COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA

LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 11, 2018

SESSION OF 2018 202D OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY No. 43

providing for definitions, for eligibility, for amount of grants and for HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES limitations. The House convened at 9:30 a.m., e.d.t. VETERANS AFFAIRS AND EMERGENCY THE SPEAKER (MIKE TURZAI) PREPAREDNESS. PRESIDING SB 31, PN 12 By Rep. DiGIROLAMO

PRAYER An Act amending the act of June 26, 2001 (P.L.755, No.77), known as the Tobacco Settlement Act, in Commonwealth universal research HON. STEPHEN BLOOM, member of the House of enhancement, establishing the Spinal Cord Injury Research Program and Spinal Cord Research Advisory Committee, further providing for Representatives, offered the following prayer: department responsibilities and for use of funds and providing for spinal cord injury research programs funding. Let us pray. Let us start, Lord God, with a prayer of all of us, by all of us, HUMAN SERVICES. for the victims and first responders of the hurricane that is passing through the entire eastern seaboard of our country today. Let us RESOLUTION REPORTED have a moment of silent prayer. FROM COMMITTEE Lord, help us. The decisions we face are bigger than us. The challenges we face are bigger than us. The discord that surrounds HR 1112, PN 4122 By Rep. BARRAR and immerses us is bigger than us. But, Lord, there is good news because You, Lord, are bigger than all that. A Resolution calling upon the Federal Government to prioritize and Your wisdom and mercy, Lord, transcend the decisions we consider the need for resilient infrastructure to reduce risks and meet the face. Your power and grace, Lord, overcome the challenges we country's economic, environmental and social needs. face. Your peace, Lord, and Your love quench the fires of anger VETERANS AFFAIRS AND EMERGENCY and hatred we face. Your Word, Lord God, says that unless You PREPAREDNESS. build the house, we who build it labor in vain.

So today, Lord, let us rest in You. Let us put our faith in You. The SPEAKER. All members are requested to come to the Let us listen and follow to Your still small voice. To You, God, floor. We are going to be moving into retirement remarks, be the glory. In the name of my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, farewell remarks, from members who are retiring. I pray. Amen. All members, please come to the floor and take your seats. We have some guests that have traveled some distance to be with us PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE today.

(The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by members and visitors.) DR. PAMELA GUNTER-SMITH PRESENTED

JOURNAL APPROVAL POSTPONED The SPEAKER. The York County delegation has been gracious enough to invite Dr. Pamela Gunter-Smith, president of The SPEAKER. Without objection, the approval of the York College, and with her I believe today is Jeff Vermeulen, Journal of Wednesday, October 10, 2018, will be postponed until assistant vice president for External Relations. York College is printed. celebrating its 50th anniversary. So I am going to ask the Sergeants at Arms to ask all members BILLS REPORTED FROM COMMITTEES, to take their seats. All members, please take your seats, and we CONSIDERED FIRST TIME, AND TABLED are going to close the doors of the House. Dr. Pamela Gunter-Smith began serving as president of York HB 2696, PN 4195 By Rep. BARRAR College on July 1, 2013. She previously served as Drew University's provost and academic vice president and as the An Act amending Title 51 (Military Affairs) of the Pennsylvania endowed porter professor of physiology at Spelman College, Consolidated Statutes, in military educational programs, further very prestigious school. Dr. Gunter-Smith has also held academic 1278 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11 appointments at George Washington University and the Our graduates are especially marketable in the workforce, and Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences. For of our recent graduates, 91 percent are currently employed and 12 years before joining Spelman College, Dr. Gunter-Smith was many of them have jobs well before their graduation date. The a research scientist and science administrator at the Armed Forces number of students who have positions 6 weeks before Radiobiology Research Institute in Bethesda, Maryland. graduation significantly exceeds the national average for all Her background is quite impressive. She holds a bachelor of institutions. Many of them are involved in the nonprofit sector science degree in biology from Spelman College and a Ph.D. and public service, exemplifying the college's motto, "Servire Est (doctor of philosophy) in physiology from Emory University. Vivere," to serve is to live. We are especially proud to serve our She, in fact, conducted postdoctoral studies out my way, at the veterans who are continuing their education and proud of being University of School of Medicine, and then also at the recognized among the top 20 percent of American institutions of University of Texas Health Science Center in Houston. She has higher education doing the most to embrace veteran students. published significantly in the areas of gastrointestinal physiology While reflecting on the 50th, it became clearer more than ever and membrane ion transport and is the recipient of grants to just how important the college's role is in our community and how support science education and research. important the support and partnership of the community and the She is married to J. Lawrence Smith, a native of St. Louis, Commonwealth is to York College. We are deeply rooted in the Missouri. He currently works with IBM. They are proud parents city of York and York County. The city of York is undergoing a of two sons, Lealand of Nashville, Tennessee, and Philip of powerful economic and cultural rebirth, and York College is very Auburn, Alabama. proud to be part of this renaissance. We are a major employer in The York County delegation was so proud to bring in York and York County and a source of significant economic and Dr. Gunter-Smith when there was a resolution that tax revenue for our community and for the Commonwealth. The Representative had sponsored celebrating the annual economic impact of York College in the Commonwealth 50th anniversary of the college, and we did not have time that day measured in 2014 is well over $170 million annually. to have her speak. We had not really prepared her for it, and I had Under my leadership, the college has recommitted to serving asked her if she would come back at my request to speak to this York City and the region and in very real, tangible ways. We august body. opened the Center for Community Engagement in the heart of At this time I would like to bring up Dr. Gunter-Smith, downtown York, and through our programming and student president of York College. involvement, the Center for Community Engagement promotes Dr. GUNTER-SMITH. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the the college's positive relationship with the community and invitation to give remarks this morning. provides much-needed expertise for important projects. For And my special thanks to Representative Seth Grove, an example, our students recently completed the first-ever accomplished alumnus from York College who helped champion comprehensive study of the York Latinx community that will HR 1043, commemorating the 50th anniversary of York College lead to the development of important policies to serve this as a 4-year institution. It is such a great honor for me to be here growing underserved community in York. Another of our with you today as president of the college, representing over downtown locations, Marketview Arts, has become a hub for 4200 students, 800 employees, 30,000 known alumni nationwide, culture and creativity in the city. many of whom are citizens of our Commonwealth. I would be remiss if I did not mention the impact of our more This past week the college marked the occasion of our than 30,000 alumni who throughout the Commonwealth, the 50th anniversary as a 4-year institution, a weeklong celebration country, and the world live to serve. Our graduates are thriving of the past, and in doing so, the college also took the time to in Pennsylvania in a variety of fields, such as engineering, reflect on our role in higher education, the York community, and computer science, business, nursing, cyber security, and they, importantly, our evolution as a modern-day institution of higher like Representative Seth Grove, class of 2002, are making their education. mark right here in Pennsylvania. York College of Pennsylvania has been linked to the As a private institution, we value and make access and Commonwealth from our earliest days when the Pennsylvania affordability our number one priority for our current and future General Assembly provided the college's earliest ancestor, York students. We deliver a high-quality personalized experience with County Academy, with an official charter in 1787. a tuition that is comparable to some of the Pennsylvania public While we are celebrating 50 years as a 4-year institution, we and State-supported institutions. If you were to compare us to celebrate well over 230 years as an educational institution serving Penn State or to Millersville, you would see that our tuition is the citizens of York, York County, and the Commonwealth of very comparable to theirs, and we deliver this with a cost that is Pennsylvania. It is indeed a rich heritage. nearly half of other private institutions. Since our founding, the college has stayed true to its mission This said, we are extremely appreciative of the partnership we to create a transformative educational experience for our have with the Commonwealth in helping us educate Pennsylvania students, one that will empower them to lead purposeful and students and lowering student debt. PHEAA (Pennsylvania fulfilling lives and meaningful careers in a rapidly changing Higher Education Assistance Agency) grants are an important world. The college has evolved now into a predominantly tool in taking on the complex issue of student debt, and we thank undergraduate residential comprehensive college that offers a you for continued support and continued funding for this unique blend of professional programs such as engineering, program. What is important to know is that PHEAA follows the nursing, hospitality management, and business within a liberal student and this along with the nearly $22 million provided arts education. In addition, we offer leading-edge graduate annually from York College institutional funds is helping programs also in nursing, education, and business. students to select the institution that best fits their needs, one in which they will thrive.

2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1279

Over the years we have received Pennsylvania grants that have County for the day, and Representative of helped us with a variety of projects, including the creation of a Allegheny County for the day. Without objection, those will be business incubator on campus which is playing a role with respect granted. to innovation, job creation, in today's knowledge economy. We have also received an "It's On Us Pennsylvania" grant to fuel our MASTER ROLL CALL efforts to curb sexual violence on campus. For this and others we thank you. The SPEAKER. Members will proceed to vote on the master Higher education in Pennsylvania is something that we do roll. exceptionally well. We have many different options for our students from which they can choose. The following roll call was recorded: In 1799 our founding institution, York County Academy, received a grant from the Commonwealth in the amount of PRESENT–183 $2,000. Even in today's dollars, which this would now be about $50,000, you would be hard pressed not to be pleased by the Barbin Ellis Lawrence Rapp magnitude of this return on Pennsylvania's investment. Barrar Emrick Lewis Ravenstahl Bernstine English Longietti Reed On behalf of our entire York College community, thank you Bizzarro Evans Mackenzie Roae for recognizing York College of Pennsylvania, especially at this Bloom Farry Madden Roe time of its 50th anniversary, and I am honored to have had this Boback Fee Maher Roebuck time to be with you this morning. Thank you so very much for all Boyle Fitzgerald Mako Rothman Bradford Flynn Maloney Rozzi that you do for the citizens of Pennsylvania and especially for the Briggs Frankel Markosek Ryan students that we serve. Thank you very much. Brown, R. Freeman Marshall Saccone Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Brown, V. Fritz Marsico Sainato The SPEAKER. Dr. Gunter-Smith, please stay here for just a Bullock Gainey Masser Samuelson Burns Galloway McCarter Sankey moment. We are going to invite the York County delegation up Caltagirone Gillen McClinton Santora for photos. Those remarks were outstanding. What an Carroll Gillespie McGinnis Schemel outstanding school and we love your message. Thank you for all Causer Godshall McNeill Schlossberg you are doing for the students in Pennsylvania and for the Cephas Goodman Mehaffie Schweyer Charlton Greiner Mentzer Simmons community and for the State. Thank you. Christiana Grove Metcalfe Sims Comitta Haggerty Metzgar Snyder Conklin Hahn Miccarelli Solomon GUEST INTRODUCED Cook Hanna Millard Sonney Corbin Harkins Miller, B. Staats The SPEAKER. We also have a student at York College. She Costa, D. Harper Milne Stephens is actually from Saudi Arabia, and she is the guest of Costa, P. Harris, A. Moul Sturla Representative . Lamyaa Alsheri. Lamyaa, please Cox Harris, J. Mullery Tai Cruz Heffley Murt Tallman wave to everybody. It is great to have you here today. Thank you Culver Helm Mustio Taylor very much. Thank you. Cutler Hickernell Neilson Tobash Daley Hill Nelson Toepel The Sergeants at Arms will open the doors of the House. Davidson Irvin Nesbit Toohil Davis, A. Jozwiak O'Neal Topper All members, please come to the House floor. We are going Dawkins Kampf O'Neill Vazquez to be taking the master roll. Day Kaufer Oberlander Vitali Dean Kauffman Ortitay Walsh Deasy Keefer Owlett Ward LEAVES OF ABSENCE DeLissio Keller, F. Pashinski Warner Delozier Keller, M.K. Peifer Warren The SPEAKER. The majority whip requests leaves of absence DeLuca Keller, W. Petrarca Wentling Dermody Kim Pickett Wheeland for the following members: Mike REESE of Westmoreland Diamond Kinsey Pyle White County for the day, of Venango County for the day, DiGirolamo Kirkland Quigley Youngblood Representative Kathy WATSON of Bucks County for the day, Donatucci Klunk Quinn, C. Zimmerman Representative of Centre County for the Dowling Knowles Quinn, M. Driscoll Krueger Rabb Turzai, day, Representative of Chester County for Dunbar Kulik Rader Speaker the day. Without objection, those will be granted. Dush The minority whip requests leaves of absence for Representative Sid KAVULICH of Lackawanna County for the ADDITIONS–0 day, Representative of Allegheny County for the day, Representative Mike O'BRIEN of Philadelphia NOT VOTING–0 County for the day, Representative Bill KORTZ of Allegheny EXCUSED–18 County for the day, Representative Rob MATZIE of Beaver County for the day, Representative of Bucks County Benninghoff Hennessey Miller, D. Saylor for the day, Representative Dan MILLER of Allegheny County Corr James O'Brien Thomas for the day, Representative Curtis THOMAS of Philadelphia Davis, T. Kavulich Readshaw Watson Everett Kortz Reese Wheatley Gabler Matzie

