DOCSLIB.ORG

The Relationship Between Public Policy and Judicial Review in South Africa’S Constitutional Democracy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Relationship Between Public Policy and Judicial Review in South Africa’S Constitutional Democracy The Relationship between Public Policy and Judicial Review in South Africa’s Constitutional Democracy Puleng Ndjwili-Potele Supervisor: Professor Susan Booysen RESEARCH REPORT Masters of Management in Public Policy (MMPP) School of Governance Faculty of Commence Law and Management October 2017 Table of Contents ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................................................. 4 CHAPTER 1 .............................................................................................................................................. 5 1.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 5 1.2 Problem statement ........................................................................................................................... 8 1.3 Research questions ........................................................................................................................... 9 1.4 Research objectives ........................................................................................................................ 10 1.5 Research paradigm ......................................................................................................................... 10 1.6 Limitations of the study .................................................................................................................. 11 1.7 Ethical considerations in conducting research ............................................................................... 12 1.8 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 12 CHAPTER 2: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY AND DATA ANALYSIS ............................................................ 14 2.1 Research methodology ................................................................................................................... 14 2.1.1 Research design ....................................................................................................................... 14 2.1.2 Data sources ............................................................................................................................. 16 2.1.3 Data collection ......................................................................................................................... 17 2.1.4 Data collection process ............................................................................................................ 18 2.1.5 Research approach................................................................................................................... 20 2.1.6 Methods ................................................................................................................................... 21 2.1.7 Themes guiding the analysis .................................................................................................... 21 2.1.8 Questionnaire and targeting of the interviews........................................................................ 22 2.2 Data analysis ................................................................................................................................... 24 2.2.1 Induction .................................................................................................................................. 25 2.2.2 Content analysis ....................................................................................................................... 26 2.2.3 Data analysis tools ................................................................................................................... 27 2.3 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 28 CHAPTER 3: LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK ................................................... 29 3.1 Conceptual clarifications ................................................................................................................. 29 3.2 Theoretical framework ................................................................................................................... 32 3.2.1 Constitutional supremacy and the rule of law ......................................................................... 32 3.2.2 Separation of powers ............................................................................................................... 34 1 | P a g e 3.2.3 Chapter Nine institutions ......................................................................................................... 38 3.2.4 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 39 3.3 Literature review ............................................................................................................................. 39 3.3.1 Judicial review of public policy and separation of powers ...................................................... 39 3.3.2 Judicial deference .................................................................................................................... 42 3.3.3 The meeting between the Chief Justice and the executive ..................................................... 44 3.3.4 Consequences of judicial review .............................................................................................. 