With Circulation Falling

Setting the standard Island of Ireland Report December 2011 Island of Ireland Report - Dec 2011 This period

Last Period

Contents Last Year Dec 2003

Description Page Section

Average Circulation by Product 3 Section 1

Daily Average Unique Browsers by Product 6 Section 1

Paid Newspapers - Republic of Ireland 7 Section 2

Free Letterbox Newspapers - Republic of Ireland 8 Section 3

Regional Publications - Northern Ireland 9 Section 4

Consumer Magazines - Republic of Ireland 10 Section 5

Consumer Magazines - Northern Ireland 11 Section 5

Business Magazines - Dec 2011 - Republic of Ireland 12 Section 6

Business Magazines - Dec 2011 - Northern Ireland 12 Section 6

Business Magazines - Jun 2011 - Republic of Ireland 13 Section 7

Business Magazines - Jun 2011 - Northern Ireland 13 Section 7

ABC Bulk Distribution - Republic of Ireland 14 Section 8

ABC Bulk Distribution - Northern Ireland 14 Section 8

Online Properties - Republic of Ireland 15 Section 9

Online Properties - Northern Ireland 15 Section 9

Notes

1 The circulation figures may include copies sold or distributed in the Republic of Ireland/Northern Ireland, the rest of United Kingdom and other countries. Some products have chosen to report a geographic breakdown of their circulation. These are indicated by 'Geo'. The geographic breakdown is included as part of the certificate, available on the 2 website www.abc.org.uk 3 Business Magazines either report to ABC annually to December, or annually to June each year. This publication contains two separate reports, one for each reporting schedule.

4 Products appear in Section 1 (product listing) where they are registered with ABC.

5 Where a product is listed as Certificate Pending this advises that data has been received by ABC, but the certification process is not yet complete.

6 Where a product is listed as Not Reported this advises that data has not yet been received by ABC, from the publisher.

No part of this report may be reproduced, stored or introduced to a retrieval system, copied or transmitted, in any form or by any means

(electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise) without the prior permission of the copyright holder.

While every effort is taken to ensure that all information published is accurate, ABC cannot accept responsibility for mistakes or omissions.

Page 2 Island of Ireland Report.xls Average Circulation by Product

Media Owner Product Name Figure Audit Period Newspaper Paid - Republic of Ireland Anglo Celt Ltd The Anglo Celt 12,310 Jul-Dec 2011 Clare Champion Ltd Clare Champion 15,742 Jan-Dec 2011 Connacht Tribune Ltd Connacht Sentinel 4,872 Jul-Dec 2011 Connacht Tribune Ltd Connacht Tribune 20,702 Jul-Dec 2011 The Herald Printing & Publishing Ltd The Tuam Herald 8,482 Jul-Dec 2011 Independent Newspapers Ireland Dublin - Evening Herald 62,411 Jul-Dec 2011 Independent Newspapers Ireland Dublin - Irish Independent - Morning 131,161 Jul-Dec 2011 Independent Newspapers Ireland Sunday Independent 250,641 Jul-Dec 2011 Irish Examiner Publications (Cork) Ltd Cork - Evening Echo 18,632 Jul-Dec 2011 Irish Examiner Publications (Cork) Ltd Irish Examiner - Morning 42,083 Jul-Dec 2011 Irish Times Ltd Dublin - Irish Times - Morning 96,150 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Kilkenny People 11,536 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Leinster & Offaly Express 11,070 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Leinster Leader 6,497 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Leitrim Observer 6,893 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Limerick Leader (Weekend) 14,851 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Longford Leader 7,684 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland The Nationalist - Tipperary 9,382 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Press Ireland Tipperary Star 7,115 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Donegal Democrat (Thurs) 9,191 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Donegal Democrat (Tues) 6,618 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Donegal on Sunday 3,547 Jul-Dec 2011 Meath Chronicle Limited Meath Chronicle 10,862 Jul-Dec 2011 The Munster Express Ltd Munster Express 5,389 Jul-Dec 2011 Nationalist & Leinster Times Ltd The Nationalist 13,175 Jul-Dec 2011 Nenagh Guardian Ltd Nenagh Guardian 6,928 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Donegal News - Friday Edition 11,186 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Donegal News - Monday Edition 4,044 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Donegal News Group 15,230 Jul-Dec 2011 Post Publications Ltd Sunday Business Post 44,529 Jul-Dec 2011 River Media Newspapers Ltd Inish Times 4,873 Jul-Dec 2011 Roscommon Herald Ltd Roscommon Herald 8,671 Jul-Dec 2011 Sunday Newspapers Ltd Sunday World 251,455 Jul-Dec 2011 Tallaght Publishing Ltd The Echo 7,210 Jul-Dec 2011 Western People Limited Western People 14,166 Jan-Dec 2011 Westmeath Examiner Ltd Westmeath Examiner 5,799 Jul-Dec 2011

Newspaper Free Letterbox - Republic of Ireland Carnbeg Ltd Limerick Post 17,424 Jul-Dec 2011 Cork Independent Newspapers Ltd Cork Independent 25,018 Jul-Dec 2011 Cork News and Media Ltd The Cork News 37,995 Jul-Dec 2011 Galway Advertiser Ltd Galway Advertiser 28,956 Jul-Dec 2011 Galway Advertiser Ltd Kilkenny Advertiser 7,496 Jul-Dec 2011 Galway Advertiser Ltd Mullingar Advertiser 5,790 Jul-Dec 2011 Galway Independent Newspapers Ltd Galway Independent 24,882 Jul-Dec 2011 North Dublin Publications Ltd Northside People East 26,406 Jul-Dec 2011 North Dublin Publications Ltd Northside People West 22,538 Jul-Dec 2011 North Dublin Publications Ltd Southside People 29,160 Jul-Dec 2011

