FOURm REpUBLIC 7m NATIONAL ASSEMBLY FIRsT SESSION No.8 45

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS Wednesday, 6 July, 2011

1. The House met at 2.25 p.m. Mr Speaker read the Prayers.

2. Votes and Proceedings: Mr Speaker announced that he had examined and approved the Second Votes and Proceedings of Tuesday, 5 July, 2011.

By unanimous consent, the Votes and Proceedings was adopted.

3. Announcements: (I) Visitors: ", Mr Speaker recognized the presence of Staff and Students of Phelish International School, Warri, Delta State who were in the Gallery.

(il) Ad-hoc Committee on Constitution Review: Mr Speaker announced that the Leadership of the House was yet to receive nominees for membership of the Ad-Hoc Committee on Constitution Review from the following States: Akwa Thorn, Bauchi, Bayelsa, Benue, Cross River, Delta, Edo, Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, , Katsina, Kebbi, Kwara, Lagos, Nasarawa, Niger, Ogun, Osun, Sokoto, Taraba, Yobe and Zamfara.

He directed that the names of the nominees from the concerned States should reach the Office of the Deputy Speaker not later than today, 6 July, 2011.

4. Impending Strike Action by the Organised Labour over Non-Implementation of N18,OOO.OO National Minimum Wage: Motion made and Question proposed,

The House:

Notes that since the National Assembly passed the National Minimum Wage (Amendment) Bill, 2011, which approved N18,OOO.OO for Nigerian workers and the Bill having been assented to by Mr President, there has been discordant tunes from the State Governors in implementation;

Aware that the Organised Labour are threatening to embark on an industrial action unless the Governors accept to pay the new minimum wage;

Conscious of the fact that such an industrial action is unhealthy for our democracy and the Nation's economy;

Disturbed that unless this Honourable House takes urgent steps by mediating in the matter, the workers will carry out their threat to embark on the strike action which could paralyze the economy of the country;

Resolves to:

(0 Calion the Organized Labour to allow the House dialogue with the Minister of Labour, Employment and Productivity and other relevant Agencies on the issue;

PRINTED BY NA T/ONAL ASSEMBLY PRESS, 46 Wednesday, 6 July, 2011 No.8

(il) urge the Leadership of the House to meet with Nigeria Governors' Forum (NGF) with a view to resolving this crucial issue once and for all (Hon. Peace U. Nnaji - Nkanu EastlNkanu West Federal Constituency) .

Debate:

Amendments Proposed:

(I) Insert a new Prayer (iii) as follows: - "Urge the Executive arm to initiate a new revenue allocation formula in favour of the Local Governments and States" (Hon. Munir B. Banagundi - Kumbotso Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and agreed to.

(il) Leave out Prayer (il) and insert a new Prayer (ii) as follows: "Urge the Federal and States governments to obey the law and seek redress through Constitution amendment" (Hon. Umar Bature - Sokoto North/Souin Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived.

(iiI) Insert a new Prayer (iv) as follows: "Urge the House to dialogue with the Nigerian Labour Congress (NLC) to provide better solution" (Hon. Henry D. Ofongo - Southern /jaw Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived.

(iv) Insert a new Prayer (Iv) as follows: "Urge the House to set an Ad-hoc Committee to identify States that are not capable of paying the MI8,GOO minimum wage to their workers" (Hon. Olisa Omegwu - Ndokwa EastiNdokwa WestlUkwuani Federal Constituency). ~I ~

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived.

(v) Insert a new Prayer (iv) as follows: "Urge the Leadership of the House to meet with the Organised Labour, Minister of Labour and Productivity and the Nigerian Governor's Forum (NGF) with a view to resolving the issue of payment of the national minimum wage" (Hon. Andrew Uchendu - IkwerrelEmohua Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and agreed to.

(vI) Leave out Prayer (i) and insert a new Prayer (i) as follows: "Urge the House to use Constitutional means in supporting the Nigerian Labour Congress to compel the State Governments to pay the MI8,OOO minimum wage to their workers" (Hon. Umar Adam Katsayal- DauralMai'adualSandamu Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived.

