WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 1
Grand design: Tough external competition is expected to precipitate revenue decline
This report was provided to Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) by IBISWorld on 27 October 2019 in accordance with their license agreement with IBISWorld
IBISWorld Industry Report 45399 Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 Claire O’Connor
2 About this Industry 18 International Trade 29 Revenue Volatility 2 Industry Definition 19 Business Locations 30 Regulation and Policy 2 Main Activities 31 Industry Assistance 2 Similar Industries 21 Competitive Landscape 3 Additional Resources 21 Market Share Concentration 32 Key Statistics 21 Key Success Factors 32 Industry Data 4 Industry at a Glance 21 Cost Structure Benchmarks 32 Annual Change 23 Basis of Competition 32 Key Ratios 5 Industry Performance 24 Barriers to Entry 33 Industry Financial Ratios 5 Executive Summary 25 Industry Globalization 5 Key External Drivers 34 Jargon & Glossary 7 Current Performance 26 Major Companies 9 Industry Outlook 26 Leslie’s Poolmart Inc. 11 Industry Life Cycle 26 The Container Store Group Inc. 27 The Yankee Candle Company Inc. 13 Products and Markets 27 Williams-Sonoma 13 Supply Chain 13 Products and Services 28 Operating Conditions 16 Demand Determinants 28 Capital Intensity 17 Major Markets 29 Technology and Systems www.ibisworld.com | 1-800-330-3772 | [email protected] WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 2 About this Industry
Industry Definition Industry operators retail specialized general merchandise auction houses lines of goods: kitchenware, art (except electronic auctions), but supplies, cigarettes and cigars, excludes mass merchandisers, collectors’ items, fireworks and department stores, grocery stores, trophies. This industry also includes warehouse clubs and supercenters.
Main Activities The primary activities of this industry are Retailing general merchandise Retailing tobacco and tobacco products (e.g. cigarettes and cigars) Retailing art supplies Retailing collectors’ items (e.g. autographs, cards, coins and stamps) Retailing fireworks Retailing candles Retailing religious goods (except books) Retailing trophies Retailing specialized occupational supplies Retailing calendars
The major products and services in this industry are Art materials and supplies Collectibles and monuments Groceries and alcoholic beverages Home goods Pools, pool chemicals, pool supplies and accessories Tobacco products and smokers’ accessories Other
Similar Industries 44831 Jewelry Stores in the US This industry retails a wide array of jewelry and time pieces.
45211 Department Stores in the US This industry retails a wide range of merchandise including apparel, cosmetics and appliances.
45322 Gift Shops & Card Stores in the US This industry retails a variety of goods, including greeting cards and gift items such as glassware.
45331 Used Goods Stores in the US This industry retails a broad range of merchandise, such as antiques, clothing and books.
45392 Art Dealers in the US This industry includes art galleries and art auction houses that retail a broad range of original and limited edition artwork.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 3
About this Industry
Similar Industries 45411a E-Commerce & Online Auctions in the US continued This industry retails a wide array of merchandise via the internet. 45411b Mail Order in the US This industry retails a wide array of products via mail order or catalogs.