Section 01 Page 3 Island of Ireland Report.xls Average Circulation by Product

Media Owner Product Name Figure Audit Period Regional Publication - Northern Ireland Banbridge Chronicle Press Ltd Banbridge Chronicle 4,367 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Media Group Andersonstown News 10,755 Jan-Dec 2011 Belfast Media Group North Belfast News 4,199 Jan-Dec 2011 Belfast Media Group The Nuachtain Group of Newspapers 14,954 Jan-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Belfast Telegraph 53,771 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Community Telegraph East Belfast 33,533 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Community Telegraph Group 104,867 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Community Telegraph North Belfast 24,243 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Community Telegraph North Down & Ards 24,748 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Community Telegraph South Belfast 22,343 Jul-Dec 2011 Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Sunday Life 54,004 Jul-Dec 2011 D E Alexander & Sons Ltd County Down Spectator 8,741 Jan-Dec 2011 D E Alexander & Sons Ltd Newtownards Spectator 640 Jan-Dec 2011 Edward Hodgett Ltd Newry Reporter 11,495 Jul-Dec 2011 Irish News Ltd Irish News - Morning 41,932 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Ballymena Times 3,437 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Belfast News 29,150 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Coleraine Times 6,749 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Derry Journal (Fri) 16,721 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Derry Journal (Tue) 14,381 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Derry Journal Group 33,659 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Larne Times 8,274 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Lisburn Echo 13,825 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Londonderry Sentinel 4,056 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Lurgan Mail 6,921 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Mid Ulster Mail 7,987 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Morton Newspaper Paid Group 60,930 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Portadown Times 8,996 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Sunday Journal 2,557 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) The Leader 3,400 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Tyrone Times 3,407 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Ulster - News Letter 22,548 Jul-Dec 2011 Johnston Publishing (NI) Ulster Star 7,703 Jul-Dec 2011 Mourne Observer Ltd Mourne Observer 10,340 Jul-Dec 2011 Newtownards Chronicle Ltd Newtownards Chronicle & County Down Observer 8,483 Jan-Dec 2011 River Media Newspapers Ltd County Derry Post 4,757 Jul-Dec 2011 River Media Newspapers Ltd Derry News - Monday 6,035 Jul-Dec 2011 River Media Newspapers Ltd Derry News - Thursday 5,919 Jul-Dec 2011 River Media Newspapers Ltd Derry News Group 16,711 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Fermanagh Herald 12,810 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Strabane Chronicle 5,256 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd The North West of Ireland Printing & Publishing News Group 36,456 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Tyrone Herald 6,785 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Ulster Herald 11,605 Jul-Dec 2011 The North-West of Ireland Printing & Publishing Co Ltd Ulster Herald Group 23,646 Jul-Dec 2011 W Y Crichton & Company Ltd Down Recorder 9,699 Jul-Dec 2011 William Trimble Ltd Impartial Reporter 13,472 Jul-Dec 2011

Section 01 Page 4 Island of Ireland Report.xls Average Circulation by Product

Media Owner Product Name Figure Audit Period Consumer Magazine - Republic of Ireland 21st Century Media Ltd Social & Personal 19,460 Jan-Dec 2011 Agricultural Trust Irish Farmers Journal 72,046 Jul-Dec 2011 Agricultural Trust Irish Field 11,599 Jul-Dec 2011 All About Publishing Ltd Prudence 10,855 Jan-Dec 2011 Barndee Publishing Stellar 22,597 Jul-Dec 2011 Carnbeg Ltd Limerick Post 35,393 Jul-Dec 2011 Cork Independent Newspapers Ltd Cork Independent 25,130 Jul-Dec 2011 Dyflin Publications Ltd Confetti 5,563 Jan-Dec 2011 Dyflin Publications Ltd House and Home 14,552 Jan-Dec 2011 Gazette Group Newspapers Lucan Gazette 38,479 Jan-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited Food & Wine 7,470 Jan-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited Ireland of the Welcomes Not Reported Jan-Dec-2011 Harmonia Limited Irish Tatler 23,919 Jan-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited Irish Tatler Man 10,595 Jul-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited U Magazine 25,241 Jan-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited U Magazine Ultimate Girls Guide to Absolutely Everything 17,366 Jul-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited Woman's Way 22,488 Jan-Dec 2011 Harmonia Limited Womans Way Cookbook Not Reported Jan-Dec-2011 Image Publications Ltd Image 21,261 Jul-Dec 2011 Image Publications Ltd Image Interiors & Living 14,463 Jul-Dec 2011 Irish Garden Publishers The Irish Garden 9,363 Jul-Dec 2011 Irish Wedding Diary. ie Ltd Irish Wedding Diary 7,048 Jan-Dec 2011 Minjara Ltd Kiss 21,611 Jan-Dec 2011 Minjara Ltd VIP Magazine 20,202 Jan-Dec 2011 Nalac Ltd Business Plus 10,453 Jan-Dec 2011 National Lesbian & Gay Federation Ltd GCN (Gay Community News) 11,002 Jan-Dec 2011 Ni4Kids Ltd ireland4kids 26,245 Jan-Dec 2011 North Dublin Publications Ltd Northside People East 18,279 Jul-Dec 2011 North Dublin Publications Ltd Northside People West 9,006 Jul-Dec 2011 North Dublin Publications Ltd Southside People 13,509 Jul-Dec 2011 Osnovina Ltd Hot Press 17,688 Jan-Dec 2011 Penfield Enterprises Ltd The Phoenix 15,878 Jan-Dec 2011 Radio Telefís Éireann RTE Guide 74,381 Jan-Dec 2011 Radio Telefís Éireann RTE Guide Annual 15,929 01-Nov-2010-17-Dec 2011 RSVP Publishing Ltd RSVP Cert Pending Jan-Jun 2011 Trader Publishing Ltd Auto Trader - Republic of Ireland 9,171 Jan-Dec 2011 Valigan Ltd TV Now! 27,778 Jan-Dec 2011 Zahra Publishing Ltd Easy Food 26,363 Jan-Dec 2011 Zahra Publishing Ltd Easy Health and Living 9,193 Jan-Dec 2011 Zahra Publishing Ltd Easy Parenting 7,347 Jan-Dec 2011

Consumer Magazine - Northern Ireland Belfast Visitor and Convention Bureau Ltd About Belfast Cert Pending Jan-Dec 2011 Harrison Publications IN! Magazine 6,356 Jul-Dec 2011 Ireland's Homes Interiors and Living Magazine All Ireland Kitchen Guide 4,297 Jan-Dec 2011 Ireland's Homes Interiors and Living Magazine Ireland's Homes Interiors and Living Magazine 9,647 Jan-Dec 2011 Ni4Kids Ltd Ni4Kids 46,252 Jul-Dec 2011 Penton Publications Ltd Ireland's Wedding Journal Cert Pending Jan-Dec 2011 Trader Publishing Ltd Auto Trader - Northern Ireland 7,812 Jan-Dec 2011 Trader Publishing Ltd Auto Trader Ireland Group 16,983 Jan-Dec 2011 Ulster Journals Ltd Ulster Tatler 10,790 Jan-Dec 2011

Business Magazine - Republic of Ireland Autobiz Ltd Autobiz 5,197 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Chartered Accountants Ireland Accountancy Ireland 24,450 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Checkout Publications Limited Checkout Ireland 5,302 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Danstone Ltd Irish Medical News 7,488 Jan-Dec 2011 European Society of Cataract & Refractive Surgeons ESCRS Eurotimes 32,332 Jan-Dec 2011 GreenCross Publishing Medical Independent Cert Pending Jul-Dec 2011 Mediateam Ltd Shelflife 8,116 Jan-Dec 2011 Metropolis Business Media Irish Medical Times 6,931 Jan-Dec 2011 Tara Publishing Co Ltd Retail News 5,793 Jan-Dec 2011 Temple Media Ltd Construct Ireland 7,419 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Think Media Ltd Journal Of The Irish Dental Association Cert Pending Jan-Dec 2011

