DOCSLIB.ORG

Jrcpe 49 1 Omahony.Pdf Version Access to the Full Text of the Published Version May Require a Subscription

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Jrcpe 49 1 Omahony.Pdf Version Access to the Full Text of the Published Version May Require a Subscription UCC Library and UCC researchers have made this item openly available. Please let us know how this has helped you. Thanks! Title Petr Skrabanek: the abominable no-man Author(s) O'Mahony, Seamus Publication date 2019-03 Original citation O'Mahony, S., 2019. Petr Skrabanek: the abominable no-man. Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh, 49(1), pp. 65-69. DOI:10.4997/JRCPE.2019.114 Type of publication Article (peer-reviewed) Link to publisher's https://www.rcpe.ac.uk/sites/default/files/jrcpe_49_1_omahony.pdf version http://dx.doi.org/10.4997/JRCPE.2019.114 Access to the full text of the published version may require a subscription. Rights © 2019 JRCPE http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ Item downloaded http://hdl.handle.net/10468/8263 from Downloaded on 2021-09-29T22:05:11Z C&W COURSES & J R Coll Physicians Edinb 2019; 49: 65–9 | doi: 10.4997/JRCPE.2019.114 PAPER WORKSHOPS Petr Skrabanek: the abominable no-man HistorySeamus O’Mahony1 & Humanities Petr Skrabanek (1940–94) was a Czech-born doctor, polemicist and literary Correspondence to: scholar. He quali ed in medicine in Ireland, and spent most of his career Seamus O’Mahony Abstract at the Medical School of Trinity College Dublin. He was an outspoken critic Gastroenterology Unit of modern medicine, particularly of what he called ‘coercive healthism’. Cork University Hospital Skrabanek’s sceptical and iconoclastic ideas are more relevant today than Wilton ever. This essay aims to rekindle interest in his life and work. Cork Ireland Keywords: environmental tobacco smoke, healthism, medicalisation, Skrabanek Email: Financial and Competing Interests: No confl ict of interests declared [email protected] Introduction and biography his sharp pen was directed at population medicine and the apostles of lifestyle – those who preached the fallacy Petr Skranabek was born on 27 October 1940 in Náchod, of cheating death … the medical community began to Czechoslovakia.1 He entered Charles University in Prague adopt him as a gadfl y who roamed the world adding zip RCPE MSc courses in 1957, taking a degree in chemistry. He then became and controversy to otherwise anodyne meetings.2 The College offers two online courses completed a researcher at the Institute for Toxicology and Forensic Medicine in Prague. In 1962, he was appointed Head of the Skrabanek attacked screening, ‘risk-factor’ epidemiology part-time over 3 years, in partnership with the Toxicology Department in the Institute for Forensic Medicine and political attempts to control the lifestyles of individuals. University of Edinburgh. at Purkynĕ University in Brno, but resigned the following He argued that medicine had lost sight of its true purpose, year to enter the medical school there. In July 1968, he namely, the relief of suffering. He died of prostate cancer went to the Richmond Hospital Dublin (with his future wife, on 21 June 1994 at the age of 53 years; his polemical MSc Critical Care @Ed_CritCare_On Vera Capková) for a summer student elective. On 21 August book The Death of Humane Medicine and the Rise of Students will learn the essentials of the clinical 1968, Skrabanek was in County Sligo visiting the grave of Coercive Healthism3 was published a few months after his management of critically unwell adults, whilst developing WB Yeats when he heard the news that the Soviet army death. In 2018, Skrabanek was posthumously awarded the expertise in accessing, interpreting and integrating the had invaded Czechoslovakia. He decided there and then prestigious Stearne medal of the Royal College of Physicians findings of clinical research into clinical care. to stay in Ireland. He continued his medical studies at the of Ireland. Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, and qualifi ed in 1970. The course is aimed at doctors, nurses and allied He spent several years training in neurology in various Skrabanek’s infl uences health professionals seeking to develop as independent Dublin hospitals. In 1975 he joined the Endocrine Oncology practitioners and future leaders of healthcare change. Research group at the Mater Hospital Dublin as a senior Skrabanek’s most obvious infl uence was Ivan Illich, whose research fellow, and became an internationally recognised polemic, Medical Nemesis was published in 1974.4 The > rcpe.ac.uk/careers-training/msc-critical-care expert in the neurotransmitter substance P. In 1984, he joined book opened with the famous