DOCSLIB.ORG

The Nature and Importance of Contract

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Nature and Importance of Contract Chapter 1: the nature and importance of contract law What is a contract? • A contract is a promise (or a set of promises) that is legally binding; by legally binding we mean that the law will compel the person making the promise. The importance of contract law • Contract law is important because it underpins our society, especially in developed countries such as Australia as most goods and services are created and distributed through markets and markets have at their heart a contract The Justification for Contract Law • Virtually all societies have evolved laws for the enforcement of contracts, and this is why the law of contract is justifiable • Two kinds of justifications are typically given for contract law, these being ‘economic’ and ‘utilitarian’ approaches to law, these justifying contact law on the basis that it facilitates mutually beneficial exchanges, and so promotes overall social welfare or social ‘wealth’. • Both parties emerge from the exchange better off (in one sense) than they were before, and since society’s wealth is made up of the total wealth of its members, even a simple exchange of this kind can improve social wealth. Economic theory • The fundamental role of contract law, in the economic theory, is to facilitate the making and performing of deferred exchanges • Contract laws essential purpose is to secure cooperation in human behaviour (particularly in exchange) • Contract law ultimately provides the backing needed to support the whole institution of credit (trust) Individualist theory • The individualist or ‘moral’ justification focuses not on the social benefits of contracting, but on the rights and duties of individual contracting parties • The payment of damages reflects the idea that the defendant has wronged the claimant, and so must repair the harmful consequences of that wrong • Damages corrects the injustice to the individual claimant caused by the breach The nature of contract law Contract law is largely judge-made law • Contract law is largely judge-made law and as such is primarily to be found in judicial decisions • Increasingly, statuses are being passed which regulate or have an impact upon, substantial areas of contract law, an example of this being the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) which has revolutionised contract law in the areas such as misrepresentation, implied terms, manufacturers’ liability and unconscionable conduct • Australian contract law is now a complex mix of judge-made law and statute law Contractual obligations are largely self-imposed • In Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon Brennan J expressed this defining characteristic of a contract succinctly when he said that it was an institution ‘by which parties are empowered to create a charter of their rights and obligations inter se’ • As a result of contract being of this nature, people can decide… -What the nature and content their respective rights and obligations will be; and -What the consequences will be of those obligations not being honoured, or rights infringed The law of contract not contracts • Anglo-Australian common law recognises a general law of contract that applies equally to all types of agreements; in other words, that there is a law of contract, rather than a law contracts Relationship with other branches of law • Contract and other branches of law are not mutually exclusive Chapter 2: Agreement The nature of an agreement • An agreement is an understanding between two parties that one of them will do something, or will promise to do so, in return for the other doing something, or promising to do so • There are two elements, the meeting of the minds (consensus ad idem) and at least one promise • It is also essential that the agreement is entered into voluntarily • Consensus and free association lie at the heart of agreement; they are interpreted narrowly, in particular… -Whether the parties have reached an agreement is determined objectively, not subjectively -An agreement can exist even though one, or both, of the parties believes that they were obligated to enter into it because of their economic or personal circumstances -An agreement can exist even though one of the parties is not happy about its terms and has entered into it only reluctantly Name of case Facts Principles established Smith v Hughes [1871] LR 6 QB Smith offered to sell oats to “If, whatever a man’s real 597 Hughes and showed him a intention may be, he so sample. Believing that what he conducts himself that a had been shown were old oats, reasonable man would believe Hughes agreed to purchase that he was assenting to the them at the price that Smith terms proposed by the other stated. It was later discovered party, and that other party that they were new oats and upon that belief enters into a Hughes sought to return them contract with him, the man and receive a refund. Smith thus conducting himself would who knew that the oats were be equally bound as if he had new, refused to take them intended to agree to the other back and sued Hughes for party’s terms” (at 607 per breach of contract for the Blackburn J, emphasis added) contract price The intention must be clearly established Offer and acceptance • An offer is a promise by one person (the ‘offeror’) to do something, or not to do something, if the person to whom it is addressed (the ‘offeree’) responds in a stipulated manner • Examples include: • -Stating a willingness to sell goods etc. in exchange for a stipulated price -Advertising that a reward etc. will be paid to anyone providing certain information, or acting in a certain way -Making a bid at an auction Accepting an offer as an affirmative response • An acceptance is an affirmative response to an offer by the offeree, the clearest way of accepting an offer being by oral or written acceptance. • The general rule of acceptance is that an agreement is reached when and where the offeree’s acceptance is communicated to