Business Magazine - Northern Ireland BMF Business Services agendaNi 5,986 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Buckley Publications Business Eye 7,103 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Farmweek Ltd Farmweek 10,020 Jan-Dec 2011 Greer Publications Hospitality Review NI 4,521 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Greer Publications Specify 3,839 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Greer Publications Ulster Business 6,610 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Greer Publications Ulster Grocer 4,843 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Penton Publications Ltd Ireland's Forecourt & Convenience Retailer 4,443 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Penton Publications Ltd Licensed & Catering News 5,416 Jul 2010-Jun 2011 Penton Publications Ltd Neighbourhood Retailer 4,639 Jul 2010-Jun 2011

ABC Bulk Distribution - Republic of Ireland FortuneGreen Ltd Metro Herald 60,151 Dec-2011

Section 01 Page 5 Island of Ireland Report.xls Daily Average Unique Browsers by Product

Media Owner Product Name Figure Audit Period Online - Republic of Ireland (Daft Media) Distilled Media Distilled Media 85,765 Mar-2010 DoneDeal.ie cars.donedeal.ie 88,444 Mar-2011 Independent News & Media Independent Digital 211,174 Nov-2010 Irish Times Ltd www.irishtimes.com 234,974 Nov-2010 Radio Telefís Éireann RTE 353,701 May-2011 Trader Media Group Ireland carzone.ie 45,490 Jan-2010 Webzone Ltd www.autotrader.ie 12,410 Jan-2010

Online - Northern Ireland Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Belfast Telegraph Online 58,908 Nov-2010 Flagship Media Group Ltd 4ni.co.uk 17,213 Oct-2010 Flagship Media Group Ltd 4rfv.co.uk 4,059 Oct-2010 Irish Football Association Irishfa 2,864 Sep-2010 Propertynews.com Ltd Propertynews.com 14,714 Mar-2010 Saon Group NIJobs.com 11,263 Jan-2012

Section 01 Page 6 Island of Ireland Report.xls Other countries 381 4,325 029 9,068 Northern Ireland 62 1,723 7,076

Geographical Circulation Republic of Ireland

Basic Cover Price

No. of Available Publishing Days / No. of Issues Included on the Island of Ireland Report.xls Certificate Is this title a Group of Supplementary Data certified titles, reporting together Is this title a series of Editions with changed advertising Sep Average Net Circulation Per Issue Aug Oct Nov Dec By Audit Month - Period ending Dec 2011 Jul

Sports Edition Sales

Special Edition Sales

Issue Specific Multiple Copy / Bulk Sales

Regular Multiple Copy / Page 7 Bulk Sales

Analysis of Circulation Sales outside of the RoI & UK

RoI & UK Lesser Rate Republic of Ireland Paid Newspapers Subscription Sales RoI & UK Full

