Excess and the Mean in Early Modern English Literature

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Excess and the Mean in Early Modern English Literature qqqqqqq EXCESS AND THE MEAN IN EARLY qqqqqqqMODERN ENGLISH LITERATURE LITERATURE IN HISTORY SERIES EDITORS David Bromwich, James Chandler, and Lionel Gossman The books in this series study literary works in the context of the intellectual conditions, social movements, and patterns of action in which they took shape. OTHER BOOKS IN THE SERIES Lawrence Rothfield, Vital Signs: Medical Realism in Nineteenth-Century Fiction David Quint, Epic and Empire: Politics and Generic Form from Virgil to Milton Alexander Welsh, The Hero of the Waverly Novels Susan Dunn, The Deaths of Louis XVI: Regicide and the French Political Imagination Sharon Achinstein, Milton and the Revolutionary Reader Esther Schor, Bearing the Dead: The British Culture of Mourning from the Enlightenment to Victoria Elizabeth K. Helsinger, Rural Scenes and National Representation: Britain, 1815–1850 Katie Trumpener, Bardic Nationalism: The Romantic Novel and the British Empire Karen Chase and Michael Levenson, The Spectacle of Intimacy: A Public Life for the Victorian Family qqqqqqqq qqqqqqqqJOSHUA SCODEL Excess and the Mean in Early Modern English Literature PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS PRINCETON AND OXFORD COPYRIGHT 2002 BY PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS PUBLISHED BY PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS, 41 WILLIAM STREET, PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY 08540 IN THE UNITED KINGDOM: PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS, 3 MARKET PLACE, WOODSTOCK, OXFORDSHIRE OX20 1SY ALL RIGHTS RESERVED LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA SCODEL, JOSHUA, 1958– EXCESS AND THE MEAN IN EARLY MODERN ENGLISH LITERATURE / JOSHUA SCODEL P. CM. (LITERATURE IN HISTORY SERIES) INCLUDES BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES AND INDEX. ISBN 0-691-09028-9 (ACID-FREE PAPER) 1. ENGLISH LITERATURE—EARLY MODERN, 1500–1700—HISTORY AND CRITICISM. 2. MODERATION IN LITERATURE. 3. LITERATURE AND SOCIETY—ENGLAND— HISTORY—16TH CENTURY. 4. LITERATURE AND SOCIETY—ENGLAND—HISTORY—17TH CENTURY. 5. DIDACTIC LITERATURE, ENGLISH—HISTORY AND CRITICISM. 6. ENGLISH LITERATURE—CLASSICAL INFLUENCES. 7. TEMPERANCE IN LITERATURE. 8. POLARITY IN LITERATURE. 9. ETHICS IN LITERATURE. I. TITLE. PR428.M63 S36 2002 2001059168 THIS BOOK HAS BEEN COMPOSED IN GOUDY PRINTED ON ACID-FREE PAPER. ∞ WWW.PUPRESS.PRINCETON.EDU PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 13579108642 qqqqqqqq qqqqqqqqCONTENTS Acknowledgments and Note on Citations vii Introduction: Ancient Paradigms in Modern Conflicts 1 PART ONE Two Early Modern Revisions of the Mean 19 1. Donne and the Personal Mean 21 2. “Mediocrities” and “Extremities”: Baconian Flexibility and the Aristotelian Mean 48 PART TWO Means and Extremes in Early Modern Georgic 77 3. Moderation, Temperate Climate, and National Ethos from Spenser to Milton 79 4. Concord, Conquest, and Commerce from Spenser to Cowley 111 PART THREE Erotic Excess and Early Modern Social Conflicts 143 5. Passionate Extremes and Noble Natures from Elizabethan to Caroline Literature 145 6. Erotic Excess versus Interest in Mid- to Late-Seventeenth-Century Literature 170 PART FOUR Moderation and Excess in the Seventeenth-Century Symposiastic Lyric 197 7. Drinking and the Politics of Poetic Identity from Jonson to Herrick 199 8. Drinking and Cultural Conflict from Lovelace to Rochester 225 PART FIVE Reimagining Moderation: The Miltonic Example 253 9. Paradise Lost, Pleasurable Restraint, and the Mean of Self-Respect 255 Postscript: Sublime Excess, Dull Moderation, and Contemporary Ambivalence 285 Notes 289 Index 353 This page intentionally left blank qqqqqqqq qqqqqqqqACKNOWLEDGMENTS I AM DEEPLY INDEBTED to Gordon Braden, David Bromwich, Jim Chandler, Michael Murrin, Janel Mueller, and Richard Strier for extraordinarily helpful readings of earlier versions of this book. For immensely useful responses to portions of this study (as well as for much else), I am very grateful to Ullrich Langer and David Quint; my sister Ruth Scodel; and cherished Chicago col- leagues David Bevington, Sandra Macpherson, Lisa Ruddick, and Jay Schleu- sener. I thank Philip Gossett and Geoffrey Stone for graciously providing me