Effects of Stock Market Crash on Investors Behavior

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Effects of Stock Market Crash on Investors Behavior Journal of Management Info Vol. 2, No. 2 (2015) 13-21 Journal of Management Info (JMI) ISSN:2313-3376 www.readersinsight.net/jmi Effects of stock market crash on investors behavior Adnan Ali*1, Farzand Ali Jan2, Mughira Jehanzeb2 1Lecturer, Institute of Business and Management Sciences, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar 2Professor Comsats University of Technology, 3MS, Institute of Business and Management Sciences, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar * Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract ARTICLE INFORMATION Stock exchanges crises have remained the major dilemma for countries for many years. This study Received: 25 March 2015 was conducted to identify the various factors of the effects of stock market crash on investors’ Revised: 25 June 2015 behavior. The crash occurred in March 2005. The data collected was a five-year w.e.f. 2005, which Accepted: 25 June 2015 is the primary data and was collected in Peshawar from brokerage houses. The objective of the study was to investigate the perceptions of investors about the main causes of the crash, to observe DOI: the relationship between money losses and the shares invested in high and low rated companies http://dx.doi.org//10.31580/jmi.v6i1.42 and chi square test was applied to check the difference between before and after crash investment and association among investment in high and low rated companies. During test result it’s been vivid that my alternate hypothesis H1 showed significant result reflecting that sentiments are highly influenced by the fluctuations in stock prices. The results declared that there was significant difference between investment before and after the crash. It is recommended that the Government should provide transparency system to give a good image to the country. Keywords: Investor Behavior; Stock Prices; Market Crash; Brokerage Houses; Cash Investments; © Readers Insight Publication Introduction few days trading March 25 Karachi Stock Exchange has lost more than 2500 point. According to Wehmier (2005), stock market is the business of The highest end day record made by index of 10,303.13 points, the buying and selling shares in companies and the places where this next day with a record 10,509 points March 16, and 2005.The first happen. Stock market transaction started in the 12th century from sign of the outbreak of the index closed 10,077.89 points. The France, and large reforms are made in 13th century in this regard. The collapse of the market started and prevailed throughout the month, trading in stock market is mainly effected by internal factors like resulting in hurting the confidence of the investors. March 31,2005 projected earning per share, timing of the earning stream, riskiness of KSE index fell down to 7770.33 points, with the result that during the the project earning, dividend policy, level of debts and external month of March the KSE 100 index shed 489.73 points from the factors like general economic environment, tax law and stock market previous month ,a month of month change of -5.90%. conditions. Like any other market, stock market runs under the force In the month of March 2005, on an average, 510.24 million shares of demand and supply. The price of shares is determined by the changed hands daily as against an average daily turnover of 698.15 demand and supply force. million shares2 in February 2005. This research is an effort to find out the main causes and forward All these fluctuation were taking pace due to the speculative elements suggestions to avoid such aggravation in future by acquiring affecting the market and the anguish investors trying to achieve new information of major events much time is not required to influence the heights of KSE 100 index as they were not changed during that whole stock prices .the importance of specific events their effect on the stock crash. By buying the high weighted stocks such as Oil Gas market is a subject of the study in the financial economic literature Development Company Limited (OGDCL), Pakistan since a long time. When the prices of shares fall suddenly and Telecommunication Company Limited (PTCL), Pakistan State Oil unexpectedly because of unexpected events, political changes or (PSO), major banks and cement stocks the market participants crises with in or out side the country and people lose money; this is pumped up the index. known as stock market crash. The small and medium investors were badly affected when the market Further stock market crash when basis points of the index drastically crashed, though everything seemed to be right and seemed to be on fall quiet low, due to certain reasons like such as speculative elements rise. There seemed to be no cure and hope for the investors. All this sweeping the market and the frenzy of investors to reach new heights occur due to jealousy, poking by the regulators especially State Bank in the index. In the result of crash their biggest threat for equity of Pakistan and the Security Exchange Commission of Pakistan investors because accident brings heavy losses for investors. (SECP) in the market, due to investors over indulgence. They finally In many different ways the month of March was an astonishing in the eroded the confidence and stability in the market. KSE history whereas the rise shown by KSE 100 index in the first To overcome their own short fall and mistakes the State Bank of half of the month was followed by the biggest crash in the history Pakistan, SECP and Karachi Stock Exchange management look up .Due to these speculative elements the index crossed the magical some measures with the hope that it would bring some life in the figure from 8,260 points to 10,000 points on 14 March 2005.with in Copyright © 2018 Authors. