DOCSLIB.ORG

Mutually Assured Construction

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Mutually Assured Construction MUTUALLY ASSURED CONSTRUCTION Æthelflæd’s burhs, Landscapes of Defence and the Physical Legacy of the Unification of England, 899-1016 Submitted by David John Fiander Stone to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Archaeology March 2017 This thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. I certify that all material in this thesis which is not my own work has been identified and that no material has previously been submitted and approved for the award of a degree by this or any other University. Signature: …………………………………………………………. Abstract This thesis examines the physical legacy left by the unification of the Kingdom of England during the tenth century, and seeks to redress the way in which the Kingdom of Mercia is often overlooked or discounted in the traditional historical narrative. It principally examines the means by which Æthelflæd of Mercia extended political and military control over the West Midlands, both in terms of physical infrastructure and through ‘soft’ power in terms of economic control and material culture. It uses landscape archaeology, artefactual and textual evidence to compare Mercia with its ally, Wessex, and assess the different means by which Æthelflæd of Mercia and her brother Edward the Elder were able to consolidate and expand their territory, the physical infrastructure they established in order to defend it, and the ways in which these sites developed in response to the changing political, military and economic climates of the later tenth century. It will assess why some defensive sites developed into proto-urban settlements while others disappeared, and the extent to which this was a conscious or planned process. This thesis seeks to overturn the idea that burhs constructed in Mercia were insignificant or unplanned ‘emergency’ sites and instead were part of a sophisticated network of landscapes of defence, reflecting a significant level of manpower and logistical investment on the part of the Mercian state. It will furthermore seek to explore the ways in which the Mercian state supported such a network, how sites were chosen, constructed, maintained and garrisoned, and the impact these sites had both on the local population, in terms of patterns of settlement and material culture, and on the wider political scale. Acknowledgements I am grateful foremost to my supervisors, Professor Oliver Creighton and Dr Levi Roach for all their help and guidance in researching and writing this thesis, and to Rory Naismith at the Fitzwilliam Museum, and Robert Webley of the Portable Antiquities Scheme for their help with the finer points of Anglo-Saxon numismatics and material culture. Thanks also go to Ray at Lower Drayton Farm for facilitating access to much of my fieldwork, and helping liaise with local metal detectorists. Dedicated to my family and to Jade for their incredible support. 2 Contents List of Figures ............................................................................................................. 5 Notes on Abbreviations and References .................................................................. 8 Introduction ................................................................................................................. 9 I: The State of Play: Anglo-Saxon History, ‘Burghal Hidage Studies’ and Mercia 13 Enclosures, Forts and Towns: Burghal Terminology ................................................ 17 The Burghal Hidage as Documentary Evidence ...................................................... 21 Burhs and the Administration of Defence ................................................................ 25 Burhs: Form, Function and Location ........................................................................ 27 Civil Functions: Burhs as Economic, Symbolic and Religious Sites ......................... 35 A Burghal Network? ................................................................................................ 39 II: Burghal Paradigms: Bridgnorth, Eddisbury and Chirbury ................................ 45 Eddisbury ................................................................................................................ 47 Bridgnorth................................................................................................................ 60 Chirbury .................................................................................................................. 69 III: Communications and Visual Networks in Landscape Control ......................... 77 Connecting to the Network: Communications and Beacons .................................... 78 An Anglo-Saxon Beacon Chain? ............................................................................. 79 Identifying a Potential Beacon Network ................................................................... 82 Development and Archaeology of Beacon Sites ...................................................... 84 Identifying Areas for Case Study ............................................................................. 87 Case Studies Methodology: Preliminary Surveys .................................................... 91 Testing the Network: Fieldwork and Visibility Surveys ............................................. 97 Staffordshire: Derby to Totmonslow ..................................................................... 99 Cheshire: Chester to Wardle .............................................................................. 108 Staffordshire: Watling Street to Stoke-on-Trent .................................................. 