Newstrade, Single Copy and Rate

% Change against Dec end 2010

Average Net Circulation Dec end 2010

% Change against Jun end 2011

Average Net Circulation Jun end 2011 Comparison of Dec 2011 data to historic 91.9% 100,951 -4.8% 102,543 -6.2% 84,453 3,362 642 5,751 1,942 - - 94,285 95,772 95,732 95,528 100,962 94,944 Series 156 / 149 `€1.90 to `€2.25 88,444 3, 87.2% 134,228 -2.3% 138,510 -5.3% 110,941 2,784 771 16,665 - - - 133,157 137,087 134,551 135,464 126,969 117,149 Series98.2% 7,601 1.1% 156 / 149 8,079 `€1.85 to `€2.25 -4.9% 122,3 7,552 - - 132 - - - 7,508 7,658 7,602 7,993 7,701 7,662 26 / 24 `€1.90 7,546 - 138 93.8% 61,936 0.8% 65,435 -4.6% 58,378 209 - 3,824 - - - 62,51598.8% 62,030 62,865 6,766 63,484 1.9% 62,344 7,487 60,374 Series -7.9% 6,813 130 / 122 - `€1.00 - 62,411 80 - - - - - 7,071 6,676 6,993 7,058 6,882 6,572 26 / 24 `€1.90 6,713 - 180 94.9% 255,806 -2.0% 254,311 -1.4% 236,326 897 800 12,618 - -98.8% 6,809 - 257,614 -4.6% 255,988 7,482 253,867 252,812 -13.2% 243,242 232,697 6,425 Series - 26 / - 24 `€2.60 to `€2.70 72 234,544 7, - - - 6,263 6,423 6,696 6,873 6,461 6,125 26 / 24 `€2.10 6,459 - 38 99.2%97.1% 43,390 47,849 -3.0% -6.9% 46,011 45,696 -8.5% -2.6% 41,082 43,141 677 109 - 16 324 1,263 ------43,406 43,408 43,633 42,416 42,171 44,448 41,566 46,094 41,308 46,339 40,528 44,480 156 / 26 151 / 24 `€1.90 to `€2.70 `€2.00 42,083 - 43,273 1,228 - 28 77.2% 7,026 2.6% 7,125 1.2% 5,572 - - 1,514 124 - - 6,148 6,203 7,126 7,810 8,293 7,710 Series 26 / 25 `€1.75 7,210 - - 99.3% 21,043 -1.6% 21,860 -5.3% 20,505 - 64 133 - - - 20,689 20,336 20,716 21,003 21,013 20,492 26 / 24 `€2.12 20,016 3 683 98.9% 5,138 -5.2% 5,241 -7.0% 4,822 - - 50 - - - 4,908 4,844 4,910 5,027 4,777 4,738 26 / 24 `€0.67 4,872 - - Actively Purchased % 98.5% - N/A 16,691 -5.7% 15,473 - 42 - 227 - - 15,726 15,847 16,026 15,723 15,559 15,296 52 / 49 `€2.00 15,377 - 365 100.0%100.0% 6,072100.0% 13,171 -11.2%100.0% 9,650 0.0% 6,286100.0% 6,968 -2.8% 14,661 -14.3% 8,640 -0.6% -10.1% 11,087 5,389 -15.4% 0.4% 13,173 7,364 9,382 8,663 -5.9% - - 0.1% 6,920 - 8,638 - 2 - 20 - - - 8 13 ------5,887 - 12,481 - 12,441 5,282 9,121 - 14,212 - 5,452 9,266 6,904 13,647 8,620 5,251 13,116 9,619 6,884 8,514 5,265 12,801 9,416 7,012 Series 8,787 5,358 9,555 6,910 9,015 9,214 6,843 8,658 26 6,871 / 24 8,316 `€2.15 26 / 25 `€2.00 26 / 13,078 24 `€1.90 26 / 24 26 / 24 `€2.00 - `€2.05 5,389 9,266 97 - 6,900 8,406 - - - 1 116 28 264 100.0% 11,142 -2.5% 12,171 -10.8% 10,861 - 1 - - - - 10,639 10,929 11,353 11,020 10,797 10,126 26 / 24 `€2.00 10,767 94 1 100.0%100.0% 20,011 3,548 -6.9% 21,301 0.0% -12.5% 3,702 18,506 -4.2% 126 3,547 ------18,491 18,558 - 18,909100.0% 18,930 3,836 18,716 15,147 3,666 18,138 -2.0% 3,673 16,535 3,426 -10.2% 3,428 14,851 3,115100.0% 156 - / 148100.0% `€1.50 7,175100.0% 8,622 -0.8% -100.0% -1.6% 7,898 5,770 - 8,883 18,632 26 - -9.9% / 0.5% 24 N/A -4.5% `€1.25 7,115 6,183 15,062 - 8,482 - -6.2% -5.9% - 14,155 5,798 - - - 3,544 - - - - - 3 14,622 - 11 1 14,757 - - 14,739 - - 14,843 - - 15,079 - - 15,179 ------6,989 8,470 - 6,998 - 14,055 26 8,333 / 7,482 24 5,752 14,730 `€2.10 8,503 7,268 5,895 13,841 8,613 6,993 13,778 5,777 8,599 13,541 6,790 5,980 14,656 13,563 8,370 5,742 5,606 - 195 26 / 24 52 26 / / `€1.90 50 25 `€2.15 `€1.80 26 / 24 `€2.00 6,997 14,141 8,307 - 5,767 - - 118 31 25 175 1 100.0%100.0% 4,872100.0% 11,594 0.0% 11,339 -0.5% 5,269 -2.4% 12,983 12,493 -11.1% -7.5% -11.4% 11,536 4,873 11,070 ------11,274 4,900 10,934 11,152 4,985 10,939 12,549 11,303 11,772 4,922 11,371 11,221 4,843 11,097 10,811 4,806 10,597 Series 4,738 26 / 24 26 / 24 `€2.10 `€1.90 26 / 24 `€1.50 11,005 11,363 - 4,806 - 67 65 173 - 100.0%100.0% 9,451100.0% 6,553 -2.8%100.0% 11,288 10,385 1.0%100.0% 3,880 -0.9% -11.5% 15,168 7,650 11,436 4.2% 9,191 -13.5% 0.4% -2.2% 4,132 15,568 6,561 11,140 -2.1% - -2.2% 57 4,044 38 15,184 - 38 - 8 - - 8 ------9,613 11,538 6,903 9,749 - 11,313 - 6,828 9,228 15,958 11,221 4,420 6,873 15,748 11,190 8,726 4,435 15,534 6,872 11,088 8,879 15,185 10,758 4,313 6,212 8,858 14,838 3,995 5,737 13,972 3,750 3,214 Group 26 / Var 25 26 / / Var 24 `€1.50 26 `€1.45 / 24 `€1.45 26 / 24 11,147 `€1.00 8,535 15,190 6,479 - 242 134 - 4,043 414 39 5 40 - 1 100.0% 246,875100.0% 1.9% 12,133 251,334 1.5% 0.0% 250,667 12,885 -4.5% - 12,300 788 - - 10 ------263,845 264,864 252,173 - 249,162 241,125 11,941 232,692 12,652 Series 12,501 12,376 12,244 26 12,028 / 24 `€2.35 177,575 61,994 26 / 24 `€2.00 11,886 11,941 359 10 9,382 6,928 8,671 5,389 3,547 7,684 7,115 8,482 5,799 6,893 6,497 4,873 9,191 6,618 4,044 7,210 4,872 96,150 13,175 10,862 18,632 62,411 14,851 14,166 42,083 44,529 11,536 11,070 11,186 15,230 20,702 Average Net Circulation 12,310 15,742 131,161 250,641 Dec end 2011 251,455 Section 2 Dublin - Irish Times Morning The Nationalist The Nationalist - Tipperary Nenagh Guardian Roscommon Herald Meath Chronicle Munster Express Cork - Evening Echo Product Name Tipperary Star Donegal on Sunday Dublin - Evening Herald Dublin - Irish Independent Morning Limerick Leader (Weekend) Longford Leader The Tuam Herald Western People Westmeath Examiner Leitrim Observer Irish Examiner - Morning Sunday Business Post Sunday Independent Kilkenny People Leinster & Offaly Express Leinster Leader Inish Times Donegal Democrat (Thurs) Donegal Democrat (Tues) Donegal News - Friday Edition Donegal News - Monday Edition Donegal News Group The Echo Connacht Tribune Sunday World Clare Champion Connacht Sentinel The Anglo Celt Publishing Frequency Daily Titles Non-Daily Titles Republic of Ireland Free Letterbox Average Net Circulation Dec Dec Circulation Net Average Average Net Circulation Per Issue Comparison of Dec 2011 data to historic data Supplementary Data Geographical Circulation Publishing Frequency Publishing By Audit Month - Audit Period ending Dec 2011 Publishing Days / No. of No. / Days Publishing A A % Change against Dec Dec against Change % % Change against Jun Jun against Change % Issues Included on the onthe Included Issues Editions with changed changed with Editions Is this title a series of verage Net Circulation Net verage Circulation Net verage Average Pagination Average Editoral % Content % Editoral Republic of Ireland of Republic end 2011 end Northern Ireland Northern No. of Available Available of No. Other countries Other Dec end2010 Dec Jun end2011 Jun advertisin Certificate Product Name end 2011 end 2010 Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec g

Non-Daily Titles Cork Independent 25,018 25,404 -1.5% 27,754 -9.9% 25,404 25,404 25,404 25,404 24,825 23,086 26 / 24 21% - 50% 85 25,018 - - The Cork News 37,995 37,785 0.6% 37,995 0.0% 37,991 37,994 37,998 37,998 37,993 37,998 26 / 25 51% - 100% 96 37,995 - - Galway Advertiser 28,956 29,073 -0.4% 29,093 -0.5% 29,058 28,974 28,853 28,909 28,973 28,990 26 / 26 21% - 50% 118 28,956 - - Galway Independent 24,882 24,843 0.2% 25,009 -0.5% 24,882 24,883 24,882 24,882 24,881 24,882 26 / 24 21% - 50% 85 24,882 - - Kilkenny Advertiser 7,496 7,537 -0.5% 8,058 -7.0% 7,488 7,500 7,500 7,500 7,500 7,488 26 / 25 21% - 50% 32 7,496 - - Limerick Post 17,424 17,406 0.1% 17,369 0.3% 17,424 17,424 17,424 17,424 17,424 17,424 26 / 25 21% - 50% 107 17,424 - - Mullingar Advertiser 5,790 5,907 -2.0% 5,921 -2.2% 5,882 5,786 5,767 5,786 5,740 5,786 26 / 25 21% - 50% 43 5,790 - - Northside People East 26,406 - N/A - N/A 26,406 26,406 26,406 26,406 26,406 26,406 26 / 24 21% - 50% 54 26,406 - - Northside People West 22,538 - N/A - N/A 22,538 22,538 22,538 22,538 22,538 22,538 26 / 24 21% - 50% 28 22,538 - - Southside People 29,160 - N/A - N/A 29,160 29,160 29,160 29,160 29,160 29,160 26 / 24 21% - 50% 37 29,160 - -

