The 92Ndmeeting of the State Levelexpert Appraisalcommittee

Minutes oft/Ie 92"d meeting ofthe State Expert Appraisal Committee /Ield on 22"d& 23,d December. 2014

The 92ndMeeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22nd" 23rd December, 2014 at Conference Hall no. 1 " 2, National Environmental Research Institute, Nehru Marg, Nagpur - 440020.

The following members were present for the committee meeting:

Shri. T. C. Benjamin Chairman Prof. (Dr.) Bhaskar N. Thorat Member Shri. ChandrakantI. Sambutwad Member Dr. M. M. Kulkarni Member Prof. (Dr.) RameshDod Member Shri. Dinesh Hiremath Member Dr. B. N. Patil Member Secretary

At the outset the Chairman welcomed all Members present to the meeting. Thereafter the items in the agenda were taken up for discussion.

The Minutes of 9ptmeeting of SEAC held on 5th& 6th December, 2014 were confirmed without any change by all the members.

/ /

(

Meinber Secretary Page1 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Commiuee held on 22nd&23,d December. 2014

District Collector and DMO presented the 188 proposals before the Committee.

Sr. Name of Village Taluka Name of the Cluster Location of the Sand Gut Area of the Area Tota Total Permitt GSDA Gram Whet No. river Number (Gut No.) etc. Sand block in I depth ed sand certifi Sabha her (LxB) in m2 Hect. dept recom resourc cate Certifi block h of mend es (Y/N) cate mark sand edby LxBxDe (Y/N) ing is as GSDA pth in dust per for m3= er L B GSD excav brass A (m) ation (m) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 1 Bramhapuri Akola Purna River A 37, 2, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4 235 20 0.47 2.50 0.5 830 Y Y Y 2 Chandur Akola Morna River F 39,56,57,71,100,101,129 170 30 0.51 2.50 0.3 541 Y Y Y 3 Changephal Akola Morna River F 5,6,7 35 20 0.07 2.50 0.5 124 Y Y Y 4 Dahihanda Akola Shahanoor A 236 to 257, 268, 277, 276, 274, 600 15 0.9 3.00 1 3180 Y Y Y River 273,270,269,267,266,265, 264, 263, 260, 5 Dhamna Akola Purna River D 134 to 137 & 128, 129 220 22 0.48 3.00 1 1710 Y Y Y 6 Donwada Akola Purna River R 10,11,12, 13, 14, 73, 74, 384, 800 18 1.3 2.50 0.5 2544 Y Y Y 388,389,390,295 7 Eklara Akola Purna River A 7,8,5,307,306,303,274,272, 250 50 1.25 3.00 1 4417 Y Y Y 279,271,270,268,269,264, 261,254,253 8 Gandhi Gram Akola Purna River E 1,41,181 212 11 0.24 3.00 1 824 Y Y Y 9 Gopalkhed Akola Purna River D 139,140 117 14 0.16 3.00 1 579 Y Y Y 10 Hingna Akola Morna River F 2,3,4 148 36 0.53 2.50 0.5 941 Mhaispur Y Y Y 11 Hingna Akola Purna River E 169,170,9,12,17,19,18,164, 198 26 0.51 3.00 1 1819 Y Y Y Tamaswadi 163, 152/1,153/3,152 (J 6 ~

Page2of58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23rdDecember. 2014

12 [awla Bu. Akola Katepurna H 6,7,5 38 30 0.11 2.50 0.5 201 Y Y Y River 13 Kapileshwar Akola Katepurna B 204, 205, 206, 207, 209, 751 50 3.76 2.50 0.5 6634 Y Y Y River 217,220,225,223,224,226, 235 14 Kati Akola Purna River C 58,1,2,101,134,135 920 20 1.84 3.00 1 6502 Y Y Y 15 Katyar Akola Purna River B 20 to 26, 31, 32 740 30 2.22 3.00 1 7845 Y Y Y 16 Mhaisang Akola Purna River B 25,1,739,740,711 666 15 1.2 3.00 1 3530 y y y 17 Nimbhora Akola Purna River E 104,110,111,112,138 473 24 1.28 3.00 1 4011 Y Y Y 18 Nirat Akola Purna River D 2,3,4 200 20 0.4 3.00 1 1413 Y Y Y 19 Pati Akola Purna River C 140,141,142,143,144,145, 650 20 1.24 3.00 1 4594 Y Y Y 146,147,148,149,150,153, 154,156,158,175,176,174,6, 7 20 Rohna Akola Purna River A 4,19,18,17,20,21,38,39,40, 980 20 1.96 3.00 1 6926 y y y 41,43,44

21 Sanglud Bu. Akola Paisaga nulla I 476,370,369,362 540 4 0.22 2.50 0.5 382 Y Y Y 22 Sangvi Kh. Akola Morna River G 71,72,74 200 55 1.1 2.50 0.5 1943 Y Y Y 23 Somthana Akola Morna River F 30,31,33,25,26,27,34,35, 149 35 0.52 2.50 0.5 921 Y Y Y 36, 24 Takli Pote Akola Katepurna H 2,4 80 20 0.2 2.50 0.5 283 Y Y Y River 25 Ugwa Akola Morna River G 734,790,791,792,566,565, 120 15 0.18 2.50 0.5 318 Y Y Y 564,570,569,568,567,539, 540,541,542

26 Vairat Rajapur Akola Purna River D 44,45,146 190 20 0.38 3.00 1 1343 y y y 27 Vadad Bk. Akola Purna River R 322 to 343 34,35,372,36,41 830 50 4.15 2.50 0.5 7332 Y Y Y to 50 28 Vadad Kh. Akola Purna River A 128,127,126,118,117,116, 675 15 1.02 3.00 1 3578 y y y 105,103,102,92,93,94,95, 106,107,108,109,110,111, 112,114 29 A~oda Akot Khai Rivar A-E 145,147,149, 151, 71,72 l 160 15 0.24 2.50 0.4 339 y y y \ 1\

~ Me~ Page 3 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o[the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,d December. 2014

30 Balegaon Akot Khar Nulla A-B 172 to 180, 194' 195, 198, 199, 340 9 0.31 2.50 0.3 324 y y y 201,208,209 31 Bhod Akot Purna River A-A 63 160 30 0.48 3.00 1 1696 Y Y Y 32 Keliveli Akot Purna River A-A 41,39,40 1330 15 2 2.60 0.6 4230 Y Y Y 33 Lamkani Akot Chandrika A-B 253, 254, 255 75 6 0.05 2.30 0.3 48 Y Y Y river 34 Maroda Akot Khar Nulla A-D 146,145,141,142,140,139, 350 5 0.18 2.50 0.3 186 Y Y Y 138,137 35 Mundgaon Akot Chandrika A-B 188 141 5 0.07 2.50 0.3 75 Y Y Y river 36 Nandkhed Akot Shahanoor A-A 5, 1,6,7,223,219,188,218, 112 7 0.08 2.50 0.3 83 y y y River 217 37 Palsod Akot Maholi A-D 116,76,174,175,172,169, 770 9 0.69 2.50 0.3 735 Y Y Y 145, 147,12,79 38 Nakhegaon Akot Purna River A-A 57,58,1 1251 12 1.5 3.00 1 5305 y y y Pilakwadi 39 Rambhapur Akot Bordi Nulla A-C 66,69,76,77,276,341,301, 100 7 0.07 2.50 0.2 49 Y Y Y 267,265 40 Rudhadi Akot Pathar River A-E 169,157,152,149,148,147, 500 30 1.5 2.50 0.5 2650 Y Y Y Chinchona 143,142,138

41 Shahagur Karla Akot Aad river A-C 26, 20, 38, 39 77 10 0.08 2.50 0.3 82 Y Y Y 42 Varula Akot Khar Nulla A-B 110 to 139 175 9 0.16 2.50 0.3 167 Y Y Y 43 Wadali Desh. Akot Bordi Nulla A-C 516,520,463,537,128,160, 170 9 0.15 2.50 0.5 270 Y Y Y 64 44 Andura Part 1 Balapur Purna River B-K 622 to 627, 630, 662 to 669, 340 15 0.51 3.00 1 1802 Y Y Y 675 to 677, 681, 3, 5, 6, 7 45 Andura Part 2 Balapur Purna River B-D 36 to 45 205 5 0.1 3.00 1 362 y y y 46 Babhulkhed Balapur Mhais River B-L 84,85,40,41,71,74,47,51 480 5 0.24 2.50 0.5 424 Y Y Y Kalbai &Piwala Nulla 47 Bahadura Balapur Man River B-A 9 to 13,15, 16, 21 to 25, 31, 32, 130 12 0.16 2.50 0.5 276. y y y 33 in the Man river 48 Barlinga Balapur Barlinga B-L 76,77,78,72,73,62,61,79, 450 1.5 0.07 2.50 0.5 119 y y y Nulla 75,29,30,31,74,60,79,54, 52,36,88

Page 4 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"4 meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"4& 23,4 December. 2014

49 Borgaon Vairale Balapur Purna River B-D 285 to 292, 296, 12 to 15, 17, 400 5 0.2 3.00 1 707 Y Y Y 18,21 to 23, 32 to 39, 52 to 55 50 Chincholi Ganu Balapur Man River B-G 5 to 15, 18 to 21 450 10 0.45 2.50 0.5 Tandali 795 Y Y Y 51 Dadham Bu. Balapur Dadham Bu B-L 40,41,42 200 1.5 0.3 2.50 0.5 35 y y y Nulla 52 Dagadkhed Balapur Purna River B-1 112,113, 1 to 5 105 15 0.16 2.50 0.5 278 Y Y Y 53 Dhadi Balladi Balapur Man River B-G 1 to 6, 11 to 14,20,21,79 to 375 10 0.38 2.50 0.5 663 y y y 81,93,95,96 54 Dhanegaon & Balapur Man River B-G 1 to 21, 23,136 to 139, 70, 69 400 20 0.8 2.50 0.5 1413 Y Y Y Degaon Degaon 638 to 661, 703 to 709, 689 to 691, 667 to 675 in the Man 55 Dongargaon Balapur Man River B-C 583 to 587, 595 to 604, 630 to 400 10 0.4 2.50 0.5 707 Y Y Y 641, 653 to 665, 1, 5, 6, 7

56 Hata Balapur Purna River B-K 858,859,861,863,864,694, 598 10 0.6 3.00 1 2113 Y Y Y 767, 14, 15, 16, 35, 36, 39 to 43 57 Hatrun 1 Balapur Morna River B-J 14, 16, 554,555 90 10 0.09 2.50 0.5 159 Y Y Y 58 Hingna Adsul Balapur Man River B-H 1/1 A, 1/2,2,3/3,4/1,5/1, 350 10 0.35 3.00 1 1237 Y Y Y 5/2,6/3 59 Hingna Nimba Balapur Man River B-C 17 to 22, 41, 43, 44, 46, to 49, 195 12 0.24 2.50 0.5 413 Y Y Y 51 to 56 73, 74

60 Hingna Shikari Balapur Man River B-H 17/1, 17/1 A, 17/c, 17/1 D, 320 10 0.32 3.00 1 1131 Y Y Y 17/2,21/2

61 Kajikhed 1 Balapur Man River B-H 99 to 101,93,88,89,128 to 550 10 0.53 2.50 0.5 972 y y y 133 62 Kajikhed 2 Balapur Purna River B-1 1, 6 to 16, 22, 23, 34 550 15 0.65 3.00 1 2915 Y Y Y 63 Kalamba Bu. Balapur Man River B-H Songiri 244 to 246, 1, Kalamba 60 9 0.06 2.50 0.5 95 Y Y Y Bk. 262 to 264, 259, 260, 257, 247,246 64 Kalamba Kh. Balapur Man River B-H 7 to 13, 16, 17, 18,207,208,3, 250 20 0.5 2.50 0.5 883 y y y 6 65 Kalamba Balapur Man River B-H 224,225 50 10 0.05 2.50 y y y Mahagaon 0.5 88 66 Kavtha Balapur Man River B-A 5 to 7, 16 to 24, 75 to 83 670 10 0.67 3.00 1 2367 Y Y Y

. ~

~ Page5 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23rdDecember. 2014

67 Khamkhed Balapur Nirguna B-L 1,3,5, 93,94,95,206 to 210, 194 20 0.39 2.50 0.5 686 y y y River 214,216 68 Khirpuri Bu. Balapur Khapoli B-L 12,49,51,53,55,59,103,148, 600 1.5 0.09 2.50 0.5 159 Y Y Y Nulla 150,11,48,54,56,60, 101, 109, 147,154 69 Lohara 3 Balapur Man River & B-A 84,86,89 to 95, 113, 117, 118, 2500 7 1.75 2.50 0.5 3092 Y Y Y Ghanmoda 134,135, 137 to 139, 901 Nulla to914, 891 to 898, 888, 889,954,566, 959,131,510 to 513,531,532,545 to 547, 550 to 552,483 to 485, 479, 480, 829 to 834, 818, 819,821 to 827,782,771 to 776, 719 to 724,711 to 713, 672, 673, 645 to 647, 633 to 637, 630, 650, 617,618,610,611,811 to 813, 806,807, 560 to 562, 553 to 555,556,558,564,565,567, 570,577 to 582, 584, 587 70 Manjri 1 Balapur Khandala B-J 174,221 to 224,227,269,270, 3000 5 1.5 2.50 0.5 2650 Y Y Y Nulla 272,273,276 to 282, 1 to 5, 412,419 71 Manjri 3 Balapur Kanchanpur B-J 91 to 94, 89, 87, 70 to 79,39 to 2500 7 1.75 2.50 0.5 3092 y y y Nulla 43,47 to 52,56,57,59,66 to 69,98,109,414 72 Mokha Balapur Purna River B-B 1,2,3, 10, 15,204,192, 198 325 12 0.39 3.00 1 1378 Y Y Y 73 Nagad Balapur Purna River B-E 3,251. 248, 233, 232, 231, 229, 334 12 0.4 3.00 1 1416 Y Y Y 228,227, 226, 225, 224, 223, 177,173,172

74 Nandkhed Takli Balapur Nandkhed B-L 6~3~3~31,3~1~1~2a 500 1 0.05 2.50 0.3 53 Y Y Y Khureshi Nulla 24,23,31,57 75 Nimbi Balapur Man River B-C 107,102,101,100,97,96,92 105 12 0.13 2.50 0.5 223 y y y 76 Ridhora Balapur Ridhora B-L 110,111,96,97,174,176,129, 550 1 0.06 2.50 0.5 97 y y y Nulla 123,121,116,112 77 Sagad Balapur Purna River B-F 2 to 5, 36, to 44, 239 280 12 0.34 3.00 1 1187 Y Y Y 78 Sangvi [om Balapur Man River B-L 2 to 13,34,35,47,54,57,59, 312 20 0.62 2.50 0.5 1102 Y Y Y 67 1\