45 3.3.4.1 Courts and politics ............................................................................................................ 45 3.3.4.2 Judicial independence ....................................................................................................... 47 3.3.4.3 Enforcement of court judgments ...................................................................................... 49 3.3.4.4 Legitimacy of courts .......................................................................................................... 52 3.3.4.5 Judiciary as policy-maker .................................................................................................. 55 3.4 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 56 CHAPTER 4: RESEARCH FINDINGS I: CASE STUDY REVIEW ................................................................... 57 4.1 The exercise of public power by the executive ............................................................................... 58 4.1.1 The SABC case study ................................................................................................................ 58 4.1.2 The Nkandla case study ........................................................................................................... 61 4.1.3 The Bashir case study ............................................................................................................... 65 4.2 Additional cases .............................................................................................................................. 71 4.2.1 SASSA and the Department of Social Development ................................................................ 71 4.2.2 The Hawks ................................................................................................................................ 72 4.2.3 The IPID .................................................................................................................................... 73 4.2.4 National Treasury ..................................................................................................................... 74 4.2.5 The NPA .................................................................................................................................... 77 4.2.6 State of Capture report ............................................................................................................ 79 4.3 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 81 CHAPTER 5: RESEARCH FINDINGS II: INTERVIEWS ................................................................................ 82 5.1 Findings from the interviews ...................................................................................................... 82 5.2 Summary of the findings ............................................................................................................. 85 5.3 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 87 CHAPTER 6: COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT OF THE CUMULATIVE RESEARCH FINDINGS ...................... 88 6.1 Findings from the interviews .......................................................................................................... 88 6.2 Findings from the literature review ................................................................................................ 89 6.2.1 Reasons for judicial review ...................................................................................................... 89 2 | P a g e 6.2.2 Independence of the judiciary ................................................................................................. 90 6.2.3 Ideology of judges ...................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Country Guide South Africa
    Human Rights and Business Country Guide South Africa March 2015 Table of Contents How to Use this Guide .................................................................................. 3 Background & Context ................................................................................. 7 Rights Holders at Risk ........................................................................... 15 Rights Holders at Risk in the Workplace ..................................................... 15 Rights Holders at Risk in the Community ................................................... 25 Labour Standards ................................................................................. 35 Child Labour ............................................................................................... 35 Forced Labour ............................................................................................ 39 Occupational Health & Safety .................................................................... 42 Trade Unions .............................................................................................. 49 Working Conditions .................................................................................... 56 Community Impacts ............................................................................. 64 Environment ............................................................................................... 64 Land & Property ......................................................................................... 72 Revenue Transparency
    [Show full text]
