AGENDA ITEM NO

COMMITTEE/SUB Planning Committee

DATE OF MEETING 26 th APRIL 2010

TITLE DELEGATION

PUBLICITY For Publication

CONTENTS Items approved by the Group Leader, Development Management under the following Delegation references:-

Building Regulations P150D and P160D, P570D P580D

Planning Applications P020D, P200D to P250D, P270D to P320D, P350D to P370D, P390D, P420D to P440D

Felling and Pruning of Trees P100D, P120D, P130D

Agricultural and Telecommunications P330D and P340D

RECOMMENDATIONS Not applicable

LIST OF BACKGROUND Relevant applications PAPERS

INDEX TO GROUP LEADER, DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT’S DELEGATED REPORT TO PLANNING COMMITTEE ON THE 26 TH APRIL 2010

Item 1 Building Regulations

Item 2 Planning Applications

Item 3 Application to Fell or Prune Trees

These are reported to Planning Committee for information only. Anyone requiring further information on any of the matters contained in this report should contact:-

Building Regulations Chris Robinson 345818

Planning Applications Paul Staniforth 345781

Applications to Fell or Prune Trees Steve Perry 345791 DECISIONS MADE UNDER THE BUILDING REGULATIONS

09/00378/DCC Alterations to existing kitchen Conditional supply premises to approval accommodate local authority offices/business unit. Works to comprise internal alterations including new ceilings, partitions, flooring and associated mechanical and electrical services 8 Hallsteads, Dove Holes, , Derbyshire County Council

10/00049/DEXF Extension to rear Conditional Middlecroft and 31 Middlecroft Road, approval Poolsbrook Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S43 3XN Pat McClune

10/00201/DEXF Two storey rear extension Conditional Brockwell 37 Malvern Road, approval Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 4DX Mr and Mrs D Guard

10/00279/DCC Pitched tile re roof and Conditional Holmebrook replacement rainwater goods approval William Rhodes Primary School, Hunloke Avenue, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 2NR Derbyshire County Council

10/00265/MULF Two storey rear extension Conditional Walton and internal alterations approval 67 Orchards Way, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 3DA Mr and Mrs D Towndrow

10/00490/OTHF Replacement of entrance Conditional Walton canopy to hospital day unit approval Walton Hospital, Whitecotes Lane, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 3HN Derbyshire County Primary Care Trust

10/00215/DCC Cellar conversion to form Conditional bedroom and shower room approval 5 Rock Bank, , Derbyshire, SK23 7LE Mr Marchington

10/00244/DEXF Two storey extension with Conditional Walton loft conversion 17 Hazel approval Drive, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 3EN Mr and Mrs Bonynge

10/00245/DEXF Single storey extension Conditional Holmebrook 18 Clifton Street, approval Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 1DQ Mrs Natma Ayub

10/00442/DEXF Single storey rear extension Conditional Loundsley Green 2 Skiddaw Close, approval Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 4RP C R Hardie

10/00446/MULF Single storey rear Conditional Hasland extension, extension to approval garage and internal alterations 8 Waltham Croft, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S41 0UZ Mr and Mrs S Ward

09/00858/DCC Relocation of the existing Decision advice reception and formation of notice new toilet facilities Newhall Community Junior School, Chesterfield Avenue, Newhall, , Derbyshire, DE11 0TR Derbyshire County Council

10/00461/PART Proposed landlord’s works Decision advice (Option A) to enable basement and notice ground floors of vacant listed building to be used as a shop for Aegon Management UK 25-29 Wheeler Gate, Nottingham, NG2 2NA Ward McHugh Associates

09/00194/DCC Refurbishment of the Unconditional Brockwell existing Creative Arts approval Centre, with small extensions to the entrance lobby and plant room and associated external works The Donut Creative Arts Studios, Springbank Road, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S40 1NL Derbyshire County Council

