In the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE DATED THIS THE 21 ST DAY OF JANUARY 2013 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE N. ANANDA W.P.No.10873/2012 (GM-CPC) BETWEEN: 1. SMT SAROJAMMA, 68 YEARS W/O LATE N.A. JAYARAM REDDY 2. SRI N J BHOOPALA REDDY, 34 YEARS S/O LATE N A JAYARAM REDDY BOTH ARE R/AT NO. 17/11 POST OFFICE ROAD DODDANEKKUNDI BANGALORE – 560 037. ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI G.L.VISHWANATH, ADV.) AND : 1. SRI V CHANDRASHEKAR, 47 YEARS S/O LATE P. VENKATASWAMY R/AT NO. 25, ‘B’ CROSS, NANJAREDDY COLONY BANGALORE - 560017 2. SRI. S. NATARAJ, 36 YEARS S/O SURYANARAYANA RAO R/AT NO. 80/A, SNEHA SADAN, 4TH CROSS NEW MANJUNATHA LAYOUT RAMAMURTHY NAGAR BANGALORE - 560016 2 3. SRI. PANDITH ARADYA, 35 YEARS S/O SRI. SOMA ARADHYA NO. FA-651, 3RD FLOOR, C.T.S. HAL FLAT TYPE QUARTERS HAL COLONY, MARATHALLI POST BANGALORE - 560037 4. SRI. GNANAPRAGASAM, 45 YEARS S/O G. LAZAR R/AT: C/O AMIRTHNATHAN, NO. 6 2ND CROSS, BEHIND MANJUNATH LAYOUT ESHWARA TEMPLE, MARATHALLI BANGALORE - 560037 5. SRI. A. BYATAPPA, 48 YEARS S/O APPAIAH R/AT NO. 579, UDAYANAGAR KUVEMPU ROAD, DOORAVANINAGAR POST BANGALORE - 560016 6. SMT. D.K. PRASANNA KUMARI W/O T.P. RAGHAVAN, 51 YEARS R/AT NO. 175, MUNI NIVAS, 2ND MIAN 14TH CROSS, ANNASANDRAPALYA EXTENSION HAL POST, BANGALORE - 560017 7. SRI P.MAHESH, 35 YEARS S/O P.PUTTASWAMAPPA C/O. S.VIVEKANANDA NO.110/4, 3RD CROSS, MURUGESHAPALYA BANGALORE-560 017 8. SMT K.VIJAYALAKSHMI, 30 YEARS W/O MURALIDHARAN R/AT. NO.50, BALAKRISHNA VILLA 10 TH CROSS, VINAYAKANAGAR, ANNASANDRA PALYA EXTENSION, BANGALORE-560 017 3 9. SRI K.UNNIKRISHNAN, 40 YEARS S/O SRI M.PARAMESHWARAIAH NAIR R/AT. NO.425, 8TH CROSS ASWATHNAGAR, MARATHAHALLI BANGALORE-560 037 10. SRI K.K.SURESH, 34 YEARS S/O K.K.NARAYAN 11. SMT K.DEVAYANI, 32 YEARS W/O K.K.SURESH RESP. NO.10 & 11 ARE R/AT. NO.106/B AIR VIEW LAYOUT, 3RD CROSS VINAYAKANAGAR, KONENA AGRAHARA BANGALORE-560 017 12. SRI A. PERIYANAYAGAM, 54 YEARS S/O ANTHONY, R/AT. 35, 1 ST CROSS SRIRAMANAGIRI, KONENA AGRAHARA BANGALORE-560 017 13. SRI TRIBHUVANAN SINGH, 60 YEARS S/O VISWANATH SINGH R/AT. NO.FC-37, HAL OLD TOWNSHIP VINAYAKANAGAR BANGALORE-560 017 14. SRI RATISH SHARMA, 29 YEARS S/O R.K.SHARMA R/AT. NO.4, 2ND FLOOR LALBAHADUR SHASTRY NAGAR INDIRANAGAR II STAGE, BANGALORE. 15. SMT OMANA S NAIR, 48 YEARS W/O K.N.S.NAIR R/AT. NO. 37, 1ST FLOOR HAGADUR COLONY 4 IMMADIHALLI MAIN ROAD, WHITEFIELD BANGALORE-560 066. 16. SRI GANAPATHI VAKUDA, 45 YEARS S/O LAKSHMINARAYANA VAKUDA R/AT. PAPAYYA BUILDING BEHIND SHILPA ENTERPRISES MARATHAHALLI BANGALORE-560 037. 17. SRI RAMA SETTY, MAJOR S/O THAMMAIAH SETTY R/AT. G-22, 2ND MAIN, HAL COLONY OPP: AMBEDKAR PARK, VIMANAPURA POST BANGALORE-560 017 18. SMT RAMIZUNNISA, 38 YEARS W/O SYED AKRAM R/AT. 535/2, NEAR RAIZAWANIA MASJID ANNASANDRAPALYA, HAL POST BANGALORE-560 017 19. SRI S.R.PATIL, 50 YEARS S/O RAMOJI R/AT. 38, 3RD MAIN ROAD L.N.REDDY COLONY NEAR BOGAI VILLA APARTMENT BASAVANAGAR EXTN. MARATHALLI POST OFFICE BANGALORE-560 037. 