Lenehan (23) 50 Balfour Street, Glasgow. John Lenihan, fireman, landed Galway. Crew lists A (Fireman), Not on list B, C or D (problem same initial and address as brother).

Fireman and Greaser - J McConnell 12 Ross Street, Glasgow. J McConnell, fireman, landed Greenock. Crew lists A (Fireman), not on list B, C or D (problem same initial and address as relation? brother?).

Fireman and Greaser - Peter McFlynn 113 Neptune Street, Glasgow. P McFlinn (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A (Fireman), B, C, D.

Fireman and Greaser - Henry Miller 45 Cromwell Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A (Fireman), B, C, D.

Fireman and Greaser - F Young 137 London Road, Glasgow. F Young (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Trimmer - J B Meechan 70 Lenzie Street, Glasgow. J Meechan, trimmer, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stoker? - George McEwan (20) 202 Baltic Street, Bridgeton, Glasgow (Townsville Daily Bulletin, Australia, 7 Sep 1939 p5) (Brisbane Courier-Mail 7 Sep 1939 p3). No landing info. Quoted widely in Greenock (e.g. Liverpool Echo 5th Sep 1939, p6) (Edinburgh Evening News 5 Sep 1939 p5). Crew lists - not on any crew list.

Apprentice/Cadet - James Toole Donald St Helen ? St Hilda's, Cochrane Place, Largs, North Ayrshire. J T Donald, apprentice, landed Greenock. In Caulfield (1958) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Apprentice/Cadet - John Reginald "Jack" White 165 Onslow Drive, Dennistoun, Glasgow. Jack White, cadet, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

STEWARDS' DEPARTMENT

Chief Steward - Reginald Rankin St Lawrence Place, High Road, Saltcoats, North Ayrshire. Rankin, chief steward, landed Galway. (Acknowledged Caulfield, 1958.) Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Second Steward - R Crawford 27 Apsley Street, Glasgow. Landed Galway not recorded. Steward Crawford is mentioned helping Stewardess Rogerson (an acknowledged source in Caulfield, 1958). Photo being carried off Knute Nelson, so presumably to Central Hospital Galway (Daily Record 6 Sep 1939 p16). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

First Saloon Steward and Head Waiter - John Kelly St John Street, Glenluce, Wigtownshire. John Kelly, head waiter, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 8 of 23

Second Saloon Steward - John Kerrigan 1281 Duke Street, Glasgow. J Korrigan (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Injured - on Glasgow list of the injured. Greenock Royal Infirmary (Dundee Evening Telegraph 6th Sep 1939 p4). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Deck Steward - Jack McKinnon 3 Merrick Gardens, Glasgow. Jack MacKinnon, deck steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Smoke-room Steward - James Hamill 3 Arthur Street, Glasgow. James Hammill, smoke- room steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C - J Hanill), D.

Librarian - Thomas Mackie 25 Holmhead Place, Glasgow. Thomas Mackie, librarian, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Tourist Deck Steward - Alex Campbell 19 Rutland Crescent, Glasgow. Possibly N Campbell (male) Landed Greenock not under "crew" (Northern Whig and Belfast Post 6 Sep 1939 p7). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Deck Steward's Boy - William McGuire 4 Incle Street, Paisley, Renfrewshire. William McGuire, deck steward's boy, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Tourist Smoke-room Steward - David Murray 10 Rowantree Place, Lennoxtown, East Dunbartonshire. Two of D Murray (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Tourist Lounge Steward - James "Jimmie" Grant 46 Victor Street, Belfast, Co. Down. J Grant, tour lounge steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Chief Steward's Writer - Robert Wills 41 Whitworth Street, Glasgow. Robert Willett, writer, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - James Blaney 6 Lawrence Street, Glasgow. James Blayney, BR steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - John F Burk 545 Scotland Street, Glasgow. John Burke, B R steward, landed Galway (listed twice, adjacent? - duplication). Crew lists A (John F Burt), B, C, D (D, John F Burt).

Assistant Saloon Steward - James Carlin (56), 83 Hillhouse Street, Balornock, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Hugh Douglas? 33 Middlesex Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - G Flint 315 Crown Street, Glasgow. James Flynn?, section steward, landed Galway. 2 different people? Crew lists A, B, C, D (all G Flint).

