2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY

WHAT MADE THIS POSSIBLE? YOU! TOWARD A CONSERVATION MAJORITY In 2019 and 2020, you used your voice to tell your Because LCV is both political and non- legislators to move forward with clean energy, partisan, our goal is to build a pro-conservation demand clean drinking water in our communities majority of state lawmakers from both parties who and conserve our state’s incredible natural support protecting the health of our communities resources. by tackling the big issues facing Michigan’s land, air, and water. Together, we are making a difference. An important part of our work is holding our elected officials accountable. This scorecard tells HOUSE you whether your representatives in Lansing Conservation Majority Breakdown listened to you and your neighbors, or if they listened to special interests. YES = 50 TELL YOUR LEGISLATORS MAYBE = 31 YOU KNOW THE SCORE NO = 31 1 It only takes a minute to say thanks-- or to TOTAL = 112 say no thanks-- to your legislators.

DONATE Because we could not accomplish our 2 mission without the generous support of SENATE our members, please make a donation so Conservation Majority Breakdown we can continue fighting for clean air and clean water in your community and continue YES = 16 our stewardship of Michigan’s unparalleled natural resources. MAYBE = 11 NO = 11 SPREAD THE WORD Finally, share this scorecard with your TOTAL = 38 3 friends and family so they know the score of their elected officials, too. Total number of legislators in the Michigan House exceeds number YOU CAN DO ALL OF THIS AT of House districts due to an early resignation and the passing of one MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD Representative during the term. 2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD

HOUSE FLOOR VOTES

KEY

REPRESENTATIVE DISTRICT TERM HB 4007 HCR 0001 HB 4465 & 4069 4391 4390, HB 4389, HB 4567 HR 282 SB 757 HB 6233 SB 241 2019-2020 SESSION SCORE # LIFETIME TERMS PREVIOUS LIFETIME SCORE LIFETIME SCORE

Tenisha Yancey 1 2 67 % 2 100 % 83 % Anti-conservation vote 2 1 78 % 1 78 % Pro-conservation vote 3 3 67 % 3 86 % 80 % 4 1 100 % 1 100 % Excused (neutral), not counted in total number of votes scored Isaac Robinson 4 1 75 % 1 75 % Cynthia A. Johnson 5 1 71 % 1 71 % Absent (negative) Tyrone Carter 6 1 78 % 1 78 % anti-conservation vote LaTanya Garrett 7 3 57 % 3 97 % 84 % *Indicate that a special election took Sherry Gay-Dagnogo 8 3 63 % 3 97 % 86 % place or member served a partial 9 1 83 % 1 83 % term. Leslie Love 10 3 83 % 3 100 % 94 % 11 2 67 % 2 95 % 81 % 12 1 78 % 1 78 % 13 3 89 % 3 100 % 96 % HB 4007 (Tie Bar w/ 4008-4016): Legislative 14 2 89 % 2 100 % 94 % Open Records Act 15 2 100 % 2 100 % 100 % Kevin Coleman 16 1 67 % 1 67 % HCR 0001: Resolution to Disapprove of Anti- Joseph Bellino 17 2 67 % 2 16 % 41 % Industrial Oversight Executive Order 18 2 78 % 2 100 % 89 % HB 4465 & 4069: Alternative Energy Property 19 1 100 % 1 100 % Tax Exemption 20 1 100 % 1 100 % Kristy Pagan 21 3 100 % 3 100 % 100 % HB 4389, 4390, 4391: Tracks the Use of PFAS 22 3 88 % 3 97 % 94 % Laden Fire Fighting Foams 23 2 100% 2 100% 100% HB 4567 (Tie bar w/ 4568, 4569): Commercial Steve Marino 24 2 67 % 2 26 % 46 % Fishing Statute Update 25 1 89 % 1 89 % HR 282: Resolution Supporting the Continued Jim Ellison 26 2 100 % 2 100 % 100 % Transportation of Oil/Gas Under the Straits of Robert Wittenberg 27 3 100 % 3 93 % 95 % Mackinac 28 1 100 % 1 100 % 29 1 88 % 1 88 % SB 757: Allows Pre-Processing of AV Ballots 30 2 67 % 2 26 % 46 % HB 6233: Effort to Block EV Sales in Michigan William Sowerby 31 2 100 % 2 100 % 100 % Moratorium on Water Shutoffs During 32 2 44 % 2 16 % 30 % SB 241: Pandemic Jeff Yaroch 33 2 78 % 2 47 % 62 % 34 3 100 % 3 98 % 99 % 1 2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD

HOUSE FLOOR VOTES

KEY

REPRESENTATIVE DISTRICT TERM HB 4007 HCR 0001 HB 4465 & 4069 4391 4390, HB 4389, HB 4567 HR 282 SB 757 HB 6233 SB 241 2019-2020 SESSION SCORE # LIFETIME TERMS PREVIOUS LIFETIME SCORE LIFETIME SCORE

Cynthia Neeley 34 1 75 % 1 75 % Anti-conservation vote Kyra Bolden 35 1 88 % 1 88 % Pro-conservation vote Douglas Wozniak 36 1 56 % 1 56 % Excused (neutral), not counted in Christine Greig 37 3 100 % 3 100 % 100 % total number of votes scored 38 3 67 % 3 31 % 43 % 39 1 56 % 1 56 % Absent (negative) 40 1 89 % 1 89 % anti-conservation vote 41 1 100 % 1 100 % *Indicate that a special election took 42 1 67 % 1 67 % place or member served a partial 43 1 71 % 1 71 % term. 44 1 44 % 1 44 % Michael Webber 45 1 67 % 1 67 % John Reilly 46 2 44 % 2 32 % 38 % Hank Vaupel 47 3 67 % 3 39 % 48 % HB 4007 (Tie Bar w/ 4008-4016): Legislative Sheryl Kennedy 48 1 78 % 1 78 % Open Records Act John Cherry 49 1 67 % 1 67 % 50 2 78 % 2 100 % 89 % HCR 0001: Resolution to Disapprove of Anti- 51 1 56 % 1 56 % Industrial Oversight Executive Order 52 2 89 % 2 100 % 94 % HB 4465 & 4069: Alternative Energy Property 53 2 78 % 2 100 % 89 % Tax Exemption Ronnie Peterson 54 2 89 % 2 100 % 94 % HB 4389, 4390, 4391: Tracks the Use of PFAS Rebekah Warren 55 4 100 % 4 100 % 100 % Laden Fire Fighting Foams 56 3 67 % 3 36 % 46 % 57 2 67% 2 36% 51% HB 4567 (Tie bar w/ 4568, 4569): Commercial 58 3 67 % 3 37 % 47 % Fishing Statute Update Aaron Miller 59 3 56 % 3 31 % 39 % HR 282: Resolution Supporting the Continued 100 % 100 % 100 % 60 3 3 Transportation of Oil/Gas Under the Straits of 61 3 67 % 3 26 % 40 % Mackinac 62 1 89 % 1 89 % 63 1 67 % 1 67 % SB 757: Allows Pre-Processing of AV Ballots Julie Alexander 64 2 63 % 2 32 % 47 % HB 6233: Effort to Block EV Sales in Michigan 65 1 67 % 1 67 % SB 241: Moratorium on Water Shutoffs During 66 2 67 % 2 26 % 46 % Pandemic 67 1 100 % 1 100 % 68 2 100 % 2 88 % 94 % 2 2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD

HOUSE FLOOR VOTES

KEY

REPRESENTATIVE DISTRICT TERM HB 4007 HCR 0001 HB 4465 & 4069 4391 4390, HB 4389, HB 4567 HR 282 SB 757 HB 6233 SB 241 2019-2020 SESSION SCORE # LIFETIME TERMS PREVIOUS LIFETIME SCORE LIFETIME SCORE