20. SRI T.K.MUNISWAMY, 45 YEARS S/O KRISHNAPPA R/AT. NO. 152/1, BEHIND GOVT. SCHOOL MARATHALLI, BANGALORE-560 037 21. SRI RAJASHEKARA REDDY, 39 YEARS S/O SRI ABBAIAH REDDY R/AT. NO.57, CHALLAGHATTA 5 B.NAGASANDRA ROAD, YAMALUR POST BANGALORE-560 037 22. SMT KALAISELVI M, 35 YEARS W/O SRI M NAGARAJ 23. SRI M NAGARAJ, 37 YEARS FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN RESP. NO.22 & 23 ARE R/AT. NO.106/3 ARI VIEW LAYOUT, KONENA AGRAHARA BANGALORE-560 017 24. SMT KAVITHA S, 28 YEARS W/O T.R.SHANKAR R/AT. NO. 37, SARASWATHINAGAR NAGARABHAVI ROAD, VIJAYANAGAR BANGALORE-560 040 25. SRI MICHEAL LAWRENCE, 57 YEARS S/O RAYER MICHEAL R/AT. NO. 3/10, ANTILLEM ROAD ULSOOR, BANGALORE-560 008 26. SMT LAKSHMAMMA, 51 YEARS W/O A.VENKATARAMA REDDY R/AT. NO. 60, CHALLAGHATTA VILLAGE YEMALUR POST, BANGALORE-560 037 27. SMT RUKMINI, 45 YEARS W/O K LAKSHMI NARASIMHA R/AT. ADJACENT HEGADUR NEAR GRAMAPANCHAYATH OFFICE IMMADIHALLI POST, BANGALORE-560 066 28. SRI ABDUL RAHAMAN, 25 YEARS S/O M.SATHIVELU R/AT. NO.8/2, BAZAAR STREET VANNARPET, BANGALORE-560 047 6 29. SRI S.K.VIJAYENDRA, 35 YEARS S/O KANNAN, R/AT. NO.1364, THIRUMALA NILAYA 8TH CROSS, 8TH MAIN, BHUVANESHWARI NAGAR T-DASARAHALLI POST, BANGALORE-560 057 30. SMT SANGEETHA SHARMA, 25 YEARS W/O DERENDRA KUMAR SHARMA R/AT. NO.593, CHALLASHATTA YEMALUR POST, BANGALORE-560 037 31. SRI S.Y.SHIVA REDDY, 33 YEARS S/O YARAPPA R/AT. NO. FA (M) 399, 2ND CROSS NEW TOWNSHIP, MARATHAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 037 32. SRI B.SURESH KUMAR NAIDU, 34 YEARS S/O G.BABU, R/AT. NO. 384, 11TH CROSS GBJ QUARTERS, MARATHAHALLI BANGALORE-560 037 33. SRI VINAY KUMAR, 30 YEARS S/O VILTA D SHETTY R/AT. NO. U-345, HAL QUARTERS OLD TOWNSHIP, VIMANAPURA POST BANGALORE-560 037 34. SRI MAHESH KADAM, 29 YEARS S/O N.NAGESH RAO R/AT. NO. 185, 9TH CROSS CIL LAYOUT, CHOLANAYAKANAHALLI R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 032 35. SRI BABU RAJAN THAKKAN, 44 YEARS S/O T.C.RAMACHANDRA R/AT. NO. V-12, NAL QUARTERS HINDUSTAN AERONAUTICS LTD. BANGALORE-560 017 7 36. SRI T VARADARAJU, 27 YEARS S/O V.THAMMAIAH R/AT. NO. 72, CHALLAGHATTA, YEMALUR POST, BANGALORE-560 037 37. SRI VISHWANATH BAIRY, 27 YEARS S/O SUBBANNA BIARY R/AT. HARIHARA STREET SHRUNGERI TOWN CHICKAMAGALORE DISTRICT. 38. SRI V.BIJU, 31 YEARS S/O V.VASUDEVAN R/AT. C-53, NAL STAFF QUARTERS KODI HALLI, BANGALORE-560 017 39. SRI K.B.AJITH KUMAR, 36 YEARS S/O BALAKRISHNA NAIR R/AT. NO.6, RAMAIAH REDDY COLONY SECTOR-A, DOORAVANINAGAR BANGALORE-560 037 40. SRI SUDHAKARA REDDY, MAJOR FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN R/AT. NO. 388, 2ND CROSS HAL TOWNSHIP, MARATHAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 037 41. SMT MARY MATHEW, 27 YEARS W/O SRI T.ANIL KOSE R/AT. NO. 243, MATHRU SMRUTHI 2ND MAIN, SHANBHOG LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 037. ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRIYUTHS VIPIN KUMAR MUNEGOWDA & S.RAJENDRA, ADVS. FOR C/R2 & R5; SRI K.S.NARAYANASWAMY, ADV FOR R1; SRI S.RAJENDRA, ADV. FOR R3, R9, R29 & R32; M/s.KOCHHAR & CO., ADV. FOR R6; SERVICE OF NOTICE TO 8 RESPONDENTS R7 TO R41 HELD SUFFICIENT V.C.O. DATED 31.10.2012) THIS PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER AT ANNEXURE-J & ETC. THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING IN ‘B’ GROUP THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING: O R D E R The plaintiffs had made an application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC r/w Order 23 Rule 1 CPC and sought for amendment of plaint as follows:- “Proposed Para 7 [b] The plaintiffs are the absolute owners in possession and enjoyment of the land measuring 2 acres 14 guntas [out of 3 Acres 29 Guntas] in Sy. No.81/2 & 83/3 of Doddanekundi, K.R.Hobli, Bangalore East Taluk. The Defendant nos.2 to 42 are claiming rights over individual sites forming part of the suit schedule property under alleged sale deeds said to have been executed by defendant no.1 proclaiming himself as alleged GPA Holder of the plaintiffs. The said GPA is denied and disputed by the plaintiffs. Hence the plaintiffs have claimed a declaration in terms of prayer [c] to declare that the alleged sale deeds are not binging on the right and interests of the plaintiffs. 9 Proposed Para 7 [c] The extent of land covered by each of the impugned sale deeds [if added up together] comprises only about 1 acre 11 guntas whereas the plaintiffs are the absolute owners in possession of the entire schedule property which measures 2 acres 14 guntas. Regarding the land covered by the Sale Deeds, the defendants cannot and ought not to dispute the title of the plaintiffs, since the defendants are claiming rights and interest to their sites from the plaintiffs [through alleged GPA holder]. Insofar as the balance land i.e., excluding the sale deed area, the defendants are not concerned about the same. Hence there is no need or necessity for the plaintiffs to seek for declaration of that balance area i.e., 1 acre 3 guntas [which is 2 acres 14 guntas minus 1 acre 11 guntas]. In the above circumstances insofar as the declaratory relief [a] and injunctive relief [b] are concerned the plaintiffs restrict such declaration and injunction only to the extent of the area/measurements as mentioned in the respective sale deeds which is stated in prayer [c]. Therefore, the plaintiffs do not press declaratory relief [a] and injunctive relief [b] for an extent beyond the area covered by the sale deeds mentioned in the prayer [c]. Hence declaratory relief [a] and injunctive relief [b] is only sought for 1 acre 11 guntas extent and not for 2 acres 14 guntas. The extent of the sites covered by the impugned sale deeds and referred in relief [c] is 10 morefully described in the schedule nos.1 to 39 in place of the schedule as existing. Proposed amendment to relief [a] To declare that the plaintiffs are the absolute owners of the suit schedule property nos.1 to 39, which is the respective schedules to the impugned sale deeds referred in relief – [c] and totally measuring 1 acre 11 guntas in Sy.