“The Jaguares are not toothless and there’s no team more at home on the road, as proven by them winning in against a outfit that went on to run the Volume 19, Number 24 close in Saturday’s semi-final.” - AllOutRugby.com 04 July 2019 Register to receive your own free weekly newsletter at www.rugbyrsa.co.za

Refereeing Incompetence Rears Ugly Head

Throughout this year’s tournament, the element of incompetent – or perhaps just stupid – referees has repeatedly reared its head. The examples are too many to mention is such a small space but two incidents that stand out happened at Newlands: Egon Seconds screwing the Lions; and Marius Jonker (TMO) screwing the Crusaders.

Not surprisingly, it happened again on semifinal weekend, but more about that later. As we noted last week, the didn’t really deserve a place in the knock-out rounds and only got there because of the competition structure and by benefiting from The visitors were easily among the top three sides in appalling refereeing in this year’s competition. this year’s competition so it was brilliant rugby from both sides for most of the 80 minutes. The lead This was abundantly evident in the way in which the changed several times during the match and the Jaguares destroyed the Australians in the semifinal: visitors could have, and perhaps should have, won the the Argentinians were 10-0 up after 7 minutes and contest. already 20-0 up before the end of the first quarter. And it might have been worse: that score included The difference, for some fans, was the refereeing two penalty kicks that could easily have been screw-up (see pic in PDF version) that allowed a directed at the corner rather than the posts. blatant infringement by to go unpunished in the last few minutes of the match. [The The visitors finally managed to get on the video in the linked article above is geo-locked so scoreboard with a seven-pointer in the last act of the you’ll need a VPN to fool the NZ Herald into thinking first half but when play resumed after half-time, the you’re in - Ed] Jaguares turned the screws. They ran in three more tries without reply to take the match with a It was a crucial decision that could have been convincing scoreline of 39-7. corrected by the TMO given that the whistle was blown for a scrum at that point. If he had done that, The second semifinal was a New Zealand derby in the replays would have led to only one conclusion: where the visiting Hurricanes took on Hurricanes penalty about 12 metres out and that might the home-town Crusaders. have changed the result of the match.

KEY TOPICS IN THIS NEWSLETTER

Can the Jaguares Slay the Giant Crusaders? Player Exodus Not All Bad for SA Rugby ’s All Black No 10 Dilemma Questions Remain Over Springbok Selections First Division Starts Friday Can the Springboks be Perfect at RWC2019?

Page 1 Can the Jaguares Slay the Giant Crusaders? Steve Hansen’s All Black No 10 Dilemma

A favourite local rugby commentator was on Twitter in the wee hours of Monday and asked: “The SA Conference champs lead Super Rugby for Kicks, Turnovers Won and Passes. Can the Jags make these work for them in Christchurch on Saturday?”

It’s a good question but let’s look at the history first. The Crusaders have been in Super Rugby from the very beginning in the early 1990s when it was the Super 6 involving three New Zealand teams, two Australian teams and the Fijian national team. The Super Rugby semifinal between the New But the Canterbury outfit first won the competition Zealand’s top two teams, the Hurricanes and the when it was the Super 12 back in 1998 and, since Crusaders, presented the All Black coaching staff then, they have won the title another eight times, with a wonderful opportunity to see a head-to-head including 2017 & 2018, when they defeated the between the top two contenders for the number 10 Lions in the final on both occasions. jersey at the . And the match itself provided some surprises in that regard. For the Jaguares, on the other hand, this is only their fourth season in Super Rugby. In 2016, they finished However, before we get there and, indeed, before that 13th (out of 18); in 2017 they finished 10th (also out match was played, Two Cents Rugby put together an of 18); and last year they were 7th (out of 15), interesting statistical comparison. As he puts it: “A making the play-offs for the very first time. This run through on the key stats for and season they finished the regular season in second Richie Mo'unga for the 2019 Super Rugby season to spot, a mere seven points adrift of the table-topping see who is playing better in the lead up to the Rugby Crusaders. Championship and Rugby World Cup.”