Section 3 Page 8 Island of Ireland Report.xls Regional Publications - Northern Ireland

Average Net Circulation Per Issue Analysis of Circulation Comparison of Dec 2011 data to historic data By Audit Month - Audit Period ending Dec 2011 Publishing Days / No. of No. / Days Publishing A A Newstrade, Single Cop Single Newstrade, Free Letterbox Delivery Letterbox Free Regular Multiple Copy / Copy Multiple Regular Dec against Change % Circulation Dec 2011 Dec Circulation onthe Included Issues % Change against Jun Jun against Change % and Subscription Sales and Subscription Free) with percentage with Free) Issue Specific Multiple Primary Type (Paid or or (Paid Type Primary Editions with changed changed with Editions Is this title a series of verage Net Circulation Net verage Circulation Net verage Special Edition Sales Sports Edition Sales Edition Sports Free Pickup Copies Pickup Free Copy /Bulk Sales Delivered Copies Delivered Free Requested Requested Free No. of Available Available of No. Average Net Net Average Cover Price advertising Certificate Bulk Sales Dec 2010 Dec Title 2011 Jun 2011 2010 Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec y

Northern Ireland Daily Titles 56,499 54,578 53,467 54,529 51,883 51,880 Belfast Telegraph 53,771 42,761 2,664 - - - 8,346 - - Series 79.5% Paid 156 / 146 £0.70 59,319 -9.4% 58,491 -8.1% 42,786 42,813 41,870 41,649 41,715 40,932 Irish News - Morning 41,932 41,868 - 64 - - - - - 99.8% Paid 156 / 152 £0.70 43,647 -3.9% 44,222 -5.2% 2,622 2,710 2,580 2,594 2,450 2,324 Sunday Journal 2,557 2,557 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £0.90 2,568 -0.4% 2,598 -1.6% 55,233 56,207 56,302 53,944 51,199 49,419 Sunday Life 54,004 53,036 968 ------98.2% Paid 26 / 24 £1.40 55,067 -1.9% 54,435 -0.8% 23,381 22,721 22,670 22,132 22,000 22,399 Ulster - News Letter 22,548 22,207 341 ------98.4% Paid 156 / 149 £0.72 to £0.82 23,492 -4.0% 23,669 -4.7% Non-Daily Titles 10,150 10,605 10,616 10,851 10,467 10,049 Andersonstown News 10,755 10,755 ------100.0% Paid 52 / 51 £1.00 - N/A 12,090 -11.0% 3,238 3,153 3,670 3,478 3,552 3,484 Ballymena Times 3,437 3,437 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 3,280 4.8% 3,664 -6.2% 4,258 4,277 4,381 4,386 4,497 4,411 Banbridge Chronicle 4,367 4,367 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.00 4,354 0.3% 4,857 -10.1% 29,751 28,981 29,406 29,075 28,591 29,181 Belfast News 29,150 ------29,150 - 100.0% Free 26 / 24 42,673 -31.7% 48,160 -39.5% 6,719 6,926 7,057 6,621 6,584 6,423 Coleraine Times 6,749 6,749 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 23 £1.05 6,968 -3.1% 7,133 -5.4% 33,567 33,171 33,780 33,465 33,883 33,277 Community Telegraph East Belfast 33,533 ------33,533 - 100.0% Free 26 / 24 32,841 2.1% 33,420 0.3% 104,362 104,660 105,411 104,474 105,001 105,036 Community Telegraph Group 104,867 ------104,867 - 100.0% Free Var / Var 102,569 2.2% 102,178 2.6% 23,981 23,937 24,459 24,490 24,206 24,266 Community Telegraph North Belfast 24,243 ------24,243 - 100.0% Free 26 / 24 24,012 1.0% 23,357 3.8% 24,343 24,876 24,812 24,553 24,824 24,967 Community Telegraph North Down & Ards 24,748 ------24,748 - 100.0% Free 26 / 24 23,903 3.5% 23,536 5.1% 22,471 22,676 22,360 21,966 22,088 22,526 Community Telegraph South Belfast 22,343 ------22,343 - 100.0% Free 26 / 24 21,813 2.4% 21,865 2.2% 4,527 4,845 4,891 4,864 4,728 4,619 County Derry Post 4,757 4,757 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.00 4,502 5.7% 4,810 -1.1% 9,435 8,032 8,735 9,358 8,457 8,812 County Down Spectator 8,741 8,741 ------100.0% Paid 52 / 49 £0.80 - N/A 8,967 -2.5% 16,458 16,720 17,176 16,672 16,834 16,230 Derry Journal (Fri) 16,721 16,721 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 16,997 -1.6% 18,182 -8.0% 13,925 14,348 14,676 14,582 14,732 13,807 Derry Journal (Tue) 14,381 14,381 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 14,987 -4.0% 15,848 -9.3% 33,005 33,778 34,432 33,848 34,016 32,361 Derry Journal Group 33,659 33,659 ------100.0% Paid Var / Var 54,104 -37.8% 58,365 -42.3% 5,929 5,830 6,150 6,212 6,133 5,892 Derry News - Monday 6,035 6,035 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.00 5,964 1.2% 5,936 1.7% 5,824 5,839 6,030 5,952 6,004 5,809 Derry News - Thursday 5,919 5,919 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.00 5,770 2.6% 5,858 1.0% 16,280 16,514 17,071 17,028 16,865 16,320 Derry News Group 16,711 16,711 ------100.0% Paid Var / Var 16,236 2.9% 16,604 0.6% 9,400 9,812 9,847 9,677 9,886 9,671 Down Recorder 9,699 9,699 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 25 £1.00 9,780 -0.8% 10,200 -4.9% 12,379 12,862 12,956 13,068 12,911 12,591 Fermanagh Herald 12,810 12,810 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.10 12,901 -0.7% 13,376 -4.2% 13,303 13,141 13,337 13,785 13,921 13,351 Impartial Reporter 13,472 13,472 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.00 13,464 0.1% 13,093 2.9% 8,149 8,144 8,716 8,110 8,299 8,021 Larne Times 8,274 8,274 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 23 £1.05 8,570 -3.5% 8,946 -7.5% 3,263 3,291 3,561 3,386 3,526 3,301 The Leader 3,400 3,400 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 3,703 -8.2% 3,509 -3.1% 13,667 13,906 13,697 13,794 13,816 14,066 Lisburn Echo 13,825 ------13,825 - 100.0% Free 26 / 24 14,330 -3.5% 17,889 -22.7% 4,010 4,064 4,101 3,963 3,981 4,258 Londonderry Sentinel 4,056 4,056 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 4,134 -1.9% 4,451 -8.9% 7,059 6,971 7,018 6,799 7,076 6,513 Lurgan Mail 6,921 6,921 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 23 £1.05 7,045 -1.8% 7,418 -6.7% 7,876 7,945 8,282 8,049 8,076 7,595 Mid Ulster Mail 7,987 7,987 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 8,360 -4.5% 8,652 -7.7% 59,855 60,126 63,379 60,512 61,465 59,298 Morton Newspaper Paid Group 60,930 60,930 ------100.0% Paid Var / Var 62,487 -2.5% 65,194 -6.5% 10,230 10,486 10,534 10,384 10,306 10,054 Mourne Observer 10,340 10,340 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 25 £1.00 10,360 -0.2% 10,839 -4.6% 10,890 11,518 11,681 11,972 11,671 11,095 Newry Reporter 11,495 11,495 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.00 11,877 -3.2% 12,414 -7.4% 8,109 8,555 8,602 8,803 8,521 8,653 Newtownards Chronicle & County Down Observer 8,483 8,483 ------100.0% Paid 52 / 48 £0.80 - N/A 8,872 -4.4% 540 574 647 921 567 - Newtownards Spectator 640 640 ------100.0% Paid 21 / 19 £0.80 - N/A 698 -8.3% 3,897 4,196 4,290 4,408 4,375 4,066 North Belfast News 4,199 4,199 ------100.0% Paid 52 / 50 £1.00 - N/A 4,438 -5.4% 35,305 36,528 37,123 37,477 36,618 35,213 The North West of Ireland Printing & Publishing News Group 36,456 36,456 ------100.0% Paid Var / Var 52,180 -30.1% 53,363 -31.7% 14,047 14,801 14,906 15,259 14,842 14,115 The Nuachtain Group of Newspapers 14,954 14,954 ------100.0% Paid Var / Var - N/A 23,289 -35.8% 8,930 8,932 9,214 8,978 9,066 8,734 Portadown Times 8,996 8,996 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 9,210 -2.3% 9,578 -6.1% 5,261 5,358 5,222 5,316 5,208 5,158 Strabane Chronicle 5,256 5,256 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £0.90 5,327 -1.3% 5,466 -3.8% 6,417 6,864 7,142 7,020 6,825 6,212 Tyrone Herald 6,785 6,785 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £0.80 6,733 0.8% 6,841 -0.8% 3,260 3,277 3,550 3,491 3,457 3,371 Tyrone Times 3,407 3,407 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 25 £1.05 3,443 -1.0% 3,660 -6.9% 11,248 11,444 11,803 12,073 11,674 11,252 Ulster Herald 11,605 11,605 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.10 12,051 -3.7% 12,112 -4.2% 22,926 23,666 24,167 24,409 23,707 22,622 Ulster Herald Group 23,646 23,646 ------100.0% Paid Var / Var 24,111 -1.9% 24,419 -3.2% 7,351 7,423 8,210 7,637 7,848 7,598 Ulster Star 7,703 7,703 ------100.0% Paid 26 / 24 £1.05 7,774 -0.9% 8,183 -5.9%