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. 13 Journal of Management Info Vol. 2, No. 2 (2015) 13-21 stock market. Yet the doubt lay about the measures taken whether it is done the qualitative methodology and suggested that hoarding and possible to support and return the money of unfortunate investors speculation could be the best determinants of the stock prices, and often caused huge bubbling in prices index. Problem Statement Aharony and Swary, (1980) have studied about the dividend changes The overall economy of a country depends up on its stock market and stakeholder behavior. In which they found a significant positive exchange. Macro economy of a country depends on the stock market relationship between announcement of dividend changes and the .When the foreign countries intend to invest in other countries they stock return, by using the dividend announcement made in isolation of first of all try to find out the trend of Stock Market of that particular other firm news report. They used regression model to check the country. The economic situation of a country is severely affected by relation between the dividend policy and the market stock prices .they the disruption occurred by certain reason. Similarly the behavior of were on the view that the changes in dividend rate has positive effect investors also affected, for most of them lose their money and on stock prices return and stake holder were likely to have invest confidence in the security market. Therefore it is need of time is to more which yielded positive increase in stock prices return. By predict and find out the impact of the collapse of stock market on their applying regression on dividend change and prices index he obtained behavior and how to restore their confidence .5 present that reveals no difference between the variables. So it could be summarized that bond liquidity could cause the big change in Objectives of the study prices index. The present study was conducted to: Chen et al., (1986) examined equity returns relative to a set of 1. Find out the effect of the economic crises on the investors macroeconomic variables and found that all the macroeconomic behavior. variables that may explain a significant yields sock includes growth of 2. Check the relationship between money losses and the shares industrial production, changes the risk premium, the change in the invested by the investors in high and low rated companies yield curve, measures of unexpected inflation and changes in 3. Test the average amount of shares before and after the stock expected inflation during periods of volatility inflation. The co- market crash relation test model between macroeconomic variables i.e. inflation, 4. Suggest recommendations based upon the findings of the study badla and change in bond prices between stock index showed that these variables are highly co-related with each other and change in Hypotheses one factor could affect the other value. Hypothesis In the study gave the following assumptions have Garcia, (1987) proposed that investment in high portfolio companies been considered: is the major obstacle towards the volatility of the stock market prices. (a). H0: There is no significant association between amount of There were concerns that the use of portfolio insurance could lead money lost and number of shares invested in high rated companies; many investors to sell stocks for future” .he present the model by and amount of money lost and investment in low rated companies using index arbitrage in which he took the two value current stock H1: There exist significant association between amount of money lost prices rates and future rates. It is been shown that future speculating and number of shares invested in high rated companies; and amount of shares is the main cause to fluctuate the equilibrium of arbitrage of money lost and investment in low rated companies mode.
Recommended publications
  • Money Market Fund Glossary
    MONEY MARKET FUND GLOSSARY 1-day SEC yield: The calculation is similar to the 7-day Yield, only covering a one day time frame. To calculate the 1-day yield, take the net interest income earned by the fund over the prior day and subtract the daily management fee, then divide that amount by the average size of the fund's investments over the prior day, and then multiply by 365. Many market participates can use the 30-day Yield to benchmark money market fund performance over monthly time periods. 7-Day Net Yield: Based on the average net income per share for the seven days ended on the date of calculation, Daily Dividend Factor and the offering price on that date. Also known as the, “SEC Yield.” The 7-day Yield is an industry standard performance benchmark, measuring the performance of money market mutual funds regulated under the SEC’s Rule 2a-7. The calculation is performed as follows: take the net interest income earned by the fund over the last 7 days and subtract 7 days of management fees, then divide that amount by the average size of the fund's investments over the same 7 days, and then multiply by 365/7. Many market participates can use the 7-day Yield to calculate an approximation of interest likely to be earned in a money market fund—take the 7-day Yield, multiply by the amount invested, divide by the number of days in the year, and then multiply by the number of days in question. For example, if an investor has $1,000,000 invested for 30 days at a 7-day Yield of 2%, then: (0.02 x $1,000,000 ) / 365 = $54.79 per day.