Assistant Saloon Steward - William Fotheringham 13 Moir Street, Alloa, Clackmannanshire. William Fotheringham, assistant saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - R Grant 23 Albion Street, Belfast, Co. Down. R Grant, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. (In Carroll 2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 9 of 23

Assistant Saloon Steward - Ernest A Hayden 30 Tormore Street, Govan, Glasgow. Ernest Hayden, assistant saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - William Hughes 21 Glenturret Street, Glasgow. William Hughes, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - B Kemp 64 McLean Street, Glasgow. B Kemp, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - John Kent (50), 7 Colbert Street, Bridgeton,Glasgow. Tower Hill memorial Panel 12. Husband of Jessie Darroch Kent. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY.

Assistant Saloon Steward - J Kinney 205 Wolseley Street, Glasgow. J Kinney, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - John Landells 130 McCulloch Street, Glasgow. John Landells, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - William Lang 24 Farnaw Street, Glasgow. William Lang, steward, landed Galway. Successful request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - James McBain 34 Vicarfield Street, Glasgow. J McBain (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - A McCartney 104 McLean Street, Glasgow. A McCartney, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, A McCarthy), D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - E D McDaid 109 Howwood Street, Glasgow. D McDade (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Peter McDonald 4 Kingsacre Road, Glasgow. Peter McDonald, b r steward, landed Galway. Macdonald? Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Donald McFarlane? 103 Laidlaw Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Donald McKellar 7 Ladysmith Terrace, Dunoon, Argyllshire. Donald McKellor, assistant saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Angus Mackenzie 14 Elderpark Street, Glasgow. Angus McKenzie, assistant saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - A Mackinnon 10 Eskdale Street, Glasgow. William McKinnon?, assistant saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, A McKinnon), D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Thomas McLachlan 11 Midton Street, Glasgow. Thomas McLachlan, assistant saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - J McLean? 7 Springbank Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 10 of 23

Assistant Saloon Steward - J McMullen 5 Meikle Earnock Road, Hamilton, South Lanarkshire. J McMullen (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, J McMullan), D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - A McVey 580 Old Shettleston Road, Glasgow. A McVey, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - P Milmore? 83 Sandyfaulds Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D (B, C and D - B Milmore).

Assistant Saloon Steward - James Morton 490 Paisley Road West, Glasgow. J Morton (male) listed twice, British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Thomas Muir 37 Lochlea Road, Glasgow. Thomas Muir, saloon steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A (F Muir), B, C (B and C, S Muir), D (D, F Muir).

Assistant Saloon Steward - James Murphy 13 Walker Street, Glasgow. No landing info. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - D M Murray 47 Kelvinhaugh Street, Glasgow. Two of D Murray (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Same address Bedroom Steward David Murray. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Colin Ritchie 71 Alldorn Street, Glasgow. C Ritchie, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Edward Stitchell (18) Police Station, Lennoxtown, East Dunbartonshire. Edward Stitchell, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - James Sutherland 274 Bath Street, Glasgow. James Sutherland, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - W Thomson 20 Blackburn Street, Glasgow. W Thomson, (job?) landed Galway (official list). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - A Whiteford 100 George Street, Glasgow. A Whiteford, assistant saloon steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Saloon Steward - Robert Whitelaw 64 Gorbals Street, Glasgow. Robert Whitelaw, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Head Watchman - James M McKay 68 Craigie Street, Glasgow. James McKay, head watchman, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Watchman - Charles William Fordyce (65), 44 Couper Street, Glasgow. Tower Hill memorial Panel 12. Son of George and Jessie Fordyce, husband of Mary Penelope Fordyce. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY

Watchman - Alex McBeth 35 Avenel Road, Glasgow. Alex. MacBeth, watchman, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, Alec Macbeth), D.

Watchman - David Milne 6 Kirkwood Street, Glasgow. David Milne, watchman, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 11 of 23

First bedroom Steward - Archie Graham 9 Edwin Street, Glasgow. Archie Graham, bedroom steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Bedroom Steward - Hugh Cameron 5 Glensie Terrace, Lennoxtown (Glenside Terrace?) No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - John Cummings 13 Kayden Street, Glasgow. John Cummings, bedroom steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, John Cumming in Cook's Dept?), D (D, John Cummins).