Section 4 Page 9 Island of Ireland Report.xls Consumer Magazines - Republic of Ireland Average Net Circulation Dec end Dec Circulation Net Average Average Net Circulation Jun end Jun Circulation Net Average Average Net Circulation Dec Circulation Net Average Period / Period % change +/- %change Period / Period Year / Year % change +/- %change Year / Year Is a Geographic Analysis Analysis aGeographic Is

Actively Purchased % Purchased Actively Breakdown of circulation for the current Audit Period No of Issues reported? reported? end 2011 end Basic Cover

2011 2010 During the Price at the Title Period / No of Newstrade Multiple Society / Non- end of the Single Copy Issue Controlled Monitored Months During and other Copy Regular Bulk Association / Controlled Period Subscription Specific Bulk Free Free the Period single copy Subscription Sales Organisation Free Sales Sales Circulation Distribution sales Sales Circulation Circulation

Auto Trader - Republic of Ireland 9,171 100.0% - N/A 17,401 -47.3% 9,171 ------50/12`€4.00 - Business Plus 10,453 19.9% - N/A 10,022 4.3% 1,465 617 670 6,647 40 - 163 - 851 11 / 12 `€2.30 - Confetti 5,563 64.4% - N/A 5,678 -2.0% 3,483 104 - 1,568 225 - - 183 - 4 / 12 `€5.80 - Cork Independent 25,130 0.0% 24,952 0.7% 22,328 12.5% ------25,130 26 / 6 N/A - Easy Food 26,363 99.8% - N/A 27,102 -2.7% 19,961 6,375 -----27-10/12`€2.90 - Easy Health and Living 9,193 64.1% - N/A 10,264 -10.4% 5,897 - - 2,000 - - - 1,296 - 6 / 12 `€2.90 - Easy Parenting 7,347 58.7% - N/A - N/A 4,170 143 - 3,000 - - - 34 - 4 / 12 `€2.90 - Food & Wine 7,470 88.0% - N/A 7,815 -4.4% 4,814 1,763 - 732 14 - 113 34 - 10 / 12 `€3.80 - GCN (Gay Community News) 11,002 0.7% - N/A 11,001 0.0% - 82 -----11410,806 12 / 12 `€0.00 - Hot Press 17,688 70.7% - N/A 17,725 -0.2% 10,533 1,986 - 2,231 2,938 ----24/12`€3.50 - House and Home 14,552 97.1% - N/A 15,385 -5.4% 11,216 2,928 - 117 - - - 291 - 6 / 12 `€3.85 - Image 21,261 67.0% 21,045 1.0% 19,005 11.9% 12,539 1,725 17 3,813 3,007 - - 160 - 6 / 6 `€3.95 - Image Interiors & Living 14,463 61.3% 12,717 13.7% 9,070 59.5% 7,111 1,755 - 2,009 3,527 - - 61 - 3 / 6 `€3.95 - Ireland of the Welcomes Not Reported ireland4kids 26,245 0.0% - N/A 28,285 -7.2% ------26,245 5 / 12 N/A - Irish Farmers Journal 72,046 95.3% 71,022 1.4% 70,405 2.3% 68,152 560 12 3,144 - - 178 - - 26 / 6 `€2.50 - Irish Field 11,599 99.3% 11,978 -3.2% 12,382 -6.3% 11,365 156 3 - 41 - 34 - - 27 / 6 `€3.10 - Irish Tatler 23,919 92.9% - N/A 23,536 1.6% 20,433 1,809 11 486 1,039 - 131 10 - 11 / 12 `€2.10 - Irish Tatler Man 10,595 89.7% 7,557 40.2% - N/A 9,481 33 - 1,050 - - 31 - - 1 / 6 `€2.99 - Irish Wedding Diary 7,048 72.4% - N/A 6,102 15.5% 5,105 - - 100 1,500 - - - 343 4 / 12 `€5.80 - Kiss 21,611 100.0% - N/A 22,469 -3.8% 20,351 1,260 ------11/12`€2.95 - Limerick Post 35,393 0.0% 34,340 3.1% 33,025 7.2% ------35,393 25 / 6 `€0.25 - Lucan Gazette 38,479 0.0% - N/A 41,653 -7.6% ------38,479 49 / 12 N/A - Northside People East 18,279 0.0% - N/A - N/A ------18,279 24 / 6 N/A - Northside People West 9,006 0.0% - N/A - N/A ------9,006 24 / 6 N/A - Prudence 10,855 96.3% - N/A 11,021 -1.5% 8,706 1,752 - 200 - - - 197 - 6 / 12 `€2.85 - RSVP Certificate Pending RTE Guide 74,381 92.4% - N/A 84,018 -11.5% 67,841 928 -----1,432 4,180 51 / 12 `€1.65 - Social & Personal 19,460 79.1% - N/A 19,056 2.1% 15,144 249 - 3,976 91 ----11/12`€3.65 - Southside People 13,509 0.0% - N/A - N/A ------13,509 24 / 6 N/A - Stellar 22,597 97.6% 22,007 2.7% 21,556 4.8% 20,493 1,579 - 525 -----6/6`€2.20 - The Irish Garden 9,363 95.3% 13,622 -31.3% 11,459 -18.3% 4,448 4,477 - 201 - - - 237 - 5 / 6 `€4.75 - The Phoenix 15,878 96.7% - N/A 16,601 -4.4% 11,693 3,665 - 520 -----25/12`€2.65 - TV Now! 27,778 98.6% - N/A 29,204 -4.9% 27,394 - - 384 -----51/12`€1.20 - U Magazine 25,241 99.1% - N/A 27,564 -8.4% 23,915 1,113 4 68 8 - 118 15 - 25 / 12 `€1.50 - U Magazine Ultimate Girls Guide to Absolutely Everything 17,366 100.0% 16,225 7.0% - N/A 17,366 ------1/6`€1.99 - VIP Magazine 20,202 97.7% - N/A 24,113 -16.2% 18,563 1,193 - - 446 ----15/12`€2.50 - Woman's Way 22,488 99.1% - N/A 22,197 1.3% 21,134 1,169 15 - - - 134 36 - 51 / 12 `€1.35 - Womans Way Cookbook Not Reported

Section 5 Page 10 Island of Ireland Report.xls Consumer Magazines - Northern Ireland Average Net Circulation Dec end Dec Circulation Net Average Average Net Circulation Jun end Jun Circulation Net Average Average Net Circulation Dec Circulation Net Average Period / Period % change +/- %change Period / Period Year / Year % change +/- %change Year / Year Is a Geographic Analysis Analysis aGeographic Is

Actively Purchased % Purchased Actively Breakdown of circulation for the current Audit Period No of Issues reported? reported? end 2011 end Basic Cover

About Belfast Certificate Pending All Ireland Kitchen Guide 4,297 100.0% - N/A 5,186 -17.1% 4,297 ------2/12£5.95 - Auto Trader - Northern Ireland 7,812 100.0% - N/A 14,018 -44.3% 7,812 ------50/12£2.80 - Auto Trader Ireland Group 16,983 100.0% - N/A 31,419 -45.9% 16,983 ------50/12Various - IN! Magazine 6,356 89.7% 6,053 5.0% 6,230 2.0% 5,515 191 ------6505/6£2.90 - Ireland's Homes Interiors and Living Magazine 9,647 98.0% - N/A 11,298 -14.6% 9,272 189 2 - 7 - 97 - 80 12 / 12 £3.50 - Ireland's Wedding Journal Certificate Pending Ni4Kids 46,252 0.0% 47,589 -2.8% 44,546 3.8% ------46,252 6 / 6 N/A - Ulster Tatler 10,790 44.1% - N/A 11,012 -2.0% 3,879 881 - 1,051 - - - 579 4,400 12 / 12 £2.95 -

Section 5 Page 11 Island of Ireland Report.xls Business Magazines - Dec 2011 - Republic of Ireland Average Net Circulation per Issue Issue per Circulation Net Average Average Newstrade Sales per Issue per Sales Newstrade Average Is a Geographic Analysis reported? reported? Analysis aGeographic Is Net Circulation for the Audit Issue Audit the for Circulation Net Analysis of the Audit Issue No. of issues during the Period the during issues of No. Multiple Copy Subscription Sale Paid and Controlled Circulation - Circulation andControlled Paid Newstrade and other Single Single andother Newstrade Controlled Free Circulation Non-Controlled Free Circulation CC - Age of Requests Single Copies Sold on Sold Copies Single / Association / Society Organisation - Total - Organisation Subscription - Total - Subscription Copy Sales - Total - Sales Copy Bulk Sales - Total Non - Requested by Job Job by Requested - Non Company Requested by by Requested Company Company Requested by by Requested Company Company Requested in in Requested Company Individually Requested Requested Individually Individually Requested Requested Individually Requested Individually Non - Requested by by Requested - Non 13 to 24 months % 24months 13 to % 36months 25 to 1 to 12 months % 12months 1 to - Total Title Function / Title by Telephone by Total by Internet Telephone in Writing Internet Writing Name Not by Total Total By Name Name s

ESCRS Eurotimes 10 32,332 - 33,435 - - - - 4,027 621 320 301 ------28,787 28,780 7 Geo Irish Medical News 48 7,488 - 7,559 - - 88 - - 7,471 - 395 - - - 1,288 5,788 - - - - - Irish Medical Times 49 6,931 - 6,704 - - 121 - - 6,033 5,089 944 ------550 534 16 - Journal Of The Irish Dental Association Certificate Pending Medical Independent Certificate Pending Retail News 10 5,793 - 5,800 - - - - - 5,800 ------1,814 3,986 - - - - Shelflife 11 8,116 - 7,640 - - 71 - 303 6,043 - 599 - - - - - 5,444 1,223 1,223 - Geo

Business Magazines - Dec 2011 - Northern Ireland Farmweek 51 10,020 9,509 9,927 9,417 - 75 ------435435- -

Section 6 Page 12 Island of Ireland Report.xls Business Magazines - Jun 2011 - Republic of Ireland Average Net Circulation per Issue Issue per Circulation Net Average Average Newstrade Sales Newstrade Issue Average per Is aGeographic Analysis Is reported? Net Circulation for the Audit Issue the CirculationNet for