with invaluable leave time, and Mary Murrell, Fred Appel, and Henry Krawitz for their editorial efficiency. For advice and aid let me also express my gratitude to Lauren Berlant, Douglas Bruster, Laura Demanksi, Heather Dubrow, David Engster, Richard Goodkin, Achsah Guibbory, Paul Hunter, Ralph Johnson, Aaron Kitch, Adam Krantz, Jim Lastra, Stephen Lewis, Paula McQuade, Steve Monte, Maria Parks, Steve Pincus, Hank Sartin, Christopher Segrave-Daly, Joshua Shaw, Steven Streed, Katie Trumpener, Peter White, and David Wil- son-Okamura. I can also now, at last, thank Mayumi Fukui, Sarah Scodel, Harvey Scodel, Bettie Scodel, Barbara Scodel, and Lewis Kopel, who endured my volubly anxious travails with loving grace; and Hatsuaki and Kiku Fukui, who spurred me on with polite but nudging queries. Earlier versions of portions of this book appeared as articles: chapter 1 in Modern Philology 90 (1993): 479–511, and sections of chapter 1 in John Donne’s Religious Imagination: Essays in Honor of John T. Shawcross, ed. Raymond-Jean Frontain and Frances Malpezzi (Conway, Ark., 1995), 45–60; chapter 2 in Creative Imitation: New Essays on Renaissance Literature in Honor of Thomas M. Greene, ed. David Quint et al., MRTS, vol. 95 (Binghamton, N.Y., 1992), 89–126 (copyright Arizona Board of Regents for Arizona State University); and chapter 9 in Comparative Literature 48 (1996): 189–236. I am grateful for permission to reprint them here. NOTE ON CITATIONS Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics is abbreviated throughout as NE. All citations and translations of classical texts are from the Loeb Classical Library except where it is noted that I have modified the Loeb translation or substituted my viii A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S own. Citations of church fathers are from the Patrologia Cursus Completus . Series Graeca, ed. J. P. Migne (Paris, 1857–1866) and the Patrologia Cursus Completus . Series Latina, ed. J. P. Migne (Paris, 1878–1890). Citations of Milton’s poetry are from John Milton, Paradise Lost, ed. Alastair Fowler, 2d ed. (London, 1998), and Complete Shorter Poems, ed. John Carey, 2d ed. (London, 1997). qqqqqqqq qqqqqqqqINTRODUCTION Ancient Paradigms in Modern Conflicts “WE MAY QUICKLY EXCEED a mediocrity, even in the praise of Mediocrity,” cautioned John Donne in a 1625 sermon.1 With a destabilizing paradox, Donne invoked the venerable norm of “mediocrity” or the “golden mean” to warn his contemporaries against the danger of overuse. Twenty-first-century readers might well conclude that early modern authors, including Donne, cel- ebrated the mean to excess. Yet, as his admonition suggests, the mean was not only a cultural commonplace but also a source of controversy. This book studies English literary representations of means and extremes from the late sixteenth to the late seventeenth century. Classical in origin, the notion of a virtuous mean between two vicious extremes figured crucially in the writings of educated early modern English authors. Historians and literary scholars have studied the concept’s importance for the period’s struggles con- cerning the national church and the constitution. This study is the first, how- ever, to examine a broad variety of literary treatments of the mean-extremes polarity as representations of major cultural tensions extending far beyond— though often related to—ecclesiological and constitutional conflicts. Early modern authors apply the schema to numerous aspects of personal and collec- tive life in innovative, surprising, and contentious ways. Writers not only con- struct highly original versions of the mean; they also advocate various extremes. Donne himself transforms the classical mean to promote individual freedom, while the aggressively modern Francis Bacon holds extremism necessary for human empowerment. Erotic literature pits extreme passion against temperate conjugal love; symposiastic or drinking-party poetry extols polemically defined norms of sociable moderation or of intoxicating excess. Imagining a modern rival to ancient Rome, georgic poets laud the nation as the embodiment of the golden mean, warn against national excesses, or urge extreme ways of increas- ing the nation’s power and wealth. Challenging his predecessors’ and contem- poraries’ erotic, symposiastic, and georgic writings, John Milton deploys the mean to celebrate ideals of pleasurable restraint and self-respect that his coun- trymen have ignored to their peril. Such literary adaptations and transforma- tions of an ancient opposition figure centrally in the emergence of a deeply divided, ambivalent, yet self-consciously modern English culture. In both con- spicuous and subtle ways, furthermore, these clashing treatments of means and extremes continue to resonate within contemporary cultural debates. 