Bedroom Steward - James Elliot 17 Harland Street, Glasgow. James Elliott, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - Archie Gillespie 7 Carmichael Street, Glasgow. Archie Gillespie, bedroom steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - George Hepburn? 20 Blackburn Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - David Lindsay 114 Summerfield Street, Glasgow. David Lindsay b r steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - William McIvor 251 Carnwadric Street, Thornliebank, East Renfrewshire. William McIvor, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - John McKeown (47), Craigielea or Craigillen, Queen Street, Dunoon, Argyllshire. Tower Hill memorial Panel 12. Husband of M E McKeown. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D. CASUALTY.

Bedroom Steward - George McLachlan? no address. George McLachlan, b r steward, landed Galway. Crew lists - not on any crew list.

Bedroom Steward - Thomas B Murphy 17 Woodlands Crescent, Bothwell. South Lanarkshire, Thomas Murphy, b r steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Bedroom Steward - David Murray 47 Kelvinhaugh Street, Glasgow. David Murray, bedroom steward, landed Greenock. Same address D M Murray Assistant Saloon Steward. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bedroom Steward - Thomas Rogers 312 Keppochhill Road, Glasgow. T Rogers (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bathroom Steward - Archibald Campbell (52), Maybank, Auchamore Road, Dunoon, Argyllshire, Landed Greenock, not recorded, and to Glasgow Western Infirmary (Dundee Evening Telegraph 6th Sep 1939 p4). Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bathroom Steward - George Duncan 101 Middleton Street, Glasgow. George Duncan, bathroom steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Bathroom Stewardess - Elizabeth English 47 Crow Road, Glasgow. E English, bathroom stewardess, landed Greenock. Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 12 of 23

Bathroom Stewardess - Mary Hill 81 Coplaw Street, Glasgow. M Hill, bathroom stewardess, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Saloon Pantryman - R William Dawson 161 Tantallon Road, Glasgow. No landing info. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Second Saloon Pantryman - George McMillan 36 Briarlea Drive, Giffnock, Glasgow. George McMillan, assistant pantryman, landed Galway. George McMillan Assistant Pantryman in Caulfield (1959) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Saloon Pantryman - Henry Greer 110 Warriston Street, Glasgow. Henry Greer, assistant pantryman, landed Galway. Crew lists A (H Grear), B (H Greer in Cook's Dept?), C, D (D, H Grear).

Tourist Pantryman - R Matthewson 38 Kelvinside Avenue, Glasgow. R Mathewson, tourist pantryman, landed Greenock. Crew lists A (A, R Mathewson), B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Pantry Boy - W Douglas Douglas (14), Shore Houses, Port Lamont, Loch Striven, Dunoon, Argyllshire. Landed Greenock, not recorded, and then Western Infirmary Glasgow, released evening of 5th September (Dundee Evening Telegraph 6th Sep 1939 p4). Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Pantry Boy - Martin A Tacy 61 Liberton Street, Cartyne, Glasgow. Martin Tacy, pantry-boy, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Pantry Boy - S Williamson 80 Allan Street, Dalmarnock, Glasgow. S Williamson, pantry boy, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

First Third Class Steward - J Hamilton 38 Aberdour Street, Glasgow. J Hamilton, first third class steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Third Class Deck Steward - R Thomson 75 Burnbank Road, Hamilton, South Lanarkshire. R Thomson, third class deck steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, not in list C, D.

Third Class Smoke-room Steward - Nigel McKinnon 3 Merrick Gardens Glasgow. N D McKinnon (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Requested assistance from Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Third Class Saloon Steward - Thomas "Tommy" McArthur (24), 27 Sussex Street, Glasgow. Tommy McArthur, steward, landed Galway. Successful request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, not in list B or C, in list D.