~\~ ~~ ecretary ~ ~ Page 6 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

79 Sonala Balapur Purna River B-D 22,23,24,31,32,47,59 to 71, 290 5 0.16 3.00 1 512 Y Y Y 75 80 Swarupkhed Balapur Purna River B-1 155 to 159 350 15 0.53 3.00 1 1855 Y Y Y 81 Tamshi Balapur Man River B-G 8 to 12,36, 273,275,276, 15, 16, 450 10 0.45 2.50 0.5 795 Y Y Y 18 to 21, 124 to 130, 132, 133 82 Wazegaon Balapur Man River B-H 138,137,136,135,134,133, 450 10 0.45 2.50 0.5 795 Y Y Y 129,128,125,124,123 83 Wadegaon 1 Balapur Nirguna B-M 505,486,423,429,422,527,389, 1300 30 4.8 2.50 0.5 6890 Y Y Y River 811,525,1132,2440,2590,2561, 2562,1155,1823,1275,1183, 1386,1453,1475,1460 to 1462, 1465 to 1467 84 Wadegaon 2 Balapur Bordi Nulla B-M 1188,1189,1196,1200,1204, 300 30 0.9 3.00 0.8 2544 Y Y Y 1207,1226,1220,1216,1212 85 Bakhrapur Barshitakli Bakhara BT-C 78,7,41 to 46 290 4 0.12 2.50 0.5 205 Y Y Y Nulla 86 BelkhedjChilnch Barshitakli Morna River BT-C 18 + 19 170 11 0.21 2.50 0.5 330 y y y oli Rud. 87 Chinchkhed Barshitakli Katepurna BT-A 152,164 to 175, 100 15 0.15 3.00 1 530 y y y River 88 Donad Bu. Barshitakli Katepurna BT-B 173,174,204 75 10 0.08 2.80 0.5 133 Y Y Y River 89 Hatola (Dochka) Barshitakli Katepurna BT-A 1,2,18,17 30 8 0.24 2.50 0.5 42 Y Y Y River 90 Morgaon Kakad Barshitakli Katepurna BT-B 43,44,47 100 12 0.12 2.50 0.5 212 Y Y Y River 91 Nimbhara Barshitakli Katepurna BT-A 25,157 to 160, 152 30 8 0.024 2.50 0.5 42 Y Y Y River 92 Pardi Barshitakli Katepurna BT-B 30,8,37 120 15 0.18 2.50 0.5 318 y y y River 93 Rahit Barshitakli Katepurna BT-B 7 300 6 0.18 2.50 0.5 318 y y y River 94 Rajanda Part 2 Barshitakli Morna River BT-C 71,89,97,91,92 350 9 0.32 3.00 1 1113 y y y 95 Shindkhed Barshitakli Morna River BT-C 77,76,81,93,97,98, 124, 127, 400 8 0.32 2.50 0.5 565 y y y 152 to 154, 156, 157, 160, 160/2 96 Sukli Shivar Barshitakli Morna River BT-C 317,319to 321,323 to 325 350 11 0.39 2.50 0.5 680 y y y 97 Tamsi Barshitakli Katepurna BT-A 12,13,15,16,17,31,32 170 10 0.17 2.50 0.5 300 Y Y Y A River \~\~ ~ ~ Mem Secretary Page 7 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o[the State ExPert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23Ni December. 2014

98 Waghjali Barshitakli Morna River BT-C 1,84, 119, 87 700 8 0.56 2.50 0.5 989 y y y 99 Warkhed Wagh Barshitakli Morna River BT-C 2,3,4 90 9 0.08 2.90 0.7 200 y y y 100 Aamatwada Murtizapur Katepurna M-F 185 25 15 0.04 2.50 0.3 40 y y y River 101 Bapori 1 Murtizapur Pethi River M-A 419 200 15 0.3 2.50 0.5 530 y y y 102 Bapori 2 Murtizapur Khokra Nulla M-A 36,37,38,39,31,40 50 4 0.02 2.50 0.5 88 y y y 103 Bapori3 Murtizapur Khokra Nulla M-A 232,233,230 100 5 0.05 2.50 0.5 177 y y y 104 Bhatori Murtizapur Purna River M-G 466,467,468,473 600 20 1.2 3.00 1 4240 y y y 105 Borta Murtizapur Purna River M-I 140,139,170 150 10 0.15 2.50 0.3 159 y y y 106 Bramhi Kh. Murtizapur Kamalganga M-C 35 100 15 0.15 2.50 0.3 159 y y y River 107 Dapura 1 Murtizapur Purna River M-H 105,106,107 215 20 0.43 3.00 0.8 1216 y y y 108 Dapura 2 Murtizapur Purna River M-H 14,15 290 20 0.58 3.00 0.8 1640 y y y 109 Datala Murtizapur Katepurna M-D 34,35,36 270 20 0.54 2.50 0.5 954 y y y River 110 Datvi Murtizapur Purna River M-D 1,2,8,9 310 12 0.37 3.00 1 1314 y y y 111 Durgwada Murtizapur Purna River M-I 1,2,3,243 to 247, 249 540 15 0.81 3.00 0.8 2290 y y y 112 Gajipur Murtizapur Katepurna M-F 141,142,145 35 18 0.06 2.50 0.3 67 y y y River 113 Ghungshi Murtizapur Purna River M-I 2,3,4,5,6 230 33 0.76 3.00 1 2682 y y y 114 Goregaon Murtizapur Katepurna M-F 259 20 14 0.03 2.50 0.3 30 y y y River 115 [arnbha bu. Murtizapur Katepurna M-I 1,4,11 i 90 10 0.09 2.50 0.5 159 y y y River 116 [amthi Bu. Murtizapur Karli M-A 554,557,558,559,560,561, 124 3 0.04 2.50 0.3 39 y y y Sultanpur 562,563, 564 Nulla 117 Kavtha Kho.2 Murtizapur Pethi River M-A 33,35 600 15 0.9 2.50 0.4 1272 y y y 118 Khaparwada 1 Murtizapur Purna River M-C 63 315 20 0.62 3.00 0.8 1781 y y y 119 Khaparwada 2 Murtizapur Purna River M-C 37,38,39,40 290 20 0.58 3.00 0.8 1640 y y y 120 Kholad 1 Murtizapur Chambhar M-A 294,282,226,57,58,59,60 190 12 0.14 2.50 0.5 403 y y y Nulla 121 KhAad2 , Murtizapur Pethi River M-A 297,6 140 10 0.23 3.00 1 495 y y y

Me~ Page 8 of 58 ~aD Minutes o(the 91"4 meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 21"4& 23,4 December, 2014

122 Koisara 3 Murtizapur Pethi River M-8 15,16,66 300 15 0,52 2,50 0,4 636 y y y 123 Laet Murtizapur Purna River M-D 161,167,1,2,4 500 15 0,75 3,00 1 2650 y y y 124 Lonsana Murtizapur Pethi River M-8 152,154 400 15 0,66 2,50 0,4 848 y y y 125 Manrul Kambe Murtizapur Katepurna M-D 1,2,3,4 210 15 0.32 2.50 0.3 334 y y y River 126 Mungshi Murtizapur Purna River M-G 37, 38, 39, 2, 3 710 20 1.42 3,00 0,8 4014 Y Y Y 127 Parad Murtizapur Purna River M-G 217,218 200 20 0.4 3,00 1 1413 Y Y Y 128 Pingla 1 Murtizapur Purna River M-C 86,11/1 340 15 0,51 3,00 0,8 1442 Y Y Y 129 Pivshi Murtizapur Ramtek M-A 20,27 200 5 0.1 2.50 0.3 106 Y Y Y Navsal Nulla 130 Pohi Murtizapur Champakali M-A 34,35,49,68,143,154,156, 405 10 0.41 2.50 0.5 716 Y Y Y River 69, 70 131 Pota Murtizapur Nandurapoti M-A 47,84 200 5 0.1 2.50 0.3 106 Y Y Y Nulla 132 Ramtek Murtizapur Ramtek M-A 76,54,51 100 5 0.05 2.50 0.3 53 y y y Navsal Nulla 133 Rohna 1 Murtizapur Uma River M-8 72 80 10 0.08 2.60 0.5 141 Y Y Y 134 Rohna 2 Murtizapur Rohana M-8 52,63,79 55 5 0.03 2,50 0.3 29 Y Y Y Nulla 135 Salatwada Murtizapur Katepurna M-F 3,4,5,6,7 40 15 0.06 2.50 0.3 64 Y Y Y River 136 Sangvil Murtizapur Purna River M-C 4,5,6,9,40,80,78,67,68 675 15 1.16 2.50 0.5 1789 Y Y Y 137 Sangva Mel Murtizapur Purna River M-E 274,275,276,277 815 17 1.39 3.00 0.8 4896 Y Y Y 138 Shelu 8ajar Murtizapur Pethi River M-8 135,136 250 15 0.38 2.50 0.5 663 y y y 139 Shelu Najik Murtizapur Katepurna M-F 25,34,35,36 140 20 0.28 2.50 0.5 495 Y y y River 140 Virvada Murtizapur Purna River M-F 1,2,22,23 620 33 2,05 3.00 1 7230 y y y 141 Adgaon Kh. Patur Utawali P-D 1,27,23,24,26,25 150 20 0.3 2.50 0.3 318 y y y River 142 Alegaon Patur Nirguna P-C 63,119 40 8 0.03 2,50 0.3 37 y y y River 143 Andhar Sanvi Patur Nirguna P-C 14,28,6,7,11,10,8 20 8 0.02 2.50 0.3 17 Y y y River

~ Page 9 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92"4meeting oUhe State ExPert Appraisal Committee held on 22"4& 23,4December. 2014

144 Bhandaraj Patur Bordi Nulla P-A 148,149,49,50,51 80 7 0.056 2.50 0.3 59 y y y Bu.Kh. 145 Digras Kh. Patur Nirguna P-B 27,33,34, 245, 1, 224, 223, 220, 75 6 0.05 2.50 0.3 48 Y Y Y River 221,218,217

146 Hingna Patur Nirguna P-B 13,14,15,118,119,120,121, 80 17 0.14 2.60 0.6 288 Y Y Y Wadegaon River 128,129,130,147,140,149, 150,151 147 Khetri Patur Vishwamitra P-E 56,47,48 65 15 0.1 2.50 0.3 103 Y Y Y River 148 Pimpalkhuta Patur Man/Utawali P-D Man-93,88, 113,109,97,98, 100, 150 20 0.3 2.50 0.5 530 y y y river 119,118,125,124,120,122,162, 2,186,185,184,189,178,177 Utawali-1,2, 3, 110,Man4,5,8, 11,15,16,19,22,24,25,26 149 Raher Patur Utawali P-D 61 to 67, 89, 90, 91, 84, 85, 86, 150 20 0.3 2.50 0.3 318 Y Y Y River 87,1,12,2 150 Sasti Patur Nirguna P-B 17/1,261, 139/5, 279/1 230 20 0.46 2.50 0.5 813 y y y River 151 Shirpur Patur Man River P-E 45,8,11,15,16,19,22,24,25, 75 20 0.15 2.50 0.3 159 Y Y Y 26 152 Tandali Bu.Kh. Patur Bordi Nulla P-A 24,25,173 80 6 0.05 2.50 0.3 51 y y y 153 Tulanga Kh. Patur Man river P-E 19,23,29 210 7 0.15 2.50 0.3 156 y y y 154 Vahala Bk. Patur Torna River P-D 82,83,84,85,88,3,4,8,9 45 20 0.1 2.50 0.3 95 Y Y Y 155 Vivra Patur Nirguna p-c 117,120, 122 250 7 0.18 2.50 0.3 186 Y Y Y River 156 Adsul Telhara Purna River T-F 105,132,140,165,119,102, 520 7 0.37 3.00 1 1286 Y Y Y 131,163 157 Akoli Ruprao Telhara Vidrupa T-B 17,23,25,70,14,77,78,80 110 5 0.06 2.70 0.7 136 y y y River 158 Babhulgaon Telhara Purna River T-G 72,73,74 180 19 0.37 3.00 1 1208 Y Y Y 159 Belkhed Telhara Aas River T-D East 324 to 378 in West. 319 to 60 4 0.02 2.50 0.5 42 Y Y Y 780 160 Bhokar Telhara Vidrupa T-B 3,4,5,45,19,100 100 4 0.04 2.50 0.5 71 Y Y Y River 161 Danapur Telhara Van River T-D 47,45,44,42,720,721,717,718, 300 10 0.3 3.00 1 1060 y y y 719,745,714,713,712,711,710, 709,701,702,703,667,658,664, Q. 666,670,657,655,650 \~

Me_!!!b ~ Page 10 of 58 ~D Minutes ofthe 92ndmeeting ofthe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,d December. 2014

162 Oaula Talegaon Telhara Puma River T-F 18,19,20,26,27,34,35 145 10 0.14 2.50 0.5 256 Y Y Y 163 Hiwarkhed Part Telhara Bagala Nulla T-O 481,480,478,470,461 to 463, 466 300 2.5 0.08 2.50 0.5 133 Y Y 2 to 468, 450, 455, 430, 461, 459, Y 474,453,452,429,427,426,403, 402,401,380 to 384,342,337, 317,311 to 313,315,431,432, 450,400,397,396,386,387,307 to 309, 281, 277, 276 164 Hiwarkhed Part Telhara Aas River T-O 315,316,319,320,321 240 2 0.05 3.00 1 3 170 Y Y Y 165 Hiwarkhed Part Telhara Kharsa River T-O East Side- 53, 52, 64,65, 31, 30, 35, 190 1.5 0.03 3.00 1 101 Y Y 1 29,28,23,22,21,92, 94,95,96, Y 148, 171, 190, 177 West Side- 49, 53, SO,32, 33, 34, 44,11,13,14,20, 99 to 102,97,147,149,150,151, 169,164,163,179,180 166 Isapur Telhara Nagzari T-E 35,61 20 8 0.02 2.50 0.5 28 Y Y River Y 167 [afrapur Telhara Gautama T-E 44,45,43 12 15 0.02 2.50 0.5 32 y y y River 168 Khakta Telhara Vidrupa T-c 51 to 57, 47, 49 110 5 0.06 2.50 0.5 97 Y Y River Y 169 Khandala Telhara Iarnuna T-A 108,105,102,101,67,59,58, 180 3 0.05 2.50 0.5 95 y y y River 69,71,72,106,107,54,53,55, 56,57,30,24,23,393 170 Malthana Bu. Telhara Chillar Nulla T-A 20,22,23, 159, 163, 164, 165, 185 5 0.1 2.50 0.2 65 Y Y Y 144,194 171 Malthana Kh. Telhara Chillar Nulla T-A 163,164,165,159 320 5 0.16 2.50 0.3 170 Y Y Y 172 Manatri Bu. Telhara Vidrupa T-c 50 E,51 73 E,76, 68, 52, 78, 67, 215 5 0.11 2.50 0.5 190 Y Y Y River 69 173 Manatri Kh. Telhara Vidrupa T-c 16,17,70,72,62,63,64,65 179 7 0.13 2.50 0.5 221 Y Y River Y 174 Ner Telhara Puma River T-I 227 to 234, 215 to 217, 210, 830 15 1.25 2.50 0.5 2200 y y y 211,213 175 Nimbhora Bu. Telhara Gautama T-E 44,46 40 12 0.05 2.50 0.5 85 y y y River 176 Pathardi Part 2 Telhara Vidrupa T-B 723,735, 728, 757, 766, 586, 30 7 0.08 2.50 0.5 37 y y y River 553,587,97,99,95,94,96,62, 61,102,86,66,50,220,41,40, ...... 790,541, 506 iQoX;1 ~ Me~ Page 11 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92ndmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'" December. 2014

