A Critical Analysis of Deaths in Psychiatric Detention, 1845-2018

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Critical Analysis of Deaths in Psychiatric Detention, 1845-2018 Secrecy and Denial in Matters of Life and Death: A Critical Analysis of Deaths in Psychiatric Detention, 1845-2018 By Carly Jane Speed A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements of Liverpool John Moores University for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2018 1 Abstract Each year detained patients die in psychiatric detention in England and Wales in contentious circumstances. Despite the fact that deaths in psychiatric detention is not a new phenomenon, minimal critical research exists which analyses this problem. Underpinned by a critical criminological framework focusing on power, marginalisation and resistance, the thesis undertakes a critical analysis of deaths in psychiatric detention in both a historical and contemporary context. This is achieved through combining primary archival research with interviews and questionnaires undertaken with a number of individuals directly involved with this issue. In addition, the thesis utilises and analyses family campaign websites that were set up following the death of their detained relative. In order to understand the response to patients in death, a critical understanding of the response to them during their lives is also developed, both historically and contemporaneously. Further areas of focus include the official response to patients and their families, inquest and investigation procedures, the issue of accountability and the challenging of dominant discourses surrounding psychiatric detention. Based upon the findings of the thesis, a number of radical alternatives are outlined. These alternatives would address the issue of deaths in psychiatric detention and transform the current failing systems for the benefit of some of the most vulnerable members of society. 2 Acknowledgements First, thank you to all of the participants who took the time to share your experiences with me. Without you willing to talk in such depth, this research would not have been possible. Second, thank you to the staff at The National Archives in London for your assistance. The stories and experiences hidden within these files have formed an integral part of this thesis. Thank you also to the team at INQUEST for taking the time to meet with me at the beginning of the research and sharing your expertise with me. Thank you to the Criminology team at Liverpool John Moores University, particularly Janet Jamieson, for your support since I joined in 2009. It has been a brilliant experience, hence why I have never left! Thanks also to Steve Lawler for always being on hand to assist with all my IT queries, along with the IT technicians for your patience in loaning me laptops when mine repeatedly broke. Thank you also to Lindsey Metcalf for facilitating numerous writers group sessions which proved particularly helpful. Having presented a number of papers at conferences during the duration of my doctoral studies, I also wish to thank the conference organisers for facilitating my presentations. Speaking at these conferences has provided me with very helpful feedback. Thank you also to the editors at Sage, Policy Press, the European Group for the Study of Deviance and Social Control and the Centre for the Study of Crime, Criminalisation and Social Exclusion for allowing material first published by them to be reproduced within this thesis1. Thank you to Dr Victoria Cooper for your support and a memorable trip to the cathedral cafe. Thank you also to Dr David Scott for your support, encouragement 1 See Appendix A. 3 and for all your Take That emails, I will ‘never forget’ them. To my Director of Studies, Professor Joe Sim, you have been integral in making my entire university experience what it has been. Thank you for always being there to listen, advise and encourage me. You have gone above and beyond time and time again. A ‘thank you’ does not seem enough, so a Take That CD may have to do sometime. To my family who have passed away, particularly my Granddad, I know you would have been proud to see me progress through university. To Ollie, thank you for always being there and thank you to Gran for all of your support and encouragement. Finally, to my best friend, Mum. Thank you for always believing in me and encouraging me to pursue my dreams. Thank you for everything. 4 Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... 2 Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................ 3 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 8 The Problems Being Examined ........................................................................................................ 9 The Deaths of Detained Patients ..................................................................................................... 9 The Question of Accountability ..................................................................................................... 12 Research Aims ............................................................................................................................... 15 The Structure of the Thesis ........................................................................................................... 16 Chapter One: ‘A Social, Mental and Metaphysical Death’: Theorising Life and Death in Psychiatric Detention ................................................................................................................. 22 The Pathologisation and Criminalisation of Mental Health Problems .......................................... 22 Conceptualising the Rise and Role of Asylums and Psychiatric Hospitals as ‘Total Institutions’ .. 27 Theorising the Role of the Medical Profession and Psychiatrists as ‘Judges of Normality’ .......... 35 ‘Confined’ and ‘Controlled’: The Experiences of Females ........................................................... 45 Subjugating and Denying the Patients’ Experiences ..................................................................... 48 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 57 Chapter Two: Methodology and Methods .................................................................................. 