Thank You for Your Support!
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2019 SACRED PLACES Approaches to preserving historic houses of worship RESCUED Saves of 10 Most Endangered Thank you for your Annualsupport! Report FROM THE PRESIDENT BY THE NUMBERS BOARD OF DIRECTORS OFFICERS William R. Goins Rushville Hon. Randall T. Shepard Honorary Chairman Tracy Haddad Columbus Parker Beauchamp Patience Pays Off Chairman David A. Haist Culver James P. Fadely, Ph.D. MANY OF THE PROJECTS Indiana Landmarks undertakes Past Chairman Judith A. Kanne Rensselaer Sara Edgerton require a long view and lots of patience. If immediate gratification Vice Chairman Christine H. Keck Evansville were our goal, we’d be a miserable lot. Saving historic places can Marsh Davis President Matthew R. Mayol, AIA $ take years of trial-and-error strategies, endless committee meet- Indianapolis Doris Anne Sadler ings, and a fair number of fundraising culs-de-sac. Secretary/Assistant Treasurer Sharon Negele Attica Thomas H. Engle 209,415 Take our multi-year effort to save the Thomas Taggart Assistant Secretary Cheryl Griffith Nichols in grants awarded by Little Rock, AR Memorial in Indianapolis’s Riverside Park. The Neoclassical Brett D. McKamey Indiana Landmarks for Treasurer Martin E. Rahe monument was built in 1931 to honor Taggart, the city’s mayor Cincinnati, OH Judy A. O’Bannon reuse studies, repairs, from 1895 to 1901 and credited for developing a plan for Secretary Emerita James W. Renne Newburgh and preservation Indianapolis’s public park system. DIRECTORS George A. Rogge Gary education programs Over time, as the memory of Taggart faded and maintenance Hilary Barnes Memorial Opera Indianapolis Sallie W. Rowland House, Valparaiso priorities in the city’s parks shifted, the Taggart Memorial fell Indianapolis LEE LEWELLEN Edward D. Clere into such disrepair that it landed on Indiana Landmarks’ 10 Most New Albany Peter J. Sacopulos Terre Haute Endangered list. We formed a task force, chaired by Indiana Ellen Swisher Crabb Indianapolis Robert L. Santa Bloomington Landmarks’ past board chair and Taggart biographer Jim Fadely. Cheri Dick Zionsville Charlitta Winston While our Taggart Task Force raised money and stabilized the Indianapolis Olon F. Dotson structure, a relevant and sustainable use—and badly needed resto- Muncie John D. Zeglis Culver ration—proved elusive but the task force remained persistent. Jeremy D. Efroymson Indianapolis Beau F. Zoeller Patience was rewarded with the Lilly Endowment’s recent, Indianapolis miles traveled by Gregory S. Fehribach extraordinary gift of $9.2 million to the Indianapolis Parks Indianapolis Indiana Landmarks Foundation for the Taggart Memorial Mainstage Amphitheatre staff to project. We collaborated on the grant application, which includes OFFICES & HISTORIC SITES events—tours, lectures, workshops, Landmark Looks, the memorial’s restoration. It will find new life as the backdrop Headquarters Southeast Field Office for a multipurpose outdoor amphitheater, home stage of the Indiana Landmarks Center Aurora art shows—plus daily tours at 1201 Central Avenue 812 926 0983 the historic West Baden and Indianapolis Shakespeare Company’s free performances, and a Indianapolis, IN 46202 Southwest Field Office [email protected] Evansville French Lick Springs hotels, host of cultural events staged by Indy Parks. 317 639 4534 812 423 2988 800 450 4534 and hundreds of seasonal tours Patience may, indeed, be a virtue. And often it’s a key strategy in Western Regional Office Northwest Field Office Terre Haute in Indianapolis of Monument communities to saving historic places. Gary 812 232 4534 219 947 2657 Circle, City Market Catacombs, Huddleston Farmhouse help people save and Central Regional Office Cambridge City and the Athenaeum—that educate Indianapolis E 765 478 3172 V A revitalize historic 317 639 4534 N and entertain people and highlight H Coca-Cola Building Tour Morris-Butler House A L Eastern Regional Office Indianapolis E historic places places Cambridge City 317 639 4534 765 478 3172 Marsh Davis, President Veraestau Northern Regional Office Aurora South Bend 812 926 0983 574 232 4534 in grants recom- French Lick and West Northeast Field Office Baden Springs tours mended by Indiana Wabash 866 571 8687 (toll free) Landmarks and 800 450 4534 812 936 5870 Southern Regional Office awarded by the Jeffersonville Efroymson Family 812 284 4534 Fund to stabilize, Indiana Landmark’s Sacred Places Indiana program awarded a $25,000 grant rehabilitate, and On the to Terre Haute’s United Hebrew Congregation for exterior repairs to the 1911 ©2019, Indiana Landmarks; ISSN#: 0737-8602 restore historic Cover temple. Learn about other historic houses of worship we’re assisting on pg. 4. Indiana Landmarks publishes Indiana Preservation bimonthly PHOTO