177 Sadarpur Telhara Kachakdora T-A 36,37,38,39 500 5 0.25 2.50 0.5 442 Y Y Y Nulla 178 Sangvi Telhara Purna River T-J 158,156,160,155,154,100, 410 20 0.82 3.00 1 2898 Y Y Y 99,98, 95,94,93,91, 109, 108, 107,106,105,102,101,150, 151,152,153 179 Sheri Vadner Telhara Nagzari T-E 31,32,9 80 5 0.04 2.50 0.5 71 Y Y Y River 180 Shirsoli Telhara Vidrupa T-A 736,720,722,583,582,580, 150 3.5 0.05 2.50 0.5 93 y y y River 579,578,575,705,706,707, 590 181 Shivaji Nagar Telhara Motha T-A Adgaon Bu. 205,204,162,103, 174 5 0.09 2.50 0.5 154 Y Y Y Chillar Nulla 189,187,106 Shivaji Nagar 11, 21,60,55,78,4,5 182 Talegaon Bul. Telhara Vidrupa T-D 85 to174 & 443 300 4 0.12 2.50 0.5 212 Y Y Y River 183 Talegaon Kh. Telhara Vidrupa T-D 86,82,77,76,79,329,330, 500 4 0.2 2.50 0.5 353 y y y River 497,70 to 73, 75, 18, 17, 16, 15, 14,1,4 184 Talegaon Telhara Purna River T-H 54,55,61 400 25 1 3.00 1 3534 Y Y Y Paturda 185 Tudgaon Telhara Motha Nulla T-E 80,79,75,81,82,84 190 2 0.04 2.50 0.5 67 Y Y Y 186 Umri Telhara Purna River T-K 228,235, 236, 238 590 10 0.19 3.00 1 2085 Y Y Y 187 Wadi Adampur Telhara Nagzari T-E 42,55,41 50 5 0.03 2.50 0.5 44 Y Y Y River 188 Wangargaon Telhara Purna River T-G 69 150 15 0.23 3.00 1 795 Y Y Y

PPinformed that initially 275 sand guts were proposed by the administration but GSDA rejected 87 and remaining 188 were proposed with Gramsabha Resolution. After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 188 proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC) subject to compliance of the following conditions:

Page 12 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92nd meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22nd&23,d December. 2014

2. Sand excavation is allowed only for the Reti Guts having sand deposition more than 2 m and excavation should be for layers above 2 m of sand deposit as recommended by GSDA. 3. District Collector to ensure that every receipt given is serially scanned and registration number so generated must be written on such receipt to avoid duplicction and unauthorized transportation of the sand. 4. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that vehicles transporting sand should not be overloaded beyond stated capacity. 5. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to miningfor its nesting. 6. The depth of miningshall be restricted to the recommendations of GSDA. 7. The green belt development /tree plantation willbe made in an area of 20'Yo of the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 8. Measures for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Mining officer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the miningplan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously.

Additional Collector and DMO presented total 97 proposals. However they failed to submit the actual depth of sand as measured by GSDA. The proposals are therefore deferred. Ddid

Me~ Page 13 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92"dmeeting oUhe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

Collector I Additional Collector and DMOpresented 62 proposals before the Committee.

Wh Area of the Total Permitted sand resources LxBx Dpth in m3 Total eth Sand block (LxB)in m2 depth =Brass depth er of GSD Location of Gram Blo recom A Name of Name Cluster of sand Sabh ck sr. mended Cert the Taluka of the the Sand in the a rna no by ifica Village River number Gut (Gut are block (LxBx Certif rki GSDA Lengt Breadt Dep te No) LXB L B a as per LXBXD D)m3 icate ng for hX hX th (YI ha GSDA( (YIN) is excavati =Brass N) m) clu on(m) ste r 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21,22, 23,26,40, Dudha Individ 2.2 1 Vazar [alna 43,44, 300x75 300 75.46 300x7 SDM na al 3.00 0.50 300 75.46 0.50 4000 Yes No 138,236, 6 5xO.50 Y 238,242 14,16, 17,19, Nanegao Badnap Sukhan Individ 20,26, 1.7 400x4 SDM 2 400x42 400 42.45 2.50 0.50 400 42.45 0.50 3000 Yes No n ur a al 27,28, 0 2xO.50 Y 208,209, 215,216 140,141, 4.9 908x5 3 [afrabad [afrabad Purna 145,150, 908x55 908 55 3.00 0.50 SDM 9 908 55 0.50 8823 Yes Yes 153,155 5xO.50 Y

[afraba 1.6 400x4 4 Takli Iafrabad Purna 38,39,40 400x40 400 40 2.50 0.50 400 40 0.50 2827 Yes Yes Yes d 0 OxO.50 Cluster- Gharkhe 1.4 355x4 SDM 5 [afrabad Purna 1 12,14,18 355x40 355 40 2.50 0.50 355 40 0.50 2509 Yes Yes da 2 OxO.50 Y

~ Page 14 of 58 Chairman Minutes of the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

22,23,25, 6 Sawangi [afrabad Purna 26, 1.7 400x4 SDM 400x42 400 42.45 2.50 0.50 400 42.45 0.50 3000 Yes Yes 27,28 0 2xO.50 Y

Gondha nkheda 7 64,65, 1.7 400x4 [afrabad Purna 400x42 400 42.45 3.00 0.50 400 42.45 Khamkh 67,95 0 2xO.50 0.50 3000 Yes Yes Yes eda

71,72, Nimkhe 73,74, 8 [afrabad Purna 75,78, 2.2 300x7 SDM da Bu 300x75 300 75.46 3.00 0.50 300 75.46 0.50 4000 Yes Yes 79,80, 6 5xO.50 Y 82,85 86,88, Pimpalk Dhamn 9 [afrabad [afraba 93,94, 0.4 400xl huta a 400xl0 400 9.9 2.50 0.50 400 9.9 0.50 700 Yes Yes Yes d 95,96 0 OxO.50 Cluster- Nimkhe Dhamn 168,169, 10 Iafrabad 2 400x15 0.6 400xl SDM da Bu a 170,171 400 15.56 3.00 0.50 400 15.56 0.50 1100 Yes Yes 2 5xO.50 Y 45,46, 47,49, Walsa Bhokard 11 52,55, 2.2 300x7 Purna 300x75 300 75.46 2.50 0.50 300 75.46 Khalsa an 234,236, 6 5xO.50 0.50 4000 Yes Yes Yes 238,257, 258,259 Kedarkh Bhokard 12 Bhokar 1.7 400x4 Purna 15,17,40 400x42 400 42.45 2.50 0.50 400 42.45 eda an dan 0 2xO.50 0.50 3000 Yes Yes Yes Cluster- Pimpals Bhokard 13 20,23, 0.5 94x60 Purna 1 94x60 94 60.21 2.50 0.50 94 ul an 26,27 7 xO.50 60.21 0.50 1000 Yes Yes Yes

lavkhed a Bhokard 336,338, 14 Purna 339,340, 1.1 150x7 SDM Thombr an 150x75 150 75.46 2.50 0.50 150 75.46 0.50 2000 Yes Yes 3 5xO.50 Y e 342

Bhokard 1,2,3,4, 1.7 400x4 15 Belora Purna 400x42 400 42.45 3.00 0.50 SDM an 5,30,36 0 20xO.5 400 42.45 0.50 3000 Yes Yes r-; 0 Y

~~ ~ M[~~ Secretary Page 15 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember, 2014

Dudha 190,243, 2.9 430x7 16 Amba Partur 430x69 430 69.1 3.00 1.00 430 69.1 1.00 10499 Yes Yes Yes na 245,246 7 Ox1.00 Nandhar Dudha 120,121, 3.6 490x7 17 Partur 490x75 490 75 3.00 1.00 490 75 1.00 12986 Yes Yes Yes a na Partur 129,130 8 5x1.00 Cluster- 40,41, 4300x Babultar Dudha 1 2.4 SDM 18 Partur 42,43, 400x60 400 60 3.00 0.50 60xO.5 400 60 0.50 4240 Yes Yes a na 0 Y 44,45,46 0 Dudha 4.1 520x8 19 Ekrukha Partur 54,55 520x80 520 80 2.50 0.50 520 80 0.50 7350 Yes Yes Yes na 6 Ox1.00 54, ISO, Dudha 4.3 520x8 20 Babai Partur 151,152, 520x83 520 83.46 2.50 0.50 520 83.46 0.50 7668 Yes Yes Yes na 4 3xO.50 165,166 449,450, Dudha 3.3 520x6 SDM 21 Dolhara Partur 452,463, 520x65 520 65.25 2.50 0.50 520 65.25 0.50 5995 Yes Yes na 9 5xO.50 Y 464 Bramah Dudha 305,306, 2.7 460x5 22 awadga Partur 460x59 460 59.99 3.00 0.50 460 59.99 0.50 4876 Yes Yes Yes na 307,308 6 9x1.00 on 210,211, 212,213, 214,215, Devthan 2.4 900x2 23 Mantha Purna 216,217, 900x27 900 27.25 4.00 1.50 900 27.25 1.50 12999 Yes Yes Yes a 5 7x1.50 251,252, 253,254, 255,256 37,38, 39,40, 41,42, 43,44, Takalkh 45,46, 1.7 860xl 24 Mantha Purna 860x20 860 19.74 4.00 1.50 860 19.74 1.50 8998 Yes Yes Yes opa Mantha 47,48,49, 0 9x1.50 Cluster- 50,51, 1 52,53, 54,55, 56,57,58 1,2,154, 1.3 700xl 25 Dudha Mantha Purna 700x19 700 18.86 3.50 1.50 700 18.86 1.50 6998 Yes Yes Yes 1"\ 155 2 8x1.50

~ Memh1~ Page 16 of 58 Chairman Minutes ofthe 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23M December. 2014

43,44 3.5 700x5 26 Kirla Mantha Purna ,47,48, 700x50 700 50 3.50 1.50 700 50 1.50 18551 Yes Yes Yes 0 Ox1.50 51,61,62 0.7 350x2 27 Bhuvan Mantha Purna 1 350x22 350 21.56 3.00 1.50 350 21.56 1.50 4000 Yes Yes Yes 5 1x1.50

0.7 350x2 28 Waghala Mantha Purna 76,80 3s0x21 350 21.56 3.00 1.50 350 21.56 1.50 4000 Yes Yes Yes 5 1x1.s0 23,25, 36,37,39, 40,41, 0.9 700x1 SDM 29 Kandi Mantha Purna 700x13 700 13.48 4.00 1.50 700 13.48 1.50 5001 Yes Yes 47,50, 4 3x1.50 Y 51,53, 54,56 Chamba Dudha 0.1 50x22 SDM 30 Ambad 7,11,12 50x23 50 22.64 2.50 0.50 50 22.64 0.50 200 Yes Yes rwadi na 1 xO.50 Y Alamgao Dudha 0.0 26x22 31 Ambad 166 26x22 26 22 2.50 0.50 26 22 0.50 101 Yes Yes Yes n na 6 xO.50 78,70, Bhokar 69,68 0.1 85x20 32 Ambad Galati 85x20 85 20 2.50 0.50 85 20 0.50 300 Yes Yes Yes wadi ,67,66, 7 xO.50 65 Dadhega 0.7 734x1 33 Ambad Galati 151.154 734x10 734 10 2.50 0.50 734 10 0.50 1297 Yes Yes Yes on 3 OxO.50

Pethori 0.7 500x1 34 Sirasgao Ambad Galati 49.5 sOOx14 500 14 3.00 0.50 500 14 0.50 1237 Yes Yes Yes 0 4xO.50 n

Maherb 0.0 34x21 35 Ambad Sukna 1,265 34x22 34 21.97 2.50 0.50 34 21.97 0.50 132 Yes Yes Yes haigaon 7 xO.50

Mussa- 45,46,47, Individ 0.2 65x30 36 Bhardi Ambad Bhadry 77,133,8 65x30 65 30.04 2.50 0.50 65 30.04 0.50 345 Yes Yes No al 0 xc.sc ani 2

Page 17 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'" December, 2014

Mudheg Ghansa Dudha Individ 0.4 200x2 37 23,24,41 200x21 200 21.19 2.50 0.50 200 21.19 0.50 749 Yes Yes No aon wangi na al 2 lxO.50 201 to [ogladev Ghansa Godavr Individ 3.3 450x7 SDM 38 206& 450x75 450 75 3.00 1.00 450 75 1.00 11926 Yes i wangi i al 8 5xO.50 y No 209 200xl Banegao Ghansa Godavr 12,35,34 200xl0 2.0 SDM 39 200 100 3.00 1.00 00x1.0 200 100 1.00 7067 n wangi i 6,361 0 0 Yes y Yes 0 200xl Lengsew Ghansa Godavr 200xl0 2.0 SDM 40 35&65 200 100 3.00 1.00 00x1.0 200 100 1.00 7067 Yes Yes adi wangi i 0 0 Y 0 Cluster 200xl Saundlg Ghansa Godavr -1 200xl0 2.0 SDM 41 93,92,77 200 100 3.00 1.00 00x1.0 200 100 1.00 7067 Yes Yes aon wangi i 0 0 Y 0 26,27.28. Bhoggao Ghansa Godavr 29 3.3 560x6 SDM 42 560x60 560 60 3.00 1.00 560 60 1.00 11873 Yes Yes n wangi i & 6 Oxl.00 Y 31,32,33 Mudreg Ghansa Godavr 165,166, 2.0 400x5 43 400x50 400 50 2.50 0.50 400 50 0.50 3534 Yes Yes Yes aon wangi i 167,168 0 OxO.50 283,284 Ghansa Godavr /1,291,29 0.2 250xl SDM 44 Rajatakli 250xl0 250 10 3.00 0.50 250 10 0.50 442 Yes Yes wangi i 2, 5 OxO.50 Y 298 26,27,14 Ukkadga Ghansa Godavr to 18,12, 4.2 680x6 SDM 45 680x63 680 63 3.00 1.00 680 63 1.00 15138 Yes Yes on wangi i 10,9,185 8 3x1.00 Y to 188 204 to 207,213,2 02, 161,162,1 73,172, Shiwang Ghansa Godavr 182,200,2 3.6 500x7 46 500x73 500 73.58 3.50 1.00 500 73.58 1.00 13000 Yes aon wangi i 11,212, 8 3x1.00 Yes Yes 215,216,2 17,218, 220,211,2 12,215,21 (\ 6,217,218, I~ rl(.11 ~ [::;~ ~ Me~ Secretary Page 18 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92',dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23rdDecember. 2014

220,225, 193,211,2 12,215, 216,217,2 18,220, 225,193,1 96,195, 214,209,2 08,207 150to 500x9 SDM Ghansa Godavr 154,160,2 500x99 4.9 1.50 9.70xl 500 99.7 1.50 26502 Yes Yes 47 Bhadli 500 99.7 3.50 Y wangi i 7, .70 9 .50 28,29 36,388,38 7,385,374 4.8 644x7 SDM Ghansa Godavr ,372,371,3 644x75 644 75 5.00 3.00 644 75 3.00 51237 Yes Yes 48 GunjBK 3 5x3.00 Y wangi i 69,368, 367,366 400xl 240,237,2 400xl0 4.0 Changat Godavr 400 100 3.50 1.50 00x1.5 400 100 1.50 21201 Yes Yes Yes 49 Partur 34,231, 0 puri i 185 0 0 302,304to 515x7 Golegao Godavr 306,309, 3.6 1.50 515 70.48 1.50 19239 Yes Yes Yes 50 Partur 515x70 515 70.48 3.50 Ox1.50 n i 310,330to 3 333 408x9 SDM Sawangi Godavr 24,25,26,2 4.0 1.50 408 99.84 1.50 21591 Yes Yes 51 Partur 408x99 408 99.84 3.50 9x1.50 Y Gangi i 8 7 404 1113x SDM Sashtpi Godavr to408,429 1113x4 111 4.9 1.00 44x1.0 1113 44.8 1.00 17619 Yes Yes 52 Ambad 44.8 3.50 Y mplgaon i to 4 3 9 0 432,442 5,8,9,16,17 1.2 500x2 SDM Godavr Cluster ,19,20, 500x25 500 25 3.50 1.00 500 25 1.00 4417 Yes Yes 53 Gori Ambad 5 5x1.00 Y i 110to 115 number 450x3 SDM Gandhar Godavr 1.3 1.00 450 30 1.00 4770 Yes Yes 54 Ambad -1 6,5,8,9 450x30 450 30 3.50 Ox1.00 Y i i 5 100x3 Walkesh Godavr 10,9,8,6,7 0.3 1.00 100 35 1.00 1237 Yes Yes Yes 55 Ambad 100x35 100 35 2.50 5x1.00 war i 7 to 83 5 10 to 925x4 SDM Godavr 13,15,22, 3.9 925 42.9 1.50 21044 Yes Yes Ambad 925x43 925 43 3.00 1.50 Y 56 Kuran i 172 8 3x1.50 to 175 IQMr-; ~ Me~etary Page19 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember, 2014

