Planning Board Minutes

PLANNING BOARD MEETING 1 APRIL 20, 2017 In compliance with the Open Public Meetings Act of the State of New Jersey adequate notice of this meeting has been mailed to The Daily Record, Mount Olive Chronicle, and posted at the municipal building and on the township website. ROLL CALL: Members Present: Joe Fleischner, Brian Schaechter, John Mania, John Batsch, Howie Weiss Members Excused: Ken Forlenza, Kim Mott, Henry Fastert, Dan Nelsen, Carl Mase, Joseph Ouimet Professionals Attending: Chuck McGroarty, Planning Consultant; Eugene Buczynski, Township Engineer, Scott Eveland, Esq., Catherine Natafalusy, Planning Administrator/Secretary Professionals Excused: Edward Buzak, Esq. MR. WEISS: Thank you. Before we get into the agenda tonight, I have one announcement. Application Number PB 16‐34, Manjit Singh Bajwah has been carried and will not be heard tonight. It was carried till June 8th, 2017. There will be no further notice. That application will not be heard tonight. If you are here for that application, it will certainly not be heard tonight. Next item on our agenda is Approval… MS. NATAFALUSY: Mr. Chairman, we also got a letter from Mr. Sposaro granting us an extension thru the end of June with the application. MR. WEISS: It expired when? MS. NATAFALUSY: May 10th. MR. WEISS: Ok. MS. NATAFALUSY: So, the board is ok with that extension? MR. WEISS: Yes, of course, we don’t have much of a choice on that one. MS. NATAFALUSY: Right. MR. WEISS: Ok, so we’ll hear that and that’s going to be the only thing heard on June 8th, correct? MS. NATAFALUSY: Correct. MR. WEISS: So far, nothing else on the agenda. MS. NATAFALUSY: We are not putting…we are totally giving them the night. MR. WEISS: Fair enough, that’s the right thing to do. APROVAL OF MINUTES DECEMBER 15, 2016 PUBLIC MEETING MR. WEISS: Approval of minutes, December 15, 2016, you’ve gotten a copy of that in advance. Does anybody have any comments or questions? John, would you like to make a motion, John Batsch? MR. BATSCH: Yes, I’ll make a motion to approve minutes of December 15th. MR. WEISS: Thank you, John. Joe, second? MR. FLEISCHNER: Second. MR. WEISS: Comments, questions? Catherine, roll call. PLANNING BOARD MEETING 2 APRIL 20, 2017 ROLL CALL: Joe Fleischner ‐ yes Brian Schaechter ‐ yes John Batsch ‐ yes Howie Weiss ‐ yes RESOLUTION PB 16‐32, JR BON‐1, LLC, BLOCK 8300, LOT 6 MR. WEISS: We have a bunch of resolutions on the agenda. Let’s skip the first one for now because there will be some conversation. We are going to jump over to PB 16‐32, JR‐Bon 1, LLC. Somebody please make a motion. MR. SCHAECHTER: I’ll make the motion to move PB 16‐32, JR Bon‐1, LLC. MR. WEISS: Thank you, Brian. MR. FLEISCHNER: I’ll second it. MR. WEISS: Joe seconded it. Any comments, conversations? Scott, just to confirm there are no changes on this. MR. EVELAND: No, there’s been no changes or revisions. INAUDIBLE MR. EVELAND: Yes, they were…on the last agenda that we had ended up carrying so these are the same ones. MR. WEISS: I just wanted to make sure that the time between that and now, there has been no conversation that required a change. So the copy I have will be the official copy. Catherine, roll call. ROLL CALL: Joe Fleischner ‐ yes Brian Schaechter ‐ yes John Batsch ‐ yes Howie Weiss ‐ yes RESOLUTION PB 11‐35, ELEVENTH HOUR RESCUE, BLOCK 8301, LOTS 11 & 12 MR. WEISS: Next resolution, PB 11‐35, Eleventh Hour Rescue. Joe? MR. FLEISCHNER: I move we approve PB 11‐35, Eleventh Hour Rescue. MR. SCHAECHTER: I’ll second that. MR. WEISS: Thank you, Joe. And thank you, Brian. Any conversation? Seeing none. Scott same thing. MR. EVELAND: Same thing, yes. No changes. MR. WEISS: Ok, motion made and seconded. Catherine, roll call. ROLL CALL: Joe Fleischner ‐ yes Brian Schaechter ‐ yes John Batsch ‐ yes Howie Weiss ‐ yes PLANNING BOARD MEETING 3 APRIL 20, 2017 RESOLUTION PB 15‐23, NOVAKY, BLOCK 2603, BLOCKS 1 & 4 MR. WEISS: Next resolution is PB 15‐23, Todd Novaky, Brian, would you move that please. MR. SCHAECHTER: Sure, I would like to move PB 15‐23, Todd C. Novaky. MR. WEISS: Thank you. MR. BATSCH: I second. MR. WEISS: Thank you, John. Any comments, questions? And I’m sure there are no changes there. Scott? MR. EVELAND: No. MR. WEISS: Catherine, roll call. ROLL CALL: Joe Fleischner ‐ yes Brian Schaechter ‐ yes John Batsch ‐ yes Howie Weiss ‐ yes RESOLUTION PB 17‐01, MINHSON NGUYEN, BLOCK 7610, LOT 18 MR. WEISS: We have resolution for PB 17‐02, Minhson