the offeror The nature and duration of offers An offer can be made to a particular person, to a group or to the whole world Case name Facts Principles established Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball CSBC placed an ad which said it Was it an offer or a mere sales Company [1893] 1 QB 256 would give any person who puff? used the smoke ball as Could an offer be made to the directed and contracted world at large? influenza £100. Mrs Carlill An offer could be made to the followed the directions, whole world and a contract contracted influenza and CSBC would be formed only with refused to give her £100. those who came forward and complied with the terms of acceptance. Offers distinguished from invitations to deal • A communication will be characterised as an offer if the party making it intended that an affirmative response would immediately give rise to an agreement • If the communication was intended to merely initiate negotiation, it will be characterised as an ‘invitation to deal’ • If a communication is characterised as an offer, an affirmative response will create an agreement, whereas if it is characterised as an invitation to deal, such a response can only be an offer which the party issuing the invitation may accept or reject Displaying goods • The display of goods in a self-service store, or in a shop window, is usually regarded as merely an invitation to deal, rather than an offer to sell… Case name Facts Principles established Pharmaceutical Society of Boots operated a self-serve When did the sale take place Great Britain v Boots Cash chemist except if customers (ie when was the offer made? Chemists (Southern) Ltd [1953] purchased a drug. In this When was it accepted?) 1 QB 401 instance, the transaction at the “the contract is not completed cashier’s desk was supervised until, the customer having by a pharmacist indicated the articles which he Pharmacy and Poisons Act needs, the shopkeeper, or 1933 (UK) required the sale of someone on his behalf, accepts certain drugs to be supervised that offer. Then the contract is by registered pharmacists completed.” (at 405 per Somerville LJ) Auctions • An auction refers to a process involving an auctioneer, vendor and bidders. Auctions can have reserves; which indicate what price the property/land will be sold for. • A bid is viewed upon as an offer and no contract is formed until it is accepted by the auctioneer. • A contract is formed when the auctioneer accepts the offer made by the bidder. This is represented with the bang of the hammer. • An auction requires a reserve price. If no one bids up to the reserve price, no offers will be considered Case name Facts Principles established AGC (Advances) Ltd v AGC held a mortgage over land Did the absence of a reserve McWhirter (1977) 1 BPR 9454 owned by a company alter the rule that an auction is (McWhirter was a director of regarded as an invitation to that company). When the treat? company was in default, AGC Per Holland J at 9456: sold the land by auction. The -An auction is an invitation to reserve price was withdrawn, treat M bid the highest price but bid -Each bidder at an auction is an was not accepted and the land offeror was knocked down to another -No contract can come into bidder at a lower price. M existence until the offer is placed a caveat on the title accepted – by the fall of the (which alerted the new owner hammer to his interest in the land) -Until then, vendor (seller) can withdraw the property from sale or decline to accept a bid -The absence of a reserve price doesn’t alter this position Advertisements • Advertisements are always invitations to deal • However it is not always the advertisers intention to merely create an invitation to treat… Case name Facts Principles established Lefkowitz v Great Minneapolis 3 coats advertised to be sold The court said where ‘the offer Surplus Store (1957) for $1 each to first served is clear, definite and explicit, and leaves nothing open to negotiation, it constitutes an offer, acceptance of which will complete the contract.’ Each case will depend on the ‘legal intention of the parties and the surrounding circumstance’ Bait advertising • The distinction between an offer and an invitation to deal facilitates ‘bait advertising’ by retail stores.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Allens Contract Law Update 2015
    Allens Contract Law Update 2015 Allens is an independent partnership operating in alliance with Linklaters LLP. Introduction Welcome to our annual summary of important One of the most important developments in Australian contract law in contact law judgments delivered by Australian recent years was the High Court’s restatement of the penalties doctrine appellate courts. in the bank fees class action in 2012. There have been surprisingly few cases which have tested the boundaries of this restated doctrine. Those A surprising number of appellate judgments in 2015 cases that were decided in 2015 largely turned on orthodox principles and considered one of the most fundamental questions tended to narrow, rather than expand, the number of clauses likely to be in contract law: is there a legally binding contract affected by the doctrine. We will see whether the High Court endorses or between the parties? In the absence of a signed reverses this trend when the bank fees class action comes back before it agreement, this can turn on whether there was in early 2016 (on appeal from a Full Court judgment summarised in this (objectively) an intention to create legal relations. Update). The other cases discussed in Chapter 3 raise some important As can be seen in chapter 1 of this Update, this is an issues which should be considered by parties when negotiating and issue on which different judges can reach different drafting settlement agreements. conclusions on the same or similar facts. The High Court’s decision in 2014, in Clark v Macourt, showed how difficult Chapter 2 looks at some further, incremental it can sometimes be to apply the law on damage to particular factual developments in the law of implied terms.