335 SDM Godavr to237,263 4.2 680x6 63 1.00 15138 Yes Yes Gondi Ambad 680x63 680 63 3.00 1.00 680 Y 57 i to 8 3x1.00 267,271 90,89,88 1.0 300x3 SDM Kothala Godavr 35 3.00 1.00 300 35 1.00 3710 Yes Yes 58 Ambad ,82,81,80 300x35 300 5 5x1.00 Y Kh i ,83,84 Cluster SDM Indalgao Godavr 7,8,9,53,54 1.4 500x4 1.00 5256 Yes Yes Ambad 500x35 425 35 3.50 1.00 425 35 Y 59 i ,55 9 5x1.00 n number 119 to -2 500x4 SDM Ganga Godavr 123134 2.2 45 1.00 7951 Yes Yes 60 Ambad 500x45 500 45 3.50 1.00 500 Y Chicholi i 19 5 5x1.00 to 23 Ghansa SDM Ramasg wangi 225 to 230 600x7 4.5 600x75x 2.50 39753 Yes Yes 600 75 4.50 1.00 600 75 Y aon Dist- &232 5 0 2.50 [alna Godavr 61 i Majalga Borgaon 1,2,3,40,41, 250x5 1.2 250x50x 0.50 3700 Yes YES on 250 50 2.50 0.50 250 50 Thadi 45 0 5 0.50 Dist- Beed 5.7 43453 ~ 5 Ambad SDM Domalg 70to74,5 700x2 1.7 700x25x 1.00 6184 Yes Yes Dist- 700 25 3.50 1.00 700 25 Y aon to 9 5 5 1.00 lalna 62 9,10,12,13,1 Georai Mahlasp 6,17,23,24,2 340x5 1.7 340x50x 0.50 3000 Yes Dist- 340 50 2.50 0.50 340 50 implgao 5,26,27,37,4 0 0 0.50 Beed n 1,42,44,46,

PPinformed that all 62 sand guts are recommended through Gramsabha Resolution and that these were not located in any Reserved Forest or ESA and all excavations would be done beyond 300 m of river structures. Collector outlined steps to prevent unauthorized mining like coordinating of mining activity by issuing Transit Passes with specific duration, frequent inspection by Revenue and Mining officers etc. This will be verified by SEAC through site visits. After detailed deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 62 proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC) subject to compliance of the following conditions:

Page 20 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,d December. 2014

1. District Collector to ensure that conditions stipulated in the Government Resolution (G.R.) dated 12/03/2013 issued by Revenue and Forest Department, Government of Maharashtra (GoM) and Office Memorandum (O.M) of Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF), dated 24/12/2013 is implemented in letter and spirit. 2. Sand excavation is allowed only for the Reti Guts having sand deposition more than 2 m and excavation should be for layers above 2 m of sand deposit as recommended by GSDA. 3. District Collector to ensure that every receipt given is serially scanned and registration number so generated must be written on such receipt to avoid duplication and unauthorized transportation of the sand. 4. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that vehicles transporting sand should not be overloaded beyond stated capacity. 5. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to mining for its nesting. 6. The depth of mining shall be restricted to the recommendations of GSDA. 7. The green belt development Itree plantation will be made in an area of 20'10 of the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 8. Measures for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Mining officer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the mining plan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in" Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously.

Page 21 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92"dmeeting oUhe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

Additional Collector and RDC presented 133 proposals before the Committee but was observed that GSDA has recommended only 81 proposals considering the depth of sand available.

Total Total depth of depth Gram Whethe sand in Permitted GSDA recomme Sabha r Block Name of Sand Ghat/ Name of the Cluste Lacation of the Sand Ghat Area the sand Certific Sr. Tahsil nded by Certifi Markin Village River rNo. (Adjoining SurveyIGut Nos.) (m2) block as resources in ate GSDAfor cate gis per Brass (YIN) excavatio (YIN) cluster GSDA n (m) em) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 1 Purnanagar 1 1. Bhatkuli Purna - Gat No. 13,14,15,17,18,& 19 1500 2.2 0.20 106 Y Y N Gat No.718, 659, 660,661,662, 678, N 2 Purnanagar 2 2. Bhatkuli Purna 4500 2.2 0.20 318 Y Y - 679,682 Watonda Himmatpur N 3 3. Bhatkuli Purna Gat No. 10,11,12,20,21,22, 2250 2.3 0.30 239 Y Y 1 - Watonda Himmatpur N 4 4. Bhatkuli Purna - Gat No. 176, 177,178, 179,180 3000 2.3 0.30 318 Y Y 2 Watonda Himmatpur N 5 5.Bhatkuli Purna - Gat No. 166,167,168 & 170 4500 2.3 0.30 477 Y Y 3 6 Dautpur 6. Bhatkuli Pedhi - Gat No. 164 to 170 3000 2.3 0.30 318 Y Y N 7 Chakur 1 7. Bhatkuli Pedhi - Gat No. 1,11,12,13 3000 2.5 0.50 530 Y Y N 8 Chakur 2 8. Bhatkuli Pedhi - Gat No. 136 200 2.5 0.50 35 Y Y N Gat No. 57,66,64,188,189,242, N 240,239,236,235,233,232, 226, 9 Bhatkuli 9. Bhatkuli Pedhi 15000 2.2 0.20 1060 Y Y - 225,224,223,222,221,45,243 to 249,251,260,263,281,268 to 275 Gat No. 218 to 222,246,247,251, N 10 Nimbha 10. Bhatkuli Pedhi - 8000 2.5 0.50 1413 Y Y 256,258,259,279 & 283 11 Wasewadi 11. Bhatkuli Pedhi - Gat No. 15,16,17,36,50,45 to 48 6000 2.5 0.50 1060 Y Y N 1. Dhaman gaon N Wardha River Gat No. 57 & 58 42,000 3 1.00 14841 Y Y 12 Nayegaon Rly, - 2. Dhaman gaon N 13 Borgao~ Nistane Wardha River - Gat No 71,72 & 73 23,100 3 1.00 8163 Y Y "\ 1 Rly.

~ Page 22 of 58 Chairman ~ Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'" December. 20J 4

3. Dhaman gaon . 14 Gokulsara Wardha River N Rly. - Gat No. 2,3,8,9,10,11,13,14,15 & 16 40,500 3 1.00 14311 Y Y Chincholi (Maramaya 4. Dhaman gaon Gat No 125, 126, 127, 149, 158, 159, 15 Wardha River N sand ghat) Rly. - 160, 164,165,166,167, 4200 3 1.00 1484 Y Y 5. Dhaman gaon 16 Vitada Wardha River - N Rly. Gat No. 4,5,7,10 & 11 1050 3 1.00 371 Y Y 6. Dhaman gaon 17 Dighimahalle Wardha River N Rly. - Gut No 2,3,4,5,6,7, 51, 52, 53,54 24300 3 1.00 8587 Y Y 7. Dhaman gaon 18 Waknath Wardha River N Rly. - Gat No. 66/4 5000 3 1.00 1767 Y Y 19 Chandur Dhore 1. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gat No. 3 &4 4200 3 1.00 1484 Y Y N 20 Fatehpur 2. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gut No. 36 7000 2.75 0.75 1855 Y Y N 21 [awra 3. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gat No. 1,2,3,& 107 7175 2.75 0.75 1902 Y Y N 22 Bharwadi Old 4. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gat No.1 & 6 10200 2.75 0.75 2703 Y Y N 23 Godary(Namaskary) 5. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gat No.48,51,42,& 12 12000 3 1.00 4240 Y Y N 24 Dhamantry 6. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gat No. 52,50,1,2,3, &4 9300 2.75 0.75 2465 Y Y N 25 Umberkhed 7. Tiwsa Wardha River - Gut No 1,52,51 17500 2.75 0.75 4638 Y Y N 26 Nimbharni 1. Morshi Wardha River - adjoining to Survey No. 1. 3300 2.5 0.50 583 Y Y N 27 Shivra part-I 2. Morshi Wardha River - Survey No 29 AntoraQ_end 3000 2.3 0.30 318 Y Y N 28 Shivra part-II 3. Morshi Wardha River - Survey No 1 Chincholipend 1800 2.3 0.30 191 Y Y N Gut No 96 to 100,116,119 to 121, 29 Deutwada-l 1. Warud Wardha river - 6840 N 136 to 138 2.3 0.30 725 Y Y 30 Deutwada-2 2. Warud Wardha river - Gut No 139 to 144, 146 & 147 7920 2.3 0.30 840 Y Y N 31 Tongalabad 1. Achalpur Purna - Gat n. 126,127, 1000 2.5 0.50 177 Y Y N 32 Yelki 2. Achalpur Purna - Gat No. 265 to 270 6600 2.5 0.50 1166 Y Y N 33 Yesurna 3. Achalpur Sapan - Gat No. 494,493,55,51,& 50 3600 2.5 0.50 636 Y Y N 34 Wadgaonkhurd 4. Achalpur Chandra bhaga - Gat No.22,15,14,12,10,6 & 11 1400 2.5 0.50 247 Y Y N Sawalapur& 35 5. Achalpur Purna N Khanapur - Gat No.78 2000 2.5 0.50 353 Y Y 36 Bajitpur 6. Achalgur Purna - Gat No. 5,4,6 & 7/5 2000 2.5 0.50 353 Y Y N 37 Tamaswadi 1. Chandurbazar Purna - Gat No. 18 & 24 1800 2.3 0.30 191 Y Y N 38 Talani Purna 2.Chandurbazar Purna - Gat No. 10 13500 2.25 0.25 1193 Y Y N 39 Chincholi Purna 3. Chandurbazar Purna - Gat No.6 & 28 6750 2.2 0.20 477 Y Y N Gat No. 68,113,122,126,127, 40 Takarkheda Purna 4.Chandurbazar Purna - 12500 2.2 N 128,129,269,270,278 0.20 883 Y Y 41 Peth itbarpur 1.DaryClQur Bhuleshwari - Gat No. 193 2000 2.2 0.20 141 Y Y N 42 Hasanpur 2..Daryapur Chandrabhaaa - GatNo 190 2000 2.5 0.50 353 Y Y N 43 Shahpur 3.D~ur Chandrabhaga - Gat No 124, 131 2000 2.2 0.20 141 Y Y N 44 Aamla A 4.Daryapur Purna - Gat No 255 & 256 2000 2.5 0.50 353 Y Y N

~ ~S; eeretary Page 23 of 58 ~ Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

2.2 0.20 523 y y N 45 Khairi 5.Daryapur Purna - Gat No 81,82, 94,95, 100 7400 0.30 445 Y Y N 46 Kuksa 6.Daryapur Purna - Gat No. 51,52, 55 to 57 4200 2.3 0.50 663 y y N 47 Echora 7.Daryapur Purna - Gat No 19 3750 2.5 N Gat N02,8,9,10,16,17 ,20,23, 24, 5700 2.2 0.20 403 Y Y 48 Takli 8.Daryapur Purna - 27,28,29,44,49,52 to 55,59 &60 0.30 270 Y Y N 49 Bhujwada 9.Daryapur Purna - Gat No.l,121,203,& 204 2550 2.3 0.30 488 Y Y N 50 Golegaon Ifl.Daryapur Purna - Gat No.4,5,167,& 168 4600 2.3 0.20 208 Y Y N 51 Panora Lt.Darvapur Purna - Gat No.41,42,44,50,51, & 52 2948 2.2 N Gat No.468,469,483,484,486, 487, 21250 2.5 0.50 3754 y y 52 Ramtirath 12.Daryapur Purna - 495,543 to 545 0.50 1449 Y Y N 53 Rustampur 13.Daryapur Purna - Gat no. 3 to 7,16,21 to 25 8200 2.5 0.30 1193 Y Y N 54 Karatkheda 14.Daryapur Purna - Gat no.3,4,5,38 to 40,49 to 52, & 54 11250 2.3 Gat No.279,272 to 274,267, N Purna 33250 2.3 0.30 3525 Y Y 55 Lasur 15.Daryapur - 266,261,248, 0.50 1502 Y Y N 56 Tongalabad 16.Daryapur Chandrabhaga - Gat No.160,159,156 8500 2.5 Gat No. 216,224,226, 215, 214, 13 y y N Purna - 3000 2.5 0.50 530 57 Chandola 17.Daryapur to 15 2.2 0.20 141 Y Y N 58 Sonkhed 18.Daryapur Purna - Gat No. 10 to 15 2000 2.2 0.20 141 Y Y N 59 Bhuikhed 19.Darvapur Purna - Gat No. 127 & 153 2000 2.2 0.20 113 Y Y N 60 Nardoda 20.Daryapur Chandrabhaga - Gat No 1,13,14,17,19,23,25 1600 Gat No. 161,174,237,228,7 to 10, N Chandrabhaga 2750 2.3 0.30 292 Y Y 61 Ramgaon 21.Daryapur - 25 to 27 2.3 0.30 254 Y Y N 62 Belora 22.Daryapur Chandrabhaga - Gat No 3,15,17,105,106,20 2400 Gat No 431 to 436,527 to 535, 456, N - 8500 2.5 0.50 1502 Y Y 63 Pimplodh 23.Daryapur Bordi nala 496,614,615,628,& 629 0.50 530 y y N 64 Wadura 24.Daryapur Purna - Gat No 1,314,315 3000 2.5 Gat No 335,337, 338,341,348, N Chandrabhaga 2400 2.5 0.50 424 Y Y 65 Mahuli Dhande 25.Daryapur - 317,318,&319 Gat No.279 to 281,283,179, N 2.2 0.20 601 y y 66 Warud Bk 26.Daryapur Bordi river - 190,189,184,185,194,203,234 8500 ,201,202 2.1 0.10 35 y y N 67 Kapsi 27.Daryapur Chandrabhaga - GatNo 2 1000 2.2 0.20 177 y y N 68 Bembala Bk 28.Darvapur chandrabhaga - Gat No.l,2,262,& 263 2500 1.00 1060 Y Y N 69 Kharya Tembu 1. Dharni Tapi - Survey No.82 & 47 3000 3 1.00 106 Y y N 70 Kutunaa 2. Dharni Tapi - Survey No.48,49, 50 & 51 300 3 1.00 353 y y N 71 Ratnanur 3. Dharni Tapi River - Survey No. 14,16, 1000 3 N Chinchghat 1.00 353 y y 72 4. Dharni Tapi River - Gat No.94,101,102 1000 3 (Ramakheda ghat)

Page 24 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

Chinchghat(Zirnya 73 5. Dharni N _ghat Mokha) Tapi - Survey No. 26 & 23, 1000 3 1.00 353 y y 74 Bairagad 6. Dharni Tapi - Survey No. 255 to 258 300 3 1.00 106 y y N 75 Sonabardi 7. Dharni Tapi - Survey No. 18,19,23 & 24 3000 3 1.00 1060 Y Y N 76 Khodgaon 1.Anjangaon Shhanur - Survey No. 59,60,63, & 64 1800 2.5 0.50 318 y y N 77 Dombala 2. Anjan_gaon Bhuleshwari - Gat No. 34,28,27,29,& 30 7200 2.5 0.50 1272 Y Y N 78 Hingani 3.Anj_angaon Gaymukh river - Gat No. 341,342,343 & 344 750 2.5 0.50 133 y y N 79 Kharbi Gund 1. Nan

PP informed that all 81 sand guts are recommended through Gramsabha Resolution and that these were not located in any Reserved Forest or ESA.After due deliberntions on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 81proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC)subject to compliance of the following conditions:

ecretary Page 25 of 58 Chairman Minutes DUlle 92"· meeting DUlle State E.wert Appraisal Committee IIeld on 22"·& 23'· December. 2014

9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Miningofficer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the miningplan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously.

