DOCSLIB.ORG

Viewpoint Selection and Additional Wirelines For

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Viewpoint Selection and Additional Wirelines For Appendix 6.2: Viewpoint Selection and Additional Wirelines for Comparison with the Consented Development - Appendix 6.2 Viewpoints and Additional Wirelines for Comparison with the Consented Development Appendix 6.2 Shelloch Wind Farm EIA Report November 2020 Viewpoints and Additional Wirelines for Comparison with the Consented Development Viewpoint Selection Location Reasons for Omission 6.1 The selection of viewpoints for assessment in the LVIA was determined through consultation, both through the Scoping Report Lees Hill North-east of the Spout of Ballochleam, represented by VP4 Carletheran. (June 2020), and consultation directly with Stirling Council and Scottish Natural Heritage, as set out in Table 6.1 of Chapter 6. Holehead Local hill above Fintry, represented by VP3 B822 Crow Road. Viewpoints included in the Assessment Callender Park, Falkirk Distant location surrounded by woodlands and buildings of Falkirk, no view. 6.2 Table 6.10 of Chapter 6 sets out details relating to viewpoint locations selected for inclusion in the LVIA. Ben Venue (AOD 727m) Represented by VP12 Ben Ledi. Additional Viewpoints used in the LVIA for Craigton & Spittalhill Wind Farm East Fintry Hills summit (AOD 482m) Represented by VP5 Tomtain. 6.3 A number of other viewpoints were used in the LVIA for the Consented Craigton & Spittalhill Wind Farm but have not been re- Stronend Local hill represented by other hills around the site (VP4 Carletheran, VP5 Tomtain), used in the LVIA for the Development. However, for completeness, wirelines for these viewpoints are provided in Appendix 6.3 visualisation provided in Chapter 10 for Stronend Cairn (Figure 10.x). showing a comparison between the Consented Development and the Development. The table below sets out details as to why the Callander No views from within settlement. Views from higher slopes e.g. golf course represented by viewpoints were omitted from the current assessment. VP 11 at Bracklinn Falls. Table 6.1: Viewpoints not re-used for the LVIA A9 north of Dunblane Limited visibility, H&S issues for fieldwork and photography, represented by VP14 Sherrifmuir. Location Reasons for Omission Comparative Wireline Figure Number Thornhill Viewpoint Limited visibility. More visibility at VP8 A873 Ruskie. Meikle Bin More frequent views from B822 Crow Road represented by new viewpoint (VP3). Figure 6. 28iv Thornhill, B822 Limited visibility. More visibility at VP8 A873 Ruskie. Rob Roy Way More frequent views from A81 represented by new viewpoint at Port of Menteith (VP9). Figure 6. 28ix Conic Hill Limited visibility. Represented by VP12 Ben Ledi. Sheildhill More frequent views from Falkirk area represented by new viewpoint at Falkirk Wheel Figure 6. 28xi A81 at Portend North of Lake of Menteith Moved to clearer location closer to Port of Menteith (VP9). (VP15). B8034 at Arndale, Parks and Garden Used in Craigton and Spittalhill Wind Farm ES. Representative of views from the Carse of Ben Cleuch More frequent views from Sherriffmuir represented by new viewpoint (VP14) which can Figure 6. 28xii Forth, on this route between Port of Menteith and Arnprior. Moved to Easter Garden (VP7). represent views from Ben Cleuch. Ben Vorlich Distant views in this direction can be represented by VP12 Ben Ledi. Figure 6. 28xiii Ben Lomond Distant views in this direction can be represented by VP10 David Marshall Lodge or Figure 6. 28xiv VP12 Ben Ledi. Meall an-t Seallach Distant views in this direction can be represented by VP12 Ben Ledi. Figure 6. 28xv Other Viewpoints omitted from the Assessment 6.4 The table below sets out details relating to other potential viewpoint locations considered during the viewpoint selection process, but not included in the LVIA. Table 6.2: Viewpoint Locations Omitted from the LVIA Location Reasons for Omission Cairnoch Hill Local high point in the Campsie Hills, represented by VP2 Sir John de Graham's Castle and VP5 Tomtain. B8034 East of Lake of Menteith Minor road from Port of Menteith to Arnprior. Represented by VP9 A81 Port of Menteith and VP7 B8034 Easter Garden. Junction A73 and A81 Part of a sequence along the A81, but screened by trees at the junction. Represented by VP9 A81 Port of Menteith and VP8 A873 Ruskie. Dundaff Hill Local hill above the Carron Valley, represented by VP5 Tomtain. LUC | 1 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Scottish Highlands Hillwalking