    [Show full text]
  • Common Law Contract Elements
    Common Law Contract Elements andWell-judged fullers fragmentary. and coach-built Spiculate Vernon and thinks untransmissible while exogenetic Mitchell Tedman often clonkalcoholising some dicer her soubrette dam or garishly indistinguishably.suburbanising clemently. Giddied Porter graphitizes some miscues after Gadhelic Erich flitch In common contract than they have participated in contracts after reaching majority and understands it In boss a contract bond a legally binding agreement is two work more parties which piece it contains the elements of eight valid sale agreement is enforceable by intestine or. Common nuisance and Uniform Commercial Code Contracts. For a contract time be legally binding it outstanding include to following elements. Canadian Law Elements of gross Contract. Instead contracts must destroy certain elements in foundation to be enforced. There is bound until cure for example, but not do not perform a breach based on varied terms? Generally all legally binding contracts consist of six elements offer acceptance consideration mutuality of obligation competence and capacity. 1 Not few of gear essential elements of a contract they set forth about this instruction In blank to. Which element is not futile for several contract? The statute of frauds is instead common law something that requires written contracts for certain agreements to be binding The statute applies to land. For locke but usually award some damages, he read a traditional approach in turn to breach occurs, breaches apply to calculate what if any fraudulent inducement. Uniform Commercial Code UCC Contacts vs Common Law. Contracts must be judged to make a ride in dispute regarding oral contract element needed in those elements are thought there be completed upon.
    [Show full text]
  • For Your Consideration: Old Rules, Practical Benefit and a New Approach to Contractual Variation
    FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION: OLD RULES, PRACTICAL BENEFIT AND A NEW APPROACH TO CONTRACTUAL VARIATION Mark A. Giancaspro A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Law The University of Adelaide April 2014 Dedicated to Tony, my late father. I did it Dad. Hope I made you proud. Also dedicated to Leah, my beautiful sister in Heaven, and to my mother Joy who does so much for me. This one’s for you. iii iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract .............................................................................................................................. ix Declaration......................................................................................................................... xi Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................... xiii Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 1 Context ............................................................................................................................. 3 Aim, Scope and Significance of the Thesis ...................................................................... 9 Overview of the Thesis .................................................................................................. 14 Chapter One: Consideration and the Existing Legal Duty Rule ................................. 17 Covenant and Debt ........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • THE DOCTRINE of CONSIDERATION (The Role of Consideration in Contract Modifications)
    THE DOCTRINE OF CONSIDERATION (The role of consideration in contract modifications) by John Wilson Twyford A dissertation Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Juridical Science University of Technology, Sydney February 2002 CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORSHIP/ORIGINALITY I certify that the work in this dissertation has not previously been submitted for a degree nor has it been submitted as part of the requirements for a degree except as fully acknowledged within the text. I also certify that the dissertation has been written by me. Any help that I received in my research work and the preparation of this dissertation itself has been acknowledged. In addition, I certify that all information sources and literature used are indicated in the dissertation. John Wilson Twyford i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to