Recidivism of Young Parolees
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
If you have issues viewing or accessing this file, please contact us at NCJRS.gov. U.S. Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics " -' -y":: '-~ Recidivism of Young Parolees By Allen J. Beck, Ph.D. BJS Statistician May 1987 Bernard E. Shipley BJS Program Manager Recidivism is one of the most States. It examines the relationship important issues facing those who between rates of recidivism and a Approximately 69% of a group of young formulate and administer our variety of other factors, including parolees were rearrested for a serious sentencing and corrections the age and prior arrest record of crime within 6 years of their release policies-policies intended to the parolees, the length of time each from prison, 53% were convicted for a punish and rehabilitate offenders parolee had spent in prison, and the new offense, and 49% returned to pris and to protect the public from nature and location of the rearrest on. These findings are based on a crim e. This special report, with charges. sample of 3,995 parolees, representing its innovative methodology, broad The Bureau of Justice Statistics 11,347 persons between the ages of 17 scope of coverage, and rich data, wishes to express its gratitude to the and 22, who were paroled from prisons should be of particular interest to personnel at the Identification in 22 States in 1978. These States all those concerned abou t these Division of the FBI and all others accounted for 50% of all State prison policies. whose cooperation and assistance ers paroled in the Nation during that This report traces the made this report possible. year. criminal activities over a 6-year Stet'en R. Schlesinger period of a sample of young adults Director Other findings include the follow paroled in 1978 from prisons in 22 ing: • Excluding violations of parole and those paroled had been rp.arrestedj • The longer the parolee's prior arrest probation, these parolees were re within 2 years, 47% had been re record, the higher the rate of recidi arrested for more than 36,000 new fel arrested. vism-over 90% of the parolees with six onies or serious misdemeanors, includ or more previous adult arrests were re ing approximately 6,700 violent crimes • Recidivism was higher among men, arrested compared to 59% of the first . and nearly 19,000 property crimes. blacks, and persons who had not com time offenders. pleted high school than among women, • Approximately 10% of the persons whites, and high school graduates. • The earlier the parolee's first adult paroled accounted for 40% of the sub arrest, the more likely the chances for -sequent arrest offenses. • Almost three-quarters of those pa rearrest-7!J% of those arrested and roled for property offenses were re charged as an adult before the age of • About a fifth of the subsequent ar arrested for a serious crime compared 17 were rearrested, compared to 51% rests occurred in States other than the to about two-thirds of those paroled for of those first arrested at the age of 20 original paroling State. violent offenses. or older. • An estimated 37% of the parolees • Approximately a third of both prop • Time served in prison had no consis were rearrested while still on parole. erty offenders and violent offenders tent impact on recidivism rates-those were rearrested for a violent crime who had served 6 months or less in pris • Recidivism rates were highest in the upon release from prison. on were about as likely to be rearrested first 2 years after an offender's release as those who had served more than 2 from prison. Within 1 year, 32% of years. Measuring recidivism Cumulative percent of young adults paroled in 1978 Criminal history da ta for the who were rearrested, reconvicted, and reincarcerated, sample of parolees in this study were by6-month intervals obtained from the Federal Bureau of Investigation. These data included Cumulallve percent information on arrests, prosecutions, 100 and incarcera tions for felonies and serious misdemeanors that occurred either before the parolee was released from state prison in 1978 or within 6 years after release. (See Methodology for a further description of the sample 75 and discussion of data contained in the FBI criminal history files.) A rate of recidivism is an estimate of the likelihood that oomeone released from prison commits another crime. 50 Estimates of recidivism vary with the length of the followup period and the measure selected. Three measures of recidivism are employed in this study: rearrest, reconviction, and reincarcer ation. 