What Is the Electron?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
What is the Electron? Edited by Volodimir Simulik Apeiron Montreal Published by C. Roy Keys Inc. 4405, rue St-Dominique Montreal, Quebec H2W 2B2 Canada http://redshift.vif.com © C. Roy Keys Inc. 2005 First Published 2005 Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication What is the electron? / edited by Volodimir Simulik. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0-9732911-2-5 1. Electrons. I. Simulik, Volodimir, 1957- QC793.5.E62W48 2005 539.7'2112 C2005-902252-3 Cover design by François Reeves. Cover graphic by Gordon Willliams. Table of Contents Preface ................................................................................................. i Jaime Keller – A Comprehensive Theory of the Electron from START.................................................................................... 1 Hidezumi Terazawa – The Electron in the Unified Composite Model of All Fundamental Particles and Forces .................. 29 Thomas E. Phipps, Jr. – Prospects for the Point Electron ................ 43 Martin Rivas – The Spinning Electron ............................................. 59 Claude Daviau – Relativistic Wave Equations, Clifford Algebras and Orthogonal Gauge Groups.............................. 83 H. Sallhofer – What is the Electron? .............................................. 101 Volodimir Simulik – The Electron as a System of Classical Electromagnetic and Scalar Fields...................................... 105 Malcolm H. Mac Gregor – What Causes the Electron to Weigh?................................................................................ 129 Paolo Lanciani and Roberto Mignani – The Electron in a (3+3)-Dimensional Space-Time ......................................... 155 Vesselin Petkov – Can Studying the Inertial and Gravitational Properties of the Electron Provide us with an Insight into its Nature?.................................................................... 169 Horace R. Drew – The Electron as a Periodic Waveform of Spin ½ Symmetry ............................................................... 181 Fabio Cardone, Alessio Marrani and Roberto Mignani – A Geometrical Meaning of Electron Mass from Breakdown of Lorentz Invariance ...................................... 195 Paramahamsa Tewari – On the Space-Vortex Structure of the Electron............................................................................... 207 Milo Wolff and Geoff Haselhurst – Solving Nature’s Mysteries: Structure of the Electron and Origin of Natural Laws....................................................................... 227 William Gaede – Light: Neither Particle nor Transverse Wave..... 251 Françoise Tibika-Apfelbaum – A Matter of Life… or Hypothesis on the Role of Electron Waves in Creating “Order out of Chaos”.......................................................... 269 Adolphe Martin – The Electron as an Extended Structure in Cosmonic Gas..................................................................... 273 Preface The electron is the first elementary particle, from both the physical and the his- torical point of view. It is the door to the microworld, to the physics of elemen- tary particles and phenomena. This book is about electron models. The year 1997 marked the centenary of the discovery of the electron as a particle by J.J. Thomson. We have already passed the centenary of Planck’s great discovery and the beginning of quantum physics; 2001 marked the 75th anniversary of Schrödinger’s equation and the beginning of quantum mechan- ics, while the year 2003 was the 75th anniversary of the Dirac equation and Dirac’s model of the electron. Today the most widely used theoretical approaches to the physics of the electron and atom are quantum mechanical and field theoretical models based on the non-relativistic Schrödinger and the relativistic Dirac equations and their probabilistic interpretation. This is the basis of modern quantum field theory. More than 75 years is a long time for a physical theory! This theory is the basis for all contemporary calculations of physical phenomena. After 75 years most physical theories tend to be supplanted by new theo- ries, or to be modified. The theory’s successes, as well as its difficulties, are now evident to specialists. There is no proof of the uniqueness of the quantum field theory approach to the model of the electron and atom. Are other ap- proaches possible? Quantum field theory may be sufficient to describe the elec- tron, but is it necessary? This theory and its mathematics are very complicated; can we now propose a simpler construction? Is the electron an extended struc- ture, a compound object made up of sub-particles, or is it a point-like elemen- tary particle, which does not consist of any sub-particles? What is the limit of application of modern classical physics (based either on the corpuscular or wave model) in the description of the electron? These and many other ques- tions remain without definitive answers, while experiments on quantum entan- glement have given rise to new discussion and debate. New high-precision ex- perimental data, e.g., on the electric and magnetic dipole moments of the elec- tron, may prove decisive. This book, What is the electron?, brings together papers by a number of authors. The main purpose of the book is to present original papers containing new ideas about the electron. What is the electron? presents different points of view on the electron, both within the framework of quantum theory and from competing approaches. Original modern models and hypotheses, based on new principles, are well represented. A comparison of different viewpoints (some- times orthogonal) will aid further development of the physics of the electron. More than ten different models of the electron are presented here. More than twenty models are discussed briefly. Thus, the book gives a complete pic- What is the Electron? i edited by Volodimir Simulik (Montreal: Apeiron 2005) ii Preface ture of contemporary theoretical thinking (traditional and new) about the phys- ics of the electron. It must be stressed that the vast majority of the authors do not appeal to quantum field theory, quantum mechanics or the probabilistic Copenhagen in- terpretation. The approaches adopted by these authors consist in using “lighter” mathematics and a “lighter” interpretation than in quantum theory. Some of them are sound approaches from the methodological point of view. The editor will not presume to judge the models or the authors. We will not venture to say which model is better, and why. The reasons are simple. (i) Readers can reach their own conclusions themselves. (ii) Investigation of the electron is by no means finished. (iii) My own point of view is presented in my contribution to the book. So I want my paper to be on an equal footing with other new models of the electron presented here. The general analysis of the electron models presented here shows that they can be classified as follows: corpuscular and wave, classical and quantum, point and extended, structureless and with structure. The reader can compare and ponder all these approaches! I would like to thank the authors for their con- tributions. It is my hope that this volume will prove worthwhile for readers, and en- courage them to pursue further investigation of electron models. Volodimir Simulik Senior Research Associate Institute of Electron Physics Ukrainian National Academy of Science. Uzhgorod, Ukraine A Comprehensive Theory of the Electron from START Jaime Keller Departamento de Física y Química Teórica Facultad de Química Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México AP 70-528, 04510, México D.F., MEXICO E-mail: [email protected] and [email protected] Space and Time are primitive concepts in science, used to describe material ob- jects in relation with other material objects and the evolution of those relations. Mathematical description of those relations results in an observer’s geometric frame of reference. To describe the object’s behaviour, we add one more geo- metric element: the Action attributed to the system of objects. A fundamental concept is that of action carriers. The resulting Theory has a deductive character. A comprehensive (mass, charge, weak charge, spin, magnetic moment) theory of the electron is presented from this point of view. The main emphasis is given to the mathematical structures needed and the epistemological issues of the theory. PACS number(s): 01.55.+b, 31.15.Ew, 71.10.-w, 71.15.Mb Keywords: Space-Time-Action, Electron, Neutrino, Magnetic Interaction, Weak Interaction, START. 1. Introduction: space, time and material objects – mathematical structures This paper contributes to the construction of a deductive theory of matter, start- ing from first principles and using a single mathematical tool, geometric analy- sis. We present a comprehensive theory, where the analysis is centered in the theory of the electron. It represents a logical continuation of the material presented in the volume The Theory of the Electron, A theory of matter from START and a series of pub- lications [1-5]. We recast here our fundamental philosophical and methodological re- mark. The theory of the electron developed in the above mentioned book is based on two main theoretical considerations: the nature of a scientific theory and the elements used to describe nature. The basic purpose of the theory pre- sented here is a description of what can be observed, inferred, related and pre- dicted within the fundamental limitations of experimental and theoretical sci- ence. We do not go