JJournalournal of of Oil O ilPalm Palm Research Research Vol. 26 (2)26 (J (2)UNE June 2014) 2014 p. 140-145

POPULATION DYNAMICS OF Oryctes rhinoceros IN DECOMPOSING OIL PALM TRUNKS IN AREAS PRACTISING ZERO BURNING AND PARTIAL BURNING CIK MOHD RIZUAN ZAINAL ABIDIN*; ABU HASSAN AHMAD**; HASBER SALIM** and NOOR HISHAM HAMID*

ABSTRACT Zero burning concepts during oil palm - to - oil palm replanting has provided ample breeding and foraging sites for the Oryctes rhinoceros . This study investigated the impact of the different techniques of residue management in oil palm replanting to the abundance of O. rhinoceros. Two types of breeding sites, zero and partial burning were selected and the populations were determined between three to 18 months after felling and chipping (MAF). At the sixth MAF, different stages of O. rhinoceros were collected from chipped trunks. The results showed that a high population of O. rhinoceros was detected at the 13th MAF; no beetles were detected at the third, fourth and fifth MAF from both types of breeding sites. The third instar larvae were recorded as the dominant stage detected during the study. The females were found to be more abundant than the males, indicating better food quality and a potential for higher infestation for the coming months. There was no significant differences on the population ofO. rhinoceros in both sites. The beetles population tended to increase with MAF. The results of this study suggested that the partial burning of chipped trunks did not decrease the population of O. rhinoceros apart from polluting the environment.

Keywords: Oryctes rhinoceros, zero and partial burning, month after felling and chipping (MAF).

Date received: 22 April 2013; Sent for revision: 27 June 2013; Received in final form: 3 February 2014; Accepted: 12 March 2014.

INTRODUCTION technique during replanting. Prolonged and severe damage can result in delayed palm maturity (Chung The rhinoceros beetle (RB), Oryctes rhinoceros is et al., 1991). Adult feeding produces galleries which endemic to the lowland areas of South-east Asia. can be several centimetres long at the base of the The beetle attacks and destroys the developing unopened spears (Jacquemard et al,. 2002). fronds and spears of oil palms, and it is the most In younger palms, the damage can be more important pest on palms of less than four severe because the feeding galleries can retard years, especially in areas practicing the zero burning the development or even kill the palms (Turner, 1981; Mariau, 2000). In mature palms, attacks by * Crop Protection Division, FELDA Agricultural Services Sdn Bhd, Pusat Penyelidikan Pertanian Tun Razak, 27000 adult beetles may reduce the yield by 20% to 25%, Jerantut, Pahang, Malaysia. and in immature palms the attack may be lethal. E-mail: [email protected] Furthermore, the damage caused by RB may provide entry points for secondary attacks by the ** School of Biological Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 11800, Minden, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia. palm weevil or by pathogens.

140 POPULATION DYNAMICS OF Oryctes rhinoceros IN DECOMPOSING OIL PALM TRUNKS IN AREAS PRACTISING ZERO BURNING AND PARTIAL BURNING