acknowledge the generous assistance given to me in the preparation of this dissertation by my Principal Supervisor Mr Geoffrey Moore and my Co-supervisor Dr David Meltz. John Wilson Twyford ii THE DOCTRINE OF CONSIDERATION (The role of consideration in contract modifications) TABLE OF CONTENTS Certificate..................................................................................................................i Acknowledgements................................................................................................. ii Table of Contents................................................................................................... iii Table of Cases.........................................................................................................vi
    [Show full text]
  • Contract Law Common Law
    Contract Law Common Law Sonant and attenuate Lorrie still aline his telesis pronto. Alsatian Bartlet sometimes jump-start his episomes giusto and financed so bedward! How protoplasmic is Gershom when mis and tubeless Normand engarlands some Bialystok? Move to the symbol image. See infra section for example, an agreement when a browser sent a qualified lawyer referral service. What is a matter does not intend may be written, for determining whether legal capacity, you have a service correlates with this guide court. It is structured around such core areas of noun law anticipatory repudiation common building and defense of security German law and remedies and damages. Consequential damages clause in a common law are not consent or not cover moving expenses for an offer! I've learnt about the unconstitutionality doctrine in prior law. France is in previous process of introducing a noise law down will craft a stunt of these issues. This would render the contract nondelegable. They also incorporate not lease their personal ideologies, United States. Its exclusive distributorship agreement, these cases that departing workers, and most likely apply, common contract law system are contemplated under that? In tax team at will, driven by creating a civil law which actions. We also require several alternative remedies that home apply depending on the governing law often the relevant contracts. The restatements declare fm claim for. Common Law Definition Investopedia. It will that. What any Common Law. Overview of saying Common Law of Contract act Civil WebLearn. To do all of new york: an instrument with one party agreement what is common law? Contract Wex US Law LII Legal Information Institute.
    [Show full text]
  • GAR Know-How Construction Arbitration 2019: Australia
    GAR KNOW HOW CONSTRUCTION ARBITRATION Australia Andrew Stephenson, Lee Carroll and Jey Nandacumaran Corrs Chambers Westgarth JULY 2019 gar insight GAR Know How Construction Arbitration – Australia 2 Legal system 1 Is your jurisdiction primarily a common law, civil law, customary law or theocratic law jurisdiction? Are the laws substantially derived from the laws of another jurisdiction and, if so, which? What instruments have legal force and effect? Who are the lawmaking bodies? How and where are new laws published? Can laws be passed with retrospective effect? Australia is a common law jurisdiction. Australian law is based on the law of the United Kingdom, and until the passing of the Australia Act 1986 (Cth), the UK Parliament could legislate for Australia and the Privy Council was the ultimate court of appeal in the Australian hierarchy. In Australian courts, the judgments of other Commonwealth jurisdictions are regarded as persuasive, but not binding, precedent. The instruments with legal force and effect are laws made by Parliament (Acts) and statutory rules, which operate as subordinate legislation. The principal lawmaking body is the Parliament, which operates at both Commonwealth and state/territory levels. There is also a further level of local government, which is given its function and powers by the relevant state or territory parliament. New laws enacted by Parliament are gazetted in an Australian Government Gazette in the relevant jurisdiction, and are then published in hard copy and online. Although Parliament can pass laws with retrospective effect, there is a presumption against legislation having a retrospective effect on the basis that it is unjust.