That’s the history so now let’s consider the article And the results presented in a YouTube video may that Front Row Grunt linked to on AllOutRugby.com surprise you – some of them certainly surprised us. . It compares the statistics of the two teams over the For example, he tried to measure the x-factor of the 2019 season and provides an interesting perspective. two players using statistics and Mo'unga came out marginally on top. There was one passage that stood out for us: “The Jaguares are not toothless and there’s no team more Interestingly, we would have been surprised if we at home on the road, as proven by them winning in saw that before Saturday’s semifinal but not so much Wellington against a Hurricanes outfit that went on after it. The link behind the photo in the PDF version to run the Crusaders close in Saturday’s semi-final.” of this newsletter shows some of the play the pair produced this season in Super Rugby. It’s sublime.

As completely unbiased observers we were struck by how Mo'unga has matured and evolved as a player over the past few seasons and were extremely impressed with the confidence he brings to his job these days.

We suspect that All Black coach Steve Hansen will start all of the tough games with Mo'unga at 10 and bring Barrett on off the bench. It’s certainly what we’d do in his position.

Page 2 Page 3 Blue Looking Good in U21 Champs Currie Cup First Division Starts Friday

It’s difficult to believe but it’s already Currie Cup time again - the First Division of the venerable competition kicks off on Saturday at 14:30. But it was not without challenges as the Namibian XV originally scheduled to take part was withdrawn and had to be replaced by the .

Brenden Nel tells us that this was because Namibia decided that the risk of injury to its World Cup players was too high. Authorities felt that a couple of warm up games against South African provincial teams in August followed by a test match against a Although it’s early days yet, a report on tier two nation would be better preparation for Ruggaworld.com suggests that the are RWC2019. showing championship form in the SA Rugby U21 Championship. The competition kicked off two weeks ago and after two rounds, the -based outfit is the sole remaining undefeated team.

But that record is likely to come under serious threat this weekend when they face last year’s champions, the , on Saturday. Although, if they want to retain their title, the team from will have to lift their game after their rather lacklustre start to the competition this year.

In round one, Bulls beat Western Province (55-27), Lions defeated Free State (54-33) and prevailed over the . But back to the Currie Cup First Division. The first match in the 2019 season will be at the King Edward Last weekend, Bulls thrashed Cheetahs (73-31), Sport Grounds in Montagu, Western Cape. It will pit Lions suffered a shock defeat to the Sharks (23-12) against Border Bulldogs on and WP beat Leopards (50-28). Saturday at 14:30.

Elsewhere, there’s a 3pm kick-off in where Leopards host EP Elephants as well as in where entertain a Jaguares XV from Argentina. Half-an hour later, the fourth and final match of the weekend kicks off in Brakpan where Valke welcome the defending champion, SWD Eagles.

But sadly, it appears that you’ll have to go down to the respective grounds if you want to catch any of the action as none of it appears to be scheduled to be broadcast on television. This level of the 2019 Currie Cup competition will culminate in a final scheduled for August 30.

Page 4 Page 5 Player Exodus Not All Bad for SA Rugby Questions Remain Over Springbok Selections

It was always inevitable that SA Rugby's new Last week, SA Rugby released Springbok coach contracting model would exacerbate the annual ’ extended training squad for the exodus as players explore their earning potential Rugby World Cup 2019. And on Friday, Rassie overseas. added another fourteen players to the camp.

And Rassie Erasmus’ decision to bring no fewer than [The 14th player not mentioned in the piece linked nine overseas-based players into his Springbok above is Marco van Staden, added as cover for the training group was the cherry on top. It’s highly still injured - Ed] unlikely that, having called them up, the Springbok coach will not make use of all of these players in the True to form, the assembled punditry has been run-up to the World Cup. Just look at the names: salivating and adding their two cents to the debate over the selections. Interestingly, the general (Ulster, Ireland), consensus is that the squad, largely, is as expected. (Toulouse, France), But there remain a few puzzling names of players (Saracens, England), either well past their best or never of the required (Gloucester, England), quality in the first place. (Sale Sharks, England), (Toulouse, France), (, Japan), (, England), Frans Steyn (Montpellier, France)