117 IV: Burghal Minting: Coinage and Context............................................................ 129 The Evolution of the Coinage ................................................................................ 131 Catalogues, Hoards and Single Finds: Working with the Coinage ......................... 135 Burghal Minting: Design and Function ................................................................... 138 Coinage Distribution and Economic Networks ....................................................... 153 3 V: Fashion, Function and Fortification: Material Culture and the Proliferation of Political Control and Cultural Identity ................................................................... 173 Ceramics ............................................................................................................... 178 Metalwork .............................................................................................................. 187 Cheshire ............................................................................................................ 199 Shropshire ......................................................................................................... 201 Staffordshire ...................................................................................................... 205 Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 213 Appendix ................................................................................................................. 229 Bibliography ............................................................................................................ 240 4 List of Figures 1. Plan of Tamworth's defensive circuit (Bassett, 2008) ...................................... 32 2. Reconstruction of Tamworth defensive ramparts (Gould, 1968) ...................... 32 3. Defensive circuits at Hereford (Bassett, 2008) ................................................. 33 4. Defensive circuit at Stafford (Carver, 2010b) ................................................... 34 5. Pictorial coinage of Edward the Elder from the Chester mint (EMC) ................ 36 6. Topographical map of Eddisbury, Bridgnorth and Chirbury in west Mercia ...... 46 7. Map of Eddisbury and environs within the Cheshire Plain ............................... 48 8. Aerial photograph of Eddisbury Hillfort (University of Liverpool) ...................... 49 9. LIDAR data of Eddisbury Hillfort (Cheshire West and Chester Council) ........... 50 10. Plan of 1935-9 excavations at Eddisbury Hillfort (Varley, 1950)....................... 52 11. Plan of areas of significant excavation at Eddisbury Hillfort ............................. 52 12. 1937 sketches of ramparts at the north-west entrance to Eddisbury (Varley, 1950) .............................................................................................................. 56 13. 1937 sketches of Inner and outer northern ramparts at Eddisbury (Varley, 1950) ........................................................................................................................ 58 14. Map of Bridgnorth and environs ...................................................................... 61 15. Digital terrain model of Bridgnorth (Geomatics Group UK) .............................. 63 16. Map of two possible defensive ditches at Bridgnorth ....................................... 66 17. Map of probable defensive circuits at Bridgnorth ............................................. 68 18. Map of Chirbury and environs ......................................................................... 70 19. OS map of modern Chirbury (Ordnance Survey) ............................................. 70 20. Digital terrain model of Chirbury village and ringwork (The Environment Agency)
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Collections Development Policy
    Collections Development Policy Harris Museum & Art Gallery Preston City Council Date approved: December 2016 Review date: By June 2018 The Harris collections development policy will be published and reviewed from time to time, currently every 12-18 months while the Re-Imagining the Harris project develops. Arts Council England will be notified of any changes to the collections development policy, and the implications of any such changes for the future of the Harris’ collections. 1. Relationship to other relevant policies/plans of the organisation: The Collections Development Policy should be read in the wider context of the Harris’ Documentation Policy and Documentation Plan, Collections Care and Conservation Policy, Access Policy Statement and the Harris Plan. 1.1. The Harris’ statement of purpose is: The Re-Imagining the Harris project builds on four key principles of creativity, democracy, animation and permeability to create an open, flexible and responsive cultural hub led by its communities and inspired by its collections. 1.2. Preston City Council will ensure that both acquisition and disposal are carried out openly and with transparency. 1.3. By definition, the Harris has a long-term purpose and holds collections in trust for the benefit of the public in relation to its stated objectives. Preston City Council therefore accepts the principle that sound curatorial reasons must be established before consideration is given to any acquisition to the collection, or the disposal of any items in the Harris’ collection. 1.4. Acquisitions outside the current stated policy will only be made in exceptional circumstances. 1.5. The Harris recognises its responsibility, when acquiring additions to its collections, to ensure that care of collections, documentation arrangements and use of collections will meet the requirements of the Museum Accreditation Standard.
