SUMMARY OF AONB PLANNING CONSULTATIONS

APRIL 2017 – SEPTEMBER 2017

Code No. (1) Site Address Brief Description of Summary of AONB Comments LPA Response to Development Decision AONB Comments (2) 055920 Land at Maes Mynan Change of use to holiday park Object Withdrawn Quarry, , CH7 (Amended plans) 23/08/17 5UB 05/2017/0239 Land adjacent to Tyn Y Erection of a food manufacturing No objection in principle, but Granted Llidiart Industrial Estate, plant, warehousing and office concerns over scale of 19/06/17 Corwen, facilities and associated works. development; design changes LL21 9RJ suggested. 15/2017/0172 Engine House at Former Restoration and conversion of Concerns over impact on sensitive Nant Lead Mine, Eryrys, engine house and erection of site but accept need to restore CH7 4TD extension to form dwelling Listed Building. Further details required. 07/2017/0241 Fedw Waen, Llandrillo, Erection of extension to front of No observations Granted N/A LL21 0SP dwelling 10/05/17 03/2016/1017 Abercregan House Erection of an agricultural Additional detail required, suggest Granted Llangollen, LL20 7PS building design changes 12/05/17 47/2017/0255 Bryntirion Farm Rhuallt, Erection of an agricultural Query agricultural need, suggest Refused LL17 0TG building design changes. 08/05/17 056630 Plas Yn Llan, , CH7 Conversion of existing outbuilding Support, subject to Conservation Granted N/A 5PB to holiday units Officer views 03/05/17 056631 Plas Yn Llan, Cilcain, CH7 Listed Building application for Support, subject to Conservation Granted N/A 5PB conversion of existing outbuilding Officer views 12/10/17 to holiday units 16/2017/0198 Rhesgoed Farm Llanbedr Change of use of agricultural land No objection, subject to seasonal D C to camping site use, landscaping and other LL15 1YE controls 05/2017/0202 Land adj Maes Y Waen, Development of land by the No objection subject to retention Carrog erection of six dwellings (outline of rural character and affordable LL21 9AH application) housing. 05/2017/0266 Station Camp Site Extension to existing camp site No objection subject to Granted Carrog, LL21 9BD landscaping and extra controls on 14/07/17 use 05/2017/0129 Coed y Glyn, Erection of Log Cabin Object Granted Glyndyfrdwy, 18/07/17 LL21 9BP 056527 Bod Arthur, , CH7 Extension and re-modelling of No objection Granted N/A 5LL dwelling 10/05/17 41/2017/0222 Heron Cottage, Forge Erection of single storey extension No objection subject to pitched Granted Farm, Bodfari, LL16 4DW to rear of dwelling slate roof 15/07/17 05/2017/0320 Flat Fferyllfa Corwen, LL21 Erection of conservatory to rear No observations subject to Refused N/A 0AB Conservation Officer views 20/07/17 05/2016/1237 Corwen Day Nursery, Erection of two storey extension No objection, suggest painting of Granted LL21 0DN building 07/07/17 056718 Tirionfa, , Mold, Lawful development certificate for No observations Granted N/A CH7 5RW holiday caravan 09/05/17 056735 New Bungalow, Erection of detached No observations subject to Granted garage/workshop/store landscaping scheme 09/05/17 CH7 5ET 056703 Former Centre Point Erection of 3no. dwellings Object – outside settlement Refused Garage, Afonwen boundary 05/07/17

056782 Maes Yr Haf, , Variation of agricultural No objection, suggest reduced LL18 6EW occupancy condition on period for variation. permission 0741/89 056684 19 Railway Terrace, Erection of log cabin for use as No observations on principle, Granted Afonwen, CH7 5UD Arts and Craft Room suggest colour of materials 23/05/17 03/2017/0329 44 Berwyn Street, Construction of a new vehicular Object – impact on historic Refused