    SHHG-3 back cover-Q8__- 15/12/16 9:08 AM Page 1 TRAILBLAZER Scottish Highlands Hillwalking 60 DAY-WALKS – INCLUDES 90 DETAILED TRAIL MAPS – INCLUDES 90 DETAILED 60 DAY-WALKS 3 ScottishScottish HighlandsHighlands EDN ‘...the Trailblazer series stands head, shoulders, waist and ankles above the rest. They are particularly strong on mapping...’ HillwalkingHillwalking THE SUNDAY TIMES Scotland’s Highlands and Islands contain some of the GUIDEGUIDE finest mountain scenery in Europe and by far the best way to experience it is on foot 60 day-walks – includes 90 detailed trail maps o John PLANNING – PLACES TO STAY – PLACES TO EAT 60 day-walks – for all abilities. Graded Stornoway Durness O’Groats for difficulty, terrain and strenuousness. Selected from every corner of the region Kinlochewe JIMJIM MANTHORPEMANTHORPE and ranging from well-known peaks such Portree Inverness Grimsay as Ben Nevis and Cairn Gorm to lesser- Aberdeen Fort known hills such as Suilven and Clisham. William Braemar PitlochryPitlochry o 2-day and 3-day treks – some of the Glencoe Bridge Dundee walks have been linked to form multi-day 0 40km of Orchy 0 25 miles treks such as the Great Traverse. GlasgowGla sgow EDINBURGH o 90 walking maps with unique map- Ayr ping features – walking times, directions, tricky junctions, places to stay, places to 60 day-walks eat, points of interest. These are not gen- for all abilities. eral-purpose maps but fully edited maps Graded for difficulty, drawn by walkers for walkers. terrain and o Detailed public transport information strenuousness o 62 gateway towns and villages 90 walking maps Much more than just a walking guide, this book includes guides to 62 gateway towns 62 guides and villages: what to see, where to eat, to gateway towns where to stay; pubs, hotels, B&Bs, camp- sites, bunkhouses, bothies, hostels.
    [Show full text]
  • Scenic Routes in the National Park
    Scenic Routes in the National Park Too often when we travel, we forget to stop along the way, take a breath, Sloc nan Sìtheanach Scenic Routes greet the day, and take in the Faerie Hollow by in the National Park Ruairidh Campbell Moir An Ceann Mòr many fantastic views that by BTE Architects Scenic Route Faerie Hollow is Scotland has to offer. Loch Lubnaig beag situated beside An Ceann Mòr is the small picnic site A84 Callander to Strathyre Along the loch shore there are at Inveruglas, on by Loch Lubnaig, the shores of Loch between Callander native woodlands and conifer The viewpoint nestles between Scenic Route Lomond on the A82 and Strathyre on A84 forests, home to red squirrels the shrubs in a natural hollow in opposite Loch Sloy > Did you know? about 5 miles before and pine martens thant climb the Inveruglas the landscape with stunning views power station Inveruglas, translates Balquhidder slopes above. Salmon and the A82 Tarbet to Crianlarich across Loch Lubnaig to Ben Ledi. into Gaelic as Inbhir rare Arctic charr lurk in the loch An Ceann Mòr (translated as large Dhùbhghlais (inivur This site, overlooking Loch Lubnaig, called for a place to as well as pike. Great views can be It’s not just the These artworks are part of the Scottish Scenic Routes headland) at Inveruglas on the GHOOlish) – ‘mouth stop, sit and linger to take in the surroundings. A natural seen as you go north of Strathyre, Initiative, created in partnership with: banks of Loch Lomond is a stunning eight metre high of the dark stream’.