2 INTRODUCTION The Classical Mean in Early Modern England The social and intellectual elite of early modern England often espoused Aris- totle’s definition, most fully developed in his Nicomachean Ethics, of ethical virtues as habits that preserve a mean between excess and deficiency in actions and emotions. Throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, as in the medieval period, Aristotle’s works remained the core of the university curriculum. Accompanied by various medieval and early modern commentar- ies and epitomes, the Nicomachean Ethics was the major university text in ethics.2 Numerous Latin translations made the work accessible to those with little Greek.3 Cicero’s De officiis, which invokes the “mean” (“mediocritas”) and the closely associated notion
Recommended publications
  • YUVAL LEVIN on the War on Civil Society
    2012_8_13 B UPC_1_cover61404-postal.qxd 7/24/2012 7:14 PM Page 1 August 13, 2012 $4.99 AURORA & EVIL — D GEORGE GILDER: WHAT IS CAPITALISM? a v id G e le rn te r Under President Obama: Julia has looked to the government for guidance and succor at every stage of her life. But it has been no subst itute for real community. She is a bleached-out creature of the state, living in a hollow republic. $4.99 YUVAL LEVIN 33 on the war on civil society 0 74820 08155 6 www.nationalreview.com base_milliken-mar 22.qxd 7/23/2012 3:45 PM Page 2 Trim 1 D CYAN BLK : 2400 9 45˚ 105˚ 75˚ G PMS base_milliken-mar 22.qxd 7/23/2012 3:46 PM Page 3 Strike Mobility Surveillance & Engagement Unmanned & Missile Systems Global Support www.boeing.com/militaryaircraft TODAYTOMORROWBEYOND D BLK : 2400 9 45˚ 105˚ 75˚ G toc_QXP-1127940144.qxp 7/25/2012 1:37 PM Page 1 Contents Amity Shlaes on Calvin Coolidge p. 18 AUGUST 13, 2012 | VOLUME LXIV, NO. 15 | www.nationalreview.com COVER STORY Page 27 BOOKS, ARTS The Hollow Republic & MANNERS 41 GREEN SHIFT President Obama’s “you didn’t build Steven F. Hayward reviews How that” speech in Roanoke, Va., shows to Think Seriously about the Planet: The Case for an us not only a man chilly toward the Environmental Conservatism, potential of individual initiative, and not by Roger Scruton. only a man deluded about the nature 42 THE OBAMA FAILURE of his opponents and their views, but Samuel R.
    [Show full text]
  • White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America
    "A Plumb Craving for the Other Color": White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America By Alison Marie Weiss A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Paula Fass, Chair Professor Waldo Martin Professor Margaret Chowning Professor Brian DeLay Professor Elisa Tamarkin Spring 2013 Copyright 2013 by Alison Marie Weiss 1 Abstract “A Plumb Craving for the Other Color”: White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America by Alison Marie Weiss Doctor of Philosophy in History University of California, Berkeley Professor Paula Fass, Chair “‘A Plumb Craving for the Other Color’: White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America” examines interracial relations between white men and non-white women in the antebellum period. Focusing on black, Indian, and Spanish American women, this dissertation argues that such liaisons were far more prevalent, institutionalized, and tolerated than historians have previously argued. Although such phenomena as black concubines, tribally organized Indian marriages, and land-rich Mexican wives have been separately examined, no single study has put them together and questioned their particular prevalence at a specific time in American history. This dissertation argues that the relationships white men formed with non- white women follow certain patterns that evidence a sexual “crisis” in antebellum America. Taking evidence from court records, periodicals, diaries, letters, travelogues and fiction, this study reveals that non-white women and their relations with white men were often portrayed in astonishingly similar ways.