accusation, ‘The medical the Department of Community Health at Trinity College Dublin, establishment has become a major threat to health’. Illich MSc Internal Medicine @internalmeded funded by a grant from the Wellcome Foundation. He forged (1926–2002) was an Austrian-born priest, historian and a close personal and professional relationship with the head social philosopher. His core idea, argued over several Complementing the syllabus for MRCP(UK), students will of that department, Professor James McCormick, and spent books, was that industrialisation and institutionalisation develop their knowledge, understanding and professional the remainder of his career there. had robbed people of their freedom and handed over control practice of internal medicine, gaining skills in advanced of fundamental aspects of human life to professions.5 patient management and preparation for future audit, During the 1980s, Skrabanek forged a reputation as a In The Death of Humane Medicine (1994), Skrabanek research and publication. polemicist and critic of medicine. His provocative essays acknowledged Illich’s infl uence, devoting much of the fi rst appeared regularly in the Lancet; Robin Fox, who edited the chapter of the book to his ideas. But he differed from Illich The course is primarily for doctors early in their careers. journal from 1990 to 1995, wrote: in a fundamental way: Skrabanek was a Humean sceptic > rcpe.ac.uk/careers-training/msc-internal-medicine who believed in the rigorous application of scientifi c method. …by the mid-1970s he was gaining attention through a Although Illich filled Medical Nemesis with voluminous series of critical and witty letters in The Lancet, addressed footnotes and scientific references, he simply did not from the endocrine unit of a Catholic hospital. Increasingly, understand or revere science, and was gullible about the 1Consultant Physician/Gastroenterologist, Gastroenterology Unit, Cork University Hospital, Cork, Ireland MARCH 2019 VOLUME 49 ISSUE 1 JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS OF EDINBURGH 65 S O’Mahony claims of alternative medicine, arguing, for example, for choose. Matters of daily living – habits, attitudes, sexuality, ‘more public support for alpha waves, encounter groups beliefs – they all become legitimate concerns of health and chiropractic’. promotionists’.3 Skrabanek’s objection to healthism was partly aesthetic. He was contemptuous of jogging and food Many of the critics of scientifi c medicine who emerged in the faddism, and observed that ‘simple minds, stupefi ed by the 1960s and 70s, such as Michel Foucault, were of the left. sterilised pap of television and the bland diet of Bowdlerised Skrabanek was unusual in that his natural political leaning culture and semi-literacy, are a fertile ground for the gospel was to a form of radical libertarianism. (The Death of Humane of new lifestyle’.3 Medicine was published by the Social Affairs Unit, a right- leaning British think tank with a strong libertarian ethos.) His Skrabanek noted that medicine had begun to shift its gaze libertarianism was formed by reading John Stuart Mill as a from the sick to the well: he called this ‘anticipatory’ medicine. student in Czechoslovakia: He distinguished this from traditional preventive medicine, which concerned itself with such matters as vaccination Mill’s concept of autonomy spells disobedience, non- and maintaining a supply of clean water. The cornerstone of compliance, rebellion. Attempts to coerce independent ‘anticipatory’ medicine is screening for disease. Skrabanek minds fail, because ‘they will infallibly rebel against the argued that there was little or no evidence of any benefi t yoke’. It was for good reason that Mill’s essay On Liberty for most forms of screening, and, furthermore, that this was banned by the communists. How eagerly it was read, ‘anticipatory’ medicine somehow managed to exempt in secretly copied typescripts, during my student years in itself from the ethical constraints that apply to traditional communist Prague!3 medicine.6 He believed that the coercion of entire populations to lead ‘healthy’ lifestyles, and to screen them for disease Skrabanek’s formative years instilled in him a life-long horror was a catastrophic error. of communism: he rebelled instinctively against any form of state intrusion into the private lives of its citizens. Medicine is not about conquering diseases and death, but about the alleviation of suffering, minimising harm, Healthism smoothing the painful journey of man to the grave. Medicine has no mandate to be meddlesome in the lives Skrabanek argued that the pursuit of ‘health’ was self- of those who do not need it.3 defeating. The medical profession, he wrote, provided