1280 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

LEAVES ADDED–10 son, Spencer, are dear friends. We talked for hours. He regaled me with stories of legislative adventures in days gone by and how Cruz Irvin Lewis Metcalfe if you did not comply with the leadership's demands, they would Davidson Kirkland McNeill Miccarelli Haggerty Krueger take your office away from you. The East Wing did not exist, so apparently that is where your desk would have gone, in that LEAVES CANCELED–2 breezeway. They said if you were not going to vote the right way, that they would lock you in the broom closet. Irvin Watson So I want to say thank you to our leadership team, to Speaker Turzai, to Leader Reed, for empowering me to represent the voters in my district, even when I might not have voted the way The SPEAKER. There are 183 members on the House floor. they wanted me to, even when they have not agreed with me. We have a quorum. I appreciate that so much that they allowed me to put my people first. And I think that if I had served back in the olden days, I may Members, please take your seats. Representative Kristin have spent a lot of time without an office, locked in a broom Phillips-Hill will be giving her farewell remarks. The Sergeants closet. at Arms will close the doors of the House. I have found that one of the greatest challenges in public life is not forgetting who you are and where you came from, and I am FAREWELL ADDRESS certain that none of you can forget that before I was a legislator, BY MRS. HILL I was a school board director. I know. I can tell you are very, very surprised. But I will tell you this, that if the States are laboratories The SPEAKER. Representative Kristin Phillips-Hill was of democracy, the school board was my test kitchen, and I need elected in 2015 to represent the 93d District of York County. to thank my former school board directors, the students, and the From the moment she arrived, she has been engaged in so many staff and administration at Dallastown for helping me to learn that significant issues. Her experience as a school board member gave educational excellence and fiscal responsibility are not mutually her much insight into how to successfully educate students, not exclusive goals, that government can deliver high-quality only in her community but all across the State, in a cost-effective outcomes by creatively using scarce resources; that by working manner, and she has brought that skill set here to the General collaboratively with various stakeholders, you can hold the line Assembly. She is at this time running for the State Senate, and as on taxes and create well-rounded students ready to take on the you know, she resides in York County with her husband, Rick. challenges of tomorrow. But most importantly, they taught me They have three children: Spencer, Victoria, and Gavin. And how to implement zero-based budgeting and performance I am honored to call her up to the rostrum at this time to present measures and that they really do work, and all of those lessons her farewell remarks. have served me so well here in the Capitol. Representative Phillips-Hill. I need to thank my remarkable parents, Karen and Jay Phillips, Mrs. HILL. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. for their unwavering love and support and encouragement, even I have struggled to find just the right words to share with you when they have not agreed with me. today. It is not easy to say goodbye, and I consider myself so Joining me here today is my wonderful husband, Rick Hill. He incredibly fortunate to have had something that has been so is the consummate political spouse. When I was in college, my wonderful that it makes it so hard to say goodbye. professors told me that there was no such thing as Prince There are so many different ways that you can approach this Charming and happily ever after, and I need to publicly thank farewell address. Some people have spoken of great philosophic Rick Hill for proving them wrong. principles, others have extolled legislative accomplishments, and Thank you to our children: Victoria, Gavin, and Spencer. I am several have even discussed their family's political genealogy, so proud to be their mom, and I am so grateful for the lessons that and I, too, am not the first member of my family to serve in this they taught me, many of which prepared me for my service here institution. But really, none of that is important. To me, the most in Harrisburg. important thing to convey to you here today is the deep and Thank you to the wonderful people that have worked with me profound gratitude that I have and to say thank you. over the last 4 years in the district and in Harrisburg: Tom Metz, Thank you to the incredible people of the 93d Legislative Galen Weibley, Michael Curley, Scott Little, Michelle Pinkerton, District in southern York County that believed in me and trusted and Lauren Evans. Each of them has brought different talents and me to do their will and be their voice here in Harrisburg. It has skills to serve the people of the 93d District well, but what they truly been the greatest honor and privilege to serve them. I have have all had in common is a passion for the people, solving their been humbled to have been so warmly welcomed into their lives problems and making government work better for them. You are to share in their great joys and celebrations, but also to mourn only as good as the people that you surround yourself with, and with them and share in their great sorrows. they have made me look good every day that they have served. Thank you to each and every one of you, the duly elected Thank you to the many exceptional interns that we have had Representatives of the people of the Commonwealth of join us, especially our senior intern, Margaret Ibex, who always Pennsylvania. I am grateful to have had the opportunity to serve brought sunshine to our office, kept us organized, and even baked with you and to get to know each of you as we have endeavored us cookies. to do the people's work. Thank you to the York County delegation, my Harrisburg The summer before I was elected to the House, I had the family, that the voters of York County gave to me: Stan, Keith, opportunity to spend some time with former York County State Seth, Kate, Dawn, and Carol. I am so proud to be a member of Senator Ralph Hess. His granddaughter, Anna, and our youngest this cohesive team that has worked so hard for all of York County. 2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1281

We have a joke in York County, and that is that we never need to get this done and get me an answer or we're running the sleep. There is someone up on duty 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, bill regardless." Chairman Metcalfe turned to me and he said, and it is so bad that at one point even our former State Senator "You know, I'm not used to being the good guy." Scott Wagner texted us – I think it was like 1:30, 2 o' clock in the I am grateful to my dear friends and colleagues in the morning – and said, "Do you people ever sleep?" The answer is Common Sense Caucus, particularly Chairman Moul. That is "no." M-o-u-l, not M-a-o. That summer was a really difficult one, and Thank you to my dear friend, Seth Grove. Thank you for being in the past I had been asked by my constituents, "You know, why the Reagan to my Thatcher, my closest political ally, fellow don't you have a seat at the table?" And said, "You policy wonk, and really, truly a dear friend. know, I'm coming back here until I find a solution." And we did. has often admonished me that "Kristin, you can't Dan, you are often irreverent, you always make me laugh, and helicopter-parent your delegation." They are a lot of work, but you are a dear friend. I also need to thank , whom I gladly turn the reins over to Representative . I really got to know that summer. I am proud to be called his I know that she will take very good care of them. granddaughter. York County and Adams County, they have a really close We have endeavored to do some really important public connection. Adams County was actually part of York County at policy. The one that I have appreciated working with Dawn one point, and and Dan Moul, they seem like one Keefer and the most on has been regulatory of us. Will Tallman has always made me laugh. The first time reform. Thank you for being champions of something that has I met Will Tallman was over the phone. I had recently been hired; been so important to the people that I represent. Thank you to it was actually my first day on the job working for my Greg Rothman. When Greg came into the House, he came up to predecessor, Ron Miller. I picked up the phone and I said, "Good me with his fist clenched and unloaded an entire stack of Reese's morning. Representative Ron Miller's office. This is Kristin. How peanut butter cups and said, "I hope that we can be friends." And can I help you?" And the voice on the other end of the phone said, I thought, well, obviously my reputation precedes me; I am a "What is Ron wearing today?" Calmly I said, "Hold on a moment, tough customer and I really like candy. please." I went into the other office and said, "We have a creeper To Rick Saccone. Rick Saccone was my first seatmate, and on line one." Will, it has been a pleasure to serve with you. I have I have to tell you, he needs to come with a warning label. On a few words for Dan Moul later in my remarks. swearing-in day, I am here and this is so new and everything is Kate Klunk, thank you for being the sister that I never had. so fresh and I wanted to do my very best and we said the prayer Almost every crazy adventure that I have had in this place has and then we said the Pledge, and for those of you who do not included Kate, including teaching Emily Rauch, our legislative know, when Rick Saccone gets to the part of the Pledge where it assistant, how to do the bunny hop to Lawrence Welk at says "one nation," he literally shouts, "under God." I came out of 11 o'clock at night one evening in the East Wing. my shoes and almost broke my ankle. I warned Dawn Keefer Bryan Cutler, I have to thank you for giving me the when she took that seat. opportunity to serve as a deputy majority whip since I arrived I have been fortunate to have great times with my seatmates. here in the Capitol. Thanks for taking a chance on a freshman I think one of the things people do not really know is how many legislator, although I am not really sure if that was not some sort sacrifices you make here and how many difficult decisions that of hazing because you put Jeff Pyle on my deputy whip list, and you have to make and the sacrifices that your families make. And I am sure Becky Corbin can relate to this, but Jeff really put me my son, Spencer, was swimming in the PIAA State through my paces early on and I can tell you that for the first Championship Finals at Bucknell and the medical marijuana bill 6 months he would not give me an answer on how he would vote. was on the floor and I felt that it was really important for me to The next 6 months, while he gave me a response, there was not a be here. I had promised people back home I would cast those column for his answer and I really cannot say what it was publicly votes. I have never missed one, and it was really tough and from this rostrum. Jeff avoided me for a while, and I have to tell I called him and I said, "Hey, Bud, I'm just so sorry. I'm so sorry. you that I know every shortcut and every hiding place in this We're here. We're voting on medical marijuana. It is really so Capitol because I have tracked him down. Harry Lewis and important." And he says, "Hey, guys, my mom is talking about I were going to a meeting on the other side of the Capitol pot up on the House floor. She's not going to be here." The entire Complex, I said, "Oh, wait, Harry. This is the way we can get locker room erupted in laughter. I said, "Son, that's not what there faster." And he said, "How do you know that?" I said, "I've I said." But thanks to our IT (Information Technology) tracked Jeff Pyle down for over a year." Department and Carl Metzgar and , I somehow got I need to thank our exceptional staff, particularly those that that swim meet on my laptop at my desk and I had a cheering serve the Education, Health, and State Government Committees. section from all over the Commonwealth when he medaled. You are exceptional people, and I thank you so much for all of Working across the aisle, it happens more than you know. your hard work. People always say, "Can't you people in Harrisburg get along?" I need to thank the chairmen of those committees: Chairman Well, we do. It just does not make the front page of the Hickernell, Chairman Baker, and now Chairwoman Rapp, and newspaper. I need to thank my colleagues across the aisle who Chairman Metcalfe. I have really enjoyed the policy work that we have partnered with me: Pam DeLissio for working on teacher have done. Probably one of my fondest committee moments was certification for military spouses and getting it signed into law. when I was working on a piece of legislation in the State for standing against bigotry and hatred in the Government Committee and I was struggling to get what I needed wake of the bomb threats against the Jewish Community Center from the administration, and I said to the gentleman, "I'm going in my district. Mike Schlossberg, thank you for being a partner to tell you what I tell my sons, and that is, your lack of on suicide prevention. And to my dear friend, , thank preparedness does not constitute an emergency on my part. You you for working with me to close the digital divide.