In the field, the felled oil palm trunk residue METHODOLOGY takes three to four years to rot completely. Within this period, the young oil palm replant are exposed Study Site to pests, especially the RB. The nutrients released from the biodegradation of the palm residues partly This study was carried out in an area of supply the total nutrients required by the young approximately 45 ha out of 544.86 ha oil palm palms in subsequent years (Basri and Norman, replanting at FELDA Global Ventures Plantation 2000; Khalid et al., 2002). In special cases, where (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd [FGVP (M) SB] Lepar Utara 05 open burning is still practised, the palm biomass Estate, Pahang. The study which took 16 months is left to dry before burning in order to reduce pest covers all types of land topography as sampling and disease problems. Illegal burning of oil palm sites: hilltops, hillsides, roadsides, borders to mature trunks is prohibited to avoid excessive release of palms, swamps and valleys. The oil palm biomass smoke, which has a major effect on the air quality was stacked to form a single heap of about 0.5 m high and the visibility of the area undergoing replanting and 2.0 m wide in between rows or at the terracing (Ho, 1996; Basri and Norman, 2000; Khalid et al., lips. The trial commenced about three months after 2002). The law has provision for open burning but the completion of the chipping and stacking phase. requires prior permission from the Department of The estate practiced one round random partial Environment (DOE) before controlled burning is burning of oil palm residue in this replanting area. allowed (Khalid et al., 2002). The existence of large oil palm estates profound- Sampling Procedures ly modifies the environment, resulting in one of the most dynamic features in oil palm cultivation, i.e. Two types of study sites, namely zero burning changes in the importance of individual pest spe- and partial burning were sampled every fortnightly. cies. Pest problem can become acute without any In every sampling occasion, nine 1 m² of decomposed control regarding to the infestation of pest (Chung et trunks (1 m² per sampling x 9 samples x 2 sites) were al., 1995; Ho, 2002; Turner and Gilbank, 2003; Chung, randomly selected and examined for RB population. 2004). The population of RB increases tremendously A hoe and manual hand pick were used to collect the (Norman, 2001) in zero burning replanting fields. different stages of RB from the decomposing heaps In situ breeding sites (chipped trunk heap) provide of chipped trunk. The RB were classified to the seven stages of development: eggs, 1st instar larvae, suitable sites for the beetle’s growth and multiplica- nd rd tion. The RB takes only five to six months to develop 2 instar larvae, 3 instar larvae, prepupae, pupae and adults. Their numbers were recorded in situ and into adult beetles (Norman, 2001) when feeding on the RB at different stages of development were then young palms. Natural controls, such as infection by destroyed. pathogens or predations by predators, may reduce The sexual differentiation can be determined the pest numbers in many situations. Integrated at the pupal stage by examining the dorsal part of Pest Management (IPM), utilising the full use of bio- the head. The head of the female pupa has a short logical control measures would be the best option to horn while the male pupa has a longer horn. But achieve environmentally sustainable oil palm pro- for adult stage, the sex of a sexually matured adult duction in facing the RB threat (Jackson et al., 2003; is determined using the tip of the abdomen. The Ramle et al., 2011). female adult has a tuff of velvet bristle while the Palms in the replanting areas are especially at male does not. risk because the decaying logs of the former stand For a normal data, a paired t-test and one- provide the breeding ground for the larvae, which way ANOVA were carried out with the number of feed on the rotting organic material (Wood, 1968). RB in zero burning and partial burning trunks as When feeding is completed, the larvae pupate and dependent variables and the duration in months later emerge as adult beetles. Adult RB feed on after felling and chipping (MAF) as the independent the growing palms leaf tissues causing damage as variables. Analyses were performed on the log ҳ + 1 discussed earlier. Within the oil palm replanting transformation for the number of beetles at different ecosystem, study on the population and infestation stages of development collected in the decomposing levels of O. rhinoceros is fundamentally important to trunks. understand the relationship between environmental factors and natural enemies (Norman, 2001). This RESULTS AND DISCUSSION study aims to investigate the population dynamics of O. rhinoceros in different stages of decomposition Table 1 shows the seven stages of development of of oil palm trunks in zero burning and partial the RB collected during the 16th month sampling burning replanting techniques.

141 Journal of Oil Palm Research 26 (2) (JUNE 2014)

TABLE 1. NUMBER OF O. rhinoceros IN ZERO BURNING AND PARTIAL BURNING SITES

Zero burning Partial burning Stages of t value p value Sex ratio beetles N Mean ±SE N Mean ±SE

Eggs 25 0.1736 ± 0.121 25 0.1736±0.211 t = 0.260 p = 0.795 - df = 143

1st instar 48 0.3542±0.041 195 1.347±0.122 t = 2.139 p = 0.035* - df =143 2nd instar 364 2.500±0.025 341 2.299±0.032 t = 0.162 p = 0.873 - df = 143

