Intrafamilial Variability and Clinical Heterogeneity in a Family with PLA2G6-Associated Neurodegeneration
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Precision and Future Medicine 2019;3(3):135-138 CASE https://doi.org/10.23838/pfm.2019.00086 REPORT pISSN: 2508-7940 · eISSN: 2508-7959 Intrafamilial variability and clinical heterogeneity in a family with PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration 1 2,3 2,3 Jong Kyu Park , Jinyoung Youn , Jin Whan Cho 1 DepartmentofNeurology,SoonchunhyangUniversityCheonanHospital,SoonchunhyangUniversityCollegeofMedicine, Cheonan,Korea 2 DepartmentofNeurology,SamsungMedicalCenter,SungkyunkwanUniversitySchoolofMedicine,Seoul,Korea 3 NeuroscienceCenter,SamsungMedicalCenter,Seoul,Korea Received: August 8, 2019 Revised: August 21, 2019 Accepted: August 23, 2019 ABSTRACT PhospholipaseA2groupVI(PLA2G6)-associatedneurodegeneration(PLAN)isanauto- Corresponding author: Jin Whan Cho somalrecessiveneurodegenerativediseasewithawideclinicalspectrum;however,the Department of Neurology, genotype-phenotypecorrelationisunknown.Here,wereportdifferentphenotypesin Samsung Medical Center, onefamilywiththesamegenotype.A28-year-oldmalepresentedwithslowlyprogres- Sungkyunkwan University sivegaitdisturbancewithspasticity.Onsetoccurredat11years.Interestingly,his School of Medicine, 81 Irwon- youngerbrother,a24-year-oldmale,presentedwithprogressiveParkinsonism,which ro, Gangnam-gu, Seoul 06351, beganat22years.Heshowedexcellentresponsetolevodopabutdevelopedafluctuat- Korea ingmedicationresponseandlevodopa-induceddyskinesia1yearafterstartinglevodo- Tel: +82-2-3410-3599 pamedication.Healsodemonstratedhyperreflexia,butnospasticity.Dopaminetrans- E-mail: porterimagingshowedreduceduptakeinthebilateralputamen.Inwhole-exome [email protected] sequencingandSangersequencing,ahomozygouspathogenicvariant(p.R747W)in thePLA2G6genewasdetectedinbothcases.Despitedifferentclinicalfeatures,both subjectshadhyperreflexiaduringtheexaminationandclavalhypertrophywasshown onthebrainmagneticresonanceimaging. Keywords: PLA2G6;Parkinsondisease;Geneticanalysis INTRODUCTION PhospholipaseA2groupVI(PLA2G6)-associatedneurodegeneration(PLAN)isanautosomal recessiveneurodegenerativediseasewithmultiplephenotypes,includinginfantileneuroaxo- naldystrophy,neurodegenerationwithbrainironaccumulation,anddystonia-Parkinsonism [1,2].TheclinicalspectrumofPLANhasbeenproposedtoincludevariousphenotypesassoci- This is an Open Access article atedwithPLA2G6mutations.AlthoughvariousphenotypesareknowninpatientswithPLAN, distributed under the terms of the genotype-phenotypecorrelationhasyettobeclearlyelucidated.Further,therearenoreports Creative Commons Attribution demonstratingvariousphenotypeseveninonefamilywiththesamegenotype.Here,wede- Non-Commercial License (http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/ scribeafamilywiththesamegenotypeofPLAN,butwithphenotypicvariability. by-nc/4.0/). Copyright © 2019 Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine 135 IntrafamilialvariabilityinPLA2G6mutation CASE REPORTS ousparentsofArabianancestry.Hehadnohistoryofpreterm deliveryorperinatalinjury,andhisdevelopmentalmile- Subject 1 stoneswerenormal.Therewasnofamilyhistoryofmove- A28-year-oldmalewithprogressivespasticgaitdisturbance