    [Show full text]
  • Strathyre and Loch Earn
    STRATHYRE AND LOCH EARN SPECIAL QUALITIES OF BREADALBANE STRATHYRE & LOCH EARN Key Features Small flats strips of farmland around watercourses Open upland hills Ben Vorlich and Stuc a’Chroin Loch Lubnaig and Loch Earn Pass of Leny Glen Ogle Landmark historic buildings and heritage sites including Edinample Castle and Dundurn Pictish Hill Fort Summary of Evaluation Sense of Place The visual/sense of place qualities are important. The open upland hills dominate much of this area, with Ben Vorlich and Stuc a’ Chroin the highest peaks, creating an open and vast sense of place with diverse features such as rocky outcrops and scree. Although open uplands are characteristic of much of the highland area of the Park they are distinctive in the Breadalbane area as being generally higher and more unbroken with distinct exposed upper slopes. Loch Earn and Loch Lubnaig are the two main lochs in the area and both have quite distinct characters. Loch Lubnaig is enclosed by heavily planted glen sides and rugged craggy hills such as Ben Ledi and the loch shores are largely undeveloped. Loch Earn in contrast is broad in expanse and flanked by steep hills to the north and south. There are areas of residential, recreational and commercial development along areas of the north and south shore. The flat glen floors are a focus for communication routes and settlement. The flat strips of farmland around the watercourses provide an enclosed landscape which contrasts with the surrounding hills. Cultural Heritage The cultural heritage of the area is of high importance with substantial evidence of continuity of use of the landscape.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dalradian Rocks of the North-East Grampian Highlands of Scotland
    Revised Manuscript 8/7/12 Click here to view linked References 1 2 3 4 5 The Dalradian rocks of the north-east Grampian 6 7 Highlands of Scotland 8 9 D. Stephenson, J.R. Mendum, D.J. Fettes, C.G. Smith, D. Gould, 10 11 P.W.G. Tanner and R.A. Smith 12 13 * David Stephenson British Geological Survey, Murchison House, 14 West Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3LA. 15 [email protected] 16 0131 650 0323 17 John R. Mendum British Geological Survey, Murchison House, West 18 Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3LA. 19 Douglas J. Fettes British Geological Survey, Murchison House, West 20 Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3LA. 21 C. Graham Smith Border Geo-Science, 1 Caplaw Way, Penicuik, 22 Midlothian EH26 9JE; formerly British Geological Survey, Edinburgh. 23 David Gould formerly British Geological Survey, Edinburgh. 24 P.W. Geoff Tanner Department of Geographical and Earth Sciences, 25 University of Glasgow, Gregory Building, Lilybank Gardens, Glasgow 26 27 G12 8QQ. 28 Richard A. Smith formerly British Geological Survey, Edinburgh. 29 30 * Corresponding author 31 32 Keywords: 33 Geological Conservation Review 34 North-east Grampian Highlands 35 Dalradian Supergroup 36 Lithostratigraphy 37 Structural geology 38 Metamorphism 39 40 41 ABSTRACT 42 43 The North-east Grampian Highlands, as described here, are bounded 44 to the north-west by the Grampian Group outcrop of the Northern 45 Grampian Highlands and to the south by the Southern Highland Group 46 outcrop in the Highland Border region. The Dalradian succession 47 therefore encompasses the whole of the Appin and Argyll groups, but 48 also includes an extensive outlier of Southern Highland Group 49 strata in the north of the region.