25 Rearrest refers to any felony or se rious misdemeanor arrest reported to the FBI after the date of parole. Ar rest data were reported on fingerprint o K-_______________________________________________ •________ _ cards, which were submitted by an ar resting agency, typically a police Months 24 36 48 72 department or a sheriff's office. Re 12 60 conviction refers to a conviction on at Figure 1 least one charge after the date of pa role entry. Reconviction data were reported to the FBI by prosecutors' cidivism rates because not all offenders Recidivism and time on parole offices, courts, and correctional are prosecuted or go to trial. Parolees agencies. Reincarceration refers to are often not prosecuted for new offen Within 6 years after their release any return to a prison or any admission ses but have their parole revoked and from prison in 1978, an estimated 69% to a local jail with a new sentence. are returned to prison to serve the of the 11,347 young parolees had been Confinements in correctional institu balance of their original sentence. rearrested; 53% had been reconvicted; tions were reported to the FBI by the and 49% were reincarcerated (figure receiving agencies, typically State or Moreover, new convictions were 1). Recidivism rates were the highest Federal prisons and local jails. the most underreported of the three in the first 2 years for all three meas measures. Data on convictions and ures. Nearly a fifth of those paroled Because the three measures reflect other dispositions were not reported for were rearrested in the first 6 months, a successive transactions within the approximately a third of the arrests in third in the first year, and nearly half criminal justice system, the percen t the criminal history files; however, by the end of the second year. Of all rearrested will always be the highest; more than half of the 927 persons who those who were rearrested during the 6- the pe,<1'9nt reincarcera ted, the lowest. lacked a final disposition on their first year followup period, more than two rearrest were convicted on a subse thirds were arrested by the end of the In previous studies of criminal quent arrest. secQnd year. history records, criminologists have relied on arrests Sf the principal meas Because of this underreporting, the Approximately a fifth of all parol ure of recidivism. For the sake of true reconviction rate following parole ees were incarcerated within a year of simplicity and comparability with these would be greater than the reported con their release from prison; nearly a studies, arrests are also emphasized in viction rate, but still less than the re third, within 2 years. Of all those who this report. Violations of parole or pro ported arrest rate. If all persons with were reincarcerated within 6 years of bation that lead to incarceration arE:: in out dispositions on their first rearrest parole, 62% were reincarcerated by the cluded among arrests. or without convictions on subsequent end of the second year. arrests had been convicted, the under Although oome rearrested individ estimate would be at most 15%. These rates of recidivism are simi uals may have been innocent of the lar to those reported in recent single crime charged, using only reported con State stUdies (see Appendix). vic tions would understa te the true re- lFor II discussion or problcms with other measures or recidivism, see Maltz, M.D., Recidivism (Orlando, Fla.: Academic Press, 1984). 2 Volume of crime Table 1. The DUmber or DeW arrest charges Cor you~ adults paroled in 1978, by type or offense The 11,347 young inmates entering pal'Ole in 1978 were rearrested an esti Number of charges for which parolees were arrested within 6 :lears of release mated 25,383 times and charged with Before -36,726 new offenses. More than 6,700 Rearrest minimum eligible of the new charges were violent offen charge Total discharge dateS ses, including an estimated 324 mur b ders, 231 rapes, 2,291 robberies, and All charges 36,726 10,832 3,053 assaults (table 1). Violent offenses 6,753 2,259 Murder 324 132 Rape 231 55 More than half of the new charges Robbery 2,291 882 were for property offenses (51 %). Assault 3,053 906 These parolees were arrested for Property offenses 18,904 5,528 approximately 6,600 burglaries, 5,590 Burglary 6,620 1,916 larcenies, and 2,300 forgery and fraud Fraud 2,300 770 offenses. Almost a third of the new Larceny 5,590 1,533 charges were for drug offenses (9%), Drug offenses 3,244 884 public-order offenses (18%), and other Public-order offensesb 6,735 1,757 unspecified felonies (3%). Other offenses 1,090 404 An estimated 10,832 (29%) of the ILrhe date when the offender is first ~ctors affecting this date. f eligible for complete discharge from all xcluding violations of probation, parole, new arrest charges occurred before pa corl'ectional supervision, including and warrants. rolees were first eligible for discharge deductions for time credits and other from parole. For each parolee a date was established by the paroling agency indicating when the offender was first Table 2.