mentdisorders,exceptinhisyoungerbrother(Subject2). thatbeganattheageof11presentedatSamsungMedical ThefamilialpedigreeisillustratedinFig.1.Hewasnormalin Center,Seoul,Korea.Hewasborntohealthyconsanguine- cognitiveandlanguageskillsandfinishedhismaster’sde- greeincollege.Theonlyaccompanyingsymptomwasuri- naryurgencyandincontinence. Whenhecametoourclinic,spasticitywaspresentinthe hipadductormuscles,aswellasinthekneeandanklejoints. Sensorydisturbanceoflowerlimbswasabsent.Briskreflex- eswerepresentonbothlimbs,andpathologicreflexes,such asHoffmansign,ankleclonusandBabinskisign,werealso present.Grade4mildmuscleweaknesswaspresentwith bothankledorsiflexions.Hedemonstratedspasticgaitwith dystonicanklemovementsinterferingspeedofgait,butno rigidityorbradykinesia.Anerveconductionstudyonlower limbswasnormal.Therewasnoironaccumulation,butcla- valhypertrophywasshownonthebrainmagneticresonance imaging(MRI)(Fig.2A).Thecervicalthroughthoracicspinal Fig. 1. Pedigree of the index subjects: black symbols indicate MRIwasnormal. affected individuals and arrows indicate subjects. A B C Fig. 2. (A) T2 fluid attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) midsagittal section image of subject 1 shows claval hypertrophy (white arrow). (B) T2 FLAIR midsagittal section image of subject 2 shows claval hypertrophy (white arrow) and a vertical corpus callosum (black arrow). (C) Dopamine transporter image of subject 2 demonstrated significantly reduced uptake in the bilateral putamen. 136 http://pfmjournal.org JongKyuPark,etal. Fig. 3. Sequencing analysis of index subjects showing homozygous variants in phospholipase A2 group VI (PLA2G6). Analysis of parental samples demonstrated that the PLA2G6 variants were heterozygous, which is consistent with autosomal recessive inheritance. Wholeexomesequencingforsubject1revealedahomozy- andthesamehomozygouspathogenicvariant(p.R747W) gousc.2239C> T(p.R747W)pathogenicvariantinthePLA2G6 wasdetected(Fig.3).HisParkinsonismimproveddramati- gene.Sangersequencingshowedthatbothoftheparents callywithlevodopamedication,buthedevelopedwear- wereheterozygousforthisvariant(Fig.3).Hisgaitdistur- ing-offphenomenonandlevodopa-induceddyskinesiawith- bancedidnotrespondwithlevodopatreatmentbutpartially in1yearfromthelevodopastartdate. improvedwithbaclofen(30mg/day)andbotulinumtoxin typeAinjectiononthetibialisposteriormuscle(50units, DISCUSSION each). Here,wedescribedtwodifferentphenotypesofthesame Subject 2 genotypeofPLANinonefamily.Onephenotypewaslevodo- Theyoungerbrotherofsubject1,a24-year-oldmale,pre- pa-responsiveParkinsonismandtheotherwasspasticpara- sentedatourclinicwithslowlyprogressiveParkinsonism plegia.Bothsharedhyperreflexiaonlowerlimbsandpyrami- thatbeganattheageof22.Likesubject1,hehadnohistory daltractsyndrome,buttotallydifferentmainphenotypic ofpretermdeliveryorperinatalinjury,andthedevelopmen- presentationsinthesamegenotypearerarelyreported.In- talmilestoneswerenormal.Urinaryurgencywascombined, terestingly,PLANcoversvariousphenotypesofPLA2G6mu- whilegeneralcognitionwasnormal. tation,andvariousphenotypesofPLANaredescribedac- Ontheneurologicexam,bradykinesiaandrigiditywere cordingtotheageofonset(e.g.,infantileneuroaxonaldys- presentinbothlimbs,butmoreprominentlyontheleftside. trophyoccursinchildhoodanddystonia-Parkinsonismoc- Additionally,resttremorwasseeninbotharms.Deepten- cursinearlyadulthood).However,eventhoughvariousphe- donreflexeswerebriskandtheBabinskisignwaspresentin