Additional Resources For additional information on this industry www.awardspersonalization.org Awards and Personalization Association www.iamart.org iAMart www.candles.org National Candle Association www.nrf.com National Retail Federation www.tma.org Tobacco Merchants Association
IBISWorld writes over 1000 US industry reports, which are updated up to four times a year. To see all reports, go to www.ibisworld.com
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 4 Industry at a Glance Small Specialty Retail Stores in 2019
Key Statistics Revenue Annual Growth 14–19 Annual Growth 19–24 Snapshot $38.6bn 3.2% -2.5% Profit Wages Businesses $2.0bn $5.0bn 141,850
Revenue vs. employment growth Per capita disposable income Market Share There are no major 8 4 players in this industry 4 2
0 0 % change % change -4 -2
-8 -4 Year 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 Year 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 Revenue Employment SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM p. 26 Products and services segmentation (2019) 2.4% Art materials Key External Drivers and supplies 4.2% Per capita disposable Groceries and 7.5% alcoholic beverages income Home goods E-commerce sales Consumer 13.8% 34.3% Confidence Index Pools, pool chemicals, pool Tobacco products and supplies and accessories smokers' accessories Excise tax on tobacco products
15.8% Collectibles and monuments
p. 5 22.0% Other SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM
Industry Structure Life Cycle Stage Decline Regulation Level Light Revenue Volatility Medium Technology Change Low Capital Intensity Low Barriers to Entry Low Industry Assistance Low Industry Globalization Low Concentration Level Low Competition Level High
FOR ADDITIONAL STATISTICS AND TIME SERIES SEE THE APPENDIX ON PAGE 32
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 5 Industry Performance Executive Summary | Key External Drivers | Current Performance Industry Outlook | Life Cycle Stage
Executive Summary Operators in the Small Specialty Retail operators through one-stop shopping and Stores industry sell a diverse range of lower prices for similar products. products, from premium cigars to grave External competition has also driven markers. Due to its fragmented nature, underperforming retailers to exit the the industry is not driven by product- industry. However, while external specific trends but rather by broad competition has squeezed the industry’s macroeconomic variables. However, market size, rising income levels and individual segments do respond to confidence during the period have limited specific shifts in consumer preferences. revenue declines. Nonemployers and Over the five years to 2019, rising income small retail stores with low barriers to and employment have boosted demand entry dominate this industry, promoting throughout the retail sector. Despite this, a fluidity for companies to enter and exit. small specialty stores are experiencing Despite moderate revenue declines, the increasing competition from e-commerce number of enterprises in this industry is and department stores, limiting gains marginally increasing. Small companies are able to start up with low capital input, and they are increasingly attempting to Rising income and employment have boosted generate higher margins on more premium items. demand throughout the retail sector Over the five years to 2024, industry revenue is forecast to decline at an from increased consumer spending. annualized rate of 2.5% to $34.0 billion. Overall, IBISWorld expects industry IBISWorld anticipates consumer revenue to increase at an annualized rate spending will rise while consumer of 3.2% to $38.6 billion over the five confidence is expected to decrease. years to 2019. High growth in this period Consequently, increasing levels of has been driven by large increases in discretionary spending will focus on price 2015 and 2016 as a result of double-digit over specialty. Furthermore, industry growth in the Consumer Confidence participation is expected to expand at a Index in 2014 and 2015. much slower rate. Underperforming However, revenue is expected to companies are expected to exit, while the decline 4.2% in 2019 as e-commerce sales few large companies are expected to improve and consumer confidence wanes acquire smaller ones. Additionally, tough due to prolonged slow growth and external competition and the rising uncertainty. Discount department stores popularity of online sales are expected to and online retailers have increasingly reduce the industry’s share of the overall taken retail market share from industry retail sector.
Key External Drivers Per capita disposable income increase in 2019, representing a The majority of products supplied by potential opportunity for the industry. this industry are discretionary items. A rise in household disposable income E-commerce sales increases the propensity of consumers E-commerce retailers often offer to purchase these goods, leading to substitute industry products at heavily growth in demand. Per capita discounted prices. In addition, specialty disposable income is expected to items, such as rare cigars and collectibles,
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 6
Industry Performance
Key External Drivers are sometimes easier to find and industry tend to be discretionary in continued purchase online. Therefore, as more nature, industry revenue tends to consumers visit online retailers for their positively correlate with the index. The shopping needs, demand for brick-and- Consumer Confidence Index is expected mortar establishments will fall. to decrease in 2019. E-commerce sales are expected to increase in 2019, posing a potential Excise tax on tobacco products threat to the industry. Tobacco sales have historically comprised almost one-third of revenue for the Small Consumer Confidence Index Specialty Retail Stores industry. As the The Consumer Confidence Index excise tax level on tobacco products measures consumers’ propensity to increases, tobacco purchases fall, harming spend their discretionary income, rather industry revenue. Excise taxes on tobacco than save. Since products sold by the are expected to increase in 2019.