    [Show full text]
  • FEDERAL FUNDS Marvin Goodfriend and William Whelpley
    Page 7 The information in this chapter was last updated in 1993. Since the money market evolves very rapidly, recent developments may have superseded some of the content of this chapter. Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Richmond, Virginia 1998 Chapter 2 FEDERAL FUNDS Marvin Goodfriend and William Whelpley Federal funds are the heart of the money market in the sense that they are the core of the overnight market for credit in the United States. Moreover, current and expected interest rates on federal funds are the basic rates to which all other money market rates are anchored. Understanding the federal funds market requires, above all, recognizing that its general character has been shaped by Federal Reserve policy. From the beginning, Federal Reserve regulatory rulings have encouraged the market's growth. Equally important, the federal funds rate has been a key monetary policy instrument. This chapter explains federal funds as a credit instrument, the funds rate as an instrument of monetary policy, and the funds market itself as an instrument of regulatory policy. CHARACTERISTICS OF FEDERAL FUNDS Three features taken together distinguish federal funds from other money market instruments. First, they are short-term borrowings of immediately available money—funds which can be transferred between depository institutions within a single business day. In 1991, nearly three-quarters of federal funds were overnight borrowings. The remainder were longer maturity borrowings known as term federal funds. Second, federal funds can be borrowed by only those depository institutions that are required by the Monetary Control Act of 1980 to hold reserves with Federal Reserve Banks.
    [Show full text]
  • Guaranteed Money Market Account
    GUARANTEED MONEY MARKET ACCOUNT As of 09/01/2021 GUARANTEED MONEY MARKET ACCOUNT RATES AND TERMS Annual Combined APY Minimum Interest Interest Rate Minimum Balance Monthly Percentage Yield (6 mos GMMA rate, Balance to Compounded (first 6 months) to Earn APY Fee (First 6 months) 6 mos MMA rate) Open and Credited 0.10% 0.10% 0.07% $0.00 Compounded 0.10% 0.10% 0.08% $10,000 Daily, $15,000.00 None 0.50% 0.50% 0.28% $15,000 Credited Monthly 0.50% 0.50% 0.29% $50,000 Eligibility: The Guaranteed Money Market Account is available to new memberships only, within first 30 days that membership is established. Minimum opening deposit of $15,000 must come from an institution other than Rivermark (New Money). Requires a new Free Checking Plus Account. Truth in Savings Disclosures 1. Rate Information – The Interest Rates and Annual Percentage Yields on your deposit account are stated above and may change at any time as determined by us, except as otherwise disclosed herein. The promotional APY is guaranteed for six months from the date of account opening. After the six-month promotional period ends, the account will convert to a Money Market Account with variable APYs in effect at time of conversion and based on the account balance as described on the applicable rate sheet. The APY is a percentage rate that reflects the total amount of interest to be paid on an account based on the interest rate and frequency of compounding for an annual period. The APY assumes that interest will remain on deposit until maturity.
    [Show full text]
  • Currency Risk Management
    • Foreign exchange markets • Internal hedging techniques • Forward rates Foreign Currency Risk • Forward contracts Management 1 • Money market hedging • Currency futures 00 M O NT H 00 100 Syllabus learning outcomes • Assess the impact on a company to exposure in translation transaction and economic risks and how these can be managed. 2 Syllabus learning outcomes • Evaluate, for a given hedging requirement, which of the following is the most appropriate strategy, given the nature of the underlying position and the risk exposure: (i) The use of the forward exchange market and the creation of a money market hedge (ii) Synthetic foreign exchange agreements (SAFE's) (iii) Exchange-traded currency futures contracts (iv) Currency options on traded futures (v) Currency swaps (vi) FOREX swaps 3 Syllabus learning outcomes • Advise on the use of bilateral and multilateral netting and matching as tools for minimising FOREX transactions costs and the management of market barriers to the free movement of capital and other remittances. 4 Foreign Exchange Risk (FOREX) The value of a company's assets, liabilities and cash flow may be sensitive to changes in the rate in the rate of exchange between its reporting currency and foreign currencies. Currency risk arises from the exposure to the consequences of a rise or fall in the exchange rate A company may become exposed to this risk by: • Exporting or importing goods or services • Having an overseas subsidiary • Being a subsidiary of an overseas company • Transactions in overseas capital market 5 Types of Foreign Exchange Risk (FOREX) Transaction Risk (Exposure) This relates to the gains or losses to be made when settlement takes place at some future date of a foreign currency denominated contract that has already been entered in to.