(vii) Leave out Prayer (il) and insert a new Prayer (il) as follows: "Urge the Nigerian Governor's Forum to respect the law of the land and implement the MI8,OOO minimum wage" (Hon. Umar Adam Katsayal- DauralMai'adualSandamu Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived.

(viiI) Leave out Prayer (i) and insert a new Prayer (i) as follows: "Urge the House to dialogue with the Nigerian Labour Congress, Minister of Labour and Productivity the Nigerian Governor Forum and other relevant agencies" (Hon. Chinda Kingsley - Obio-Akpor Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived.

(ix) Insert a new Prayer (v) as follows: "Urge the Federal, States and Local Governments to pay the MI8,OOD minimum wage to their respective workers" (Hon. Yusuf Manu Swa - Balanga/Billiri, Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made. put and negatived. No.8 Wednesday, 6 July, 2011 47

(x) Insert a new Prayer (v) as follows: "Urge the States Government to employ intellectual and political resource persons to improve their internal generated revenue significantly to reduce over dependence in Federal Government funds" (Hon. Ibrahim Olafia - Oluyole Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made, put and negatived.

(xl) Insert a new Prayer (v) as follows: "Urge the Federal Government to give bail out funds to the States to unable them pay the minimum - wage pending the res-structuring of the revenue formula" (Hon. Umar Buba fibril - Lokoja/Kogi/Koton-Karfi Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made, put and negatived.

(xii) Insert a new Prayer (v) as follows: "CalIon States Government not to condition the payment of minimum wage on the removal of oil subsidy in order to save Nigerian from unprecedented hardship" (Hon. Abubakar Momoh - Etsako Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made, put and negatived.

(xiil) Insert a new Prayer (v) as follows: "Urge the National Assembly to work with the States House of Assembly on the issue of national minimum wage" (Hon. Arua Arunsi - Arochukwu/Ohafia Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made, put and negatived.

Main Question as amended, put and agreed to:

The House: .,. Noted that since the National Assembly passed the National Minimum Wage (Amendment) Bill, 2011, which approved N18,OOO.OO for Nigerian workers and the Bill having been assented to by Mr President, there has been discordant tunes from the State Governors in implementation;

Aware that the Organised Labour are threatening to embark on an industrial action unless the Governors accept to pay the new minimum wage;

Conscious of the fact that such an industrial action is unhealthy for our democracy and the Nation's economy;

Disturbed that unless this Honourable House takes urgent steps by mediating in the matter, the workers will carry out their threat to embark on the strike action which could paralyze the economy of the country;

Resolved to:

(r) CalIon the Organized Labour to allow the House dialogue with the Minister of Labour, Employment and Productivity and other relevant Agencies on the issue;

(iI) urge the Leadership of the House to meet with Nigeria Governors' Forum (NGF) with a view to resolving this crucial issue once and for all;

(iiI) further urge the Executive arm to initiate a new revenue allocation formula in favour of the Local Governments and States;

(iv) also urge the Leadership of the House to meet with the Organised Labour, Minister of Labour and Productivity and the Nigerian Governor's Forum (NGF) with a view to resolving the issue of payment of the national minimum wage (HR. 07/2011).

s. Non Take-off of the Proposed Federal University in Ekiti State: Motion made and Question proposed,

The House: "

48 Wednesday, 6 July, 2011 No.8

Notes that in November, 2010, the Federal Government declared its intent to establish six (6) new Universities in State(s) without Federal Universities across the six (6) geopolitical zones of the country with the purpose of balancing access to quality higher education in the country, among others;

Further notes that the choice of Ekiti State in the Southwest geopolitical zone to site one of the proposed Federal Universities was conveyed to the Nigerian public on 22 November, 2010;

Aware that following due consultations with stakeholders and recommendations of the Federal Government Visitation Panel comprising of the Minister of Education, the Executive Secretary of National Universities Commission among other officials, Ikole-Ekiti was announced as the location for the University;