Page 1 of 6

Code No. (1) Site Address Brief Description of Summary of AONB Comments LPA Response to Development Decision AONB Comments (2) Llangollen, LL20 8NB access character of area 06/06/17 27/2017/0308 Bryn Rhedyn Llandynan, Erection of garden room/study Serious concerns over scale, Granted Llangollen, LL20 7YU above existing garage suggest design changes 27/06/17 03/2017/0095 Land adj to 4 Craig Y Erection of 2 no. semi-detached No objection, suggest design Don, Llangollen, LL20 dwellings and associated works changes 8LD 15/2017/0121 Outbuilding at Cyfnant Extension, alterations and No objection, suggest design Granted Ganol Llanarmon-Yn-Ial conversion of barn into 2 changes and removal of PD rights 15/06/17 CH7 4QD dwellings 056751 Pen Uchaf Barn, , Change of use of barn to a single No objection in principle but Withdrawn CH7 5BH dwelling design unacceptable. 17/05/17 16/2017/0331 Land at Bryn Glas, Erection of detached dwelling and No objection subject to retention Granted Llanbedr Dyffryn associated works of trees, hedges and stone walls. 25/05/17 LL15 1UP 03/2017/0084 The Pines, Abbey Road, Conversion and extension of No objection Granted N/A Llangollen, LL20 8SW existing garage to holiday 14/07/17 accommodation 03/2017/0329 44 Berwyn Street, Construction of a new vehicular Serious concerns, but defer to Refused Llangollen, LL20 8NB access (amended plans) Conservation advice 06/06/17 27/2017/0244 Outbuilding at Dinbren Conversion of barn to dwelling No objection subject to no impact Granted Isa, Llangollen, LL20 8ED (revised scheme to ref no on existing footpath, design 12/05/17 27/2004/1196) changes and removal of PD rights P/2017/0255 Cefn y Maes Installation of one wind turbine Concerns over impact of turbine, (Powys) Rhydycroesau (height 101m) and ground suggest reduced height. Oswestry mounted solar array. SY10 7JB 21/2017/0045 4 Bryn Artro Avenue, Erection of replacement dwelling No objection in principle, retain Granted Llanferres, existing hedge 14/06/17 CH7 5SG 21/2017/0178 Windyridge, Loggerheads, Erection of a replacement dwelling No objection subject to Granted CH7 5SB and associated access landscaping and stone 23/06/17 boundary/retaining walls. 05/2017/0449 Hendre Forfydd Bach, Extension to existing agricultural No objection Granted N/A Carrog building for housing sheep 27/06/17 LL21 9LD 03/2017/0347 25 Castle Street Change of use from Class A1 to No observations Granted N/A Llangollen, LL20 8NY class A3 07/07/17 056890 Transmitting Station, Prior notification of proposed No objection Granted N/A , Afonwen, installation of back-up power 12/06/17 CH7 5UU generator 10/2017/0330 Land at Brooklyn Development of land by 6 No objection in principle but Bryneglwys dwellings (outline application with serious concerns about loss of LL21 9LG access) hedge and trees 05/2017/0239 Land adjacent to Tyn Y Erection of a food manufacturing No objection in principle; welcome Granted Llidiart Industrial Estate, plant, warehousing and office reduction in height but suggest 14/06/17 Corwen, facilities and associated works resiting. LL21 9RJ (Amended plans). 15/2017/0476 1 Maes Ial, Llanarmon Yn Erection of extension and No objection Granted N/A Ial CH7 4PZ alterations to dwelling 27/06/17 05/2017/0457 Corwen Hydro, Nant y Change cladding of Turbine House No objection, recommend front Granted Pigyn, Corwen approved under Code No. elevation clad in stone 15/06/17 05/2014/0836 05/2017/0387 Cae Einion Corwen, Change of use to camping site No objection, suggest additional Granted Ll21 9BY including 6 bell tents, facilities landscaping, control of colour and 29/06/17 building, parking and access track reinstatement 05/2017/0423 Fron Newydd Carrog, Erection of an agricultural No objection, suggest reduced Granted LL21 9LA building for sheep height, materials and landscaping 24/07/17 05/2017/0466 Corwen Health Centre, Erection of extensions and internal Welcome investment, no objection, Granted LL21 0DN alterations suggest stone boundary wall 14/07/17 03/2017/0511 Riverwood Llangollen, Installation of 2 no. dormer No objection Granted N/A LL20 8LA windows 12/10/17 42/2017/0514 Red Roofs, Dyserth, LL18 Erection of extension to dwelling No objection Granted N/A 6BY 11/07/17 15/2017/0534 Bod Alun, Llanarmon Yn Erection of extensions and No objection Granted N/A Ial , CH7 4QE alterations to dwelling 17/07/17 18/2017/0430 Coed Coppi Fancer, Alterations to dwelling and No objection, suggest natural slate Granted Llandyrnog balcony and construction of roof 07/07/17 LL16 4LY dormer to side of dwelling 47/2017/0346 Panorama, Rhuallt Ll17 Siting of two holiday pods No objection, suggest site Granted

