Compendium of Adjudications 2008-2009
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PRESS COUNCIL OF INDIA Compendium of Adjudications (April 1, 2008-March 31, 2009) New Delhi Compendium of Adjudications Contents Preface Index of Adjudications of the Council for -- 1 the Period April 1, 2008- March 31, 2009 Adjudications of the Council -- 12 PREFACE The Press Council of India over the last three years has been preparing and publishing its Compendium of Adjudications giving an account of the complaints received from and against the press and the number of complaints adjudicated during the year. These adjudications include matters in which principles of far reaching importance to guide the conduct of the press and the authorities have been laid down. I am confident that all concerned will give the observations of the Council the serious consideration they merit and try to follow the code that develops from these adjudications. G.N. Ray Chairman Press Council of India Index of Adjudications of the Council for the Period April 1, 2008 - March 31, 2009 S.No. Parties Date of Decision Harassment of Newsmen 1. Complaint of Shri Rajesh Kumar, Editor, Reporter’s June 12, Eyes and Shri Sardar Bhupinder Singh, Editor, India 2008 One Day, New Delhi against the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Faridabad and the S.D.M. Ballabhgarh, Haryana 2. Complaint of Shri Vijay Kumar Srivastava, Publisher/ ’’ Editor, Bagpat News, New Delhi against Shri O.P. Singh, Sub-Inspector, Pakwara, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh 3. Complaint of Smt. Krishna Shukla, Chief Editor, ’’ Taphtish, Hindi weekly, Sultanpur, Uttar Pradesh against local police authorities, Sultanpur 4. Complaint of Shri Rajkishore Gupta, Journalist, Dainik ’’ Navkaramyug, Gandhi Nagar, Chitrakoot, Uttar Pradesh against local police authorities and Railway Police Force, Chitrakoot, Uttar Pradesh 5. Complaint of Shri Gurinder Singh Mehandiratta, Press ’’ Correspondent, Daily Spokesman, Faridkot, Punjab against local police authorities 6. Complaint of the President and other members of October 14, Press Club of Mengalganj, Lakhimpur, Khiri, U.P. 2008 against local police authorities 7. Complaint of Shri H.R. Khan, Editor, Operation, Hindi ’’ weekly, Uttar Pradesh against the District Magistrate, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh 8. Complaint of Shri Salman Rizvi, Journalist, Dainik Jagran, ’’ Khiri, Uttar Pradesh against local police authorities, Khiri, Uttar Pradesh 1 S.No. Parties Date of Decision 9. Complaint of Shri Prashant Gaur, District Bureau Chief, October 14, Dainik CNN, Bulandshahar, Uttar Pradesh against local 2008 police authorities 10. Complaint of Shri Pramendra Sirohi, Sub-Editor, ’’ Khuli Kahaniya, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh against the local police authorities, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh 11. Complaint of Shri Imamuddin Khan, Correspondent, ’’ Dainik Jagran, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, against local police authorities 12. Complaint of Shri Ved Gupta, Editor, Doon Ujala, ’’ Dehradun, Uttarakhand against local police authorities 13. Complaint of Shri Ved Prakash Pandey, Freelancer, ’’ Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh against local police authorities 14. Complaint of Shri M.M. Khan, Editor, Indica Times, ’’ Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh against local police authorities 15. Complaint of Pt. Umesh Kumar Chaturvedi, Journalist, March 2, Satyamail, Jhansi, U.P. against Shri Dilip Sarawagi and 2009 local police authorities, U.P. 16. Complaint of Shri Shivakant Pathak, Correspondent, ’’ Dainik Dewan and Dainik Karamyug Prakash, Jalaun, U.P. against police authorities of Jalaun, U.P. 17. Complaint of Shri Jitender Mohan Saxena, Editor, Kalyug ’’ Ki Duniya, Pilibhit, U.P. against the Chief Medical Officer, Pilibhit, U.P. 18. Complaint of Shri Iliyaskhan, Editor/Publisher, weekly ’’ Barasta Toofan, Badanpur, Maharashtra against local police authorities Facilities to the Press 19. Complaint of the Editor, Apradh Bodh, Hathras, Uttar June 12, Pradesh against the Additional District Information 2008 Officer, Hathras, Uttar Pradesh 2 S.No. Parties Date of Decision 20. Complaint of the Publisher, Gramanchal Shilpanchaler June 12, Khabar, Burdwan, West Bengal against the DAVP, 2008 New Delhi 21. Complaint of Pandit Sanjib Narayan Dass, Chief October 14, Editor, Jugar Sadhan and Jyotishphalak against the 2008 I&PRD, Government of Assam, Guwahati 22. Complaint of Shri Uttam Chandra Sharma, Editor-in- ’’ Chief, Muzaffarnagar Bulletin, Uttar Pradesh against U.P. Power Corporation 23. Complaint of Shri Umashankar Mishra, the Editor, USM ’’ Patrika, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh against the DAVP, New Delhi 24. Complaint of Shri Prashant Kumar Singh, Publisher/ ’’ Owner, Farmer Sandesh, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh against the DAVP, New Delhi 25. Complaint of Shri Uttam Chandra Sharma, Editor, March 2, Muzaffarnagar Bulletin, Muzaffarnagar against