Nguyen. Joe, would you move that please. MR. FLEISCHNER: I move we approve PB 17‐02, Minhson Nguyen. MR. MANIA: I’ll second it. MR. WEISS: Thank you, Joe and John. I have a question though in the copy I have, it says Application 17‐01. Is it 01 or 02? MS. NATAFALUSY: It should be 01. That’s the first application this year. MR. WEISS: Ok, the resolution that I have is correct then, it’s typed wrong on the agenda then. Just…is everyone ok with that? Now that the application number is correct it’s 17‐01. MS. NATAFALUSY: Yes. MR. WEISS: Ok. MR. FLEISCHNER: So noted. MR. WEISS: Thank you, Joe. It’s noted that it’s correct on the document that we are going approve or not approve. Motion made and seconded. Catherine, roll call. ROLL CALL: Joe Fleischner ‐ yes Brian Schaechter ‐ yes John Mania ‐ yes Howie Weiss ‐ yes PLANNING BOARD MEETING 4 APRIL 20, 2017 RESOLUTION PB 16‐33 NEW CINGULAR, BLOCK 7500, LOT 6 MR. WEISS: And we have PB 16‐33, New Cingular Wireless, it’s an amended resolution. MR. EVELAND: We are going to have to hear testimony on that one first. So, we are going to need to hear testimony because there was some amendments that they wanted to make to it subsequent to when we do the memorializing resolution so what they’re going to do is come back…either they are going to come on, present their engineer’s testimony as to what the amendments were that basically reflect what was approved previously. They went back to the previous approval but they are going to put on the record exactly what was done. Mr. Buczynski is going to…you know…go through and ask any questions that have to do with that so we have a clear record on that. What’s been prepared for you is an amended resolution. Amended that’s based upon what I think they’re going to be testifying to today in terms of the changes after discussions with their attorney. So that’s what we have and we’ll go through that after… MR. WEISS: So we don’t have to memorialize what we did the first time before we changed the resolution? MR. EVELAND: No, no, so… MR. WEISS: Ok, I’ll take your advice… MR. EVELAND: We’re going to do the amended…we are going to have them put testimony on tonight and then we’re going to amend it. MR. WEISS: And then we’ll approve or not this resolution? MR. EVELAND: Yes, that’s correct. RESOLUTION PB 16‐13, EYE SPY (DENIAL), BLOCK 102, LOT 5 MR. WEISS: Ok, so let’s jump back up to our Eye Spy resolution PB 16‐13. Eye Spy Media denial. Joe, will you please make a motion? MR. FLEISCHNER: Before we do that, Catherine, there was a…could you hand out the revised…inaudible…please? MR. EVELAND: What you have are in black line so that the revisions that we made just recently and they are highlighted for you what those revisions were based upon…discussions that I had with Mr. McGroarty, Mr. Weiss, and so there was some other revisions that we made in there and also I just want to put on the record that Mr. McGroarty had another revision on Page 5, in paragraph 14, it’s about the 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8, about the 9th line down where it refers to 16 existing billboards, you see that in the middle of the paragraph? That’s going to be revised when the motion comes around to say due to the fact that there are 16 existing billboards along the five mile length of Route 46 in the Budd Lake area…ok, it will be stricken within a distance of approximately five miles…that portion will be stricken in order to reflect more accurately what Mr. McGroarty’s testimony was that night. MR. FLEISCHNER: Ok, with that said, thank you. I move that resolution PB 16‐13 Eye Spy Media resolution be moved forward for denial. MR. WEISS: Brian? MR. SCHAECHTER: I second that. MR. EVELAND: Therefore a yes vote will be for denial. MR. FLEISCHNER: Yes vote will be for denial. MR. WEISS: So, perhaps we should review this? Scott, would you like to spend the time, there’s been some changes and I know that there’s been just a lot of communication back and forth as PLANNING BOARD MEETING 5 APRIL 20, 2017 to the other copies that we had so some of the changes were…were kind of late and of course Chuck’s addition was this evening. So, Scott why don’t you walk us through some of the things that… MR. EVELAND: In Page 2 was more just stylistic things after I…we went back and starting reviewing them of course it always opens up whatever I start looking at something again, I just make a couple of stylistic revisions that were there on that.

Load more