Assistant Steward - John Brogan (36), 51 Barnes Road, Maryhill, Glasgow. Landed Greenock, not recorded, burns to leg Glasgow Western Infirmary, (Dundee Evening Telegraph 6th Sep 1939 p4). Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - E H Connell 202 North Woodside Road, Glasgow. E H Connell, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Assistant Steward - N Coull Bertishill House, Shettleston, Glasgow. M Coull, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, N Coul assistant steward in Cook's Dept?), D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 13 of 23

Assistant Steward - John Cunningham 95 Plantation Street, Glasgow. John Cunningham, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Frank Daly 138 Roland Street, Glasgow. F Daly (male), British, landed Greenock not under "crew." Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Ian McPhee Donnelly (26), 52 Gorbals Street, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Son of Bella and Peter. Married to Mary "Molly." Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D. CASUALTY.

Assistant Steward - John Donnelly (23), 100 Kellas Street, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, B (J Donnally in Pantrymen, Cook's Dept?), C (J Donnally), D. CASUALTY

Assistant Steward - J Easton 87 Gilmore Place, Edinburgh. J Easton, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - William Evans 22 Gardner Street, Glasgow. William Evans, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Pantrymen, Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Tommy Graham 72 Carville Street, Glasgow. Tommy Graham, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, (A, in Pantrymen, Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - George Hail (28), 53 (or 33?) Mackeith Street, Bridgeton, Glasgow. Mr George Hail, crew, landed Greenock, not under "crew." (First Class Steward - Carroll, 2012). Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - W Hall? 17 Craebor Street, Thornliebank, East Renfrewshire. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Peter Hammond 54 McLean Street, Glasgow. Peter Hammond, assistant steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Thomas Irving 24 Fairfield Street, Glasgow. Thomas Irving, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - James Kerr 62 Marburn Street, Glasgow. J Kerr, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - D McColl 138 Stanley Street, Glasgow. D McCall (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B (in Pantrymen, Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Michael J McDermott (33), 19 McLean Street, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D. CASUALTY.

Assistant Steward - P McIntyre? 248 Seaward Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - G McLennan? 169 Duke Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 14 of 23

Assistant Steward - D M MacLeod 30 Shieldaig, Strathcarron, Ross-shire. D McLeod (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - J Miller? 8 Crown Terrace, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - James Muirhead (23), 1042 London Road, Glasgow. James Muirhead, steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Pantrymen, Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - J Patterson 153 Stockwell Street, Glasgow. J Patterson (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A (A, J Paterson), B (Pantryman, Cook's Dept?), C, D (D, J Paterson).

Assistant Steward - Kennedy Porter Killyboggin, Magherafelt, Co. Londonderry, Northern Ireland. Kennedy Porter, waiter, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Jake Reid 26 Balglass Street, Glasgow. J Reid, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, mangled as Assistant Stewart J Reid, in Cook's Dept?), D.

Assistant Steward - Thomas "Tom" McKenna Ritchie (19), 71 Killearn Street, Glasgow. T Ritchie, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - John Sorbie Jr (18), 12 Hillview Place, Coalburn, South Lanarkshire. J Sorbie, assistant steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - Samuel Thomson (45), 49 Adelphi Street, Glasgow. Husband of Julia McCafferty Thomson. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D. CASUALTY.

Assistant Steward - Arthur Williamson 80 Allan Street, Glasgow. Arthur Williamson, third class steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Steward - A Wilson, 115 Blackburn Street, Glasgow. A Wilson (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B (in Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - Claude Barrie 153 Mount Annan Drive, King's Park, Glasgow. Mr Claude Barrie, crew, landed Greenock, not under "crew." In Caulfield (1958) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - G Boyd? 88 Agnes Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - Henry Bunton 33 Mill Street, Glasgow. Henry Bunton, BR steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B(Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - A Cameron 32 Clyde Ferry Street, Glasgow. A Cameron (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - John Cartlidge 1480 Overdale Avenue, Montreal. J Cartiledge, assistant br steward, landed Greenock. Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 15 of 23

Assistant Bedroom Steward - P Connor? 16 Naburn Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - George Coyle 681 Argyle Street, Glasgow. George Coyle, assistant br steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - R Eadie 371 Cathcart Road, Glasgow. R Eadie, assistant br steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - John Hogg (51), 166 Hospital Street, Glasgow. Husband of Sarah A. Hogg, of Brantford, Ontario, Tower Hill Memorial panel 12. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY

Assistant Bedroom Steward - W Hogg? 85 Plantation Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - John Inglis 19 Lady Campbells Walk, Dunfermline, Fife (Dundee Courier 5 Sep 1939 p7). John Inglis, bedroom steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - D Johnstone? 2 Knowe Terrace, Giffnock, East Renfrewshire. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, D Johnstone, Cook's Dept?), D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - John Livingston 594 Springburn Road, Glasgow. John Livingston, assistant br steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A (J Livingston), not in list B, C or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - F Macdonald 277 Saracen Street, or 277 Foyers Terrace, Glasgow. J Macdonald (male), British, landed Greenock not under "crew." Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - J McMillan? 556 Dumbarton Road, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), not in list C or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - F MacPhail? 133 Aitkenlead Road, Glasgow. (Aikenhead Road?). No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), C, not on list D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - R McPhee? 58 Risk Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), not in list C or D.

Assistant Bedroom Steward - John Robb 26 Wellshot Road, Glasgow. John Robb, b r steward, landed Galway. Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), C, D.

Third Class Pantryman - Fred Evans 288 Mathieson Street, Glasgow. Fred Evans, pantryman, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Assistant Third Class Pantryman - Thomas Graham Fingal House, Argyll Road, Dunoon, Argyllshire. Thomas Grahan, assistant pantryman, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B (Cook's Dept?), not in list C or D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 16 of 23

Third Class Pantry Boy - Johnston Joyce 27 Balglass Street, Glasgow. ? J Johnston, pantry- boy, landed Galway. Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Linen Steward - J Watson? 90 Albert Road, Gourock, Renfreshire. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Mess Room Steward - R Heath 39 St Mungo Street, Glasgow. R Heath, mr steward, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Mess Room Steward - David Morrison (32), c/o Kennedy, 35 Mayfield Street, Ruchill, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D. CASUALTY.

Captain's Steward - John Anderson 136 Kintra Street, Glasgow. John Anderson, captain's steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Chief Officer's / Officers' Steward - Robert Turpie 52 Monksbridge Avenue, Glasgow. Robert Turpie, officers' steward, landed Galway. In Caulfield (1958). Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Bellboy - F Barnetson 5 Balgair Drive, Paisley, Renfrewshire. Bornetso, bell boy, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Bellboy - George F Benson 11 Meadowpark Street, Glasgow. George Benson, bell boy, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bellboy - Felix Caulfield (17) 224 Forge Street, Garngad, Glasgow. Felix Caufield, bell boy, landed Galway. In Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Bellboy - Freddie Collins 157 Crossloan Road, Glasgow. Fred Collins, bell boy, landed Galway. Fred Collins request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bellboy - Neil Currie 15 Fullerton Street, Paisley, Renfrewshire. Neil Corrie, bell boy, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bellboy - A Forrester, 65 Ladykirk Drive, Glasgow. A Forrester, bell boy, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bellboy - Charles Joseph Gilhooly (14), 3 Barnflat Street, Rutherglen, Glasgow. Landed Greenock, not recorded. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bell Boy - Hugh McFarlane 102 Purdon Street, Glasgow. Hugh McFarlane, bell boy, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bellboy - Thomas McNeill (19) 257 Bellahouston Drive, Glasgow. Thomas McNeill, bells, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bellboy - James Marshall (15), 8 Duthil Street, Govan, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D. CASUALTY.

Bellboy - James Miller (16), 27 South Main Street, Rosehall, Coatbridge, North Lanarkshire. James Miller, bell boy, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 17 of 23

Boots - John Gay 15 Harewood Drive, Edinburgh. John Gay (?) [sic], bedroom steward, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Bugler - F White 21 Clarence Street, Paisley, Renfrewshire. F White, bugler, landed Greenock. Crew lists A (Pulger [sic] F White), not in list B, C, or D.

Printer - John McJarrow (39), 47 Ravenscliffe Drive, Giffnock, East Renfrewshire. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A (J Garrow), not in list B, C, or D. CASUALTY.

G H Steward? - John Guidera Moneymore, County Londonderry, Northern Ireland. George Guidenran, steward, landed Galway. GH Galley Hand? John Guidera, 15 years as a steward with Donaldson Line (Mid Ulster Mail 9 Sep 1939 p6). Crew lists A (J Curdena), not in list B, C, or D.