    [Show full text]
  • The Story of Epic Fantasy
    REALISING THE DREAM: THE STORY OF EPIC FANTASY ASHLEIGH WARD, B.A. (HONS) Department of English and Creative Writing Faculty of Education, Humanities and Law Flinders University Thesis presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy June 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS i. Summary ......................................................................................................................... 6 ii. Declaration ...................................................................................................................... 8 iii. Acknowledgments............................................................................................................ 9 1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 10 1.1. A BRIEF HISTORY OF EPIC FANTASY ........................................................... 12 2. DEFINITIONS AND METHODOLOGY ................................................................... 18 2.1. DEFINING EPIC FANTASY ............................................................................ 19 2.1.1. Fantasy................................................................................................ 19 2.1.2. Epic Fantasy ....................................................................................... 31 2.1.3. Epic Fantasy: A Definition ................................................................. 35 2.2. METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................... 38 2.2.1. Story and Discourse...........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations
    UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title "A Plumb Craving for the Other Color": White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/5g35n0pb Author Weiss, Alison Marie Publication Date 2013 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California "A Plumb Craving for the Other Color": White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America By Alison Marie Weiss A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Paula Fass, Chair Professor Waldo Martin Professor Margaret Chowning Professor Brian DeLay Professor Elisa Tamarkin Spring 2013 Copyright 2013 by Alison Marie Weiss 1 Abstract “A Plumb Craving for the Other Color”: White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America by Alison Marie Weiss Doctor of Philosophy in History University of California, Berkeley Professor Paula Fass, Chair “‘A Plumb Craving for the Other Color’: White Men, Non-White Women, and Sexual Crisis in Antebellum America” examines interracial relations between white men and non-white women in the antebellum period. Focusing on black, Indian, and Spanish American women, this dissertation argues that such liaisons were far more prevalent, institutionalized, and tolerated than historians have previously argued. Although such phenomena as black concubines, tribally organized Indian marriages, and land-rich Mexican wives have been separately examined, no single study has put them together and questioned their particular prevalence at a specific time in American history.
    [Show full text]
  • Joseph Plumb Martin and the American Imagination
    © 2011 PETER MANOS ALL RIGHTS RESERVED JOSEPH PLUMB MARTIN AND THE AMERICAN IMAGINATION A Dissertation Presented to The Graduate Faculty of The University of Akron In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy Peter Manos December, 2011 JOSEPH PLUMB MARTIN AND THE AMERICAN IMAGINATION Peter Manos Dissertation Approved: Accepted: _____________________________ ________________________________ Advisor Department Chair Dr. Elizabeth Mancke Dr. Michael Sheng _____________________________ ________________________________ Co-Advisor/ Committee Member Dean of the College Dr. Walter Hixson Dr. Chand Midha ______________________________ ________________________________ Committee Member Dean of the Graduate School Dr. Kevin Kern Dr. George Newkome _____________________________ ________________________________ Committee Member Date Dr. Kevin Adams _____________________________ Committee Member Dr. Patrick Chura ii ABSTRACT The personal narrative of ordinary Continental Army private Joseph Plumb Martin has long provided corroborating evidence for battlefield accounts of the American Revolution and has never been out of print, albeit usually in abridged form, since its discovery in the mid-twentieth century. Yet, the memoir was written in 1830, fifty years after the events Martin narrated. Its romantic literary style, its populist sensibility, its racism, its empiricism, all reflect nineteenth-century values. The memoir has value in epitomizing the solidification of American nationalism and the populist rhetoric that became associated with it. Chapter one attempts to understand Martin’s rhetoric in terms of the literary influences on his writing, which include some works of the nineteenth century, but most from earlier times. Particularly evident is a modeling of behavior and outlook on the popular “Jonathan” character emerging from the works of post-Revolutionary American playwright Royall Tyler and others coupled with the romantic low-born outdoorsmen protagonists of nineteenth century rural poet Robert Bloomfield.