Page 2 of 6

Code No. (1) Site Address Brief Description of Summary of AONB Comments LPA Response to Development Decision AONB Comments (2) 0TG restoration and lighting conditions 05/07/17 057051 Grove Villa, , CH8 Listed Building Application for No objection subject to Refused N/A 9NE alterations to garden wall Conservation Officer views. 17/07/17 057052 Grove Villa, Llanasa, CH8 Alterations to garden wall to No objection subject to Refused N/A 9NE provide parking area Conservation Officer views. 17/07/17 057020 NTL Transmitting Station, Telecommunications upgrade No objection Granted N/A Moel Y Parc, CH7 5UU installation and associated works 17/07/17 05/2017/0501 Former HSBC Bank Installation of external access No objection but suggest design Granted Corwen, LL21 0AH ramp (Listed building application) changes 26/07/17 03/2017/0574 44 Pengwern Llangollen, Erection of extension to dwelling No objection Granted N/A LL20 8AT 07/08/17 03/2017/0632 Former Natwest External alterations including new No objection subject to details of Granted 38 Castle Street shop front signage 07/08/17 Llangollen, LL20 8NH 03/2017/0609 Gifts from Castle Erection of extension and No objection subject to design, Granted Street Llangollen, LL20 alterations to shop and external materials and lighting details 22/09/17 8PE fire escape 03/2017/0452 Pen Y Bryn Barn Change of use of holiday No objection, suggest removal of Llangollen, accommodation dwelling PD rights. LL20 7PS 05/2017/0395 Station Camp Site, Lawful development certificate for Serious concerns raised Carrog, use of land for touring caravans Ll21 9BD and tents 15/2017/0577 Pen Y Maes Llanarmon Erection of extension to dwelling No observations Granted N/A Yn Ial CH7 4QF 02/08/17 15/2017/0529 Pen Y Bryn Eryrys Mold, Erection of extensions to dwelling No objection Granted N/A CH7 4DA 27/07/17 15/2017/0573 Ty Minffordd, Eryrys Erection of garage with first floor Suggest reduction in scale and Granted CH7 4DD accommodation alternative materials 13/09/17 057050 Land opposite Fair Haven, Replace existing 10m high No objection subject to colour of Granted , CH7 5LQ monopole for a 12.0m high mast mast and equipment 27/07/17 and associated development 057081 Braeside, , Alterations to roof, demolition of No objection, suggest slate roof Granted CH7 5EN buildings and other alterations 31/07/17 057168 Tan Y Fron, Pantymwyn, Conversion of attic space and No objection Granted N/A CH7 5EN erection of rear extension 22/08/17 057175 Belmont, Demolition of existing No observations Granted N/A Pantymwyn, conservatory and extension to rear 22/08/17 CH7 5EN of dwelling 057096 Plas Uchaf, First floor extension to existing No objection, suggest landscaping Granted Cilcain, dwelling and measures to minimise light 15/08/17 CH7 5NE spillage 057125 Pen Uchaf Farm, Caerwys, Conversion and extension of No objection subject to design Granted CH7 5BH existing stone barn to create a changes and landscaping 14/08/17 single dwelling 15/2017/0287 Outbuildings at Plas Farm Conversion of outbuilding to form No objection subject to design Llanarmon Yn Ial CH7 1 no. dwelling and treatment plant changes and landscaping 4QJ 21/2017/0427 6 Rectory Lane Llanferres Single storey rear extension and No objection, suggest design Granted CH7 5SR dormer windows changes 30/08/17 09/2017/0619 Ysgubor Ystlum Bodfari Erection of extensions and No objection, subject to further Granted LL16 4DE alterations to dwelling details of solar PV 30/08/17 17/2017/0284 Crown Hotel Llandegla, Erection of extension to create a Concerns over design Refused LL11 3AD garden room 05/09/17 15/2017/0711 Graig Goch Isa Mynydd Erection of a detached garage No objection subject to cladding Granted Du finish and no impact on trees 30/08/17 CH7 4BR 22/2017/0634 Glyst, Llangynhafal LL15 Demolition of garage and erection No objection Granted N/A 1RT of double garage 13/09/17 47/2017/0689 Ysgubor Tremeirchion Erection of a car port/store No objection Granted N/A LL17 0UP building 18/09/17 057243 Trelan Bungalow, Cilcain, Erection of extension to bungalow No objection Granted N/A CH7 5NX 01/09/17 057207 Field Cottage Gwaenysgor Demolition of existing dwelling Object Ll18 6EW and erection of 2 dwellings and 1 apartment 057226 Field Cottage Gwaenysgor Installation of a single wind Serious concerns; further Ll18 6EW turbine of 17.8m to blade tip and information required associated works