Julie Brixie 69 1 89 % 1 89 % Anti-conservation vote James Lower 70 3 67 % 3 32 % 44 % Pro-conservation vote 71 1 78 % 1 78 % Excused (neutral), not counted in Steven Johnson 72 2 44 % 2 34 % 39 % total number of votes scored 73 3 67 % 3 52 % 57 % 74 1 78 % 1 78 % Absent (negative) David LaGrand 75 2 89 % 2 100 % 94 % anti-conservation vote 76 1 89 % 1 89 % *Indicate that a special election took 77 2 56 % 2 33 % 44 % place or member served a partial 78 1 56 % 1 56 % term. 79 1 67 % 1 67 % 80 2 67 % 2 26 % 46 % 81 1 67 % 1 67 % Gary Howell 82 2 67 % 2 34 % 50 % HB 4007 (Tie Bar w/ 4008-4016): Legislative 83 3 56 % 3 26 % 36 % Open Records Act 84 1 56 % 1 56 % 85 2 67 % 2 20 % 43 % HCR 0001: Resolution to Disapprove of Anti- Thomas Albert 86 2 56 % 2 16 % 36 % Industrial Oversight Executive Order 87 2 56 % 2 34 % 45 % HB 4465 & 4069: Alternative Energy Property 88 1 56 % 1 56 % Tax Exemption 89 2 67 % 2 28 % 47 % HB 4389, 4390, 4391: Tracks the Use of PFAS 90 1 67 % 1 67 % Laden Fire Fighting Foams Greg VanWoerkom 91 1 56 % 1 56 % 92 2 67% 2 100% 83% HB 4567 (Tie bar w/ 4568, 4569): Commercial 93 1 67 % 1 67 % Fishing Statute Update 94 1 67 % 1 67 % HR 282: Resolution Supporting the Continued 100 % 100 % 100 % 95 3 3 Transportation of Oil/Gas Under the Straits of 96 3 88 % 3 84 % 85 % Mackinac 97 2 67 % 2 22 % 44 % 98 1 67 % 1 67 % SB 757: Allows Pre-Processing of AV Ballots 99 2 67 % 2 28 % 47 % HB 6233: Effort to Block EV Sales in Michigan Scott VanSingel 100 2 63 % 2 42 % 52 % SB 241: Moratorium on Water Shutoffs During Jack O’Malley 101 1 67 % 1 67 % Pandemic 102 2 56 % 2 26 % 41 % 103 2 67 % 2 18 % 42 % 3 2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD

HOUSE FLOOR VOTES

KEY

REPRESENTATIVE DISTRICT TERM HB 4007 HCR 0001 HB 4465 & 4069 4391 4390, HB 4389, HB 4567 HR 282 SB 757 HB 6233 SB 241 2019-2020 SESSION SCORE # LIFETIME TERMS PREVIOUS LIFETIME SCORE LIFETIME SCORE

Larry Inman 104 3 57 % 3 44 % 48 % Anti-conservation vote 105 3 67 % 3 28 % 41 % Pro-conservation vote 106 2 56 % 2 58 % 57 % Excused (neutral), not counted in Lee Chatfield 107 3 67 % 3 27 % 40 % total number of votes scored Beau LaFave 108 2 44 % 2 16 % 30 % 109 2 67 % 2 74 % 70 % Absent (negative) 110 1 50 % 1 50 % anti-conservation vote *Indicate that a special election took place or member served a partial term.

HB 4007 (Tie Bar w/ 4008-4016): Legislative Open Records Act

HOUSE HCR 0001: Resolution to Disapprove of Anti- Conservation Majority Industrial Oversight Executive Order Based on Score HB 4465 & 4069: Alternative Energy Property Tax Exemption

YES = 50 HB 4389, 4390, 4391: Tracks the Use of PFAS MAYBE = 31 Laden Fire Fighting Foams NO = 31 HB 4567 (Tie bar w/ 4568, 4569): Commercial Fishing Statute Update

TOTAL = 112 HR 282: Resolution Supporting the Continued Transportation of Oil/Gas Under the Straits of Mackinac

SB 757: Allows Pre-Processing of AV Ballots HB 6233: Effort to Block EV Sales in Michigan

