Page 1of27 between this versionandtheVersionofrecord. Pleasecitethis articleasdoi:10.1111/trf.14488. through thecopyediting, typesetting, pagination andproofreading process,whichmay lead todifferences This istheauthor manuscriptaccepted forpublicationandhas undergonefullpeerreview buthasnotbeen Netherlands; Affiliations: Affiliations: (Blo Network Research Blood Care Critical Pediatric Institute, San Francisco, CA; CA; Francisco, Institute,San Kenneth E. Remy MD, MHSc MD, Remy KennethE. Hospital, Columbus, OH; Columbus, Hospital, Pediatrics, Division of Pediatric Critical Care, An Critical of Pediatric Division Pediatrics, Keywords: Keywords: 3333 count: Word [email protected] 286 2830 Office:(314) Louis,63110 MO St. 8208 Box Ave. Campus Euclid S. 660 MHSc. MD, Remy, KennethE. Author Corresponding OH; 5 1 MD OH; OH; and Laboratory Medicine, University of Rochester, R Rochester, University of LaboratoryMedicine, and Philip J. Norris MD Norris J. Philip California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA; CA; Francisco, San Francisco, San California, Critical Care, St. Louis, MO; Louis,MO; Care, St. Critical Department of Intensive Care Medicine, Academic Med Academic Care Intensive Medicine, Departmentof Departmen of Medicine, School University Washington 5 , Kathleen Nicol MD Kathleen , Nicol 4 7 Mechanisms of Red Blood Cell Transfusion-Related Im Transfusion-Related Cell Blood Red Mechanismsof Pediatric Critical Care and Cardiology, University Care and Cardiology, Critical Pediatric Transfusion Medicine/Blood Bank and Clinical Labora and Clinical Bank Medicine/Blood Transfusion
6 transfusion, immunomodulation, RBC, plasma immunomodulation, transfusion,
Author ManuscriptHosp Children’s Nationwide of Pathology, Department
8,9
, Mary , PhD Dahmer K. : : This article isprotected by copyright. All rights reserved. 6 3 , Allan Doctor MD Allan , The Research Institute at Nationwide Children’s Hos Children’s Instituteat Nationwide TheResearch 2 9 1 Division of Critical Care Medicine, Nationwide Chil of Critical Care Nationwide Medicine, Division Departments of Laboratory Medicine and Medicine, Un Medicine, and Laboratory Medicine of Departments , Mark W. Hall MD Hall Mark , W. Transfusion 10 1 10 , and Jennifer A. Muszynski MD, MPH MD, Muszynski A. and Jennifer , , Neil Blumberg MD Neil , University of Michigan, Department of Department Universityof Michigan, n Arbor, MI. n 2,3 , Jill Cholette , MD Jill od Net) Net) od ochester, NY; of Rochester, Rochester, NY; NY; Rochester, ofRochester, t of Pediatrics, Division of Pediatric of Pediatric Division of Pediatrics, t ical Center, Amsterdam, the the Amsterdam, ical Center, tories, Departments of Pathology of Pathology Departments tories,
munomodulation (TRIM) munomodulation 8 7 Blood Systems Research Research Systems Blood , Philip C. Spinella MD Spinella C. Philip , ital, Columbus, Columbus, ital, 4 , Nicole P. Juffermans , Juffermans P. Nicole pital, Columbus, Columbus, pital, dren's 2,3 2,3 iversity of iversity for the 1 , ,
researchdirections. immunomodulati transfusion related of RBC mediators In this products. of RBC effects immunomodulatory requires an complexities these factors.Unpacking produ blood betweeninteractions individual complex pati transfused in of RBCs effects immunomodulatory Defini effects. andimmunosuppressive inflammatory Thes cellfunction. immune and alter interactwith mult a contain products RBC adverse with outcomes. crit in common is cell(RBC) transfusion blood Red systemic inflammation both whom in trauma patients Abstract
ScholarOne, 375GreenbrierDrive,Charlottesville, VA,22901 1 (434)964-4100 Author Manuscript
This article isprotected by copyright. All rights reserved. Transfusion e interactions can lead to both pro both lead to can einteractions in depth understanding of the mechanisms of mechanisms the of understanding depth in ct characteristics and patient specific risk risk patient specific and characteristics ct review, we outline and classify potential potential classify and review,we outline itude of immunomodulatory mediators that that mediators of immunomodulatory itude and immune suppression are associated are suppression associated andimmune ng clinical outcomes related to ngoutcomes clinical ents remains a challenge, likely due to to due likely a remains challenge, ents on and provide suggestions for future for suggestions and provide on ically ill, post surgical, and post post surgical, icallyill, Page 2of27 Page 3of27 particularly for critically ill patients. ill critically for particularly blood products. Clinically, RBC transfusion is ass is transfusion RBC Clinically, products. blood In the United States, 11 to 16 million red blood c red blood million 16 to 11 States, United In the a RBC to equating decade, last annuallythe during INTRODUCTION and increased mortality and morbidity; mechanisms o morbidity; mechanisms and mortality andincreased betwee associations independent demonstrate studies hospitalization. r ICU patients of 37 60% with suites, andoperating emergenc in commonplace particularly is transfusion dysregulated recipient immune responses. immune recipient dysregulated infectio of nosocomial development the dysfunction, and immunosuppressive effects of RBC product exposu product of RBC effects andimmunosuppressive More rece transfusion. RBC allogeneic leukoreduced transfusion. renal cadaveric higher in significantly kidneyswas observatio the with (TRIM) relatedimmunomodulation Immunomodulation Transfusion-Related Cell Blood Red criticalknowledge. mediat potential classify relatedimmunomodulation, current literat summarize will review Thefollowing Beginning in 1973, Opelz and colleagues provided in and colleagues provided Opelz 1973, in Beginning ScholarOne, 375GreenbrierDrive,Charlottesville, VA,22901 1 (434)964-4100
