Inside Founding Father of DNA Research Causes Media Storm, See Page 3
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Th e student newspaper of Imperial College London Issue 1,386 felix Friday 9 November 2007 felixonline.co.uk Inside Ask The President Page 20 Flaming hot Ash Page 16 Hindu Garba Pages 26 & 27 Race: genetics Mountaineering or racism? Founding father of DNA research causes media storm, see page 3 Page 30 2 felix Friday 9 November 2007 News News Editor – Andrew Somerville [email protected] Council increases by eight... Halt the Beit redevelopment ...but hardly anybody turns up to hear the outcome of the results project or run the gauntlet? Once again, Beit was the main point of Tom Roberts discussion at the most recent meeting Editor-in-Chief of the Executive (Exec) committee. The Union is in somewhat of a quandary; Last week, the Council and Trustee whether or not to go ahead with the Board elections came to a close with second phase of the Beit Masterplan. many positions remaining unfilled The Masterplan is the long-term partly due to an initial lack of partici- redevelopment plan to update Beit’s pation but also because RON (re-open facilities. The first phase was com- nominations) beat some of the can- pleted last academic year when da- didates. In total, Council has gained Vinci’s was refurbished and a lift was eight more members whilst the Trus- installed in the Union’s main entrance. tee Board has added one more to its Several weeks ago Felix reported on committee. the revelation that funding for the first Before voting had even begun, it was phase came from the Union’s General known that there would be vacancies Reserve, a very large pot of money in- on Council. Some positions were not tended for use in the event of a catas- even contested; postgraduate repre- trophe. The money for Phase 1 should sentation was especially dismal with never have been authorised to come only one PhD student running. from this reserve in the first place. The majority of the results were an- Now however, the Union is debating nounced in dB’s last Friday at lunch- whether to deplete the General Reserve time, to an audience of approximately even more in order to fund the second six people as well as the handful of stu- phase of the Masterplan which will see Is it the end of the line for the Beit dents who just happened to be sinking a massive redesign of the Union offices redevelopment? their teeth into a bite to eat. Unsurpris- including a sparkling new Student Ac- ingly the student body didn’t flock in tivities Centre, to replace the existing droves to be a part of the nail-biting one in the East Basement of Beit Quad Either way, if a decision to go ahead climax to a month’s worth of non-ex- as well as a new gymnasium and activ- with the redevelopment is taken, the istent campaigning. The lack of candi- ity space on the third floor. Union may be forced to call upon Col- dates waiting to hear their fate, how- A plethora of Council candidates eagerly await the results College has said that it is happy to lege for help should it encounter finan- ever, was more worrying and begs the give over £1.4m to fund the second cial difficulty further down the line, question: did those students even care phase, however the Union needs to something that many fear may com- whether they won a place on Council bring some much needed debate to the elsewhere on the page. There were a stump up the rest of the cash: around promise ICU’s independence from IC. or not? Either that or the Union has monthly meetings. few surprises in the Undergraduate £1.7m. In a report to Exec, the Union There are also further complications done an incredibly lousy job of email- A flattering two thousand votes Engineering Councillor and the Trus- President Stephen Brown wrote that involving building interest rates that ing people to tell them when the results were cast individually, but overall the tee Board categories where this year’s “we are confident … that Union Re- have increased the cost by roughly 10 – were going to be released. Neverthe- turnout was low with the most suc- RON representative, RON Weasley, serves could be used to fund £1.2m of 15% since the initial plans were drawn less, the committee has gained a hand- cessful candidate receiving 74 votes. A managed to vanquish three foes with our share”. up two years ago. The Presidents will ful of new members who will hopefully breakdown of the results can be found his magic wand. These positions will If the full amount is used, the Union have to dig even deeper down the be recontested at the next Council would be left with a severely compro- backs