1282 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

In closing, I want to thank you once again. It has been such a Mr. D. COSTA. Thank you so much. Thank you. great honor and privilege to serve here with you. And I want to That means the world to me, believe me. It makes it very, very leave you with this promise, and that is that I will never forget difficult for me to leave this wonderful organization. At first who I am and where I came from and know that I look forward I was toying with the idea of not doing a speech and the Speaker to the day when I can say, "Do you know I used to be a House told me that if I made it quick and Mike engaged the rule, the member?" 5-minute rule, on our side, with deputy whips, that I have to be Thank you once again. God bless each and every one of you. quick and he would let us out early. So I am not going to stand in God bless the great Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and the between you and getting out of here early. But it is important, my United States of America. mother, God rest her soul, told me that you are better than no one, no one is better than you, and it is important to say a couple of REMARKS BY SPEAKER things: thank you when needed and I love you when needed. And those words were powerful. And I am here to thank the people The SPEAKER. Kristin, I know how dedicated you are to your that helped me serve the people of this Commonwealth in my three children, you and your husband are to your three children, district. and to miss— I remember her telling me that day and I was there, And this aisle, I always tease that this aisle in the middle that like, "Kristin, what are you doing here?" And your dedication to is supposedly the dividing aisle is, if I was ever the Speaker, the citizens of your district and to the citizens of the which I will not be and I just never intended to be the Speaker, it Commonwealth is so deep. I know you will make a great Senator would be for walking, because the seats would be Republican, on the other side of the Capitol, but do not forget us when you are Democrat, Republican, Democrat, Republican, Democrat. Thank there. you. At the end of the day we all have the same issues. We have I also wanted to just say, Kristin, so many people just really families, and when we are sitting there talking to each other, you admire how you are able to tackle tough issues, but you never say, oh, I forgot to get my car inspected; I got this; I have that; make it personal. You are always so professional about how you I have this." But we all have the same goals. address them, how you handle yourself in your remarks on the Since I have been here, we were very blessed by getting Katie floor or in caucus and how you handled them up here today. You Klunk here, and I had seen and shared the grief when she lost her are so gracious, and we wish you and your family nothing but the father and I shared the joy when she had her daughter, Grace. And best. Thank you for your tenacity, but your tenacity with class that is what it is about, folks. Think about it. When we as people and grace. Thank you so much. amongst us lose someone or one of our colleagues loses someone, If the York County delegation could come up to the rostrum, Sid Kavulich in the hospital, we all come as one. Republican and please, for a photo. Democrat equal people. When we have our races, we go out and we race and we fight (Commemorative gavel was presented.) hard. When we come on that side of the rail, this is an arena. Let us not make it personal. I think I have garnered the friendship of both sides because of that, because of that philosophy. We are all LEAVES OF ABSENCE people, we all care about each other, we all love our families, and we all have the same goal, to serve the people of this The SPEAKER. Representative has requested to Commonwealth. be placed on leave. Without objection, that will be granted. Now, I would like to start the thank yous, if I could. My first Representative Rich IRVIN has requested to be placed on thank you is to the people of the 21st District that supported me leave. Without objection, that will be granted. and were the rock of my whole reason for being here. Representative Jozwiak, who was a State trooper and sheriff, we FAREWELL ADDRESS know that when we take these jobs as police officers, we all take BY MR. D. COSTA them for one reason, to help people, to make things better. Well, I hope that I made things better in the 21st District, I believe The SPEAKER. Representative . When I was – I did, and with my wonderful staff, and we all know without your this goes back some years – an assistant district attorney in staff we are really nothing because they really make us what we Allegheny County, Representative Costa, Dom Costa, was a city are. of detective and then later became chief of I would like to thank my friends in organized labor. They were police, and he has been serving the 21st Legislative District of with me over the years, their support. I especially would like to Allegheny County since 2008. His district is just south of my thank two guys that were with me when I was a nobody, when district, and he is chairman of the Allegheny County delegation. I just started, and I came against the Democratic Party for an Dom resides in Pittsburgh with his wife, Darlene; two West endorsement. Ken Broadbent from Steamfitters 449 and Tom Highland white terriers, Bennie and Maverick; three grown Bigley from the Plumbers Union 27, which my dad and my children – Tina, Julie, and Scott – and two grandchildren, of brothers were all members of, they stood with me with big which they are abundantly proud, Quinn and Liam. $500 checks back then, but they stood with me and I will never I am going to ask everybody to please take their seats because forget that. Loyalty to me means a lot because loyalty begins with we are going to close the doors of the House. If anybody needs "L" and so does love. to step off, now is the time. I would invite everybody else to I also would like to thank my brothers and sisters in blue. The please come on to the floor and take your seats. PA Troopers Association, Dave Kennedy, current president; Joe Dom, you have been a great friend to so many on both sides Kovel, past president. Les Neary from the F.O.P. (Fraternal Order of the aisle. I invite you to the rostrum for your farewell remarks, of Police), State F.O.P.; Joe Regan from the F.O.P.; and Bob sir. Swartzwelder from my F.O.P., city of Pittsburgh Lodge No. 1. 2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1283

A lot of people here do not know, there are a couple of things and his executive director, Art McNulty. They got me my first about me you do not know. You knew I was a police officer, you bill, and that also was with the help of this side of the aisle knew I was chief of police, but when I was a young police officer, because we do not get bills unless we work together and get them there were two young D.A.s in the D.A.'s office, and we young together. So Tony DeLuca, you know, through his trying times, cops knew the D.A.s did not know anything. Well, you know, it you know, I want to make sure that, you know, we all look out comes back to bite you because one of them is sitting right there, for him, these senior members here and senior in time. Keith my good friend, Frank Dermody, who has been friends with me McCall was up here when I came in and he said about Ben for many, many years and I love him like a brother, and the other Franklin being here. And I leaned over to Tony and I said, "You one is sitting up here, Mike Turzai. Mike Turzai worked with the know, you and Joe and Tom Caltagirone have been here for quite D.A.'s office. We had seen each other every morning. We had the a while." I said, "How was it when Ben Franklin was here?" So coffee cart on the third floor, and life seemed simpler then, he knew that was going to be a start of a good, funny, you know, gentlemen, did it not? But now here I am answering to them. career for us and we have had a good one. Back then I said, "Oh, I'm a cop. I can tow their car, whatever." My neighbor in the aisle, Anita Kulik. She is probably one of But now I am answering to both of them. So watch what you do the best additions to our delegation that we have ever had. She is as you are coming up because it will come back to bite you solid. She works hard. She cares about her district, and she keeps 20 years later. So again, they were both great and it was a joy Harry on one end of the aisle and me on the other end of the row working with them then. It is a great honor to see where they have because Harry and I are always sniping at each other. So, Anita, come and to work with them now because they are both good thank you very much for being my neighbor and my friend and men. I hope you have a long career because your people are in good My delegation members, I have – no offense to anyone – but hands with you. Thank you. I have the best delegation in this caucus, in this House. Ed was a music teacher. My priest told me Gainey, I knew him when he was a young lad, and when I say one time just to move my lips in church because my singing was "young," I mean like 10. Okay? Now, I am giving my age away bad. My son when he was 8 said this, you know. And then finally because – but Ed is only 20, so that means that I am only 10 years when a teacher told me to stop singing, he said move my lips, that longer. We have Joe Markosek, . Believe it or not, is what I do. Eddie is an honorary member to our delegation and I caught him out prowling one night in my district in zone six. good people, and I want to thank him for that. Dan was a Representative and we were having some break-ins, would call me at 2:15 in the morning. I swear he you know, and I am out after hours, you know, and I see Dan has a plumbing company because a lot of you may not know I am walking around. I said, "What are you doing?" So I knew he was a master plumber too. That is what I started out as. Pat Harkins coming down a side street, so I said, okay. Well, naturally, I said would call me; literally at 2:15 in the morning he would text me, Dan Frankel, State Representative, but I still checked him out. "Are you up? Can you call me?" And he would tell me his No. Dan, thank you. Thank you for all your support in the past. plumbing problems. So I really believe that if you go to Erie, you Joe Markosek. My leadership team has been great. We have Dan are going to see signs "Harkins Plumbing and Heating." So Deasy, city council member before; ; Austin, thanks, Pat. Thank you for your friendship. our newest member. I was a police officer longer than Austin is The committees I was on were great. Insurance Committee, alive. So that tells you where we are coming from. , wonderful lady. Tony DeLuca. Judiciary, which Harry Readshaw, who texted me – unfortunately, he could not was one of my favorites because that is me. You know, they tell, be here, and I will tell you why – he says that he has something my staff, my wife, my kids, they say, "If you cut my dad, he's to do in his district, a groundbreaking and stuff, which was very going to bleed blue." And I bleed law enforcement. And I want important to his district, and I told him that I was going to tell the to thank Joe Petrarca, minority chair and my friend, and Ron story about when you are going around as a police officer, you Marsico, the majority chair, and you know, I cannot say enough go to a lot of meetings and I had met a lot of these folks. So I was good things about Ron. He has been nothing but fair to all of us. very fortunate when I came here that I knew some of them. And He cares. He cares about the people and we move good bills. Harry would bust my chops at the meetings. He said, "That guy Sometimes they were tough bills, but we move good bills which with the scrambled eggs on his hat, you know, he says he's that." we thought would protect the people of this Commonwealth, and So one day I leaned over to my sergeant and I said, "Find his car I thank you for the honor of working with you, Ron. and tow it." And he said, "Pardon me?" I said, "Find his car and Veterans Affairs, Steve Barrar, , I cannot find tow it" at the meeting. So Harry leaves the building and he is two guys that care more about our veterans and our emergency looking for his car. Well, we had it on the flatbed around the services than them, and it has been an honor working with them corner. So needless to say, Harry did not give me much trouble in doing that because it is all in public safety. If people do not after those meetings, and there is a guy that I can tell you this, feel safe, they are not going to come to this Commonwealth. They once a Marine, always a Marine, like Neal. I would be in a are not going to spend time here. They are not going to spend foxhole with Harry anytime. He is a great man and a good friend. their money here. They are not going to set up business here. So And let me go back to my other mentor, Tony DeLuca. Tony again, thank you. DeLuca, I have known him since I was a boy. We would go into And the policy chairman – I do not see him – but . his father's Italian market and Tony and his brother would cut I learned more on policy traveling this Commonwealth, and meat and stuff and I would look at him cutting this meat and diversity of this Commonwealth, than I have learned anywhere. I was always in awe, and just for the record, he was not that much I have actually been in 67 counties, and I will tell you what, it has older than me. Okay? So I do not want Tony coming back at me. been an amazing, amazing experience. I would never move from But he has been a family friend. Tony, when I was here my first this Commonwealth for any reason. It is the most beautiful place term, he took me from being a Representative to a lawmaker, he in the world. The diversity is unbelievable. You think you have