    [Show full text]
  • Nber Working Papers Series
    NBER WORKING PAPERS SERIES WAS THERE A BUBBLE IN THE 1929 STOCK MARKET? Peter Rappoport Eugene N. White Working Paper No. 3612 NATIONAL BUREAU OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH 1050 Massachusetts Avenue Cambridge, MA 02138 February 1991 We have benefitted from comments made on earlier drafts of this paper by seminar participants at the NEER Summer Institute and Rutgers University. We are particularly indebted to Charles Calomiris, Barry Eicherigreen, Gikas Hardouvelis and Frederic Mishkiri for their suggestions. This paper is part of NBER's research program in Financial Markets and Monetary Economics. Any opinions expressed are those of the authors and not those of the National Bureau of Economic Research. NBER Working Paper #3612 February 1991 WAS THERE A BUBBLE IN THE 1929 STOCK MARKET? ABSTRACT Standard tests find that no bubbles are present in the stock price data for the last one hundred years. In contrast., historical accounts, focusing on briefer periods, point to the stock market of 1928-1929 as a classic example of a bubble. While previous studies have restricted their attention to the joint behavior of stock prices and dividends over the course of a century, this paper uses the behavior of the premia demanded on loans collateralized by the purchase of stocks to evaluate the claim that the boom and crash of 1929 represented a bubble. We develop a model that permits us to extract an estimate of the path of the bubble and its probability of bursting in any period and demonstrate that the premium behaves as would be expected in the presence of a bubble in stock prices.
    [Show full text]
  • Money Market Funds V. Ultra-Short Bond Funds
    THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY SCHREYER HONORS COLLEGE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE MONEY MARKET FUNDS VS. ULTRA-SHORT BOND FUNDS TIMOTHY NEUBERT FALL 2009 A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a baccalaureate degree in Finance with honors in Finance Reviewed and approved by the following: James Alan Miles Professor of Finance Thesis Supervisor Honors Adviser Chris Muscarella Professor of Finance Faculty Reader *Signatures are on file in the Schreyer Honors College Abstract This thesis explores the investment vehicles known as Money Market Funds and Ultra-Short Bond Funds. Both types of funds are commonly used to invest short term cash savings as an alternative to a conventional bank savings account or certificate of deposit. Since both funds are marketed towards prospective investors to fulfill the same need, understanding the differences between the two will help individuals make better investment decisions. The key components of the two types of funds being explored will be their respective risk and return profiles, both historically and in the contemporary economic climate. i Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 1 MONEY MARKET FUNDS 2 Return Profile 2 Types of Money Market Funds 3 Regulations 5 Risk of Loss 6 ULTRA-SHORT BOND FUNDS 9 Return Structure 10 Risk of Loss 10 MONEY MARKET FUNDS VS. ULTRA-SHORT BOND FUNDS 16 Research Methods 16 Variance 17 Risk 18 Returns 19 CONCLUSION 22 i APPENDIX A 23 APPENDIX B 24 APPENDIX C 25 APPENDIX D 27 APPENDIX E 29 APPENDIX F 30 APPENDIX G 31 APPENDIX H 32 BIBLIOGRAPHY 34 Introduction I invite you to go to ridgeworth.com, the website of RidgeWorth Investments.