of their sofas. meeting along with the other out- mised General Reserve. Even then, The general response from Executive standing places. A by-election will be the Union is £500k short of the total committee members and observers at The winners were... UG Engineering run, whereby people will turn up to the amount it needs to raise. Mr Brown the meeting was one of caution, that (number of votes in brackets) John James (34) Council meeting and put themselves continued by stating that the differ- the Union should tread carefully and John James (18) forward to be on the committee. ence would have to be made up over a not rush into a decision. Trustee Board RON (11) If you were completely unaware the period of 19 months using “other rev- And, finally, what about the third and Ali Al-Hussaini (190) election had even happened and you enue streams within the Union” such final phase of the Masterplan – the re- RON (124) PG Engineering have a burning desire to be on Coun- as trading and entertainment. The development of dB’s? Just don’t ask. Ashley Brown (16) cil or the Trustee Board, come along £1.2m figure is not set in stone how- UG Medicine to the next meeting in the Union Din- ever. For instance, it was suggested at What do you think? Should the Alexander Walls (74) UG Natural Sciences ing Hall on Monday 10th December at Exec that a smaller proportion of the Union go ahead with the second Mark Chamberlain (41) Shray Amar (49) 6:30pm. There were some rather tasty Reserve could be taken meaning even phase or should it save its pen- Olivia Kenyon (39) Jose Videira (27) pastries at the last meeting so what more money would need to be gener- nies? Email comment.felix@impe- have you got to lose? ated from other revenue streams. rial.ac.uk or text 07980 148 785 Felix, Beit Quad, Prince Consort Road, London felix 1,386 SW7 2BB. Tel: 020 7594 8072. Fax: 020 7594 8065. Printed by The Harmsworth Printing Ltd, 17 Brest Road, Derriford, Plymouth. Registered newspaper Friday 09/11/07 ISSN 1040-0711. Copyright © Felix 2007. Felix was brought to you by: Editor-in-Chief Politics Editor Games Editors LOLCATS Tom Roberts Li-Teck Lau Azfarul Islam Sebastian Nordgren News Editor Arts Editors Andrew Somerville Mike Cook Travel Editors Rosie Grayburn Nadine Richards Layout Editors Caz Knight Ahranyan Arnold OF TEH WEEK Jemil Salami David Paw Sumera Shahaney Fashion Editor Murray Angus Music Editors Sarah Skeete Sally Longstaff Jenny Gibson Matty Hoban Sports Editor Copy Editors Jovan Nedić Louise Etheridge Welfare Editors Tom Culley Nigel Cooke Food Editor Anthony Maina Kirsty Patterson Oroma Oyewole Science Editor Nightlife Editor Photography Ed Henley Greg Mead Sally Longstaff Vitali Lazurenko Business Editor Film Editor Afonso Campos Alex Casey Double phew. Friday 9 November 2007 felix 3 [email protected] News “You what, son? You can’t say that!” DNA pioneer Dr James Watson’s recent comments have caused a storm of controversy within the media that has reverberated throughout the world. Felix headed to the Biology department in search of answers Andrew Turley New York. point of acceptable debate”. Watson On 25 October, the laboratory an- was forced to cancel the tour to pro- The Scientist, or the Science? The recent controversial comments nounced he would be retiring af- mote his new book, Avoid Boring Peo- made by American geneticist and ter nearly 40 years at the research ple: Lessons from a Life in Science, and Controversy and prejudice in academia DNA pioneer, Dr James Watson, have institute. returned to America. led to accusations of racism, the can- Previously, the Science Museum The controversial comments lead- Whenever a scientist or prominent academic makes any comment cellation of his UK book tour, and most in London cancelled a sold-out talk ing up to these events were made in an on a sensitive subject there is always a flurry of discussion and com- recently, his resignation as Chancellor Watson was due to give, stating that interview Watson gave for The Sunday ment. In media circles, the perceived weight of a scientist’s view of Cold Springs Harbour Laboratory in his comments had “gone beyond the Times. In it he said he was “inherently immediately opens up their statement to intense scrutiny. Harvard gloomy about the prospect of Africa” president Lawrence Summers, and his infamous 2005 speech on the because “all our social policies are differences between male and female abilities, is a classic example of based on the fact that their intelligence ill-advised personal opinion, and the negative impact that it can have is the same as ours – whereas all the on a well-respected institute.