09/00146/OTHF New build single storey Unconditional Walton wards for elderly persons approval mental health with central therapy facilities Walton Hospital, Whitecotes Lane, Chesterfield, Derbyshire Strata Construction Limited

10/00273/DCC Installation of disabled Unconditional persons level access wet approval floor shower facility 15 Willows Close, , Derbyshire, DE55 7EQ Housing Limited

10/00238/DCC Re-roofing to flat roof area Unconditional including scheme of falls approval insulation Parkwood Centre, Alfreton Park, Alfreton, Derbyshire, DE55 7AL Derbyshire County Council

09/00842/DCC Renewal of existing flat roof Unconditional Dunston coverings to wood-wool approval deck Gilbert Heathcote Infant and Nursery School, Sheffiield Road, Whittington Moor, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S41 8NF Derbyshire County Council

09/00847/DCC Single storey side extension Unconditional to provide disabled persons approval bedroom and assisted washing facilities 60 Collingwood Road, , Derbyshire, NG10 1DR Mrs Dawson

10/00437/DCC Flat roof recover Unconditional Kilburn Junior School, The approval Flat, , Derbyshire, DE56 0LA Derbyshire County Council

10/00439/DCC Replacement aluminium Unconditional windows and doors approval Granville Community School, Burton Road, Woodville, Swadlincote, Derbyshire, DE11 7JR Derbyshire County Council

10/00484/DIS Ramp and larger door for Unconditional Holmebrook disabled access approval Ash Lodge Medical Centre, 73 Old Road, Chesterfield, Derbyshire Ability

10/00209/DCC Internal through floor lift and Unconditional Dunston level access shower approval 2 Keswick Drive, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S41 8HP Mr W Staton

10/00451/DCC Re roofing to flat roof area Unconditional Brimington South including scheme of falls approval insulation The Spinney, Woodlands, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, S43 1BE Derbyshire County Council

10/00040/DCC Installation of new double Unconditional doors approval Woodville Infant School, Woodville, Swadlincote, Derbyshire, DE11 7EA Derbyshire County Council

10/00030/PART Proposed house and Unconditional St Leonards garage at plot 4 for Mr and approval Mrs K Bailey Land adjacent to Farm Cottage, 148 Hady Lane, Chesterfield, Derbyshire M W Caddy

Delegated List

Planning Applications

Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00034/FUL Hollingwood Side extension to provide Conditional 26/03/2010 and Inkersall suite permission At 1691, 10 5 Ashover Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 3EG For Mr J Kennedy CHE/10/00074/RET St Leonards Retention of illuminated Conditional 26/03/2010 fascia sign permission At 2472 38 St Marys Gate Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7TH For Mr Mark Jennison CHE/10/00069/FUL Walton Additional security fence Conditional 26/03/2010 behind existing Lea Hurst permission day unit At 2410 Walton Hospital Whitecotes Lane Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3HN For Derbyshire County Primary Care Trust CHE/10/00055/FUL Brockwell Formation of new shop refused 29/03/2010 frontage and internal alterations At 2112 41 - 43 West Bars Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 1AZ For West Bars Tandoori

14 April 2010 Page 1 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00053/FUL St Leonards New shop front including Conditional 29/03/2010 replacement of pvc permission rainwater goods with iron At 1999 She Fashions 56 Knifesmithgate Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 1RQ For She Fashion CHE/10/00022/FUL Brimington Proposed two storey Conditional 31/03/2010 South extension to rear of property permission comprising bedroom and dining room At 3392 229 Manor Road Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 1NS For Ms Lorraine McMahon CHE/10/00090/FUL West Two storey pitched roof Conditional 31/03/2010 extension to side permission At 1736 40 Netherleigh Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QJ For Mr Martin Reynolds CHE/09/00777/FUL Walton Single storey rear and side Conditional 31/03/2010 extensions and pitched roof permission to existing garage At 3900 164 Walton Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3BS For Mr Tony Burnley