No. of issues Period during of the No. Analysis of the Audit Issue Paid andControlled Circulation Newstrade and other Single andother Newstrade Multiple Copy Subscription Subscription Copy Multiple Controlled Free Circulation Non-Controlled Free Circulation CC - Age of Requests Single Copies Sold on Society / AssociationSociety / / Organisation - Total Organisation - Subscription - Total Subscription - Copy Sales Total - Bulk Sales - Total - Sales Bulk Company in Requested Individually Requested Individually Requested Individually Requested Company Requested Company Requested Sales - Total - Sales Non - Requested by Requested Non - Non - Requested by Requested Non - Job Title / Function Job Title / 13 to 24 months % 24months 13 to % 36months 25 to Title % 12months 1 to by Telephone by Telephone Total by Internet by Internet in Writing in Writing Name Not by Total Total By Name Name

Accountancy Ireland 6 24,450 - 23,054 - - 203 - 21,621 1,143 227 - - 916 ----8787- - Autobiz 10 5,197 - 5,175 ------5,175 5,175 - - Checkout Ireland 12 5,302 - 5,350 - - 267 43 - 5,040 - - - 3,008 - - 1,373 659 - - - Geo Construct Ireland 5 7,419 724 6,692 1,047 - 231 - 115 ------5,299 5,297 2 - Business Magazines - Jun 2011 - Northern Ireland agendaNi 9 5,986 98 7,058 58 - 210 256 - 5,369 630 - - - - - 4,739 - 1,165 1,165 - - Business Eye 9 7,103 146 7,517 92 - 434 - - 5,442 461 - - 6 - - 4,204 771 1,549 556 993 - Hospitality Review NI 10 4,521 - 4,495 - 11 - - - 1,916 1,151 44 87 69 51 1 510 3 2,568 878 1,690 - Ireland's Forecourt & Convenience Retailer 5 4,443 - 4,489 ------4,489 4,299 190 - Licensed & Catering News 9 5,416 - 5,365 ------5,365 2,863 2,502 - Neighbourhood Retailer 11 4,639 - 4,724 ------4,724 4,574 150 - Specify 6 3,839 - 4,008 - 14 - - - 1,197 872 26 135 33 1 130 - - 2,797 1,206 1,591 - Ulster Business 11 6,610 134 6,732 132 131 - - - 6,200 2,101 94 63 84 1 - 3,553 304 269 214 55 - Ulster Grocer 10 4,843 - 4,756 - 24 - - - 1,785 1,110 56 54 164 5 1 278 117 2,947 1,568 1,379 -

Section 7 Page 13 Island of Ireland Report.xls ABC Bulk Distribution - Republic of Ireland

Certified Distribution Figures for the Audit Period noted below Total Certified Distribution Total Certified Distribution

Title Pd/Pd % +/- Yr/Yr % +/- Jun end 2011 Dec end 2010 Total Certified Distribution Average Number of for the period stated below Number of Issues Distribution Points Per Issue (unless otherwise stated)

Metro Herald (Jul 2011) 55,440 20 101 - N/A -N/A Metro Herald (Aug 2011) 55,181 11 101 - N/A -N/A Metro Herald (Sep 2011) 62,753 25 90 - N/A -N/A Metro Herald (Oct 2011) 63,777 20 90 - N/A -N/A Metro Herald (Nov 2011) 62,548 19 91 - N/A -N/A Metro Herald (Dec 2011) 60,151 19 88 - N/A -N/A

ABC Bulk Distribution - Northern Ireland None

Section 8 Page 14 Island of Ireland Report.xls Online Properties - Republic of Ireland

Site URL Daily Average Monthly Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Site Name To view the full list of URL's for each of the sites listed Period Unique Browsers Unique Browsers Page Impressions Page Impressions Visits Visits please check their indivudual certificates on the ABC website

www.autotrader.ie www.autotrader.ie 12,410 248,860 422,583 13,100,058 - - 01-Jan-2010 to 31-Jan-2010 ***Boards www.boards.ie 96,961 2,139,759 1,149,882 35,646,329 - - 01-Mar-2010 to 31-Mar-2010 *Build.ie www.build.ie 3,916 103,537 15,008 313,914 - - 01-Oct-2011 to 31-Oct-2011 cars.donedeal.ie http://cars.donedeal.ie 88,444 1,839,768 1,944,078 60,266,414 - - 01-Mar-2011 to 31-Mar-2011 carzone.ie www.carzone.ie 45,490 719,085 3,248,295 100,697,138 - - 01-Jan-2010 to 31-Jan-2010 ***DAFT www.daft.ie 85,765 1,734,860 4,192,906 129,980,100 - - 01-Mar-2010 to 31-Mar-2010 Daft Media (Distilled Media) Daft Media 176,162 3,654,762 5,342,788 165,626,429 - - 01-Mar-2010 to 31-Mar-2010 Independent Digital Independent Digital 211,174 3,154,690 1,373,611 41,208,335 - - 01-Nov-2010 to 30-Nov-2010 ****Independent.ie www.independent.ie 173,232 2,475,348 1,086,556 32,596,670 - - 01-Nov-2010 to 30-Nov-2010 www.irishtimes.com www.irishtimes.com 234,974 3,892,929 1,207,767 36,233,017 - - 01-Nov-2010 to 30-Nov-2010 RTE www.rte.ie 353,701 4,519,738 2,625,887 81,402,512 - - 01-May-2011 to 31-May-2011

Online Properties - Northern Ireland 4ni.co.uk www.4ni.co.uk 17,213 440,871 45,259 1,403,022 - - 01-Oct-2011 to 31-Oct-2011 4rfv.co.uk www.4rfv.co.uk 4,059 110,619 9,014 279,429 - - 01-Oct-2011 to 31-Oct-2011 Belfast Telegraph Online www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk 58,908 1,275,408 462,800 13,883,988 - - 01-Nov-2010 to 30-Nov-2010 Irishfa www.irishfa.com 2,864 63,143 15,779 473,372 - - 01-Sep-2010 to 30-Sep-2010 **NIJobfinder.co.uk www.nijobfinder.co.uk 5,673 103,291 63,098 1,892,935 01-Nov-2010 to 30-Nov-2010 NIJobs.com www.nijobs.com 11,263 239,410 - - 13,048 404,487 01-Jan-2012 to 31-Jan-2012 Propertynews.com www.propertynews.com 14,714 274,680 715,756 22,188,430 - - 01-Mar-2010 to 31-Mar-2010

Notes * this is a breakout of a larger certified online property, Build, which is available on our website. ** this is a breakout of a larger certified online property, Belfast Telegraph Online, which is available on our website. *** this is a breakout of a larger certified online property, Daft Media, which is available on our website. **** this is a breakout of a larger certified online property, Independent Digital, which is available on our website.

Section 9 Page 15 Island of Ireland Report.xls www.abc.org.uk