DMOpresented 51 proposals before the Committee. However the PPfailed to submit individualGSDAcertificates indicating actual depth of sand available and excavable depth pertaining to proposals. The proposals were, therefore deferred.

DMO presented 99 proposals before the Committee. The Committee observed that GSDA Certificate does not mention anything about the actual depth of sand available on the river bed. The proposals were, therefore deferred.

Page 26 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

District Collector gave a detailed presentation of 154 proposals of sand mining in Pune District. He informed that out of 154 sand guts only 94 were recommended by Gramsabha Resolution. Therefore the Committee decided to consider only 94 proposals. Taluka wise presentation was made by the Collector. Committee observed that GSDA has given unambiguouscertificate regarding depth of sand available in 53 cases as follows.

Sr. Name of Taluka Name of Cluster Location of the Sand Ghat (Gat Area of Sand Total Total Permitted GSOA Gram Wheth Village River No. No.) Block (L x B) depth of depth sand Certifica Sabha er inm. sandin recomme resources te Certifi Block Block as nded by LxBx (Y/N) cate markin per GSOA GSOA for Depth in (Y/N) g is L B (m.) excavatio m3 Brass cluster n [m) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 1. Shirapur-1 Oaund Bhima 0/1 East-Jalalpur shiv, West-347 to 232, 657 75 3.5 1 17431 Y Y Yes South-Spot No.2 North-Pedzaon shiv 2. Shirapur-2 Oaund Bhima 0/1 East-Ialapur to sidhtek shiv, West- 657 75 3.5 1 17431 Y Y Yes Gat No.3S6, South- Spot no.3,North - Spot No.232 3. Shirapur-3 Oaund Bhima 0/1 East-Siddhtek shiv, West-Gat.No.42 657 75 3.5 1 17431 Y Y Yes and gavthan, Soutb-Hingarberdi shiv, North-Spot No.2 4. Pimpalgaon Oaund Mulamutha 0/3 Undavdi shiv Gat No.181S to KT 1658 16 3.5 1 9147 Y Y Yes Spot No.1 bandhara 5. Pimpalgaon Oaund Mulamutha 0/3 Rahu Pimpalgaon bridge to Delavadi 1937 16 3.5 1 10688 Y Y Yes Spot No.2 shiv 6. Kangaon Oaund Bhima Gat No.1121, 3 to 38, 0/4 751 36 3.5 1 9560 Y Y Yes Spot No.1 7. Hatwalan Oaund Bhima 0/5 Kangaon shiv, West-Sadalgaon 931 18 3.5 1 5927 Y Y Yes Hatwalan Bandhara, South- G.No.33 to 48, North-Sadalgaon shiv 8. Wadgaon Oaund Bhima 0/6 East- 144 to 20S West-Arvi shiv, 285 75 3.0 1 7568 Y Y Yes Darekar-I South-De. Raje shiv, NOrth-Ajnuj shiv 9. Wadgaon Oaund Bhima 0/6 East-Ajnuj W.darekar brdige, West- 255 75 3.0 1 6771 Y Y Yes Darekar-Z Spot NO.1Arvi shiv, South-Gat No.237 to 279 North-Ajanui shiv ~'cdU ~ ~ ~er Secretary 1 Page 21 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on nnd& 13MDecember, 1014

10, Wadgaon Oaund Bhima 0/6 East-Pedgaon shiv, West- Spot No.2, 284 75 3.0 1 7528 Y Y Yes Oarekar-3 Ajnuj w.darekar brdige south-gat no.12 to 36 north-ajnuj shiv 11. Khoravadi Oaund Bhima 0/9 East-Spot No.2,West-Daund shiv, 145 90 3.0 1 4608 Y Y Yes Spot No.1 south- Gat No.10 to 13, North- Kavathe shiv 12. Khoravadi Oaund Bhima 0/9 East-KT bandhara, West-Spot No.1, 145 90 3.5 1 4608 Y Y Yes Spot No.2 South-Khoravadi Gat No.14 to 18, North-Kawathe shiv 13. Khoravadi Oaund Bhima 0/9 East-Alegaon 1, West-Kolhapur 145 90 3.0 1 4608 Y Y Yes Spot No,3 bandhara, South-khoravdi gat no.18 to 71, North-Kawathe 14. Takali Spot Oaund Bhima 0/11 East-Takali S.No.246, 248, 270, 281, 547 14 3.0 1 2784 Y Y Yes No.1 273,280 South-Patethan shiv, West- Takali shiv, North-Bhima River 15. Takali Spot Oaund Bhima 0/11 East-Panvali shiv, West-River, South- 494 17 3.0 1 2935 Y Y Yes No.2 Gat No.27 to 37, North- Takali shiv 16. Nangaon Oaund Bhima 0/12 East-Sadalgaon, South-River, West- 1201 12 3.25 1 5099 Y Y Yes Gat No.318, 326, 327, 340, 319, 374, 12, 13,43,49 North-Ganesh Road shiv 17. Ganesh Road Oaund Bhima 0/13 East-Nangaon shiv, South-Gat No. 1051 12 3.50 1 4461 Y Y Yes 270 to 138, West-Pargaon shiv 18. Patethan Oaund Bhima 0/14 East-Takali shiv, West-sangavi shiv, 266 9 3.0 1 874 Y Y Yes South-Gat No.432 to 459, North- River 19. Wadgaon Oaund Bhima 0/16 East-Arangaon shiv, West-Gat 88 18 3.0 1 560 Y Y Yes Bande No.125 to 127 Gavthan 206, South- Koregaon bhivar shiv, North-Panvali shiv 20. Mirvadi Spot Oaund Mulamutha 0/18 East-Mirvadi Spot No.2 West- 601 30 3.50 1 6373 Y Y Yes No.1 Hingangaon shiv, South-River, North- Gat No.18/1, 18/2 21. Mirvadi Spot Oaund Mulamutha 0/18 East-Dahitane shiv, West-Miravadi 601 30 3.0 1 6373 Y Y Yes No.2 Spot No.1, South-River, North-Gat no.405, 369, 386 22. Panavali Oaund Bhima 0/19 East-Urali shiv, West-Gat No.96, 1,9, 620 18 3.0 1 3946 Y Y Yes 10 South-Wadgaon bane shiv Gat No.77, 94 to 106, North-Parvadi Dahitane shiv 23. Alegaon Spot Oaund Bhima 0/20 Khorvadi spot no.3 to Alegaon spot 145 90 3,0 1 4608 Y Y Yes No.1 No.2 South - Gat No. 236, 237 & 1 North- Arvi Shiv

Page 28 of 58 Chairman Minutes o[the 92"d meeting ofthe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 12"d& 13rdDecember. 1014

24. Alegaon Spot Daund Bhima D/20 East- Alegaon Spot No.1, West- 145 90 3.5 1 4608 Y Y Yes No.2 Alegaon Spot No.3,South- Gat No.1, 2, 3. North- Arvi shiv 25. Undavadi Daund Mulamutha D/22 East-- West-River, South-Gat No.1, 2, 227 13 3.5 1 1035 Y Y Yes 399,400,401,403,404,405 to 407 North-Rivar 26. Rahu Daund Mulamutha D/24 East-Rahu Undavadi Bridge, South- 2462 16 3.5 1 13588 Y Y Yes (Devkardhar Khamgaon shiv, West-North-1587 1 27. Rahu Daund East-Pimpalgaon shiv, West- Mulamutha D/24 1965 17 3.5 1 11466 Y Y Yes (Tambkhada Undavadi birdge, South-Undavadhi ~ shiv, North-K'I' bandhara. 28. Rahu Daund Mulamutha D/24 East-Pimpalgaon Walki shiv, West- 2171 18 3.5 1 13823 Y Y Yes (Tengalbet) Gat No.1247 to 1282 Rahu gavthan, South-Rahu pimpalgan bridge North- 1244 to 1245 29. Takali Haji Shirur Kukadi S/l East - Mhase Village boundary, West- 1649 8 3.5 1.00 4374 Y Y Yes Spot 1 Takali boundary, South-Mhase bound'!!}', North-Malwadi boundary 30. Mhase Bu. Shirur Ghod East -Kohokadi boundary, West- S/3 961 5 3.5 1.00 1530 Y Y Yes Mhase Village, South-Annapur boundary, North-Takali haji boundary 31. Dongargan Shirur Ghod East -Mhase Bu boundary, West- S/5 958 6 3.5 1.00 2033 Y Y Yes Takali haji boundary, South-Annapur boundary, North-Dongargan bounda!}'_ 32. larnbut Shirur Kukadi East -Sharadwadi boundary, West- S/6 1138 6 3.5 1.00 2415 Y Y Yes Pimparkhed boundary, South- Lakhangaon boundary, North- Jambut boundDaund Taluka, North-Gavthan 35. Apati Shirur Bhima S/12 East -Vadhu Bu. Boundary, West- 811 6 3.0 1.00 1721 Y Y Yes boundary, South-Tulapur boundary, North-Shinde Gavhan boundary 36. Golegaon Shirur Ghod Golegaon Tardobachiwadi bounary S/13 1081 36 3.5 1.00 13766 Y Y Yes 37. gInchani Shirur Ghod S/14 Gat No.-I73 to 131 and boundary 685 21 3.0 1.00 5086 Y Y Yes

~~ ~ ~ M~ Secretary Page 29 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting ofthe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23rdDecember. 2014

38. Chandoha Shirur Ghod Sj16 East-Fakate boundary, West- 631 8 3.5 1.00 1673 Y Y Yes Pimparkhed boundary, South- Lakhangaon boundary, West- Chandoha boundary 39. Sanvindane Shirur Odha Sj17 East-Kawathe boundary, West-Loni 739 17 3.0 1.00 4311 Y Y Yes boundary South-Gat NO.1318, 1319, North- Gat No.1 to 100 40. Nimone Shirur Ghod Sj18 East ,West and North -River, South- 1051 42 3.5 1.00 15614 Y Y Yes Gat No.431, 435, 465 467, 468, 41. Kawathe Shirur Ghod Sj19 Nimgaon Dude boundary to 586 9 3.0 1.00 1864 Y Y Yes Yemai Lakhangaon boundary 42. Kawathe Shirur KharOdha Sj20 Savindane boundary to Kawathe 360 9 3.0 1.00 1147 Y Y Yes Yemai village 43. Dhanore Shirur Bhima Sj21 East-Talegaon boundary, West- 330 15 3.5 1.00 1753 Y Y Yes Dingrajwadi boundary, South- Pimpari Sandas boundary, North- Gat No.407, 417,352,350,325,240 Talegaon bounary 44. Shirasgaon Shirur Ghod Sj24 East-Pimpalsuti bounary, West- 285 14 3.25 1.00 1362 Y Y Yes Kata Dhumalwadi boundary, South- Shirasgaon Kata North- Shrigonda Taluka 45. Tandali Shirur Ghod Sj25 East-- Shrigonda Taluka, West-Gat 1162 95 3.50 1.00 38846 Y Y Yes No.-660 to 667, 670 to 681, 690 South-Daund Taluka boundary, North-Tandali Area 46. Amdabad Shirur Ghod Sj26 East-- Annapur boundary, West- 357 6 3.0 1.00 758 Y Y Yes Nimgaon Dude boundary, South- Amdabad boundary, North- Dongargan boundary 47. Babhulsar Shirur Bhima Sj28 East- Ganegaon boundary, West- 282 75 3.0 1.00 7488 Y Y Yes Mandavgan Farata boundary, South- Daund Taluka, North-Babhulsar Bu. 48. Mandavgan Shirur Bhima Sj29 East- Babhulsar Bu.West-Wadgaon 150 27 3.0 1.00 1434 Y Y Yes Fa rata Rasai, South-Daund Taluka, North- Mandavgan Farata 49. WadnerKh. Shirur Kukadi Sj31 East- Malwadi boundary West- 1138 5 3.50 1.00 1812 Y Y Yes Sharadwadi boundary South-Wadner Kh.Gavthan North- Wadner Bu. 50. Shirur Shirur Ghod Sj32 Bridge of Pune-Nagar Rd., Sr.No.282, 841 60 3.50 1.00 17845 Y Y Yes (Tardobachi 277,210,288,290 wadi) 51. Shirur 1 Shirur Ghod Sj33 Tardobachiwadi boundary to Motilal 1761 69 3.0 1.00 42985 Y Y Yes r Corporation boundary ,IW-- ?7- ?~erSecretary Page 30 of 58 Chairman Minutes o{tlle 92"dmeeting o{tlle State Expert Appraisal Committee IIeldon 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

52. Shirur Shirur Ghod 5/34 Tardobachiwadi boundary to Motilal 1288 36 3.0 1.00 16405 Y Y Yes (Ramlingto Corporation boundary Sal_!g_amwadiJ 53. Shirur (Old) Shirur Ghod 5_L35 old Shirur Gat No.3490 to 638 1229 36 3.0 1.00 15655 Y Y Yes

The Committee noted that in a recently published news miningof sand next to pillars of railwaybridgein Daund Taluka was reported. This is a matter of concern. The Collector promised that necessary action would be taken against the negligent officers whose lack of concern has put the safety of bridge in jeopardy. Colector also promised a thorough review of sand mining in nearby vicinity of bridges, dams, KT weirs etc. to ensure safety of the structures. He reiteratedthe seriousness with which the District Administration has persued unauthorized sand miningand ensured the Committee that such clandestine activities will be controlled with all seriousness.

After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 53proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC)subject to compliance of the following conditions:

~ ~ Page 31 of 58 Chairman Minutes of the 91"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 21"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Mining officer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the mining plan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously.

Additional Collector and DMO presented 20 proposals before the Committee. Committee observed that GSDA had given unambiguous certificate regarding depth of sand available in 17 cases.