Per capita disposable income E-commerce sales
4 2.5
2.0 2
1.5 0 1.0 $ trillion % change -2 0.5
-4 0 Year 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 Year 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 7
Industry Performance
The Small Specialty Retail Stores industry Industry revenue Current retails specialized lines of goods, with 8 Performance operators offering a wide and distinct range of products, from cigarettes and pool supplies to funerary items. Therefore, broad 4 changes in consumer confidence and spending patterns, rather than product- 0
specific trends, drive overall industry % change performance. Several economic factors that -4 tend to improve industry revenue have been positive during the period. Industry -8 products tend to be highly discretionary, so Year 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 the industry relies on consumer trends. Employment figures have been strong SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM during the period and the economy has been on a prolonged streak of positive jobs traditional advantage of specialty retailers growth. Recently, this trend has supported has been the scarcity of the products they increased wages and household income sell, but online retailers have eroded this levels, driving up retail sales. However, advantage. Additionally, since most of this overall revenue growth for the period has industry’s competitors retail a variety of been undermined by unfavorable consumer products within a single establishment, trends such as an increasing percentage of their fixed costs are spread over a much services conducted online. Over the five larger product base. Consequently, they are years to 2019, revenue is expected to usually able to undercut prices charged by increase at an annualized rate of 3.2% to small specialty retail stores and have used $38.6 billion. their cost advantages to capture a greater Industry operators experience high share of the retail market. In 2019, external competition from online retailers, industry revenue is expected to decline discount department stores, mass 4.2%, in line with the long-term trend. merchandisers and warehouse clubs. Most Revenue experienced high growth in 2015 of the products sold by this industry can and 2016 due to a drastic increase in also be found at these establishments; consumer confidence, which was great moreover, the industry’s competitors offer enough to facilitate growth despite the benefits of one-stop shopping. The e-commerce encroachment.
External competition Consumers have increasingly shifted their price, and convenience is increasingly intensifies business from specialty stores to warehouse integral to retail success. This trend has cut clubs and discount department stores. This into industry demand and has contributed external competition has siphoned revenue to long-term revenue decline. from industry operators by offering The primary threat confronting the convenience and price advantages. In industry is the growing prevalence of online addition, large retailers can achieve cost sales. Niche industry products, the savings through bulk purchasing and cornerstone of small retail locations, can generally offer lower prices than industry easily be found online. Moreover, operators. Despite growing consumer consumers can shop online for the best confidence during the five-year period, prices, while also gaining access to broader individuals have remained conscious of selections. The percentage of services
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 8
Industry Performance
External competition conducted online is expected to increase to price changes and individual income. intensifies from 11.0% in 2014 to 18.5% in 2019. Therefore, industry sellers often rely on continued Nonetheless, industry operators are able to consistent sales from these products. combat competition and limit declines by Increased federal excise taxes to discourage offering a positive in-store experience. smoking have had a negative effect on Stores focus on designed point-of-purchase tobacco sales (see the Regulation and Policy displays, upscale locations and intimate section). Reports from the Centers for product knowledge. As a result, stores Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) provide added value above price, and it has found that the percentage of adult smokers become increasingly fashionable among has decreased slowly during the five-year many consumers to shop at specialty stores. period, falling from 17.8% in 2013 to an Social concerns regarding small business expected 15.5% in 2016 (latest data owners and national efforts to “shop local” available). The decline is largely attributed also act to support the industry. However, to increased exposure to health warnings. these tend to have short-lived effects, as the However, other forms of tobacco products, novelty wears off in favor of lower prices, such as e-cigarette and chewing tobacco, greater selection and increased convenience. have risen in popularity. For example, the Tobacco products and accessories make number of middle school and high school up the largest product segment in the students using e-cigarettes increased from industry, representing an estimated 34.3% 2.1 million in 2017 to 3.6 million in 2018 of revenue. Tobacco products are (latest available data). In total, while tobacco discretionary purchases; however, many usage is declining, the use of alternative products tend to have an inelastic response tobacco products is increasing.
