DOCSLIB.ORG

An Analysis of Casa De La Mujer Women's Resource Centre In

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
An Analysis of Casa De La Mujer Women's Resource Centre In APRENDER PARA NO DEPENDER: An Analysis of Casa de la Mujer Women’s Resource Centre in Nicaragua By Samantha Blostein A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of Graduate Studies Of The University of Guelph In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts In Sociology Guelph, Ontario, Canada © Samantha Blostein, January, 2013 ABSTRACT APRENDER PARA NO DEPENDER: AN ANALYSIS OF CASA DE LA MUJER WOMEN’S RESOURCE CENTRE IN NICARAGUA Samantha Blostein Advisor: University of Guelph, 2013 Professor Lisa Kowalchuk This thesis investigates an adult education program led by Casa de la Mujer, a women’s organization in San Juan del Sur in the south of Nicaragua. At this centre, women acquire vocational skills and engage in workshops about women’s rights, domestic violence awareness and sexual and reproductive health. Several gender and development scholars suggest that empowerment can be achieved through women’s informal education programs that aim to facilitate critical learning for consciousness-raising and self-awareness. This was the topic of my field research at this centre. I conducted semi-structured interviews and participant observation to gain an understanding of how those in the program feel that their participation has impacted their gendered power social relations and livelihood opportunities. My research indicates that despite facing various barriers, through the skills development and gender training programs participants of Casa de la Mujer are able to act as agents to make strategic life decisions. This thesis is dedicated to Mayra Calderón who has committed her life to promoting women’s rights in Nicaragua. Thank you Mayra and all of the women of Casa de la Mujer who supported me with my research and taught me to keep fighting for what we want to achieve. ----------------- Esta tesis esta dedicada a Mayra Calderón, quien a comprometido su vida a la promoción de los derechos de la mujer en Nicaragua. Te agradezco mucho Mayra y a todas las mujeres de La Casa de la Mujer quienes me apoyaron en mi investigación y me enseñaron a seguir luchando por lo que queremos lograr. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would foremost like to thank my brilliant Academic Advisor, Professor Lisa Kowalchuk, for her guidance and for propelling me to continuously excel, Professor Kerry Preibisch, for her critical comments and questions on my drafts, Professor Sally Humphries for her careful consideration of the details and arguments of my research, Shelagh Daly for being my Grad Mother, and Professor Vivian Shalla for her attention to my progress throughout the Master’s program. The completion of this thesis could not have been possible without the love and care of Alexzander Smith. I am deeply grateful to my friends Olivia Kijewski, Alia Ziesman, Eduardo Huesca, and Amir Mostaghim for stimulating me intellectually and helping me laugh through it all. I am filled with gratitude for my family, Arlene and Barry Blostein and Shawna Rathbun, who always ask enough questions to keep me on track and provide daily (and sometimes hourly) encouragement. I would also like to express my appreciation for the work and struggle of Mayra Calderón and all of the women of the Casa de la Mujer who shared their stories with me as an ally in the fight for women’s rights. iv Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction ..................................................................................... 1 Chapter 2: Literature Review and Conceptual Framework............................ 3 Overview of Education Policy in Nicaragua .....................................................................3 Overview of the Women’s Movement and Gender Issues in Nicaragua .......................12 Women-led organizations: Empowerment and Adult Education....................................20 Conceptualizations of Empowerment ............................................................................23 The Roots of San Juan del Sur’s Casa de la Mujer.......................................................24 Casa de la Mujer, Women’s Education, and Empowerment .........................................29 Chapter 3: Methodology.................................................................................. 32 Participant Observation..................................................................................................34 Semi-Structured Interviews............................................................................................37 Coding............................................................................................................................38 Chapter 4: Data Analysis ................................................................................ 40 Resources......................................................................................................................40 Education ...................................................................................................................40 Social Networks .........................................................................................................59 Outcomes.......................................................................................................................61 Agency...........................................................................................................................69 Chapter 5: Discussion and Conclusion......................................................... 83 Research Questions Addressed ....................................................................................83 Limitations and Future Research Directions..................................................................88 Implications of Research................................................................................................88 Works Cited...................................................................................................... 92 Appendix A: Interview Guide.......................................................................... 