Page 3 of 6

Code No. (1) Site Address Brief Description of Summary of AONB Comments LPA Response to Development Decision AONB Comments (2) 057189 Holmescales, Pantymwyn, Erection of extensions, re- No observations, suggest natural Granted CH7 5NJ modelling of existing house and slate and natural timber finishes 25/08/17 garage conversion 057271 Trefechan Barn, Afonwen, Erection of extension to side and No objection, suggest control of Granted CH7 5UP front of dwellng external lighting 01/09/17 056631 Plas Yn Llan, Cilcain, Listed Building application to Support subject to views of Granted N/A Mold, CH7 5PB convert outbuilding to holiday Conservation Officer 12/10/17 units 10/2017/0747 Bryn Y Ffynnon Erection of extension to dwelling No objection subject to slate roof Refused Bryneglwys and protection of dark skies 20/09/17 LL21 9LN 053325 land adj Siglen Uchaf Outline application for the No objection in principle subject Gwernymynydd, CH7 5LG erection of 10 No. dwellings to element of affordable homes (Amended plans) 27/2017/0657 3 Fron Deg Llandynan, Erection of extensions and No objection subject to finish of Refused LL20 7YU alterations to dwelling natural stone facing 14/08/17 21/2017/0481 Mill Cottage Loggerheads Excavations to form patio area and Concerns over retrospection; Refused CH7 5SB erection of fencing (retrospective) object 16/10/17 21/2017/0713 Land at Bryn Gerllig Deposit of excavated material on Concerns over retrospection; no Maeshafn agricultural land (retrospective) observations subject to reseeding CH7 5LU 10/2017/0627 Land at Ty Isaf Erection of an agricultural workers No objection subject to proven Bryneglwys dwelling (outline application) agricultural need LL21 9LF 05/2017/0202 Land adj Maes Y Waen, Development of land by the No objection subject to retention Carrog erection of six dwellings (outline of rural character and affordable LL21 9AH application) (Amended plans) housing. 03/2017/0467 Llangollen Civic Amenity Change of use of land to form a Support Site public amenity space (pocket LL20 7UH park) and associated works 03/2017/0770 38 Bishops Walk Erection of extension to dwelling No objection Granted N/A Llangollen, and garage and erection of garden 22/09/17 LL20 8RZ shed 05/2017/0589 Foel Bach Change of use of land from Concerns over retrospection; no Corwen, agriculture to vehicle hire observations subject to additional LL21 9BY (Retrospective) landscaping 057226 Field Cottage Gwaenysgor Erection of barn or animal Concerns over retrospection and Ll18 6EW sanctuary, retrospective change in need; object levels P/2017/0645 Bwythyn Pen Y Gaer, Erection of detached double No objection subject to tree Granted Garth, garage protection, suggest local stone 13/09/17 LL20 7YN facing 21/2017/0713 Land at Bryn Gerllig Deposit of excavated material on Supplementary comments relating Maeshafn agricultural land (retrospective) to site restoration and compliance CH7 5LU 10/2017/0780 Glan Y Wern, Bryneglwys Erection of a replacement porch No objection, suggest minor Granted LL21 9LH design changes 28/09/17 05/2017/0578 Y Bwthyn Glyndyfrdwy Demolition of lean-to porch/store No objection, suggest material Granted LL21 9HW and erection of extension to changes 04/10/17 dwelling 18/2017/0699 Outbuildings at Fron Conversion of outbuildings to No objection N/A Gelyn, Llandyrnog LL16 form 2 no. holiday units, and 4LY associated works 18/2017/0752 Coed Coppi Fancer Erection of a utility building for No objection Granted N/A Llandyrnog the storage of equipment 22/09/17 LL16 4LY 20/2017/0769 Cae Ffolt Llanfair Dyffryn Change of use to holiday No objection subject to holiday Granted Clwyd LL15 2UW accommodation and extension to use only 04/10/17 rear 16/2017/0824 The Gate House Llanbedr Erection of hipped roof over No objection subject to views of Granted N/A D C, existing flat roof area Conservation Officer 12/10/17 LL15 1UP 03/2017/0829 Glas Aber, Llangollen, Erection of extension to dwelling No objection Granted N/A LL20 8AA 16/10/17 03/2017/0733 Land adjoining Tregwern, Erection of dwelling, garage and No objection subject to Refused Llangollen vehicular access Conservation Officer views, stone 09/10/17 walls and tree retention 057416 2 Gadlys Court, Llanasa, Erection of single storey extension No objection Granted N/A CH8 9LY 11/10/17