Suddenly, the disincentive for players to ply their trade overseas is gone and top players see the opportunity to improve their games in more competitive leagues as another route to Springbok selection. Or even for selection by other countries, For most, that boils down to three names: Frans with or without an ancestral claim to citizenship. Malherbe, and Andre Esterhuizen. Malherbe used to be a quite decent This can be seen in the growing list of Super Rugby tighthead but that was long ago and far away. He was players who have signed overseas contracts for next repeatedly out-scrummed in virtually every game he season. We ran a piece in May talking about it but played in this year’s Super Rugby tournament. And that list has now grown considerably, mostly due to yet, he remains in the squad. the addition of a host of Lions heading overseas: The two crash-ball specialists in the midfield have (, Scotland) neither the guile nor the intelligence to make an Stephan Lewies (Harlequins, England) impact at the World Cup. Neither has the imagination (Stade Français, France) to vary their play and, as a result, are entirely too (Stade Français, France) predictable – much to the joy of any and all Harold Vorster (TBC) opposition. It’s pointless being big and strong if the (TBC) opponents always know what you're going to do. Danie Mienie (TBC) (TBC) A far better combination for the Springbok midfield (TBC) was recently suggested by Unbiased Rugby on his video blog. Basically, in the absence of Jan But it’s not necessarily bad news because from Serfontein due to injury, he suggests playing Jesse adversity comes opportunity. The vacancies created Kriel at 12 and at 13. It’s an idea that by this mass exodus will have to be filled - probably makes far too much sense not to be tried. by the talent on display in the SA U21 Championship and Currie Cup.

Page 6 Can the Springboks be Perfect at RWC2019?

In his latest column on AllOutRugby.com, the inimitable Dan Retief has posed another good question in the run-up to Rugby World Cup 2019 in Japan: Can Boks be perfect?

According to Retief: “As always the answer could either be a simple, 'yes they can', or boundlessly complicated. is good at rugby, if not in recent years, and contained in the raw material that coach Rassie Erasmus has to work with there is certainly the essence of a formidable combination...

“Siya Kolisi’s men are capable of the perfect formula, but whether they can unfailingly conjure it “It was classic Vermeulen, the ultimate battering ram, to win all the little battles that add up to an 80- but instead of his usual head-down surge, the No 8 minute performance, over the course of a nine- flicked the ball behind his back to who week tournament, is doubtful.” had looped around on the left, and the captain on the day scooted over in at the corner for the try that put the He recalls a moment of magic at Boks into the last four. the 2015 World Cup: “There were two crucial elements in this important “With five minutes to go in the quarter- score. Vermeulen did something he was not known to final...against Wales at Twickenham the do, thus catching the Welsh wanting, and the execution Springboks were 18-19 down and seemingly of the behind-the-back flip pass was perfect and headed out of the tournament; unable to break straight to the hands of Du Preez.” down dogged Welsh defence. But off a strong, left- hand scrum close to the Welsh goal line, which It’s that kind of magic that the Springboks will have to wheeled right, Duane Vermeulen picked up and replicate, probably more than once, if they are to broke to the blindside. The Welsh flanker on that triumph in Japan. So, can they do it? Absolutely. But side had been compromised by the wheel and when whether they will be given the time and space to do it Vermeulen was confronted by scrumhalf Lloyd is another question entirely. Williams, wing Alex Cuthbert was drawn off his wing to assist with the tackle.

Page 7

For your weekend viewing pleasure

We mentioned last week that Super Rugby is wrapping up and so it is, with the final this Saturday (09:35) in Christchurch when Jaguares tackle defending champions and nine-time competition winners, Canterbury Crusaders.

Will the home team make it a tenth title or will the visitors win their first? That is the question.

But sadly, it’s one of the very few rugby questions that will be answered on television this weekend. There is other rugby action, such as the final two days of the U18 and Academy Week 2019. And, fortunitously, it is being LiveStreamed for those not in the Free State near and Grey College.

Unfortunately, there’s no such luck with the Currie Cup First Division, which kicks off on Saturday (page four) or with the U21 SA Rugby Championships. It appears that neither event is being televised this year. Such a pity.

Thanks for reading our newsletter. We need feedback to improve The Rugby Team at Leopard Newsletters. it – and only you can give us that feedback. Please take the time to send us an email. We want to hear from you – good, bad or ugly, a pat on the back or a kick in the butt. Remember to look us up on Twitter, where you'll find many of our contributors on our timeline.

Page 8