A Brief Discourse Regarding Collllllon Characteristics of Fishing Clubs and Their Men1bers by Richard G. Bell
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Mother Club, a Mystery, and Best of the Worsts Man's life is but vain; For 'tis subject to pain, And sorrow, and short as a bubble; 'Tis a hodge-podge of business and money and ca re, and care and money and tro uble. But we'll take no care when the weather proves fair; Nor will we vex now though it rain; We'll banish all sorrow and sing to tomorrow, and angle and angle again. hus singeth Walton and friends as recorded in The Compleat Angler. Groups of anglers bonding over com- Tmon experience and common water is as old as . .. well, at least as old as Walton, with Thatcht-House being dubbed the Mother Club by author Richard G. Bell. In "Common Threads among the Gold: A Brief Discourse Regarding Common Characteristics of Fishing Clubs and Their Members," Bell begins with the Bible and Berners for stories of fishermen, angling, and attitude. But, he claims, it is Walton who gives us "clubness." Bell's article, originally a presentation to the Lime- stone Club of East Canaan, Connecticut, is filled with stories and songs of anglers banding together for the sake of tradition to fish, eat, drink, be merry, exaggerate, and complain. This rather lively piece begins on page 2. About ten years ago, Frederick Buller found a collection of flies at a rummage sale in a box marked "Unusual Salmon Flies (circa 188o) ." Since then, he's been researching these flies and asking the opinions of others. The flies are, in fact, still a bit of a mystery. Buller recently sent some of these flies to John Betts, a frequent contributor to this journal, for his consideration as well. Betts's additional commentary can be found at the end of Buller's article, "A Hoard of Mysterious Salmon Flies;' which begins on page 13. We live in a culture that loves lists and that regularly issues lists of"best" and "worst" of almost anything. Given that, as well as the tendency of anglers to love anything written about their From Izaak Walton's The Compleat Angler, 7th ed. sport, Paul Schullery set out to create a list of bad fishing books, (London: Henry Kent, circa 1802), facing page So. of "Fly Fishing's Greatest Dogs." It turned out to be a tougher task than he imagined, even after eliminating all living writers from this criticism. He quickly discovered that among his well- out an opposing voice for balance; but these readers found read friends, there is little consensus out there as to which books Boyle's article not only praiseworthy, but challenging and are bad or why they are. "Crazy Coots and Mere Farragos;' inspiring. Read these letters, and write to us when you have therefore, is Schullery's list, and by the end, you'll be wanting to comments. read the bad books too. This survey begins on page 17. Of course, the progress on the new building is always the big Never in the years that I've worked on the journal has an story here. See Sara Wilcox's report, "Into the Homestretch," article received such positive and eloquent comment as Robert beginning on page 30 for the latest update. And fear not- H. Boyle's "'Flies Do Your Float': Fishing in Finnegans Wake," there's still time to buy a brick and be part of it all (see page 26). which appeared in the Spring 2004 issue. We include two let- ters, beginning on page 29. Yes, there is praise for the journal, KATHLEEN ACHOR which perhaps I shouldn't so boldly publish without searching EDITOR Time Amm (CCffiiiTl THE AMERICAN MusEUM OF FLY FISHING Preserving the Heritage of Fly Fishing FALL 2004 VOLUME 30 NUMBER 4 TRUSTEES E. M. Bakwin Walter T. Matia Common Threads among the Gold: A Brief Discourse Michael Bakwin William C. McMaster, M.D. Regarding Common Characteristics of Fishing Clubs Foster Bam james Mirenda 2 Pamela Bates john Mundt and Their Members . Steven Benardete David Nichols Richard G. Bell Paul Bolinger Wayne Nordberg Duke Buchan Ill Michael B. Osborne A Hoard of Mysterious Salmon Flies . 13 Mickey Callanen Raymond C. Pecor Frederick Buller Peter Corbin Stephen M. Peet Blake Drexler Leigh H. Perkins Some Notes and Comment .................... 16 William j. Dreyer Allan K. Poole Christopher Garcia john Rano John Betts George R. Gibson III Roger Riccardi Gardner L. Grant Kristoph j. Rollenhagen Crazy Coots and Mere Farragos . ... 17 Chris Gruseke Wil liam Salladin Paul Schullery )ames Hardman Ernest Schwiebert Lynn L. Hitschler Robert G. Scott Museum News. 24 Arthur Kaemmer, M.D. james A. Spend iff Woods King III john Swan Contributors 28 Carl R. Kuehner TIT Richard G. Tisch james E. Lutton III David H. Walsh Letters ......... 