1284 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11 diversity in your districts; go through the Commonwealth and see about the gentleman that called him yesterday, I get things like, and it builds a respect for everyone because you understand what you know, he says, "Don't vote, you know, for Kavanaugh." they are facing. It is not all about us or me. Okay. Well, it was an easy one. I get them where "Don't bomb Now, I want to thank our hidden heroes, these folks. Dave, Syria." Okay? "Well, okay, I won't bomb Syria. That's no Ray, you know, the people that actually do the things behind the problem." I mean, really. scenes for us, and I do not want to say anything. I am not going Okay. Now, I just want you to know, the staff that I started to mention her name, but every time a thing comes out for a job with here, most of them are the staff that I am leaving with. They – I am looking for a job, guys – so you know, when it comes out, have been that good. Mary Echevarria. She has become a family I file, and Angela – I will mention her name – says, "You're too – please, stand, Mari – she has become a family member of mine. qualified, you're overqualified," and says "no," sends me an Thank you. Her husband, José; her son, Martin; and her daughter, e-mail back. So I keep trying, but she keeps shooting me down. Samantha. I have watched Samantha grow from a little girl to a So, David, thank you. And thank you— For those of you who do young lady, and a beautiful young lady that is. So, Mari, thank not know, David is the head of the committee for the security of you for your loyalty, your friendship, and I call her my sister now. this House, and I have never seen anyone carry the ball and run So she is a definite asset to this caucus and she will be here, and with it like he has. Thank you, David. It means the world to me, she is ready to start crying, I can see, so— Thank you, Mari; I do and I thank you for your friendship. appreciate it. Our A-team over here and the staff all in front of us, our pages, Keontay is sitting here. She is representing Harry Readshaw we would not be anything without these folks, literally; you know because he could not be here because he knew I would talk about that. When you are going down the hall, smile and thank them. him. Keontay and Mari were both in the office with Rob Matzie You know, money is nice, but a thank you goes a long way every and me, as our L.A.s. (legislative assistants). Love you, Keontay. day to keep the morale of our people up. You are absolutely a wonderful person, knowledgeable, and a I have one unsung hero which has been instrumental in true friend, and she is into politics now. So God bless you. She is everything. Think about it. Most of our requests, I believe in my the best. Thank you. area, are PennDOT. Well, Patrick Brady is a supervisor in our Now, we are going to shift back to the west side of the State. caucus for PennDOT, he and his staff. Patrick Brady is just work, Unfortunately, my chief of staff, she left just a few months ago work, work, and he gets it done. He goes over and above. People and it was health issues, Polly Grimpe. She did a wonderful job like this – if you walk down the hall, a lot of people would not for me, and unfortunately, I wish her well and I wish her success even know who Patrick Brady is, but do you know what? He in the future in what she does, and I hope her health improves to made Dom Costa's office and Dom Costa look fantastic, like a a point where she can enjoy life because she deserves it. She has miracle worker. had many health problems throughout – a young lady, too – she Please, when you see the folks that serve us, our security staff, has had many health problems throughout the time she has they are phenomenal. They are with us. They care about us. worked with me, but she always came to work and did her best Thank them. Thank them for that service because this place and I appreciate that. Thank you. would not be what it is if it was not for the people who work here, And then the delegation. My delegation members, they have because, you know, anybody that is a working person, I do not been fantastic, and when I say "delegation," I mean care what their hands are, I do not care how dirty they are, I am Republican/Democrat. I took the title from the Democratic shaking their hand because they deserve our respect and they delegation to just Allegheny County delegation, because we all deserve a smile and a kind word during the day because their lives represent Allegheny County. And when we did things, it was both are hard too. sides and both Houses. Everyone was invited – the Senators from My friends on the other side – across the aisle. I have made so Allegheny County, the Representatives from Allegheny County many. I want to thank you. Karen, your next birthday I will be – because if you are going to get things done, you need to do it thinking of you, but I will not be able to stand up on the floor. together and work together, and I want to thank all the members. I think you will be 23 then. Okay? But I want to thank you for I especially want to thank our delegation executive director, your kindness. I want to thank you for your friendship. Anita Boehm. Anita has, since I took over the delegation, she has Like I said, Bernie – I was sad to leave Bernie, and then Bernie worked with me – for 10 years she has been here, and I thought is leaving. So that is – he is a great man. He has been a good it was best to move the delegation and I talked to the leader. friend. I always get a birthday card from him. I keep shaking the Allegheny County and Philadelphia are kind of unique. Your envelope. There is nothing in it, but I get the birthday card, and delegation executive director, it does not make sense to me for I expect one my next birthday, even if you are gone, Bernie. them to be posted up here when all our stuff is there. Others have Thank you. multiple counties and I can understand that, but here it works I have worked with everyone on both sides of the aisle, I have fantastically. The people that needed to travel up here before no worked with everyone on this side, and if you have the right longer need to travel. We had many meetings, as the leader can legislation, if you have the right attitude, you know, as they say, attest to, in Allegheny County. Anita has been one of the rocks of as Representative Hill said, "Even Daryl. Even Daryl." You the ideas of the things that we have been able to do there and the know, believe it or not, Daryl and I are friends, and that is what success that we have had there, and she has been one of my it is about. It is not about you come on this side of the aisle, we strongest supporters and now, again, one of my best friends; wrestle, we argue, we fight. You do not make it personal. You go another little sister. So again, I want to thank Anita for all her on that side of the aisle and you are friends, and that is what it is work, everything she has done to move this delegation forward about, folks. If you keep it that way, it will be much more civil. and to move the cause of our caucus and our legislation and the We do get things done here. Pennsylvanians should know we do people in our district, just like – I am not sure who said it, but you get work done here and we do like each other. So for anybody wonder when you are leaving, if they say "Is Anita going to be that is out there believing it, like Representative Maher said, okay? Is Polly going to be okay?" you wonder whom they were 2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1285 really voting for when you went out and got the vote. It is our So one of my things was I would go up into the drive-in, there staff, because they do, they make us look good. And I cannot tell were like five or six drive-ins out there and I would chase the you, you know, if you get that feeling as a parent when you go lovers out so they are gone and everybody is safe, and then out with your children or somebody says," Oh, I met your son. I would come down and there was a steep hill coming down and He is such a nice young person," when you hear that about your I could look right at the donut shop. So I am prewriting citations, staff, it gives you that same feeling that you hear about your so if I write somebody a ticket, I do not keep them waiting. And children, when they say your children are such great people, so— law enforcement guys know you are not – your head is not down, And I will be closing here. I guess one of the most – you save up, down, up watching the person and so you do not get hurt. So the best for last, and the best is my family. A lot of people know I am prewriting them and I look and I see two men come around that I was a police officer but did not know my wife was a police the corner in this shopping center and it is about 1:15 in the officer. I met her on the job and we became one. She has been my morning and I am thinking, where are they at, walking on Route strongest supporter. She does not like politics and sometimes it is 30 with no car, in a big shopping center? So I see them look good not to take her places because she is going to say what she around and then the next thing I know they pull ski masks over believes and it is not always good. So we bite our tongues their heads. They go into the donut shop and I see them ordering sometimes, but she is a wonderful lady. She is the mother of my everybody in the back. So I call on the radio, tell the guys that the son. She has endured a lot with me, and when I say "a lot," it is place is being – "Look for the car on the east side of the shopping scary when you go to your door at night and you see the silhouette center, but stay over there." So I roll my patrol car down on the of two police officers and your husband is a police officer, and side with the lights out and I use the emergency brake and I get they are there to tell you that he has been shot. So it is out with the shotgun and I am watching them. So during this time shell-shocking to her, but she has been there with me. She has they fire a shot through the ceiling of the donut shop, and I am been there with me for all the ups and downs, and believe me, telling the guy, "Stay there. Stay there. He fired into the ceiling." you know, I was not the average police officer. I seemed to, you I said, "I'll wait for them to get out because we don't want a know, be pretty active and get into things. They used to say they hostage situation. Once they come your way, I'll let you know wanted me around on rainy days because rainy days were your and I'll prevent them from going back into the donut shop." slow days and they knew I would find something. So I want to Well, they came out, made a sharp left, ran toward the police thank Darlene for being there. I am sorry she could not be here, cars, the awaiting police cars, which they were unaware of. As but my three children are all working, and the two puppies, soon as they hit the corner, they do a stop, do a 180, start back Bennie and Maverick, the Speaker would not let me bring them my way. I rack the shotgun just for the sound effect, because there up here and sit them here, so she is there with them, because we is nothing more frightening than a shotgun being racked and cannot trust them. The house would be gone by the time we aimed at you, and I asked them politely to get down on the ground would get home. And I want to thank her for her continued – not in those words. So they both went down on the ground. support of me and her love. It means the world to me. Now, as our two district attorneys know, you do not transport And the most precious commodity that I have are my three them together because they would get a story together. So we children. My two daughters: one is in San Francisco with her bring two patrol cars around and we are putting one in one and husband, Tom Delaney, Tina Costa Delaney and her husband, one in the other. One looks at the other one and he says to him, Tom; and my daughter, Julie, Julie Costa-Malcolm, and her "I told you not to rob – we don't rob no blankety-blank donut husband, Devin, and my two grandsons, Quinn and Liam. They shop. They're always here." And when we went to court, the live in the Johnstown area, and unfortunately, my daughter's judge enjoyed that so much that he made me repeat it three times. health is not good right now but, you know, she is there. And then So the myth of donuts was out there long before today. my son – the light of my life – he kept me young. He was to a And again, I want to thank you for the honor of allowing me different marriage, but they are brothers and sisters. There is none to serve with you and, most of all, for your friendship, and I thank of this half-brothers, half-sisters; I do not buy that. And he keeps you. God bless all of you. May God keep you, your families safe me on my toes. He is 28 years old and he keeps me in touch with in the future and your friends. reality, you know. Mr. Speaker, I thank you very much for the opportunity. God So again, now I am going to tell you that is – I love them, you bless you. Thank you. know, and I wish them the best – but I am going to tell you one The SPEAKER. Just as he was as a police officer – look, you funny cop story that everybody likes to hear and I think you will did not become chief of police of the city of Pittsburgh without enjoy this one. Do you know cops and donuts? Okay? Well, in being a police officer who was going the extra mile all the time. the old days, believe it or not – when I say "old days," I say '78, We all knew that, Dom. Everybody who was a D.A. knew that. '79, '80 – there were no ampm's, there were no GetGo's where we You were one of the most tenacious and thoughtful and could stop and get a coffee. The only thing open 24 hours a day well-prepared detectives, and guess what? When we come here were donut shops. So that is where you got your coffee, and it and see you as a State legislator, you are the same way. You are was tough for me because I did not like coffee for a long time. so well prepared. You always know the issues you are talking Now I love it. So one night I started my patrol, and we all meet about. You bring worldly life experience to the issues at hand, at a donut shop. I am not going to say what donut shop, because and you are so evenhanded, Chief and Representative. You are I do not want to promote anybody. But so I am on Route 30 and so evenhanded, and you have so many great friends across the I am sure Mike and Frank are, you know, people from there, and Commonwealth and on both sides of the aisle. there was a drive-in theater in the township I worked in. We We may try your suggestion next Monday. What do you would all meet and have coffee and then go to our respective think? I do not know if we can switch it that quick to go municipalities. Republican, Democrat, Republican, Democrat, but maybe we will end it on that note.

1286 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

Representative Dom Costa, thank you so much for your Mrs. BULLOCK called up HR 1138, PN 4181, entitled: service to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and to the folks in your district. A Resolution designating the week of October 7 through 13, 2018, as "Love Your Avenue Week" in Pennsylvania.

(Commemorative gavel was presented.) * * *

The SPEAKER. The Allegheny County delegation, if you will Mr. NELSON called up HR 1148, PN 4201, entitled: join Representative Costa up on the rostrum, please. Any members from the Allegheny County delegation – A Resolution recognizing 2018 as the 100th anniversary year of Representative English, Representative Maher, Representative women in the United States Marine Corps. Mustio – if you would want to come up. Representative Mustio, I think you are being requested. On the question, Representative Maher. Will the House adopt the resolutions?

The Sergeants at Arms will open the doors of the House. The following roll call was recorded:

YEAS–177 LEAVES OF ABSENCE Barbin Dush Longietti Roae The SPEAKER. Representative MICCARELLI has requested Barrar Ellis Mackenzie Roe to be placed on leave. Without objection, that will be granted. Bernstine Emrick Madden Roebuck Bizzarro English Maher Rothman Representative KIRKLAND has requested to be placed on Bloom Evans Mako Rozzi leave. Without objection, that will be granted. Boback Farry Maloney Ryan Representative HAGGERTY has requested to be placed on Boyle Fee Markosek Saccone leave. Without objection, that will be granted. Bradford Fitzgerald Marshall Sainato Representative has requested to be placed Briggs Flynn Marsico Samuelson Brown, R. Frankel Masser Sankey on leave. Without objection, that will be granted. Brown, V. Freeman McCarter Santora Representative Harry LEWIS has requested to be placed on Bullock Fritz McClinton Schemel leave. Without objection, that will be granted. Burns Gainey McGinnis Schlossberg Caltagirone Galloway McNeill Schweyer Carroll Gillen Mehaffie Simmons LEAVE OF ABSENCE CANCELED Causer Gillespie Mentzer Sims Cephas Godshall Metzgar Snyder Charlton Goodman Millard Solomon The SPEAKER. Representative Kathy Watson is on the Christiana Greiner Miller, B. Sonney House floor and should be placed on the master roll. Comitta Grove Milne Staats Conklin Hahn Moul Stephens Cook Hanna Mullery Sturla UNCONTESTED CALENDAR Corbin Harkins Murt Tai Costa, D. Harper Mustio Tallman Costa, P. Harris, A. Neilson Taylor RESOLUTIONS PURSUANT TO RULE 35 Cox Harris, J. Nelson Tobash Culver Heffley Nesbit Toepel Ms. OBERLANDER called up HR 1119, PN 4153, entitled: Cutler Helm O'Neal Toohil Daley Hickernell O'Neill Topper A Resolution designating the week of November 11 through 17, Davidson Hill Oberlander Vazquez 2018, as "Diabetes and Cardiovascular Disease Awareness Week" in Davis, A. Jozwiak Ortitay Vitali Pennsylvania. Dawkins Kampf Owlett Walsh Day Kaufer Pashinski Ward * * * Dean Kauffman Peifer Warner Deasy Keefer Petrarca Warren DeLissio Keller, F. Pickett Watson Mr. KAMPF called up HR 1135, PN 4179, entitled: Delozier Keller, M.K. Pyle Wentling DeLuca Keller, W. Quigley Wheeland A Resolution designating the month of November 2018 as "National Dermody Kim Quinn, C. White Dog Show Month" in Pennsylvania. Diamond Kinsey Quinn, M. Youngblood DiGirolamo Klunk Rabb Zimmerman * * * Donatucci Knowles Rader Dowling Krueger Rapp Turzai, Driscoll Kulik Ravenstahl Speaker Mrs. BULLOCK called up HR 1137, PN 4180, entitled: Dunbar Lawrence Reed

A Resolution designating the week of September 30 through NAYS–0 October 6, 2018, as "Financial Planning Week" in Pennsylvania. NOT VOTING–0 * * *