Stagnant margins Profit margins have stagnated at low shares of revenue during the period; however, as Operators are situating consumer confidence and spending have increased, higher-margin product lines themselves to provide have become more viable. Therefore, a retail experience that despite lower revenue and volume, some merits higher prices operators have succeeded in selling higher-margin items. Still, profit has been restricted by the prevalence of e-commerce, employees over the five years to 2019. This which provides a wider range of products at is driven by the expansion of large lower prices. Industry profit, measured as companies and the efforts of niche shops to earnings before interest and taxes, is provide better service. estimated to total 5.2% of revenue in 2019, The number of industry up from 4.1% in 2014. establishments is expected to increase The primary factor supporting industry at an annualized rate of 0.9% to 147,347 profitability has been the increased effort of establishments. This is largely due to operators to leverage their specialty nature. the few large industry retailers, which Companies are offering a value-added have expanded operations to gain shopping experience, but increased wages market share despite falling demand. and store front management costs still Profit has held steady due to shifting hinder profitability. Additionally, consumer sentiments that have employment is anticipated to increase at an benefited certain segments of the annualized rate of 2.8% to 266,539 industry. For instance, demand for
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 9
Industry Performance
Stagnant margins candles has increased significantly, and operators are situating themselves to continued specialty brands in particular are provide a retail experience that merits selling at higher prices while higher prices, rather than trying to maintaining low production costs. Thus match e-commerce’s price advantages.
IBISWorld forecasts that the Small and specialty items. Over the five years Industry Specialty Retail Stores industry will begin to 2024, revenue is expected to decrease Outlook to decline as external competition at an annualized rate of 2.5% to $34.0 intensifies. Revenue is forecast to billion. Consumer spending is forecast continue on a downward trend as to continue growing steadily during the consumer preferences shift toward other outlook period, but consumer retail sources for specialty goods. Beyond confidence will decline. Financial the pressure generated from external uncertainty and sluggish growth will competition, the industry will experience drag on consumers’ propensity to spend market conditions unfavorable to niche on discretionary items.
Online competition Competition from external retailers, especially e-commerce and auction Increasing competition websites, will increase over the next five years. The percentage of services conducted is expected to force online is expected to increase to 23.2% by unprofitable players to exit 2024. Additionally, e-commerce sales are the industry anticipated to increase at an annualized rate of 8.0% over the next five years. These online stores will continue to pose a major rare cigars, which are sometimes easier competitive threat to this industry. The to find online than in traditional brick- largest operators will be able to continue and-mortar stores. As companies like growing within the retail space through Amazon continue to move forward with their size and strong customer loyalty, but greater inventories and delivery these large retailers are only a small improvements, industry operators portion of the industry. The smaller increasingly lose value to consumers. For companies that comprise the bulk of the example, while local specialty cigar shops industry will experience pressure from once provided local convenience, they online retailers. The primary competitive will increasingly compete against online strength of small specialty stores will warehouses with greater selection, bulk continue to be experience and locality. pricing and fast delivery. Therefore, the Operators are increasingly focusing on space for industry companies to operate improving the in-store experience and is expected to shrink and only those that relying on conspicuous consumption by can effectively provide premium retail higher-income individuals. service will persist. Consumers are expected to Increasing competition is expected to increasingly shift to online shopping due force unprofitable players to exit the to its relative convenience. This factor is industry. Overall, the number of industry particularly pertinent for industry enterprises is expected to decrease at an products such as collectible items and annualized rate of 0.6% to 137,500
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 10
Industry Performance
Online competition companies over the five years to 2024. for specialty products slows and continued Employment is anticipated to decrease at customers continue to use external a similar pace, exhibiting an annualized retailers, small operators that cannot decrease of 1.4% to 248,763 individuals generate sufficient operating margins will during the period. As growth in demand exit the industry.