59 Critical Research and the Critical Researcher ................................................................................ 59 Methodology: Approaching the Research .................................................................................... 67 Gathering the Historical Data ........................................................................................................ 70 Archival Research as a Genealogy ................................................................................................. 79 Gathering the Contemporary Data ............................................................................................... 83 Sampling in Interviews and Questionnaires .................................................................................. 83 Undertaking Interviews and Questionnaires ................................................................................. 87 Examining Family Campaign Websites ......................................................................................... 91 Data Analysis: Reliability, Validity and Credibility ......................................................................... 94 Ethical Issues ................................................................................................................................. 97 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 100 Chapter Three: ‘An Outrage so Gross and Barefaced’: A Revisionist History of Life and Death in Psychiatric Detention in England and Wales, 1845-1959 .......................................................... 103 Psychiatric Detention: The Emergence of Challenge and Complaint .......................................... 105 The Alleged Lunatics’ Friend Society ........................................................................................... 107 5 Issues and Failings ....................................................................................................................... 112 ‘Hushing up What Looks Like a Very Black Affair’: Contentious Deaths and Their Investigation 117 ‘Secrets of the Prison House of Lunacy’: Accusations, Dismissals and Denials ........................... 123 ‘Sheer Wanton Cruelty’: Into the Twentieth Century ................................................................. 128 Confessions of an Asylum Doctor ................................................................................................ 131 Further Deaths and Failings ........................................................................................................ 134 The Introduction of the National Health Service and Beyond .................................................... 139 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 147 Chapter Four: ‘We Are Waving, Yet We Are Still Drowning’: Detained Patients in Life and Death, 1960-2018 ..................................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Woking's World War Ii Hospitals
    WOKING’S WORLD WAR II HOSPITALS Iain Wakeford 2017 s in the Great War, the Second World The Southern Railwayman’s Orphanage in Oriental Road was taken over as the part of the ‘Woking War Hospital’. War also saw a number of local After the war the Home took over the ‘Wynberg’ War Hospital (the house with a corner turret, above) across the road A hospitals converted (in part) into as extra accommodation. ‘emergency war hospitals’, such as Brookwood Asylum, the Woking Victoria Hospital and the Woking Maternity Home (Wynberg) – but other local institutions and private residences also played their part such as the Southern Railwaymen’s Home in Oriental Road. The Southern Railway Magazine from May 1940 noted the many meetings between the Board of Managers of the Railwayman’s Home, the Office of Works and the Ministry of Health regarding the take-over of the orphanage. They proudly pointed out the ‘complimentary remarks which have been made as to the high standard of maintenance and hygiene to be found in the Home’ as well as favourable comments regarding the children’s library. The children had already been evacuated to places such as Basingstoke and Guildford, although how much safer they were there as opposed to Woking is perhaps debatable. Another local institution which catered for a number of war wounded was the St Nicholas and St Martin’s Homes at Pyrford run by the Church of England Waifs and Strays Society. Their expertise at dealing with children with various disabilities proved vital in the treatment of servicemen who suffered similar injuries during the war.
    [Show full text]
  • To See a Searchable
    Woking Remembers: World War One Woking Town Memorial. Men shown in Black have been identified, those in Red have not. If you have any information, photographs, documents relating to any of these men, or other Woking Borough casualties, Surrey History Centre would like to hear from you. Surname Christian Names Initials Regiment Battalion Rank Regimental Age Date of Death Cemetery Grave/Memorial Remarks Number Reference Cambrin Churchyard Son of Philip and Jane Acock, of 103, Oval Road, Croydon, Acock Sydney Walter S W Queen's 1st Private G/3913 36 2 February 1916 C.33 Extension Surrey. Son of Mr & Mrs C Akehurst, of Bridge Cottage, Arthur's Akehurst Charles C Queen's 2/4th Private 206591 23 27 December 1917 Jerusalem War Cemetery Q. 59. Bridge Road, Woking Pier and Face 5 A and 5 Son of Tom and Miriam Alesbury, of 22, Horsell Moor, Alesbury Sydney Thomas S T Gloucestershire 1/5th Private 4922 28 27 August 1916 Thiepval Memorial B. Woking Faubourg D'Amiens Cemetery, Alexander John J Norfolk 7th Private 12330 40 16 March 1917 II. H. 10. Son of Mrs. H. Carpenter, of 37, Poole Rd., Woking. Arras Allard Stanley Nelson S N Hampshire 2nd Private 8471 25 18 October 1916 Bancourt British Cemetery X. B. 14. Son of William and Rosina Allard, of 50, High St., Woking. Son of Mr. Henry George Allen, of Preston Villa, Preston Grenadier Allen William George W G 4th Coy. 2nd Bn. Private 14650 27 10 November 1914 Menin Gate, Ypres Panel 9 and 11. Rd., Yeovil, Somerset husband of Lilian Mary Allen, of New Guards Cottages, Old Alresford, Hants.