2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1287

EXCUSED–24 centennial celebrations of our nation held in Philadelphia in the 1870s. Benninghoff Haggerty Kortz O'Brien So it is a tremendous thing, it is a national spotlight for all of Corr Hennessey Lewis Readshaw Cruz Irvin Matzie Reese us, and I am glad that the Sansones are here. Mr. Sansone is the Davis, T. James Metcalfe Saylor vendor chair for the event and he is also on the board of the Everett Kavulich Miccarelli Thomas Philadelphia Kennel Club, and Mrs. Sansone is a member of the Gabler Kirkland Miller, D. Wheatley Kennel Club. So thanks, everyone, for voting for that excellent resolution, and if I can, Mr. Speaker, I would like to turn this over to The majority having voted in the affirmative, the question was Representative Milne. determined in the affirmative and the resolutions were adopted. Thank you very much. The SPEAKER. Yes, sir. The SPEAKER. At this time I am going to ask members to please take their seats. Representative Warren Kampf, you can come up to the STATEMENT BY MR. MILNE rostrum or you can go to the front podium, your choice. He is going to speak on HR 1135, and Representative Kampf has some The SPEAKER. Representative Milne, the floor is yours, sir. guests with him here today. Representative is Mr. MILNE. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. joining him at the podium. I am going to ask everybody to please My colleague from the 157th well summarized the resolution take their seats. We have guests that have traveled far to be here and the purpose of it, and we certainly appreciate your unanimous with Representative Kampf. Please take your seats. Please take support of the resolution. I would just want to quickly add a word your seats. Members, please take your seats. Please. We have of welcome to my constituents, Steve and Cynthia Sansone. I am guests that have traveled far. delighted to be able to welcome them to our chamber here and, Members, in the back, if you need to step off the floor, as I joked with them, to our "office," and they were most I understand, but we do have guests here and I am going to have impressed with the office that we get to work in every day. everybody seated on the floor. If you have to step off the floor, I would just quickly note that I was never surprised to learn of Sergeants at Arms, just have the members step off the floor. For Steve and Cynthia's involvement with the National Dog Show. the conversations in the back, if you could please take them off They are both very accomplished equestrians and have the floor. contributed much to equestrian activities and the equestrian sector, both in Chester County as well as across the State. They also are wonderful patrons and supporters of arts and culture, and STATEMENT BY MR. KAMPF I know they were quite mesmerized when they saw this beautiful chamber that we were in and we took a look around at the The SPEAKER. Representative Kampf, the floor is yours, sir. wonderful decor here. I know that from their art appreciation Please introduce your guests as part of your remarks. Thank perspective, it really made quite an impression on them. They you. have done much to contribute to open space and good Mr. KAMPF. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. development in our area, which is very, very important and, Colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, this is a great occasion. It actually, part of what the equestrian community does in Chester is sort of a fun and, perhaps, unknown-to-some-of-you fact about County is raise proceeds to help good, open-space preservation our great State, and that is that between noon and 2 o'clock every efforts in Chester County. So I am delighted to be able to Thanksgiving Day on NBC, a Pennsylvania institution, the welcome them here to the Capitol. National Dog Show, is televised. I do not know if you remember In closing, I would just note one additional title of J. Peterman, from Seinfield, Elaine's boss. Mr. O'Hurley is his Mr. Sansone is that he has the title of chairman. He is chairman given name. He is one of the two announcers and has been for of the Willistown Township Republican Party, which also 17 years. The National Dog Show is put on in mid-November happens to be my home township. So besides being a constituent, every year in Oaks, Pennsylvania, which happens to be in the he and I are both township residents of good old Willistown, and 157th District, so that is why this resolution is in my name. in that capacity as well, I am certainly delighted to be able to We do have Representative Milne's constituents, two special continue to work with both of them. guests here, Steve and Cynthia Sansone. If you would both stand So thank you for the warm welcome that you have extended for us. Steve and Cynthia are both members of the Philadelphia to my constituents. Kennel Club, which is the entity that puts on this awesome Thank you, Mr. Speaker. National Dog Show. Something like 15,000 people visit it in The SPEAKER. Thank you, Representative Milne. those 2 days. I believe there are over 2,000 dogs that are in the And Representative Kampf. show, and it is a benched show, which means that the owners Mr. KAMPF. Mr. Speaker, I did indicate to our guests I would have to remain on-site in Oaks with their dogs so that spectators mention five other guests who could not make it today. They are can come and see them throughout the day, whether they are the Sansones' five giant schnauzers: Baccus, Mimi, Louie, Prada, performing or not. and Bella. Baccus, Mimi, Louie, Prada, and Bella. Twenty-five million people watch this show between Macy's Thank you very much, members. and football on Thanksgiving Day. It is really just a wonderful The SPEAKER. Thank you. institution of our State, and it dates back in various forms, I think To Steve Sansone and his wife, Cynthia Macaleer Sansone, something like 130 years. The Kennel Club of Philadelphia, the Kennel Club of Philadelphia is such an outstanding institution I believe, was putting on shows as far back as one of the in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. We are so honored to

1288 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11 have you here today. Thank you very, very much, and we are withdrawn, and I am going to call out these: 9500— I will call going to have you come up and take some photos with us, if that up Representative Tobash's amendment, 9860, and is okay. Thank you. Representative Tobash, you can tell me which amendments are being withdrawn, given that your amendment is being offered. LEAVE OF ABSENCE CANCELED On the question recurring, The SPEAKER. Representative Irvin is on the House floor Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration? and should be placed on the master roll. Mr. TOBASH offered the following amendment No. A09860: LEAVE OF ABSENCE Amend Bill, page 12, lines 18 through 22, by striking out The SPEAKER. Representative McNEILL has requested to be "telemedicine if the health insurer" in line 18, all of lines 19 through 21 placed on leave. Without objection, that will be granted. and "shall apply to a telemedicine encounter." in line 22 and inserting both in-person and telemedicine services in accordance CALENDAR with the terms and conditions of the network participation agreement between the insurer and the participating provider. Amend Bill, page 12, lines 23 and 24, by striking out "OR BILLS ON SECOND CONSIDERATION PROPRIETARY TELEMEDICINE TECHNOLOGY OR" and inserting The House proceeded to second consideration of HB 2557, telemedicine platform or telemedicine PN 4196, entitled: On the question, An act establishing intergovernmental cooperation authorities for Will the House agree to the amendment? certain cities of the third class; providing for powers and duties; and making an appropriation. The SPEAKER. On the amendment, Representative Tobash. On the question, Mr. TOBASH. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration? I am offering amendment 9860 in an effort to make sure that we can continue to have cost containment and quality control, as The SPEAKER. HB 2557, PN 4196, creates an we start to roll out additional opportunities for advanced health intergovernmental cooperation authority for certain cities of the care in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. It is my third class; providing for powers and duties. My understanding is understanding that it is an agreed-to amendment, and I would ask it maintains certain tax revenues that had been enabled under Act my colleagues to vote in the affirmative. 47 and there is an expiration for that and also has a prohibition Thank you, Mr. Speaker. with respect to a commuter tax. I think I am summarizing that The SPEAKER. Yes. correctly. Representative Mark Mustio, on the amendment. There were four amendments filed by Representative Todd Mr. MUSTIO. Yes, Mr. Speaker, the maker of the amendment Stephens, and my understanding is all four of those have been is correct. This is an agreed-to amendment. withdrawn. Is that accurate, Representative Stephens? So Representative Todd Stephens' four amendments have On the question recurring, been withdrawn. I do not see any other amendments. I do not see Will the House agree to the amendment? any other amendments. The following roll call was recorded: On the question recurring, Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration? YEAS–177 Bill was agreed to. Barbin Dush Lawrence Roae Barrar Ellis Longietti Roe * * * Bernstine Emrick Mackenzie Roebuck Bizzarro English Madden Rothman The House proceeded to second consideration of SB 780, Bloom Evans Maher Rozzi Boback Farry Mako Ryan PN 1997, entitled: Boyle Fee Maloney Saccone Bradford Fitzgerald Markosek Sainato An Act relating to telemedicine; authorizing the regulation of Briggs Flynn Marshall Samuelson telemedicine by professional licensing boards; and providing for Brown, R. Frankel Marsico Sankey insurance coverage of telemedicine. Brown, V. Freeman Masser Santora Bullock Fritz McCarter Schemel On the question, Burns Gainey McClinton Schlossberg Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration? Caltagirone Galloway McGinnis Schweyer Carroll Gillen Mehaffie Simmons Causer Gillespie Mentzer Sims The SPEAKER. Now, I understand certain amendments are Cephas Godshall Metzgar Snyder being withdrawn – certain, not all – certain members, and this Charlton Goodman Millard Solomon includes – and then we are going to be calling up 9860, Christiana Greiner Miller, B. Sonney Comitta Grove Milne Staats Representative Tobash's amendment. Are any amendments being Conklin Hahn Moul Stephens 2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1289

Cook Hanna Mullery Sturla Ms. McCLINTON. Mr. Speaker, they are not withdrawn. Corbin Harkins Murt Tai The SPEAKER. Okay. I will be calling on you shortly. I am Costa, D. Harper Mustio Tallman Costa, P. Harris, A. Neilson Taylor just trying to see what is left. Cox Harris, J. Nelson Tobash Representative Maher, not withdrawn. Culver Heffley Nesbit Toepel Representative Christiana's, I know, are not withdrawn. Cutler Helm O'Neal Toohil Representative Sims has 9508. Withdrawn? That is Daley Hickernell O'Neill Topper Davidson Hill Oberlander Vazquez withdrawn; 9508 is withdrawn. Davis, A. Irvin Ortitay Vitali Representative Mustio's amendments, 9643 and 9644; 9643 Dawkins Jozwiak Owlett Walsh and 9644? Okay. Day Kampf Pashinski Ward Then I know Representative Rapp has amendment 9481. Dean Kaufer Peifer Warner Deasy Kauffman Petrarca Warren So what we have, the Tobash amendment, 9860 has been DeLissio Keefer Pickett Watson voted in. Delozier Keller, F. Pyle Wentling The amendments remaining are 9500, Representative DeLuca Keller, M.K. Quigley Wheeland Christiana; Representative Maher's 9478; Representative Dermody Keller, W. Quinn, C. White Diamond Kim Quinn, M. Youngblood McClinton's 9498; Representative McClinton's 9499; DiGirolamo Kinsey Rabb Zimmerman Representative McClinton's 9502; Representative Rapp's 9481; Donatucci Klunk Rader Representative Christiana's 9509; Representative Mustio's 9643; Dowling Knowles Rapp Turzai, and Representative Mustio's 9644. Driscoll Krueger Ravenstahl Speaker Dunbar Kulik Reed BILL PASSED OVER TEMPORARILY NAYS–0 The SPEAKER. We are going to go over SB 780 at this time. NOT VOTING–0 At this time we are going to ask the Appropriations Committee EXCUSED–24 to make an announcement, the vice chair.

Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien Representative George Dunbar, for a committee Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw announcement. Cruz James McNeill Reese The Appropriations Committee has to meet on third Davis, T. Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor consideration bills. Once they vote them out, we are going to Everett Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas Gabler Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley come back and vote them on the floor. So we are going to be at ease at this time, after this announcement.