98 v Chapter 1: Introduction The purpose of the research for my Master’s thesis is to examine an adult education program led by the women’s organization, Casa de la Mujer (Women’s House), located in San Juan del Sur in the south of Nicaragua. At this centre, women acquire basic literacy, job training, and practical vocational skills. They also engage in discussions about women’s rights to control over their bodies and a life free of violence. I conducted interviews and participant observation at this centre from May – July 2011 and from February – March 2012, to gain an understanding of how those in the program feel that their participation has impacted their gendered power social relations and livelihood opportunities. This research is beneficial to the wider understanding of the relationship between empowerment and women-led organizations and will specifically add to knowledge about the impacts and outcomes of educational programs provided by women-led organizations. At present in Latin America, neoliberal policies designed to reduce countries’ financial deficits and international debt have exacerbated poverty. A severe reduction in state funded social services has intensified gender inequalities. Women are disproportionately affected by situations of poverty in which their agency is compromised by restricted access to education, abuse, and the inability to voice concerns. Specifically in Nicaragua, the neoliberal reforms that were implemented in the conservative administrations of the1990’s have led to state austerity measures, free market economic policies, increased inflation and rising levels of unemployment which have worsened gender inequality. As the FSLN came to power in 2006 abortion became criminalized in all cases, even when the pregnancy endangers the life of the mother. This has led to an increase in clandestine abortions and maternal mortality. Nicaragua is the second poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, after Haiti. Forty-three percent of the population lives on less than a dollar a day, and seventy-eight percent live on less than two dollars a day (Bradshaw, 2002). In Nicaragua, as a result of social service cuts that were implemented in the 1990’s, local and foreign organizations have stepped in to provide informal literacy and job training programs to low-income adults. Many of these are still running today and many new groups have emerged to deal with Nicaragua’s situation of poverty. Given women’s subordinate socioeconomic status, literacy and job training are important methods of providing them with useful life skills. Several gender and development scholars suggest that one way to achieve gender equality is through women’s informal education programs that aim to facilitate critical learning for self-awareness. This was the topic of my field research at Casa de la Mujer. By looking at the specific case study of Casa de la Mujer, my research examines the impacts of a women-led community education program in the specific context of Nicaragua. The questions that this 1 research seeks to address are: How, if at all, does Casa de la Mujer promote and facilitate women’s empowerment? How, if at all, do courses and workshops run by Casa de la Mujer promote gender transformation, characterized by a change in power relations between genders? And what factors inhibit women from accessing the programs offered by Casa de la Mujer? 2 Chapter 2: Literature Review and Conceptual Framework Overview of Education Policy in Nicaragua With backing from a large section of the populace including
Load more

Recommended publications
  • When and Why Religious Groups Become Political Players
    11 When and Why Religious Groups Become Political Players The Pro-Life Movement in Nicaragua1 Silke Heumann and Jan Willem Duyvendak In this chapter we ask when and why religious groups become political play- ers, by analyzing the involvement of Catholic and Evangelical churches in the Nicaraguan “pro-life” movement. The movement emerged as a collective player after the 1990 elections that marked the end of the Sandinista regime and the transition to neoliberal democracy under the 14-party opposition coalition UNO (Unión Nacional Opositora). Its mobilizing capacity grew dramatically over time, especially in opposition to therapeutic abortion: while the first anti-abortion rally in 1994 drew around 5,000 people (Envío Team, 1994), in 2000 rallies drew 15,000 (La Prensa, 2000), and by 2006 200,000 people (Kampwirth, 2008: 129). The emergence and growth of the pro-life movement represented a major challenge to the quest for greater recognition of gender equality, sexual rights and reproductive rights in Nicaragua and culminated in a total abortion ban in 2006 – even when the life of the pregnant woman is at stake (Heumann, 2010; Reuterswärd et al., 2011; Kampwirth, 2006; Kampwirth, 2008). Much of this success is attributed to the political power and mobilizing capacity of the churches (Kane, 2008). It may seem almost self-evident to see churches as political allies or even the driving force of the pro-life movement. However, as we demon- strate in this chapter, there is nothing natural about churches becoming an ally or active participant in this or any political movement. In the case of Nicaragua, we show how Evangelical churches were initially at odds with the Catholic Church and eschewed all political activism as outside their spiritual mandate.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 1 Anthropological Theory
    Introduction This dissertation is a historical ethnography of religious diversity in post- revolutionary Nicaragua, a study of religion and politics from the vantage point of Catholics who live in the city of Masaya located on the Pacific side of Nicaragua at the end of the twentieth century. My overarching research question is: How may ethnographically observed patterns in Catholic religious practices in contemporary Nicaragua be understood in historical context? Analysis of religious ritual provides a vehicle for understanding the history of the Nicaraguan struggle to imagine and create a viable nation-state. In Chapter 1, I explain how anthropology benefits by using Max Weber’s social theory as theoretical touchstone for paradigm and theory development. Considering postmodernism problematic for the future of anthropology, I show the value of Weber as a guide to reframing the epistemological questions raised by Michel Foucault and Talal Asad. Situating my discussion of contemporary anthropological theory of religion and ritual within a post-positive discursive framework—provided by a brief comparative analysis of the classical theoretical traditions of Durkheim, Marx, and Weber—I describe the framework used for my analysis of emerging religious pluralism in Nicaragua. My ethnographic and historical methods are discussed in Chapter 2. I utilize the classic methods of participant-observation, including triangulation back and forth between three host families. In every chapter, archival work or secondary historical texts ground the ethnographic data in its relevant historical context. Reflexivity is integrated into my ethnographic research, combining classic ethnography with post-modern narrative methodologies. My attention to reflexivity comes through mainly in the 10 description of my methods and as part of the explanation for my theoretical choices, while the ethnographic descriptions are written up as realist presentations.