First Barkeeper - D Hutchinson 31 Kilchattan Drive, Glasgow. D Hutchinson, first barkeeper, landed Greenock. Crew lists A (D Hutcheson), not in list B, C, or D.

Second Barkeeper - Philip Brown (55), 112 Stamperland Road, Glasgow. P Brown (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." Successful request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Barkeeper - R Sinclair 534 Gallowgate, Glasgow. R Sinclair (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Storekeeper - Frank Robinson 54 Commerce Street, Glasgow. Frank Robinson, storekeeper, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Assistant Storekeeper - Hugh Cameron 10 McLean Street, Glasgow. Hugh Cameron, assistant storekeeper, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C or D.

Barber - David Provan (65), 569 Mosspark Drive, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Communication with Athenia Relief Fund - from daughter only? Son of Alec and Mary Provan, husband of Martha Provan. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D. CASUALTY.

Barber - John Farrell Shaw (26), 24 Kennishead Road, Glasgow. John Shaw, hairdresser, landed Galway. Crew lists A (J Shaw), not in list B, C, or D.

Manicurist - M Maltman 65 Sinclair Street, Helensburgh, Argyll and Bute. Maltman, manicurist, landed Galway. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

Manicurist - Helen Provan 569 Mosspark Drive, Glasgow. Helen Provan, manicurist, landed Galway. Communicated with Athenia Relief Fund, daughter of David Provan. Crew lists A, not in list B, C, or D.

COOKS' DEPARTMENT

Chef - Charles Robertson 12 Seamore Place, Largs, North Ayrshire. No landing info. Chef for 16 years - Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Assistant Chef - Walter Davies 107 East Clyde Street, Helensburgh, Argyll and Bute. Walter Davis, assistant chef, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 18 of 23

Second Cook - Alex Cardow 9 Paisley Road West, Glasgow. Alex. Cardow, second ship's cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Third Cook - Charles Simpson 313 Nuneaton Street, Glasgow. C Simpson (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Second Fish Cook - Sidney "Sid" Worrall 40 Avon Street, Hamilton, South Lanarkshire. Landed Galway, not recorded, extensive burns, scalded steam / oil in galley. Central Hospital Galway (many skin grafts), St Bride's Nursing Home, Sea Road, Galway. (In Caulfield, 1958, as Syd Wall). Crew lists A, B, C (all S Worrall), no cooks listed in D.

Second Vegetable Cook - James Whitelaw 421 Moss Road, Glasgow. James Whitelaw, second vegetable cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Soup Cook - James Robinson 6 Mordaunt Street, Glasgow. James Robinson, soup cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Cook? - A Hamilton 2 Lewis Street, Glasgow. A Hamilton British Landed Greenock not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Cook? - D Hobby? 9 Grace Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Cook - Robert McFarlane 213 Stobcross Street, Glasgow. Robert McFarlane, cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Cook - Andrew McOnie (39) 46 Burnhouse Street, Glasgow. Landed Galway not recorded, injured in galley with Worrall. Thank you letter from Galway nursing home in Athenia Relief Fund docs at Mitchell Library, Glasgow. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Cook? - D Moffat 200 London Road, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C - B Moffat), not in list D.

Cook - John Joseph O'Keefe (35) 33 Grant Street, Helensburgh. Landed Galway, not recorded. Seriously scalded - extensive burns. Several months in Central Hospital, Galway. Died in Helensburgh? after not recovering Dec 15, 1940 (helensburgh-heritage.co.uk). Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D. Later CASUALTY

Cook - John Phelps 15 Scanlon Road, Paisley, Renfrewshire. John Phillips, cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Cook? - George Williams 421 Moss Road, Glasgow. Landed Galway, not recorded. Quoted Carroll (2012). Crew lists - not on any crew list.

Assistant Cook - Charles Chalmers 13 Kirkwood Street, Rutherglen, South Lanarkshire. Charles Chalmer, assistant cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Assistant Cook - Michael Dahlscrom 32 (or 38?) Whiteferry Street, Glasgow. Michael Dahlscrom, assistant cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A (M Dahlstrom), B, C, not in list D.