    [Show full text]
  • Æthelstan: the First King of England
    Published on Reviews in History (https://reviews.history.ac.uk) Æthelstan: The First King of England Review Number: 1151 Publish date: Saturday, 1 October, 2011 Author: Sarah Foot ISBN: 9780300125351 Date of Publication: 2011 Price: £30.00 Pages: 336pp. Publisher: Yale University Press Place of Publication: New Haven, CT Reviewer: Rory Naismith Æthelstan might not, to the uninitiated, seem a very likely candidate for a volume in the prestigious Yale English Monarchs series. He lacks the name-recognition associated with a Conquerer or a Confessor, and is not the subject of any compelling anecdotes about beaches or cakes which have wormed their way into the popular consciousness. To say Æthelstan is forgotten might be to go too far, but he is certainly not well remembered outside a select audience of Anglo-Saxon illuminati. Professor Foot swims against this current. Even undertaking a biography of Æthelstan is a strong statement of the importance she would assign to him and his reign (which spanned the years 924–39), and her central point in this book is encapsulated by the subtitle: ‘First King of England’. The achievement which lies immediately behind this acclamation is Æthelstan’s conquest, in 927, of the Viking kingdom of York. This victory was just one act in the process by which warrior-kings of the West Saxon dynasty of Ecgberht (802–39) created a kingdom which broadly approximated modern England in extent. Alfred the Great (871–99) and his son Edward the Elder (899–924), along with the latter’s sister Æthelflæd (d. 918) and her husband Æthelred (d.
    [Show full text]
  • Unclassified Fourteenth- Century Purbeck Marble Incised Slabs
    Reports of the Research Committee of the Society of Antiquaries of London, No. 60 EARLY INCISED SLABS AND BRASSES FROM THE LONDON MARBLERS This book is published with the generous assistance of The Francis Coales Charitable Trust. EARLY INCISED SLABS AND BRASSES FROM THE LONDON MARBLERS Sally Badham and Malcolm Norris The Society of Antiquaries of London First published 1999 Dedication by In memory of Frank Allen Greenhill MA, FSA, The Society of Antiquaries of London FSA (Scot) (1896 to 1983) Burlington House Piccadilly In carrying out our study of the incised slabs and London WlV OHS related brasses from the thirteenth- and fourteenth- century London marblers' workshops, we have © The Society of Antiquaries of London 1999 drawn very heavily on Greenhill's records. His rubbings of incised slabs, mostly made in the 1920s All Rights Reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation, and 1930s, often show them better preserved than no part of this work may be photocopied, stored in a retrieval they are now and his unpublished notes provide system, published, performed in public, adapted, broadcast, much invaluable background information. Without transmitted, recorded or reproduced in any form or by any means, access to his material, our study would have been less without the prior permission of the copyright owner. complete. For this reason, we wish to dedicate this volume to Greenhill's memory. ISBN 0 854312722 ISSN 0953-7163 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the
    [Show full text]
  • Early Medieval Dykes (400 to 850 Ad)
    EARLY MEDIEVAL DYKES (400 TO 850 AD) A thesis submitted to the University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities 2015 Erik Grigg School of Arts, Languages and Cultures Contents Table of figures ................................................................................................ 3 Abstract ........................................................................................................... 6 Declaration ...................................................................................................... 7 Acknowledgments ........................................................................................... 9 1 INTRODUCTION AND METHODOLOGY ................................................. 10 1.1 The history of dyke studies ................................................................. 13 1.2 The methodology used to analyse dykes ............................................ 26 2 THE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE DYKES ............................................. 36 2.1 Identification and classification ........................................................... 37 2.2 Tables ................................................................................................. 39 2.3 Probable early-medieval dykes ........................................................... 42 2.4 Possible early-medieval dykes ........................................................... 48 2.5 Probable rebuilt prehistoric or Roman dykes ...................................... 51 2.6 Probable reused prehistoric
    [Show full text]
  • Viking Wirral … and the Battle of Brunanburh Professor Steve Harding