Social and structural Over the next five years, rising consumer change aversion to smoking will continue to Sluggish growth will drag impede demand for tobacco products, the industry’s largest product segment. on consumers’ propensity According to the latest data released by to spend on discretionary the Centers for Disease Control and items Prevention, the goal is to decrease the percentage of smokers from 15.5% in 2016 to 12.0% by 2020. Greater increasingly rely on higher markups, but restrictions on where people can smoke, increased regulation will hinder gains to such as new e-cigarette bans in profit. As a result, profit margins are restaurants and public places, will further anticipated to decrease from 5.2% in discourage smoking and decrease tobacco 2019 to 5.0% in 2024. demand. In addition, excise tax increases Although the industry is in decline, a during the period will likely curb demand market remains for effective stores to for tobacco, with tobacco retailers operate in the industry. Consumer anticipated to experience an increasingly demand for specialty retail stores will regulated market. Food and Drug continue to be subject to shifting Administration regulations now cover a preferences. However, individuals are greater range of tobacco products. For expected to continue paying premiums example, in 2019, the FDA announced on retail items based on the perceived new restrictions on the sale of flavored value added by industry stores. Small e-cigarettes and proposed a ban of specialty retailers are forecast to menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars. As become increasingly located in higher a result, retailers of loose tobacco, income areas, whereas previously a premium cigars and electronic tobacco large portion were in rural or suburban products will encounter the regulatory areas without large department stores. strain that traditional cigarette retailers Industry viability will become have traditionally experienced. These increasingly reliant on servicing products are typically strong revenue particular local needs and foregoing producers for industry companies, as competition with large retailers. they provide an opportunity for elevated Therefore, despite the gradual decline margins through markups on premium of the industry overall, there is room items. As overall demand for tobacco for operators that can effectively tap products recedes, industry operators will into local markets.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 11
Industry Performance Life Cycle Stage The industry’s relative contribution to US GDP is expected to increase at a slower rate than US GDP during the 10-year period The industry’s size is expected to increase only slight during the 10-year period The industry is losing market share to discount retailers and online outlets
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 12
Industry Performance
Industry Life Cycle The Small Specialty Retail Stores enterprises and establishments are industry is in the decline stage of its life estimated to increase slightly, mainly cycle. Over the 10 years to 2024, industry because barriers to entry are so low. While This industry is value added, which measures the underperforming operators will exit the in Decline industry’s contribution to GDP, is industry due to declining profitability and expected to increase at an annualized rate poor demand for their specialty items, the of 1.6%. During the same period, the US low barriers to entry make it easy for economy is projected to grow at an anyone to enter the industry. The long- annualized rate of 2.0%. The industry has term trend of a decline in smoking will exhibited little technological change that have a negative effect on sales of tobacco would affect growth and businesses are products, the industry’s largest product lagging behind trends in the overall retail segment. Warehouse clubs, discount sector. Furthermore, operators are losing department stores and online retailers consumers due to intense external have all effectively eroded the industry’s competition from online platforms, super market share by providing the centers and department stores. convenience of one-stop shopping and Tough competition is expected to lower prices. This trend is expected to constrain industry participation. Over the continue over the next five years, further 10 years to 2024, the number of contributing to the industry’s decline.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 13 Products & Markets Supply Chain | Products and Services | Demand Determinants Major Markets | International Trade | Business Locations
Supply Chain KEY BUYING INDUSTRIES 56172 Janitorial Services in the US This industry purchases various janitorial equipment from specialty retail stores. 61161 Fine Arts Schools in the US This industry purchases art materials and supplies from specialty retail stores. 62161 Home Care Providers in the US This industry purchases nursing scrubs from specialty retail stores. 81311 Religious Organizations in the US This industry purchases goods from specialty retail stores. 99 Consumers in the US Consumers purchase various goods from specialty retail stores.