3rd instar 433 2.965±0.074 566 4.056±0.055 t = 0.373 p = 0.710 - df = 143

Prepupae 12 0.0764±0.033 33 0.1667±0.014 t = 1.026 p = 0.306 - df = 143

Pupae 30 0.1875±0.028 63 0.4375±0.025 t = 1.568 p = 0.119 - df = 143

Adults 27 0.1875±0.017 41 0.2431±0.028 t = 0.917 p = 0.361 (1:2) df = 143 21♂,47♀

Note: * Significant, p < 0.05. period in zero burning and partial burning study 35.7 beetles were found in zero burning and partial th sites. The results showed that the number of eggs burning area, respectively at 13 MAF which usu- found were equal in both sites. The number of eggs ally represented the maximum samples found. One- found in the palm residues was much higher (within way ANOVA test indicated a significant difference one to 24 eggs m-2 per sampling) as compared to the between the stages of beetle and duration of MAF (F mean fecundity of females captured by trap [16 eggs = 25.313: df = 6, 15; p < 0.05). per female, Norman et al. (1999)] but lower than the Wood (2004) stated that sometimes ground female mass-reared in the laboratory, between 49 -60 vegetation, for example Mucuna bracteata failed to eggs per female (Hurpin and Fresneau, 1973). act as a barrier to cover the heaps to make them The number of females collected in the chipped unsuitable as breeding sites for the RB in the trunk was double that of males. A significant replanting area. Irrespective of MAF, our results tend difference exists only between the number of first to agree with that of Wood (2004). The study sites instar larvae in zero burnt and partial burnt trunk has 80%-90% ground cover provided by Asystasia th chips (t = 2.143, df = 143, p ≤ 0.05) (Table 1). The low intrusa sp. and Mucuna bracteata at 12 MAF, but the sex ratio of RB adults suggests that environment, beetle population remained high (Figure 1). habitat and abiotic factor strongly affect the High numbers of second and third instar population (Norman, 2011). Figures 1 and 2 show the larvae were regularly found, while the pupae and numbers of different stages of RB in relation to MAF prepupae were easily observed in all parts of the (all stages). Starting from the sixth MAF, O. rhinoceros heaps especially in the decomposing fronds and th beetles could be found in the decomposing trunks. deep beneath the soil (0.46 m) during the 16 MAF. The highest beetle population was detected at 13th This is probably due to the fact that decomposing MAF followed by 16th and 10th MAF. No beetles oil palm trunks attracted a high number of beetles were found during the third, fourth and fifth MAF. to breed during the 6 to 24 months after replanting At sixth MAF, the immature stages of RB started to (Norman, 2001). appear in the decomposing trunks. Decomposing crown and frond of the palms A total of three third instar larvae, one prepu- provide suitable habitats for the prepupal and pal, one pupal, and five adults were observed at pupal stages. In fact, Norman (2001) found that sixth MAF. This was probably due to the immigra- the O. rhinoceros was detected in the decomposed th tion of adults, especially the gravid beetles from trunk heaps up to 26 MAF. This may be due to the adjacent areas (either from mature area or other attraction of the beetles to the volatile compounds nearest replanting area). The first, second and third produced by the decaying biomasses as well as the instar larvae were observed to be present continu- aggregation pheromone, ethyl – 4 – methyloctanoate ously after six MAF. The third instars of O. rhinoc- (produced by beetles) which was used to trap beetles eros started to appear between 3.2 - 6 months after of both sexes (Jackson et al., 2003). eggs were laid (Catley, 1969; Chung, 2004; Hinckley, The presence of the immature stages was easily 1973; Bedford, 1976a; b). Altogether, about 23.9 and detected by the shape of the faeces in the decompos-

142 POPULATION DYNAMICS OF Oryctes rhinoceros IN DECOMPOSING OIL PALM TRUNKS IN AREAS PRACTISING ZERO BURNING AND PARTIAL BURNING