29 Nancy Mackinnon )ames C. Woods TRUSTEES EMERITI Into the Homestretch 30 Charles R. Eichel David B. Ledlie Sara Wilcox G. Dick Finlay Leon L. Martuch W. Michael Fitzgerald Keith C. Russell ON THE covER: "Jack Fishing- Lea Bridge" by artist Henry Heath Jr. William Herrick Paul Schullery (c. 1850) shows an angler playing a fish or "giving it the butt." The Victorians Robert N. johnson Stephen Sloan used long rods with enough whip in the top joint to allow them to point the rod back over the shoulder while playing a big fish. Frederick Buller references OFFICERS this practice in ''A Hoard of Mysterious Salmon Flies," which begins on page Chairman of the Board Robert G. Scott 13. Buller included this illustration in his book, Pike and the Pike Angler President David H. Walsh (London: Stanley Paul, 1981, p. 187), courtesy of Walter Spencer. Vice Presidents Lynn L. Hitschler Michael B. Osborne 'J'he American J-<'ly Fisher (ISSN 0884-3562) is published four times a year by the Museum at P.O. J3ox 42, Ma nchester, Vermont 05254. james A. Spendiff Publication dates are winter, spring, summer, and fall. Membership dues include the cost of the Treasurer james Mirenda journal ($15) and are tax deductible as provided for hy law. Membership rates arc listed in the back of each issue. Secretary james C. Woods AI! letters, manuscripts, photographs, and materials intended for publication in the journal should be sent to the Museum. The Museum and journal are not responsible for uniiolicited manuscripts, drawings, photographic STAFF material, or memorabilia. The Museum cannot accept responsibility for statements and interpretations that are Interim Executive Director Yoshi Akiyama wholly the author's. Unsolicited manuscripts cannot be returned unless postage is provided. Contributions to The American Fly Fisher are to be considered gratuitous and the property of the Museum unless otherwise requested Events & Membership Diana Siebold by the contributor. Articles appearing in this journal are abstracted and indexed in Historical Abstracts and America: Special Projects Sara Wilcox History and Life. Copyright © 2004, the American Museum of Ply Fishing, Manchester, Vermont 05254. Original Administrative Assistant Linda McWain material appearing may not be reprinted without prior permission. Periodical postage paid at Manchester, Vermont 05254 and additional offices (USPS 057410). The American Fly Fisher (ISSN 0884-3562) Art Director john Price EMAIL: [email protected] WEBSITE: www.amff.com THE AMERICAN FLY FISHER POSTMASTER: Send address changes to The American Fly Fisher, P.O. Box 42, Manchester, Vermont 05254. Editor Kathleen Achor Design & Production john Price We welcome contributions to The American Fly Fisher. Before making a submission, please review our Contributor's Guidelines on our website (www.amff.com), or Copy Editor Sarah May Clarkson write to request a copy. The Museum cannot accept responsibility for statements and interpretations that are wholly the author's. Collllllon Threads an1ong the Gold: A Brief Discourse Regarding Collllllon Characteristics of Fishing Clubs and Their Men1bers by Richard G. Bell "E'uening firelight stories ." This friendly image appears in The Speckled Brook Trout by Louis Rhead (New York: R.H. Russell, 1902, facing page 30 ). ecause I'm a very amateur historian, and because I was BACK TO THE BEGINNING markedly influenced by a statement made by the late BJustice Oliver Wendell Holmes when I first read it many Where to start? Well, there is no shortage of material. I have years ago in law school, it seemed important to me to get at the been told that the volume of fishing literature alone exceeds subject of fishing clubs from a particular perspective. The the combined volume of the literature of all other sports. If Holmes statement to which I refer is this: this was last year, I would have had a different beginning. But now, with Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ playing at The life of the law has not been logic; it has been history.' every local theater, giving voice to a powerful religious reex- What Holmes was saying in this wonderful phrase was that the amination, maybe-to be safe- we ought to start with the law is not the way it is because that's what makes sense, and it's Bible. Just to be able to say we've done so. I recommend it. You not because that's how it's supposed to be, and God knows it's sometimes come up with surprising results. not because it's the best way to do it. No. The law is what it is There are, in fact, forty-five references in the King James because it has been shaped that way by historical forces, and to Version of the Bible to "boats" and to "fishing." Forty-five. understand it, yo u need to understand its history. I find this None, however, to fishing clubs specifically. But that's all right.