  • Tom Gerald Daly, University of Melbourne
    Constitutional Court Review 2019 © The Authors Volume 9, 387–408 Open Access article distributed in terms of the https://doi org/10 2989/CCR 2019 0015 Creative Commons Attribution License [CC BY 4 0] Kindred Strangers: Why has the Constitutional Court of South Africa Never Cited the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights? TOM GERALD DALY ABSTRACT: Why has the Constitutional Court of South Africa never cited the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights? The two courts appear to be natural allies, having both elaborated a robust jurisprudence promoting civil-political and socio-economic rights, accountability, political participation, and good governance However, despite the African Court having issued a raft of landmark merits judgments since June 2013, the Constitutional Court has yet to cite its jurisprudence This article attempts to account for this apparent lacuna in South African case-law, placing it against the Constitutional Court’s overall approach to citing international law and courts, and suggesting a range of possible explanatory factors, including: the state’s position as a ‘reluctant regionalist’; institutional factors (such as the Constitutional Court’s possible preference to retain constitutional supremacy and adjudicative autonomy, and tendency to more readily cite non-African jurisprudence); and broader structural factors (such as a lack of citations in submissions to the Court) It is argued that this matters for two reasons First, it may possibly deprive the Constitutional Court of sources that could enrich its
    [Show full text]
  • FW De Klerk Foundation Conference on Uniting Behind the Constitution
    FW de Klerk Foundation Conference on Uniting Behind the Constitution 2nd February 2013 DR HOLGER DIX, RESIDENT Representative OF THE KONRAD Adenauer Foundation FOR SOUTH Africa, AND FORMER PRESIDENT FW DE KLERK. On Saturday, 2 February 2013, the FW de Klerk Foundation hosted a successful conference at the Protea Hotel President in Bantry Bay, Cape Town. Themed “Uniting Behind the Constitution” and held in conjunction with the Konrad Adenauer Foundation, the conference was well attended by members of the public and a large press contingent. The speakers included thought leaders from civil society, business, academia and politics. This publication is a compendium of speeches presented on the day (speeches were transcribed from recordings), each relating to an important facet of the South African Constitution. Each speech was followed by a lively panel discussion, and panelists included: Dr Lucky Mathebula (board member of the FW de Klerk Foundation), John Kane-Berman (CEO of the South African Institute for Race Relations), Adv Paul Hoffman (Director of the Southern African Institute for Accountability), Adv Johan Kruger (Director of the Centre for Constitutional Rights), Dr Theuns Eloff (Vice-Chancellor of North-West University), Adv Johan Kruger SC (Acting Judge and board member of the FW de Klerk Foundation), Michael Bagraim (President of the Cape Chamber of Commerce), Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi (Leader of the IFP) and Paul Graham (Executive Director of the Institute for Democracy in South Africa). UpholdingCelebrating Diversity South
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2018
    ANNUAL REPORT 2018 Annual Report 2018 1 ORGANISATIONAL OVERVIEW Information and ADVISORY BOARD Communications Management: PROF JOSÈ FRANTZ JACOB NTHOIWA Deputy Vice-Chancellor University of Communications Manager the Western Cape, represented by Prof Julian May, Director: DST-NRF Office Management: Centre for Excellence on Food DEBBIE GORDON Security (Chair) Office Manager PROF JACQUES DE VILLE MANDY CUPIDO Dean of the Faculty of Law Receptionist PROF JAAP DE VISSER, Director: Dullah Omar Institute Children’s Rights Project: ADV KARRISHA PILLAY ASSOC PROF BENYAM DAWIT Advocate at the Cape Bar Judge MEZMUR VINCENT SALDANHA Project Head Judge at the Western Cape High DR MARIA ASSIM Court Senior Researcher MR ASHRAF MAHOMED MESERET KIFLE Practising attorney Doctoral Researcher ADV GEOFF BUDLENDER SC CRYSTAL NITSCKIE Advocate at the Cape Bar Administrator ASSOC PROF LEA MWAMBENE Law Faculty representative Africa Criminal Justice Reform: ASSOC PROF YONATAN FESSHA ASSOC PROF LUKAS MUNTINGH Law Faculty representative Project Head JEROME SMITH JEAN REDPATH South African Research Chair Law Students representative Researcher in Multilevel Government, KRISTEN PETERSEN Law and Policy: MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE Researcher PROF NICO STEYTLER PROF JULIAN MAY TINA LORIZZO South African Research Chair Associate Researcher PROF JACQUES DE VILLE DR TINASHE CHIGWATA PROF JAAP DE VISSER SAFEEYA MAHOMED Senior Researcher (from June 2018) Intern ASSOC PROF LEA MWAMBENE MICHELLE MAZIWISA CRYSTAL NITSCKIE Postdoctoral Researcher Administrator STAFF ANNETTE MAY Doctoral
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 1999