SB 241: Moratorium on Water Shutoffs During Pandemic

4 2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD

SENATE FLOOR VOTES

KEY

SENATOR DISTRICT TERM HCR 0001 4391 4390, HB 4389, SB 47 SB 530 SB 714 SB 757 SB 241 2019-2020 SESSION SCORE # LIFETIME TERMS PREVIOUS LIFETIME SCORE LIFETIME SCORE

Stephanie Chang 1 3 100 % 3 100 % 100 % Anti-conservation vote 2 2 100 % 2 91 % 96 % Pro-conservation vote 3 2 100 % 2 100 % 100 % Excused (neutral), not counted in 4 1 100 % 1 100 % total number of votes scored 5 1 100 % 1 100 % 6 3 100 % 3 96 % 97 % Absent (negative) 7 1 100 % 1 100 % anti-conservation vote Pete Lucido 8 3 57 % 3 41 % 46 % *Indicate that a special election took Paul Wojno 9 1 100 % 1 100 % place or member served a partial Michael MacDonald 10 1 71 % 1 71 % term. 11 3 100 % 3 100 % 100 % 12 1 100 % 1 100 % Mallory McMorrow 13 1 100 % 1 100 % 14 1 57 % 1 57 % HCR 0001: Resolution to Disapprove of Anti- 15 3 57 % 3 36 % 43 % Industrial Oversight Executive Order 16 5 71 % 5 25 % 34 % 17 4 71 % 4 38 % 46 % HB 4389, 4390, 4391: Tracks the Use of PFAS 18 4 100 % 4 91 % 93 % Laden Fire Fighting Foams 19 3 71 % 3 35 % 47 % SB 47: Alternative Energy Property Tax Sean McCann 20 3 100 % 3 81 % 87 % Exemption Kim LaSata 21 2 71 % 2 26 % 49 % SB 530: Air Quality Sunset & Revision 22 3 57 % 3 28 % 38 % Curtis Hertel Jr. 23 2 100 % 2 100 % 100 % SB 714: Coastal Zone Hardening Act Tom Barrett 24 3 43% 3 25% 31% SB 757: Allows Pre-Processing of AV Ballots 25 4 57 % 4 32 % 38 % 26 4 57 % 4 38 % 43 % SB 241: Moratorium on Water Shutoffs During 27 3 100 % 3 95 % 97 % Pandemic Peter MacGregor 28 4 71 % 4 27 % 38 % 29 4 100 % 4 97 % 98 % 30 4 71 % 4 33 % 43 %

5 2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE SCORECARD SUMMARY MICHIGANLCV.ORG/SCORECARD

SENATE FLOOR VOTES

KEY

SENATOR DISTRICT TERM HCR 0001 4391 4390, HB 4389, SB 47 SB 530 SB 714 SB 757 SB 241 2019-2020 SESSION SCORE # LIFETIME TERMS PREVIOUS LIFETIME SCORE LIFETIME SCORE

Kevin Daley 31 4 71 % 4 34 % 43 % Anti-conservation vote Ken Horn 32 2 71 % 2 28 % 50 % Pro-conservation vote 33 4 71 % 4 40 % 48 % Excused (neutral), not counted in 34 4 57 % 4 31 % 38 % total number of votes scored Curt Vanderwall 35 2 67 % 2 16 % 41 % 36 5 71 % 5 27 % 36 % Absent (negative) Wayne A Schmidt 37 5 71 % 5 33 % 41 % anti-conservation vote Ed McBroom 38 4 57 % 4 38 % 43 % *Indicate that a special election took place or member served a partial term.

HCR 0001: Resolution to Disapprove of Anti- Industrial Oversight Executive Order

SENATE HB 4389, 4390, 4391: Tracks the Use of PFAS Conservation Majority Laden Fire Fighting Foams Based on Score SB 47: Alternative Energy Property Tax Exemption YES = 16 SB 530: Air Quality Sunset & Revision MAYBE = 11 SB 714: Coastal Zone Hardening Act NO = 11 SB 757: Allows Pre-Processing of AV Ballots TOTAL = 38 SB 241: Moratorium on Water Shutoffs During Pandemic

6