    [Show full text]
  • Your New Refurbished Cinema Is Here
    Your new refurbished cinema is here Meet your Family Centres Team Winter 2020 @wokingcouncil www.facebook.com/wokingbc Please read and then recycle www.woking.gov.uk/thewokingmagazine Winter | 2020 Introduction Contents News in brief Latest news from across 4 Welcome to the the borough winter edition Woking Police of The Woking Supporting communities 13 Magazine. with crime prevention Nova Cinema ready to launch Your new cinema experience 16 We are nearing the end of a year unlike any that is here most of us would have witnessed before in our Brookwood Cemetery lifetimes. I want to take a moment to remember Exciting plans unveiled for those that have suffered, as well as say another 21 iconic heritage site heartfelt thank you to all of those key workers and volunteers who have kept our larders stocked, kept our towns and cities working and, most importantly, One good turn deserves another Celebrating the work of cared for us, even in our darkest days. 22 Woking Rotary Amongst this cohort, I must include my colleagues here at the Council. On the back page of this Give your family the best magazine you will see an ‘infographic’ which gives start in life 23 a snapshot of the incredible work that has been Introducing your Family Centres Team acheived so far to keep you safe during the pandemic and reopen Woking for business. Discover Brookwood Country Park The aim of this edition, as always, is to bring you a 26 Explore Woking’s green spaces bit of winter cheer. Because despite everything, there is also a lot of positive news.
    [Show full text]
  • 1502831940.Pdf
    Knaphill Methodist Church, Broadway, Knaphill, Surrey. GU21 2DR Minister: 01483 472524 [email protected] www.knaphill-methodist-church.com SUNDAY SERVICES 10am - Morning Worship (includes Junior and Youth Church) Our services are warm and cordial. We include traditional and contemporary hymns and songs, led by our worship group. The first 15 minutes of the service includes children and young people before going to their own groups. The sermons are Bible based and are often themed over several weeks. Holy Communion is generally on the second Sunday of every month. After the service everyone is welcome to join us for refreshments, a time for a chat and to get to know visitors. 6.30pm - Monthly Evening Holy Communion This is usually the fourth Sunday of the month. This is a small intimate service of Communion with about 15 or so people, many from other churches in the village. You will be made most welcome. If you would like to worship on a Sunday evening when we do not have a service, you will be able to at these churches: 2nd Sunday of the month - Holy Trinity church at 6.30pm. 3rd Sunday of the month - St Saviour's church, Brookwood at 6.00pm. This is a Q code - scan it with your For further information see the notice board Smartphone to go straight to outside the church or contact: our website [email protected] KMC MAGAZINE Editor: Barbara Humphries. Layout & design: Allan Wright FOR NEXT ISSUE: See “The Notices” for copy deadline. Copy to: Barbara Humphries - [email protected] 2 There is no Minister’s Message in this edition following the recent bereavement in Dave Faulkner’s family; our thoughts and prayers are with Dave and his family at this difficult time.