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dubliners Live in Carré, Amsterdam Mp3, Flac, Wma
    The Dubliners Live In Carré, Amsterdam mp3, flac, wma DOWNLOAD LINKS (Clickable) Genre: Folk, World, & Country Album: Live In Carré, Amsterdam Country: Netherlands Released: 2002 Style: Celtic MP3 version RAR size: 1966 mb FLAC version RAR size: 1453 mb WMA version RAR size: 1105 mb Rating: 4.7 Votes: 439 Other Formats: MPC ADX MP1 MP1 AIFF VOX RA Tracklist Hide Credits Sweets Of May 1 2:43 Arranged By – The Dubliners Dicey Reilly 2 3:45 Arranged By – The Dubliners Song For Ireland 3 4:55 Written-By – P Colclough* Building Up And Tearing England Down 4 3:39 Written-By – D Behan* Medley 4:58 Dunphy's Hornpipe 5.1 Arranged By – The Dubliners Leitrim Fancy 5.2 Arranged By – The Dubliners Down The Broom 5.3 Arranged By – The Dubliners Dirty Old Town 6 3:40 Written-By – E MaColl*, E MacColl* The Old Triangle 7 3:39 Arranged By – B Behan* Whiskey In The Jar 8 3:15 Arranged By – The Dubliners Waterford Boys (Reels: The Humours Of Scariff / The Flannel Jacket) 9 5:16 Arranged By – The Dubliners Galway Races 10 2:51 Arranged By – The Dubliners The Prodigal Son 11 4:08 Written-By – J Sheahan* The Sick Note 12 3:18 Written-By – J Cooksey* The Wild Rover 13 4:02 Arranged By – The Dubliners Seven Drunken Nights 14 4:02 Arranged By – The Dubliners Companies, etc. Record Company – Karussell Licensed To – Karussell International Licensed From – Polydor B.V. Exported By – Karussell International Phonographic Copyright (p) – Polydor B.V. Copyright (c) – Karussell Made By – Disctronics, UK Pressed By – Disctronics, UK Recorded At – Theater Carré Published By – Tolka Music Published By – Logo Songs Ltd.
    [Show full text]
  • The Dubliners Drinkin' & Courtin' Mp3, Flac
    The Dubliners Drinkin' & Courtin' mp3, flac, wma DOWNLOAD LINKS (Clickable) Genre: Folk, World, & Country Album: Drinkin' & Courtin' Country: New Zealand Released: 1968 Style: Folk MP3 version RAR size: 1959 mb FLAC version RAR size: 1126 mb WMA version RAR size: 1913 mb Rating: 4.1 Votes: 703 Other Formats: VOX MIDI AUD DTS VOC MP3 VQF Tracklist Hide Credits Dirty Old Town A1 Written-By – Ewan McColl* A2 Quare Bungle Rye A3 Peggy Gordon A4 Rattling Roaring Willie A5 Carolan Concerto A6 The Herring A7 The Parting Glass B1 Maids, When You're, Never Wed An Old Man B2 Gentleman Soldier Hand Me Down Me Petticoat B3 Written-By – Dominic Behan B4 Donkey Reel B5 I Know My Love Mrs. McGrath B6 Written-By – Dominic Behan B7 Maid Of Sweet Brown Knowe B8 My Little Son Credits Arranged By – The Dubliners (tracks: A2 to B2, B4, B5, B7, B8) Producer – Tommy Scott Written-By – Trad.* Other versions Category Artist Title (Format) Label Category Country Year Drinkin' & Courtin' (LP, SMLP 14 The Dubliners Major Minor SMLP 14 UK 1968 Album) FLPS 1627 The Dubliners The Dubliners (LP) Fiesta FLPS 1627 US 1971 FLPS 1737 The Dubliners I Know My Love (LP, Album) Fiesta FLPS 1737 US Unknown FMC 1627 The Dubliners The Dubliners (Cass, RE) Fiesta FMC 1627 US 1982 Drinkin' & Courtin' (LP, BE 804 The Dubliners Major Minor BE 804 Canada 1968 Album) Related Music albums to Drinkin' & Courtin' by The Dubliners Rock The Dubliners - Drinking And Wenching Rock / Pop / Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - A Drop Of The Dubliners Rock / Pop / Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - The Dubliners Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - In Session Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - Songs Of The Dubliners Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - Peggy Gordon / Whiskey In The Jar / The Irish Navy Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - The Collection Rock / Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - 20 Original Greatest Hits Rock The Dubliners - Seven Drunken Nights Folk, World, & Country The Dubliners - All For Me Grog.
    [Show full text]