    [Show full text]
  • The Latest Fallacy About Money Market Funds
    The Latest Fallacy About Money Market Funds By Melanie L. Fein July 2012 CONTENTS I. THE LATEST FALLACY................................................................................1 A. “MMFs Threaten the Lending Ability of Banks” ...............................1 II. WHY IT’S A FALLACY..................................................................................3 A. MMFs Are Permitted to Invest Only in Short-Term High Quality Instruments, Not Bank Loans .................................................3 B. Banks Rely on Deposits, Not MMFs, To Make Loans.......................3 C. Banks Have Access to Other Sources of Funding and Liquidity..............................................................................................4 D. MMFs Purchase Commercial Paper Issued by Bank Holding Companies for Their Nonbanking Activities ......................................6 E. Commercial Paper Is Not an Appropriate Funding Source for Bank Loans .........................................................................................7 F. SEC Filings Show That MMFs Are Not a Primary Source of Funding for Bank Loans .....................................................................9 G. Numerous Factors Affect Banking Organizations’ Access to Funds.................................................................................................11 III. BANK FUNDING AND LIQUIDITY MANAGEMENT HAS BEEN DEFICIENT .................................................................................................14 A. Banking Regulators Have Acknowledged
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Financial Management: a Practical Guide Guideline Answers to the Concept Check Questions
    Understanding Financial Management: A Practical Guide Guideline Answers to the Concept Check Questions Chapter 10 Raising Funds and Cost of Capital Concept Check 10.1 1. What are the three primary roles of financial markets? Explain. Financial markets serve three major functions. • Channel funds. Financial markets help channel funds from suppliers to demanders. Within an economy, some have a surplus of funds while others have a shortage of funds. Financial markets provide a mechanism to help move funds from those who have a surplus (suppliers) to those who have a shortage (demanders). Business firms are net users of funds. • Provide a resale market. Financial markets provide a resale market. Such markets provide liquidity by enabling the holder to convert an asset into cash with ease. If investors believe that liquidating the investment would be difficult or costly, they would be reluctant to commit funds. • Establish market prices and rates of return. Financial markets establish market prices and rates of return. Setting prices is difficult but occurs through the interaction of suppliers and demanders. Factors contributing to markets efficiently pricing securities include high volume, standardization of securities, and a concentration of traders. 2. What is the major difference between capital markets and money markets? Give two examples of securities in each market. A money market is a financial market for short-term debt instruments. Money markets have several distinguishing features. First, the original maturity of money market securities is one year or less from their original issue date. Second, money market securities do not trade in a physical location but through a network of wires, telephones, and computers connecting banks and dealers.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparison of Money Market Fund Ratings
    Updated July 2016 A comparison of money market fund ratings IMMFA money market funds typically always obtain a triple-A money market fund rating from at least one credit rating agency (“CRA”), in particular Fitch Ratings, Moody’s Investors Services and S&P Global Ratings. Each of these CRAs awards a range of fund ratings. Their assessment criteria for money market funds will also vary. IMMFA provides this summary of the triple-A ratings criteria for money market funds in conjunction with the three named CRAs (each of which provided the information specific to their ratings). Our aim is to make comparative information on money market fund ratings more easily accessible. To our knowledge and belief the information contained herein is correct as at the date indicated. For those who require additional information on ratings, this may be obtained directly from the relevant CRA. Fitch Ratings Moody’s Investors Services S&P Global Ratings General Ratings Criteria Rating Definition An opinion on the capacity of a MMF to Moody’s money market fund ratings A principal stability fund rating preserve principal and provide are opinions on a money market addresses a fund’s ability to maintain shareholder liquidity through limiting fund’s ability to meet the dual principal stability and to limit exposure credit, market and liquidity risk. objectives of providing liquidity and to principal losses due to credit risk. preserving capital. Criteria applicable to CNAV and VNAV MMFs and other liquidity/cash The guidelines below are purely management products that have indicative. A rating committee could comparable investment objectives.