    Viking Wirral … and the Battle of Brunanburh Professor Steve Harding Neil Oliver, “History of Scotland” BBC2, 2009 “ The many armies, tens of thousands of warriors clashed at the site known as Brunanburh where the Mersey Estuary enters the sea . For decades afterwards it was simply known called the Great Battle. This was the mother of all dark-age bloodbaths and would define the shape of Britain into the modern era. Althouggg,h Athelstan emerged victorious, the resistance of the northern alliance had put an end to his dream of conquering the whole of Britain. This had been a battle for Britain, one of the most important battles in British historyyy and yet today ypp few people have even heard of it. 937 doesn’t quite have the ring of 1066 and yet Brunanburh was about much more than blood and conquest. This was a showdown between two very different ethnic identities – a Norse-Celtic alliance versus Anglo-Saxon. It aimed to settle once and for all whether Britain would be controlled by a single Imperial power or remain several separate kingdoms. A split in perceptions which, like it or not, is still with us today”. Some of the people who’ve been trying to sort it out Nic k Hig ham Pau l Cav ill Mic hae l Woo d John McNeal Dodgson 1928-1990 Plan •Background of Brunanburh • Evidence for Wirral location for the battle • If it did happen in Wirra l, w here is a like ly site for the battle • Consequences of the Battle for Wirral – and Britain Background of Brunanburh “Cherchez la Femme!” Ann Anderson (1964) The Story of Bromborough •TheThe Viking
    [Show full text]
  • Winckley Square Around Here’ the Geography Is Key to the History Walton
    Replica of the ceremonial Roman cavalry helmet (c100 A.D.) The last battle fought on English soil was the battle of Preston in unchallenged across the bridge and began to surround Preston discovered at Ribchester in 1796: photo Steve Harrison 1715. Jacobites (the word comes from the Latin for James- town centre. The battle that followed resulted in far more Jacobus) were the supporters of James, the Old Pretender; son Government deaths than of Jacobites but led ultimately to the of the deposed James II. They wanted to see the Stuart line surrender of the supporters of James. It was recorded at the time ‘Not much history restored in place of the Protestant George I. that the Jacobite Gentlemen Ocers, having declared James the King in Preston Market Square, spent the next few days The Jacobites occupied Preston in November 1715. Meanwhile celebrating and drinking; enchanted by the beauty of the the Government forces marched from the south and east to women of Preston. Having married a beautiful woman I met in a By Steve Harrison: Preston. The Jacobites made no attempt to block the bridge at Preston pub, not far from the same market square, I know the Friend of Winckley Square around here’ The Geography is key to the History Walton. The Government forces of George I marched feeling. The Ribble Valley acts both as a route and as a barrier. St What is apparent to the Friends of Winckley Square (FoWS) is that every aspect of the Leonard’s is built on top of the millstone grit hill which stands between the Rivers Ribble and Darwen.
    [Show full text]
  • The Early Medieval Period, Its Main Conclusion Is They Were Compiled at Malmesbury
    Early Medieval 10 Early Medieval Edited by Chris Webster from contributions by Mick Aston, Bruce Eagles, David Evans, Keith Gardner, Moira and Brian Gittos, Teresa Hall, Bill Horner, Susan Pearce, Sam Turner, Howard Williams and Barbara Yorke 10.1 Introduction raphy, as two entities: one “British” (covering most 10.1.1 Early Medieval Studies of the region in the 5th century, and only Cornwall by the end of the period), and one “Anglo-Saxon” The South West of England, and in particular the three (focusing on the Old Sarum/Salisbury area from the western counties of Cornwall, Devon and Somerset, later 5th century and covering much of the region has a long history of study of the Early Medieval by the 7th and 8th centuries). This is important, not period. This has concentrated on the perceived “gap” only because it has influenced past research questions, between the end of the Roman period and the influ- but also because this ethnic division does describe (if ence of Anglo-Saxon culture; a gap of several hundred not explain) a genuine distinction in the archaeological years in the west of the region. There has been less evidence in the earlier part of the period. Conse- emphasis on the eastern parts of the region, perhaps quently, research questions have to deal less with as they are seen as peripheral to Anglo-Saxon studies a period, than with a highly complex sequence of focused on the east of England. The region identi- different types of Early Medieval archaeology, shifting fied as the kingdom of Dumnonia has received detailed both chronologically and geographically in which issues treatment in most recent work on the subject, for of continuity and change from the Roman period, and example Pearce (1978; 2004), KR Dark (1994) and the evolution of medieval society and landscape, frame Somerset has been covered by Costen (1992) with an internally dynamic period.