    [Show full text]
  • Wells in Woking Is Delivered by Woking Borough Council in Partnership with the Following Organisations: H.G
    FREE SOUVENIR PROGRAMME 150years ago Sponsored by: Media partner: Wells in Woking is delivered by Woking Borough Council in partnership with the following organisations: H.G. Wells Conference and Events Centre • H.G. Wells Society • Horsell Common Preservation Society Horsell Residents’ Association • Ochre Print Studios • Surrey Arts • Surrey History Centre • The Ambassadors The Lightbox • The Living Planet Centre • United Agents • Visit Surrey • Woking History Society 150TH ANNIVERSARY FIND OUT MORE AT WWW.WELLSINWOKING.INFO 3 150years ago ...one of the nation’s greatest literary talents Contents and public intellectuals was born. H.G. Wells moved to Woking in May 1895 where his Wells: the story of a short biography 4 writing gathered pace as did his ascent to fame The writer Wells’ work with a Woking connection 6 and fortune. His inspiration Martians landing on Horsell Common 8 He made Woking infamous in the late 19th The artist screen and print with Ochre Print Studios 10 Century by choosing Horsell Common as the location for his Martian invasion in his The teacher inspiring young people 12 science-fiction serial, The War of the Worlds. The local man exhibition at Surrey History Centre 14 Wells in Woking is a celebration of the Wells in Woking Event Diary Centre pull-out Borough’s connections with H.G. Wells and a Wells in Woking Heritage Trail Centre pull-out page-turning tale of inspiration, imagination A global influencer by Stephen Baxter 15 and success that is as much about the person as it is the place. Visit Woking, in the heart of The visible man new sculpture of H.G.
    [Show full text]
  • The Story of Nursing in British Mental Hospitals
    Downloaded by [New York University] at 12:59 29 November 2016 The Story of Nursing in British Mental Hospitals From their beginnings as the asylum attendants of the nineteenth century, mental health nurses have come a long way. This is the first comprehensive history of mental health nursing in Britain in over twenty years, and during this period the landscape has transformed as the large institutions have been replaced by services in the community. McCrae and Nolan examine how the role of mental health nursing has evolved in a social and professional context, brought to life by an abundance of anecdotal accounts. The nine chronologically ordered chapters follow the development from untrained attendants in the pauper lunatic asylums to the professionally qualified nurses of the twentieth century, and, finally, consider the rundown and closure of the mental hospitals from nurses’ perspectives. Throughout, the argument is made that while the training, organisation and environment of mental health nursing has changed, the aim has remained essentially the same: to nurture a therapeutic relationship with people in distress. McCrae and Nolan look forward as well as back, and highlight significant messages for the future of mental health care. For mental health nursing to be meaningfully directed, we must first understand the place from which this field has developed. This scholarly but accessible book is aimed at anyone with an interest in mental health or social history, and will also act as a useful resource for policy- makers, managers and mental health workers. Niall McCrae is a lecturer in mental health nursing at Florence Nightingale Faculty of Nursing & Midwifery, King’s College London.
    [Show full text]
  • The Council 1961-62
    i THE COUNCIL 1961-62 President.— WILLIAM McCARTAN, M.D., M.R.C.P., D.P.H., D.P.M. O. W. S. FITZGERALD, M.A., M.D., D.P.M. (South-Eastern). R. F. BARBOUR, M.A., M.B., Ch.B., F.R.C.P., D.P.M., F.B.Ps.S. (South- Western). Vice-Presidents and a E. U. H. PENTREATH, M.R.C.S., L.R.C.P., D.P.M. (Northern Divisional Chairmen. \ and Midland). P r o f . T . FERGUSON RODGER, B.Sc., MB., F.R.C.P.E., D.P.M., F.B.Ps.S. (Scottish). N. O'HIGGINS, M.D., D.P.M. (Irish). President-Elect.— ISABEL G. H. WILSON, C.B.E., M.D., F.R.C.P., D.P.M. Immediate Past-President.— ALEXANDER WALK, M.D., D.P.M. Treasurer.— THOMAS TENNENT, M.D., F.R.C.P., D.P.H., D.P.M. General Secretary.— A. B. MONRO, M.D., Ph.D., D.P.M. Registrar.— WILLIAM SARGANT, M.A., M.D., F.R.C.P., D.P.M. Editor-in-Chief.— ELIOT SLATER, M.D., F.R.C.P., D.P.M. Librarian.— ALEXANDER WALK, M.D., D.P.M. South-Eastern.— S. W. HARDWICK, B.Sc., M.D., M.R.C.P., D.P.M. South-Western.— R. W. SIMPSON, M.D., D.P.M. Divisional Northern and Midland.— W. V'. WADSWORTH, B.Sc., M.B., Ch.B., Secretaries. | M.R.C.P., D.P.M. Scottish.— M. M. WHITTET, M.R.C.P.E., F.R.F.P.S.G., D.P.M.