The majority having voted in the affirmative, the question was APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE MEETING determined in the affirmative and the amendment was agreed to. The SPEAKER. Representative Dunbar. On the question, Mr. DUNBAR. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration as There will be an immediate meeting of the Appropriations amended? Committee in the majority caucus room. That is Appropriations in the majority caucus room. Thank you. The SPEAKER. Representative Tobash, if I might, you have The SPEAKER. So members of the Appropriations seven other amendments. Are you withdrawing those? Committee should proceed directly to the majority caucus room. Mr. TOBASH. Yes, Mr. Speaker. Now that we have voted in There are a number of third consideration bills that need to be the affirmative on 9860, I would like to withdraw all the moved, and then we will be at ease until the Appropriations additional amendments. Thank you. Committee comes back. The SPEAKER. So amendment 9553 is withdrawn, While the Appropriations Committee is meeting, we are going amendment 9554 is withdrawn, amendment 9469 is withdrawn, to have members who want to speak on resolutions called up at amendment 9479 is withdrawn, amendment 9664 is withdrawn, this time. amendment 9665 is withdrawn, amendment 9666 is withdrawn. So we are back in order. Let me just cover a few other amendments here. Representative Donatucci, are you still offering your STATEMENT BY MR. NELSON amendments? Representative Donatucci? They are all waived off? Okay. So amendment 9505 is withdrawn, amendment 9506 The SPEAKER. Representative Eric Nelson is going to speak is withdrawn, amendment 9507 is withdrawn. on HR 1148, and Representative Oberlander will be called up to Representative Jordan Harris. Sir, you have three speak on HR 1119. amendments: 9495, 9496, 9497. All withdrawn, sir? Those three Mr. NELSON. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. amendments are withdrawn. Today I rise to thank my colleagues for their support in Representative McClinton. Representative McClinton has recognizing 2018 as the 100-year anniversary of women serving amendments 9498, 9499, and 9502. Are they all withdrawn? If in the United States Marine Corps. Be it the mystery of Lucy they are not, that is okay. I just need to know what is left. None Brewer, a possible Marine Corps sniper who may have served on of them are withdrawn? the U.S. Constitution in the 1800s, or Opha May Johnson, the Representative McClinton. first official woman who joined our corps in 1918 for service 1290 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11 during World War I, women Marines have served this country Pennsylvanians have prediabetes, and Type 2 diabetes is the most with bravery and distinction, determined to do their part to protect common type of diabetes. They also have a two to four times our freedoms. Initially they were called WMs, Women Marines. greater risk of developing cardiovascular disease. Whereas, Today they are jarheads just like the rest of us. I say that, cardiovascular disease accounts for 68 percent of deaths in Mr. Speaker, not because it is harder for women to complete the individuals with Type 2 diabetes. Findings from a recent study same tasks as all other Marines, but because they had to fight for revealed that 52 percent of adults living with Type 2 do not the same right to do it, and once they were given that opportunity, realize they are at additional risk of getting cardiovascular I am confident there were occasions when they were met with disease. So this resolution seeks to help promote awareness, opposition because of their gender. education, and action to let people know about the link in these But, Mr. Speaker, bias changes through sacrifice and the two diseases and the increase in the rate of death. blood stripe we wear on our uniforms shares the same ultimate I wish to thank all of my colleagues for their unanimous sacrifice for flag and country. Sgt. Jeannette Winters was the first support of this important resolution. woman Marine killed in a hostile fire zone, and Maj. Megan Thank you, Mr. Speaker. McClung was the first female Marine officer to lose her life in the Al Anbar Province of Iraq. The fact is, Mr. Speaker, their STATEMENT BY MRS. WATSON commitment to our Marine Corps is equally great, and they have fought hard to be a proud part of it. Mr. Speaker, a Marine's job The SPEAKER. Representative Kathy Watson, on unanimous is to take: we take ground, we take lives, and we take fire in order consent. to accomplish our mission. Today our sister Marines are doing Mrs. WATSON. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. that all over the globe. I just want to thank you, the members of the House, for a vote During our Civil War women dressed as men in order to fight. that you made a little while ago. It was on a bill that I had Today we recognize female Marines have the equal ability to kill sponsored, the Kinship Navigator Program, that would give or die for our great nation. Thankfully, over time, more and more grandparents one place to go to get the appropriate information people realize women in the military possess equal depth of skills for them because they are taking care of their grandchildren, and knowledge to rage ferocious war on our enemies and provide perhaps as a result of their children's inability to care for them selfless compassion for the lives they have been sent to protect. due to the opioid crisis, alcoholism, whatever the issue might be. Mr. Speaker, I have had the pleasure to serve overseas with At the same time, the Federal government was catching on that women Marines in multiple countries and it has brought me great children of those who are afflicted are the real victims in this pride. When I think of a hard-core, tough, smart woman Marine, crisis and grandparents really are the saviors to come and keep I immediately think of Gunnery Sergeant Lingle. Ours was one that family together. So they have put forth money, and of the first American units to occupy ground in Albania during remember we said we would not do a new program unless we the Kosovo Conflict a number of years back. In a country where could try to figure out a way to pay for it. Thank you, ladies and women were like possessions, where they could not even walk gentlemen, the Department of Human Services applied to the alone without a man being beside them, Gunnery Sergeant Lingle Federal government and received a grant for almost $500,000 to ripped and roared our unit into shape and dispensed us as get that Kinship Navigator Program started. Very, very necessary. Despite the initial stammer and perplexity of our important. Albanian Imperial Police soldiers, the mirrors who were assigned Of course, we need the Senate to pass the bill next week, so if to us, they, too, quickly realized that Gunny Lingle was no one to you have got a Senator that is a good friend of yours, you might mess with and she earned their respect. I am proud to have served tell him, please make sure they do it, because we now have the with great women Marines like Lingle, Miller, Fortune, Flora, money for that program to start. Mr. Speaker, I know that is and many others, and I am confident our country and the United unusual in Harrisburg, but in fact, we actually found the funding States Marine Corps shall continue to be a premier fighting force to start the program that will help our grandparents across with men and women equally protecting our flag. Pennsylvania who save us billions of dollars by taking over the In conclusion, Mr. Speaker, I offer my sincere thanks and responsibility of raising their grandchildren. appreciation for the women Marines who have served over these Thank you for the opportunity to speak, Mr. Speaker. past 100 years to protect this country, its people and its ideals. The SPEAKER. Thank you, Representative Watson. That is no small feat. I also thank my colleagues in the House for recognizing the service of women in our Marine Corps. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. BILLS REREPORTED FROM COMMITTEE HB 270, PN 4210 By Rep. DUNBAR STATEMENT BY MS. OBERLANDER An Act amending the act of August 26, 1971 (P.L.351, No.91), The SPEAKER. Representative , on known as the State Lottery Law, in pharmaceutical assistance for the elderly, further providing for definitions, providing for medication HR 1119. synchronization, further providing for the Pharmaceutical Assistance Ms. OBERLANDER. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Contract for the Elderly Needs Enhancement Tier and for board, I rise on behalf of HR 1119, and this resolution designates the providing for medication therapy management and further providing for week of November 11 through November 17 as "Diabetes and coordination of benefits.

Cardiovascular Disease Awareness Week" in Pennsylvania. I rise APPROPRIATIONS. because this is an important issue where 1.4 million

Pennsylvanians have diabetes. An additional 3.5 million

2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1291

HB 2638, PN 4211 By Rep. DUNBAR (Bill analysis was read.)

An Act amending the act of December 8, 2004 (P.L.1801, No.238), The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three known as the Transit Revitalization Investment District Act, in general provisions, further providing for declaration of policy and for different days and agreed to and is now on final passage. definitions; adding provisions relating to military installation The question is, shall the bill pass finally? remediation and water, sewer and storm water systems remediation Agreeable to the provisions of the Constitution, the yeas and projects; and establishing the Remediation Fund. nays will now be taken.

APPROPRIATIONS. The following roll call was recorded:

SB 748, PN 2095 By Rep. DUNBAR YEAS–177 An Act providing for public safety facilities. Barbin Dush Lawrence Roae Barrar Ellis Longietti Roe APPROPRIATIONS. Bernstine Emrick Mackenzie Roebuck Bizzarro English Madden Rothman SB 888, PN 1998 By Rep. DUNBAR Bloom Evans Maher Rozzi Boback Farry Mako Ryan An Act amending Title 75 (Vehicles) of the Pennsylvania Boyle Fee Maloney Saccone Consolidated Statutes, in rules of the road in general, further providing Bradford Fitzgerald Markosek Sainato for additional parking regulations. Briggs Flynn Marshall Samuelson Brown, R. Frankel Marsico Sankey APPROPRIATIONS. Brown, V. Freeman Masser Santora Bullock Fritz McCarter Schemel Burns Gainey McClinton Schlossberg SB 945, PN 1718 By Rep. DUNBAR Caltagirone Galloway McGinnis Schweyer Carroll Gillen Mehaffie Simmons An Act amending Title 75 (Vehicles) of the Pennsylvania Causer Gillespie Mentzer Sims Consolidated Statutes, in registration of vehicles, further providing for Cephas Godshall Metzgar Snyder contributions to Veterans' Trust Fund. Charlton Goodman Millard Solomon Christiana Greiner Miller, B. Sonney APPROPRIATIONS. Comitta Grove Milne Staats Conklin Hahn Moul Stephens Cook Hanna Mullery Sturla SB 1078, PN 1560 By Rep. DUNBAR Corbin Harkins Murt Tai Costa, D. Harper Mustio Tallman An Act amending Title 65 (Public Officers) of the Pennsylvania Costa, P. Harris, A. Neilson Taylor Consolidated Statutes, in open meetings, further providing for executive Cox Harris, J. Nelson Tobash sessions. Culver Heffley Nesbit Toepel Cutler Helm O'Neal Toohil APPROPRIATIONS. Daley Hickernell O'Neill Topper Davidson Hill Oberlander Vazquez Davis, A. Irvin Ortitay Vitali The SPEAKER. Members, please take your seats. Dawkins Jozwiak Owlett Walsh Day Kampf Pashinski Ward Dean Kaufer Peifer Warner SUPPLEMENTAL CALENDAR A Deasy Kauffman Petrarca Warren DeLissio Keefer Pickett Watson BILLS ON THIRD CONSIDERATION Delozier Keller, F. Pyle Wentling DeLuca Keller, M.K. Quigley Wheeland Dermody Keller, W. Quinn, C. White BILL PASSED OVER TEMPORARILY Diamond Kim Quinn, M. Youngblood DiGirolamo Kinsey Rabb Zimmerman The SPEAKER. We are going to need a motion to proceed on Donatucci Klunk Rader HB 270 in just a moment, if anybody wants to make it, but right Dowling Knowles Rapp Turzai, Driscoll Krueger Ravenstahl Speaker now we are going to go to the bills that are timely. The bill will Dunbar Kulik Reed be passed over temporarily. NAYS–0 * * * NOT VOTING–0 The House proceeded to third consideration of SB 1078, PN 1560, entitled: EXCUSED–24

An Act amending Title 65 (Public Officers) of the Pennsylvania Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien Consolidated Statutes, in open meetings, further providing for executive Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw sessions. Cruz James McNeill Reese Davis, T. Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor Everett Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas On the question, Gabler Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? Bill was agreed to.

1292 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

The majority required by the Constitution having voted in the The following roll call was recorded: affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and the bill passed finally. YEAS–177 Ordered, That the clerk return the same to the Senate with the information that the House has passed the same without Barbin Dush Lawrence Roae Barrar Ellis Longietti Roe amendment. Bernstine Emrick Mackenzie Roebuck Bizzarro English Madden Rothman * * * Bloom Evans Maher Rozzi Boback Farry Mako Ryan Boyle Fee Maloney Saccone The House proceeded to third consideration of SB 888, Bradford Fitzgerald Markosek Sainato PN 1998, entitled: Briggs Flynn Marshall Samuelson Brown, R. Frankel Marsico Sankey An Act amending Title 75 (Vehicles) of the Pennsylvania Brown, V. Freeman Masser Santora Consolidated Statutes, in rules of the road in general, further providing Bullock Fritz McCarter Schemel for additional parking regulations. Burns Gainey McClinton Schlossberg Caltagirone Galloway McGinnis Schweyer On the question, Carroll Gillen Mehaffie Simmons Causer Gillespie Mentzer Sims Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? Cephas Godshall Metzgar Snyder Bill was agreed to. Charlton Goodman Millard Solomon Christiana Greiner Miller, B. Sonney (Bill analysis was read.) Comitta Grove Milne Staats Conklin Hahn Moul Stephens Cook Hanna Mullery Sturla The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three Corbin Harkins Murt Tai different days and agreed to and is now on final passage. Costa, D. Harper Mustio Tallman The question is, shall the bill pass finally? Costa, P. Harris, A. Neilson Taylor Cox Harris, J. Nelson Tobash Agreeable to the provisions of the Constitution, the yeas and Culver Heffley Nesbit Toepel nays will now be taken. Cutler Helm O'Neal Toohil Daley Hickernell O'Neill Topper (Members proceeded to vote.) Davidson Hill Oberlander Vazquez Davis, A. Irvin Ortitay Vitali Dawkins Jozwiak Owlett Walsh VOTE STRICKEN Day Kampf Pashinski Ward Dean Kaufer Peifer Warner The SPEAKER. Representative Dush, for what— We will Deasy Kauffman Petrarca Warren DeLissio Keefer Pickett Watson strike the vote. Delozier Keller, F. Pyle Wentling Representative Dush, for what purpose do you rise? DeLuca Keller, M.K. Quigley Wheeland Strike the vote. Dermody Keller, W. Quinn, C. White Diamond Kim Quinn, M. Youngblood DiGirolamo Kinsey Rabb Zimmerman Go ahead, Representative Dush. Go ahead. Donatucci Klunk Rader For what purpose do you rise, sir? Dowling Knowles Rapp Turzai, Mr. DUSH. Mr. Speaker, I am just noting that on our calendar Driscoll Krueger Ravenstahl Speaker it says 4:02 is the time limit for this and we would have to have a Dunbar Kulik Reed motion. NAYS–0 The SPEAKER. The Parliamentarian and the Mace both say that is not true for SB 888. NOT VOTING–0 Mr. DUSH. That is fine. It is just that it is different on the clock. That is the only reason I raise it. On our calendar, the EXCUSED–24 electronic calendar says 4:02. The SPEAKER. Both the Parliamentarian and the Mace say Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw that that is not the case, but we will check. Let me double-check. Cruz James McNeill Reese Lori Hoffman, will you double-check for that, and Jordan. Davis, T. Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor No, there was no amendment. The bill was not amended. Everett Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas Yes, Representative Dush, the bill was not amended. Gabler Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Sir, whatever change you are seeing is from September 21. That was from September 21. That is not an amendment that occurred yesterday. That was on September 21. The majority required by the Constitution having voted in the Okay. No problem. affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and the bill passed finally. On the question recurring, Ordered, That the clerk return the same to the Senate with the Shall the bill pass finally? information that the House has passed the same with amendment in which the concurrence of the Senate is requested.