    [Show full text]
  • Approved Minutes Annual Parish, Allot
    72 ………………………………………………………Signed ………………………..Dated AUDLEY RURAL PARISH COUNCIL MINUTES OF THE ALLOTMENT COMMITTEE MEETING held in Audley Pensioners Hall 17 th April 2014 at 6.30pm Present: Chairman: Mr T Sproston Councillors: Mr H Proctor, Mrs V Pearson, Mr P Breuer, Mr N Blackwood, Mr A Wemyss, Mr C Cooper, Mr P Morgan, Mrs A Beech and Mr M Dolman. Clerk – Mrs C. Withington Mr Neil Breeze, Mrs Holleen Breeze, Mrs Linda Johnson – Halmer End Mrs Pam Patten, Ms Rachel Bailey and Mr Roger Beech – Audley Allotments No. Item Action 1. To receive apologies Apologies were received from Mrs K Davison, Mrs C D Cornes, Mr E Durber, Mr D Cornes, Mrs B Kinnersley and Lewis Moore. 2. Approval of minutes from last meeting 21 st March 2013 These were approved as a true and accurate record and signed at the meeting. 3. Agreement of siting of allotment fencing with Audley Allotment Association – letter from Audley Millennium Green Trust Brief discussion took place, following Mr Blackwood reading a letter on behalf of the Millennium Green Trust raising concerns about the process of carrying out the fencing work by the Allotment Association and where it has been sited, although it was noted there were no concerns with the quality of the work. Noted that further work was required to complete the job. RESOLVED that a site visit would take place with the MGT Chair, Parish Council and Audley Allotment Association to discuss the concerns and resolve the issues. This will be brought back to a future meeting. Site visit arranged for Thursday 24 th April 2014 at 6pm – Mrs Pearson gave her apologies.
    [Show full text]
  • Sir Gawain in the Moorlands of North Staffordshire, an Investigation
    STRANGE COUNTRY: Sir Gawain in the moorlands of North Staffordshire, an investigation. by David Haden 2018 CONTENTS Timeline. 1. An overview of the previous work on Sir Gawain and North Staffordshire. 2. Sir Gawain’s possible routes into and through North Staffordshire. 3. Alton Castle as the castle of Bertilak of Hautdesert. 4. Who was William de Furnival, of Alton Castle? 5. The annual regional Minstrel Court at Tutbury. 6. “100 pieces of green silk, for the knights” at Tutbury. 7. The King’s Champion: William de Furnival’s friend in Parliament and a model for the Green Knight? 8. The nearby Cistercians at Croxden Abbey. 9. Wetton Mill and the Green Chapel: new evidence. 10. Two miles by mydmorn? 11. Some other local Gawain-poet candidates discounted. 12. “Here the Druids performed their rites”: some other poets of the district. 13. Tolkien and the Gawain country: the 1960s in Stoke-on-Trent. Appendix 1: A thrice ‘lifting and heaving’ folk practice in the Peak. Appendix 2: Some pictures of continental wild-men. Appendix 3: ‘A Bag of Giant Bones’: Erasmus Darwin and the district. Appendix 4: A letter to the Staffordshire Advertiser, 1870, and article in The Reliquary, 1870. (Full-text). Appendix 5: ‘Notes on the Explosions and Reports in Redhurst Gorge, and the Recent Exploration of Redhurst Cave’. (Full-text). Selected bibliography. Index. 1. An overview of the previous work on Sir Gawain and North Staffordshire. his chapter offers a short survey of the works which have, over the decades, associated Gawain with North T Staffordshire. I discuss them in order of appearance.