    Fourth Annual Report December 1998 - December 1999 South African Human Rights Commission 4th Annual Report December 1998 December 1999 Table of contents Page Preface ………………………………………………………………………………… v Executive Summary ………………………………………………………………… vii 1. Introduction ………………………………………………………………….. 1-8 Overview of 1999 ……………………………………………………… 1 The human rights environment ………………………………………. 2 Relations with government …………………………………………… 4 Relationship with Parliament ………………………………………..…. 5 International relations …………………………………………………... 5 Annual Planning Meeting ………………………………………………. 7 Conclusion ………………………………………………………………. 8 2. Major Projects of 1999 …………………………………………………… 9-16 Equality …………………………………………………………..……… 9 Racism and Racial Discrimination ……………………………….. 9 Inquiry into Racism in the Media …………………………………. 10 Other equality activities ……………………………………………. 11 Roll Back Xenophobia Campaign……….………………………. 12 Human rights in the criminal justice system ………………………….. 13 Interventions ………………………………………………….…… 14 HIV/AIDS Seminar ……………………………………….…………….… 15 The rights of older persons ………………………………………….…. 16 3. Finance ………………………………………………………………………..17-22 Balance Sheet March 1999 …………………………………….………. 18 Income Statement March 1999 ………………………………………… 19 Budget 1999/2000 ……………………………………………………….. 20 Report of the Auditor-General ………………………………………….. 21 4. Administration …..………………………………………….…….………… 23-27 Office Developments ………………………………………………….. 23 New provincial offices …………………………………………… 23 Staffing …………………………………………………………… . 23 Information technology advancements …………………………
    [Show full text]
  • South Africa
    SOUTH AFRICA Background and Possibilities for Danish Transitional Assistance By Finn Tarp Institute of Economics University of Copenhagen for Danida December 1992 Danida Views expressed in this study do not necessarily correspond to those of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Danida, December 1992 SOUTH AFRICA Background and Possibilities for Danish Transitional Assistance By Finn Tarp Institute of Economics University of Copenhagen for Danida December 1992 Danida TABLE OF CONTENTS page Preface v Acknowledgements vii List of Abbreviations viii I. GENERAL COUNTRY BACKGROUND 1 1.1 Geography, Natural Resources and Land Use 1 1.2 Government, Constitution and Regional Administration 3 1.3 Infrastructure and Urban Centres 5 1.4 Population and Society 6 II. POLITICAL SETTING 9 2.1 Historical Background 9 2.2 Apartheid 10 2.3 Armed Struggle and International Sanctions 11 2.4 Toward a Negotiated Settlement 13 2.5 Constitutional Issues and Human Rights 17 2.6 Violence 19 2.7 Prospects for the Future 21 III. ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL SITUATION 23 3.1 Macroeconomic Features 23 3.2 Socio-economic Characteristics 25 3.3 Sectoral Characteristics 28 3.4 Regional Dimensions 31 3.5 Summing-up 32 IV. DEVELOPMENT CONTEXT AND POLICY CONCERNS 34 4.1 Introduction 34 4.2 Major Actors 34 4.3 Policy Frameworks 42 4.4 Major Development Issues 48 3 4.5 Conclusion and Outlook 54 V. INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AND FOREIGN AID 58 5.1 Global Political Relations 58 5.2 Regional Dimensions 59 5.3 Foreign Aid 61 5.4 Experiences Gained and Absorptive Capacity 64 5.5 Prospects for the Future 66 VI.
    [Show full text]
  • Powers of the Public Protector: Are Its Findings and Recommendations Legally Binding?
    POWERS OF THE PUBLIC PROTECTOR: ARE ITS FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS LEGALLY BINDING? by MOLEFHI SOLOMON PHOREGO 27312837 Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree: Master of Laws (LLM Research): Public Law Study Leader: Professor Danie Brand Department of Public Law, University of Pretoria November 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS SUMMARY………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS……………………………………………………………………….........................vii CHAPTER 1 Introduction…..…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..1 The Public Protector as a Chapter Nine Institution………………………………………………………1 Research problem………………………………………………………………………………………………………..2 Aims and objectives of study……………………………………………………………………………………….3 Research Methodology………………………………………………………………………………………………..3 Research Questions………………………………………………………………………………………………………4 Limitations…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….4 Chapter Outline……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..4 CHAPTER 2 CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY PROVISIONS GOVERNING THE OPERATIONS OF THE OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC PROTECTOR Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….6 The Constitutional provisions……………………………………………………………………………………..7 Meaning of “Appropriate remedial action’ as contained in the Constitution….…………..11 STATUTORY PROVISIONS REGULATING THE OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC PROTECTOR……...10 Section 6 of the Public Protector Act………………………………………………………………………….12 i Section 7 of the Public Protector Act………………………………………………………………………….17 Section 8 of the Public Protector Act………………………………………………………………………….19
    [Show full text]
  • Download 2018 Annual Report