Page 4 of 6

Code No. (1) Site Address Brief Description of Summary of AONB Comments LPA Response to Development Decision AONB Comments (2) 17/2016/1029 Plough Hotel Llandegla Change of use of existing Inn to Support, suggest amended LL11 3AB Bed and Breakfast facility and boundary treatment and lighting access controls 053332 Land adj Siglen Uchaf, Erection of 1no. dwelling and No objection subject to no impact Gwernymynydd, CH7 5LG detached garage (Amended plans) on existing trees 15/2017/0767 Land adjoining Canol Y Installation of loose boxes for No objection, recommend reduced Granted Cae, Eryrys CH7 4BX horses within existing building and size, landscaping and use/lighting 22/09/17 new manege conditions 057497 Penallt, Cilcain Single storey extension to and No objection subject to N/A CH7 5NN entrance porch Conservation Officer views P/2017/0699 Kronospan, Chirk, LL15 Log Delivery/ Transfer Serious Concerns; impact on 5NT System/Building for Replacement AONB and WHS setting Wood Chipping/Flaking System and Demolition of Existing Facilities P/2017/0700 Kronospan, Chirk, LL15 Development of a raw board store Serious Concerns; impact on 5NT AONB and WHS setting 47/2017/0582 New Inn Cottage Demolition of cottage and Object; inappropriate design Tremeirchion outbuilding and erection of a LL17 0UG replacement dwelling 057475 The Barn, Fron House, Erection of detached double No objection; require details of Nannerch, CH7 5RW garage lighting 03/2017/0743 Land at Bryn Awel Change of use of land by the No objection; suggest design Granted Geraint Llangollen, LL20 siting of 3 no. shepherd huts for amendments and landscaping 13/10/17 8AA holiday use 47/2017/0839 Bryntirion Farm Rhuallt Erection of an agricultural No objection, subject to N/A LL17 0TG building for lambing agricultural need and landscaping 17/2017/0833 Land near Maes , Erection of a timber reception No objection, suggest Llandegla LL11 3AA building (retrospective) reinstatement condition 15/2017/0893 Parc Farm Holiday Park, Erection of a boundary wall with No objection to wall but object to Llanarmon Yn Ial CH7 inset signs and freestanding sign freestanding sign 4QW 03/2017/0725 Former HSBC, Bridge Change of use from a bank to an Support, subject to Conservation Street Llangollen, LL20 outdoor pursuit's HQ, café and Officer views. Suggest design 8PF bunk house changes

Total Number of Applications: 115

Policy and Strategic Consultation Responses: April 2017 – September 2017

WG Consultation - Draft Circular for the Planning of Gypsy, Traveller and Show People Sites

Kronospan Long Term Landscape Strategy (May 2017)

WG Consultation – Draft Integrated Sustainability Appraisal Scoping Report for the National Development Framework

Flintshire Draft SPG Note 8A – Great Crested Newt Mitigation Requirements

WG Consultation - Taking Forward Wales’ Sustainable Management of Natural Resources

Notes:

(1.) Denbighshire planning application code numbers are shown as 12/3456/7891, as 12345 and Wrexham as P/1234/5678. Details of applications can be viewed on the Planning Portal for the relevant authority. See links below:

http://planning.denbighshire.gov.uk/Planning/lg/GFPlanningWelcome.page

http://planning.wrexham.gov.uk/Planning/lg/plansearch.page?org.apache.shale.dialog.DIALOG_NAME=gfplannings earch&Param=lg.Planning

Page 5 of 6

http://www.flintshire.gov.uk/en/Resident/Planning/Databases/Planning-Applications.aspx

(2.) LPA response to AONB comments colour coded as follows: green for fully accepted, orange for part accepted and red for not accepted.

(3.) Local Planning Authority (LPA) position updated 18/10/17.

(4.) Copies of full AONB comments on specific applications available on request.

Page 6 of 6