Good legume cover crops 10 9 -2 8 7 6 5 4 3

Beetle population m 2 1 0 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Month after felling and chipping (MAF) Eggs First instar larval Second instar larval Third instar larval Prepupal Pupal Adult

Figure 1. Different stages ofO. rhinoceros in relation to months after felling and chipping (MAF) with legume cover crop covered 80% to 90% of the trunk chips at 12th MAF at FGVP (M) SB Lepar Utara 05 oil palm plantation in both sites. ) -2 Beetle population (m

Month after felling and chipping (MAF)

Zero burning Partial burning

Figure 2. Total number of O. rhinoceros in decomposing trunks up to 18 months after felling and chipping (MAF) at FGVP(M)SB Lepar Utara 05 oil palm plantation in partially burned and zero burned sites. Bars indicate the standard error of the mean (±SEM). ing trunk. The moist condition of the rotting trunks such as wild and other . The 3rd was preferred by the second and third instar larvae. instar larvae may need suitably low temperature or Unidentified mites (Archridae) were found on the humidity to become prepupae, pupae and finally external surfaces of the various stages of the RB, ex- adults (Bedford, 1980; Norman, 2001). cept the eggs. Moreover, they were observed living The trunk heaps need to be burned four to five inside the cases of prepupae or pupae. These mites times to achieve complete burning. However, the could probably be the ectoparasites of the beetle. DOE limits the activities of open burning to only Most arachnids are carnivorous, vegetarian and par- the outer layer of the chipped trunks. Partially burnt asitic (Wood, 1968). chips still serve as suitable breeding habitats for During the immature stages, the RB are exposed O. rhinoceros to lay their eggs. However, biological to several mortality factors. Immature beetles are agents such as Metarhizium anisopliae and Oryctes preyed upon by several ground animals such as rats virus can help to manage immature and adult beetles (Rattus tiomanicus), wild boars and reptiles. These in oil palm biomass at the early stage of replanting different stages of the RB are preyed upon because (Ramle et al., 2004; 2007; Noor Hisham, et al., 2005). of their large size and long life cycle of about 160 The application of the fungus of M. anisopliae in days (Norman, 2001). However, they would burrow the decomposing trunks of oil palm could infect all deep into the soil to avoid sunlight and predators stages of O. rhinoceros (except egg) with the highest

143 Journal of Oil Palm Research 26 (2) (JUNE 2014) infection observed on the third instar larvae (Ramle REFERENCES et al., 2000; Noor Hisham et al., 2011). This biocontrol agent can provide between 33% to 80% control in BASRI, M W and NORMAN, K (2000). Insect pests, the field using different delivery techniques (Ramle pollinator and barn owl. Advances in Oil Palm et al., 2013). Research (Yusof Basiron; Jalaini, B S and Chan, K W eds.). MPOB, Bangi. p. 466-541.