KEY SELLING INDUSTRIES 31310 Textile Mills in the US This industry supplies textile products such as flags. 33994 Art & Office Supply Manufacturing in the US This industry supplies art materials. 42392 Toy & Craft Supplies Wholesaling in the US This industry supplies fireworks, as well as traditional toys and craft supplies. 42494 Cigarette & Tobacco Products Wholesaling in the US This industry supplies tobacco, tobacco products and smokers’ accessories. 51119 Greeting Cards & Other Publishing in the US This industry supplies greeting cards and calendars.
Products and Services Products and services segmentation (2019) 2.4% Art materials and supplies 4.2% 7.5% Groceries and Home goods alcoholic beverages 13.8% Pools, pool chemicals, pool supplies and accessories 34.3% Tobacco products and smokers' accessories
15.8% Collectibles and monuments
22.0% Other Total $38.6bn SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM
Tobacco products and an estimated 34.3% of revenue in 2019. smokers’ accessories These products include cigars, cigarettes, Tobacco products and smokers’ chewing tobacco and snuff, as well as accessories represent the industry’s accessories such as lighters, pipes, rolling largest product segment, accounting for papers, vaporizers and hookahs. Social
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 14
Products & Markets
Products and Services and governmental efforts, including revenue through sales of collectibles and continued national anti-smoking campaigns and monument type items. As consumer state excise taxes, have contributed to a confidence increases during the period, reduction in the number of smokers over individuals are more like to make the five years to 2019. According to the discretionary expenditures on collectible latest data released by the Centers for items. Specifically, sales of collectible Disease Control and Prevention, the items are expected to account for 11.0% percentage of adult smokers in the of industry revenue, as prices increase. United States decreased from 17.8% in Additionally, trophies are included in this 2013 to an expected 15.5% in 2018 (latest segment, and consumer preferences available data). However, other forms of during the period have increased demand tobacco use are growing during the for trophies and plaques. A steady source period and e-cigarettes are now the most of revenue in this segment is derived commonly used tobacco products among from monuments, which include grave the younger generation. E-cigarette use markers, caskets and urns. As the median was estimated at 16.0% of high-school age of the population increases, as is the students in 2015, 13.6% of adults aged case during the current period, demand 18-24 in 2014 and 5.7% of adults 25 years for these items necessarily increases. As a or older in 2014 (latest available data) result, an aging population is expected to and increasing. Furthermore, 11.7% of bolster sales from stores specializing in high school students reported that they funerary products. used electronic cigarettes in the past 30 days in 2017, which marks an increase Pools, pool chemicals, pool from 1.5% in 2011. Additionally, the use supplies and accessories of smokeless tobacco products, like Small specialty stores specializing in chewing tobacco is increasing from pools and pool supplies are expected to previous lows, with adult use at 3.4% in generate 13.8% of industry revenue, 2014 and teenagers use at 5.5% in 2017. making this product segment one of the Furthermore, the number of middle and industry’s largest. Over the past five high school students using e-cigarettes years, an improving economy has buoyed increased from 2.1 million in 2017 to 3.6 replacement and maintenance demand for million in 2018. The number of smokers pools, keeping this product segment’s is decreasing at a slower rate than in overall share of revenue strong. Consumer previous decades, which bodes well for confidence and rising income levels drive industry participants. Despite campaigns the use of these products, as pools are and taxes hurting cigarette sales, other typically discretionary. However, the forms of use are maintaining product segment does supply products to more revenue. Although, competition from stable markets like public and private online retailers and non-specialty stores pools at large athletic facilities. Over the place significant pressure on tobacco next five years, this product line may be stores for sales. Over the five years to limited by falling consumer confidence. 2024, tobacco revenue for small specialty However, warmer average temperatures retail stores is forecast to slowly decline, have the possibility of supporting pool as societal and external business sales to a larger range of the country as pressures erode sales. more regions have longer pool seasons.