Assistant Cook - J Thomas McGregor (22), 114 Brandon Street, Motherwell, North Lanarkshire. J T McGregor, assistant cook, landed Greenock. Injured. In Caulfield (1958) and Carroll (2012). Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, T McGregar), no cooks listed in D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 19 of 23

Assisant Cook - Tommy McLaughlin (23), 97 Glenisten Street, Glasgow. Thomas McLachlan, cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (all C McLaughlin), (cooks missing from D).

Assistant Cook - Francis Henry "Frank" McClory (34), 1005 Maryhill Road, Glasgow. F McGlory (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Successful request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B, C, (all F McClony), not in list D.

Assistant Cook - Charles Paynter (32) 36 Renfield Street, Glasgow. No landing info. Injured - request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. lists A, B, C (B and C - C Payner), not in list D.

Assistant Cook - William Henry Robinson (32) Canadian, lodged 13 Sugnall Street, Liverpool. W Robinson (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Assistant Cook - James Swan (21), 25 McLean Street, Glasgow. No landing info. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Assistant Cook - William "Willie" Joseph White (22) 8 Caithness Street, Milton, Glasgow. Landed Greenock, not recorded. William White, Assistant Cook, to Greenock and to Glasgow Western Infirmary, released evening of 5th September (Dundee Evening Telegraph 6th Sep 1939 p4). William Whyte passenger request for assistance Athenia Relief Fund. (Crew?) request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists - not on any crew list.

Assistant Cook - H Williamson 81 McLean Street, Glasgow. H Williamson, assistant cook, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

First Baker - H Wilkin 46 Wellington Street, Greenock, Renfrewshire. H Wilkin, first baker, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Baker - B Fyfe? 42 Madras Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Baker - J Lindsay? 9 Malvern Place, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C not in list D.

Baker - J Kelly? 10 Hope Street, Greenock, Renfrewshire. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Baker - Fred Scott 17 Cromer Street, Glasgow. F Scott (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Baker - J McKenzie 83 Stratford Street, Glasgow. J McKenzie (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Baker - James Main? 98 Cambridge Street, Glasgow. No landing info. or other confirmation. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Confectioner - R Currie 53 St Peter Street, Glasgow. R Corrie, crew, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Confectioner - James Rutherford 14 Holmes Street, Hamilton. J Rutherford (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 20 of 23

Butcher - William Graham Inglehouse, Argyll Road, Dunoon, Argyllshire. W Graham (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Butcher - R Jamieson 5 Crathie Drive, Glasgow. R Jamieson (male) British Landed Greenock not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Butcher - R Donnon 72 Cartvale Road, Glasgow. R Donnan (male), British, landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Butcher - Malcolm Hendrie Daisy Cottage, Victoria Road, Dunoon, Argyllshire. Hendrie butcher (?) [sic], landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C - butcher Henry Malcolm), not in list D.

Butcher - A Scrimgeour Hawthorn Place, Edward Street, Dunoon, Argyllshire. E Scrimageour (male), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Sauce Cook - Joy Love 16 Sandylord Street, Glasgow. Joy Love, sauce cook, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D (B, C and D - J Love in stewardesses).

Chief Stewardess - Mrs Christina P Dunlop 5 James Gray Street, Glasgow. Christina Dunlop, chief stewardess, landed Galway. Canadian. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Stewardess - Mrs Hannah Russell Crawford Baird (66), 719 Galt Avenue, Verdun, Montreal, Province of Quebec. Canadian Merchant Navy Halifax Memorial, Nova Scotia, Canada Panel 17. (Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY.

Stewardess - Mrs Barbara Black 14 Drive Road, Glasgow. Barbara Black, stewardess, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Marion Campbell (32), 4 Meadow Road, Glasgow. No Landing Information. (In Carroll, 2012). Crew lists A, B, C, D (B, C and D - Moira Campbell).

Stewardess - Florence E Collister 5784 Tenth Avenue, Rosemont, Montreal. Florence Collister, passage worker, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C, M E Collister), D.

Stewardess - Martha "Mattie" Davidson (29), Auchinblae, Lady Wilson Street, Airdrie, North Lanarkshire. Mattie Davidson, stewardess, landed Galway. Photo with 9 other crew in Galway (Daily Record 6th Sep 1939 p3). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Mrs Elizabeth "Betty" Dumphie mother's address 29 Coats Street, Coatbridge, North Lanarkshire. Bessie Dunchie, stewardess, landed Galway. Request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A (R Dumphie), B, C (B and C Betty Dumphrie), D.