* * *

2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1293

The House proceeded to third consideration of SB 945, EXCUSED–24 PN 1718, entitled: Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien An Act amending Title 75 (Vehicles) of the Pennsylvania Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw Consolidated Statutes, in registration of vehicles, further providing for Cruz James McNeill Reese contributions to Veterans' Trust Fund. Davis, T. Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor Everett Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas Gabler Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley On the question, Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? Bill was agreed to. The majority required by the Constitution having voted in the affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and (Bill analysis was read.) the bill passed finally. Ordered, That the clerk return the same to the Senate with the The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three information that the House has passed the same without different days and agreed to and is now on final passage. amendment. The question is, shall the bill pass finally? Agreeable to the provisions of the Constitution, the yeas and The SPEAKER. We have three bills that we cannot vote on nays will now be taken. without a motion to proceed: HB 270, PN 4210; HB 2638, PN 4211; and SB 748, PN 2095. Respectively, it would be The following roll call was recorded: 12:07 p.m., 12:48 p.m., and 12:49 p.m.

YEAS–177 MOTION TO PROCEED TO CONSIDERATION Barbin Dush Lawrence Roae UNDER RULE 24 Barrar Ellis Longietti Roe Bernstine Emrick Mackenzie Roebuck Bizzarro English Madden Rothman The SPEAKER. The Chair calls upon the majority leader with Bloom Evans Maher Rozzi respect to a motion with respect to those bills: HB 270, HB 2638, Boback Farry Mako Ryan and SB 748. Boyle Fee Maloney Saccone You may proceed. Bradford Fitzgerald Markosek Sainato Briggs Flynn Marshall Samuelson Mr. REED. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Brown, R. Frankel Marsico Sankey I make a motion to proceed to the immediate consideration of Brown, V. Freeman Masser Santora HB 270, HB 2638, and SB 748. Bullock Fritz McCarter Schemel Burns Gainey McClinton Schlossberg Caltagirone Galloway McGinnis Schweyer On the question, Carroll Gillen Mehaffie Simmons Will the House agree to the motion? Causer Gillespie Mentzer Sims Cephas Godshall Metzgar Snyder The SPEAKER. Representative Dermody, minority leader, on Charlton Goodman Millard Solomon Christiana Greiner Miller, B. Sonney the motion. Comitta Grove Milne Staats Mr. DERMODY. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Conklin Hahn Moul Stephens I would also urge the members to support the motion to Cook Hanna Mullery Sturla proceed. Corbin Harkins Murt Tai Costa, D. Harper Mustio Tallman Costa, P. Harris, A. Neilson Taylor On the question recurring, Cox Harris, J. Nelson Tobash Will the House agree to the motion? Culver Heffley Nesbit Toepel Cutler Helm O'Neal Toohil Daley Hickernell O'Neill Topper The following roll call was recorded: Davidson Hill Oberlander Vazquez Davis, A. Irvin Ortitay Vitali YEAS–165 Dawkins Jozwiak Owlett Walsh Day Kampf Pashinski Ward Barbin Dush Krueger Roe Dean Kaufer Peifer Warner Barrar Ellis Kulik Roebuck Deasy Kauffman Petrarca Warren Bernstine Emrick Lawrence Rothman DeLissio Keefer Pickett Watson Bizzarro English Longietti Rozzi Delozier Keller, F. Pyle Wentling Bloom Evans Mackenzie Ryan DeLuca Keller, M.K. Quigley Wheeland Boback Farry Madden Saccone Dermody Keller, W. Quinn, C. White Boyle Fee Maher Sainato Diamond Kim Quinn, M. Youngblood Briggs Fitzgerald Mako Sankey DiGirolamo Kinsey Rabb Zimmerman Brown, R. Flynn Maloney Santora Donatucci Klunk Rader Brown, V. Frankel Markosek Schemel Dowling Knowles Rapp Turzai, Bullock Freeman Marshall Schlossberg Driscoll Krueger Ravenstahl Speaker Burns Fritz Marsico Schweyer Dunbar Kulik Reed Caltagirone Gainey Masser Simmons Carroll Galloway McClinton Sims NAYS–0 Causer Gillespie McGinnis Snyder Cephas Godshall Mehaffie Solomon NOT VOTING–0 Charlton Goodman Mentzer Sonney 1294 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

Christiana Greiner Millard Staats The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three Comitta Grove Moul Stephens different days and agreed to and is now on final passage. Conklin Hahn Murt Sturla Cook Hanna Mustio Tai The question is, shall the bill pass finally? Corbin Harkins Neilson Taylor Costa, D. Harper Nelson Tobash Representative Markosek, on the bill. Costa, P. Harris, A. Nesbit Toepel Mr. MARKOSEK. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Cox Harris, J. O'Neal Toohil Culver Heffley O'Neill Topper Mr. Speaker, I rise today and I guess this is more under the Cutler Helm Oberlander Vazquez auspices of the fact that I am the Appropriations chairman and Daley Hickernell Ortitay Vitali I thought it my duty to say something about this. This bill raises Davis, A. Hill Owlett Walsh the income level for the PACE (Pharmaceutical Assistance Dawkins Irvin Pashinski Ward Day Jozwiak Peifer Warner Contract for the Elderly) and PACENET (Pharmaceutical Deasy Kampf Petrarca Warren Assistance Contract for the Elderly Needs Enhancement Tier) DeLissio Kaufer Pickett Watson program, which is a very good thing. I am going to vote for it. It Delozier Kauffman Pyle Wentling is something we all know and many of our constituents have DeLuca Keefer Quigley Wheeland Dermody Keller, F. Quinn, C. White used. It is very beneficial. But I would not be doing my job if Diamond Keller, M.K. Quinn, M. Youngblood I did not at least remind members – and this is more for future DiGirolamo Keller, W. Rader Zimmerman use, I guess – that there is a cost, there is a cost to adding these Donatucci Kim Rapp kinds of benefits to this program. And the lottery is very precious, Dowling Kinsey Ravenstahl Turzai, Driscoll Klunk Reed Speaker as we all know. The programs that the lottery funds are programs Dunbar Knowles Roae that I do not think anybody in this chamber would ever want to cut. So we would either have to – if the lottery is not healthy and NAYS–12 if we spend more than what we bring in, there could come a day for all of you to be faced with either cutting some of these Bradford Gillen Miller, B. Rabb Davidson McCarter Milne Samuelson programs or taking the money out of the General Fund, which Dean Metzgar Mullery Tallman puts pressure, more pressure on our always highly pressured General Fund negotiations. NOT VOTING–0 So I am going to vote for this. I would ask all of you to vote for it. It is something good. It is something our constituents EXCUSED–24 actually use and many of them need it and depend on it, but there

Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien is a cost to everything we do here and this is a good example of Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw that. Thank you. Cruz James McNeill Reese The SPEAKER. Representative , on the bill, Davis, T. Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor please. Everett Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas Gabler Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Mr. SAMUELSON. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in enthusiastic support for this legislation, which I have A majority of the members required by the rules having voted introduced with Representative of Bucks County, in the affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and I want to commend Representative Farry for his efforts. We and the motion was agreed to. have been working on this for 3 years, and when you think about it, the increase in the PACENET program that is included in this The SPEAKER. We are going to now take up those particular bill, that represents the first increase we have had in this program, bills. the first increase in the income limits in 15 years. You may remember the last time these income limits went up was January 2004, and the cost of living all across Pennsylvania for our senior BILL ON THIRD CONSIDERATION citizens has gone up significantly since January 2004. Representative Farry and I tried a more robust increase. We got The House proceeded to third consideration of HB 270, that bill passed the House last session, but it stalled over in the PN 4210, entitled: Senate. An Act amending the act of August 26, 1971 (P.L.351, No.91), Today, at this time, we are proposing a $4,000 increase, so the known as the State Lottery Law, in pharmaceutical assistance for the income limit for a single person would go up from $23,500 to elderly, further providing for definitions, providing for medication $27,500, and for a married couple it would go up from synchronization, further providing for the Pharmaceutical Assistance Contract for the Elderly Needs Enhancement Tier and for board, $31,500 to $35,500. I believe we have to revisit this issue next providing for medication therapy management and further providing for year and raise the income limits even further, but in working with coordination of benefits. the Senate and working with the administration, we believe this $4,000 increase is what we can achieve at this time. On the question, There is a cost. I know the previous speaker talked about the Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? cost. There is a cost to our senior citizens if we do not act, and as Bill was agreed to. the costs of prescriptions rise and people are looking for ways to pay for their prescriptions, it is long overdue for us to address this (Bill analysis was read.) issue and to raise the income limits for our senior citizens.

2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1295

If you look at the fiscal analysis of this bill, there are an Delozier Keller, F. Pyle Watson estimated 14,400 senior citizens who will now be eligible for the DeLuca Keller, M.K. Quigley Wentling Dermody Keller, W. Quinn, C. Wheeland PACENET program thanks to the increase that is included in this Diamond Kim Quinn, M. White bill. So I would like to thank a unanimous vote in our House DiGirolamo Kinsey Rabb Youngblood Aging Committee, I would like to thank each one of Donatucci Klunk Rader Zimmerman 43 cosponsors, and I would like to thank, once again, Dowling Knowles Rapp Driscoll Krueger Ravenstahl Turzai, Representative Farry for his efforts. Let us approve this increase Dunbar Kulik Reed Speaker today, let us send it to the Senate, and then let us revisit this next Dush Lawrence year to raise the income limit even further. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. NAYS–0 The SPEAKER. Representative Farry, do you wish to— NOT VOTING–0

On the question recurring, EXCUSED–25 Shall the bill pass finally? The SPEAKER. Agreeable to the provisions of the Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien Constitution, the yeas and nays will now be taken. Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw Cruz James McNeill Reese Davidson Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor (Members proceeded to vote.) Davis, T. Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas Everett Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Gabler LEAVE OF ABSENCE

The SPEAKER. Representative DAVIDSON has requested to The majority required by the Constitution having voted in the be placed on leave. Without objection, that will be granted. affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and the bill passed finally. CONSIDERATION OF HB 270 CONTINUED Ordered, That the clerk present the same to the Senate for concurrence. On the question recurring, Shall the bill pass finally? LEAVE OF ABSENCE The following roll call was recorded: The SPEAKER. Representative KRUEGER-BRANEKY has

requested to be placed on leave. Without objection, that will be YEAS–176 granted. Barbin Ellis Longietti Roae Barrar Emrick Mackenzie Roe Bernstine English Madden Roebuck BILLS ON THIRD CONSIDERATION Bizzarro Evans Maher Rothman Bloom Farry Mako Rozzi The House proceeded to third consideration of SB 748, Boback Fee Maloney Ryan PN 2095, entitled: Boyle Fitzgerald Markosek Saccone Bradford Flynn Marshall Sainato An Act providing for public safety facilities. Briggs Frankel Marsico Samuelson Brown, R. Freeman Masser Sankey Brown, V. Fritz McCarter Santora On the question, Bullock Gainey McClinton Schemel Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? Burns Galloway McGinnis Schlossberg Bill was agreed to. Caltagirone Gillen Mehaffie Schweyer Carroll Gillespie Mentzer Simmons Causer Godshall Metzgar Sims (Bill analysis was read.) Cephas Goodman Millard Snyder Charlton Greiner Miller, B. Solomon The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three Christiana Grove Milne Sonney different days and agreed to and is now on final passage. Comitta Hahn Moul Staats Conklin Hanna Mullery Stephens The question is, shall the bill pass finally? Cook Harkins Murt Sturla Agreeable to the provisions of the Constitution, the yeas and Corbin Harper Mustio Tai nays will now be taken. Costa, D. Harris, A. Neilson Tallman Costa, P. Harris, J. Nelson Taylor Cox Heffley Nesbit Tobash The following roll call was recorded: Culver Helm O'Neal Toepel Cutler Hickernell O'Neill Toohil YEAS–175 Daley Hill Oberlander Topper Davis, A. Irvin Ortitay Vazquez Barbin Ellis Longietti Roae Dawkins Jozwiak Owlett Vitali Barrar Emrick Mackenzie Roe Day Kampf Pashinski Walsh Bernstine English Madden Roebuck Dean Kaufer Peifer Ward Bizzarro Evans Maher Rothman Deasy Kauffman Petrarca Warner Bloom Farry Mako Rozzi DeLissio Keefer Pickett Warren Boback Fee Maloney Ryan 1296 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

