Council Meeting Minutes
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CITY COUNCIL MEETING NO. 17 The Regular Meeting of City Council was held on Tuesday, June 3, 2003 at 7:47 pm in the Council Chamber, City Hall. Her Worship Mayor Isabel Turner presided. There was an "In-Camera" meeting of the Committee of the Whole from 7:01 pm to 7:45 pm in the Councillors’ Lounge. There was a Public Meeting of Council in order to obtain public input on the cancellation, reduction or refund of taxes from 7:45 pm to 7:46 pm. (Council Chambers) ROLL CALL Present: Mayor Turner, Councillor Beavis, Councillor Campbell, Councillor Clements, Councillor Downes (arrived 7:11 pm), Councillor Foster, Councillor Garrison, Councillor George, Councillor Meers, Councillor Pater, Councillor Rogers, Councillor Stoparczyk, Councillor Sutherland (arrived 7:09 pm) (13) (Council Chambers) Administrative Staff Present: Mr. B. Meunier, Chief Administrative Officer Mrs. C. Downs, Manager, Council Support/City Clerk Mr. J. Keech, President & CEO, Utilities Kingston Ms. N. Sullivan, Deputy City Clerk Ms. N. Taylor, Vice-President, Utilities Kingston * * * * * * * * * * * * DISCLOSURE OF PECUNIARY INTEREST (1) Mayor Turner declared a possible pecuniary interest in the matter of Clause 1(b) of Report No. 53 as she is a member of the Royal Canadian Legion. (2) Councillor Beavis declared a pecuniary interest in the matter of Clause 2 of Report No. 54 as he is a former employee of Utilities Kingston and receives benefits from same. (3) Councillor Beavis declared a pecuniary interest in the matter of Clause 1(b) of Report No. 53 as he has a daughter who organizes bingos. (4) Councillor Pater declared a pecuniary interest in the matter of Clause 1(b) of Report No. 53 as her son owns a restaurant in the downtown area. (5) Councillor Meers declared a pecuniary interest in the matter of Clause 1(b) of Report No. 53 as he operates a business that sells tobacco products and smoking-related items; and sells lottery tickets and break-open tickets under contract to the Ontario Lottery Commissioner, as do Bingo Halls, which are also licensed to do so by the Ontario Commission. * * * * * * * * * * * * COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE “IN CAMERA” City Council Meeting No. 17 Minutes June 3, 2003 (A) Moved by Councillor Campbell Seconded by Councillor George THAT Council resolve itself into the Committee of the Whole “In Camera” to consider the following item: 1. Legal Matter CARRIED (Councillor Meers OPPOSED) (B) Moved by Councillor Pater Seconded by Councillor Rogers THAT Council rise from the Committee of the Whole “In Camera” without reporting. CARRIED (Councillors Garrison and Meers OPPOSED) * * * * * * * * * * * * (Council Chambers) Administrative Staff Present: Mr. B. Meunier, Chief Administrative Officer Ms. C. Beach, Commissioner, Planning & Development Services Ms. P. Carrol, Manager, Taxation & Revenue, Finance Mr. L. Cleary, Financial Supervisor, Housing Division Mrs. C. Downs, Manager, Council Support/City Clerk Ms. R. Etherington, Supervisor, Culture & Recreation Mr. J. Giles, Manager, Solid Waste Mr. G. Grange, Manager, Housing Division Mr. G. Hunt, Manager, Finance Mr. J. Keech, President & CEO, Utilities Kingston Mr. D. Leger, Commissioner, Corporate Services Mr. H. Linscott, Director, Legal Services Mr. K. Riley, Manager, Treatment Group Mr. R. Rowe, Supervisor of Administration, Housing Division Mr. M. Segsworth, Commissioner, Operations Services Mrs. L. Seiffert, Communications Officer, Strategic Initiatives & Corporate Communications Ms. N. Sullivan, Deputy City Clerk Ms. N. Taylor, Vice-President, Utilities Kingston Mr. L. Thurston, Commissioner, Community Services * * * * * * * * * * * * PRESENTATIONS Moved by Councillor Stoparczyk Page 319 City Council Meeting No. 17 Minutes June 3, 2003 Seconded by Councillor Sutherland THAT Council consent to allow Presentation No. (1) 15 minutes. CARRIED (Councillor Rogers OPPOSED) (1) Marcia O’Connor and Robert Foster of the Stonewell Management Consulting Group spoke to Council concerning the findings of the Social Housing Portfolio Technical Audit Assessment. (File No. CSU-C13-000-2003) (2) Janet Brooke of the Agnes Etherington Art Centre spoke to Council concerning the role played by the Art Centre in the community. (File No. CSU-C13-000-2003) * * * * * * * * * * * * DELEGATIONS * * * * * * * * * * * * PETITIONS * * * * * * * * * * * * REPORTS Report No. 53 of the Chief Administrative Officer (Consent) Page 320 City Council Meeting No. 17 Minutes June 3, 2003 Council consented to the separation of Clauses (a) and (b). Moved by Councillor Downes Seconded by Councillor Foster THAT Report No. 53 of the Chief Administrative Officer (Consent) be received and adopted. Report No. 53 To the Mayor and Members of Council: The Chief Administrative Officer reports and recommends as follows: All matters listed on the Consent Report are considered to be routine and are enacted by one motion. There is no separate discussion on these items. If discussion is desired upon request of a Member of Council, that item is removed from the Consent Report and is considered separately. Council Members may request that an item be considered separately if they have a conflict of interest. 