Performance Analysis of Cellular Networks with Opportunistic Scheduling Using Queueing Theory and Stochastic Geometry Bartlomiej Blaszczyszyn, Mohamed Kadhem Karray
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Performance analysis of cellular networks with opportunistic scheduling using queueing theory and stochastic geometry Bartlomiej Blaszczyszyn, Mohamed Kadhem Karray To cite this version: Bartlomiej Blaszczyszyn, Mohamed Kadhem Karray. Performance analysis of cellular networks with opportunistic scheduling using queueing theory and stochastic geometry. IEEE Transactions on Wire- less Communications, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, 2019, 18 (12), pp.5952-5966. 10.1109/TWC.2019.2940938. hal-01824986v2 HAL Id: hal-01824986 https://hal.inria.fr/hal-01824986v2 Submitted on 9 Sep 2019 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. 1 Performance analysis of cellular networks with opportunistic scheduling using queueing theory and stochastic geometry Bartłomiej Błaszczyszyn∗y and Mohamed Kadhem Karrayz Member, IEEE ∗Inria-ENS, 23 Avenue d’Italie, 75214 Paris, FRANCE; Email: [email protected] y DI-ENS, CNRS, Inira, PSL Research University, Paris, France z Orange Labs, 44 avenue de la Rpublique, 92320 Chatillon,ˆ FRANCE; Email: [email protected] network stations. These queues are related to each other via Abstract—Combining stochastic geometric approach with some some system of cell-load equations capturing the dependence classical results from queueing theory regarding generalized caused by the extra-cell interference, and bridging the spatial processor sharing queues, in this paper we extend the syn- thetic framework for the performance study of large cellular analysis of the SINR distribution of the typical user and networks, previously proposed in [1,2], by allowing it to take the temporal analysis of the load of the typical cell of the into account opportunistic scheduling. Rapid and verifiable with network. Among principal metrics studied via the cell-load respect to real data, our approach is particularly useful for equations are cell loads (defined as the fraction of time the network dimensioning and long term economic planning. It is station is busy), mean number of users and their throughput based on a detailed network model combining an information- theoretic representation of the link layer, a queueing-theoretic at individual network cells. Following [2], we also propose representation of the users’ scheduler, and a stochastic-geometric an efficient Gaussian approximate model for the rapid study representation of the signal propagation and the network cells. It of the spatial distribution of these metrics across the network. allows one to evaluate principal characteristics of the individual The study of our synthetic model involves only simulations cells, such as loads the mean number of users and the user of the point process of base stations and the shadowing field throughput. A simplified, Gaussian approximate model is also proposed to facilitate study of the spatial distribution of these to estimate the expectations of some stochastic geometric metrics across the network. Using of both models requires functionals not admitting explicit expressions. All lower level only simulations of the point process of base stations and the performance characteristics, involving the link layer and the shadowing field to estimate the expectations of some stochastic- opportunistic scheduler admit explicit expressions and need geometric functionals not admitting explicit expressions. A key not be estimated by simulations. This approach allows one for observation of our approach, bridging spatial and temporal analysis, relates the SINR distribution of the typical user to the a rapid and verifiable with respect to real data evaluation of the load of the typical cell of the network. The former is a static impact of the opportunistic scheduling on the global network characteristic of the network related to its spectral efficiency performance. It is particularly useful for network dimensioning while the latter characterizes the performance of the (generalized) and long term economic planning. processor sharing queue serving the dynamic population of users of this cell. Index Terms—user-throughput, traffic demand, cell-load equa- tions, cellular network, opportunistic scheduling, typical cell, A. Contributions queueing theory, point process, ergodicity, Palm theory, Little’s law, measurements This paper contributes to the development of the synthetic framework for the performance study of large cellular net- I. INTRODUCTION works previously proposed in [1,2]. The contribution consists in using generalized processor sharing queues in the medium Motivated by the increasing traffic in commercial cellular access layer to model opportunistic scheduling implemented networks featuring opportunistic scheduling policies, in this in operational networks. Previously considered model assumes paper we propose a synthetic model, based on queueing round-robin scheduling. This contribution, summarized in theory and stochastic geometry, allowing one to evaluate Proposition2, implies revisiting of Proposition3, providing performance of such networks by some static simulations, the mean characteristics of the main stochastic geometric with a particular focus on the variability of the quality of model, as well as the extension of some analytic and numerical service characteristics across the network. We build on our results (these latter formulated as Observations) justifying the previous work [1,2], where a network evaluation model has Gaussian approximate model (Observation2, Proposition6, been proposed, assuming a homogeneous space-time Poisson Proposition7, Observation3). A special effort is made to process of call arrivals served by a spatially stationary cellular validate the proposed extension with respect to the real data network, with processor sharing queue models operating at all collected in a reference 4G network featuring opportunistic This paper reports the results of a research undertaken under the contract scheduling, at the level of individual cells (Observation1) and CRE No G10192 between Inria and Orange. at the network level (Observation4). 2 B. Paper organization More recently and in a different context, [25] leverages The remaining part of the paper is organized as follows. We stochastic geometric and queueing theoretic techniques to complete our introduction by discussing in Section I-C some investigate the performance of some cooperative communica- related work. The detailed model is described in SectionII. tions in decentralized wireless networks. In [26] the uplink Theoretical analysis of this model and a Gaussian approximate of K-tier heterogeneous networks is studied using M/G/1 model is presented in Section III. Our numerical study, includ- queueing model in stochastic geometric setting. Delays in the ing validation of the Gaussian approximate model with respect heterogeneous cellular networks with spatio-temporal random to the detailed model and with respect to real data is presented arrival of traffic are studied in [27]. The authors of [28] in SectionIV. We recapitulate our work in SectionV. investigate interference, queueing delay and network through- put in interference-limited networks while taking into account C. Related work diverse QoS requirements. These theoretical works have not yet been compared to real data. A large amount of literature has emerged on the perfor- Our study features in particular realistic evaluation of the mance analysis of cellular networks; a complete review falls opportunistic scheduler and the spatial variability of the quality out of the reach of this paper. In what follows we mention of service across the networks. In what follows we comment only some works that we found most relevant. on some previous work in this matter. a) Pure simulation approach: Many network operators d) Opportunistic schedulling: and other actors develop complex and time consuming simu- It leverages an inherent lation tools such as those developed by the industrial contribu- diversity of wireless networks provided by independently time- tors to 3GPP (3rd Generation Partnership Project)[3]. There varying channels across the different users. The benefit of are many other simulation tools such as TelematicsLab LTE- this diversity is exploited by scheduling transmissions to users Sim [4], University of Vienna LTE simulator [5,6] and LENA when their instantaneous channel quality is near its best values. tool [7,8] of CTTC, which are not necessarily compliant The diversity gain increases with the dynamic range of the with 3GPP. Our approach requires only static simulations to fluctuations; it can be improved by some dynamic beamform- estimate some stochastic geometric expectations with all lower ing [29] in environments with little scattering and/or slow level performance characteristics admitting explicit expres- fading. Specific opportunistic schedulers for wireless systems sions. This makes it significantly more rapid. have been proposed and studied for some thirty years. There b) Analytic approach: Most of the analytic studies of is a large number of papers available that propose different the performance of