Boyle Fitzgerald Markosek Saccone On the question, Bradford Flynn Marshall Sainato Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? Briggs Frankel Marsico Samuelson Brown, R. Freeman Masser Sankey Bill was agreed to. Brown, V. Fritz McCarter Santora Bullock Gainey McClinton Schemel (Bill analysis was read.) Burns Galloway McGinnis Schlossberg Caltagirone Gillen Mehaffie Schweyer Carroll Gillespie Mentzer Simmons The SPEAKER. This bill has been considered on three Causer Godshall Metzgar Sims different days and agreed to and is now on final passage. Cephas Goodman Millard Snyder The question is, shall the bill pass finally? Charlton Greiner Miller, B. Solomon Agreeable to the provisions of the Constitution, the yeas and Christiana Grove Milne Sonney Comitta Hahn Moul Staats nays will now be taken. Conklin Hanna Mullery Stephens Cook Harkins Murt Sturla The following roll call was recorded: Corbin Harper Mustio Tai Costa, D. Harris, A. Neilson Tallman Costa, P. Harris, J. Nelson Taylor YEAS–165 Cox Heffley Nesbit Tobash Culver Helm O'Neal Toepel Barbin Ellis Longietti Roae Cutler Hickernell O'Neill Toohil Barrar Emrick Mackenzie Roe Daley Hill Oberlander Topper Bernstine English Madden Roebuck Davis, A. Irvin Ortitay Vazquez Bizzarro Evans Maher Rothman Dawkins Jozwiak Owlett Vitali Bloom Farry Mako Rozzi Day Kampf Pashinski Walsh Boback Fee Maloney Ryan Dean Kaufer Peifer Ward Boyle Fitzgerald Markosek Saccone Deasy Kauffman Petrarca Warner Bradford Flynn Marshall Sainato DeLissio Keefer Pickett Warren Briggs Frankel Marsico Samuelson Delozier Keller, F. Pyle Watson Brown, R. Freeman Masser Sankey DeLuca Keller, M.K. Quigley Wentling Brown, V. Fritz McCarter Santora Dermody Keller, W. Quinn, C. Wheeland Bullock Gainey McClinton Schemel Diamond Kim Quinn, M. White Burns Galloway Mehaffie Schlossberg DiGirolamo Kinsey Rabb Youngblood Caltagirone Gillen Mentzer Schweyer Donatucci Klunk Rader Zimmerman Carroll Gillespie Metzgar Simmons Dowling Knowles Rapp Causer Godshall Millard Sims Driscoll Kulik Ravenstahl Turzai, Cephas Goodman Miller, B. Snyder Dunbar Lawrence Reed Speaker Charlton Greiner Milne Solomon Dush Christiana Hahn Moul Sonney Comitta Hanna Mullery Staats NAYS–0 Conklin Harkins Murt Stephens Cook Harper Mustio Sturla

Corbin Harris, A. Neilson Tai NOT VOTING–0 Costa, D. Harris, J. Nelson Taylor Costa, P. Heffley Nesbit Tobash EXCUSED–26 Cox Helm O'Neal Toepel Culver Hickernell O'Neill Topper Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien Cutler Hill Oberlander Vazquez Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw Daley Jozwiak Ortitay Vitali Cruz James McNeill Reese Davis, A. Kampf Owlett Walsh Davidson Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor Dawkins Kaufer Pashinski Warner Davis, T. Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas Day Kauffman Peifer Warren Everett Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Dean Keefer Petrarca Watson Gabler Krueger Deasy Keller, F. Pickett Wentling DeLissio Keller, M.K. Quigley Wheeland Delozier Keller, W. Quinn, C. White DeLuca Kim Quinn, M. Youngblood The majority required by the Constitution having voted in the Dermody Kinsey Rabb Zimmerman affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and DiGirolamo Klunk Rader the bill passed finally. Donatucci Knowles Rapp Turzai, Ordered, That the clerk return the same to the Senate with the Driscoll Kulik Ravenstahl Speaker Dunbar Lawrence Reed information that the House has passed the same with amendment in which the concurrence of the Senate is requested. NAYS–10

* * * Diamond Grove Pyle Toohil Dowling Irvin Tallman Ward Dush McGinnis The House proceeded to third consideration of HB 2638, PN 4211, entitled: NOT VOTING–0

An Act amending the act of December 8, 2004 (P.L.1801, No.238), EXCUSED–26 known as the Transit Revitalization Investment District Act, in general provisions, further providing for declaration of policy and for Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien definitions; adding provisions relating to military installation Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw remediation and water, sewer and storm water systems remediation Cruz James McNeill Reese projects; and establishing the Remediation Fund. Davidson Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor 2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1297

Davis, T. Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas The following roll call was recorded: Everett Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Gabler Krueger YEAS–174

Barbin Dush Lawrence Roae The majority required by the Constitution having voted in the Barrar Ellis Longietti Roe affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and Bernstine Emrick Mackenzie Roebuck the bill passed finally. Bizzarro English Madden Rothman Bloom Evans Maher Rozzi Ordered, That the clerk present the same to the Senate for Boback Farry Mako Ryan concurrence. Boyle Fee Maloney Saccone Bradford Fitzgerald Markosek Sainato Briggs Flynn Marshall Samuelson GUEST INTRODUCED Brown, R. Frankel Marsico Sankey Brown, V. Freeman Masser Santora The SPEAKER. To the left of the Speaker, we would like to Bullock Fritz McCarter Schemel Burns Gainey McClinton Schlossberg recognize Jocelyn Hill. She is here as a guest of Representatives Caltagirone Galloway Mehaffie Schweyer John Taylor and Bill Keller, and she is Director of Corporate Carroll Gillen Mentzer Simmons Affairs and Deputy General Counsel for Conrail. Thank you so Causer Gillespie Metzgar Sims much for joining us today, Jocelyn. Cephas Godshall Millard Snyder Charlton Goodman Miller, B. Solomon Christiana Greiner Milne Sonney CALENDAR CONTINUED Comitta Grove Moul Staats Conklin Hahn Mullery Stephens Cook Hanna Murt Sturla CONSIDERATION OF SB 780 CONTINUED Corbin Harkins Mustio Tai Costa, D. Harper Neilson Tallman The SPEAKER. We are going to return to SB 780. SB 780. Costa, P. Harris, A. Nelson Taylor Cox Harris, J. Nesbit Tobash Representative McClinton, my understanding is amendments Culver Heffley O'Neal Toepel 9498, 9499, and 9502 will be withdrawn. She approached me to Cutler Helm O'Neill Toohil tell me that those were withdrawn. Correct? Thank you. Daley Hickernell Oberlander Topper So amendments 9498, 9499, and 9502 are withdrawn. Davis, A. Hill Ortitay Vazquez Dawkins Irvin Owlett Vitali The remaining amendments that we have on that are 9500, Day Jozwiak Pashinski Walsh 9478, 9481, 9509, 9643, and 9644. Dean Kampf Peifer Ward Deasy Kaufer Petrarca Warner BILL PASSED OVER DeLissio Kauffman Pickett Warren Delozier Keefer Pyle Watson DeLuca Keller, F. Quigley Wentling The SPEAKER. We will go over that bill at this time. Dermody Keller, M.K. Quinn, C. Wheeland Diamond Keller, W. Quinn, M. White DiGirolamo Kim Rabb Youngblood MOTION PURSUANT TO RULE 15 Donatucci Kinsey Rader Zimmerman Dowling Klunk Rapp The SPEAKER. Members, as you know, we have been Driscoll Knowles Ravenstahl Turzai, coming in at 11 on Mondays, but that requires a motion. At this Dunbar Kulik Reed Speaker time I call upon the majority leader with respect to a motion for NAYS–1 the start time for Monday, October 15, and Leader? Mr. REED. I would like to make a motion to have the House McGinnis come into order on Monday at 11 a.m. NOT VOTING–0 On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? EXCUSED–26

Benninghoff Haggerty Lewis O'Brien The SPEAKER. And the minority leader, Representative Corr Hennessey Matzie Readshaw Dermody, on the motion. Cruz James McNeill Reese Mr. DERMODY. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Davidson Kavulich Metcalfe Saylor Davis, T. Kirkland Miccarelli Thomas I would also urge the members to support the motion. Everett Kortz Miller, D. Wheatley Gabler Krueger On the question recurring, Will the House agree to the motion? A majority of the members required by the rules having voted in the affirmative, the question was determined in the affirmative and the motion was agreed to.

1298 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE OCTOBER 11

BILL RECOMMITTED BILL REMOVED FROM TABLE

The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, who moves that HB 2557 be recommitted to the Committee on who moves that HB 1142 be removed from the tabled calendar Appropriations. and placed on the active calendar.

On the question, On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to. Motion was agreed to.

BILLS REMOVED FROM TABLE * * *

The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, The House proceeded to second consideration of SB 403, who moves that the following bills be removed from the tabled PN 1228, entitled: calendar and placed on the active calendar: An Act amending Title 53 (Municipalities Generally) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, in employees, further providing for SB 10; commission members. SB 31; SB 353; On the question, SB 500; Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration? SB 502; SB 798; BILL TABLED SB 897; SB 915; The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, SB 916; who moves that SB 403 be removed from the active calendar and SB 961; placed on the tabled calendar. SB 1092; SB 1205; On the question, SB 1127; and Will the House agree to the motion? SB 1209. Motion was agreed to.

On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? BILL REMOVED FROM TABLE Motion was agreed to. The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, who moves that SB 403 be removed from the tabled calendar and BILLS ON SECOND CONSIDERATION placed on the active calendar.

The House proceeded to second consideration of HB 1142, On the question, PN 1365, entitled: Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to. An Act amending the act of December 18, 1984 (P.L.1005, No.205), known as the Municipal Pension Plan Funding Standard and Recovery Act, in standards for municipal pension systems, further providing for BILL ON THIRD CONSIDERATION definitions and providing for special procedures for certain professional services contracts. The House proceeded to third consideration of SB 461, On the question, PN 1026, entitled:

Will the House agree to the bill on second consideration? An Act amending Title 44 (Law and Justice) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, in DNA data and testing, further providing for policy, for definitions, for powers and duties of State Police, for State BILL TABLED DNA Data Base, for State DNA Data Bank, for State Police recommendation of additional offenses, for procedural compatibility The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, with FBI and for DNA sample required upon conviction, delinquency who moves that HB 1142 be removed from the active calendar adjudication and certain ARD cases, providing for collection from and placed on the tabled calendar. persons accepted from other jurisdictions and further providing for procedures for withdrawal, collection and transmission of DNA samples, for procedures for conduct, disposition and use of DNA analysis, for On the question, DNA data base exchange and for expungement. Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to. On the question, Will the House agree to the bill on third consideration? 2018 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL—HOUSE 1299

BILL TABLED ADJOURNMENT

The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, The SPEAKER. At this time Representative who moves that SB 461 be removed from the active calendar and moves that the House be adjourned until Monday, October 15, placed on the tabled calendar. 2018, at 11 a.m., e.d.t., unless sooner recalled by the Speaker.

On the question, On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to. Motion was agreed to, and at 12:13 p.m., e.d.t., the House adjourned. BILL REMOVED FROM TABLE

The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, who moves that SB 461 be removed from the tabled calendar and placed on the active calendar.

On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to.

RESOLUTION

Mr. REED called up HR 284, PN 1556, entitled:

A Resolution urging the Congress of the United States to repeal the Environmental Protection Agency's MS4 program.

On the question, Will the House adopt the resolution?

RESOLUTION TABLED

The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, who moves that HR 284 be removed from the active calendar and placed on the tabled calendar.

On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to.

RESOLUTION REMOVED FROM TABLE

The SPEAKER. The Chair recognizes the majority leader, who moves that HR 284 be removed from the tabled calendar and placed on the active calendar.

On the question, Will the House agree to the motion? Motion was agreed to.

BILLS AND RESOLUTIONS PASSED OVER

The SPEAKER. Without objection, all remaining bills and resolutions on today's calendar will be passed over. The Chair hears no objection.