    [Show full text]
  • Brookwood News
    BROOKWOOD CRICKET CLUB BROOKWOOD Brookwood Cricket Club play Sunday friendly matches from April through to September, hold net sessions every Tuesday and compete Thanks to everybody who supported our Easter BBQ – £173 was raised in an indoor cricket league during the winter. We welcome new adult NEWS on the day for our charities! members of any age, who are looking for a friendly sociable cricket Our next Cash Bingo evenings are on Saturday 6 May and Saturday team, who enjoy their o eld activities almost as much as their May 2017 3 June, both 8pm for 'eyes down' at 8.30pm. £1 per book. Everybody matches. Our upcoming xtures are: welcome, including non-members. We have Skittles on Sunday 28 May. Come along and try your hand, 7 May 2017 Seven Sports CC Home FOR THEN, FOR NOW, FOR EVER from noon onwards – all welcome, including non-members. EDITORIAL 14 May 2017 The Golden Age Home Welcome to the May edition of the We have extended opening hours for the 1 and 29 May Bank Holiday 21 May 2017 Hale CC Home Brookwood News. This month sees Mondays – see the notice outside the Club for opening times. another event associated with the 28 May 2017 Eversley CC Home Memberships for 2017 are now available, so please enquire at the bar if centennial commemoration of The Great you are interested in joining your village social club. War. The Commonwealth War Grave Anyone interested in joining can contact Adrian on 07909 873187, Commission (CWGC)’s forthcoming Find out what is happening at the Club by following us on Facebook or [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • NOTICES UNDER the TRUSTEE ACT 1925, S. 27
    NOTICES UNDER THE TRUSTEE ACT 1925, s. 27 Notice is hereby given pursuant to s. 27 of the Trustee Act 1925 that any person having a claim send such particulars before the date specified in relation to that deceased person in the fourth against or an interest in the estate of any of the deceased persons whose names and addresses column of the said Table, after which date the personal representatives will distribute the estate are set out in the first and second columns of the following Table is hereby required to send among the persons entitled thereto having regard only to the claims and interests of which they particulars in writing of his claim or interest to the person or persons whose names and addresses have had notice and will not, as respects the property so distributed, be liable to any person of are set out opposite the name of the deceased person in the third column of the Table, and to whose claim they shall not then have had notice. Name of Deceased Address, description and date of death of Names, addresses and descriptions of Persons to whom notices of claims are to be Date before which Deceased given and names, in parentheses, of Personal Representatives notices of claims (Surname first) to be given FORGATSCH, Erika, other- 1010 Vienna, Schottenring, 19, Austria. 27th Oct- Barclays Bank Trust Company Limited, Poole Area Office, Old Orchard House, 13th April 1986 wise Erika Bertha Leonore ober 1982. 39/61 High Street, Poole, Dorset BH151BG. (001) 1 Sw ANDERSON, Stanley Tertius 16 Stone Park Avenue, Beckenham, Kent, Bank Barclays Bank Trust Company Limited, Grosvenor House (9th Floor), 125 High 14th April 1986 22! Mills Official (Retired).
    [Show full text]
  • THE OPENING of the SECOND SURREY PAUPER LUNATIC ASYLUM at BROOKWOOD Iain Wakeford 2015
    THE OPENING OF THE SECOND SURREY PAUPER LUNATIC ASYLUM AT BROOKWOOD Iain Wakeford 2015 s promised a few weeks ago, this week we are looking at the early history of Brookwood Hospital, the Second Surrey A County Pauper Lunatic Asylum, the first patents of which were admitted on the 17th June 1867. The site covered over 150 acres, bought from the Necropolis Company in 1860 The first Surrey County Asylum was established spade cultivation and thirty-three men go out wells and reservoirs, although for a number of at Wandsworth in 1841, but by the end of the daily under the gardener and farm bailiff’. years water was also taken from the 1850’s it was clear that accommodation there Basingstoke Canal, the canal company was not enough and proposals were made to The gardener (who had to be married) was apparently charging £10 a month for the erected a second asylum at Woking – ‘a spot apparently paid 21/- a week and provided with privilege. easily approached from various points of the ‘a house, gas and coals’. County by the convergence – of several The asylum was almost self-sufficient with male The reference to gas is interesting as the railroads traversing the district’. patients not just employed in the gardens and Asylum had its own gas works (more or less farms, but also in shoe-making, tailoring and As we have already seen in previous weeks, one where the Sainsbury’s Petrol Station is today). ‘other useful trades’, whilst the women did hundred and fifty acres were bought from the They also had their own water supply through Necropolis Company, and the County surveyor, C.H Howell set to work designing the buildings.