    1 Faculty of Law 2018 Centre for ANNUAL Faculty of Law Human Rights REPORT Centre for Human Rights, University of Pretoria | Annual Report 2018 The Centre for Human Rights is an internationally recognised CONTENTS university-based institution combining academic excellence and effective activism to advance human rights, particularly in Africa. DIRECTOR’S MESSAGE 4 The Centre for Human Rights was established in the Faculty of Law, University of Pretoria, in 1986, CENTRE MANAGEMENT TEAM 5 as part of domestic efforts against the apartheid system of the time. ACADEMIC PROGRAMMES 7 The Centre works towards human rights education in Africa, a greater awareness of human rights, the wide dissemination of publications on human rights in Africa, and the improvement of the rights RESEARCH 13 of women, indigenous peoples, persons with disabilities, sexual minorities and other disadvantaged or marginalised persons or groups across the continent. EDUCATION PROJECTS 17 Over the years, the Centre has positioned itself in an unmatched network of practising and academic lawyers, national and international civil servants and human rights practitioners across the entire RESEARCH UNITS 24 continent, with a specific focus on human rights law in Africa, and international development law in general. AD HOC EVENTS 40 Today, a wide network of Centre graduates contribute in numerous ways to the advancement and strengthening of human rights and democracy all over the Africa continent, and even further afield. PUBLICATIONS 42 In 2006, the Centre was awarded the UNESCO Prize for Human Rights Education, with particular ASSOCIATED INSTITUTES 46 recognition for the African Human Rights Moot Court Competition and the LLM in Human Rights and Democratisation in Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 CSO Sustainability Index for Sub-Saharan Africa
    The 2014 CSO Sustainability Index For Sub-Saharan Africa Developed by: United States Agency for International Development Bureau for Democracy, Conflict, and Humanitarian Assistance Center of Excellence on Democracy, Human Rights, and Governance Bureau for Africa Office of Sustainable Development CONTENTS INTRODUCTION III ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS IV EXECUTIVE SUMMARY VI 2014 CSO SUSTAINABILITY INDEX XVII ANGOLA 1 BOTSWANA 8 BURUNDI 16 DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO 24 ETHIOPIA 33 GABON 41 THE GAMBIA 49 GHANA 57 GUINEA 66 KENYA 74 LIBERIA 82 MALAWI 90 MALI 98 MOZAMBIQUE 107 THE 2014 CSO SUSTAINABILITY INDEX FOR SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA i NIGERIA 115 RWANDA 123 SENEGAL 132 SIERRA LEONE 139 SOUTH AFRICA 146 SOUTH SUDAN 154 SUDAN 162 TANZANIA 170 ZAMBIA 186 ZIMBABWE 194 ANNEX A: CSO SUSTAINABILITY INDEX METHODOLOGY 202 ANNEX B: STATISTICAL DATA FOR SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA 214 ii THE 2014 CSO SUSTAINABILITY INDEX FOR SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA INTRODUCTION USAID is pleased to present the sixth edition of the CSO Sustainability Index (CSOSI) for Sub-Saharan Africa. This year’s Index covers civil society organizations (CSOs) in twenty-five countries across Sub- Saharan Africa. It addresses both advances and setbacks in seven key components or “dimensions” of the sustainability of the civil society sector: legal environment, organizational capacity, financial viability, advocacy, service provision, infrastructure, and public image. The Index’s methodology relies on the knowledge of CSO practitioners and researchers, who in each country form an expert panel to assess and rate these dimensions of CSO sustainability during the year. The panel agrees on a score for each dimension, which can range from 1 (most developed) to 7 (most challenged).
    [Show full text]
  • Adeoye O. Akinola Editor the Political Economy of Xenophobia in Africa Advances in African Economic, Social and Political Development
    Advances in African Economic, Social and Political Development Adeoye O. Akinola Editor The Political Economy of Xenophobia in Africa Advances in African Economic, Social and Political Development Series Editors Diery Seck, CREPOL - Center for Research on Political Economy, Dakar, Senegal Juliet U. Elu, Morehouse College, Atlanta, GA, USA Yaw Nyarko, New York University, NY, USA Africa is emerging as a rapidly growing region, still facing major challenges, but with a potential for significant progress – a transformation that necessitates vigorous efforts in research and policy thinking. This book series focuses on three intricately related key aspects of modern-day Africa: economic, social and political development. Making use of recent theoretical and empirical advances, the series aims to provide fresh answers to Africa’s development challenges. All the socio- political dimensions of today’s Africa are incorporated as they unfold and new policy options are presented. The series aims to provide a broad and interactive forum of science at work for policymaking and to bring together African and international researchers and experts. The series welcomes monographs and contributed volumes for an academic and professional audience, as well as tightly edited conference proceedings. Relevant topics include, but are not limited to, economic policy and trade, regional integration, labor market policies, demographic development, social issues, political economy and political systems, and environmental and energy issues. More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/11885 Adeoye O. Akinola Editor The Political Economy of Xenophobia in Africa Editor Adeoye O. Akinola University of Zululand KwaDlangezwa, South Africa ISSN 2198-7262 ISSN 2198-7270 (electronic) Advances in African Economic, Social and Political Development ISBN 978-3-319-64896-5 ISBN 978-3-319-64897-2 (eBook) https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-64897-2 Library of Congress Control Number: 2017956902 © Springer International Publishing AG 2018 This work is subject to copyright.