    [Show full text]
  • Callander Community Council Topic Detail/ Discussion
    Callander Community Council Minute of the meeting: Monday 9th October 2017 Community Richard Johnson. Mike Luti Lucia Bobtova Wayne Johnson Councillors Brian Luti Paul Luti Dan McKirgan Cath McNab Also in Jeremy McDonald (Stirling Council) Stirling Observer Tom Jones Jen Shearer Attend Michelle Flynn. (Stirling Council) Sheila Winstone Toto McLellan (Min.Sec) Chair of Meeting: R. Johnson Topic Detail/ Discussion Action 1.Opening Introductions: R.Johnson welcomed everyone to the meeting, and introducing Nicole Lochead from Stirling Council and Toto McLellan, Minute Secretary. Apologies Connie Smith David Warnock (LLTNP) ILES Nicole Lochead from Stirling Council Sustainable Development Team gave a WasteWater presentation to the meeting on a proposal under the Innovative Local Energy Solutions Energy project (ILES) to generate energy from waste water treatment plants, in partnership with Scottish Water Horizons. The system has been piloted in Galashiels. Documentation was presented which detailed the fact that Stirling Council Area has higher than average fuel poverty, due to the high proportion of rural area with no access to urban fuel choices. Fuel poverty was identified as 10% or more of income spent on energy, 25% plus being extreme poverty. £100k has been awarded by Scottish Government for feasibility study, further funding will be sought for infrastructure and implementation of the process, which has the potential of generating 2.6GWh per year. Energy produced will be stored in fridge-sized energy retention units manufactured in Scotland which will be transported to individual premises for download to existing system, resulting in a 10% saving on gas supply, and c 40% saving on electricity.
    [Show full text]
  • Path Audit: Stage 1 Network Review
    CALLANDER LANDSCAPE PARTNERSHIP: PATH AUDIT: STAGE 1 NETWORK REVIEW craignish design | draft | V5 | 9th May 2017 Callander Landscape Partnership: Path Audit Stage 1: Network Review Summary This audit contains an overview of over 70km of existing and aspirational paths identified by the Callander Countryside Group (CCG) around Callander and has been prepared as part of the Callander Landscape Partnership (CLP) Stage 2 submission. A number of paths have been selected by the CCG as key projects for taking forward during the implementation stage of the CLP and these are presented in a separate document, “Callander Landscape Partnership: Path Audit: Stage 2: Path Projects”. Prepared on behalf of Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park by David Graham BA(Hons) Dip LA CMLI craignish design, chartered landscape architects Barfad, Ardfern, Lochgilphead Argyll PA31 8QN t. 01852 500 576 [email protected] www.criagnishdesign.com Callander Landscape Partnership: Path Audit: Stage 1 Overview 1 | P a g e th Craignish design _ v05_ 9 May 2017 Contents 12. Leny Wood 1. Introduction 13. Leny Flushes 2. Brief 14. Faerie Path 3. Method 15. Stank Glen and Meall Dubh 4. Recommendation 16. Drumbane 5. Glossary Figures Path Audit Fig 01 Overview 1. Callander Crags Fig 02 Areas 1 & 2 2. Brackland Glen Fig 03 Areas 3, 4, 5 & 6 3. Auchenlaich Loop Fig 04 Areas 7, 8 & 9 4. Town Centre Fig 05 Area 10 5. Meadows Fig 06 Area 11, 12 & 13 6. Esker Path & Riverside Fig 07 Area 14 & 15 7. Kilmahog Loop Fig 08 Area 16 8. Coilhallan Link 9.
    [Show full text]
  • KMRT Stories Final Draft
    Preface It has been a joy and a privilege for me to gather and merge these stories into the versions that you can read here - a task that I found very enjoyable because I was present during some of these ploys and I had heard most of the other tales during waiting periods on the hill and/or during the magical ‘debrief’ sessions so beloved of MRT people generally. Since 1975, KMRT has been a family of friends - volunteers working together to provide succour to those lost or injured on the beautiful mountains in our home area. In 2012 Team Leader Billy Stitt and his Deputies; Gus Cameron, Teddy Inglis and Calum Menzies, were continuing the tradition started by Harry Lawrie and maintained by Mike Luti, Arthur McCourt, and many others - folks who over the years have freely given their time to support this worthwhile cause. The common thread uniting their efforts has been Bill Rose - a man who has served KMRT for almost forty years as the liaison point with the Police and search agencies. A veteran of many hundreds of rescues, Bill ranks amongst the most experienced MRT members in the UK. Many lost and/or injured climbers and hillwalkers are alive today as a result of his guidance and wise counsel. My grateful thanks to everyone who contributed material, also to friends who made helpful comments at the final draft stage and to Brian Petrie (www.brianpetrie.com) for his excellent illustrations. Any errors in style or grammar are mine alone. In gathering this material, a common problem has been the fickle nature of human memory.