1. THAT Council consent to the approval of the following routine items: (a) THAT Council approve the cancellation, reduction or refund of taxes, pursuant to Section 357 of the Municipal Act, 2001, totalling $48,817.09, of which $21,530.97 is recoverable from the School Boards, and $1,369.97 is recoverable from the Downtown Business Improvement Area Board; as listed in Appendix I attached, and; THAT Council approve the cancellation, reduction or refund of taxes, pursuant to Section 358 of the Municipal Act, 2001, totalling $8,800.27, of which $2,840.80 is recoverable from the School Boards, as listed in Appendix II attached. (File No. CSU-F22-000-2003) CARRIED (Councillors Garrison and Meers OPPOSED) (See Following Motion to DEFER Which Was LOST) Moved by Councillor Garrison Seconded by Councillor Rogers THAT Clause 1(a) be deferred to the next Committee of the Whole “In Camera” session in order to provide Council with further information. LOST (3:10) (See Recorded Vote) A Recorded Vote was requested by Councillor Meers and commenced with same. YEAS: Councillor Garrison, Councillor Meers, Councillor Rogers (3) NAYS: Mayor Turner, Councillor Beavis, Councillor Campbell, Councillor Clements, Councillor Downes, Councillor Foster, Councillor George, Councillor Pater, Councillor Stoparczyk, Councillor Sutherland (10) REPORTS Report No. 53 of the Chief Administrative Officer (Consent) Mayor Turner and Councillors Beavis, Meers and Pater withdrew from the meeting. Page 321 City Council Meeting No. 17 Minutes June 3, 2003 (b) THAT a by-law be presented to amend By-Law No. 98-9 “A By-Law To Appoint Municipal Law Enforcement Officers Of The Corporation Of The ‘New’ City Of Kingston” to include new By-Law Enforcement Officers under Section 1(r), who will be appointed as Municipal Law Enforcement Officers who shall be Peace Officers for the purpose of enforcing By-Law No. 2002-231 “A By-Law To Regulate Smoking In Public Places And Workplaces In The City Of Kingston”, as provided for under Section 15 of the Police Services Act, RSO 1990 (c) P15, as amended. (File No. CSU-P01-000-2003) (By-Law No. (1), 2003-124) CARRIED Mayor Turner and Councillors Beavis, Meers and Pater returned to the meeting. (c) THAT a by-law be presented to amend By-Law No. 98-9 “A By-Law To Appoint Municipal Law Enforcement Officers Of The Corporation Of The ‘New’ City Of Kingston” to include John Pollock as a Parking Enforcement Officer under Section 1(r), who will be appointed as a Municipal Law Enforcement Officer who shall be a Peace Officer for the purpose of enforcing the by-laws of the Municipality, as provided for under Section 15 of the Police Services Act, RSO 1990(c) P15, as amended. (File No. CSU-P01-003-2003) (By-Law No. (2), 2003-125) (d) THAT, in order to meet the legislated requirements of the Municipal Elections Act, 1996, as amended, the distribution of trustees to be elected by the school electors of the City of Kingston areas shall be as follows: SCHOOL BOARD GEOGRAPHIC AREA NUMBER OF TRUSTEES English Language Public City of Kingston and Frontenac 5 trustees, one in each of the (Limestone District School Board) Islands following areas: Electoral Districts 1 & 12 and Frontenac Islands Electoral Districts 7, 8 & 11 Electoral Districts 9 & 10 Electoral Districts 5 & 6 Electoral Districts 2, 3 & 4 English Language Separate City of Kingston and Frontenac 3 trustees (Algonquin & Lakeshore Catholic Islands District School Board) French Language Public (le conseil City of Kingston and Counties of 1 trustee des écoles publiques du l’est de Frontenac, Hastings, Prince l’Ontario) Edward, Lennox & Addington, and Leeds & Grenville Page 322 City Council Meeting No. 17 Minutes June 3, 2003 REPORTS Report No. 53 of the Chief Administrative Officer (Consent) Clause (d) continued French Language Separate (le City of Kingston and Counties of 1 trustee couseil des écoles catholiques de Frontenac, Hastings, Prince langue français du centre-est) Edwards, and Lennox & Addington –and further– THAT the following by-laws be presented to Council for approval: – A By-Law to Provide for the Election of Members of the English Language Public District School Board (Limestone District School Board); the English Language Roman Catholic Separate School Board (Algonquin & Lakeshore Catholic District School Board), the French Language Public District School Board (Le conseil des écoles