14 April 2010 Page 2 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00058/OUT Middlecroft Proposed demolition of refused 01/04/2010 And Poolsbrook Hotel and Poolsbrook redevelopment of land to provide 12 x 3 bed houses with associated parking At 322 Poolsbrook Hotel Staveley Road Poolsbrook Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 3LF For Mr Mark Breen CHE/10/00047/FUL Brimington Single storey side extension Conditional 01/04/2010 North to form shower room permission

At 1679 94 Station Road Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 1LN For Mr Antonio Picillo CHE/09/00764/FUL Brimington Creation of a muga, a new Conditional 01/04/2010 North natural play area with new permission play equipment and new areas of planting, additional information received 15th February 2010 and 22nd February 2010

At 2886 Recreation Ground Station Road Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire For Mr John Burrows

14 April 2010 Page 3 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00173/NMA Hollingwood Reposition of building and Unconditional 01/04/2010 And Inkersall relocation of 1 No. car permission parking space (CHE/09/00510/REM) At 544 Plot 5 East M1 Commerce Park Markham Lane Duckmanton Chesterfield Derbyshire S44 5HS

For Henry Boot Developments Ltd CHE/10/00050/FUL Moor Remove existing upvc barrier Conditional 01/04/2010 (60 metres), replace with 60 permission metres of 1.3 metre high vertical bar railings to match existing At 493 Gordon Lamb Skoda/Mitsubishi 6 Lockoford Lane Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7JA For Gordon Lamb Ltd CHE/10/00049/FUL St Helens Proposed detached starter refused 01/04/2010 home with new vehicular access to site from Hazlehurst Avenue. At 4799 Land Adjacent To Hazlehurst Avenue Canal Wharf Chesterfield Derbyshire For Mr P Taylor

14 April 2010 Page 4 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00164/CPO Rother Installation of a timber Other Council no 06/04/2010 framed outdoor shelter obj without comments At 1424 Spire Infant and Nursery School Road Birdholme Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 2EU For Derbyshire County Council CHE/10/00052/FUL St Leonards Change of use from class Conditional 06/04/2010 B1 to class D1 including permission internal refurbishment At 953 Ground Floor Spire Walk Business Park Derby Road Chesterfield For Lincolnshire NHS Shared Services CHE/10/00169/CPO Hasland Proposed replacement of an withdrawn 07/04/2010 existing brick garage with a new timber storage unit and the erection of security fencing and gates At 1492 Hasland Infants School Eyre Street East Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0PE For Derbyshire County Council CHE/10/00054/ADV Moor 1 No internally illuminated refused 07/04/2010 flexbox At 1209 Unit 3 Chesterfield Trade Centre Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7JH For Topps Tiles

14 April 2010 Page 5 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00108/RET St Leonards Proposed amendments to Retrospective 07/04/2010 existing shop front application approved At 2472 38 St Marys Gate Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7TH For Mr S Hendon CHE/10/00033/FUL Hasland Dropped kerb for vehicle Conditional 07/04/2010 access permission At 5003 297 Hasland Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0AA For Ms Debra Noakes CHE/10/00188/CA Brimington Lime Tree - crown lift - 5.2m Unconditional 07/04/2010 North from ground level permission At 1548 Three Horseshoes High Street Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 1DE For Mr Robert Reddish CHE/10/00027/FUL Dunston Garage, kitchen, dining, Conditional 07/04/2010 bedroom extension, plus permission porch At 4132 431 Newbold Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 8AG For Mr John Jardine CHE/10/00031/CON St Leonards Demolish dilapidated Conditional 07/04/2010 outbuilding permission At 2111 Sun Inn 13 West Bars Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 1AQ For Marstons Pub Company