Sr.N Name of the Taluka Name of Cluster Location of the Area ofthe Area Total depth Total depth Permitted GSDA Gram Whether 0 village the River number Sand Gut (Gut sand block in of sand in the recommended sand Certifi Sabha Block No. etc) Hact. block as per by GSDAfor resources L cate Certifi marking is GSDA(m) excavation (m) xBx (YIN) cate cluster Depth in (YIN) L B m3 = Brass 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 1 PaIse Nashik Darna Single 1409 100 10 0.10 3.00 Meter 0.50 177 Y Y No Cluster ghat 2 [akhori Nashik Daman Single 543 150 10 0.15 3.00 Meter 0.50 265 No Cluster ghat Y Y 3 Kalvi Nashik Godhavari Single 108,143,170 180 40 0.72 3.20 Meter 1.00 2544 No Cluster - ghat Y Y

~ Page32 of 58 Chairman ~ Minutes o(the 92"J meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"J& 23MDecember. 2014

4 Ubhade Igatpuri Darna Single 354,355,356, 150 25 0.38 4.00 Meter 1.00 1325 No Cluster ghat 357 Y Y 5 Umbarkon Igatpuri Darna Single 59,60,61,76 225 25 0.56 4.00 Meter 1.00 1988 No Cluster ghat Y Y 6 Kas-l Trambake Damangan Four ghat 4,5,23,24,21 670 30 2.01 4.00 Meter 1.00 7102 Kas Y Y shwar ga combined Cluster 7 Tamaswadi Niphad Godawari Single 495,546,547, 550 70 3.85 2.50 Meter 0.50 6802 No Cluster ghat 548 y y 8 Lohaner-l & Devla Girna Two ghat 956 to 958,971 760 60 4.56 5.00 Meter 1.00 16113 Lohner Y Y 2 combined to 973 Cluster 9 Kalwan -1 & Kalwan Girna Two ghat 18,25, 101, 103, 580 40 2.32 3.00 Meter 1.00 8198 Kalwan 2 combined 104,115, 116, Y Y Cluster 119 10 Desgaon Kalwan Girna Single 54 to 67 900 50 4.50 3.00 Meter 1.00 15901 No Cluster _ghat Y Y 11 Dhandri-2 Baglan Girna Single 21,24,20,6,5 & 500 60 3.00 3.50 Meter 1.00 10601 No Cluster ghat 4 Y Y 12 Adharkurd-2 Malegaon Girna Single 222 to 228 500 90 4.50 3.50 Meter 1.00 15901 No Cluster ghat towards west upto Adhar Kh. y Y Keti Ware Dam 13 Savtawadi Malegaon Mosam Single 10/3 B, 10/2/2 440 40 1.76 3.50 Meter 1.00 6219 No Cluster _g_hat y y 14 Vadner Malegaon Mosam Single 349,350 680 40 2.72 3.50 Meter 0.50 4806 No Cluster ghat Y Y 15 Chinchwad-2 Malegaon Girna Single 662 500 90 4.50 3.50 Meter 0.50 7951 No Cluster ghat Y Y 16 Valwade Malegaon Mosam Single 391,401,402 800 50 4.00 3.50 Meter 1.00 14134 No Cluster ghat Y Y 17 Savandgaon Malegaon Girna Single 13,14,&16 600 80 4.80 3.50 Meter 1.00 16961 No Cluster ghat Y Y

After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 17 proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC)subject to compliance of the following conditions: 1. District Collector to ensure that conditions stipulated in the Government Resolution (G.R.)dated 12/03/2013 issued by Revenue and Forest Department, Government of Maharashtra (GoM)and Office Memorandum (O.M)of Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF),dated 24/12/2013 is implemented in letter and spirit. ot1 ~ Page 33 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'dDecember, 2014

2. Sand excavation is allowed only for the Reti Guts having sand deposition more than 2 m and excavation should be for layers above 2 m of sand deposit as recommended by GSDA. 3. District Collector to ensure that every receipt given is serially scanned and registration number so generated must be written on such receipt to avoid duplication and unauthorized transportation of the sand. 4. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that vehicles transporting sand should not be overloaded beyond stated capacity. 5. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to miningfor its nesting. 6. The depth of miningshall be restricted to the recommendations of GSDA. 7. The green belt development /tree plantation willbe made in an area of 20,},o of the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 8. Measures for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Mining officer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the miningplan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously. /

Page 34 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting of the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember, 2014

In 91st SEAC-l meeting held on 5_6th December, 2014, PPpresented 58 proposals out of which 49 were recommended and 8 were rejected as the proposals were not recommended by Gramsabha. DMO presented the 8 proposals before the Committee which are now recommended by Gramsabha. State.ment ~howin8 d.SpUsof Joint ,"urvey Regort fgr SPOdGhpts

013$0.'" Gn.m of ~"" vt:tlOl.!&,(,-' C_tiifk S

Distrijd Mi officer Collector Office.Chaodrill,put"

After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 8 proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC)subject to compliance of the following conditions:

~. ~

Page 35 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"· meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"·& 23'· December. 2014

2. Sand excavation is allowed only for the Reti Guts having sand deposition more than 2 m and excavation should be for layers above 2 m of sand deposit as recommended by GSDA. 3. District Collector to ensure that every receipt given is serially scanned and registration number so generated must be written on such receipt to avoid duplication and unauthorized transportation of the sand. 4. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that vehicles transporting sand should not be overloaded beyond stated capacity. 5. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to miningfor its nesting. 6. The depth of miningshall be restricted to the recommendations of GSDA. 7. The green belt development /tree plantation will be made in an area of 20'Yo of the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 8. Measures for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Miningofficer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the miningplan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously. /

Page 36 of 58 Chairman Minutes of the 92nd meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember, 2014

DMO presented 6proposals before the Committee. Committee observed that GSDA had given unambiguouscertificate regarding depth of sand available in these cases. These cases were also recommended by thr respective Gramsabha.

r=~T'~7~~7'''';:'':7'~T·4i:'. '..=~"=~...'- -,=;:....T. ~'Q-;;f~rClull«;;:;;;,~•..C::,.:....-c:-~(o::..~~...'.''·j"~ii'tt;" ·~ij€iiIe~jjDd·nTriif:!ll.tli*i·id. dqichij'Cij"i(j",frffl;ari.rT"Ft;.iidSiIid""T-osGStDAM· ;-.-~lfjf,~-;,r~~~"l b, mu ~ NIIld Qui;.No .l!, Wod;.(L'dt1in ROoi.'I·"'1tIt ~ ~~ (:o:nI~ "liM. m:4 ""It,) ~ .. PIlf .-d'by 1.~.Ilii.Opdlill ( YiN) f YiN, ~ 1$ osDlit. m:DA by IIiIJ'o>1lik11D ~ (m$ mDA'~ ~ .. , 11

NO'"

After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 6proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC)subject to compliance of the following conditions: 1. District Collector to ensure that conditions stipulated in the Government Resolution (G.R,) dated 12/03/2013 issued by Revenue and Forest Department, Government of Maharashtra (GoM) and Office Memorandum (O.M) of Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF), dated 24/12/2013 is implemented in letter and spirit. 2. Sand excavation is allowed only for the Reti Guts having sand deposition more than 2 m and excavation should be for layers above 2 m of sand deposit as recommended by GSDA. 3. District Collector to ensure that every receipt given is serially scanned and registration number so generated must be written on such receipt to avoid duplication and unauthorized transportation of the sand. 4. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that vehicles transporting sand should not be overloaded beyond stated pacit .

Page37 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

5. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to miningfor its nesting. 6. The depth of miningshall be restricted to the recommendations of GSDA. 7. The green belt development /tree plantation willbe made in an area of 20'Yoof the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 8. Measures for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Miningofficer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the miningplan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously.

DMOpresented 16proposals before the Committee. Committee observed that GSDA has given unambiguous certificate regarding depth of sand avala·1 ble andida so recommen ed b)y Gramsabha.The Comrmit+ee deCIided t o reject 3 proposa Is for th e reasons stat ed beow:I Sr Sand gut Reasonfor rejection Village Taluka River 1 Deoli Tambha-2 Wardha The depth of sand as per GSDA is only 0.9 m. 2 The GSDA certificate shows overwriting which raises doubt about the credibility of the Hinganghat Nandgaon (Borgaon)-2 Vana certificate. 3 Samudrapur Mangaon Vana Depth of sand is not sufficient.

Page 38 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting oUhe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember, 2014

The remammg 13 cases were consi ered Sr. Name of Taluka Name of Cluster Location of the Sand Area of Total depth Total depth Permitted GSDA Gram- Whether No. the village the number Gut the sand of sand in recommended sand Certificate Sabha Block River (Gut No.) block the block as by GSDA for resources (YIN) Certificate marking etc. (L x B) per GSDA excavation LxBxDpth (YIN) is cluster inm2. (m) (rn) in m3 = Brass 1 Ashti Bharaswada Deemed Wardha 241,234 19950 2.5 0.5 3525 Y N concurrence 2 Ashti Nawabpur Deemed Wardha 2,3 22860 2.5 0.5 4039 Y N concurrence 3 Arvi Takarkheda-1 Wardha 279,280,278 18605 3.0 1.0 6574 Y Y N 4 Arvi Wadgaon-1 Deemed Wardha 12,13,14 1368 2.5 0.5 271 Y N concurrence 5 Arvi Wadgaon-2 125,126,132,133,134, Deemed Wardha 2610 2.5 0.5 461 Y N 135 concurrence 6 Arvi Saykheda Deemed Wardha 28,29,31,32 4806 2.5 0.5 850 Y N concurrence 7 Deoli Apti-1 Wardha 6 1274 2.5 0.5 225 Y Y N 8 Hinganghat Junona Vana HV-I 32,33,36,37 33489 2.5 0.5 5917 y y Y Sonegaon 9 Hinganghat Vana (Dhote) 58 6992 2.5 0.3 742 y y N 10 Hinganghat Chikmoh Vana 97,107,108,109,129,130 30866 2.5 0.3 3272 y Y N II Hinganghat Pardi (Nagaji) Vana 11111,111/2 8220 3.0 1.0 2905 Y Y N 12 Hinganghat Chichghat Pothara 23,27 5490 2.5 0.3 582 Y Y N Aurangpur 13 Samudrapur Vana (Rith)-2 III, 1/2 13908 2.8 0.5 2457 Y Y N

After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend these 13 proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC) subject to compliance of the following conditions:

1. District Collector to ensure that conditions stipulated in the Government Resolution (G,RI)dated 12/03/2013 issued by Revenue and Forest Department, Government of Maharashtra (GoM) and Office Memorandum (OIM) of Ministry of Environment and Forest Mdated 24/12/2013 is implemented in letter and spirit. ~

Page 39 of 58 Chairman Minutes o[the 92"d meeting o[the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 12"d& 13,d December. 1014

2. Sand excavation is allowed only for the Reti Guts having sand deposition more than 2 m and excavation should be for layers above 2 m of sand deposit as recommended by GSDA. 3. District Collector to ensure that every receipt given is serially scanned and registration number so generated must be written on such receipt to avoid duplication and unauthorized transportation of the sand. 4. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that vehicles transporting sand should not be overloaded beyond stated capacity. 5. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to miningfor its nesting. 6. The depth of miningshall be restricted to the recommendations of GSDA. 7. The green belt development /tree plantation will be made in an area of 201'0 of the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 8. Measures for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 9. Project Proponent and District Collector to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters. 10. District Collector and District Miningofficer will be held individually responsible for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 11. Transport of sand should be -through vehicle which is properly covered with Tarpaulin and it should not be overloaded. 12. District Collector to ensure that the mining plan is approved by Director of Geology and Mining comprising study to show that annual replenishment of sand in the mining lease area is sufficient to sustain the mining operations at levels prescribed in the miningplan and that the transport infrastructure is adequate to transport the mined material. 13. Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure A' should be followed scrupulously.

Page40 of 58 Chairman Minutes ofthe 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

The Committee observed that in 87th SEAC-1 held on 19th& 20th September, 2014, 26 proposals were deferred as the PP could not indicate location of quarries with regard to the water courses and habitations. Now, the PPsubmitted the maps indicating the locations of quarries with regards to water courses and habitations.

Sr. Mouza Taluka Name of Lease Khasra No. / Gat Land Area Cluster I - Junner No. Type (ha) Lease Status I Junner Dhule Mis. Shri Ram Stone Crusher throll_g_hMr. Sumanbai Ravindra Akhade 2 55 Pvt. 2.10 Junner Dhule Mis. Vishvakarma Stone Metal throll_g_hMr. Bhatu Ratan B~ul New with approved mine plan 68/1 A& B 3 Junner Dhule Mr. Sudhakar Babaj_iRaul Pvt. 0.58 New with ~roved mine plan 4 Junner 58/2 Pvt. 2.12 Dhule Mis. Sl!£ram Metal throllgh Mr. Amar Premji Katira & Mr. Nimit A. Katira New with ~roved mine.2_lan 5 Junner 67/2 B Pvt. 0.40 Dhule Mis. H.M. Stone Metal Supply through Mr. YusufSaifuddin Saifee New with approved mine_Qlan 6 Junner 45/3 B 11/3 Pvt. 2.57 Dhule Mis. Sai Stone Crusher throl!&_hMrs. Tarabai Subhashlal Jaiswal New with approved mine plan 7 Junner 48/1 Pvt. 2.00 Dhule Mis. Giriraj Stone Crusher through Mr. Sheshraj Jag_annath Jadhav New with ~oved mine plan 45 8 Junner Dhule Mr. RaJendrea Dattatrll)' Mahale Pvt. 1.41 New with ~oved mine plan Cluster II - Dahyane 54 Pvt. 3.00 New with 1!Pproved mine.2_lan 9 Dahyane Dhule Mis. Bedse & Sons throll_g_hMr. Anant Panditrao Bedse 10 Dah_y_ane 55/2 A Pvt. 1.39 Dhule Mis. New Tanl?ia Stone Crusher throllgh Mr. Narendra Arjundas Taneja New with ~oved mine plan II Dahyane 45/1 A Pvt. 1.91 Dhule Mis. Sameer EnteIprises through Mr. Jitendra Vedprakash Palhani New with ~roved mine ..£!an SiJ!gle Quarry - Dahyane 55/1 A-I Pvt. 2.27 New with approved mine..£!an 12 Da~ane Dhule Mis. Manekar Brothers Stone Crusher throl!gh Mr. Mohan Vasant Manekar Cluster III - Fl!Kne-Babhulwadi 39/2B I Pvt. 1.33 I New with ~oved mine plan 13 Fag_ne Dhule Mis. Trimurti Stone Crusher through Mrs. Kalpana Pramod Mundake 439/1-2-2 Pvt. 0.43 New with approved mine.2_lan 14 Fagne Dhule Mis. Shri. Swami Samarth Stone Crusher through Mr. Bhanudas Abhimanyu New with approved mine plan Kachawe 434/2A Pvt. 1.21 15 Babulwadi Dhule Mis. Kulswamini Stone Crusher through Mr. Pramod Eknath Shelar 16 Babulwadi 44/1-2 B Pvt. 0.76 New with approved mine plan Dhule Mis. Dhanalaxmi Stone Crusher through Mr. Amol Ashokrao Deshmukh Cluster IV - Kasvihir 44/3, 44/4 & 44/5 Pvt. 2.40 New with approved mine plan 17 Kasvihir Dhule Mis. Om Stone Crusher throl!Bh Mr. Raj_eshGhevarlal Bafna 18 46/2 B Pvt. Kasvihir Dhule Mis. S. N. Patil & Sons throl!Bh Mr. S. N. Patil 0.85 New with ~oved mine plan Si'!_gle_Quarry - Kalkheda 45 1 Pvt. 1.51 New with !lQProved mine..£!an 19 Kalkheda Dhule Mis. J'!Y_Ambika Stone Crusher through Mr. Shantaram Bhurmal Patil Si'!&ie_Quarn' - Mukti 272/2 Pvt. 1.82 New with ~oved mine plan 20 Mukti Dhule Mis. Vindhyasini Stone Crusher through Mrs. Sangitabai Ramesh Patil 537/2 A & 3 A Pvt. 3.05 New with approved mine plan (I.'crl11::1 ~ ~ Jemtler Secretary ~ Page 41 of 58 Chairman MiI,utes o(tlle 92"d meeting oft/Ie State Expert Appraisal Committee Ileld on 22nd& 23,d December. 2014