    [Show full text]
  • Crackdown on Freedom 1N 1Caragua and Profiles Of
    United States Department of State "Crackdown on Freedom 1n@ 1caraguaell and Profiles of Internal · Opposition Leaders August 1986 I \ \ \ t \ I CRACKDOWN ON FREEDOM IN NICARAGUA AND PROFILES OF INTERNAL OPPOSITION LEADERS U.S. Department of State August 1986 CRACKDOWN ON FREEDOM IN NICARAGUA INTRODUCTION 1 CLOSURE OF LA PRENSA 3 La Prensa under Somoza 3 La Prensa under the Sandinistas 6 ATTACK ON THE CHURCH 7 CARDINAL OBANDO Y BRAVO 9 Archbishop of, Managua CRACKDOWN ON POLITICAL ACTIVITY 14 PROFILES OF INTERNAL OPPOSITION LEADERS VIOLETA CHAMORRO 17 Publisher, La Prensa Former Member, Sandinista Junta AZUCENA FERREY 20 Vice President Social Christian Party ALVIN GUTHRIE 24 Secretary General Confederation for Labor Unification ENRIQUE BOLANOS 27 President Superior Council of Private Enterprise CONCLUSION 29 NOTES 31 INTRODUCTION In late June 1986, the Sandinista government intensified repression in Nicaragua by cracking down on the free press, the church, and political parties. on June 26, the government closed La Prensa, the last independent newspaper in Nicaragua. Only the Sandinista National Liberation Front (FSLN) newspaper, Barricada, and the pro-FSLN, government-subsidized El Nuevo Diario remain in circulation. Radio and television are completely under Sandinista control. on July 28, 1986, Monsignor Bismarck Carballo was prevented from returning to Nicaragua after a trip abroad, several days later, on July 4, Bishop Pablo Antonio Vega of Juigalpa in Chon tales province was detained by State security forces, taken by helicopter to the Honduran border, and expelled from Nicaragua. The government simultaneously announced stricter enforcement of already severe restrictions on Nicaraguan political parties. The Sandinistas' crackdown on Nicaraguans met strong criticism both outside and inside Nicaragua.
    [Show full text]
  • Nicaragua: Update on Government Corruption Scandal & Related Events, July 24 - August 2 Deborah Tyroler
    University of New Mexico UNM Digital Repository NotiCen Latin America Digital Beat (LADB) 8-7-1992 Nicaragua: Update On Government Corruption Scandal & Related Events, July 24 - August 2 Deborah Tyroler Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/noticen Recommended Citation Tyroler, Deborah. "Nicaragua: Update On Government Corruption Scandal & Related Events, July 24 - August 2." (1992). https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/noticen/7656 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Latin America Digital Beat (LADB) at UNM Digital Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in NotiCen by an authorized administrator of UNM Digital Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. LADB Article Id: 060103 ISSN: 1089-1560 Nicaragua: Update On Government Corruption Scandal & Related Events, July 24 - August 2 by Deborah Tyroler Category/Department: General Published: Friday, August 7, 1992 July 24: In a Managua press conference, former deputy economy minister Noel Vidaurre accused Presidency Minister Antonio Lacayo of "covering-up" the embezzlement of over US$1 million in government funds. (For previous coverage of scandal, see CAU 07/24/92.) Vidaurre said that in November 1991, he had personally informed Lacayo of the misappropriation of funds from the economy ministry, but Lacayo indicated that he was not interested in pursuing the matter. Vidaurre further charged that in June 1992, Lacayo dismissed him from his government post as "punishment" for having "washed dirty laundry in public." [In January 1992, Vidaurre was fired from his post as deputy economy minister. (See CAU 01/10/92.) Shortly thereafter, he was given a high-level post in the government's National Public Administration Corporation (Corporacion Nacional del Sector Publico-CORNAP).] Next, Vidaurre said that he has proof that former deputy presidency minister Antonio Ibarra had embezzled US$200,000 and deposited the funds in bank accounts in Switzerland and the US.
    [Show full text]