Stewardess - Miss Elizabeth Joan Fulton 37 Castlemilk Crescent, Glasgow. E T Fulton (female), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." E T Fulton request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Canadian. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Miss Alison Harrower (41), 10 Shaw Street, Govan, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Daughter of William and Hannah Foster Denny Harrower. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 21 of 23

Stewardess - Robertina Johnson 8 Craig Road, Cathcart, Glasgow. R Johnson, stewardess, landed Greenock. Detained Victoria Infirmary (Daily Record 6 Sep 39 p4). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Miss Margaret Johnstone (41), 1253 Cathcart Road, Glasgow. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Margaret Johnston? In Carroll (2012). Letter from mother to Athenia Relief Fund. Daughter of James and Christina Johnstone. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY.

Stewardess - Mrs Jessie Lawler (60), 45 Cornwall Street, Glasgow. Wife of Patrick Lawler, of Sholing, Southampton. Tower Hill Memorial Panel 12. Crew lists A, B, C, D. CASUALTY.

Stewardess - Mrs Jessie Lowe 578 Pollokshaws Road, Glasgow. Mrs Jessie Lowe, stewardess, landed Galway. Crew lists A (A, J Lorne), B, C, D (B, C and D, Jessie Lorne), later CASUALTY?

Stewardess - Marion Mackay 8 Foyers Terrace, Glasgow. Marion Mackay, stewardess, landed Greenock. Successful request for assistance to Athenia Relief Fund. Crew lists A, B, C, not in list D.

Stewardess - Katherine McKechnie c/o Price 8 Garriochmill Road, Glasgow. K McKechnie, stewardess, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C (B and C - Catherine McKechnie), D.

Stewardess - Mrs Mary McLeod 37 Elizabeth Street, Ibrox, Glasgow. Mary McLeod, stewardess, landed Greenock. (Acknowledged Caulfield, 1958). Mary McLeod on Glasgow list of the injured. (Glasgow Western Infirmary) exposure, released evening of 5th September (Dundee Evening Telegraph 6th Sep 1939 p4). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Miss Rachel Reid 6 Stable Row, Gartsherrie, Coatbridge, North Lanarkshire. Rachel Reid, stewardess, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - J Robertson 10 Parkgrove Terrace, Glasgow. J Robertson, stewardess, landed Greenock. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Miss Janet Rogerson stayed with sister, 27 Woodburn Avenue, Airdrie, North Lanarkshire. Landed Galway, not recorded. Acknowledged source for Caulfield (1958). Crew lists A, B, C (B and C Jean Rogerson), D (Jen Rogerson).

Stewardess - Violet Stoddart 10 Whitefield Road, Glasgow. Violet Stoddart, stewardess, landed Galway. Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Stewardess - Mrs Sarah Taylor 263 Main Street, Rutherglen, South Lanarkshire. S Taylor (female), British landed Greenock, not under "crew." To Glasgow Western Infirmary, back injury (Daily Record 6 Sep 1949 p11). Crew lists A, B, C, D.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 22 of 23

SOURCES

Websites AHOY = Mackenzie J Gregory's website http://www.ahoy.tk-jk.net/macslog/IndextoarticlesaboutPasse.html

Benjidog website (Brian Watson) https://www.benjidog.co.uk/MiscShips/Athenia.html

CWGC = Commonwealth War Graves Commission 3945war site Mike Kemble (not accessible Feb 2020) uboat.net wrecksite.eu

Book Sources Francis M Carroll (2012) Athenia Torpedoed: The U-Boat Attack that Ignited the Battle of the Atlantic. Annapolis: Naval Institute Press and Pen & Sword, Croyden. (Francis M Carroll, Professor emeritus University of Manitoba, historian.) Max Caulfield (1958) Tomorrow Never Came, W W Norton and Company, New York and Night of Terror, Frederick Muller Ltd., London.

Alastair M Dunnett (1960), The Donaldson Line - A Century of History - 1854-1954, Jackson and Company, Glasgow.

Analysis of Crew Lists: Ronnie MacLean 27 July 2020 Page 23 of 23