River Restoration to Achieve a Stage 0 Condition Summary of Workshop Held November 5‐6, 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
River Restoration to Achieve a Stage 0 Condition Summary of Workshop Held November 5‐6, 2020 0 Cover photo credit: Steve Wondzell, USDA Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station River Restoration to Achieve a Stage 0 Condition Summary of a Workshop Held November 5‐6, 2020 February 26, 2021 Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board Institute for Natural Resources at Oregon State University Recommended Citation Behan, Jeff, K. Fetcho, R. Davis, and L. Gaines. 2021. River Restoration to Achieve a Stage 0 Condition: Summary of a Workshop Held November 5‐6, 2020. Report to the Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board. Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board (Salem, Oregon) and the Institute for Natural Resources (Corvallis, Oregon). Table of Contents Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................................... 3 Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... 1 Core themes .............................................................................................................................................. 1 Introduction and background for the workshop .......................................................................................... 4 Workshop goal and objectives .................................................................................................................. 5 Workshop planning, execution, and documentation ............................................................................... 6 Plenary Session I: Stage 0 Restoration Background and Overview .............................................................. 8 Presentation overview .............................................................................................................................. 8 Key points that emerged from this session .............................................................................................. 8 Plenary Session II: Uncertainties and Questions ........................................................................................ 12 Presentation and panel overview ........................................................................................................... 12 Key points that emerged from this session ............................................................................................ 12 Chat‐based questions ............................................................................................................................. 16 Breakout 1: Challenges and Opportunities Related to Session II Uncertainties & Questions .................... 19 Combined responses from all breakout groups ...................................................................................... 19 Based on what you heard and learned during the two sessions this morning, what do you think is the most important uncertainty is to be addressed? .......................................................................... 19 What opportunities exist to address the most important uncertainty (that you listed above)? ........ 23 What challenges should we be mindful of when addressing this uncertainty? .................................. 25 Plenary Session III: Monitoring Approaches, Challenges, and Evolving Knowledge of Stage 0 Restoration .................................................................................................................................................................... 28 Session III, PART 1: Current Monitoring Approaches .............................................................................. 28 Presentation overview ........................................................................................................................ 28 Key points that emerged from this session ........................................................................................ 29 Session III, PART 2: Evolving knowledge about Stage 0 Restoration Approaches .................................. 38 Presentation overview ........................................................................................................................ 38 Key points that emerged from this session ........................................................................................ 38 Chat‐based questions ......................................................................................................................... 39 Plenary Session IV & Breakout Groups: Create a Communication Network or Process for Sharing Updates as New Information Emerges ...................................................................................................................... 45 Presentation overview ............................................................................................................................ 45 Breakout session ..................................................................................................................................... 45 What are you most interested in tracking and learning about following this workshop? ................. 46 What are effective ways (e.g., annual workshop, online forum) for you to receive this [Stage 0‐ related] information? .......................................................................................................................... 48 Closing comments and workshop takeaway messages. ............................................................................. 50 Key points that emerged from this session ............................................................................................ 50 Appendix A: Steering Committee member list ........................................................................................... 54 Steering Committee Members ............................................................................................................... 54 OWEB Staff .............................................................................................................................................. 54 Workshop Support Staff.......................................................................................................................... 54 Appendix B: Responses to pre‐workshop survey........................................................................................ 55 Survey background and overview ........................................................................................................... 56 Raw Data ............................................................................................................................................. 60 Responses and response clips that addressed timeframe question .................................................. 66 Positive: Working well, overall positive impression ........................................................................... 68 Neutral/Equivocal: Don’t know yet, need more information ............................................................. 71 Some concerns .................................................................................................................................... 73 Negative, skeptical, not working well ................................................................................................. 74 Compilation Methods ......................................................................................................................... 74 Flora & Fauna ...................................................................................................................................... 74 Physical (Hydrology and Geomorphology) Effects/Impacts ............................................................... 77 Water Quality Effects/Impacts (Temperature, Nutrients, Turbidity) ................................................. 78 Long‐term effects & resilience, including to climate change ............................................................. 80 Risks, Unforeseen Consequences, Levels of Disturbance ................................................................... 81 Site selection or prioritization; restoration design guidance; clarification of Stage 0 terms & methods .............................................................................................................................................. 83 Monitoring & Project Assessment ...................................................................................................... 86 Social, Policy & Economic Issues; Information Synthesis, Sharing & Outreach .................................. 89 Compilation methods.......................................................................................................................... 92 Summary ............................................................................................................................................. 93 Flora & Fauna ...................................................................................................................................... 97 Physical (Hydrology and Geomorphology) ....................................................................................... 101 Water Quality .................................................................................................................................... 104 Monitoring & Project Assessment .................................................................................................... 105 Social, Policy & Economic Issues; Information Synthesis, Sharing