CONCLUSION BEDFORD, G O (1976a). Use of a virus against the coconut palm rhinoceros in Fiji. PANS, 22: 11-25. This study demonstrates that the RB population increased in abundance at the sixth MAF of matured BEDFORD, G O (1976b). Observations on the biology oil palm. All life stages such as egg, first, second and ecology of Oryctes rhinoceros and Scapanes and third instar larvae, prepupae, pupae and adults australis: pests of coconut palms in Melanesia. J. were observed in the field in zero burning areas. In Australian Entomological Society, 15: 241-251. the partial burning areas, the third instar larvae first appeared at the sixth MAF. The presence of different BEDFORD, G O (1980). Biology, ecology and control stages of RB in the decomposing trunk continued th of palm RBs. Annual Review of Entomology, 25: 309- up to 18 MAF and the majority of the beetle stages 339. found in the decomposing trunks were the second and third instar larvae. Some of the eggs had CATLEY, A (1969). The coconut RB Oryctes rhinoceros already hatched before they were sampled. The high (L.). PANS, 15: 18-30. abundance of the first generation RB in the oil palm th decomposing trunks occurred between ninth to 18 CHUNG, G F (2004). Control of RBs in Immature and MAF. It is therefore concluded that the palm chips Young Mature Oil Palms. Consolidated Plantations provided the optimum habitat for the breeding of Berhad. 10 pp. RB in replanting areas. However, no difference was detected in the number of RB found in zero burnt CHUNG, G F; SIM, S C; HON, K M and RAMLI, and partially burnt habitats. The abundances of K (1995). Monitoring and surveillance system RB in both areas started to appear from the sixth for integrated pest management of leaf eating MAF. Therefore, for the management of RB, residue caterpillars in oil palm. The Planter, 71: 253-263. burning should be stopped and the implementation of zero burning should be encouraged. Our finding CHUNG, G F; SIM, S C and TAN, M W (1991). shows that late introduction of the legume cover Chemical control of RBs in the nursery and immature crops failed to control the RB population. Perhaps oil palms. Proc. of the 1991 PORIM lnternational Palm the legume covers should be established earlier to Oil Congress - Agriculture Conference. p. 380-395. fully cover the trunk chips within six MAF as to prevent the female beetles from laying their eggs HINCKLEY, A D (1973). Ecology of the coconut in the decomposing palm residues. The burning of RB, Oryctes rhinoceros (L.) (Col., Scarabaedae, chipped trunks not only cost more, but also caused ). Biotropica, 5: 111-116. environmental pollution. This practice too had failed to reduce the RB population. HO, C T (2002). Ecological Studies on Pteroma pendula Joannis and Metisa plana Walker (Lepidoptera: ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Pcsychidae) towards Improved Integrated Management of Infestation in Oil Palm. Ph.D. dissertation, Universiti Putra Malaysia. 560 pp. This project was supported by Yayasan Federal Land Development Authority (FELDA) research fund. HO, C T (1996). The integrated management of The authors are grateful to Mr S Palaniappan, Senior Oryctes rhinoceros (L). populations in the zero burning Vice President R&D/CEO, FELDA Agricultural environments. Proc. of the 1996 PORIM International Services Sdn Bhd (FASSB), and Dr Sharifah Shahrul Palm Oil Congress - Agricultural Conference. p. 336- Rabiah Syed Alwee Principal Researcher, FELDA 338. Biotechnology Centre, FELDA Global Ventures (R&D), for their approval to publish this article. The HURPIN, B and FRESNEAU, M (1973). Laboratory authors also wish to thank Mr Chin Cheuk Weng for studies on fecundity factors in Oryctes monoceros and his invaluable comments. Parts of this study were O. rhinoceros L. (Col. ). Annales de la presented as an oral presentation at the International Societe Entomologique de France, 9: 89-117. Symposium on Insects 2012, 3-5 December 2012, Mines Wellness Hotel, Selangor, Malaysia.

144 POPULATION DYNAMICS OF Oryctes rhinoceros IN DECOMPOSING OIL PALM TRUNKS IN AREAS PRACTISING ZERO BURNING AND PARTIAL BURNING