Collectibles and monuments Home goods In 2019, small specialty retail shops are Home goods are anticipated to account expected to generate 15.8% of industry for 7.5% of 2019 industry revenue.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 15
Products & Markets
Products and Services Specialty stores focusing on home goods Art materials and supplies continued sell kitchenware, cleaning supplies, Art materials and supplies, which include various toiletries and home improvement paint, paintbrushes, knives, canvases, supplies. These products are typically cutting mats and other accessories, are higher quality or niche type products that expected to account for 2.4% of industry differentiate from what consumers sales in 2019. This segment’s share of purchase from big box or department industry revenue is expected to decline stores. Improving consumer sentiment is during the five-year period due to tough helping sales of these products during the competition from online retailers and period, as individuals are more likely to department stores. Nonetheless, the spend on specialty goods for the home. industry has a dedicated core consumer Additionally, improving home base of product users who continue to construction and remodeling markets provide patronage to industry during the period should lead to establishments. Since these artists and consumers buying an increasing variety students require art materials and of home goods. However, this segment supplies as part of their jobs and studies, experiences significant pressure from fluctuations in disposable income and e-commerce, as consumers are consumer confidence are less influential in increasingly likely to shop online for determining this segment’s performance. various niche products. The segment is reliant on shoppers deriving value from Other the in-store experience. The industry includes a large number of small retailers that sell a wide variety of Groceries and alcoholic beverages products; thus, industry revenue An estimated 4.2% of industry revenue generated by other products is quite is accounted for by sales of groceries large. In 2019, 22.0% of total revenue is and alcohol in 2019. Consumers tend to expected to come from retailers of do shopping at larger establishments calendars, candles, emergency for groceries, however, purchases are preparedness equipment, flags and typically made in small stores to avoid banners, artificial flowers, fireworks and long lines or to find specialty products. all other products not included in other Additionally, per capita consumption of segments. One shared characteristic of alcohol is increasing. As with other the products in this segment is their specialty goods, this segment is reliant discretionary quality, directly tying the on the overall economy, when performance of this segment to changes consumers feel confident, they are more in consumer spending. Consumer likely to forego bulk discounts from spending is increasing during the period, large grocers that rely on volume and which aids sales of these products. purchase specialty products. Changing Although, stores that specialize in these consumer preferences have also aided items are typically small, making it this segment, as US consumers are difficult to get exposure to consumers increasingly interested in organic or when large e-commerce sites are so specialty grocery items. readily available.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 16
Products & Markets
Demand The Small Specialty Retail Stores the first half of the next five years as Determinants industry incorporates a range of consumers feel the strain of political operators that retail a wide variety of uncertainty and the persistence of goods, all of which are affected by unique below average GDP growth. trends of their own, along with the broad Social perception and trends have a economic trends that affect discretionary significant effect on demand for tobacco purchases in general. Most industry products, the industry’s largest product products are considered discretionary or segment. Increasing public awareness nonessential, so the level of disposable about the health dangers of smoking income experienced by consumers fueled a decline in the number of generally determines spending at small smokers during the past few decades. specialty retail stores. Furthermore, According to data from the Centers for higher discretionary income enables Disease Control and Prevention, the consumers to freely spend on higher- percentage of adult smokers declined quality goods, which are often retailed by from 20.9% to 15.5% in 2016, a trend that this industry. Discretionary spending has is anticipated to continue (latest available been on the rise during the period. The data). This decline has negatively affected United States is experiencing a prolonged demand for all tobacco products. More period of slow growth. As a result, recently, the percentage of smokers has consumers are increasingly willing to continued to decrease, but at a slower make expenditures on specialty goods. rate, resulting in relatively steady but still However, as interest rates increase and declining demand for tobacco. Shifting consumers become weary of the slow consumer sentiments about other growth, this is expected to drag on products also drive demand. For many discretionary spending patterns. operators, they are able to maintain Consumer confidence also drives