the ‘theoretical underpinning of healthism – the doctrine of He argued that the ancient, almost mystical relationship lifestylism, according to which most diseases are caused by between doctor and patient was undermined by the State, unhealthy behaviour’.3 Individuals now had a moral duty to ‘which sees both the doctor and the patient as its servants’.3 maximise their health by maintaining a responsible lifestyle. Skrabanek believed that healthism fi lled the gap left by Trinity College and collaboration with religion in secular societies: James McCormick As an ersatz religion it has a wide appeal, especially Skrabanek was contemptuous of modern epidemiology, among the middle classes who have lost their links with particularly of what he called ‘riskfactorology’ or ‘black traditional culture and feel increasingly insecure in a box epidemiology’.7,8 This was an unusual position for an rapidly changing world. Healthism is embraced eagerly as academic working in a University Department of Community a path to surrogate salvation.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Family Medicine - European Edition Published on the Occasion of the 25Th Anniversary
    The World Book of Family Medicine - European Edition Published on the occasion of the 25th Anniversary of WONCA Europe Berlin, December 2020 The World Book of Family Medicine – WONCA Europe Edition 2020 First Edition 2020 (published by Stichting WONCA Europe) World Organization of Family Doctors - Europe (WONCA Europe) Polsjanski Nasip 58, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia © 2020 Stichting WONCA Europe and the Authors Stichting WONCA Europe has asserted its right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 to be identified as the author of this work. Every effort has been made to ensure that the information in this book is accurate. This does not diminish the requirement to exercise clinical judgement, and neither the publisher nor the authors can accept any responsibility for its use in practice. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. Requests for permission to reproduce or translate WONCA publications for commercial use or distribution should be addressed to the WONCA Secretariat at [email protected] The Authors remain the sole copyright owners of their contribution. Design: Carl Steylaerts Available online at https://www.woncaeurope.org/page/the-world-book-of-family-medicine-wonca-europe-edition Electronic copy: Kataložni zapis o publikaciji (CIP) pripravili v Narodni in univerzitetni knjižnici v Ljubljani COBISS.SI-ID=41339395 ISBN 978-961-07-0307-5 (epub) This book uses British English as the language for carrying thoughts. 2 The World Book of Family Medicine – WONCA Europe Edition 2020 Erika Baum, MD [email protected] Mehmet Ungan, MD [email protected] Carl Steylaerts, MD [email protected] Prologue “Conceiving of a World Book of Family Medicine is easy.
    [Show full text]
  • Petr Skrabanek: the Abominable No-Man
    C&W COURSES & J R Coll Physicians Edinb 2019; 49: 65–9 | doi: 10.4997/JRCPE.2019.114 PAPER WORKSHOPS Petr Skrabanek: the abominable no-man HistorySeamus O’Mahony1 & Humanities Petr Skrabanek (1940–94) was a Czech-born doctor, polemicist and literary Correspondence to: scholar. He quali ed in medicine in Ireland, and spent most of his career Seamus O’Mahony Abstract at the Medical School of Trinity College Dublin. He was an outspoken critic Gastroenterology Unit of modern medicine, particularly of what he called ‘coercive healthism’. Cork University Hospital Skrabanek’s sceptical and iconoclastic ideas are more relevant today than Wilton ever. This essay aims to rekindle interest in his life and work. Cork Ireland Keywords: environmental tobacco smoke, healthism, medicalisation, Skrabanek Email: Financial and Competing Interests: No confl ict of interests declared [email protected] Introduction and biography his sharp pen was directed at population medicine and the apostles of lifestyle – those who preached the fallacy Petr Skranabek was born on 27 October 1940 in Náchod, of cheating death … the medical community began to Czechoslovakia.1 He entered Charles University in Prague adopt him as a gadfl y who roamed the world adding zip RCPE MSc courses in 1957, taking a degree in chemistry. He then became and controversy to otherwise anodyne meetings.2 The College offers two online courses completed a researcher at the Institute for Toxicology and Forensic Medicine in Prague. In 1962, he was appointed Head of the Skrabanek attacked screening, ‘risk-factor’ epidemiology part-time over 3 years, in partnership with the Toxicology Department in the Institute for Forensic Medicine and political attempts to control the lifestyles of individuals.