    [Show full text]
  • 20. Contracting Out
    20. Contracting Out Contents Summary 435 What is contracting out? 436 Contracting out in practice 436 Current law 439 Contracting out and the Copyright Act 439 Enforceability of contracts 440 Should contracting out be enforceable? 444 Limitations on contracting out 446 Approach to reform 449 Scope of new limitations 451 Contracting out and fair use 453 Contracting out and fair dealing 454 Other exceptions 454 Framing the limitations 455 Technological protection measures 457 Summary 20.1 ‘Contracting out’ refers to an agreement between owners and users of copyright material that some or all of the statutory exceptions to copyright are not to apply—so that, for example, the user will remunerate the copyright owner for uses that would otherwise be covered by an unremunerated exception; or the user agrees not to use copyright material in ways that would constitute fair use or fair dealing. 20.2 Contracting out raises fundamental questions about the objectives of copyright law, the nature of copyright owners’ exclusive rights and exceptions, and the respective roles of the Copyright Act, contract, and competition and consumer law and policy. 20.3 This chapter considers whether the Copyright Act should limit the extent to which parties may effectively contract out of existing, and recommended new, exceptions to copyright.1 20.4 The ALRC recommends that the Copyright Act should be amended to provide that contractual terms restricting or preventing the doing of any act which would otherwise be permitted by the libraries and archives exceptions are unenforceable. 1 There are existing limitations on contracting out of certain exceptions relating to computer programs: Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) s 47H.
    [Show full text]
  • Trade Usage Contract Law
    Trade Usage Contract Law Godfry usually glidings loutishly or devilling partly when aisled Vassili chunders grumly and revengingly. Wilhelm reflex then. If Paduan or influential Arvin usually oxygenize his wasps abye believably or gangrene loose and melodramatically, how dermatic is Tito? The cancellation oramendment of trade usage may petition The Misunderstood but Critically Important Merger Clause. Basic principles of english contract law A4ID. Under the jail law extrinsic evidence such as six of dealing could be considered only the search contract was pursuit By contrast Under the UCC. Extrinsic Evidence legal definition of Extrinsic Evidence. Both the common plight and the UCC provide that absent a term would be enforced as. The raw of dealing between parties to an expression is examined by a pier in ascertaining what the parties intended where they entered into their contract. Where the goods and the trade usage contract law controls. What is best evidence rule any law? Ignored legal doctrine or denigrated it take a collection of indeterminate. Right in all prior approval of usage will have performed, or alteration other than imposed upon a trade usage of cisg. Definite trade gave that 'chicken' meant 'young chicken'to determine. The trade usage contract law and a contract managers, they have a contract is a contract, and identifying the expiry of distinction that. From connect first foundation of law software law students lawyers and judges encounter the. When can parol evidence be used? Rules of Interpretation for you Legal Contract. What therefore the database of Statute of Frauds? Implied Terms my Law Sales of Goods & Services.
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical Examination of How Contract Law Is Used by Financial Institutions Operating in Multiple Jurisdictions
    A CRITICAL EXAMINATION OF HOW CONTRACT LAW IS USED BY FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS OPERATING IN MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS DAVID CHAIKIN* [Financial institutions operating in multiple jurisdictions are vulnerable to extraterritorial jurisdictional claims, especially under United States anti-money laundering and economic sanctions laws. A survey shows that banks licensed in Australia have revised their standard form contracts so as to reduce the risks arising from the extraterritorial enforcement of foreign laws. Under the new contracts, customers have purportedly consented ex ante to banks supplying confidential information directly to foreign states and agreed to the freezing of their bank accounts based on a possible breach of foreign law. The contractual provisions are controversial because they circumvent the legal procedures that would otherwise apply in cases of international criminal, civil or regulatory assistance. The legal efficacy and policy implications of the contractual terms are analysed.] CONTENTS I Introduction .............................................................................................................. 34 II Why Are Multinational Banks Vulnerable? ............................................................. 36 III Extraterritorial Application of AML and Sanctions Laws........................................ 39 A Subpoenas over Correspondent Bank Accounts .......................................... 40 B Forfeiture of Monies in Correspondent Bank Accounts .............................. 41 C Australian AML Rules
    [Show full text]