The Committee observed that the locations were beyond the prescribed distance of 300 m from habitation and that the quarries would not affect surface / ground water regime. The Committee again deliberated environmental impact of quarries with reference to baseline and incremental ground level concentrations of air quality and observed that these would not exceed the prescribed limits and that the impacts due to quarrying would be minimal. After due deliberations on all the aspects of environmental impact Committee decided to recommend 13 proposals for Environmental Clearance (EC)subject to compliance of the following conditions:

1. The approved mining plans shall be submitted to the Committee at the earliest. 2. No stone crushing shall be allowed in any of the quarries approved. 3. Existing quarries have not maintainedanybenches.The approved quarries shall maintain benches with the configurations: 60 degrees slope in the cut, 6 mt depth for cut and 6 mt width for the bench. 4. No dumpingof material shall be allowed in water sources or nallas. 5. DMO mentioned that there were no abandoned quarries. The Committee is oftheopinion that there may be abandoned quarries. DMO shall verify this from Tahshildars and wherever the abandoned quarries arefound,restoratioin plan for the same should be prepared. The future applications for environmental clearance for quarries will not be considered unless restoration plan for the abondoned quarries are submitted. 6. General Conditions as stipulated in "Annexure H' should be followed scrupulously. ******

Page 42 of 58 Chairman Minutes oft/Ie 92"d meeting oUhe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8(a)• B2 category of EIA Notification, 2006. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. During discussion and deliberations on the matter following points emerged: 1. PP to submit details regarding use of paint and exact nature of chemicals used. PPto carry out QRA and mitigation measures thereof. 2. PPto submit details of treatment of coolant. 3. Onsite and Off-site hazard managent plan of flammable material stored within premises. 4. PPto submit consent for water supply from competent authority. 5. PP to submit permission for storage of diesel/gasoline from competent authority. After deliberation, Committee decided to defer the proposal for compliance of the above mentioned points.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8(a)-Bl category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PPwas approved with the following additional ToR:

1. A maximumof about 20 'Yo saving in energy shall be targetted while planning the industtrial construction.

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8(a) B category of EIA Notification, 2006. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. During discussion and deliberations on the matter following points emerged: 1. PPhas to carry out QRA studies pertaining to cyclopentane handling. 2. The Committee observed that the project is supported by MoEFF&CC,GoI and appreciates the initiative in ODS reduction. The details of the same may be submitted. After deliberation,elrpoints.Committee decided to defer the proposal for compliance of the

~ Page43 of 58 Chairman Minutes of the 92',d meeting of the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23" December. 2014

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as led) & 5 (j) category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PP was approved. PP shall carry out public consultation and approach SEACwith EIA report incorporating minutes of the same.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 5 (j) & 1 (d) category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, the ToR presented by the PPwas approved with the following additional ToR: 1. Consent for water supply from competent authority to be submitted. 2. Stack height shall be based on the 100% use of Indian coal.

PPshall carry out public consultation and approach SEACwith EIA report incorporating minutes of the same.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 5 (j) & 1 (d) category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PPwas approved with the following additional ToR: 1. Consent for water supply from competent authority to be submitted. 2. Applicability of RRZPolicyto be analyzed. 3. Details of ash management to be incorporated. 3. Stack height shall be based on the 100'Youse of Indian coal.

PPshall carry out public consultation and approach SEACwith EIA report incorporating minutes of the same.

Page44 of 58 Chairman Minutes of the 92"dmeeting of the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 5(f)-Bl category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PPwas approved with the following additions. 1. Submit details of spent acid recycling. 2. Provide STP for domestic effluent. 3. PPto ensure provision of denitrification in ETP. 4. PPto submit MSDS, especially TLVsof nitrotoluene and amino aromatics 4. PPto carry out ambient air quality monitoring for benzene and benzopyrane.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 1 (a) category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PPwas approved with the following additional ToR: 1. MiningPlan shall be got approved by the competent authority. 2. PPto submit prospecting details. 3. PPto submit details of waste management. 4. PPto submit details of closure plan. 5. The nearest habitation in Gaothan shall be one of the monitoring station.

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8(a)• B category of EIA Notification, 2006. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. During discussion and deliberations on the matter following points emerged: 1. PPto resubmit the proposal complyingwith the MIDC DCRfor parking and green belt. Since the areas provided for these land uses appear to be insufficient.

After deliberation, Committee decided to defer the proposal for compliance of the above mentioned point.

Page45 of 58 Chairman Minutes o[the 92',d meeting o[the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23N December. 2014

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 5 (f) category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PPwas approved with the following additional ToR: 1. PPto allocate 12'70of gross plot area for parking. 2. PPto provide one more gate in the plant premises. 3. Stack height shall be based on 100 '70use of Indian coal. 4. PPto submit details of handling of 60'70H202. 5. Effluent sent to CETPshall be only for dilution purpose, ideally PPto achieve ZLD. 6. PPto carry out Risk assessment studies.

The PPwas absent.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8 a (b2) category of EIA Notification, 2006. The PPadmitted that the construction activity has been completed and production activities are initiated. This constitutes a violation and therefore the proposal should be referred to the Department of Environment, Government of Maharashtra for further ation.

The PPwas absent.

Page 46 of 58 '4 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Ewert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'"December. 2014

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8 a (b2) category of ErA Notification, 2006. The PP admitted that the construction activity was completed by April 2012 and the production was initiated in December, 2012. This constitutes a violation and therefore the proposal should be referred to the Department of Environment, Government of Maharashtra for further action.

The PPwas absent.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project.The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8(a)-B1 category of ErA Notification, 2006. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PP was approved with the following additional ToR: 1. A maximumof about 20 'Yo saving in energy shall be targeted while planning both in building and process. 2. PPto submit details of hazardous, flammable material/solvents. Work place monitoring for the same may be indicated. 3. PPto submit details of QRA and Emergency Management Plan. 4. Height of the stack shall be correctly worked out with reference to maximum height of the neighbouring buildings. 5. PPto submit details of construction initiated prior to applicability of ECand copies of Commencement Certificates obtained till date.

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent.PP explained the process of stripping jigs in a paint stripping plant which uses thermal fluidized bed for paint stripping. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8(a) B2 category of ErA Notification, 2006. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. During discussion and deliberations on the matter followi points emerged: JJ Page47 of 58 ~nnan Minutes o{the 92"dmeeting o{the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'd December. 2014

1. PP to justify that the temperature of 4500 C is adequate enough to burn out all VOCsso that no harmful emissions escape. 2. The Risk Assessment and fire protection measures for the LPGPipeline serving the paint stripping plant may be outlined. After deliberation, Committee decided to defer the proposal for compliance of the above mentioned points.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed expansion of bauxite mining from capacity of 12000 TPA to 89000 TPA. Committee noted that the project was considered as 1 (a) category of EIA Notification, 2006.AII issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion, ToR presented by the PP was approved with the following additional ToR: 1. In the presentation submitted by PPthe ambient air quality in the core and buffer zone seems to be on the higher side. A thorough study shall be done on ambient air quality level taking into conSideration processing of ore, mineral rejects and transportation activities from mine to outstation .. 2. A monitoing station shall be placed at Hariharishewar Temple. 3. Approved Miningplan shall be submitted alongwith EIA report. PPshall carry out public consultation and approach SEACwith EIA report incorporating minutes of the same.

The Project Proponent presented draft TOR before the committee for the proposed project. Committee noted that the project was considered as 8 a (b2) category of EIA Notification, 2006. The PP admitted that the 60 'Yo of the proposed construction activity was completed without obtaining prior EC. This constitutes a violation and therefore the proposal should be referred to the Department of Environment, Government of Maharashtra for further action.

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. Committee noted that the project was considered as 1 (d) category of EIA Notification, 2006. The Committee noted that the PP was seeking revalidation of previous EC granted since PP had applied for Consent to Operate for which valid EC is mandated. It appears that PP has applied in the prescribed format. The pr osal is therefore deferred. Jr1 ~ Page48 of 58 Chairman

------Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22nd& 23,d December. 2014

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. Committee noted that the project was considered as 1 (d) category of EIA Notification, 2006. The Committee noted that the PP is seeking revalidation of previous EC granted since PP has applied for Consent to Operate for which valid EC is mandated. The proposal is therefore deferred for preparation of EIA report.

The PPwas absent.

The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by the proponent. The PP was granted ToR in the BPtSEAC-l meeting .Committee noted that the project was considered as 7(h)-Blcategory of EIA Notification, 2006.

The Committee noted that the new CETP was necessiciated by the unprecidental industrial growth in Tarapur MIDC post 2000 when a large number of textile processing, pharma and chemical industries got established there. In 2003, MoEF declared Tarapur MIDC as "Critically Polluted Industrial Area". A Monitoring Committee constituted by Hon'ble Supreme Court visited Tarapur MIDC along with representatives of MIDC, MPCB,TIMA and local NGOs. The abstract of this visit was to set up new CETP for which purpose a society under Companies Act named as "Tarapur Environment Protection Society (TEPS)" was established. The TEPS is the PP in the present case.

Page49 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"dmeeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23rdDecember. 2014

The Committee is fully conscious about the urgency of augmenting the capacity of effluent treatment in Tarapur MIDC. The Committee first deliberated the project in its 81st and 82ndmeeting and following decisions were taken:

Decision taken in 81st SEAC 19th - 20tb June, 2014.

nuision: The case was discussed on the _s of the pcaentation made by the proponent. The Committee observed that the existing CETP is of 2S MLD and the proposal under consideration is of additional SO MLD capacity. Besides the TOR presented by the project proponent and the Model ToR foUowing points shan also be covered during the preparation orElA report: f f • PP to submit CRZ Clearance ifthe treated .nluent is to be deposed in Navapur Creek. 2. Calculations of primary sludge generation shall be submitted. 3. Decanter ~tem followed by filter press OR parallel fUteration equipment followed by thermal drymg shall be provided. Provision of sludge drying beds shall be avoided. 4. DeSign details with size of various units/ Components shoJI be submitted. ~ environmental consultant to be engaged for preparation of EWEMP report should be accredIted by Quality Council of India {QCl)I NABET. For data coJJcction and analysis only MoEF or NABL approved laboratories should be emplOYed. A~ soon as the draft ElA report is prepared. the same may be submitted to the Maharasbtra Pollution Control .Board (MPCB) for conducting public harlng as per FJA Notification. 2006 and MoEF OM .no. J.ll~1313612014~AI-1 dU6'" May, 2014. On revising the EfA Report, addressing all concerns raised during the public hearing /public consultation.. the same shall be submitted to the SEAC I, Maharashtra for appraisaL

Considered in 82nd SEAC 3rd_4thJuly, 2014. Table Item Mia T...... r ...... ~ Prot. dIOII •• .,,: Proposed construction L- .....t...::":.:,.f,::.;SI:::..·ML;;.;;,;\.:=•• ·=.,Dct."P m T!!!p_I.,.1SttiaI Area, MlDC T Thane.

Derision: The case was discussed in 81- SEAC-I meeting wherein ~ proposal was ~idcrcd in B 1 Category and ToR W1I5 _cd to PP mandadng poblic COIlfiuhauon. The Commattee notcd ~ representation submitted vide letter dated 04.07.2014 by PP reqIIesting. to exempt it &om publiC consultation. The Committe deliberatr.d.Oft. whe«her exemptkm could be given to the proposed CETP t Tarapur being a facility to control pollution. The Committee unanimously felt dal eETP should be :Onsideted as arty otha' industry by virtue of its cnviromrlental concerns it poses to diwrse of several stakcboldcn. Thcn::fO«';tIwl· Commin" folt tbrd no_ptioa ftoo_ Pub" COM..... tin shalJ be given to CETP Tarapur.

Thereafter the Committee visited Tarapur MIDC area and inspected the existing CETP and the site of the proposed CETP.Certain observations were made by the Committee, foremost among which were follOWing: 1. The MIDC should complete the installation of outfall pipe to a distance prescribed by National Institute of Oceanography (NIO), Simultaneously with the establishment of CETP. 2. Since there are certain industries whose effluent have high content of nitrogenous aromatics capable of causing shock loads to the system, it is necessary to monitor the system for which purpose the PPshould undertake the profiling of industrial effluents from individual units without further delay. JAl A-y Page 50 of 58 Chairman Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Aporaisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,d December, 2014

3. Pursuant to the existing regulations regarding requirement of public hearing, the Collector was requested to expediate the same. (It may be noted that this requirement has since been deleted vide MoEF OM dt. 10.12.2014, however the PPhas undertaken public hearing.)

Brief extract of the project details as submitted by PPis as below:

NameoftheProject Proposedconstruction of 50MLD CommonEffluent Treatment Plant(CETP) Name, address,e-mail Name:Rameshpoddar &contactnumber of · Address:Plot no AM-29/Pt, Near Shivaji Nagar,MIDC Proponent Tarapur,Dist Palghar,401506 · Telephonenumber:(02525)325656 / 205013 · Mobilenumber:09323023612 · EmailID: teDs123 [email protected];[email protected] Nameof Consultant Name:VITYA ConsultantsPvt Ltd New Project/Expansion NewProject

Activity scheduled in the EIA 7(h) Notification Area DetaiIs Totalplotarea(sq.m.):84984.04(21acres) Builtuparea(Sq.m.):56656.04(14acre) Greenbeltarea(Sq.m.):28328.02(7acre) Name of the Notified MIDC Tarapur,PalgharDistrict Industrial Area/MIDC area TOR given by SEAC?(If yes Yes. 8pt meetingof SEACduring 18-21,June 2014 then specify the meetirlg) Estimated cost of the project: 79.5 Crores Location details of the Latitude:19~22.3a'N project Longitude:72'74'16.71"E Location:TarapurMIDC,AtPlotNo:05-30 Process details & Keepingthe present scenarioand future in mind the Tarapur Manufacturing DetaiIs EnvironmentProtection Society (TEPS)has proposedto set- up a CommonEffluent Treatment Plant ( CETP)of 50 MLD capacity. The treated effluent is proposedto be discharged into MIDC Tarpur sump. Rainwater Harvesting(RWH) Rainwater Harvesting has been considered in the project area Total water requirement The water requirement for the project being a CETPproject is very minimal Strom water Drainage Suitable drainage system will be considered in the project area. ETPDetails Primarytreatment comprisesof screening,oil removal, equalization,coagulation& flocculation Secondarytreatment compriSingAnoxictreatment followed by two stage Activated SludgeProcesswith 4 stream