    [Show full text]
  • The Death of Humane Medicine and the Rise of Coercive Healthism
    THE DEATH OF HUMANE MEDICINE THE DEATH OF HUMANE MEDICINE AND THE RISE OF COERCIVE HEALTHISM Petr Skrabanek THE SOCIAL AFFAIRS UNIT © The Social Affairs Unit 1994 All Rights Reserved British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A cataloguing record of this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0 907631 59 2 Reprinted 1995 (twice), 1998 TO PAUL SACHET The views expressed in this book are the author's own, not those of the Social Affairs Unit, its Trustees, Advisers or Director Book production by Crowley Esmonde Ltd Typeset by Rowland Phototypesetting Ltd, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk Printed and bound in Great Britain by St Edmundsbury Press Ltd, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk Contents The Author 7 Preface 9 Robin Fox Foreword 11 Acknowledgements 13 Part One: Healthism 1 The rise of healthism 15 2 After Illich 17 3 Before Illich 23 4 Health for sale 29 5 'Anticipatory' medicine 31 6 Unhealthy obsession with health 37 7 'Positive health' and its promotion 41 8 Green healthism 51 9 Thanatophobia and the medicalisation of death 53 Part Two: Lifestylism 1 Recipes for longevity 57 2 Fitness craze 71 3 Foodism 78 4 The wages of sin 99 5 The demon drink 111 6 Damned tobacco 119 5 DEATH OF HUMANE MEDICINE Part Three: Coercive Medicine 1 From theory to practice 137 2 Coercive altruism 139 3 The doctor as agent of the state 146 4 Totalitarian medicine 152 5 Pregnancy police 157 6 Lifestyle surveillance 161 7 The Stakhanovite worker 167 8 Genetic tyranny 171 9 The war on drugs 176 10 Autonomy 184 Notes and References 195 6 The Author Petr Skrabanek died on 21st June 1994 from an aggressive prostatic cancer at the age of fifty three.
    [Show full text]
  • False Premises, False Promises
    FALSE PREMISES FALSE PROMISES FALSE PREMISES FALSE PROMISES Selected writings of PETR SKRABANEK With an introduction by Professor George Davey Smith Tarragon Press for the Skrabanek Foundation This collection first published May 2000 ISBN 1 870781 11 2 Typeset in 10 pt Bookman by Tarragon Press, Whithorn Printed by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham CONTENTS Petr Skrabanek 1940-1994 vii Petr Skrabanek and the Limits of Epidemiology xi George Davey Smith Selected Papers of Petr Skrabanek 1 In Defence of Destructive Criticism 1 2 False Premises and False Promises of Breast Cancer Screening 11 3 Acupuncture: Past, Present and Future 29 4 Convulsive Therapy — a Critical Appraisal of its Origins and Value 53 5 From Language to Lesion 79 6 Scepticism, Irrationalism and pseudoscience 106 7 Cervical Cancer in Nuns and Prostitutes: A Plea for Scientific Continence 120 8 Provision for Research with Animals 132 9 Nonsensus Consensus 139 10 Why is preventive medicine exempted from ethical constraints ? 143 11 Risk-Factor Epidemiology: Science or Non-science ? 153 12 Smoking and Society 164 13 The Poverty of Epidemiology 178 14 The Emptiness of the Black Box 183 15 Irish traditional medicine: the foxglove ordeal and other folk 'cures' 189 16 A subversive man 204 5 PETR SKRABANEK 1940-1994 Petr was born in Nachod in Bohemia in 1940 and it was there he spent his childhood. Nachod is a provincial town but one with a lively cultural tradition. When still at school he developed a passionate interest in chemistry and in due course entered Charles University to read natural sciences. While still a student he worked as an honorary research assistant at the Institute for Toxicology and Forensic Medicine and at the remarkably young age of twenty two was appointed head of the Toxicology Department at the Institute for Forensic Medicine, Purkyne University in Brno.
    [Show full text]