Further aware that the choice of Ikole- Ekiti was further confirmed by the Minister of Information and Communication, during a press briefmg after the Federal Executive Council meeting of 22 December, 2010;

Worried that after the pronouncement of the proposed site of the University as Oye- Ekiti on 11 February, 2011, instead of Ikole- Ekiti as previously announced, violence erupted in Ikole- Ekiti which claimed about 3 lives with several persons wounded and properties destroyed including a Police van;

Concerned that nothing is on ground at the moment to ensure the take-off of the university in September alongside other new Federal Universities despite the release of N1.S billion for its smooth take-off;

Resolves to:

(I) Urge the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria to direct that the initial choice of Ikole-Ekiti be maintained and efforts intensified towards the take-off alongside other Universities;

(il) mandate an Ad-hoc Committee to investigate the inconsistencies in relation to the choice of location for the university, the remote and immediate cause(s) of the violence and other factors hindering the smooth take-off of the University, and report back to the House within two (2) weeks (Hon. Abimbola Daramola - Ikole/Oye North). " . Debate:

Amendments Proposed: (I) Leave out Prayer (I) (Hon. Farouk Lawan - Shanono/Bagwai Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made, put and agreed to.

(il) Leave out Prayer (if) and insert a new Prayer (il) as follows: "Urge the House to mandate the Committee on Education, when constituted, to investigate the inconsistencies in relation to the choice of location for the university, the remote and immediate cause(s) of the violence and other factors hindering the smooth take-off of the University, and report back to the House" (Hon. Farouk Lawan - Shanono/Bagwai Federal Constituency).

Question that the amendment be made, put and agreed to.

Main Question as amended, put and agreed to:

The House:

Noted that in November, 2010, the Federal Government declared its intent to establish six (6) new Universities in State(s) without Federal Universities across the six (6) geopolitical zones of the country with the purpose of balancing access to quality higher education in the country, among others;

Further noted that the choice of Ekiti State in the Southwest geopolitical zone to site one of the proposed Federal Universities was conveyed to the Nigerian public on 22 November, 2010;

Aware that following due consultations with stakeholders and recommendations of the Federal Government Visitation Panel comprising of the Minister of Education, the Executive Secretary of National Universities Commission among other officials, Ikole-Ekiti was announced as the location for the University;

Further aware that the choice of Ikole-Ekiti was further confirmed by the Minister of Information and Communication, during a press briefing after the Federal Executive Council meeting of 22 December, 2010; No.8 Wednesday, 6 July, 2011 49

Worried that after the pronouncement of the proposed site of the University as Oye-Ekiti on 11 February, 2011, instead ofIkole-Ekiti as previously announced, violence erupted in Ikole-Ekiti which claimed about 31ives with several persons wounded and properties destroyed including a Police van;

Concerned that nothing is on ground at the moment to ensure the take-off of the university in September alongside other new Federal Universities despite the release of N1.5 billion for its smooth take-off;

Resolved to:

Urge the House to mandate the Committee on Education, when constituted, to investigate the inconsistencies in relation to the choice of location for the university, the remote and immediate cause(s) of the violence and other factors hindering the smooth take-off of the University, and report back to the House (HR. 08/2011).

6. Legislative Agenda: Legislative Agenda/or the House 0/ Representatives (A4journed Debate): Motion made and Question proposed, "That this House do resume debate on the Proposed Legislative Agenda of the House of Representatives" (Hon. Albert T. Sam-Tsokwa, Donga/Ussa/Takum Federal Constituency).

Question put and agreed to.

Debate:

Debate adjourned till the next Legislative Day.

7. Adjournment: That this House do now adjourn till Thursday, 7 July, 2011 at 10.00 a.m. (Hon. Albert T. Sam-Tsokwa, Donga/Ussa/Takum Federal Constituency).

Adjourned accordingly at 6.00 p.m.

Aminu Waziri Tambuwal Speaker