    [Show full text]
  • Glen Finglas Management Plan 2018-2023
    Glen Finglas Glen Finglas Management Plan 2018-2023 Glen Finglas MANAGEMENT PLAN - CONTENTS PAGE ITEM Page No. Introduction Plan review and updating Woodland Management Approach Summary 1.0 Site details 2.0 Site description 2.1 Summary Description 2.2 Extended Description 3.0 Public access information 3.1 Getting there 3.2 Access / Walks 4.0 Long term policy 5.0 Key Features 5.1 Wood Pasture 5.2 Connecting People with woods & trees 6.0 Work Programme Appendix 1: Compartment descriptions Glossary MAPS Access Conservation Features Management 2 Glen Finglas THE WOODLAND TRUST INTRODUCTION PLAN REVIEW AND UPDATING The Trust¶s corporate aims and management The information presented in this Management approach guide the management of all the plan is held in a database which is continuously Trust¶s properties, and are described on Page 4. being amended and updated on our website. These determine basic management policies Consequently this printed version may quickly and methods, which apply to all sites unless become out of date, particularly in relation to the specifically stated otherwise. Such policies planned work programme and on-going include free public access; keeping local people monitoring observations. informed of major proposed work; the retention Please either consult The Woodland Trust of old trees and dead wood; and a desire for website www.woodlandtrust.org.uk or contact the management to be as unobtrusive as possible. Woodland Trust The Trust also has available Policy Statements ([email protected]) to confirm covering a variety of woodland management details of the current management programme. issues. There is a formal review of this plan every 5 The Trust¶s management plans are based on the years and a summary of monitoring results can identification of Key Features for the site and be obtained on request.
    [Show full text]
  • Callander Paths Leaflet
    Ancaster square Coilhallan Wood Upper Crags The Meadows Further Information For more information on these paths, Distance: 4.5miles (7km) Distance: 2miles (3.5km) Distance: 1.2miles (2km) and other places to visit in the area, The route starts from North Ancaster Square. The route starts at Callander Crags Car Park on The route starts in North Ancaster Square. please contact: Bracklinn Road. Turn right along Main Street then left into Forestry Commission Scotland Turn left into Main Street, then right into The path surface is a mixture of well Bridge Street. On the right before the bridge a Cowal & Trossachs Forest District South Church Street where the old metal compacted surfaces with some loose material. path leads you to the Meadows car park. The Aberfoyle, Stirlingshire FK8 3UX bridge crosses the river. path continues alongside the River Teith. Tel: 01877 382383 Follow the forest road through the barrier. The e-mail: cowal&[email protected] Web: www.forestry.gov.uk/scotland The path leads you to the road by the High path turns right, climbing steeply through This route provides a very pleasant level School. Turn right and on the other side of conifer woodlands where benches have been tarmaced riverside route with lots of wildlife. Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park placed so you can quietly enjoy the ambience (Callander Office) the road you will see two small sandstone You can feed the ducks and swans by the river 52-54 Main Street pillars at the entrance to Coilhallan Wood. of the forest. and on a clear day you will have a magnificent Callander FK17 8BD This section of the route is a mixture of view of the conical mountain Ben Ledi in the Tel: 01389 722600 well-compacted surface and forest road As you head along the top of the Crags views distance.
    [Show full text]
  • Strath Gartney, Achray and Loch Ard Forests
    STRATH GARTNEY, ACHRAY AND LOCH ARD FORESTS SPECIAL QUALITIES OF THE TROSSACHS STRATH GARTNEY, ACHRAY AND LOCH ARD FORESTS Key Features The Trossachs Duke’s Pass Queen Elizabeth Forest Park and mix of forested and wooded landscapes Lochs including Loch Katrine, Loch Arklet, Loch Venachar Glasgow Corporation Water Supply The Romantic Movement Summary of Evaluation Sense of Place This area lies just north of the Highland Boundary Fault and falls within the area known as ‘the Trossachs’. The Trossachs are a combination of lochs, woodlands and craggy slopes and summits and it is this combination which gives the area its valued sense of place/visual qualities. The inland lochs of Loch Katrine, Loch Arklet, Loch Venachar, Loch Achray, Loch Ard, Loch Drunkie and Loch Chon are important features of the area. Slopes rise directly from the loch shores to the surrounding uplands and peaks. There are areas of open upland including the peaks of Ben Ledi, Ben Vane, Ben Venue and Ben An. Settlements are small and focus on loch shores and strath floors. Part of the area is designated as the Trossachs National Scenic Area in recognition of its nationally important scenic qualities. Woodland is an important characteristic of the landscape of this area of the Park. The woods to the north of Brig O’ Turk are the only wooded upland hills in the Park. Wooded upland glens are an important characteristic of this area of the Park, representing a relatively large area of apparently natural wooded landscape. Duke’s Pass is a particularly important scenic drive and visitor destination.