JACKSON, T A; RAMLE, M; GLARE, R T; RAMLE, M; MOHD BASRI, M and NORMAN, NORMAN, K; BARLOW, N D; MOHD BASRI, W K (2000). The granular and power formulations and SITI RAMLAH, A A (2003). Achieving the full of Metarhizium anisopliae for control of Oryctes potential benefit of Oryctes virus for the control of rhinoceros. MPOB Information Series No. 117. RBs in oil palm plantations. Proc. of the PIPOC 2003 International Palm Oil Palm Congress – Agriculture RAMLE, M; ZAINI, M A; RAZMAN, G; NORMAN, Conference. p. 335-348. K and MOHD BASRI, W (2004). The effects of Metarhizium anisopliae var. major on coleopteran JACQUEMARD, J C H; SURYANA, H E; ASMADY, insects under oil palm and its toxicity to the H and DESMIER, D C R (2002). Oil palm (Elaeis mammalian and fish. Poster paper presented at the guineensis Jacq.) and Oryctes rhinoceros L.; planting International Conferences on Pests and Diseases material effect. International Oil Palm Conference. of Importance to the Oil Palm Industry - Fostering Nusa Dua, Bali. p. 197-203. Global Cooperation in Instituting Quarantine Shield. 18-19 May 2004, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. KHALID, H; ZIN, Z Z; TARMIZI, M and ARIFFIN, D (2002). Crop residue management during oil palm RAMLE, M; NORMAN, K; ANG, B N; SITI replanting. MPOB Technology No. 25: 1-24. RAMLAH, A A and MOHD BASRI, W (2007). Application of powder formulation of Metarhizium MARIAU, D (2000). Oryctes rhinoceros Linn. in anisopliae to control Oryctes rhinoceros in rotting oil oil palm and coconut pests. In: Jacquemard, J C palm residues under leguminous cover crop. J. Oil H; Suryana, H E; Asmady, H and Desmier D C R Palm Res. Vol. 19: 319-331. (2002). Oil palm ( Jacq.) and Oryctes rhinoceros L.; planting material effect. International RAMLE, M; NORMAN, K; IDRIS, A G; MOHD Oil Palm Conferences. Nusa Dua, Bali. p. 197-203. BASRI, W; JACKSON, A T; TEY C C and MOHD ADLY A (2011). Molecular approaches in the NOOR HISHAM, H; CIK MOHD RIZUAN, Z A assessment of Oryctes rhinoceros virus for the control and SUHAIDI, H (2011). The efficacy of Metarhizium of rhinoceros beetles in the oil palm plantations. J. anisopliae var. major (ORY-X™) to control Oryctes Oil Palm Res. Vol. 23: 1096-1109. rhinoceros (Linn.) population in oil palm replanting areas through ‘artificial breeding sites technique’. RAMLE, M; NORMAN, K; NOOR HISHAM, H Proc. of the International Conference on Biopesticide and CIK MOHD RIZUAN, Z A (2013). Delivery 6 (ICOB 6). 11-16 December 2011, Chiang Mai, techniques of Metarhizium for biocontrol of RB in oil Thailand. 289 pp. palms plantation. The Planter, 89: 571-583.

NOOR HISHAM, H; RAMLE, M; HASBER, S; TURNER, P D (1981). Oil Palm Diseases and Disorders. MOHD BASRI, W; NORMAN, K and SUHAIDI, The Incorporated Society of Planters, Kuala Lumpur, H (2005). Powder formulation of Metarhizium Malaysia. 280 pp. anisopliae, its stability and effects against Oryctes rhinoceros. Proc. of the 2001 PIPOC International Palm TURNER, P D and GILBANKS, R A (2003). Oil Oil Congress - Agriculture Conference. p. 914-927. Palm Cultivation and Management. The Incorporated Society of Planter, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. 915 pp. NORMAN, K (2001). Kajian Persekitaran dan Infestasi Kumbang Badak, Oryctes rhinoceros (Linn.) WOOD, B J (1968). Studies on the effect of ground (Coleoptera: Scarabaiedae) dalam Ekosistem Tanam vegetation on infestation of Oryctes rhinoceros (L.) Semula Sawit. Ph.D. dissertation. Faculty of Science (Col. Dynastidae) in young oil palm replanting in and Technology, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia. Bulletin of Entomological Research, 59: 85- Bangi, Malaysia. 270 pp. 96.

NORMAN, K; MOHD BASRI, W; ZAIDI, M I and WOOD, B J (2004). IPM in practice - the oil palm MAIMON, A (1999). Population studies of Oryctes story. The Planter, 81: 321-326. rhinoceros in an oil palm replant using pheromone traps. Proc. of the 2003 PIPOC International Palm Oil – Agriculture Conference. p. 467-475.

145