competitiveness by providing a retail industry demand. Movements in environment that caters to consumer consumer confidence take into account preferences like luxury imports or household finances, business organic goods. conditions, unemployment, inflation, External competition from department interest rates, income and government stores, warehouse clubs and e-commerce economic policy. When consumer websites unfavorably affect industry perceptions of the economy are demand. Comparable items offered at positive, consumers spend more freely lower prices from external competitors on discretionary items, including shift consumer spending away from industry products. Perceptions of the industry operators. Over the five years to economy have since been improving, 2019, competition has heightened, consumers have remained cautious hurting industry revenue. The breadth of with their spending in some respects. goods available online forces industry Since 2014, consumer confidence has operators to compete on experience. experienced strong growth in line with Store layout, design and location help declining unemployment and the companies provide a shopping experience improving economy. However, starting that can help limit the effects of price in 2019, it is expected to decline over competition with large retailers.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 17
Products & Markets
Major Markets Major market segmentation (2019)
4.6% Consumers aged 24 and younger 15.3% Businesses 31.2% Consumers aged 45 to 64
22.6% Consumers aged 25 to 44 26.3% Consumers aged 65 and older
Total $38.6bn SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM
Based on US Census Bureau data and nonsmokers. Although under age tobacco IBISWorld research, businesses are use, especially of non-cigarette estimated to account for 15.3% of the alternatives exists, they are not counted industry’s total market in 2019. These as purchases. buyers purchase occupational supplies, such as nurse scrubs and janitorial Consumers aged 25 to 44 equipment, from industry operators for This age range is anticipated to account business use. The remaining 84.7% of the for 22.6% of demand for industry market represents households and products. Consumers in this age group individual buyers, who purchase products are typically employed and have steady for personal use. As consumer confidence income streams, enabling them to spend and disposable income improved, freely on industry items. In addition, this consumers are expected to have group includes cigarette smokers and increased their consumption across the other tobacco users, who consistently retail sector. purchase products despite price changes. As disposable income Consumers aged 24 and younger continues to improve over the five years Consumers 24 and younger are expected to 2024, this segment’s share of revenue to make up 4.6% of total sales. A majority is expected to increase. of this segment’s consumers are teenagers and young adults who have Consumers aged 45 to 64 limited disposable income; therefore, this Individuals between the ages of 45 to 64 segment’s share of revenue is expected to are estimated to account for 31.2% of the remain flat over the five years to 2019. market in 2019. Since consumers in this Home goods and funerary monuments group generally have sufficient are not typically demanded by consumers disposable income, they are able to in this age range. This group will only spend on both inexpensive items and spend money on necessary items, such as more costly items, such as hard-to-find art supplies for school, or inexpensive collectibles and antiques. As consumers merchandise, such as souvenirs or in this segment decrease expenses on novelties. Additionally, this segment children that have moved out of the includes a significant amount on home, they have greater time and income
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 18
Products & Markets
Major Markets to purchase goods from this industry’s than 10.0% according to the CDC, they continued operators, thereby increasing their are more likely to frequent small shops share of revenue during the five-year for various goods. This segment is period. Although, individuals in this limited to an extent by diminished range smoke at a lower rate than the income, but retirement age consumers 25 to 44 age demographics. have more time to spend at small shops. Additionally, this age range is Consumers aged 65 and older less likely to make use of e-commerce In 2019, consumers aged 65 and older sites, preferring brick and motor are expected to generate 26.3% of locations. Moreover, this is age range industry revenue. Although these has grown in number as the baby consumers only smoke at a rate of less boomer generation enters this cohort.
International Trade Since merchandise trade figures are that are sourced to foreign suppliers, classified to the relevant upstream including cigars and cigarettes (Cigarette production industries, small specialty and Tobacco Manufacturing industry, retail stores do not engage in IBISWorld report 31222), art supplies international trade. However, the (Art and Office Supply Manufacturing industry retails a wide range of products industry, 33994) and collectible items.
Provided to: Autobahn Consultants (2134210691) | 27 October 2019 WWW.IBISWORLD.COM Small Specialty Retail Stores in the US July 2019 19
Products & Markets
Business Locations 2019