    [Show full text]
  • Strathard Community Council Topic Discussion Action
    Strathard Community Council Minutes of meeting: Thursday 2nd November 2017 Aberfoyle Memorial Hall Community John Clow . Ros Dingwall Andre Goulancourt Colin Smith Councillors Michelle Colquhoun Trevor Geraghty Fiona McEwan, Fergus Wood Attending: Jeremy McDonald (Stirling Council) Toto McLellan (Min.Secretary) Michelle Flynn. (Stirling Council) 8 members of the public Topic Discussion Action 1.Opening Introductions: TG welcomed everyone to the meeting. Apologies Geraint Short, Stuart Stephen ILES Nicole Lochead from Stirling Council Sustainable Development Team gave a WasteWater presentation to the meeting on a proposal under the Innovative Local Energy Solutions Energy project (ILES) to generate energy from waste water treatment plants, in partnership with Scottish Water Horizons. The system has been piloted in Galashiels. Documentation was presented which detailed the fact that Stirling Council Area has higher than average fuel poverty, due to the high proportion of rural area with no access to urban fuel choices. Fuel poverty was identified as 10% or more of income spent on energy, 25% plus being extreme poverty. £100k has been awarded by Scottish Government for feasibility study, further funding will be sought for infrastructure and implementation of the process, which has the potential of generating 2.6GWh per year. Energy produced will be stored in fridge-sized energy retention units manufactured in Scotland which will be transported to individual premises for download to existing system, resulting in a 10% saving on gas supply, and c 40% saving on electricity. It is hoped that this innovation will encourage Contact new businesses, job creation and upskilling. It was noted that High School pupils may High School value being involved in the process.
    [Show full text]
  • Callander Landscape Capacity Study for Development Final Report March 2013
    Project Team 0 Callander Landscape Capacity Study for Development Final Report March 2013 Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority Janet Falkingham Landscape and Environmental Consultancy 1 Project Team Project Team Loch Lomond and The Trossachs National Park Authority Carrochan 20 Carrochan Road Balloch G83 8EG t: 01389 722600 email: [email protected] web: www.lochlomond-trossachs.org Callander Landscape Capacity Study for Development – Final Report Project Team 2 Project Team Douglas Harman Douglas Harman Landscape Planning 4/3D Catchpell House Carpet Lane Edinburgh EH6 6SP t: 0131 5539397 e: [email protected] Janet Falkingham Landscape and Environmental Consultancy 12/2 Morningside Gardens Janet Falkingham Edinburgh Landscape and Environmental Consultancy EH10 5LA t: 07752 082766 e: [email protected] Nigel Buchan Buchan Landscape Architecture 2 Longnewton Cottages Haddington East Lothian EH41 4JW t: 01620 811276 e: [email protected] Cover photo by Sheila Winstone©. All other photos by Janet Falkingham© unless otherwise stated. All maps reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO © Crown copyright and database right 2013. All rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number 100031883. Callander Landscape Capacity Study for Development – Final Report 3 Contents Contents Section 1: Executive Summary Page 4 Section 2: Introduction Page 8 Section 3: Strategic Context Page 10 Section 4: Detailed Survey & Analysis Page 22 Section 5: Landscape Sensitivity Analysis Page 47 Section 6: Opportunities and Constraints Analysis Page 60 Section 7: Appendices Page 69 Callander Landscape Capacity Study for Development – Final Report Section 1: Executive Summary 4 Section 1: Executive Summary This report examines the capacity of the landscape surrounding the town of Callander to accommodate a range of development types.
    [Show full text]