    [Show full text]
  • Read Article
    AFRICAN HUMAN RIGHTS LAW JOURNAL (2013) 13 AHRLJ 55-81 Achieving social justice in the human rights/intellectual property debate: Realising the goal of access to medicines Yousuf A Vawda* Associate Professor of Law, University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa Brook K Baker** Professor of Law, Northeastern University, Boston MA, USA; Honorary Research Fellow, University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa Summary What happens when the assertion of intellectual property rights by their holders impacts on the human rights of consumers, in particular, their right to access health care and health products such as medicines? Proponents of access to medicines as a human right reference the soft law of human rights and the broad ethical frameworks within which human rights understandings are situated but, paradoxically, the pharmaceutical companies that hold proprietary interests in medicines also claim human rights to their medical discoveries. They argue that the ecology of research and development on medicines is inextricably linked to the possession of exclusive rights in the form of patent and data protections. The proprietary interests of pharmaceutical companies are stringently pursued and enforced by global powers via their trade policy and otherwise. Thus, this article argues that human rights must trump those proprietary rights, for a number of reasons, and seeks to introduce a social justice perspective on the human rights/intellectual property debate. It begins by reviewing the competing paradigms of the right to health versus proprietary intellectual property rights, showing how the human rights regime has achieved superiority in theory, but inferiority in practice. It proceeds to delineate the context in which essential medicines have increasingly * BA (UDW), BProc (UNISA), LLM (UDW), LLD (UKZN); [email protected] ** BA (Harvard), JD (Northeastern); [email protected] 56 (2013) 13 AFRICAN HUMAN RIGHTS LAW JOURNAL become endangered global public goods.
    [Show full text]
  • Compendium of Key Human Rights Documents of the African Union
    COMPENDIUM OF KEY HUMAN RIGHTS DOCUMENTS OF THE AFRICAN UNION Fourth Edition Editors: Christof Heyns and Magnus Killander 2010 Compendium of Key Human Rights Documents of the African Union (Fourth Edition) Published by: Pretoria University Law Press (PULP) The Pretoria University Law Press (PULP) is a publisher, based in Africa, launched and managed by the Centre for Human Rights and the Faculty of Law, University of Pretoria, South Africa. PULP endeavours to publish and make available innovative, high-quality scholarly texts on law in Africa that have been peer-reviewed. PULP also publishes a series of collections of legal documents related to public law in Africa, as well as text books from African countries other than South Africa. For more information on PULP, see: www.chr.up.ac.za/pulp To order, contact: Centre for Human Rights Faculty of Law University of Pretoria South Africa 0002 Tel: +27 12 420 4948 Fax: +27 12 362 5125 [email protected] www.chr.up.ac.za/pulp Printed and bound by: ABC Press Cape Town Cover design: Yolanda Booyzen and Lizette Besaans, the Centre for Human Rights Copyright permission: Reproductions from the African Human Rights Law Reports (2000-2004) with permission from JUTA, ISSN 1812-2418 and from Human Rights Law in Africa (2004) Christof Heyns and Morné van der Linde (eds), ISBN 90 04 13881 1, with permission from Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. ISBN: 978-0-9869857-1-3 Table of Contents FOREWORD vii INTRODUCTION ix INSTRUMENTS OF THE AFRICAN UNION Charter of the Organization of African Unity (1963/1963) 2 Treaty
    [Show full text]