Author13,27 Manuscript 6 12 These findings strongly suggested immunosuppress suggested These findings strongly
Nonetheless, RBC transfusion may deleteriou have Nonetheless, transfusion RBC
This article isprotected by copyright. All rights reserved. 13,14 Mounting evidence from predominantly observationa from predominantly Mounting evidence 13,14,21,28 32 Transfusion ociated with new or worsening organ organ worsening new or ociatedwith transplant patients who received RBC RBC received who patients transplant transfusion every 2 seconds. 2 every transfusion eceiving a transfusion during eceivinga transfusion ure on mechanisms of RBC transfusion RBC of uremechanisms on The extent to which RBC which to The transfusion extent n, and cancer recurrence, suggesting suggesting and cancer n, recurrence, ors, and propose a research agenda to fill fill to agenda aresearch and propose ors, n RBC transfusion, dysregulated immunity immunity dysregulated transfusion, RBC n y departments, intensive care units (ICUs) care units yintensive departments, f which are only partly understood. only fare which partly nt findings suggest both pro inflammatory pro inflammatory both suggest findings nt n that the survival rate of transplanted of transplanted rate survival the that n re, including pre storage leukoreduced re,leukoreduced including pre storage ell (RBC) units were administered were (RBC) administered units ell
itial evidence for RBC transfusion evidence for itial RBC ive effects of non effects ive s immunologic effects, effects, immunologic s 1 5 RBC RBC 15 26
l l
presentation, suppression of lymphocyte proliferati suppression presentation, blood products on individual patients and to mitiga and to patients individual on products blood blood products and the multitude of potentially imm of potentially multitude and the products blood function. impaired natural killer cell function, alterations alterations function, cell natural killer impaired 1). (Figure vesicles extracellular iron (heme, contents hemolytic component mediators, i have been mediators potential many characterized, mechanisms of RBC transfusion related immunomodulat transfusion related of RBC mechanisms re Future challenging. remains patients individual ef immunomodulatory total sum the Overall,defining activation, and inflammatory cytokine release. cytokine and inflammatory activation, neut enhanced priming, leukocyte including: effects models Inof pre clinical a variety cellfunction. that demonstrates evidence aofwealth pre clinical i dysregulation immunologic to contributes directly inflammation and immune suppression are significant are suppression and immune inflammation for critic relevant be particularly may transfusion i Indeed,mixed effects surprising. not are mixed effects of RBC transfusion may seem contradictory, contradictory, may seem transfusion of RBC effects While mechanisms for RBC transfusion related immuno transfusion related for RBC mechanisms While 14,36 40
ScholarOne, 375GreenbrierDrive,Charlottesville, VA,22901 1 (434)964-4100
Author Manuscript pro inflammatory both evidence While supporting
This article isprotected by copyright. All rights reserved.
Transfusion 13,17,21,31,33 35 in T lymphocyte ratios, defective antigen antigen defective ratios, lymphocyte T in , RBC product exposure results in inflammatory in results exposure product RBC , ally ill patients in whom both excess excess both whom in patients ill ally mmunomodulatory potential of RBC of RBC potential mmunomodulatory search to determine the effects of individual of individual effects the searchdetermine to RBC products can directly modulate immune immune modulate can products directly RBC on, and decreased macrophage phagocytic phagocytic and decreased on, macrophage te potential risks depends on understanding understanding on depends risks te potential n transfused patients remains unclear, though unclear, though remains transfused n patients rophil chemotaxis, monocyte/macrophage chemotaxis, rophil dentified. These include leukocyte derived leukocyte derived These include dentified. unomodulatory mediators contained therein, therein, contained mediators unomodulatory given the complex nature of transfused nature of transfused complex given the fects of particular RBC products in in products RBC of particular fects ly associated with adverse outcomes. adverse with lyassociated release), platelet