\~~ ~,ecretary Page 51 of 58 ~aD Millutes o(the 92"dmeetillg of the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23'd December, 2014

confiquration of 12,5 MLD each for CETPof 50 MLD Note on ETP technology to be Primary treatment comprises of screening, oil removal, used equalization ,coagulation & flocculation Secondary treatment comprising Anoxic treatment followed by a two stage Activated Sludge Process, Disposal of the ETP sludge The Sludge which shall be generated shall be sent to TSDF (If applicable) site located in Taloja, Mumbai Solid waste Management S, Source Qty From Composition No (tpm) (sludge/Dry/ Siunyetc,) 2 ETP 1260 1260 840 840 Chemical sludge, 1260 tpm, will be sent to authorized TSDF located in Taloja, Mumbai with prior authorization from SPCB Biological sludge, 840 tpm, after proper examination will be used as manure, Atmospheric Emissions S, Pollutant Sourceof Emission Concentration (Flue gas characteristics SPM, No Emission rate(kg/hr) influe gas S02, NOx, CO, e+c.) Standby (g/m3) DGset 1 SPM Standby 0.158 0,021 DGset 2 S02 DGset - - 3 NOX DGset 32,9 4,39 4 CO DGset 1.862 0,248 5 others DGset 0,398 0,053 Ambient Air Quality Data Pollutants Permissible Backgrol..l1d Remarks Standard Concentration ( inpg/m3) 3 100 67,2 RPMin.ug/m Within Standards 3 S02 in.ug/m 80 23.1 Within Standards 3 80 NOx in.ug/m 31.3 Within Standards The details are presented in EIA Report. Energy PowerSupply:MIDC ProposedPowerrequirement:7500 kVA DGSets: Numberand capacity DGsets to be used (existing)2*2000 kVA Green Belt Development Greenbeltarea(Sq,m,):28328,02(33,33I'o)7 acres Pollution control systems: Since it is a CETPproject, no such pollution control system are proposed EMP Budgetary allocation Capital cost (With break up): 7950 Lakhs , EIA submitted (If yes then EIA report issubmitted, submit the salient features) Period of data collected between June and August 2014

r»: Details of secondary data collection ~1~ ~ ~~ Page 52 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92"dmeeting oUhe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,dDecember. 2014

Potential hazard and mitigation measures Conclusionof the EIA study

Public Hearing Report (if Public Hearing was conducted on 29-11-2014 at 11am in TIMA public hearing conducted then hall, Tarapur in accordance with the procedure laid in EIA submit the salient features) 2006 notification. Issues were raised on treated effluent standards of existing 25MLD CETP operated by TEPS. Accordingly, TEPS has emphasized the need of additional CETP of 50MLD so that the treated effluent standards can be met for both the plants. The participants have positively reacted accordingly with the suggestion that the proposed CETP also should run continuously and shall meet the stipulated standards. A detailed presentation of EIA report was made by the Environmental Consultant. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. After discussion and deliberations on the matter following points emerged:

1. Profiling of industrial effluents has not been carri~d out and the Committee fears that in the absence of proper monitoring of shock loads, the system may suffer major failure. Profiling needs to be completed by end of February, 2015. 2. The PPstated that he was not responsible for disposing off the effluent post the MIDC sump. The Committee expressed concern that the management of the project unless entrusted with a single authority will be rendered infructuous. It is absolutely necessary to coordinate the efforts of TEPS and MIDC so that the CETPas well as the outfall pipe are completed Simultaneously. 3. The Committee feels that a suitable agency should coordinate the efforts of TEPS and MIDC for the effective and timely completion of the project as a whole. An Expert Committee needs to be authorized for this purpose.

After deliberation, Committee decided to recommend the proposal for Environmental Clearance to SEIAA, subject to compliance of above mentioned points.

The proposal was previously considered in 87th SEAC meeting. SEAC received Minutes of Meeting of rr» SEIAA. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and biodiversity and social aspects were once again discussed in detail.

During discussion and deliberations PPwas asked to comply with following points: 1. Exhaustive list of raw material alongwith MSDS. 2. Toposheet showing details of 25 km radius.

These details should be submitted by 3rd Jan, 2015. Further, the Committee decided to convene site visit on 9th January, 2015, primarily to assess the impact of the proposed projectOMon the nearly environment in particular the water bodies. ~ Page 53 of 58 Chairman Minutes ofthe 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 2]nd& 23,d December. 2014

"Annexure A"

The Specific and General conditions applicable for Mining of Sand

Specific conditions: 1. Proposals are recommended for Environmental Clearancefor period 2014- 2015 only. 2. Provisions stipulated in Maharashtra Minor Minerals Extraction (development and Regulation) Rules 2013 and Government Resolution of Revenueand Forest Department dated 12/03/2013. 3. District Collector and District Mining officer will be held responsible individually for non compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 4. District Collector will take bank guarantee upto 2'Yoof the total auction cost for the given auction period from project proponent to ensure the compliance of the conditions stipulated. In case of violation of stipulated conditions by project proponent bank guarantee so obtained shall be forfeited and legal action under the law should be initiated against such project proponent. 5. The depth of sand layer to be mined, after retaining 2 m minimum layer below, should not be more than 2 meters as per Government Resolution of RevenueDepartment dated 12th March 2013 e.g. if the total depth of sand is 3 m, only up to one metre of sand shall be mined. 6. It shall be ensured that excavation of minor mineral does not disturb or change the underlying soil characteristics of the river bed /basin, where mining is carried out. 7. It shall be ensured that mining does not in any way disturb the turbidity, velocity and flow pattern of the river water. 8. A siltation study should be carried out before commencement of the mining activity or within a period of one year through some expert Agency like NIO/CWPRS to determine the siltation load so that there is no over exploitation of the material at any point of time. The mineral to be removed shall be determined based on siltation load. This study shall be steered by competent authority while granting further mining lease and or renewing of the license. A copy of siltation study shall be submitted to the Environment Department, the District Mining Officer and respective Regional Office of the State Pollution Control Board. 9. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependant on the river bed or areas close to mining for its nesting. 10. Turtle nesting units' conservation is very important. Therefore sand mining in such areas is to be prohibited. 11. The green belt development/tree plantation will be made in an area of 20'Yoof the total leased area either on river bank or along road side. 12. Measure for prevention & control of soil erosion and management of silt shall be undertaken. Protection of dumps against erosion, if any, shall be carried-out with geo textile matting or other suitable material. 13. District Collector and Project proponent to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order and orders of the National Green Tribunal given in the related matters.

Page 54 of 58 ~man Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o[the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23,d December. 2014

General conditions:

1. Precise mining area will be jointly demarcated at site by officials of Mining/Revenue department prior to mining operations for all proposals under consideration. Such site plan, duly verified by competent authority shall be submitted to Environment Department. 2. All necessary statutory clearances shall be obtained before start of mining operations. 3. Depth of mining shall be restricted to 3 m or water level whichever is less. 4. No mining shall be carried out in the streams. 5. Mining shall be limited to day hours time only. The loading shall not be done during night hours. 6. No mining shall be carried out in the safety zone of any bridge and/or embankment. 7. No mining shall be carried out in the vicinity of natural/ manmadearchaeological sites. 8. The lease holder shall obtain necessary prior permission of the competent authorities for drawal of requisite quantity of water (surface water and groundwater), if required for the project. 9. Waste water, if any, shall be properly collected and treated so as to conform to the standards prescribed by MoEF/CPCB. 10. No wildlife habitat will be infringed. 11. Environmental clearance is subject to obtaining clearance under the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 from the competent authority, if applicable to this project. 12. Green belt development shall be carried out considering CPCBguidelines including selection of plant species and in consultation with the local DFO/Horticulture Officer. 13. Parking of vehicles should not be made on public places. 14. Transportation of materials shall be done by covering the trucks / tractors with tarpaulin or other suitable mechanismso that no spillage of mineral/dust takes place. 15. Appropriate mitigation measures shall be taken to prevent any kind of pollution in consultation with the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board. It shall be ensured that there is no leakage of oil and grease from the vehicles used for transportation. 16. Vehicular emissions shall be kept under control and regularly monitored. The mineral transportation shall be carried out through the covered trucks only and the vehicles carrying the mineral shall not be overloaded. 17. Special Measures shall be adopted to prevent the nearby settlements from the impacts of mining activities. Maintenance of roads through which transportation of minor minerals is to be undertaken, shall be carried-out regularly. 18. Dispensary facilities for first-aid shall be provided at site. 19. Occupational health surveillance program of the workers should be undertaken periodically. 20. Provision shall be made for housing the workers at site, if required, with all necessary infrastructure and facilities such as fuel for cooking, safe drinking water, medical health care and sanitation etc. 21. Ambient air quality will be monitored at the site and the nearest habitation in the months of January, April and November. Ambient air quality at the boundary of the precise mining area shall conform to the norms prescribed by MoEF, GOI. 22. Measures shall be taken for control of noise level to the limits prescribed by CPCB 23. An Environmental Audit shall be annually carried out during the operational phase and t1s1eIlatl:submitted to the Environment Department.

Me~ Page 55 of 58 Chairman Minutes oUhe 92"d meeting oUhe State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22nd& 23,d December. 2014

24. Digital processing of the entire leasearea in the district using remote sensing technique shall be done regularly once in three years for monitoring and report submitted to the Environment Department. The funds earmarked for environmental protection measures shall be kept in separate account and shall not be diverted for other purpose. Year wise expenditure shall be reported to the Regional Office, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Bhopal. 25. Revenue Authorities shall submit within 3 months their policy towards address (i) Standard operating process/ procedure to bring into focus any infringement/deviation /violation of environmental norms /conditions, (ii) Hierarchical system or Administrative order to deal with environmental issues and ensuring compliance of EC conditions and (iii) System of reporting of non compliance/violation of environmental norms to the District collector. 26. The Mining officer shall submit six monthly reports in hard and soft copy on the status of compliance of the stipulated environmental clearance conditions including results of monitored data (both in hard & soft copies) to the Environment department and the District Collector, the respective Regional Office of the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board. 27. Any change in mining area, khasra /Gat numbers, entailing capacity addition with change in process and or mining technology, modernization and scope of working shall again require prior Environmental Clearance as per provisions of EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended). 28. SEAC appraised the proposals on the basis of information submitted by concerned District Mining Officer. Mining Officer shall submit the list of blocks satisfying conditions stipulated above to Revenue & Environment dept. The list of blocks and conditions stipulated above shall be made available in public domain. It should be published in two local language newspapers and display at each block where mining operation is proposed. District mining officer should ensure this and submit compliance report to Environment department with approval from Collector. =0=

''Annexure 8"

The Specific and General conditions applicable for Mining of Stone:

Specific conditions:

1. Provisions stipulated in Maharashtra Minor Minerals Extraction (development and Regulation) Rules 2013 shall be strictly adhered to. 2. District Collector and District Mining officer will be held responsible personally for non- compliance of the conditions stipulated in the Environmental clearance and shall be liable for legal action under Environment (Protection) Act of 1986. 3. District Collector will take bank guarantee of Rs. 2,00,000/- OR upto 2"0of the annual royalty, whichever is higher, for the given lease from the lease holder to ensure the com lienee of the conditions sti ulated. In case of violation of sti ulated conditions b

~ Page56 of 58 Chairman

------Minutes o(the 92"d meeting o(the State Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22"d& 23rdDecember. 2014

project proponent bank guarantee so obtained shall be forfeited and legal action under the law should be initiated against such project proponent. 4. It shall be ensured that there is no fauna dependent on the areas close to mining for its nesting. 5. To prevent dust / particulate matter pollution, the lease holder shall take up tree plantation in an area 10 m from the boundary of the leased area and also on either side of the road leading to the quarry from the already surfaced road. 6. District Collector and Project proponent to ensure that there is no violation of the Supreme Court order given in related matters. 7. District Collector shall prepare closure plan and get it approved by the competent authority for all abandoned mines in the District.

General conditions: 1. Precise mining area will be jointly demarcated at site by officials of Mining/Revenue department prior to mining operations for all proposals under consideration. Such site plan, duly verified by competent authority shall be submitted to Environment Department. 2. All necessary statutory clearances shall be obtained before start of mining operations. 3. Mining / loading shall be limited to day hours' time only. The quarrying / loading shall not be done during night hours. 4. No mining shall be carried out in the safety zone of any bridge and/or embankment. 5. No mining shall be carried out in the vicinity of natural/ manmadearcheological sites. 6. The lease holder shall obtain necessary prior permission of the competent authorities for drawl of requisite quantity of water (surface water and groundwater), if required for the project. 7. Waste water, if any, shall be properly collected and treated so as to conform to the standards prescribed by MoEF/CPCB. 8. No wildlife habitat will be infringed. 9. Where, the quarrying is in a hilly terrain hill cutting shall be allowed only in the recharge zone to be identified by the officials of GSDA. 10. Environmental clearance is subject to obtaining clearance under the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 from the competent authority, if applicable to this project. 11. Green belt development shall be carried out considering CPCBguidelines including selection of plant species in consultation with the local DFO/Horticulture Officer. 12. Parking of vehicles should not be made on public places. 13. Transportation of materials shall be done by covering the trucks / tractors with tarpaulin or other suitable mechanismso that no spillage of mineral/dust takes place. 14. Appropriate mitigation measures shall be taken to prevent any kind of pollution in consultation with the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board. It shall be ensured that there is no leakage of oil and grease from the vehicles used for transportation. 15. Vehicular emissions shall be kept under control and regularly monitored. The mineral transportation shall be carried out through the covered trucks only and the vehicles carrying the mineral shall not be overloaded. 16. Special Measures shall be adopted to prevent the nearby settlements from the impacts of mining activities. Maintenance of roads through which transportation of minor minerals is to be undertaken, shall be carried-out regularly.

7+ Page57 of 58 Chairman

------Minutes o(tlle 92"" meeting o(tlle State Expert Appraisal Committee IIeldon 22""& 23'" December. 2014

17. Dispensary facilities for first-aid shall be provided at site. 18. Occupational health surveillance program of the workers should be undertaken periodically. 19. Provision shall be made for housing the workers at site, if required, with all necessary infrastructure and facilities such as fuel for cooking, safe drinking water, medical health care and sanitation etc. 20. Ambient air quality will be monitored at the site and the nearest habitation in the months of January, April and November. Ambient air quality at the boundary of the precise mining area shall conform to the norms prescribed by MoEF, GOr. 21. Measures shall be taken for control of noise levels to the limits prescribed by CPCB. 22. An Environmental Audit shall be annually carried out during the operational phase and be submitted to the Environment Department. 23. Digital processing of the entire leasearea in the district using remote sensing technique shall be done regularly once in three years for monitoring and report submitted to the Environment Department. The funds earmarked for environmental protection measures shall be kept in separate account and shall not be diverted for other purpose. Year wise expenditure on environmental protection measures shall be reported to the Regional Office, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Bhopal. 24. RevenueAuthorities shall submit within 3 months their policy of (i) Standard operating process/ procedure to bring into focus any infringement/deviation /violation of environmental norms /conditions, (ii) Hierarchical system or Administrative order to deal with environmental issues and to ensure compliance of EC conditions and (iii) System of reporting of non-compliance /violation of environmental norms to the District collector. 25. The Mining officer shall submit six monthly reports in hard and soft copy on the status of compliance of the stipulated environmental clearance conditions including results of monitored data (both in hard & soft copies) to the Environment Department, and the District Collector and the respective Regional Office of the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board. 26. Any change in mining area, khasra /Gat numbers, entailing capacity addition with change in process and or mining technology, modernization and scope of working shall again require prior Environmental Clearance as per provisions of EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended). 27. SEAC-I has appraised the proposals on the basis of information submitted by concerned District Mining Officer. Mining Officer shall submit the list of blocks satisfying conditions stipulated above to Revenue& Environment dept. The list of blocks and conditions stipulated above shall be made available in public domain. It should be published in two local language newspapers and displayed at each block where mining operation is proposed. District mining officer should ensure this and submit compliance report to Environment department with approval from Collector.

******

Page 58 of 58 Chairman

------