    [Show full text]
  • The Search for Stock Market Bubbles: an Examination of the Nyse Index
    Ursinus College Digital Commons @ Ursinus College Business and Economics Faculty Publications Business and Economics Department Spring 2002 The eS arch for Stock Market Bubbles: An Examination of the NYSE Index Andrew J. Economopoulos Ursinus College, [email protected] Avinash G. Shetty Ursinus College Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.ursinus.edu/bus_econ_fac Part of the Behavioral Economics Commons, Macroeconomics Commons, and the Portfolio and Security Analysis Commons Click here to let us know how access to this document benefits oy u. Recommended Citation Economopoulos, Andrew J. and Shetty, Avinash G., "The eS arch for Stock Market Bubbles: An Examination of the NYSE Index" (2002). Business and Economics Faculty Publications. 24. https://digitalcommons.ursinus.edu/bus_econ_fac/24 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Business and Economics Department at Digital Commons @ Ursinus College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Business and Economics Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Ursinus College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Pennsylvania Economic Review Volume 11, Number 1, Spring 2002 THE SEARCH FOR STOCK MARKET BUBBLES: AN EXAMINATION OF THE NYSE INDEX Andrew J. Economopolous and Avinash G. Shetty Ursinus College ABSTRACT Many have put forth reasons why the stock market has climbed to new and unprecedented heights. Two reason are examine: (1) investors are expecting prices to increase and are bidding up price irrationally; (2) investors have moved to a long-term strategy and are requiring a lower risk premium. For the latter reason, the rise in stock prices is due to a change in the fundamentals, and for the former reason the rise represents the classical bubble.
    [Show full text]
  • Money Market Mutual Funds: a Financial Stability Case Study
    Updated March 24, 2020 Money Market Mutual Funds: A Financial Stability Case Study A money market mutual fund (MMF) is a mutual fund that Financial Stability Considerations under Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Rule 2a- Threats to financial stability, or systemic risk, can be 7 can invest only in high-quality, short-term debt securities, viewed in different ways (e.g., spillover, contagion, and such as U.S. Treasury bills or commercial paper (a type of negative feedback loops). They largely relate to the corporate debt). MMFs are commonly considered as safe transmission of risks from one event to broadly affect the alternatives to bank deposits, although they are not confidence and functioning of the financial system as a federally insured like bank deposits. However, this whole. MMFs pose financial stability concerns because perceived-to-be-safe financial instrument triggered major they demonstrated during the 2008 market events that they market disruptions in 2008 that accelerated the 2007-2009 were susceptible to sudden large redemptions (runs), financial crisis. At the time, the Treasury Department and causing dislocation in short-term funding markets. Share the Fed developed multiple intervention tools. As the 2020 redemption is the MMF feature that is often discussed coronavirus-induced market stress continues, some of the under the context of runs. same tools are being reconsidered. The Fed reintroduced its MMF facility. The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Redemptions at Per Share Net Asset Value Security Act of 2020 (S. 3548) also proposes to permit a Share redemption allows MMF investors to exit their Treasury Department guarantee program for temporary use investment positions by selling their shares back to the fund during the coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak.
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of Hedging Transaction Exposure Using Financial Contracts
    International Conference on Network and Finance Development,NFD 2010 Analysis of Hedging Transaction Exposure Using Financial Contracts in International Financial Market Hua LIU, Xiaojin SUN School of Economics, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, China Email: [email protected], [email protected] Abstract: Since 2008, the sub-prime crisis, which lasted for more than one year has evolved into a global fi- nancial crisis, more and more people pay attention to the financial risk management. As one of the foreign exchange risk, or exposure, distinguishing with the economic exposure and translation exposure, the transac- tion exposure often happens during the course of international trade and international capital flow, but the ex- istence of this risk must meet two conditions in the financial contract agreed by two parities: time and foreign currency. Faced with the transaction exposure, we are apt to adopt the financial hedge approaches to eliminate the uncertainty caused by exchange rate change. This paper focuses on introducing one study case and analy- ses the financial market technique. By compared three hedge approaches: forward hedge, money hedge and option hedge, we can draw a conclusion: in reality, every hedge method has itself advantages and disadvan- tages. Keywords: transaction exposure; exchange rate; financial hedge 1 Introduction to treat the transaction exposure. Many international activities lead to money exchanges in 2 Analysis on Study Case the future. This is true of many international trade activi- Suppose that an American Corporation exported an air- ties, whose payments are not due until sometime in the plane to an German Airways and billed ¢10 million future.
    [Show full text]