14 April 2010 Page 6 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00163/TPO West Crown thinning and reduce Conditional 08/04/2010 crown to the front of permission bungalow and removal of any dead or diseased wood At 1089 17 Yew Tree Drive Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3NB For Mrs Merrifield CHE/09/00772/FUL Dunston Form proposed side Conditional 08/04/2010 extension compromising of permission car port and first floor bedroom At 313 33 Grasmere Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 8EF For Derbyshire County Council CHE/10/00165/TPO Walton Crown thinning of sycamore Conditional 08/04/2010 T4 to reduce density and permission allow light to garden

At 1668 32 Hillside Drive Walton Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 2DB For Mr Richard Hawksworth CHE/10/00110/FUL Dunston Single storey rear extension Conditional 08/04/2010 permission At 1308 583 Newbold Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 8AA For Mr and Mrs J Bradley

14 April 2010 Page 7 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00106/FUL Rother To provide multi use games Conditional 12/04/2010 area permission At 2623 Playing Fields Langer Lane Chesterfield Derbyshire For Chesterfield Borough Council CHE/10/00138/CPO Holmebrook Erection of new single storey Other Council no 12/04/2010 library and reception suite obj without within recess of building with comments entrance ramp and steps

At 1884 Old Hall Junior School Old Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QR For Derbyshire County Council CHE/10/00028/FUL Hasland Construction of two storey Conditional 12/04/2010 extension to the rear of the permission existing dwelling - revised plans received 22/03/2010 At 2811 20 Saxton Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0SL For Shaun Lawson CHE/10/00057/FUL West The installation of a 15,000 Conditional 12/04/2010 litre diesel fuel storage tank permission and dispensing pump, including construction of reinforced concrete base and filling apron. Connections to existing drainage and petrol interceptors At 2656 The Ambulance Station Old Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QF For MSPM Ltd

14 April 2010 Page 8 Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision Date File No CHE/10/00153/CPO Barrow Hill Foxlow Tip: The extraction of Other Council no 12/04/2010 And New brick clay, secondary obj without Whittington aggregates and incidental comments coal with stockpiling of brick clay and associated activities

At 2540 Foxlow Tip Site Staveley Lane Chesterfield S43 2NP

For Phoenix Brick Company Ltd CHE/10/00100/FUL Walton Proposed two storey Conditional 13/04/2010 extension - amendment to permission CHE/09/00621/FUL At 5578 14 Creswick Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3PX For Mr and Mrs P and E Walter

14 April 2010 Page 9 SECTION 1 APPLICATION TO FELL OR PRUNE TREES

DATE OF CODE NO FILE NO WARD DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL TERMS OF DECISION DECISION CHE/10/00163/TPO 4901.155 West The pruning of one tree Consent is granted to reference T1 Whitebeam on the the shortening of order map for Westside branches growing Landscapes on behalf of Mrs towards 17 Yew Tree 08/04/10 Merrifield of 17 Yew Tree Drive, Drive and the crown Somersall. The tree is allegedly thinning of the outer blocking out light and close to canopy to allow light to the dwelling. filter through. CHE/10/00165/TPO 4901.15 Walton The pruning of one Sycamore Consent is granted to tree reference T4 on the order the crown thinning of the map for Richard Hawksworth of tree to allow more light 32 Hillside Drive, Walton. The to filter through and 08/04/10 tree is allegedly blocking out reduce leaf coverage. light into the rear garden of 32 Hillside Drive.

SECTION 2 NOTIFICATION OF INTENT TO AFFECT TREES IN A CONSERVATION AREA

DATE OF CONTENTS OF NOTICE SUMMARY OF CONSIDERATIONS TERMS OF DECISION DECISION CHE/10/00188/CA The Lime tree is within the Brimington Agreement to the crown lifting The pruning of one Lime tree in Conservation Area and the applicant and removal of basal epicormic the front car park of the Three wishes to remove basal epicormic re- re-growth of one Lime tree which 07/04/10 Horseshoes, High Street, growth and low branches over the car will remove low branches over Brimington park. the car park. The pruning will have no adverse effect on the amenity value of the area.