    [Show full text]
  • 95-96. 5) Abbey Rangers 2015-16
    1) Abbey Hey 96-97. 2) Abbey Hulton United 95-96. 3) Abbey National 94-95. 4) Abbey National (MK) 95-96. 5) Abbey Rangers 2015-16. 6) Abbey United 47-48. 7) Abbotonians United 78-79. 8) Aberford Albion 91-92. 9) Abingdon Town 48-49. 10) Abingdon United 77-78. 11) ABS Kilnhurst 1999-2000. 12) Accrington Loyal 2003-04. 13) Accrington Stanley Pre Lg. 20- 21. 14) Accrington Stanley (1970-71 club) 70-71. 15) Accrington Stanley (1968 club) 68-69. 16) ACD 94-85. 17) AC Delco 86- 87. 18) ACD Tridon 96-97. 19) Achilles 84-85. 20) Acklam Steelworks 2008-09. 21) Acle United 87-88. (Some programmes printed in error with Acle Town on the cover). 22) AC London 2015-16, 23) The Acorn Football Club of Whitecote 94-95. 24) A.C. Sphinx. 25) Acton Crown 91-92. 26) Acton United 43-44. 27) Adderbury Park 95-96. 28) Adderley Green 2001-02. 29) Addersley Rovers. 30) Addlestone 54-55. 31) Addlestone and Weybridge Town 80-81. 32) Addlestone Town 93-94. 33) Addmult 68-69. 34) AD Flooring 96-97. 35) Admiral 2003-04. 36) Admiral Group 2002-03. 37) Adur Athletic (Portslade). 38) AEI Rugby 2015-16. 39) AEI Sports 2016-17. 40) Aero Lucas 86-87. 41) AEK Boco 2014-15. 42) Aerostructure Sports and Social 90-91. 43) Aigburth People’s Hall 2009-10. 44) Ainsworth 2013-14. 45) Airdale Celtic 2000-01. 46) Airfield Construction Group. 47) Airspeed 50-51. 48) Air Training Corps (Manchester) 44-45.
    [Show full text]
  • Hospital Ups and Downs Hospital Ups and Downs
    HOSPITAL UPS AND DOWNS Iain Wakeford 2019 Later turned into a Geriatric Unit, the old Maternity Hospital in Heathside Road lived up to the claim that the NHS treated you from the cradle to the grave. 968-69 was a time of ups and downs as each at Windlesham and Walton, but a used ‘partly as a convalescent unit to which far as local hospitals were concerned. newspaper report the previous year had patients at St Peter’s Hospital could be 1 The main ‘down’ was the announced claimed the new unit would only cater for 120, transferred when they no longer need specialist closure of the Woking’s Maternity Hospital in noting that the Heathside Road facility catered attention, but are still not well enough to return Heathside Road, which together with maternity for just fifty-seven with a further fourteen home’. Sadly the radical idea that ‘no patient, units at Windlesham and Walton was being housed at the annexe on Kettlewell Hill. due to pressure for beds at St Peter’s Hospital, replaced by a brand-new maternity suite at St should be discharged and return home when Peter’s Hospital in Chertsey. Whatever the numbers, the old Maternity unit in conditions there are unsuitable for satisfactory Heathside Road was earmarked to be used as a convalescence’, appears not to have become The former war-hospital at Chertsey (in the Geriatric Hospital, with calls for it also to be policy. grounds of the Botleys Park Mental Hospital), had almost unlimited room for expansion it was claimed, with work taking place on the construction of a new district hospital that was predicted to eventually provide about 1,000 beds.
    [Show full text]