postal 2009 authorities, Muzaffarnagar, U.P. 26. Complaint of Shri Sarvesh Kumar ‘Suyash’, Research ’’ Journalist, Kanpur against the Director, I&PRD, Lucknow 27. Complaint of Shri L.C. Gupt, Editor, Pilibhit Times, ’’ Pilibhit, U.P. against the District Magistrate, Pilibhit and the DIO, Pilibhit, U.P. 28. Complaint of Shri Satish Sharma, Managing Editor, Savera ’’ India Times, Nani-Daman against the Information and Publicity Department, Government of Daman and Diu 29. Complaint of Dr. H.H. Majid Hussain, Chief Editor, ’’ Daily Urdu Action, Bhopal, M.P. against the Commissioner, Public Relations Department, Bhopal, M.P. Curtailment of Press Freedom 30. Complaint of Shri Sharad Audhichya, Editor, Semaria March 2, Express, Satna, M.P. against anti social elements, Satna, 2009 M.P. 3 S.No. Parties Date of Decision Principles and Publication 31. Complaint of the Assistant Inspector General of Police, June 12, CBI, New Delhi against Media Force, New Delhi 2008 32. Complaint of Shri Jayanta Deka, Advocate and others, ’’ Mangaldai, Assam against Asomiya Pratidin, Guwahati, Assam, October 14, 2008 33. Complaints of Smt. Karabi Dutta, Guwahati against ’’ (i) Dainik Janasadharan, (ii) Asomiya Khabar, (iii) Amar Asom, (iv) Dainik Janambhoomi, (v) Dainik Agradoot, (vi) Aji and (vii) Asomiya Pratidin, Guwahati 34. Complaint of Shri Kailash Chand Jain, Nagaland against ’’ the Editor, Jain Gazette, Guwahati 35. Complaint of Shri Alok Kumar Dutta, Advocate, Howrah, ’’ West Bengal against Anand Bazar Patrika, Kolkata 36. Complaint of Shri Konsam Lanngamba, Advocate/Hon. ’’ President, United Committee Manipur (UCM) against The Telegraph, Guwahati 37. Complaint of Shri S.C. Sharma, Advocate, New Delhi ’’ against Dalal Street Journal, Mumbai 38. Complaint of Shri Binod Kumar Sinha, Ramgarh Cantt., ’’ Jharkhand against Saras Salil, New Delhi 39. Complaint of Smt. Rachana Viswanathan, New Delhi ’’ against The Hindustan Times, New Delhi 40. Complaint of Shri Nadir Khan, Meerut Cantt, Uttar ’’ Pradesh against the Editor, Amar Ujala, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh 41. Complaint of Ms. Anjali Gopalan, Executive Director, March 2, NAZ Foundation (India) Trust, New Delhi against the 2009 Editor, The Hindustan Times, New Delhi 42. Complaint of Dr. D. Chinniah, Bangaluru against the ’’ Editor, Lankesh Patrike, Bangaluru 43. Complaint of Shri Shivalingaiah, Bangaluru against the ’’ Editor, Lankesh Patrike, Bangaluru 4 S.No. Parties Date of Decision 44. Complaint of Shri M. Prabhakara, Director of Treasuries March 2, and others, Bangaluru, Karnataka against the Editor, 2009 Gauri Lankesh, Bangaluru 45. Complaint of the Director, Programmes Committee, ’’ Catholic Sabha Mangalore Pradesh ® Kandapura, Karnataka against the Editor Udayavani, Manipal, Karnataka Press and Defamation 46. Complaint of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, June 12, Government of India, New Delhi against the Editor, 2008 Punjab Kesari, New Delhi 47. Complaint of Shri Virender Singh Sachan, Kanpur Dehat, ’’ Uttar Pradesh against the Editor, The Aj, Kanpur 48. Complaint of the Chairman, Geetanjali Public School, ’’ Delhi against the Editor, Nazar-ki-Nazar 49. Complaint of Shri Ashutosh Varshney, Aligarh against the ’’ Editor, Shikhar Ki Gunj, Aligarh 50. Complaint of Shri S.K. Shukla, Lecturer, Vivekanand ’’ National Inter College, Pukhrayan, Kanpur against the Editor, Aj, Kanpur 51. Complaint of Shri Manoj Kumar Trivedi, Assistant Regional ’’ Manager, Uttar Pradesh Transport Corporation, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh against the Editor, Dainik Jagran, Meerut, U.P 52. Complaint of Mohd. Fasih Uddin, Advocate, Moradabad, ’’ Uttar Pradesh against the Editor, Dainik Jagran, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh 53. Complaint of Shri Ved Prakash Saini, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh against the Editor, Pradesh Ke Apradh, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh 54. Complaint of Smt. Usha Nagar, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh ’’ against the Editor, Dainik Prayan, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh 5 S.No. Parties Date of Decision 55. Complaint of Mahatma Jagdishwaranandji, Barabanki, June 12, Uttar Pradesh against the Editor, Sarita, New Delhi 2008 56. Complaint of Shri Bhagwati Prasad, Chief Executive, ’’ National Cooperative Union of India, New Delhi against the Editor, Mission India 57. Complaint of Shri Dependra Pathak, IPS, A.C.P., Delhi ’’ against the Editor, Metro Now, New Delhi 58. Complaint of Dr. Mangal Das, Senior Medical Officer, ’’ Fatehpur, Himanchal Pradesh against the Editor, Punjab Kesari, Jalandhar 59. Complaints of Shri M.L. Syal, President, Haryana Civil ’’ Pensioners Welfare Association, Sirsa against Editors, (i) Punjab Kesari; and (ii) Haryana Deep, Haryana 60. Complaint of Shri S.L. Koli, General Secretary, Christian ’’ Solidarity Society, Dehradun against the Editor, Parwat Jan, Dehradun 61. Complaint of Shri Chandrabhan Garg, Chairman, Municipal ’’ Corporation Council, Udhamsingh Nagar against