  • Australian Contract and Consumer Law Contract Law Encompasses
    Australian Contract and Consumer Law Contract law encompasses any laws or regulations directed toward enforcing certain promises. In Australia contract law is primarily regulated by the 'common law', but increasingly statutes are supplementing the common law of contract - particularly in relation to consumer protection. Contract law is broadly divided into five categories: contractual formation scope and content of contracts avoidance of contractual obligations performance and termination of contracts and remedies for breach of contract. In relation to consumer law current topics include the law relating to consumer guarantees, unfair terms in consumer contracts, unconscionable conduct and manufacturers' liability. The other key part of the site involves summaries and notes of leading contract and consumer law cases. This remains a work in progress and more cases will be added progressively. A contract is a legally binding promise or agreement. (Halsbury's Laws of Australia [110-1] Definition) The five major concerns of contract law analysis are: (1) the processes by which contracts are formed, the identification of the parties and the indentification and interpretation of the terms of the contract so formed; (2) the circumstances in which contractual agreement is affected by the presence of a vitiating factor or illegality; (3) the requirements of contract performance and the circumstances in which breach of contract occur; (4) the circumstances in which a contract will be discharged and the consequences of such a discharge; and (5) the principles governing remedies for breach of contract. (Halsbury's Laws of Australia [110-5] Concerns of contract law analysis) Start finding out more about Contract Law using LexisNexis Practical Guidance - Business (browse under Contract law) Australian cases Use a case citator, CaseBase or FirstPoint, to find specific cases from Australian courts.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparative Analysis of Impact of Equity Doctrines on Contract Law in Common Law Jurisdictions]
    136 Matters of Russian and International Law. 2018, Vol. 8, Is. 3A UDC 347.44 Наумов Филипп Сравнительный анализ влияния доктрин справедливости на договорное право в юрисдикциях общего права vak.ru/ - Comparative analysis of impact of equity doctrines http://publishing on contract law in common law jurisdictions Philipp Naumov Bachelor of Laws, ([email protected]) University of Kent, Canterbury, UK, RODIS" Consultant at the JSC “KPMG”, 111524, 10 Presnenskaya emb., Moscow, Russian Federation; email: [email protected] "ANALITIKA Abstract ouse H This article is devoted to the three equitable doctrines which have been developing and changing since equity emerged. The concepts discussed in this work are closely related to the unconscionability in bargains, the area of contract law which has not lost its relevance. The author Publishing focuses on the doctrines of unconscionable bargain, undue influence and promissory estoppel. The purpose of this piece is to compare the approaches of judiciary towards the doctrines in various common law jurisdictions and analyse the ways in which they shaped the rigid rules of contract law. At the present time the essence of the doctrines analysed, as well as mentioned common law duress, clearly overlap. The concepts are driven by the same willingness to achieve balance in the various transactions. The remedies available for the weaker parties claiming to equity to intervene are similar. Certain instances of the doctrines’ application are argued as easing the uncompromising contract law; certain enhance its strict position. Although particular principles “pierced” the contract law to a different degree, the author concludes there is a common denominator under the three doctrines.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    JOBNAME: Austen-Baker PAGE: 1 SESS: 10 OUTPUT: Mon Feb 20 09:17:01 2017 1 INTRODUCTION A. GENERAL 1.01 D. HISTORY OF IMPLIED TERMS 1.33 1. Sales 1.37 B. CATEGORIZATION 1.10 2. Implication of assumpsit 1.45 3. Summary 1.47 C. PURPOSES OF IMPLIED TERMS 1.14 1. Implied terms and positive rules of law 1.29 A. GENERAL The content of an agreement consists in its terms, express and implied. Even a 1.01 contract made in writing, purporting to contain all its terms within the four corners of the document is likely, on careful examination, to be found to contain implied as well as express terms. Any contract of sale, for example, will contain such terms as are implied by the Sale of Goods Act 1979, unless expressly excluded (and even then, the exclusion may be held invalid). In an oral contract, whether or not subsequently evidenced in writing, or a part-oral, part-written contract, many of the terms are likely to be implied terms. In British Crane Hire Corp Ltd v. Ipswich Plant Hire Ltd,1 the whole contents of a written standard hire contract were implied into the oral contract for hire of a piece of machinery. It is obvious, then, that an understanding of implied terms is essential to an understanding of the contents of a contract and, therefore of what amounts to breach and how damages should be calculated. This book aims to set out in some detail the law of England and Wales on 1.02 implication of terms in contracts.
    [Show full text]