notypesofPLANhavebeenreported,therearecurrentlyin- bothlowerlimbs.F-18fluorinated-N-3-fluoropropyl-2-b-car- sufficientstudiesonphenotype-genotypecorrelation.Fur- boxymethoxy-3-b-(4-iodophenyl)nortropanepositronemis- ther,ourpatientsweresimilarinagebutpresentedwith siontomography(FP-CITPET)demonstratedsignificantlyre- completelydifferentphenotypesinasinglefamilywiththe duceduptakeinthebilateralputamen(Fig.2C).Additionally, samegenotype,unlikevariousphenotypesinPLAN.Tothe corpuscallosumchangesandclavalhypertrophywereseen bestofourknowledge,thisisthefirstreportofintrafamilial onthebrainMRI(Fig.2B). variabilityinmonogenicPLAN.Themechanismsresponsible WeperformedSangersequencingofthePLA2G6gene, fordeterminationofphenotypesarenotyetknown. https://doi.org/10.23838/pfm.2019.00086 137 IntrafamilialvariabilityinPLA2G6mutation Thefirstphenotypeofoursubjectswaslevodopa-respon- CONFLICTS OF INTEREST siveParkinsonism.Parkinsonismisacommonlyreported symptominPLANpatients,andthesamegenotype(p. Nopotentialconflictofinterestrelevanttothisarticlewasre- R747W)hasbeenpreviouslyreportedinapatientwith ported. levodopa-responsiveParkinsonism[3,4].Inaccordancewith previouslyreportedPLANcaseswithParkinsonism,ourcase ORCID alsoshowednormalbirth,achievednormalmilestones,and symptomsbeganinadulthood.Allcasesprogressedrapidly JongKyuPark https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9261-790X aftertheonsetandshowedadramaticresponsetolevodopa JinyoungYoun https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3350-5032 therapy,butanimpulsecontroldisorderorearlydyskinesia JinWhanCho https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9145-6729 appeared.Additionally,ourcasealsorevealedpresynaptic dopaminergiclossbyFP-CITPETimagingstudy. REFERENCES Intermsofspasticparaplegia,60hereditaryspasticpara- plegia(HSP)-relatedgeneshavebeenreported,buttheun- 1. GuoYP,TangBS,GuoJF.PLA2G6-associatedneurode- derlyingcausesofHSPstillremainunidentified[5].Recently, generation(PLAN):reviewofclinicalphenotypesand PLANwithphenotypeofcomplicatedHSPwasreported[6,7], genotypes.FrontNeurol2018;9:1100. butpureformspasticparaplegiawasnotreported.With 2. LeeJH,ParkJ,RyuHS,ParkH,KimYE,HongJY,etal.Clin- wholeexomesequencing,weexcludedassociatedgenesfor icalheterogeneityofatypicalpantothenatekinase-asso- HSPinsubject1;thus,wesuggestpureformspasticparaple- ciatedneurodegenerationinKoreans.JMovDisord2016; giaisanewphenotypeofPLANbasedonourcase. 9:20-7. Despitedifferentmainphenotypesofourpatients,both 3. Paisan-RuizC,LiA,SchneiderSA,HoltonJL,JohnsonR, subjectsalsodemonstratedcommonclinicalfeatures.First, KiddD,etal.WidespreadLewybodyandtauaccumulation pyramidaltractsyndromewasseeninbothsubjects.Addi- inchildhoodandadultonsetdystonia-parkinsonismcases tionally,bothcaseshadclavalhypertrophy(Fig.2A,B).In withPLA2G6mutations.NeurobiolAging2012;33:814-23. termsofbrainimaging,abnormalironaccumulationiscon- 4. GiriA,GuvenG,HanagasiH,HauserAK,Erginul-Unaltuna sideredasacharacteristicsignofneurodegenerationwith N,BilgicB,etal.PLA2G6mutationsrelatedtodistinct brainironaccumulation,butironaccumulationisnolonger phenotypes:anewcasewithearly-onsetparkinsonism. apathognomonicfindinginPLA2G6mutations.Similarly,