    [Show full text]
  • 12 Feb 2012 7Pm – Audley Rural Parish Council Public Meeting UK
    12 th Feb 2012 7pm – Audley Rural Parish Council Public Meeting UK Coal Open cast proposals at Bignall End Councillors – Mr H Proctor (Chair), Mr N Blackwood, Mrs C D Cornes (Cllr), Mr D Cornes, Mr C Cooper, Mr P Breuer, Mrs A Beech (Cllr). Clerk – Mrs C Withington 126 members of public in attendance Purpose of the meeting: To hear the residents views in respect of the scoping proposal for Open Cast mining at Bignall End, prior to the Parish Council commenting on the Planning Application when received. Noted that UK Coal had provided public exhibitions to provide answers to residents questions. The following concerns were raised by residents: A resident of Ravens Lane - Open cast was proposed 20 years ago in the 80’s, why was it dropped after getting to the formal stage? A resident of Monument View - Clarification was requested on the planning application consultation process, notifications to residents and the ability for residents to comment upon the application. It was noted that residents will be notified directly around the site by the County, notices will be put up in noticeboards, library etc. All residents have the ability to comment individually in addition to the Parish Council through Staffordshire County Council website. Noted that the Parish Council would call another public meeting to hear individual concerns, and possibly invite representatives from other agencies to answer questions such as applicant, planners etc. It was noted that it was expected to be a planning committee decision (consisting of 15 county councillors at Staffordshire County Council). Residents are able to attend this committee if open.
    [Show full text]
  • Anglo-Saxon Kings
    Who were the famous Anglo Saxon Kings? Who was Alfred the Great? • https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/topics/zxsbcdm/articles/z9tdq6f Edward The Elder Ruled899 – 924 • King Edward was well trained by his father, Alfred the Great. • He was a bold soldier who won large portions of land from the Danes in the east and the north. • Much of his success was thanks to the help of his sister, the mighty Aethelflaed. • Edward set up his court in the city of Winchester and built a fine cathedral there. He was married three times and had at least fourteen children. • Some say he was a great supporter of the Church. Others say he was scolded by the Pope for neglecting his faith. • Edward died as he would have wished - at the head of his army, leading his men into battle against a band of rebels. He was laid to rest in his new cathedral at Winchester. Athelstan Ruled 924 - 939 • Athelstan was a daring soldier who fought many battles. But his greatest triumph was the Battle of Brunanburh, when he was faced with an army of Scots and Welsh and Danes. • After this great victory, he seized control of York - the last of the Viking strongholds. Then he forced the kings of Scotland and Wales to pay him large sums of money. • Athelstan wasn't just a soldier. He worked hard to make his kingdom strong, writing laws and encouraging trade. • Athelstan was buried at Malmesbury. At the time of his death he was recognised as the very first King of All England.
    [Show full text]
  • Old Oswestry Hillfort and Its Landscape: Ancient Past, Uncertain Future
    Old Oswestry Hillfort and its Landscape: Ancient Past, Uncertain Future edited by Tim Malim and George Nash Archaeopress Archaeology Archaeopress Publishing Ltd Summertown Pavilion 18-24 Middle Way Summertown Oxford OX2 7LG www.archaeopress.com ISBN 978-1-78969-611-0 ISBN 978-1-78969-612-7 (e-Pdf) © the individual authors and Archaeopress 2020 Cover: Painting of Old Oswestry Hillfort by Allanah Piesse Back cover: Old Oswestry from the air, photograph by Alastair Reid Please note that all uncredited images and photographs within each chapter have been produced by the individual authors. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the copyright owners. Printed in England by Holywell Press, Oxford This book is available direct from Archaeopress or from our website www.archaeopress.com Contents Contributors ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ii Preface: Old Oswestry – 80 years on �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������v Tim Malim and George Nash Part 1 Setting the scene Chapter 1 The prehistoric Marches – warfare or continuity? �������������������������������������������������������������������������� 1 David J. Matthews Chapter 2 Everybody needs good neighbours: Old Oswestry hillfort in context ���������������������������������������������
    [Show full text]