BY PAIGE WASSEL for members. To join and learn other membership benefits, buildings statewide Alber House, Wabash visit indianalandmarks.org or contact memberships@ indianalandmarks.org, 317-639-4534 or 800-450-4534. To PHOTOS BY PAUL HAYDEN offer suggestions forIndiana Preservation, contact editor@ indianalandmarks.org. 2 INDIANA PRESERVATION indianalandmarks.org 3 NEWS this extraordinary work of art. We’ll continue to make the land- mark a top preservation priority in 2019. In Connersville, the diocese donated Trinity Episcopal Church to us, knowing it would be protected. Using a $10,000 grant from the Efroymson Family Fund of the Central Indiana Community Foundation, Indiana Landmarks repaired the roof of the 1859 Gothic Revival church and is repainting the adja- cent parish house built in the same era. We’re offering the two buildings for sale, with preservation easements to protect their exterior character, for $70,000. You can get more details and see additional photos at indianalandmarks.org/for-sale. Three years ago, we created Sacred Places Indiana, a pro- gram aimed at turning the tide by helping congregations remain in historic houses of worship. Originally a three-year pilot funded by a $1.2 million grant from Lilly Endowment, we won support for another year from the Allen Whitehill Clowes Charitable Foundation, Inc., and the Efroymson Family Fund. Launched in 2015 in partnership with Philadelphia-based Partners for Sacred Places, the program has provided intensive training in landmark stewardship, com- munity engagement, and fundraising to 29 congregations in historic churches dating from 1849 to 1964. David Frederick directs the program and he’s encouraged by the success of many participating congregations. “Here’s just one example,” he offers. “Spencer Presbyterian Church, Aid for Sacred Places in Distress a participant in the second-year cohort, harnessed the train- ing we provided to address the needs of its 1879 structure and AS THE NEW YEAR DAWNS, INDIANA LANDMARKS Indiana Landmarks glass windows and furnishings by engage the community. It was the first in its cohort to apply for owns five former houses of worship, landmarks we bought or is working to pre- New York’s Tiffany Studios make the one of our $5,000 Sacred Places Indiana planning grants.” The serve the stunning that were gifted to us when the congregations dwindled, in one Reid Memorial interior a stunning experience—and a congregation hired Bloomington’s Matheu Architects to survey case to a single parishioner. It’s a deeply troubling trend. We’re Presbyterian rarity—enhanced by a dramatic fan- the church and establish repair priorities. searching for buyers who’ll repurpose some of these places, Church in vaulted ceiling, carved wood trim, and “We have begun addressing those items,” notes Sylvia Dyar, architecturally among communities’ most significant struc- Richmond with a a historic organ built by Boston’s Hook a member of the congregation that received the Sacred Places Tiffany Studios- tures. Indiana Landmarks Center in Indianapolis occupies such designed interior. and Hastings. training. “Number One on the list was electrical needs. The a structure, a nineteenth-century Methodist church we adapted The church closed The church sits empty after dimin- report scared our members and spurred them to address that as theaters, reception hall, gallery, and office building. in 2017 and faces an ished attendance prompted the pres- issue at once. It confirmed some issues we knew about and uncertain future. As Protestant, Jewish, and Catholic congregations shrink in PHOTO BY EVAN HALE bytery to close the building in 2017. highlighted items we were not aware of. The congregation has number, they struggle with a tough religious and preservation Indiana Landmarks has been working begun to step up and get enthused about this restoration which challenge: how to maintain aging landmarks built for much with local groups to create a future for ties into our sesquicentennial celebration in 2020,” Dyar notes. larger congregations and facing deferred maintenance. Indiana the building. A complicated ownership In the past year, the church received a $25,000 grant from Landmarks plays a leading role in advocating for these impor- situation makes its next chapter unclear. Sacred Places Indiana to seed its building fund. tant places, seeking solutions for shuttered church buildings Built through a gift from Richmond Sacred Places Indiana awarded $137,500 in grants in the past and providing stewardship and building advice to congrega- industrialist Daniel Reid, the church’s fiscal year to help the participating churches with repairs, fund- After Connersville’s Trinity Episcopal Church (top) closed in 2018, tions still occupying their historic structures. deed stipulates that should